A14350:2189
The common places of the most famous and renowned divine Doctor Peter Martyr divided into four principal parts: with a large addition of many theological and necessary discourses, some never extant before. Translated and partly gathered by Anthony Marten, one of the sewers of her Majesties most honourable chamber.The common places of the most famous and renowmed diuine Doctor Peter Martyr diuided into foure principall parts: with a large addition of manie theologicall and necessarie discourses, some neuer extant before. Translated and partlie gathered by Anthonie Marten, one of the sewers of hir Maiesties most honourable chamber.
Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rowe, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henry Denham, Thomas Chard, William Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rovve, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henrie Denham, Thomas Chard, VVilliam Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
38 But there ariseth a harder doubt; 1namely, whether it be lawful to make a lie, for the preservation of our neighbours life? Augustine, 2De mendacio ad Consentium, saith; If a man should be in great peril of death, and the same man should also know, that his son were in extreme danger; who happening to die, thou having knowledge thereof, if the father ask thee; Doth my son live? And thou art sure that he also will die, if thou show him that his son is departed, what wouldest thou do in this case? Whether thou sayest, he liveth; or whether thou sayest, I cannot tell: thou liest. But if so be thou answer that he is dead, all men will cry out upon thee, as though thou haddest committed man-slaughter; and as though thou, by thy heavy news, haddest been the occasion of the death of this father, being sick, and lying at the point of death. Augustine granteth that the case is hard; neither denieth he, but that (as a man) he should be moved; and perhaps it might so chance, that affections would not suffer him to speak that, which is just and right. But at the length he concludeth, that he ought not to lie.
38 But there ariseth a harder doubt; 1namelie, whether it be lawfull to make a lie, for the preseruation of our neighbors life? Augustine, 2De mendacio ad Consentium, saith; If a man shuld be in great perill of death, and the same man should also knowe, that his sonne were in extreame danger; who happening to die, thou hauing knowledge thereof, if the father aske thée; Dooth my sonne liue? And thou art sure that he also will die, if thou shew him that his sonne is departed, what wouldest thou doo in this case? Whether thou saiest, he liueth; or whether thou saiest, I cannot tell: thou liest. But if so be thou answer that he is dead, all men will crie out vpon thée, as though thou haddest committed man-slaughter; and as though thou, by thy heauie newes, haddest béene the occasion of the death of this father, being sicke, and lieng at the point of death. Augustine granteth that the case is hard; neither denieth he, but that (as a man) he should be mooued; and perhaps it might so chance, that affections would not suffer him to speake that, which is iust and right. But at the length he concludeth, that he ought not to lie.
And he addeth moreover, that if thou know, that any unchaste woman loveth thee inordinately, which also threateneth to kill her self; 1yea and will do it indeed, except thou assent to her wicked lusts, whether herein thou oughtest to commit any shameful things against chastity? I think not. So likewise (saith he) thou oughtest not to offend against the truth, for saving of thy neighbours life. And moreover, what a window should be opened unto lying, if we ⟨p. 547⟩should determine to do otherwise? For that, which one should think to be lawful in respect of life, another would judge that he may do the same for money; another for estimation, or for defending of lands and possessions. And so it would come to pass, that there would be no measure nor end of lying. We may not suffer (saith Augustine) that any man should kill his own soul for the bodily life of another man. No, nor that it is lawful to lie for the salvation of any mans soul. Every lie (saith John) is not of GOD. But we ought not to speak those things, which are not of God.
And he addeth moreouer, that if thou knowe, that anie vnchast woman loueth thée inordinatelie, which also threateneth to kill hir selfe; 1yea and will doo it indéed, except thou assent to hir wicked lusts, whether herein thou oughtest to commit anie shamefull things against chastitie? I thinke not. So likewise (saith he) thou oughtest not to offend against the truth, for sauing of thy neighbors life. And moreouer, what a windowe should be opened vnto lieng, if we ⟨p. 547⟩should determine to doo otherwise? For that, which one should thinke to be lawfull in respect of life, another would iudge that he may doo the same for monie; another for estimation, or for defending of lands and possessions. And so it would come to passe, that there would be no measure nor end of lieng. We may not suffer (saith Augustine) that anie man should kill his owne soule for the bodilie life of another man. No, nor that it is lawfull to lie for the saluation of anie mans soule. Euerie lie (saith Iohn) is not of GOD. But we ought not to speake those things, which are not of God.
139 What if a man were sought out of murderers to be killed, and that thou knewest that the man lieth there hidden, where thou presently art; and they demand of thee if thou knowest whether he be there or no? He answereth, that if thou be of a valiant courage, and as becometh a christian, thou must say; Where he is I know, but I will not utter it, do you what ye will. Notwithstanding, when the matter cometh to this point, that for the defence of any mans life thou must make a lie: know thou, that thou oughtest to commit the matter unto God, and that thou hast no more there to do. Either thou must answer, that thou wilt not betray him, or else thou must hold thy peace. But by thy silence the murderer will suspect that he is in thy house, and then thou shalt seem to have given an occasion of his apprehension. But in very deed, thou hast not given it; for thou canst not let him to think what he will. Wherefore, the matter must rather be committed unto God, than to make a lie. Howbeit, thou must temper thy words with singular consideration; namely, that thou speak in such sort, as thou utter not all, and yet speak not falsely. For in these cases, I think it is not forbidden; nay, I rather think it most lawful to speak doubtfully. And, as touching this question, this is sufficient.
139 What if a man were sought out of murtherers to be killed, and that thou knewest that the man lieth there hidden, where thou presentlie art; and they demand of thée if thou knowest whether he be there or no? He answereth, that if thou be of a valiant courage, and as becommeth a christian, thou must saie; Where he is I knowe, but I will not vtter it, doo you what ye will. Notwithstanding, when the matter commeth to this point, that for the defense of anie mans life thou must make a lie: knowe thou, that thou oughtest to commit the matter vnto God, and that thou hast no more there to doo. Either thou must answer, that thou wilt not betraie him, or else thou must hold thy peace. But by thy silence the murtherer will suspect that he is in thy house, and then thou shalt séeme to haue giuen an occasion of his apprehension. But in verie déed, thou hast not giuen it; for thou canst not lett him to thinke what he will. Wherefore, the matter must rather be committed vnto God, than to make a lie. Howbeit, thou must temper thy words with singular consideration; namelie, that thou speake in such sort, as thou vtter not all, and yet speake not falselie. For in these cases, I thinke it is not forbidden; naie, I rather thinke it most lawfull to speake doubtfullie. And, as touching this question, this is sufficient.
140 There be some so importunate men, as although God have heaped his benefits upon them, yet are they always complaining; We have borne the burden and heat of the day, 2and yet doest thou make us equal unto them? Some also be so modest, as even in prosperity they humble themselves. Others be broken with misery, and are become more humble. But they, which in their losses and afflictions retain still the fierceness of nature, be too insolent and obstinate. Humility is like a bridle, 3wherewith the insolencie of our nature must be held in his duty. And men be most of all reclaimed unto modesty, when they begin to consider how very little they have of themselves. Howbeit, the same humbling of our selves ought to be joined with the acknowledging of Gods benefits. For many, while they be either ignorant thereof, or else dissemble it, become like unto beasts; as they, which cannot one whit understand, with what benefits they be endued by God. But there must be a special regard had, that we do not counterfeit that modesty; and that the same consist not only in words, but in the mind also.
140 There be some so importunate men, as although God haue heaped his benefits vpon them, yet are they alwaies complaining; We haue borne the burthen and heate of the daie, 2and yet dooest thou make vs equall vnto them? Some also be so modest, as euen in prosperitie they humble themselues. Others be broken with miserie, and are become more humble. But they, which in their losses and afflictions reteine still the fearsenes of nature, be too insolent and obstinate. Humilitie is like a bridle, 3wherewith the insolencie of our nature must be held in his dutie. And men be most of all reclaimed vnto modestie, when they begin to consider how verie little they haue of themselues. Howbeit, the same humbling of our selues ought to be ioined with the acknowledging of Gods benefits. For manie, while they be either ignorant thereof, or else dissemble it, become like vnto beasts; as they, which cannot one whit vnderstand, with what benefits they be indued by God. But there must be a speciall regard had, that we doo not counterfet that modestie; and that the same consist not onelie in words, but in the mind also.
Yet to retain that virtue, 1it is not lawful for thee to make a lie upon thy self for modesty sake. For Aristotle himself, in his Ethics, reckoneth a lie among unhonest things. And (as Paul saith; We must not do evil, that good may come of it. Augustine, in his 8. epistle to Jerome, touching this matter, citeth the words of Paul to the Corinthians;2) If Christ be not risen, in vain is our preaching, and your faith also is in vain. For we be found false witnesses of God, when we say, that God raised up Christ from the dead; whom he raised not up, if the dead do not rise again. But here (saith Augustine) a man might say unto Paul; Why doest thou so much detest lying, since the same tendeth to the setting forth of the glory of God? And he maketh Paul to answer, that he doth detest such lies, and that it is no less evil, to commend things that be not true concerning God, than not to believe things that be true of him. Hereby we gather this argument; If it be not lawful to lie for the honour of God, it is much less lawful to lie for the retaining of any virtue. Yea, and it is no less evil to ascribe to thy self evil, which thou hast not committed, than to arrogate unto thy self any good, which thou hast not done.
Yet to reteine that vertue, 1it is not lawfull for thée to make a lie vpon thy selfe for modestie sake. For Aristotle himselfe, in his Ethiks, reckoneth a lie among vnhonest things. And (as Paule saith; Wee must not doo euill, that good may come of it. Augustine, in his 8. epistle to Ierom, touching this matter, citeth the words of Paule to the Corinthians;2) If Christ be not risen, in vaine is our preaching, and your faith also is in vaine. For we be found false witnesses of God, when we saie, that God raised vp Christ from the dead; whom he raised not vp, if the dead doo not rise againe. But here (saith Augustine) a man might saie vnto Paule; Why dooest thou so much detest lieng, since the same tendeth to the setting foorth of the glorie of God? And he maketh Paule to answer, that he dooth detest such lies, and that it is no lesse euill, to commend things that be not true concerning God, than not to beléeue things that be true of him. Hereby we gather this argument; If it be not lawfull to lie for the honour of God, it is much lesse lawfull to lie for the reteining of anie vertue. Yea, and it is no lesse euill to ascribe to thy selfe euill, which thou hast not committed, than to arrogate vnto thy selfe anie good, which thou hast not doone.
41 Contrariwise nevertheless, 1Paul unto Timothy seemeth somewhat to make a lie of himself; Christ (saith he) came to save sinners, 2of whom I am the chief. For Paul was not the chief, or the greatest sinner. And in the 30. chapter of the Proverbs, the prophet Agur, whether he were Solomon himself, or some other man; 3I am (saith he) more foolish than all men, and the wisdom of man is not in me; I have learned no knowledge, neither have I the understanding of holy things. Yet was he both a prophet, and a wise man, and answered prudently unto questions. And Christ himself, of himself; I am (saith he) a worm and no man, 4a very scorn of men, and the outcast of the people. Some defend these speeches on this wise, saying; that They, which have thus amplified their sins, ⟨p. 548⟩they only respected their own strength, which they themselves had by themselves, and a certain natural inclination of their own unto evil. For they themselves saw, that they should grievously have fallen, unless God had stayed them. These in very deed be no small provocations, to make us judge humbly and lowly of our own selves. But it is one thing for a man to say that he is prone and ready bent unto evil; and an other thing to confess that he hath done some evil, which he hath not done. For there is as much difference between these, as there is between act and power. Certainly, we may every one of us slip, yet no man ought to say that he hath slipped, when he hath not. We ought all to confess our selves to be sinners, but none ought to ascribe unto himself any sin by name, which he hath not committed.
41 Contrariwise neuerthelesse, 1Paule vnto Timothie séemeth somwhat to make a lie of himselfe; Christ (saith he) came to saue sinners, 2of whom I am the cheefe. For Paule was not the chéefe, or the greatest sinner. And in the 30. chapter of the Prouerbs, the prophet Agur, whether he were Salomon himselfe, or some other man;
I say therefore, that those speeches, which I have made mention of, if they be throughly weighed, they be true. For some be uttered after that sort, because absolutely they be so; some, for that they be extolled by an excessive speech; some, because they be compared with an other thing by contention. 1Paul calleth himself the principal sinner, either because he was the first that came unto Christ, among those that persecuted the church of GOD; or because he judged himself in very deed to be chief and greatest of the sinners. Not as if there had been no man that had sinned more heinously (for there were such as had sinned against the holy Ghost, there were those which had sinned without any repentance:) but because that among all them, which were redeemed by Christ, and had obtained the mercy of God, he thought himself to have sinned most grievously. For some had sinned of infirmity, some of plain error and incredulity; some had proceeded so far, as they crucified Christ, who nevertheless were afterward, by the preaching of the word of God, called home unto repentance. 2Therefore saith Peter in the Acts; I know brethren that ye did it by ignorance, even as did your rulers. But Paul had no recourse unto the sermons of the apostles: there was need of greater bonds for the drawing of him unto Christ. Whereupon Christ spake thus unto him from heaven; 3Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me? With these men therefore he compareth himself: and of these he saith he is the principal.
I saie therefore, that those spéeches, which I haue made mention of, if they be throughlie weighed, they be true. For some be vttered after that sort, bicause absolutelie they be so; some, for that they be extolled by an excessiue spéech; some, bicause they be compared with an other thing by contention. 1Paule calleth himselfe the principall sinner, either bicause he was the first that came vnto Christ, among those that persecuted the church of GOD; or bicause he iudged himselfe in verie déed to be chéefe and greatest of the sinners. Not as if there had béene no man that had sinned more heinouslie (for there were such as had sinned against the holie Ghost, there were those which had sinned without anie repentance:) but bicause that among all them, which were redéemed by Christ, and had obteined the mercie of God, he thought himselfe to haue sinned most gréeuouslie. For some had sinned of infirmitie, some of plaine error and incredulitie; some had procéeded so farre, as they crucified Christ, who neuerthelesse were afterward, by the preaching of the word of God, called home vnto repentance.
And so Chrysostom, upon this place, saith; that These words be against other words of his in the epistle to the Philippians. 1For there he saith, that he was conversant in the Jewish religion, without crime, and without complaint. But these things (saith he) are nothing repugnant. For even they themselves, which had performed the righteousness of the law, yet were they sinners nevertheless. And although Paul spake those things modestly of himself, yet did he not ascribe an untruth unto himself. For, notwithstanding he granteth himself to have been a persecutor, and a blasphemer; yet he saith not, that he was an adulterer, or a fornicator, or a thief; seeing these things should not have been true. The things objected out of the Proverbs, touching Agur the prophet, 2were true by way of comparing them unto those things, whereof a demand was made. He saith that he had no wisdom; not in respect that the wisdom which he had, was no wisdom; but because the same, being compared unto so great matters, might seem to be none. So Socrates was wont to say; This only I know, that I know nothing: because that knowledge, which he had, would be nothing, in comparison of the multitude of those things that he knew not. 3So Christ called himself a worm, and a reproach of the people; because men so accounted of him, by reason of his afflictions and cross. Also in speaking, there happeneth sometime an excessive or hyperbolical speech; such indeed as is not joined with a a lie, but which may serve for the better setting forth of the matter.
And so Chrysostome, vpon this place, saith; that These words be against other words of his in the epistle to the Philippians. 1For there he saith, that he was conuersant in the Iewish religion, without crime, and without complaint. But these things (saith he) are nothing repugnant. For euen they themselues, which had performed the righteousnesse of the lawe, yet were they sinners neuerthelesse. And although Paule spake those things modestlie of himselfe, yet did he not ascribe an vntruth vnto himselfe. For, notwithstanding he granteth himselfe to haue béene a persecuter, and a blasphemer; yet he saith not, that he was an adulterer, or a fornicatour, or a théefe; séeing these things should not haue béene true. The things obiected out of the Prouerbs, touching Agur the prophet,
42 In the beginning of the ninth chapter of the second book of Samuel, David demandeth; 1Is there any man left alive of the family of Saul, to whom I may do good for Jonathans sake? When he speaketh of Jonathan, he excludeth not God; nay rather, that which he did for Jonathans sake, he did chiefly for God and godliness sake. So God saith, that he would do well to the people of the Jews, for the covenant which he had made with Abraham; yet doth he not exclude his own goodness. Nay rather, he chiefly includeth the same therein; seeing that covenant proceeded of the mere goodness and mercy of God. But thou wilt demand, why David saith that he will do good unto any of the house of Saul, for Jonathans sake; and not for Sauls own sake. For in the 24. chapter of the first book of Samuel, what time as he had cut off the skirt of Sauls cloak, 2he being enforced by Saul to swear, promised, that he would not root out his seed. Whereby he was bound, not only unto Jonathan, but also unto Saul. Some answer, that David was now discharged of his oath; because Saul kept not promise with him, but had done him exceeding great wrong. For he that breaketh his faith (say they) let faith be broken with him. And Cicero, in his third book of Offices, ⟨p. 549⟩citeth a verse out of Accius an old Poet; Hast thou broken thy faith? Atreus, whom he bringeth in to speak, answereth; Neither have I given neither do I give my faith to any faithless person.
42 In the beginning of the ninth chapter of the second booke of Samuel, Dauid demandeth; 1Is there anie man left aliue of the familie of Saule, to whom I may doo good for Ionathans sake? When he speaketh of Ionathan, he excludeth not God; naie rather, that which he did for Ionathans sake, he did chéefelie for God and godlinesse sake. So God saith, that he would doo well to the people of the Iews, for the couenant which he had made with Abraham; yet dooth he not exclude his owne goodnesse. Naie rather, he chéefelie includeth the same therein; séeing that couenant procéeded of the méere goodnesse and mercie of God. But thou wilt demand, whie Dauid saith that he will doo good vnto anie of the house of Saule, for Ionathans sake; and not for Saules owne sake. For in the 24. chapter of the first booke of Samuel, what time as he had cut off the skirt of Saules cloke,
But this is no sure rule at all times. For if one be wicked, and false of promise: yet oughtest not thou for that cause to shrink from thy promises; seeing God doth oftentimes keep promise even with us that do evil. He promised, that he would continue the kingdom, or else some great honour in the family of David, even unto Messiah. He promised that he would give a son which should redeem mankind. Men undoubtedly were evil, unfaithful, and unworthy to have the promises kept with them: yet did he perform these things to them, according to his excellent faithfulness. Some answer on this wise, that faith in deed must be kept with an evil and unfaithful man, if he be unfaithful towards other, so he be no such towards us; or else, if he do hurt us, so it be not in the self same thing, wherein it was agreed upon between us. Nay rather, if he fail even in the very same thing which is agreed upon, yet must we keep promise: if by that means, neither his naughtiness be increased; nor a greater power to do hurt be given unto him. We be therefore loosed of our promise, if the thing cannot be, which we have promised; or else, if it should fall out ill unto himself, to whom the promise is made: as if thou deliver a sword unto a furious man, which thou didst promise unto a man of sobriety; or if he wax worse and worse, as though, through thy patience, he meaneth to reap a benefit of his unfaithfulness: or else, if thou shalt promise such a thing, as is against the word of God, or the profit of the Church or Common-weal. Therefore it is written in the 22. cause, question second; In evil promises break thy faith.
But this is no sure rule at all times. For if one be wicked, and false of promise: yet oughtest not thou for that cause to shrinke from thy promises; séeing God dooth oftentimes kéepe promise euen with vs that doo euill. He promised, that he would continue the kingdome, or else some great honour in the familie of Dauid, euen vnto Messias. He promised that he would giue a sonne which should redéeme mankind. Men vndoubtedlie were euill, vnfaithfull, and vnworthie to haue the promises kept with them: yet did he performe these things to them, according to his excellent faithfulnes. Some answer on this wise, that faith in déed must be kept with an euill and vnfaithfull man, if he be vnfaithfull towards other, so he be no such towards vs; or else, if he doo hurt vs, so it be not in the selfe same thing, wherein it was agréed vpon betwéene vs. Naie rather, if he faile euen in the verie same thing which is agréed vpon, yet must we kéepe promise: if by that meanes, neither his naughtinesse be increased; nor a greater power to doo hurt be giuen vnto him. We be therefore loosed of our promise, if the thing cannot be, which we haue promised; or else, if it should fall out ill vnto himselfe, to whom the promise is made: as if thou deliuer a sword vnto a furious man, which thou didst promise vnto a man of sobrietie; or if he wax woorse and woorse, as though, through thy patience, he meaneth to reape a benefit of his vnfaithfulnesse: or else, if thou shalt promise such a thing, as is against the word of God, or the profit of the Church or Common-weale. Therfore it is written in the 22. cause, question second; In euill promises breake thy faith.
But most of all, we be at liberty of our promise, if we being circumvented by any fraud, have promised any thing that we ought not to have done; or else, if the things themselves be now changed. Some have added; If thou being compelled either by force or fear, doest promise any thing that thou wouldest not. But it can scarcely be perceived, how so great a fear and compulsion can happen unto a courageous and good man, that he should promise that, which might be against either his duty, or the word of God. Howbeit, if a man be fallen in such wise, he is at liberty. But above all, we must take heed, that we do not craftily colour our promises, and seek by fraud and counterfeit means to unwind our selves out: seeing fraud (as Cicero very rightly said) doth not undo perjury, but it tieth it fast. David, when as perhaps he might have invented many things to break his promises; yet would he do no such thing. For being a godly prince, he was rather minded to follow truth and faithfulness.
But most of all, we be at libertie of our promise, if we being circumuented by anie fraud, haue promised anie thing that we ought not to haue doone; or else, if the things themselues be now changed. Some haue added; If thou being compelled either by force or feare, dooest promise anie thing that thou wouldest not. But it can scarselie be perceiued, how so great a feare and compulsion can happen vnto a couragious and good man, that he should promise that, which might be against either his dutie, or the word of God. Howbeit, if a man be fallen in such wise, he is at libertie. But aboue all, we must take héed, that we doo not craftilie colour our promises, and séeke by fraud and counterfet meanes to vnwind our selues out: séeing fraud (as Cicero verie rightlie said) dooth not vndoo periurie, but it tieth it fast. Dauid, when as perhaps he might haue inuented manie things to breake his promises; yet would he doo no such thing. For being a godlie prince, he was rather minded to followe truth and faithfulnesse.