139 What if a man were sought out of murderers to be killed, and that thou knewest that the man lieth there hidden, where thou presently art; and they demand of thee if thou knowest whether he be there or no? He answereth, that if thou be of a valiant courage, and as becometh a christian, thou must say; Where he is I know, but I will not utter it, do you what ye will. Notwithstanding, when the matter cometh to this point, that for the defence of any mans life thou must make a lie: know thou, that thou oughtest to commit the matter unto God, and that thou hast no more there to do. Either thou must answer, that thou wilt not betray him, or else thou must hold thy peace. But by thy silence the murderer will suspect that he is in thy house, and then thou shalt seem to have given an occasion of his apprehension. But in very deed, thou hast not given it; for thou canst not let him to think what he will. Wherefore, the matter must rather be committed unto God, than to make a lie. Howbeit, thou must temper thy words with singular consideration; namely, that thou speak in such sort, as thou utter not all, and yet speak not falsely. For in these cases, I think it is not forbidden; nay, I rather think it most lawful to speak doubtfully. And, as touching this question, this is sufficient.
139 What if a man were sought out of murtherers to be killed, and that thou knewest that the man lieth there hidden, where thou presentlie art; and they demand of thée if thou knowest whether he be there or no? He answereth, that if thou be of a valiant courage, and as becommeth a christian, thou must saie; Where he is I knowe, but I will not vtter it, doo you what ye will. Notwithstanding, when the matter commeth to this point, that for the defense of anie mans life thou must make a lie: knowe thou, that thou oughtest to commit the matter vnto God, and that thou hast no more there to doo. Either thou must answer, that thou wilt not betraie him, or else thou must hold thy peace. But by thy silence the murtherer will suspect that he is in thy house, and then thou shalt séeme to haue giuen an occasion of his apprehension. But in verie déed, thou hast not giuen it; for thou canst not lett him to thinke what he will. Wherefore, the matter must rather be committed vnto God, than to make a lie. Howbeit, thou must temper thy words with singular consideration; namelie, that thou speake in such sort, as thou vtter not all, and yet speake not falselie. For in these cases, I thinke it is not forbidden; naie, I rather thinke it most lawfull to speake doubtfullie. And, as touching this question, this is sufficient.
- 1We must not lie no not to save a mans life.We must not lie no not to saue a mans life.