A14350:5017
The common places of the most famous and renowned divine Doctor Peter Martyr divided into four principal parts: with a large addition of many theological and necessary discourses, some never extant before. Translated and partly gathered by Anthony Marten, one of the sewers of her Majesties most honourable chamber.The common places of the most famous and renowmed diuine Doctor Peter Martyr diuided into foure principall parts: with a large addition of manie theologicall and necessarie discourses, some neuer extant before. Translated and partlie gathered by Anthonie Marten, one of the sewers of hir Maiesties most honourable chamber.
Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rowe, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henry Denham, Thomas Chard, William Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rovve, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henrie Denham, Thomas Chard, VVilliam Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
123 Of this question there be many Arguments on both parts. For first kings are stirred up unto clemency, which would be done in vain unless they might forgive. Also David forgave seditious men, 2and sware unto Shimei, that he would not punish him. And Paul commendeth Onesimus, 3a fugitive servant, unto his Master Philemon & prayeth him to forgive him his fault. And the use was among Christian Emperors that in the week before Easter, 4when the memory of Christ his death was celebrated, the prisons were set at large. And among the Jews the custom was, 5that in Easter some one condemned man should be set at liberty by the chief Ruler. Also Augustine made intercession oftentimes for the Donatists and Circumcellions, which had not only troubled Religion, but also had done injury to the life and goods of the Christians. Further we read that it was decreed among them of old time, that if a guilty person had fled unto Churches, he should be without harm. And hereof Chrysostom maketh mention in his Oration against Gainas.
123 Of this question there be many Arguments on both parts. For first kings are stirred vp vnto clemencie, which woulde bée doone in vaine vnlesse they might forgiue. Also Dauid forgaue seditious men, 2and sware vnto Semei, that he woulde not punish him. And Paul commendeth Onesimus, 3a fugitiue seruant, vnto his Maister Philemon & prayeth him to forgiue him his fault. And the vse was among Christian Emperours that in the wéeke before Easter, 4when the memorie of Christ his death was celebrated, the prisons were set at large. And amōg the Iewes the custome was, 5that in Easter some one condemned man should be set at libertie by the chiefe Ruler. Also Augustine made intercession oftentimes for the Donatistes and Circumcellions, which had not onely troubled Religion, but also had doone iniurie to the life and goods of the Christians. Further we reade that it was decréed among them of olde time, that if a guiltie person had fled vnto Churches, he should be without harme. And hereof Chrysostome maketh mention in his Oration against Gainas.
24 Also there want not firm Arguments on the contrary part. 1For first, it seemeth that a godly work should not be hindered: and it is a godly work to punish the guilty, seeing it profiteth the Common weal, and taketh away sins. Moreover by this means the office of Princes is hindered. For they bear the sword: which if they use not when time and cause requireth, they do not their duty. Besides: he that releaseth punishments giveth of another's and not of his own, sith judgement is the right of God, as it is written in the first Chapter of Deuteronomy. And in the second of Paralip. the 19. 2Chapter Jehoshaphat sayeth: Exercise judgement, not only for man but as it were for God. And the punishments of the law can not be taken away unless it be by him that appointed them. But God appointed the punishments for sins. Wherefore no man should diminish or take them away. But that God appointed the punishment of death for grievous sins, it appeareth out of the 18. Chapter of Deuteronomy, where it is thus written, 3that the people desired that God himself would not speak unto them, because they might not abide so great a Majesty: and for that they chose rather to hear Moses to be the interpreter: that GOD heard these prayers of the people, and promised not only that he would give Moses unto them, but also would provide that no Prophet should at any time be wanting unto them. A Prophet (sayeth he) will I raise up unto you from among your own brethren. But he addeth: If any man will not hear that Prophet, I will make inquisition against him. Howbeit this place proveth not, that that punishment was the punishment of death. More certain is the other place in the 17. Chapter of Deuteronomy: If (sayeth God) there shall happen a difficult case, 4ye shall go up to the high Priest or unto a Levite: and he that shall not hear the voice of the Levite or high Priest, or of the Judge, shall die the death. But that was for changing the state of the Common weal. Samuel's counsel was demanded as concerning that matter, and he was not only a Prophet but also a judge; they gave not ear unto him therefore they were worthy of death. In deed, GOD might have forgiven them, but the Prince could not. Furthermore there is a way opened unto mischiefs, when men promise to themselves, that either through grace or reward they shall escape unpunished.
This also may be proved out of the histories. God commanded that all the Amalekites should be slain, Saul spared Agag their King: 1he was grievously reproved by Samuel, because this was not lawful for him to do. 2And when the king of Israel had spared Benhadad the king of Syria, whom God had commanded to be slain: 3Thy soul (sayeth the Prophet) shall be for his soul. In deed the Prince hath power of life and of death. But yet, as he may not punish him that is innocent, so must he not let him escape that is guilty. Yea and the Lord saith: Thou shalt take away the murderer from my Altar, and shalt put him to death. 4Finally, if this should be permitted unto Princes, judgements of death would be sold, and the execution of Justice should be at pleasure of the Magistrate. Thus have we Arguments on both parts.5
This also may bee prooued out of the histories. God commaunded that all the Amalachites should be slaine, Saul spared Agag their King: 1he was grieuously reprooued by Samuel, because this was not lawfull for him to doe. 2And when the king of Israel had spared Benhadad the king of Syria, whō God had commanded to be slaine: 3Thy soule (saieth the Prophet) shall be for his soule. In déede the Prince hath power of life and of death. But yet, as he may not punish him that is innocent, so must he not let him escape that is guiltie. Yea and the Lord saith: Thou shalt take awaie the murtherer from my Altar, and shalt put him to death. 4Finally, if this should be permitted vnto Princes, iudgements of death would be solde, and the execution of Iustice should be at pleasure of the Magistrate. Thus haue we Arguments on both parts.
25 But here must we consider, that some laws there be humane, and other some divine. ⟨p. 161⟩And it belongeth much to the state of this question, whether sort they be. For humane laws, because they proceed of a weak reason, are never perfect: neither can they comprehend all things, or foresee all chances and circumstances. 1Wherefore oftentimes, if we should severely and sharply urge the words of the law, many unjust things would be decreed. And so, there is oftentimes need of moderation, 2and interpretation, and correction of the law. And moderation is the bridle and rule of humane laws, when we consider not so much the words themselves, as the counsel & mind of the writer. Furthermore, Lawyers may interpret mens laws if they seem doubtful, either by other laws, or by examples of former judgements, or by the ordinance and custom of the City: or else according to justice and safety of the Common weal: but to correct or change, or to mitigate a law, is not any private mans part, but the office of the Prince alone, who made the Law. Wherefore Augustine in his Book De vera Religione, A Judge (sayeth he) ought not to judge of the law, but according to the law: otherwise all things would be bought. The same thing we have in the Pandectes, De legibus & Senatus Consultis. But now can we not say that the laws of God are unperfect so as they contain not all things. For the mind of God is infinite and most perfect. Doubtless it is the part of wise men and divines diligently to weigh and examine the laws of God and to expound some places by other places, 3to consider the decree and order which the Lord hath made, to discuss things that seem to be repugnant, and to judge of two laws, 4when both of them cannot be kept, whether is to be preferred before the other. For example: The law is that the Sabaoth day must be kept holy: there is another law that the City must be defended: it so falleth out sometime, that unless we fight on the Sabaoth day, the City cannot be defended. Here the better law must be kept, namely, that the safety of the City be defended.
here the better law must be kept: to wit, that we obey God. This is lawful for us in the law of God. But to abrogate or correct, or by moderation to diminish, and put away the law of God, is by no means lawful for us. Wherefore let Pigghius take heed what moderation it is by which he teacheth us that we should understand the first precept: Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, with all thy soul, &c. 1For seeing this cannot be, he sayeth, that the words of the law must be mitigated by a fit interpretation. 2Christ gave and instituted his Supper, and commanded that the same should be ministered in both kinds. But the Roman Antichrist sayeth: that many chances may happen by reason of beards, of diseases, of shedding of the blood: therefore the Cup must be plucked from the laity. God in the holy assembly would have all things to be ministered in the vulgar and known tongue. Nevertheless these men say, 3that their mysteries must not be rashly profaned: There is no necessity that the people should understand all things: These things must be committed only to the learned and wise. But who hath taught these men this moderation in the law of God? The Jews used only the laws of God, therefore the Princes might not mitigate them by interpretations, but humane laws they may, because they be enacted by them.
héere the better lawe must be kept: to wit, that we obey God. This is lawfull for vs in the lawe of God. But to abrogate or correct, or by moderation to diminish, and put awaie the lawe of God, is by no meanes lawfull for vs. Wherefore let Pigghius take héede what moderation it is by which he teacheth vs that we should vnderstand the first precept: Thou shalt loue the Lorde thy God with all thy heart, with all thy soule, &c. 1For séeing this cannot be, he saieth, that the wordes of the lawe must be mitigated by a fit interpretation. 2Christ gaue and instituted his Supper, and commaunded that the same should be ministred in both kindes. But the Romane Antichrist saieth: that many chances may happen by reason of beardes, of diseases, of shedding of the bloud: therefore the Cup must be plucked from the laitie. God in the holy assemblie would haue all things to bee ministered in the vulgar and knowne tongue. Neuerthelesse these men say,
26 Furthermore some commandments forbid a thing to be done, others command or (as the Schoolmen speak:1) Some be affirmative, others be negative. Those laws which forbid or deny any thing, do evermore hold. As for example: we are bound at all times that we shall not steal: that we shall not commit adultery, &c. But those which command any thing, although that they also have great strength, yet do they not perpetually bind. If any shall give us a blow upon the right cheek, 2we are commanded to offer unto him the left. Assuredly we ought always to have a mind ready so to do: howbeit we are not bound at all times, and towards all men thus to do: For this Christ himself did not, but being stricken, answered: If I have spoken evil, 3bear witness of the evil. And Paul: God (sayeth he) shall strike thee thou painted wall. We must thus do when either the glory of God or the salvation of him that hath stricken shall seem to require it. God commandeth that we should come together to the holy congregation, to celebrate the Sacraments and to give Alms. Yet doeth he not command that we should always do these things. But to what purpose is all this? 4namely hereunto: God commandeth if any man shall not obey the Judge or the high Priest, that he be slain. This law in very deed bindeth the Magistrate, yet not always, ⟨p. 262⟩but when it may be done: 5and sometime it happeneth that it cannot be. Nevertheless if thou punish not when it may be, thou offendest the law of God. Moreover we must take heed, that the greater good be not hindered by the lesser. Joab was an evil man and a murderer, and worthy to be slain by David. But when David saw that he was able to do much with the army, 6least any trouble and sedition should arise, he would not lay hold of him. And it may be that he spared Shimei for the self same cause.
127 Now let us make answer to the Arguments which are wont to be objected: whereas they say, that Princes are often stirred up unto clemency, it behooveth to understand what is the nature of clemency. And this may easily be understood by the contrary. Cruel is he which in punishing exceedeth measure, through a certain cruelty of the mind, and is not moved at the miseries of men. 2On the contrary part he is merciful which cannot abide to execute punishments but releaseth them, and that through a gentleness of the mind. And I add: Through a gentleness of the mind: for if he be led by reward or favour or necessity to release punishments, he is not merciful. This virtue (as sayeth Seneca,) doeth chiefly belong unto Princes, and them which bear rule. For kings, are therefore called pitiful and merciful, not because they be so, but for that they ought to be so. But private men which have no public power of punishing, may forgive many things, yea and oftentimes also ought: howbeit they should not be called merciful, but gentle. And we ought to know, that clemency doeth diminish punishments, not rashly nor by chance: not after a mans own pleasure, but by a right reason. And I call reason, not mans judgement by it self, but that which is framed according to the word of God. For if punishments be released unadvisedly or at a mans own pleasure, now can it not be a virtue, for it doeth violate justice. And virtue is a certain form of right reason. Clemency doeth make the law somewhat to yield. But severity is by no means turned. And sometime the one is to be used and sometime the other. If there happen an outrageous cause, severity must be used, not clemency. Sometime the cause is made the lighter by circumstances: then there is place for clemency. Doubtless clemency, although it bend the common law, yet doeth it nothing against right reason. Seeing it hath a consideration of the Circumstances, and according to that it appointeth punishments. And when the merciful man remitteth any part of the punishment, this •ee judgeth that he whom he forgiveth, ought not to suffer any more. For he respecteth not the words, but the meaning and purpose of the law. Nevertheless when the punishment due is altogether remitted, it is no clemency but pardon, and that is to be hoped for from God alone.
Which the Jews also understood when they said: 1Who is this that forgiveth sins? Yet do the Papists brag, that they and theirs can give a pardon of sins. But thou wilt say: If so the case stand: then might other princes use clemency, but the Jews might not, because they used the laws of God. I answer, 2that they also might be merciful, yet not otherwise, than where no certain punishment was prescribed by the law of God. In Leviticus and in Deuteronomy it is commanded, That weights should be just, and measures right. He that had done otherwise, was to be punished, yet no certain punishment was appointed. Wherefore in that case there was place for the clemency and severity of the Judge. Another law there was, 3that he which had deserved to be beaten with s•aves, should be punished with no more but forty stripes. In this case it was in the power of the judge, that the party should be punished with few or many stripes within that number. 4There was another law that the servant which had sold himself into the power of another man, should be grievously punished. But if his Master had oppressed him with violence, there was no punishment determined by the laws. Herein also was place for the clemency of the Judge. Wherefore not in vain was clemency often repeated unto the Princes of the Jews. For it was lawful to use the same both in the humane laws set forth by them, as I have said, and in the divine laws, so far forth as punishments were not prescribed by the laws.
Which the Iewes also vnderstoode when they said: 1Who is this that forgiueth sinnes? Yet doe the Papists bragge, that they and theirs can giue a pardon of sinnes. But thou wilt say: If so the case stand: then might other princes vse clemencie, but the Iewes might not, because they vsed the lawes of God. I answere, 2that they also might be mercifull, yet not otherwise, than where no certaine punishment was prescribed by the lawe of God. In Leuiticus and in Deuteronomie it is commaunded, That weights should be iust, and measures right. He that had doone otherwise, was to be punished, yet no certaine punishment was appointed. Wherefore in that case there was place for the clemencie and seueritie of the Iudge. Another lawe there was,
28 And as touching the clemency of Augustus Caesar, I answer, 1that that law which we have, Ad legem Juliam maiestatis, was humane. For by what punishment conspirators must be afflicted, it was decreed by ⟨p. 263⟩princes, and so that law might be mitigated by him. He judged it would be sufficient, if he had grievously rebuked Cinna: And assuredly we read in that history, that he was greatly vexed: and therefore he judged it better, to remit somewhat of the punishment. But how small a portion must be remitted, 2just moderation doth declare. But humane laws, when they follow the prescript of nature, must be accounted the laws of God: As to put a murderer to death. Herein must nothing be remitted by the Judge. Doubtless, Clemency is an habit wherewith by the gentleness of the mind we mitigate legal punishments within the limits of Justice. 3David forgave Shimei: I grant, but yet when he perceived that it was not lawful that he should go unpunished, he commanded Solomon that he should not suffer his grey hairs to escape unpunished unto the grave: Nevertheless, it was not expedient for David himself to kill him. For first Shimei being of the family of Saul, he might seem to be moved with hatred against his posterity. Further he had confirmed his words of whom he had been called before, a bloody man. Lastly it was not meet for him to disturb that gladness and gratulation of the people. After this sort he forgave Joab, 4who had killed two better men. For he saw that he was able to do much with the army: Wherefore he also remitted him unto Solomon. Howbeit it cannot be denied, but that David sinned, both when he absolved Amnon of Incest, and Absalom of parricide. But what David refused to do, that did God himself afterward by himself. 5For Amnon was slain by Absalom, and Absalom being hanged on a tree, was thrust through by Joab with a spear. And whereas Paul commendeth Onesimus unto his Master Philemon,
1For in Deuteronomium, there is a law, If an other mans servant shall fly unto thee, thou shalt not restore him to his Master, which must be understood: so long as his Master is in a rage and unpatientlie disquieted. This was profitable to the Master least he should overmuch feed his wrath: and unto the servant, least he should be overmuch punished,
1For in Deuteronomium, there is a lawe, If an other mans seruant shal flye vnto thee, thou shalt not restore him to his Maister, which must be vnderstoode: so long as his Maister is in a rage and vnpatientlie disquieted. This was profitable to the Maister least he should ouermuch féede his wrath: and vnto the seruant, least he should be ouermuch punished,
129 But the fact of the Romans, in that at the feast of Easter they released unto the Jews some man that was bound and condemned, we cannot allow. 2For God never commanded, that in their solemnities any guilty man should be released. Howbeit, the Romans by this means curried favour with the Jews, to the intent they might the more easily bear that servitude. 3The selfsame reason it was why Christian princes in the holy week [of Easter] would open the prisons, and let forth guilty men: insomuch, that they were not very skilful in the laws of God. For if they had bin bound for debt, they had forgiven not their own but other mens. Again, if for heinous offences, this had bin to open a window unto mischief. But princes cannot easily hold the mean. And in like case, as they will have the Ministers of the word either to be poor wretches, or else after a sort to be princes and Gods, so do they either punish the guilty together with the innocent (as Theodosius did) or else they so spare all men, that nothing is administered severely. And as touching Augustine, in deed I grant that he entreated for the Donatists: yet he denied it not to be lawful for Magistrates to punish Heretics. But when the Circumcellions or idle persons became cruel against the Christians, and that the Church was constrained to call for the help of princes, and that now these idle persons were punished, the Church seemed to be cruel and to prosecute her own injuries. Howbeit Augustine desireth not that they should be wholly forgiven, but only that their blood might not be shed. Yet howsoever it were, 4the example of Augustine ought not to prejudice any mans opinion, sith we live by laws, not by examples. At this day if a man had killed a Minister, or done a robbery, who would entreat for him? But there was a refuge unto the churches for such as were guilty. Admit it were so, and we also do not take away sanctuaries, for God permitted them. For if the cause be obscure, they may better be there than in prison while the same be known. Nevertheless the cause being manifest, God himself commanded, that the wicked man should be taken from the very altar and be slain. These be the things which move me to think, that it is not lawful for a prince to forgive the punishment of offenders.
And assuredly the wise men have always held that commonweal to be well ordered: where very few things are left to the power of the Judges. But few such things had the Commonwealth of the Israelites. Yet had it some. That which was defined by the ⟨p. 264⟩laws, 1was in no wise to be remitted. Let not thine eye (saith God) spare thine own wife that sleepeth in thy bosom.
And assuredlie the wise men haue alwayes held that commonweale to be well ordered: where verie few thinges are left to the power of the Iudges. But fewe such thinges had the Commonwealth of the Israelites. Yet had it some. That which was defined by the ⟨p. 264⟩lawes, 1was in no wise to be remitted. Let not thine eye (saith God) spare thine owne wife that sleepeth in thy bosome.
What is the office of a king in promotion of godliness, look the Epistles 18. and 36. at the end of this book.
What is the office of a king in promotion of godlynesse, looke the Epistles 18. and 36. at the end of this booke.
24 Also there want not firme Arguments on the contrarie part. 1For first, it séemeth that a godly worke shoulde not be hindred: and it is a godly worke to punish the guiltie, séeing it profiteth the Common weale, and taketh awaie sinnes. Moreouer by this meanes the office of Princes is hindered. For they beare the sword: which if they vse not when time and cause requireth, they doe not their duetie. Besides: he that releaseth punishments giueth of anothers and not of his own, sith iudgement is the right of God, as it is written in the first Chapter of Deuteronomie. And in the second of Paralip. the 19. 2Chapter Iosaphat saieth: Exercise iudgement, not onely for man but as it were for God. And the punishments of the lawe can not be taken awaie vnlesse it be by him that appointed them. But God appointed the punishments for sinnes. Wherefore no man shoulde diminish or take them awaie. But that God appointed the punishment of death for grieuous sinnes, it appeareth out of the 18. Chapter of Deuteronomie, where it is thus written, 3that the people desired that God himselfe would not speake vnto them, because they might not abide so great a Maiestie: and for that they chose rather to heare Moses to be the interpretour: that GOD heard these prayers of the people, and promised not onely that he woulde giue Moses vnto them, but also woulde prouide that no Prophet should at any time be wanting vnto them. A Prophet (saieth he) will I raise vp vnto you from among your owne brethren. But he addeth: If any man will not heare that Prophet, I will make inquisition against him. Howbeit this place prooueth not, that that punishment was the punishment of death. More certaine is the other place in the 17. Chapter of Deuteronomie: If (saieth God) there shall happen a difficult case, 4yee shall goe vp to the high Priest or vnto a Leuite: and he that shall not heare the voyce of the Leuite or high Priest, or of the Iudge, shal die the death. But that was for changing the state of the Common weale. Samuels counsell was demaunded as concerning that matter, and he was not onely a Prophet but also a iudge; they gaue not eare vnto him therfore they were worthie of death. In déed, GOD might haue forgiuen them, but the Prince could not. Furthermore there is a waie opened vnto mischiefes, when men promise to themselues, that either through grace or rewarde they shall escape vnpunished.
25 But here must we consider, that some lawes there be humane, and other some diuine. ⟨p. 161⟩And it belongeth much to the state of this question, whether sort they be. For humane lawes, because they procéed of a weake reason, are neuer perfect: neither can they comprehend all things, or foresée all chaunces and circumstances. 1Wherefore oftentimes, if we shoulde seuerely and sharpely vrge the wordes of the lawe, many vniust things would be decréed. And so, there is oftentimes néede of moderation, 2and interpretation, and correction of the lawe. And moderation is the bridle and rule of humane lawes, when wee consider not so much the wordes themselues, as the counsell & minde of the writer. Furthermore, Lawiers may interprete mens lawes if they séeme doubtfull, eyther by other lawes, or by examples of former iudgements, or by the ordinance and custome of the Citie: or else according to iustice and saftie of the Common weale: but to correct or change, or to mitigate a lawe, is not any priuate mans part, but the office of the Prince alone, who made the Lawe. Wherefore Augustine in his Booke De vera Religione, A Iudge (saieth he) ought not to iudge of the lawe, but according to the lawe: otherwise all things would be bought. The same thing we haue in the Pandectes, De legibus & Senatus Consultis. But nowe can we not say that the lawes of God are vnperfect so as they containe not all things. For the minde of God is infinite and most perfect. Doubtlesse it is the part of wise men and diuines diligently to weigh and examine the lawes of God and to expound some places by other places, 3to consider the decrée and order which the Lord hath made, to discusse things that séeme to be repugnant, and to iudge of two lawes, 4when both of them cannot bée kept, whether is to be preferred before the other. For example: The lawe is that the Sabaoth day must be kept holy: there is another lawe that the Citie must be defended: it so falleth out sometime, that vnlesse wée fight on the Sabaoth day, the Citie cannot be defended. Here the better lawe must bée kept, namely, that the safetie of the Citie be defended. 5For God saith: I will haue mercie, not Sacrifice. And Christ answereth: that it is lawfull to doe good on the Sabaoth daie. 6The Lawe of God is, 7that we must obey our Parents. Another lawe is, that we must obey God: the Parentes commaund something, which is against the lawe of GOD:
26 Furthermore some commandements forbid a thing to be doone, others commaund or (as the Schoolemen speake:1) Some bée affirmatiue, others bee negatiue. Those lawes which forbid or denie any thing, doe euermore holde. As for example: wée are bound at all times that we shall not steale: that we shall not commit adulterie, &c. But those which commaund any thing, although that they also haue great strength, yet doe they not perpetuallie binde. If any shal giue vs a blowe vpon the right chéeke, 2wee are commaunded to offer vnto him the left. Assuredly wee ought alwayes to haue a minde readie so to doe: howbeit we are not bounde at all times, and towardes all men thus to doe: For this Christ himselfe did not, but being striken, aunswered: If I haue spoken euil, 3beare witnesse of the euill. And Paule: God (saieth he) shall strike thee thou painted wall. We must thus doe when eyther the glorie of God or the saluation of him that hath striken shall séeme to require it. God commaundeth that we shoulde come together to the holie congregation, to celebrate the Sacraments and to giue Almes. Yet doeth he not commaunde that we shoulde alwaies doe these things. But to what purpose is all this? 4namely hereunto: God commaundeth if any man shall not obey the Iudge or the high Priest, that he be slaine. This lawe in verie déede bindeth the Magistrate, yet not alwayes, ⟨p. 262⟩but when it may be doone: 5and sometime it happeneth that it cannot be. Neuerthelesse if thou punish not when it may bée, thou offendest the lawe of God. Moreouer we must take héede, that the greater good be not hindred by the lesser. Ioab was an euill man and a murtherer, and worthie to bée slaine by Dauid. But when Dauid sawe that he was able to do much with the armie, 6least any trouble and sedition shoulde arise, hée woulde not laie holde of him. And it may be that he spared Semei for the selfe same cause. 7In like maner Saul, least any trouble or sedition should arise, or least that the election should be disturbed, woulde not at that time kill the rebels. For otherwise he might not haue forgiuen them those punishmentes which were appointed by God. Nay rather he coulde not by sacrifices haue purged a sinne which had bin doone with a stretched out hand and of set purpose.
28 And as touching the clemencie of Augustus Caesar, I aunswere, 1that that lawe which we haue, Ad legem Iuliam maiestatis, was humane. For by what punishment conspirators must be afflicted, it was decréed by ⟨p. 263⟩princes, and so that lawe might be mitigated by him. He iudged it would be sufficient, if he had gréeuouslie rebuked Cinna: And assuredlie we reade in that historie, that he was greatlie vexed: and therefore he iudged it better, to remit somewhat of the punishment. But how small a portion must be remitted, 2iust moderation dooth declare. But humane lawes, when they followe the prescript of nature, must be accounted the lawes of God: As to put a murtherer to death. Herein must nothing be remitted by the Iudge. Doubtlesse, Clemencie is an habite wherewith by the gentlenesse of the minde we mitigate legal punishmentes within the limites of Iustice. 3Dauid forgaue Semei: I graunt, but yet when he perceiued that it was not lawfull that he should goe vnpunished, he commaunded Salomon that he should not suffer his gray hayres to escape vnpunished vnto the graue: Neuerthelesse, it was not expedient for Dauid himselfe to kill him. For first Semei being of the familie of Saul, he might séeme to be mooued with hatred against his posteritie. Further he had confirmed his words of whom he had béene called before, a bloudie man. Lastlie it was not méete for him to disturbe that gladnesse and gratulation of the people. After this sort he forgaue Ioab, 4who had killed two better men. For he sawe that he was able to doe much with the armie: Wherefore he also remitted him vnto Salomon. Howbeit it cannot be denyed, but that Dauid sinned, both when he absolued Amnon of Incest, and Absolon of parricide. But what Dauid refused to doe, that did God himselfe afterward by himselfe. 5For Amnon was slayne by Absolon, and Absolon being hanged on a trée, was thrust through by Ioab with a speare. And whereas Paul commendeth Onesimus vnto his Maister Philemon, 6that serueth not much to the purpose. For Philemon was a priuate man, and here was no prescribed lawe of God, onelie Paul prayeth him to forgiue priuate iniurie, which is a common thing vnto all Christians. He prayeth (I say) Philemon to let passe his wrath. And that he dooth not against the lawe of God, but according to the same.
129 But the fact of the Romans, in that at the feast of Easter they released vnto the Iewes some man that was bound and condemned, we cannot alowe. 2For God neuer commaunded, that in their solemnities any guiltie man should be released. Howbeit, the Romans by this meanes curried fauour with the Iewes, to the intent they might the more easilie beare that seruitude. 3The selfesame reason it was why Christian princes in the holy wéeke [of Easter] would open the prisons, and let foorth guiltie men: insomuch, that they were not verie skilful in the lawes of God. For if they had bin bound for debt, they had forgiuen not their owne but other mens. Againe, if for hainous offences, this had bin to open a windowe vnto mischiefe. But princes cannot easilie hold the meane. And in like case, as they will haue the Ministers of the word either to be poore wretches, or else after a sort to be princes and Gods, so doe they either punish the guiltie together with the innocent (as Theodosius did) or else they so spare all men, that nothing is administred seuerelie. And as touching Augustine, in déede I graunt that he intreated for the Donatistes: yet he denyed it not to be lawful for Magistrates to punish Hereticks. But when the Circumcellions or idle persons became cruel against the Christians, and that the Church was constrained to call for the helpe of princes, and that now these idle persons were punished, the Church séemed to be cruell and to prosecute her owne iniuries. Howbeit Augustine desireth not that they should be wholy forgiuen, but onelie that their bloud might not be shed. Yet howsoeuer it were, 4ye example of Augustine ought not to preiudice anie mans opinion, sith we liue by lawes, not by examples. At this day if a man had killed a Minister, or doone a robbery, who would intreate for him? But there was a refuge vnto the churches for such as were guiltie. Admit it were so, and we also doe not take away sanctuaries, for God permitted them. For if the cause be obscure, they may better be there than in prison while the same be knowen. Neuerthelesse the cause being manifest, God himselfe commaunded, that the wicked man should be taken from the verie altar and be slayne. These be the thinges which mooue me to thinke, that it is not lawfull for a prince to forgiue the punishment of offenders.