A67926:7584
Acts and monuments of matters most special and memorable, happening in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an universal history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitive age to these latter times of ours, with the bloody times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions against the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperors, as now lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realm of England and Scotland. Newly revised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time again published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the help of Christ our Lord) John Fox, which desireth thee good reader to help him with thy prayer.Actes and monuments of matters most speciall and memorable, happenyng in the Church. [vol. 2, part 1] with an vniuersall history of the same, wherein is set forth at large the whole race and course of the Church, from the primitiue age to these latter tymes of ours, with the bloudy times, horrible troubles, and great persecutions agaynst the true martyrs of Christ, sought and wrought as well by heathen emperours, as nowe lately practised by Romish prelates, especially in this realme of England and Scotland. Newly reuised and recognised, partly also augmented, and now the fourth time agayne published and recommended to the studious reader, by the author (through the helpe of Christ our Lord) Iohn Foxe, which desireth thee good reader to helpe him with thy prayer.
London: printed by John Daye, 1583London: printed by Iohn Daye, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To this Philpot replied, and said, you have not directly answered to the saying of the angel: Christ is risen, and is not here, because you have omitted that which was the chiefest point of all.1 For (said he) I proceeded further, as thus: He is risen, ascended, and sitteth at the right hand of God the father: Ergo, he is not remaining on the earth. Neither is your answer to Cyril, by me alleged, sufficient. But by and by I will return to your interpretation of Cyril, and more plainly declare the same, after that I have first refelled the authority of Chrysostom, which is one of your chief Principles that you alleged to make for your gross carnal presence in the sacrament. Which being well weighed and understanded, pertaineth nothing thereunto.
To this Philpot replied, and said, you haue not directly answeared to the saying of the angel: Christ is risen, and is not heere, because you haue omitted that which was ye chiefest poynt of all.1 For (sayd he) I proceeded further, as thus: He is risen, ascended, and sitteth at the right hande of God the father: Ergo, he is not remaining on the earth. Neither is your answere to Cyril, by me alleaged, sufficient. But by and by I will returne to your interpretation of Cyrill, and more plainly declare the same, after that I haue first refelled the authority of Chrysostome, which is one of your chief Principles that you alleaged to make for your grosse carnall presence in the sacrament. Which being wel weied and vnderstanded, pertaineth nothing thereunto.
At that the Prolocutor startled, that one of the chief pillars in this point should be overthrown, & therefore recited the said authority in Latin first, & afterward Englished the same, willing all that were present, to note that saying of Chrysostom, which he thought invincible on their side. But I shall make it appear, quoth Philpot, by and by to make little for your purpose. And as he was about to declare his mind in that behalf, the Prolocutor did interrupt him as he did, almost continually. Wherewith Philpot not being content,1 said: Master Prolocutor thinketh that he is in a Sophistry school, where he knoweth right well the manner is, that when the Respondent perceiveth that he is like to be enforced with an argument to the which he is not able to answer, then he doth what he can with cavillation & interruption to drive him from the same. This saying of Philpot was ill taken of the Prolocutor and his adherents: and the Prolocutor said, that Philpot could bring nothing to avoid that authority, but his own vain imagination. Hear quoth Philpot, and afterward judge. For I will do in this as all other authorities wherewith you shall charge me in refelling any of my arguments that I have to prosecute, answering either unto the same by sufficient authorities of scripture, or else by some other testimony of like authority to yours, & not of mine own imagination: the which if I do, I will it to be of no credit. And concerning the saying of Chrysostom, I have 2. ways to beat him from your purpose, the one out of Scripture, the other of Chrysostom him self, in the place here by you alleged.
At that the Prolocutour startled, that one of the chiefe pillers in this point should be ouerthrowen, & therfore recited the sayd authoritie in Latine first, & afterward Englished the same, wyllinge all that were present, to note that saying of Chrysostome, which he thought inuincible on their side. But I shall make it appeare, quoth Philpot, by and by to make litle for your purpose. And as he was about to declare his minde in that behalfe, the Prolocutor did interrupt him as he did, almost continually. Wherwith Philpot not being content,1 said: Master Prolocutour thinketh that he is in a Sophistrie schoole, where he knoweth right well the maner is, that when the Respondent perceiueth that he is like to be inforced with an argument to the which he is not able to answer, then he doth what he can with cauillation & interruption to driue him from the same. This saying of Philpot was ill taken of the Prolocutor and his adherents: and the Prolocutor said, that Philpot could bring nothing to auoid that authoritie, but his owne vaine imagination. Heare quoth Philpot, and afterward iudge. For I wil do in this as al other authorities wherwith you shal charge me in refelling any of my argumentes that I haue to prosecute, answearing either vnto the same by sufficient authorities of scripture, or els by some other testimonye of like authoritie to yours, & not of mine owne imagination: the which if I doe, I will it to be of no credite. And concerning the saying of Chrysostom, I haue 2. wayes to beat him from your purpose, the one oute of Scripture, the other of Chrysostome him selfe, in the place here by you alleaged.
First, where he seemeth to say, that Christ ascending, took his flesh with him,1 and least also his flesh behind him, truth it is: for we all do confess and believe that Christ took on him our humane nature in the virgin Mary's womb, and through his passion in the same, hath united us to his flesh, and thereby are we become one flesh with him, so that Chrysostom might therefore right well say, that Christ ascending took his flesh which he received of the virgin Mary, away with him: and also left his flesh behind him, which are we that be his elect in this world, which are the members of Christ, and flesh of his flesh: as very aptly S. Paul to the Ephes. in the 5. chap. doth testify, saying: We are flesh of his flesh, and bones of his bones. And if percase any man will reply, that he entreateth there of the Sacrament, so that this interpretation can not so aptly be applied unto him in that place,2 then will I yet interpret Chrysostom an other way by himself. For in that place a few lines before those words, which were here no rather read, are these words: that Christ after he Ascended into heaven, lea•t unto us endued with his Sacraments, his flesh in mysteries, that is, Sacramentally. And that mystical flesh Christ leaveth as well to his Church in the Sacrament of Baptism, as in the sacramental bread and wine. And that S. Paul justly doth witness, saying: As many of us as are baptised in Christ, have put upon us Christ. 3And thus you may understand that S. Chrysostom maketh nothing for your carnal and gross presence in the Sacrament, as you wrongfully take him.
First, where hee seemeth to say, that Christe ascending, tooke hys flesh with him,1 and least also hys flesh behinde him, truth it is: for we all do confesse and beleue that Christ tooke on hym oure humane nature in the virgine Maryes wombe, and through his passyon in the same, hath vnyted vs to hys flesh, and thereby are we become one fleshe with him, so that Chrysostome might therfore right well say, that Christ ascending tooke his fleshe which hee receiued of the virgin Mary, away with him: and also left his flesh behind him, which are we that be his electe in this worlde, whych are the mēbers of Christ, and flesh of his flesh: as very aptly S. Paul to the Ephes. in the 5. chap. doth testifie, saying: We are flesh of his flesh, and bones of his bones. And if percase any man will reply, that he entreateth there of the Sacrament, so that this interpretation can not so aptly be applied vnto him in that place,
Now in this mean while M. Pie rounded the Prolocutor in the ear to put Philpot to silence and to appoint some other, mistrusting lest he would shrewdly shake their carnal presence in conclusion, if he held on long, seeing in the beginning he gave one of their chief foundations such a pluck. Then the Prolocutor said to Philpot,1 that he had reasoned sufficiently enough, & that some other should now supply his room. Wherewith he was not well content, saying: Why sir, I have a dozen Arguments concerning this matter to be proposed, and I have not yet scarce overgone my first Argument: for I have not brought in any confirmation thereof out of any ancient writer (whereof I have for the same purpose many) being hitherto still letted by your oft interrupting of me.
Nowe in this meane while M. Pye rounded the Prolocutor in the eare to put Philpot to silence and to appoint some other, mistrusting lest he would shrodely shake theyr carnal presence in cōclusion, if he held on long, seeing in the beginning he gaue one of their chiefe foundations suche a plucke. Then the Prolocutor sayde to Philpot,1 that he had reasoned sufficiently enough, & that some other shuld now supply his rowme. Wherwith he was not wel cōtent, saying: Why sir, I haue a dosen Argumentes concerning this matter to be proposed, and I haue not yet scarce ouergone my first Argument: for I haue not brought in any confirmation therof out of any auncient wryter (whereof I haue for the same purpose manye) beinge hitherto still letted by your oft interrupting of me.
Well, quoth the Prolocutor, you shall speak no more now, and I command you to hold your peace. You perceive, quoth Philpot, that I have stuff enough for you, and am able to withstand your false supposition, and therefore you command me to silence. If you will not give place, quoth the Prolocutor, I will send you to prison. This is not,1 quoth Philpot, according to your promise made in this house, nor yet according to your brag made at Pauls cross, that men should be answered in this disputation, to whatsoever they can say, since you will not suffer me of a dozen arguments to prosecute one.
Wel, quoth ye Prolocutor, you shal speake no more now, and I commaund you to holde your peace. You perceyue, quoth Philpot, that I haue stuffe enoughe for you, and am able to withstand your false supposition, and therefore you commaund me to silence. If you will not geue place, quoth ye Prolocutor, I wil send you to prison. This is not,1 quoth Philpot, accordinge to youre promise made in this house, nor yet according to your brag made at Paules crosse, that men should be answeared in this disputation, to whatsoeuer they cā say, since you wil not suffer me of a dosen arguments to prosecute one.
Then M. Pie took upon him to promise that he should be answered an other day. Philpot seeing he might not proceed in his purpose, being therewith justly offended, ended, saying thus: A sort of you here, which hitherto have lurked in corners, and dissembled with God & the world, are now gathered together to suppress the sincere truth of Gods holy word, and to set forth every false devise, which by the Catholic doctrine of the Scripture, ye are not able to maintain.
Then M. Pie tooke vpon him to promise that he shuld be answeared an other day. Philpot seeing he myghte not proceede in hys purpose, being therewith iustly offended, ended, saying thus: A sort of you here, which hitherto haue lurked in corners, and dissembled with God & the worlde, are nowe gathered together to suppresse the sincere truthe of Gods holy woorde, and to sette foorth euerye false deuise, which by the Catholike doctrine of the Scripture, yee are not able to maintaine.
Then stepped forth M. Elmar Chaplain to the Duke of Suffolk:1 whom M. Moreman took upon him to answer. Against whom M. Elmar objected divers and sundry authorities for the confirming of the argument he toke the day before in hand to prove, that [Greek or Hebrew] in the sentence of Theodoret brought in by M. Cheiney,2 must needs signify substance, and not accidence. Whose reasons and approbations, because they were all grounded and brought out of the Greek I do pass over, for that they want their grace in English, and also their proper understanding.3 But his allegations so encumbered M. Moreman, that he desired a day to overview them, for at that instant he was without a convenient answer.
Then stepped forth M. Elmar Chapleine to the Duke of Suffolke:1 whome M. Moreman tooke vpon him to answeare. Against whō M. Elmar obiected diuers and sundry authorities for the confirming of the argument he toke the day before in hand to proue, that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in the sentence of Theodoret brought in by M. Cheiney,2 must needes signifie substance, and not accidence. Whose reasons and approbations, because they were all grounded and broughte out of the Greeke I doe passe ouer, for that they want theyr grace in English, and also their proper vnderstanding.3 But hys allegations so incombred M. Moreman, that hee desired a day to oueruiew them, for at that instant he was wythout a conuenient answeare.
Then did the Prolocutor call M. Haddon dean of Exeter, & Chaplain to the Duke of Suffolk,1 who prosecuted Theodoretes authority in confirming M. Elmar's argument. To whom D. Watson took upon him to give answer, who after long talk was so confounded, that he was not able to answer to the word Mysterium. But for as much as he seemed to doubt therein, M. Haddon took out of his bosom a Latin author to confirm his saying, & showed the same to M. Watson, asking him whether he thought that translation to be true, or that the Printer were in any fault.2 There may be a fault in the Printer, quoth Watson, for I am not remembered of this word. Then did M. Haddon take out of his bosom a Greek book, wherein he showed forth with his finger the same words, which M. Watson could not deny. His arguments further I omit to declare at large, because they were for the most part in Greek, about the bolting out of the true signification of [Greek or Hebrew].
Then did the Prolocutor cal M. Haddon deane of Exeter, & Chaplaine to the Duke of Suffolke,1 who prosecuted Theodoretes authoritie in confirminge M. Elmars argument. To whom D. Watson tooke vpon hym to geue aunswer, who after long talk was so confounded, that he was not able to answer to the word Mysterium. But for as much as he seemed to doubt therein, M. Haddon tooke out of his bosome a Latine author to confirme his saying, & shewed the same to M. Watson, asking him whether he thought yt translation to be true, or yt the Printer were in any faulte.2 There may be a fault in the Printer, quoth Watson, for I am not remembred of this worde. Then did M. Haddon take out of his bosome a Greeke booke, wherin he shewed forth with his finger the same wordes, whiche M. Watson could not deny. His arguments further I omit to declare at large, because they were for the moste parte in Greeke, about the boulting out of the true signification of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
Then stepped forth M. Perne,1 & in argument made declaration of his mind against transubstantiation, & confirmed the sayings and authorities alleged by M. Elmar & M. Haddon. To whom the Prolocutor answered, saying: I much marvel, M. Perne, that you will say thus, for so much as on friday last you subscribed to the contrary. Which his saying master Elmar did mislike, saying to the Prolocutor that he was to blame so to reprehend any man,2 partly for that this house (quoth he) is an house of free liberty for every man to speak his conscience, and partly for that you promised yester day, that notwithstanding any man had subscribed, yet he should have free liberty to speak his mind. And for that the night did approach, and the time was spent, the Prolocutor giving them praises for their learning, did yet notwithstanding conclude, that all reasoning set apart, the order of the holy church must be received, & all things must be ordered thereby.
Thē stept forth M. Perne,1 & in argument made declaration of his minde against transubstātiation, & confirmed the sayings and authorities alleaged by M. Elmar & M. Haddon. To whome the Prolocutor answered, saying: I much maruel, M. Perne, that you wil say thus, for somuch as on friday last you subscribed to the contrary. Which hys saying master Elmar did mislike, saying to the Prolocutor that he was to blame so to reprehend any man,2 partlye for that this house (quoth he) is an house of free libertye for euery man to speake his conscience, and partly for that you promised yester day, that notwtstanding any man had subscribed, yet he should haue free libertie to speake his mind. And for that the night did approche, and ye time was spent, the Prolocutor geuing them praises for their learning, did yet notwythstanding conclude, that al reasoning set apart, the order of the holy churche must be receiued, & all thyngs must be ordered thereby.
ON Friday the 27. of Octob. D. Weston the Prolocutor did first propound the matter, showing that the Convocation had spent 2. days in disputation already about one only doctor,1 which was Theodoret, & about one only word, which was [Greek or Hebrew]. Yet were they come the 3. day to answer all things that could be objected, so that they would shortly put out their arguments. So M. Haddon Dean of Exeter, desired leave to appose M. Watson, which with 2. other more, that is, Morgan & Harpsfield, was appointed to answer.2 M. Haddon demanded this of him, whether any substance of bread or wine did remain after the consecration. Then Master Watson asked of him again, whether he thought there to be a real presence of Christs body or no? M. Haddon said, it was not meet nor orderlike, that he which was appointed to be respondent, should be opponent, & he whose duty was to object, should answer. Yet M. Watson along while would not agree to answer, but that thing first being granted him. At last an order was set, and M. Haddon had leave to go forward with his argument.
ON Friday the 27. of Octob. D. Weston the Prolocutor did first propounde the matter, shewing that the Conuocation had spent 2. dayes in disputation already aboute one only doctor,1 which was Theodoret, & about one onely worde, which was 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Yet were they come the 3. daye to answer al things that could be obiected, so that they would shortly put out their argumēts. So M. Haddon Deane of Exeter, desired leaue to appose M. Watson, which wyth 2. other mo, that is, Morgan & Harpsfield, was apoynted to answer.2 M. Haddon demaunded this of him, whether any substāce of bread or wine did remaine after the consecration. Then Master Watson asked of him againe, whether he thought there to be a reall presence of Christes body or no? M. Haddon saide, it was not meete nor orderlike, that hee which was appoynted to be respondent, should be opponent, & he whose duty was to obiect, shuld answer. Yet M. Watson along while would not agree to answer, but that thing first being granted him. At last an order was set, and M. Haddon had leaue to go forwarde with his argument.
Then he proved by Theodorets words, a substance of bread and wine to remain. For these are his words: The same they were before the sanctification, 1which they are after. M. Watson said, that Theodoret meant not the same substance, but the same essence. Whereupon they were driven again unto the discussing of the Greek word [Greek or Hebrew], and M. Haddon proved it to mean a substance,2 both by the Etymology of the word, and by the words of the Doctor. For [Greek or Hebrew] (quoth he) cometh of the Participle [Greek or Hebrew], which descendeth of the verb [Greek or Hebrew], and so cometh the Noun [Greek or Hebrew], which signifieth substance.
Then he prooued by Theodorets words, a substance of breade and wine to remaine. For these are his wordes: The same they were before the sanctification, 1whiche they are after. M. Watson sayde, that Theodoret meant not the same substance, but the same essence. Whereupon they were driuen againe vnto the discussing of the Greeke woorde 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and M. Haddon prooued it to meane a substaunce,2 bothe by the Etimologie of the word, and by the wordes of the Doctor. For 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 (quoth he) cōmeth of the Participle 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which descendeth of the verbe 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and so commeth the Noune 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which signifieth substance.
Then M. Watson answered that it had not that signification only. But M. Haddon proved that it must needs so signify in that place. Then he asked Watson when the bread & wine became Symbols? Whereunto he answered: after the consecration and not before. Then gathered M. Haddon this reason out of his author.
Then M. Watson answeared that it had not that signification onely. But M. Haddon prooued yt it must nedes so signifie in that place. Then hee asked Watson when the bread & wine became Symboles? Wherunto he answered: after the consecration and not before. Then gathered M. Haddon this reason out of hys author.
Da- The same thing, sayeth Theodoret, that the bread and wine were before they were Symbols, the same they remain still in nature and substance,1 after they are Symbols.
Da- The same thing, saieth Theodoret, that the bread and wine were before they were Symboles, the same they remaine still in nature and substance,1 after they are Symboles.
ti- Bread and wine they were before:
si. Therefore bread and wine they are after.