pp. 1410–1417125 passagespart 1 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where as divers and uncertain rumours be spread abroad of the Disputation had in the Convocation house,1 to the intent that all men may know the certainty of all things therein done and said, as much as the memory of him that was present▪ thereat can bear away, he hath thought good at request, throughly to describe what was said therein on both parties of the matters argued and had in question, and of the entrance thereof.
WHere as dyuers and vncertayne rumoures bee spread abroad of the Disputation had in the Conuocation house,1 to the entent that all men may know the certaintie of all things therein done and sayd, as much as the memory of him that was present▪ thereat can beare away, hee hath thought good at request, throughly to describe what was sayd therein on both parties of the matters argued and had in question, and of the enteraunce thereof.
First upon Wednesday, being the 18. of October,1 at after noon, M. Weston the Prolocutor certified the house that it was the Queens pleasure,2 that the company of the same house being learned men, assembled, should debate of matters of Religion, and constitute laws thereof, which her grace and the Parliament would ratify. And for that (said he) there is a book of late set forth, called the Catechism (which he showed forth) bearing the name of this honourable Synod, & yet put forth without your consents as I have learned, being a book very pestiferous, and full of heresies, and likewise a book of Common prayer very abominable (as it pleased him to term it) I thought it therefore best, first to begin with the articles of the Catechism, concerning the sacrament of the altar, to confirm the natural presence of Christ in the same, and also transubstantiation: Wherefore (said he) it shall be lawful on Friday next ensuing, for all men freely to speak their conscience in these matters, that all doubts may be removed, and they fully satisfied therein.
FIrst vpon Wednesday, beyng the 18. of October,1 at after noone, M. Weston the Prolocutor certified the house that it was the Queenes pleasure,2 that the company of the same house beyng learned men, assembled, should debate of matters of Religion, and constitute lawes therof, which her grace and the Parliament would ratifie. And for that (sayd he) there is a booke of late set forth, called the Catechisme (which he shewed forth) bearing the name of this honorable Synode, & yet put forth without your consents as I haue learned, beyng a booke very pestiferous, and ful of heresies, and likewyse a booke of Common prayer very abominable (as it pleased hym to terme it) I thought it therfore best, first to beginne with the articles of the Catechisme, concernyng the sacrament of the aultar, to confirm the naturall presence of Christ in the same, and also transubstantiation: Wherfore (sayd he) it shall be lawfull on Friday next ensuyng, for all men freely to speake their conscience in these matters, that all doubts may be remooued, and they fully satisfied therein.
The Friday coming, being the 20. of October, when men had thought they should have entered Disputation of the questions proposed,1 the Prolocutor exhibited two several bills unto the house: the one for the natural presence of Christ in the sacrament of the altar, the other concerning the Catechism, that it was not of that houses agreement set forth, and that they did not agree thereunto: requiring all them to subscribe to the same, as he himself had done. Whereunto the whole house did immediately assent, except six, which were the Dean of Rochester,2 the Dean of Exeter, the Archdeacon of Winchester, the Archdeacon of Hertford, the Archdeacon of Stow, and one other. And while the rest were about to subscribe these two articles. John Philpot stood up and spake first concerning the Article of the Catechism, that he thought they were deceived in the title of the Catechism, in that it beareth the title of the Synod of London last before this, although many of them which then were present, were never made privy thereof, in setting it forth,3 for that this house had granted the authority to make ecclesiastical laws unto certain persons to be appointed by the kings majesty, & what so ever ecclesiastical laws they or the most part of them did set forth, according to a statute in that behalf provided, it might be well said to be done in the Synod of London, although such as be of this house now, had no notice thereof before the promulgation. And in this point he thought the setter forth thereof, nothing to have slandered the house as they by their subscription went about to persuade the world, since they had our Synodal authority unto them committed, to make such spiritual laws as they thought convenient and necessary.
The Friday commyng, beyng the 20. of October, whē men had thought they should haue entred Disputation of the questions proposed,1 the Prolocutor exhibited two seueral bils vnto the house: the one for the naturall presence of Christ in the sacrament of the aultar, the other concernyng the Catechisme, that it was not of that houses agrement set forth, and that they did not agree therunto: requiryng all them to subscribe to the same, as he hymselfe had done. Wherunto the whole house did immediately assent, except sixe, which were the Deane of Rochester,
And moreover he said, as concerning the article of the natural presence in the sacrament, that it was against reason ⟨p. 1411⟩and order of learning, and also very prejudicial to the truth, that men should be moved to subscribe before the matte were throughly examined and discussed. But when he saw that allegation might take no place,1 being as a man astonied at the multitude of so many learned men as there were of purpose gathered together to maintain old traditions more then the truth of Gods holy word, he made his request unto the Prolocutor, that where as there were so many ancient learned men present on that side,2 as in the realm the like again were not to be found in such number, & that on the other side of them that had not subscribed, were not past v. or vj. both in age and learning far inferior unto them: therefore, that equality might be had in this disputation, he desired that the Prolocutor would be a mean unto the Lords, that some of those that were learned, & setters forth of the same Catechism might be brought into the house to show their learning that moved them to set forth the same,3 and that D. Ridley & M. Rogers, with two or three more, might be licensed to be present at this disputation, and to be associate with them.
And moreouer he sayd, as concernyng the article of the naturall presence in the sacramēt, that it was against reason ⟨p. 1411⟩and order of learnyng, and also very preiudiciall to the truth, that men should be mooued to subscribe before the matte were throughly examined and discussed. But when he saw that allegation might take no place,1 being as a mā astonied at the multitude of so many learned men as there were of purpose gathered together to maintayne olde traditions more then the truth of Gods holy word, he made his request vnto the Prolocutor, that where as there were so many auncient learned men present on that side,2
This request was thought reasonable, and was proposed unto the Bishops, who made this answer: that it was not in them to call such persons unto our house, since some of them were prisoners. But they said, they would be petitioners in this behalf unto the Counsel, and in case any were absent that ought to be of the house, they willed them to be taken in unto them if they listed. After this they minding to have entered into disputation, there came a Gentleman as messenger from the Lord great master, signifying unto the Prolocutor, that the L. great master, and the Earle of Devonshire would be present at the disputations, and therefore he deferred the same unto monday, at one of the clock at after noon.
This request was thought reasonable, and was proposed vnto the Bishops, who made this aunswer: that it was not in them to call such persons vnto our house, since some of them were prisoners. But they sayd, they would be petitioners in this behalfe vnto the Counsayle, and in case any were absent that ought to bee of the house, they willed them to bee taken in vnto them if they listed. After this they mindyng to haue entred into disputation, there came a Gentleman as messenger from the Lord great master, signifiyng vnto the Prolocutor, that the L. great maister, and the Earle of Deuonshire would be present at the disputations, and therfore he deferred the same vnto monday, at one of the clocke at after noone.
Upon Monday the xiij. of October, at the time appointed,1 in the presence of many Earls, Lords, Knights, gentlemen, and divers other of the Court and of the City also, the Prolocutor made a Protestation, that they of the house had appointed this disputation, not to call the truth into doubt, to the which they had already all subscribed, saving v. or six, but that those gainsayers might be resolved of their arguments in the which they stood, as it shall appear unto you, not doubting but they will also condescend unto us.
Upon Monday the xiij. of October, at the time apointed,1 in the presence of many Erles, Lordes, Knights, gentlemen, and diuers other of the Court and of the Citie also, the Prolocutor made a Protestation, that they of the house had appoynted this disputation, not to call the truth into doubt, to the which they had alredy all subscribed, sauing v. or sixe, but that those gainsayers might be resolued of their arguments in the which they stood, as it shall appeare vnto you, not doubting but they will also condescēd vnto vs.
1Then he demanded of M. Haddon whether he would reason against the questions proposed, or no. To whom he made answer, that he had certified him before in writing, that he would not, since the request of such learned men as were demanded to be assistant with them, would not be granted. M. Elmar likewise was asked. Who made the Prolocutor the like answer, adding moreover this, that they had done too much prejudice already to the truth, to subscribe before the matter was discussed: and little or nothing it might avail to reason for the truth, since all they were now determined to the contrary. After this he demanded of M. Cheyney, whom the Prolocutor said allowed the presence with them,2 but he denied the transubstantiation by the means of certain authorities upon the which he standeth, and desireth to be resolved, as you shall hear, whether he will propose his doubts concerning Transubstantiation or no. Yea, quoth he, I would gladly my doubts to be resolved, which move me not to believe Transubstantiation.
1Then he demanded of M. Haddon whether he would reason against the questions proposed, or no. To whom he made answer, that he had certified hym before in writyng, that he would not, since the request of such learned men as were demaunded to be assistent with them, would not bee graunted. M. Elmar likewyse was asked. Who made the Prolocutor the like aunswer, addyng moreouer this, that they had done too much preiudice already to the truth, to subscribe before the matter was discussed: and little or nothyng it might auayle to reason for the truth, since all they were now determined to the contrary. After this he demaunded of M. Cheyney, whome the Prolocutor sayd allowed the presence with them,2 but he denyed the transubstantiation by the meanes of certayne authorities vppon the which he standeth, and desireth to be resolued, as you shall heare, whether he will propose his doubtes concernyng Transubstantiation or no. Yea, quoth he, I would gladly my doubts to be resolued, which mooue me not to beleeue Transubstantiation.
The first is out of S. Paul to the Cor. who speaking of the Sacrament of the body and blood of Christ,1 calleth it oft times bread after the consecration.
The first is out of S. Paule to the Cor. who speakyng of the Sacrament of the body and bloud of Christ,1 calleth it oft tymes bread after the consecration.
The second is out of Origene, who speaking of this sacrament saith, that the material part thereof goeth down to the excrements.
The second is out of Origene, who speaking of this sacrament sayth, that the materiall part therof goeth down to the excrements.
The third is out of Theodoretus, who making mention of the sacramental bread and wine after the consecration, saith that they go not out of their former substance, form, and shape. These be some of my doubts among many other, wherein I require to be answered.
The third is out of Theodoretus, who making mention of the sacramentall bread and wine after the consecration, saith that they go not out of their former substance, forme, and shape. These be some of my doubts among many other, wherein I require to be answered.
Then the Prolocutor assigned D. Moreman to answer him,1 who to Saint Paul answered him thus: That the Sacrament is called by him bread in deed, but it is thus to be understood, that it is the sacrament of bread, that is, the form of bread.
Then the Prolocutor assigned D. Moreman to answer him,1 who to Saint Paule answered him thus: That the Sacrament is called by hym bread in deede, but it is thus to be vnderstood, that it is the sacrament of bread, that is, the forme of bread.
Then M. Cheyney inferred and alleged, that Hesychius called the sacrament both bread and flesh.
Then M. Cheyney inferred and alledged, that Hesychius called the sacrament both bread and flesh.
1Yea quoth Moreman, Hesychius calleth it bread, because it was bread, & not because it is so. And passing over Origen, he came to Theodoretus, & said, that men mistook his authority, by interpreting a general into a special, as Peter Martyr hath done in the place of Theodoret, interpreting [Greek or Hebrew], for substance,2 which is a special signification of the word whereas [Greek or Hebrew], is a general word, as well to accidence, as to substance, and therefore I answer thus unto Theodoret, that the sacramental bread and wine do not go out of their former substance, form, and shape, that is to say, not out of their accidental substance and shape.
1Yea quoth Moreman, Hesychius calleth it bread, because it was bread, & not because it is so. And passing ouer Origen, he came to Theodoretus, & sayd, that men mistooke hys authoritie, by interpreting a general into a special, as Peter Martyr hath done in ye place of Theodoret, interpretyng 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, for substance,2 which is a special signification of ye word whereas 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, is a general word, as well to accidence, as to substane, and therefore I answer thus vnto Theodoret, yt the sacramental bread and wine do not go out of their former substance, forme, and shape, that is to say, not out of their accidentall substance and shape.
After this M. Cheyney sat him down, & by and by M. Elmar stood up as one that could not abide to hear so fond an answer to so grave an authority,1 & reasoned upon the authority of Theodoret alleged before by M. Cheyney▪ & declared that Moreman's answer to Theodoret, was no just nor sufficient answer, but an illusion and a subtle evasion contrary to Theodorets meaning. For, said he, if [Greek or Hebrew], should signify an accident in the place alleged, as it is answered by M. Moreman, then were it a word superfluous set in Theodoret there, where do follow two other words which sufficiently do expound the accidences of the bread, that is [Greek or Hebrew], which signify in English, shape and form: & so prove out of the same author by divers allegations,2 that [Greek or Hebrew], in Greek could not be so generally taken in that place as Moreman for a shift would have it. But Moreman, as a man having no other salve for that sore, affirmed still that [Greek or Hebrew], which signifieth substance, must needs signify an accidental substance properly. To whose importunity, since he could have no other answer. Elmar as a man wearied with his importunity, gave place.
After this M. Cheyney sat him downe, & by and by M. Elmar stood vp as one that could not abide to heare so fōd an answer to so graue an authoritie,1 & reasoned vpon the authoritie of Theodoret alledged before by M. Cheyney▪ & declared that Moremans aunswer to Theodoret, was no iust nor sufficient answer, but an illusion and a subtill euasion contrary to Theodorets meaning. For, said he, if 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, should signify an accident in the place alledged, as it is answered by M. Moreman, then were it a word superfluous set in Theodoret there, where do follow two other wordes which sufficiently do expound the accidēces of ye bread, yt is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which signify in English, shape and forme: & so prooue out of the same author by diuers allegations,2
After this stood up John Philpot and said,1 that he could prove that by the matter that Theodoret entreateth of in the place above alleged, and by the similitude which he maketh to prove his purpose, by no means M. Moreman's interpretation of [Greek or Hebrew], might be taken for an accidē tall substance, as he for a shift would interpret it to be. For the matter which Theodoret entreateth of in that place,2 is against Eutiches an heretic, which denied two natures of substance to remain in Christ being one person, and that his humanity after the accomplishment of the mystery of our salvation, ascending into heaven,3 & being joined unto the Divinity, was absorpt or swallowed up of the same, so that Christ should be no more but of one divine substance only by his opinion. Against which opinion Theodoret writeth, and by the similitude of the sacrament proveth the contrary against the heretic: that like as in the sacrament of the body of Christ after the consecration, there is the substance of Christs humanity, with the substance of bread, remaining as it was before, not being absorpt of the humanity of Christ, but joined by the divine operation thereunto, even so in the person of Christ being now in heaven, of whom this sacrament is a representation, there be two several substances, that is, his divinity & humanity united in one hypostasie or person, which is Christ, the humanity not being absorpt by the conjunction of the divinity, but remaining in his former substance.
After this stood vp Iohn Philpot and sayd,1 yt hee could prooue that by the matter that Theodoret intreateth of in the place aboue alledged, and by the similitude whiche hee maketh to prooue his purpose, by no meanes M. Moremans interpretation of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, might be taken for an accidē tall substaunce, as he for a shift would interprete it to be. For the matter which Theodoret intreateth of in yt place,2 is against Eutiches an hereticke, whiche denied two natures of substance to remayne in Christ beyng one person, and that his humanitie after the accomplishment of ye mysterie of our saluation, ascendyng into heauen,
And this similitude quoth Philpot, brought in of Theodoret to confound Eutiches, should prove nothing at all, if the very substance of the sacramental bread did not remain, as it did before. But if D. Moreman's interpretation might take place for transubstantiation, then should the heretic have thereby a strong argument by Theodorets authority, so taken to maintain his heresy,1 and to prove himself a good christen man, and he might well say thus unto Theodoret. Like as thou Theodoret, if thou were of D. Moreman's mind, doest say, that after the consecration in the sacrament, the substance of the bread is absorpt or transubstantiate into the humane body of Christ coming thereunto, so that in the sacrament is now but one substance of the humanity alone, and not the substance of bread as it was before: even likewise may I affirm and conclude by thine own similitude, that the humanity ascending up by the power of God into heaven, & adjoined unto the deity, was by the might thereof absorpt & turned into one substance with the deity: so that now there remaineth but one divine substance in Christ, no more then in the sacramental signs of the Lords supper,2 after the consecration doth remain any more then one substance, according to your belief and construction.
And this similitude quoth Philpot, brought in of Theodoret to confound Eutiches, should prooue nothing at al, if the very substance of the sacramentall bread dyd not remayne, as it did before. But if D. Moremans interpretation might take place for transubstantiatiō, then should the heretike haue thereby a strong argument by Theodorets authoritie, so taken to maintayne his heresie,1 and to prooue hymselfe a good christen man, and he might well say thus vnto Theodoret. Like as thou Theodoret, if thou were of D. Moremans mynd, doest say, that after the consecration in the sacrament, the substaunce of the bread is absorpt or transubstantiate into the humane body of Christ commyng thereunto, so that in the sacrament is now but one substance of the humanitie alone, and not the substance of bread as it was before: euen likewise may I affirme and conclude by thine owne similitude, that the humanitie ascending vp by the power of God into heauen, & adioyned vnto the deitie, was by the might therof absorpt & turned into one substance with the deitie: so that now there remayneth but one diuine substance in Christ, no more then in the sacramental signes of the Lords supper,
In answering to this D. Moreman staggered, whose defect Philpot perceiving, spake on this wise. Well, M. Moreman, if you have no answer at this present ready, I pray you devise one, if you can conveniently, against our next meeting here again.1
In aunsweryng to this D. Moreman stackerd, whose defect Philpot perceiuyng, spake on this wyse. Well, M. Moreman, if you haue no answer at this present ready, I pray you deuise one, if you can conueniently, agaynst our next meetyng here agayne.1
With that his saying the Prolocutor was grievously offended, telling him that he should not brag there, but that he should be fully answered· Then said Philpot, it is the thing that I only desire, to be answered directly in this behalf, & I desire of you, & of all the house at this present▪ that I may be sufficiently answered, which I am sure you are not able to do, saving Theodoretus authority and similitude ⟨p. 1412⟩upright, as he ought to be taken. None other answer then was made to Philpots reasons, but that he was commanded to silence.
With that his saying the Prolocutor was grieuously offended, tellyng hym that he should not bragge there, but that he should be fully answered· Then sayd Philpot, it is the thing that I only desire, to be answered directly in this behalfe, & I desire of you, & of all the house at this present▪ that I may be sufficiently answered, which I am sure you are not able to do, sauyng Theodoretus authoritie and similitude ⟨p. 1412⟩vpright, as he ought to be taken. None other answer then was made to Philpots reasons, but that hee was commaunded to silence.
Then stood up the Dean of Rochester offering him self to reason in the first question against the natural presence,1 wishing that the scripture and the ancient Doctors in this point might be weighed, believed, and followed. And against this natural presence he thought the saying of Christ in Saint Matthew to make sufficiently enough, if men would credit and follow scripture, who said there of himself, that poor men we should have alway with us, but him we should not have always: which was spoken, quoth he, concerning the natural presence of Christs body, therefore we ought to believe as he hath taught, that Christ is not naturally present on earth in the sacrament of the altar.
Then stoode vp the Deane of Rochester offeryng hym selfe to reason in the first question agaynst the natural presence,1 wishing that the scripture and the auncient Doctors in this poynt might be weyghed, beleeued, and followed. And agaynst this naturall presence he thought the saying of Christ in Saint Mathew to make sufficiently enough, if men would credite and follow scripture, who sayd there of hymselfe, that poore men wee should haue alway with vs, but hym we should not haue alwayes: which was spoken, quoth he, concernyng the naturall presence of Christes body, therefore we ought to beleeue as hee hath taught, that Christ is not naturally present on earth in the sacrament of the aultar.
But the Dean prosecuted his argument, and showed it out of S. Austen further,1 that the same interpretation of the scripture alleged, was no sufficient answer, who writeth in the 50. treatise of S. John on this wise, on the same sentence: When as he said (saith S. Austen) me shall ye not have always with you, he spake of the presence of his body. For by his majesty, 2by his providence, by his unspeakable & unuisible grace, that is fulfilled which is said of him. Behold I am with you until the consummation of the world. But in the flesh which the word took upon him, in that which was borne of the virgin, 3in that which was apprehended of the Jews, which was crucified on the Cross, which was let down from the cross, which was wrapped in clouts, which was hid in the Sepulchre, which was manifested in the resurrection, you shall not have me always with you. And why? for after a bodily presence he was conversant with his disciples forty days, and they accompanying him, seeing and not following him, he ascended & is not here, for there he sitteth at the right hand of the father, and yet here he is, because he is not departed in the presence of his majesty. After another manner we have Christ always by presence of his majesty, but after the presence of his flesh it is rightly said: You shall not verily have me always with you. For the Church had him in the presence of his flesh a few days, and now by faith it apprehendeth him and seeth him, not with eyes.
But the Deane prosecuted his argument, and shewed it out of S. Austen further,1 that the same interpretation of the scripture alledged, was no sufficient aunswere, who writeth in the 50. treatise of S. Iohn on this wise, on the same sentence: When as he sayd (sayth S. Austen) me shal ye not haue always with you, he spake of the presence of his bodye. For by his maiestie, 2by his prouidence, by his vnspeakable & vnuisible grace, that is fulfilled which is sayd of him. Behold I am with you vntill the consummation of the world. But in the fleshe which the worde tooke vpon hym, in that which was borne of the virgin,
1To this authority D. Watson took upon him to answer, and said, he would answer S. Austen by S. Austen, and having a certain book in his hand of notes, he alleged out of the 70. treatise upon S. John, that after that mortal condition and manner we have not now Christ on the earth as he was heretofore before his passion.
1To this authority D. Watson tooke vpon him to aunswer, and sayd, he would answer S. Austen by S. Austen, and hauyng a certaine booke in hys hand of notes, he alledged out of the 70. treatise vpon S. Iohn, that after that mortall condition and maner we haue not now Christ on the earth as he was heretofore before his passion.
Against whose answer, John Philpot replied and said,1 that M. Watson had not fully answered S. Augustine by S. Augustine, as he would seem to have done, for that in the place above mentioned by M. Dean of Rochester, he doth not only teach the mortal state of Christs body before his passion, but also the immortal condition of the same after his resurrection: in the which mortal body S. Augustine seemeth plainly to affirm, that Christ is not present upon the earth, neither in form visibly, neither in corporal substance invisibly, as in few lines after the place above alleged. S. Augustine doth more plainly declare by these words, saying: Now these two manners of Christs presence declared, which is by his majesty, providence, & grace now present in the world, which before his ascension was present in flesh, and being now placed at the right hand of the father, is absent in the same from the world, I think (saith Saint Augustine) that there remaineth no other question in this m•t•er.
Agaynst whose aunswer, Iohn Philpot replyed and said,1 that M. Watson had not fully answered S. Augustine by S. Augustine, as he would seeme to haue done, for that in the place aboue mentioned by M. Deane of Rochester, he doth not onely teach the mortall state of Christes body before his passion, but also the immortall condition of the same after his resurrection: in the which mortal body S. Augustine seemeth plainely to affirme, that Christ is not present vpon the earth, neither in forme visibly, neither in corporall substance inuisibly, as in few lynes after ye place aboue alledged. S. Augustine doth more plainely declare by these wordes, saying: Now these two manners of Christes presence declared, which is by his maiestie, prouidence, & grace now present in the world, which before his ascension was present in flesh, and beyng now placed at the right hand of the father, is absent in the same from the world, I thinke (saith Saint Augustine) that there remayneth no other question in thys m•t•er.
Now quoth Philpot, if S. Augustine acknowledged no more presence of Christ to be now on earth, but only his divine presence, and touching his humanity to be in heaven, we ought to confess and believe the same. But if we put a third presence of Christ, that is, corporally to be present always in the sacrament of the altar invisibly, according to your suppositions, whereof S. Augustine maketh no mention at all in all his works: you shall seem to judge that which S. Augustine did never comprehend.
Now quoth Philpot, if S. Augustine acknowledged no more presence of Christ to be now on earth, but onely his diuine presence, and touching his humanitie to bee in heauen, we ought to confesse and beleeue the same. But if we put a third presence of Christ, that is, corporally to bee present always in the sacrament of the aultar inuisibly, according to your suppositions, whereof S. Augustine maketh no mention at all in all his works: you shal seeme to iudge that which S. Augustine did neuer comprehend.
1Why, quoth Watson, S. Augustine in the place by me alleged, maketh he not mention how S. Steven being in this world, saw Christ after his ascension?
1Why, quoth Watson, S. Augustine in the place by me alledged, maketh he not mention how S. Steuen beyng in this world, saw Christ after his ascension?
It is true, said Philpot, but he saw Christ, as the scripture telleth,1 in the heavens being open, standing at the right hand of God the father. Further to this Watson answered not.
It is true, said Philpot, but he saw Christ, as the scripture telleth,1 in the heauens beyng open, standyng at the right hand of God the father. Further to this Watson answered not.
Then the Prolocutor went about to furnish up an answer to S. Augustine, saying, that he is not now in the world after that manner of bodily presence,1 but yet present for all that in his body.
Then the Prolocutor went about to furnish vp an answere to S. Augustine, saying, that he is not now in the world after that maner of bodily presence,1 but yet present for all that in his body.
To whom Philpot answered, that the Prolocutor did grate much upon this word Secundum, in S. Augustine,1 which signifieth after the manner, or in form: but he doth not answer to id quod, which is that thing or substance of Christ, in the which Christ suffered, arose, and ascended into heaven, in the which thing and substance he is in heaven, and not on earth, as S. Augustine in the place specified most clearly doth define.
To whom Philpot answered, that the Prolocutor dyd grate much vpon this worde Secundum, in S. Augustine,1 which signifieth after the maner, or in forme: but he doth not answer to id quod, which is that thyng or substance of Christ, in the which Christ suffred, arose, and ascended into heauen, in the which thing and substance he is in heauen, and not on earth, as S. Augustine in the place specified most clearely doth define.
To this nothing else being answered, the Dean of Rochester proceeded in the maintenance of his argument,1 and read out of a book of Annotations, sundry authorities for the confirmation thereof. To the which Moreman, who was appointed to answer him, made no direct answer, but bade him make an argument,2 saying that master Dean had recited many words of Doctors, but he made not one argument.
To this nothing els beyng aunswered, the Deane of Rochester proceeded in the maintenance of his argument,1 and read out of a booke of Annotations, sundry authorities for the confirmation therof. To the which Moreman, who was appointed to answer him, made no direct aunswer, but bade him make an argument,2 saying that maister Deane had recited many wordes of Doctors, but he made not one argument.
Then said the Dean, the authorities of the doctors by me rehearsed, be sufficient arguments to prove mine intent, to the which my desire is to be answered of you. But still Moreman cried, make an argument to shift of the authority, which he could not answer unto. After this the Dean made this argument out of the institution of the sacrament: Do this in remembrance of me: and thus ye shall show forth the Lords death until he come.
Then said the Deane, the authorities of the doctors by me rehersed, be sufficient arguments to proue mine intent, to the which my desire is to be answered of you. But still Moreman cried, make an argument to shift of the authoritie, which he could not answer vnto. After this ye Deane made this argument out of the institution of the sacramēt: Do this in remembraunce of me: and thus ye shall shew foorth the Lordes death vntill he come.
The sacrament is the remembrance of Christ: Ergo, 1the sacrament is not very Christ: for yet he is not come. For these words, Until he come, do plainly signify the absence of Christs body. Then the Prolocutor went about to show that these words Until he come, 2did not import any absence of Christ on the earth, by other places of scripture, where, Donec, until, was used in like sense: but directly to the purpose he answered nothing.
The sacrament is the remembrance of Christ: Ergo, 1the sacrament is not very Christ: for yet he is not come. For these words, Vntill he come, do plainly signify the absence of Christes bodye. Then the Prolocutor went about to shew that these wordes Vntill he come, 2did not import any absence of Christ on the earth, by other places of scripture, where, Donec, vntill, was vsed in like sense: but directly to the purpose he answered nothing.
In conclusion, the Dean fell to questioning with Moreman, whether Christ did eat the Paschal lamb with his disciples, or no? He answered, Yea. Further, he demanded whether he eat likewise the Sacrament with them, as he did institute it? Moreman answered, Yea.1 Then he asked what he did eat, and whether he eat his own natural body, as they imagine it to be, or no? Which when Moreman had affirmed, then said the Dean, it is a great absurdity by you granted, and so he sate down.
In conclusiō, the Deane fel to questioning with Moreman, whether Christ did eate the Paschal lambe with hys disciples, or no? He answered, Yea. Further, he demanded whether he eate likewise the Sacrament with them, as he did institute it? Moreman aunswered, Yea.1 Then he asked what he did eate, and whether he eate his owne naturall body, as they imagine it to be, or no? Which when Moreman had affirmed, then said the Deane, it is a great absurditie by you granted, and so he sate downe.
Against this absurdity, Philpot stood up and argued,1 saying, he could prove it by good reason deduced out of scripture, that Christ eat not his own natural body at the institution of the sacrament, and the reason is this.
Against this absurditie, Philpot stood vp and argued,1 saying, he could proue it by good reason deduced out of scripture, that Christ eat not his owne natural body at the institution of the sacrament, and the reason is this.
ro- Christ eating the sacrament, had no promise of remission of sin.
ro- Christ eating the sacrament, had no promise of remission of sinne.
co. Ergo, Christ in the Sacrament did not eat his own body.
co. Ergo, Christ in the Sacrament did not eate his owne body.