A JUST DEFENCE OF THE FORMER DISCOURSE AND ARGUMENTS AGAINST THE ANSWER OF A NAMELESS Popish Priest thereunto:A IVST DEFENCE OF THE FORMER DISCOVRSE AND ARGVMENTS AGAINST THE ANSWER OF A NAMELES Popish Priest thereunto:
pp. 35–233513 passagespart 10 of 13
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. Look how this man argueth, so did the Heretics of old, to prove our Saviour Christ to have an airy, spiritual, and fantastical body. kLet it not deceive you, you simple sots, (saith John of Jerusalem) when you read that lChrist showed Thomas his hands and his side, or when you hear him say, that he hath mflesh and bones: These things he made some show of indeed to strengthen the saith of his doubting Disciples. But he showed that he had an airy and spiritual body in truth, when nhe came to his Disciples while ⟨p. 164⟩the doors were shut, and ohe vanished out of their sight. And to the like purpose did pthe Marcionites urge his qescape from those of Nazareth. Now what do the ancient Fathers hereunto answer? rThat Christs body (saith Tertullian) is no fancy ever, hereby appeareth, in that it endured violent handling, when he was taken and held, and haled to the hill-brow. For salbeit he made an escape through the midst of them, being first forcibly held, and after let go, either the throng being dissolved, or forcibly broken through; yet was it not by any fantastical delusion. For he had a true body still, and hands that he touched others still with, and were by them felt; (and then his body belike was not impalpable as this fellow saith it was.) And again, twhen Christ showeth his Disciples his hands and his feet, without doubt he hath hands, and feet, and bones, which a spirit hath not. And Jerome refuting John of Jerusalem;
As Christ showed his Disciples true hands and a true side; so he ate truly with them, spake with his tongue truly to them, and with his hands truly brake, and reached them out bread. For that he suddenly vanished out of their sight; as before his passion also at Nazareth he passed through the midst of them, that is, he made an escape out of their hands,
Could not Christ do as much as some Magicians have done? Apollonius, as he stood in the Court before Domitian, vanished suddenly out of sight. Yet do you not therefore match Christs power with Magicians jugglings in making him seem to be that that he was not, to eat without teeth, break bread without hands, walk without feet, speak without tongue, show a side without ribs. And whereas it might be demanded how it came to pass that
those two Disciples did not know him, till a little before he left them;
2. Looke how this man argueth, so did the Heret•kes of old, to prooue our Sauiour Christ to haue an aiery, spirituall, aad fantasticall body. kLet it not deceiue you, you simple sots, (saith Iohn of Ierusalem) when you reade that lChrist shewed Thomas his hands and his side, or when you heare him say, that he hath mflesh and bones: These things he made some shew of indeede to strenghthen the saith of his doubting Disciples. But he shewed that hee had an ai•ry and spirituall body in truth, when nhe came to his Disciples while ⟨p. 164⟩the doores were shut, and ohee vanished out of their sight. And to the like purpose did pthe Marci•nites vrge his qescape frō those of Nazareth. Now what do the ancient Fathers hereunto answer? rThat Christs body (saith Tertullian) is no fancy euer, hereby appeareth, in that it end•red violent handling, when hee was taken and held, and haled to the hill-brow. For salbeit hee made an escape through the midst of them, being first forcibly held, and after let goe, either the throng being dissolued, or forcibly broken through; yet was it not by any fantasticall delusion. For he had a true body still, and hands that hee touched others still with, and were by them felt; (and then his body belike was not impalpable as this fellow saith it was.) And againe, twhen Christ sheweth his Disciples his hands and his feet, without doubt he hath hands, and feet, and bones, which a spirit hath not. And Ierome refuting Iohn of Ierusalem; uAs Christ shewed his Disciples true hands and a true side; so hee ate truely with them, spake with his tongue truely to them, and with his hands truely brake, and reached them out bread. For that he suddenly vanished out of their sight; as before his passion also at Nazareth he passed through the midst of them, that is, he made an escape out of their hands, *it was done by his diuine power, not by any fantasticall delusion. “Could not Christ doe as much as some Magitians haue done? Apollonius, as he stood in the Court before Domitian, vanished suddenly out of sight. Yet doe you not therefore match Christs power with Magicians iuglings in making him seeme to bee that that hee was not, to eate without teeth, breake bread without hands, walke without feet, speake without tongue, shew a side without ribs. And whereas it might be demanded how it came to passe that xthose two Disciples did not know him, till a little before hee left them;
kJoan. Hieroscl. Ep in Fpist Hieren. contr. error. […].Ioan. Hieroscl. Ep in Fpist Hieren. contr. •rror. 〈…〉.
rTertul, contr. Marc lib. 4.Tertul, cōtr. Marc lib. 4.
sEtsi per medios evasit, sed ante jam vim expertus, & post à dimissus scil. soluto, uti assolet, tumultu, vel etiam irrupto, non tamen per caliginem eluso &c.Etsi per medios euasit, sed ante iam vim expertus, & poste à dimissus scil. soluto, vti assolet, tumultu, vel etiam irrupto, non tamen per caliginem eluso &c.
tIdem contr. eund. lib. 5.
uHieron. ad Pammach. contra error. Joan. Hieros.Hieron. ad Pāmach. contra error. Ioan. Hieros.
*Virtus Dei est, non umbtae aut phantasmatis.Virtus Dei est, non vmbtae aut phantasmatis.
“Quod Magis licet, hoc Domino non licet? Apollonius, &c. repente non comparuit. Noli potentiam Domini Magorū praestigiis coaequa re, ut videatur fuisse quod nō suit, comedisse sine dentibus, fregisse panem sine manibus, ambulasse sine pedibus, locutus sine lingua, latus •stendisse sine costis.Quod Magis licet, hoc Domino non licet? Apollonius, &c. repente non comparuit. Noli potentiam Domini Magorū praestigiis coaequa re, vt videatur fuisse quod nō suit, comedisse sine dentibus, fregisse panem sine manibus, ambulasse sine pedibus, locutus sine lingua, latus •stendisse sine costis.
yJerome maketh answer out of the Text it self, that it was not because his body was not the same it had been, but because their eyes were held that they might not know him. And the same ⟨p. 165⟩Jerome else-where dealing against the same dotages, zChrist (saith he) had hands and sides, had breast and belly too: he that had hands and feet, had arms and thighs too. And seeing he had all the members of the body, he must needs have a whole body that consisteth of those members. Let us reason backward, as well we may. If Christ have an entire body consisting of those limbs, then he hath all those limbs, whereof such a body consisteth. And then let us say to these, as he then to them, aYou hear of flesh, and feet, and hands, and other limbs. And bdo you forge us some cStoical round balls, and airy dotages. (As these do little round wafer-cakes, which they bear us down to be Christs body.) He alludeth to the Stoics, who held that the Gods had some shape; and dthat shape was as a body, but yet no body; and had as it were blood and yet no blood. Wherein the Marcionites also in a manner agreed with them, (and our Romanists at this day with either) imagining our Saviour (e saith Tertullian) to have fflesh hard without bones, solid without muscles, bloody without blood, clad without coat, speaking without tongue, eating without teeth, &c. Whereupon Tertullian concludeth, that since Christ had all his limbs when he showed them to his Disciples, they that imagined such a Christ as this, gthat deceiveth, beguileth, and deludeth all mens eyes, and senses and touchings, (and taste too he might have said, we at least may say) should not bring him from heaven (from whence the Marcionites said their Christ had his body, though the Papists dare not say, they have theirs from thence) but fetch him rather out of some hjugglers box (the Popish pyx, or the like) not to work salvation, but to make sport with. This I have the rather insisted upon to show how the Papists jump in their conceits ⟨p. 166⟩about this their breaden God; and strange fantastical body, that hath all parts of a mans body, and yet none at all to be seen, felt, heard, yea or understood, with the Heretics of old time; and to confirm these their dotages use and urge the very same Arguments that they then did, by the ancient Fathers long since answered:
yIerome maketh answer out of the Text it selfe, that it was not because his body was not the same it had beene, but because their eyes were held that they might not know him. And the same ⟨p. 165⟩Ierome else-where dealing against the same dotages, zChrist (saith hee) had hands and sides, had breast and bellie too: he that had hands and feete, had armes and thighes too. And seeing hee had all the members of the body, hee must needs haue a whole body that consisteth of those members. Let vs reason backward, as well wee may. If Christ haue an entire body consisting of those limmes, then he hath all those limmes, whereof such a body consisteth. And then let vs say to these, as he then to them, aYou heare of flesh, and feet, and hands, and other limmes. And bdoe you forge vs some cStoicall round bals, and aiery dotages. (As these doe little round wafer-cakes, which they beare vs downe to be Christs body.) He alludeth to the Stoicks, who held that the Gods had some shape; and dthat shape was as a body, but yet no body; and had as it were blood and yet no blood. Wherein the Marcionites also in a manner agreed with them, (and our Romanists at this day with either) imagining our Sauiour (e saith Tertullian) to haue fflesh hard without bones, solide without muscles, bloody without blood, clad without coate, speaking without tongue, eating without teeth, &c. Whereupon Tertullian concludeth, that since Christ had all his limmes when hee shewed them to his Descipl•s, they that imagined such a Christ as this, gthat deceiueth, beguileth, and deludeth all mens eyes, and senses and touchings, (and taste too hee might haue said, we at least may say) should not bring him from heauen (from whence the Marcionites said their Christ had his body, though the Papists dare not say, they haue theirs from thence) but fetch him rather out of some
yHieron. ibid.
zIdem in Epitaph. Paulae.
aIdem. ibid.
bSticorum globos & a• ria quaedam deliramenta.
cGlobosam sive rotundā formam Diis dabant Stoici. Ex Sen ep. 94. Lips. physiol. Stoic. l. 1. c. 8.Globosam siue rotundā formam Diis dabant Stoici. Ex Sen ep. 94. Lips. physiol. Stoic. l. 1. c. 8.
dNec tamen ea species corpus est sed quasi corpus; nec habet sanguinem, sed quasi sanguinem. C•c. de nat. Deor. l. 1.
eTertul. de carne Christi & contr. Marc.
fUt carnem gestaret sine ossibus durā, sine mus. ulis solidam, sine sanguine cruen•, sine tunica vestitam, sine same esurientem, sine dentibus edentem, sine lin•••quer ten.Vt carnem gestaret sine ossibus durā, sine mus. ulis solidam, sine sanguine cruen•, sine tunica vestitam, sine same esurientem, sine dentibus edentem, sine lin•••quer tē.
gEcce […], decipit, circumuenit omnium o•ulos, sensus, access•s, contactus. Ergò Christum non de coelo deferre debueras, sed de caetu aliquo circul•torio, spectaculi artificem, non salutis Pontificem,Ecce 〈…〉, decipit, circumuenit omnium o•ulos, sensus, access•s, contactus. Ergò Christum non de coelo deferre debueras, sed de caetu aliquo circul•torio, spectaculi artificem, non salutis Pontificem,
As also that the ancient Fathers used then the very same Arguments against them, that we do now against these; which yet it pleaseth this vain trifler to term grossly carnal and unworthy to be answered.
As also that the ancient Fathers vsed then the very same Arguments against them, that we doe now against these; which yet it pleaseth this vaine trifler to tearme grossely carnall and vnworthy to be answered.
§ 2. Oh but (saith he) it is a gross kind both of divinity and philosophy fit for such a stupid Professor, to hold that local extension, visibility, palpability, and other natural accidents and sensible proprieties cannot by Gods omnipotency be severed from his own body without the destruction of it.
§ 2. Oh but (saith hee) it is a grosse kinde both of diuinity and philosophie fit for such a stupide Professor, to hold that locall extention, visiblitie, palpability, and other naturall accidents and sensible proprieties cannot by Gods omnipotency be severed from his owne body without the destruction of it.
1. Yea and to omit that it is a very sorry shift to have recourse to Gods omnipotency for the justifying of such monstrous fictions and forged miracles as either in this their prodigious dotage, or in their lying Legends they have endeavoured to obtrude upon the world: To say that God can make Christs body to remain still in his full stature, and yet at the same time to be no bigger then to enter in at a mans mouth, or go down a child's throat, or to make *a mans body consisting of flesh, blood and bone to have no dimensions or extension at all, not other accidents and properties of a natural body; is manifestly to say that God can make a thing at the same time to be and not to be, to be a body and no body; which implieth contradiction. And ithose things that imply contradiction, they them selves grant that God cannot do. For it were to make falsehood truth; which he that is kTruth it self can never do.
1. Yea and to omit that it is a very sorry shift to haue recourse to Gods omnipotency for the iustifying of such monstrous fictions and forged miracles as either in this their prodigious dotage, or in their lying Legends they haue endeauoured to obtrude vpon the world: To say that God can make Christs body to remaine still in his full stature, and yet at the same time to be no bigger then to enter in at a mans mouth, or goe downe a childs throat, or to make *a mans body consisting of flesh, blood and bone to haue no dimensions or extention at all, not other accidents and properties of a naturall body; is manifestly to say that God can make a thing at the same time to be and not to be, to be a body and no body; which implyeth contradiction. And ithose things that imply contradiction, they thē selues grant that God cannot doe. For it were to make falshood truth; which hee that is kTruth it selfe can neuer doe.
*Ex vi Sacramenti sub specie panis continentur, non solum caro, sed totum corpus Christi, soil. osla & nervy, & alia huiusmodi; non enim dicitur, Haec est caro mea, sed, Hoc est corpus meum. Thom. Aq sum. part 3. q. 76. a. 1. ad 2.Ex vi Sacramenti sub specie panis continentur, non solum caro, sed totum corpus Christi, soil. osla & nerui, & alia huiusmodi; non enim dicitur, Haec est caro mea, sed, Hoc est corpus meum. Thom. Aq sum. part 3. q. 76. a. 1. ad 2.
iQuae contradictionem implicant, sub divina omnipotentia non continentur. Idem ibid. part. 1. q. 25. a 3.
2. In this very manner also did the Heretics reason as appeareth by Theodoret, to maintain their absurd dotages ⟨p. 167⟩against the Orthodox Christians, who likewise answered them then, as we do these now. mThere is nothing (saith the Heretic) that God cannot do. We say, that nall things are possible with God. And Job saith, that oGod can do all things, and there is nothing impossible with him. There is nothing therefore but he can do, that is able to do all things. Now how doth the Orthodox disputer answer this? pGod (saith he) can do qwhatsoever he will: But rGod neither can do, nor will any thing which is not agreeable to his own nature. As for example she cannot sin; the cannot lie, unor do any unjust thing, being justice and truth it self. xMany things there are therefore that God, that can do all things, yet cannot do. Yea it is a part of his power that he cannot do them, no argument at all of any impotency in him. This was deemed a sufficient answer to those Heretics then; and may as well now be returned our Popish Adversaries, fighting with the same weapons that they then did, for points as absurd as ever any of them held.
2. In this very manner also did the Heretickes reason as appeareth by Theodoret, to maintaine their absurd dotages ⟨p. 167⟩against the Orthodox Christians, who likewise answered them then, as wee doe these now. mThere is nothing (saith the Hereticke) that God cannot doe. Wee say, that nall things are possible with God. And Iob saith, that oGod can doe all things, and there is nothing impossible with him. There is nothing therefore but he can doe, that is able to doe all things. Now how doth the Orthodoxe disputer answer this? pGod (saith hee) can do qwhatsoeuer he will: But rGod neither can doe, nor will any thing which is not agreeable to his owne nature. As for example she cannot sin; thee cannot ly, unor do any vniust thing, being iustice and truth it selfe. xMany things there are therefore that God, that can doe all things, yet cannot doe. Yea it is a part of his power that he cannot doe them, no argument at all of any impotency in him. This was deemed a sufficient answere to those Heretikes then; and may as well now be returned our Popish Adversaries, fighting with the same weapons that they then did, for points as absurd as euer any of them held.
m[Greek or Hebrew]. Eranista apud Theod. dial 1. & 3.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Eranista apud Theod. dial 1. & 3.
Another Argument is by my Adversary tediously prosecuted 1pag. 12. wherein from Christs local being still in heaven, he argueth and endeavoureth to prove an utter impossibility of his bodily being in the Sacrament. Of which kind of disputing I may fitly say with Saint Augustine, aBehold with what manner of Arguments humane infirmity possessed with vanity, contradicteth Gods omnipotency. As if natural under standing were able to comprehend the utmost limit and extension of Gods power, which is in it self infinite and inscrutably manifested in many of his wonderful miracles: of which (as I have said) no other reason can be given, but that he is omnipotent that did them, and cannot deceive us when he is pleased to testify them. Can we conceive (for example) the creation of the world of nothing at ⟨p. 168⟩all preexisting; the resurrection and repair which God will make of all bodies so utterly by frequent and successive conversions into other things altered and consumed; the personal union of man with God; the torment of souls and devils wholly spiritual by corporal fire; the consubstantial subsisting of the divine nature simply one of it self in three distinct persons; and other like mysteries of faith not conceivable more then the bodily being of our Saviour in the Sacrament; yet upon the warrant of Scripture and doctrine of Christs Church faithfully by us believed? Can this Minister tell me (to come more nearly to our purpose) how our Saviour appeared visibly to S. Paul on earth (as diverse plain texts import, particularly by Bellarmine bproduced and discussed) and yet (as himself will not deny) still remaining in heaven? Or can he tell me, how our Saviours body went out of his Sepulchre, without removing that huge stone, rolled afterward by the Angel from it? Or how he entered the house, the doors being and remaining still shut upon his disciples; as for a great miracle the Evangelist recounted? Or how he pierced the solid and huge Orbs of heaven in his ascension without making any hole in them? Sithence it is equally above nature for many bodies to possess one place, as for one body to be in many places.
ANother Argument is by my Aduersarie tediously prosecuted 1pag. 12. wherein from Christs locall being still in heaven, hee argueth and endeauoureth to prooue an vtter impossibility of his bodily being in the Sacrament. Of which kinde of disputing I may fitly say with Saint Augustine, aBehold with what manner of Arguments humane infi•mity possessed with vanity, contradicteth Gods omnipotency. As if naturall vnder standing were able to comprehend the vtmost limit and extention of Gods power, which is in it selfe infinite and inforutably manifested in many of his wonderfull miracles: of which (as I haue said) no other reason can be giuen, but that hee is omnipotent that did them, and cannot deceiue vs when hee is pleased to testifie them. Can wee conceiue (for example) the creation of the world of nothing at ⟨p. 168⟩all preexisting; the resurrection and repaire which God will make of all bodies so vtterly by frequent and successiue conuersions into other things altered and consumed; the personall vnion of man with God; the torment of soules and diuels wholly spirituall by corporall fire; the consubstantiall subsisting of the divine nature simply one of it selfe in three distinct persons; and other like mysteries of faith not conceiuable more then the bodily being of our Saviour in the Sacrament; yet vpon the warrant of Scripture and doctrine of Christs Church faithfully by vs beleeued? Can this Minister tell me (to come more neerely to our purpose) how our Sauiour appeared visibly to S. Paul on earth (as diuerse plaine texts import, particularly by Bellarmine bproduced and discussed) and yet (as himselfe will not deny) still remaining in heauen? Or can he tell me, how our Sauiours body went out of his Sepulcher, without remoouing that huge stone, rolled afterward by the Angell from it? Or how hee entred the house, the doores being and remayning still shut vpon his disciples; as for a great miracle the Euangelist recounted? Or how he pierced the solide and huge Orbes of heauen in his ascension without making any hole in them? Sithence it is equally aboue nature for many bodies to possesse one place, as for one bodie to be in many places.
1N. P.
aAug. lib 2•. de Civit. Dei, cap. 51.Aug. lib 2•. de Ciuit. Dei, cap. 51.
And if according to Christian true Philosophy, the soul of man being a spiritual and indivisible substance can at one be entirely in distant parts of mans body exercising all distinct operations in them, why is it impossible for God to give his humane body distant presences and a spiritual manner of being in the Sacrament? when as by personal union with himself, he giveth to the same body a far higher and more inconceivable manner of being.
And if according to Christian true Philosophy, the soule of man being a spirituall and indiuisible substance can at one be entirely in distant parts of mans body exercising all distinct operations in them, why is it impossible for God to giue his humane body distant presences and a spirituall manner of being in the Sacrament? when as by personall vnion with himselfe, he giueth to the same body a far higher and more inconceiuable manner of beeing.
MY fifth Argument is from the nature of a true body which cannot possibly be the same whole and entire 1in many places at once, much less in places as far distant, as East and West, Heaven and Earth.
MY fift Argum•nt is from the nature of a true body which cannot possibly be the same whole and entire 1in many places at once, much lesse in places as farre distant, as East and West, Heauen and Earth.
Now here again is he fain to fly (as before) to Gods omnipotency. That is their dDeus è machina; as they ⟨p. 169⟩had wont to speak; that is the knife still at hand to help to cut all those knots that by their wanton wits and absurd fantasies they have snarled themselves in. And the better to enforce this eCatholic Answer, that se•ueth them for the salving of all sores, he reckoneth up a long bead roll of wonderful works; as the Creation, the Resurrection, the Hypostatical union, the Trinity in Unity, the torment of Spirits by corporal fire, Christ coming out of the Sepulchre without removing the huge stone, his entering into the house while the doors were still shut, his appearing to Paul on earth while he was still in heaven, (which he telleth us Bellarmine hath plainly proved) his piercing of the solid Orbs of heaven in his Ascension, the soul being at once entirely in distant parts of mans body, &c. And then demandeth why God cannot cause Christs body to be as well one and the same, whole and entire in so many several distant places at once; the rather since that it is equal above nature for many bodies to possess one place, as for one body to be in many places.
Now heere againe is hee faine to fly (as before) to Gods omnipotency. That is their dDeus è machina; as they ⟨p. 169⟩had wont to speake; that is the knife still at hand to helpe to cut all those knots that by their wanton wits and absurd fantasies they haue snarled themselues in. And the better to enforce this eCatholike Answer, that se•ueth them for the saluing of all sores, hee reckoneth vp a long bead roll of wonderfull works; as the Creation, the Resurrection, the Hypostaticall vnion, the Trinity in Unity, the torment of Spirits by corporall fire, Christ comming out of the Sepulcher without remooving the huge stone, his entring into the house while the doores were still shut, his appearing to Paul on earth while hee was still in heauen, (which he telleth vs Bellarmine hath plainely prooued) his piercing of the solide Orbes of heauen in his Ascention, the soule being at once entirely in distant parts of mans body, &c. And then demandeth why God cannot cause Christs body to be as well one and the same, whole and entire in so many seuerall distant places at once; the rather since that it is equall aboue nature for many bodies to possesse one place, as for one body to be in many places.
d[Greek or Hebrew]. Quem aduocabant Comici, ubires haerere videbatur.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Quem aduocabant Comici, vbires haerere videbatur.
eCatholicon Medicorum, sive Panacaeú Papisticum.Catholicon Medicorum, siue Panacaeú Papisticum.
1. Here are divers things that are questionable both in Divinity and Philosophy: which albeit he take pro concessis, will not so easily be granted him, till they be better proved then as yet they are, howsoever we exclude not diverse of them out of the reach of Gods omnipotency, even as he understandeth them; as
1. Here are diuers things that are questionable both in Diuinity and Philosophy: which albeit he take pro concessis, will not so easily be granted him, till they be better prooued then as yet they are, howsoeuer we exclude not diuerse of them out of the reach of Gods omnipotency, euen as he vnderstandeth them; as
1. The manner of the fsouls being in distant parts of the body is disputable: nor is there the same reason of bodies and of spirits.
1. The manner of the fsoules being in distant parts of the body is disputable: nor is there the same reason of bodies and of spirits.
fVise Jul. Scalig. de subtil. exercit. 307. Sect. 29. Aegidium in l. 2. de anima. c. 2. q. 6. & Hospinian. de sede anim.Vise Iul. Scalig. de subtil. exercit. 307. Sect. 29. Aegidium in l. 2. de anima. c. 2. q. 6. & Hospinian. de sede anim.
3. The manner of hChrists apparition to S. Paul is not certain. Neither doth Bellarmine prove that Christ was below on earth, or near the earth in his humanity; nor is it to the purpose whether he were or no. iSteven saw him in heaven, the heavens opened: kPaul was rapt up ⟨p. 170⟩himself into heaven. Yea lin heaven, and mfrom heaven it was that Christ appeared to him; if we may believe Pope Gregory and one that goeth ordinarily for Ambrose. Nor can nBellarmine produce any one of the Ancients that saith otherwise. Howbeit neither do we so pen up Christ in heaven, but that he may at his pleasure (though ordinarily he doth not) descend.
3. The manner of hChrists apparition to S. Paul is not certaine. Neither doth Bellarmine prooue that Christ was below on earth, or neere the earth in his humanity; nor is it to the purpose whether he were or no. iSteuen saw him in heauen, the heauens opened: kPaul was rapt vp ⟨p. 170⟩himselfe into heauen. Yea lin heauen, and mfrom heauen it was that Christ appeared to him; if we may beleeue Pope Gregory and one that goeth ordinarily for Ambrose. Nor can nBellarmine produce any one of the Ancients that saith otherwise. Howbeit neither do we so pen vp Christ in heauen, but that he may at his pleasure (though ordinarily he doth not) descend.
lApparuit illi primum in coelo. Ambr. hom. in 1. Cor. 15.
mSuperna ei pietas coelos aperuit, seseque illi Jesus de sublim•bus ostendit. Greg. mor. l. 19. c. 5.Superna ei pietas coelos aperuit, seseque illi Iesus de sublim•bus ostendit. Greg. mor. l. 19. c. 5.
4. For oChrists coming in to his Disciples when the doors were shut. Why might not (as Jerome speaketh) pthe creature give way to the Creator; as qthe iron gate did to Peter? rIt is said, saith Durand, one of their Schoolmen, that Christ came when the doors were shut: but it is not said, that he came in through the doors so shut: he might enter in by some other place; or cause the doors to open suddenly, and shut instantly again.
4. For oChrists comming in to his Disciples when the doores were shut. Why might not (as Ierome speaketh) pthe creature giue way to the Creator; as qthe iron gate did to Peter? rIt is said, saith Durand, one of their Schoolemen, that Christ came when the doores were shut: but it is not said, that he came in through the doores so shut: he might enter in by some other place; or cause the doores to open suddenly, and shut instantly againe.
5. For Christs resurrection; Let him hear the same Durand. sIt cannot (saith he) be proved by any Text of Scripture, that Christ rose again while the Tomb was so shut: and so consequently that his body passed through the stone. Or if Durand's authority will not serve; let them hear Pope Leo in one of his decretal Epistles: tChrists body (saith he) rose again the stone being rolled away.
5. For Christs resurrection; Let him heare the same Durand. sIt cannot (saith hee) be prooued by any Text of Scripture, that Christ rose againe while the Tombe was so shut: and so consequently that his body passed through the stone. Or if Durands authority will not serue; let them heare Pope Leo in one of his decretall Epistles: tChrists body (saith he) rose againe the stone being rolled away.
sIdem ibid. ad 2.
tRevoluto monumenti lapide caro surrexit. Leo Pp. epist. 83.Reuoluto monumenti lapide caro surrexit. Leo Pp. epist. 83.
6. For his Ascension; to omit, that this usolidity of the Orbs is in Philosophy a thing questionable; and such a point, as if it be denied, this great Doctor will hardly be ever able to make good: I answer with Durand; that xWhether the heavens be divisible in their own nature, or by divine virtue, (as the one they well may be, and the other certainly they are) there is no necessity that Christs body in his Ascension should be together in the same place with the bodies of the Orbs.
6. For his Ascension; to omit, that this usolidity of the Orbes is in Philosophy a thing questionable; and such a point, as if it bee denyed, this great Doctor will hardly be euer able to make good: I answer with Durand; that xWhether the heauens bee divisible in their owne nature, or by divine vertue, (as the one they well may bee, and the other certainly they are) there is no necessity that Christs body in his Ascension should be together in the same place with the bodies of the Orbes.
uVid: Zanc de operibus creat part. 2. l. 2. c. 3. Th. 3 Et Keckerm. system. physic. l. 2 c. 2.
So that in none of these Examples there is any necessity of two bodies being in one place at once. Which yet if it were proved (if they will believe their own Schoolmen) were not sufficient. For howsoever this great Doctor tell us, that it is equally above nature for many bodies to ⟨p. 171⟩be in one place, and for one body to be in many places: yet they say, that it is not so. yThough two bodies (saith Aquinas) may be in one places at once; yet it followeth not that one body may be in two places at once. The former is not possible but by miracle; the latter not at all. zIt is not alike (saith Durand) for two bodies to be at once in one place; and for one body to be at once in more places then one. For the one implieth a contradiction; the other doth not, (the former he meaneth) though it may seem so to do.
So that in none of these Examples there is any necessitie of two bodies being in one place at once. Which yet if it were prooued (if they will beleeue their owne Schoolemen) were not suffiicient. For howsoeuer this great Doctor tell vs, that it is equally aboue nature for many bodies to ⟨p. 171⟩be in one place, and for one body to bee in many places: yet they say, that it is not so. yThough two bodies (saith Aquinas) may be in one places at once; yet it followeth not that one bodie may bee in two places at once. The former is not possible but by miracle; the latter not at all. zIt is not alike (saith Durand) for two bodies to be at once in one place; and for one body to be at once in more places then one. For the one implieth a contradiction; the other doth not, (the former he meaneth) though it may seeme so to doe.
2. And so he hath a direct answer, why we deny that a body can be in diverse places at once; notwithstanding we believe and acknowledge Gods wonderful works of Creation, Resurrection, Christs Incarnation, and those unsearchable mysteries of the Trinity, and Hypostatical union, &c. because the one implieth a contradiction, those other do not.
2. And so he hath a direct answer, why wee deny that a body can be in diuerse places at once; notwithstanding we beleeue and acknowledge Gods wonderfull workes of Creation, Resurrection, Christs Incarnation, and those vnsearchable mysteries of the Trinitie, and Hypostaticall vnion, &c. because the one implyeth a contradiction, those other doe not.
And here let me entreat the Reader (since that these men so much press us with Gods omnipotency) to cast his eye back with me to those manifold aimpossibilities before mentioned, and by themselves acknowledged, even in this very business concerning the Sacrament. Whereby it may appear, that they make use of it only to serve their own turns, urging it then when it may stead them, and denying it then when it doth not. To recite again some one or two of them only, adding one or two more to them bLuther's opinion (saith Bellarmine) cannot be true: because cit is no way possible that one thing should not be changed, and yet should become another. And dIt is impossible (saith Lanfranc) that one thing should be turned into another, and not cease to be, so far forth as it is converted. eIt is impossible (saith this Defendant, that cannot endure here to hear of any impossibility) That a man should be a Rock, or a Vine. And fIt is impossible (saith Bellarmine) that bread should be Christs body. gIt is not ⟨p. 172⟩possible (saith Maironis) that one should be in two times at once. (And is it not as impossible then, for one to be in two places at once?) And hit is impossible that one single effect should have diverse total causes: and iimpossible therefore that one and the same accident should be in diverse subjects. (And why not as impossible for one subject to have diverse accidents, as diverse seats, sites, qualities, and quantities at once? which Christ's body must needs have, i• it be with us in the Eucharist.) kIt is impossible (saith Durand) that one and the same thing should move two contrary ways at once. And lIt is impossible (saith Aquinas) that the same body should by local motion arrive in diverse several places at once. And mIt is impossible that one and the self same thing should both rest and stir at once. And yet should Christs body, if it were in the Host, or if it were the very Host rather, do all this, when at the same time it both resteth in the Pyx in one place, and goeth in Procession in another place, and is in diverse processions, or on sundry several occasions carried contrary ways to several persons and places at the same instant.
And here let me entreat the Reader (since that these men so much presse vs with Gods omnipotency) to cast his eye backe with me to those manifold aimpossibilities before mentioned, and by themselues acknowledged, euen in this very businesse concerning the Sacrament. Whereby it may appeare, that they make vse of it onely to serue their owne turnes, vrging it then when it may stead them, and denying it then when it doth not. To recite againe some one or two of them onely, adding one or two more to them bLuthers opinion (saith Bellarmine) cannot be true: because cit is no way possible that one thing should not be changed, and yet should become another. And dIt is impossible (saith Lanfranck) that one thing should be turned into another, and not cease to be, so farre forth as it is converted. eIt is impossible (saith this Defendant, that cannot endure here to heare of any impossibility) That a man should be a Rocke, or a Uine. And fIt is impossible (saith Bellarmine) that bread should bee Christs body. gIt is not ⟨p. 172⟩possible (saith Maironis) that one should be in two times at once. (And is it not as impossible then, for one to bee in two places at once?) And hit is impossible that one single effect should haue diuerse totall causes: and iimpossible therefore that one and the same accident should bee in diuerse subiects. (And why not as impossible for one subiect to haue diverse accidents, as diuerse seates, sites, qualities, and quantities at once? which Christsbody must needs haue, i• it bee with vs in the Eucharist.) kIt is impossible (saith Durand) that one and the same thing should mooue two contrary wayes at once. And
bBellarm, de Euchar. […]. 3. c. 19.Bellarm, de Euchar. 〈…〉. 3. c. 19.
cNullo modo fierr potest ut una res non mutetur, & ta•en […] alia.Nullo modo fierr potest vt vna res non mutetur, & ta•en 〈…〉 alia.
dImpossibile rem unā converti in aliam, nec tamen in ea parte desinere esse quod erat. Lanfranc. contr. Bereng.Impossibile rem vnā converti in aliam, nec tamen in ea parte desinere esse quod erat. Lanfranc. contr. Bereng.
eSupra Divi•. 2.Supra Diui•. 2.
fFieri non potest ut pavis sit corpus Christi. Bellar. de Euch. l. 1. […]. 1•.Fieri non potest vt pauis sit corpus Christi. Bellar. de Euch. l. 1. 〈…〉. 1•.
gNon potest esse aliquis simul in diversis temporibus. Fr. Mairon, in sent, l. 4. d. 11. q. 1.Non potest esse aliquis simul in diuersis temporibus. Fr. Mairon, in sent, l. 4. d. 11. q. 1.
hIdem effectus non potest habere plures causas totals. Ibid.Idem effectus non potest habere plures causas totales. Ibid.
iIdeò idem a••idens non potest esse in diversis subiectis. Ibid.
No more therefore do we curb or restrain Gods omnipotency, when we deny that a body can be by any means in two distant places at once, then they do, when they deny a possibility of the things before spoken. And for the reason of our denial, let them hear be side Durand's, Aquinas his confession. *For one body (saith he) to be locally in two places at once, it implieth a contradiction: and therefore cannot a body be in two places at once; no not by miracle neither: For those things that imply contradiction God cannot do. nGod therefore cannot make a body to be locally in two places at once. The very self same saith oAegidius too: and Amolynus on him; that palthough a thousand miracles were wrought, nothing could be effected that implieth a contradiction; as this doth.
No more therefore doe we curb or restraine Gods •mnip•tency, when we deny that a body can bee by any meanes in two distant places at once, then they doe, when they deny a possibility of the things before spoken. And for the reason of our denyall, let them heare be side Durands, Aquinas his confession. *For one body (saith hee) to bee locally in two places at once, it implieth a contradiction: and therefore cannot a body be in two places at once; no not by miracle neither: For those things that imply contradiction God cannot do. nGod therefore cannot make a body to bee locally in two places at once. The very selfe same saith oAegidius too: and Amolynus on him; that palthough a thousand miracles were wrought, nothing could bee effected that implyeth a contradiction; as this doth.
*V•um corpus non potest esse in lu•bus locis. V• enim corpus esse localiter in duobus locis implicat contradictionem. Thom. Aq. quodlib. 1. art. 22.
nDeus non potest sacere, ut unum corpus localiter sit simul in duobus locis. Idem quodli I. 3. art. 2.Deus non potest sacere, vt vnum corpus localiter sit simul in duobus locis. Idem quodli I. 3. art. 2.
oAegid. Rom. quodlib 1. q. 1.
pSi essent mille miracula, non adaequarent potentiam ad id quod implicat contradictione. Laurent. Amolyn. in eund. ibid.
Certainly the holy Fathers doubted not to affirm that 1Christ left his body here on earth, and yet assumed with him the same body into heaven; he held his body in his own hands at his last Supper, and distributed it severally to his Apostles; as hath been already out of S. Chrysostom, S. Augustine, and other holy Fathers formerly by me alleged. Insomuch as Melanchthon one of the main pillars of Protestant Religion, understood the opinion of the holy Fathers so well in this point, and attributed so much withal to Gods omnipotency, as he writeth thus of this very Argument. cI had rather offer my self to death then to affirm as Zwinglians do, that Christs body cannot be but in one place at once. And S. Augustine (as Bellarmine proveth) was so far from denying this to the body of Christ, as he doubted whether the holy Martyrs may not be at the self same time in several Churches and Memories erected of them; albeit naturally no spirit nor body can be more then in one place, or remain without some certain place of being: which latter is in the places cited by this Minister out of him only affirmed. And if a perfect substance or nature (as was the humanity of Christ) could want the natural personality and subsistence thereof, supplied by the divine person and hypostasis of the Son of God (as our Christian faith teacheth us) why cannot in like manner by Gods omnipotency the accidents of bread and wine remain without actual inhering and being in their natural subject?
CErtainely the holy Fathers doubted not to affirme that 1Christ left his body here on earth, and yet assumed with him the same bodie into heauen; hee held his body in his owne hands at his last Supper, and distributed it severally to his Apostles; as hath beene already out of S. Chrysostome, S. Augustine, and other holy Fathers formerly by me alle•dged. Insomuch as Melancthon one of the maine pillars of Protestant Religion, vnderstood the opinion of the holy Fathers so well in this point, and attributed so much withall to Gods omnipotency, as hee writeth thus of this very Argument. cI had rather offer my selfe to death then to affirme as Zwinglians doe, that Christs body cannot bee but in one place at once. And S. Augustine (as Bellarmine prooueth) was so farre from denying this to the bodie of Christ, as he doubted whether the holy Martyrs may not be at the selfe same time in severall Churches and Memories erected of them; albeit naturally no spirit nor body can bee more then in one place, or remaine without some certaine place of beeing: which latter is in the places ciced by this Minister out of him onely affirmed. And if a perfect substance or nature (as was the humanity of Christ) could want the naturall personality and subsistence thereof, supplyed by the divine person and hypostasis of the Sonne of God (as our Christian faith teacheth vs) why cannot in like manner by Gods omnipotency the accidents of bread and wine remaine without actuall inhering and being in their naturall subiect?
His other Arguments page 15. are drops of an afterstorme, and objections gathered out of S. Augustine, which do only prove that Christ is not visibly but in heaven; not denying his sacramental being in many places; as this Minister would have him. And surely our Saviour himself in the 6. Chapter of S. John, verse 61. solveth this very objection (as S. Chrysostom understandeth him) when perceiving that his Disciples murmured at his promise of giving his flesh for meat, &c. he said to them, Doth this scandalize you? If then you shall see the Son of Man ascending where he was before, &c. As if he had said; Are ⟨p. 174⟩you scandalised that I said being now present with you, I will give my flesh for food? what then will you do, or how far will▪ you be from believing that I can so give you my flesh, when I •ll ascend to heaven and be absent so far from you?
His other Arguments page 15. are drops of an afterstorme, and obiections gathered out of S. Augustine, which doe onely prooue that Christ is not visibly but in heauen; not denying his sacramentall beeing in many places; as this Minister would haue him. And surely our Saviour himselfe in the 6. Chapter of S. Iohn, verse 61. solueth this very obiection (as S. Chrysostome vnderstandeth him) when perceiving that his Disciples murmared at his promise of giuing his flesh for meate, &c. he said to them, Doth this scandalize you? If then you shall see the Sonne of Man ascending where he was before, &c. As if hee had said; Are ⟨p. 174⟩you scandalised that I said being now present with you, I will giue my flesh for food? what then will you doe, or how farre will▪ you be from beleeuing that I canso giue you my flesh, when I •ll ascend to heauen and be absent so sarre from you?
§ 2. The places of the Fathers here pointed at, were before answered, where by him they were a•1large alleged. And howsoever Augustine qspake modestly (after his manner) of a difficult Question, not daring peremptorily to determine by what means that was effected, that by divers other means might be: yet in his books against Faustus the Manichee he saith expressly and peremptorily, that rChrist in regard of his bodily presence could not be at once in the Sun and in the Moon, and upon the Cross also: as they absurdly imagined and maintained that he was. And again in his Comment aries on the Gospel of S. John; not (as Bellarmine corruptly citeth him, as he doth also many others) that sChrists body in which he rose again, M AY be; but (as tPeter Lombard, uand other of their own Authors acknowledge him to say) that xit MUST be in one place; howsoever his verity (that is, his Deity) be every where. Yea discussing the question at large in one of his Epistles, and having concluded the Negative, he saith that ythey take away the truth of his body, that maintain it to be in many places at once: Whereas though zimmortality be conferred on it, yet nature is not taken from it. To which purpose he disputeth much of the nature of a true body, and delivereth those things, which I press out of him: all which together with the testimonies of other of the Ancients this superficial Answerer passeth over with sad silence; only boldly and b•asen facedly avouching that all that is alleged out of Augustine proveth nothing but this, that Christ is not visibly but in Heaven. Did he think that his Reader would not cast an eye on them, ⟨p. 175⟩whom they were verbatim set down before him?
§ 2. THe places of the Fathers here pointed at, were before answered, where by him they were a•1large alledged. And howsoeuer Augustine qspake modestly (after his manner) of a difficult Question, not daring peremptorily to determine by what meanes that was effected, that by diuers other meanes might be: yet in his bookes against Fa•stus the Manichie hee saith expressely and peremptorily, that rChrist in regard of his bodily presence could not bee at once in the Sunne and in the Moone, and vpon the Crosse also: as they absurdly imagined and maintained that he was. And againe in his Comment aries on the Gospell of S. Iohn; not (as Bellarmine corruptly citeth him, as hee doth also many others) that sChrists body in which he rose againe, M AY be; but (as tPeter Lombard, uand other of their owne Authors acknowledge him to say) that xit MVST be in one place; howsoeuer his verity (that is, his Deitie) be every where. Yea discusing the question at large in one of his Epistles, and hauing concluded the Negatiue, hee saith that ythey take away the truth of his body, that maintaine it to be in many places at once: Whereas though zimmortality bee conferred on it, yet nature is not taken from it. To which purpose hee disputeth much of the nature of a true body, and deliuereth those things, which I presse out of him: all which together with the testimonies of other of the Ancients this superficiall Answerer passeth ouer with sad silence; onely boldly and b•asen facedly auouching that all that is alleadged out of Augustine prooueth nothing but this, that Christ is not visibly but in Heauen. Did hee thinke that his Reader would not cast an eye on them, ⟨p. 175⟩
1T. G.
qAug. de cura pro mort. ger. c. 16.
rSecundum presentiā corporalem simul & in Sole, & in Luna, & in Cruce esse nō potest. Aug. contr. Faust. l. 20. c. 11.Secundum presentiā corporalem simul & in Sole, & in Luna, & in Cruce esse nō potest. Aug. contr. Faust. l. 20. c. 11.
sCorp. Christi, in quo resurr. uno in loco esse potest. Bellar. de Euthar. l. 2. c. 24.Corp. Christi, in quo resurr. vno in loco esse potest. Bellar. de Euthar. l. 2. c. 24.
tUno in loco esse oportet. Aug. in Joan. tr. 30.Vno in loco esse oportet. Aug. in Ioan. tr. 30.
uPetr. Lomb. sen. l. 4. d. 10. A
xGrar. de consecr. d. z. c. 1. Thom. in 4. d. 10. a. 1. Scot. in 4. q. 3. & alii. ibid.
yCavendum ne veritatem corporis auferamus, August. Epist. 17.Cauendum ne veritatem corporis auferamus, August. Epist. 17.
zImmortalitatem dedit, naturam non abstulit. Ibid.
§ 3. Yea but our Saviour himself (he saith) solveth this Objection, John 6. 61. as Chrysostom understandeth him, when he saith, Doth this scandalize you? What if you shall see the Son of Man ascending where he was before, &c? as if he had said; Are you scandalized because I said being now, present with you, I will give my flesh for food? What then will you do, or how far will you be from believing that I can so give you my flesh when I shall ascend to heaven, and be so far above from you?
§ 3. Yea but our Saviour himselfe (he saith) solveth this Obiection, Iohn 6. 61. as Chrysostome vnderstandeth him, when hee saith, Doth this scandalize you? What if you shall see the Sonne of Man ascending where hee was before, &c? as if hee had said; Are you scandalized because I said being now, present with you, I will giue my flesh for food? What then will you doe, or how farre will you be from beleeuing that I can so giue you my flesh when I shall ascend to heauen, and be so farre aboue from you?
1. Where Chrysostom thus expoundeth the place, I know not. Upon the place (I am sure) he hath nothing but this, that aChrist by these words did intimate to them his Deity. Yea so bJansenius also saith, that Chrysostom understandeth these words as spoken to assure them that he came down from heaven. The truth is; this exposition it not Chrysostoms, but Bellarmines, (from whom this Collector hath filched it) who yet to add some grace and procure some weight to an invention of his own, saith that c Chrysostom to him seemeth to point at some such thing. 3And what Bellarmine saith cautiously, and timorously, Chrysostom to him seemeth to point at; that this blind bayard saith boldly and confidently, that Chrysostom saith; and upon the Exposition as backed now sufficiently with Chrysostom, he buildeth a peremptory answer to all mine Objections, that will easily remove them all. Did this man think that these things would ever be examined? Or is his credit so mean already that he need not fear to be discredited, that he dare use such sorry shifts as these are?
1. Where Chrysostome thus expoundeth the place, I know not. Vpon the place (I am sure) he hath nothing but this, that aChrist by these wordes did intimate to them his Deitie. Yea so bIansenius also saith, that Chrysostome vnderstandeth these words as spoken to assure them that hee came downe from heauen. The truth is; this exposition it not Chrysostomes, but Bellarmines, (from whom this Collector hath filched it) who yet to adde some grace and procure some weight to an inuention of his owne, saith that c Chrysostome to him seemeth to point at some such thing. 3And what Bellarmine saith cautelously, and timorously, Chrysostome to him seemeth to point at; that this blinde bayard saith boldly and confidently, that Chrysostome saith; and vpon the Exposition as backed now sufficiently with Chrysostome, he buildeth a peremptory answer to all mine Obiections, that will easily remooue them all. Did this man thinke that these things would euer be examined? Or is his credit so meane already that he need not feare to bee discredited, that hee dare vse such sorry shifts as these are?
aChrysost. in Joan. hom. 47.Chrysost. in Ioan. hom. 47.
2. Grant all to be Chrysostoms, and all to be as true, as if not Chrysostom, but Christ himself had said it: what will thence be concluded to prove that Christs body may be in many places at once? But since he hath cited this place, though to small purpose; let him hear Augustine's words on it, going directly against them, and these absurd fantasies of theirs. dChrist (saith he) doth in▪⟨p. 176⟩these words esolve that that moved them: and openeth that whereas they were jcandalized. For they thought that he would give them out his body: but he told them that be should g•e up whole into heaven. As if he had said, fWhen you shall see the Son of Man ascend where he was before▪ certainly then you shall see, that he doth not give out his body in such a manner as you imagine: Certainly even then you shall understand, that his grace is not consumed by bits. And to Augustine adieu Athanasius one as ancient as the Nicene Council and a principal person in it gChrist disputing (saith he) of the eating of his body, and seeing many thereupon scandalized, thus spake; Doth this scandalize you? What then if you shall see the Son of Man ascend where before he was? It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing. The words that I speak are spirit and life. For here he spake of both, both his flesh and his spirit, and distinguished the spirit from the flesh, that believing not only that that appeared to the eyes, but that also that was invisible, they might learn that those things also that he spake were hnot carnal, but spiritual. iFor to how many men could his body have sufficed to eat of? that it might be the food also of the whole world. But therefore made he▪ mention of his ascension into heaven, that he might withdraw them form the corporal understanding; and that then they might understand that his flesh which he spake of was heavenly meat from above, and spiritual food to be given by him. For, saith he, Those things which I have spoken to you are spirit and life. Which is even all one as if he had said; My body that is showed and given, shall be given to be meat for the whole world, kthat it may spiritually be distributed to each one, and become to each one a safeguard and preservative for resurrection to life eternal. So little doth this place avail for this purpose, as the Ancients both Latin and Greek expound it:
2. Grant all to be Chrysostomes, and all to bee as true, as if not Chrysostome, but Christ himselfe had said it: what will thence bee concluded to prooue that Christs body may be in many places at once? But since hee hath cited this place, though to small purpose; let him heare Augustines words on it, going directly agaiust them, and these absurd fantasies of theirs. dChrist (saith he) doth in▪⟨p. 176⟩these wordes esolue that that mooued them: and openeth that whereas they were jcandalized. For they thought that hee would giue them out his body: but he told them that be should g•e vp whole into heauen. As if hee had said, fWhen you shall see the Sonne of Man ascend where hee was before▪ certainely then you shall see, that he doth not giue out his body in such a manner as you imagine: Certainely euen then you shall vnderstand, that his grace is not consumed by bits. And to Augustine addewe Athanasius one as ancient as the Nicene Councell and a principall person in it gChrist disputing (saith hee) of the eating of his body, and seeing many therevpon scandalized, thus spake; Doth this scandalize you? What then if you shall see the Sonne of Man ascend where before he was? It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing. The words that I speake are spinit and life. For heere he spake of both, both his flesh and his spirit, and distinguished the spirit from the flesh, that beleeuing not onely that that appeared to the eyes, but that also that was invisible, they might learne that those things also that he spake were hnot carnall, but spirituall. iFor to how many men could his body haue sufficed to eate of? that it might be the foodalso of the whole world. But therefore made he▪ mention of his ascension into heauen, that hee might withdraw them form the corporall vnderstanding; and that then they might vnderstand that his flesh which hee spake of was heauenly meate from aboue, and spirituall food to be giuen by him. For, saith he, Those things which I haue spoken to you are spirit and life. Which is euen all one as if hee had said; My body that is shewed and giuen, shall be giuen to bee meate for the whole world,
dAugust. in Joan. tr. 27.August. in Ioan. tr. 27.
eHie so •uit, quod eos moverat, &c.Hie so •uit, quod eos mouerat, &c.
fAug ibid.
gAthanas. in illud Evang. Quicunque dixerit, &c.Athanas. in illud Euang. Quicunque dixerit, &c.
making much rather against them & this popish doctrine of a carnal feeding on Christs flesh; which those Fathers gather and prove thence to be wholly spiritual. But thus judicious is he in the choice of ⟨p. 177⟩his allegations; and so sincere in his citations of the Ancients, putting down their names only, but pointing to no place, that his fraud and forgeries may not be discovered; and fastening upon them his own, or his own associates expositions, wholly differing and dissenting from that that themselves say.
making much rather against them & this popish doctrine of a carnall feeding on Christs flesh; which those Fathers gather and prooue thence to be wholly spirituall. But thus iudicious is he in the choice of ⟨p. 177⟩his allegations; and so sincere in his citations of the Ancients, putting downe their names only, but pointing to no place, that his fraud and forgeries may not be discouered; and fastening vpon them his owne, or his owne associates expositions, wholly differing and dissenting from that that themselues say.
Moreover it is a wild kind of arguing from the natural 1and local extension of bodies to infer (as my Adversary doth page 16.) that by no possible power of God any body can want this local extension; this being a secondary effect of quantity, and an accidental propriety, which God may therefore easily hinder, and conserve without it bodily substance; as our Saviour himself insinuateth in the Gospel; affirming for a thing possible with God, to make a great Camel to pass through the eye of a needle; by taking (to wit) from it exterior bigness and local extension. Of which Camel so extenuated and straitened in place all the very same may be proportionably affirmed, which this Minister accounteth so absurd, by us held of Christs body in the Sacrament. And supposing truly that the body of Christ hath no extension in place, it is ridiculous for this ignorant Minister to make such inferences; as that any part of Christs body must be as great and greater then his whole body; and his whole body less then any part of it. For if neither the whole nor any part thereof, as it is in the Sacrament hath any exterior bigness at all, how can one part be said to be bigger then the whole? as of two black things a man should say, one was whiter then the other, when neither had any whiteness at all in them.
MOreouer it is a wilde kinde of arguing from the naturall 1and locall extension of bodies to inferre (as my Adversary doth page 16.) that by no possible power of God any body can want this locall extension; this being a secondary effect of quantity, and an accidentall propriety, which God may therefore easily hinder, and conserue without it bodily substance; as our Sauiour himselfe insinuateth in the Gospell; affirming for a thing possible with God, to make a great Camell to passe through the eye of a needle; by taking (to wit) from it exterior bignesse and locall extension. Of which Camell so extenuated and straitned in place all the very same may be proportionably affirmed, which this Minister accounteth so absurd, by vs held of Christs body in the Sacrament. And supposing truely that the body of Christ hath no extension in place, it is ridiculous for this ignorant Minister to make such inferences; as that any part of Christs body must be as great and greater then his whole body; and his whole body lesse then any part of it. For if neither the whole nor any part thereof, as it is in the Sacrament hath any exterior bignesse at all, how can one part be said to bee bigger then the whole? as of two blacke things a man should say, one was whiter then the other, when neither had any whitenesse at all in them.
§ 4. TO the recital of their absurd assertions, that 1there is la whole Christ, flesh, blood, and bone, head, ⟨p. 178⟩hands and feet, belly, breast and back, in every little wafercake, and every least crumb of each; and consequently, the whole body of Christ on earth less then the least limb or fingers end of it in heaven: as also to the allegations out of Augustine that this cannot be; for that in every true body, the parts cannot be altogether, but must have their due distance, and each of them his space or place according to his bigness; and none of them can be bigger then the whole: He maketh answer, that this is but a wild kind of reasoning: (and yet it is Augustine that so reasoneth, whom he might have been pleased to use with better terms:) telleth us what our Saviour saith of a Camel passing through a needles eye: as if what were spoken there by our Saviour of the one did relieve the absurdity of the other: (which no whit it doth, being only man hyperbolical speech, used to set forth the impossibility nwith man, of osuch a rich mans salvation as he there speaketh of:) and informeth this ignorant Minister, that neither the whole body of Christ nor any part of it, as it is in the Sacrament, hath any exterior bigness at all.
§ 4. TO the recit•ll of their absurd assertions, that 1there is la whole Christ, flesh, blood, and bone, head, ⟨p. 178⟩hands and feet, belly, breast and backe, in euery little wafercake, and euery least crumme of each; and consequently, the whole body of Christ on earth lesse then the least limme or fingers end of it in heaven: as also to the allegations out of Augustine that this cannot be; for that in euery true body, the parts cannot bee altogether, but must haue their due distance, and each of them his space or place according to his bignesse; and none of them can be bigger then the whole: He maketh answer, that this is but a wilde kinde of reasoning: (and yet it is Augustine that so reasoneth, whom hee might haue beene pleased to vse with better tearmes:) telleth vs what our Sauiour saith of a Camell passing thorow a needles ey: as if what were spoken there by our Sauiour of the one did relieue the absurditie of the other: (which no whit it doth, being onely man hyperbolicall speech, vsed to set forth the impossibility nwith man, of osuch a rich mans salvation as hee there speaketh of:) and informeth this ignorant Minister, that neither the whole body of Christ nor any part of it, as it is in the Sacrament, hath any exterior bignesse at all.
1T. G.
lOmnes partes integrales Corporis Christi, caput, pectus, manus, pedes, &c. Gabr. Biel. in Can. Miss. lect. 42. Qui & asserit lect. 80. Non esse inconueniens, si ponantur infinitae parts substantiae pu•ctualis paris ante co•ecratio enquod infinities corpus Christi est sub speciebus panis post consecrationē. That Christs body may be ten thousand thousand times (and why not ten thousand thousand bodies of Christ then?) with head, feet, hands, legs, back, breast, and belly, in one wafer if there be but so many crumbs as big a needles point in it. Vide & Fr. Maironis in 4. •ist▪ 10. quest. a.Omnes partes integrales Corporis Christi, caput, pectus, manus, pedes, &c. Gabr. Biel. in Can. Miss. lect. 42. Qui & asserit lect. 80. Non esse inconueniens, si ponantur infinitae partes substantiae pu•ctualis paris ante co•ecratio ēquod infinities corpus Christi est sub speciebus panis post consecrationē. That Christs body may be ten thousand thousand times (and why not ten thousand thousand bodies of Christ then?) with head, feet, hands, legs, backe, breast, and belly, in one wafer if there be but so many crums as big a needles point in it. Vide & Fr. Maironis in 4. •ist▪ 10. quest. a.
mHyperbole, qua nihil aliud quam hoc difficillimum esse intelligi voluit. Erasm. de rat. ver. Theolog.
1. Did any man ever before hear of a body without bigness? or a co•pus non quantum, without those dimensions that are so unseparable from a body, that the very same pname is given unto either, and we have no particular name either in Greek or Latin to express the one by, but that which is the usual appellation of the other? But a number of such absurd dreams and dotages doth this prodigious doctrine produce. qAccidents without subjects: Bodies without bigness: Parts bigger then the whole: The whole less then the least part: A grown mans entire body with all limbs and toynts of it, couched and cooped up in a thin wafer-cake and in every crumb of it. The same body that is entire in heaven still, in a thousand places entire too at the same time here on earth; and yet never stir an inch from the place that in heaven it still holdeth. These are rmagical mysteries indeed, which it is no marvel if this ignorant Minister cannot conceive.
1. Did any man euer before heare of a body without bignesse? or a co•pus non quantum, without those dimensions that are so vnseparable from a body, that the very same pname is giuen vnto either, and wee haue no particular name either in Greeke or Latine to expresse the one by, but that which is the vsuall appellation of the other? But a number of such absurd dreames and dotages doth this prodigious doctrine produce. qAccidents without subiects: Bodies without bignesse: Parts bigger then the whole: The whole lesse then the least part: A growne mans entire body with all limmes and toynts of it, couched and cooped vp in a thinne wafer-cake and in every crum of it. The same body that is entire in heauen still, in a thousand places entire too at the same time here on earth; and yet never stirre an inch from the place that in heauen it still holdeth. These are rmagicall mysteries indeed, which it is no maruell if this ignorant Minister cannot conceiue.
p[Greek or Hebrew]. Corpus Addst. categor. quantit.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Corpus A•st. categor. quantit.
qMonstra quis tanta explicet? Sen. Theb. 1▪
r[Greek or Hebrew]. Theod. Rhaetens. de haeres.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Theod. Rhaetens. de haeres.
2 Yea but our Saviours words of sa Camel passing through a needles eye, showeth that a body may be freed from it exterior bigness and local extension: that is as much as if he had said, they show that a body may become no body, and yet be a body still. The speech is hyperbolical: and no more proveth a possibility of the thing therein spoken, (as tPiscator well observeth answering uBellarmine, from whom he here hath it) then of many xother things, spoken commonly in speeches of the like kind. *Quantity (saith Bonaventure) is of the verity of a body: and a true body consequently cannot be without it. And ythough it were granted that some substance might be without quantity, yet it cannot be that any quick or organical body (such as a Camels is, and such as he granteth Christs to be) should be without it. Yea and therefore also znot the verity only (as this fellow would have it) but the quantity also (as Bonaventure avoweth, and this fellow denieth) that is, the exterior bigness of Christs body must needs be with it in the Sacrament, if it be at all there.
2 Yea but our Sauiours wordes of sa Camell passing through a needles eye, sheweth that a body may be freed from it exterior bignesse and locall extension: that is as much as if hee had said, they shew that a bodie may become no bodie, and yet be a body still. The speech is hyperbolicall: and no more prooueth a possibility of the thing therein spoken, (as tPiscator well obserueth answering uBellarmine, from whom he here hath it) then of many xother things, spoken commonly in speeches of the like kinde. *Quantitie (saith Bonaventure) is of the verity of a body: and a true bodie consequently cannot bee without it. And ythough it were granted that some substance might bee without quantitie, yet it cannot be that any quicke or organicall body (such as a Camels is, and such as hee granteth Christs to be) should be without it. Yea and therefore also znot the veritie onely (as this fellow would haue it) but the quantity also (as Bonauenture auoweth, and this fellow denieth) that is, the exterior bignesse of Christs body must needs bee with it in the Sacrament, if it bee at all there.
xSic [Greek or Hebrew]. Et ex En•io Vairo, Prius pariet Locusta Lucā Bovem, i. Elephantem.Sic 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Et ex En•io Vairo, Prius pariet Locusta Lucā Bouem, i. Elephantem.
*Quantitas est de veritate corporis. Bonavent. in sen. l. 4. d. 10. q. 2.Quantitas est de veritate corporis. Bonauent. in sen. l. 4. d. 10. q. 2.
yQuamuis substantia possit abstrahi à quā •itate: tamen quod corpus vivat & sit organicum, & non sit quantum, hoc nec esse nec intelligi potest. Ibid.Quamuis substantia possit abstrahi à quā •itate: tamen quod corpus viuat & sit organicum, & non sit quantum, hoc nec esse nec intelligi potest. Ibid.
zIn altari nō tantum est corporis Chri sty veritas, into etiam quantitas. Bonaven. ibid.In altari nō tantum est corporis Chri sti veritas, into etiam quantitas. Bonauen. ibid.
3. To conclude this wild discourse indeed, because we are in it compelled to follow one that turneth round till he be giddy again: when we reason thus from the nature and property of a true body to be but in one place; we reason no otherwise (howsoever he esteem it a wild kind of reasoning) then wise and learned men, yea Angels too, have taught us to reason. For as the Angel reasoneth with the nomen that came to seek Christ in the Sepulchre; aHe is not here; for he is risen again: which were no good Argument, if his body might have been in two places at once: So the ancient Fathers also reason in their disputes against Heretics, where it stood them upon to speak warily, and not to argue wildly, as this giddy brains termeth it. bChrists body (saith Theodoret) albeit it be now glorified, yet is a body still, and hath the same circumscription that before it had Which (as the cAngels teach) shall come in the same manner as it was seen go to heaven. ⟨p. 180⟩But they saw it then circumscribed. Yea our Lord himself saith, dYou shall see the Son of Man come in the clouds. But that nature cannot be seen, that is not circumscribed. He showeth then that his body is circumscribed. It is not therefore changed into another nature, but it remaineth still a true body, though filled with divine glory. So Fulgentius, eOne and the same Christ (saith he) is both local man of man, and God infinite of his Father. One and the same according to his humane nature fabsent from heaven, when he was here upon earth, and leaving the earth when he went up into heaven: but according to his divine and infinite nature, neither leaving heaven, when he came down from heaven; nor forsaking the earth, when he went up into heaven. Which may most certainly be gathered from his own words, who to show that his humanity was local, said, gI go up to my Father, &c. Now how went he up into heaven, but because he was local and true man? Or how is he hyet present with his faithful ones, but that he is infinite and true God? And Uigilius most evidently against Eutyches (to pass by all other places, which are more then one in him) iIf the Word (saith he) and the Flesh were both of one nature, how should not the flesh be every where as well as the word? For kwhen it (to wit, Christs flesh, or his body, his humanity) was on earth, it was not in heaven;
3. To conclude this wilde discourse indeed, because we are in it compelled to follow one that turneth round till hee be giddy againe: when wee reason thus from the nature and property of a true body to be but in one place; wee reason no otherwise (howsoeuer hee esteeme it a wilde kinde of reasoning) then wise and learned men, yea Angels too, haue taught vs to reason. For as the Angell reasoneth with the nomen that came to seeke Christ in the Sepulcher; aHe is not here; for he is risen againe: which were no good Argument, if his bodie might haue beene in two places at once: So the ancient Fathers also reason in their disputes against Heretikes, where it stood them vpon to speake warily, and not to argue wildly, as this giddy braines tearmeth it. bChrists body (saith Theodoret) albeit it be now glorified, yet is a bodie still, and hath the same circumscriptiō that before it had Which (as the cAngels teach) shall come in the same manner as it was seene goe to heauen. ⟨p. 180⟩But they saw it then circumscribed. Yea our Lord himselfe saith, dYou shall see the Son of Man come in the clouds. But that nature cannot be seene, that is not circumscribed. He sheweth then that his body is circumscribed. It is not therefore changed into another nature, but it remaineth still a true body, though filled with divine glory. So Fulgentius, eOne and the same Christ (saith hee) is both locall man of man, and God infinite of his Father. One and the same according to his humane nature fabsent from heauen, when he was here vpon earth, and leaving the earth when he went vp into heauen: but according to his divine and infinite nature, neither leaving heauen, when he came downe from heauen; nor forsaking the earth, when hee went vp into heauen. Which may most certainely bee gathered from his owne wordes, who to shew that his humanity was locall, said, gI goe vp to my Father, &c. Now how went he vp into heauen, but because hee was locall and true man? Or how is hee h
land now because it is in heaven, it is not on earth: for that according to it mwe expect Christ to come from heaven, whom according to the Word (that is, his Deity) we believe to be with us on earth. It is apparent therefore that the same Christ is of a twofold nature, and is every where indeed according to the nature of his divinity; but is contained in a place according to the nature of his humanity. And he concludeth his discourse thus; nThis is the Catholic Faith and Confession, which the Apostles have delivered, Martyrs have confirmed, and the faithful keep to this day. And if this be so, then sure the Popish doctrine that affirmeth the clean contrary to it, is not.
land now because it is in heauen, it is not on earth: for that according to it mwe expect Christ to come from heauen, whom according to the Word (that is, his Deitie) we beleeue to be with vs on earth. It is apparent therefore that the same Christ is of a twofold nature, and is every where indeed according to the nature of his diviniti•; but is cōtained in a place according to the nature of his humanity. And hee concludeth his discourse thus; nThis is the Catholike Faith and Confession, which the Apostles haue deliuered, Martyrs haue confirmed, and the faithfull keepe to this day. And if this be so, then sure the Popish doctrine that affirmeth the cleane contrary to it, is not.
lEt nunc quia in coelo est, non est utique in terra.Et nunc quia in coelo est, non est vtique in terra.
nHaec est fides & confessio Catholica, quam A. postoli tradiderunt, Martyrs roboraverunt, & fideles nunc usque custodiunt.Haec est fides & confessio Catholica, quam A. postoli tradiderūt, Martyres roborauerunt, & fideles nunc vsque custodiunt.
Page 16. and 17. My Adversary wisely after his accustomed 1manner undertaketh by comparisons to declare the true manner of Christs body and blood being conveyed unto us in the Sacrament: and that so easily as if there were no difficulty at all in the explication thereof; whereas oCalvin himself accounteth it an inconceivable and unexplicable mystery, worthy with wonder and astonishment to be by us believed, how (to wit) Christs body so remotely distant as heaven is from the earth, can be eaten and received by us. pWe confess it (saith Beza) to be an incomprehensible mystery, wherein it cometh to pass that the same body which is and still remaineth in heaven, and is no where but there, should be truly communicated to us who are now on earth and no where else. This indeed is a mystery and true Jewell of Protestanticall doctrine harder to be conceived, as Calvin, Beza, and other chief Calvinists seem sometime to mean it, then to conceive all those true miracles, which we teach to be wrought by God in the consecration and use of this wonderful Sacrament. Yea surely it implieth an evident contradiction that Christs body should be truly given together with the sacramental signs, as Calvin expressly affirmeth, and so by ut eaten, that is no nearer then the top of heaven is to the mouth of such as receive him. If by faith only and a grateful memory of his passion we eat Christ in the Sacrament, as this Minister solveth the former riddle; no more present therein, nor in any other manner conjoined with the sacramental signs, then the land conveyed by an Indenture sealed is present or conveyed with the seal thereof, or then he is present in the water of Baptism: (they are his own comparisons) then is their Sacrament a bare sign and figure of Christs body, having no mystery at all worthy of admiration in it. For what wonder is it for a man to eat one thing thinking upon another; bread (for example) remembering our Saviours passion? And then are Calvin, Beza and many more of their ⟨p. 182⟩learnedest companions mere Jugglers and Impostors, who seek to plaster rotten walls, and mask with great words the naked breadinesse of their Protestanticall Sacrament.
PAge 16. and 17. My Adversarie wisely after his accustomed 1manner vndertaketh by comparisons to declare the true manner of Christs body and blood being conveighed vnto vs in the Sacrament: and that so easily as if there were no difficulty at all in the explication thereof; whereas oCaluin himselfe accounteth it an inconceiuable and vnexplicable mysterie, worthy with wonder and astonishment to bee by vs beleeved, how (to wit) Christs body so remotely distant as heauen is from the earth, can be eaten and receiued by vs. pWee confesse it (saith Beza) to be an incomprehensible mystery, wherein it commeth to passe that the same body which is and still remaineth in heauen, and is no where but there, should be truely cōmunicated to vs who are now on earth and no where else. This indeed is a mystery and true Iewell of Protestanticall doctrine harder to be conceived, as Caluin, Beza, and other chiefe Calvinists seeme sometime to meane it, then to conceiue all those true miracles, which we teach to be wrought by God in the consecration and vse of this wonderfull Sacrament. Yea surely it implyeth an evident contradiction that Christs body should be truely given together with the sacramentall signes, as Caluin expressely affirmeth, and so by vt eaten, that is no neerer then the top of heauen is to the mouth of such as receiue him. If by faith onely and a gratefull memory of his passion we eate Christ in the Sacrament, as this Minister solueth the former riddle; no more present therein, nor in any other manner conioyned with the sacramentall signes, then the land conveighed by an Indenture sealed is present or conveighed with the seale thereof, or then he is present in the water of Baptisme: (they are his owne comparisons) then is their Sacrament a bare signe and figure of Christs body, having no mystery at all worthy of admiration in it. For what wonder is it for a man to eate one thing thinking vpon another; bread (for example) remembring our Saviours passion? And then are Caluin, Beza and many more of their ⟨p. 182⟩learnedest companions meer Iuglers and Impostors, who seeke to plaister rotten wals, and maske with great wordes the naked breadinesse of their Protestanticall Sacrament.
AT the end of this Argument I answer an Objection, 1how Christs body and blood can be conveyed unto us, or eaten and drunk of us in the Eucharist, if he be not there present. Which Question from the Fathers (as you heard before) may in a word be soon answered. Because our Saviour showed it by those words of his concerning his ascension, & his speech thereunto annexed, to be a spiritual not a corporal kind of communication. And if they will hear one of their own Bishops, Jansenius; he will tell them, that qto eat Christs flesh and drink his blood is to believe in his Incarnation and in his passion and blood, shedding; and that so by faith either of them are both present with us, and conveyed to us as well in the Sacrament, as out of it. But hereupon this mine Adversary befooling me for my labour, for taking such a task upon me, to answer such a Question; saith, I undertake to declare that by comparisons, as if there were no difficulty at all in it, cwhich Calvin and Beza confess to be a mystery, unconceivable, incomprehensible, inexplicable, yea which (as we hold it) implieth an evident contradiction: affirming that Christ is no more present therein, nor in any manner conjoined with the sacramental signs, then the land conveyed by an Indenture sealed is present with the same, or then he is present with the water in Baptism. Whereupon he worthily inferreth; that this our Sacrament then is but a bare sign or figure of Christs body having no mystery at all worthy of admiration; and Calvin and Beza, &c. are but Jugglers and Impostors.
AT the end of this Argument I answer an Obiection, 1how Christs body and blood can be conveighed vnto vs, or eaten and drunke of vs in the Eucharist, if hee be not there present. Which Question from the Fathers (as you heard before) may in a word be soone answered. Because our Sauiour shewed it by those wordes of his concerning his ascension, & his speech therunto annexed, to be a spirituall not a corporall kind of communication. And if they will heare one of their owne Bishops, Iansenius; hee will tell them, that qto eate Christs flesh and drinke his blood is to beleeue in his Incarnation and in his passion and blood, sheading; and that so by faith either of them are both present with vs, and conueighed to vs as well in the Sacrament, as out of it. But hereupon this mine Aduersary befooling me for my labour, for taking such a task vpon me, to answer such a Question; saith, I vndertake to declare that by comparisons, as if there were no difficulty at all in it, cwhich Calvin and Beza confesse to be a mysterie, vnconceiuable, incomprehensible, inexplicable, yea which (as wee hold it) implyeth an evident contradiction: affirming that Christ is no more present therein, nor in any manner conioyned with the sacramentall signes, then the land conveighed by an Indenture sealed is present with the same, or then hee is present with the water in Baptisme. Whereupon hee worthily inferreth; that this our Sacrament then is but a bare signe or figure of Christs body having no mystery at all worthy of admiration; and Calvin and Beza, &c. are but Iuglers and Impostors.
1T. G.
qJansen. in concold. Evang. c. 59.Iansen. in concold. Euang. c. 59.
cAll this of Calvin and Beza he borroweth from Bellarmine de Euch. l. 1. c. 1.
It might well have been one of Hercules his labours to purge this mans writings. Augaeus his stable was not fuller of dirt and dung, then they are of foul and filthy corrupt matter, and of loud and lewd lies.
It might well haue been one of Hercules his labours to purge this mans writings. Augaeus his stable was not fuller of durt and dung, then they are of foule and filthy corrupt matter, and of lowd and lewd lies.
1. Where do I affirm it to be a matter without all difficulty fully to explicate the admirable efficacy and ⟨p. 183⟩operation of divine mysteries, or the manner how the same is effected? I show only by some comparisons (and those such as the Apostle warranteth the use of) how Christ may being absent, be truly and effectually conveyed and assured unto us. But followeth it thence that I hold the thing it self for the manner of effecting it to have no difficulty at all in it? Do not the ancient Fathers hold the Trinity an unsearchable mystery? And yet what is more common among them then sby Comparisons and similitudes to show how in one nature there may be a plurality of persons? This Disputant himself among other wondrous works reckoneth the resurrection of mens bodies for one: will he say that the Fathers therefore deem that there is no difficulty in it, because tby sundry similitudes they endeavour to prove a possibility of it; notwithstanding the frequent and successive conversions of them into other things altered and consumed, as he speaketh?
1. Where doe I affirme it to bee a matter without all difficulty fully to explicate the admirable efficacy and ⟨p. 183⟩operation of divine mysteries, or the manner how the same is effected? I shew onely by some comparisons (and those such as the Apostle warranteth the vse of) how Christ may being absent, bee truely and effectually conueighed and assured vnto vs. But followeth it thence that I hold the thing it selfe for the manner of effecting it to haue no difficulty at all in it? Doe not the ancient Fathers hold the Trinitie an vnsearchable mysterie? And yet what is more common among them then sby Comparisons and similitudes to shew how in one nature there may be a plurality of persons? This Disputant himselfe among other wondrous workes reckoneth the resurrection of mens bodies for one: will hee say that the Fathers therefore deeme that there is no difficulty in it, because tby sundry similitudes they endeauour to proue a possibilitie of it; notwithstanding the frequent and successiue conuersions of them into other things altered and consumed, as hee speaketh?
sSee Greg. Naz. ad Nectar. and Aug. de Trinit l. 10, 11, 12, 13. & de verb. Ap hom 1. &c.
tSee Tertull. de resurr. carn. Athenag. de resurr. &c yea the Apostle himself 1Cor. 15. 35, 36. 37.
iuglers box (the Popish pyx, or the like) not to worke saluation, but to make sport with. This I haue the rather insisted vpon to shew how the Papists iump in their conceits
⟨p. 166⟩
about this their breaden God; and strange fantasticall body, that hath all parts of a mans body, and yet none at all to be seen, felt, heard, yea or vnderstood, with the Hereticks of old time; and to confirme these their dotages vse and vrge the very same Arguments that they then did, by the ancient Fathers long since answered:
hSo translate I him, aliuding to our English phrase. His sense is apparent.So translate I him, aliuding to our Enlish phrase. His sense is apparent.
It is impossible that one and the selfe same thing should both rest and stirre at once. And yet should Christs body, if it were in the Host, or if it were the very Host rather, doe all this, when at the same time it both resteth in the Pyx in one place, and goeth in Procession in another place, and is in diuerse processions, or on sundry seuerall occasions carried contrary wayes to seuerall persons and places at the same instant.
Ideò idem a••idens non potest esse in diuersis subiectis. Ibid.
kUnde & idē non potest simul moveri motibus oppositis. Durand. in sent. l. 4. d. 10. q. 3.Vnde & idē non potest simul moueri motibus oppositis. Durand. in sent. l. 4. d. 10. q. 3.
lImpossibile est quod unus motus eiusdē corporis localiter moti terminetur simul ad diversa •oca. Thom sum. p. 3. q 75. a. 2.Impossibile est quod vnus motus eiusdē corporis localiter moti terminetur simul ad diuersa •oca. Thom sum. p. 3. q 75. a. 2.
mImpossibile est idem esse motum & quietum. Ibid. q 76. a. 6.
that it may spiritually be distributed to each one, and become to each one a safegard and preseruatiue for resurrection to life eternall. So little doth this place auaile for this purpose, as the Ancients both Latine and Greeke expound it:
yet present with his faithfull ones, but that hee is infinite and true God? And Uigilius most euidently against Eutyches (to passe by all other places, which are more then one in him)