THE THIRD PART. Mr. BALMFORDS Arguments against Games consisting in or depending upon Chance, taken out of his Dialogue. Together with Mr. GATAKERS Answer to them in his Book of the Nature and Use of LOTS. As also Mr. Bs. Reply in defence of them: and Mr. Gs. Rejoinder thereunto.THE THIRD PART. Mr. BALMFORDS Arguments against Games consisting in or depending vpon Chance, taken out of his Dialogue. Together with Mr. GATAKERS Answer to them in his Booke of the Nature and Vse of LOTS. As also Mr. Bs. Reply in defence of them: and Mr. Gs. Reioinder thereunto.
pp. 163–270256 passagespart 4 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
T. G. Then belike it was produced to prove nothing at all that was to be proved. For the point to be proved was not that Gods people prayed at the use of a Lot, but that that a Lot doth suppose the determining presence, or immediate providence of God. Which hereby also Mr. B. endeavoured to prove. But now Mr. B. it seemeth, taketh that for a thing granted; which is the point that he is to prove. The instance is to the purpose; for it doth show that Prayer is not therefore implied in a Lot, as in an Oath, though it be used thereabout.
T. G. Then belike it was produced to proue nothing at all that was to be proued. For the point to bee proued was not that Gods people praied at the vse of a Lot, but that that a Lot doth suppose the determining presence, or immediate prouidence of God. Which hereby also Mr. B. endeuoured to proue. But now Mr. B. it seemeth, taketh that for a thing granted; which is the point that he is to proue. The instance is to the purpose; for it doth shew that Praier is not therefore implied in a Lot, as in an Oath, though it be vsed thereabout.
I. B. If then there be an immediate providence of God in a Lot, and in regard thereof prayer is to be expressed or understood in the lawful use of a Lot, then praying and playing (though they rime well together, yet) run not well together in the lawful use of a Lot. Nay rather it followeth from both, That a Lot is not to be used but in a case of necessity more or less. And therefore strange (I will not say, absurd) is Mr. Gs. Position p. 111. to wit, The less weighty the matter is, wherein a Lot is used, the lawfuller the Lot is. Except it be proved, that the less weighty the matter is, the greater is the necessity of ending the controversy by a Lot. The said Position is more strange, because he granteth p. 95. That Prayer specially applied to the Lot may (in some case) be conceived, where the matter is more weighty, as in the choice of a Magistrate. But concerning ⟨p. 213⟩this also more shall be said in my next Reply.
I. B. If then there be an immediate prouidence of God in a Lot, and in regard thereof praier is to be expressed or vnderstood in the lawfull vse of a Lot, then praying and playing (though they rime well together, yet) run not well together in the lawfull vse of a Lot. Nay rather it followeth from both, That a Lot is not to be vsed but in a case of necessitie more or lesse. And therefore strange (I will not say, absurd) is Mr. Gs. Position p. 111. to wit, The lesse weightie the matter is, wherein a Lot is vsed, the lawfuller the Lot is. Except it be proued, that the lesse weightie the matter is, the greater is the necessitie of ending the controuersie by a Lot. The said Position is more strange, because he granteth p. 95. That Prayer specially applied to the Lot may (in some case) be conceiued, where the matter is more weightie, as in the choise of a Magistrate. But concerning