THE SECOND ARTICLE OF COMMUNION UNDER BOTH KINDS.THE SECONDE ARTICLE OF COMMVNION VNDER BOTHE KINDES.
pp. 96–150330 passagespart 2 of 9
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The argument that hereof is gathered, standeth thus: Clement saith, that Christ gave only unto his Apostles, the office of the Ministry, and authority to offer the spiritual Sacrifice, Ergo, these words, drink ye all of this, pertain nothing to the people. Here is a very faint conclusion. For by force of this reason, he may take from the people both parts of the Sacrament, as well as one, and so leave them no Sacrament at all.
The argument that hereof is geathered, standeth thus: Clement saithe, that Christe gaue onely vnto his Apostles, the office of the Ministerie, and authoritie to offer the spiritual Sacrifice, Ergo, these woordes, drinke ye al of this, perteine nothinge to the people. Here is a very fainte conclusion. For by force of this reason, he may take from the people bothe partes of the Sacrament, as wel as one, and so leaue them no Sacrament at al.
M. Harding. The .4. Division.
M. Hardinge. The .4. Diuision.
And this understood they which above one hundred years past, 501 changing the old custom of the Church of receiving the Communion under one kind by their private authority, would needs usurp the Cup also. For seeing them selves not to have sufficient proof, and warrant for their doing,2 of these words, drink ye all of this, the better to bolster up their new fangled attempt, they thought it better to allege the words of Christ in S. John. Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, ye shall not have life in you: which words, for all that our new Masters of forty years paste, will to be understanded of the spiritual, and not of the Sacramental eating, as it may be, and is taken for both, of the Doctors, viewed a part: Yet in all that Chapter, there is no mention of the Cup, nor of Wine at all. Wherefore they that cry so much on the institution and commandment of Christ, cannot find in all the Scriptures neither commandment, where he gave charge, the Sacrament so to be given, neither so much as any example, where Christ gave it under both kinds to any other then to the Apostles. Where as contrariwise it may be showed of our part, that the Sacrament was given under one kind only to the two Disciples, that went to Emmaus.