Rainoldes. But Genebrard hath granted that to be false which he voucheth. For he saith that Constantine did give to Pope Sylvester, the provinces, and places, and fortresses of all Italy, or of the western countries, and not the city of Rome only. Neither doth he vouch this in respect of Rome but of Constantinople: which being to enjoy the privileges of Rome oby a law y• Photius rehearseth in his Nomocanon, Now if you will know the privileges of Rome (saith Balsamon) they are enrolled in the decree of Constantine's donation made to Pope Sylvester. So that it was for love to the Patriarchs See of Constantinople, not to the Popes of Rome, that he avoucheth it: that as Rome might thereby claim all the West, so Constantinople might get all the East. Wherefore, that circumstance, that Balsamon was an enemy of the See of Rome, doth nothing help the credit of Constantine's donation. Neither doth S. Isidore make much more for it, as pNauclerus citeth him. For, as he citeth him, he giveth him a touch withal to overthrow him. There is (saith Nauclerus) no mention of Constantine's donation in any authors, but in the book of decrees: and the Archbishop of Florence, Antoninus, affirmeth in his chronicles, that in ancient books of the Decrees it is not neither. Which I greatly marvel at, sith Isidore reporteth plainly in his story, that Constantine did yield the city of Rome unto the Pope, and all the imperial ornaments, that is to say, the crown, the apparel, and the white palfrey to ride upon. Nauclerus therefore citeth Isidore as saying it: but so, as though he thought all were not well in Isidore, sith there is no mention of it in any authors of credit or antiquity. I showed you qbefore how the writings of the ancient Fathers have been corrupted to countenance the Popes ⟨p. 413⟩power. The story of Isidore might be wrought in like sort to countenance the Popes pomp, his triple crown, his robes imperial, his *horses of estate. Which to have been so, it is the more likely, because it is testified by rmen who had helps to search and see such ancient evidences, that in old copies of Isidore that is not found. And perhaps if that story of Isidore were printed, that we might have the sight of it: it were no hard matter to find s•me tokens there of forgery. At the least, it seemeth that Genebrard himself suspected some weakness in that point of Isidore:
Rainoldes. But Genebrard hath graunted that to be false which he voucheth. For he saith that Constantine did giue to Pope Syluester, the prouinces, and places, and fortresses of al Italie, or of the westerne countries, and not the citie of Rome onely. Neither doth he vouch this in respect of Rome but of Constantinople: which being to enioy the priuileges of Rome oby a law y• Photius rehearseth in his Nomocanon, Now if you will know the priuileges of Rome (saith Balsamon) they are enrolled in the decree of Constantines donation made to Pope Syluester. So that it was for loue to the Patriarkes Sée of Constantinople, not to the Popes of Rome, that hee auoucheth it: that as Rome might therby claime al the West, so Constantinople might get all the East. Wherefore, that circumstance, that Balsamon was an enimie of the See of Rome, doth nothing helpe the credit of Constantines donation. Neither doth S. Isidore make much more for it, as pNauclerus citeth him. For, as he citeth him, he giueth him a touch withall to ouerthrow him. There is (saith Nauclerus) no mention of Constantines donation in any autours, but in the booke of decrees: and the Archbishop of Florence, Antoninus, affirmeth in his chronicles, that in ancient bookes of the Decreees it is not neither. Which I greatly maruaile at, sith Isidore reporteth plainely in his storie, that Constantine did yeeld the citie of Rome vnto the Pope, and all the imperiall ornaments, that is to say, the crowne, the apparell, and the white palfrey to ride vpon. Nauclerus therefore citeth Isidore as saying it: but so, as though he thought all were not well in Isidore, sith there is no mention of it in any autours of credit or antiquitie. I shewed you qbefore how the writings of the auncient Fathers haue beene corrupted to countenance the Popes ⟨p. 413⟩power. The storie of Isidore might be wrought in like sort to countenance the Popes pompe, his triple crowne, his robes imperiall, his *horses of estate. Which to haue beene so, it is the more likely, because it is testified by rmen who had helpes to se•ch and sée such auncient euidences, that in olde copies of Isidore that is not found. And perhaps if that storie of Isidore were printed, that we might haue the sight of it: it were no hard matter to finde sme tokens there of forgerie. At the least, it séemeth that Genebrard himselfe suspected some weakenes in that point of Isidore:
- oIn nomoca•. ••ot. tit. 8. cap. 1.
- pChronogr. volum. 2. generat. 11.
- qChap. •. Divis. 2.Chap. •. Diuis. 2.
- *Equi albi phaleris auteis cope•tisque de cremosino ornati. Sacr. ceremon. Rom. eccles. lib. 1. tit. 2.
- rIllyricus, Wigandus, Index & Faber Histor. ecclesiast. Magdeb. Centur. •. cap. 7.