Rainoldes. You are the writer, M. Hart. I showed by the history of Sigonius, and others, most worthy of credit, that the Popes usurped Rome, and the dominion of the Roman Dukedom, defrauding the Emperor of his right by treason. You affirm the contrary. And for proof thereof you allege sundry epistles of S. Gregory, whereby it appeareth that they had possessions in Africa, in Naples, in Campania, in Dalmatia, in France, in Italy, in Sicily, and in Sardinia, before the time wherein Sigonius declareth them to have usurped. But, as your self answered, they might have these possessions while they were Bishops, and not Princes. Wherefore in bringing this to prove that they usurped not the Princedom (so to term it) and temporal dominion of the Papal State: you disprove not the history of Sigonius, and the rest, but bewray your own frowardness or folly. Nay you bewray greater faults of evil & guileful dealing, as you handle it. For whereas Sigonius, & the rest, whom I cited to prove the Popes usurping, are of y• Popes religion, & therefore of greater credit against the Popes: you say nought to them, but name in their steed our authors of the Centuries. Even as if the writer (whom I told you of) being urged with the credit of sir Thomas More and English historians, should answer that although Funccius, a German, report in his Chronicle that Richard did usurp, yet is he notably disproved by the evidences of the house of York. Again, where your conclusion ought to be resolute that the Churches possessions were more in S. Gregory's time, then they be now: you say they were more, as it may probably be thought. To overbear verity with probability; the truth, with likelihood of truth: and leave your self a lurking hole, that, although the thing be found to be false, yet you may escape who vouch it not as true, but probable. Moreover, the time of Gregory's being Bishop, you term it his reign: thereby to breed opinion that he had the temporal dominion, as they have now. Wherein that word is used so much the more deceitfully: because it prepareth a way to the mistaking of that ⟨p. 420⟩which you allege out of Gregory's epistles touching S. Peters patrimony. For. S. Peters patrimony doth signify the temporal dominion of the Popes, in that of lClemangis, which you began your answer with. And so by this [reign] a man would take it here.
Rainoldes. You are the writer, M. Hart. I shewed by the historie of Sigonius, and others, most worthie of credit, that the Popes vsurped Rome, and the dominion of the Roman Dukedom, defrauding the Emperour of his right by treason. You affirme the contrarie. And for proofe thereof you alleage sundrie epistles of S. Gregorie, whereby it appeareth that they had possessions in Afrike, in Naples, in Campania, in Dalmatia, in Fraunce, in Italie, in Sicilia, and in Sardinia, before the time wherein Sigonius declareth them to haue vsurped. But, as your selfe answered, they might haue these possessions while they were Bishops, and not Princes. Wherefore in bringing this to proue that they vsurped not the Princedome (so to terme it) and temporall dominion of the Papall State: you disproue not the historie of Sigonius, and the rest, but bewray your owne frowardnesse or follie. Nay you bewray greater fautes of euil & guilful dealing, as you h•ndle it. For whereas Sigonius, & the rest, whom I cited to p•oue the Popes vsurping, are of y• Popes religion, & therefore of greater credit against the Popes: you say nought to them, but name in their steed our autors of the Centuries. Euen as if the writer (whom I told you of) being vrged with the credit of sir Thomas More and English historians, should answere that although Funccius, a German, report in his Chronicle that Richard did vsurpe, yet is he notably disproued by the euidences of the house of Yorke. Againe, where your conclusion ought to be resolute that ye Churches poss•ssions were more in S. Gregories time, then they be now: you say they were more, as it may probably be thought. To ouerbeare veritie with probabilitie; the truth, with likelihood of truth: and leaue your selfe a lurking hole, that, although the thing be found to be false, yet you may escape who vouch it not as true, but probable. Moreouer, the time of Gregories being Bishop, you terme it his reigne: thereby to bréede opinion that he had the temporall dominion, as they haue now. Wherein that worde is vsed so much the more deceitfully: because it prepareth a way to the mistaking of that ⟨p. 420⟩which you alleage out of Gregories epistles touching S. Peters patrimonie. For. S. Peters patrimonie doth signifie the temporall dominion of the Popes, in that of lClemangis, which you began your answere with. And so by this [reigne] a man would take it here.
- lDe corrupt. eccles. stat. cap. 4