WILLIAM WHITAKERS. The answer to the eighth Reason, which is the Paradoxes of our adversaries.WILLIAM WHITAKERS. The answere to the eighth Reason, which is the Paradoxes of our aduersaries.
pp. 191–25957 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Hierome said that he would not have any man to be patient, if he were suspected of heresy. And therefore, Campian, in so much the worser part do I take it, that these which you term Paradoxes, being so false, so many, and so horrible, be now by you objected against us. And certainly you that have ever exceeded all other Papists in impudency and audaciousness, have in this place in very ⟨p. 192⟩
deed surpassed your self: for unless you had quite and clean put off both all religion of God, and reverence toward men, and now of late made shipwreck of your own conscience, and cast off utterly all humanity, you would never have admitted so much impiety into your self, as to upbraid us with these monstrous opinions. But I perceive what you intend: for you hope that by slandering boldly, as he being most like you, was wont to say, somewhat would always clean fast. For sith you lack true imputations, whereby you might oppugn our Churches, it remained that either you should leave off writing, which had been your honestest way, or at lest devise some slanders, which you would cast like unomed darts upon us; which thing is both in it self very filthy, and also a sure argument of your desperateness. But now if I shall so wipe away these your Paradoxes and impossibilities, that all men may perceive, they were ascribed to us by you most falsely and most impudently; I do crave not only of all men of our Universities, but also of all Christians, that have care of true religion, and of their own salvation, that they will not suffer themselves to be misled by any lies and impostures of the adversary, from that holy doctrine which they have learned. Wherefore I will set upon these your monsters, Campian, that after I have stopped your mouth, being full of blasphemy, both the glory of God, which is in hand, and our innocency, which is oppugned, may be preserved from your violence. You say, the disputation shall be, if they please, of God, of Christ, of Man, of Sin, of Righteousness, of the Sacraments, of Manners. But we are ready to dispute with you not only about these, but also about other points, which are now in difference: of the Scripture, of the Church, of the Bishop of Rome, of Transubstantiation, of Freewill, of Indulgences, of Purgatory, and of the rest of your doctrines.
HIerome said that hee would not haue any man to bee patient, if hee were suspected of heresie. And therefore, Campian, in so much the worser part do I take it, that these which you terme Paradoxes, being so false, so many, and so horrible, be now by you obiected against vs. And certainlie you that haue euer exceeded all other Papists in impudency and audaciousnes, haue in this place in very ⟨p. 192⟩deed surpassed your selfe: for vnlesse you had quite and cleane put off both all religion of God, and reuerence toward men, and now of late made shipwracke of your owne conscience, and cast off vtterly all humanity, you would neuer haue admitted so much impietie into your selfe, as to vpbraide vs with these monstrous opinions. But I perceiue what you intend: for you hope that by slaundering boldly, as he being most like you, was wont to say, somewhat would alwaies cleane fast. For sith you lacke true imputations, whereby you might oppugne our Churches, it remained that either you should leaue off writing, which had been your honestest way, or at lest deuise some slaunders, which you would cast like vnomed darts vpon vs; which thing is both in it selfe very filthy, and also a sure argument of your desperatenes. But now if I shall so wipe away these your Paradoxes and impossibilities, that al men may perceiue, they were ascribed to vs by you most falsly and most impudently; I do craue not only of all men of our Vniuersities, but also of all Christiās, that haue care of true religion, and of their owne saluation, that they will not suffer themselues to be misled by any lies and impostures of the aduersarie, from that holy doctrine which they haue learned. Wherefore I will set vpon these your monsters, Campian, that after I haue stopt your mouth, being ful of blasphemy, both the glory of God, which is in hand, and our innocency, which is oppugned, may be preserued from your violence. You say, the disputation shall be, if they please, of God, of Christ, of Man, of Sinne, of Righteousnes, of the Sacraments, of Manners. But we are readie to dispute with you not only about these, but also about other points, which are now in difference: of the Scripture, of the Church, of the Bishop of Rome, of Transubstantiation, of Freewill, of Indulgences, of Purgatorie, and of the rest of your doctrines.
Nevertheless ⟨p. 193⟩either many are deceived, or else you do rather think of fighting then disputing. And I hope that you shall once have freedom granted you for that disputation, which you so often desire. But now let us attend how you endeavour to make us know these positions of our men.
Neuerthelesse ⟨p. 193⟩either many are deceiued, or else you do rather thinke of fighting then disputing. And I hope that you shall once haue freedome granted you for that disputation, which you so often desire. But now let vs attend how you endeuour to make vs know these positions of our men.
God (say you) is the willing, 1suggesting, efficient, commanding, and working author and cause of sin, and such a one as therein governeth the impious counsels of the wicked. It is an horrible thing and not to be uttered, Campian, that any one should make God the author of sin: such an one were worthy to be smitten instantly by the Lord, with a thunderbolt into the deepest pit of hell. Ifa Calvin, or Martyr, or Philip, or Luther, or any of us do affirm it, I do not deny but we are all guilty of horrible blasphemy and impiety. If I would largely prosecute this whole cause, which you do but touch, I should make no end: therefore I will declare in few words, both what we teach, and wherein you lie. We profess, not only that God is good, but also goodness it self; yea good in himself & in his own essence: in whom there is no evil; from whom nothing but good can come: who is so good, that all his doings be very good, and that not so much as any of his thoughts can be evil. These things we speak, these things we teach, these things we believe with our harts, and confess with our mouths. Seeing therefore God is so perfectly good, ⟨p. 194⟩that all his things be in a certain excellent manner good, it hath been in times past inquired and most gravely disputed, whence that evil sprung, which had spread so far, & what might be the cause of this evil. This question Augustine often handled, because of the Manichees,3 and therein also Thomas of Aquine employed himself much and diligently. We say that this evil was brought in by theb Devil, who although he were made good in the beginning by the Lord, yet by his freewill he made defection from the Lord and sinned; •nd did persuade, and was the author unto man, to commit sin: from hence, whatsoever is sin either in the devils, or in men, did wholly flow, and not any the least piece of it had being from God, whom we do maintain by infinite testimonies of Scripture to be the author of noc sin; and so do teach it in our schools and Churches.6 For he hateth sin, he loveth righteousness: he which is the Judge of the whole earth, it must needs be that he is every way most just: God is light, and there is no darkness in him. And these are the things which we teach the people concerning God, that all may understand he is a most severe revenger of all sins.
God (say you) is the willing, 1suggesting, efficient, commaunding, and working author and cause of sinne, and such a one as therein gouerneth the impious counsels of the wicked. It is an horrible thing and not to be vttred, Campian, that any one should make God the author of sinne: such an one were worthy to be smitten instantly by the Lord, with a thunderbolt into the deepest pit of hell. Ifa Caluin, or Martyr, or Philip, or Luther, or any of vs do affirme it, I do not denie but we are all guilty of horrible blasphemie and impiety. If I would largely prosecute this whole cause, which you doe but touch, I should make no end: therfore I will declare in few words, both what we teach, and wherein you lie. We professe, not only that God is good, but also goodnes it self; yea good in himself & in his owne essēce: in whom there is no euill; from whom nothing but good can come: who is so good, that all his doings be very good, and that not so much as any of his thoughts can be euil. These things we speake, these things we teach, these things we beleeue with our harts, and confesse with our mouthes. Seeing therefore God is so perfectly good, ⟨p. 194⟩that all his things be in a certaine excellent manner good, it hath been in times past inquired and most grauely disputed, whēce that euil sprung, which had spread so far, & what might be the cause of this euill. This question Augustine often handled, because of the M•nichies,3 and therein also Thomas of Aquine imployed himselfe much and diligently. Wee say that this euill was brought in by theb Diuell, who although hee were made good in the beginning by the Lord, yet by his freewill he made defection from the Lord and sinned; •nd did perswade, and was the author vnto man, to commit sin: from hence, whatsoeuer is sin either in the diuels, or in men, did wholy flow, and not any the least peece of it had being from God, whom we do maintaine by infinite testimonies of Scripture to be the author of noc sinne; and so do teach it in our schooles and Churches.6 For he hateth sin, he loueth righteousnes: he which is the Iudge of the whole earth, it must needs be that he is euery way most iust: God is light, and there is no darknes in him. And these are the things which wee teach the people concerning God, that all may vnderstand hee is a most seuere reuenger of all sinnes.
1Of God.
aDVR. But if I do not show, that Calvin is the maintainer of this so horrible ablasphemy. I refuse no punishment for so great a slander: thus he writeth Instit. lib. 1. cap. 18. sect. 1. Absalom defiling his fathers bed with incest committed a detestable crime: yet God pronounceth that this was his work. WHIT pag. 525. I wonder that there is any man found like to Campian, who will •uow that to be said and defended by our men, which they have ever most plainly condemned, as Melanct. on Rom. 1. &c. Pet. Mart on Judg 9. and Caluin on Jam. 1. vers. 13. Beza against Castellio, of eternal predestination: for touching these words which you object to Calvin, what doth he affirm, but that which the Scripture hath delivered, 2. Sam 12.11.12? unless perhaps you will deny that to be Gods deed, which God himself witnesseth to be his. Neither will your sophism follow hereupon, ergo God is the author of sin: for Calvin ascribeth not the sin, but the work to God. For if in that incest you can consider nothing but sin, it must be imputed to your ignorance.DVR. But if I do not shew, that Caluin is the maintainer of this so horrible ablasphemy. I refuse no punishment for so great a slāder: thus he writeth Instit. lib. 1. cap. 18. sect. 1. Absolom defiling his fathers bed with incest committed a detestable crime: yet God pronounceth that this was his worke. WHIT pag. 525. I wonder that there is any mā found like to Campian, who will •uow that to be said and defended by our men, which they haue euer most plainly condemned, as Melanct. on Rom. 1. &c. Pet. Mart on Iudg 9. and Caluin on Iam. 1. vers. 13. Beza against Castellio, of eternall predestination: for touching these words which you obiect to Caluin, what doth he affirme, but that which the Scripture hath deliuered, 2. Sam 12.11.12? vnlesse perhap• you will deny that to be Gods deed, which God himselfe witnesseth to be his. Neither will your sophisme follow hereupon, ergo God is the author of sin: for Caluin ascribeth not the sinne, but the worke to God. For if in that incest you can consider nothing but sinne, it must bee imputed to your ignorance.
Now then, Campian, with what face dare you, seeing you know these to be our doctrines, impute unto us such a slander not to be uttered, in so much as you affirm that we speak and think things flat contrary? But you say Calvin and Martyr have taught this ⟨p. 195⟩this thing. Nay rather they are wholly bent upon this, that they maintain, that can by no means be. It would be long to set down their words. I do beseech the Reader, to read with an attentive and peaceable mind, these same very places, which Campian hath abused unto slander. And if they do not both deny most plainly that God is the author and cause of sin; and also if they do not prove that they do most truly deny this, which they deny, I will submit my self to any punishment. But yet there is doubtless somewhat, which these men say, and which Campian doth attribute to them: what that is, let us consider.
Now then, Campian, with what face dare you, seeing you know these to bee our doctrines, impute vnto vs such a slāder not to be vttred, in so much as you affirme that we speake and thinke things flat contrary? But you say Caluin and Martyr haue taught this ⟨p. 195⟩this thing. Nay rather they are wholy bent vpō this, that they maintaine, that can by no meanes bee. It would be long to set down their words. I do beseech the Reader, to reade with an attentiue and peaceable mind, these same very places, which Campian hath abused vnto slander. And if they doe not both deny most plainly that God is the author and cause of sin; and also if they do not proue that they do most truly deny this, which they deny, I will submit my selfe to any punishment. But yet there is doubtlesse somewhat, which these men say, and which Campian doth attribute to them: what that is, let vs consider.
There was a certain inveterate opinion among men, that whatsoever sin was committed by any, all that was done, God only permitting, and not willing it: now they did separate this permission utterly from all will of God, so as they affirmed that God did no way will those things which he had permitted. But now seeing the Lord is to be held tod permit those things which are done, not only that they might be done, as if he did no whit intermeddle himself in those things, nor had nothing at all to do therein, but also doth by his special providence so govern all things, as that nothing in the whole world happeneth against tha•, that he hath willed & decreed: certainly it cannot be denied, that God doth will after a sort those things, which the wicked do, & that this will of God is so effectual, that in the wicked actions of men, God doth execute his own decree. For in sin two things are to be considered, the action it self, and the corruption of the action: which thing your Aquine might teach you, which ⟨p. 196⟩also he learned from Augustine. The action so far forth as it is a thing and a work, is good; for God effecteth it: but so far forth as this self same action is vicious, it proceedeth not from God, but from the corrupt nature of man. Although therefore God who worketh all things in all, and against whose will nothing can be done; doth bring to pass a certain work of his in the evil actions of men; yet he doth those things that are just, nor ought he any way to be thought to be guilty of the sins of the men themselves: therefore that which a wicked man doth, that, as it is a sin, and as it hath the proper nature of sin, the Lord neither willeth nor suggesteth, nor biddeth, nor effecteth; nay he detesteth and revengeth it, and judgeth it worthy of everlasting punishment. But that which is spoken of the thing, that you apply maliciously and unskilfully, to the quality of the thing, that you may conclude, that God, because he is the author and cause of the action, is also the author and cause of whatsoever corruption is found in that action. I will not prosecute any long digression, nor overwhelm you with that multitude of Scriptures, which I could here use: for I have not taken upon me to expound any point in the Schools, but briefly to confute your filthy slander.
There was a certaine inueterate opinion among men, that whatsoeuer sinne was committed by any, all that was done, God only permitting, and not willing it: now they did separate this permission vtterly from all will of God, so as they affirmed that God did no way will those things which he had permitted. But now seeing the Lord is to be held tod permit those things which are done, not only that they might bee done, as if hee did no whit intermeddle himselfe in those things, nor had nothing at all to do therein, but also doth by his speciall prouidence so gouerne all things, as that nothing in the whole world happeneth against tha•, that he hath willed & decreed: certainly it cānot be denied, that God doth will after a sort those things, which the wicked doe, & that this wil of God is so effectual, that in the wicked actions of men, God doth execute his owne decree. For in sinne two things are to be considered, the action it selfe, and the corruption of the action: which thing your Aquine might teach you, which ⟨p. 196⟩also he learned from Augustine. The action so farre forth as it is a thing and a worke, is good; for God effecteth it: but so farre forth as this selfe same action is vitious, it proceedeth not from God, but from the corrupt nature of man. Although therefore God who worketh all things in all, and against whose will nothing can bee done; doth bring to passe a certaine worke of his in the euill actions of men; yet hee doth those things that are iust, nor ought he any way to be thought to be guiltie of the sinnes of the men themselues: therefore that which a wicked man doth, that, as it is a sinne, and as it hath the proper nature of sinne, the Lord neither willeth nor suggesteth, nor biddeth, nor effecteth; nay he detesteth and reuengeth it, and iudgeth it worthy of euerlasting punishment. But that which is spoken of the thing, that you applie malitiously and vnskilfully, to the qualitie of the thing, that you may conclude, that God, because he is the author and cause of the action, is also the author and cause of whatsoeuer corruption is found in that action. I will not prosecute any long digression, nor ouerwhelme you with that multitude of Scr•ptures, which I could here vse: for I haue not taken vpon me to expound any poynt in the Schooles, but briefely to confute your filthie slaunder.
dDVR. Here you, while you, would defend that God is not the author of sin, yet do nothing else but make him the author of sin: for if he do not only permit, but also willeth that man sin, tell me which way, if the will of God be the first and effecting cause of sin, God is not the author of sin. WHIT. pag▪ 535. There is no need that I should expound to you that which you demand for we do not make the will of God to be the first and •ffecting cause of the sin, but of the action, which as it cometh from a wicked man, is vicious, so then not the vvill of God, but the naughtiness of the instrument, is the cause that those things are done wickedly, which the Lord doth rightly.DVR. Here you, while you, vvould defend that God is not the author of sinne, yet do nothing else but make him the author of sinne: for if he do not only permit, but also willeth that man sinne, tell me which way, if the will of God be the first and effecting cause of sinne, God is not the author of sinne. WHIT. pag▪ 535. There is no need that I should expound to you that which you demaund for we do not make the will of God to be the first and •ffecting cause of the sin, but of the action, which as it commeth from a wicked man, is vitious, so then not the vvill of God, but the naughtines of the instrument, is the cause that those things are done vvic•edly, which the Lord doth rightly.
Now answer me, Campian, do you think that that which any one doth, how wicked soever, is done whether God will or no? If you hold that any thing is done against Gods will, what providence or omnipotency do you leave him? For he which permits that to be done, which he would by no means have to be done, it is certain that he is not endued with so great power, as that he can forbid that which he would not have done. Wherefore you must need• confess that all things which are done, are done by the will of God; not that God doth will, that is, ⟨p. 197⟩eallow the sins of men, but because by this means he doth exercise his judgement and execute his decree, which he both willeth and alloweth. God can use evil instruments well, and bring to pass by wicked men, those things which agree with his will and liking. Now whatsoever things God doth by evil instruments, those he neither doth nor alloweth, as they be evil things, but as they be his good and holy judgements: so as although he both willeth those things which be done, & doth move the wills of men, and doth exercise in evil instruments, though unknown to the instruments themselves, an effectual power, and doth govern the wicked counsels of impious men, that they can do nothing which he willeth not; yet both men are wicked, albeit they do those things which the Lord willeth; and the Lord is holy, howsoever he willeth those things which the wicked do. This may be made manifest by examples; but I had rather you should hear Augustine than me. When the Father (saith he) delivered the Son, 2and the Lord his body, and Judas the Lord by treachery, why is God just in this delivery, and man guilty, but because in one thing which they did, the cause was not one for which they did it? Again, In that the wicked sin, it is their own: in that in sinning they do this or that, it comes from the power of God, who divides the darkness as he seeth good. And in another place: It skilleth much (saith he) what will agreeth to man, and what to God, and to what end each one referreth his will, so as it may be allowed or ⟨p. 198⟩disallowed. For God fulfilleth certain of his wills, being surely good, by the evil wills of evil men:
Now answere me, Campian, doe you thinke that that which any one doth, how wicked soeuer, is done whether God will or no? If you hold that any thing is done against Gods wil, what prouidence or omnipotencie doe you leaue him? For he which permits that to be done, which he would by no meanes haue to be done, it is certaine that he is not endued with so great power, as that he can forbid that which he would not haue done. Wherefore you must need• confesse that all things which are done, are done by the will of God; not that God doth will, that is, ⟨p. 197⟩eallow the sinnes of men, but because by this means he doth exercise his iudgement and execute his decree, which he both willeth and alloweth. God can vse euill instruments well, and bring to passe by wicked men, those things which agree with his will and liking. Now whatsoeuer things God doth by euill instruments, those he neither doth nor alloweth, as they be euill things, but as they be his good and holy iudgements: so as although he both willeth those things which be done, & doth moue the wils of men, and doth exercise in euill instruments, though vnknowne to the instruments themselues, an effectuall power, and doth gouerne the wicked counsailes of impious men, that they can doe nothing which hee willeth not; yet both men are wicked, albeit they doe those things which the Lord willeth; and the Lord is holy, howsoeuer he willeth those things which the wicked doe. This may be made manifest by examples; but I had rather you should heare Augustine than me. When the Father (saith he) deliuered the sonne, 2and the Lord his body, and Iudas the Lord by treacherie, why is God iust in this deliuerie, and man guiltie, but because in one thing which they did, the cause was not one for which they did it? Againe, In that the wicked sinne, it is their owne: in that in sinning they doe this or that, it comes from the power of God, who diuides the darkenes as he seeth good. And in another place: It skilleth much (saith he) what will agreeth to man, and what to God, and to what end each one referreth his will, so as it may be allowed or ⟨p. 198⟩disallowed. For God fulfilleth certaine of his wils, being surely good, by the euill wils of euill men:
eDVR. You say that God willeth evil, but that he doth not allow it: as if God could will that which he doth not allow, or as if he could not allow his own judgement and decree. WHIT. pag. 538. It is no hard thing to prove this, that God doth vvill many things which he doth not allow: for if is do happen to Princes, that they do not simply allow of war, as being dangerous to them and their subjects, but they would willingly shun it it they could, and yet they are compelled sometime to vvill it for the public peace sake: and so to a Magistrate, who spareth the lives of his people, and never liketh of murder, yet now and then doth willingly deliver some one or other malefactor unto the executioner; shall we think that the like cannot happen unto God, that he willeth some thing in some sort and for some other respect, which he doth not allow simply and of it self? Thus then God cannot but allow the action, which he hath destinated to a certain end: but he doth not allow the corruption and sin of the action, whereof not he but man is the author.DVR. You say that God willeth euill, but that he doth not allow it: as if God could will that vvhich he doth not allovv, or as if he could not allovv his ovvne iudgement and decree. WHIT. pag. 538. It is no hard thing to proue this, that God doth vvill many things vvhich he doth not allovv: for if is do happen to Princes, that they doe not simplie allovv of vvarre, as being dangerous to them and their subiects, but they vvould vvillingly shun it it they could, and yet they are compelled sometime to vvill it for the publike peace sake: and so to a Magistrate, vvho spareth the liues of his people, and neuer liketh of murther, yet novv and then doth vvillinglie deliuer some one or other malefactor vnto the executioner; shall vve thinke that the like cannot happen vnto God, that hee vvilleth some thing in some sort and for some other respect, vvhich hee doth not allovv simplie and of it selfe? Thus then God cannot but allovv the action, vvhich he hath destinated to a certaine end: but he doth not allovv the corruption and sinne of the action, vvhereof not he but man is the author.
as by the ill willed Jews, through the good will of the father, Christ was slain, which was so great a good, that the Apostle Peter, what time he would not have had it done, is termed Satan by him who was willing to be slain. And elsewhere: God (saith he) hardened Pharaoh by just judgement, 1and Pharaoh hardened himself by his own free will. And that you may plainly perceive there is nothing taught by us touching the will of God, but that which the Church of Christ long since hath taught, I will annex some other sentences which the same Augustine hath written in another place: Great are (saith he) the works of the Lord distinguished into all his wills, 2so as after a wonderful and unutterable manner that is not done without his will, which also is not done against his will: because it should not be done, if he did not suffer it, neither certainly doth he suffer it unwilling, but willing. And again: God worketh in the hearts of men to incline their wills whither so ever he will, 3whether to good according to his mercy, or unto evil, according to their merits. And that certainly in his judgement sometime open, sometime secret, but always just. I can use infinite testimonies in this matter, but I think, not very needful. I will raise up out of your own schoole Hugo de Sancto victore, who shall most clearly approve our opinion with his own words. For thus he writeth:4 His will is never idle, so as that is not done, which he willeth: neither in a word can any thing be done at any time which he willeth not. And a little after:5 The will of God is ever fulfilled, and wicked men are not therefore excused, because the will of God is performed in them and by them, for that they are not directed by their own will, to fulfil the will of God, but by his secret providence.
as by the ill willed Iewes, through the good will of the father, Christ was slain, which was so great a good, that the Apostle Peter, what time he would not haue had it done, is termed Satan by him who was willing to be slaine. And elsewhere: God (saith he) hardened Pharao by iust iudgement, 1and Pharao hardened himselfe by his owne free will. And that you may plainely perceiue there is nothing taught by vs touching the will of God, but that which the Church of Christ long since hath taught, I will annexe some other sentences which the same Augustine hath written in another place: Great are (saith he) the works of the Lord distinguished into all his wils, 2so as after a wonderfull and vnutterable manner that is not done without his will, which also is not done against his will: because it should not be done, if he did not suffer it, neither certainely doth he suffer it vnwilling, but willing. And againe: God worketh in the hearts of men to incline their wils whither so euer hee will, 3whether to good according to his mercie, or vnto euill, according to their merits. And that certainely in his iudgement sometime open, sometime secret, but alwaies iust. I can vse infinite testimonies in this matter, but I thinke, not very needfull. I will raise vp out of your owne schoole Hugo de Sancto victore, who shall most clearely approue our opinion with his owne words. For thus he writeth:4 His will is neuer idle, so as that is not done, which he willeth: neither in a word can any thing bee done at any time which hee willeth not. And a little after:5 The will of God is euer fulfilled, and wicked men are not therefore excused, because the will of God is performed in them and by them, for that they are not directed by their owne will, to fulfill the will of God, but by his secret prouidence.
Do you perceive at length (Campian) that no new paradox is defended in our Churches, which ⟨p. 199⟩was not both received in times past in the Churches of Christ, and is also defended as the truth it self? For that which you add, As the calling of Paul, so also Davids adultery, and Judas his treachery, were the proper work of God: from whence you drew these positions I know not. These works of God not one of our writers do so compare together, as that we should say that God wrought alike in David and Judas to the committing of heinous offences, as he did in Paul for his effectual conversion. Indeed the Lord wrought both in this and in them, but not after one and the like manner: he did inspire inwardly the heart of Paul by his spirit, and endued his mind with true faith, which he lacked before: but to David and Judas he did cast in no new kind of impiety or inclination of will, nor did he stir up new motions unto sinning (God forbid that any Christian should so much as think it:) but they running of their own accord, and stirred up by and of themselves, be did so hold and bend, that they unwitting to themselves, and not imagining any such thing, did execute Gods decree. For by this adultery of David the Lord did both chastise David, in that he did punish sin with sin, as he is wont, and also he made a way open for his purposes in time succeeding. Like hereunto is that of Absalom: he defiled Davids Concubines:1 the heinousness of which offence cannot be uttered: yet this way the Lord had decreed to take punishment of David. But the treachery of Judas, if you respect the covetousness and perfidiousness of the man, did so displease God, that never any thing did offend him more: and yet the Lord used both Judas treachery and the Priests cruelty for the finishing of that work of our salvation, and he would have these wretched instruments to effect that divine work. Therefore the Apostles do testify that all these did nothing else but ⟨p. 200⟩those things which the hand and counsel of the Lord did decree to be done.2 And yet there is not here any monstrous thing, whereof either Philip Melanchthon or any other ought to be ashamed, unless perhaps the holy doctrine of the Scripture seem monstrous to you.
Doe you perceiue at length (Campian) that no new paradoxe is defended in our Churches, which ⟨p. 199⟩was not both receiued in times past in the Churches of Christ, and is also defended as the truth it selfe? For that which you adde, As the calling of Paul, so also Dauids adulterie, and Iudas his treacherie, were the proper worke of God: from whence you drew these positions I know not. These works of God not one of our writers doe so compare together, as that wee should say that God wrought alike in Dauid and Iudas to the committing of hainous offences, as he did in Paul for his effectuall conuersion. Indeed the Lord wrought both in this and in them, but not after one and the like manner: he did inspire inwardly the heart of Paul by his spirit, and endued his minde with true faith, which he lacked before: but to Dauid and Iudas hee did cast in no new kinde of impietie or inclination of will, nor did hee stirre vp new motions vnto sinning (God forbid that any Christiā should so much as thinke it:) but they running of their owne accord, and stirred vp by and of themselues, be did so hold and bend, that they vnwitting to themselues, and not imagining any such thing, did execute Gods decree. For by this adulterie of Dauid the Lord did both chastice Dauid, in that he did punish sinne with sinne, as hee is wont, and also hee made a way open for his purposes in time succeeding. Like hereunto is that of Absalom: he defiled Dauids Concubines:1 the h•inousnes of which offence cannot bee vttered: yet this way the Lord had decreed to take punishment of Dauid. But the treacherie of Iudas, if you respect the couetousnes and perfidiousnes of the man, did so displease God, that neuer any thing did offend him more: and yet the Lord vsed both Iudas treacherie and the Priests crueltie for the finishing of that worke of our s•luation, and he would haue these wretched instruments to effect that diuine worke. Therefore the Apostles doe testifie that all these did nothing else but ⟨p. 200⟩those things which the hand and counsaile of the Lord did decree to bee done.2 And yet there is not here any monstrous thing, wherof either Philip Melanchton or any other ought to bee ashamed, vnlesse perhaps the holy doctrine of the Scripture seeme monstrous to you.
As for that that you demand with what mind Luther did take away this verse from the Church prayers, O holy Trinity, one God, have mercy upon us, certainly you are too suspicious. If Luther did think erroneously touching the Trinity, convince him: his books are in mens hands, and they are read by you, as it seemeth, very diligently. Allege, if you can, any one word, injurious either to the Trinity or Unity. For if out of all his writings, which are innumerable, you can draw no probable inkling of this suspicion, why do you make question about one verse taken away from the Church prayers? which whether it be taken away or no, I know not: and though it be taken away, yet how appears it that it was taken away by him? But Luther's condition is very hard, who must stand unto, both what he hath written, and what he hath not written. And these are those our paradoxes concerning God, which you could carp at in the books of all our writers, which have come forth in a manner infinitely. The matter is safe and sound: the adversary hath viewed over all of them, and yet hath found nothing.
As for that that you demaund with what minde Luther did take away this verse from the Church prayers, O holy Trinitie, one God, haue mercie vpon vs, certeinly you are too suspitious. If Luther did think erroneously touching the Trinitie, conuince him: his bookes are in mens hands, and they are read by you, as it seemeth, very diligently. Alleage, if you can, any one word, iniurious either to the Trinitie or Vnitie. For if out of all his writings, which are innumerable, you can draw no probable inkling of this suspition, why doe you make question about one verse taken away from the Church prayers? which whether it bee taken away or no, I know not: and though it bee taken away, yet how appeares it that it was taken away by him? But Luthers condition is very hard, who must stand vnto, both what hee hath written, and what hee hath not written. And these are those our paradoxes concerning God, which you could carpe at in the bookes of all our writers, which haue come foorth in a manner infinitely. The matter is safe and sound: the aduersarie hath viewed ouer all of them, and yet hath found nothing.
By and by you proceed to the person of Christ,1 and you demand what these words of Calvin mean; Christ i• the Son of God, God of God, God of himself▪ What reprove you here Campian? what, that he said, Christ is the Son of God? or for that he termed him God of God? or else, that he affirmeth him to be God of himself? But which of these assertions is it, that is not holy, not granted, not agreeable to the Catholic faith? which if you deny, you do not ⟨p. 201⟩convince any Paradox of ours, but you bewray your own heresy. But this is the point, unless I be deceived, wherein you have found, I know not what, knot, as it were in a rush. The Nicene Fathers do profess Christ to be God of God, to the end they may teach that the Son is of the same substance with the Father. This saying, some afterward catched at so, as that they did maintain that Christ is not God by himself and of himself, but that he received it of his Father: wherein they quite took away the Divinity of Christ. For unless he be God of himself, he cannot be God at all. For that he may be God, he must needs be God of himself. Wherefore howsoever those Fathers did say that Christ is God of God, yes Calvin maintaineth that it is most firmly to be believed, that Christ hath this, to be God of himself, unless we will rob Christ of his Divinity. To be the Son, he received that indeed of the Father: for he is the Son of the Father. To be God, he hath that off himself, because he is God by himself. What say you now Campian? God of God, is with Calvin, God of himself: and say you so indeed? hath not Calvin admonished you of this, that the name of God is to be taken for the Father, when as Christ is termed the Son of God? That therefore which the Nicene Fathers deliver, that Christ is God of God, that is so to be understood, that we should confess the Son ⟨p. 202⟩to be begotten of the Father, and not that we should attribute the name of God only to the Father: for we must look to it, that we do not so determine the Son to be of the Father, as that we should deny him to be God of himself. And these things Calvin hath interpreted most diligently and most holily, nor hath he set forth any one word at all different from the faith of the Scriptures and of the Catholic Church. Remember that sentence of Augustine:
By and by you proceede to the person of Christ,1 and you demand what these words of Caluin meane; Christ i• the sonne of God, God of God, God of himselfe▪ What reprooue you here Campian? what, that hee said, Christ is the Sonne of God? or for that hee termed him God of God? or else, that he affirmeth him to be God of himselfe? But which of these assertions is it, that is not holy, not granted, not agreeable to the Catholike faith? which if you deny, you doe not ⟨p. 201⟩conuince any Paradox of ours, but you bewray your owne heresie. But this is the point, vnlesse I be deceiued, wherin you haue found, I know not what, knot, as it were in a rush. The Nicene Fathers doe professe Christ to bee God of God, to the end they may teach that the Son is of the same substance with the Father. This saying, some afterward catcht at so, as that they did maintaine that Christ is not God by himselfe and of himselfe, but that hee receiued it of his Father: wherein they quite tooke away the Diuinity of Christ. For vnlesse he be God of himselfe, he cannot be God at all. For that hee may be God, hee must needs be God of himselfe. Wherefore howsoeuer those Fathers did say that Christ is God of God, yes Calain maintaineth that it is most firmely to be beleeued, that Christ hath this, to be God of himself, vnlesse we will rob Christ of his Diuinity. To be the Sonne, he receiued that indeed of the Father: for he is the Son of the Father. To be God, he hath that off himselfe, because he is God by himselfe. What say you now Campian? God of God, is with Caluin, God of himselfe: and say you so indeed? hath not Caluin admonished you of this, that the name of God is to be taken for the Father, when as Christ is termed the Sonne of God? That therefore which the Nicene Fathers deliuer, that Christ is God of God, that is so to be vnderstood, that we should confesse the Sonne ⟨p. 202⟩to be begotten of the Father, and not that we should attribute the name of God only to the Father: for we must looke to it, that wee doe not so determine the Sonne to bee of the Father, as that wee should deny him to be God of himselfe. And these things Caluin hath interpreted most diligently and most holily, nor hath he set forth any one word at all different from the faith of the Scriptures and of the Catholike Church. Remember that sentence of Augustine:
1Of Christ.
fDVR. If the Sonne of God have not his essence from the Father, surely be is not the Sonne of the Father. WHIT. pag. 542. And why so? did Calvin ever deny that the Son hath his essence from the Father? he and we all teach that the Sonne was begotten of the Fathers essence; and that the Sonne hath the whole essence of the Father, and that not by decision or propagation, as the wicked Prithe••s dream, but by communication. And yet h••e you multiply Scriptures and Fathers needlessly. This we say, Christ is God of himself, but in this sense, that, that essence which is in the Sonne, is not from any other essence, but of and from himself, seeing that the essence of the Father and the Sonne is one and the same. For essence, as Basil truly writeth against Eunomius, cannot be generated: and pag. 543. wherefore Christ, so far forth as he is God, is of himself; and so far forth as he is the Sonne, is of the Father: for he cannot be God, whose essence is not of and from it self, so Basil and Augustine.DVR. If the Sonne of God haue not his essence from the Father, surely be is not the Sonne of the Father. WHIT. pag. 542. And vvhy so? did Caluin euer deny that the Son hath his essence from the Father? he and vve all teach that the Sonne vvas begotten of the Fathers essence; and that the Sonne hath the vvhole essence of the Father, and that not by decision or propagation, as the wicked Prithe••s dreame, but by cōmunication. And yet h••e you multiply Scriptures and Fathers needlesly. This vve say, Christ is God of himselfe, but in this sense, that, that essence vvhich is in the Sonne, is not from any other essence, but of and from himselfe, seeing that the essence of the Father and the Sonne is one and the same. For essence, as Basil truly vvriteth against Eunomius, cannot be generated: and pag. 543. vvherefore Christ, so farre forth as he is God, is of himselfe; and so farre forth as he is the Sonne, is of the Father: for he cannot be God, vvhose essence is not of and from it selfe, so Basil and Augustine.
Christ in respect of himself is termed God, 1but in respect of the Father he is termed the Son: wherein you may acknowledge the opinion of the ancient Church.
Christ in respect of himself is termed God, 1but in respect of the Father he is termed the Sonne: wherein you may acknowledge the opinion of the auncient Church.
Now you set upon Beza: for like to the fashion of mad dogs, you stand not in one place, but fly hither and thither, and upon whomsoever you light, you bite him shrewdly with your venomous teeth. Beza saith (as you say) he is not begotten of the essence of the Father. Why are you angry with Beza, if he say the same things, which are wont to be said & maintained by your own selves? For you cannot be ignorant, what your Lombard teacheth touching the essence of God, which both he, and the school men that have followed him do affirm, neither to get, nor to be begotten. For that essence is not begotten by essence, but person by person. If Beza would imitate these, in saying that Christ was begotten not of the essence but of the person of the Father, why do you reprove him? and yet we may not imagine that the essence is separated from the person, as if the essence of the Son were another from the essence of the Father: (for there is but one simple essence of the Deity) but forasmuch as person is distinguished from essence; albeit not in the thing, yet by relation; and sith tho Ancient were wont to speak after this manner, that they said Christ was begotten of the person of the Father, rather then of his essence: it is no marvel that the same form of speech did like Beza best, ⟨p. 203⟩whose judgement it was ever, that we ought to set down determinations touching the highest mysteries very warily and with great consideration. Now that the essence is not begotten, the whole ancient Church held, as Basil writeth expressly:1 God is not begotten either of himself […] of any other. Albeit I do not very well know, whether these be Bezoar words which you recite: surely I remember not that I have ever read them in Beza, nor can I find them in this place which you quote. But those that follow, are very malicious. Beza said once, that there be two personal unions in Christ, as you say, the one of the soul with the body, the other of the Godhead with the manhood. Which speech of his James Andreas reproved: and indeed not without cause; albeit this doth not follow out of that speech, that there are two persons in Christ, though there be two personal unions: but that, because it was written ambiguously, Beza professeth that he would willingly mend it. And what can you desire more? if he have erred, yet he persisted not in his error, but hath amended his fault:
Now you set vpon Beza: for like to the fashion of mad dogges, you stand not in one place, but flie hither and thither, and vpon whomsoeuer you light, you bite him shrewdly with your venomous teeth. Beza saith (as you say) he is not begotten of the essence of the Father. Why are you angrie with Beza, if he say the same things, which are wont to be said & maintained by your owne selues? For you cannot be ignorant, what your Lombard teacheth touching the oslence of God, which both he, and the schoole men that haue followed him do affirme, neither to get, nor to be begotten. For that essence is not begotten by essence, but person by person. If Beza would imitate these, in saying that Christ was begotten not of the essence but of the person of the Father, why doe you reproue him? and yet we may not imagine that the essence is separated from the person, as if the essence of the Sonne were another from the essence of the Father: (for there is but one simple essence of the Deity) but for asmuch as person is distinguished frō essence; albeit not in the thing, yet by rolation; and sith tho Ancient were wont to speake after this manner, that they said Christ was begotten of the person of the Father, rather then of his essence: it is no maruel that the same forme of speech did like Beza best, ⟨p. 203⟩whose iudgement it was euer, that we ought to set downe determinations touching the highest mysteries very warily and with great consideration. Now that the essence is not begotten, the whole auncient Church held, as Basil writeth expresly:1 God is not begotten either of himselfe 〈…〉 of any other. Albeit I do not very wel know, whether these be Beza• words which you recite: surely I remember not that I haue euer read them in Beza, nor can I find them in this place which you quote. But those that follow, are very malitious. Beza said once, that there be two personall vnions in Christ, as you say, the one of the soule with the body, the other of the Godhead with the manhood. Which speech of his Iames Andreas reproued: and indeed not without cause; albeit this doth not follow out of that speech, that there are two persons in Christ, though there bee two personall vnions: but that, because it was written ambiguously, Beza professeth that he would willingly mend it. And what can you desire more? if he haue erred, yet he persisted not in his error, but hath amended his fault:
with what face therefore can you upbraid him with that, which fell from him but once ere he was aware, seeing he corrected it after? And touching the person of Christ, Beza every where teacheth those things, than which nothing can be more true and sincere: nor is there any of us that is wont to affirm or defend that which you object concerning those two personal unions. For we confess but one person, constituted of the two natures, as also we acknowledge but one personal union: for although Christ did assume both body and an humane soul; yet these parts are not so personally joined together in Christ, as that they do make any person separate from his Godhead, lest we should imagine that Christ consisteth of two persons.
with what face therefore can you vpbraide him with that, which fell from him but once ere he was aware, seeing he corrected it after? And touching the person of Christ, Beza euery where teacheth those things, than which nothing can be more true and sincere: nor is there any of vs that is wont to affirme or defend that which you obiect concerning those two personall vnions. For we confesse but one person, constituted of the two natures, as also we acknowledge but one personall vnion: for although Christ did assume both body and an humane soule; yet these parts are not so personally ioyned together in Christ, as that they do make any person separate from his Godhead, lest we should imagine that Christ consisteth of two persons.
Now again you make recourse to Calvin, whom ⟨p. 204⟩I thought you had quite given over before. Calvin denieth▪ that the place of John, I and my Father are one, doth show that Christ is God of the same substance with the Father. What then Campian? was it so heinous an offence, to dissent from the ancient Fathers in the exposition of one place? Did he ever deny that Christ is of the same substance with the Father? you cannot maintain it. For he always taught it most constantly, and confuted the Arians by other innumerable texts of holy Scripture. For what? do you think that he cannot be of the same substance with the Father, unless this place teach it? he that heedfully readeth over that dispute of Christ with the Jews, which John in that chapter setteth down,1 shall easily perceive that ratherg an unity of will and power, then of essence, is signified. Christ affirmeth that no man can take his sheep out of his hands: & that he may persuade it plainly, he adjoineth, I and my Father are one. I do not see how you can thereout conclude an unity of substance, unless you still understand that same word, One, of the substance. What is it then that Christ saith, not of himself only, and his Father, but of all the faithful,3 that they all may be one, as thou O Father art in me, and I in thee? That place in the Epistle of John, These three are one, the Ordinary Gloss doth thus expound, that is, witnessing of the same thing. 4But Erasmus doth much more vehemently find fault with the old Fathers, because they abused these words, I and the Father are one, against the Arians. Not, I think, for that he did any whit favour the Arriant, but because he thought it was done by the Fathers with no great reason. But you say, that, that word, Homoousion, was odious to Luther. For he saith, my soul hateth this word, Homoousion. Luther never said that: only this he said, if he had hated that word, ⟨p. 205⟩Homoousion, yet he should be no heretic as long as he held the thing it self. These are Luther's words: But if my soul did hate that word, Homoousion, and would not use it, I should not be an heretic: for who should compel me to use it, so as I hold the thing, which was determined in a Council by the Scriptures? hBut howsoever he did hate the name, yet he did love the thing it self as his own soul.
Now againe you make recourse to Caluin, whom ⟨p. 204⟩I thought you had quite giuen ouer before. Caluin denieth▪ that the place of Iohn, I and my Father are one, doth shew that Christ is God of the same substance with the Father. What then Campian? was it so hainous an offence, to dissent from the auncient Fathers in the exposition of one place? Did he euer deny that Christ is of the same substance with the Father? you cannot maintaine it. For hee alwaies taught it most constantly, and confuted the Arrians by other innumerable texts of holy Scripture. For what? doe you thinke that he cannot be of the same substance with the Father, vnlesse this place teach it? he that heedfully readeth ouer that dispute of Christ with the Iewes, which Iohn in that chapter setteth downe,1 shal easily perceiue that ratherg an vnity of will and power, then of essence, is signified. Christ affirmeth that no man can take his sheepe out of his hands: & that he may perswade it plainly, he adioyneth, I and my Father are one. I doe not see how you can thereout conclude an vnity of substance, vnlesse you still vnderstand that same word, One, of the substance. What is it then that Christ saith, not of himselfe only, and his Father, but of all the faithfull,3 that they all may be one, as thou O Father art in me, and I in thee? That place in the Epistle of Iohn, These three are one, the Ordinarie Glosse doth thus expound, that is, witnessing of the same thing. 4But Erasmus doth much more vehemently find fault with the old Fathers, because they abused these words, I and the Father are one, against the Arrians. Not, I think, for that he did any whit fauour the Arriāt, but because he thought it was done by the Fathers with no great reason. But you say, that, that word, Homoousion, was odious to Luther. For he saith, my soule hateth this word, Homoousion. Luther neuer said that: only this he said, if he had hated that word, ⟨p. 205⟩Homoousion, yet he should be no heretike as long as he held the thing it selfe. These are Luthers words: But if my soule did hate that word, Homoousion, and would not vse it, I should not bee an heretike: for who should compell me to vse it, so as I hold the thing, which was determined in a Councell by the Scriptures?
gDVR. What is this that you say? John signified the union of power & will, and not of essence: are you so rude, as that you are ignorant that in God, power, and essence are the same? WHIT. pag. 546. I am not so rude, but that I well understand, that the power of God is the essence of God: but doth it follow, if Christ being endowed and environed with the power of God could not be overcome, but that God also should be overcome, that the essential power of God and Christ is the same?DVR. What is this that you say? Iohn signified the vnion of power & will, and not of essence: are you so rude, as that you are ignorant that in God, povver, and essence are the same? WHIT. pag. 546. I am not so rude, but that I well vnderstand, that the power of God is the essence of God: but doth it follow, if Christ being endowed and enuironed with the power of God could not be ouercome, but that God also should be ouercome, that the essentiall power of God and Christ is the same?
hDVR. What more foolish then to hate a name uncopable of hatred? WHIT. pag. 547. Then is he no heretic for hating the name, when he loveth the thing: and out of these words to faine and cast such a position upon Luther as this; My soul hateth that word, Homoousion; it is a devise most worthily deserving perpetual hatred.DVR. What more foolish then to hate a name vncopable of hatred? WHIT. pag. 547. Then is he no heretike for hating the name, when he loueth the thing: and out of these words to faine and cast such a position vpon Luther as this; My soule hateth that word, Homoousion; it is a deuise most worthily deseruing perpetual hatred.
And with this same name, it is certain that many and those very excellent men were in times past offended, in so much as they have wished it had never been heard of. For this name being once brought in, the Churches were at such conflicts between themselves through hatreds and contentions, that the holy Fathers themselves did not a little repent them of that name: nor if a man would have perhaps some name to be taken away, which hath given occasion of many dissentions, is he therefore to be thought to disallow the thing declared by that name.1 Hierome could not be persuaded to receive the three Hypostases, because he had that new name, Hypostasis, in suspicion: for he was afraid lest there lay some venom under that name: yet he did acknowledge and preach three persons. And now both those terms are received, nor ought any one to be offended with it.
And with this same name, it is certaine that many and those very excellent men were in times past offended, in so much as they haue wished it had neuer been heard of. For this name being once brought in, the Churches were at such conflicts betweene themselues through hatreds and contentions, that the holy Fathers themselues did not a little repent them of that name: nor if a man would haue perhaps some name to be taken away, which hath giuen occasion of many dissentions, is he therefore to be thought to disallow the thing declared by that name.1 Hierome could not be perswaded to receiue the three Hypostases, because he had that new name, Hypostasis, in suspition: for he was afraide lest there lay some venome vnder that name: yet hee did acknowledge and preach three persons. And now both those tearmes are receiued, nor ought any one to be offended with it.
Go ye forward, say you: go you also forward, Campian, seeing you will needs do so, but it had been better for you rather to give over, than to go on of this fashion. It is better to retire than to run ill. You reproach us now for this, that we say, Christ was not perfect in Grace from his infancy, but that he grew in the gifts of his mind as other men do, and was made wiser every day by experience. I do easily endure you to object many paradoxes against us, seeing you tax the very history of the Gospel with the same fault: for who may hope that he can escape ⟨p. 206⟩your slander, who stick not most audaciously to fly upon the writings of the Gospel: for what do we teach else herein, but that which the Evangelist hath expressed in his writings once or twice? for thus we read in Luke. The Child increased, 1and was strengthened in the spirit, and he was filled with wisdom, and the grace of God was in him. And again,2 Jesus grew iin wisdom, and in stature, and in favour both with God and men. What else can be understood out of these words, but that Jesus did increase both in stature and wisdom, & the more he grew in age, so much the greater progresses had he in the gifts of the holy Ghost: for so our Evangelist had written a little before of John: The Child grew and was strengthened in the spirit. 4Do you think that John was presently as soon as he was borne endowed with perfect wisdom and grace of the spirit, so as he had no addition ever made him? But Luke saith that Christ was full of wisdom. I ⟨p. 207⟩do not deny it:5 albeit Luke do not say filled, as though he were full of wisdom, but filling, whereby some growth and addition is signified. But to grant that he was full, will you therefore have it that nothing was added afterward? what then do you determine of John, of whom the Angel foretold that he should be full of the holy Ghost from his mothers womb? Wherefore if Christ had this, that at what time he first was made man, absolute & perfect wisdom, and other gifts of the spirit were heaped upon him, certainly he had it not alone; nor am I moved with the authority of the schoolmen, who lest they might seem to think less honourably of Christ, do attribute to him presently all perfections.
Goe yee forward, say you: goe you also forward, Campian, seeing you will needs doe so, but it had been better for you rather to giue ouer, than to goe on of this fashion. It is better to retire than to runne ill. You reproach vs now for this, that wee say, Christ was not perfect in Grace from his infancie, but that he grew in the gifts of his mind as other men doe, and was made wiser euery day by experience. I doe easilie endure you to obiect many paradoxes against vs, seeing you taxe the very historie of the Gospell with the same fault: for who may hope that he can escape ⟨p. 206⟩your slander, who sticke not most audaciously to fly vpon the writings of the Gospell: for what doe we teach else herein, but that which the Euangelist hath expressed in his writings once or twice? for thus we reade in Luke. The Child increased, 1and was strengthned in the spirit, and he was filled with wisdome, and the grace of God was in him. And againe,2 Iesus grew iin wisdome, and in stature, and in fauour both with God and men. What els can be vnderstood out of these words, but that Iesus did increase both in stature and wisdome, & the more he grew in age, so much the greater progresses had he in the gifts of the holy Ghost: for so our Euangelist had written a little before of Iohn: The Child grew and was strengthned in the spirit. 4Doe you thinke that Iohn was presently as soone as he was borne endewed with perfect wisdome and grace of the spirit, so as he had no additiō euer made him? But Luke saith that Christ was full of wisdome. I ⟨p. 207⟩doe not deny it:5 albeit Luke doe not say filled, as though he were full of wisdome, but filling, wherby some growth and addition is signified. But to grant that he was full, will you therefore haue it that nothing was added afterward? what then doe you determine of Iohn, of whom the Angell foretold that he should be full of the holy Ghost from his mothers wōbe? Wherefore if Christ had this, that at what time he first was made man, absolute & perfect wisdome, and other gifts of the spirit were heaped vpon him, certainly he had it not alone; nor am I moued with the authority of the schoolmen, who lest they might seeme to thinke lesse honorablie of Christ, doe attribute to him presently all perfections.
iDVR. That is, saith Jeremiah, and the ancient Fathers, Christ grew in wisdom, because together with his age that his wisdom did every day more shine forth and show it self to men. Jeremiah thus, a woman shall compass a man; and Augustine, Justine, Clement, and Hilary say, to ascribe to Christ ignorance, is an impious thing, and not to be believed. WHIT. pag. 550. Thus you argue, Jeremiah chap. 31. wrote: A woman shall compass a man: therefore Christ was a man in his mothers womb, full of knowledge and wisdom. Out of all doubt with these arguments you will win the field: but yet take this with you; if a woman compassed a man, in such sort as you affirm, then it will follow that Christ was a man, before he was borne; and Mary did bear him, not an infant, but a man; and old Simeon took in his arms a man, and not a child. These are expositions worthy your patronage. As for the Fathers that you cite, they speak only of Christs Divine nature. DVR. Adam in his creation was endued with excellent wisdom and knowledge: what madness is it then to attribute to Christ the infirmity of ignorance? WHIT. I answer, you dispute very admirably. Adam was created with excellent knowledge, therefore Christ was ignorant of nothing: first, Adam know not all things, but you say Christ was never ignorant of any thing. Again from this ground you may conclude, that Christ is not dead. For if Adam in the beginning was so created, that he could not die, what madness is it, (to use your own words) to attribute the infirmity of mortality to Christ? Tell me I pray you, which is more befitting to Christ, mortality or infirmity? But when the Scripture is manifest, that Christ did not take our nature whole and sound, as it was then in Adam, but infirm and weak, yet without sin; it is no marvel if he would be borne such as we are, not such as Adam was created.DVR. That is, saith Ieremy, and the auncient Fathers, Christ grew in wisdome, because together with his age that his wisdome did euery day more shine forth and shew it selfe to men. Ieremy thus, a woman shall compasse a man; and Augustine, Iustine, Clement, and Hilary say, to ascribe to Christ ignorance, is an impious thing, and not to be beleeued. WHIT. pag. 550. Thus you •rgue, Ieremy chap. 31. wrot: A woman shall compasse a man: therefore Christ was a man in his mothers wombe, full of knowledge and wisdome. Out of all doubt with these arguments you will win the field: but yet take this with you; if a woman compassed a man, in such sort as you affirme, then it will follow that Christ was a man, before he was borne; and Marie did beare him, not an infant, but a man; and old Symeon tooke in his armes a man, and not a child. These are expositions worthy your patronage. As for the Fathers that you cite, they speake only of Christs Diuine nature. DVR. Adam in his creation vvas indued with excellent wisdome and knowledge: what madnes is it then to attribute to Christ the infirmitie of ignorance? WHIT. I answere, you dispute very admirablie. Adam was created with excellent knowledge, therefore Christ was ignorant of nothing: first, Adam knovv not all things, but you say Christ was neuer ignorant of any thing. Againe from this ground you may conclude, that Christ is not dead. For if Adam in the beginning was so created, that he could not die, what madnes is it, (to vse your owne words) to attribute the infirmitie of mortalitie to Christ? Tell me I pray you, which is more befitting to Christ, mortalitie or infirmitie? But when the Scripture is manifest, that Christ did not take our nature whole and sound, as it was then in Adam, but infirme and weake, yet without sinne; it is no maruell if he would be borne such as we are, not such as Adam was created.
And Damascens argument taken from the personal union doth not conclude it,1 unless we will think that the Deity did infuse all the quality of it self into the humanity of Christ. That which the Evangelist writeth of this progress of wisdom, pertaineth only to the human nature of Christ? And seeing that Christ would assume the whole nature of man,2 saving in sin, and lay off that person of God, and empty himself, and take the form of a servant,3 will it be unbeseeming the person of Christ, that we say he was made both wiser and fuller of grace by little and little? He was indeed most full of grace, •nd whatsoever grace any body hath, all that he drew out of this ever remaining fountain of most abundant grace:4 but yet this hindereth not, but that Christ, as the Evangelist writeth, might grow in grace: which thing also Ambrose confesseth. For so he saith:5kAccording to the flesh certainly he ⟨p. 208⟩was filled with wisdom and grace. Nor do some of your men, Campian, differ from this judgement, lest you should perhaps imagine it to be so horrible, as that it cannot fall upon a Catholic: for I ansenii•• Bishop of Gandava,7 who was present at the Conventicle of Trent, professeth that he doth willingly incline to this judgement: and Erasmus (albeit I name him not among writers on your side) doth give his note that it is the truer opinion.
And Damascens argument taken from the personall vnion doth not conclude it,1 vnlesse we will thinke that the Deity did infuse all the quality of it selfe into the humanity of Christ. That which the Euangelist writeth of this progresse of wisdome, pertaineth only to the human nature of Christ? And seeing that Christ would assume the whole nature of man,2 sauing in sinne, and lay off that person of God, and emptie himselfe, and take the forme of a seruant,3 will it be vnbeseeming the person of Christ, that wee say hee was made both wiser and fuller of grace by little and little? He was indeed most full of grace, •nd whatsoeuer grace any bodie hath, al that he drew out of this euer remaining foū taine of most abundant grace:4 but yet this hindreth not, but that Christ, as the Euangelist writeth, might grow in grace: which thing also Ambrose confesseth. For so he saith:5kAccording to the flesh certainly hee ⟨p. 208⟩was filled with wisdome and grace. Nor doe some of your men, Campian, differ from this iudgement, lest you should perhaps imagine it to be so horrible, as that it cannot fall vpon a Catholike: for I ansenii•• Bishop of Gandaua,7 who was present at the Cōuenticle of Trent, professeth that he doth willingly incline to this iudgement: and Erasmus (albeit I name him not among writers on your side) doth giue his note that it is the truer opinion.
kDVR. But he saith, lib. 5. de fide cap. 8. I say that the Sonne was ignorant of nothing, but he took upon him our affection, that he might say, he was ignorant by our ignorance. WHIT pag. 553. If Christ as a child was ignorant of nothing, because of the personal union with the Deity, yet it is a very childish argument, to reason from the person to the humane nature; that because the man Christ is ignorant of nothing, therefore the humanity of Christ is not ignorant of any thing. If Ambrose sometime upon occasion differ from himself, let him look to it.DVR. But he saith, lib. 5. de fide cap. 8. I say that the Sonne was ignorant of nothing, but he tooke vpon him our affection, that hee might say, hee was ignorant by our ignorance. WHIT pag. 553. If Christ as a child was ignorant of nothing, because of the personall vnion with the Deity, yet it is a very childish argument, to reason from the person to the humane nature; that because the man Christ is ignorant of nothing, therefore the humani•y of Christ is not ignorant of any thing. If Ambrose sometime vpon occasion diffe• from himselfe, let him looke to it.
7Comment. in concord. cap. 12. Erasm. annot. in Luc. cap. 2.
But, say you, they affirm also, that Christ was ignorant of some things. And why may they not affirm it? This (say you) is as much, as if they affirmed that he was defiled with original sin. Now at length you begin to argue very wittily, that our University men may understand your wonderful subtlety in disputing. Would you deal on this manner with us, Campian, if that dispute, which you so often wish, might be permitted you? For what could be spoken more absurdly? Christ was ignorant of something: therefore Christ was defiled with original sin. As if he that is ignorant of something, which may be known, or he which is not endued with the perfect knowledge of all things, it must needs be that he is defiled with sin. Thus then I will return you a like argument:l The Angels are now ignorant of many things (for ⟨p. 209⟩they know not that day and hour) and Adam, 2before he sinned, was ignorant of many things: (for he did not understand that Satan lay in wait for him) therefore both the Angels are now defiled with sin, and Adam in his greatest innocency was a sinner. You shall never prick us with these goads so, as that we may fear any deadly wound. If you know not that there is an ignorance void of all fault, learn it of Thomas, who will teach you, that negative ignorance, which he terms nescience,3 is not sin, but the privative. If you can conclude that consequent out of our judgement, that Christ was ignorant of somewhat, which he then ought to have known, when he was ignorant of it, then you put us down from this our standing. For it is not a fault not to know those things, which yet may be known, unless it concern us to have them known. For who will blame a Porter, for that he is ignorant of the Mathematics? But concerning Christ, I answer now that unto you, which toucheth this cause nearer. Although he were most pure from all spot of sin, so as nothing could be more uncorrupt; yet he took upon himself the punishment due to sin, that he might deliver us from it. Therefore also he would die, albeit death issued from sin. He then that suffered death for us, which sin brought in; can any thing, which is ours, be unbeseeming him, so as it be not infected with sin? And you can never prove, that ignorance in Christ was any whit more faulty, than death.
But, say you, they affirme also, that Christ was ignorant of some things. And why may they not affirme it? This (say you) is as much, as if they affirmed that he was defiled with originall sinne. Now at length you begin to argue very wittely, that our Vniuersitie men may vnderstand your wonderfull subtiltie in disputing. Would you deale on this manner with vs, Campian, if that dispute, which you so often wish, might bee permitted you? For what could be spoken more absurdly? Christ was ignorant of something: therfore Christ was defiled with originall sinne. As if he that is ignorant of something, which may be knowne, or he which is not endued with the perfect knowledge of all things, it must needs be that he is defiled with sinne. Thus then I will returne you a like argument:l The Angels are now ignorant of many things (for ⟨p. 209⟩they know not that day and houre) and Adam, 2before he sinned, was ignorant of many things: (for he did not vnderstand that Satan lay in waite for him) therefore both the Angels are now defiled with sin, and Adam in his greatest innocencie was a sinner. You shall neuer pricke vs with these goades so, as that wee may feare any deadly wound. If you know not that there is an ignorance void of all fault, learne it of Thomas, who wil teach you, that negatiue ignorance, which he termes nescience,3 is not sinne, but the priuatiue. If you can conclude that consequent out of our iudgement, that Christ was ignorant of somewhat, which hee then ought to haue knowne, when he was ignorant of it, then you put vs downe from this our standing. For it is not a fault not to know those things, which yet may bee knowne, vnlesse it concerne vs to haue them knowne. For who will blame a Porter, for that he is ignorant of the Mathematikes? But concerning Christ, I answere now that vnto you, which toucheth this cause neerer. Although he were most pure from all spot of sinne, so as nothing could be more vncorrupt; yet hee tooke vpon himselfe the punishment due to sinne, that he might deliuer vs from it. Therefore also hee would die, albeit death issued from sinne. He then that suffered death for vs, which sinne brought in; can any thing, which is ours, be vnbeseeming him, so as it be not infected with sin? And you can neuer proue, that ignorance in Christ was any whit more faultie, than death.
lDVR. Though they were ignorant of many things, yet they had not that ignorance, which cometh fr• original corruption, which if you say Christ had, you must affirm that he was defiled with original sin. WHIT. pag. 555. All ignorance cometh not from original sin, as appeareth by the ignorance of Adam and the Angels; therefore Christ might be ignorant without sin. And though we affirm all ignorance is now the punishment of sin: yet will it not follow that no ignorance was in Christ, nay rather that there was; for he was to take upon him the punishment of all our sins. Therefore he underwent not only this punishment, but also death, being the punishment of sin, Rom. 6.2•. yet for all this was he not defiled with original sin. DVR. The Fathers say he knew not the day of judgement, because he hath not revealed it, and would that others should be ignorant of it. WHIT. pag. 556. This interpretation is easily refelled. For from this will follow that the Father also was ignorant of it, seeing the Father did no more tell it and manifest it to others, then the Sonne did.DVR. Though they were ignorant of many things, yet they had not that ignorance, which commeth fr• originall corruption, vvhich if you say Christ had, you must affirme that he was defiled vvith originall sinne. WHIT. pag. 555. All ignorance commeth not from originall sinne, as appeareth by the ignorance of Adam and the Angels; therefore Christ might be ignorant without sinne. And though we affirme all ignorance is now the punishment of sinne: yet will it not follow that no ignorance was in Christ, nay rather that there was; for hee was to take vpon him the punishment of all our sinnes. Therefore hee vnderwent not only this punishment, but also death, being the punishment of sinne, Rom. 6.2•. yet for all this was he not defiled with originall sinne. DVR. The Fathers say he knevv not the day of iudgement, because hee hath not reuealed it, and would that others should be ignorant of it. WHIT. pag. 556. This interpretation is easilie refelled. For from this will follow that the Father also was ignorant of it, seeing the Father did no more tell it and manifest it to others, then the Sonne did.
Christ as he was a true man, albeit a pure man, so he did never think, imagine or understand all things at once, and he did sleep sometimes. Do you think that Christ while he was sleeping, did comprehend all things in his memory? which though you should affirm, yet I see no reason to believe you. That which Christ spake of that day and hour, (no man knoweth it, 1nor the Son himself) Cyril writeth ⟨p. 210⟩that Christ spake it of himself, and that he knew not the day of judgement,2 as he was man, because it is proper to the humane nature to be ignorant of things to come.
Christ as he was a true man, albeit a pure man, so hee did neuer thinke, imagine or vnderstand all things at once, and he did sleepe sometimes. Do you thinke that Christ while hee was sleeping, did comprehend all things in his memorie? which though you should affirme, yet I see no reason to beleeue you. That which Christ spake of that day and houre, (no man knoweth it, 1nor the Sonne himselfe) Cyrill writeth ⟨p. 210⟩that Christ spake it of himself, and that he knew not the day of iudgement,2 as he was man, because it is proper to the humane nature to bee ignorant of things to come.
But now, say you, we shall take knowledge of worse things, and here you recite many things concerning Christs swea•e, horror, and sudden outcry. I acknowledge that which you allege, but I see no paradox therein. I am not ignorant what is wont to be given out by you in corners, that Christ is reproached, when we say he was tormented with so great griefs of mind. But it is so far off, Campian, that I do either deny or dissemble those things which you now object, that I do teach and avow them openly and freely. And though the whole nation of Jesuits should set upon me, yet I will never be ashamed to celebrate Christs mercy, which I see to be violated by them with unspeakable injuries. For what think you was it that Christ felt, which brought so great sadness and vexation to him, that it wrung from him a bloody sweat? was it only death,1 which takes away life and sense? Do you think that Christ could be broken so with the fear of that death that he should conceive so much grief in his mind, to make him sweat water and blood, for the desire he had to escape tasting of that cup which he came to drink of? Did Christ so much abhor this death, which the Martyrs have gone unto, joyful and cheerful? That were indeed to cast a greater reproach upon Christ, while ye would avoid the lesser. Wherefore that which raised so great horrors in Christ, was the most bitter wrath of God against mankind, which Christ must needs have suffered for a time. For the whole weight of our sins was imposed upon Christ, which brought with it a most heavy remembrance of Gods wrath. Seeing therefore Christ our Mediator being laden with our sins, ⟨p. 211⟩did suffer the greatness of Gods displeasure, and did alone endure the punishment of our sins, certainly he did quake, as man, and did express those incredible sorrows of his mind many ways. Hence came that speech upon the Cross, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? which he uttered not feignedly, but from his heart; not despairingly, as you wickedly write, but upon the consideration of Gods wrath, which then he was to be subject unto.m This is that Hell, of which Christ while he was alive, and not as you object against Calvin, after he was dead, did taste. And certainly this vexation, which Christ endured at that time, did equal after a sort the very pains of hell.
But now, say you, wee shall take knowledge of worse things, and here you recite many things concerning Christs swea•e, horror, and sudden outcrie. I acknowledge that which you alleage, but I see no paradoxe therein. I am not ignorant what is wont to be giuen out by you in corners, that Christ is reproched, when wee say he was tormented with so great griefes of minde. But it is so farre off, Campian, that I doe either denie or dissemble those things which you now obiect, that I doe teach and auow them openly and freely. And though the whole nation of Iesuits should set vpon me, yet I will neuer be ashamed to celebrate Christs mercie, which I see to bee violated by them with vnspeakable iniuries. For what thinke you was it that Christ felt, which brought so great sadnes and vexation to him, that it wrung from him a bloody sweate? was it only death,1 which takes away life and sense? Doe you thinke that Christ could be broken so with the feare of that death that he should conceiue so much griefe in his minde, to make him sweate water and blood, for the desire he had to escape tasting of that cup which hee came to drinke of? Did Christ so much abhorre this death, which the Martyrs haue gone vnto, ioyfull and cheerefull? That were indeede to cast a greater reproch vpon Christ, while ye would auoide the lesser. Wherefore that which raised so great horrors in Christ, was the most bitter wrath of God against mankinde, which Christ must needes haue suffered for a time. For the whole weight of our sinnes was imposed vpon Christ, which brought with it a most heauie remembrance of Gods wrath. Seeing therefore Christ our Mediatour being laden with our sins, ⟨p. 211⟩did suffer the greatnes of Gods displeasure, and did alone endure the punishment of our sinnes, certainly he did quake, as man, and did expresse those incredible sorrowes of his minde many waies. Hence came that speech vpon the Crosse, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? which he vttered not fainedly, but from his heart; not despairingly, as you wickedly write, but vpon the consideration of Gods wrath, which then he was to be subiect vnto.m This is that Hell, of which Christ while he was aliue, and not as you obiect against Caluin, after he was dead, did taste. And certainly this vexation, which Christ endured at that time, did equall after a sort the very paines of hell.
1[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
mDVR. Christ truly was the Sonne of God, who knew nothing in himself worthy of wrath, and so could not fear the pains of hell. WHIT. pag. 558. You dispute wittily: as if he were not the Sonne of Man also, and sustained the person of sinful men. Neither did he so fear hell, as you imagine: but when the punishment of us all was upon him alone, he must needs as a man be greatly affected and moved with it. For God was exceedingly incensed against us for our sins: Christ interposed himself; and he alone underwent the greatness of that wrath poured upon him, he therefore that saith, Christ felt nothing, diminisheth the greatness of sin, the justice of God, and the merit of Christ. I hat he was not swallowed up of those torments, it must be imputed to the power of his divine nature. DVR. But how could he think himself forsaken of God. who offered himself wholly to God? WHIT. pag. 559. If be did nor feel this defection, why did he say vainly and rashly that he was forsaken? he o••ed himself by his eternal spirit, that is, his Divinity, Hebr. 9.14. Therefore this freewill offering did not hinder, but that he might feel in his mind those sorrows which men should have suffered.DVR. Christ truly was the Sonne of God, who knew nothing in himselfe worthie of wrath, and so could not feare the paines of hell. WHIT. pag. 558. You dispute wittily: as if he were not the Sonne of Man also, and sustained the person of sinfull men. Neither did he so feare hell, as you imagine: but when the punishment of vs all was vpon him alone, he must needs as a man be greatly affected and moued with it. For God was exceedingly incensed against vs for our sinnes: Christ interposed himselfe; and he alone vn•erwent the greatnes of that wrath powred vpon him, he therfore that saith, Christ felt nothing, diminisheth the greatnes of sin, the iustice of God, and the merit of Christ. I hat he was not swallowed vp of those torments, it must be imputed to the power of his diuine nature. DVR. But how could hee thinke himselfe forsaken of God. vvho offered himselfe vvholy to God? WHIT. pag. 559. If be did nor feele this defection, why did hee say vainely and rashly that he was forsaken? he o••ed himselfe by his eternall spirit, that is, his Diuinity, Hebr. 9.14. Therefore this freewill offering did not hinder, but that he might feele in his mind those sorrowes which men should haue suffered.
But these things are reproved by you, because they be not understood. For the Papists with their dull hearts cannot conceive, what Christ performed for us by his death, and what pains he endured for the satisfying of his Father. Therefore they think wrong is done to Christ, when we say he suffered those things which he both would and ought to have suffered for us. For it was necessary not only that Christ should die inn body, but also in his soul wrestle with death, because not only ⟨p. 212⟩mans body, but also his soul had offended God, and deserved everlasting death. And they that speak against this doctrine, being very full of divine comfort, if Calvin do prosecute somewhat eagerly, no good man ought justly to be displeased with him for this cause. But that you cannot abide: and therefore you cry out, Oh wicked days! oh monstrous times! It may be you have seen a monster at Rome, or rather many monsters, which trouble you now with furious thoughts, and urge you to make an outcry. But we University men are not wont much to be moved with the clamours of mad men. For he overcomes in the Schools, not who can cry out most shrilly, but who can dispute most fitly unto the truth. But I pray you, Campian, spare your voice a while, and gather your wits together, and then I trust you will be somewhat milder anon, when you have rested you a little, for I do not hear that this is the ⟨p. 213⟩continual dint of your mind, and I do not doubt but you may be pacified with words. You say that Christ hath contumelious injury offered him by us. Wherefore? because he is by this means too much abased, and much is detracted from his Majesty. Concerning that Nazianzen answers you: Is Christ therefore spoiled of his honour, 2because he is become humble for thy sake? Now how great bitterness of grief Christ felt, learn of Rabanus, 3if haply you regard him. Thus doth he expound those words of Christ, Why hast thou forsaken me: Our Saviour (saith he) spake this, carrying about him our affections, who being in danger think our selves to be forsaken. For his humane nature was forsaken because of sin: but because the Son of God was made our Advocate, he bewails their misery whose fault he took upon him. And Hierome though he did differ from this opinion because of the Arians,4 yet the very power of truth did wring from him some confession.
But these things are reproued by you, because they bee not vnderstood. For the Papists with their dull hearts cannot conceiue, what Christ performed for vs by his death, and what paines hee endured for the satisfying of his Father. Therefore they thinke wrong is done to Christ, when we say he suffered those things which hee both would and ought to haue suffered for vs. For it was necessarie not onely that Christ should die inn bodie, but also in his soule wrastle with death, because not onely ⟨p. 212⟩mans bodie, but also his soule had offended God, and deserued euerlasting death. And they that speak against this doctrine, being very full of diuine comfort, if Caluin doe prosecute somewhat eagerly, no good man ought iustly to bee displeased with him for this cause. But that you cannot abide: and therefore you cry out, Oh wicked daies! oh monstrous times! It may be you haue seene a monster at Rome, or rather many monsters, which trouble you now with furious thoughts, and vrge you to make an outcrie. But we Vniuersitie men are not woont much to bee moued with the clamours of mad men. For he ouercomes in the Schooles, not who can crie out most shrilly, but who cā dispute most sitly vnto the truth. But I pray you, Campian, spare your voyce a while, and gather your wits together, and then I trust you will be somewhat milder anon, when you haue rested you a little, for I doe not heare that this is the ⟨p. 213⟩continuall dint of your minde, and I doe not doubt but you may bee pacified with words. You say that Christ hath contumelious iniurie offered him by vs. Wherefore? because he is by this meanes too much abased, and much is detracted from his Maiestie. Concerning that Nazianzen answers you: Is Christ therefore spoiled of his honour, 2because hee is become humble for thy sake? Now how great bitternes of griefe Christ felt, learne of Rabanus, 3if happely you regard him. Thus doth he expound those words of Christ, Why hast thou forsaken mee: Our Sauiour (saith he) spake this, carrying about him our affections, who being in danger thinke our selues to be forsaken. For his humane nature was forsaken because of sinne: but because the Sonne of God was made our Aduocate, he bewailes their miserie whose fault he tooke vpon him. And Hierome though he did differ from this opinion because of the Arrians,4
nDVR. Christ being God and man satisfied the divine justice, not by the greatness and multitude of his punishment, but by the weight of his actions, every one of which is sufficient to be a full price of mans redemption. Neither was it necessary that Christ should undergo the same punishment; which man should have suffered, as if any man would free another from prison, who is cast into it for debt; it is not necessary that be go into prison for him. Besides, who will say that the body of man aid sin? it is man that sinneth, not the body. WHIT. pag. 562. See I pray you what followeth upon your defence, that it was needless that Christ should die at all: for if any action of him being God and man, would have satisfied Gods justice, and wrought mans redemption, in vain did he shed his blood and suffer death But if this be contrary to the decree & justice of God, and not every punishment but extreme sufferings both of body and soul was to be undergone, as Christ suffered in his body the most b••ter •eath, so did he in his soul exquisite and extreme sorrows. And out of your similitude it will follow •s well, that he need not to have descended from heaven to have been made man, or to have suffered any sorrows: and yet who knoweth not, that not only the debtors themselves, but their su••ies must be cast into prison, till the creditor be satisfied? And seeing that in such a surety as this, not the bare payment of money, but a real suffering of grievous pains was necessary, why should we doubt but Christ hath most truly accomplished the part of a surety? Lastly if the body do not sin, why should it suffer the punishment of sin? for is it equal, that the body, which in your judgment doth not sin, should be grievously and eternally punished for sin? And if it be as you say, that the man doth sin, then must the body have a finger in it; for the soul of it self is not a man. And if Christ took mans sin upon him, it was certainly the sin of the whole man, because he hath redeemed the whole.DVR. Christ being God and man satisfied the diuine iustice, not by the greatnes and multitude of his punishment, but by the weight of his actions, euerie one of vvhich is sufficient to be a full price of mans redemption. Neither vvas it necessary that Christ should vndergoe the same punishment; vvhich man should haue suffered, as if any man vvould free another from prison, vvho is cast into it for debt; it is not necessary that be go into prison for him. Besides, who will say that the body of man aid sinne? it is man that sinneth, not the bodie. WHIT. pag. 562. See I pray you what followeth vpon your defence, that it was needlesse that Christ should die at all: for if any action of him being God and man, would haue satisfied Gods iustice, and wrought mans redemption, in vaine did hee shead his blood and suffer death But if this be contrary to the decree & iustice of God, and not euery punishment but extreame sufferings both of body and soule was to be vndergone, as Christ suffered in his body the most bter eath, so did he in his soule exquisite and extreame sorrowes. And out of your similitude it will follow s well, that he need not to haue descended from heauen to haue been made man, or to haue suffered any sorrowes: and yet who knoweth not, that not only the debtors themselues, but their suies must be cast into prison, till the creditor be safied? And seeing that in such a suerty as this, not the bare payment of money, but a reall suffering of grieuous paines was necessary, why should we doubt but Christ hath most truly accomplished the part of a suertie? Lastly if the bodie doe not sinne, why should it suffer the punishment of sinne? for is it equall, that the body, which in your iudgment doth not sinne, should be grieuously and eternally punished for sinne? And if it bee as you say, that the man doth sinne, then must the body haue a finger in it; for the soule of it selfe is not a man. And if Christ tooke mans sinne vpon him, it was certainly the sin of the whole man, because he hath redeemed the whole.
Concerning Christs prayer, wherein he entreated, that that cup might be taken away, thus he writeth: Nevertheless returning to himself, that which he had refused somewhat fearfully in his nature, as man, he ratifieth in his nature as he was God and the Son: Yet not as I will, but as thou wilt, saith he, let not this be done which I speak in my humane affection, but that for which I came down to the earth by thy will. 1And Ambrose useth these words to Gratian: As he took my will, so he took my sorrow. Finally,2 I will annex the judgement of Melchior Canus, to whom you owe much on good cause, that you may know the opinion of a flat Catholic touching this matter. Surely (saith he) it was convenient that the Son of God, being to exhibit himself a sacrifice for sin, should take upon him not only the sorrows of the body, and of the sensitive faculty of the soul, but also the otorments of the spirit, and the grief ⟨p. 214⟩of the will, to the end that that most acceptable sacrifice to God for all our sins, might be by all means broken and bruised. And a little after: He being forsaken of God, and destitute utterly of all comfort, did not rejoice.
Concerning Christs prayer, wherein he entreated, that that cup might be taken away, thus he writeth: Neuerthelesse returning to himselfe, that which he had refused somewhat fearefully in his nature, as man, he ratifieth in his nature as he was God and the Sonne: Yet not as I will, but as thou wilt, saith he, let not this be done which I speake in my humane affection, but that for which I came downe to the earth by thy will. 1And Ambrose vseth these words to Gratian: As he tooke my will, so he tooke my sorrow. Finally,2 I will annexe the iudgement of Melchior Canus, to whom you owe much on good cause, that you may know the opinion of a flat Catholike touching this matter. Surely (saith he) it was conuenient that the Sonne of God, being to exhibite himselfe a sacrifice for sinne, should take vpon him not onely the sorrowes of the bodie, and of the sensitiue facultie of the soule, but also the otorments of the spirit, and the griefe ⟨p. 214⟩of the will, to the end that that most acceptable sacrifice to God for all our sinnes, might be by all meanes broken and bruised. And a little after: Hee being forsaken of God, and destitute vtterly of all comfort, did not reioyce.
1Ambrosius.
2Melch. Canus. lib. 12. cap. 13.
oDVR. But it followeth not that so he did despair or feel the pains of hell. WHIT. pag. 564. There was no danger, lest Christ might perchance despair, nor is it necessary, that whosoever sustaineth the pains of hell for a while, the same should be overwhelmed with perpetual despair: many of the godly are sometime afflicted with a very deep sense of Gods anger, which they yet overcome through Gods spirit, much more then could Christ overcome all the pains of hell.DVR. But it followeth not that so he did dispaire or feele the paines of hell. WHIT. pag. 564. There was no dāger, lest Christ might perchance despaire, nor is it necessary, that whosoeuer sustaineth the paines of hell for a while, the same should bee ouerwhelmed with perpetuall despaire: many of the godly are sometime afflicted with a very deepe sense of Gods anger, which they yet ouercome through Gods spirit, much more then could Christ ouercome all the paines of hell.
You say that Bucer in comparison of this madness was modest, although he were very impudent, who takes Hell in the Creed for the grave. I let pass your reproach, which you lack not in any place, nor am I disposed to extend any longer answer about this Hell. The matter is in some difference among learned men, who albeit they agree not so well among themselves about the thing, yet they agree herein excellent well, in that they affirm that the Papists do very wickedly understand it of Christs descent into Hell. For as for Hell, whether it signify the burial of Christ, as Bucer thought, or that sorrow of mind, wherewith Christ was affected a little before his death, as Calvin would have it; yet we retain the Article, and we teach that Christ did descend into Hell. If that cannot be otherwise understood than thus, that Christ did descend into, I know not what, Limbus Patrum, wherein you suppose the Fathers to have been, and that he did out of that place bring with him an infinite multitude of holy men, I will confess that Bucer did err, and that Calvin made a foul slip. But those your dreams concerning Hell, are worthy to be buried in Hell it self. Now as for that you say, that it was in deliberation in a certain conventicle at London, how that article might be taken out of the Creed, this certainly is the first time that ever I heard of it, neither do I give any credit either to your self, or to your wretched Cheiny, who told you this tale. Although if the ancient Creeds of the Roman and East Church did lack that Article, as he affirmeth, whosoever he is, that in Cyprian's works expounded the Creed with his Commentaries, ⟨p. 215⟩perhaps their fault wasp less, which would imitate the Church of Rome, which you hold cannot err.
You say that Bucer in comparison of this madnes was modest, although hee were very impudent, who takes Hell in the Creed for the graue. I let passe your reproch, which you lacke not in any place, nor am I disposed to extend any longer answere about this Hell. The matter is in some difference among learned men, who albeit they agree not so well among themselues about the thing, yet they agree herein excellent well, in that they affirme that the Papists doe very wickedly vnderstand it of Christs descent into Hell. For as for Hell, whether it signifie the buriall of Christ, as Bucer thought, or that sorrowe of minde, wherewith Christ was affected a little before his death, as Caluin would haue it; yet we retaine the Article, and we teach yt Christ did descend into Hell. If that cannot bee otherwise vnderstood than thus, that Christ did descend into, I know not what, Limbus Patrum, wherein you suppose the Fathers to haue been, and that hee did out of that place bring with him an infinite multitude of holy men, I will confesse that Bucer did erre, and that Caluin made a foule slip. But those your dreames concerning Hell, are worthie to be buried in Hell it selfe. Now as for that you say, that it was in deliberation in a certaine conuenticle at London, how that article might bee taken out of the Creed, this certainly is the first time that euer I heard of it, neither doe I giue any credit either to your selfe, or to your wretched Cheiny, who told you this tale. Although if the ancient Creeds of the Romane and East Church did lacke that Article, as hee affirmeth, whosoeuer hee is, that in Cyprians workes expounded the Creed with his Commentaries, ⟨p. 215⟩perhaps their fault wasp lesse, which would imitate the Church of Rome, which you hold cannot erre.
pDVR. Js it a small fault to cross out of the Apostles Creed Christ his descension into hell? It is solid in the Creed of Athanasius, where there is mention of burial, and in the Nicene Creed, when his burial is mentioned, this descension is not expressed. And who seeth not that it was necessary that his soul must descend into the common place of other souls? WHIT. pag. 568. If it be a heinous fact to put out this article, then the Church of Rome (which you say cannot err) is guilty of this, as Ruffinus writeth in exposit. Symb. And it is no strange thing, when in very few ancient Creeds it is to be found. I could produce fifty Creeds, which have it not; in certain it is found, but then saith Ruffinus it must be understood by the precedent article, for it is the same with that, which saith he was buried. And this was Bucers opinion, which the two Creeds of Athanasius and Nice do confirm: for if they be so diversly set down, that in some of them is mention of his burial only, in others only of his descension; it is manifest, that there is one and the same sense in them, and that to be buried is as much as to descend into hell, and this as much as that. Finally it is true his soul went into the common receptacle of souls, but how prove you that that place is in hell? for if his soul went into Paradise, it could not go into hell, unless Paradise be there.DVR. Js it a small fault to crosse out of the Apostles Creed Christ his descension into hell? It is solid in the Creed of Athanasius, where there is mention of buriall, and in the Nicene Creed, when his buriall is mentioned, this descension is not expressed. And who seeth not that it was necessary that his soule must descend into the common place of other soules? WHIT. pag. 568. If it be a haynous fact to put out this article, then the Church of Rome (which you say cannot erre) is guiltie of this, as Ruffinus writeth in exposit. Symb. And it is no strange thing, when in very few auncient Creeds it is to be found. I could produce fiftie Creeds, which haue it not; in certaine it is found, but then saith Ruffinus it must be vnderstood by the precedent article, for it is the same with that, which saith he was buried. And this was Bucers opinion, which the two Creeds of Athanasius and Nice do confirme: for if they be so diuersly set downe, that in some of them is mention of his buriall only, in others only of his descension; it is manifest, that there is one and the same sense in them, and that to be buried is as much as to descend into hel, and this as much as that. Finallie it is true his soule went into the common receptacle of soules, but how proue you that that place is in hell? for if his soule went into Paradise, it could not go into hell, vnlesse Paradise be there.
1Now you make your question concerning man: and you bring us in speaking on this fashion. The image of God is utterly blotted out in man, no spark of good being left: For so, say you, have Illyricus and Calvin taught. I know well the judgement of Illyricus, which I do not think ought to be laid to our charge. For you are not ignorant, Campian, that his opinion touching the image of God, and of the nature of original sin, hath been reproved and confuted by our men: he went somewhat farther than he should; I believe he did it, that he might remove himself farthest off from you, whom he throughly hated. But I would he had amended some things: then certainly had he been a very excellent man. As for Calvin you do him open wrong, whom you join with Illyricus in the fellowship of this judgement: for he writeth directly and flatly contrary to that,2 that you bring him in speaking;q That the image of God was not quite blotted out in man. But this is your fashion, that when you cannot reprove those things which we do say, then you feign those ⟨p. 216⟩things to be said by us, which may easily be reproved. We teach, that man was created and formed so in the beginning, that he was answerable to the image of God in all things. Now that image was a most perfect entireness of all parts, heaped up with all good graces and virtues, which could be incident to the pure nature of man. Whatsoever he did imagine, desire, will, think, or understand, was holy and right, and agreeable to Gods will, yea even to the rule of that law, Thou shalt love God with all thy heart, with all thy soul, with all thy strength, and thy neighbour as thy self. But after that Adam had slid back from God, we say that this image was pitifully corrupted and deformed, that neither the understanding did retain that ancient light, nor the will did love God, nay the whole will was turned from him, neither did there remain entire any faculty either of body or soul. Although therefore we deny not that some relics of that most noble image do remain still, yet we hold that all that which may reconcile and make us acceptable unto God, and be sufficient for us to salvation, is blotted out and extinguished. ⟨p. 217⟩All reason, and judgement, and understanding, which was some little piece of that image, is not utterly lost, there is not no will at all left in us;
1Now you make your question concerning man: and you bring vs in speaking on this fashion. The image of God is vtterly blotted out in man, no sparke of good being left: For so, say you, haue Illyricus and Caluin taught. I know well the iudgement of Illyricus, which I doe not thinke ought to bee laide to our charge. For you are not ignorant, Campian, that his opinion touching the image of God, and of the nature of originall sinne, hath been reprooued and confuted by our men: he went somewhat farther than he should; I beleeue he did it, that he might remooue himselfe farthest off from you, whom hee throughly hated. But I would he had amended some things: then certainely had he been a very excellent man. As for Caluin you doe him open wrong, whom you ioyne with Illyricus in the fellowship of this iudgement: for he writeth directly and flatly contrarie to that,2 that you bring him in speaking;q That the image of God was not quite blotted out in man. But this is your fashion, that when you cannot reprooue those things which we doe say, then you faine those ⟨p. 216⟩things to be said by vs, which may easily be reprooued. We teach, that man was created and formed so in the beginning, that hee was answerable to the image of God in all things. Now that image was a most perfect entirenes of all parts, heaped vp with all good graces and vertues, which could bee incident to the pure nature of man. Whatsoeuer he did imagine, desire, will, thinke, or vnderstand, was holie and right, and agreeable to Gods will, yea euen to the rule of that law, Thou shalt loue God with all thy heart, with all thy soule, with all thy strength, and thy neighbour as thy selfe. But after that Adam had slid backe from God, we say that this image was pitifully corrupted and deformed, that neither the vnderstanding did retaine that ancient light, nor the will did loue God, nay the whole will was turned from him, neither did there remaine entire any facultie either of bodie or soule. Although therefore we denie not that some reliques of that most noble image do remaine still, yet we hold that all that which may reconcile and make vs acceptable vnto God, and bee sufficient for vs to saluation, is blotted out and extinguished. ⟨p. 217⟩All reason, and iudgement, and vnderstanding, which was some little peece of that image, is not vtterly lost, there is not no will at all left in vs;
1Of Man.
2Inslit. lib. 1. cap. 15. sect. 4.
qDVR. But Calvin saith, that the Saints have nothing within but contagion and corruption. For if there be in the Saints no true justice, but all their works are sins, what can be in them besides corruption, and contagion. WHIT. pag. 572. Do you neither fear God, nor reverence man? Show v• any such words of Calvin, if you can: if you cannot, why do you repeat that which Campian most falsely objected at the first? There are in the Saints and the regenerate many excellent virtues and graces of the holy Ghost, as faith, love, hope, patience, &c. who ever said that these were nothing but corruption and contagion? fie, away with you and your slander. As for your argument it is marue love slender, for though the Saints have no justice of their own, which doth perfectly satisfy the Law of God, yet they are endued with many excellent virtues and ornaments of the holy Ghost. If I should reason, because there is no sound learning in you at all, therefore there is nothing but mere ignorance in you, I should conclude the one as truly, as you the other. As for your last slander, that all the works of the Saints are sins; we say no that they are sins, but that by reason of the inherent corruption they are tainted with some spot of sin, and have not that perfection which the law and justice of God requireth. Will you say, that he who is lightly touched with some disease, is nothing else, but the disease? you should certainly stand in need of Physicians and much Physic, if you should thus speak.DVR. But Caluin saith, that the Saints haue nothing within but contagion and corruption. For if there be in the Saints no true iustice, but all their vvorkes are sinnes, vvhat can be in them besides corruption, and contagion. WHIT. pag. 572. Doe you neither feare God, nor reuerence man? Shew v• any such words of Caluin, if you can: if you cannot, why doe you repeate that which Campian most falsely obiected at the first? There are in the Saints and the regenerate many excellent vertues and graces of the holy Ghost, as faith, loue, hope, patience, &c. who euer said that these vvere nothing but corruption and contagion? fie, away vvith you and your slander. As for your argument it is marue lous slender, for though the Saints haue no iustice of their ovvne, vvhich doth perfectly satisfie the Lavv of God, yet they are indued vvith many excellent vertues and ornaments of the holy Ghost. If I should reason, because there is no sound learning in you at all, therefore there is nothing but meere ignorance in you, I should conclude the one as truly, as you the other. As for your last slander, that all the vvorkes of the Saints are sinnes; vve say no that they are sinnes, but that by reason of the inherent corruption they are tainted vvith some spot of sin, and haue not that perfection vvhich the law and iustice of God requireth. Wil you say, that he vvho is lightly touched vvith some disease, is nothing else, but the disease? you should certainly stand in need of Physitions and much Physicke, if you should thus speake.
but yet the fall of Adam did inflict such a blow upon all these faculties which yet remain in us, that neither can our will of it self will any thing, which God may like of, nor our mind think, understand, or judge right and true things without error. Therefore John saith that the light shineth in the darkness,1 but yet the darkness comprehendeth it not. But now those greater things, faith, righteousness, holiness, and perfect virtue, which may lead us unto everlasting felicity, these did not only receive a wound to become weaker, but they did quite perish, and became none, until that they be renewed in us by the holy Ghost and the grace of regeneration. Wherefore thus doth the Lord speak touching man whom he had fashioned after his own image, whom also he knew throughly:2 The wickedness of man was great in the earth, and all the imagination of the thoughts of his hart was only evil continually. And that we might understand that these things were pronounced of mankind as it is in it self, and not only of those wicked men, who lived before the flood, the Lord doth again repeat these things after the flood, what time Noah only with his family were left alive upon the earth:3 Hereafter (saith he) I will not curse the earth any more for mans sake, for the frame of mans heart is evil from his youth. Can you, Campian, judge better and righter of the image of man, than the Lord himself could? If all the thoughts of mans heart be both always and only evil, and the very frame and beginning & fountain as it were of all his thoughts most corrupt, what now is left of that image which was sometime so excellent, which may help any whit to attain happiness? Hitherto belongeth that ⟨p. 218⟩which Christ saith, That which is borne of the flesh, 4is flesh: and that which is borne of the spirit, is spirit. If the whole man be flesh, certainly the whole is unclean. And Paul saith, we were the children of wrath. 5But the Lord doth not hate his own image, nay wheresoever he beholds it, he loveth it entirely. And Paul pronounceth that the whole man every whit is the child of wrath: wherefore that image which may make us acceptable to God, can never now be found in us.
but yet the fall of Adam did inflict such a blow vpon all these faculties which yet remaine in vs, that neither can our will of it selfe will any thing, which God may like of, nor our minde thinke, vnderstand, or iudge right and true things without error. Therefore Iohn saith that the light shineth in the darkenes,1 but yet the darkenes comprehendeth it not. But now those greater things, faith, righteousnesse, holinesse, and perfect vertue, which may leade vs vnto euerlasting felicitie, these did not onely receiue a wound to become weaker, but they did quite perish, and became none, vntill that they bee renewed in vs by the holy Ghost and the grace of regeneration. Wherefore thus doth the Lord speake touching man whom hee had fashioned after his owne image, whom also he knew throughly:2 The wickednes of man was great in the earth, and all the imagination of the thoughes of his hart was onely euill continually. And that we might vnderstand that these things were pronounced of mankind as it is in it selfe, and not onely of those wicked men, who liued before the flood, the Lord doth againe repeate these things after the flood, what time Noah onely with his familie were left aliue vpon the earth:3 Hereafter (saith he) I will not curse the earth any more for mans sake, for the frame of mans heart is euill from his youth. Can you, Campian, iudge better and righter of the image of man, than the Lord himselfe could? If all the thoughts of mans heart bee both alwaies and onely euill, and the very frame and beginning & fountaine as it were of al his thoughts most corrupt, what now is left of that image which was sometime so excellent, which may helpe any whit to attaine happines? Hitherto belongeth that ⟨p. 218⟩which Christ saith, That which is borne of the flesh, 4is flesh: and that which is borne of the spirit, is spirit. If the whole man be flesh, certainly the whole is vncleane. And Paul saith, we were the children of wrath. 5But the Lord doth not hate his owne image, nay wheresoeuer he beholds it, hee loueth it entirely. And Paul pronounceth that the whole man euery whit is the child of wrath: wherefore that image which may make vs acceptable to God, can neuer now be found in vs.
For he saith, not only that we are so hurt and wounded, as that yet some hope of life remaineth, but that we wholly, such as we are in our selves, are obnoxious and subject to everlasting death, as if nature had framed us thereunto. What should I heap up more testimonies of the Scriptures, which are so plentiful through the whole Scripture, that nothing is oftener repeated than the loss of this image? wherefore we judge so of man after sin, before restitution, even as Augustine writeth, whom the very School-men themselves durst not reprove. Natural gifts were corrupted in man by sin, and the supernatural extinguished. But of man regenerate we do not say those things, which you affirm, that nothing is found in him but mere corruption and contagion. For he is endued with the spirit of Christ, he possesseth Christ dwelling in him, he is endued with faith, hope, and charity. But he who hath nothing in him but corruption, it is certain that he is no whit regenerate. For the new man which is created according to God,1 must be reformed after righteousness and true holiness. Indeed that which the regenerate man hath of his own and proper to himself, is vicious. For so the Apostle saw another law in his members rebelling against the law of his mind:2 but those things which he received from God, are contrary to this corruption and contagion; which if any do deny to be good and holy, he may well be held blasphemous ⟨p. 219⟩against the holy Ghost. As for that you both feign that we speak these things, and also express for what cause we speak them, you bewray your wonderful wisdom, which for those things that are not at all, can set down a reason wherefore they be. But we do willingly preach faith, and do easily permit it to be contemned of you. For you that defend nature against grace, and do trust rather to your own power than to Christs mercy, and do make void the promises by precepts, cannot have an honourable opinion of faith.
For he saith, not onely that wee are so hurt and wounded, as that yet some hope of life remaineth, but that we wholy, such as wee are in our selues, are obnoxious and subiect to euerlasting death, as if nature had framed vs thereunto. What should I heape vp more testimonies of the Scriptures, which are so plentiful through the whole Scripture, that nothing is oftner repeated than the losse of this image? wherfore we iudge so of man after sin, before restitution, euen as Augustine writeth, whom the very Schoole-men themselues durst not reprooue. Naturall gifts were corrupted in man by sinne, and the supernaturall extinguished. But of man regenerate wee doe not say those things, which you affirme, that nothing is found in him but meere corruption and contagion. For he is indued with the spirit of Christ, he possesseth Christ dwelling in him, he is indued with faith, hope, and charitie. But he who hath nothing in him but corruption, it is certaine that he is no whit regenerate. For the new man which is created according to God,1 must bee reformed after righteousnes and true holines. Indeed that which the regenerate man hath of his owne and proper to himselfe, is vitious. For so the Apostle saw another law in his members rebelling against the law of his minde:2 but those things which he receiued from God, are contrarie to this corruption and contagion; which if any do denie to be good and holy, he may well be held blasphemous ⟨p. 219⟩against the holy Ghost. As for that you both faine that we speake these things, and also expresse for what cause wee speake them, you bewray your wonderfull wisedome, which for those things that are not at all, can set downe a reason wherefore they be. But we doe willingly preach faith, and doe easily permit it to bee contemned of you. For you that defend nature against grace, and doe trust rather to your owne power than to Christs mercie, and doe make voide the promises by precepts, cannot haue an honourable opinion of faith.
You never keep your standing,1 Campian, and you begin the battle like a runaway. For you have a wandering and unstable wit, as it seemeth. You oppose Illyricus to us again in the same cause, whose testimony ought not to be of force against us. For herein I profess my self no less an adversary to him than your self, I had almost said, than to your self. For what an unjust and unreasonable thing is it, that you should tax that opinion as defended by us, which your self knoweth to be condemned by our Churches? Object our own opinion to us, Campian, if you can object any: we are not such, as that we should think whatsoever Illyricus could, as being a man, err in, did any whit concern us. But either Illyricus must needs be drawn into this taxation, or else this place was quite to be left void by you. For beside Illyricus, I think you have no man that thinks so. If you desire to know our opinion of this matter, I confess indeed that that defence of Illyricus did seem ever very absurd to me. For it both smells of the folly of the Manichees, and it maketh two souls in a regenerate man: and which is a greater matter, it destroys the soul. That was always the judgement of the Catholic Church, which I profess to be ours, that the substance of the soul ⟨p. 220⟩was not quite slain by sin, but only charged and infected with vicious qualities: and that sin is no inward substance of the soul, but anr accident.s Basil writeth truly, in that he denieth that sin is any living substance, or endued with a soul,4 but a quality contrary to the virtue of the soul. Augustine: tOriginal sin (saith he) remaineth not substantially, as it were some body or spirit, but it is a certain affection of an evil quality, like a disease. Finally ⟨p. 221⟩Ambrose most plainly:6uHow dwelleth sin in the flesh, seeing it is no substance, but a straying from good? Therefore let us, if you please, send away the suspicion of this error imposed by you upon us, to the author himself.
You neuer keepe your standing,1 Campian, and you begin the battaile like a runnaway. For you haue a wandring and vnstable wit, as it seemeth. You oppose Illyricus to vs againe in the same cause, whose testimonie ought not to be of force against vs. For herein I professe my selfe no lesse an aduersarie to him than your selfe, I had almost said, than to your selfe. For what an vniust and vnreasonable thing is it, that you should taxe that opinion as defended by vs, which your selfe knoweth to be condemned by our Churches? Obiect our owne opinion to vs, Campian, if you can obiect any: wee are not such, as that we should thinke whatsoeuer Illyricus could, as being a man, erre in, did any whit concerno vs. But either Illyricus must needes be drawne into this taxation, or else this place was quite to be left voide by you. For beside Illyricus, I thinke you haue no man that thinkes so. If you desire to know our opinion of this matter, I confesse indeed that that defence of Illyricus did seeme euer very absurd to me. For it both smels of the follie of the Manichies, and it maketh two soules in a regenerate man: and which is a greater matter, it destroyes the soule. That was alwaies the iudgemēt of the Catholike Church, which I professe to be ours, that the substance of the soule ⟨p. 220⟩was not quite slaine by sinne, but onely charged and infected with vitious qualities: and that sinne is no inward substance of the soule, but anr accident.s Basill writeth truly, in that hee denieth that sinne is any liuing substance, or indued with a soule,4 but a qualitie contrarie to the vertue of the soule. Augustine: tOriginall sinne (saith he) remaineth not substantially, as it were some bodie or spirit, but it is a certaine affection of an euill qualitie, like a disease. Finally ⟨p. 221⟩Ambrose most plainly:6uHow dwelleth sin in the flesh, seeing it is no substance, but a straying from good? Therfore let vs, if you please, send away the suspition of this error imposed by you vpon vs, to the author himselfe.
1Of Sin.Of Sinne.
rDVR. The Catholic Church never believed that sin was an accident or quality, but only a privation, for if it were an accident, God should be the cause and author of it. WHIT. pag. 573. But this privation is it not an accidental thing? why then make you a scruple in words, when you understand the sense? An accident is commonly called that which is in some substance, but is no part of it, which may either be absent or present without the corruption of the subject and such a thing every man knoweth sin is. And though I confess that the nature of sin consisteth in a privation; yet it is not a bare privation, as you may learn ou• of your Thomas. For. 1.2. quaest. 82. art. 1. he saith, sin is not a mere privation, but a corrupt habit, like unto a disease, whereby not only health is taken away, but bad humours are brought upon the body. And the School men when they make privation of original justice to be the form of original sin, and the matter to be concupiscence or a corrupt inclination of the faculties of the soul, what do they teach, but that in sin there is some positive thing, as Thomas useth to call it? But why do I endeavour to refel you, for whom Physic is fitter then a refuration? As for your reason it hath no force; for God is not to be accounted the author of all accidencies, but indirectly and by accident. Basil saith, That the root and cause of sin is in our selves, even our freewill.DVR. The Catholike Church neuer beleeued that sinne was an accident or qualitie, but only a priuation, for if it were an accident, God should be the cause and author of it. WHIT. pag. 573. But this priuation is it not an accidentall thing? vvhy then make you a scruple in vvords, vvhen you vnderstand the sense? An accident is commonly called that vvhich is in some substance, but is no part of it, vvhich may either be absent or present without the corruption of the subiect and such a thing euery man knovveth sinne is. And though I confesse that the nature of sinne consisteth in a priuation; yet it is not a bare priuation, as you may learne ou• of your Thomas. For. 1.2. quaest. 82. art. 1. he saith, sinne is not a meere priuation, but a corrupt habit, like vnto a disease, vvhereby not only health is taken avvay, but bad humours are brought vpon the bodie. And the Schoole men vvhen they make priuation of originall iustice to be the forme of originall sinne, and the matter to be concupiscence or a corrupt inclination of the faculties of the soule, vvhat doe they teach, but that in sinne there is some positiue thing, as Thomas vseth to call it? But vvhy do I endeuour to refell you, for vvhom Physike is fitter then a refuration? As for your reason it hath no force; for God is not to be accounted the author of all accidencies, but indirectly and by accident. Basil saith, That the roote and cause of sinne is in our selues, euen our freewill.
As for that you add, that it is a thing commonly held by this filthy sect, that all sins be equal, verily nothing could be spoken more impudently. Pardon me, Campian, if I answer you somewhat sharply: for your unmodest and intolerable impudency wrung that term from me. Are you so far spent that you are not able to charge us with any true crime, but shamelessly to object those things against us, from which we, of all others, are farthest off? For who did ever more vehemently disallow, or more strongly confute this paradox of the Stoics, than our Divines, whom you now pursue? All records of these times may be witnesses hereof, our books, Churches and Schools be witnesses, as also both the civill and Church Discipline may be a witness. Did you think that you could creep into the minds of our University men by these means, by lying so openly, so shamefully, and so boldly? O Rome, what a Campian hast thou returned to us! how much changed from him that he was when thou receivedst him? Art thou wont so to instruct, adorn and polish thy pensioners, as that they retain nothing of their ancient shamefastness? What may I complain of, or to whom should I appeal? surely even to the very same our University men, to whom you your self write: they may convince you by their testimonies. For within these two years our Cambridge men have heard this very matter twice ⟨p. 222⟩propounded and defended in the divinity Schools, That sins are not equal. If neither our own confession, nor the testimony of all mortal men can make enough for the defending of our innocency; be it, that we are Stoics, and heretics, and every thing else.
As for that you adde, that it is a thing commonly held by this filthie sect, that all sinnes be equall, verily nothing could be spoken more impudently. Pardon me, Campian, if I answere you somewhat sharpely: for your vnmodest and intolerable impudencie wrung that terme from me. Are you so far spent that you are not able to charge vs with any true crime, but shamelessely to obiect those things against vs, from which we, of all others, are farthest off? For who did euer more vehemently disallow, or more strongly confute this paradoxe of the Stoiks, than our Diuines, whom you now pursue? All records of these times may be witnesses hereof, our bookes, Churches and Schooles be witnesses, as also both the ciuill and Church Discipline may be a witnesse. Did you thinke that you could creepe into the minds of our Vniuersitie men by these meanes, by lying so openly, so shamefully, and so boldly? O Rome, what a Campian hast thou returned to vs! how much chaunged from him that he was when thou receiuedst him? Art thou wont so to instruct, adorne and polish thy pensioners, as that they retaine nothing of their auncient shamefastnes? What may I complaine of, or to whom should I appeale? surely euen to the very same our Vniuersitie men, to whom you your selfe write: they may conuince you by their testimonies. For within these two yeares our Cambridge men haue heard this very matter twise ⟨p. 222⟩propounded and defended in the diuinity Schooles, That sinnes are not equall. If neither our owne confession, nor the testimonie of all mortall men can make enough for the defending of our innocencie; be it, that we are Stoikes, and heretikes, and euery thing else.
But these are* Calvins words, saith Campian, howsoever with an exception, if they be pondered by God the Judge. What are these the words of Calvin? that he saith sins are equal, but so, if they be weighed by God the Judge? nothing less: for Gods judgements could not be right, if so be he did judge sins to be equal. But mark ye a singular witness. The Fathers of the Council of Trent pronounce a curse on them, who affirm that a just man doth sin either mortally or venially in every good work. To this Calvin answereth that which Solomon saith,2 that man thinketh his own ways right, but God pondereth the hearts. But in the judgement of God nothing is sincere and honest, but that which floweth from the perfect love of him. Calvin speaketh not one word of the equality of sins, nor was there any cause why he should. Only this he intendeth, if the Lord would weigh in his balance the excellentest works of godly men, that he would easily find what to condemn: what is this to the purpose?
But these are* Caluins words, saith Campian, howsoeuer with an exception, if they be pondered by God the Iudge. What are these the words of Caluin? that he saith sinnes are equall, but so, if they be weighed by God the Iudge? nothing lesse: for Gods iudgements could not be right, if so be he did iudge sinnes to be equall. But marke yee a singular witnesse. The Fathers of the Councell of Trent pronounce a curse on them, who affirme that a iust man doth sin either mortally or venially in euery good worke. To this Caluin answereth that which Salomon saith,2 that man thinketh his owne waies right, but God pondereth the hearts. But in the iudgement of God nothing is sincere and honest, but that which floweth from the perfect loue of him. Caluin speaketh not one word of the equalitie of sins, nor was there any cause why he should. Only this he intendeth, if the Lord would weigh in his ballance the excellentest works of godly men, that he would easily find what to cōdemne: what is this to the purpose?
*DVR. Herein Calvin made sins equal, for that he thought all sins to be deadly, and worthy of everlasting punishment. WHIT. pag. 578. Therefore doth Calvin make all sins equal, because he proveth that all sinner are in their own nature deadly? but the Scripture hath taught this most plainly. For if every sin be the transgression of Gods law, and an aversion & defection from God, which is the chiefest good, it must needs in it self deserve eternal death, Rom. 6.21.23. Jam. 2.10. though every sin in Gods justice is odiudged to eternal death, yet it doth not equally deserve it.DVR. Herein Caluin made sinnes equall, for that hee thought all sins to be deadly, and vvorthy of euerlasting punishment. WHIT. pag. 578. Therefore doth Caluin make all sinnes equall, because hee proueth that all sinner are in their owne nature deadly? but the Scripture hath taught this most plainly. For if euery sinne be the transgression of Gods law, and an auersion & defection from God, which is the chiefest good, it must needs in it selfe deserue eternal death, Rom. 6.21.23. Iam. 2.10. though euery sinne in Gods iustice is odiudged to eternall death, yet it doth not equally deserue it.
2Antidote. 6. Sess. in Can. 25.Antidot. 6. Sess. in Can. 25.
As for that, that Thomas Walsingham did object against Wycliffe, it is not much material, he wrote many things against Wycliffe being dead, and let pass no slander which witty malice could devise. While Wycliffe was alive, no adversaries could hurt him, but being dead they condemned him, they plucked him out of his grave, burned his body, when they might without danger devise any thing against that most holy man. Neither can I ever be induced to believe, ⟨p. 223⟩that Wycliffe taught these things, if this imputation depend upon no greater credit than of an adversary. As touching that, that you report of the Duke of Guise, I defend not the fact: he that committed it, suffered punishment greater I wis, than Taverners are wont, that kill pullen when there is no need. I confess that the Guise was a man of admirable fortitude: I would he had been of more clemency. He was flayed, even as you say, by a wicked man, whom if perhaps either hope of impunity or fear of punishment did induce, that being examined, he did accuse very noble and innocent men, it is neither marvellous nor new. Him that he did appeach as the Ringleader of his plot, the King himself did pronounce an innocent: but as for Beza all good men have acquitted him in their judgements long ago.
As for that, that Thomas Walsingham did obiect against Wicliffe, it is not much materiall, he wrote many things against Wicliffe being dead, and let passe no slander which witty malice could deuise. While Wicliffe was aliue, no aduersaries could hurt him, but being dead they condemned him, they plucked him out of his graue, burned his body, when they might without danger deuise any thing against that most holy man. Neither can I euer be induced to beleeue, ⟨p. 223⟩that Wicliffe taught these things, if this imputation depend vpon no greater credit than of an aduersarie. As touching that, that you report of the Duke of Guise, I defend not the fact: he that committed it, suffered punishmēt greater I wis, than Tauerners are wont, that kill pullen when there is no need. I confesse that the Guise was a man of admirable fortitude: I would he had been of more clemencie. He was flaine, euen as you say, by a wicked man, whom if perhaps either hope of impunity or feare of punishment did induce, that being examined, hee did accuse verie noble and innocent men, it is neither marueilous nor new. Him that he did appeach as the Ringleader of his plot, the King himselfe did pronounce an innocent: but as for Beza all good men haue acquitted him in their iudgements long ago.
From Sin you pass your speech to Grace:1 I would rather you your self did make passage: and you hope, that we who are so strict in the matter of sin, will play the Philosophers so gloriously about Gods Grace. Surely we shall think we play the Philosophers very well, if we refer all our Philosophy for the amplifying of the Cross of Christ.2 You also do treat of Grace, but as still you are wont, in few words. But what do you reprove in our Philosophy? because we place Grace out of us only in the favour of God. For you, Campian, would have your men to be persuaded, that we take all Grace from man, and do place it only in the mind of God, like Plato's Idea. But either you know not what you talk of in this place, and that you are ignorant of this Philosophy, or else you suffer not our opinion, being infolded in your slanders, to be manifest. For we make grace to be twofold (that I may omit many distinctions) wherein we do not disallow the Philosophy of your School men. For either Grace declareth the free goodwill and clemency of God toward us, or else it ⟨p. 224⟩signifieth those gifts, which flow out of that mercy of God to us. That they commonly call, Grace making acceptable; and this, Grace freely given. Now for thatx goodwill and favour whereby the Lord embraceth us in Christ, and forgiveth us our sins, and receiveth us into favour; we place it in God: but the effects of this Grace are in us: which effects are these, that we do by the holy Ghost perceive that we are ⟨p. 225⟩loved of God, that we believe in God, and repose all hope of salvation in that mercy of God. We do not therefore take away all grace from man, and place it only in Gods favour: but that first grace, whereby he hath reconciled us to himself in Christ, and wherein our salvation is contained, that alone we place in God; which being felt by us, faith, hope, and charity and other virtues do follow it, which are ours, and resident in us. But we deny that position of yours of infused grace, whereby you defend, that the grace whereby we are justified, is a certain habit situate in our minds within: and we acknowledge no other justifyingy grace, but the great and free mercy of God, whereby he did elect and predestinate us in Christ before all eternity unto life everlasting, and hath called us in time and justified us.z
From Sinne you passe your speech to Grace:1 I would rather you your selfe did make passage: and you hope, that we who are so strict in the matter of sin, will play the Philosophers so gloriously about Gods Grace. Surely we shall thinke we play the Philosophers very well, if we referre all our Philosophie for the amplifying of the Crosse of Christ.2 You also do treate of Grace, but as still you are wont, in few words. But what do you reproue in our Philosophie? because we place Grace out of vs only in the fauouer of God. For you, Campian, would haue your men to be perswaded, that we take all Grace from man, and doe place it only in the mind of God, like Platoes Idea. But either you know not what you talke of in this place, and that you are ignorant of this Philosophie, or els you suffer not our opinion, being infolded in your slanders, to bee manifest. For wee make grace to bee twofold (that I may omit many distinctions) wherein wee doe not disallow the Philosophie of your Schoole men. For either Grace declareth the free goodwill and clemencie of God toward vs, or else it ⟨p. 224⟩signifieth those gifts, which flow out of that mercy of God to vs. That they commonly call, Grace making acceptable; and this, Grace freely giuen. Now for thatx goodwill and fauour whereby the Lord embraceth vs in Christ, and forgiueth vs our sinnes, and receiueth vs into fauour; we place it in God: but the effects of this Grace are in vs: which effects are these, that we do by the holy Ghost perceiue that wee are ⟨p. 225⟩loued of God, that we beleeue in God, and repose al hope of saluation in that mercy of God. We do not therefore take away all grace from man, and place it only in Gods fauour: but that first grace, wherby he hath reconciled vs to himselfe in Christ, and wherin our saluation is contained, that alone wee place in God; which being felt by vs, faith, hope, and charity and other vertues do follow it, which are ours, and resident in vs. But we deny that position of yours of infused grace, whereby you defend, that the grace whereby we are iustified, is a certaine habite situate in our minds within: and we acknowledge no other iustifyingy grace, but the great and free mercy of God, whereby hee did elect and predestinate vs in Christ before all eternitie vnto life euerlasting, and hath called vs in time and iustified vs.
xDVR. I know well your doctrine of imputative justice, than which I know not whether any man can devise one thing more against the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 582. Thus you speak, like a Jesuit: but what is there that the Scripture doth more celebrate than imputative justice? Rom. 4.3.4.5.6. is a most clear text for it. But what? know you not that our sins were imputed to Christ? and why then may not Christs righteousness be imputed to us in l•ke manner? Think you that Christ had our sins really infused into him? I suppose, you will never say so: seeing then in the one part you are compelled against your will to confess an imputation, why do you not also grant it in the other, specially seeing the Apostle himself propoundeth us this Antithesis, 2. Cor. 5.21. Christ was made sin for us, that we might be made the righteousness of God in him? Therefore we are so made righteousness in Christ, as he was made sin for us, which must necessarily be understood of imputation. And ve••ly whereas our injustice or iniquity is a debt, and Christ hath payed it, then must it of necessity follow, that, that payment is ours no otherwise then only by imputation. Again, I pray you, what can be imagined more absurd, then that the merit• of Saints should be imputed unto us, and Christ his righteousness cannot be? for they who buy indulgences with money, do not doubt but to reap much fruit from the merits of others. It then the merits of Saints, as you think, can make them more just, in whom they are not inherent, what an impious and absurd thing were it to give less power of imputation to the merits and righteousness of Christ? DVR. Charity i• the end of the Law. Rom. 13. For he that loveth his brother hath fulfilled the Law. So that if charity be truly in us, we have true justice: and well said Augustine, Charity begun, is justice begun; charity increased, is justice increased; great charity is great justice; perfect charity is perfect justice. WHIT. pag. 583. All is true you say touching charity. Love your neighbour as the law requireth, and you have fulfilled the second Fable: but this you cannot do; therefore be not brag in the opinion of your charity, which if it were as great as ever any man had, yet it should be far short of that the Law requireth, neither can it make you just. As for Augustine we confess as much as he saith: but this is not the justice which freeth us from the wrath of God, for that never increaseth or groweth, but is ever most absolute and perfect, that is Christ his obedience imputed unto us by faith. Of charity August. Epist. 29. writeth thus. As long as charity may be increased, that verily which is less, is faulty: by that which is faulty, there is none just upon earth.
For grace infused, wherein regeneration and sanctification consisteth, and which the Scriptures call the new man, ⟨p. 226⟩is not strong enough to justify us,a because it never satisfieth the law of God in this life, and ought every day to be restored, and aspire to greater perfection. For so Paul saith,2 Although our outward man perish, yet our inward man is renewed daily: which place Augustine hath very often used in this cause. You see therefore both what grace we place in God, and what we confess to be infused into our hearts. For as for that you say we bark out, that grace is not strong enough for the resisting of sin, therein you go about thorough our sides to wound Paul himself, upon whom this your reproach reboundeth.3 For though he were endued with infused grace, as much as any other, yet he denieth that he could attain, to perfect that which is good:b for that he did not the good which he would, but the evil that he would not: and that when he desired to do good, evil was present with him: finally that the law of his members doth ⟨p. 227⟩so rebel against the law of his mind, that it maketh him captive to the law of sin. Hence you may know how great strength sin hath, which even the Apostle himself, albeit he were endued with singular grace, could not so fully resist, but that sometimes he was both overcome of it, and bound up in it, as Augustine speaketh. If you doubt, Campians, whether the Apostle spake this of himself, I had rather you should take advise of Augustine, 5than of the Masters of Trent, seeing they be very bad interpreters of the Apostle. What should I remember to you David, and the rest of the Fathers, who have taught by their examples, that it is not easy to resist sin? but herein you are like your self, in that you say, that Christ is no otherwise said by us to b• full of grace and truth, but th••, that the Father did very much favour him. I pray you Campian, whence could you gather this? Do we not say that Christ was full of grace so; that from his ⟨p. 228⟩fullness we all receive grace: who of us did ever deny that there was very great and infinite grace in Christ. For they that say that Christ was so full of grace, that all men did declare that he was worthy of the unspeakable favour both of God and men, they do not only hold, that Christ was no otherwise full of grace, but herein that God did very much favour him;
For grace infused, wherein regeneration and sanctification consisteth, and which the Scriptures call the new man, ⟨p. 226⟩is not strong enough to iustifie vs,a because it neuer satisfieth the law of God in this life, and ought euery day to be restored, and aspire to greater perfection. For so Paul saith,2 Although our outward man perish, yet our inward man is renewed daily: which place Augustine hath very often vsed in this cause. You see therfore both what grace we place in God, and what we confesse to be infused into our hearts. For as for that you say wee barke out, that grace is not strong enough for the resisting of sinne, therein you goe about thorough our sides to wound Paul himself, vppon whō this your reproch reboundeth.3 For though he were indued with infused grace, as much as any other, yet he denieth that he could attaine, to perfect that which is good:b for that he did not the good which he would, but the euill that he would not: and that when he desired to do good, euill was present with him: finally that the law of his members doth ⟨p. 227⟩so rebell against the law of his mind, that it maketh him captiue to the law of sin. Hence you may know how great strength sinne hath, which euen the Apostle himselfe, albeit hee were indued with singular grace, could not so fully resist, but that sometimes he was both ouercome of it, and bound vp in it, as Augustine speaketh. If you doubt, Campians, whether the Apostle spake this of himselfe, I had rather you should take aduise of Augustine, 5than of the Masters of Trent, seeing they be very bad interpreters of the Apostle. What should I remember to you Dauid, and the rest of the Fathers, who haue taught by their examples, that it is not easie to resist sinne? but herein you are like your selfe, in that you say, that Christ is no otherwise said by vs to b• full of grace and truth, but th••, that the Father did very much fauour him. I pray you Campian, whence could you gather this? Do we not say that Christ was full of grace so; that from his ⟨p. 228⟩
aDVR. Grace infused and our inherent righteousness, though it be not perfect, yet it is true justice, and doth justify us. WHIT. pag. 58•. By this you overthrow your doctrine of justification: for that justice which doth reconcile us to God ought to be most perfect, that such as neither the law nor God himself can require a more perfect. That which is not perfect, is in it kind corrupt. If then •n imperfect justice can please God, then a corrupt thing will please him, and so should he not be perfectly just: but being most just, that only pleaseth him, which is according to the prescription of the law, most perfect. Luk. 10.27.28. Levit. 18.5.DVR. Grace infused and our inherent righteousnes, though it be not perfect, yet it is true iustice, and doth iustifie vs. WHIT. pag. 58•. By this you ouerthrow your doctrine of iustification: for that iustice which doth reconcile vs to God ought to be most perfect, that such as neither the law nor God himselfe can require a more perfect. That which is not perfect, is in it kind corrupt. If then •n imperfect iustice can please God, then a corrupt thing will please him, and so should he not be perfectly iust: but being most iust, that only pleaseth him, which is according to the prescription of the law, most perfect. Luk. 10.27.28. Leuit. 18.5.
bDVR. S. Paul saith only, that he was assayed and tempted by those motions; but seeing it is not sin, where the consent of the vvill is not, be saith, it was not he that did it, but the flesh, for he doubted not but grace was sufficient for him, whereby be might overcome all these, seeing he had the word of Christ for it. 2. Cor. 12.9. And he shevoeth that by this grace we may overcome our corruptions,
but also they do set out Christs grace to have bin more abundant. For they do confess,1 both that the grace of the spirit was plentiful in Christ without measure, and also they hold that there did an outward grace so shine forth in Christ, that all did love him and did perceive that he was beloved of God, this doth Brentius and Bucer, and all our Divines acknowledge.
but also they doe set out Christs grace to haue bin more abundant. For they doe confesse,1 both that the grace of the spirit was plentiful in Christ without measure, and also they hold that there did an outward grace so shine forth in Christ, that all did loue him and did perceiue that he was beloued of God, this doth Brentius and Bucer, and all our Diuines acknowledge.
What thing therefore (say you) is Justice? 1you make answer to your self, a Relation. If you commence an action against us about Aristotle's Predicaments, certainly we fear not, but we shall have a Philosopher gentle enough in this cause. For though Justice bec a Relation, yet Philosophy will not be cashiered: but that it is a quality you can never prove, either out of the Predicaments, or out of the chiefest Philosophy. But your Theological virtues, faith, hope, and charity, had never any injury offered to them by us: indeed they be so handled by you, that you seem to take them not for Theological, but for Philosophical ⟨p. 229⟩virtues. But the cause that maketh us not to hold, that our righteousness is compounded of these virtues, as you would have it, is this, because they are never so perfect in this life, as throughly to satisfy the law of God: now the law must be satisfied or else we cannot be just. For the Lord doth allow no other righteousness, but the very same which is described in the law, which whosoever cannot attain, are pronounced guilty of eternal death. Therefore if we will be righteous and saved, and free from that horrible curse, such a righteousness must be sought out, than which the law cannot require a more absolute. And where shall we find this? Is it in our virtues, in our faith, in our charity? But these are weak many ways, and want that integrity which the law requireth, & whereunto it propoundeth righteousness. For faith is but begun, & we are always to pray that it may be increased in us. Now if faith be weak,3 other virtues which spring from faith, cannot be perfect. But righteousness must be of that kind, as that nothing at all may be added thereunto. From hence it followeth, that righteousness is not compounded of our virtues, as you unfitly speak, but it must be fetched elsewhere. Seeing therefore we had no such virtue, as might obtain righteousness for us with the Lord, Christ was given us by the Lord, who performed perfect obedience to the law, that by his obedience we might be made righteous. For this obedience of Christ imputed to us, and apprehended by faith,4 is that righteousness of ours, which you enquire after, not heaped up with our virtues, as you would have it, but place in Christ, who is made unto us of God, 5wisdom, righteousness, sanctification, and redemption.
What thing therfore (say you) is Iustice? 1you make answere to your selfe, a Relation. If you commence an action against vs about Aristotles Predicaments, certainly we feare not, but we shall haue a Philosopher gentle enough in this cause. For though Iustice bec a Relation, yet Philosophie will not be cashierd: but that it is a quality you can neuer proue, either out of the Predicaments, or out of the chiefest Philosophie. But your Theologicall vertues, faith, hope, and charity, had neuer any iniurie offred to them by vs: indeed they be so handled by you, that you seeme to take them not for Theologicall, but for Philosophicall ⟨p. 229⟩vertues. But the cause that maketh vs not to hold, that our righteousnes is compounded of these vertues, as you would haue it, is this, because they are neuer so perfect in this life, as throughlie to satisfie the law of God: now the law must be satisfied or else we cannot be iust. For the Lord doth allow no other righteousnes, but the very same which is described in the law, which whosoeuer cannot attaine, are pronounced guilty of eternall death. Therfore if we will be righteous and saued, and free from that horrible curse, such a righteousnesse must bee sought out, than which the law cannot require a more absolute. And where shall we find this? Is it in our vertues, in our faith, in our charitie? But these are weake many waies, and want that integrity which the law requireth, & wherunto it propoundeth righteousnes. For faith is but begun, & we are alwaies to pray that it may bee increased in vs. Now if faith be weak,3 other vertues which spring from faith, cannot be perfect. But righteousnesse must be of that kind, as that nothing at all may be added thereunto. From hence it followeth, that righteousnesse is not compounded of our vertues, as you vnfitly speake, but it must be fetcht elsewhere. Seeing therefore wee had no such vertue, as might obtaine righteousnesse for vs with the Lord, Christ was giuen vs by the Lord, who performed perfect obedience to the law, that by his obedience we might be made righteous. For this obedience of Christ imputed to vs, and apprehended by faith,4 is that righteousnes of ours, which you enquire after, not heaped vp with our vertues, as you would haue it, but place in Christ, who is made vnto vs of God, 5wisedome, righteousnesse, sanctification, and redemption.
1Of Justice.Of Iustice.
cDVR. That which is not at all cannot be a real Relation. WHIT. pag. 600. But Christs righteousness is not, not at all. For Christ performed all things which the Law required, therefore was endued with the quality of perfect justice: but that reason which persuadeth us, to confess, that this righteousness of the Law in Christ was a quality, the same compelleth us to think that this righteousness is not a quality inherent in us; for that we never in our own person obeyed the Law. Now what doth let, that that righteousness in Christ cannot be made ours by relation and imputation? for common sense might have taught you this, if a man do pay money in your name, this payment is yours by imputation. If you ask, how that is yours, which is not inherent in you; I say again, which thing the Apostle doth so oft press, it is yours by imputation. Now rub up your Philosophy, if you can, to prove that nothing is made ours by imputation.DVR. That vvhich is not at all cannot bee a reall Relation. WHIT. pag. 600. But Christs righteousnesse is not, not at all. For Christ performed all things vvhich the Lavv required, therefore vvas indued vvith the qualitie of perfect iustice: but that reason which perswadeth vs, to confesse, that this righteousnesse of the Law in Christ was a quality, the same compelleth vs to thinke that this righteousnesse is not a quality inherent in vs; for that vvee neuer in our owne person obeyed the Lavv. Novv vvhat doth let, that that righteousnesse in Christ cannot bee made ours by relation and imputation? for common sense might haue taught you this, if a man do pay money in your name, this payment is yours by imputation. If you aske, how that is yours, vvhich is not inherent in you; I say againe, which thing the Apostle doth so oft presse, it is yours by imputation. Now rub vp your Philosophie, if you can, to proue that nothing is made ours by imputation.
And this is ourd righteousness, even ⟨p. 230⟩Christe himself, whosef righteousness and innocency being ascribed unto us, doth bring assured remission of sins, and true righteousness. This the Divines call the first justice, after which followeth another, compounded of these virtues of yours. For with that remission of sins, which dependeth on Christs obedience, faith, and hope, & charity are joined, which make us just also after a sort, but inchoatively not perfectly.
And this is ourd righteousnes, euen ⟨p. 230⟩Christe himselfe, whosef righteousnes and innocencie being ascribed vnto vs, doth bring assured remission of sinnes, and true righteousnes. This the Diuines cal the first iustice, after which followeth another, compounded of these vertues of yours. For with that remission of sinnes, which dependeth on Christs obedience, faith, and hope, & charity are ioyned, which make vs iust also after a sort, but inchoatiuely not perfectly.
dDVR. The Scripture plainly witnesseth, that as we are made sinners by Adam, so we are made just by Christ. Rom. 5. WHIT. pag. 602. You understand not the Apostle. For though we be just in Christ, as we were sinners in Adam, yet not after the same manner. In Adam we sinned, and had his sin by propagation derived to us: but the justice of Christ, thought it was communicated unto us by imputation, ye […] •as it not so derived unto us. The Apostle would only teach and say this, as Adam was the author of sin, so Christ was the author of righteousness.DVR. The Scripture plainly witnesseth, that as vve are made sinners by Adam, so vve are made iust by Christ. Rom. 5. WHIT. pag. 602. You vnderstand not the Apostle. For though we bee iust in Christ, as we were sinners in Adam, yet not after the same manner. In Adam we sinned, and had his sinne by propagation deriued to vs: but the iustice of Christ, thought it was communicated vnto vs by imputation, ye 〈…〉•as it not so deriued vnto vs. The Apostle would only teach and say this, as Adam was the author of sin, so Christ was the author of righteousnesse.
eDVR. Answer me I pray you, why the Apostles and Christ do so oft exhort us to the obedience of the law? and never bid us apprehend the righteousness of Christ by faith? as Luk. 10. Matth. 25. WHIT. pag. 603. Christ and his Apostles do exhort us to the obedience of the law, not to the end we may deserve everlasting life by our works, but because it is our duty to walk in that race of piety wherein we are placed, that we walking in those good works, and insisting in that way which the Lord hath propounded to us, may come at length to that most happy mark For albeit we never come to a mark unless we go the right way, yet the way is not the cause of the mark. Now whereas you say that we are no where commanded to apprehend Christ righteousness by faith, you bewray your miserable ignorance. Peruse therefore better these famous places for proof of that the Scriptures do command us this. Rom. 4.5. Rom. 5.19. Rom. 1.17. Gal. 2.16. Gal. 3.14. Jon. 3 18. Joh. 5.24. Act. 10.43. As for the cause for which Christ in Matth. 25. saith he vvill make mention of works in the day of judgement, it is for that as James (chap. 2.18.) saith, works do make show & proof of faith. But in that very place vers. 34. before Christ mentioneth those works of the Saints, he toucheth the true and proper causes of salvation. 1. Gods adoption in Christ [Greek or Hebrew] possess by the right of inheritance. For that which one possesseth by the right of inheritance, he doth not deserve it by his merits. 2. The eternal election of God, when he saith that it is a kingdom prepared for them from the foundations of the world. Now if your opinion be this, that God did prepare them this kingdom, because he did foresee their great good works, your own Thomas is an adversary against you. Thom de verit. quast. 6. art. 2. & Thom. 1. part quaest. 23. art 1.DVR. Answere me I pray you, why the Apostles and Christ do so oft exhort vs to the obedience of the law? and neuer bid vs apprehend the righteousnes of Christ by faith? as Luk. 10.
fDVR. Christ is called by S. Paul our righteousness: so in the same place he saith, that he is our wisdom, and our sanctification. WHIT pag. 609. That wisdom, and righteousness, & sanctification, which S. Paul affirmeth Christ to be made unto us, are not resident in us as qualities, nor are they otherwise ours, than as we do embrace and possess whole Christ by faith.DVR. Christ is called by S. Paul our righteousnes: so in the same place hee saith, that he is our vvisdome, and our sanctification. WHIT pag. 609. That vvisdome, and righteousnes, & sanctification, vvhich S. Paul affirmeth Christ to be made vnto vs, are not resi•ent in vs as qualities, nor are they othervvise ours, than as vve doe embrace and possesse vvhole Christ by faith.
I have declared to you in few words our opinion touching righteousness, sith you make inquiry, what it is. But your virtues cannot so clothe the soul round about, as that no naked thing may appear. For all our righteousnesses, are likeg filthy clouts,2⟨p. 231⟩and those not only defiled, but also torn and rent in many pieces.3 Christ himself must be put upon us, that we may be found in him, not having our ownh righteousness which is of the law, but that which is by the faith of Christ; namely the righteousness that is of God through faith. For God was in Christ and reconciled the world unto himself, not imputing their sins to them. With this clothing our souls must be clothed, that they may be beautified and gloriously adorned: neither are we ashamed of that word, upon which you play, when we say that our righteousness is a covering of the fault. For so doth the Prophet David pronounce him to be a blessed man,5 whose iniquities be forgiven, & whose sins are covered. And this pardon we apprehend only by faith: now this faith is not feigned, nor dead, nor separate from other virtues, nor void of good works, but it is of that nature, that it worketh by love. It is therefore faith alone, which justifieth, that is, which embraceth Christs obedience ⟨p. 232⟩wherein our righteousness consisteth; but yet this faith which justifieth, is never alone: for it is ever accompanied with hope, and charity, and doth not suffer it self to be disjoined from it. For as the heat alone of the fire doth set the wood on fire, and yet this heat is not alone, but continually joined with the light: so faith alone of it self doth justify, albeit it can never be quite alone.
I haue declared to you in few words our opinion touching righteousnes, sith you make inquiry, what it is. But your vertues cannot so cloath the soule round about, as that no naked thing may appeare. For all our righteousnesses, are likeg filthie clouts,2⟨p. 231⟩and those not only defiled, but also torne and rent in many peeces.3 Christ himselfe must be put vpon vs, that we may be found in him, not hauing our owneh righteousnes which is of the law, but that which is by the faith of Christ; namely the righteousnes that is of God through faith. For God was in Christ and reconciled the world vnto himselfe, not imputing their sinnes to them. With this cloathing our soules must be cloathed, that they may be beautified and gloriously adorned: neither are wee ashamed of that word, vpon which you play, when we say that our righteousnes is a couering of the fault. For so doth the Prophet Dauid pronoūce him to be a blessed man,5 whose iniquities be forgiuē, & whose sins are couered. And this pardon we apprehēd only by faith: now this faith is not feined, nor dead, nor separate from other vertues, nor void of good workes, but it is of that nature, that it worketh by loue. It is therefore faith alone, which iustifieth, that is, which embraceth Christs obedience ⟨p. 232⟩wherin our righteousnes consisteth; but yet this faith which iustifieth, is neuer alone: for it is euer accompanied with hope, and charity, and doth not suffer it selfe to be disioyned from it. For as the heate alone of the fire doth set the wood on fire, and yet this heate is not alone, but continually ioyned with the light: so faith alone of it self doth iustifie, albeit it can neuer be quite alone.
gDVR. Jf you speak of that justice, which we get to our selves without the help of Christ, you say truly: but if of that which Christ hath purchased for us by his blood, and poured into our harts, you do an intolerable juturie unto Christ. WHIT. pag 610. I speak of that righteousness which every regenerate man hath by the help of Christ. For do you think the Prophet wanted the help of Christ? yet he professeth his righteousness is impure and imperfect: if you think he did speak of their works which are not regenerate, you must deny that he was regenerate, who confesseth the imperfection of his works. Of this righteousness Beruard doth understand it, Serm. 5. de verbis Isay And all the godly have thus confessed of them clues. Psal. 130.3. Dan. 9.7. Ezra. 9.15. Job. 9.3.28. 1. Joh. 1.8. & 1. Joh. 2.7.DVR. Jf you speake of that iustice, vvhich vve get to our selues vvithout the helpe of Christ, you say truly: but if of that which Christ hath purchased for vs by his blood, and powred into our harts, you doe an intollerable iuturie vnto Christ. WHIT. pag 610. I speake of that righteousnes which euerie regenerate man hath by the help of Christ. For do you thinke the Prophet wanted the helpe of Christ? yet he professeth his righteousnes is impure and imperfect: if you thinke hee did speake of their workes which are not regenerate, you must deny that hee was regenerate, who confesseth the imperfection of his workes. Of this righteousnesse Beruard doth vnderstand it, Serm. 5. de verbis Isay And all the godly haue thus confessed of them clues. Psal. 130.3. Dan. 9.7. Ezra. 9.15. Iob. 9.3.28. 1. Ioh. 1.8. & 1. Ioh. 2.7.
Now seeing that all our righteousness and happiness, do consist in the pardon of sins, we also teach that this ought to be most certainly persuaded to us and known of us, so as our souls may rest therein as in a most safe and quiet haven. For being justified by faith, we have peace toward God, through our Lord Jesus Christ. Now what could this peace be, it we were always distracted with a doubtful hope & thoughts, and tossed as it were with waves hither and thither about our salvation? Albeit therefore our consciences are set upon oftentimes by many terrors, so as they cannot be so secure in this life, as if we did already enjoy the endless joy of heaven; yet we say that this faith ought to depend most certainly and strongly upon the promises of God, so as we may expel all doubting about the grace of God, our adoption, and salvation. For true faith cannot agree with unbelief. It is the property of this to distrust Gods promises, but the property of that is to overcome and drive away all doubting; as much as may be. But if faith be full of doubting, wherein doth it go beyond unbelief? let us believe the Apostle, who both knew very well, and hath described exactly the nature of true faith. He propoundeth Abraham unto un, in whom we may behold a most notable image of true faith. What did he? did he stagger? was he in suspense with himself? did he doubt? nay in him all things were contrary:1 he against hope did believe under hope: he was not weak in the faith: he did ⟨p. 233⟩not discourse against the promise of God through unbelief: he was strengthened in the faith: he was fully persuaded, that God which had promised, could perform it. And this faith was imputed to him for righteousness.2 This was Abraham's faith: shall ours be unlike it? but he is our Father, we his children, and children should be like their father. The conclusion is made now against you Campian, that by faith we arei made certain of our salvation, and that your variable and suspicious faith is liker to infidelity than to faith.4kBasil saith excellently: What is the property of faith? a full or certain persuasion void of all doubting. But what mean I to convince you by testimonies of the ancient, whom the very Catechism of Trent doth confute?6 The word belief (saith it) as the holy Scriptures teach, hath the force of most certain consent.
Now seeing that all our righteousnes and happines, do consist in the pardon of sinnes, we also teach that this ought to be most certainly perswaded to vs and knowne of vs, so as our soules may rest therin as in a most safe and quiet hauen. For being iustified by faith, wee haue peace toward God, through our Lord Iesus Christ. Now what could this peace be, it we were alwaies distracted with a doubtful hope & thoughts, and tossed as it were with waues hither and thither about our saluation? Albeit therefore our consciences are set vpon oftentimes by many terrors, so as they cannot be so secure in this life, as if wee did alreadie enioy the endlesse ioy of heauen; yet we say that this faith ought to depend most certainly and strongly vpon the promises of God, so as wee may expell all doubting about the grace of God, our adoption, and saluation. For true faith cannot agree with vnbeliefe. It is the propertie of this to distrust Gods promises, but the property of that is to ouercome and driue away all doubting; as much as may be. But if faith be full of doubting, wherein doth it go beyond vnbeliefe? let vs beleeue the Apostle, who both knew very well, and hath described exactly the nature of true faith. He propoundeth Abraham vnto vn, in whom wee may behold a most notable image of true faith. What did he? did he stagger? was hee in suspense with himselfe? did he doubt? nay in him al things were contrary:1 he against hope did beleeue vnder hope: he was not weake in the faith: hee did ⟨p. 233⟩not discourse against the promise of God through vnbeliefe: he was strengthned in the faith: hee was fully perswaded, that God which had promised, could performe it. And this faith was imputed to him for righteousnes.2 This was Abrahams faith: shal ours bee vnlike it? but he is our Father, wee his children, and children should bee like their father. The conclusion is made now against you Campian, that by faith wee arei made certaine of our saluation, and that your variable and suspicious faith is liker to infidelity than to faith.4kBasil saith excellently: What is the propertie of faith? a full or certaine perswasion void of all doubting. But what meane I to conuince you by testimonies of the auncient, whom the very Catechisme of Trent doth confute?6
iDVR. You can never show out of Gods word, that forgiveness of all sins is given to them, who apprehend the righteousness of Christ by saith. WHIT. pag. 618. This that you deny to be showed in the Scriptures, is most plainly taught in them, as Joh. 3.16. Act. 10.43. Act. 13.39. DVR. But we know not whether we be endued with true faith. WHIT. pag. 620. Indeed it cannot be denied, that many are deceived with a feigned faith: but they who are endued with true faith, they do know that they have true faith: so did Paul 2. Tim. 1.12. know for himself & in 2. Cor. 13.5. he biddeth other learn to know it. So a Christian may know that he hath true faith, & that by the spirit that he hath given us, as 1. Joh. 3.24.DVR. You can neuer shew out of Gods word, that forgiuenes of all sinnes is giuen to them, vvho apprehend the righteousnes of Christ by saith. WHIT. pag. 618. This that you deny to be shewed in the Scriptures, is most plainly taught in them, as Ioh. 3.16. Act. 10.43. Act. 13.39. DVR. But vve know not vvhether vve be endued vvith true faith. WHIT. pag. 620. Indeed it cannot be denied, that many are deceiued with a fained faith: but they who are indued vvith true faith, they do know that they haue true faith: so did Paul 2. Tim. 1.12. know for himself & in 2. Cor. 13.5. he biddeth other learne to know it. So a Christiā may know that he hath true faith, & that by the spirit that he hath giuen vs, as
Wherefore he believeth, to whom any thing is certain and assured without doubting. Now we ⟨p. 234⟩believe everlasting life, therefore it ought to be most certain & assured to us without any doubting. I require now nothing more, the Catechism of the Council of Trent, ratified by the authority of the Pope and Council, teacheth me that a man ought to be certain of his salvation.
Wherefore he beleeueth, to whom any thing is certaine and assured without doubting. Now we ⟨p. 234⟩beleeue euerlasting life, therefore it ought to be most certaine & assured to vs without any doubting. I require now nothing more, the Catechisme of the Councell of Trent, ratified by the authoritie of the Pope and Councell, teacheth me that a man ought to be certaine of his saluation.
But are you not yet quiet, but still question farther, for (say you) how can a man be sure lof his future perseverance? That may be certain, Campian, by faith, which if it be true cannot utterly decay.2 The Apostle termeth faith them ground of things that are hoped for, & the evidence of things that are not seen. Now how are those things extant which be hoped for, or demonstrated which are not seen, if faith be not perpetual? But they which are endued with this faith, they do now after a sort enjoy those good things, which are yet hoped for, & they do contemplate those things, which cannot be seen with mens ⟨p. 235⟩eyes. So that faith admits us being alive here, and as the Apostle saith,4 walking by faith and not by sight, into the very possession of heaven, so as because we aren certain that we shall one day be there, we seem now after a sort to live and converse in heaven. But all these things would be fading and light, if saith could not persevere. Thereforeo Paul had a most certain persuasion, that neither life nor death, nor things present, nor things to come, nor any other creature can separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus. 7But such as do not persevere, they may be separated: but these cannot be separated, therefore they persevere. And for this cause the pledge of our adoption, even the holy Ghost himself is given to us, who assureth us most certainly that we are the sons of God, so as now we do not doubt to call God Father.8 But how dare such a one call him Father, who thinketh that he may be sometime not his son? for the Saints may profess with the Apostle,9 we know that we shall be like him. Knowledge is certain, & consisteth on assured principles: to doubt is the property of opinion, not of knowledge. Hear Cyprian: 10Let such a man fear to die, who not being borne again of water and the spirit, is thrall to the fire. Let him fear to die, that thinketh not he hath his part in Christs Cross and Passion. 11Chrysostom upon these words of the Apostle, Into this grace wherein we stand, writeth thus: The grace of God hath no end, it ⟨p. 236⟩knoweth no full point, but it maketh progress unto greater. And anon after, saith he, we must be fully assured not only of things given, but also of things to be given as well as of things given already. And Augustine:
But are you not yet quiet, but stil question farther, for (say you) how can a man be sure lof his future perseuerance? That may be certaine, Campian, by faith, which if it be true cannot vtterly decay.2 The Apostle termeth faith them ground of things that are hoped for, & the euidence of things that are not seene. Now how are those things extant which bee hoped for, or demonstrated which are not seene, if faith bee not perpetuall? But they which are endued with this faith, they doe now after a sort enioy those good things, which are yet hoped for, & they do contemplate those things, which cannot be seene with mens ⟨p. 235⟩eies. So that faith admits vs being aliue here, and as the Apostle saith,4 walking by faith and not by sight, into the very possession of heauen, so as because vve aren certaine that wee shall one day bee there, wee seeme now after a sort to liue and conuerse in heauen. But all these things would be fading and light, if saith could not perseuere. Thereforeo Paul had a most certaine perswasion, that neither life nor death, nor things present, nor things to come, nor any other creature can seperate vs from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus. 7But such as doe not perseuere, they may be separated: but these cannot bee separated, therefore they perseuere. And for this cause the pledge of our adoption, euen the holy Ghost himselfe is giuen to vs, who assureth vs most certainely that we are the sonnes of God, so as now we do not doubt to call God Father.8 But how dare such a one call him Father, who thinketh that he may be sometime not his sonne? for the Saints may professe with the Apostle,9 we know that we shall bee like him. Knowledge is certaine, & consisteth on assured principles: to doubt is the property of opinion, not of knowledge. Heare Cyprian:
lDVR. Who could ever be certain of his own perseverance to the end, without the peculiar revelation of God? WHIT. pag. 626. In this speech you cut in sunder the sinews of Gods everlasting decree. For seeing Gods predestination is certain and unchangeable, it doth cause our calling, justifying, and glorifying to be as certain as it self. For is it in your power to dissolve and break in sunder that golden chain of the Apostle? Rom. 8.30. and to whom can his own perseverance be doubtful, seeing God testifieth his perpetual good will towards us, as these scriptures fully teach. Jer. 32 40. Joh. 13. 1. Luc 22.32. Job. 17.20.21. Matth. 21.22. Rom. 8.9. Joh. 14.16. Joh. 10.28. Phil. 2.6. Rom. 11.29. 1. Joh. 3.9. Matth. 24.24.DVR. VVho could euer be certaine of his ovvne perseuerance to the end, vvithout the peculiar reuelatiō of God? WHIT. pag. 626. In this speech you cut in sunder the sinevves of Gods euerlasting decree. For seeing Gods predestination is certaine and vnchangeable, it doth cause our calling, iustifying, and glorifying to be as certaine as it selfe. For is it in your povver to dissolue and breake in sunder that golden chaine of the Apostle? Rom. 8.30. and to vvhom can his owne perseuerance be doubtfull, seeing God testifieth his perpetual good wil towards vs, as these scriptures fully teach. Ier. 32 40. Ioh. 13. 1. Luc 22.32. Iob. 17.20.21. Matth. 21.22.
bDVR. But Calvin saith, that when the Devil moveth men to sin, he is rather the instrument of God, than th• author o• sin. Instit. lib. 2. cap. 4. Ser. 5. WHIT pag. 528. This allegation is full of slander. This is Calvins meaning, that albeit the Devil be rather an instrument than the author of the action, yet he is the supreme and chief of the sin in the action.DVR. But Caluin saith, that when the Diuel moueth men to sinne, hee is rather the instrument of God, than th• author o• sinne. Instit. lib. 2. cap. 4. Ser. 5. WHIT pag. 528. This allegation is full of slander. This is Caluins meaning, that albeit the Diuell be rather an instrument than the author of the action, yet hee is the supreme and chiefe of the sinne in the action.
cDVR. But what is more often in the mouth of Calvin & all Calvinists, •hen this, that God doth not only permit but will sin, that he doth move and thrust us forward to sin, nay that be doth by the efficacy of his will impose a necessity of sinning upon us? WHIT. pag. 529. God willeth sin, but not simply, and so far forth as it is sin, but as it is a chastisement, so 1. Pet. 4.19. and God doth stir up and move that sin which lieth hid in us, yet he doth not frame or put sin into us: as the Physician, is not the author of diseases, when he purgeth out the most corrupt humours. And man not endued with the holy Ghost, falleth of his own accord into a necessity of sinning, so as he sinneth, not by any fault of God, but by his own fault.DVR. But what is more often in the mouth of Caluin & all Caluinists, •hen this, that God doth not only permit but will sinne, that he doth moue and thrust vs forward to sinne, nay that be doth by the efficacie of his will impose a necessity of sinning vpon vs? WHIT. pag. 529. God willeth sinne, but not simplie, and so farre forth as it is sinne, but as it is a chastisement, so 1. Pet. 4.19. and God doth stirre vp and moue that sinne which lieth hidde in vs, yet he doth not frame or put sinne into vs: as the Physitian, is not the author of d•seases, when he purgeth out the most corrupt humours. And man not indued with the holy Ghost, falleth of his ovvne accord into a necessity of sinning, so as he sinneth, not by any fault of God, but by his ovvne fault.
But howsoeuer he did hate the name, yet he did loue the thing it selfe as his owne soule.
4Luk. 1.82.
5[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
yet the very power of truth did wring frō him some confession.
••
•
•
••
••
2Nazianz.
3Rabanus, in Catena Thoma.
4Hieronym.
sDVR. Basil saith not, that sin is an accident or a quality, but an affection contrary to virtue. WHIT. pag. 575. Then must it be somewhat, for nothing cannot be contrary to virtue.DVR. Basil saith not, that sin is an accident or a quality, but an affection cōtrary to vertue. WHIT. pag. 575. Then must it be somevvhat, for nothing cannot be contrarie to vertue.
tDVR. Augustine vvill accuse you for slandering him, because he spake not of sin, but of concupiscence, which he accounted to be no sin. WHIT. pag. 576. Doth Augustine account concupiscence no sin? why then calleth he it an affection of an evil quality? why doth he compare it to a disease? why doth he demand the question, how concupiscence should remain in the regenerate, whose sins are all remitted, if it were not a sin? his answer proveth it yet more fully. For he saith, concupiscence is remitted in Baptism, not that it should be no sin at all as you would have it, but that it should not be imputed for a sin. If it were no sin, how could it be imputed for a sin? Finally August. cont. Julian. lib. 5 cap. 3. affirmeth that it is a sin, and a punishment of sin, and a cause of sin, and that in the regenerate. It is manifest in the place, that he speaketh of that concupiscence against which the spirit lusteth, and which in without the consent of the vvill. It at any time he deny it to be a sin, it i• not simply, but in opposition to actual sin; for how should that be nothing, which is remitted in Baptism, which Christ satisfied for by his blood? or is God angry with us for nothing? It must therefore needs be sin.DVR. Augustine vvill accuse you for slandering him, because he spake not of sin, but of concupiscence, vvhich he accounted to be no sinne. WHIT. pag. 576. Doth Augustine account concupiscence no sinne? vvhy then calleth he it an affection of an euill quality? vvhy doth he compare it to a disease? vvhy doth he demaund the question, hovv concupiscence should remaine in the regenerate, vvhose sinnes are all remitted, if it vvere not a sinne? his ansvvere proueth it yet more fully. For he saith, concupiscence is remitted in Baptisme, not that it should be no sinne at all as you vvould haue it, but that it should not be imputed for a sinne. If it vvere no sinne, hovv could it be imputed for a sinne? Finally August. cont. •ulian. lib. 5 cap. 3. affirmeth that it is a sinne, and a punishment of sin, and a cause of sinne, and that in the regenerate. It is manifest in the place, that he speaketh of that concupiscence against vvhich the spirit lusteth, and vvhich in vvithout the consent of the vvill. It at any time he denie it to be a sinne, it i• not simplie, but in opposition to actuall sinne; for hovv should that be nothing, vvhich is remitted in Baptisme, vvhich Christ satisfied for by his blood? or is God angry vvith vs for nothing? It must therfore needs be sin.
uDVR. Ambrose his words refel your error. WHIT. pag. 577. Nay they refel your error. For he saith, it is a straying from good. Now this straying is an action, and not a mere privation. And you your selves earnestly defend that sin is an action. If it be an action, then an accident, then no mere privation, thē not nothing.DVR. Ambrose his vvords refell your error. WHIT. pag. 577. Nay they refell your error. For hee saith, it is a straying from good. Novv this straying is an action, and not a meere priuation. And you your selues earnestly defend that sin is an action. If it be an action, then an accident, then no meere priuation, thē not nothing.
DVR. I know vvell your doctrine of imputatiue iustice, than vvhich I know not whether any man can deuise one thing more against the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 582. Thus you speake, like a Iesuite: but vvhat is there that the Scripture doth more celebrate than imputatiue iustice? Rom. 4.3.4.5.6. is a most cleere text for it. But what? know you not that our sins were imputed to Christ? and why then may not Christs righteousnes be imputed to vs in l•ke manner? Thinke you that Christ had our sinnes really infused into him? I suppose, you will neuer say so: seeing then in the one part you are compelled against your will to confesse an imputation, why do you not also grant it in the other, specially seeing the Apostle himselfe propoundeth vs this Antithesis, 2. Cor. 5.21. Christ vvas made sinne for vs, that we might be made the righteousnes of God in him? Therefore we are so made righteousnes in Christ, as he was made sinne for vs, which must necessarily bee vnderstood of imputation. And ve••ly whereas our iniustice or iniquitie is a debt, and Christ hath payed it, then must it of necessity follow, that, that payment is ours no otherwise then only by imputation. Againe, I pray you, what can bee imagined more absurde, then that the merit• of Saints should be imputed vnto vs, and Christ his righteousnes cannot bee? for they who buy indulgences with money, doe not doubt but to reape much fruit from the merits of others. It then the merits of Saints, as you thinke, can make them more iust, in whom they are not inherent, what an impious and absurd thing were it to giue lesse power of imputation to the merits and righteousnes of Christ? DVR. Charity i• the end of the Law. Rom. 13. For he that loueth his brother hath fulfilled the Lavv. So that if charity be truly in vs, vve haue true iustice: and vvell said Augustine, Charitie begun, is iustice begun; charitie encreased, is iustice encreased; great charity is great iustice; perfect charitie is perfect iustice. WHIT. pag. 583. All is true you say touching charitie. Loue your neighbour as the law requireth, and you haue fulfilled the second Fable: but this you cannot doe; therefore be not brag in the opinion of your charitie, which if it were as great as euer any man had, yet it should be farre short of that the Law requireth, neither can it make you iust. As for Augustine wee confesse as much as hee saith: but this is not the iustice which fre•th vs from the wrath of God, for that neuer increaseth or groweth, but is euer most absolute and perfect, that is Christ his obedience imputed vnto vs by faith. Of charitie August. Epist. 29. writeth thus. As long as charity may be encreased, that verily vvhich is lesse, is faulty: by that vvhich is faulty, there is none iust vpon earth.
yDVR. Why do you not then freely confess that you do place all grace only in the favour of God without us, which favour doth neither amend the wicked, nor purge, nor illuminate, nor enrich them, but only dissemble their old remaining & stinking channel, God winking at it? WHIT. pag. 584. You cease not to trouble us with your ignorance: for doth it follow that we remove all grace from us, because we place justifying grace, which is the mercy of God in Christ, not in us, but in God only? for beside this grace, there is another grace communicated to all the Saints, whereby their souls •re purged and renewed. This consisteth in faith, and in the fruits of faith, which they commonly call Grace infused: therefore that channel of sin doth remain not within them, that have attained true righteousness, as you slander us to teach; but by the power of the holy Ghost it is daily purged out; yet so, that as long as we live there remain some relics of sin & old Adam. For if that channel were so purged, that no blots of sin did remain in us; neither would S. Paul complain of the law of his members, and the body of death, Rom. 7.23.24. Neither should we need the renewing of the spirit, 2. Cor. 4.16.DVR. Why do you not then freely confesse that you doe place all grace only in the fauour of God vvithout vs, vvhich fauour doth neither amend the wicked, nor purge, nor illuminate, nor enrich them, but only dissemble their old remaining & stinking chanell, God winking at it? WHIT. pag. 584. You cease not to trouble vs with your ignorance: for doth it follow that wee remoue all grace from vs, because wee place iustifying grace, which is the mercy of God in Christ, not in vs, but in God only? for beside this grace, there is another grace communicated to all the Saints, wherby their soules •re purged and renewed. This consisteth in faith, and in the fruits of faith, which they cōmonly cal Grace infused: therfore that chanell of sin doth remaine not within them, that haue attained true righteousnes, as you slander vs to teach; but by the power of the holy Ghost it is daily purged out; yet so, that as lōg as we liue there remaine some reliques of sin & old Adam. For if that chanel were so purged, that no blots of sinne did remaine in vs; neither would S. Paul complaine of the law of his members, and the body of death, Rom. 7.23.24. Neither should wee neede the renuing of the spirit, 2. Cor. 4.16.
zDVR. But what place of Scripture doth distinguish justification from sanctification? S. Paul doth not, 1. Cor. 6.11. Rom. 6.13. That also is a strange thing, that faith should justify us and not sanctify us: but more strange that Christ should impute his righteousness to us, that we may be just, and yet not holy and sanctified. WHIT. pag 586. Who can read the Scripture, specially the Epistle to the Romans, and not find these two distinguished? for in the first part of it he treateth of justification, in the latter of sanctification; what is more manifest then that he writeth, Rom 8.30. whom he hath called, those he hath justified; whom he hath justisted, those he hath glorified. Now this glorification signifieth the glorious renovation, which is begun here, and perfected in another life, as your Thomas upon this place hath observed. Again, 1. Cor. 1.30. Is not here justification and sanctification distinguished? justification and sanctification are inseparable, yet must they be distinguished: which because you do not, you place justification in sanctification Your place out of the Epistle to the Corinthians, doth plainly distinguish them. Your second place showeth that a kind of justification is in sanctification: but it is not that perpect justice, by which we are justified before God, but only an imperfect one. As for your wonders and strange things, they come from your ignorance: for we have never separated these two, but affirm that he who is by faith partaker of Christ his righteousness, must needs have the old man crucified, and the body of sin destroyed in him, that he may no longer serve sin.DVR. But vvhat place of Scripture doth distinguish iustification from sanctification? S. Paul doth not, 1. Cor. 6.11. Rom. 6.13. That also is a strange thing, that faith should iustifie vs and not sanctifie vs: but more strange that Christ should impute his righteousnes to vs, that vve may be iust, and yet not holy and sanctified. WHIT. pag 586. Who can reade the Scripture, specially the Epistle to the Romanes, and not find these two distinguished? for in the first part of it he treateth of iustification, in the latter of sanctification; vvhat is more manifest then that he vvriteth, Rom 8.30. vvhom he hath called, those hee hath iustified; vvhom hee hath iustisted, those hee hath glorified. Now this glorification signifieth the glorious renouation, which is begun heere, and perfected in another life, as your Thomas vpon this place hath obserued. Againe, 1. Cor. 1.30. Is not heere iustification and sanctification distinguished? iustification and sanctification are inseparable, yet must they be distinguished: which because you do not, you place iustification in sanctification Your place out of the Epistle to the Corinthes, doth plainly distinguish them. Your second place sheweth that a kind of iustificatiō is in sanctification: but it is not that perpect iustice, by which we are iustified before God, but only an imperfect one. As for your wonde•s and strange things, they come from your ignorance: for we haue neuer sepa•ated these two, but affirme that he who is by faith partaker of Christ his righteou•nes, must needs haue the old man crucified, and the body of sinne destroyed in him, that he may no longer serue sinne.
fulnes we all receiue grace: who of vs did euer deny that there was very great and infinit grace in Christ. For they that say that Christ was so full of grace, that all men did declare that hee was worthy of the vnspeakeable fauour both of God and men, they doe not only hold, that Christ was no otherwise full of grace, but herein that God did very much fauour him;
. he •aith, he did that which he hated. Why did he hate it, unless it were worthy hatred? Now nothing is worthy hatred, but sin. And vers. 19. he addeth, he did the evil, which he would not. Then he sinned: for to be tempted with evil, is not to do that a man would not: but to be tempted and to overcome them, is to do that a man both should and would do. And vers. 23. he saith, he was led captive to the law of sin. How can he be a captive and not be overcome? Believe the Apostle then, and he could not resist sin always by all his grace. But you say his will did not give consent: be it so, yet those motions are sin against the tenth Commandment. For
. he showeth that he speaketh of concupiscence without consent. For lusts with consent, subduing the will, the Philosophers confessed to be sin. For the place you allege
. the sufficiency of Gods grace is but so much, that he should not be swallowed up of temptations. The godly fall often, but God lifteth them up again. For the other place,
. you are deceived by the corrupt Latin translation. For in the Greek it is, I thank God by Jesus Christ: you read it as if asking the question, who should deliver him from the body of death; he had answered himself; The grace of God by Jesus Christ, when he giveth thanks to God, as if he had said; Though this body of death be troublesome unto me, because it compelleth me to serve sin, yet I rest in that hope, which I have placed in Christ.
DVR. S. Paul saith only, that hee vvas assayed and tempted by those motions; but seeing it is not sinne, vvhere the consent of the vvill is not, bee saith, it vvas not hee that did it, but the flesh, for hee doubted not but grace vvas sufficient for him, vvhereby be might ouercome all these, seeing he had the vvord of Christ for it. 2. Cor. 12.9. And he shevoeth that by this grace vvee may ouercome our corruptions, Rom. 7.25. WHIT. pag. 594. But the Apostle sheweth that he was not only tempted by these, but ouercome. Rom. 7.15. he •aith, he did that vvhich he hated. Why did he hate it, vnlesse it were worthie hatred? Now nothing is worthy hatred, but sinne. And vers. 19. he addeth, hee did the euill, vvhich he vvould not. Then he sinned: for to be tempted with euill, is not to do that a man would not: but to be tempted and to ouercome them, is to do that a man both should and would do. And vers. 23. he saith, he was led captiue to the lavv of sinne. How can he be a captiue and not be ouercome? Beleeue the Apostle then, and he could not resist sinne alwaies by all his grace. But you say his will did not giue consent: bee it so, yet those motions are sinne against the tenth Commandement. For Rom. 7.7. he sheweth that he speaketh of concupiscence without consent. For lusts with consent, subduing the will, the Philosophers confessed to be sinne. For the place you alleage 2. Cor. 12.9. the sufficiencie of Gods grace is but so much, that hee should not bee swallowed vp of temptations. The godly fall often, but God lifteth them vp againe. For the other place, Rom. 7.25. you are deceiued by the corrupt Latin translation. For in the Greeke it is, I thanke God by Iesus Christ: you reade it as if asking the question, vvho should deliuer him from the body of death; he had answered himselfe; The grace of God by •esus Christ, when he giueth thankes to God, as if hee had said; Though this body of death be troublesome vnto me, because it compelleth me to serue sin, yet I rest in that hope, which I haue placed in Christ.
5August. de verb. Apost. Serm. 5 & alibi. Gal. 5.17.August. de verb. Apost. Serm. 5 & •libi. Gal. 5.17.
Matth. 25
. WHIT. pag. 603. Christ and his Apostles do exhort vs to the obedience of the law, not to the end wee may deserue euerlasting life by our workes, but because it is our duty to walke in that race of piety wherein vvee are placed, that vvee walking in those good workes, and insisting in that vvay vvhich the Lord hath propounded to vs, may come at length to that most happy mark For albeit we neuer come to a marke vnlesse we goe the right way, yet the way is not the cause of the marke. Novv vvhereas you say that we are no where commanded to apprehend Christ righteousnes by faith, you bewray your miserable ignorance. Peruse therefore better these famous places for proofe of that the Scriptures do commaund vs this.
. saith he vvill make mention of vvorkes in the day of iudgement, it is for that as Iames (chap. 2.18.) saith, works do make shevv & proofe of faith. But in that very place vers. 34. before Christ mentioneth those vvorkes of the Saints, he toucheth the true and proper causes of saluation. 1. Gods adoption in Christ 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 possesse by the right of inheritance. For that which one possesseth by the right of inheritance, hee doth not deserue it by his merits. 2. The eternall election of God, vvhen hee saith that it is a kingdome prepared for thē from the foūdations of the world. Novv if your opinion be this, that God did prepare them this kingdome, because he did foresee their great good vvorkes, your ovvne Thomas is an aduersarie against you. Thom de verit. quast. 6. art. 2. & Thom. 1. part quaest. 23. art 1.
hDVR. Saint Paul calleth the righteousness of the law, that which is gotten by the doctrine of the law without the help of Grace: And the justice of faith, not any apprehended by faith, but because they come unto it by faith. WHIT. pag. 613. In examining the place we shall see of what justice S. Paul speaketh: first he denieth that to be any part of justice, whatsoever he had gloriously done when he was a Pharisee; that though he was then according to the justice of the Law without reproof, & endued with many good qualities, yet he accounted all loffe for Christs sake. vers. 4.5.6.7. And lest any should think that he attributed any thing to his works oftener faith; he addeth that he rejecteth these also, neither ascribed his justification unto them. Adding in the 8. verse. that he accounted all things loss. Not the other, but these also I contemn: and upon this inferreth. vers. 9. Not having my own righteousness, which is of the law▪ but that which is through the faith of Christ. When then he excludeth all kind of works, he must needs understand the justice of Christ.DVR. Saint Paul calleth the righteousnes of the law, that which is gotten by the doctrine of the lavv without the helpe of Grace: And the iustice of faith, not any apprehended by faith, but because they come vnto it by faith. WHIT. pag. 613. In examining the place we shall see of what iustice S. Paul speaketh: first he denieth that to bee any part of iustice, whatsoeuer he had gloriously done when he was a Pharisie; that though he was then according to the iustice of the Law without reproofe, & indued with many good qualities, yet he accounted all loffe for Christs sake. vers. 4.5.6.7. And lest any should thinke that he attributed any thing to his workes ofter faith; he addeth that he reiecteth these also, neither ascribed his iustification vnto them. Adding in the 8. verse. that hee accounted all things losse. Not the other, but these also I contemne: and vpon this inferreth. vers. 9. Not hauing my owne righteousnes, which is of the law▪ but that which is through the faith of Christ. When then he excludeth all kind of workes, hee must needs vnderstand the iustice of Christ.
4Basil. in [Greek or Hebrew].Basil. in 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
kDVR. That which you bring out of Basil and the Tridentime Catechism doth overthrow your self: & what certainty can a man have of his justification, when as S. Paul saith. 1. Cor. 4.4. I know nothing by my self, yet am I not thereby justified. And the like hath Job. cap. 9.15.20. WHIT pag. 622. If they attribute to faith a most certain persuasion without doubting, as they do, do they not confirm our doctrine, that a man may be certain of his salvation. For those temptations which come from the flesh, though they may shake it, yet they cannot overthrow it. As for S. Paul doth he deny himself to be justified, doth he doubt of his salvation? Read the end of the eight to the Romans, and you shall find him so certain of his justification and salvation, as that you Papists are glad to answer, that he had it by an extraordinary revelation of the spirit. And do you now make him doubting of his salvation? But you understand not Saint Paul in the place you allege: for he doth not not deny that he is justified; but he saith that thereby he is not justified, because he knoweth nothing by himself. Job also though he dare not trust to his own works and innocency, yet he showeth himself to be certain of his own salvation. Job 19.26.DVR. That which you bring out of Basil and the Tridentime Catechisme doth ouerthrow your selfe: & what certaintie can a man haue of his iustification, vvhen as S. Paul saith. 1. Cor. 4.4. I knovv nothing by my selfe, yet am I not thereby iustified. And the like hath Iob. cap. 9.15.20. WHIT pag. 622. If they attribute to faith a most certaine persvvasion without doubting, as they do, do they not cōfirme our doctrine, that a man may be certaine of his saluation. For those temptations which come frō the flesh, though they may shake it, yet they cannot ouerthrow it. As for S. Paul doth hee denie himself to be iustified, doth he doubt of his saluatiō? Reade the end of the eight to the Romans, and you shall find him so certaine of his iustification and saluation, as that you Papists are glad to ansvvere, that he had it by an extraordinary reuelation of the spirit. And do you novv make him doubting of his saluation? But you vnderstand not Saint Paul in the place you alleadge: for he doth not not deny that he is iustified; but he saith that thereby he is not iustified, because he knovveth nothing by himselfe. Iob also though he dare not trust to his owne workes and innocency, yet he shevveth himselfe to be certaine of his ovvne saluation. Iob 19.26.
Let such a man feare to die, who not being borne againe of water and the spirit, is thrall to the fire. Let him feare to die, that thinketh not hee hath his part in Christs Crosse and Passion.
Chrysostome vpon these words of the Apostle, Into this grace wherein we stand, writeth thus: The grace of God hath no end, it
⟨p. 236⟩
knoweth no full point, but it maketh progresse vnto greater. And anone after, saith he, we must be fully assured not only of things giuen, but also of things to be giuen as well as of things giuen alreadie. And Augustine:
mDVR. No man ever doubted but that all those things which we believe are most certain. But you ought to show that every ode ought to believe that he shall persevere in that faith to his end, Saint Paul she weth that certain had made shipwreck of faith. 1. Tim. 1.19. WHIT. pag. 627. The question is not whether things believed be certain or no: for that the Devils do certainly know; which is as much as you Papists do believe, by your own confession, and so you confess your selves to be void of true faith But the faith, the Apostle speaketh of, doth not only believe those things are true in themselves, but that they are partakers of them. Therefore he saith, it is the ground of things hoped for, because it enjoyeth those good things which are prepared for another life by a certain & an approved hopes and the evidence of things not seen, because it now beholdeth things that are hid from our eyes. The perseverance then of the faithful is so certain, that they may think they have the possession of those things which they shall receive in another world. Now the faith S. Paul speaketh of, is not a justifying faith, but only true and sound doctrine, of which Hym•naeus and Alexander had made shipwtacke.DVR. No man euer doubted but that all those things which vve beleeue are most certaine. But you ought to shevv that euery ode ought to beleeue that he shall perseuere in that faith to his end, Saint Paul she vveth that certaine had made shipvvracke of faith. 1. Tim. 1.19. WHIT. pag. 627. The question is not vvhether things beleeued be certaine or no: for that the Diuels do certainly knovv; vvhich is as much as you Papists doe beleeue, by your ovvne confession, and so you confesse your selues to bee void of true faith But the faith, the Apostle speaketh of, doth not only beleeue those things are true in themselues, but that they are partakers of them. Therefore he saith, it is the ground of things hoped for, because it enioyeth those good things vvhich are prepared for another life by a certaine & an approued hopes and the euidence of things not seene, because it novv beholdeth things that are hid from our eies. The perseuerance then of the faithfull is so certaine, that they may thinke they haue the possession of those things vvhich they shall receiue in another vvorld. Novv the faith S. Paul speaketh of, is not a iustifying faith, but only true and sound doctrine, of vvhich Hym•naeus and Alexander had made shipvvtacke.
nDVR. 1. Cor. 10. He that standeth let him take heed lest he fall. Phil. 2. work out your salvation which fear:the like. Heb. 4. WHIT. pag. 633. 1. You have falsified, 1. Cor. 10. for Pauls words are, he that thinketh he standeth let him take heed lest he fall. Wherein you go against even your own authentical Latin translation. Blush you not at this? 2. The very Saints themselves are diligently to be admonished, to fly carnal security, to be ware of Sathans assaults, and to be in continual care. And yet this hind•eth not, but that they are in the mean while most certain of their salvation. For although Paul (Act. 27) sailing, did not doubt a whit whether he should come safe to land, yet he let pass nothing, which it behooved a man careful of his safety, to care for and to do.DVR. 1. Cor. 10. He that standeth let him take heed lest he fall. Phil. 2. vvorke out your saluation vvhich feare:the like. Heb. 4. WHIT. pag. 633. 1. You haue falsified, 1. Cor. 10. for Paules vvords are, he that thinketh he standeth let him take heed lest hee fall. Wherein you go against euen your ovvne authenticall Latin translation. Blush you not at this? 2. The very Saints themselues are diligently to be admonished, to flie carnal securitie, to be ware of Sathans assaults, and to be in cōtinual care. And yet this hind•eth not, but that they are in the meane vvhile most certaine of their saluation. For although Paul (Act. 27) sayling, did not doubt a whit whether he should come safe to land, yet he let passe nothing, vvhich it behooued a man carefull of his safetie, to care for and to do.
oDVR Will you say that the Apostle speaketh in the person of all t•e elect. WHIT. pag. 629. The Apostle proveth it, speaking •n their person; what shall separate us (not me only) from the love of Christ. And again, I am persuaded that nothing shall separate us (not me only) from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus. Therefore he speaketh of all those who are predestinated.DVR Will you say that the Apostle speaketh in the person of all t•e elect. WHIT. pag. 629. The Apostle proueth it, speaking •n their person; vvhat shall separate vs (not me only) from the loue of Christ. And againe, I am persvvaded that nothing shall separate vs (not me only) from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus. Therefore he speaketh of all those vvho are predestinated.