No. The Prophet speaks concisely, the better to express the stubborn behaviour of this people; in saying, the thing is desperate: it is all one as if they had cast all admonitions and exhortations far away from them: he afterwards adds; he will do nothing. There is no verb in the Hebrew: but this cutted manner of speech hath more efficacy in it (as I have said) and doth more fully set forth the peoples pride and rebellion. Isaiah on the contrary complains of them, in chap. 57.10. for not saying, It is done, there is no more hope: and thus it seems that Isaiah and Jeremiah should contradict one another: for Jeremiah here reproves the people for saying, there is no hope; Object. and Isaiah, because they said it not. Answ. But the Jews in answering here thus cuttedly, The thing is desperate; meant to say, the Prophets do but loose their labour, in regard they purposed to prosecute that which they had taken in hand, to the uttermost. These words therefore,1 the thing is desperate, shows what a desperate rebellion there was in the people: for they give us to understand, that they could never be reclaimed; and therefore plainly, and without many circumlocutions avouch, The thing is desperate. But Isaiah reproves the people, because they said not, There is no hope: that is, in regard that by long experience, their folly was not convinced. For having often trotted down into Egypt, and then into Assyria, God gave them to understand, by their own experience, how unadvised they were. They might well have concluded then by the things they had seen, that God disappointed them of their hope, to bring them to a change of their purposes. Isaiah therefore rightly saith, that the Jews were grown too sottish, because they never ceased to follow their blind obstinacy; and yet perceived not that God (as you would say) had set bars and obstacles in their way, thereby causing them to change their course, to recoil back, and to forsake those vain hopes wherewith they had been seduced. Now we see then what a ⟨p. 108⟩good agreement there is between these two Prophets; albeit their manners of speaking be divers. Jeremiah brings in the Jews here speaking thus cuttedly, to set forth their obstinacy; There is no hope: that is to say, O ye Prophets, ye cease not still to dull our ears with your admonitions, but it is to no purpose:
No. The Prophet speakes concisely, the better to expresse the stubborne behauiour of this people; in saying, the thing is desperate: it is all one as if they had cast all admonitions and exhortations farre away from them: he afterwards adds; he will doe nothing. There is no verbe in the Hebrew: but this cutted manner of speech hath more efficacy in it (as I haue said) and doth more fully set forth the peoples pride and rebellion. Isaiah on the contrary complaines of them, in chap. 57.10. for not saying, It is done, there is no more hope: and thus it seemes that Isaiah and Ieremiah should contradict one another: for Ieremiah heere reprooues the people for saying, there is no hope; Obiect. and Isaiab, because they said it not. Answ. But the Iewes in answering here thus cuttedly, The thing is desperate; meant to say, the Prophets doe but loose their labour, in regard they purposed to prosecute that which they had taken in hand, to the vttermost. These words therefore,1 the thing is desperate, shewes what a desperate rebellion there was in the people: for they giue vs to vnderstand, that they could neuer be reclaimed; and therfore plainly, and without many circumlocutions auouch, The thing is desperate. But Isaiah reprooues the people, because they said not, There is no hope: that is, in regard that by long experience, their folly was not conuinced. For hauing often trotted downe into Egypt, and then into Assyria, God gaue them to vnderstand, by their owne experience, how vnaduised they were. They might well haue concluded then by the things they had seene, that God disappointed them of their hope, to bring them to a change of their purposes. Isaiah therefore rightly saith, that the Iewes were growne too sottish, because they neuer ceased to follow their blind obstinacy; and yet perceiued not that God (as you would say) had set barres and obstacles in their way, thereby causing them to change their course, to recoyle backe, and to forsake those vaine hopes wherwith they had been seduced. Now wee see then what a ⟨p. 108⟩good agreement there is betweene these two Prophets; albeit their manners of speaking bee diuers. Ieremiah brings in the Iewes heere speaking thus cuttedly, to set forth their obstinacy; There is no hope: that is to say, O ye Prophets, ye cease not still to dull our eares with your admonitions, but it is to no purpose:
- 1How Jeremiah and Jsaiah may be reconciled touching their divers manner of speaking.How Ieremiah and Jsaiah may be reconciled touching their diuers manner of speaking.