pp. 173–19573 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
AS though M. Doctor were at utter defiance with all good order / & Method of writing / that which was given him orderly by the Admonition / he hath turned upside down. For where the Admonition speaketh first of the elders / then of that which is annexed unto them / which is the discipline (whereof excommunication is a part) considering that the subject is in nature before that which is annexed unto it / M. Doctor hath turned it clean contrary / and first speaketh of excommunication / and then of the elders. I will therefore that the reader may the easelyer understand that which is said / follow the order of the Admonition / and first of all speak of the elders or seniors which ought to be in the church. And in speaking of them / I must call to remembrance that division which I made mention on before / that is: Of those which have care and which govern the whole congregation / some there be which do both teach the word and govern also: some which do not teach / but only govern / and be aiders in the government / unto those which do teach. This division is most manifestly set forth in the Epistle unto Timothy: where he sayeth the elders 1which rule well / are worthy of double honour / and especially those which labour in the word and doctrine / where he maketh by plain and express words two sorts of elders / the one which doth both govern and teach: the other which governeth only. These therefore are the seniors which are meant / whose office is in helping the pastor or bishop / in the government of that particular church / where they be placed pastors and elders. Now that it is known what these seniors be / in entreating of them I am content to answer M. Doctor three requests which he maketh in the. 125. page / where he desireth that one would do so much for him / as first to show that these seniors were in every congregation: secondarily he will have it proved that this regiment is perpetual / and not to be altered: last of all he desireth to know / whether these seniors were lay men / and not rather ministers of the word and bishops. This last is a fond request / and such ⟨p. 174⟩as is already answered / but he must be followed. For the first therefore / which is / that there were seigniors in every congregation / although M. Doctor in the 114. page / and in the. 132.
AS though M. Doctor were at vtter defiance with all good order / & Methode of wryting / that which was geuen hym orderly by the Admonition / he hath turned vpsyde downe. For where the Admonition speaketh first of the elders / then of that which is annexed vnto them / which is the dyscipline (whereof excommunication is a part) consydering that the subiect is in nature before that which is annexed vnto it / M. Doctor hath turned it cleane contrary / and first speaketh of excommunication / and then of the elders. I will therefore that the reader may the easelyer vnderstand that which is sayde / follow the order of the Admonition / and first of all speake of the elders or senyors which ought to be in the church. And in speaking of them / I must call to remembrance that diuision which I made mention on before / that is: Of those which haue care and which gouerne the whole congregation / some there be which do both teache the word and gouerne also: some which doe not teach / but only gouerne / and be ayders in the gouernment / vnto those which doe teache. Thys dyuision is most manifestly set forth in the Epistle vnto Timothe: where he sayeth the elders 1which rule well / are worthy of double honor / and especially those which labor in the word and doctryne / where he maketh by playne and expresse words two sorts of elders / the one which doth both gouerne and teach: the other which gouerneth only. These therefore are the senyors which are meant / whose office is in helping the pastor or byshop / in the gouernement of that particulare church / where they be placed pastors and elders. Now that it is knowne what these senyors be / in entreating of them I am content to answere M. Doctor three requestes which he maketh in the. 125. page / where he desireth that one would do so much for hym / as first to shew that these senyors were in euery congregation: secondarely he will haue it proued that thys regiment is perpetual / and not to be altered: last of all he desireth to know / whether these senyors were lay men / and not rather mynisters of the word and byshops. Thys last is a fond request / and suche ⟨p. 174⟩as is alredy answeared / but he must be followed. For the first therefore / which is / that there were segnyors in euery congregation / although M. Doctor in the 114. page / and in the. 132.
page / constrained / by Ambrose authority / confesseth it in plain words / yet because he requireth it to be showed / and maketh a jest at those places which are alleged out of the scripture to prove it / some thing must be spoken thereof. The first place is in the Acts / which is / that Paul & Barnabas did appoint by election / elders in every congregation / but it is not like they did appoint divers ministers or bishops / which preached in every congregation / which were not to be had for such a number of congregations as were 1then to be preached unto: therefore in every congregation there were besides those that preached / other elders which did only in government assist the pastors which preached. And what should we follow conjectures here / when S. Paul doth in the place before alleged declare / what these elders are. But M. Doctor 2sayeth that there is no mention made of the office of such an elder: therefore that place maketh nothing to prove that there should be such elders in every congregation. So M. Doctor write / he careth not what he write. Belike he thinketh the credit of his degree of Doctorship / will give weight to that which is light / and pith to that which is froth / or else he would never answer thus. For then I will if this be a good reason say / that for so much as S. Luke doth not in that 3place describe the office of the pastor or bishop which preacheth the word / therefore that place proveth not that in every congregation there should be a bishop or a pastor. Besides that / M. Doctor taketh up the authors of the Admonition for reasoning negatively of the testimony of all the scriptures / and yet he reasoneth negatively of one only sentence in the scripture. For he would conclude that for so much as there is no duty of a senior described in that place / therefore there is no duty at all / and consequently no senior.
page / constrayned / by Ambose authoritie / confesseth it in playne wordes / yet because he requireth it to be shewed / and maketh a iest at those places which are alledged out of the scripture to proue it / some thing muste be spoken thereof. The first place is in the Actes / whych is / that Paule & Barnabas dyd appoynte by election / elders in euerie congregation / but it is not lyke they dyd appoynt dyuers ministers or bishops / which preached in euery congregation / which were not to be had for suche a number of congregations as were
Afterwards he sayeth / that for so much as this place hath been used to prove a pastor or bishop in every church / therefore it can not be used to prove these elders / so that (sayeth he) there must needs be either a contradiction or else a falsification. The place is rightly alleged for both the one and the other / and yet neither contradiction to them selves / nor falsification of the place: but only a must before M. Doctors eyes / which will not let him see a plain and evident truth / which is / that the word (elder) is general / and comprehendeth both those elders which teach and govern / and those which govern only / as hath been showed out of S. Paul. And whereas M. Doctor sayeth / that the place of the Corinthians 1may be understanded of civil magistrates / of preaching ministers / of governors of the whole church / and not of every particular church / and finally any thing / rather then that whereof it is in deed understanded: I say first that he still stumbleth at one stone / which is / that he can not put a difference between the church and common wealth: and so between the church officers which he there speaketh of / and the officers of the common wealth / those which are ecclesiastical: and those which are civil. Then that he meaneth not the minister which preacheth / it may appear / for that he had noted them before in the word (teachers) and last of all he can not mean governor of the whole church / onles he should mean a Pope / and if he will say he meaneth an Archbishop which governeth a whole province / besides that it is a bold speech without all warrant / I have showed before that the word of God alloweth of no such office / and therefore it remaineth that it must be understanded of this office of Elders. The same answer may be made unto that which he sayeth of the place to the Romans / where speaking of the offices of the church / after that he had set forth 2the office of the pastor / and of the doctor / he addeth those other two offices of the Church / whereof one was occupied in the government only / the other in providing for the poor / and helping the sick. And if besides the manifest words ⟨p. 175⟩of the Apostle in both these places / I should add the sentences of the writers upon those places / as M. Calvin / M. Beza / M. Martyr / M. Bucer. &c. It should easily appear / what just cause M.
Doctor hath to say / that it is to daily with the scriptures / and to make them a nose of wax / in alleging of these to prove the elders / that all men might understand / what terrible outcries he maketh / as in this place / so almost in all other / when there is cause / that he should lay his hand upon his mouth.
Doctor hath to say / that it is to daily with the scriptures / and to make them a nose of waxe / in alledging of these to proue the elders / that all men might vnderstand / what terrible outcryes he maketh / as in thys place / so almost in all other / when there is cause / that he shoulde lay hys hand vpon hys mouth.
This I am compelled to write / not so much to prove that there were seniors in every church (which is a thing confessed) as to redeem those places from M. Doctors false and corrupt interpretations. And as for the proof of elders in every congregation / besides his confession / I need have no more but his own reason: For he sayeth that the office of these elders in every church / was in that time wherein there were no christian magistrates / and when there was persecution / but in the Apostles times there was both persecution / and no christian magistrates / therefore in their time the office of these elders was in every congregation. I come therefore to the second point wherein the question especially lieth / which is / whether this function be perpetual / and ought to remain always in the church. And it is to be observed by the way / that where as there are divers sorts of adversaries to this discipline of the church / Master Doctor is amongst the worst. For there be that say / that this order may be used or not used now / at the liberty of the churches: But M. Doctor sayeth that this order is not for these times / but only for those times when there were no christian magistrates / and so doth flatly pinch at those churches which having christian magistrates / yet notwithstanding retain this order still.
Thys I am compelled to wryte / not so much to proue that there were senyors in euery church (which is a thing confessed) as to redeame those places from M. Doctors false and corrupt interpretations. And as for the proufe of elders in euery congregation / besydes hys confession / I neede haue no more but hys owne reason: For he sayeth that the office of these elders in euery church / was in that tyme wherein there were no christian magistrates / and when there was persecution / but in the Apostles tymes there was both persecution / and no christian magistrates / therefore in theyr tyme the office of these elders was in euery congregation. I come therefore to the second poynt wherein the question especially lyeth / which is / whether thys function be perpetuall / and ought to remayne alwayes in the churche. And it is to be obserued by the way / that where as there are dyuers sortes of aduersaryes to thys disciplyne of the church / Maister Doctor is amongst the worst. For there be that saye / that thys order may be vsed or not vsed now / at the lybertie of the churches: But M. Doctor sayeth that thys order is not for these tymes / but only for those tymes when there were no christian magistrates / and so doth flatly pinch at those churches which hauing christian magistrates / yet notwithstanding retayne thys order still.
And to the end that the vanity of this distinction / which is / that there ought to be seniors or ancients in the times of persecution / and not of peace: under tyrants and not under christian magistrates may appear: the cause why these seniors or ancients were appointed in the church / is to be considered / which must needs be granted to be / for that the pastor not being able to oversee all him self / and to have his eyes in every corner of the church / and places where the churches abode / might be helped of the ancients. Wherein the wonderful love of God towards his church doth manifestly appear / that for the greater assurance of the salvation of his / did not content him self to appoint one only overseer of every church / but many over every church.
And to the ende that the vanitie of thys distinction / which is / that there oughte to bee senyors or auncientes in the tymes of persecution / and not of peace: vnder tyrantes and not vnder christian magistrates may appeare: the cause why these senyors or auncientes were appoynted in the church / is to bee consydered / which must needes be graunted to bee / for that the pastor not being able to ouersee all hym selfe / and to haue hys eyes in euery corner of the church / and places where the churches aboade / might be helped of the auncientes. Wherin the wonderfull loue of God towards hys church doth manifestly appeare / that for the greater assurance of the saluation of hys / dyd not content hym selfe to appoynt one only ouerseer of euery church / but many ouer euery church.
And therefore seeing that the pastor is now in the time of peace / and under a christian magistrate not able to oversee all him self / nor his eyes can not be in every place of the parish present to behold the behaviour of the people / it followeth that as well now as in the time of persecution / as well under a christian prince as under a tyrant / the office of an ancient or seignior is required. Onles you will say that God hath less care of his church in the time of peace and under a godly magistrate / then he hath in the time of persecution / and under a tyrant. In deed if so be the ancients in the time of persecution and under a tyrant / had meddled with any office of a magistrate / or had supplied the room of a godly magistrate / in handling of any of those things which belonged unto him / then there had been some cause why a godly magistrate being in the church / the office of the senior / or at least so much as he exercised of the office of a magistrate / should have ceased.
And therefore seeing that the pastor is now in the tyme of peace / and vnder a christian magistrate not able to ouersee all hym selfe / nor hys eyes can not bee in euery place of the paryshe present to beholde the behauiour of the people / it followeth that as well now as in the tyme of persecution / as well vnder a christian prince as vnder a tyrant / the office of an auncient or seignior is required. Onles you will say that God hath lesse care of hys church in the time of peace and vnder a godly magistrate / then he hath in the tyme of persecution / and vnder a tyrant. In deede if so bee the auncientes in the tyme of persecution and vnder a tyrant / had medled with any office of a magistrate / or had supplyed the roume of a godly magistrate / in handling of any of those things which belonged vnto hym / then there had bene some cause why a godly magistrate being in the church / the office of the senior / or at least so much as he exercised of the office of a magistrate / shuld haue ceased.
But when as the ancient neither did / nor by any means might meddle with those things which belonged unto a magistrate / no more under a tyrant than under a godly magistrate / there is no reason why the magistrate entering into the church / the elder should be therefore thrust out. For the elders office was to admonish severally / those that did amiss / to comfort those which he saw weak & shaking / and to have need of comfort / to assist the pastor in ecclesiastical censures of ⟨p. 176⟩reprehensions / sharper or milder as the faults required / also to assist in the suspē scions from the supper of the Lord until some trial were had of the repentance of that party which had confessed him self to have offended / or else if he remained stubborn / to assist him in the excommunication. These were those things / which the elders did / which forsomuch as they may do as well under a christian magistrate / as under a tyrant / as well in the time of peace as in the time of persecution / it followeth that as touching the office of elders / there is no distinction in the times of peace and persecution / of a christian prince and of a tyrant. But I will yet come nearer. That without the which / the principal offices of charity can not be exercised / is necessary and always to be kept in the church. But the office of ancients & elders are such as with out which the principal offices of charity can not be exercised / therefore it followeth that this office is necessary. That the principal offices of charity can not be exercised without this order of ancients / it may appear for that he which hath faulted / and amendeth not after he be admonished once privately / and then before one witness or two / can not further be proceeded against / according to the commandment of our saviour Christ / onlesse there be in the church / ancients and elders / therefore this principal office of charity / which tendeth to the amendment of him which hath not profited by those two former admonitions / can not be exercised without them. For it is commanded of our saviour Christ / that in such a case when a brother doth not profit by these 1two warnings / it should be told the church.
But when as the auncient neither dyd / nor by any meanes might meddle with those things which belonged vnto a magistrate / no more vnder a tyrant thē vnder a godly magistrate / there is no reason why the magistrate entring into the church / the elder shuld be therfore thrust out. For the elders office was to admonish seuerally / those that dyd amisse / to comfort those which he saw weake & shaking / and to haue neede of comfort / to assist the pastor in ecclesiasticall censures of
Now I would ask who be meant by the church here / if he say by the church are meant all the people / then I will ask how a man can conveniently complain to all the whole congregation / or how can the whole congregation conveniently meet to decide of this matter. I do not deny / but the people have an interest in the excommunication / as shall be noted hereafter / but the matter is not so far come / for he must first refuse to obey the admonition of the church / or ever they can proceed so far. Well / if it be not the people that be meant by the church / who is it? I hear M. Doctor say it is the pastor / but if he will say so / and speak so strangely / he must warrant it with some other places of scripture where the church is taken for one / which is as much to say as one man is many / one member is a body / one alone is a company. And besides this strangeness of speech / it is clean contrary to the meaning of our saviour Christ / and destroyeth the sovereignty of the medicine which our saviour Christ prepared for such a festered sore / as would neither be healed with private admonition / neither with admonition before one or two witnesses. For as the fault groweth / so our saviour Christ would have the number of those before whom he should be checked and rebuked / likewise grow. Therefore from a private admonition he riseth unto the admonition before two or three / & from them to the church / which if we should say it is but one / then to a daungerouser wound should be laid an easier plaster: and therefore our saviour doth not rise from two to one / (for that were not to rise but to fall / nor to proceed but to go backward (but to many. Seeing then that the church here is neither the whole congregation / nor the pastor alone / it followeth that by the church here he meaneth the pastor / with the ancients or elders. Or else whom can he mean? And as for this manner of speech / wherein by the church is understanded the chief governors and elders of the church / it is oftentimes used in the old Testament / from the which our saviour borrowed this manner of speaking / as in Exodus it is said. That Moses wrought his miracles before the people / when mention is 1made before / only of the elders of the people / whom Moses had called together.
Now I would aske who be meant by the church heere / if he say by the church are meant all the people / then I will aske how a man can conueniently complayne to all the whole congregation / or how can the whole congregation conueniently meete to decide of thys matter. I doe not deny / but the people haue an interest in the excommunication / as shall be noted heereafter / but the matter is not so farre come / for hee must first refuse to obey the admonition of the church / or euer they can proceede so farre. Well / if it be not the people that be meant by the church / who is it? I heare M. Doctor say it is the pastor / but if he will say so / and speake so straungely / he must warrant it wyth some other places of scripture where the church is taken for one / which is as much to say as one man is many / one member is a body / one alone is a company. And besydes thys strangenes of speach / it is cleane contrary to the meaning of our sauiour Christ / and destroyeth the soueraignitie of the medycine which our sauiour Christ prepared for such a festered sore / as would neyther be healed with priuate admonition / neyther with admonition before one or two witnesses. For as the fault groweth / so our sauiour Christ woulde haue the number of those before whome he shoulde be checked and rebuked / lykewise grow. Therefore from a priuate admonition he ryseth vnto the admonition before two or three / & from them to the church / which if we should say it is but one / then to a daungerouser wound should be layde an easier plaister: and therefore our sauiour doth not ryse from two to one / (for that were not to ryse but to fall / nor to proceede but to goe backward (but to many. Seeing then that the church heere is neyther the whole congregation / nor the pastor alone / it followeth that by the church here he meaneth the pastor / with the auncients or elders. Or else whome can he meane? And as for thys manner of speach / wherein by the church is vnderstanded the cheefe gouernours and elders of the church / it is oftentymes vsed in the olde Testament / from the which our sauiour borowed thys maner of speaking / as in Exodus it is sayde. That Moses wrought hys myracles before the people / when mention is
And most manifestly in * Joshua / where it is said / that he that killed a man at 1unawares / shall return unto the city until he stand before the congregation to be judged. Where by the congregation / he meaneth the governors of the congregation / for it did not appertain to all to judge of this case. Likewise in the ⟨p. 177⟩Chronicles / and divers other places. And therefore I conclude that forsomuch 2as those be necessary and perpetual which are spoken of in those words (tell the Church) and that under those words are comprehended the elders or ancients / that the elders and ancients be necessary and perpetual officers in the church. Furthermore S. Paul having entreated throughout the whole first Epistle to Timothy / of the orders which ought to be in the church of God / and of the government / as him self witnesseth in the third chapter of that Epistle (when he sayeth he wrote that Epistle to teach Timothy how he should behave him self in the house of God) and having set forth both bishop / and elder / and deacons / as ministers and officers of the church / in the shutting up of his Epistle he (for the observation of all the orders of that Epistle) adjureth Timothy / and 3with the invocation of the name of God straitly chargeth him / to observe those things which he had prescribed in that Epistle. I charge thee (sayeth he) before God which quickeneth all things / and before Jesus Christ which witnessed under Pontius Pilate a good profession that thou keep this commandment without spot or blemish / until the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ. The weight of which sentence for the observing of those things which are mentioned in this Epistle / that it may be the better understanded / I will note the words severally.
And most manifestly in * Iosue / where it is sayde / that he that kylled a man at 1vnwares / shall returne vnto the citie vntill he stand before the congregration to be iudged. Where by the congregation / he meaneth the gouernoures of the congregation / for it dyd not appertayne to all to iudge of thys case. Lykewyse in the ⟨p. 177⟩
First therefore it is to be noted that he sayeth (I denounce or I charge.) He doth not say (I exhort or give counsel) leaving it to the liberty of Timothy.
First therefore it is to be noted that he sayeth (I denounce or I charge.) He doth not say (I exhorte or giue counsell) leauing it to the lyberty of Timothe.
Secondarily it is to be noted / that he calleth the whole Epistle a commandment / and therefore it is no permission / so that it may be lawful for the churches to leave it / or to keep it.
Secondarely it is to be noted / that he calleth the whole Epistle a commaū dement / and therefore it is no permission / so that it may be lawfull for the churches to leaue it / or to keepe it.
Thirdly / when he maketh mention of the living God / and of Christ / which witnessed a good profession under Pontius Pilate / he showeth that the things contained in this Epistle are such / as for the maintenance thereof we ought not to doubt to give our lives / and that they be not such as we ought to keep / so that we have them without strife and without sweat / or easily / but such as for the keeping of them if we have them / and for the obtaining of them if we have them not (I will not say our honours / or our commodities and wealth / but as I have said) our lives ought not to be dear unto us. For therefore doth he make mention of the confession of Christ unto the death / that he might show us an example / and forthwith speaketh of God / which raiseth from the dead / that by this means he might comfort Timothy if he should be brought into any trouble for the defence of any of these things.
Thirdly / when he maketh mention of the lyuing God / and of Christ / which witnessed a good profession vnder Pontius Pilate / he sheweth that the thinges contayned in thys Epistle are such / as for the mayntenaunce thereof wee ought not to doubt to geue our lyues / and that they be not such as we ought to kepe / so that we haue them without strife and without sweate / or easely / but such as for the keeping of them if we haue them / and for the obtayning of them if we haue them not (I will not say our honoures / or our commodities and wealth / but as I haue sayd) our lyues ought not to be deare vnto vs. For therefore doth hee make mention of the confession of Christ vnto the death / that he might shew vs an example / and forthwith speaketh of God / which rayseth from the dead / that by thys meanes he might comfort Timothe if he should be brought into any trouble for the defence of any of these things.
Fourthly / if we refer those words without spot or blemish unto the commandment (as I for my part think they ought to be) then there is a weight in these words not to be passed over / which is / that the apostle will not only have the rules here contained / not trodden under the feet / or broken in pieces / but he will not have them so much as in any one small point or speck neglected. But I see how M. Doctor will wipe away all this / and say that these things / or some of them were to be observed thus necessarily and precisely / until there were christian princes and peace in the church: but the print is deeper then that it will be so washed away. Therefore it is to be observed / what he sayeth in the latter end of the sentence / where he chargeth Timothy / and in him all / that he should keep all these things / not until the time of peace / or to the times of Christian Princes / but even until the coming or appearing of our saviour Christ / which is as long as the world lasteth. And therefore I conclude that the seigniors or elders of the church (being a part of that order and government of the church / which S. Paul appointeth in this Epistle) are necessary / perpetual / and by no means to be changed. So that we have / not only now the examples of all the primitive churches (which ought to move us / if there were no commandment) but ⟨p. 178⟩we have also a straight commandment: I say the only examples ought to move us / for what way can we safelyer follow / then the common high way / beaten and trodden by the steps of all the Apostles / and of all the churches? Things also growing / and being preserved by the same means by the which they were engendered / why should we think but that the churches now will prosper by that government / whereby it first came up? But I say we have not only the examples of the churches / but we have also commandment and straight charge to keep this office of elders and ancients in the church / and therefore it is not only rashness in leaving the way that the Apostles and churches by the Apostles advise have gone / but disobedience also to depart from their commandment / and to maintain and defend that we may do so / I can almost give it no gentler name then rebellion.
Fourthly / if we refer those wordes without spot or blemish vnto the commaundement (as I for my part thinke they ought to be) then there is a waight in these words not to be passed ouer / which is / yt the apostle will not only haue the rules heere contayned / not troden vnder the feete / or broken in peeces / but hee will not haue them so much as in any one small poynt or specke neglected. But I see how M. Doctor will wype away all thys / and say that these thinges / or some of them were to bee obserued thus necessarily and precisely / vntill there were christian prynces and peace in the churche: but the print is deeper then that it will bee so washed away. Therefore it is to be obserued / what he sayeth in the latter end of the sentence / where he chargeth Timothe / and in hym all / that hee should keepe all these things / not vntill the tyme of peace / or to the times of Christian Princes / but euen vntill the comming or appearing of our sauiour Christ / which is as long as the world lasteth. And therfore I conclude that the seigniors or elders of the church (being a part of that order and gouernment of the church / which S. Paule appoynteth in thys Epistle) are necessary / perpetuall / and by no meanes to be changed. So that we haue / not only now the examples of all the primitiue churches (which ought to moue vs / if there were no commaundement) but
Now I will come to Master Doctors reasons which he hath in the hundred and fourteen / and a hundred and fifteen pages / where he granteth that there were elders in every church in times past / but saith that it ought not now so to be. For sayeth he / the times alter the government / and it can not be governed in the time of prosperity / as in the time of persecution / under a christian prince as under a tyrant. Thus he sayeth / but showeth no reason / bringeth no proof / declareth not how nor why prosperity will not bear the Elders as well as persecution / neither why they may not be under a godly prince as well as under a tyrant / onles this be a reason / that because the godly prince doth nourish the church as a civil magistrate / therefore the ancients may not nourish it as Ecclesiastical overseers.
Now I will come to Mayster Doctors reasons which he hath in the hundreth and fourteene / and a hundred and fifteene pages / where he graunteth that there were elders in euery church in tymes past / but sayth that it ought not now so to bee. For sayeth hee / the tymes alter the gouernment / and it can not be gouerned in the tyme of prosperitie / as in the tyme of persecution / vnder a christian prince as vnder a tyrant. Thus he sayeth / but sheweth no reason / bringeth no proofe / declareth not how nor why prosperity will not beare the Elders as well as persecution / neyther why they may not be vnder a godly prince as well as vnder a tyrant / onles thys be a reason / that because the godly prince doth nourishe the church as a cyuill magistrate / therefore the auncientes may not nourish it as Ecclesiasticall ouerseers.
Now seeing Master Doctor can show us no cause why they may not as well be now / as in the time of the Apostles / as well under a christian prince as under a tyrant / I will show him that although they be always necessary / yet there is better cause why they should rather be now then in the apostles times / greater necessity under a christian prince / then under a tyrant. First of all in the apostles times it is known that the gifts of the spirit of wisdom / discretion / knowledge / enduring of travail / were poured forth more plentifully then ever they were / either before / or shall be after. By reason whereof the pastors and ministers of the churches that were then / were (I speak generally / and of the estate of the whole Church) better furnished with the gifts needful for their ministry / then are the ministers of these days. Whereupon I conclude that if the aid and assistance of the pastor by the Elders / was thought necessary by the apostles in those times / when the ministers were so well / and so richly replenished with such gifts / much more is that aid and assistance meet for the ministers of these days / wherein their gifts of discretion and knowledge / and diligence / are not so plentiful. For if they whose eye sight was so clear to perceive / whose hands so nimble to execute / had need for their aid / of other eyes & other hands / then the ministers now / whose eyes are dimmer / and hands heavier then theirs were / have much more need of this aid then they had.
Now seeing Maister Doctor can shew vs no cause why they may not as well be now / as in the tyme of the Apostles / as well vnder a christian prince as vnder a tyrant / I will shew hym that although they be alwayes necessary / yet there is better cause why they should rather be now then in the apostles times / greater necessyty vnder a christian prince / then vnder a tyrant. First of all in the apostles tymes it is knowne that the giftes of the spirite of wisedome / discretion / knowledge / enduring of trauaile / were poured forth more plentifully then euer they were / eyther before / or shall be after. By reason whereof the pastoures and mynisters of the churches that were then / were (I speake generally / and of the estate of the whole Church) better furnyshed with the giftes needefull for their mynistery / then are the mynisters of these dayes. Wherupon I conclude that if the ayde and assistance of the pastor by the Elders / was thought necessary by the apostles in those tymes / when the mynisters were so well / and so richly replenished with such giftes / much more is that ayde and assistance meete for the mynisters of these dayes / wherein their giftes of discretion and knowledge / and dyligence / are not so plentifull. For if they whose eye sight was so cleare to perceiue / whose handes so nimble to execute / had neede for their ayde / of other eyes & other handes / then the mynisters now / whose eyes are dimmer / and hands heauier then theirs were / haue much more neede of thys ayde then they had.
Again / if S. Paul did charge the persecuted / & therefore pore churches / 1with the finding and providing for the seniors in every church (as it appeareth in the Epistle to Timothy / where he sayeth that Elders which rule well / are worthy double honour / whereby he signifieth a plentiful reward / and such as may be fully sufficient for them and their households / as when he biddeth that the widow which served the church in attending upon the sick / and upon the strangers should be honoured / that is / have that wherewith she might honestly and soberly live) if I say Saint Paul would charge the churches then with maintaining the elders / which being poor / were not sometimes able to live without some relief from the church / because they were compelled oftentimes to leave their own affairs / to wait of the affairs of the church: how ⟨p. 179⟩much more ought there now to be seniors / when the churches be in peace / and therefore not so pore / and when there may be chosen such for the most part throughout the realm / as are able to live without charging the church any whit / as the practise of these days doth manifestly declare.
Agayne / if S. Paule dyd charge the persecuted / & therefore pore churches / 1with the fineding and prouiding for the senyors in euery church (as it appeareth in the Epistle to Timothe / where he sayeth that Elders whiche rule well / are worthy double honour / whereby he signifyeth a plentifull rewarde / and suche as may be fully sufficient for them and their housholdes / as when he biddeth that the widdow which serued the churche in attending vpon the sicke / and vppon the straungers shoulde be honoured / that is / haue that wherewyth shee might honestly and soberly liue) if I say Saynt Paule woulde charge the churches then with mayntayning the elders / which being poore / were not sometimes hable to liue without some reliefe from the church / because they were compelled oftentimes to leaue their owne affaires / to wayte of the affaires of the church: how ⟨p. 179⟩much more ought there now to be senyors / when the churches be in peace / and therefore not so pore / and when there may be chosen such for the most part thoroughout the realme / as are able to liue without charging the church any whit / as the practise of these dayes doth manifestly declare.
And if S. Paul that was so desirous to have the gospel adapanon, that 1is / free and without charges as much as is possible / and so loth to lay any burden upon the churches / especially those which were poor / did notwithstanding enjoin the maintenance of the elders unto the churches poor and persecuted / how much more shall we think / that his mind was that the Churches which live in peace / and are rich / and may have this office without charge / ought to receive this order of ancients?
And if S. Paule that was so desirous to haue the gospell adapanon, that 1is / free and without charges as much as is possible / and so loth to lay any burthen vpon the churches / especially those which were poore / dyd notwithstanding enioyne the mayntenaunce of the elders vnto the churches poore and persecuted / how much more shall we thincke / that hys mynde was that the Churches which liue in peace / and are rich / and may haue thys office without charge / ought to receiue thys order of auncientes?
Moreover those that be learned know / that the government of the church which was in the apostles times / being partly in respect of the people that had to do in the elections and other things popular: partly in respect of the pastors and ancients Aristocratical / that is the rule of the best: I say they know that these governments do easily decline into their contraries / and by reason thereof both the government of those which were most virtuous / might easily be changed into the government of few of the richest / or of greatest power / and the popular estate might easily pass to a confused tumult. Now this incommodity were they more subject unto under a tyrant / then under a godly prince. For they had no civil magistrate which might correct and reform those declyninges when they happened. For the tyrants did not know of it / and if they had known of it / they would have been glad to see the churches go to wrack. Therefore now we have a godly civil magistrate / which both will & ought to remedy such declinings & conversions of good government into evil / it followeth that this estate & government by ancients / is rather to be used under a christian prince then under a tyrant.
Moreouer those that be learned know / that the gouernement of the church which was in the apostles tymes / being partly in respect of the people that had to doe in the elections and other things popular: partly in respect of the pastors and auncientes Aristocraticall / that is the rule of the best: I say they know that these gouernmentes do easely declyne into their contraries / and by reason therof both the gouernment of those which were most vertuous / might easely be chaunged into the gouernment of few of the richest / or of greatest power / and the populare estate might easely passe to a confused tumulte. Now thys incommoditie were they more subiect vnto vnder a tyrant / then vnder a godly prince. For they had no cyuill magistrate which might correct and reforme those declyninges when they happened. For the tyrantes dyd not know of it / and if they had known of it / they would haue bene glad to see the churches goe to wracke. Therfore now we haue a godly ciuil magistrate / which both wil & ought to remedy such declinings & conuersions of good gouernment into euill / it followeth that thys estate & gouernmēt by auncientes / is rather to be vsed vnder a christian prince then vnder a tyrant.
Besides this / in the time of persecution all assemblies of divers together were dangerous and put them all in hazard of their life which did make those assemblies: And therefore if the pastor alone might have ordered and determined of things pertaining to the church by him self / it had been less danger to him / and more safety for others of the Church. And therefore if the seniors were then thought meet to govern the church / when they could not come together to exercise their functions without danger / much more ought they to be under a christian prince / when they may meet together without danger.
Besides thys / in the tyme of persecution all assemblyes of dyuers together were daungerous and put them all in hazard of their lyfe which dyd make those assemblies: And therefore if the pastor alone might haue ordered and determyned of things pertayning to the church by hym selfe / it had bene lesse daunger to him / and more safety for others of the Church. And therfore if the senyors were then thought meete to gouerne the church / when they could not come together to exercise their functions without daunger / much more ought they to be vnder a christian prince / when they may meete together without daunger.
M. Doctor proceedeth / & sayeth it can not be governed in a whole realm / as it may be in a city or town. This government by seniors is not only in one city / but also hath been of late throughout the whole realm of France / where there were any churches: and M. Doctor confesseth that it was in all the primitive churches / and therefore not only in one realm / but almost throughout the whole world / and therefore the large spreading of the church / can not hinder it. So that the difference lieth still in the peace and persecution of the Church / and not in the capacity and largeness of the place where the churches abide. So might one reason against the lawful estate of a Monarchy: For he might say that although the rule of one be needful and convenient in a household / yet it is not convenient in a town / and although it be convenient in a town / yet it is not in a city / and although in a city / yet not in a realm.
M. Doctor proceedeth / & sayeth it can not be gouerned in a whole realme / as it may be in a citie or town. This gouernment by senyors is not only in one citie / but also hath beene of late throughout the whole realme of Fraunce / where there were any churches: and M. Doctor confesseth that it was in all the primitiue churches / and therefore not onely in one realme / but almost throughout the whole world / and therefore the large spreading of the church / can not hynder it. So that the difference lyeth still in the peace and persecution of the Church / and not in the capacitie and largenesse of the place where the churches abyde. So might one reason agaynst the lawfull estate of a Monarchie: For he might say that although the rule of one be needefull and conuenient in a housholde / yet it is not conuenient in a towne / and although it be conuenient in a towne / yet it is not in a citie / and although in a citie / yet not in a realme.
To be short sayeth he / when he can say no more / it can not be governed when it is full of hypocrites / Papists / Atheists / and other wicked persons / as in the times of persecution / when there were few or none such. I have showed before / how great want of knowledge it bewrayeth / to say that Papists and Atheists be of the church / and I love not as Master Doctor doth to use often repetition / but if there be now moe hypocrites & other wicked and unruly parsons in the church / then there were in the time of persecution (which I will not deny) ⟨p. 180⟩then there is greater cause now / why there should be seniors in every church / then there was then when there were fewer. For the more naughty persons / and the greater disorders there be / the more aid and help hath the pastor need to have / both to find out their disorders / and also when they have found them out / to judge of the quality of them / and after also to correct them with the censures of the church / which standeth in such reprehensions private and open / and excommunication / as I have before rehearsed.
To be short sayeth hee / when he can say no more / it can not be gouerned when it is full of hypocrites / Papistes / Atheistes / and other wicked persons / as in the times of persecution / when there were few or none such. I haue shewed before / how great want of knowledge it bewrayeth / to say that Papistes and Atheistes be of the church / and I loue not as Maister Doctor doth to vse often repetition / but if there bee now moe hypocrites & other wicked and vnruely parsones in ye church / then there were in the tyme of persecution (which I wil not deny) ⟨p. 180⟩thē there is greater cause now / why there should be senyors in euery churche / then there was then when there were fewer. For the more naughty persons / and the greater disorders there be / the more ayde and helpe hath the pastor neede to haue / both to finde out their disorders / and also when they haue founde them out / to iudge of the qualitie of them / and after also to correct them with the censures of the church / which standeth in such reprehensions priuate and open / and excommunication / as I haue before rehearsed.
Afterward he asketh what seniors may be had in most of the parishes of England fit for that office? he asketh the same question in the. 133. page / where he also addeth pastors / asking where may be gotten such pastors as the authors of the Admonition require / when as they require no other then those which the word of God requireth. Well then if this be a good reason why there should be no elders in any church / because fit men are not to be gotten in all parishes: it followeth by M. Doctors reason / that forasmuch as we have not fit and able pastors for every church / that therefore we ought to have no able pastor in any church.
Afterwarde he asketh what senyors may bee had in most of the paryshes of Englande fitte for that office? he asketh the same question in the. 133. page / where he also addeth pastors / asking where may be gotten such pastoures as the authors of the Admonition require / when as they require no other then those which the word of God requireth. Well then if thys be a good reason why there should be no elders in any church / because fitte men are not to be gotten in all paryshes: it followeth by M. Doctors reason / that forasmuch as we haue not fit and able pastors for euery church / that therfore we ought to haue no able pastor in any church.
And if he will grant that we ought to have able pastors in as many places as they may be gotten: how can he deny / that we should have elders in those churches where fit men may be had. And I say further / where we have an express commandment laid upon us to do a thing / there all disputations must cease / of hardness / of impossibility / or profit / or else of peace. For first God hath not commanded any orders in his church which are impossible / and if they seem hard / it must be remembered / that the best and excellentest things are hardest / and that there is nothing so hard / which diligence and travail to bring it to pass / will not overcome. Which thing if it be proved true in worldly affairs / the truth thereof will much more appear in the matters pertaining unto God / considering that if God with his blessing do surmount all the difficulties in worldly matters which are otherwise hard to be compassed / he will in his own matters / and matters pertaining to his glory / fill up the valleys / although they be never so low / bring down the hills / although they be never so high / plain the ways be they never so rough: so that he will make of a way not passable in the eyes of flesh / away tracked and easy to go in / and to walk towards that kingdom / whereunto he calleth us. Besides that / I answer wheresoever there is a church / there are the riches of the spirit of God / there is with knowledge / discretion & wisdom / and there are such as * S. Paul calleth wise / 1and can discern and judge. And we see that when men are called to a lawful and profitable calling / and especially to a public calling / God doth pour on his gifts of that person which is called so plentifully / that he is as it were suddenly made a new man / which if he do in the wicked as Saul was / there is no 2doubt but he will do it in those / which are with the testimony of the church / and with experience of their former godly behaviour / chosen to such offices of weight. So that there is not / nor can not be any want to obey God's commandment / and to establish the order in the church which God hath appointed / but our own either negligence and slothfulness / or fearfulness / or ambition / or some other leaven which we nourish within our selves.
And if he will graunt that we ought to haue able pastoures in as many places as they may be gotten: how can he deny / that wee should haue elders in those churches where fitte men may bee had. And I say further / where wee haue an expresse commaundement layde vpon vs to doe a thing / there all disputations must cease / of hardenes / of impossibility / or profite / or else of peace. For first God hath not commaunded any orders in hys churche which are impossible / and if they seeme harde / it must bee remembred / that the best and excellentest things are hardest / and that there is nothing so harde / which dyligence and trauayle to bring it to passe / will not ouercome. Which thing if it bee proued true in worldly affaires / the truth therof will much more appeare in the matters pertayning vnto God / considering that if God with hys blessing doe surmount all the difficultyes in worldly matters whych are otherwyse harde to be compassed / hee will in hys owne matters / and matters pertayning to hys glory / fill vp the valleys / although they be neuer so low / bring downe the hylles / althoughe they bee neuer so high / playne the wayes be they neuer so rough: so that he will make of a way not passable in the eyes of flesh / away tracked and easie to goe in / and to walke towardes that kingdome / whereunto hee calleth vs. Besides that / I answere wheresoeuer there is a churche / there are the riches of the spirite of God / there is wyth knowledge / discretion & wisdom / and there are suche as * S. Paule calleth wise /
It is true / that we ought to be obedient unto the civil magistrate / which governeth the church of God in that office which is committed unto him / and according to that calling. But it must be remembered / that civil magistrates must govern it according to the rules of God prescribed in his word / & that as they are nurses / so they be servants unto the church / and as they rule in the church / so they must remember to subject them selves unto the church / to submit their sceptres / to throw down their crowns / before the church / yea as the Prophet speaketh / to lick the dust of the 1feet of the church. Wherein I mean not / that the church doth either wring ⟨p. 181⟩the sceptres out of Princes hands / or taketh their crowns from their heads / or that it requireth Princes to lick the dust of her feet (as the Pope under this pretence hath done) but I mean as the Prophet meaneth / that whatsoever magnificence / or excellency / or pomp / is either in them or in their estates and common wealths / which doth not agree with the simplicity / and in the judgement of the world) poor and contemptible estate of the church / that that they will be content to lay down.
It is true / that we ought to be obedyent vnto the cyuill magistrate / which gouerneth the church of God in that office which is committed vnto hym / and according to that calling. But it must be remembred / that cyuil magistrates must gouerne it according to the rules of God prescribed in hys word / & that as they are nourises / so they be seruauntes vnto the church / and as they rule in the churche / so they must remember to subiect them selues vnto the churche / to submit their scepters / to throw downe their crownes / before the church / yea as the Prophet speaketh / to licke the dust of the 1feete of the churche. Wherein I meane not / that the churche doth eyther wring ⟨p. 181⟩the scepters out of Princes hands / or taketh their crownes from their heads / or that it requireth Princes to licke the dust of her feete (as the Pope vnder thys pretence hath done) but I meane as ye Prophet meaneth / that whatsoeuer magnificence / or excellencye / or pompe / is eyther in them or in their estates and common wealthes / whych doth not agree wyth the simplicity / and in the iudgement of the world) poore and contemptible estate of the church / that that they will be content to lay downe.
And here cometh to my mind / that wherewith the world is now deceived / and wherewith M. doctor goeth about both to deceive him self and others to / in that he thinketh that the church must be framed according to the common wealth / and the church government according to the civill government / which is as much to say / as if a man should fashion his house according to his hangings / when as in deed it is clean contrary / that as the hangings are made fit for the house / so the common wealth must be made to agree with the church / and the government thereof with her government. For as the house is before the hangings / & therefore the hangings which come after / must be framed to the house which was before: so the church being before there was any common wealth / and the common wealth coming after / must be fashioned and made suitable unto the church. Otherwise God is made to give place to men / heaven to earth / and religion is made (as it were) a rule of Lesbia / to be applied unto any estate of common wealth whatsoever.
And heere commeth to my minde / that wherwyth the world is now deceyued / and wherwyth M. doctor goeth about bothe to deceiue him selfe and others to / in that he thinketh that the church must be framed according to the common wealth / and the church gouernment accordyng to the ciuill gouernment / whych is as much to say / as if a man shuld fashion hys house according to hys hāgings / when as in deede it is cleane contrary / that as the hangings are made fit for the house / so the common wealth must be made to agree wyth the church / and the gouernment therof wyth her gouernmēt. For as the house is before the hangings / & therefore the hangings whych come after / must be framed to the house whych was before: so the church being before there was any common wealthe / and the common wealthe comming after / muste be fashioned and made sutable vnto the church. Otherwyse God is made to geue place to men / heauen to earth / and religion is made (as it were) a rule of Lesbia / to be applyed vnto any estate of common wealth whatsoeuer.
Seeing that good men / that is to say the church / are as it were the foundation of the world / it is meet that the common wealth which is builded upon that foundation / should be framed according to the church / & therefore those voices ought not to be heard / this order will not agree with our common wealth / that law of God is not for our state / this form of government will not match with the policy of this realm.
Seing that good men / that is to say the church / are as it were the foundation of the worlde / it is meete that the common wealthe whych is builded vppon that foundation / should be framed according to the churche / & therfore those voyces ought not to be heard / thys order will not agree wyth oure common wealth / that lawe of God is not for our state / thys forme of gouernment will not matche wyth the pollicy of thys realme.
Now to come again to M. Doctors reasons / he sayeth in the. 133. page / that if they urge governors because they are spoken of in the. 12. to the Corin. then they may as well urge the power to work miracles / the gift of healing. &c. for that they are likewise reckoned up in the same place. But doth not M. doctor know / that although some things be extraordinary / and for a time / yet other some things are ordinary / and to endure always? Will he say for that the gifts of miracles and of healing are extraordinary / therefore the teachers which are there reckoned together with the gift of working miracles and of healing are extraordinary? hath he forgotten that he (in deed untruly) made before the office of Apostles and Prophets / and Evangelists / a perpetual office / and yet they are there joined with these gifts which were but for a time / and therefore it is a very absurd argument to say / that for that some thing reckoned with governors / is for a time / and extraordinary / therefore the governors be so. As for Musculus authority / which is / that the times do change the orders / besides that I have answered before / and besides that he doth not speak it of the Elders / I have proved that it can have no place here / for so much as the Elders are necessary / and commanded in the scripture.
Nowe to come againe to M. Doctors reasons / he sayeth in the. 133. page / that if they vrge gouernoures because they are spoken of in the. 12. to the Corin. then they may as well vrge the power to worke miracles / the gift of healing. &c. for that they are likewyse reckened vp in the same place. But dothe not M. doctor know / that although some thyngs be extraordinarye / and for a time / yet other some thyngs are ordinary / and to endure alwayes? Will he say for that the gifts of miracles and of healing are extraordinarye / therefore the teachers whych are there reckened together wyth the gift of working miracles and of healing are extraordinary? hath he forgotten that he (in deede vntruely) made before the office of Apostles and Prophets / and Euangelists / a perpetual office / and yet they are there ioyned wyth these gifts whych were but for a time / and therfore it is a very absurde argument to saye / that for that some thyng reckened with gouernors / is for a time / and extraordinary / therfore the gouernors be so. As for Musculus authoritye / whych is / that the tymes do chaunge the orders / besides that I haue answeared before / and besides that he dothe not speake it of the Elders / I haue proued that it can haue no place heere / for so much as the Elders are necessarye / and commaunded in the scripture.
Unto the authors of the Admonition saying that it is easier to overthrow by bribing / one man / then the faith and piety of a godly company: he answereth / that so it should come to pass / that the moe that ruled / the better estate it should be / and so the popular estate should be the best. But where do the authors of the admonition say / that the more that rule / the better it is? is it all one to say / that the government of a few of the best / is better then the government of one / and to say / the more that rule the better? If it were to the purpose / it might be showed both by Divinity and by Philosophy / which M. Doctor speaketh of / that that estate which he meaneth / is not the best: and I have in a word before ⟨p. 183⟩spoken of it / where I declared that the mixed estate is best / both by the example of the kingdom of Christ / and also of this our realm. It is sufficient now to admonish you / that although it be granted that the government of one / be the best in the common wealth / yet it can not be in the church. For the Prince may well be Monarch immediately between God & the common wealth / but no man can be Monarch between God & his church but Christ / which is the only head thereof. Therefore the Monarchy over the whole church / and over every particular church / and over every singular member in the church / is in Christ alone.
Vnto the authors of the Admonition saying that it is easier to ouerthrowe by bryving / one man / then the fayth and piety of a godly company: he answeareth / that so it should come to passe / that the moe that ruled / the better estate it shoulde be / and so the populare estate should be the best. But where do the authors of the admonition say / that the more that rule / the better it is? is it all one to saye / that the gouernment of a fewe of the best / is better then the gouernment of one / and to saye / the more that rule the better? If it were to the purpose / it myghte be shewed both by Diuinitye and by Philosophye / whych M. Doctor speaketh of / that that estate whych he meaneth / is not the best: and I haue in a word before ⟨p. 183⟩spoken of it / where I declared that the mixed estate is best / bothe by the example of the kingdome of Christ / and also of thys our realme. It is sufficient nowe to admonyshe you / that although it be graunted that the gouernment of one / be the best in the common wealth / yet it can not be in the church. For the Prince may wel be Monarche immediately betwene God & the common wealth / but no man can be Monarche betwene God & hys church but Christ / whych is the only head therof. Therfore the Monarchie ouer the whole church / and ouer euery particulare church / and ouer euery singular membre in the church / is in Chryst alone.
Last of all / to prove that there ought to be no seniors in the church under a Christian prince / he citeth Ambroses authority both in the. 114. and. 132. pages / which sayeth that the synagogue or church of the Jews / & after that the church of the christians had seniors / without whose counsel nothing was done in the church: whereupon he concludeth / that for as much as they were not in Ambrose time / therefore they were not under a christian prince. And here M. doctor hath in one sentence proclaimed both his great ignorance in the whole story of the church / and withal either a marvellous abusion / and suffering him self to be misled by some unadvised prompter / or subtle fox that thought to deceive him / or else a notable evil conscience / which wrestleth against the truth. His ignorance doth appear partly in that he sayeth / that because there were no seniors in Amb. church / and in those churches about him / therefore there was none at all: but most manifestly in that he sayeth / for so much as there were no seniors in Amb. time / therefore there was none under a christian Prince / as though there were not many years before Amb. time christian Emperors / when as between the time of S. Ambrose being bishop / and the time of Phillip successor of Gordias the first christian Emperor / there is more then a. 150. years / and between the time of Constantine the Emperor / and the time of Ambrose being bishop / there be above. 80. years. And if M. Doctor had ever red the ecclesiastical stories / he mought have found easily the eldership most flourishing in Constantine's time / and other times / when as the peace of the christians was greatest.
Last of all / to proue that there ought to be no senyors in the church vnder a Christian prince / he citeth Ambroses authority both in the. 114. and. 132. pages / whych sayeth that the sinagogue or church of the Iewes / & after that the church of the chrystians had senyors / wythout whose counsell nothyng was done in the church: whervpon he concludeth / that for as much as they were not in Ambrose tyme / therfore they were not vnder a christian prince. And heere M. doctor hath in one sentence proclaimed bothe hys great ignorance in the whole storye of the churche / and wythall eyther a maruellous abusion / and suffering hym selfe to be misled by some vnaduysed prompter / or subtile foxe that thought to deceyne him / or else a notable euill conscience / whych wrastleth agaynst the truthe. Hys ignorance doth appeare partly in that he sayeth / that because there were no senyors in Amb. church / and in those churches about hym / therefore there was none at all: but moste manifestly in that he sayeth / for so much as there were no senyors in Amb. time / therefore there was none vnder a christian Prince / as though there were not many yeres before Amb. tyme christian Emperors / when as betwene the tyme of S. Ambrose being byshop / and the tyme of Phillip successor of Gordias the first christian Emperor / there is more then a. 150. yeares / and betweene the time of Constantine the Emperor / and the tyme of Ambrose being byshop / there be aboue. 80. yeares. And if M. Doctor had euer red the ecclesiasticall storyes / he mought haue founde easely the eldershyp moste flourishyng in Constantines tyme / and other tymes / when as the peace of the chrystians was greatest.
And that the presbytery or eldership endured in the church after Ambrose time / and in the time of peace / and as it is very like in Amb. time / although not where he was / it may be showed plainly by Jerome (which followed Ambrose 1immediately) who in his third chapter upon Isaiah / sayeth that they had also the presbytery or eldership in the church. The same might be showed by divers other testimonies / which I omit / because that it may appear by the former treatise touching the election of the minister / that this order of eldership continued in the church divers hundred years after Ambrose time / even as long almost as there was any sound part of the church / from the head to the heel. Now I have showed the ignorance / it remaineth to show how that either M. Doctor was marvellously him self abused / or else desireth to abuse other. For if whereas he toke half Ambrose sentence / he had taken the other half with him / and had not suddenly stopped his breath that he should speak no more / in stead of a false witness against the eldership / he should have brought forth as clear and as flat a witness for the proof of them / as a man could desire out of an ancient writer. The whole sentence is this / speaking of this office of the elders / (although not upon so good occasion) thus he sayeth: Whereupon the synagogue / and 2after the church had elders / without whose counsel nothing was done in the church / which Elders I know not by what negligence they are worn out / onles it be through the slothfulness of the doctors / or rather through their pride / whilst they only would seem to be somewhat.
And that the presbyterie or eldershyp endured in the church after Ambrose tyme / and in the tyme of peace / and as it is very lyke in Amb. tyme / although not where he was / it may be shewed plainly by Ierome (whych folowed Ambrose 1immediatlye) who in hys third chapter vpon Esay / sayeth that they had also the presbyterie or eldershyp in the church. The same myght be shewed by diuers other testimonies / whych I omit / because that it may appeare by the former treatise touchyng the election of the mynister / that thys order of eldershyp continued in the church diuers hundreth yeares after Ambrose tyme / euen as long almoste as there was any sound part of the church / from the head to the heele. Nowe I haue shewed the ignorance / it remayneth to shewe howe that eyther M. Doctor was maruellously hym selfe abused / or else desyreth to abuse other. For if wheras he toke halfe Ambrose sentence / he had taken the other halfe wyth hym / and had not sodenly stopped hys breath that he should speake no more / in steade of a false wytnes agaynst the eldershyp / he should haue brought forthe as cleare and as flat a witnes for the proofe of them / as a man coulde desire out of an auncient wryter. The whole sentence is thys / speakyng of thys offyce of the elders / (although not vpon so good occasyon) thus he sayeth: Whervpon the sinagoge / and
Now that I have showed the place / I will say no more / I will leave it to M. Doctor to think of it in his chamber by him self / and so will conclude this question: that for so much as this order is such / as without which / the principal ⟨p. 183⟩offices of charity can not be exercised: and that it is that which is commaū dead by the scriptures / approved and received by all the churches in the Apostles times / and many hundred years after in the most flourishing churches / both in time of peace / & in time of persecution: and that there are greater causes why it should be in the time of peace / then in time of persecution / why rather under a christian prince / then under a tyrant / why rather now / then in the apostles times / that in consideration of these things / the eldership is necessary / and such an order as the church ought not to be without. And so also is answered the third question / that for so much as they were church officers / and over the people in matters 1pertaining to God / & such as watched over the souls of men / that therefore although they were not pastors to preach the word / yet were they no lay men (as they term them) but ecclesiastical persons. The rest comprehended in these sections / is answered before / being matter which pertained unto the archbishop.
Now that I haue shewed the place / I wyll say no more / I wyl leaue it to M. Doctor to thinke of it in his chamber by hym selfe / and so will conclude this question: that for so much as thys order is such / as wythout whych / the principall ⟨p. 183⟩offices of charity can not be exercysed: and that it is that which is commaū ded by the scryptures / approued and receyued by all the churches in the Apostles tymes / and many hundreth yeares after in the most flouryshing churches / bothe in tyme of peace / & in tyme of persecution: and that there are greater causes why it should be in the tyme of peace / then in tyme of persecution / why rather vnder a christian prince / then vnder a tyrant / why rather now / then in ye apostles times / that in consyderation of these things / the eldershyp is necessary / and such an order as the church ought not to be wythout. And so also is answeared the third question / that for so much as they were church offycers / and ouer the people in matters 1
Now I return back again to Excommunication / which M. Doctor thinketh to be the only discipline in the church / but he should understand / that beside that part of private discipline / (which is ordinarily and daily to be exercised by every one of the pastors & elders / as Admonition and reprehension) there are .iij. principal parts / which are exercised of them jointly and together / whereof the first is the election or choice / and the abdication or putting out of Ecclesiastical officers. The second is in excommunication of the stubborn / or absolution of the repentant. The third is the decision of all such matters as do rise in the church / either touching corrupt manners / or perverse doctrine.
Nowe I returne backe agayne to Excommunicacion / whych M. Doctor thynketh to be the only disciplyne in the church / but he shuld vnderstand / that besyde that parte of priuate disciplyne / (whych is ordinarily and dayly to be exercised by euery one of the pastors & elders / as Admonition and reprehension) there are .iij. princypal parts / whych are exercised of them ioyntly and together / wherof the first is the election or choyse / and the abdication or putting out of Ecclesiasticall officers. The second is in excommunication of the stubburne / or absolution of the repētant. The third is the decision of all such matters as doe ryse in the church / eyther touchyng corrupt manners / or peruerse doctryne.
As touching the election / and consequently the throwing out / it hath been showed before / that together with the church / the eldership hath the principal sway. For the decision of controversies when they rise / it may appear in the. 15. of the Acts / that the Presbytery or Eldership of the church hath to determine of that also. Now it remaineth here / that whereas M. Doctor sayeth that the Excommunication / and consequently the absolution or restoring to the church again / doth pertain only to the minister / that I show that the Presbytery or eldership / and the whole church also / hath interest in the Excommunication / and consequently in the absolution or restoring unto the church. But here by the way it is to be noted / that in saying that it belongeth to the minister / he confesseth the disorder in our church / wherein this power is taken away from the minister / and given to the bishop and his officers.
As touchyng the election / and consequently the throwing out / it hath bene shewed before / that together wyth the churche / the eldershyp hathe the principall sway. For the decision of controuersyes whē they ryse / it may appeare in the. 15. of the Acts / that the Presbyterie or Eldershyp of the churche hath to determine of that also. Nowe it remayneth heere / that whereas M. Doctor sayeth that the Excommunication / and consequently the absolution or restoryng to the church agayne / doth pertayne only to the minister / that I shewe that the Presbyterye or eldership / and the whole church also / hath interest in the Excommunication / and consequently in the absolution or restoryng vnto the churche. But heere by the way it is to be noted / that in saying that it belongeth to the minister / he confesseth the dysorder in our church / wherin this power is taken away from the minister / and geuen to the byshop and hys offycers.
Now that this charge of excommunication belongeth not unto one / or to the minister / but chiefly to the eldership and pastor / it appeareth by that which the authors of the admonition allege out of S. Matthew / which place I have 1proved before to be necessarily understanded of the elders of the church. It is most absurdly said of M. doctor in the. 135. page / that by the church is understanded either my Lords grace / or the bishop of the diocese / or the Chancellor or Commissary. And that when a man complaineth unto one of these / he may be well said to complain unto the church: which is the more untollerable / for that being so strange a saying / and such as may astonish all that hear it / he neither confirmeth it by any reason / or like phrase of scripture / or by the authority of any godly or approved writer old or new / which notwithstanding he seeketh for so diligently / and turneth the commentaries in his study so painfully / when he can have but one against twenty / and but a syllable where he can not have a sentence. It may be the clearlyer understanded / that the presbytery or eldership / had the chief stroke in this excommunication / if it be observed / that this was the policy and discipline of the Jews / and of the synagogue from whence our saviour Christ toke this / and translated it unto this church / that when any man had don any thing that they held for a fault / that then the same was punished and censured by the Elders of the church / according to the quality of the fault / as it may appear in S. Matthew. For although it be of some (and those very learned) ⟨p. 184⟩2expounded of the civill judgement / yet for so much as the Jews had nothing to do with civill judgements (the same being altogether in the hands of the Romans) and that the word sanhedrin, corrupted of the Greek word synedrion, which S. Matthew useth / is known by those that have skill in the Rabbins / and especially the Jews Talmud, to signify the ecclesiastical governors / there can be no doubt but he meaneth the ecclesiastical censures. And if the fault were judged very great / then the sentence of Excommunication was awarded by the same elders / as appeareth in S. John. And this was the cause why our saviour 3Christ spake so shortly of this matter in the. 18. of S.
Matthew / without noting the circumstances more at large / for that he spake of a thing which was well known and used amongst the Jews whom he spake unto. And that this was the meaning of our saviour Christ in those words / it may appear by the practise which is set forth in the Epistles to the Corinthians. For it is certain that S. Paul did both understand and observe the rule of our saviour Christ. But he communicateth this power of Excommunication with the church / and therefore it must needs be the meaning of our saviour Christ / that the excommunication should be by many / and not by one / and by the church / and not by the minister of the church alone. For he biddeth the church of Corinth twice in the first Epistle / once by a Metaphor / an other time in plain words / that they should excommunicate the incestuous person. By metaphor / saying: (purge out your old leaven) in plain and flat words / when he sayeth (take away that wicked 1man from amongst you.) And in the second Epistle understanding of the repentance of that man / he entreateth them that they would receive him in again / 2showing that he was content to release the bond and chain of his excommunication / so that they would do the same / and therefore considering the absolution / or reconciliation of the excommunicate / doth pertain unto the church / it followeth that the excommunication doth in like manner appertain unto it.
Mathew / wythout noting the circumstances more at large / for that he spake of a thyng whych was well knowne and vsed amongst the Iewes whome he spake vnto. And that this was the meaning of our sauioure Christe in those wordes / it may appeare by the practise whych is set forthe in the Epistles to the Corinthians. For it is certain that S. Paule dyd bothe vnderstand and obserue the rule of our sauyor Christ. But he communicateth thys power of Excommunication wyth the church / and therfore it must needes be the meaning of oure sauioure Christe / that the excommunication should be by many / and not by one / and by the church / and not by the minister of the church alone. For he biddeth the church of Corinthe twise in the first Epistle / once by a Metaphore / an other time in playne woordes / that they should excommunicate the incestuous person. By metaphore / saying: (purge out your olde leauen) in playne and flat words / when he sayeth (take away that wicked 1
Now / whereas M. Doctor upon those words of S. Paul / that he being absent in body / and present in spirit / had determined. &c. concludeth that the right of excommunication was in S. Paul / and not in the rest / it is as much as if he should say / S. Paul as much as lay in him excommunicated / therefore s. Paul excommunicated: or S. Paul excommunicated / therefore the church did not. For what if S. Paul did excommunicate him so much as lay in him / should he therefore have been excommunicated / if the church of Corinth / and the minister there would have admitted him to the supper / and not abstain from familiar companying with him? You will say he should have been bound in heaven and before God / although the church of Corinth had not put him forth. It is true that the apostles denunciation of Gods vengeance upon the impenitent sinner / is ratified in heaven / and so should he also have been if S. Paul had said nothing / and yet S. Paul did not excommunicate the incestuous person / but so much as lay in him / and as far as his right stretched: not being therefore yet excommunicated by S. Paul / it followeth that the church had a stroke in the excommunication. Again / to prove that the church hath nothing to do with excommunication / it is not enough to say that S. Paul had the right of excommunication: But you should have showed that he only had it / and then you are manifestly convicted by S. Pauls own words / which joineth the church with him in that excommunication / saying that he had decreed that the doer of that fact (by his spirit / and them gathered together in the name of Jesus Christ / and by his power) should be given to satan. And if the right of excommunication were only in S. Paul / how is it that you said before / that it is in the minister of the church? had the minister of the church of Corinth nothing to do? And if it were in S. Paul alone / why doth he chide with the church / that they had not already excommunicated him before he wrote unto them to signify his ⟨p. 185⟩will to excommunicate? or if it were in the minister of the church only / why w•• S. Paul chide and sharply rebuke the church / for that the incestuous man was not cast forth? Why doth he charge the Corinthians with that which was the only fault of the minister?
Now / wheras M. Doctor vpon those wordes of S. Paule / that he being absent in body / and present in spirite / had determined. &c. concludeth yt the ryght of excommunication was in S. Paule / and not in the rest / it is as much as if he should say / S. Paule as much as lay in hym excommunicated / therfore s. Paule excommunicated: or S. Paule excommunicated / therefore the churche dyd not. For what if S. Paule dyd excommunicate hym so muche as lay in hym / shoulde he therfore haue bene excommunicated / if the church of Corinthe / and the minyster there would haue admitted hym to the supper / and not abstaine from familiare companying wyth hym? You will say he should haue bene bounde in heauen and before God / although the church of Corinthe had not put hym forthe. It is true that the apostles denunciation of Gods vengeance vpon the impenitent sinner / is ratifyed in heauen / and so shoulde he also haue bene if S. Paule had sayd nothyng / and yet S. Paule dyd not excommunicate the incestuous persone / but so much as lay in hym / and as farre as hys ryght stretched: not being therfore yet excommunicated by S. Paule / it foloweth that the church had a stroke in the excommunication. Againe / to proue that the church hath nothyng to doe wyth excommunication / it is not enoughe to say that S. Paule had the ryght of excommunication: But you shoulde haue shewed that he only had it / and then you are manifestly conuicted by S. Paules own words / whych ioyneth the church with hym in that excommunication / saying that he had decreed that the doer of that fact (by hys spirite / and them gathered together in the name of Iesus Christe / and by hys power) should be geuen to sathan. And if the right of excommunication were only in S. Paule / how is it that you sayd before / that it is in the minister of the churche? had the minister of the churche of Corinthe nothing to doe? And if it were in S. Paule alone / why doth he chide wyth the church / that they had not already excommunicated hym before he wrote vnto them to signifye hys
An other objection M. doctor hath out of the .16. of S. Matthew / and the 20. of John / in which places because he giveth power to the .xij. to bind and to lose / M. Doctor will conclude that they only have power to bind and to lose. Solomon sayeth that the just man is first the accuser of himself / and therefore it 1behoved M. doctor or ever he should have accused the authors of the Admonition of dallying and unreverent handling of the scriptures / to have first of all spoken to him self / and have stricken him self upon the thigh. For if this be not to abuse the scriptures / I know not what is to abuse them / for to let pass that some and of the ancient writers do expound the place of S. Matthew of every member of Christ / and of as many as have faith to confess Christ to be the some of God / and so by that means to have power of excommunication / I say to let that go / M. doctor might easily know if he would / that in that pla•e our saviour Christ speaketh of the binding and losing which ••y the preaching of the word of God / standing in threats and promises / and therefore that binding pertaineth only unto the ministers / to whom the preaching doth only belong. But in the .18. of S. Matthew where he speaketh of the binding and losing by excommunication and receiving to the church again / there he attributeth this power unto the church. He hath an other objection out of S. Paul to Timothy / where for that it is said that s. Paul did excommunicate Hymineus and Alexander / he concludeth after his old manner / that therefore he only excommunicated. But for so much as I have proved that both the rule of Christ / & the practise of S. Paul according to that rule / be otherwise / it can not be that S. Paul did excommunicate him self alone those persons: for then he should disagree both with our saviour Christ and with him self. But as I have showed before in other ecclesiastical actions and exercises of discipline / that one man is said to do that which was done of many / for because one was moderator of that action or exercise: so s. Paul here sayeth that he did excommunicate / not that he did it by him self alone / but because he was president & chief in that action. And although it should be granted (which can not) that S.
An other obiection M. doctor hath out of the .16. of S. Mathew / and the 20. of Iohn / in whych places because he giueth power to the .xij. to bynde and to lose / M. Doctor will conclude that they only haue power to binde and to lose. Salomon sayeth that the iust man is first the accuser of himselfe / and therfore it
Paul did excommunicate himself alone (being an apostle / or for one time) yet it neither followeth that the bishop or minister may do that which the apostle did / or that he may do continually ye which was done but once and extraordinarily. As for the place of Titus the third / it maketh nothing to excommunication / onles you would conclude that for that S. Paul biddeth Titus to trouble himself no more with confuting an obstinate heretic / therefore he biddeth him excommunicate an heretic by him self. As touching Basil's place in the second book of Offices when the book cometh forth & is Printed / then it shall be answered / as for me I know of none such that is extant now. To the rest I will answer with this protestation / that if all men should do contrary to the order of God / yet their authority or example ought not to have the weight of a feather / which I have said before / & do understand it in all places where I do not express it / & with this I come to M. doctors authorities.
Paule dyd excommunicate hymselfe alone (being an apostle / or for one tyme) yet it neyther foloweth that the byshop or minister may do that whych the apostle dyd / or that he may do continually ye which was done but once and extraordinarily. As for the place of Titus the thirde / it maketh nothyng to excommunication / onles you wold conclude that for that S. Paule biddeth Titus to trouble hymselfe no more wyth confuting an obstinate hereticke / therfore he biddeth hym excommunicate an hereticke by hym selfe. As touching Bafiles place in the second booke of Offices when the booke commeth forth & is Printed / then it shalbe answered / as for me I know of none such that is extant now. To the rest I will answer wyth thys protestation / that if all men should do contrary to the order of God / yet their authority or example ought not to haue the waight of a fether / which I haue said before / & do vnderstand it in all places wher I do not expres it / & wyth this I come to M. doctors authorities.