pp. 173–19573 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And as for Theodoretus bishop of Laodicea / which Sozomene maketh mention of in his sixth book / I find none such / but there is mentioned of one Theodotus / who is said to have separated or excommunicated Apollinaris / but it doth not appear there that he alone of his own authority did excommunicate him. And there be great reasons in that Chapter / to prove that he did it not of his own authority / for immediately after his heresy was known / Damasus bishop of Rome / and Peter bishop of Alexandria / caused a synod to be gathered at Rome / where his heresy was condemned. Now for so much as the custom of ⟨p. 186⟩synods and councils is / when they condemn the heresies / to excommunicate the heretics / it is to be thought that that council did excommunicate him / and that Theodotus bishop of Laodicea / did execute that decree and excommunication. And in deed Sozomene doth so expound him self / when immediately after he had said that he did excommunicate him / he addeth acoinonetoh auton apophainei, which is / that he declared him excommunicate / which in deed properly belongeth to the minister / when the excommunication is decreed by those to whom it appertaineth. Which thing may yet better appear by the manner of speech which is used in an other place / where speaking of victor excommunicating Theodotus / he uttereth it by this apekeryxe, which is to promulgate or pronounce the sentence which was decreed by others. As for Amb. although he be greatly commended for excommunicating the Emperor / yet he was never commended / for that he did excommunicate him himself alone: and if he did excommunicate him himself alone / yet his fault was the less / for so much as he being desirous of an eldership / could not as it seemeth by his complaint (which I have spoken of before) •••aine one. And although the stories do not make mention y• there were others / whose authority came into this excommunication / yet it followeth not y• there were no other. And how often will you stumble at that / which you do so sharply reprove in others / which is in making of arguments of authority negatively?
And as for Theodoretus byshop of Laodicea / whych Sozomene maketh mention of in hys sixthe booke / I finde none suche / but there is mentioned of one Theodotus / who is sayd to haue seperated or excommunicated Apollinaris / but it doth not appeare there that he alone of hys owne authority dyd excommunicate hym. And there be great reasons in that Chapter / to proue that he dyd it not of hys owne authority / for immediatly after his heresy was knowne / Damasus bishop of Rome / and Peter bishop of Alexandria / caused a sinode to be gathered at Rome / where hys heresy was condemned. Now for so much as the custome of ⟨p. 186⟩synodes and councels is / when they condenme the heresyes / to excommunicate the heretickes / it is to be thoughte that that councell dyd excommunicate hym / and that Theodotus byshop of Laodicea / dyd execute that decree and excommunication. And in deede Sozomene doth so expound hym selfe / when immediatly after he had sayde that he dyd excommunicate him / he addeth acoinonetoh auton apophainei, whych is / that he declared him excommunicate / whych in deede properly belongeth to the minister / when the excommunication is decreed by those to whō it appertaineth. Whych thing may yet better appeare by the manner of speache whych is vsed in an other place / where speaking of •ictor excommunycating Theodotus / he vttereth it by thys apekeryxe, whych is to promulgate or pronounce the sentence whych was decreed by others. As for Amb. although he be greatly commended for excommunicating the Emperor / yet he was neuer commended / for that he did excommunicate him himselfe alone: and if he dyd excommunicate him himselfe alone / yet hys fault was the les / for so much as he being desirous of an eldershyp / could not as it semeth by hys complaint (which I haue spoken of before) •••aine one. And although the storyes doe not make mention y• there were others / whose authority came into thys excommunication / yet it followeth not y• there were no other. And how often wil you stomble at that / which you do so sharply reproue in others / whych is in making of arguments of authority negatiuely?
And if you will not grant this manner of reasoning in the scripture / in matters pertaining to the government of the church / which are all comprehended in the scripture / how would you reason of a common story / which neither can / nor doth profess to speak all those things which fall into that matter which it writeth of? But what if so be it be proved that Ambrose did not this of his own authority / but by the authority also of others / will you then confess that he is commended of all those which write stories for so doing / and confess that the use and practise of the primitive church was far from this that is now? For proof whereof I will give you a place which Ambrose the best witness of this matter hath in one of his epistles / where he showeth that as soon as the murder which Theodosius had caused to be done at the city of Thessalonica was 1heard / by and by the bishops of France came and there was holden a Synod: where also Ambrose sayeth / that his communicating with Theodosius / could 2not absolve him (for that as it might appear) the bishops in that synod had in excommunicating him / ordained that he should not be absolved until such time as he had done repentance / which he did afterward with confession of his fault before the congregation / and asking forgiveness of it. So it appeareth that that which he did / he did it by the sentence of the synod / and not of his own authority alone. In the. 220. & 221. pages / he speaketh of this thing a fresh / but hath no new matter / but maketh a bare rehearsal of the places of the admonition / asking after his accustomed manner of confuting / what maketh this or what proveth that? only whereas he said before / and proved (as he thought) that the minister had only to do with excommunication / being pressed there / by the admonition either to defend or renounce his Chancellors. &c. he had rather deny both the truth and himself / then he would have any of that horrible confusion and profanation of the holy discipline of God (brought in by popery threatening the overthrow of the whole church / & serving for nothing but for the nourishing of the ambition and idleness of a few) driven out of the church.
And if you will not graūt thys manner of reasonyng in the scripture / in matters pertaining to the gouernment of the church / whych are all comprehended in the scripture / how would you reason of a common story / whych neither can / nor dothe professe to speake all those things whych fall into that matter whych it wryteth of? But what if so be it be proued that Ambrose did not this of hys owne authoritye / but by the authoritye also of others / will you then confesse that he is commended of all those whych wryte stories for so doing / and confesse that the vse and practise of the primitiue church was far from thys that is nowe? For proufe whereof I will geue you a place whych Ambrose the best wytnes of thys matter hath in one of his epistles / wher he sheweth that assone as the murther whych Theodosius had caused to be done at the citye of Thessalonica was
Of the which I will upon occasion speak a word / if first I show that the use of the ancient church hath been not to permit the excommunication to one / but that the sentence thereof should come from the governors and elders of the church / unto whom that did especially appertain. Although I can not pass by that which M. doctor saith / that for so much as the authors of the Admonition had alleged the words (tell the church) to prove the interest of the church in excommunication / that therefore ⟨p. 187⟩they could not use the same to prove the interest of the pastor / as who should say that the pastor is not one of the church. But of the absurdity of this / I have spoken sufficiently before / and how all men do see the vanity of this reason / that because that people have an interest by this place / therefore the pastor hath none. But I come to show the use of the primitive church in this matter / whereof we have a manifest testimony in Tertullian. If (saith he) there be any which hath committed 1such a fault that he is to be put away from the partaking of the prayer of the church / and from all holy matters or affairs: there do bear rule or be presidents certain of the most approved ancients or elders / which have obtained this honour / not by money / but by good report. And that the ancients had the ordering of these things / and the peoples consent was required / and that if the case were a very difficult case / it was referred unto the synods or councils / and that the ministers did not take upon them of their own authority to excommunicate / and that those which did receive the excommunicate without the knowledge & consent of the church were reprehended / it may appear almost in every page of 2Cyprian's Epistles / and namely in these which I have noted in the margin.
Of the whych I will vpon occasion speake a word / if first I shewe that the vse of the auncyent church hath bene not to permit the excommunication to one / but that the sentence therof should come from the gouernors and elders of the church / vnto whome that dyd especially appertaine. Although I can not passe by that which M. doctor sayth / that for so much as the authors of the Admonition had alledged the words (tell the church) to proue the interest of the church in excommunication / that therefore ⟨p. 187⟩
In Augustine's time it appeareth also / that the consent of the church was required / for in the third book against the epistle of Parmenian / he showeth that if the multitude of the church be not in that fault for which one is to be excommunicated / that then it helpeth much to make the party both afraid and ashamed / that he be excommunicated or anathematised (as he calleth it) by all the church / and in hys books de Baptis. contra Donatistas, in divers places / he is so far from permitting the excommunication to one man / that he seemeth to fall into the other extremity / which is to make the estate of the church to popular / and the people to have too great a sway. For there he showeth / that if the most of the people be infected with the fault which is to be punished by excommunication / that then no excommunication ought to be attempted / for because a sufficient number of voices will not be obtained for the excommunication. By which testimonies / besides the institution of God / & the practise of the churches in the apostles times / appeareth manifestly what hath ben the use of the churches touching excommunication / as long as there was any purity in the church. And it is to be observed here / that both in this part of the discipline / and also in all other parts of it (as I have showed) as in harder and difficulter causes / things were referred unto the Synods provincial / national / or general / as the case required: so if the elders of any church shall determine any thing contrary to the word of God / or inconveniently in any matter that falleth into their determination / the parties which are grieved / may have recourse for remedy / unto the elders and pastors of divers churches / that is to say unto Synods of shires / or dioceses / or provinces / or nations of as great or of as small compass as shall be thought convenient by the church / according to the difficulty or weight of the matters / which are in controversy. Which meetings ought to be as often as can be conveniently / not only for the decision of such difficulties which the several presbyteries can not so well judge of / but also to the end that common counsel might be taken for the best remedy of the vices or incommodities which either the churches be in / or in danger to be in.
In Augustines tyme it appeareth also / that the consent of the church was required / for in the third boke agaynst the epistle of Parmenian / he sheweth that if the multitude of the church be not in that fault for which one is to be excommunicated / that then it helpeth much to make the party both afrayde and ashamed / that he be excommunicated or anathematised (as he calleth it) by all the churche / and in hys bookes de Baptis. contra Donatistas, in diuers places / he is so far from permitting the excommunication to one man / yt he semeth to fal into the other extremity / whych is to make the estate of the church to populare / and the people to haue too great a sway. For there he sheweth / that if the most of the people be infected wyth the fault whych is to be punyshed by excommunication / that then no excommunication ought to be attempted / for because a sufficient numbre of voyces will not be obtained for the excommunication. By whych testimonies / besydes the institution of God / & the practise of the churches in the apostles times / appeareth manifestly what hath ben the vse of the churches touchyng excommunication / as long as there was any purity in the church. And it is to be obserued heere / that bothe in thys parte of the discipline / and also in all other partes of it (as I haue shewed) as in harder and difficulter causes / thyngs were referred vnto the Synodes prouincial / nationall / or generall / as the case required: so if the elders of any church shall determine any thing contrary to the worde of God / or inconueniently in any matter that falleth into their determination / the partyes whych are greeued / may haue recourse for remedy / vnto the elders and pastoures of dyuers churches / that is to say vnto Synodes of shires / or dioceses / or prouinces / or nations of as great or of as small compasse as shall be thought conuenient by the church / according to the difficulty or waight of the matters / whych are in controuersy. Whych meetings ought to be as often as can be conueniently / not only for the decision of suche difficultyes whych the seuerall presbyteries can not so well iudge of / but also to the ende that common counsell myght be taken for the best remeady of the vices or incommodities whych eyther the churches be in / or in daunger to be in.
And as those things which can not be decided by the Eldership of the churches are to be reserved unto the knowledge of some Synod of a shire or diocese: so those which for their hardness can not be there decided / must be brought into the Synods of larger compass as I have showed to have been done in the apostles times / and in the churches which followed them long after.
And as those thyngs whych can not be decided by the Eldershyp of the churches are to be reserued vnto the knowledge of some Synode of a shire or diocese: so those whych for their hardnesse can not be there decided / must be brought into the Synodes of larger compasse as I haue shewed to haue bene done in the apostles times / and in the churches whych followed them long after.
These things standing in this sort / all those Courts of bishops and archbishops must needs fall / which were by Antichrist erected against this lawful jurisdiction of Eldership / as the court of faculties / and those which are ⟨p. 188⟩holden by chancellors / commissaries / officials / and such like / the describing of the corruptions whereof / would require a whole book / of which I will note the principal heads and sums.
These thyngs standing in thys sorte / all those Courtes of byshoppes and archbyshoppes must needes fall / whych were by Antichrist erected against thys lawfull iurisdiction of Eldership / as the courte of faculties / and those whych are ⟨p. 188⟩holden by chauncellors / commissaries / officials / and suche lyke / the describyng of the corruptions wherof / would require a whole boke / of whych I will note the principall heads and summes.
First / for ye they enter into an office which pertaineth not unto them / but to every particular church / and especially to the eldership or governors of the church / and therefore although they should do nothing but that which were good / lawful / and godly / yet can they not approve their labours unto men / much less to God / putting their sickle in an other mans harvest. For neither by the truth of the word of God doth that appertain unto them / neither by M. Doctors own judgement (if his yea were yea / and his nay nay) considering that he said before / that this jurisdiction belongeth to the ministers. And although it should pertain unto the Bishop / (as he is called) to whom notwithstanding it doth not appertain) yet were it not lawful for him to translate this office unto an other / and to appoint one to do it when he listeth / no more then he can appoint them to do his other offices of ministering / as preaching the word / and ministering the sacraments.
First / for ye they enter into an offyce whych pertaineth not vnto them / but to euery particulare church / and especially to the eldershyp or gouernoures of the church / and therfore although they should do nothing but that whych were good / lawfull / and godly / yet can they not approue their labors vnto men / much les to God / puttyng their sickle in an other mannes harnest. For neyther by the truthe of the worde of God dothe that appertayne vnto them / neyther by M. Doctors owne iudgement (if hys yea were yea / and hys nay nay) consydering that he sayd before / that thys iurisdiction belongeth to the ministers. And although it should pertaine vnto the Byshop / (as he is called) to whom notwythstanding it dothe not appertaine) yet were it not lawfull for hym to translate thys office vnto an other / and to appoynt one to doe it when he lysteth / no more then he can appoynt them to doe hys other offyces of ministring / as preaching the worde / and ministring the sacraments.
An other thing is / that in these courts (which they call spiritual) they take the knowledge of matters / which are mere civil / thereby not only perverting the order which God hath appointed / in severing the civill causes from the ecclesiastical / but jostling also with the civill magistrate / and thrusting him from the jurisdiction / which appertaineth unto him / as the causes of the contracts of marriage / of divorces / of wills & testaments / with divers such other like things. For although it appertain to the church and the governors thereof / to show out of the word of God which is a lawful contract or just cause of divorce / and so forth / yet the judicial determination / and definitive sentences of all these / do appertain unto the civill magistrate. Hereunto may be added / that all their punishments almost are penalties of money / which can by no means appertain to the church / but is a thing merely civill.
An other thyng is / that in these courts (whych they cal spiritual) they take the knowledge of matters / which are meere ciuil / therby not only peruerting the order whych God hath appoynted / in seuering the ciuill causes from the ecclesiasticall / but iustling also wyth the ciuill magistrate / and thrusting hym from the iurisdiction / whych appertaineth vnto hym / as the causes of the contracts of mariage / of diuorces / of willes & testaments / wt diuers suche other like things. For although it appertaine to the church and the gouernors therof / to shew out of the word of God whych is a lawfull contract or iust cause of diuorce / and so forthe / yet the iudiciall determination / and definitiue sentences of all these / do appertaine vnto the ciuill magistrate. Heerevnto may be added / that all their punishments almost are penalties of mony / whych can by no meanes appertaine to the church / but is a thyng meerely ciuill.
Thirdly / as they handle matters which do not appertain unto the Ecclesiastical jurisdiction / so those which do appertain unto the church / they do turn from their lawful institution / unto other ends not sufferable / which M. doctor him self doth confess in excommunicating for money. &c.
Thirdly / as they handle matters whych do not appertain vnto the Ecclesiasticall iurisdiction / so those whych do appertaine vnto the church / they do turne from their lawfull institution / vnto other ends not sufferable / whych M. doctor hym selfe doth confesse in excommunicating for money. &c.
Last of all they take upon them those things / which are neither lawful for civill nor ecclesiastical jurisdiction / nor simply for any man to do / of which sort divers are reckoned up by the admonition / and same confessed by M. Doctor. I will not here speak of the unfitness of those which are chief officers in these courts / that the most of them are either papists / or bribers / or drunkards / (I know what I write) or epicures and such as live of benefices and prebends in England or in Ireland / doing nothing of those things which appertain unto them / and of other such naughty persons which are not only not meet to be governors in the church / but which in any reformed church / should not be so much as of the church. I speak not of all / I doubt not but there be some do ye which they do of conscience / and with mind to help forward the Church / which I trust will (when the Lord shall give them more knowledge) keep them selves in their vocations / and being men for their gifts apt and able either to serve the Church or the common wealth in some other calling / will rather occupy their gifts there / then where they have no ground to assure them selves / that they do please God. Now I will take a short survey of that which M. doctor allegeth to prove his offices of master of faculties / chancellors. &c. First he saith in the. 117 page out of the Ancyran council / that there were vicars of bishops / where although y• name be not found of chancellors. &c. yet there is (saith he) the office. What vicar s. Pauls B. may have / and in what case / I have showed before / where I have proved the necessary residence of every pastor in his flock. But I will note here ⟨p. 189⟩how M. Doctor both go about to abuse his reader in these vicars. And first where there were three editions / of which one only maketh mention of these vicars he took that & left the other / which is to be observed / for that this variety of editions rose of the divers understanding of the greek word (chorepiscopos,) which may be taken either for him that is bishop for an other / and in his place / or for him that is bishop in the country / that is in some town which is no city / so that chorepiscopus, was opposed unto the bishop which was of some city. And if it be so taken / then here is no proof for the vicars of bishops.
Last of all they take vpon them those thyngs / whych are neyther lawful for ciuill nor ecclesiasticall iurisdiction / nor simply for any man to doe / of whych sorte diuers are reckened vp by the admonition / and same confessed by M. Doctor. I will not heere speake of the vnfitnes of those whych are chefe offycers in these courts / that the most of them are eyther papists / or bribers / or drunkardes / (I know what I wryte) or epicures and such as liue of benefices and prebends in England or in Ireland / doing nothing of those things whych appertaine vnto them / and of other suche naughty persons whych are not only not meete to be gouernors in the church / but whych in any reformed church / shoulde not be so much as of the church. I speake not of all / I doubt not but there be some do ye whych they do of conscience / and with minde to healpe forwarde the Churche / whych I trust will (when the Lorde shall giue them more knowledge) keepe them selues in their vocations / and being men for their giftes apte and able either to serue the Church or the common wealth in some other calling / will rather occupye theyr gifts there / then where they haue no grounde to assure them selues / that they doe please God. Now I will take a short suruey of that whych M. doctor alleageth to proue his offices of master of faculties / chancellors. &c. First he sayth in ye. 117 page out of the Ancyran councel / yt there were vicars of bishops / wher although y name be not foūd of chācclors. &c. yet there is (sayth he) the office. What vicar s. Paules B. may haue / and in what case / I haue shewed before / where I haue proued the necessary residence of euery pastor in his flock. But I will note heere
But howsoever it be / it shall appear that the names of chancellors and / chorepiscopos, do not so much differ / as the offices and functions of them. For it appeareth in the same Council and Canon / that they were like the. 70. disciples / that they had also some care to provide for the poor / and that they were such as did minister the sacraments. And in an other Council / they have authority given them to 1make subdeacons / exorcists / and readers. I know this was a corruption of the ministry / but yet all men see / how Master Doctor looketh as it were a far of upon things / and therefore taketh a man for a molehill / when he would make us believe that these were chancellors. &c.
But howsoeuer it be / it shall appeare that the names of chauncelors and / chorepiscopos, doe not so much differ / as the offices and functions of them. For it appeareth in the same Councell and Canon / that they were like the. 70. disciples / that they had also some care to prouide for the poore / and that they were such as dyd mynister the sacramentes. And in an other Councell / they haue authoritie geuen them to 1make subdeacons / exorcists / and readers. I know thys was a corruption of the mynistery / but yet all men see / how Maister Doctor looketh as it were a farre of vpon things / and therefore taketh a man for a molehill / when he would make vs beleeue that these were chauncelors. &c.
In the. 125. page to the admonition desiring that these may be removed and the eldership established according to Gods order / M. Doctor answereth / that that were to place in stead of wise and discrete men / unlearned / ignorant and unapt to rule. Let Master Doctor take heed / least in allowing so well of the popish ceremonies / not only as tolerable / but as fit / and then acquainting him self with the papists manner of speaking / in saying that the people be ignorant and unlearned / he fall or over he be aware into some worse thing. Moses in Deuteronomy / 1and Solomon in his proverbs / place the principal wisdom in keeping Gods commandments and in fearing God. And David sayeth / that the secretes and the privy counsel of the Lord / is known to those which fear him / and I have showed out of S. Paul / that he giveth to the spiritual man great 2discretion and judgement of things. If therefore there be in every church which fear God and keep his commandments / there are both wise and learned & discrete men / and therefore not to be spoken of so contemptuously as M. Doctor speaketh. And God be praised there are numbers in the church / that are able to be teachers unto most of the chancellors / in any matter pertaining to the church / and are able to give a riper judgement in any ecclesiastical matter / then the most part of them can.
In the. 125. page to the admonition desyring that these may be remoued and the eldershyp establyshed according to Gods order / M. Doctor aunswereth / that that were to place in stede of wise and discrete men / vnlearned / ignorant and vnapt to rule. Let Maister Doctor take heede / least in alowing so well of the popishe ceremonies / not only as tollerable / but as fitte / and then acquainting hym selfe with the papistes maner of speaking / in saying that the people be ignoraunt and vnlearned / he fal or ouer he be aware into some worse thing. Moses in Deuteronomie / 1and Salomon in hys prouerbes / place the principall wisedome in keeking Gods commaundementes and in fearing God. And Dauid sayeth / that the secretes and the priuy councell of the Lord / is knowen to those which feare hym / and I haue shewed out of S. Paule / that he geueth to the spirituall man great 2discretion and iudgement of things. If therefore there be in euery church which feare God and keepe hys commaundementes / there are both wise and learned & discrete men / and therefore not to be spoken of so contemptuously as M. Doctor speaketh. And God be praysed there are numbers in the church / that are hable to be teachers vnto most of the chauncelors / in any matter perteyning to the church / and are hable to geue a ryper iudgement in any ecclesiastical matter / then the most part of them can.
And besides that the choicest are to be taken to this office / this ought not to be forgotten / that seeing good success of things depend upon the blessing of God / and that blessing followeth the church when the Lords order is kept / simple men which carry no great countenance or show / will undoubtedly do more good unto the church / having a lawful calling / then those of great port which have no such calling.
And besides that the choysest are to be taken to thys office / thys ought not to be forgotten / that seeing good successe of thinges depend vppon the blessing of God / and that blessing followeth the church when the Lordes order is kept / simple men which carry no great countenaunce or shew / will vndoubtedly doe more good vnto the church / hauing a lawfull calling / then those of great port whiche haue no such calling.
In the. 228. page he thinketh the Archbishops Court necessary / but bringeth no reason / and further confesseth him self ignorant of the estate of it / and therefore I know not from whence that good opinion of his should come / onlesse it be from thence that he liketh of all things be they never so evil which the admonition missyketh. The rest which M. D. hath of this matter is nothing else but great and high words. And as for the Canon law / it is known what a stroke it beareth with us / and that a few cases excepted it remaineth in her former effect.
In the. 228. page he thinketh the Archbyshoppes Courte necessary / but bringeth no reason / and further confesseth hym selfe ignoraunt of the estate of it / and therefore I know not from whence that good opynion of hys shoulde come / onlesse it be from thence that he lyketh of all things be they neuer so euill whych the admonition missyketh. The rest which M. D. hath of thys matter is nothing else but great and high wordes. And as for the Canon law / it is knowen what a stroke it beareth with vs / and that a few cases excepted it remayneth in her former effect.
It was before showed that of the governors of the church / there were some ⟨p. 190⟩whose charge pertained unto the whole church / of the which we have spoken: some other / whose charges extend but to a part of the church / that is unto the poor / and these are the deacons. And as in the former part I showed there were two kinds / so in this latter part the same is to be noted / that of those whose charge was over the poor / some had charge over all the poor of the church (as those which are called deacons) some had charge over the poor strangers / and those poor which were sick only / and those S. Paul calleth in one place Deaconesses / and in an other place widows. For the deacons did distribute unto the necessities as well of the poor strangers and the sick poor / as unto the other 1poor of the church. And the widows did employ their labours to the washing of the feet of the strangers / and attending upon the poor which were sick / and had no friends to keep them. First I will speak of the deacons / & whereas M. Doctor crieth out of dallying with the scriptures / for alleging the. 8. verse of the twelfth unto the Romans / to prove deacons / affirming that there is no word of them: Truly I can find no words to set forth this so gross ignorance. And had it not been enough for M. Doctor to have uttered this ignorance / but he must also with an outcry proclaim it / and as it were spread the banner of it? What do these words note (he that distributeth in simplicity) but the office of the deaconship. For in that place S. Paul reckoneth up all the ordinary and perpetual offices of the church / as the office of the doctor / of the pastor / of the deacon / of the elder / and leaveth not out so much as the widow / which he comprehendeth in these words (showing mercy). If the authors of the Admonition do daily with the scriptures in this place / surely Master Calvin / M / Beza / M. Bucer / Peter Martyr. &c. do dally with them. And shall all these be esteemed to play with the scriptures / and M. Doctor only to handle them seriously? And as M. Doctors ignorance appeareth in this place / so his mind not desirous of the truth / but seeking to cavil / doth as manifestly show it self.
It was before shewed that of the gouernoures of the church / there were some ⟨p. 190⟩whose charge pertayned vnto the whole church / of the which we haue spoken: some other / whose charges extend but to a part of the church / that is vnto the poore / and these are the deacons. And as in the former part I shewed there were two kindes / so in this latter part ye same is to be noted / that of those whose charge was ouer the poore / some had charge ouer all the poore of the church (as those which are called deacons) some had charge ouer the poore straungers / and those poore which were sicke only / and those S. Paule calleth in one place Dyaconisses / and in an other place widdowes. For the deacons dyd distribute vnto the necessyties as well of the poore straungers and the sicke poore / as vnto the other
For all men see / that the admonition allegeth not the place to the Thessalonians to prove the office of deacons / but to show that idle vagabonds might not have any of that relief / which belongeth unto those which be poor in deed / which thing appeareth both by the placing of the quotation over against that allegation / & by the letter which directeth thereunto. And whereas M. Doctor saith / that the office of the deacons is not only to provide for the poor / but also to preach and minister the sacraments / I have showed before / that it doth not appertain unto them / to do either the one or the other. For the proof whereof / this place of the Romans quoted by the admonition / is very fit & most proper. For S. Paul speaketh there against those which not contenting themselves with their own vocations / did break into that which appertained unto others / as if the hand should take upon it the office of the eye / or of some other member of the body / & therefore S. Paul doth (as it were) bound & point the limits of every office in the church / & so placeth the deacons office only in the provision for the poor. This one thing I will add to that matter / that if the apostles which had such excellent and passing gifts / did find them selves (preaching of the word / and attending to prayer) not able to provide for the poor / but thought it necessary to discharge them selves of that office / to the end they might do the other effectually and fruitfully / he that shall do both now / must either do none well and profitably / or else he must have greater gifts then the Apostles had.
For all men see / that the admonition alledgeth not the place to the Tessalonians to proue the office of deacons / but to shew that idle vagavondes might not haue any of that reliefe / which belongeth vnto those which bee poore in deede / which thing appeareth both by the placing of the quotation ouer agaynst that allegation / & by the letter which directeth therunto. And whereas M. Doctor sayth / that the office of the deacons is not only to prouide for the poore / but also to preach and mynister the sacramentes / I haue shewed before / that it doth not appertayne vnto them / to doe eyther the one or the other. For the proofe whereof / thys place of the Romaines quoted by the admonition / is very fit & most proper. For S. Paule speaketh there agaynst those which not contenting themselues with their owne vocatiōs / dyd breake into that which appertayned vnto others / as if the hand should take vpon it the office of the eye / or of some other member of the body / & therfore S. Paule doth (as it were) bound & point the limites of euery office in ye church / & so placeth the deacons office only in the preuysion for the poore. Thys one thing I will adde to that matter / that if the apostles whiche hadde suche excellent and passing gyftes / dyd fynde them selues (preaching of the woorde / and attending to prayer) not able to prouyde for the poore / but thought it necessarye to dyscharge them selues of that offyce / to the ende they myght doe the other effectually and fruitefully / hee that shall doe both now / must eyther doe none well and profitably / or else hee must haue greater giftes then the Apostles had.
The second point is touching that there were deacons in every church / which is well proved of the admonition / both by the place of the Philippians / and of the Acts / for although it be not there said / that the deacons were in every church / yet for so much as the same use of them was in all churches which was in Jerusalem & at Philippos / and for that the Apostles (as hath been before ⟨p. 191⟩touched) labouring after the uniformity of the church / ordained the same officers in all churches / the proof of one is the proof of all / and the showing that there were deacons in one church / is the showing in all. The place which they allege out of the first to Timothy / is of all other most proper: for S. Paul there describing not how the church of Ephesus / but simply and generally how the church must be governed / reckoneth there the order of deacons. Whereunto may be added the continual practise of the church long after the Apostles times / which appeareth by the often superscriptions and subscriptions in these words (the bishop / elders / and deacons of such a church / and unto the bishop / elders / and deacons of such a church). And by that it is so often times said in the councils where the churches assembled / y• there were so many bishops / so many elders / so many deacons.
The seconde poynt is touching that there were deacons in euery churche / which is well proued of the admonition / both by the place of the Phillippyans / and of the Actes / for although it be not there sayd / that the deacons were in euery church / yet for so muche as the same vse of them was in all churches which was in Ierusalem & at Philippos / and for that the Apostles (as hath bene before ⟨p. 191⟩touched) laboring after the vniformitie of the church / ordeyned the same officers in all churches / the proofe of one is the proofe of all / and the shewing that there were deacōs in one church / is ye shewing in all. The place which they alledge out of the first to Timothe / is of all other most proper: for S. Paule there describing not how the church of Ephesus / but simply and generally how the church must be gouerned / reckneth there the order of deacons. Whereunto may be added the contynuall practise of the church long after the Apostles times / which appeareth by the often superscriptions and subscriptions in these words (the byshop / elders / and deacons of such a church / and vnto the byshop / elders / and deacons of such a church). And by that it is so often times sayd in the councelles where the churches assembled / y there were so many byshops / so many elders / so many deacons.
The third point in this deaconship is / whether it be a necessary office in the church / or for a time only / which controversy should not have been / if M. Doctors english tong had been agreeable with his latin. For in a certain latin pamphlet of his / whereof I spake before / he maketh the deaconship a necessary office / and such as ought not to be taken out of the church: here he singeth another song. There / because he thought the necessity of the deacon made for him / he would needs have deacons: here because it maketh against him he saith there is no need of them / whereby appeareth how small cause there is / that M. Doctor should upbraid the authors of the admonition with mutability and discord with them selves. But that this office is durable and perpetual / it may appear by that which I have alleged before out of the sixth of Timothy / for the necessity of elders: for the arguments serve to prove the necessity of those orders which are there set forth / whereof the deacon is one. And where as M. Doctor saith that every church is not able to find a curate (as he termeth him) and a deacon / I have before showed / entreating of the seniors / that the churches in the Apostles times / might best have said this / being poor and persecuted / although I see not why the church may not have a deacon or deacons (if moe be needful) with as small charges as they may have a collector or collectors.
The thirde poynt in thys deaconship is / whether it be a necessary office in the church / or for a tyme only / which controuersy shoulde not haue bene / if M. Doctors english tong had bene agreable with hys latin. For in a certayne latin pamphlet of hys / whereof I spake before / he maketh the deaconship a necessary office / and such as ought not to be taken out of the church: here he singeth a nother song. There / because he thought the necessitie of the deacon made for hym / he wold nedes haue deacons: here because it maketh agaynst hym he sayth there is no neede of them / wherby appeareth how small cause there is / that M. Doctor should vpbrayde the authors of the admonition with mutability and discord with them selues. But that thys office is durable and perpetuall / it may appeare by that which I haue alledged before out of the sixt of Timothe / for the necessitie of elders: for the argumentes serue to proue the necessitie of those orders which are there set forth / whereof the deacon is one. And where as M. Doctor sayth that euery church is not hable to fynde a curate (as he termeth hym) and a deacon / I haue before shewed / intreating of the senyors / that the churches in the Apostles tymes / might best haue sayd thys / being poore and persecuted / althoughe I see not why the church may not haue a deacon or deacons (if moe be needefull) with as small charges as they may haue a collector or collectors.
There remaineth to speak of the widows / which were godly poor women in the church above the age of. 60. years / for the avoiding of all suspicion 1of evil which might rise by slanderous tongues / if they had been younger. These as they were nourished at the charges of the church being poor / so did they serve the church in attending upon poor strangers and the poor which were sick in the church / whereof they were widows. Now although there is not so great use of these widows with us / as there was in those places where the churches were first founded / and in that time wherein this order of widows was instituted / part of the which necessity grew both by the multitude of strangers through the persecution / & by the great heat of those east countries / whereupon the washing & supplying of their feet was required: yet for so much as there are poor which are sick in every church / I do not see how a better and more convenient order can be devised / for the attendance of them in their sickness & other infirmities / then this which S. Paul appointeth / that there should be (if there can be any gotten) godly poor widows of the age which S. Paul appointeth / which should attend upon such. For if there be any such poor widows of that age destitute of all friends / it is manifest that they must needs live of the charge of the church / & seeing they must needs do so / it is better they should do some duty for it unto the church again / than the church should be at a new charge to find others to attend upon those which are sick & destitute of keepers / seeing that there can be none so fit for that purpose as those women / which S. Paul doth there describe: so that I conclude that (if such may be gotten) we ought also to keep that order of widows in the church still. I know y• there be learned men which think otherwise / but I stand upon the authority of Gods word / and not upon the ⟨p. 192⟩opinions of men be they never so well learned. And if the matter also should be tried by the judgement of men I am able to show the judgement of as learned as this age hath brought forth / which thinketh that the institution of widows is perpetual / and ought to be where it may be had / and where such widows are found. In deed they are more rare now then in the Apostles times:
There remayneth to speake of the widdowes / which were godly poore women in the church aboue the age of. 60. yeares / for the auoyding of all suspition
For then by reason of the persecution / those which had the gift of continency / did abstain from marriage after the death of their husbands / for that the sole life was an easier estate and less dangerous and chargeable when they were driven to fly / then the estate of those which were married. Unto all the rest until the end of the first part of the admonition I have answered already. Yet there is a point or two / which I must touch whereof the first is in the. 126. page / where he would bear men in hand / that the authors of the admonition and some other of their mind / would shut out the civil magistrate and the Prince / from all authority in Ecclesiastical matters / which surmise although I see it is not so much because either he knoweth or suspecteth any such thing / as because he meaneth hereby to lay a bait to entrap with all / thinking that where he maketh no conscience to give he careth not what authority to Princes / we will be loth to give more then the word of God will permit / whereby he hopeth to draw us into displeasure with the Prince: yet for because he shall understand / we nourish no opinions secretly which we are ashamed to declare openly / and for that we doubt not of the equity of the prince in this part / which knoweth that although her authority be the greatest in the earth yet it is not infinite / but is limited by the word of God / and of whom we are persuaded that as her majesty knoweth / so she will not unwillingly hear the truth in this behalf / these things I say being considered / I answer in the name of the authors of the admonition / and those some other which you speak of / that the Prince and civil magistrate hath to see / that the laws of God touching his worship / and touching all matters and orders of the church be executed & duly observed / & to see that every Ecclesiastical person do that office whereunto he is appointed / and to punish those which fail in their office accordingly. As for the making of the orders & ceremonies of the church / they do (where there is a constituted and ordered church) pertain unto the ministers of the church and to the ecclesiastical governors / and that as they meddle not with the making of civil laws and laws for the common wealth: so the civil magistrate hath not to ordain ceremonies pertaining to the church.
For then by reason of the persecution / those which had the gift of continency / dyd abstayne from mariage after the death of their husbandes / for that the sole lyfe was an easyer estate and lesse daungerous and chargeable when they were driuen to flye / then the estate of those which were maryed. Vnto all the rest vntill the ende of the first part of the admonition I haue answered alredy. Yet there is a poynt or two / which I must touch wherof the first is in the. 126. page / where he would beare men in hand / that the authors of the admonition and some other of theyr mynde / would shut out the cyuill magistrate and the Prince / from all authoritie in Ecclesiastical matters / which surmise although I see it is not so much because eyther he knoweth or suspecteth any such thing / as because he meaneth heereby to lay a bayte to entrappe with all / thinking that where he maketh no conscience to geue he careth not what authority to Princes / we will be loth to geue more then the word of God will permit / wherby he hopeth to draw vs into displeasure with the Prince: yet for because he shall vnderstande / we norish no opynions secretly which we are ashamed to declare openly / and for that we doubt not of the equitie of the prince in thys part / which knoweth that although her authoritie be the greatest in the earth yet it is not infinite / but is lymitted by the word of God / and of whome we are perswaded that as her maiesty knoweth / so shee will not vnwillingly heare the truth in thys behalfe / these things I say being considered / I answere in the name of the authors of the admonition / and those some other which you speake of / that the Prince and cyuill magistrate hath to see / that the lawes of God touching hys worshippe / and touching all matters and orders of the church be executed & dewly obserued / & to se that euery Ecclesiasticall person do that office whereunto he is appoynted / and to punish those which fayle in their office accordingly. As for the making of the orders & cerimonyes of the church / they doe (where there is a constituted and ordered church) pertayne vnto the mynisters of the church and to the ecclesiastycall gouernoures / and that as they meddle not with the making of cyuill lawes and lawes for the common wealth: so the cyuill magistrate hath not to ordayne cerimonies pertayning to the churche.
But if those to whom that doth appertain / make any orders not meet / the magistrate may and ought to hinder them / and drive them to better / for so much as the civill magistrate hath this charge to see that nothing be done against the glory of God in his dominion.
But if those to whome that doth appertayne / make any orders not meete / the magistrate may and ought to hynder them / and dryue them to better / for so much as the ciuill magistrate hath thys charge to see that nothing be done agaynst the glory of God in hys domynion.
This distinction if M. Doctor knoweth not / nor hath not heard of / let him look in the. 2. book of the Chronicles / he shall see / that there were a number appointed 1for the matters of the Lord / which were priests and levites / and there were other also appointed for the Kings affairs and for matters of the common wealth / amongst which were the Levites / which being more in number then could be applied to the use of the church / were set over civil causes / being therefore most fit / for that they were best learned in the laws of God / which were the politic laws of that country. There he may learn if it please him / that the making of orders and giving of judgements in civil and Ecclesiastical / in common wealth and church matters / pertained unto divers persons / which distinction the writer to the Hebrews doth note / when he sayeth that the 2Priest was ordained in things pertaining to God.
Thys distinction if M. Doctor knoweth not / nor hath not heard of / let him looke in the. 2. booke of the Chronicles / he shall see / that there were a number appoynted 1for the matters of the Lord / which were priestes and leuites / and there were other also appoynted for the Kinges affaires and for matters of the common wealth / amongst which were the Leuites / which being more in number then coulde be applyed to the vse of the churche / were set ouer cyuill causes / being therefore most fit / for that they were best learned in the lawes of God / which were the politicke lawes of that countrey. There he may learne if it please hym / that the making of orders and geuing of iudgementes in cyuill and Ecclesiasticall / in common wealth and church matters / pertayned vnto dyuers persons / which distinction the wryter to the Hebrewes doth note / when he sayeth that the 2Priest was ordayned in things pertayning to God.
This might Master Doctor have learned by that which the noble emperor 1* Constantine attributeth to the fathers of the Nicene council and to the Ecclesiastical persons there gathered: which he doth also permit the Bishops / ⟨p. 193⟩Elders / and Deacons of churches to do / either by correcting or adding / or making new if need be. And by the continual practise of the church in the time of christian Emperors / which always permitted unto the ministers assembled in 2councils / as well the determination of controversies which rose / as the making or the abolishing of needful or hurtful ceremonies / as the case required. Also by the Emperors epistle in the first action of the council of Constantinople where by the epistle of the Emperor it appeareth / that it was the manner of 3the Emperors to confirm the ordinances which were made by the ministers / and to see them kept. The practise of this he might have also most plainly seen in Ambrose / who would by no means suffer that the causes of the churches should be debated in the Princes consistory or court / but would have them handled in the church / by those that had the government of the church: and therefore excuseth him self to the emperor Valentinian / for that (being convented to answer of the church matters / unto the civill court) he came not. And by whom can the matters and orders of the church be better ordained / then by the ministers of the church? And if that be a good reason of Master Doctor in the forty and seventh page / that the Bishops ought therefore to ordain ministers / because they are best able to judge of the learning and ability / of those which are the fittest / it is also as good reason / that therefore the ministers and governors of the church should appoint and decree of such ceremonies and orders as pertain to the church / for because it is to be supposed that they can best judge of those matters / bestowing their studies that ways / and further best understanding the estate of the church about the which they are wholly occupied. And this is not (Master Doctor) to shake hands with the papists. For the papists would exempt their priests from the subjection / and from the punishment of the civil magistrate / which we do not.
And the papists would that whatsoever the clergy doth determine / that that forthwith should be holden for good / and the Prince should be forthwith compelled to maintain and set forth that / be it good or evil / without further inquiry: but we say that if there be no lawful ministry to set good orders (as in ruinous decays and overthrows of religion) that then the Prince ought to do it: and if (when there is a lawful ministry) it shall agree of any unlawful or unmeet order / that the Prince ought to stay that order / and not to suffer it / but to drive them to that which is lawful and meet. And if this be to shake hands with the papists / then Master Doctor is to blame / which hath taught us once or twice before / that the appointing of ceremonies of the church / belongeth unto the church. And yet I know that there is one or two of the later writers / that think otherwise / but as I take no advantage of their authority which think as I do / so I ought not to be prejudiced by those / that think otherwise. But for so much as we have M. Doctor yet of this judgement / that the church ceremonies should be ordained by the church / I will travail no further in this matter / considering that the practise of this church commonly is to refer these matters unto the ecclesiastical persons: only this is the difference / that where it is done now of one or a few / we desire that it may be done by others also / who have interest in that behalf.
And the papistes would that whatsoeuer the cleargy doth determyne / that that forthwith should be holden for good / and the Prince should be forthwith compelled to mayntayne and set forth that / bee it good or euill / without further inquiry: but wee say that if there bee no lawfull mynistery to set good orders (as in rumous decayes and ouerthrowes of relygion) that then the Prince ought to doe it: and if (when there is a lawfull mynistery) it shall agree of any vnlawfull or vnmeete order / that the Prince ought to stay that order / and not to suffer it / but to driue them to that which is lawfull and meete. And if thys be to shake handes with the papistes / then Maister Doctor is to blame / which hath taught vs once or twise before / that the appoynting of ceremonies of the church / belongeth vnto the church. And yet I know that there is one or two of the later wryters / that thinke otherwise / but as I take no aduauntage of their authoritie which thinke as I doe / so I ought not to be preiudiced by those / that thinke otherwise. But for so much as we haue M. Doctor yet of thys iudgement / that the church ceremonies shoulde bee ordayned by the church / I will trauaile no further in thys matter / consydering that the practise of thys church commonly is to referre these matters vnto the ecclesiasticall persons: only thys is the difference / that where it is done now of one or a few / wee desire that it may be done by others also / who haue interest in that behalfe.
The other point is in the hundred thirty and eight page / where he most untruly and slanderously chargeth the authors of the Admonition / and maketh wonderful outcries of them / as though they should deny that there had been any reformation at all / sithens the time that the Queens majesty began to reign / manifestly contrary / not only to their meaning / but also to their very words / which appeareth in that they move to a thorough reformation / & to contend / or to labour to perfection / denying only that the reformation which hath been made in her majesties days / is thorough and perfect. We confess willingly / that next unto the Lord God / every one of us is most deeply bound unto ⟨p. 194⟩her majesty / whom he hath used as an excellent instrument to deliver his church here / out of the spiritual Egypt of popery / and the common wealth also / and the whole land out of the slavery and subjection of strangers / whereunto it was so near: This I say we willingly confess before men / and do in our prayers daily give most humble thanks to God therefore.
The other poynt is in the hundreth thirty and eyght page / where hee most vntruely and slaunderously chargeth the authors of the Admonition / and maketh wonderfull outcryes of them / as though they should deny that there hadde beene any reformation at all / sythens the tyme that the Queenes maiestye began to raigne / manyfestly contrary / not onely to theyr meaning / but also to theyr very words / which appeareth in that they moue to a thorough reformation / & to contende / or to labour to perfection / denying only that the reformation which hath bene made in her maiesties dayes / is thorough and perfect. We confesse willingly / that next vnto the Lorde God / euery one of vs is most deepely bounde vnto ⟨p. 194⟩her maiesty / whome he hath vsed as an excellent instrument to delyuer his church heere / out of the spirituall Egipt of popery / and the common wealth also / and the whole lande out of the slauery and subiection of straungers / whereunto it was so neare: Thys I say we willingly confesse before men / and do in our prayers dayly geue most humble thankes to God therefore.
And by this humble suit and earnest desire which we have for further reformation / we are so far from unthankfulness unto her majesty / that we thereby desire the heap of her felicity / & the establishment of her royal throne amongst us / which then shall be most sure and unremoved / when our saviour Christ sitteth wholly and fully / not only in his chair to teach / but also in his throne to rule / not alone in the hearts of every one by his spirit / but also generally / and in the visible government of his church by those laws of discipline / which he hath prescribed.
And by thys humble sute and earnest desire whiche wee haue for further reformation / we are so far from vnthankfulnes vnto her maiesty / that we thereby desire the heape of her felicitie / & the establishment of her royal throne amongst vs / which then shall be most sure and vnremoued / when our sauiour Christ sytteth wholy and fully / not only in hys chayre to teach / but also in hys throne to rule / not alone in the heartes of euery one by hys spirite / but also generally / and in the visible gouernment of hys church by those lawes of discipline / whiche hee hath prescribed.
And whereas M. Doctor would bring us into a foolish paradise of our selves / as though we need not to learn any thing at the churches of France & Scotland / he should have understanded / that as we have been unto them in example / & have provoked them to follow us / so the Lord will have us also profit / and be provoked by their example / and so be mutual helps one to an other / and stir up our selves with the admonition that our saviour Christ stirred up his apostles / that oftentimes those that are first / are not forwardest / but are overrun 1of others that come after. And whereas he would privily pinch at the reformation there / for so much as the Lord hath humbled the one / and exerciseth the other by civil wars and troubles / he should have in stead of rocking us a sleep in our security / put us in remembrance of Gods scourges which hang over us / and of Gods great patience that still tarrieth for our repentance / and that if he have punished that people of his which have suffered so much for the profession of the Gospel / and which went with so straight a foot in it / with an universal hazard of their goods and lives / that we shall not escape unless we repent speedily of our coldness and halting in religion / and unwillingness / I will not say to hazard to put our lives in danger / but not to leese some of our wealth and honour / for the obtaining of a through reformation of the church / and advancement of the glory of the Lord.
And whereas M. Doctor woulde bring vs into a foolish paradise of oure selues / as though we neede not to learne any thing at the churches of Fraunce & Scotland / he should haue vnderstanded / that as we haue bene vnto them in example / & haue prouoked them to follow vs / so the Lord will haue vs also profite / and be prouoked by their example / and so be mutuall helpes one to an other / and stirre vp our selues with the admonition that our sauiour Christ stirred vp hys apostles / that oftentimes those that are first / are not forwardest / but are ouerrun 1of others that come after. And whereas he would priuely pinch at the reformation there / for so much as the Lord hath humbled the one / and exerciseth the other by cyuill warres and troubles / he should haue in steade of rocking vs a sleepe in our securitie / put vs in remembraunce of Gods scourges which hang ouer vs / and of Gods great pacience that still taryeth for our repentaunce / and that if hee haue punyshed that people of hys which haue suffered so much for the profession of the Gospell / and which went with so strayght a foote in it / with an vniuersall hazarde of their goodes and lyues / that wee shall not escape vnlesse wee repent spedely of our coldnes and halting in relygion / and vnwillingnes / I will not say to hazarde to put our lyues in daunger / but not to leese some of our wealth and honor / for the obtayning of a through reformation of the churche / and aduauncement of the glory of the Lord.
Finally / he would rather have put us in remembrance of the sermon which our saviour Christ maketh / where he showeth that those cities are not always 1the greatest sinners / or those whom God is most angry with / which have the heaviest judgements executed upon them / but that thereby the Lord calleth us to repentance / otherwise that we shall likewise perish. This had been more fit forourestate to have been said / then to have after a sort insulted upon the afflicted / & daubed up our eyes that we should not see our misery and our nakedness. In all the rest / M. Doctor hath nothing but words of reproach against the authors of the Admonition / and calling still as his manner is / for more punishment for them / which I will not bestow the answer of.
Finally / he would rather haue put vs in remembrance of the sermon which our sauiour Christ maketh / where he sheweth that those cyties are not alwares 1the greatest sinners / or those whome God is most angry with / which haue the heauiest iudgementes executed vpon them / but that thereby the Lord calleth vs to repentance / otherwyse that we shall lykewise pearish. Thys had bene more fit forourestate to haue bene sayd / then to haue after a sort insulted vpon the afflicted / & daubed vp our eyes that we should not see our mysery and our nakednes. In all the rest / M. Doctor hath nothing but wordes of reproch agaynst the authors of the Admonition / and calling still as hys manner is / for more punishment for them / which I will not bestow the answere of.
Sed etiam quodam in loco facetus esse voluisti, Deus bone, quam te illud non decet.
Here M. Doctor was disposed to make him self and his reader merry / but it is with the bagpipe or country mirth / not with the Harp or Lute / which the learned were wont to handle. For he hath packed up together the old tale of the curst wife / and of the thief that toke away the priests purse / very familiar & homely gear: It might peradventure make M. Doctor hop about the house / but the learned & the wise can not dance by this instrument. It pleaseth M. Doctor to compare those which be put out of their livings without just cause / to heretics / curst wives / and to thieves / but all men do understand how rightly. ⟨p. 195⟩What his troubles be within / and in his conscience / the Lord God and he knoweth best / but as for the outward persecution which he suffereth / it is not such / as he need thus to stoop or to groan / and to blow underneath it / as though he had some great burden upon his shoulders. And if he complain of the persecution of the tong / to let pass his immoderate heat of speech / which he useth with those that he hath to do with all / the tong which is more intemperate then his is in all his book / shall hardly be found. And although it be unreasonable enough / that he should not give men leave to complain of their troubles / when he glorieth in troubling them / yet that of all is most untollerable / that besides the injury which he doth them / he is angry ye they will not lay hands of them selves by casting them selves out of their livings / or ever they be cast out by him. Tully maketh mention of one C. Fimbria / which when he had caused Q. Scelova a singular in ā to be wounded / & saw that he dyed not of it / convented him before the judges / & being asked what he had to accuse him of / answered / for that he did not suffer the whole weapon wherewith he was stricken / to enter into his body: even so M. Doctor contenteth not him self only to do injuries unto men / but accuseth them also / that they will not do it unto them selves / or that they would not willingly suffer his weapons enter so far as he would have them. What conscience is there that bindeth a man to depart from his living / in that place where he liketh not of all the orders which are there used?
Heere M. Doctor was disposed to make hym selfe and hys reader mery / but it is with the bagpipe or countrey mirth / not with the Harpe or Lute / which the learned were wont to handle. For he hath packed vp together the olde tale of the curst wyfe / and of the theefe that toke away the priestes purse / very familiar & homely geare: It might peraduenture make M. Doctor hop about the house / but the learned & the wyse can not daunce by thys instrument. It pleaseth M. Doctor to compare those which be put out of their lyuings without iust cause / to heretickes / curst wiues / and to theeues / but all men do vnderstand how rightly.
is it not enough to abstain from them / if there be any evil in them / or to declare the unlawfulness of them / if his calling do suffer him / when as the reformation is not in his power. And if either of this abstaining or declaration of this unlawfulness of them / troubles be moved / there is no more cause why they should give place / then the other which like of those disorders / yea there is less cause / for that they are not the causes of trouble / but the other / and for that by their departure out of their places / room is made for those which will like of those disorders which the other misliked / which is to the hurt of that company or congregation in such places. And as for M. Doctors easiness to depart from his living / rather then he would cause any trouble / he giveth men great cause to doubt of / which having divers great livings / and amongst them a benefice is very loth to go from troubling of others / to do his duty at any of them. It is true / that the church of England may have an order whereunto it may justly require the subscription of the ministers in England: And so is it likewise untrue / that we desire that every one should have his own fancy / and live as him listeth / for we also desire an uniform order / but such and in such sort / as we have before declared. As for the old accusation of Anabaptism and confusion / it is answered before: therefore according to my promise / I will leave your words / and if you have any matter / I will speak to that.
is it not enough to abstayne from thē / if there be any euill in them / or to declare the vnlawfulnes of them / if hys calling do suffer hym / when as the reformation is not in hys power. And if eyther of this abstayning or declaration of thys vnlawfulnes of them / troubles be moued / there is no more cause why they should geue place / then the other which lyke of those disorders / yea there is lesse cause / for that they are not the causes of trouble / but the other / and for that by their departure out of theyr places / roume is made for those whiche will lyke of those disorders which the other mislyked / which is to the hurt of that company or congregation in such places. And as for M. Doctors easynes to depart from hys lyuing / rather then he would cause any trouble / hee geueth men great cause to doubt of / which hauing dyuers great lyuinges / and amongst them a benefice is very loth to goe from troubling of others / to doe hys duety at any of them. It is true / that the church of England may haue an order whereunto it may iustly require the subscription of the mynisters in Englande: And so is it likewyse vntrue / that we desire that euery one should haue hys own fansy / and lyue as hym listeth / for we also desire an vniforme order / but such and in such sort / as we haue before declared. As for the olde accusation of Anabaptisme and confusion / it is answeared before: therefore according to my promise / I will leaue your wordes / and if you haue any matter / I will speake to that.