pp. 203–2059 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
TO pas by the profane proverb here used / which matcheth mad men & women / & children together / most unseemly for a D. of divinity / especially handling divine matters: for the singing of psalms by course / and side after side / although it be very ancient / yet it is not commendable / and so much the more to be suspected / for that the devil hath gone about to get it so great authority / partly 1by deriving it from Ignatius time / and partly in making the world believe / that this came from heaven / and that the angels were heard to sing after this sort / which as it is a mere fable / so is it confuted by historiographers / whereof some ascribe the beginning of this to Damasus / some other unto Flavianus & Diodorus. From whence so ever it came / it can not be good / considering that when it is granted y• all the people may praise God (as it is in singing of psalms) there this ought not to be restrained unto a few / & where it is lawful both with hart and voice to sing the whole psalm / there it is not mete that they should sing but the one half with their heart and voice / and the other with their heart only. For where they may both with heart and voice sing / there the heart is not enough. Therefore besides the incommodity which cometh this way / in that being tossed after this sort / men can not understand what is song / these other two inconveniences come of this form of singing / and therefore is banished in all reformed churches.
TO pas by the prophane prouerbe here vsed / which matcheth mad men & women / & children togither / most vnsemely for a D. of diuinity / especially handling diuine matters: for the singing of psalmes by course / and side after side / although it be very auncient / yet it is not commēdable / and so much the more to be suspected / for that the deuil hath gone about to get it so great authority / partly 1by deriuing it from Ignatius time / and partly in making the world beleue / that thys came from heauen / and that the angels were heard to sing after thys sorte / whych as it is a mere fable / so is it confuted by hystoriographers / whereof some ascribe the begynning of thys to Damasus / some other vnto Flauianus & Diodorus. Frō whēce so euer it came / it can not be good / considering that when it is graūted y• all the people may praise God (as it is in singing of psalmes) there this ought not to be restrained vnto a few / & wher it is lawful both wt hart and voyce to sing the whole psalme / there it is not mete yt they should sing but the one halfe wyth their heart and voice / and the other with their heart only. For where they may both wyth heart and voice sing / there the heart is not enough. Therfore besides the incommodity whych commeth thys way / in that being tossed after thys sort / men can not vnderstande what is song / these other two inconueniences come of thys forme of singing / and therfore is banyshed in all reformed churches.
Unto two very good reasons which the admonition useth / to show the inconvenience of making courtesy / and standing at the name of Jesus / and at the gospel / rather then at other names of God / and the rest of the scripture: whereof the one is / that it is against decency and good order which is broken by scraping of the feet / and the other y• it may breed a dangerous opinion of the inequality either of the son of God with the other persons / or of the gospels with other scriptures / M. doctor saith y• it is an indifferent thing / and neither taketh away their reasons / nor setteth down any of his own: this is a slender defence. And it is no malicious dealing / to note those faults which are so general & so open / & yet notwt standing uncorrected or unreformed by those / by whom M. d. would make us believe / that the church is best governed. But I pray you tell me / why do you condemn the serving of two cures / ye allow the having of two benefices? If it be no fault to have two benefices / how is it one to have two cures? for the curate is better able to read his service in .ij. places / than the pastor to discharge his office in .ij. churches. As for the speech of the cathedral churches / either it is nothing / or else it is false. For if he say y• there is either in all those cathedral churches one / or in every of those. 12. churches one / which is able to confute papists. &c. what great thing saith he / which ⟨p. 204⟩sayeth no more of all these churches / then is to be found in one poor house of the university / whose rents are scarce three hundred pound by year? yea what hath he said of them which was not to be found in them even in Queens Mary's time / when there was yet some one almost in every Church / which for fear dissembling / was able notwithstanding to confute the Papists / Anabaptists / Puritans. And if he mean that in those .xij. houses / the worst of the Prebendaries are able to defend the truth against all Papists. &c. all men do know the untruth of it / so that although this sentence be very doubtfully put forth / yet how so ever it be taken / it is as M. Doctor hath rightly termed it / a mere brag.
Vnto two very good reasons whych the admonition vseth / to shewe the inconnenience of making curtesy / and stāding at the name of Iesus / and at the gospell / rather then at other names of God / and the rest of the scripture: wherof the one is / that it is against decencye and good order whych is broken by scraping of the feete / and the other y it may brede a dangerous opinion of the inequality either of the sonne of God with the other persons / or of the gospels wt other scriptures / M. doctor sayth y it is an indifferent thyng / and neyther taketh away their reasons / nor setteth down any of hys own: thys is a slēder defence. And it is no malicious dealing / to note those faults whych are so generall & so open / & yet notwt standing vncorrected or vnreformed by those / by whom M. d. wold make vs beleue / yt the church is best gouerned. But I pray you tel me / why do you cōdemn the seruing of two cures / ye alow the hauing of two benefices? If it be no fault to haue two benefices / how is it one to haue two cures? for ye curate is better able to read hys seruice in .ij. places / thē the pastor to discharge his office in .ij. churches. As for ye speche of ye cathedral churches / either it is nothing / or els it is fals. For if he say y ther is either in al those cathedral churches one / or in euery of those. 12. churches one / which is able to cōfute papists. &c. what great thing saith he / which
And yet I doubt not / and am well assured / that there be divers godly learned men which have livings in those places / but for all that they cease not therefore to be dens of loiterers and idle persons / whilst there are nourished there some which serve for no profitable use in the church (their offices being such as bring no commodity / but rather hurt / of which number certain are which the Admonition speaketh of in the. 224. page:) some other which having charges in other places under the colour of their prebends there / absent them selves from them: and that which they spoil and raven in other places / there they spend and make good cheer with / and therefore not without good cause called dens. Finally / there being nothing there / which might not be much better applied / and to the greater commodity of the church / whilst they might be turned into colleges / where young men might be brought up in good learning / & made fit for the service of the church and common wealth / the universities being not able to receive that number of scholars / wherewith their need may be supplied.
And yet I doubt not / and am well assured / that there be diuers godly learned men whych haue lyuings in those places / but for all that they cease not therefore to be dennes of loyterors and idle persones / whylest there are nouryshed there some whych serue for no profitable vse in the church (their offyces being suche as bryng no commoditye / but rather hurte / of whych numbre certen are whych the Admonition speaketh of in the. 224. page:) some other which hauing charges in other places vnder the coloure of their prebendes there / absent them selues from them: and that whych they spoyle and rauen in other places / there they spend and make good cheare wyth / and therfore not wythout good cause called dennes. Finally / there being nothyng there / whych might not be much better applied / and to the greater commodity of the churche / whylest they myght be turned into colledges / where yong men myght be brought vp in good learning / & made fitte for the seruice of the church and common wealthe / the vniuersities being not able to receyue that numbre of scholers / wherwyth their neede may be supplyed.
And where M. Doctor saith / that that which is spoken of the Queens majesties chapel / is worthy rather to be punished then confuted: if so be that these be abuses / the example of them in her majesties chapel / can not be but most dangerous / which with all humble submission and reverence / I beseech her majesty duly to consider.
And where M. Doctor sayth / that that whych is spoken of the Queenes maiestyes chappell / is worthy rather to be punyshed then confuted: if so be that these be abuses / the example of them in her maiesties chappell / can not be but most daungerous / whych wyth all humble submission and reuerence / I beseeche her maiesty duely to consider.
And as for the reasons which M. doctor bringeth to establish them in the 225. page / as that they are necessary (which he doth barely say) and that s. Aug. alloweth of a Dean / and that the authors of the Admonition are instruments of those which desire the spoil of them / and that a man may as well speak against universities & colleges / as against them / I have answered before / saving that it is to be feared / that colleges in universities (if M. doctor may work y• which he goeth about) will shortly be in little better case / then those cathedral churches / which not only by his own example / but with might and main / and all endeavour possible / goeth about to fill and fraught them with Non residences, and such as have charges of churches in other places: which do no good in the university / and partly are such as can do none / only are pernicious examples of riotous feasting and making great cheer / with the prays and spoils which they bring out of the country to the great hurt of the university presently / and utter ruin of it hereafter / onles speedy remedy be therefore provided. And where he saith it is not material / although these deans / vicedeanes / canons / petty canons / prebendaries. &c. come from the pope / it is as if he should say / that it skilleth not although they come out of the bottomless pit. For whatsoever cometh from the Pope which is Antichrist / cometh first from the devil: and where he addeth this condition (if it be good. &c.) in deed if of the eggs of a cockatrice can be made wholesome meat to feed with / or of a spiders web any cloth to cover with all / then also may the things that come from the Pope and the Devil / be good / profitable / and necessary unto the church. And where he sayeth that collegiate churches are of great auncientie / he proveth not the auncientie of the cathedral churches / onles he prove that cathedral and collegiate be all one. But I will not stick with him for so small a matter / & if our controversy were of the names of these churches ⟨p. 205⟩/ and not of the matter / I could be content to grant his cause in this point as good as antiquity without the word of God (which is nothing but rottenness) could make it. But for so much as those ancient collegiate churches were no more like unto these which we have now / then things most unlike:
And as for the reasons which M. doctor bringeth to establishe them in the 225. page / as that they are necessary (whych he doth barely say) and that s. Aug. alloweth of a Deane / and that the authors of the Admonition are instruments of those whych desire the spoile of them / and that a man may as well speake against vniuersities & colledges / as against them / I haue answeared before / sauing that it is to be feared / that colledges in vniuersities (if M. doctor may worke y which he goeth about) wil shortly be in little better case / then those cathedral churches / whych not only by hys own example / but wyth might and maine / and al endeuor possyble / goeth about to fill and fraught them wyth Non residences, and suche as haue charges of churches in other places: whych do no good in the vniuersitye / and partly are such as can do none / only are pernicious examples of riotous feasting and making greate cheare / wyth the prayes and spoyles whych they bryng out of the country to the great hurt of the vniuersity presently / and vtter ruine of it hereafter / onles spedy remedy be therfore prouided. And wher he sayth it is not material / although these deanes / vicedeanes / canons / peticanōs / prebēdaries. &c. come from the pope / it is as if he shoulde saye / that it skilleth not although they come out of the bottomles pit. For whatsoeuer commeth from the Pope which is Antichrist / commeth first from the deuill: and where he addeth thys condition (if it be good. &c.) in deede if of the egges of a cockatrice can be made holesome meate to feede with / or of a spiders webbe any cloth to couer with all / then also may the things that come from the Pope and the Deuill / be good / profitable / and necessary vnto the church. And where he sayeth that collegiate churches are of great auncientie / he proueth not the auncientie of the cathedrall churches / onles he proue that cathedrall and collegiate be all one. But I will not sticke wyth hym for so small a matter / & if our controuersy were of the names of these churches
our cathedral churches have not so much as this old worn cloak of antiquity / to hide their nakedness / and to keep out the shower. For the collegiate churches in times past were a senate Ecclesiastical / standing of godly learned ministers & elders / which governed and watched over that flock which was in the city or town where such churches were / and for that in such great cities and towns commonly there were the most learned pastors and ancients / therefore the towns and villages round about in hard and difficult causes / came and had their resolutions of their doubts at their hands: even as also the Lord commanded in Deuteronomy / that when there was any great matter in the country / which 1the Levites in matters pertaining to God / and the Judges in matters pertaining to the common wealth / could not discuss / that then they should come to Jerusalem / where there was a great number of Priests / Levites / and learned Judges / of whom they should have their questions dissolved / and this was the first use of collegiate churches. Afterward the honour which the smaller churches gave unto them / in asking them counsel / they took unto them selves / and that which they had by the courtesy and good will proceeding of a reverent estimation of them / they did not only take unto them of right / but also possessed them of all authority of hearing and determining any matters at all. And in the end they came to this which they are now / which is a company that have strange names and strange offices / unheard of of all the purer churches / of whom the greatest good that we can hope of is / that they do no harm. For although there be divers which do good / yet in respect that they be Deans / Prebendaries / Canons / Petty Canons. &c. for my part / I see no profit but hurt come to the church by them.
our cathedrall churches haue not so much as thys olde worne cloke of antiquity / to hide theyr nakednes / and to keepe out the shoure. For the collegiate churches in times past were a senate Ecclesiasticall / standing of godly learned mynisters & elders / which gouerned and watched ouer that flocke which was in the citie or towne where suche churches were / and for that in suche great cities and townes commonly there were the most learned pastors and auncientes / therefore the townes and villages rounde about in hard and difficult causes / came and had their resolutions of theyr doubtes at theyr handes: euen as also the Lord commaunded in Deuteronomie / that when there was any great matter in the countrey / which 1
And where he sayeth they are rewards of learning / in deed then they should be / if they were converted unto the maintenance and bringing up of scholars / where now for the most part / they serve for fat morsels to fill (if it might be) the greedy appetites of those / which otherwise have enough to live with / and for holes and dens to keep them in / which either are unworthy to be kept at the charge of the church / or else whose presence is necessary and dutiful in other places / and for the most part unprofitable there.
And where hee sayeth they are rewardes of learning / in deede then they should be / if they were conuerted vnto the mayntenance and bringing vp of scholers / where now for the most part / they serue for fat morsels to fill (if it might be) the gredy appetites of those / which otherwyse haue enough to lyue with / and for holes and dennes to keepe them in / which eyther are vnworthy to be kept at the charge of the church / or else whose presence is necessary and duetifull in other places / and for the most part vnprofitable there.
Last of all / whereas M. Doctor sayeth that we have not to follow other churches / but rather other churches to follow us / I have answered before / this only I add / y• they were not counted only false Prophets which taught corrupt doctrine / but those which made the people of God believe / that they were happy when they were not / and that their estate was very good / when it was corrupt. Of the which kind of false prophecy / Jeremiah especially doth complain. And 1therefore onles M. Doctor amend his speech / & leave this crying peace / peace / all is well / when there are so many things out of order / and that not by the judgement of the admonition & favourers thereof only / but even of all which are not willingly blind / I say if he do not amend these speeches / the crime of false prophesy will sit closer unto him / than he shall be ever able to shake of / in the terrible day of the lord.
Last of all / whereas M. Doctor sayeth that we haue not to follow other churches / but rather other churches to follow vs / I haue answeared before / thys only I adde / y• they were not counted only false Prophets which taught corrupt doctryne / but those which made the people of God beleeue / that they were happy when they were not / and that their estate was very good / when it was corrupt. Of the which kynde of false prophecie / Ieremy especially doth complayne. And 1therefore onles M. Doctor amend hys speach / & leaue thys crying peace / peace / all is wel / when there are so many things out of order / and that not by the iudgement of ye admonition & fauorers therof only / but euē of al which are not willingly blind / I say if he do not amend these speches / the crime of false prophesy will sit closer vnto him / thē he shalbe euer able to shake of / in the terrible day of the lord.