pp. 205–21428 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The places alleged by the Admonition to prove that ministers of the church may not intermeddle with civill functions (one only excepted) are well and fitly alleged: and most of them used to that end of writers / which if I should name / all would confess / that they are such / as with whom M. Doctor is not worthy to be so much as spoken of the same day.
THe places alledged by the Admonition to proue that mynisters of the church may not intermeddle with ciuill functions (one only excepted) are well and fitly alledged: and most of them vsed to that ende of wryters / which if I should name / all would confesse / that they are such / as with whome M. Doctor is not worthy to be so much as spoken of the same day.
For the first place / if so be that the minister ought rather to leave necessary 1duties of burying his father / & saluting his friends undone / then that he should not accomplish his ministry to the full: much more he ought not to take upon him those things / which are not only not necessary duties / but as it shall appear / do in no case belong unto him. And although it may be applied to all Christians / yet it doth most properly belong unto the ministers. And as for the other place of Luke / touching our saviour Christs refusal to divide the 2inheritance between the brethren / it is most aptly alleged to this purpose. For although our saviour Christ doth not there take away from men / authority to judge / yet he showeth thereby sufficiently / that it belongeth not unto the ministers of the word / to intermeddle in the judgement of civil causes. For our saviour Christ framed that answer / having respect to the bounds of his calling.
For the first place / if so be that the mynister ought rather to leaue necessary 1dueties of burying hys father / & saluting hys frends vndone / then that he shoulde not accomplysh hys ministery to the full: much more he ought not to take vpon hym those thinges / which are not only not necessary dueties / but as it shall appeare / doe in no case belong vnto hym. And although it may be applyed to all Chrystians / yet it doth most properly belong vnto the mynisters. And as for the other place of Luke / touching our sauyoure Chrystes refusall to deuide the 2inheritaunce betweene the brethren / it is moste aptly alledged to thys purpose. For althoughe our sauioure Christe doth not there take away from men / authoritie to iudge / yet hee sheweth thereby sufficiently / that it belongeth not vnto the ministers of the worde / to intermeddle in the iudgement of cyuil causes. For our sauioure Christ framed that answere / hauing respect to the boundes of his calling.
For as he being a Minister of the Gospel / did all those things which were pertaining to his ministry: So by refusing this office of judgement in civil causes / he gave to understand that it did not appertain unto the compass of that office / which he exercised / which was the ministry. And therefore it is altogether out of season that M. D. here allegeth / that the Anabaptists use this reason to prove that christians may not have magistrates. For how doth this follow / that because this place of S. Luke proveth not / that we ought to have no christian magistrates: that therefore it proveth not / that the minister should be no magistrate / as if there could be no civill magistrates / onlesse ministers of the word were.
For as he being a Minister of the Gospell / dyd all those things which were pertayning to hys mynistery: So by refusing thys office of iudgement in cyuill causes / he gaue to vnderstand that it did not appertayne vnto the compasse of that office / which he exercised / which was the ministery. And therfore it is altogether out of season that M. D. here alledgeth / that the Anabaptistes vse thys reason to proue that christians may not haue magistrates. For how doth thys follow / that because thys place of S. Luke proueth not / that we ought to haue no christian magistrates: that therfore it proueth not / that the minister should be no magistrate / as if there coulde bee no ciuill magistrates / onlesse ministers of the worde were.
And the place which he allegeth out of the learned man / doth not only not make any thing for him / but doth quite overthrow his cause. For he sayeth that our saviour Christ did not refuse this as a thing in it self unlawful / but because it did not agree with his vocation. Now the vocation of our saviour Christ / was to be a minister of the gospel / therefore it doth not agree with the vocation of a minister of the gospel to judge or to intermeddle in civil government. And if M. Doctor had been so studious of M. Calvins works / as by his often allegation of him / he would make the world believe / he might have * red in him 1this sentence cited for this purpose / to prove that the ministers have not to do with civill things. Furthermore M. D. asketh what S. Pauls place to the Romans (where he willeth that he which hath an office / must wait of that office 2he that teacheth of his teaching) maketh to this purpose. Surely M. Doc. very much. Neither can there be a place more properly alleged / both for the very plains of the words / & also for the circumstance of the place. For S. Paul speaketh there against those / which would overreach their callings / & having certain callings / contented not them selves with them / but would have an ore in every mans boat / and would take more upon them then they were able to do / or the measure of their gifts would stretch unto. And therefore showeth / that as the body is best preserved when every member thereof doth his office / and destroyed when one member will take upon it to do the office of an other: so the church is then best governed / when every Ecclesiastical person keepeth him self within the limits of his calling / not meddling with that which pertaineth unto an other. But M. Doctor sayeth that the bishop governeth as well by discipline as by preaching: so he doth. But I pray you by what discipline? what a reason is this / he governeth by discipline / ergo, by civill discipline. You say in the next sentence ⟨p. 207⟩that the authors of the admonition either dote or dream: But if these be your sharp disputations / when you are awake? surely they are very blunt when you dream. But I had rather judge the best / that Master Doctor was over-watched.
And the place which he alledgeth out of the learned man / doth not only not make any thing for hym / but doth quite ouerthrow hys cause. For he sayeth that our sauiour Christ dyd not refuse thys as a thing in it selfe vnlawfull / but because it dyd not agree with hys vocation. Now the vocation of our sauiour Christ / was to be a mynister of the gospell / therefore it doth not agree with the vocation of a mynister of the gospell to iudge or to entermeddle in cyuill gouernment. And if M. Doctor had bene so studious of M. Caluins works / as by hys often allegation of hym / he woulde make the world beleue / he might haue * red in hym
The last place which is alleged by the admonition / is out of the epistle to Tim. 1where it showeth / that for so much as the estate of a minister / is as that of a soldier / & therefore as the soldier / to the end he might the better please his captain / & do his service of warfare / quitteth all those things which he loveth / & whereof otherwise he might have care / and might enjoy: even so the minister ought to dispatch him self of all those things which may be any let to the office of his ministry / although he might otherwise lawfully use them. And if so be for the performing of the ministry to the full / he must quite those things which he may lawfully use / how much more might the admonition conclude that he ought not to entangle himself with those things / which (out of the places of S. Luke / and to the Romans) it had showed to be unlawful for him to meddle with? And although M. D. say the sentence be general / yet it is particularly meant / and most properly of the ministers / which Master Calvin teacheth M. Doctor in the same place / where he hath cited his authority twice to no purpose. For what although M. Calvin do not there apply in prescript words this sentence to prove that ministers ought not to meddle with civil offices / doth it follow therefore that this place can not be used thereto? In saying that he ought to abstain from all lets which may hinder his vocation & ministry / he doth consequently say / that he ought to abstain from all civill offices. And if so be M. Doct. had been so well red in the ancient doctors (as he would seem) he might have known that this place is used of * Cyprian / to the same purpose that it is alleged here. For Cyprian 2speaking against an elder which had taken upon him to be executor to one which was dead / allegeth this place. To these reasons of the admonition / may be added that which the admonition hath in the. 230. page / that the regiment of the church is spiritual / and respecteth the conscience / & therefore hath not to do with civill offices / which respect properly the common wealth / and the outward godly honest / and quiet behaviour.
The last place which is alledged by the admonition / is out of the epistle to Tim. 1where it sheweth / that for so much as the estate of a minister / is as that of a souldier / & therfore as the souldyer / to the end he myght the better please hys captaine / & doe hys seruice of warfare / quitteth all those things which he loueth / & whereof otherwyse he might haue care / and might enioy: euen so the mynister ought to dispatch hym selfe of all those things which may be any let to the office of hys mynistery / although he might otherwise lawfully vse thē. And if so be for the performing of ye ministery to the full / he must quite those things which he may lawfully vse / how much more might the admonition conclude that he ought not to entangle himselfe with those things / which (out of the places of S. Luke / and to the Romaines) it had shewed to be vnlawfull for hym to meddle with? And although M. D. say the sentence be generall / yet it is particularly ment / and most properly of the mynisters / which Maister Caluin teacheth M. Doctor in the same place / where he hath cited hys authoritie twise to no purpose. For what although M. Caluin doe not there apply in prescript words thys sentence to proue that mynisters ought not to meddle with cyuill offices / doth it follow therefore that thys place can not be vsed thereto? In saying that he ought to abstayne from all lets which may hinder his vocation & ministery / he doth cōsequently say / that he ought to abstayne from all ciuill offices. And if so be M. Doct. had bene so well red in the auncient doctors (as he would seeme) he might haue knowen that thys place is vsed of * Cyprian / to the same purpose that it is alledged heere. For Cyprian
And therefore their meaning is ▪ that as the civill governor doth use such kind of punishment as may bridle the outward man / & hold him / that he dare not offend in the open breach of that godliness / honesty and quietness which Saint Paul commendeth unto us: so the Ecclesiastical regiment 1doth use that kind of discipline / whereby the conscience and inward man may be kept in that willing obedience unto Gods commandment touching a godly honest and quiet life. And to note the distinction of these regiments civil and spiritual / the place unto the Thessalonians is well alleged: 2for by the words (such as rule over you in the Lord) the Apostle doth put a difference between the civil and ecclesiastical regiment. For albeit that godly civil magistrates do rule over us in the Lord / yet Saint Paul catexochen that is / by excellency / ascribeth that unto the Ecclesiastical governors / because that whereas the civil magistrate beside his care for the salvation of the souls of his people / is occupied in procuring also the wealth and quietness of this life: the Ecclesiastical governors have all their whole care set upon that only ▪ which pertaineth to the life to come. And to this end also is alleged by the admonition / the place of Tim. wherein the apostle teacheth part of the ecclesiastical discipline which the minister may use / to consist in reprehensions and rebukes / which must be tempered according as the estate and age of every one doth require. Their meaning is not (as M. Doctor untruly surmiseth) to shut out the civil magistrate / or to debar him of punishing the wicked / but that it appertaineth not unto the ministers to deal that ways / whose correction of faults lieth partly in reprehensions and admonitions / which he speaketh ⟨p. 208⟩of there / partly in excommunication / whereof is spoken before. Further touching the place of the Ephesians / for so much as our saviour Christ as he is head of his church / is the spiritual governor thereof / it is meet that their government which are appointed underneath him / as he is head / should be likewise spiritual / as his is.
And therefore their meaning is ▪ that as the ciuill gouernor doth vse such kinde of punishment as may bridle the outward man / & hold hym / that he dare not offende in the open breache of that godlynes / honesty and quietnes which Saynt Paule commendeth vnto vs: so the Ecclesiasticall regyment
For as for the civil magistrate / although he be appointed of Christ (as he is God) in which respect there is none above Christ / yet he is not appointed of him / in respect that he is head of the church / in regard whereof / God is above Christ / and as the apostle sayeth / the head of him.1
For as for the cyuill magistrate / although hee be appoynted of Christ (as he is God) in which respect there is none aboue Christ / yet hee is not appoynted of hym / in respect that he is head of the church / in regarde wherof / God is aboue Christ / and as the apostle sayeth / the head of hym.1
Now that I have showed that the places quoted by the admonition / are for the most part to the purpose of that they be quoted for / I will add a reason or two to this purpose / before I come to answer to those reasons which are brought by M. Doctor. Here I must desire the reader to remember (which I said before / when I spake agaynst non residencie) the multitude & difficulty of those things which are required of the minister of the word of God. And with all I will leave to the consideration of every one / the great infirmity and weakness which is in men / both the which considerations set together / it will easily appear how unmeet a thing it is / that the minister should have any other charge laid upon him / seeing that it being so weighty an office / as will require all the gifts he hath / be they never so great / it must needs fall out / that so much as he doth in an other calling / so much he leaveth undone in this. And what the hand of man is able to reach herein / it is to be considered in the apostles / whom if the office of the ministry did so wholly occupy and set a work / that they could admit no other charge with it / yea / & were fain to cast of that which they had / it is clear that none of those which live now / can beside that function / admit any other public calling. The story is known in the Acts / that the apostles even during 1the time that they kept together at Jerusalem / and taught the church there / were fain / that they might the better attend unto preaching and praying / (by which two things S. Luke summarily setteth forth the office of the ministry) to give over the charge of providing for the poor unto others / because they were not able to do both. Now for so much as the Apostles endued with such gifts as none have been since / or shall be hereafter / could not discharge together with the office of the minister that also of the deacon / how should any man be found / that together with that office / can discharge the office of a civill magistrate? And if the Apostles would not have the office of a Deacon / which was ecclesiastical / and therefore of the same kind with the ministry joined unto it / how much less will they suffer that the ministry should be joined with a civill office / and therefore of an other kind?
Now that I haue shewed that the places quoted by the admonition / are for ye most part to the purpose of that they be quoted for / I wil adde a reason or two to thys pourpose / before I come to answer to those reasons which are brought by M. Doctor. Here I must desire the reader to remember (which I sayde before / when I spake agaynst non residencie) the multitude & difficultie of those things which are required of the mynister of the word of God. And with all I wil leaue to the consyderation of euery one / the great infirmitie and weakenes which is in men / both the which consyderations set together / it will easely appeare how vnmeete a thing it is / that the mynister shoulde haue any other charge layde vppon hym / seeing that it being so wayghty an office / as will require all the gyftes he hath / be they neuer so great / it must needes fall out / that so much as he doth in an other calling / so much he leaueth vndone in thys. And what the hand of man is able to reach herein / it is to be considered in the apostles / whome if the office of the mynistery dyd so wholy occupy and set a worke / that they could admyt no other charge with it / yea / & were fayne to cast of that which they had / it is cleare that none of those which lyue now / can besyde that function / admytte any other publyke calling. The story is knowen in the Actes / that the apostles euen during
For reason teacheth that there is an easier mingling of those which are of one kind / then of those which are of divers kinds. Again / how can we justly reprove the papists for the use of both the swords / spiritual / and material / when as we are found in the same fault our selves? And surely howsoever long custom hath caused it to seem / yet in deed it is a very great and untollerable confusion / which may be the easelyer understanded / if so be we set before our eyes / how uncomely and disordered it is / in the like / or rather in the very same case. For let us imagine the Mayor or Bailiff of a town / or the King or Emperor of the land / to come into the pulpit / and make a sermon / afterward to minister the Sacraments / and from the Church to go with the sceptre in his hand unto the place of judgement: who would not be amazed to see this / and wonder at it / as at a strange and monstrous sight? assuredly the self same deformity it is / when as the Minister of the word / is made a Justice of peace / of Quorum / a Commissioner / an Earle / or any such like / to whom the judgement of matters pertaining to the court of the civill Magistrate is committed: especially seeing there are (God be praised) of the Nobility and gentry of the realm / that are able to discharge these offices much better / then these Ecclesiastical persons ⟨p. 209⟩to whom they are committed. And if so be that there fall out any question at any time which is to be decided by the word of God / and wherein the advise of the minister is needful / there the ministers help / may / and ought to be required. For thereof we have not only an example in Esra / where the Princes in a matter of difficulty / came & asked the counsel of Esra / but we have a plain 1commandment in Moses by the Lord▪ who commanded that the cause of perjury should be heard before the Lord in the sanctuary / at the hearing whereof the high priest should be present / by which commandment the Lord doth not (by bringing this cause into the sanctuary) declare / that the judgement thereof did appertain unto the Ecclesiastical court / but because it being a matter which touched the glory of God very expressly / he would have the Princes which were judges there / to be the nearer touched / and the depelyer affected with the glory of God / whereof they saw the sacrament before their eyes.
For reason teacheth that there is an easyer mingling of those which are of one kynd / then of those which are of dyuers kyndes. Agayne / how can we iustly reproue the papistes for the vse of both the swordes / spirituall / and materiall / when as we are found in the same fault our selues? And surely howsoeuer long custome hath caused it to seme / yet in deede it is a very great and vntollerable confusion / which may be the easelyer vnderstanded / if so be we set before our eyes / how vncomely and disordered it is / in the lyke / or rather in the very same case. For let vs imagine the Mayor or Baylife of a towne / or the King or Emperor of the lande / to come into the pulpet / and make a sermon / afterwarde to mynister the Sacramentes / and from the Church to goe with the scepter in hys hand vnto the place of iudgement: who would not be amased to see this / and wonder at it / as at a straunge and monstrous sight? assuredly the selfe same deformity it is / when as the Mynister of the word / is made a Iustice of peace / of Quorum / a Commyssioner / an Earle / or any such lyke / to whome the iudgement of matters pertayning to the courte of the ciuill Magistrate is committed: especially seeing there are (God be praysed) of the Nobilitie and gentry of the realme / that are able to discharge these offices much better / then these Ecclesiasticall persones
Neither is the high priest commanded to be present to this end / that he should sit as judge of that matter / but that he might dissolve the difficulties / if any rose of the understanding of the law / and that he might prick forward and stir up by admonition / the Princes to whom the judgement appertained / if so be he should see them cold & slack to revenge the injury done unto the Lord. Which thing may the better appear / in that the handling of the matter / is there appointed not unto the priests / but unto the judges or princes only / and so likewise of matrimony and divorce / although the judgement thereof appertain unto the civill magistrate / yet the minister if there be any difficulty in knowing when it is a lawful contract / & when the divorce is lawful / may and ought to be consulted with. Thus may the common wealth and church enjoy both the wisdom & learning which is in the minister / & things may be done in that order which God hath appointed / without such confounding and jumbling of offices and jurisdictions together. For although Aristotle's obeliscolychnion, and Plato's dorydrepanon, that is / instruments serving to two purposes / be lawful in offices of the common wealth / where things are more free / and left in greater liberty to be ordered at the judgement and advise of men / especially considering that upon the diversity of the forms of common wealths / variety of regiment may spring: yet in the church of God where things are brought to a straighter rule / and which is but one and uniform / the same may not be suffered. And yet even those common wealth Philosophers which do licence upon occasion that two offices may meet in one man / hold that it is best and convenientest / that every one should have a particular charge. For Aristotle sayeth that it is most agreeable to nature / that hen should be pros hen, that is / one instrument to one use. And Plato useth the 1proverb mede heracleis pros duo, against those which will take upon them divers vocations / and not content them selves with one / so that they make the meting of many functions in one man / to be a remedy only in extreme need & poverty of able men.
Neyther is the hyghe priest commaunded to be present to thys ende / that he should sitte as iudge of that matter / but that he might dissolue the difficulties / if any rose of the vnderstanding of the law / and that hee myght pricke forward and styre vp by admonition / the Princes to whome the iudgement appertayned / if so bee he should see them colde & slacke to reuenge the iniury done vnto the Lorde. Which thing may the better appeare / in yt the handling of the matter / is there appoynted not vnto the priestes / but vnto the iudges or princes only / and so lykewyse of matrimony and diuorse / although the iudgement thereof appertayne vnto the ciuill magistrate / yet the minister if there be any difficulty in knowing when it is a lawfull contract / & when the dyuorse is lawfull / maye and ought to bee consulted wyth. Thus may the common wealth and church enioy both the wysedome & learning which is in the mynister / & things may bee done in that order which God hath appoynted / without suche confounding and iombling of offyces and iurisdictions together. For although Aristotles obeliscolychnion, and Platoes dorydrepanon, that is / instrumentes seruing to two purposes / bee lawfull in offyces of the common wealth / where things are more free / and left in greater liberty to bee ordered at the iudgement and aduise of men / especially consydering that vppon the diuersitye of the formes of common wealthes / varietie of regiment may spring: yet in the church of God where things are brought to a strayghter rule / and which is but one and vniforme / the same may not bee suffered. And yet euen those cōmon wealth Philosophers which doe lycence vpon occasion that two offices may meete in one man / holde that it is best and conuenientest / that euery one shoulde haue a particulare charge. For Aristotle sayeth that it is most agreeable to nature / that hen shoulde be pros hen, that is / one instrument to one vse. And Plato vseth the
And although both be unlawful / yet as the case standeth in our realm / it is more tolerable that the civill magistrate should do the office of a minister / then that the minister should intermeddle with the function of the magistrate. For when the accounts shall be cast / it will fall out / that there are more sufficient & able men to serve in the common wealth of this realm / then in the church / and greater want in the one then in the other. And if beside this / both authority of the word of God and light of reason / we will look unto the practise of the church many years after the time of the Apostles / we shall find that the church hath been very careful from time to time / that this order should be kept / that the ministers should not entangle them selves with any thing beside their ministry / and those things which the word of God doth necessarily put upon them / le•st the strength of their mind & of their body / being distracted unto many things / they should be the less able to accomplish their ministry unto the full. Which ⟨p. 210⟩may also partly appear by that which I have alleged out of Cyprian / which will not permit them so much as to be executors of a Testament. And in one of the Canons which are ascribed unto the Apostles it is enjoined that they 1should not entangle them selves with worldly offices / but attend upon their Ecclesiastical affairs.
And although both be vnlawfull / yet as the case standeth in our realme / it is more tellerable that the ciuill magistrate should doe the office of a minister / then that the minister shuld intermeddle with the function of the magistrate. For when the accountes shall be cast / it will fall out / that there are more sufficient & able men to serue in the common wealth of thys realme / then in the churche / and greater wante in the one then in the other. And if besyde thys / both authoritie of the werd of God and lyght of reason / wee will looke vnto the practise of the church many yeares after the time of the Apostles / we shall finde that the church hath bene very carefull from time to time / that thys order should bee kept / that the ministers shuld not entangle them selues with any thing beside their ministery / and those things which the word of God doth necessaryly put vpon them / le•st the strength of their minde & of their body / being distracted vnto many thinges / they should be the lesse able to accomplishe their ministery vnto the full. Which
Further / in the council of Calcedon it was decreed / that none of the 1clerks or clergy (as it termeth them) should receive any charge of those which are under age / unless they were such as the laws did necessarily cast upon him / which it calleth inexcusable charges / meaning by all likelihood / the wardship of his brothers children or some such thing. Where is also declared the cause of that decree to have been / for that there were certain ministers which were stewards to noble men. And in the. 7. canon of the same council it is decreed / that none of the clergy should either go to warfare as soldiers or captains / or should receive any secular honours / and if they did / they should be excommunicated or accursed. Now I come to M. Doctors arguments / which he bringeth to establish this disorder.
Further / in the councell of Calcedon it was decreed / that none of the 1clearkes or cleargie (as it termeth them) shoulde receiue any charge of those which are vnder age / vnlesse they were suche as the lawes dyd necessarily cast vpon hym / which it calleth inexcusable charges / meaning by all lykelyhoode / the wardshyp of hys brothers children or some suche thing. Where is also declared the cause of that decree to haue beene / for that there were certeine mynisters which were stewardes to noble men. And in the. 7. canon of the same councell it is decreed / that none of the cleargy should either goe to warfare as souldyers or captaynes / or should receiue any secular honors / and if they dyd / they shoulde bee excommunicated or accursed. Now I come to M. Doctors argumentes / which he bringeth to establish thys disorder.
And first he sayeth ministers of the word may not occupy them selves in worldly business / as to be merchants / husbandmen / crafts men / and such like / but they may exercise civil offices. Where first of all I perceive M. Doctor is of this mind / that the order of God is not to be broken for small gain / or when a man must take great toil of the body to break it: but it may be broken with getting of honour / and doing of those things which may be done with out soil / & with great commendation / there it is lawful to break it. In deed so the Poet (but in the person of an unjust and ambition man / ) said: ei chre adicein, tyrannidos heneca chre, that is. If a man must do unjustly / he must do it to bear rule.
And first he sayeth mynisters of the word may not occupy them selues in wordly busines / as to be marchants / husbandmen / craftes men / and such like / but they may exercise cyuill offices. Where first of all I perceiue M. Doctor is of thys mynde / that the order of God is not to be broken for small gayne / or when a man must take great toyle of the body to breake it: but it may be broken with getting of honor / and doing of those things which may be done with out soyle / & with great commendation / there it is lawfull to breake it. In deede so the Poete (but in the person of an vniust and ambition man / ) sayd: ei chre adicein, tyrannidos heneca chre, that is. If a man must do vniustly / he must doe it to beare rule.
Secondarily I do see that M. Doctor will not be shackled and hindered from his ministry by a pair of iron fetters / but if he can get a pair of golden fetters / he is contented to be hampered and entangled / from doing the office of ministry committed unto him. For onles these should be the causes which should move him to take the one / and refuse the other / verily I see none. For where as he saith it is a help / & maintaineth religion / in deed that is the reason of the papists which M. Calvin confuteth in his institution. And although it be good 1and necessary to punish vice and iniquity / by corporal punishments and by civil corrections: yet it doth no more follow that that should be done by the ministers / then it followeth that for that preaching and ministering the sacraments and excommunication are good and necessary / therefore the same is fit to be executed by the civil magistrate. I grant the ministers have also to punish vice / for as the civil magistrates punish lighter faults with some penalty of money or loss of member: so the church and the minister especially with the church / hath to punish faults by repressions and rebukes. And as the civil magistrate punisheth greater faults by death: so the minister with other which have interest / hath with the sword of excommunication power to kill those which be rebellious / & to cut them from the church / as the other doth from the common wealth. And if it be a help to the ministers office / that he should meddle with civill punishments / why should it not be a help unto the magistrates office / that he should excommunicate and other things pertaining to the ecclesiastical discipline? And where as M. Doctor saith they may not be husbandmen / crafts men. &c. & yet may have civil offices / I think far otherwise / that although neither be lawful / yet the one were more tolerable then the other. For seeing after the ministry of the word / there is no calling under the sun weightier / and which requireth greater exercise of the mind / then the office of the magistrate / it is against all reason to lay this heavy burden upon a man that is already laden / and hath as much as he is able to bear.
Secondarely I doe see that M. Doctor will not be shackled and hyndered from hys ministery by a paire of yron fetters / but if he can get a payre of golden fetters / he is contēted to be hampered and entangled / from doing the office of ministery committed vnto hym. For onles these should be the causes which should moue hym to take the one / and refuse the other / verely I see none. For where as he sayth it is a helpe / & maynteineth relygion / in deede that is the reason of the papistes which M. Caluin confuteth in hys institution. And although it be good
It were more equal / if they will needs ⟨p. 211⟩add unto the weight of this burden / to lay some lighter charge of exercising & handy craft / then to break his back with the charge of a civil magistrate.
It were more equall / if they will needes ⟨p. 211⟩adde vnto the weyght of thys burthen / to lay some lyghter charge of exercising & handy craft / then to breake hys backe with the charge of a cyuill magistrate.
And whereas in the policy of M. Doctor it seemeth a furtherance to the gospel to join these together which was also the policy of the Idolaters / (as I have before declared) in the wisdom of God it hath seemed far otherwise / which I doubt not did therefore separate the ministry from this pomp / which is commendable in the civil magistrate / least the efficacy and power of the simplicity of the word of God and of the ministry should be obscured / whilst men would attribute the conversion of souls unto the gospel (dew unto the word and to the spirit of God) to these glorious shows. And least whilst the minister have the word in one hand / and the sword in the other / men should not be able to judge so well in their consciences of the mighty operation of the word of God in them. For they might doubt with them selves / whether the fear & out ward show of the minister / carried some stroke with them in believing the word.
And whereas in the pollicy of M. Doctor it semeth a furtherance to the gospell to ioyne these together which was also the pollicy of the Idolaters / (as I haue before declared) in the wisedome of God it hath semed farre otherwyse / which I doubt not dyd therfore separate the ministery from thys pompe / whiche is commendable in the cyuill magistrate / least the efficacy and power of the simplicitie of the word of God and of the mynistery should be obscured / whilest men would attribute the conuersion of soules vnto the gospell (dew vnto the worde and to the spirite of God) to these gloryous shewes. And least whylest the mynyster haue the woorde in one hande / and the sword in the other / men should not be able to iudge so well in their consciences of the mighty operation of the worde of God in them. For they might doubt with them selues / whether the feare & out ward shew of the mynister / caryed some stroke with them in beleuing the word.
But M. Doctor sayeth / that civil offices are not to be counted worldly affairs / but heavenly and spiritual / it is so / and yet when they are compared with the ecclesiastical offices / they may be called secular offices / for so much as they together with the care of religion / procure and provide for the things whereby we may quietly and commodiously live here / where the ecclesiastical offices are immediately and only bent / to procure the glory of God and the salvation of men / and in that signification of heavenly & spiritual which you take / merchandise / husbandry / and the handy craft be heavenly and spiritual / although not in the same degree. All lawful callings came from God / & return to him again / that is / he is both author of them / and they ought to be referred to his glory / so that if the minister may exercise all things which be heavenly / and spiritual / you may as well bring him down to the plough / as promote him to the court. And whereas M. Doctor saith that the office of a commissioner is ecclesiastical / because it handleth ecclesiastical causes / I marvel that he is so ignorant / that he can not put a difference between giving judicial sentences / and appointing bodily punishments (which are mere civil) and between the understanding the truth of every such cause according as the word of God defineth of it: which is a thing common as well unto the magistrate as unto the minister / and wherein the minister because he ought to be most ready / ought (if need be) consulted with.
But M. Doctor sayeth / that cyuill offices are not to be counted worldly affayres / but heauenly and spirituall / it is so / and yet when they are compared with the ecclesiasticall offices / they may be called secular offices / for so muche as they together with the care of relygion / procure and prouide for the things wherby we may quietly and commodiously lyue here / where the ecclesiasticall offices are immediatly and only bent / to procure the glory of God and the saluation of men / and in that signification of heauenly & spirituall which you take / marchandyse / husbandry / and the handy craft be heauenly and spyrituall / although not in the same degree. All lawfull callinges came from God / & returne to hym agayne / that is / he is both author of them / and they ought to be referred to hys glory / so that if the mynister may exercise all thinges which be heauenly / and spirituall / you may as well bring hym downe to the plough / as promote hym to the courte. And whereas M. Doctor sayth that the office of a commissyoner is ecclesiasticall / because it handleth ecclesiasticall causes / I meruayle that he is so ignorant / that he can not put a difference betweene geuing iudyciall sentences / and appoynting bodely punishmentes (which are meere cyuill) and betweene the vnderstanding the truth of euery such cause according as the worde of God defyneth of it: which is a thing common as wel vnto the magistrate as vnto the minister / and wherein the mynister because he ought to be most ready / ought (if neede be) consulted with.
An other of Master Doctors reasons is / that as kings do serve Christ by making laws for him / so bishops do serve Christ by executing laws for him. As though it pertained not unto the magistrates to execute laws / aswell as to make them / and as if the magistrate were not therefore called a speaking law / because by executing them / he doth cause the laws after a fashion to speak. This is to divide the stake of the magistrate / between him / and the bishop / yea to give the bishop the best part of it. For we know that with us / the people be at making of the laws / which may not meddle with the execution of them. And if M. Doctor say that he meaneth not hereby to shut the prince from executing the laws / then as his similitude (when it is at the best) proveth nothing: so by this means it halts down right / and is no similitude. As for Ely and Samuel they are extraordinary examples / which may thereby appear / for that both these offices first meting in Melchizedek / & afterward in Moses / were by the commandment of God severed / when as the Lord toke from Moses (being so wise & godly a man) the priesthood / & gave it to Aaron / and to his successors. And so / for so much as when the Lord would polish his church / & make it famous / & renowned in the world / he gave this order: It appeareth that he would have this to be a perpetual rule unto his church. And by so much it is the clearer / for that the Lord did not tarry until Moses death / but toke the priesthood away from ⟨p. 212⟩Moses / which was a man as able to execute both / as either Ely / or Samuel. And this may be also easily seen / for that in a manner always / where there was any good and stayed estate of the church / these offices were ministered by several persons / and then met & were mingled / when the estates were very ruinous and miserable. And if this be a good reason to prove that ministers may exercise civill offices / it is as good a reason to prove / that princes may preach / and minister the sacraments. For if the ministers may exercise civill offices / because Ely / and Samuel (being ministers) did so: the Princes / and Judges may preach the word / and minister the sacraments / because Ely and Samuel (being princes and judges) did so. And so we see / how M. Doctor going about / to defend one confusion / bringeth in an other.
An other of Maister Doctors reasons is / that as kinges doe serue Christ by making lawes for hym / so byshoppes doe serue Christ by executing lawes for him. As though it pertayned not vnto the magistrates to execute lawes / aswell as to make them / and as if the magistrate were not therefore called a speaking law / because by executing them / he doth cause the lawes after a fashion to speake. Thys is to deuide the stake of the magistrate / betwene hym / and the byshop / yea to geue the byshoppe the best part of it. For wee know that with vs / the people be at making of the lawes / which may not meddle with the execution of them. And if M. Doctor say that he meaneth not hereby to shut the prince from executing the lawes / then as hys similytude (when it is at the best) proueth nothing: so by thys meanes it haltes downe ryght / and is no simylitude. As for Elie and Samuell they are extraordinary examples / which may thereby appeare / for that both these offices first meting in Melchisedech / & afterward in Moses / were by the commaundement of God seuered / when as the Lord toke from Moses (being so wise & godly a man) the priesthode / & gaue it to Aaron / and to hys successors. And so / for so much as when the Lord would polishe hys church / & make it famous / & renoumed in the world / he gaue thys order: It appeareth that he wold haue this to be a perpetuall rule vnto his church. And by so much it is the clearer / for that ye Lord did not tary vntil Moses death / but toke the priesthode away frō
As for Elijah killing the false prophets / and our saviour Christs whipping out of the temple / it is strange that Master Doctor will allege them / as things to be followed / when he may as well teach / that we may call for fire from heaven / as Elijah did / and being demanded / answer nothing / as our saviour did: as to follow these actions which are most singular / and extraordinary. And if these one / or two examples be enough to break the order that God hath set / by this a man may prove / that the ministers may be fishers / and tent makers / because 1Peter / and Paul (being ministers) did fish and make tents. And truly these are not so extraordinary / and from the general rule / as the other be. And it was permitted in a council / that rather then a minister should have two benefices 2/ he might labour with his hands / to supply his want withal. When S. Paul willed Tim. that he should not receive an accusation against an elder / under two or three witnesses / he did commit nothing less / then any civill office unto him. And M. Doctor him self hath alleged it before / as a thing incident to the office of a bishop: and therefore he doth forget himself marvellously now / that maketh this a civill office.
As for Elias killing the false prophetes / and our sauiour Christes whipping out of the temple / it is strange that Maister Doctor will alledge them / as thinges to be followed / when he may as well teach / that we may cal for fire from heauen / as Elias dyd / and being demaunded / answere nothing / as our sauiour dyd: as to follow these actions which are most singular / and extraordinary. And if these one / or two examples be enough to breake the order that God hath set / by thys a man may proue / that the mynisters may be fyshers / and tent makers / because 1Peter / and Paule (being mynisters) dyd fyshe and make tents. And truely these are not so extraordinary / and from the generall rule / as the other be. And it was permitted in a councell / that rather then a mynister should haue two benefices 2/ he might labor with hys handes / to supply hys want withall. When S. Paule willed Tim. that he should not receiue an accusation agaynst an elder / vnder two or three witnesses / he dyd commit nothing les / then any ciuill office vnto hym. And M. Doctor hym selfe hath alledged it before / as a thing incident to the office of a byshop: and therefore he doth forget hymselfe maruellously now / that maketh thys a ciuill office.
And doth M. Doctor think / that S. Paul made magistrates? Or is he of that judgement / that the church in the time of persecution / may make civill officers? But it is true / that he that is once over the shoes / sticketh not to run over his boots.
And doth M. Doctor thincke / that S. Paule made magistrates? Or is he of that iudgement / that the church in the tyme of persecution / may make ciuill officers? But it is true / that he that is once ouer the shoes / sticketh not to run ouer hys bootes.
And last of all to prove that bishops may have prisons / he citeth Peter which punished Ananias / and Sapphira with death. M. Doctor must understand that this was Ecclesiastical power / and was done by virtue of that function / which S. Paul calleth dynamin, which is one of those functions that the 1Lord placed in his church for a time. But is this a good argument / because S. Peter punished with the word / therefore the minister may punish with the sword? And because S. Peter did so once / therefore the bishop may do so alway? & because S. Peter did that / which appertaineth to no civill magistrate / and which no civill magistrate / by any means may / or can do / therefore the minister may do that / which appertaineth unto the civill magistrate? For if there had been a civill magistrate / the same could not have punished this fault of dissimulation / which was not known / nor declared it self by any outward action. So that if this example prove any thing / it proveth that the minister may do / that no man may do / but the Lord only / which is to punish faults that are hid / and unknown. If this be ignorance / it is very gross / & if it be against knowledge / it is more dangerous. I have determined with my self / to leave unto M. Doctor his outcries and declamations / and if I should have used them / as often as he giveth occasion / there would be no end of writing. The Lord give M. Doctor either better knowledge / or better conscience.
And last of all to proue that byshoppes may haue prisons / hee citeth Peter which punyshed Ananias / and Saphira with death. M. Doctor must vnderstand that thys was Ecclesiasticall power / and was done by vertue of that function / which S. Paule calleth dynamin, which is one of those functions that the 1Lord placed in hys church for a tyme. But is thys a good argument / because S. Peter punished with the word / therefore the mynister may punyshe with the sworde? And because S. Peter dyd so once / therefore the byshop may doe so alway? & because S. Peter dyd that / which appertayneth to no ciuill magistrate / and which no ciuill magistrate / by any meanes may / or can doe / therefore the mynister may doe that / which appertayneth vnto the ciuill magistrate? For if there had bene a ciuill magistrate / the same could not haue punyshed thys fault of dissimulation / which was not knowen / nor declared it selfe by any outwarde action. So that if thys example proue any thing / it proueth that the mynister may doe / that no man may doe / but the Lord only / which is to punysh faultes that are hyd / and vnknowne. If thys be ignoraunce / it is very grosse / & if it be agaynst knowledge / it is more daungerous. I haue determyned with my selfe / to leaue vnto M. Doctor hys outcries and declamations / and if I should haue vsed them / as often as he geueth occasion / there would be no end of wryting. The Lord geue M. Doctor eyther better knowledge / or better conscience.
Unto M. Doctor / asking where it appeareth that pope Eugenius brought in prisons into the church / as also unto three or four such like demands which he maketh in this book / the authors of the Admonition answer at once / that ⟨p. 213⟩this and the other are sound in Pantaleon and M. Bales Chronicles. Here I will take in that / which the bishop of Salisbury hath in the last page of his half sheet touching this matter.
Vnto M. Doctor / asking where it appeareth that pope Eugenius brought in prysons into the church / as also vnto three or foure such like demaunds which hee maketh in thys booke / the authors of the Admonition answeare at once / that ⟨p. 213⟩thys and the other are sounde in Pantaleon and M. Bales Chronicles. Heere I will take in that / whych the byshop of Salesbury hath in the last page of hys halfe sheete touching thys matter.
And first of all I well agree / that he saith / that to give unto satan (which is to excommunicate / and to correct an Ecclesiastical person by reprehension / or putting him out of the ministry / if the case so require) is mere ecclesiastical / and not civill / and that those things ought to be done of the officers of the church. This only I deny / that the ministers ought to meddle with civill offices. For proof whereof / the B. allegeth the example of Augustine / which as Possidonius writeth / was troubled with the hearing & determining of causes. Wherein Possidonius sayeth nothing / but that I willingly agree unto. For the minister with the elders / ought both to hear / and determine of causes / but of such causes / as pertain unto their knowledge / whereof I have spoken before. And that Possidonius meant such causes as belonged unto Augustin / as he was a minister / and not of civill affairs / it appeareth by that which he writeth immediately after / where he saith. Being also consulted of / by certain in their worldly affairs / he wrote epistles to divers / but he accounted of this / as of compulsion / and restraint from his better businesses: whereby it appeareth / that S. Augustine meddled not with those worldly affairs / further / then by way of giving counsel / which is not unlawful for a minister to do / as one friend unto an other / so that his ministry be not thereby hindered. And for the truth of this matter / that ministers ought not to meddle with civill affairs / I will appeal to no other / then to the bishop him self / who doth affirm plainly the same / that the 1admonition here affirmeth.
And first of all I wel agree / that he sayth / that to geue vnto sathan (which is to excommunicate / and to correct an Ecclesiasticall person by reprehensyon / or putting hym out of the ministerye / if the case so require) is meere ecclesiasticall / and not ciuill / and that those thyngs ought to be done of the offycers of ye church. Thys only I deny / that the ministers ought to meddle wyth ciuill offyces. For proofe whereof / the B. alledgeth the example of Augustine / whych as Possidonius wryteth / was troubled wyth the hearing & determinyng of causes. Wherin Possidonius sayeth nothyng / but that I willingly agree vnto. For the minister wyth the elders / ought bothe to heare / and determine of causes / but of suche causes / as pertaine vnto their knowledge / whereof I haue spoken before. And that Possidonius ment such causes as belonged vnto Augustin / as he was a minister / and not of ciuill affaires / it appeareth by that whych he wryteth immediatly after / where he sayth. Being also consulted of / by certen in their worldly affaires / he wrote epistles to diuers / but he accompted of thys / as of compulsyon / and restraint from hys better busynesses: whereby it appeareth / that S. Augustine medled not wyth those worldly affaires / further / then by waye of giuing counsell / whych is not vnlawful for a minister to do / as one friend vnto an other / so that hys mynisterye be not thereby hindered. And for the truthe of thys matter / that ministers ought not to meddle wyth ciuill affaires / I will appeale to no other / then to the byshop hym selfe / who dothe affirme plainly the same / that the
And therefore I conclude / that for so much as both the holy scriptures do teach / that ministers ought not to meddle with civill offices / and reason / and the practise of the church do confirm it / that they ought to keep themselves within the limits of the ministry / and Ecclesiastical functions / least whilst they break forth into the calling of a magistrate / in stead of showing themselves episcopous, that is overseers / they be found to declare themselves * allotriopiscopous, that is: busy bodies / meddling in things which belong not unto them. And thus putting them in remembrance of that which they know well enough / that they ought cosman sparten hen elachon, that is to say: study to adorn that charge which they take in hand / and do profess / I leave to speak any further of this matter.
And therfore I conclude / that for so much as bothe the holy scriptures doe teache / that ministers oughte not to meddle wyth ciuill offyces / and reason / and the practise of the church doe confirme it / that they ought to kepe thēselues within the limites of the ministerye / and Ecclesiasticall functions / least whilest they breake forthe into the calling of a magistrate / in steade of shewing themselues episcopous, that is ouerseers / they be found to declare themselues * allotriopiscopous, that is: busy bodyes / medling in thyngs whych belong not vnto them. And thus putting them in remembrance of that whych they knowe well enoughe / that they ought cosman sparten hen elachon, that is to say: studye to adorne that charge whych they take in hande / and doe professe / I leaue to speake any further of thys matter.
Unto the two next sections I have spoken in that which hath been said touching excommunication / canons / and prebendaries. &c. and unto that which is contained in the. 226. and. 227. I answer that I can not excuse covetous patrons of benefices / but covetous parsons and vicars be a great plague unto this church / and one of the principal causes of rude and ignorant people.
Vnto the two next sections I haue spoken in that whych hathe bene sayde touchyng excommunication / canons / and prebendaries. &c. and vnto that whych is contained in the. 226. and. 227. I answere that I can not excuse couetous patrones of benefices / but couetous parsons and vicars be a great plague vnto this church / and one of the principall causes of rude and ignorant people.
Likewise unto the two next sections I have answered before / in speaking against the spiritual courts / which are now used / and unto the next after that / in speaking of the ordaining of ministers. And unto that which is contained in the later end of the. 234. and the beginning of the. 235. I say that the church shall judge of the aptness or unaptness of our reasons / and albeit we do find fault with divers things in the book / yet we neither oppugn as enemies / nor are by the grace of God either Papists / Anabaptists / Atheists / or Puritans / as it pleaseth M. Doctor to call us. And to the prayer against disturbers of the church / I say with all my heart. Amen.
Lykewise vnto the two next sectiōs I haue answeared before / in speaking against the spirituall courts / whych are now vsed / and vnto the next after that / in speaking of the ordayning of ministers. And vnto that whych is contained in the later ende of the. 234. and the beginning of the. 235. I say that the church shall iudge of the aptnes or vnaptnes of our reasons / and albeit we do finde fault with diuers thyngs in the booke / yet we neyther oppugne as enemyes / nor are by the grace of God eyther Papists / Anabaptists / Atheists / or Puretanes / as it pleaseth M. Doctor to call vs. And to the prayer agaynst disturbers of the churche / I say wyth all my heart. Amen.
Unto the next section I have answered in the treatise of the apparel. And unto the next after / in the treatise which declareth to whom it doth appertain to make ceremonies and orders of the church. And unto the section contained in the. 243. page / I say that M. Doctor being asked of Onions / answereth of ⟨p. 214⟩garlic. For the authors of the admonition / desiring that it might be as lawful for them to publish by Print their minds / or to be heard dispute / or that their mind put in writing / might be openly debated / master D. answereth with Augustine's sentence (which he hath made the foot of his song) nothing to the purpose of that which they said / the performance of which promise / we will notwithstanding wait for.
Vnto the next section I haue answeared in the treatise of the apparell. And vnto the next after / in the treatise whych declareth to whome it doth appertaine to make ceremonyes and orders of the church. And vnto the section contained in the. 243. page / I say that M. Doctor being asked of Oynions / answeareth of ⟨p. 214⟩garlike. For the authors of the admonition / desyring that it myght be as lawful for them to publishe by Printe their mindes / or to be heard dispute / or that theyr minde put in wryting / myghte be openly debated / maister D. answeareth wyth Augustines sentence (whych he hath made the foote of hys song) nothing to the purpose of that whych they said / the performance of which promise / we wil notwythstanding wayte for.