And where you say, that all that ever I bring, to prove that evil men eat not the body of Christ, may be shortly answered, truth it is (as you said in one place of me) that all that I have brought may be shortly answered, if a man care not what he answer: as it seemeth you pas not much what you answer, so that you may lay on lode of words. For where as I have fully proved as well by authority of scripture, as by the testimony of many old writers, that although evil men eat the sacramental bread, and drink the wine (which have the names of his flesh and blood) yet they eat not Christs very flesh nor drink his blood: Your short and whole answer is this,1 that evil men may be said not to eat Christs flesh and drink his blood, because they do it not fruitfully, as they ought to do. And that may be called a not eating, as they may be said not to hear God's word, that hear it not profitably: and a thing not well done, may be in speech called not done, in the respect of the good effect. I grant such speeches be sometime used, but very rarely and when the very truth cometh in discussion, then such Paradoxes are not to be used. As if it come in question whether a house be builded, that is not well builded, then the definition of the matter must not be, that it is not builded, although the carpenters and other workmen have failed in their covenant and bargain, and not builded the house in such sort as they ought to have done. So our saviour Christ teacheth that all heard the word,2 whether the seed fell in the high way, or upon the stones, or among the thorns, or in the good ground. Wherefore when this matter cometh in discussion among the old writers, whether evil men eat Christs body or no, if the truth had been that evil men eat it, the ⟨p. 224⟩old writers would not so precisely have defined the contrary, that they eat not, but would have said they eat it, but not effectually, not fruitfully, not profitably. But now the authors which I have alleged, define plainly and absolutely, that evil men eat not Christs body, without any other addition. But after this sort that you do use, it shall be an easy matter for every man to say what liketh him, and to defend it well enough, if he may add to the scriptures and doctors words at his pleasure, and make the sense after his own fantasy.
And where you say, that all that euer I bring, to proue that euell men eate not the body of Christ, may be shortly aunswered, truth it is (as you sayd in one place of me) that all that I haue brought may be shortly aunswered, if a man care not what he aunswer: as it seemeth you pas not much what you aunswer, so that you may lay on lode of wordes. For where as I haue fully proued as well by authoritie of scripture, as by the testimony of many olde writers, that although euell men eate the sacramentall bread, and drincke the wine (which haue the names of his flesh and bloud) yet they eate not Christes very flesh nor drincke his bloud: Your short and whole aunswer is this,1 that euell men may be sayd not to eate Christes flesh and drincke his bloud, bycause they do it not frutefully, as they ought to do. And that may be called a not eating, as they may be sayd not to heare godes word, that heare it not profitably: and a thing not well done, may be in speach called not done, in the respect of the good effect. I graunt such speaches be sometyme vsed, but very rarely and when the very truth commeth in discussion, then such Paradoxes are not to be vsed. As if it come in question whether a house be builded, that is not well builded, then the diffinition of the matter must not be, that it is not builded, although the carpenters and other workemen haue fayled in theyr couenaunt and bargayne, and not builded the house in such sort as they ought to haue done. So our sauiour Christ teacheth that all heard the word,2 whether the seed fell in the high way, or vpon the stones, or among the thornes, or in the good groūd. Wherfore when this matter cometh in discussion among the old writers, whether euell menne eate Christes body or no, if the truth had bene that euill men eate it, the ⟨p. 224⟩olde writers would not so precisely haue defined the contrary, that they eate not, but would haue sayd they eate it, but not effectually, not frutefully, not profitably. But now the authors which I haue alleaged, define playnly and absolutely, that euell men eate not Christes body, without any other addition. But after this sort that you do vse, it shall be an easy matter for euery man to say what liketh him, and to defend it well inough, if he may adde to the scriptures and doctours wordes at his pleasure, and make the sense after his owne phantasye.
- 1That may be said not done yt is not well don.That may be sayd not done yt is not well don.
- 2Li•. 8.