pp. 3941,982 passagespart 14 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Christ said to his disciples: if you loved me you would be glad,1 for I go unto my father. And again he said: It is expedient for you that I go, for if I go not,2 the comforter shall not come unto you. And yet surely the eternal word of God, the virtue of God, the wisdom of God, was ever with his Father, and in his Father, yea even at the same time when he was with us, and in us. For when he did mercifully dwell in this world, he left not his habitation in heaven, for he is every where whole with his Father, equal in divinity, whom no place can contain, for the Son filleth all things, and there is no place that lacketh the presence of his divinity. From whence then, and whether did he say he would go? Or how did he say, that he went to his Father, from whom doubtless he never departed? But that to go to his Father, and from us, was to take from this world that nature which he received of us. Thou seest therefore that it was the property of that nature to be taken away and go from us, which in the end of the world shall be rendered again to us, as the angels witnessed, saying: This Jesus which is taken from you,3 shall come again like as you saw him going up into heaven. For look upon the miracle, look upon the mystery of both the natures: the Son of God (as concerning his humanity) went from us, as concerning his divinity, he said unto us: Behold, I am with you all the days unto the worlds end.
Christ sayd to his disciples: if you loued me you would be glad,1 for I go vnto my father. And again he sayd: It is expedient for you that I go, for if I goe not,2 the comforter shall not come vnto you. And yet surely the eternall word of God, the vertue of God, the wisdome of God, was euer with his Father, and in his Father, yea euen at the same time when he was with vs, aud in vs. For whē he did mercifully dwell in this world, he left not his habitation in heauen, for he is euery where wholl with his Father, equall in diuinitie, whom no place can containe, for the Sonne filleth all thinges, and there is no place that lacketh the presence of his diuinitie. From whence then, and whether did he say he would goe? Or how did he say, that he went to his Father, from whom doubtles he neuer departed? But that to goe to his Father, and from vs, was to take from this world that nature which he receaued of vs. Thou seest therfore that it was the propertie of that nature to be taken away and goe from vs, which in the end of the world shall be rendered again to vs, as the angels witnessed, saying: This Iesus which is taken from you,3 shall come agayn like as you saw him going vp into heauen. For looke vpon the miracle, looke vpon the mistery of both the natnres: the Sonne of God (as cōcerning his humanitie) went frō vs, as concerning his diuinity, he said vnto vs: Behold, I am with you all the dayes vnto the worldes end.
Thus far have I rehearsed the words of Vigilius,1 and by and by he concludeth thus. He is with us, and not with us. For those whom he left, and went from them, as concerning his humanity, those he left not, nor forsook them not, as touching his divinity. For as touching the form of a servant (which he took away from us into heaven) he is absent from us, but by the form of God (which goeth not from us) he is present with us in earth, and nevertheless, both present and absent, he is all one Christ.
Thus farre haue I rehearsed the wordes of Vigilius,1 and by and by he concludeth thus. He is with vs, and not with vs. For those whom he left, and went from them, as concerning his humanitie, those he left not, nor forsooke them not, as touching his diuinitie. For as touching the forme of a seruaunt (which he tooke away from vs into heauen) he is absent from vs, but by the forme of God (which goeth not from vs) he is present with vs in earth, and neuertheles, both present and absent, he is all one Christ.
Hitherto you have heard Vigilius speak, that Christ (as concerning his bodily presence and the nature of his manhood) is gone from us, taken from us, is gone up into heaven, is not with us, hath left us, hath forsaken us. But as concerning the other nature of his Deity, he is still with us, so that he is both with ⟨p. 100⟩us, and not with us, with us in the nature of his Deity, and not with us in the nature of his humanity. And yet more clearly doth the same Vigilius declare the same thing in another place,1 saying.
Hetherto you haue heard Vigilius speake, that Christ (as concerning his bodely presence and the nature of his manhode) is gone from vs, taken from vs, is gone vp into heauē, is not with vs, hath left vs, hath forsaken vs. But as concerning the other nature of his Deitie, he is still with vs, so that he is both with ⟨p. 100⟩vs, and not with vs, with vs in the nature of his Deitye, and not with vs in the nature of his humanity. And yet more cleerely doth the same Vigilius declare the same thing in another place,1 saying.
If the word and the flesh were both of one nature, seeing that the word is every where, why is not the flesh then every where? For when it was in earth, then verily it was not in heaven: and now when it is in heaven, it is not surely in earth. And it is so sure that it is not in earth, that as concerning it, we look for him to come from heaven, whom as concerning his eternal word: we believe to be with us in earth. Therefore by your doctrine (saith Vigilius unto Eutiches, who defended that the divinity and humanity in Christ was but one nature) either the word is contained in a place with his flesh: or else the flesh is every where with the word. For one nature cannot receive in it self two divers and contrary things. But these two things be divers and far unlike, that is to say, to be contained in a place, and to be every where. Therefore in as much as the word is every where, and the flesh is not every where, it appeareth plainly, that one Christ himself hath in him two natures. And that by his divine nature he is every where, and by his human nature he is contained in a place, that he is created, and hath no beginning, that he is subject to death, and cannot die. Whereof one he hath by the nature of his word (whereby he is God) and the other he hath hy the nature of his flesh, whereby the same God is man also. Therefore one son of God, the self same was made the son of man, and he hath a beginning by the nature of his flesh, and no beginning by the nature of his Godhead. He is created by the nature of his flesh, and not created by the nature of his Godhead. He is comprehended in a place by the nature of his flesh, and not comprehended in a place by the nature of his Godhead. He is inferior to angels in the nature of his flesh, and is equal to his Father in the nature of his Godhead. He dyed by the nature of his flesh, and dyed not by the nature of his Godhead. This is the faith and catholic confession, which the Apostles taught, the Martyrs did corroborate, and faithful people keep unto this day.
If the word and the flesh were both of one nature, seeyng that the word is euery where, why is not the flesh then euery where? For when it was in earth, then verely it was not in heauen: and now when it is in heauen, it is not surely in earth. And it is so sure that it is not in earth, that as concerning it, we loke for him to come from heauen, whom as concerning his eternall word: we beleue to be with vs in earth. Therefore by your doctrine (saith Vigilius vnto Eutiches, who defended that the diuinity and humanity in Christ was but one nature) either the word is conteyned in a place with his flesh: or els the flesh is euery where with the word. For one nature cannot receiue in it selfe two diuers and contrary thinges. But these two thinges be diuers and farre vnlike, that is to say, to be conteyned in a place, aud to be euery where. Therfore in as much as the word is euery where, and the flesh is not euery where, it appeareth plainly, that one Christ himselfe hath in him two natures. And that by his diuine nature he is euery where, and by his humain nature he is contayned in a place, that he is created, and hath no beginning, that he is subiect to death, and cannot dy. Wherof one he hath by the nature of his word (wherby he is God) and the other he hath hy the nature of his flesh, wherby the same God is man also. Therfore one sonne of God, the selfe same was made the sonne of man, and he hath a beginning by the nature of his flesh, and no beginning by the nature of his Godhead. He is created by the nature of his flesh, and not created by the nature of his Godhead. He is comprehended in a place by the nature of his flesh, and not comprehended in a place by the nature of his Godhead. He is inferior to angels in the nature of his flesh, and is equall to his Father in the nature of his Godhead. He dyed by the nature of his flesh, and dyed not by the nature of his Godhead. This is the faith and catholick confession, which the Apostles taught, the Martirs did corroborate, and faithfull people keepe vnto this day.
Al these be the sayings of Vigilius, who according to all the other authors before rehearsed, and to the faith and catholic confession of the Apostles, Martyrs, & all faithful people unto his time) saith, that as concerning Christs humanity, when he was here on earth, he was not in heaven, and now when he is in heaven, he is not in earth. for one nature cannot be both contained in a place in heaven, and be also here in earth at one time. And for as much as Christ is here with us in earth, and also is contained in a place in heaven, he proveth thereby, that Christ hath two natures in him, the nature of a man, whereby he is gone from us, and ascended into heaven, and the nature of his Godhead, whereby he is here with us in earth. So that it is not one nature that is here with us, and that is gone from us, that is ascended into heaven and there contained, and that is permanent here with us in earth. Wherefore the papists (which now of late years have made a new faith, that Christs natural body is really and naturally present both with us both here in earth, & sitteth at the right hand of his Father in heaven) do err in two very horrible heresies.
Al these be the sayinges of Vigilius, who according to al the other authors before rehearsed, and to the faith and catholick confession of the Apostles, Martyrs, & all faithfull people vnto his time) saith, that as concerning Christs humanitie, when he was here on earth, he was not in heauen, and now when he is in heauen, he is not in earth. for one nature cannot be both conteined in a place in heauen, and be also here in earth at one time. And for as much as Christ is here with vs in earth, and also is conteined in a place in heauen, he proueth therby, that Christ hath two natures in him, the nature of a man, wherby he is gone from vs, and ascended into heauen, and the nature of his Godhead, wherby he is here with vs in earth. So that it is not one nature that is here with vs, and that is gone from vs, that is ascended into heauen and there conteined, and that is permanent here with vs in earth. Wherfore the papists (which now of late yeares haue made a new faith, that Christes naturall body is really and naturally present both with vs both here in earth, & sitteth at the right hand of his Father in heauen) doe erre in two very horrible heresies.
The one, that they confound his two natures, his Godhead and his Manhood attributing unto his humanity, that thing which appertaineth only to his divinity, that is to say, to be in heaven, earth, and in many places at one time. The other is, that they divide and separate his human nature or his body, making of one body of Christ, two bodies and two natures, one which is in heaven, ⟨p. 101⟩visible and palpable, having all members and proportions of a most perfect natural man: and an other which they say is in earth here with us, in every bread and wine that is consecrated, having no distinction, form, nor proportion of members, which contrarieties and diversities (as this holy Martyr Vigilius saith) cannot be together in one nature.
The one, that they confound his two natures, his Godhead and his Manhode attributing vnto his humanitie, that thing which appertaineth onely to his diuinity, that is to say, to be in heauē, earth, and in many places at one time. The other is, that they deuide and seperate his humain nature or his body, making of one body of Christ, two bodies and two natures, one which is in heauen, ⟨p. 101⟩visible and palpaple, hauing all members and proportions of a most perfect naturall man: and an other which they say is in earth here with vs, in euery bread and wine that is consecrated, hauing no distinction, forme, nor proportion of members, which contrarieties and diuersities (as this holy Martyr Vigilius saith) cannot be together in one nature.
These differences end in the xlviii. leaf in the second column. I intend now to touch the further matter of the book with the manner of handling of it, and where an evident untruth is, there to join an issue, and where sleight and craft is, there to note it in the whole.
These differences end in the xlviii. leafe in the second columne. I entend now to touch the further matter of the booke with the manner of handlyng of it, and where an euident vntruth is, there to ioyne an issue, and where sleight and craft is, there to note it in the whole.
The matter of the book, from thence unto the lvi. leaf, touching the being of Christ in heaven and not in earth, is out of purpose superfluous. The article of our Creed that Christ ascended to heaven, and sitteth on the right hand of his father, hath been and is most constantly believed of true Christian men, which the true faith of Christs real presence in the Sacrament doth not touch or impair. Nor Christ being whole God & man in the Sacrament, is thereby either out of heaven, or to be said conversant in earth, because the conversation is not earthly, but spiritual and godly,1 being the ascension of Christ, the end of his conversation in earth, and therefore all that reasoning of the author, is clearly void, to travail to prove that is not denied, only for a sleight to make it seem as though it were denied.
The matter of the book, from thēce vnto the lvi. leafe, touching the being of Christ in heauen and not in earth, is out of purpose superfluous. The article of our Créed that Christ ascended to heauen, and sitteth on the right hand of his father, hath béene and is most constantly beleeued of true Christian men, which the true fayth of Christes reall presence in the Sacrament doth not touch or empayre. Nor Christ being whole God & man in the Sacrament, is therby eyther out of heauen, or to be said conuersant in earth, because the conuersation is not earthly, but spirituall and godly,1 being the ascention of Christ, the end of his cōuersation in earth, and therefore al that reasoning of the author, is clearely voyde, to trauayle to proue that is not denyed, onely for a sleyght to make it seeme as though it were denyed.
Here is such a sleight used by you, as is worthy to be noted of all men.1 For I go not only about to prove in this place, only that Christ as concerning his human nature is in heaven (which I know you deny not) but I prove also that he is so in heaven, that he is not in earth, which you utterly deny, and it is the chief point in contention between us. But by this craft of appeaching me of sleight, that I go about to prove that thing which you deny not (which is untrue) you have used such a sleight, that you pass over 8. leaves of my book together, wherein I prove, that Christ (as concerning his corporal presence) is not here in earth, and you answer not one word to any of my arguments. And I pray thee note, good Reader, what a strange manner of sleight this is, to pass over eight leaves together clearly unanswered, and that in the chief point that is in variance between us, under pretence that I use sleight, where in deed I use none, but prove plainly that Christ is not bodily in heaven and in earth, both at one time. If he had but touched mine arguments glancing by them, it had been somewhat: but utterly to fly away, and not once to touch them, I think thou wilt judge no small sleight and craft therein. And me think in good reason, the matter ought to be judged against him, for default of answer: who being present answereth nothing at all to the matter whereof he is accused, seeing that the Law sayth: Qui tacet, consentire videtur.
HEre is such a sleight vsed by you, as is worthy to be noted of all men.1 For I goe not onely about to proue in this place, onely that Christ as concerning his humain nature is in heauē (which I know you deny not) but I proue also that he is so in heauen, that he is not in earth, which you vtterly deny, and it is the chiefe point in contention betwene vs. But by this crafte of appeaching me of sleight, that I goe about to proue that thing which you deny not (which is vntrue) you haue vsed such a sleight, that you passe ouer 8. leaues of my booke together, wherin I proue, that Christ (as concerning his corporall presence) is not here in earth, and you answere not one word to any of my argumentes. And I pray thee note, good Reader, what a strange manner of sleight this is, to passe ouer eight leaues together cleerely vnanswered, and that in the chief point that is in variance betweene vs, vnder pretence that I vse sleight, where in deede I vse none, but proue plainly that Christ is not bodely in heauen and in eareh, both at one time. If he had but touched mine argumēts glauncing by them, it had been somewhat: but vtterly to fly away, and not once to touch them, I think thou wilt iudge no smal sleight and craft therin. And me think in good reason, the matter ought to be iudged against him, for default of answere: who being preseut answereth nothing at all to the matter wherof he is accused, seeing that the Law sayth: Qui tacet, consentire videtur.
Yet Smith is to be commended in respect of you,1 who attempteth at the least to see what shifts he could make to avoid my proofs, and busieth himself rather than he would stand mute, to say something to them. And yet in deed it had been as good for him to have said nothing at all, as to say that which is nothing to the purpose.
Yet Smith is to be commended in respect of you,1 who attempteth at the least to see what shiftes he could make to auoyd my profes, and busyeth himself rather thē he would stand mute, to say somthing to them. And yet in deede it had been as good for him to haue said nothing at all, as to say that which is nothing to the purpose.
First to the Scriptures by me alleged particularly,1 he utterly answereth nothing. To Origen, and S. Augustine by name, and to all the ⟨p. 102⟩other Authors by me alleged, he maketh this brief answer in general, that whatsoever those authors say, they mean no more, but that Christ is not here in earth visibly, naturally, & by circumscription, and yet nevertheless he is in the sacrament above nature, invisibly, and without circumscription. This subtle distinction hath Smith devised (or rather followeth other Papists therein) to answer the Authors which I have alleged. And yet of Smiths own distinction it followeth, that Christ is not in the sacrament carnally and corporally.2 For if Christ be in the Sacrament but supernaturally, invisibly, & without circumscription, then he is not there carnally, and corporally, as S. Augustine reasoneth ad Dardanum. But yet Smith only saith that the Authors so meant, and proveth not one word of his saying, supposing that the old holy writers be like to the Papists, which write one thing, and when they list not, or cannot defend it, they say they mean another.
First to the Scriptures by me alleadged particularly,1 he vtterly answereth nothing. To Origen, and S. Augustine by name, and to all the ⟨p. 102⟩other Authors by me alleadged, he maketh this brief answere in generall, yt whatsoeuer those authors say, they meane no more, but yt Christ is not here in earth visibly, naturally, & by circumscriptiō, and yet neuerthelesse he is in the sacrament aboue nature, inuisibly, and without circumscription. This suttle distinction hath Smith deuised (or rather followeth other Papistes therin) to answere the Authors which I haue alleadged. And yet of Smithes own distinction it followeth, that Christ is not in the sacrament carnally and corporally.2 For if Christ be in the Sacrament but supernaturally, inuisibly, & without circumscription, then he is not there carnally, and corporally, as S. Augustine reasoneth ad Dardanum. But yet Smith onely saith that the Authors so meant, and proueth not one word of his saying, supposing that the old holy writers be like to the Papistes, which write one thing, and when they list not, or cannot defend it, they say they meane another.
For those Authors make no such distinction as Smith speaketh of, affirming divers and contrary things to be in one nature of Christ in divers respects, but their distinction is of the two natures in Christ, that is to say, the nature of his Godhead, and the nature of his manhood. And they affirm plainly that the diversity whereof they spake, cannot be in one nature (as you say it is) but must needs argue & prove diversity of natures. And therefore by that diversity and instinctiō in Christ, they prove against the heretics, that Christ hath two natures in him, which were utterly no proof at all, if one nature in divers respects might have that diversity. For the heretics should have had a ready answer at hand, that such diversity proveth not that Christ had two natures, for one nature may have such diversity (if it be true that Smith saith.) And so Smith, with other papists which saith as he doth putteth a sword in the heretics hands, to fight against the catholic faith. This (good Reader) thou shalt easily perceive if thou do no more but read the authors which I have in this place alleged.
For those Authors make no such distinction as Smith speaketh of, affirming diuers and contrary things to be in one nature of Christ in diuers respectes, but their distinction is of the two natures in Christ, that is to say, the nature of his Godhead, and the nature of his manhode. And they affirme plainly that the diuersity wherof they spake, cannot be in one nature (as you say it is) but must needes argue & proue diuersity of natures. And therfore by that diuersity and instinctiō in Christ, they proue against the heretickes, that Christ hath two natures in him, which were vtterly no proofe at all, if one nature in diuers respectes might haue that diuersity. For the heretickes should haue had a ready answere at hand, that such diuersitie proueth not that Christ had two natures, for one nature may haue such diuersity (if it be true that Smith saith.) And so Smith, with other papists which saith as he doth putteth a sword in ye hereticks hands, to fight against the catholick faith. This (good Reader) thou shalt easely perceiue if thou doe no more but read the authors which I haue in this place alleadged.
And yet for thy more ready instruction, I shall make a brief rehearsal of the chief effect of them, as concerning this matter.1 To answer this question how it can be said that Christ is a stranger, and gone hence into heaven, and yet is also here with us in earth, Smith and other Papists resolve this matter by divers respects in one nature of Christ, but the old catholic writers which I alleged, resolve the matter by two natures in Christ,2 affirming most certainly that such two divers things can not have place both in one nature. And therefore say they that Christ is gone hence, and is absent in his humanity, who in his Deity is still here with us. They say also that as concerning his mans nature, the Catholic profession in our Creed, teacheth us to believe that he hath made it immortal, but not changed the nature of a very mans body, for his body is in heaven, and in one certain place of heaven, because that so requireth the measure and compass of a very mans body.
And yet for thy more ready instruction, I shall make a brief rehearsal of the chief effect of them, as concerning this matter.1 To aunswere this question how it can be sayd that Christ is a stranger, and gone hence into heauen, and yet is also here with vs in earth, Smith and other Papistes resolue this matter by diuers respectes in one nature of Christ, but the old catholick wryters which I alleadged, resolue the matter by two natures in Christ,2 affirming most certainly that such two diuers thinges can not haue place both in one nature. And therfore say they that Christ is gone hence, and is absent in his humanitie, who in his Deity is still here with vs. They say also that as concerning his mannes nature, the Catholicke profession in our Creede, teacheth vs to beleeue that he hath made it immortall, but not changed the nature of a very mannes body, for his body is in heauen, and in one certain place of heauen, because that so requireth the measure and compasse of a very mannes body.
It is also (say they) visible, and hath all the members of a perfect mans body. And further they say, that if Christs body were not contained within the compass of a place, it were no body, in so much that if the Godhead were a body, it must needs be in a place, and have quantity, bigness, and circumscription. For all creatures (say they) visible, and ⟨p. 103⟩invisible, be circumscribed, and contained within a certain compass, ether locally within one place (as corporal and visible things be) or else within the property of their own substance (as angels and invisible creatures be.) And this is one strong argument, whereby they prove that the holy Ghost is God, because he is in many places at one time, which no creature can be as they teach. And yet they say moreover, that Christ did not ascend into heaven, but by his humanity, nor is not hear in earth but by his divinity, which hath no compass nor measure. And finally they say that to go to his father from us, was to take from us that nature which he received of us: and therefore when his body was in earth, then surely it was not in heaven, and now when it is in heaven, surely it is not in earth For one nature can not have in it self two sundry and contrary things.
It is also (say they) visible, and hath all the members of a perfecte mannes body. And further they say, that if Christes body were not conteyned within the compasse of a place, it were no body, in so much that if the Godhead were a body, it must needes be in a place, and haue quantitie, bignes, and circumscription. For all creatures (say they) visible, and ⟨p. 103⟩inuisible, be circumscribed, and conteyned within a certain compas, ether locally within one place (as corporall and visible thinges be) or els within the property of their own substance (as angels and inuisible creatures be.) And this is one strong argument, whereby they proue that the holy Ghost is God, because he is in many places at one time, which no creature can be as they teach. And yet they say moreouer, that Christ did not ascend into heauen, but by hys humanitie, nor is not heare in earth but by hys diuinitie, which hath no compasse nor measure. And finally they say that to go to hys father from vs, was to take from vs that nature which he receaued of vs: and therfore when hys body was in earth, then surely it was not in heauen, and now when it is in heauē, surely it is not in earth For one nature can not haue in it selfe two sundry and contrary thinges.
All things here rehearsed be written by the old ancient authors which I have alleged, and they conclude the whole matter in this wise that this is the faith and Catholic confession, which the Apostles taught, the Martyrs did corroborate, and faithful people keep unto this day. Whereby it appeareth evidently, that the doctrine of Smith and the Papists, at that day was not yet sprung, nor had taken no root.
All things here rehearsed be written by the old auncient authors which I haue alleadged, and they conclude the whole matter in this wise that this is the fayth and Catholique confession, which the Apostles taught, the Martyres did corroborate, and faythfull people keepe vnto this day. Wherby it appeareth euidently, that the doctrine of Smyth and the Papistes, at that day was not yet sprong, nor had taken no roote.
Wherefore diligently ponder and way (I beseech thee gentle reader) the sayings of these authors, and see whether they say, that one nature in Christ may be both in heaven and in earth, both here with us, and absent from us at one time, and whether they resolve this matter of Christs being in heaven and in earth (as Smith doth) to be understand of his manhood in diversity of these respects visible and invisible. And when thou hast well considered the authors sayings, then give credit to Smith as thou shalt see cause.
Wherfore diligently ponder and way (I besech thee gentle reader) the sayinges of these authors, and see whether they say, that one nature in Christ may be both in heauen and in earth, both here with vs, and absent from vs at one tyme, and whether they resolue this matter of Christs being in heauen and in earth (as Smith doth) to be vnderstand of his māhoode in diuersitie of these respectes visible and inuisible. And when thou hast well considered the authors sayinges, then geue credite to Smith as thou shalt see cause.
But this allegation of these authors hath made the matter so hot, that the Bishop of Winchester durst not once touch it, and Smith as soon as he had touched it, felt it so scalding hot, that he durst not abide it, but shrank away by and by for fear of burning his fingers. Now here what followeth further in my book.
But this allegation of these authors hath made the matter so hote, that the Bishop of Winchester durste not once touch it, and Smith as soone as he had touched it, felt it so scawlding hote, that he durst not abyde it, but shranke away by and by for feare of burning his fingers. Now here what followeth further in my booke.
But now seeing that it is so evident a matter,1 both by the express words of Scripture, and also by all the old authors of the same, that our Saviour Christ (as concerning his bodily presence) is ascended into heaven, and is not here in earth. And seeing that this hath been the true confession of the Catholic faith, ever since Christs ascension, it is now to be considered what moved the Papists to make a new and contrary faith, and what Scriptures have they for their purpose. What moved them I know not but their own iniquity, or the nature and condition of the sea of Rome, which is of all other most contrary to Christ, and therefore most worthy to be called the sea of Antichrist. And as for Scripture they allege none but only one, and that not truly understanded, but to serve their purpose wrested out of tune, whereby they make it to jar, and sound contrary to all other Scriptures pertaining to the matter.
But now seeing that it is so euident a matter,1 both by the expresse words of Scripture, and also by all the old authors of the same, that our Sauiour Christ (as concerning his bodely presence) is ascended into heauen, and is not here in earth. And seeing that this hath been the true confession of the Catholicke faith, euer since Christes ascention, it is now to be considered what mooued the Papistes to make a new and contrary faith, and what Scriptures haue they for their purpose. What moued them I know not but their own iniquitie, or the nature and condition of the sea of Rome, which is of al other most contrary to Christ, and therfore most worthy to be called the sea of Antichrist. And as for Scripture they alleadge none but onely one, and that not truely vnderstanded, but to serue their purpose wrested out of tune, wherby they make it to iarre, and sound contrary to all other Scriptures pertaining to the matter.
Christ toke bread (say they) blessed, & brake it, & gave it to his disciples, saying: This is my body: These words they ever still repeat and beat upon,1 that Christ said this is my body. And this saying they make their shoot anchor, to prove thereby as well the real and natural presence of Christs body in the Sacrament, as their imagined Transubstantiation. For these words of Christ, say ⟨p. 104⟩they, be most plain, and most true. Then for as much as he said, This is my body, it must needs be true that that thing which the Priest holdeth is his hands is Christs body. And if it be Christs body, then can it not be bread. Whereof they gather by their reasoning, that there is Christs body really present, and no bread.
Christ toke bread (say they) blessed, & brake it, & gaue it to his disciples, saying: This is my body: These words they euer still repeate and beate vpon,1 that Christ sayd this is my body. And this saying they make their shooteanker, to proue therby as well the reall and naturall presence of Christs body in the Sacrament, as their imagined Transubstantiation. For these words of Christ, say ⟨p. 104⟩they, be most plain, and most true. Then for as much as he said, This is my body, it must needes be true that that thing which the Priest holdeth is his hands is Christs body. And if it be Christes body, then can it not be bread. Whereof they gather by their reasoning, that there is Christes body really present, and noe bread.
1Now forasmuch as all their proof hangeth only upon these words, this is my body: the true sense and meaning of these words must be examined. But (say they) what need they any examination? what words can be more plain, then to say: This is my body.
1Now forasmuch as all their proofe hangeth onely vpon these wordes, this is my body: the true sence and meaning of these wordes must be examined. But (say they) what neede they any examination? what wordes can be more plain, then to say: This is my body.
1Truth it is in deed that the words be as plain as may be spoken, but that the sense is not so plain, it is manifest to every man that wayeth substantially the circumstances of the place. For when Christ gave bread to his disciples and said: This is my body. there is no man of any discretion, that understandeth the english tongue, but he may well know by the order of the speech, that Christ spake those words of the bread, calling it his body: as all the old authors also do affirm, although some of the Papists deny the same. Wherefore this sentence can not mean as the words seem and purport, but there must needs be some figure or mystery in this speech, more then appeareth in the plain words. For by this manner of speech plainly understand without any figure, as the words lye, can be gathered none other sense, but that bread is Christs body, and that Christs body is bread, which all Christian ears do abhor to hear. Wherefore in these words must needs be sought out another sense & meaning then the words of themselves do bear.
1Truth it is in deed that the wordes be as plain as may be spoaken, but that the sence is not so plain, it is manifest to euery man that wayeth substantially the circumstances of the place. For when Christ gaue bread to his disciples and said: This is my body. there is no man of any discretiō, that vnderstandeth the english tongue, but he may well know by the order of the speache, that Christ spake those wordes of the bread, callyng it his body: as all the old authors also do affirme, although some of the Papistes deny the same. Wherfore this sentence can not meane as the wordes seeme and purport, but there must needes be some figure or mistery in this speech, more then appeareth in the playne wordes. For by this manner of speeche plainly vnderstand without any figure, as the wordes lye, can be gathered none other sence, but that bread is Christes body, and that Christes body is bread, which all Christian eares do abhorre to heare. Wherefore in these wordes must needes be sought out another sence & meaning then the words of themselues do beare.
1And although the true sense and understanding of these words, be sufficiently declared before, when I spake of Transubstantiation, yet to make the matter so plain, that no scruple or doubt shall remain, here is occasion given, more fully to entreat thereof. In which process shall be showed, that these sentences of Christ, This is my body, This is my blood, be figurative speeches. And although it be manifest enough by the plain words of the gospel, and proved before in the process of Transubstantiation, that Christ spake of bread, when he said, This is my body: likewise that it was very wine, which he called his blood: yet least the Papists should say, that we suck this out of our own fingers, the same shall be proved by testimony of the old authors, to be the true and old faith of the catholic Church. Where as the school authors and Papists, shall not be able to show so much as one word of any ancient author to the contrary.
1And although the true sense and vnderstanding of these wordes, be sufficiently declared before, when I spake of Transubstantiation, yet to make the matter so playne, that no scrouple or doubt shall remayne, here is occasion giuen, more fully to intreate therof. In whiche processe shalbe shewed, that these sentences of Christ, This is my body, This is my bloud, be figuratiue speches. And although it be manifest inough by the playn wordes of the gospel, and proued before in the processe of Transubstantiation, that Christ spake of bread, when he sayd, This is my body: likewise that it was very wyne, which he called his bloud: yet least the Papistes should say, that we sucke this out of our own fyngers, the same shall be proued by testimony of the old authors, to be the true and old fayth of the catholicke Church. Where as the schole authors and Papistes, shall not be able to shew so much as one word of any auncient author to the contrary.
1First Ireneus, writing against the Valentinians in his fourth book sayeth, that Christ confessed bread (which is a creature) to be his body, and the cup to be his blood. And in the same book he writeth thus also: The bread wherein the thanks be given is the body of the Lord. And yet again in the same book he saith, that Christ taking bread of the same sort that our bread is of, confessed that it was his body. 2And that that thing which was tempered in the chalice, was his blood And in the fifth book he writeth further that of the chalice (which is his body) a man is nourished and doth grow by the bread, which is his body.
1First Ireneus, writing against the Valentinians in his fourth booke sayeth, that Christ confessed bread (which is a creature) to be his body, and the cuppe to be his bloud. And in the same booke he writeth thus also: The bread wherin the thanks be geuen is the body of the Lord. And yet again in the same booke he saith, that Christ taking bread of the same sort that our bread is of, confessed that it was his body. 2And that that thing which was tempered in the chalice, was his bloud And in the fift booke he writeth further that of the chalice (which is his body) a man is nourished and doth grow by the bread, which is his body.
1These words of Ireneus be most plain, that Christ taking very material bread, a creature of God, and of such sort as other bread is which we do use, called that his body, when he said: this is my body, and the wine also which doth feed and nourish us, he called his blood.
1These wordes of Ireneus be most plain, that Christ taking very materiall bread, a creature of God, and of such sort as other bread is which we doe vse, called that his body, when he said: this is my body, and the wine also which doth feede and nourish vs, he called his bloud.
Tertullian likewise in his book written against the Jews, saith that Christ ⟨p. 105⟩called bread his body. And in his book against Martian he oftentimes repeateth the self same words. And S. Cyprian in the first book of his epistles,1 saith the same thing, that Christ called such bread as is made of many corns joined together, his body: and such wine he called his blood, as is pressed out of many grapes, and made into mine. And in his second book he saith these words: Water is not the blood of Christ, but wine. And again in the same epistle he saith: that it was wine which Christ called his blood, and that if wine be not in the chalice,, then we drink not of the fruit of the vine. And in the same Epistle he saith: that meal alone, or water clone, is not the body of Christ, except they be both joined together to make thereof bread.
Tertullian likewise in his booke written against the Iewes, saith that Christ ⟨p. 105⟩called bread his body. And in his booke against Martian he oftentimes repeateth the selfe same wordes. And S. Cipryan in the first booke of his epistles,1 saith the same thing, that Christ called such bread as is made of many cornes ioyned together, his body: and such wine he called his bloud, as is pressed out of many grapes, and made into mine. And in his second booke he saith these wordes: Water is not the bloud of Christ, but wine. And againe in the same epistle he saith: that it was wine which Christ called hys bloud, and that if wine be not in the chalice,, then we drinke not of the fruit of the vine. And in the same Epistle he saith: that meale alone, or water clone, is not the body of Christ, except they be both ioyned together to make therof bread.
Epiphanius also saith,1 that Christ speaking of a loaf which is round in fashion, and cannot see, hear, nor feel, said of it: This is my body.
Epiphanius also saith,1 that Christ speaking of a lofe which is round in fashion, and cannot see, heare, nor feele, said of it: This is my body.
And S. Hierome writing ad Hedibiam, 1saith these words: Let us mark that the bread which the Lord brake, and gave to his disciples, was the body of our Saviour Christ, as he said unto them: Take and eat, this is my body. And S. Augustine also saith,2 that although we may set forth Christ by mouth, by writing, and by the sacrament of his body and blood, yet we call neither our tongue, nor words, nor ink, letters, nor paper, the body and blood of christ but that we call the body and blood of Christ, which is taken of the fruit of the earth, and consecrated by mystical prayer. And also he saith: Jesus called meat, his body, and drink his blood,
And S. Hierome wryting ad Hedibiam, 1saith these wordes: Let vs marke that the bread which the Lord brake, and gaue to his disciples, was the body of our Sauiour Christ, as he sayd vnto them: Take and eate, this is my body. And S. Augustine also sayth,2 that although we may set forth Christ by mouth, by writing, and by the sacrament of his body and bloud, yet we call neither our toung, nor words, nor inke, letters, nor paper, the body and bloud of christ but that we call the body and bloud of Christ, which is taken of the fruite of the earth, and consecrated by misticall prayer. And also he sayth: Iesus called meat, his body, and drynke his bloud,
Moreover Cyril upon S. John saith,1 that Christ gave to his disciples pieces of bread saying: Take, eat, this is my body.
Moreouer Cyrill vpon S. Iohn saith,1 that Christ gaue to his disciples peces of bread saying: Take, eate, this is my body.
Likewise Theoderetus saith, When Christ gave the holy mysteries, he called bread his body, and the cup mixed with wine and water, he called his blood. By all these foresaid authors and places, with many mo, it is plainly proved, that when our saviour Christ gave bread unto his Disciples, saying, Take and eat, this is my body, And likewise when he gave them the cup, saying, Divide this among you, and drink you all of this, for this is my blood: he called then the very material bread his body, and the very wine his blood.
Likewise Theoderetus saith, When Christ gaue the holy misteries, he called bread his body, and the cuppe myxt with wine and water, he called his bloud. By all these foresayd authours and places, whith many mo, it is playnly proued, that when our sauiour Christ gaue bread vnto his Disciples, saying, Take and eate, this is my body, And likewise when he gaue them the cuppe, saying, Diuide this among you, and drinke you all of this, for this is my bloud: he called then the very materiall bread his body, and the very wine his bloud.
That bread (I say) that is one of the creatures here in earth among us, and that groweth out of the earth, and is made of many grains of corn beaten into flower, and mixed with water, and so baken and made into bread, of such sort as other our bread is, that hath neither sense nor reason, and finally that feedeth and nourisheth our bodies, such bread Christ called his body, when he said, This is my body, And such wine as is made of grapes pressed together and thereof is made drink, which nourish the body, such wine he called his blood.
That bread (I say) that is one of the creatures here in earth among vs, and that groweth out of the earth, and is made of many graynes of corne beaten into flower, and mixed with water, and so baken aud made into bread, of such sort as other our bread is, that hath neither sence nor reason, and finally that feedeth and nourisheth our bodies, such bread Christ called his body, when he sayd, This is my body, And such wine as is made of grapes pressed togither and thereof is made drinke, whiche nourishe the body, such wine he called his bloud.
This is the true doctrine, confirmed as well by the holy scripture, as by all ancient authors of Christs Church, both Greeks and Latins, that is to say, that when our Saviour Christ gave bread and wine to his disciples, & spake these words, This is my body, This is my blood, it is very bread & wine which he called his body and blood.
This is the true doctrine, confirmed as well by the holy scripture, as by all auncient authours of Christes Church, both Greekes and Latines, that is to say, that whē our Sauiour Christ gaue bread and wine to his disciples, & spake these words, This is my body, This is my bloud, it is very bread & wine which he called his body and bloud.
Now let the Papists show some authority for their opinion, either of scripture, or of some ancient author. And let them not constrain all men to follow their fond devises, only because they say, It is so, without any other ground or authority, but their own bare words. For in such wise credit is to be given to Gods word only, and not to the word of any man. As many of them as I have red (the bishop of Winchester only excepted) do say, that Christ called ⟨p. 106⟩not bread his body, nor wine his blood, when he said, This is my body, This is my blood. And yet in expounding these words, they vary among them selves: which is a token that they be uncertain of their own doctrine.
Now let the Papistes shew some authority for their opinion, either of scripture, or of some aunciant author. And let them not constrayne all men to follow their fond deuises, only because they say, It is so, without any other groūd or authoritie, but their owne bare wordes. For in such wise credite is to be geuen to Gods word only, and not to the word of any man. As many of them as I haue red (the byshop of Winchester onely excepted) do say, that Christ called ⟨p. 106⟩not bread his body, nor wine his bloud, when he sayd, This is my body, This is my bloud. And yet in expoūding these wordes, they vary among them selues: which is a token that they be vncertaine of their own doctrine.
For some of them say, that by this pronoun demonstrative (this) Christ understood not the bread and wine, but his body and blood.
For some of them say, that by this pronoune demonstratiue (this) Christe vnderstoode not the bread and wine, but his body and bloud.
And other some say, that by the pronoun (this) he meant neither the bread nor wine, not his body nor blood, but that he meant a particular thing uncertain, which they call Individuum vagum, or Individuum in genere, I trow some Mathematical quiddity, they can not tell what.
And other some say, that by the pronoune (this) he ment neither the bread nor wine, not his body nor bloud, but that he ment a particuler thyng vncertain, which they call Indiuiduum vagum, or Indiuiduum in genere, I trowe some Mathematicall quiditee, they can not tell what.
But let all these Papists together show any one authority, either of scripture, or of ancient author, either Greek or Latin, that saith as they say, that Christ called not bread and wine his body and blood, but Individuum vagum, and for my part I shall give them place and confess that they say true.
But let all these Papistes togyther shew any one authoritie, eyther of scripture, or of auncient author, either Greke or Latine, that sayth as they say, that Christ called not bread and wine his body and bloud, but Indiuiduum vagum, and for my part I shall gyue them place and confesse that they say true.
And if they can show nothing for them of antiquity, but only their own bare words, then it is reason that they give place to the trueth confirmed by so many authorities, both of scripture and of ancient writers, which is, that Christ called very material bread his body, and very wine made of grapes, his blood.
And if they can shew nothing for them of antiquitie, but onely theyr own bare wordes, then it is reason that they geue place to the trueth confirmed by so many authorities, bothe of scripture and of auncient writers, which is, that Christ called very materiall bread his body, and very wine made of grapes, his bloude.
After this the author occupieth a great number of leaves, that is to say, from the lvii. leaf unto the lxxiiii, to prove Christs words. This is my body) to be a figurative speech. Sleight and shift is used in the matter without any effectual consecution, to him that is learned.
After this the author occupieth a great number of leaues, that is to say, from the lvii. leafe vnto the lxxiiii, to proue Christs words. This is my body) to be a figuratiue spech. Sleight and shift is vsed in the matter without any offectuall consecution, to him that is learned.