pp. 3941,982 passagespart 36 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
We see also that the wine, though it be consecrated, yet will it turn to vinegar, and the bread will mould: which then be nothing else but sower wine and moulded bread, which could not wax sower nor mouldy, if there were no bread nor wine there at all.
We see also that the wine, though it be consecrated, yet will it tourne to vineger, and the bread will mowle: which then be nothing els but sower wine and mowled bread, which could not wax sower nor mowly, if there were no bread nor wine there at all.
And if the sacraments were now burnt (as in the old church they burned all that remained uneaten) let the Papists tell what is burnt. They must needs say, that it is either bread or the body of Christ. But bread (say they) is none there: then must they needs burn the body of Christ, and be called Christ burners (as heretofore they have burned many of his members) except they will say, that accidents burn alone without any substance, contrary to all the course of nature.
And if the sacramentes were now brent (as in the olde church they burned all that remayned vneaten) let the Papistes tell what is brent. They must nedes say, that it is eyther bread or the body of Christ. But bread (say they) is none there: then must they nedes burne the body of Christ, and be called Christ burners (as heretofore they haue burned many of his members) except they will say, that accidents burne alone without any substaunce, contrary to all the course of nature.
The sacramental bread and wine also will nourish, which nourishment naturally cometh to the substance of the meats and drinks, and not of the accidents.
The sacramentall bread and wine also will nourish, which nourishment naturally cometh to the substaunce of the meates and drinkes, and not of the accidentes.
The wine also will poison, (as divers bishops of Rome have had experiences, both in poisoning of other, and being poisoned them selves) which poisoning they can not ascribe to the most wholesome blood of our Saviour Christ, but only to the poisoned wine.
The wine also will poyson, (as diuers bishops of Rome haue had experiences, both in poysoning of other, and being poysoned them selues) which poysoning they can not ascribe to the most holsome bloud of our Sauiour Christ, but onely to the poysoned wine.
And most of all, it is against the nature of accidents, to be in nothing. For that definition of accidents, is to be in some substance, so that if they be, they must needs be in some thing. And if they be in nothing, than they be not. And a thousand things moe, of like foolishness do the Papists affirm by their transubstantiation, contrary to all nature and reason. As that two bodies be in one place, and one body in many places at one time, and that substances be gendered of accidents only, and accidents converted into substances, and a body to be in a place, and occupy no room, and generation to be without corruption, and corruption without generation, and that substances be made of nothing, and turned into nothing, with many such like things, against all order and principles of nature and reason.
And most of all, it is agaynst the nature of accidents, to be in nothing. For that definition of accidents, is to be in some substance, so that if they be, they must nedes be in some thing. And if they be in nothing, than they be not. And a thousād thinges moe, of like foolishnes do the Papistes affirme by their transubstantiation, contrary to all nature and reason. As that two bodies be in one place, and one body in many places at one tyme, and that substances be gendred of accidents onely, and accidents conuerted into substances, and a body to be in a place, and occupy no roume, and generation to be without corruption, and corruption without generation, and that substances be made of nothing, and turned into nothing, with many such like thinges, agaynst all order and principles of nature and reason.
In the third chapter written in the xxi. leaf it troubleth this author that the doctrine of Transubstantiation is in his judgement against natural reason and natural operation: in the entry of which matter he granteth wisely that they should not prevail against gods word, and yet he saith, when they be joined with gods word, they be of §1great moment to confirm any truth: wherein if he meaneth to confirm Gods word by reason, or gods mysteries by natural operation, mine understanding cannot reach that doctrine, and is more strange to me, then this author maketh Transubstantiation to be to him. As for the reason of (vacuum) declareth a vacuum, that nature abhorreth §2not. And if we speak after the rules of nature, quantity filleth the place rather than substance. And shortly to answer this Author, it is not said in the doctrine of Transubstantiation, that there remaineth nothing: for in the visible form of bread remaineth §3the proper object of every sense truly: that is seen with the bodily eye, is truly seen, that is felt, is truly felt, that is savoured, is truly savoured, and those things corrupt, putrefy, nourish and consume after the truth of the former nature, God so ordering it that create all, using singularly that creature of bread, not to unite it unto him as he did mans nature, to be in bread impanate, & breaded as he was in flesh incarnate. And as for reason in place of service as being inferior to saith, will agree with the faith of Transubstantiation well enough. For if our faith of the true presence of Christs very body be true, as it is most true grounded upon these words of Christ (This is my ⟨p. 265⟩body,) then reason yielding to that truth, will not strive with Transubstantiation, but plainly affirm that by his judgement, if it be the body of Christ, it is not bread. For §4in the rule of common reason, the grant of one substance is the denial of an other,1 and therefore reason hath these conclusions throughly, whatsoever is bread is no wine whatsoever is wine, is no milk, and so forth.
In the third chapiter written in the xxi. leafe it troubleth this author that ye doctrine of Transubstantiation is in his iudgement agaynst naturall reason and naturall operation: in the entry of which matter he graunteth wisely that they should not preuayle agaynst gods worde, and yet he sayth, when they be ioyned with gods word, they be of
And therefore being once believed this to be the body of Christ, reason saith by and by, it is not bread by the rule aforesaid, whereby appeareth how reason doth not strive with Transubstantiation, being once conquered with saith of the true presence of Christs body, which is most evident, and no whit darkened by any thing this Author §6hath brought. As for natural operation is not in all mens judgements as this Author taketh it, who seemeth to repute it for an inconvenience, to say that the accidents of wine do sower and ware vinegar. But ulpian, a man of notable learning, is not afraid to write in the law,1 In venditionibus, de contrahenda emptione, in the Pandeas, that of wine and vinegar there is (prope eadem [Greek or Hebrew] ) in manner one substance, wherein he showeth him self far against this Authors skill, which I put for an example to show that natural operations have had in natural mens judgements divers considerations, one sometime repugnant to an other, and yet the Authors of both opinions called Philosophers all. Among which some thought (for example) they spake wisely, that esteemed all thing to alter as swiftly as the water runneth in the stream, and thought therefore no man could utter a word, being the same man in the end of the word that he was when he began to speak, and used a similitude. Like as a man standing in one place can not touch the same one water twice in a running stream, no more can a man be touched the same man twice, but he altereth as swiftly as both the stream. These were laughed to scorn, yet they thought themselves wise in natural speculation, Aristotle (that is much esteemed and worthily) fancied a first matter in all things to be one, in which consideration he seemeth to be as extreme in a stay, as the other fond Philosophers were in moving. By which two extremities I condemn not natural speculation, wherewith I think God pleased for man to marvel in contemplation of his inferior works, and to tame his rash wit in the inexplicable variety of it, but to use it so, as to make it §7an open adversary to religion, it is me seemeth without all purpose.
And therfore being once beleued this to be the body of Christ, reason sayth by and by, it is not bread by the rule aforesayd, wherby appeareth how reason doth not striue with Transubstantiation, being once conquered with sayth of the true presence of Christes body, which is most euident, and no whit darkened by any thing this Author
The doctrine of Transubstantiation doth not teach no earthly thing to remain in the Sacrament, but contrariwise, that the visible form of bread and wine is there as the visible figure of the Sacrament, and to be the same in greatness, in thickness, in weight in savour, in taste, §8in propriety also to corrupt, putrefy, and nourish, as it did before, and yet the substance of those visible creatures, to be converted into the substance (as Emissene saith) of the body of Christ. And here will reason do service is saith, to say if there be a conversion in deed as faith teacheth, and none of the accidents be converted, then the substance is converted, for in every thing all is substance and accidents, but the accidents be not changed, and yet a change there is, it must needs be then that substance is changed. Which deduction reason will make, and so agree with Transubstantiation in convenient due service. And thus I have gotten reasons good will, whatsoever this author saith, and from the ground of faith have by reason deduced such a conclusion to prove transubstantiation, as unless he destroy the true faith of the presence of Christs very body which he can not, must needs be allowed. And as for natural operation of putrefying, engendering worms, burning, and such experiences, which being the substance of bread absent, this Author thinketh can not be so; when he hath thought throughly, he can of §9his thought conclude it only to be a marvel, and it be so as against the common rules of philosophy, wherein as me seemeth it were a nearer way, as we be admonished to leave searching of (how) of the work of God in the mystery of Christs presence being that the celestial part of the sacrament so not to search (how) in the experience of the operation of nature, of the visible earthly part of the Sacrament. When God sent Manna in desert, the people saw many marvels in it, besides the common operation of nature, and yet they never troubled them selves with (hows). And as one very well writeth, it is consonant that as there is a great miracle in the work of God to make there present the substance of the body of Christ, to likewise to knowledge the miracle in the absence of the substance of bread, and both the heavenly and earthly part of the sacrament to be miraculous, and so many miracles to be joined together in one, agreeth with the ⟨p. 266⟩excellency of the Sacrament.
The doctrine of Transubstantiation doth not teach no earthly thing to remayne in the Sacrament, but contrarywise, that the visible forme of bread and wine is there as the visible figure of the Sacrament, and to be the same in greatnes, in thicknes, in wayght in sauor, in tast,
As for the objections this Author maketh in this matter, be such as he findeth in those scholastical writers, that discuss as they may or labour thereabout wherewith to satisfy idle imaginations, and to make learned men prompt §10and ready to say somewhat to these trifles, whose arguments this author taketh for his principal foundation. For plain resolution and avoiding whereof, if I would now for my part bring forth their solutions and answers, there were a part of school Theology, so brought into English, to no great praise of either of out learnings, but our vain labour, to set abroad other mens travails to trouble rude wits with matter not necessary, and by such unreverent disputing and alteration to hinder the truth. Finally all that this Author rehearseth of absurdity, repugneth in his estimation only is the conclusion of philosophy, which should nothing move the humble simplicity of saith in a christen man, who marvelleth at Gods works and reputeth them true, although he can not comprehend the ways and means of them.
As for the obiections this Author maketh in this matter, be such as he findeth in those scholasticall writers, that discusse as they may or labour thereaboute wherwith to satisfie idle imaginations, and to make learned men prompt §10and ready to say sumwhat to these trifles, whose arguments this author taketh for his principall foundation. For playne resolution and auoyding wherof, if I would now for my parte bring forth their solutions and answers, there were a part of schole Theologie, so brought into English, to no great prayse of eyther of out learninges, but our vayne labour, to set abrode other mens trauayles to trouble rude wittes with matter not necessary, and by such vnreuerent disputing and alteration to hinder the truth. Finally all that this Author reherseth of absurdity, repugneth in his estimation onely is the conclusion of philosophie, which should nothing moue the humble simplicite of sayth in a christen man, who meruayleth at Gods workes and reputeth them true, although he can not comprehend the wayes and meanes of them.
Here in the beginning of this chapter, it is a strange thing to me, that §1you should think strangeness in my saying, that natural reason and operation joined to Gods word should be of great moment to confirm any truth, not that they add any authority to Gods word, but that they help our infirmity: as the sacraments do to Gods promises, which promises in themselves be most certain and true. For did not the eating and drinking of Christ, his labouring and sweating, his agony and pangs of death,1 confirm the true faith of his incarnation? And did not his eating with the Apostles confirm and stablish their faith of his resurrection?2 Did not the sight of Christ and feeling of his wounds induce Thomas to believe that Christ was risen? When neither the report of the devout woman, nor yet of the Apostles which did see him, could cause him to believe Christs resurrection? And when they took our Saviour Christ for a spirit, did not he cause them by their sight and feeling of his flesh and bones, to believe that he was very man, and no spirit, as they fantasied? Which sensible proofs were so far from derogation of faith that they were a sure establishment thereof. Wherefore if your understanding can not reach this doctrine, it is indeed very slender in godly things.
HEre in the beginning of this chapiter, it is a strange thing to me, that §1you should thinke strangenes in my saying, that naturall reason and operation ioyned to Gods word should be of great moment to confirme any truth, not that they adde any authority to Gods word, but that they helpe our infirmity: as the sacraments do to Gods promises, which promises in themselues be most certayne and true. For did not the eating and drincking of Christ, his laboring and sweating, his agony and pangs of death,1 confirme the true fayth of his incarnation? And did not his eating with the Apostles confirme and stablish their fayth of his resurrection?2 Dyd not the sight of Christ and feeling of his woundes induce Thomas to beleue that Christ was risen? When neyther the report of the deuout woman, nor yet of the Apostles which did see him, could cause him to beleue Christes resurrection? And when they tooke our Sauiour Christ for a spirite, did not he cause them by their sight and feeling of his flesh and bones, to beleue that he was very man, and no spirite, as they phantasied? Which sensible profes were so farre from derogation of fayth that they were a sure establishment therof. Wherfore if your vnderstanding can not reach this doctrine, it is indede very slender in godly thynges.
And as for my reason of vacuum, you have not yet answered thereto, for §2nature suffereth not any place to be without some substance, which by means of his quantity filleth the place. And quantity without substance to fill any place, is so fare from the rulers of nature, that by order of nature, quantity without substance hath neither filling nor being. And although I do not say, that by the doctrine of Transubstantiation there remaineth nothing, (so that all that you speak to answer that matter, is to no purpose, but res vacua) yet by the doctrine of Transubstantiation joined unto nature, there should remain utterly nothing in deed: for substance remaineth none, by your doctrine of Transubstantiation, and without substance can be no accidents by the rules of nature. Therefore comparing your doctrine and nature together, either you must recant your doctrine of Transubstantiation, or confess that nothing remaineth, or at the least grant that your teaching repugneth to the order of nature, which sufficeth for me in this place, where my purpose is only to show, how the doctrine of Transubstantiation is against nature and reason.
And as for my reason of vacuum, you haue not yet answered thereto, for §2nature suffereth not any place to be without some substance, which by meanes of his quantity filleth the place. And quantity without substance to fill any place, is so fare from the rulers of nature, that by order of nature, quantity without substance hath neither filling nor being. And although I do not say, that by the doctrine of Transubstantiation there remayneth nothing, (so that all that you speake to answere that matter, is to no purpose, but res vacua) yet by the doctrine of Transubstantiation ioyned vnto nature, there should remayne vtterly nothing in deede: for substance remayneth none, by your doctrine of Transubstantiation, and without substance can be no accidents by the rules of nature. Therfore comparing your doctrine and nature together, eyther you must recant your doctrine of Transubstantiatiō, or confesse that nothing remayneth, or at the least graunt that your teaching repugneth to the order of nature, which suffiseth for me in this place, where my purpose is onely to shew, how the doctrine of Transubstantiatiō is agaynst nature and reason.
Now where you so often speak of the visible form of bread remaining ⟨p. 267⟩§3by this word (form) you sweetly deceive your self,1 thinking that it doth much advance your faith of Transubstantiation, understanding by that word the accidences, similitudes, and likeness without substance remaining, misunderstanding both holy scripture and the ancient doctors. S. Paul speaking of Christs incarnation saith,2 that he being in form of God, did humble him self, taking upon him the form of man. By which words S. Paul meant not, that Christ was like unto god, and not God indeed, nor yet that he was like unto man, and not very man in deed, but that he was and is very God and very man, having .ii. substances, one of his Godhead, and the other of his manhood, united together in one person. And the ancient doctors writing of this sacrament, when they speak of the forms of bread and wine, do use this vocable (form) (as S. Paul useth it) to signify very bread and very wine, or the substances of bread and wine, and not the similitude or likeness of bread and wine without the substances, as you fantasy, and imagine.
Now where you so often speake of the visible forme of bread remayning ⟨p. 267⟩§3by this word (forme) you swetely deceaue your selfe,1 thinking that it doth much auaunce your fayth of Transubstantiation, vnderstanding by that word the accidences, similitudes, and likenes without substance remayning, misunderstanding both holy scripture and the auncient doctors. S. Paule speaking of Christes incarnation sayth,2 that he being in forme of God, did humble him selfe, taking vpon him the forme of man. By which wordes S. Paule ment not, that Christ was like vnto god, and not God indede, nor yet that he was like vnto man, and not very man in dede, but that he was and is very God and very man, hauing .ii. substances, one of his Godhead, and the other of his manhod, vnited together in one person. And the aunciēt doctors writing of this sacrament, when they speake of the formes of bread and wine, do vse this vocable (forme) (as S. Paule vseth it) to signify very bread and very wine, or the substances of bread and wine, and not the similitude or likenes of bread and wine without the substances, as you fantasy, and imagine.
And you after this sort wresting holy scriptures and doctors, for maintenance of your error of Transubstantiation, do lead your self craftily into an other heinous error (if this your proposition be true, that the grant of one substance is a denial of any other) which is, to deny Christ either to be very God or man. For by your sentence, if he in substance be God, then can he not have the substance of man: for the grant of one substance is a denial of any other, as ye say.
And you after this sort wrasting holy scriptures and doctors, for maintenaunce of your error of Transubstantiation, do lead your selfe craftely into an other heinous errour (if this your proposition be true, that the graunt of one substance is a deniall of any other) which is, to deny Christ eyther to be very God or man. For by your sentence, if he in substance be God, then can he not haue the substance of man: for the graunt of one substance is a deniall of any other, as ye say.
And like as ye do err in misunderstanding of the Scripture and Doctors, so do you err in reason and judgement of things: your own eyes, nose, mouth, and fingers, bearing witness against you of your wilful error and folly. For what man is living (which hath his right wits) that can believe as you teach, that the proper object of every sense remaineth (that is to say, colour, taste, savour &c) and yet the former substance of bread and wine is gone? And here, to further your belief of Transubstantiation, you do exaggerate your accustomed absurdity of Impanation of Christs body, as if every man that believeth not your error of Transubstantiation, must of necessity fall into the error of Impanation, or as if I defended the said Impanation.1 But whether I defended any such fond opinion or no, or whether I have herein sufficiently answered the Papists, I refer to the judgement of all wise and learned men (that be any thing indifferent) which have read my book.
And like as ye do erre in misunderstanding of the Scripture and Doctours, so do you erre in reason and iudgement of thinges: your owne eyes, nose, mouth, and fingers, bearing witnes agaynst you of your wilfull error and folly. For what man is liuing (which hath his right wittes) that can beleeue as you teach, that the proper obiect of euery sence remayneth (that is to say, colour, taste, sauoure &c) and yet the former substance of bread and wine is gone? And here, to further your belefe of Transubstantiation, you do exaggerat your accustomed absurdity of Impanation of Christes body, as if euery man that beleueth not your errour of Transubstantiation, must of necessity fall into the errour of Impanation, or as if I defended ye sayd Impanatiō.1 But whether I defended any such fonde opinion or no, or whether I haue herein sufficiently answered the Papistes, I referre to the iudgement of all wise and learned men (that be any thing indifferent) which haue redde my booke.
And as concerning natural reason, where you say it will agree with the doctrine of Transubstantiation well enough, if the faith of the true presence of Christs very body be true. For answer hereto I say, that if your fantastical belief of the real presence of Christs natural body in the sacrament were as true as the gospel (as none opinion can be more erroneous and fond) yet would both faith and reason judge, that there were still bread. Faith, because holy scripture manifestly saith so: Reason, because it is so, not only to all our senses, but also in all the effects and operations of bread. And reason can not discern, but that Christs body may be as well present with the substance of bread, as with the accidents, and that rather also, forasmuch as you confess your self, that after the rules of nature, quantity filleth the place rather then substance. And so ⟨p. 268⟩may reason judge the body of Christ, to be the body of Christ, and yet the bread to be the bread still, and wine to be wine and no bread, nor none other confusion of natures to be there against reason.
And as concerning naturall reason, where you say it will agree with the doctrine of Transubstantiation well inough, if the fayth of the true presence of Christes very body be true. For aunswere hereto I say, that if your phantasticall belefe of the reall presence of Christes naturall body in the sacrament were as true as the gospell (as none opinion can be more erronious and fond) yet would both fayth and reason iudge, that there were still bread. Fayth, bicause holy scripture manifestly sayth so: Reason, bicause it is so, not onely to all our sences, but also in all the effects and opperations of bread. And reason can not discerne, but that Christes body may be as well present with the substance of bread, as with the accidents, and that rather also, forasmuch as you confesse your selfe, that after the rules of nature, quantity filleth the place rather then substaunce. And so ⟨p. 268⟩may reason iudge the body of Christ, to be the body of Christ, and yet the bread to be the bread still, and wine to be wine and no bread, nor none other confusion of natures to be there agaynst reason.
And as touching natural operation, in the handling thereof, you show §6your ignorance in natural philosophy, which teacheth that in mutation from one quality to an other, is required one substance to receive both the qualities. For white of it self can not be made black, nor cold hot, but one substance may be now hot now cold, now black now white. As cold water may be made hot although cold in it self can not be hot. Therefore you can not blame me, to think in this a great inconvenience and absurdity in nature, that sweetness of it self should change into sourness, when the substance of wine is gone, and no substance remaining to receive this mutation, this matter being so clean contrary to the precepts and rules of natural philosophy.
And as touching naturall operation, in the handling therof, you shew §6your ignoraunce in naturall philosophy, which teacheth that in mutation from one quality to an other, is required one substance to receaue both the qualities. For white of it selfe can not be made blacke, nor colde hotte, but one substance may be now hote now colde, now blacke now white. As cold water may be made hote although colde in it selfe can not be hote. Therfore you can not blame me, to thinke in this a great inconuenience and absurdity in nature, that swetenes of it selfe should change into sowernes, when the substance of wine is gone, and no substance remayning to receaue this mutation, this matter being so cleane contrary to the precepts and rules of naturall philosophy.
1And I marvel that you can not see how much Ulpian whom you allege, maketh against your self, and with my saying, that both in wine and vinegar remaineth substance, which is changed from sweet to sower, so that the sweet of it self is not made sower, but that substance which before was sweet, is after sower. And therefore what great skill you have in citing of Ulpian, to prove that the accidents of wine without substance do sower and wax vinegar, let the wise reader judge.
1And I meruayle that you can not see how much Ulpian whome you alleadge, maketh agaynst your selfe, and with my saying, that both in wine and viniger remayneth substance, which is changed from swete to sower, so that ye sweete of it selfe is not made sower, but that substaunce which before was sweete, is after sower. And therfore what great skill you haue in citing of Ulpian, to proue that the accidents of wine without substance do sower and waxe viniger, let the wise reader iudge.
But Ulpian seemeth to me to have an other sense then all men can perceive, but I will not discuss the mind of Ulpian, because I am no lawyer, least you should cast the proverb in my teeth, Ne suitor ultra crepidam.
But Ulpian semeth to me to haue an other sense then all men can perceaue, but I will not discusse the minde of Ulpian, because I am no lawyer, least you should cast the prouerbe in my teeth, Ne sutor vltra crepidam.
But to what purpose you should bring in the diversity of judgements in natural operations, and the extreme fondness of philosophers, some in moving, some in staying, I can not devise, except it be the permission of God, that as some of the philosophers by their fond opinions in nature, made themselves laughing stocks to all men, of reason so should ye Papists do. And yet so much more is the Papistical opinion of Transubstantiation to be laughed to scorn of all men, as it passeth the fondness of all the philosophers, and that so far, that the fondest of the philosophers would have laughed at it, and have clapped it out of their schools with one consent, as an opinion more mete for frantic and mad men, then for men of natural reason. And as fond opinions as some philosophers had, yet was there none that so far erred in reason, to say that accidences might stand without any substance, but all with one uniform consent agreed, that accidences had none other being or remaining, but in their substances. And yet if the faith of our religion taught us the contrary, then reason must yield to faith. But your doctrine of Transubstantiation is as directly contrary to the plain words of scripture, as it is against the order of natural reason.
But to what purpose you should bring in the diuersity of iudgements in naturall operations, and the extreme fondnes of philosophers, some in mouing, some in staying, I can not deuise, except it be the permission of God, that as some of the philosophers by their fond opinions in nature, made themselues laughing stocks to all men, of reason so should ye Papists do. And yet so much more is the Papisticall opinion of Transubstantiation to be laughed to scorne of all men, as it passeth the fondnes of all the philosophers, and that so farre, that the fondest of the philosophers would haue laughed at it, and haue clapped it out of their scholes with one consent, as an opinion more mete for frantike and mad men, then for men of naturall reason. And as fond opinions as some philosophers had, yet was there none that so farre erred in reason, to say that accidences might stand without any substance, but all with one vniforme consent agreed, that accidences had none other being or remayning, but in their substances. And yet if the fayth of our religion taught vs the contrary, then reason must yelde to fayth. But your doctrine of Transubstantiation is as directly contrary to the playne wordes of scripture, as it is agaynst the order of naturall reason.
And where you say that the doctrine of Transubstantiation doth not §7teach, that no earthly thing remaineth, but that the visible form of bread and wine remaineth the same in greatness, in thickness, in weight, in savour, in taste, in property also to corrupt, putrefy, and nourish, as it did before, tell plainly I pray you, what thing it is which you call the visible form of bread and wine, whether it be an accidence or a substance, and if it be an accidence, show whether it be a quantity or quality, or what ⟨p. 269⟩other accidence it is, that all men may understand what thing it is which (as you say) is the same in greatness, thickness, weight, savour, and other properties.
And where you say that the doctrine of Transubstantiation doth not §7teach, that no earthly thing remayneth, but that the visible forme of bread and wine remayneth the same in greatnes, in thicknes, in weight, in sauour, in tast, in property also to corrupt, putrify, and nourish, as it did before, tell playnly I pray you, what thing it is which you call the visible fourme of bread and wine, whether it be an accidence or a substance, and if it be an accidence, shew whether it be a quantity or quality, or what ⟨p. 269⟩other accidence it is, that all men may vnderstand what thing it is which (as you say) is the same in greatnes, thicknes, weight, sauour, and other properties.
And where you allege Emissen for the conversion of the substance of bread and wine,1 this conversion (as Emissene saith, and as I have declared before) is like to our conversion in baptism, where outwardly is no alteration of substance (for no sacramental alteration maketh alteration of the substance) but the marvellous and secret alteration is inwardly in our souls. And as the water in baptism is not changed, but sacramentally (that is to say, made a sacrament of spiritual regeneration, which before was none) so in the lords supper, neither the substance nor accidences of bread and wine be changed, but sacramentally: but the alteration is inwardly in the souls of them that spiritually be refreshed and nourished with Christs flesh and blood. And this our faith teacheth us, and natural reason doth good service to faith herein against your imagined Transubstantiation. So that you have not gotten reasons, good will, nor consent to your vain doctrine of Transubstantiation, although you had proved your real presence. Which hitherto you have not don, but have taken great pain to shoot away all your bolts in vain, missing quite and clean both the prick and the whole butte.
And where you alleadge Emissen for the conuersion of the substaunce of bread and wine,1 this conuersion (as Emissene sayth, and as I haue declared before) is like to our conuersion in baptisme, where outwardly is no alteration of substance (for no sacramentall alteration maketh alteration of the substance) but the meruaylous and secret alteration is inwardly in our soules. And as the water in baptisme is not changed, but sacramentally (that is to say, made a sacrament of spirituall regeneration, which before was none) so in the lordes supper, neyther the substance nor accidences of bread and wine be changed, but sacramentally: but the alteration is inwardly in the soules of them that spiritually be refreshed and nourished with Christes flesh and bloud. And this our fayth teacheth vs, and naturall reason doth good seruice to fayth herein agaynst your imagined Transubstantiation. So that you haue not gotten reasons, good wil, nor consent to your vayne doctrine of Transubstantiation, although you had proued your reall presence. Which hitherto you haue not don, but haue taken greate payne to shoote away all your boltes in vayne, missing quite and cleane both the pricke and the whole butte.
And yet in the end you take a good ready way for your own advantage, like unto a man that had shot all his shafts clean wide from the butte, and yet would bear all men in hand that he had hit the prick. And when other should go about the measure how far his shafts were wide from the butte, he would take up the matter himself, and command them to leave measuring, and believe his own saying, that his arrows stack all fast in the mark, and that this were the nearest way to finish the contention: Even so do you in this matter, willing all men to leave searching of (how) in the mystery of Christs presence in the sacrament, saying that to be the nearest way. And it were a much nearer way for you in deed, if all men would leave searching of (how) and without ground or reason believe as well your Transubstantiation as the corporal presence of Christs body only because you do say it is so. But S. Peter requireth every christen man to be ready to render a reason of his faith to every one that asketh,1 and S. Paul requireth in a christen Bishop, that he should be able to exhort by wholesome doctrine, and to convince the gainsayers, and not to require other men to give faith unto him without asking of (how or why) only because he saith so himself. The old catholic Authors tell, wherefore Christ called bread his body, and how christen people fed of his body. And the blessed virgin Mary asked how she should conceive a child, never having company with man.2 And you tell yourself how Christ is in heaven, how in us, and how in the sacrament, declaring all to be but after a spiritual manner. And what manner of men be you, that we may not ask you (how) to render a reason of your Transubstantiation, being a matter by you only devised, clearly without Gods word.
And yet in the end you take a good ready way for your owne aduantage, like vnto a man that had shot all his shaftes cleane wide from the butte, and yet would beare all men in hand that he had hitte the pricke. And when other should go about the measure how farre his shaftes were wide from the butte, he would take vp the matter himselfe, and cōmaund them to leaue measuring, and beleue his owne saying, that his arrowes stacke all fast in the marke, and that this were the nearest way to finish the contention: Euen so do you in this matter, willing all men to leaue searching of (how) in the mistery of Christes presence in the sacrament, saying that to be the nearest way. And it were a much nerer way for you in dede, if all men would leaue searching of (how) and without ground or reason beleue as well your Transubstātiation as the corporall presence of Christes body onely bicause you do say it is so. But S. Peter requireth euery christen man to be ready to render a reason of his fayth to euery one that asketh,
But at length when you have sweat well favouredly in answering to mine arguments of natural reason and natural operation,1 you be fain to confess a great part to be true, and to turn altogether into miracles, ⟨p. 270⟩and that into such kind of miracles, as the old catholic writers never knowledged nor touched in none of their works. For besides the chief miracle, which you say is in the conversion of the substance of bread into the substance of Christs body, and of the wine into his blood, there be other miracles when the forms of wine turn into vinegar, and when bread mouldeth, or a man doth vomit it, or the mouse eateth it, or the fire burneth it, or worms breed in it, and in all like chances, God still worketh miracles, yea even in poisoning with the consecrated wine. And the multitude of such miracles (as you do judge) pertaineth to the excellency of the Sacrament, where as among the school authors this is a common receaved proposition, non esse ponenda miracula sine necessitate.
But at length when you haue swette well fauoredly in answering to myne arguments of naturall reason and naturall operation,1 you be fayne to confesse a great part to be true, and to turne altogether into miracles, ⟨p. 270⟩and that into such kind of miracles, as the old catholike writers neuer knowledged nor touched in none of their workes. For besides the chief miracle, which you say is in the conuertiō of the substance of bread into the substance of Christes body, and of the wine into his bloud, there be other miracles when the formes of wine tourue into viniger, and when bread mouldeth, or a man doth vomite it, or the mouse eateth it, or the fire burneth it, or wormes breed in it, and in all like chaunces, God still worketh miracles, yea euen in poysoning with the consecrated wine. And the multitude of such miracles (as you do iudge) pertayneth to the excellency of the Sacrament, where as among the schoole authors this is a common receaued proposition, non esse ponenda miracula sine necessitate.
And where you say that I make my principal foundation upon the arguments §10of the scholastical writers, although mine arguments deduced out of the scholastical authors be unto you insoluble (and therefore you pass them over unanswered) yet I make no foundation at all upon them, but my very foundation is only upon Gods word, which foundation is so sure, that it will never fail. And mine arguments in this place, I bring in only to this end, to show how far your imagined Transubstantiation is, not only from Gods word, but also from the order and precepts of nature, and how many and portentous absurdities you fall into by means of the same. Which it seemeth you do confess by holding your peace, without making answer thereto. But now let us consider what is next in my book.
And where you say that I make my principall foundation vpon the arguments §10of the scholasticall writers, although myne arguments deduced out of the scholasticall authors be vnto you insoluble (and therfore you passe them ouer vnanswered) yet I make no foundation at all vpon them, but my very foundation is onely vpon Gods word, which foundation is so sure, that it will neuer fayle. And myne arguments in this place, I bring in onely to this end, to shew how farre your imagined Transubstantiation is, not onely from Gods word, but also from the order and precepts of nature, and how many and portentuous absurdities you fall into by meanes of the same. Which it semeth you do confesse by holding your peace, without making answere therto. But now lette vs consider what is next in my booke.
1The Papistical doctrine is also against all our outward senses, called our five wits. For our eyes say, they see there bread and wine: our noses smell bread and wine: our mouths taste, and our hands feel bread and wine. And although the articles of our faith be above all our outward senses, so that we believe things which we can neither see, feel, hear, smell nor taste, yet they be not contrary to our senses, at the least so contrary, that in such things, which we from time to time do see, smell, feel, hear and taste, we shall not trust our fences, but believe clean contrary. Christ never made no such article of our faith. Our faith teacheth us to believe things that we see not, but it doth not bid us, that we shall not believe that we see daily with our eyes, and hear with our ears, and grope with our hands. For although our senses can not reach so far as our faith doth, yet so far as the compass of our senses doth usually reach, our faith is not contrary to the same, but rather our senses do confirm our faith.2 Or else what availed it to S. Thomas, for the confirmation of Christs resurrection, that he did put his hand into Christs side, and felt his wounds, if he might not trust his senses, nor give no credit thereto?
1The Papisticall doctrine is also agaynst all our outward senses, called our fiue wits. For our eyes say, they see there bread and wine: our noses smell bread and wine: our mouthes tast, and our handes fele bread and wine. And although the articles of our fayth be aboue all our outward senses, so that we beleue thinges which we can neyther see, feele, heare, smell nor tast, yet they be not contrary to our senses, at the least so contrary, that in such thinges, which we from tyme to tyme do see, smell, fele, heare and tast, we shall not trust our fenses, but beleue cleane contray. Christ neuer made no such article of our fayth. Our fayth teacheth vs to beleue thinges that we see not, but it doth not bid vs, that we shall not beleue that we see dayly with our eyes, and heare with our eares, and grope with our handes. For although our senses can not reach so farre as our fayth doth, yet so farre as the compasse of our sences doth vsually reach, our fayth is not contrary to the same, but rather our senses do confirme our fayth.2
And what a wide door is here opened to Valentinianus, Martion, and other heretics, which said, that Christ was not crucified, but that Simon Cireneus was crucified for him, although to the sight of the people, it seemed that Christ was crucified, Or to such heretics as said, that Christ was no man, although to mens sights he appeared in the form of man, and seemed to be hungry, dry, weary, to weep, sleep, eat, drink, yea and to dye like as other men do. For if we once admit this doctrine, that no credit is to be given to our senses, we open a large field, and give a great occasion unto an innumerable rabblement of most heinous heresies.
And what a wide doore is here opened to Valentinianus, Martion, and other heretikes, which sayd, that Christ was not crucified, but that Simon Cireneus was crucified for him, although to the sight of the people, it semed that Christ was crucified, Or to such heretikes as sayd, that Christ was no man, although to mens sightes he appeared in the forme of man, and semed to be hungry, drie, weary, to wepe, sleepe, eate, drincke, yea and to dye like as other men do. For if we once admitte this doctrine, that no credite is to be geuen to our senses, we open a large field, and geue a greate occasion vnto an innumerable rablement of most heinous heresies.
And if there be no trust to be given to our senses in this matter of the sacrament, why then do the Papists so stoutly affirm, that the accidents remain after the consecration, which can not be judged but by the senses? For the scripture speaketh no word of the accidents of bread & wine but of the bread & wine themselves. And it is against the nature & definition of accidents, to be alone without any substance. Wherefore if we may not trust our senses in this matter of the sacrament, than if the substance of the bread & wine be gone, why may we not then say, that the accidents be gone also? And if we must needs believe our senses, as concerning the accidents of bread and wine, why may we not do the like of the substance, and that rather than of the accidents: forasmuch as after the consecration, the Scripture saith in no place that there is no substance of bread nor of wine, but calleth them still by such names as signify the substances, and not the accidents?
And if there be no trust to be geuen to our senses in this matter of the sacrament, why then do the Papistes so stoutly affirme, that the accidents remayne after the consecration, which can not be iudged but by the sences? For the scripture speaketh no word of the accidents of bread & wine but of the bread & wine themselues. And it is agaynst the nature & diffinitiō of accidētes, to be alone without any substāce. Wherfore if we may not trust our sences in this matter of the sacramēt, than if the substance of the bread & wine be gone, why may we not then say, that the accidēts be gone also? And if we must nedes beleue our senses, as conserning the accidēts of bread and wine, why may we not do the like of the substance, and that rather than of the accidents: forasmuch as after the consecration, the Scripture sayth in no place that there is no substance of bread nor of wine, but calleth them still by such names as signifie the substances, and not the accidents?
And finally, if our senses be daily deceived in this matter, than is the sensible sacrament nothing else, but an illusion of our senses. And so we make much for their purpose, that said that Christ was a crafty juggler, that made things to appear to mens sights, that in deed were no such things, but forms only, figures, and appearances of them.
And finally, if our senses be dayly deceaued in this matter, than is the sensible sacrament nothing els, but an elution of our senses. And so we make much for theyr purpose, that sayd that Christ was a crafty iugglar, that made thinges to appeare to mens sightes, that in dede were no such thinges, but formes onely, figures, and apparances of them.
But to conclude in few words this process of our senses, let all the Papists lay their heads together, and they shall never be able to show one article of our faith, so directly contrary to our senses that all our senses by daily experience shall affirm a thing to be, and yet our faith shall teach us the contrary thereunto.
But to conclude in fewe wordes this processe of our senses, let al the Papists lay their heades togither, and they shall neuer be able to shew one article of our fayth, so directly contrary to our senses that all our senses by dayly experience shall affirme a thynge to be, and yet our fayth shall teache vs the contrary thereunto.
As in answering to the third chapter, I have showed how reason received into faiths service, doth not strive with Transubstantiation, but agreeth well with it: so I trust to show how mans senses which this author calleth the five wits be no such direct adversaries to Transubstantiation, as a matter whereof they can no skill.1 And therefore to a question this Author asketh in the end of the second column in the 22. leaf which is this. If we believe our senses in the accidents, why may we not do the like of the substance? I answer thus, that the senses can no skill of substance as learned men speak of substance, nor this author neither, if a man should judge him by this question. For and a sensual man one that followeth his rude senses would say, Come hither master scholar, I here much talking in this world of substance and accidence, and if he were of a merry nature, would say his little boy had learned his accidence, but him self woreth not perfectly what substance meaneth, as clerks term it, and bringing forth a piece of bread, an other of cheese, and a pot of ale, would desire the scholar to learn him the substance of them, and show it with his finger, and show him also what difference §2between the substance of bread, cheese, and the ale, I think the scholar with the advice of all at cambridge and Oxford also, could not do it, and the more the scholar should travail with such a rude man so sensual in the matter, I think he should be the further of, oneles the sensual man would set a part his rude wits and learn of the scholar some reasonable understanding, which is that the substance is the inward nature, wherein those that be accidents do naturally stay the quantity immediately, and the rest by mean of quantity, in which the rest may be said to stay, which words were new divinity to this man, who touching the bread would ask the scholar roundly, Callest thou not this substance, this good thick piece that I handle? The scholar would answer, Sir as I shall answer you. You will say I play the sophister, for I must speak learning to you, that you can no skill of.
As in answering to the third chapiter, I haue shewed how reason receaued into faythes seruice, doth not striue with Transubstantiation, but agreeth well with it: so I trust to shew howe mannes sences whych this author calleth the fyue wyttes be no such direct aduersaries to Transubstantiation, as a matter wherof they can no skill.1
And be not angry though I tell you so, for and ye were learned, ye would not ask me this question, for substance as it is properly understanded to be of this or that thing, is properly neither seen by it self nor felt, and yet by reason comprehended truly to be in that we feel or see, nevertheless in common speech ⟨p. 272⟩and in the speech of such as for the purpose speak after the common capacity, the word substance is used to signify that is seen or felt, and so ye may say ye see the substance or feel the substance of bread, and yet ye do in deed see but the colour, and by it the largeness, and feel the heat or coldness, moisture or dryness, weight or lightness, hardness or softness, thickness, & thinness. If ye will learn what substance is ye must leave your outward senses, & consider in your understanding how in every thing that is, there is a stay, which we call a substance, being the principal part of every thing, which failing, we say that special thing not to be. As where the substance of bread is not, there the special thing bread is not, because bread is as every other natural visible thing is of two parts substance and accidents: now if the one part, that is to say substance be not there, which can be but by miracle, then is no bread properly there, because the one and chief part is not there, and yet I say not nothing is there, for the other part remaining hath a being as Gods visible creature, and may be called the visible part of bread: and therefore the outward kind and form of bread and the appearance of bread and a true sensible part of bread, and therefore be called also by the name of bread, not that it is so properly, but after the common speech and capacity of men, and may be called the nature of bread, signifying the property and the matter of bread signifying the grossness. The rude man I think would hereat say, Here is sophistry in deed, for here is substance, and no substance, matter of bread and no bread, appearance of bread and no bread, called bread and no bread, this is plain juggling where it happeneth.
And be not angry though I tell you so, for and ye were learned, ye would not aske me this question, for substance as it is properly vnderstanded to be of this or that thing, is properly neither sene by it selfe nor felt, and yet by reason comprehended truely to be in that we fele or see, neuertheles in cōmon speach ⟨p. 272⟩and in the speach of such as for the purpose speake after the common capacitie, the word substance is vsed to signifie that is seene or felt, and so ye may say ye see the substance or fele the substance of bread, and yet ye do in dede see but the colour, and by it the largenes, and fele the heate or coldnes, moysture or drines, weight or lightnes, hardnes or softnes, thiknes, & thinnes. If ye wil learne what substāce is ye must leaue your outward sēces, & consider in your vnderstanding how in euery thing that is, there is a stay, which we cal a substance, being the principall part of euery thing, which fayling, we say that speciall thing not to be. As where the substance of bread is not, there ye special thing bread is not, bicause bread is as euery other naturall visible thing is of two partes substance and accidentes: now if the one parte, that is to say substance be not there, which can be but by miracle, then is no bread properly there, bicause the one and chief part is not there, and yet I say not nothing is there, for the other part remayning hath a being as Gods visible creature, and may be called the visible part of bread: and therfore the outward kind and forme of bread and the apparāce of bread and a true sensible part of bread, and therfore be called also by the name of bread, not that it is so properly, but after the common speach and capacity of men, and may be called the nature of bread, signifying the property and the matter of bread signifiing the grossenes. The rude man I thinke would hereat say, Here is sophistry in dede, for here is substance, and no substance, matter of bread and no bread, apparance of bread and no bread, called bread and no bread, this is playne iugling where it hapneth.
Wherein this rude man for want of true understanding of the words and perfect consideration of the matter speaketh thus fondly, who if he should thereupon require the scholar to show him some difference of the very substance between bread, cheese, and ale, what could the learned scholar answer here, but even frankly declare his ignorance, and say I know none, which is as much to say, as I know there is a difference, but I wot not what it is. Whereunto I trow the rude man would say to the scholar. Then art thou with all thy learning as very a fool as I, to speak of a difference and can not tell what it is. Now if the scholar should utter even the extremity of his learning in proper terms, and say, I know bread is no cheese, and cheese is no ale, and of their accidental parts I can indeed show differences, but of the very substance none. The rude man if his nature were not over dull, would laugh roundly to hear a scholar utter for a point of learning that bread is no cheese, and cheese is no ale, which who so knoweth not, is a very fool, and merely to knit up the matter would keep the accidents of his bread cheese and all for him self, and give the substance to the scholar if he can divide it, as a reward for his cunning to his better nurture. And this I write after this gross sort, to show that this matter of substance is not commonly understanded as senses exercised in learning perceive it, and how mans outward senses can not as this author would have it, be judges of the inward nature of substance, which reason persuadeth to be, using the service of the senses for induction of the knowledge, in which judgement upon their report happeneth many times much deceit.1 Titus Livius speaketh of a great number of divers dishes of meat made in a solemn supper, whereat the guests wondered to see such a variety at that time of the year, and when they demanded of it, answer was made the substance was but one, all hogs flesh, so as the alteration in the accidents deceived their judgements. That stone, which among many thought to have some skill, hath been taken for a precious §2diamond, hath after by cunning lapidaries been judged to be but a white sapphire, and contrariwise:
Wherin this rude man for want of true vnderstanding of the wordes and perfect consideration of the matter speaketh thus fondly, who if he should therupon require the scholler to shew him some difference of the very substance betwene bread, cheese, and ale, what could the lerned scholler answere here, but euen frankly declare his ignoraunce, and say I know none, which is as much to say, as I know there is a difference, but I wot not what it is. Wherunto I trow the rude man would say to the scholler. Then art thou with all thy lerning as very a foole as I, to speake of a difference and can not tell what it is. Now if the scholler should vtter euen the extremity of his learning in proper termes, and say, I know bread is no cheese, and chese is no ale, and of their accidentall partes I can indede shew differences, but of the very substance none. The rude man if his nature were not ouer dull, would laugh roundly to heare a scholler vtter for a poynt of learning that bread is no cheese, and cheese is no ale, which who so knoweth not, is a very foole, and merely to knit vp the matter would kepe the accidents of his bread chese and all for him selfe, and geue the substance to the scholler if he can deuide it, as a reward for his cunning to his better nurture. And this I write after this grosse sort, to shew that this matter of substance is not commonly vnderstanded as sences exercised in learning perceaue it, and how mans outward sences can not as this author would haue it, be iudges of the inward nature of substance, which reason perswadeth to be, vsing the seruice of the sences for induction of the knowledge, in which iudgement vpon their report hapneth many tymes much deceite.
So easily may our judgement upon the report of our senses fall in error, not that the senses be properly deceived, but rather the man that is grossly sensual, and judgeth fondly by them. For the very substance is not the proper object of any of the five wits, but of their report considered in reason denied, and sometime guessed at, whereof ensueth great errour and (quid pro quo) among the poticaries and learned also in things strange, whereof they have but accidental marks. Wherefore upon consideration of the premises it may easily appear how the question of this author, why the senses be not believed in knowledge of substance, as in knowledge of accidents, may be reasonably answered. And then if the judgement of reason in the estimation of Gods natural works and denying this or that substance, when by accidents it should seem otherwise, reason doth stay sensuality, and when men of experience, knowledge, and ⟨p. 273⟩credit, have determined such a certain stone to be a very true diamond, other ignorant will be ashamed to say the contrary. And if a man fearing himself deceived to have bought one kind of drugs for an other, and yet mistrusting wisely his own judgement, having caused it to be viewed by men of knowledge, good faith and honesty, if they affirm it to be the very thing, this man will then condemn his own imagination, and upon credit call it so, and take it so to be: wherefore if in these things I say, reason doth in a man stay sensuality, and if knowledge with honesty ruleth the judgement of rude understanding, and finally, if credit among men be so much regarded, how much more convenient is it, that faith in Gods word (wherein can be no deceit §3as there is in men) should alter and change mans judgement in reason, and bring it into the obedience of faith. Of that is bread after the judgement of our reason, after the report of our senses, Christ determineth unto us the substance of that to be his body, saying: This is my body, why shall not now a true christen man answer ever according to his faith, to say and profess the same to be the substance of Christs body upon credit of Christs words, as well as the carnal man will upon report of his senses conclude in reason there to be the substance of bread?
So easily may our iudgement vpon the report of our sences fall in errour, not that the sences be properly deceaued, but rather the man that is grossely sensuall, and iudgeth fondly by them. For the very substance is not the proper obiect of any of the fiue wittes, but of their report considered in reason denied, and sometyme gessed at, wherof ensueth greate errour and (quid pro quo) among the poticaries and learned also in thinges strange, whereof they haue but accidentall markes. Wherefore vpon consideration of the premises it may easily appeare how the question of this author, why the sences be not beleued in knowledge of substance, as in knowledge of accidents, may be resonably answered. And then if the iudgement of reason in the estimation of Gods naturall workes and denying this or that substance, when by accidents it should seeme otherwise, reason doth stay sensuallity, and when men of experience, knowledge, and
whereby is not taken away the credit of our senses as this author supposeth, which have their objects still true as they had before. §4For the colour, greatness, savour, and taste, all remain truly with the experiences of them as before. Upon whose report reason nevertheless now reduced to the obsequy of faith, forbeareth reverently to conclude against the truth of faith, but according to faith confesseth the substance to be the very substance of Christs body, and the accidents to remain in their very true nature, because faith teacheth not the contrary, and that it agreeth with the rule of faith so to be, and therefore remaineth a very true greatness, thickness and weight, which may be called in common speech, substance, signifying the outward nature. And in that sense Theodoret reasoning with an heretic seemeth to call it, because having spoken of substance remaining, he declareth what he meaneth by it, adding it may be seen and felt as before, which is not the nature of substance properly, but by like common speech that remaineth may be called matter, as Origen called it, wherein also remain the true savour and taste with true propriety to corrupt, or putrefy, and also nourish, God so ordering the use of the creature of bread and likewise wine in this mystery, as the inward nature of them which indeed is the substance, but only comprehended in reason and understanding, is converted into the most precious substance of Christs body and blood, which is indeed a substance there present, by gods omnipotency only to be comprehended by faith, so far as may be understanded of §5mans weakness and imbecility. And where this author putteth a danger if senses be not trusted, there is a gap open to the Ualentinians and Marcionites, and therefore bringeth in the feeling of S. Thomas: hereunto I say that the truth of that feeling dependeth upon a true belief, according to the scriptures, that Christ was very man: for else the body glorified of Christ (as S. Gregory noteth) was not of the own glorified nature,1 then either visible or palpable:
wherby is not taken away the credite of our sences as this author supposeth, which haue their obiects still true as they had before. §4For the collour, greatnes, sauour, and tast, all remayne truely with the experiences of them as before. Upon whose report reason neuertheles now reduced to the obsequie of fayth, forbeareth reuerently to conclude agaynst the truth of fayth, but according to fayth confesseth the substance to be the very substance of Christes body, and the accidents to remayne in their very true nature, bicause fayth teacheth not the contrary, and that it agreeth with the rule of fayth so to be, and therfore remayneth a very true greatnes, thicknes and wayght, which may be called in common speach, substance, signifying the outward nature. And in that sense Theodoret reasoning with an heretique semeth to call it, bicause hauing spoken of substance remayning, he declareth what he meaneth by it, adding it may be seene and felt as before, which is not the nature of substance properly, but by like common speach that remayneth may be called matter, as Origen called it, wherein also remayne the true sauour and tast with true propriety to corrupt, or putrifie, and also nourish, God so ordering the vse of the creature of bread and likewise wine in this mistery, as the inward nature of them which indeede is the substance, but onely comprehended in reason and vnderstanding, is conuerted into the most precious substance of Christes body and bloud, which is indeede a substance there present, by gods omnipotency onely to be comprehended by fayth, so farre as may be vnderstanded of
but therein Christ condescended to mans infirmity, and as he was truth it self, left that a true testimony to such as humbly were disposed by grace to receive it, not to convince heretics, who can devise wayward answers to the external acts of Christ, as now a days they delude the miraculous entering of Christ to his disciples, the doors being shut. Our faith of the true §6manhood in Christ is truly believed, by true preaching thereof and by the scriptures, not by the outward senses of men which altogether we must confess, could be no certain inevitable proof thereof. And therefore Christ appearing to his disciples going into ••••us opened the scriptures to them, for the proof of his death that he suffered as very man, and yet he used also in some part to preach to their senses, with sensible exhibition of him self unto them. And so all Christs doings which were most true, do bear testimony to the truth, but in their degree of testimony, and the feeling of S. Thomas, being (as S. Gregory saith) miraculous, serveth for proof of an other thing, that gods work in miracle, doth not impair the truth of the thing wrought, and so S. Thomas touched then Christ, as truly by miracle, after his resurrection in his body §7glorified, as if he had touched his body before glorification. Finally, in Christs acts or his ordinances, be no illusions, all is truth and perfect truth, and our senses in the ⟨p. 274⟩visible forms of bread and wine be not illuded, but have their proper objects in those accidents and reason in carnal understanding brought and subdued in obsequy to faith, doth in the estimation of the host consecrate yield to faith, according whereunto we confess truly the same to be the body of Christ.
but therin Christ condescended to mannes infirmity, and as he was truth it selfe, left that a true testimony to such as humbly were disposed by grace to receaue it, not to conuince heretiques, who can deuise wayward answers to the externall actes of Christ, as now a dayes they delude the miraculous entring of Christ to his disciples, the dores being shutte. Our fayth of the true §6manbode in Christ is truely beleued, by true preaching thereof and by the scriptures, not by the outward sences of men which altogither we must confesse, could be no certayne ineuitable profe thereof. And therfore Christ appearing to his disciples going into us opened the scriptures to them, for the profe of his death that he suffred as very man, and yet he vsed also in some part to preach to their sences, with sensible exhibition of him selfe vnto them. And so all Christes doinges which were most true, doe beare testimony to the truth, but in their degree of testimony, and the feeling of S. Thomas, being (as S. Gregory sayth) miraculous, serueth for profe of an other thing, that gods worke in miracle, doth not empayre the truth of the thing wrought, and so S. Thomas touched then Christ, as truely by miracle, after his resurrection in his body
Where this Author would all the Papists to lay all their headers together &c I know §8no such Papists, but this I say without farther counsel, which this author with all his counsel shall not avoid, we believe most certainly the resurrection of our flesh, and be persuaded by Catholic teaching, that the same flesh by participation of Christs godly flesh in the Sacrament, shall be made incorruptible, and yet after the judgement of our senses, and conclusions gathered of them, considering the manner of the continual wasting of the said bodies appear, the utter consumption whereof some philosophers have at length after their reason declared their mind, whom Christen men contemn withal the experience of senses, which they allege being vehement in that matter, we read in Scripture of the feeding of Angels, when Loth received them.
Where this Author would all the Papistes to lay all their headers togither &c I know §8no such Papistes, but this I say without farther counsayle, which this author with all his counsayle shall not auoyde, we beleue most certaynly the resurrection of our flesh, and be perswaded by Catholique teaching, that the same flesh by participation of Christes godly flesh in the Sacrament, shalbe made incorruptible, and yet after the iudgemēt of our sences, and conclusions gathered of them, considering the manner of the continuall wasting of the sayd bodies appeare, the vtter consumption whereof some philosophers haue at length after their reason declared their mynde, whome Christen men contemne withall the experience of sences, which they alleadge being vehement in that matter, we reade in Scripture of the feeding of Angels, when Loth receaued them.