pp. 3941,982 passagespart 37 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
AS in your answer to the iii. chapter of my book you have done §1nothing but dallied and trifled, even so do you likewise in the iiii. Chapter, and yet far more unseemly then in the third. For doth it become a christen Bishop, of a matter of religion and a principal article of our faith to make a matter of bread and cheese? And of the holy supper of the Lord to make a resemblance of a dinner of hogs flesh? And yet for persuasion of your purpose, you make (as it were) a play in a dialogue, between a rude man and a learned scholar,1 wherein the matter is so learnedly handled that the simple rude man showeth himself to have more knowledge, then both you and your learned scholar. And why you should bring in this matter I know not, except it be to show your ignorance, to be as great in logic and philosophy,2 as it is in divinity. For what an ignorance is this, to say that a man can know no difference between one substance and an other, and that substances be not judged by any senses? And that all natural things be of these .ii. parts, of substances and accidents: and that their accidents be part of their substances, and be called their substances, their natures, and matters? Was there ever any such learning uttered before this time? May not all men now evidently perceive, unto what a straight your error hath driven you, that you have none other defence, but to fly to such absurdities, as be against the judgement of the whole world? Would you make men believe, that they know not the substance of the bread from drink, nor of chalk from cheese? Would you lead the world into this error, that Christ was never indeed seen, heard nor felt, when he walked here with his apostles? Did he not prove the truth of his very flesh and bones by sight? saying, A spirit hath not flesh and bones as you see me have?3 And although substances be not seen and known to our senses, but by their accidents, yet be they indeed known, and properly known, and truly known by their accidents, and more properly seen then their accidents be. For the accidents be rather the means to know the substance by, then the things that be known. Is not wine known from bear by the taste, and mustard from sugar? Is not one man known by his voice from another? And a shawm from a drum? And is not a man discerned from a beast, and one from an other by sight?
AS in your answere to the iii. chapiter of my booke you haue doone §1nothing but dalied and trifled, euen so do you likewise in the iiii. Chapiter, and yet farre more vnsemely then in the third. For doth it become a christen Bishop, of a matter of religion and a principal article of our fayth to make a matter of bread and chese? And of the holy supper of the Lord to make a resemblance of a dinner of hogges flesh? And yet for perswatiō of your purpose, you make (as it were) a play in a dialogue, betwene a rude man and a learned scholler,1 wherin the matter is so learnedly handeled that the simple rude man sheweth himselfe to haue more knowledge, then both you and your learned scholler. And why you should bring in this matter I know not, except it be to shew your ignoraunce, to be as great in logike and philosophy,2 as it is in diuinity. For what an ignorance is this, to say that a man can know no difference betwene one substance and an other, and that substances be not iudged by any sences? And that all naturall thinges be of these .ii. partes, of substances and accidents: and that their accidents be part of their substances, and be called their substances, their natures, and matters? Was there euer any such learning vttered before this tyme? May not all men now euidently perceaue, unto what a straight your errour hath driuen you, that you haue none other defence, but to flie to such absurdities, as be agaynst the iudgement of the whole world? Would you make men beleue, that they know not the substance of the bread from drincke, nor of chalke from chese? Would you leade the world into this errour, that Christ was neuer indede sene, heard nor felt, when he walked here with his apostles? Did he not proue the truth of his very flesh and bones by sight? saying, A spirite hath not flesh and bones as you see me haue?3 And although substances be not seene and knowne to our sences, but by their accidents, yet be they indede knowne, and properly knowne, and truely knowne by their accidentes, and more properly seene then their accidents bee. For the accidents be rather the meanes to know the substaunce by, then the thinges that be knowne. Is not wine knowne from beare by the taste, and mustard from suger? Is not one man knowen by his voyce from another? And a shalme from a drumme? And is not a man discerned from a beast, and one from an other by sight?
But when you turn up all speeches, all reason, and all manner of knowledge, it is less to be ⟨p. 275⟩marvelled that you turn up divinity also, wherein you can less skill then in the rest.
But when you tourne vp all speaches, all reason, and all manner of knowledge, it is lesse to be ⟨p. 275⟩meruayled that you tourne vp diuinity also, wherin you can lesse skill then in the rest.
And where you say, that the senses can no skill of substances, because they m••be deceived therein, so may they also be in the accidents. For do not the sun and moon sometime look read by means of the vapours between us and them? And doth not spectacles make allthings look of the same colour that they be of? And if you hold up your finger directly between your eyes and a candle, looking full at the candle, your finger shall seem two, and if you look full at your finger, the candle shall seem two. And an age we maketh sweet things seem bitter, and that is sweet to one, is bitter to an other. And if a man having very hot hands, and an other very cold, if they handle both one thing, the one shall think it hot, and the other cold. So that the senses may err aswell in the accidents as in the substances, and can not err in the substances, except they err also in the accidents.
And where you say, that the sences can no skill of substances, bicause they m••be deceaued therin, so may they also be in the accidents. For doe not the sunne and moone sometyme looke redde by meanes of the vapors betwene vs and them? And doth not spectacles make althinges looke of the same colour that they be of? And if you hold vp your finger directly betwene your eyes and a candell, looking full at the candell, your finger shall seeme two, and if you looke full at your finger, the candell shal seeme two. And an age we maketh swete thinges seeme bitter, and yt is swete to one, is bitter to an other. And if a man hauing very hote handes, and an other very colde, if they handle both one thing, the one shall thinke it hote, and the other colde. So that the sences may erre aswell in the accidents as in the substances, and can not erre in the substances, except they erre also in the accidents.
But in speaking of substance, you declare such a substance,1 as never was, nor never shall be, fantasying substance by your imagination, to be a thing in it self, separated from all accidents, and so confounding the substances of all things, and mixing heaven and earth together, you make all substances but one substance without any difference. And where almighty God hath taught by his word,2 that there be heavenly bodies, and earthly bodies, and that every seed hath his own proper body, and §3that all flesh is not one flesh, but the flesh of men, of beasts, of fish, and of foul be divers, you teach by your words, that all flesh is one flesh, and all substances one substance, and so confound you all flesh, with hogs flesh, making an hotch potch, like unto him that made a great variety of dishes all of hogs flesh. For take away the accidents, and I pray you what difference is between the bodily substance of the sun and the moon, of a man and a beast, of fish and flesh, between the body of one beast and an other, one herb and an other, one tree & an other, between a man and a woman? Yea between our body and Christs? and generally between any one corporal thing and an other? For is not the distinction of all bodily substances known by their accidents: without the which a mans body can not be known to be a mans body? And as substances can not be substances without accidents, so the nature of accidents can not be without substances, whose being & definition is to be in substances.
But in speaking of substance, you declare such a substance,1 as neuer was, nor neuer shalbe, phantasiyng substance by your imagination, to be a thing in it selfe, separated from all accidents, and so confounding the substances of all thinges, and mixting heauen and earth togither, you make all substances but one substance without any differēce. And where almighty God hath taught by his word,2 that there be heauenly bodyes, and earthly bodyes, and that euery seede hath his owne proper body, and §3that all flesh is not one flesh, but the flesh of men, of beastes, of fish, and of foule be diuers, you teach by your wordes, that all flesh is one flesh, and all substances one substance, and so confound you all flesh, with hogges flesh, making an hotche potche, like vnto him that made a greate variety of dishes all of hogges flesh. For take away the accidentes, and I pray you what difference is betwene the bodely substance of the sunne and the moone, of a man and a beast, of fish and flesh, betwene the body of one beast and an other, one herbe and an other, one tree & an other, betwene a man and a woman? Yea betwene our body and Christes? and generally betwene any one corporall thing and an other? For is not the distinction of all bodely substances knowen by their accidents: without the which a mans body can not be knowen to be a mans body? And as substances can not be substances without accidents, so the nature of accidentes can not be without substāces, whose being & deffinitiō is to be in substāces.
But as you speak of substances and accidents against scripture, §5sense, reason, experience and all learning, so do you also speak manifestly against your self. For you say that every thing that is, must have a substance wherein it is staid, and that every natural visible thing is of two parts, of substance and accidents, and yet by your Transubstantiation, you leave no substance at all, to stay the accidents of the bread and wine.
But as you speake of substances and accidentes agaynst scripture, §5sense, reason, experience and all learning, so doe you also speake manifestly agaynst your selfe. For you say that euery thing that is, must haue a substance wherein it is stayde, and that euery naturall visible thing is of two partes, of substance and accidentes, and yet by your Transubstantiation, you leaue no substance at all, to stay the accidentes of the bread and wine.
And moreover this is a marvellous teaching of you, to say that the accidents of bread be one part of bread, and be called the outward kind of bread,1 the sensible part of bread, the nature and matter of bread, and very bread. Was there ever any such learning taught before this day, that accidents should be called parts of substances, the nature of substances; and the matter of substances, and the very substances ⟨p. 276⟩themselves? If ever any man so wrote, tell who it is, or else knowledge the truth, that all these matters be invented by your own imagination whereof the rude man may right well say: Here is sophistry in deed and plain juggling. But you convey not your juggling so craftily, but that you be taken, (as the Greeks term it) [Greek or Hebrew], even with the manner.
And moreouer this is a meruaylous teaching of you, to say that the accidents of bread be one parte of breade, and be called the outward kinde of bread,1 the sensible parte of bread, the nature and matter of bread, and very bread. Was there euer any such learning taught before this day, that accidentes should be called partes of substances, the nature of substances; and the matter of substances, and the very substāces ⟨p. 276⟩themselues? If euer any man so wrotte, tell who it is, or els knowledge the truth, that all these matters be inuented by your owne imagination wherof the rude man may right well say: Here is sophistry in deede and playne iuggling. But you conuey not your iuggling so craftely, but that you be taken, (as the Grekes terme it) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, euen with ye māner.
1Now as concerning your expert lapidary, if his senses be deceived,§2 how shall he judge a true stone from a counterfeit? Doth he not diligently look upon it with his sight, to discern truly of it? For tell me I pray you, how a man without senses shall judge a true diamond?
1Now as concerning your expert lapidarie, if his sences be deceaued,§2 how shall he iudge a true stone from a counterfaite? Doth he not diligently looke vpon it with his sight, to discerne truely of it? For tell me I pray you, how a man without sences shall iudge a true diamond?
Put out his eyes, and is not a white sapphire, a diamond, and a glass all one in his judgement? Mary if he be a man of clear sight, of true knowledge and experience in the judgement of stones, and be therewithal a man of good faith and honesty (as you tell the tale) they that be ignorant will be ashamed to control his judgement. But if he be blind, or be a man neither of faith nor honesty, but his experience hath ben ever exercised to deceive all that trust him, and to sell them white sapphires for diamonds, then no man that wise is, will take a glass or sapphire at his hands of trust, although he say it be a true diamond. Even so likewise the Papists (being so accustomed with these merchandises of glistering glasses and counterfeit drugs, to deceive the world) what wise men will trust them with their feigned Transubstantiation, being so manifestly against the plain words of scripture, against all reason, sense, and ancient writers? And although you have taken never so great labour and pains in this place to answer mine arguments (wherein you do nothing else but show your ignorance in philosophy and logic) yet all is in vain, except you could prove Transubstantiation to be a matter of our faith, which being not proved, all that you have spoken here, serveth to no purpose, nor concludeth nothing. For you are not so ignorant in sophistry, but you know well though, that of a false Antecedent, can no Consequent directly follow.
Put out his eyes, and is not a white saphire, a diamond, and a glas all one in his iudgemēt? Mary if he be a man of cleare sight, of true knowledge and experience in the iudgement of stones, and be therewithall a man of good fayth and honesty (as you tell the tale) they that be ignorant will be ashamed to controll his iudgement. But if he be blinde, or be a man neither of fayth nor honesty, but his experience hath ben euer exercised to deceaue all that trust him, and to sell them white saphirs for diamondes, then no man that wise is, will take a glas or saphire at his handes of trust, although he say it be a true diamond. Euen so likewise the Papistes (being so accustomed with these marchandises of glistering glasses and counterfayte drugges, to deceaue the world) what wise men will trust them with their fayned Transubstantiation, being so manifestly agaynst the playne wordes of scripture, agaynst all reason, sence, and auncient writers? And although you haue taken neuer so great labor and paynes in this place to answere myne argumentes (wherin you do nothing els but shew your ignorance in philosophy and logike) yet all is in vayne, except you could proue Transubstantiation to be a matter of our fayth, which being not proued, all that you haue spoken here, serueth to no purpose, nor concludeth nothing. For you are not so ignorant in sophistry, but you know well though, that of a false Antecedent, can no Consequent directly follow.
And as concerning these words of Christ (This is my body) by your §3own teaching in these words, he called bread his body, which can be no formal and proper speech, but spoken by a figure, as the order of the text plainly declareth, and all the old authors do testify.
And as concerning these wordes of Christ (This is my body) by your §3owne teaching in these wordes, he called bread his body, which can be no formall and proper speach, but spoken by a figure, as the order of the text playnly declareth, and all the old authors do testify.
And where you say, that although the substance of bread and wine be §4gone, yet the senses have their proper object still remaining (as they had before) that is to say, the colours, greatness, thickness, weight, savour, and taste, express them I pray you plainly what thing it is that is coloured, great, thin or thick, heavy or light, savoury or tasted? For seeing you confess that these do remain, you must confess also, that there remaineth bread. For that greatness, thickness, thinness, colours, and weight be not in the body of Christ, nor in the air (which can not be weighed) and in some thing they must needs be (for by your own saying, every thing hath a substance to stay it) therefore they must needs be in the substance of bread and wine. And to say that the accidents of bread, be the natures, matters, and substances thereof, is nothing else, but to declare to the world, that you make words to signify at your pleasure.
And where you say, that although the substance of bread and wine be §4gone, yet the sences haue their proper obiect still remayning (as they had before) that is to say, the colours, greatnes, thicknes, weight, sauour, and tast, expresse thē I pray you playnly what thing it is that is coloured, great, thinne or thicke, heauy or light, sauoury or tasted? For seing you confesse that these do remayn, you must confesse also, yt there remayneth bread. For that greatnes, thicknes, thinnes, colours, and weight be not in ye body of Christ, nor in the ayre (which can not be wayed) and in some thing they must nedes be (for by your owne saying, euery thing hath a substance to stay it) therfore they must nedes be in the substance of bread and wine. And to say that the accidents of bread, be the natures, matters, and substances therof, is nothing els, but to declare to the world, that you make wordes to signify at your pleasure.
But other shift have you none to defend your Transubstantiation, but to devise such monstrous kinds of speeches, as never was heard of before. ⟨p. 277⟩For you say, that the nature, matter and substance of bread and wine remain not, but be changed into the body and blood of Christ: the old writers say directly contrary, that the nature, matter and substance remain. Christ (saith Theodoret) called bread and wine his body and blood,1 and yet changed not their natures. And again he saith, The bread and wine after the consecration lose not their proper nature, but keep their former substance, form and figure which they had before. And Origene saith that the matter of bread availeth nothing,2 but as concerning the material part thereof, it goeth down into the belly, and is avoided downward. And Gelasius saith,3 that the nature and substance of bread and wine cease not to be. Now seeing that your doctrine (who teach that the nature matter and substance of bread and wine be changed and remain not) is as clean contrary to these old writers, with many other, as black is contrary to white, and light to darkness, You have no remedy to defend your error and wilful opinion, but to imagine such portentous and wonderful kinds of speeches to be spoken by these authors, as never were uttered before by no man, that is to say, that the outward appearance and accidences of any thing, should be called the nature, matter and substance thereof. But such monsters had you rather bring forth, then you would in one jot relent in your error once by you uttered, and undertaken by you defended. And yet bring you nothing for the proof of your saying, but that if the authors words should be understand as they be spoken, this should follow thereof, that bread and wine should be seen and felt, which as no man doubteth of, but all men take it for a most certain truth, so you take it for a great inconvenience and absurdity. So far be you forced in this matter to vary in speech and judgement from the sentence and opinion of all men.
But other shift haue you none to defend your Transubstantiation, but to deuise such monstrous kindes of speaches, as neuer was heard of before.
And as touching the belief of S. Thomas,1 although he believed certainly that Christ was a man, yet he believed not that Christ was risen, and appeared to the Apostles, but thought rather that the Apostles were deceived by some vision or spirit, which appeared to them in likeness of Christ, which he thought was not he indeed. And so thought the Apostles themselves until Christ said: Videte manus meas & pedes, quia ego ipse sum: Palpate & videte, quia spiritus carnem & ossa non habent, sicut me videtis habere.2 See my hands and my feet, for I am even he: Grope and see, for a spirit hath no flesh and bones, as you see that I have. And so thought also S. Thomas,3 until such time as he put his hands into Christs side and felt his wounds, and by his sense of feeling perceived that it was Christs very body, and no spirit nor fantasy, as before he believed. And so in S. Thomas the truth of feeling depended not upon the true belief of Christs resurrection, but the feeling of his senses brought him from misbelief, unto the right and true faith of that matter. And as for S. Gregory,4 he speaketh no such things as you report, that the glorified body of Christ was of the own nature neither visible nor palpable, but he saith clean contrary, that Christ showed his glorified body to S. Thomas palpable, to declare that it was of the same nature, that it was of before his resurrection, whereby it is plain after S. Gregory's mind, that if it were not palpable, it were not of the same nature. And S. Gregory saith further in the same homely. Egit miro modo superna clementia, ut discipulus ille dubitans, ⟨p. 278⟩dum in magistro suo vulnera palparet carnis, in nobis vulnera sanaret infidelitatis. Plus enim nobis Thomae infidelitas ad fidem, quam fides credentium discipulcrum profuit: quia dum ille ad fidem palpando reducitur, nostra mens omni dubitatione postposita in fide solidatur. The supernall clemency wrought marvellously, that the disciple which doubted by groping the wounds of flesh in his master, should heal in us the wounds of infidelity. For the lack of faith in Thomas profited more to our faith then did the faith of the disciples that believed. For when he is brought to faith by groping, our mind is stablished in faith without all doubting. And why should S. Gregory write thus, if our senses availed nothing unto our faith, nor could nothing judge of substances?
And do not all the old catholic authors prove the true humanity of Christ, by his visible conversation with us here in earth: that he was heard preach, seen eating, and drinking, labouring and sweating? Do they not also prove his resurrection by seeing, hearing and groping of him? which if it were no proof, those arguments were made in vain against such Heretics that denied his true incarnation. And shall you now take away the strength of their arguments to the maintenance of those old condemned heresies, by your subtle sophistications? The touching and feeling of Christs hands, feet and wounds was a proof of his resurrection, not as you say, to them that believed, but as S Gregory saith, to them that doubted.
And do not all the olde catholike authors proue the true humanity of Christ, by his visible conuersation with vs here in earth: that he was heard preach, seene eating, and drincking, labouring and sweatting? Do they not also proue his resurrection by seing, hearing and groping of him? which if it were no proofe, those arguments were made in vayne agaynst such Heretikes that denied his true incarnation. And shall you now take away the strength of their arguments to the maintenance of those olde condemned heresies, by your subtill sophistications? The touching and feeling of Christes handes, feete and wounds was a proofe of his resurrection, not as you say, to them that beleued, but as S Gregory sayth, to them that doubted.
And if all things that Christ did and spake to our outward senses,§6 prove not that he was a natural man (as you say with Martion, Menander, Ualentinus, Apollinaris, with other like sort) then I would know how you should confute the said heresies? Marty will you say peradventure, by the scripture which sayth playnly, Verbum caro factumest. But if they would say again, that he was called a man and flesh, because he took upon him the form of a man and flesh, and would say that S. Paul so declareth it,1 saying: Forinam serui accipiens, and would then say further, that form is the accidence of a thing, and yet hath the name of substance, but is not the substance indeed, what would you then say unto them? if you deny that the forms and accidences be called substances, then go you from your own saying. And if you grant it, then will they avoid all the scriptures that you can bring to prove Christ a man, by this cavillation, that the appearances, forms and accidences of a man, may be called a man, aswell as you say that the forms and accidences of bread, be called bread. And so prepare you certain propositions and grounds for heretics to build their errors upon, which after when you would; you shall never be able to overthrow.
And if all thinges that Christ did and spake to our outward senses,§6 proue not that he was a naturall man (as you say with Martion, Menander, Ualentinus, Apolinaris, withother like sort) thē I would know how you should confute the sayd heresies? Marty will you say peraduenture, by the scripture which sayth playnly, Verbum caro factumest. But if they would say agayne, that he was called a man and flesh, bicause he tooke vpon him the forme of a man and flesh, and would say that S. Paule so declareth it,1 saying: Forinam serui accipiens, and would then say further, that forme is the accidence of a thing, and yet hath the name of substance, but is not the substance indeede, what would you then say vnto them? if you deny that the formes and accidences be called substances, then go you from your owne saying. And if you graunt it, then will they auoyde all the scriptures that you can bring to proue Christ a man, by this cauilation, that the apparances, formes and accidences of a man, may be called a man, aswell as you say that the formes and accidences of bread, be called bread. And so prepare you certayne propositions and groundes for heretikes to build their errours vpon, which after when you would; you shall neuer be able to ouerthrowe.
And where you say, that Thomas touched truly Christs body glorified, how could it be, when touching (as you say) is not of y• substance but of the accidents only? and also Christs body glorified (as you say) is neither visible nor palpable? And where as indeed you make Christs acts illusions,§7 and yet in words you pretend the contrary, call you not this illusion of our senses,1 when a thing appeareth to our senses, which is not the same thing indeed? When Jupiter & Mercury (as the comedy telleth) appeared to Alcumena in the similitude of Amphitrio & Sosia, was not Alcumena deceived thereby? And Poticaries that sell Juniper buries for pepper, being no pepper indeed, deceive they not the biers by illusion of their senses? Why then ⟨p. 279⟩is not in the ministration of the holy communion an illusion of our senses, if our senses take for bread and wine that which is not so indeed.
And where you say, yt Thomas touched truely Christes body glorified, how could yt be, whē touching (as you say) is not of y• substance but of the accidents only? and also Christes body glorified (as you say) is neyther visible nor palpable? And where as indeede you make Christs actes illusiōs,§7 and yet in wordes you pretend the contrary, call you not this illusiō of our sēses,1 whē a thing apeareth to our sēces, which is not ye same thing indeede? When Iupiter & Mercury (as the comedy telleth) apeared to Alcumena in ye similitude of Amphitrio & Sosia, was not Alcumena deceaued therby? And Poticaries yt sell Ieniper buries for pepper, being no pepper indeede, deceaue they not the biers by illusion of their sences? Why then ⟨p. 279⟩is not in the ministration of the holy communion an illusion of our senses, if our senses take for bread and wine that which is not so indeede.
Finally where as I required earnestly, all the Papists to lay their heads together, and to show one article of our faith so directly contrary to our senses, that all our senses by daily experience, shall affirm a thing to be, and yet our faith shall teach us the contrary thereunto, where I say I required this so earnestly of you, and with such circumstances, and you have yet showed none, I may boldly conclude, that you can show none. For sure I am, if you could (being so earnestly provoked thereunto) you would not have failed to show it in this place. As for the article of our resurrection, and of the feeding of angels serve nothing for this purpose. For my saying is of the daily experience of our senses, and when they affirm a thing to be, but the resurrection of our flesh, and the feeding of angels, be neither in daily experience of our senses, nor our senses affirm them not so to be. Now after the matter of our senses followeth in my book the authorities of ancient writers in this wise.
Finally where as I required earnestly, all the Papistes to lay their heades togither, and to shew one article of our fayth so directly contrary to our senses, that all our senses by dayly experience, shall affirme a thing to be, and yet our fayth shall teach vs the contrary therunto, where I say I required this so earnestly of you, and with such circumstances, and you haue yet shewed none, I may boldly conclude, that you can shew none. For sure I am, if you could (being so earnestly prouoked therunto) you would not haue fayled to shew it in this place. As for the article of our resurrection, and of the feeding of angels serue nothing for this purpose. For my saying is of the dayly experience of our senses, and when they affirme a thing to be, but the resurrection of our flesh, and the feeding of angels, be neither in dayly experience of our senses, nor our senses affirme them not so to be. Now after the matter of our senses followeth in my booke the authorities of ancient writers in this wise.
Now for as much as it is declared, how this Papistical opinion of Transubstantiation is against the word of God,1 against nature, against reason, and against all our senses, we shall show furthermore, that it is against the faith and doctrine of the old authors of Christs church, beginning at those authors, which were nearest unto Christs time, and therefore might best know the truth herein.
Now for as much as it is declared, how this Papisticall opinion of Transubstantiation is agaynst the word of God,1 agaynst nature, agaynst reason, and agaynst all our senses, we shall shew furthermore, that it is agaynst the fayth and doctrine of the olde authors of Christes church, beginning at those authors, which were nearest vnto Christes time, and therfore might best know the truth herein.
First Justinus, a great learned man,1 and an holy martyr, the oldest author that this day is known to write any treaty upon the sacraments, and wrote not much after one hundred years after Christs Ascension.
First Iustinus, a great learned man,1 and an holy martyr, the oldest author that this day is knowne to write any treaty vpon the sacraments, and wrote not much after one hundred yeares after Christes Ascention.
He writeth in his second Apology, that the bread, water, and wine, in this Sacrament, are not to be taken as other common meats and drinks be, but they be meats ordained purposely to give thanks to God and therefore be called Eucharistia, and be called also the body and blood of Christ. And that it is lawful for none to eat or drink of them, but that profess Christ, and live according to the same. And yet the same meat and drink (saith he) is changed into our flesh and blood and nourisheth our bodies.
He writeth in his second Apology, that the bread, water, and wine, in this Sacrament, are not to be taken as other common meates and drinckes be, but they be meates ordeined purposely to geue thankes to God and therfore be called Eucharistia, and be called also the body and bloud of Christ. And that it is lawfull for none to eate or drincke of them, but that professe Christ, and liue according to the same. And yet the same meate and drincke (sayth he) is changed into our flesh and bloud and nourisheth our bodies.
By which saying it is evident, that Justinus thought, that the bread and wine remained still, for else it could not have been turned into our flesh and blood to nourish our bodies.
By which saying it is euident, that Iustinus thought, that the bread and wine remayned still, for els it could not haue bene turned into our flesh and bloud to nourish our bodies.
I will spend no mo words herein,1 but having avoided this authors reasoning against Transubstantiation. Now let us examine his authorities. First he beginneth with Justine the Martyr, Whose words be not truly by this author here reported, which §2be these truly translate out of the Greek. When the priest hath ended his thanks giving and prayers, and all the people hath said Amen, they whom we call Deacons, give to every one then present, a part of the bread and of the wine and water consecrated, and carry part to those that be absent: and this is that food, which is among us called (Eucharistia) whereof it is lawful for no man to be partaker, except he be persuaded those things to be true that be taught us, and be baptized in the water of regeneration in remission of sins, and ordereth his life after the manner which Christ hath taught. For we do not take these for common bread or drink, but like as Jesus Christ our saviour incarnate by the word of God, had flesh and blood for our salvation, even so we be taught §3the food, (wherewith our flesh and blood be nourished by alteration) when it is consecrate ⟨p. 280⟩by the prayer of his word, to be the flesh and blood of the same Jesus incarnate.§3 For the Apostles in those their works, which be called gospels, teach that Jesus did so command them, and after he had taken the bread, and ended his thanks giving, said: Do this in my remembrance, This is my body. And likewise taking the cup after he had given thanks, said: This is my blood, and did give them to his Apostles only.2 And here I make an issue with this author, that he wittingly corrupteth Justine §1in the allegation of him, who writeth not in such form of words as this author allegeth out of his second Apology, nor hath any such speech. The bread, water, and wine in this sacrament, are meats ordained purposely to give thanks to God, and therefore be called Eucharistia, nor hath not these words, They be called the body and blood of Christ: but hath in plain words, that we be taught, this food consecrate by gods word, to be the flesh and blood of Christ, as Christ in his incarnation took flesh and blood: nor hath not this form of words placed to have that understanding, how the same meat and drink is changed into our flesh and blood.
For the words in Justine speaking of alteration of the food, have an understanding of the food, as it is before the consecration, showing how Christ used those creatures in this mystery, which by alteration nourish our flesh and blood.
For the wordes in Iustine speaking of alteration of the foode, haue an vnderstanding of the foode, as it is before the consecration, shewing how Christ vsed those creatures in this mistery, which by alteration nourish our flesh and bloud.
For the body of Christ, which is the very celestial substance of the host consecrate, is not changed, but without all alteration spiritually nourisheth the bodies and souls of them that worthily receive the same to immortality, whereby appeareth this authors conclusion, (that bread and wine remain still, which is turned into our flesh and blood) is not deduced upon Justines words truly understanded, but is a gloss invented by this author and a perverting of Justines words, and their true meaning. Whereupon I may say, and conclude even as this author erreth in his reasoning of mother wit against Transubstantiation, even so erreth he in the first allegation of his authorities by plain misreporting: let it be further named or thought one as the thing deserveth.
For the body of Christ, which is the very celestiall substance of the host consecrate, is not changed, but without all alteration spiritually nourisheth the bodies and soules of them that worthely receaue the same to immortality, wherby appeareth this authors conclusion, (that bread and wine remayne still, which is tourned into our flesh and bloud) is not deduced vpon Iustines wordes truely vnderstanded, but is a glose inuented by this author and a peruerting of Iustines wordes, and their true meaning. Wherupon I may say, and conclude euen as this author erreth in his reasoning of mother wit agaynst Transubstantiation, euen so erreth he in the first allegation of his authorities by playne misreporting: let it be further named or thought one as the thing deserueth.
IN this holy Martyr Justinus, I do not go about to be a translator §1of him, nor I bind not my self precisely to follow the form of his words (which no translator is bound unto) but I set forth only his sense and meaning. For where Justine hath a good long process in this matter, I take no more but that is directly to the purpose of Transubstantiation, which is the matter being here in question. And the long words of Justine, I knit up together in as few words as I can, rendering the sense truly, and not varying far from the words. And this have I done,1 not willingly to corrupt Justine (as you maliciously deprave, and thereupon will I join with you in your issue) but I do it to recite to the reader Justines mind shortly and plainly, where as you professing to observe scrupulously the words, observe in deed neither the words, nor the sentence of Justine. But this is your fashion when you lack good matter to answer, then (to find something to fill up your book) you turn the matter into trifling and cavillation in words.
IN this holy Martire Iustinus, I do not goe about to be a translator §1of him, nor I bynde not my selfe precisely to follow the forme of his wordes (which no translatour is bound vnto) but I set forth onely his sence and meaning. For where Iustine hath a good long processe in this matter, I take no more but that is directly to the purpose of Transubstantiation, which is the matter being here in question. And the long wordes of Iustine, I knit vp togither in as fewe wordes as I can, rendring the sense truly, and not varying farre from the wordes. And this haue I done,1 not willingly to corrupt Iustine (as you maliciously depraue, and therupon wil I ioyne with you in your issue) but I do it to recite to the reader Iustines mind shortly and playnly, where as you professing to obserue scrupulously the wordes, obserue in dede neither the wordes, nor the sentence of Iustine. But this is your fashion when you lacke good matter to answere, then (to finde something to fill vp your booke) you turne the matter into trifling and cauilation in wordes.
You say that Justine hath not this speech (the bread, water and wine in this Sacrament, are meats ordained purposely to give thanks to God) and yet by your own translation he hath the same thing in effect, and yet in deed the words be neither as you nor as I say, and as they be in greek, they cannot be expressed in English but by a paraphrasis: The words be these in greek, [Greek or Hebrew], and in our tongue as near as may be englished, signify thus, The bread and wine and water of thanks giving, or (as Ireneus saith, In which thanks be given). And neither hath Justine this word Sacrament (as I say) ⟨p. 281⟩nor this word Consecrated, as you say. May not all men therefore evidently see, that your chief study is to make cavillations & dallying in wordest And all the rest of my sayings, which you deny to be in Justine, be there very plainly in sense, as I will be judged by the indifferent reader.
You say that Iustine hath not this speach (the bread, water and wine in this Sacrameut, are meates ordeined purposely to giue thankes to God) and yet by your owne translation he hath the same thing in effect, and yet in deede the wordes be neither as you nor as I say, and as they be in greeke, they cannot be expressed in English but by a paraphrasis: The wordes be these in greke, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and in our tongue as nere as may be englished, signify thus, The bread and wine and water of thankes giuing, or (as Ireneus sayth, In which thankes be giuen). And neither hath Iustine this word Sacrameut (as I say) ⟨p. 281⟩nor this word Consecrated, as you say. May not all men therfore euidently see, that your chief study is to make cauilations & daylying in wordes• And all the rest of my sayinges, which you deny to be in Iustine, be there very playnly in sense, as I will be iudged by the indifferent reader.
And what need I willingly to corrupt Justine, when his words after your allegation, serve more for my purpose against your feigned transubstantiation, §2then as I allege them my self. For if the Deacons give to every one present a part of the bread, wine and water consecrated, and send part to them that be absent (as you report Justines words) do not then bread, wine and water remain after consecration? seeing that they be distributed to divers men in parts? For I think you will not say that the body of Christ is divided into parts, so that one man receiveth §3an hand, and an other a leg. And Justine saith further, that the same food of bread, wine and water called Eucharistia, nourisheth our flesh and blood by alteration, which they could not do, if no bread, wine nor water were there at all.
And what neede I willingly to corrupt Iustine, when his wordes after your allegation, serue more for my purpose agaynst your fayned transubstantiation, §2then as I alleadge them my selfe. For if the Deacons giue to euery one present a part of the bread, wine and water consecrated, and send parte to them that be absent (as you reporte Iustines wordes) do not then bread, wine and water remayne after consecration? seing that they be distributed to diuers men in partes? For I thincke you will not say that the body of Christ is deuided into partes, so that one man receaueth §3an hand, and an other a legge. And Iustine sayth further, that the same foode of bread, wine and water called Eucharistia, nourisheth our flesh and bloud by alteration, which they could not do, if no bread, wine nor water were there at all.
But here is not to be passed over one exceeding great craft and untruth in your translation, that to cast a mist before the readers eyes, you alter the order of Justines words in that place, where the pith of the matter standeth: For where Justine saith of the food of bread, wine and water after the consecration, that they nourish our flesh and blood by alteration, the nourishment which Justine putteth after consecration, you untruly put it before the consecration, and so wilfully and craftily alter the order of Justinus words, to deceive the reader,1 and in this point will I join an issue with you. Is such craft and untruth to be used of Bishops? and then in matters of faith and religion, whereof they pretend and ought to be true professors? But I marvel not so much at your sleights in this place seeing that in the whole book through out you seek nothing less, then the truth. And yet all your sleights will not serve you, for how can the food (called Eucharistia) nourish before the consecration, seeing it is not eaten until after the consecration?
But here is not to be passed ouer one exceeding great craft and vntruth in your translation, that to cast a mist before the readers eyes, you alter the order of Iustines wordes in that place, where the pith of the matter standeth: For where Iustine sayth of the foode of bread, wine and water after the consecration, that they nourish our flesh and bloud by alteration, the nourishment which Iustine putteth after consecration, you vntruly put it before the consecration, and so wilfully and craftely alter the order of Iustinus wordes, to deceaue the reader,1 and in this poynt will I ioyne an issue with you. Is such craft and vntruth to be vsed of Bishoppes? and then in matters of fayth and religion, wherof they pretend and ought to be true professors? But I meruayle not so much at your sleights in this place seeing that in the whole booke through out you seeke nothing lesse, then the truth. And yet all your sleightes will not serue you, for how can the foode (called Eucharistia) nourish before the consecration, seeing it is not eaten vntill after the consecration?
The next author in my book is Irene, whom I allege thus.
The next author in my booke is Irene, whome I alleadge thus.
Next him was Irenaeus,1 above 150. years after Christ, who (as it is supposed) could not be deceived in the necessary points of our faith, for he was a disciple of Policarpus, which was disciple to S. John the Evangelist.
Next him was Irenaeus,1 aboue 150. yeares after Christ, who (as it is supposed) could not be deceaued in the necessary poyntes of our fayth, for he was a disciple of Policarpus, which was disciple to S. Ihon the Euangelist.
This Irenaeus followeth the sense of Justinus wholly in this matter, and almost also his words, saying, that the bread wherein we give thanks unto God, although it be of the earth, yet when the name of God is called upon it, it is not than common bread, but the bread of thanks giving, having two things in it, one earthly, and the other heavenly. What meant he by the heavenly thing, but the sanctification which cometh by the invocation of the name of God? And what by the earthly thing: but the very bread which (as he said before) is of the earth: and which also (he saith) doeth nourish our bodies as other bread doth which we do use?
This Irenaeus followeth the sense of Iustinus wholy in this matter, and almost also his wordes, saying, that the bread wherein we geue thankes vnto God, although it be of the earth, yet when the name of God is called vpon it, it is not than common bread, but the bread of thankes geuing, hauing two thinges in it, one earthly, and the other heauenly. What ment he by the heauenly thing, but the sanctification which cōmeth by the inuocation of the name of God? And what by the earthly thing: but the very bread which (as he sayd before) is of the earth: and which also (he sayth) doeth nourish our bodies as other bread doth which we do vse?
Next Justine is Irene, in the allegation of whom, this author maketh also an untrue report, how hath not this for men of words in the forth book contra Valentinum, that the bread wherein we give thanks unto God, although it be of the earth, yet when ⟨p. 282⟩the name of god is called upon, it is not thru common bread, but the bread of thanks giving, having two things in it, one earthly and the other heavenly. This is Irene alleged by this author, who I say writeth not in such form of words. For his words be these. Like as the bread which is of the earth, receiving the calling of God, is now no common bread, but Eucharistia, consisting of two things, earthly and heavenly, so our bodies receiving Eucharistian, be no more corruptible. These be Irenes §1words where Irene doth not call the bread receiving, the calling of God, the bread of thanks giving, but Eucharistia, and in this Eucharistia, he showeth how that, that he calleth the heavenly things, is the body and blood of Christ, and therefore saith in his fifth book, When the chalice mixed, and the bread broken, receive the word of God, it is made Eucharistia, of the body and blood of Christ, of which the substance of our flesh is stayed and increased. And how say they that our flesh is not able to receive gods gift. who is eternal life which flesh is nourished with the body and blood of Christ? These be also Irenes words, whereby appeareth, what he meant by the heavenly thing in Eucharistia, which is the very presence of Christs body and blood. And for the plain testimony of this faith, this Irene hath been commonly alleged, and specially of Melancton to Decolampadius, as one most ancient and most plainly testifying the same. So as his very words truly alleged, overthrow this author in the impugnation of Christs real presence in the Sacrament, and therefore can nothing help this authors purpose against Transubstantiation. Is not this a goodly and godly enter of this Author, in the first two authorities that he bringeth in, to corrupt them both?
Next Iustine is Irene, in the allegation of whome, this author maketh also an vntrue reporte, how hath not this for mē of wordes in the forth booke contra Valentinum, that the bread wherein we geue thankes vnto God, although it be of the earth, yet when ⟨p. 282⟩the name of god is called vpon, it is not thru common bread, but the bread of thankes giuing, hauing two thinges in it, one earthly and the other heauenly. This is Irene alleadged by this author, who I say writeth not in such forme of wordes. For his wordes be these. Like as the bread which is of the earth, receauing the calling of God, is now no common bread, but Eucharistia, consisting of two thinges, earthly and heauenly, so our bodies receauing Eucharistian, be no more corruptible. These be Irenes
Who seeth not, that as you did before in Justine, so again in Irene you seek nothing else, but mere cavillations and wrangling in words? Is not Eucharistia called in english, thanks giving? If it be not,§1 tell you what it is called in English? And doth not Iren say, Panes in qup gratiae actae sunt, that is so say, bread wherein thanks be given, what have I offended then in englishing Eucharistiam; thanks giving? Do not I write to English men, which understand not what this greek word Eucharistia, meaneth: what great offence is it then in me to put it into English, that English men may understand what is said Should I do as you do, put greek for English and write so obscurely, that English men should not know the authors meaning?
WHo seeth not, that as you did before in Iustine, so agayne in Irene you seeke nothing els, but meare cauilations and wrangling in wordes? Is not Eucharistia called in english, thankes giuing? If it be not,§1 tell you what it is called in English? And doth not Iren say, Panes in qup gratiae actae sunt, that is so say, bread wherein thankes be giuen, what haue I offended then in englishing Eucharistiam; thankes giuing? Do not I write to English men, which vnderstand not what this greeke word Eucharistia, meaneth: what greate offence is it then in me to put it into English, that English men may vnderstaud what is sayde Should I do as you do, put greeke for English and write so obscurely, that English men should not know the authors meaning?
And do you not see, how much the words of Ireneus by you alleged, make against your self? These be his words after your citation: When the chalice mixed, and the bread broken, receive the word of God, it is made Eucharistia of the body and blood of Christ, of which the substance of our flesh is staid and increased. Doth not Irene say here plainly, that the chalice mixed, and the bread broken, after the word of God (which you call, the words of consecration) is made Eucharistia of the body and blood of Christ, and not the body and blood of Christ? And saith he not further, that they stay and increase the substance of our bodies? But how can those things stay and increase our bodies, which be transubstantiated and gone before we receive them? And have you forgotten now in Irene, what you said in the next leaf before in Justine, that the alteration and nourishment by the food of bread and wine was understand before the consecration? which you confess now to be after the consecration? And when you thus obscure the authors words, perverting and corrupting both the words and senses, yet shall you conclude your untrue dealing with these words concerning me? Is not this a goodly and godly entries of this author in the first two authorities that he bringeth in to corrupt them both? Now followeth Origene next in my book.
And do you not see, how much the words of Ireneus by you aleadged, make agaynst your selfe? These be his wordes after your citation: When the chalice mixt, and the bread broken, receaue the word of God, it is made Eucharistia of the body and bloud of Christ, of which the substance of our flesh is stayd and encreased. Doth not Irene say here playnly, that the chalice mixt, and the bread broken, after the word of God (which you call, the wordes of consecration) is made Eucharistia of the body and bloud of Christ, and not the body and bloud of Christ? And sayth he not further, that they stay and increase the substance of our bodies? But how can those thinges stay and increase our bodies, which be transubstantiated and gone before we receaue them? And haue you forgotten now in Irene, what you sayd in the next leafe before in Iustine, that the alteration and nourishment by the foode of bread and wine was vnderstande before the consecration? which you confesse now to be after the consecration? And when you thus obscure the authors wordes, peruerting and corrupting both the wordes and sences, yet shall you conclude your vntrue dealing with these wordes concerning me? Is not this a goodly and godly entres of this author in the first two authorities that he bringeth in to corrupt them both? Now followeth Origene next in my booke.
Shortly after Ireneus, was Origene,1 about 200. years after Christs ascension. Who also affirmeth, that the material bread remaineth, saying that the matter of the bread availeth nothing, but goeth down into the belly, and is avoided downward, but the word of God spoken upon the bread, is it that availeth.
Shortly after Ireneus, was Origene,1 about 200. yeares after Christs ascension. Who also affirmeth, that the materiall bread remayneth, saying that the matter of the bread auayleth nothing, but goeth downe into the bealy, and is auoyded dounward, but the word of God spoken vpon the bread, is it that auayleth.
As for Origene in his own words saith, the matter of the bread remaineth, which as I have before opened,1 it may be granted, but yet he termeth it not as this author doeth, to call it material bread. When God formed Adam of clay, the matter of the clay remained in Adam and yet the material clay remained not: for it was altered into an other substance, which I speak not to compare equally the forming of Adam to the §2Sacrament, but to show it not to be all one to say the material bread and the matter of bread. For the accidents of bread may be called the matter of bread, but not the material bread, as I have somewhat spoken thereof before: but such shifts be used in this matter, notwithstanding the importunance of it.
As for Origene in his owne wordes sayth, the matter of the bread remayneth, which as I haue before opened,1 it may be graunted, but yet he termeth it not as this author doeth, to call it materiall bread. When God formed Adam of clay, the matter of the clay remayned in Adam and yet the materiall clay remayned not: for it was altered into an other substance, which I speake not to compare equally the forming of Adam to the §2Sacrament, but to shew it not to be all one to say the materiall bread and the matter of bread. For the accidents of bread may be called the matter of bread, but not the materiall bread, as I haue sumwhat spoken therof before: but such shiftes be vsed in this matter, notwithstanding the importunance of it.
And as touching the belefe of S. Thomas,1 although he beleued certaynly that Christ was a man, yet he beleued not that Christ was risen, and appeared to the Apostles, but thought rather that the Apostles were deceaued by some vision or spirit, which appeared to them in likenes of Christ, which he thought was not he indede. And so thought the Apostles themselues vntill Christ sayd: Videte manus meas & pedes, quia ego ipse sum: Palpate & videte, quia spiritus carnem & ossa non habent, sicut me videtis habere.2 See my handes and my feete, for I am euen he: Grope and see, for a spirite hath no flesh and bones, as you see that I haue. And so thought also S. Thomas,3 vntill such tyme as he put his handes into Christes side and felt his woundes, and by his sense of feeling perceaued that it was Christes very body, and no spirite nor phantasy, as before he beleued. And so in S. Thomas the truth of feeling depended not vpon the true belefe of Christes resurrection, but the feeling of his senses brought him from misbelefe, vnto the right and true fayth of that matter. And as for S. Gregory,4 he speaketh no such thinges as you report, that the glorified body of Christ was of the owne nature neither visible nor palpable, but he sayth cleane contrary, that Christ shewed his glorified body to S. Thomas palpable, to declare that it was of the same nature, that it was of before his resurrection, whereby it is playne after S. Gregories minde, that if it were not palpable, it were not of the same nature. And S. Gregory sayth further in the same homely. Egit miro modo superna clementia, vt discipulus ille dubitans, ⟨p. 278⟩dum in magistro suo vulnera palparet carnis, in nobis vulnera sanaret infidelitatis. Plus enim nobis Thomae infidelitas ad fidem, quam fides credentium discipulcrum profuit: quia dum ille ad fidem palpando reducitur, nostra mens omni dubitatione postposita in fide solidatur. The supernall clemency wrought meruaylously, that the disciple which doubted by groping the woundes of flesh in his master, should heale in vs the woundes of infidelity. For the lacke of fayth in Thomas profited more to our fayth then did the fayth of the disciples that beleued. For when he is brought to fayth by groping, our minde is stablished in fayth without all doubting. And why should S. Gregory write thus, if our sences auayled nothing vnto our fayth, nor could nothing iudge of substances?
I will spend no mo wordes herein,1 but hauing auoyded this authors reasoning against Transubstantiation. Now let vs examine his authorities. First he beginneth with Iustine the Martyr, Whose wordes be not truly by this author here reported, which §2be these truely translate out of ye Greke. When the priest hath ended his thankes geuing and prayers, and all the people hath sayd Amen, they whom we call Deacons, geue to euery one then present, a parte of the bread and of the wine and water consecrated, and cary part to those that be absent: and this is that foode, which is among vs called (Eucharistia) wherof it is lawfull for no man to be partaker, except he be perswaded those thinges to be true that be taught vs, and be baptized in the water of regeneration in remission of sinnes, and ordreth his life after the manner which Christ hath taught. For we do not take these for common bread or drincke, but like as Iesus Christ our sauiour incarnate by the word of God, had flesh and bloud for our saluation, euen so we be taught §3the foode, (wherwith our flesh and bloud be nourished by alteration) when it is consecrate ⟨p. 280⟩by the prayer of his word, to be the flesh and bloud of the same Iesus incarnate.§3 For the Apostles in those their workes, which be called gospels, teach that Iesus did so commaund them, and after he had taken the bread, and ended his thankes geuing, sayd: Do this in my remembrance, This is my body. And likewise taking the cup after he had geuen thankes, sayd: This is my bloud, and did giue them to his Apostles onely.2 And here I make an issue with this author, that he wittingly corrupteth Iustine §1in the allegation of him, who writeth not in such forme of wordes as this author alleageth out of his second Apology, nor hath any such speach. The bread, water, and wine in this sacrament, are meates ordeined purposely to giue thankes to God, and therfore be called Eucharistia, nor hath not these wordes, They be called the body and bloud of Christ: but hath in playne wordes, that we be taught, this foode consecrate by gods word, to be the flesh and bloud of Christ, as Christ in his incarnation tooke flesh and bloud: nor hath not this forme of wordes placed to haue that vnderstanding, how the same meate and drincke is changed into our flesh and bloud.