pp. 3941,982 passagespart 40 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And as touching the second place of S. Augustine, he saith not that the body and blood of Christ be really in the Sacrament, but that in the §3Sacrifice of the church, that is to say, in the holy administration of the Lords supper, is both a Sacrament and the thing signified by the Sacrament, the Sacrament being the bread and wine, and the thing signified and exhibited, being the body and blood of Christ. But S. Augustine saith not, that the thing signified is in the bread and wine (to whom it ⟨p. 299⟩is not exhibited, nor is not in it, (but as in a figure) but that it is there in the true ministration of the Sacrament, present to the spirit and faith of the true believing man, and exhibited truly and indeed, and yet spiritually not corporally.
And as touching the second place of S. Augustine, he sayth not that the body and bloud of Christ be really in the Sacrament, but that in the §3Sacrifice of the church, that is to say, in the holy administration of the Lordes supper, is both a Sacrament and the thing signified by the Sacrament, the Sacrament being the bread and wine, and the thing signified and exhibited, being the body and bloud of Christ. But S. Augustine sayth not, that the thing signified is in the bread and wine (to whome it ⟨p. 299⟩is not exhibited, nor is not in it, (but as in a figure) but that it is there in the true ministration of the Sacrament, present to the spirite and fayth of the true beleuing man, and exhibited truely and indeede, and yet spiritually not corporally.
And what need any more evident proofs of S. Augustine's mind in this matter, how bread is called Christs body then S. Augustine's own words cited in the same place,1 where the other is de consecratione dist. 2. Hoc est quod dicimus? These be S. Augustine's words there cited. Sicut coelestis panis, qui Christi caro est, suo modo vocatur corpus Christi, cum re uera sit sacramentum corporis Christi, illius videlicet quod visibile, quod palpabile, mortale, in cruce positum est, vocaturque ipsa immolatio carnis (quae sacerdotis manibus fit) Christi passio, mors, crucifixio, non rei veritate, sed significanti misterio: sic Sacramentum fidei, (quod baptismus intelligitur) fides est. As the heavenly bread (which is Christs flesh) after a manner is called the body of Christ, where in very deed it is a sacrament of Christs body, that is to say, of that body which being visible, palpable, mortal, was put upon the cross: And as that offering of the flesh which is done by the priests hands, is called the passion, the death the crucifying of Christ, not in truth of the thing, but in a signifying mystery so is the Sacrament of faith (which is Baptism) faith. These words be so plain and manifest, that the expositor (being a very Papist) yet could not avoid the matter, but wrote thus upon the said words. Immolatio quae fit a praesbitero, improprie appellatur Christi passio, velmors, vel crucifixio, non quod sit illa, sed quia illam significat. And after he saith: Coeleste Sacramentū, quod vere repraesē tat Christi carnem, dicitur corpus Christi, sed improprie. Unde dicitur, suo modo, sed non rei veritate, sed significanti misterio, ut sit sensus, vocatur Christi corpus, id est, significat.
And what neede any more euident proofes of S. Augustines mynd in this matter, how bread is called Christes body then S. Augustines owne wordes cited in the same place,1 where the other is de consecratione dist. 2. Hoc est quod dicimus? These be S. Augustines wordes there cited. Sicut coelestis panis, qui Christi caro est, suo modo vocatur corpus Christi, cum re uera sit sacramentum corporis Christi, illius videlicet quod visibile, quod palpabile, mortale, in cruce positum est, vocaturque ipsa immolatio carnis (quae sacerdotis manibus fit) Christi passio, mors, crucifixio, non rei veritate, sed significanti misterio: sic Sacramentum fidei, (quod baptismus intelligitur) fides est. As the heauenly bread (which is Christes flesh) after a manner is called the body of Christ, where in very deede it is a sacrament of Christes body, that is to say, of that body which being visible, palpable, mortall, was put vppon the crosse: And as that offering of the flesh which is done by the priestes handes, is called the passion, the death the crucifying of Christ, not in truth of the thing, but in a signifying mistery so is ye Sacramēt of fayth (which is Baptisme) fayth. These wordes be so playne and manifest, that the expositour (being a very Papist) yet could not auoyd the matter, but wrote thus vpon the sayd wordes. Immolatio quae fit a praesbitero, improprie appellatur Christi passio, velmors, vel crucifixio, non quod sit illa, sed quia illam significat. And after he sayth: Coeleste Sacramētū, quod vere repraesē tat Christi carnem, dicitur corpus Christi, sed improprie. Vnde dicitur, suo modo, sed non rei veritate, sed significanti misterio, vt sit sensus, vocatur Christi corpus, id est, significat.
The offering which the priest maketh, is called improperly the passion, death, or crucifying of Christ, not that it is that, but that it signifieth it. And the heavenly Sacrament (which truly representeth Christs flesh) is called Christs body, but improperly. And therefore is said (after a manner, but not in the truth of the thing, but in the signifying mystery.) So that the sense is this, it is called the body of Christ, that is to say, signifieth. Now the words of S. Augustine being so plain, that none can be more, and following the other words within ten lines (so that you can allege no ignorance, but you must needs see them) it can be none other but a wilful blindness, that you will not see, and also a wilful concealing and hiding of the truth from other men, that they should not see neither.
The offering which the priest maketh, is called improperly the passion, death, or crucifying of Christ, not that it is that, but that it signifieth it. And the heauenly Sacrament (which truly represēteth Christes flesh) is called Christes body, but improperly. And therfore is sayd (after a manner, but not in the truth of the thing, but in the signifying mistery.) So that the sence is this, it is called the body of Christ, that is to say, signifieth. Now the wordes of S. Augustine being so playne, that none can be more, and following the other wordes within tenne lines (so that you can alleadge no ignorance, but you must needes see them) it can be none other but a wilfull blindnes, that you will not see, and also a wilfull concealing and hiding of the truth from other men, that they should not see neyther.
And this one place is sufficient at full to answer what so ever you can bring of the presence of Christ in the Sacrament of bread and wine. For after consecration, the body & blood of Christ be in them but as in figures, although in the godly receivers, he is really present by his omnipotent power, which is as great a miracle in our daily nourishing, as is wrought before in our regeneration. And therefore is Christ no less to be honoured of them that feed of him in his holy supper, then of them that be grafted in him by regeneration.
And this one place is sufficient at full to answere what so euer you can bring of the presence of Christ in the Sacrament of bread and wine. For after consecration, the body & bloud of Christ be in them but as in figures, although in the godly receauors, he is really present by his omnipotent power, which is as great a miracle in our dayly nurrishing, as is wrought before in our regeneration. And therfore is Christ no lesse to be honored of them that feede of him in his holy supper, then of them that be grafted in him by regeneration.
And where as I said upon S. Augustine's words, that the Sacrament consisteth of two natures, in that place I collected more of S. Augustine's words in your favour, then indeed S. Augustine saith, because ⟨p. 300⟩you should not say, that I nipped him. For S. Augustine saith not, that the sacrament consisteth of two natures, and therefore both these natures must needs remain in the Sacrament, but he saith that the Sacrifice consisteth of two things, which he calleth also natures, and thereof it followeth, that those two things must be in the sacrifice, which is to be understand, in the ministration not in the bread and wine reserved. And very true it is (as S Augustine saith) that the sacrifice of the church consisteth of two things, of the Sacrament, and of the thing thereby signified, which is Christs body, as the person of Christ consisteth of god and man.
And where as I sayd vpon S. Augustines wordes, that the Sacrament consisteth of two natures, in that place I collected more of S. Augustines wordes in your fauour, then indeed S. Augustine sayth, bicause ⟨p. 300⟩you should not say, that I nipt him. For S. Augustine sayth not, that the sacrament consisteth of two natures, and therfore both these natures must needes remayne in the Sacrament, but he sayth that the Sacrifice consisteth of two thinges, which he calleth also natures, and therof it followeth, that those two thinges must be in the sacrifice, which is to be vnderstande, in the ministration not in the bread and wine reserued. And very true it is (as S Augustine sayth) that the sacrifice of the church consisteth of two thinges, of the Sacrament, and of the thing therby signified, which is Christes body, as the person of Christ consisteth of god and man.
But yet this resemblance is not altogether like (as you say truly for so §5much) for the person of Christ consisteth so of his godhead and manhood, that they be both in him in real presence and unity of person. But in the sacrifice it is otherwise, where neither is any such union between the sacrament, and the truth of the Sacrament, nor any such presence of the body of Christ. For in the bread and wine Christ is but figuratively (as I said before) and in the godly receivers spiritually, in whom also he tarrieth & remaineth so long as they remain the members of his body.
But yet this resemblance is not altogither like (as you say truely for so §5much) for the person of Christ consisteth so of his godhead and manhod, that they be both in him in reall presence and vnity of person. But in the sacrifice it is otherwise, where neither is any such vnion betwene the sacrament, and the truth of the Sacrament, nor any such presence of the body of Christ. For in the bread and wine Christ is but figuratiuely (as I sayd before) and in the godly receauours spiritually, in whome also he tarieth & remayneth so long as they remayne the mēbers of his body.
1But if Christs similitudes should be so narrowly pressed, as you press here the similitude of the two natures of Christ in the sacrament, collecting that because the body and blood of Christ be truly present in the due administration of the Sacrament, therefore they must be there naturally present, as the two natures of the humanity and divinity be in Christ, many wicked errors should be established by them. As if the similitude of the wicked steward were strained as you strain and force this similitude, men might gather, that it is lawful for Christen men to beguile their lords and masters whiles they be in office, to help them selves when they be out of office, because the Lord praised the wicked steward. Yet you know the similitude was not taught of our Saviour Christ for that purpose (for God is no favourer of falsehood and untruth.) So you do wrong both to the holy Doctors and to me, to gather of our similitude any other doctrine, than we mean by the said similitude. Nor any reasonable man can say, that I am forced by confessing two natures in Christs person really, naturally and substantially, to confess also the nature of the body and blood of Christ to be likewise in the Sacrament, except he could prove that the holy Doctors, and I following their doctrine, do teach and affirm, that the natures of bread and wine are joined in the Sacrament with the natural body and blood of Christ in unity of person, as the natures of God and man be joined in our Saviour Christ, which we do not teach, because we find no such doctrine taught by Christ, by his Apostles, nor Evangelists.
1But if Christes similitudes should be so narrowly pressed, as you presse here the similitude of the two natures of Christ in the sacrament, collecting that bicause the body and bloud of Christ be truely present in the due administration of the Sacrament, therfore they must be there naturally present, as the two natures of the humanity and diuinity be in Christ, many wicked errours should be established by them. As if the similitude of the wicked steward were strayned as you strayne and force this similitude, men might gather, that it is lawfull for Christen men to begile theire lordes and masters whiles they be in office, to helpe them selues when they be out of office, bicause the Lord praysed the wicked steward. Yet you know the similitude was not taught of our Sauiour Christ for that purpose (for God is no fauourer of falsehod and vntruth.) So you do wrong both to the holy Doctoures and to me, to gather of oure similitude any other doctrine, than we meane by the sayd similitude. Nor any reasonable man can say, that I am forced by confessing two natures in Christes person really, naturally and substantially, to confesse also the nature of the body and bloud of Christ to be likewise in the Sacrament, except he could proue that the holy Doctoures, and I following their doctrine, do teach and affirme, that the natures of bread and wine are ioyned in the Sacrament with the naturall body and bloud of Christ in vnity of person, as the natures of God and man be ioyned in our Sauiour Christ, which we do not teach, bicause we finde no such doctrine taught by Christ, by his Apostles, nor Euangilistes.
Therefore take your own collection to your self, and make your self answer to such absurdities and inconvenience, as you do infer, by abusing and forcing of the Doctors similitude to an other end than they did use it.
Therfore take your owne collection to your selfe, and make your selfe aunswere to such absurdities and inconuenience, as you do inferre, by abusing and forcing of the Doctours similitude to an other ende than they did vse it.
1And it is not necessary for our eternal salvation, nor yet profitable for our comfort in this life, to believe that the natural body and blood of Christ is really, substantially, and naturally present in the Sacrament. For if it were necessary or comfortable for us, it is without doubt, that ⟨p. 301⟩our saviour Christ, his Apostles, and Evangelists, would not have omitted to teach this doctrine, distinctly and plainly. Yea our Saviour would not have sayd,2 Spiritus est qui vivificat, caro non prodest quitquam, The spirit giveth life, the flesh availeth nothing.
1And it is not necessary for our eternall saluation, nor yet profitable for our comfort in this life, to beleeue that the naturall body and bloud of Christ is really, substancially, and naturally present in the Sacrament. For if it were necessary or comfortable for vs, it is without doubt, that ⟨p. 301⟩our sauiour Christ, his Apostles, and Euangelistes, would not haue omitted to teach this doctrine, distinctly and playnly. Yea our Sauiour would not haue sayd,2 Spiritus est qui viuificat, caro non prodest quitquam, The spirite giueth life, the flesh auayleth nothing.
But this doctrine which the holy doctors do teach,1 is agreeable to holy scripture, necessary for all christen persons to believe for their everlasting salvation, and profitable for their spiritual comfort in this present life, that is to say, that the Sacrament of Christs body and blood in the natures and substances of bread and wine, is distributed unto all men, both good and evil which receive it, and yet that only faithful persons do receive spiritually by faith, the very body and blood of our Saviour Christ. So that Christs natural body is not in the Sacrament really, substantially, and corporally, but only by representation and signification, and in his lively members by spiritual and effectual operation.
But this doctrine which the holy doctors do teach,1 is agreable to holy scripture, necessary for all christen persons to beleue for their euerlasting saluation, and profitable for their spirituall comfort in this present life, that is to say, that the Sacrament of Christes body and bloud in the natures and substances of bread and wine, is distributed vnto all men, both good and euill which receaue it, and yet that onely faythfull persons do receaue spiritually by fayth, the very body and bloud of our Sauiour Christ. So that Christes naturall body is not in the Sacrament really, substancially, and corporally, but onely by representation and signification, and in his liuely members by spirituall and effectuall operation.
But it appeareth that you be foul deceived in judgement of the doctrine set out in my book. And if you were not either utterly ignorant in holy scriptures and doctors, or not obstinately bent to pervert the true doctrine of this holy Sacrament, you would never have uttered this sentence. §6That there was never man overturned his own assertions more evidently, then this Author doth. For I am well assured, that my doctrine is sound, and therefore do trust that I shall able to stand by mine assertions before all men that are learned, and be any thing indifferent, and not bent obstinately to maintain errors as you be, when you tumbling and tossing your self in your filthy fantasies of Transubstantiation, and of the real and carnal presence of Christs body, shall be ashamed of your assertions. But I marvel not much of your stout bragging here, because it is a common thing with you, to dash me in the teeth with your own faults.
But it appeareth that you be foule deceaued in iudgement of the doctrine set out in my booke. And if you were not eyther vtterly ignorant in holy scriptures and doctors, or not obstinately bent to peruert the true doctrine of this holy Sacrament, you would neuer haue vttered this sentence. §6That there was neuer man ouerturned his owne assertions more euidently, then this Author doth. For I am well assured, that my doctrine is sound, and therfore do trust that I shall able to stand by myne assertions before all men that are learned, and be any thing indifferent, and not bent obstinately to mayntayne errors as you be, when you tumbling and tossing your selfe in your filthy fantasies of Transubstantiation, and of the reall and carnall presence of Christes body, shalbe ashamed of your assertiōs. But I meruayle not much of your stout bragging here, bicause it is a common thing with you, to dashe me in the teeth with your owne faultes.
And it is untrue that you say, that the sacrifice is perfected before the perfection. For if the sacrifice be perfected before the perception, it is perfected also before the consecration. For between the consecration and perception was no sacrifice made by Christ (as appeareth in the Evangelists) but the one followed immediately of the other. And although Christ being in heaven be one of the parts whereof the sacrifice consisteth, & be present in the sacrifice, yet he is not naturally there present, but sacramentally in the sacrament, and spiritually in the receivers.
And it is vntrue that you say, that the sacrifice is parfited before the perfection. For if the sacrifice be parfited before the perception, it is parfited also before the consecration. For betwene the consecration and perception was no sacrifice made by Christ (as appeareth in the Euangelistes) but the one followed immediately of the other. And although Christ being in heauen be one of the partes wherof the sacrifice consisteth, & be present in the sacrifice, yet he is not naturally there present, but sacramentally in the sacrament, and spiritually in the receauours.
And by this which I have now answered, I have wrestled with you so in the matter of Christs presence, that I have not fallen upon my back my self to pull you over me, but I standing up right my self, have given you such a fall, that you shall never be able to recover. And now that I have brought you to the ground (although it be but a small piece of manhood to strike a man when he is down) yet for the truths sake, (unto whom you have ever been so great an adversary) I shall beat you with your Transubstantiation (as they say) both back and bone. Now say you sir, is whiteness or other colours the nature of bread and wine? (for the colours be only visible by your doctrine) or be they elements, or be accidents the bodily matter? Lye still, ye shall be better beaten yet, for your wilfulness. Be the accidents of bread substances, as you said not long before? And if they be substances, what manner of substances be they: corporal ⟨p. 302⟩or spiritual? If they be spiritual, then be they souls, devils, or angels. And if they be corporal substances, either they have life or no life. I trust you will say at the least, that bread hath life, because you said but even now almost, that the substance of bread is the soul of it. Such absurdities they fall into, that maintain errors.
And by this which I haue now answered, I haue wrastled with you so in the matter of Christes presence, that I haue not fallen vpon my back my selfe to pull you ouer me, but I standing vp right my selfe, haue geuen you such a fall, that you shall neuer be able to recouer. And now that I haue brought you to the ground (although it be but a small peece of manhoode to strike a man when he is downe) yet for the truthes sake, (vnto whome you haue euer bene so great an aduersary) I shall beate you with your Transubstantiation (as they say) both backe and bone. Now say you syr, is whitenes or other colours the nature of bread and wine? (for the colours be onely visible by your doctrine) or be they elements, or be accidents the bodely matter? Lye still, ye shall be better beaten yet, for your wilfulnes. Be the accidents of bread substances, as you sayd not long before? And if they be substances, what manner of substances be they: corporall ⟨p. 302⟩or spirituall? If they be spirituall, then be they soules, deuils, or angels. And if they be corporall substances, eyther they haue life or no life. I trust you will say at the least, that bread hath life, bicause you sayd but euen now almost, that the substance of bread is the soule of it. Such absurdities they fall into, that mayntayne errours.
But at length when the similitude of the two natures in Christ, remaining §9both in their proper kinds, must needs be answered unto, then cometh in again the cuttle with his colours to hide him self, that he should not be seen, because he perceiveth what danger he is in to be taken: And when he cometh to the very net, he so stoutly striveth, wrangleth and wresteth, as he would break the net, or else by some craft, wind himself out of it, but the net is so strong, and he so surely masted therein, that he shall never be able to get out.
But at length when the similitude of the two natures in Christ, remayning §9both in their proper kindes, must needes be answered vnto, then commeth in agayne the cuttill with his colours to hide him selfe, that he should not be seene, bicause he perceaueth what danger he is in to be taken: And when he commeth to the very nette, he so stoutly striueth, wrangleth and wresteth, as he would breake the nette, or els by some craft, wind himselfe out of it, but the net is so strong, and he so surely masted therein, that he shall neuer be able to gette out.
1For the old catholic Authors, to declare that two natures remain in Christ together (that is to say, his humanity and his divinity) without corruption or wasting of any of the said two natures, do give two examples thereof, one is of the body and soul, which both be in a man together, and the presence of the one putteth not away the other.
1For the olde catholike Authors, to declare that two natures remayne in Christ togither (that is to say, his humanity and his diuinity) without corruption or wasting of any of the sayd two natures, do geue two examples therof, one is of the body and soule, which both be in a man togither, and the presence of the one putteth not away the other.
The other example is of the Lords Supper or ministration of the Sacrament, where is also together the substance and nature of bread and wine with the body and blood of Christ, and the presence of the one putteth not away the other, no more then the presence of Christs humanity putteth away his divinity. And as the presence of the soul driveth not away the body, nor the presence of the flesh and blood of Christ driveth not away the bread and wine, so doth not the presence of Christs humanity, expel his divinity, but his divinity remaineth still with his humanity, as the soul doth with the body, and the body of Christ with the bread. And then if there remain not the nature and substance of bread, it must follow also, that there remaineth not the divine nature of Christ, with his humanity, or else the similitude is clearly dissolved.
The other example is of the Lordes Supper or ministration of the Sacrament, where is also togither the substaunce and nature of bread and wine with the body and bloud of Christ, and the presence of the one putteth not away the other, no more then the presence of Christes humanitie putteth away hys diuinitie. And as the presence of the soule driueth not away the body, nor the presence of the fleshe and bloud of Christ driueth not away the bread and wine, so doth not the presence of Christes humanity, expell his diuinitie, but his diuinitie remayneth still with his humanitie, as the soule doth with the body, and the body of Christ with the bread. And then if there remayne not the nature and substaunce of bread, it must follow also, that there remaineth not the diuine nature of Christ, with his humanity, or els the similitude is clearely dissolued.
But yet say you, we may not press all parts of the resemblance with a through equality, but only have respect to the end, wherefore the resemblance is made. And do you not see, how this your saying taketh away your own argument of the real presence in the sacrament? and nevertheless setteth you no whit more at liberty concerning Transubstantiation, but masteth you faster in the net, and maketh it more stronger to hold you. For the old Authors make this resemblance, only to declare the remaining of two natures, not the manner and form of remaining, which is far divers in the person of Christ, from the union in the Sacrament. For the two natures of Christ be joined together in unity of person, which unity is not between the Sacrament and the body of Christ. But in that point wherein the resemblance is made, there must needs be an equality by your own saying. And for as much as the resemblance was made only for the remaining of two natures, therefore as the perfect natures of Christs manhood & godhead, do both remain, and the perfect nature of the soul and the body both also remain so must the perfect nature of Christs body and blood, and of bread and wine also remain. But for as much as the similitude was not made for the manner ⟨p. 303⟩of remaining, nor for the place, therefore the resemblance requireth not, that the body and blood of Christ should be united to the bread and wine in person or in place, but only that the natures should remain every one in his kind. And so be you clean overthrown with your transubstantiation, except you will join your self with those Heretics, which denied Christs humanity & divinity to remain both together.
But yet say you, we may not presse all partes of the resemblance with a through equality, but onely haue respect to the end, wherfore the resemblance is made. And do you not see, how this your saying taketh away your owne argument of the reall presence in the sacrament? and neuerthelesse setteth you no whitte more at liberty concerning Transubstantiation, but masteth you faster in the nette, and maketh it more stronger to holde you. For the olde Authors make this resemblance, onely to declare the remayning of two natures, not the manner and forme of remayning, which is farre diuers in the person of Christ, from the vnion in the Sacrament. For the two natures of Christ be ioyned togither in vnity of person, which vnity is not betwene the Sacrament and the body of Christ. But in that poynt wherein the resemblance is made, there must needes be an equality by your owne saying. And for as much as the resemblance was made onely for the remayning of two natures, therfore as the perfite natures of Christes manhod & godhead, do both remayne, and the perfite nature of the soule and the body both also remayne so must the perfite nature of Christes body and bloud, and of bread and wine also remayne. But for as much as the similitude was not made for the manner
And it seemeth that your doctrine varieth very little from Valentine and Martion (if it vary any thing at all) when you say that Christs §10flesh was a spiritual flesh.1 For when S. Paul speaking of Christs body, said (we be members of his body, of his flesh and of his bones) he meant not of a spiritual body (as Ireneus saith) for a spirit hath no flesh nor bones,2 but of a very mans body, that is made of flesh, sinews and bones, And so with striving to get out of the net you roll your self faster in it.
And it seemeth that your doctrine varieth very little from Ualentine and Martion (if it vary any thing at all) when you say that Christes §10flesh was a spirituall flesh.1 For when S. Paule speaking of Christes body, sayd (we bee members of his body, of his fleshe and of his bones) he ment not of a spirituall body (as Ireneus sayth) for a spirite hath no flesh nor bones,2 but of a very mans body, that is made of flesh, sinewes and bones, And so with striuing to gette out of the nette you roll your selfe faster in it.
And as for the words of S. Augustine, make nothing for the real presence, as I have before declared. So that therein I neither have foil nor trip, but for all your brags, hooks and crooks, you have such a fall, as you shall never be able to stand upright again in this matter. And my shafts be shot so straight against you, and with such a force, that they pierce through shield & habergeon, in such sort that all the harness you have, is not able to withstand them, or to make one arrow to start back, although to avoid the stroke you shift your place, seeking some mean to fly the fight. For when I make mine argument of Transubstantiation, you turn the matter to the real presence like unto a surgeon that hath no knowledge, but when the head is wounded or sore, he layeth a plaster to the heel. Or (as the proverb sayth) Interrogatus de alijs, respondet de caepis. when you be asked of garlic, you answer of onions.
And as for the wordes of S. Augustine, make nothing for the reall presence, as I haue before declared. So that therin I neyther haue foyle nor trippe, but for all your bragges, hookes and crookes, you haue such a fall, as you shall neuer be able to stand vpright agayne in this matter. And my shaftes be shot so straight agaynst you, and with such a force, that they perse through shilde & haburgen, in such sort that all the harnes you haue, is not able to withstand them, or to make one arrow to start backe, although to auoyde the stroke you shift your place, seeking some meane to flye the fight. For when I make mine argument of Transubstantiation, you turne the matter to the reall presence like vnto a surgeon that hath no knowledge, but when the head is wounded or sore, he layth a playster to the heele. Or (as the prouerbe sayth) Interrogatus de alijs, respondet de caepis. when you be asked of garlicke, you answer of onions.
And this is one pretty sleight of sophistry,1 or of a subtle warrier, when he seeth him self overmatched, and not able to resist, then by some policy quite to put of, or at the least to delay the conflict, and so do you commonly in this book of Transubstantiation. For when you be sore pressed therein, than you turn the matter to the real presence. But I shall so straitly §12pursue you, that you shall not so escape. For where you say, that the fathers (which used the examples of the Sacrament, and of the body and blood of Christ to show the unity of two natures in Christ did believe that as really and as truly the soul of man is present in the body, so really and so truly is the body of Christ present in the Sacrament: the fathers neither said nor believed as you here report, but they taught that both the Sacrament and the thing thereby represented (which is Christs body) remain in their proper substance and nature, the sign being here and the thing signified being in heaven, and yet of these two consisteth the sacrifice of the church.
And this is one prety sleight of sophistry,1 or of a subtill warrier, when he seeth him selfe ouermatched, and not able to resist, then by some policy quite to put of, or at the least to delay the conflict, and so do you commonly in this booke of Transubstantiation. For when you be sore pressed therin, than you turne the matter to the reall presence. But I shall so straytly §12pursue you, that you shall not so escape. For where you say, that the fathers (which vsed the examples of the Sacrament, and of the body and bloud of Christ to shew the vnity of two natures in Christ did beleue that as really and as truely the soule of man is present in the body, so really and so truly is the body of Christ present in the Sacrament: the fathers neither sayd nor beleued as you here report, but they taught that both the Sacrament and the thing therby represented (which is Christes body) remayne in their proper substaunce and nature, the signe being here and the thing signified being in heauen, and yet of these two consisteth the sacrifice of the church.
But it is not required, that the thing signified should be really and corporally present in the sign and figure, as the soul is in the body (because there is no such union of person) nor it is not required in the soul and body that they should be ever together, for Christs body and soul remained both, without either corruption or Transubstantiation, when the soul was gone down into hell, and the body rested in the sepulchre. And yet was he than a perfect man, although his soul was not than really present ⟨p. 304⟩with the body. And it is not so great a marvel that his body should be in heaven, and the sacrament of it here, as it is that his body should be here, and his soul in hell.
But it is not required, that the thing signified should be really and corporally present in the signe and figure, as the soule is in the body (bicause there is no such vnion of person) nor it is not required in the soule and body that they should be euer togither, for Christes body and soule remayned both, without eyther corruption or Transubstantiation, when the soule was gone downe into hell, and the body rested in the sepulcher. And yet was he than a perfect man, although his soule was not than really present ⟨p. 304⟩with the body. And it is not so great a meruayle that his body should be in heauen, and the sacrament of it here, as it is that his body should be here, and his soule in hell.
And if the Sacrament were a man, and the body of Christ the soul of §13it, (as you dream in your trance) then were the Sacrament not in a trance, but dead for the time, whilst it were here, and the soul in heaven. And like scoffing you might make of the Sacrament of Baptism, as you do in the Sacrament of Christs body, that it lieth here in a trance, when Christ being the life thereof is in heaven.
And if the Sacrament were a man, and the body of Christ the soule of §13it, (as you dreame in your traunse) then were the Sacrament not in a traunse, but dead for the tyme, whilest it were here, and the soule in heauen. And like scoffing you might make of the Sacrament of Baptisme, as you doe in the Sacrament of Christes body, that it lyeth here in a traunse, when Christ being the life therof is in heauen.
And where you think that my second book against Transubstantiation §14was a collection of me, when I minded to maintain Luther's opinion against Transubstantiation only, you have no probation of your thought, but still you remain in your dreams, trances and vain phantasies, which you have used throughout your book, so that what so ever is in the bread and wine, there is in you no Transubstantiation, nor alteration in this thing at all.
And where you thinke that my second booke agaynst Transubstantiation §14was a collection of me, when I minded to mayntayne Luthers opinion agaynst Trāsubstantiation onely, you haue no probatiō of your thought, but still you remayne in your dreames, traunses and vayne phantasies, which you haue vsed throughout your booke, so that what so euer is in the bread and wine, there is in you no Transubstantiation, nor alteration in this thing at all.
And what availeth it you so often to affirm this untruth, that the body of Christ is present in the Sacrament, as the soul of man is present in the body, except you be like to them that tell a lye so often, that with often repeating they think men believe it, and sometime by often telling they believe it them selves. But the authors bring not this similitude of the body and soul of man, to prove thereby the presence of Christs body in the Sacrament, but to prove the two natures of the godhead and the manhood in the person of Christ. Let us now discuss the mind of Chrysostom in this matter, whom I bring thus in my book.
And what auayleth it you so often to affirme this vntruth, that the body of Christ is present in the Sacrament, as the soule of man is present in the body, except you be like to them that tell a lye so often, that with often repeating they think men beleue it, and sometyme by often telling they beleue it them selues. But the authors bring not this similitude of the body and soule of man, to proue therby the presence of Christes body in the Sacrament, but to proue the two natures of the godhead and the manhoode in the person of Christ. Lette vs now discusse the minde of Chrisostome in this matter, whome I bring thus in my booke.
1S. John Chrysostom writeth against the pestilent error of Apollinaris, which affirmed that the Godhead and manhood in Christ, were so mixed and confounded together, that they both made but one nature. Against whom S. John Chrysostom writeth thus.
1S. Iohn Chrisostom writeth against the pestilēt errour of Apolinaris, which affirmed that the Godhead and manhod in Christ, were so mixed and confounded togither, that they both made but one nature. Agaynst whome S. Iohn Chrisostome writeth thus.
When thou speakest of God, thou must consider a thing that in nature is single without composition, without conversion that is invisible, immortal, incircumscriptible, incomprehensible with such like. And when thou speakest of man thou meanest a nature that is weak, subject to hunger, thirst, weeping, fear, sweating, and such like passions, which can not be in the divine nature. And when thou speakest of Christ, thou joinest two natures together in one person, who is both passible and impassible: Passible as concerning his flesh, and impassible in his deity.
When thou speakest of God, thou must consider a thing that in nature is single without composition, without conuersion that is inuisible, immortall, incircumscriptible, incomprehensible with such like. And when thou speakest of man thou meanest a nature that is weake, subiect to hunger, thirst, weeping, feare, sweating, and such like passions, which can not be in the diuine nature. And when thou speakest of Christ, thou ioynest two natures togither in one persone, who is both passible and impassible: Passible as concerning his flesh, and impassible in his deite.
And after he concludeth saying: Wherefore Christ is both God and man: God by his impassible nature, and man because he suffered. He himself being one person, one son, one Lord, hath the dominion and power of two natures joined together, which be not of one substance, but each of them hath his properties distinct from the other. And therefore remaineth there two natures, distinct, and not confounded. For as before the consecration of the bread, we call it bread, but when Gods grace hath sanctified it by the priest, it is delivered from the name of bread, and is exalted to the name of the body of the Lord although the nature of the bread remain still in it, and it is not called two bodies, but one body of Gods son: so likewise here, the divine nature resteth in the body of Christ, and these two make one son, and one person.
And after he concludeth saying: Wherfore Christ is both God and man: God by his impassible nature, and man bicause he suffered. He himselfe being one person, one sonne, one Lord, hath the dominion and power of two natures ioyned togither, which be not of one substance, but ech of them hath his properties distinct from the other. And therfore remayneth there two natures, distinct, and not confounded. For as before the consecration of the bread, we call it bread, but when Gods grace hath sanctified it by the priest, it is deliuered from the name of bread, and is exalted to the name of the body of the Lord although the nature of the bread remayne still in it, and it is not called two bodies, but one body of Gods sonne: so likewise here, the diuine nature resteth in the body of Christ, and these two make one sonne, and one person.
These words of S. Chrysostom declare, and that not in obscure terms, but in plain words, that after the consecration, the nature of bread remaineth still, although it have an higher name, and be called the body of Christ: to signify unto the godly eaters of that bread, that they spiritually eat the supernatural bread of the body of Christ, who spiritually is there present, and dwelleth in them, and they in him, although corporally he sitteth in heaven at the right hand of his father.
These wordes of S. Chrisostome declare, and that not in obscure termes, but in playne wordes, that after the consecration, the nature of bread remayneth still, although it haue an higher name, and be called the body of Christ: to signifie vnto the godly eaters of that bread, that they spiritually eate the supernaturall bread of the body of Christ, who spiritually is there present, and dwelleth in them, and they in him, although corporally he sitteth in heauen at the right hand of his father.
S. Chrysostoms words in deed,1 if this author had had them either truly translated unto him, or had taken the pains to have truly translated them himself, which as Peter Martyr saith, be not in print but were found in Florence a copy whereof remaineth in the archdeacon or Archbishop of Canterburies hands, or else if this author had reported the words as they be translated into English out of Peter Martyrs book, wherein some point the translator in English, seemeth to have attained by guess the sense more perfectly than Peter Martyr uttereth it himself, if either of this had been done, the matter should have seemed for so much the more plain. But what is this to make foundation of an argument upon a secret copy of an epistle uttered at one time in divers senses? I shall touch one special point, Peter Martyr saith in Latin, whom the translator in English therein followeth, that the bread is reputed worthy the name of the Lords body. This author Englishing the same place, termeth it (exalted to the name of the Lords body) which words of exalting come nearer to the purpose of this author §2to have the bread but a figure and therewith never the holier of it self. But a figure can never be accounted worthy the name of our Lords body, the very thing of the Sacrament, onles there were the thing in deed, as there is by conversion, as the church truly teacheth. §1Is not hear reader a marvellous diversity in report, and the same so set forth, as thou that canst but read English mayst evidently see it? God ordering it so as such varieties and contradictions should so manifestly appear, where the truth is impugned? §3Again this author maketh Chrysostom to speak strangely in the end of this authority, that the divine nature resteth in the body of Christ, as though the nature of man were the stay to the divine nature, where as in that union the rest is an ineffable mystery, the two natures in Christ to have one substance called and termed an hipostasie, and therefore he that hath translated Peter Martyr into English doth translate it thus: The divine constitution the nature of the body adjoined, these two both together, make one son and one person.
S. Chrisostomes wordes in deede,1 if this author had had them eyther truely translated vnto him, or had taken the paynes to haue truly translated them himselfe, which as Peter Martyr sayth, be not in print but were found in Florence a copy wherof remayneth in the archdeacon or Archbishop of Caunterburies handes, or els if this author had reported the wordes as they be translated into English out of Peter Martyrs booke, wherin some poynt the translator in English, semeth to haue attayned by gesse the sense more perfectly than Peter Martyr vttereth it himselfe, if eyther of this had bene done, the matter should haue seemed for so much the more playne. But what is this to make foundation of an argument vpon a secret copy of an epistle vttered at one tyme in diuers senses? I shall touch one speciall poynt, Peter Martyr sayth in Latin, whome the translator in English therin followeth, that the bread is reputed worthy the name of the Lordes body. This author Englishing the same place, termeth it (exalted to the name of the Lordes body) which wordes of exalting come nearer to the purpose of this author
Thou reader mayst compare the books that be abroad of Peter Martyr in Latin, of Peter Martyr in English and this authors book, with that I write, and so deem §4whither I say true or no. But to the purpose of S. Chrysostoms words (if they be his words) he directeth his argument to show by the mystery, of the Sacrament, that as in it there is no confusion of natures, but each remaineth in his property, so likewise in Christ the nature of his godhead doth not confound the nature of his manhood. If the visible creatures were in the Sacrament by the presence of Christs body there truly present, invisible also as that body is, impalpable also as that body is, incorruptible also as that is, then were the visible nature altered, and as it were confounded, which Chrysostom saith is not so, for the nature of the bread remaineth, by which word of nature, is conveniently signified the property of nature. For proof whereof, to show remaining of the property without alteration, Chrysostom maketh only the resemblance, and before I have showed how nature signifieth the propriety of nature, and may signify the outward part of nature, that is to say, the accidents being substance in his proper signification the inward nature of the thing, of the conversion whereof, is specially understand transubstantiation.
Thou reader mayst compare the bookes that be abroad of Peter Martyr in Latine, of Peter Martyr in English and this authors booke, with that I write, and so deeme §4whither I say true or no. But to the purpose of S. Chrisostomes wordes (if they be his wordes) he directeth his argument to shew by the mistery, of the Sacrament, that as in it there is no confusion of natures, but each remayneth in his property, so likewise in Christ the nature of his godhead doth not confound the nature of his manhode. If the visible creatures were in the Sacrament by the presence of Christes body there truely present, inuisible also as that body is, impalpable also as that body is, incorruptible also as that is, then were the visible nature altred, and as it were confounded, which Chrisostome sayth is not so, for the nature of the bread remayneth, by which word of nature, is conueniently signified the property of nature. For proofe wherof, to shew remayning of the property without alteration, Chrisostome maketh onely the resemblance, and before I haue shewed how nature signifieth the propriety of nature, and may signifie the outward part of nature, that is to say, the accidents being substance in his proper signification the inward nature of the thyng, of the conuersion wherof, is specially vnderstand transubstantiation.
Where you like not my translation of Chrysostoms words, I trow you would have me to learn of you to translate, you use such sincerity and ⟨p. 306⟩plainness in your translation. Let the learned reader be judge. I did translate the words my self out of the copy of Florence, more truly than it seemeth you would have done. But when you see the words of Chrysostom so manifest and clear against your feigned Transubstantiation (for he saith, that the nature of bread remaineth still) you craftily for a shift, fall to the carping of the translation, because you cannot answer to the matter. And yet the words of Chrysostom cited by master Peter Martyr in latin out of Florence copy, and my translation, and the translation of master Peters book in English, do agree fully here in sense, although the words be not all one, which neither is required nor lightly found in any two translators, so that all your wrangling in the diversity of the translations, is but a sleight and common practise of you, when you cannot answer the matter, to seek faults in the translation, where none is.
WHere you like not my translatiō of Chrisostomes wordes, I trow you would haue me to learne of you to trāslate, you vse such sincerity and ⟨p. 306⟩playnnes in your translation. Let the learned reader be iudge. I did translate the wordes my selfe out of the copye of Florence, more truely than it seemeth you would haue done. But whan you see the wordes of Chrisostome so manifest and cleare agaynst your fayned Transubstantiation (for he sayth, that the nature of bread remayneth still) you craftely for a shift, fall to the carping of the translation, bicause you cannot answere to the matter. And yet the wordes of Chrisostome cyted by master Peter Martyr in latine out of Florence copy, and my translation, and the translation of master Peters booke in English, do agree fully here in sense, although the wordes be not all one, which neyther is required nor lightly found in any two translators, so that all your wrangling in the diuersity of the translations, is but a fleight and common practise of you, whan you cannot answer the matter, to seeke faultes in the translation, where none is.
And for the special point, wherein you do note a marvellous diversity §1in report, and would gather thereof no truth to be, where such diversity is, let the reader be judge, what a wonderful diversity it is. The Latin is this, Panis dignus habitus est dominici corporis appellation. The translator of M. Peter Martyrs book saith. The bread is reputed worthy the name of the Lords body. My translation hath, The bread is exalted to the name of the body of the Lord. When a man is made a Lord or Knight, if one say of him, that he is reputed worthy, the name of a Lord or Knight, and an other say, that he is exalted to the name of a Lord or Knight, what difference is between these two sayings? Is not this a wonderful diversity? I pray thee judge indifferently good reader.
And for the speciall poynt, wherin you do note a meruaylous diuersity §1in report, and would gather therof no truth to be, where such diuersity is, let the reader be iudge, what a wonderfull diuersity it is. The Latine is this, Panis dignus habitus est dominici corporis appellatione. The translator of M. Peter Martyrs booke sayth. The bread is reputed worthy the name of the Lordes body. My translation hath, The bread is exalted to the name of the body of the Lord. When a man is made a Lord or Knight, if one say of him, that he is reputed worthy, the name of a Lord or Knight, and an other say, that he is exalted to the name of a Lord or Knight, what difference is betwene these two sayinges? Is not this a wonderfull diuersity? I pray thee iudge indifferently good reader.
1But (say you) a figure can never be counted worthy the name of the §2thing onles the thing were there in deed. Wrangle then with S. John Chrysostom himself, and not with me, who saith that the bread is exalted to the name of the Lords body or is reputed worthy the name of the Lords body after the sanctification, and yet the nature of the bread remaineth still, which can not be as you say, if the body of Christ were there present.
1But (say you) a figure can neuer be counted worthy the name of the §2thing onles the thing were there in deede. Wrangle then with S. Ihon Chrisostome himselfe, and not with me, who sayth that the bread is exalted to ye name of ye Lords body or is reputed worthy ye name of ye Lordes body after the sanctificatiō, and yet the nature of ye bread remayneth still, which can not be as you say, if the body of Christ were there present.
And who heard ever such a doctrine as you here make, that the thing, must be really and corporally present, where the figure is? For so must every man be corporally buried in deed,1 when he is Baptised, which is a figure of our burial. And when we receive the Sacrament of Christs body, then is accomplished the resurrection of our bodies, for that Sacrament you affirm to be the figure thereof. But your doctrine herein is clean contrary to the judgement of Lactantius,2 and other old writers, who teach that figures be in vain, and serve to no purpose, when the things by them signified be present.
And who heard euer such a doctrine as you here make, that the thing, must be really and corporally present, where the figure is? For so must euery man be corporally buried in deede,1 when he is Baptised, which is a figure of our buriall. And when we receaue the Sacrament of Christes body, then is accomplished the resurrectiō of our bodies, for that Sacrament you affirme to be the figure therof. But your doctrine herein is cleane contrary to the iudgement of Lactantius,2 and other olde writers, who teach that figures be in vayne, and serue to no purpose, when the thinges by them signified be present.
And where you think it strange, to say that the divine nature is or §3resteth in the body of Christ, it is nothing else, but to declare your ignorance in Gods word, and ancient authors, in reading of whom, forasmuch as you have not been much exercised, it is no marvel though their speech seem strange unto you. The greek word of Chrysostom is [Greek or Hebrew], which I pray you english, and then we shall see what a strange speech you will make.1 Did you never hear tell at the least, that the word was incarnated? or Verbum caro factum est? And what signifieth this word Incarnate: but God to be made man, and his divine nature to be in flesh? ⟨p. 307⟩Doth not S. John bid us beware,2 that we believe not every spirit: for there be many false prophets, and every spirit saith he, that confesseth not Jesus Christ to have come in flesh, is not of God, but is the spirit of Antichrist? Is this then a strange speech to you, that the divine nature resteth in the flesh, that is to say, in the body of Christ? which if you deny, you know whose spirit yon have. But your trust is altogether in obscure speeches, wherewith you trust so to darken the matter, that no man shall understand it, least that if they understand it, they must needs perceive §4your ignorance and error.
And where you thinke it strange, to say that the diuine nature is or §3resteth in the body of Christ, it is nothing els, but to declare your ignorance in Gods word, and auncient authors, in reading of whome, forasmuch as you haue not bene much exercised, it is no meruayle though their speach seeme strange vnto you. The greeke word of Chrisostome is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which I pray you english, and then we shall see what a strange speach you will make.1 Did you neuer heare tell at the least, that the word was incarnated? or Verbum caro factum est? And what signifieth this word Incarnate: but God to be made man, and his diuine nature to be in flesh?
But when you promise to come to the purpose, (as to say the truth, all that you said before is clearly without purpose) but when you promise (I say) now at length to come to the purpose, your answer is nothing to the purpose of S. Chrysostoms mind: for he made not his resemblance (as you say he did) only to show the remaining of the accidents (which you call the properties) but to show the remaining of the substances, with all the natural properties thereof. That as Christ had here in earth his divinity and humanity, remaining every of them with his natural properties, the substance of his godhead, being a nature single without composition, without conversion invisible, immortal, incircumscriptible, incomprehensible, and such like, (for these be Chrysostoms own words) and the substance of his humanity, being a feeble nature, subject to hunger, thirst, weeping, fear, sweating, and such passions, so is it in the bread and Christs body, that the bread after sanctification or consecration (as you call it) remaineth in his substance that it had before: and likewise doth the body of Christ remain still in heaven in his very true substance, whereof the bread is a Sacrament and figure. For else, if the substance of the bread remained not, how could Chrysostom bring it for a resemblance, to prove that the substance of Christs humanity remaineth with his divinity? Mary this that you say, had been a gay lesson for the Manichees, to say that there appeareth bread by all the accidents thereof, and yet is none in deed, that then by this similitude they might say likewise, that Christ appeared a man by all the accidences and properties of a man, and yet he was none in deed. And to make an end of this author, your vain comment will not serve you, to call the accidents of bread, the nature of bread, except you will allow the same in the Manichees, that the nature of Christs body, is nothing else but the accidences thereof.
But when you promise to come to the purpose, (as to say the truth, all that you sayd before is clearly without purpose) but when you promise (I say) now at length to come to the purpose, your answere is nothing to the purpose of S. Chrisostoms mynd: for he made not his resemblance (as you say he did) onely to shew the remayning of the accidents (which you call the properties) but to shew the remayning of the substances, with all the naturall properties therof. That as Christ had here in earth his diuinity and humanity, remayning euery of them with his naturall properties, the substance of his godhead, being a nature single without composition, without conuersion inuisible, immortall, incircumscriptible, incomprehensible, and such like, (for these be Chrisostomes owne wordes) and the substance of his humanity, being a feble nature, subiect to hunger, thyrst, weeping, feare, sweating, and such passions, so is it in the bread and Christes body, that the bread after sanctification or consecration (as you call it) remayneth in his substance that it had before: and likewise doth the body of Christ remayne still in heauen in his very true substance, wherof the bread is a Sacrament and figure. For els, if the substance of the bread remayned not, how could Chrisostome bring it for a resemblance, to proue that the substance of Christes humanity remayneth with his diuinity? Mary this that you say, had bene a gay lesson for the Manichees, to say that there appeareth bread by all the accidents therof, and yet is none in deede, that then by this similitude they might say likewise, that Christ appeared a man by all the accidences and properties of a man, and yet he was none in deede. And to make an ende of this author, your vayne comment will not serue you, to call the accidents of bread, the nature of bread, except you will alow the same in the Manichees, that the nature of Christes body, is nothing els but the accidences therof.
Now followeth Gelasius of the same matter.
Hereunto accordeth also Gelasius, writing against Eutiches and Nestorius,1 of whom the one said, that Christ was a perfect man, but not God: and the other affirmed clean contrary, that he was very God but not man. But against these two heinous heresies, Gelasius proveth by most manifest scriptures, that Christ is both God and man, and that after his Incarnation remaineth in him as well the nature of his Godhead, as the nature of his manhood, so that he hath in him two natures with their natural properties, and yet is he but one Christ.
Hereunto accordeth also Gelasius, writing agaynst Eutiches and Nestorius,1 of whome the one sayd, that Christ was a perfect man, but not God: and the other affirmed cleane contrary, that he was very God but not man. But agaynst these two heinous heresies, Gelasius proueth by most manifest scriptures, that Christ is both God and man, and that after his Incarnation remayneth in him as well the nature of his Godhead, as the nature of his manhod, so that he hath in him two natures with their naturall properties, and yet is he but one Christ.