pp. 3941,982 passagespart 42 of 50
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And although it be not necessary the examples to be in all parts equal (as you allege of Rusticus Diaconus) yet they must needs be like in that point,§16 wherefore they were taken to be examples, for else they were none examples. And therefore seeing that the bread and wine were of Gelasius brought ⟨p. 319⟩for examples of Christs two natures, for this intent, to prove that the two natures of Christ remain in their substance, it must needs be so in the bread and wine or else they served nothing to that purpose.
And although it be not necessary the exāples to be in all partes equall (as you alledge of Rusticus Diaconus) yet they must needes be like in yt point,§16 wherfore they were takē to be examples, for els they were none examples. And therefore seyng that the bread and wine were of Gelasius brought ⟨p. 319⟩for examples of Christes two natures, for this intēt, to proue that the two natures of Christ remaine in their substaunce, it must needes be so in the bread and wine or els they serued nothyng to that purpose.
And the transition that Gelasius meant of, is in the persons that receive the Sacraments, which be transformed into the divine nature, (as Gelasius saith) by efficacy & virtue represented by the Sacraments, but the transition is not in the bread and wine (as you and your Thomas imagine of transition) which remain in the Sacrament without substantial mutation, conversion, transition, transelementatiō, or transubstantiation. For if in the mystery of the Sacrament were transition, mutation, conversion, and transelementation of the substance of bread and wine, how could that mystery be an example of the principal mystery of Christs incarnation, to prove thereby that there is no transition, mutation, conversion, or transelementation, of the two substances of Christ in his incarnation? Doth not the remaining of substance in the Sacrament, prove the remaining of substance in the Incarnation? For how can the not remaining of substance, be an example, image, and similitude to prove the remaining of the substance? But here appeareth what it is to wrestle against the truth, & to defend an evil cause, & what absurdities wit & eloquence be driven unto, when they strive against God and his word.
And the transition that Gelasius ment of, is in the persons that receaue the Sacramentes, whiche be transformed into the diuine nature, (as Gelasius sayth) by efficacie & vertue represented by the Sacraments, but the transition is not in the bread and wyne (as you and your Thomas imagine of transition) whiche remaine in the Sacrament without substāciall mutatiō, conuersiō, transitiō, transelementatiō, or trāsubstantiatiō. For if in the mystery of the Sacrament were transition, mutation, conuersion, and transelementation of the substaunce of bread and wine, how could that mystery be an example of the principall mystery of Christes incarnation, to proue thereby that there is no transition, mutation, conuersion, or transelementation, of the two substaunces of Christ in his incarnation? Doth not the remainyng of substaunce in the Sacrament, proue the remainyng of substaunce in the Incarnation? For how can the not remainyng of substaunce, be an example, image, and similitude to proue the remainyng of the substaunce? But here appeareth what it is to wrastle agaynst the truth, & to defend an euell cause, & what absurdities wit & eloquence be driuen vnto, when they striue agaynst God and his word.
And where you think your self over sore pressed with this argument and similitude of bread and wine to the two natures in Christ, I must needs press the argument and words so far, as pertaineth to the remaining of the natures and substance, for to that end was the image and similitude brought in by Gelasius. And then by argument from the cause, wherefore the resemblance was made, if the substance and nature of the bread and wine remain not in the Sacrament, it followeth that the two natures and substance of Christ remain not in his person, which is no sound teaching, wherefore to make the argument agree with the catholic teaching, we must needs say, that as in the person of Christ remain the two natures and substance, of his godhead and manhood, so in the sacrament remain the natures and substances of bread and wine, that the comparisons may agree with themselves and with the catholic faith. Like as it is also in the other example of the body and soul, which two natures must needs remain in the person of man, without transubstantiation of any nature if they shall resemble the remaining of the two natures in Christ. And how do the two natures in the Sacrament remain in their property (I pray you declare) if the nature of bread and wine be gone? And how doth not the divine nature swallow up the earthly nature, if the nature of bread and wine be so turned into the divine nature, that it remaineth not, but is clearly extinct.
And where you think your selfe ouer sore pressed with this argument and similitude of bread and wine to the two natures in Christ, I must needes presse the argument and wordes so farre, as pertayneth to the remayning of the natures and substance, for to that end was the image and similitude brought in by Gelasius. And then by argument from the cause, wherfore the resemblance was made, if the substance and nature of the bread and wine remayne not in the Sacrament, it followeth that the two natures and substance of Christ remayne not in his person, which is no sound teaching, wherfore to make the argument agree with the catholike teaching, we must needes say, that as in the person of Christ remayne the two natures and substance, of his godhead and manhod, so in the sacrament remayne the natures and substances of bread and wine, that the comparisons may agree with themselues and with the catholike fayth. Like as it is also in the other example of the body and soule, which two natures must needes remayne in the person of man, without transubstantiation of any nature if they shall resemble the remayning of the two natures in Christ. And how do the two natures in the Sacrament remayne in their property (I pray you declare) if the nature of bread and wine be gon? And how doth not the diuine nature swallow vp the earthly nature, if the nature of bread and wine be so turned into the diuine nature, that it remayneth not, but is clearly extinct.
If you may purge your self in handling of this author by confession of your ignorance, you must obtain it by great favour of them that will so accept it. For else in this one author is affirmed by you many great errors, with wilful depravation of the authors mind, to give weapons to them that be enemies to the truth, and to the subversion of the catholic faith. And no less have you done in Theodoretus next following, because you would handle them both indifferently, and do no more Injury to the one than to the other. And as for Cyprian, Ambrose, Theophilact ⟨p. 320⟩and Emissene, I have answered to them before. It is time now to hear Theodoret.
If you may purge your selfe in handling of this author by confession of your ignorance, you must obtayne it by great fauor of them that will so accept it. For els in this one author is affirmed by you many great errors, with wilfull deprauation of the authors mynd, to geue weapons to them that be enemies to the truth, and to the subuersion of the catholike fayth. And no les haue you done in Theodoretus next folowing, bicause you would handle them both indifferently, and do no more Iniury to the one than to the other. And as for Ciprian, Ambrose, Theophilact ⟨p. 320⟩and Emissene, I haue answered to them before. It is tyme now to heare Theodoret.
1Theodoretus also affirmeth the same, both in his first and in his second dialogue. In the first he saith thus: He that called his natural body, wheat and bread, and also called himself a vine, the self same called bread and wine his body and blood, and yet changed not their natures.
1Theodoretus also affirmeth the same, both in his first and in his second dialoge. In the first he sayth thus: He that called his naturall body, wheate and bread, and also called himselfe a vine, the selfe same called bread and wine his body and bloud, and yet changed not their natures.
And in his second dialogue he saith more plainly. For (saith he) as the bread and wine after the consecration lose not their proper nature, but keep their former substance, form, and figure, which they had before, even so the body of Christ, after his ascension, was changed into the godly substance.
And in his second dialogue he sayth more playnly. For (sayth he) as the bread and wine after the consecration lose not their proper nature, but keepe their former substance, forme, and figure, which they had before, euen so the body of Christ, after his ascention, was changed into the godly substance.
Now let the Papists choose, which of these two they will grant (for one of them they must needs grant) either that the nature and substance of bread and wine remain still in the Sacrament after the consecration, (and than must they recant their doctrine of Transubstantiation) or else that they be of the error of Nestorius, and other, which did say, that the nature of the Godhead, or of the manhood remained not in Christ after his incarnation or ascension. For all these old authors agree, that it is in the one, as it is in the other.
Now let the Papistes choose, which of these two they will graunt (for one of them they must needes graunt) eyther that the nature and substance of bread and wine remayne still in the Sacrament after the consecration, (and than must they recant their doctrine of Transubstantiation) or els that they be of the errour of Nestorius, and other, which did say, that the nature of the Godhead, or of the manhod remayned not in Christ after his incarnation or ascension. For all these olde authors agree, that it is in the one, as it is in the other.
1And if that I have here said be well considered, there may appear the great ignorance of this author in the alleging of Theodoret, the applying of him and the speaking of Nestorius in the end. For as the Eutychians reasoning (as S. Augustin saith) to confound the Nestorians, fell into an absurdity in the confusion of their two natures in Christ: so Theodoretus reasoning against the Eutychians, fell in a vehement suspicion to be a Nestorian, like as S. Augustine reasoning against the Manichees for defence of free will, seemed to speak that the Pelagians would allow, and reasoning against Pelagians, seemed to say that the Manichees would allow, such a danger it is to reduce extremities to the mean, wherein S. Augustine was better purged then Theodoret was, although Theodoret was reconciled. But for example of that I have said,§1 this argument of Theodoretus against the Eutychians to avoid confusion of natures in Christ showeth how in the Sacrament where the truth of the mystery of the two natures in Christ may be as it were in similitude learned, the presence of the body of Christ there in the Sacrament doth not alter the nature, that is to say, the property of the visible creatures. This saying was that the Nestorians would draw for there purpose to prove distinct persons, against whom Cyril travailed to show that in the Sacrament the flesh of Christ that was given to be eaten was given, not as the flesh of a common man, but as the flesh of God, whereby appeared the unity of the godhead to the manhood in Christ in one person, and yet no confusion, as Theodoretus doth by his argument declare. But whether the Printers negligence, or this authors §2oversight hath confounded, or confused this matter in the uttering of it, I can not tell. For the author of this book concludeth solemnly thus by induction of the premises, that even so the body of Christ was after the ascension changed into the godly substance. I ween the Printer left out a (not) and should have said not changed, into the godly substance, for so the sense should be as Peter Martyr reporteth Theodorete. And yet the triumph this author maketh against them, he calleth for his pleasure Papists, with his forked dilemma maketh me doubt, whether he wist what he said, or no:
1And if that I haue here sayd be well considered, there may appeare the great ignoraunce of this author in the alleadging of Theodoret, the applying of him and the speaking of Nestorius in the end. For as the Eutichians reasoning (as S. Augustin sayth) to confound the Nestorians, fell into an absurdity in the confusion of their two natures in Christ: so Theodoretus reasoning agaynst the Eutichians, fell in a vehement suspition to be a Nestorian, like as S. Augustine reasoning agaynst the Maniches for defence of free will, seemed to speake that the Pelagians would alow, and reasoning agaynst Pelagians, seemed to say that the Manichees would alow, such a daunger it is to reduce extremities to the meane, wherein S. Augustine was better purged then Theodoret was, although Theodoret was recōciled. But for example of yt I haue sayd,
because he bringeth in Nestorius so out of purpose, saying the Papists must either grant the substance of bread and wine to remain, or else to be of Nestorius heresy, that the nature of Godhead remained not.
bicause he bringeth in Nestorius so out of purpose, saying the Papistes must eyther graunt the substance of bread and wine to remayne, or els to be of Nestorius heresie, that the nature of Godhed remayned not.
This author of the book for the name of Nestorius, should have put Eutiches, and then said for conclusion. The nature of manhood remained not in Christ. And although ⟨p. 321⟩in Theodoret the substance of bread is spoken of to remain, yet because he doth after §3expound himself to speak of that is seen and felt, he seemeth to speak of Substance after the common capacity, and not as it is truly in learning understanded, an inward invisible and not palpable nature, but only perceived by understanding, so as this outward nature that Theodorete speaketh of, may according to his words truly §4remain, notwithstanding Transubstantiation. This author declareth plainly his ignorance, not to perceive whither the argument of Theodoret and Gelasius tendeth, which is properly against the Eutychians rather then the Nestorians. For and no propriety of bread remain, it proveth not the Godhead in Christ not to remain, but the humanity only to be as it were swallowed up of the divinity, which the Eutychians intended and specially after Christs resurrection, against whom the argument by Theodorete is specially brought, how so ever this author confoundeth the Nestorians and Eutiches names and taketh one for an other, which in so high a matter is no small fault, and yet no great fault among so many other huger and greater as be in this book committed.
This author of the booke for the name of Nestorius, should haue put Eutiches, and then sayd for conclusion. The nature of manhod remayned not in Christ. And although ⟨p. 321⟩in Theodoret the substance of bread is spoken of to remayne, yet bicause he doth after §3expound himselfe to speake of that is seene and felt, he seemeth to speake of Substance after the common capacity, and not as it is truely in learning vnderstanded, an inward inuisible and not palpable nature, but onely perceaued by vnderstanding, so as this outward nature that Theodorete speaketh of, may according to his wordes truly §4remayne, notwithstanding Transubstantiation. This author declareth playnly his ignoraunce, not to perceaue whither the argument of Theodoret and Gelasius tendeth, which is properly agaynst the Eutichians rather then the Nestorians. For and no propriety of bread remayne, it proueth not the Godhead in Christ not to remayne, but the humanity onely to be as it were swallowed vp of the diuinity, which the Eutichians entended and specially after Christes resurrection, agaynst whome the argumēt by Theodorete is specially brought, how so euer this author confoundeth the Nestorians and Eutiches names and taketh one for an other, which in so high a matter is no small fault, and yet no great fault among so many other houger and greater as be in this booke committed.
IF that which you have said to Gelasius be well considered and conferred with this in Theodorete, it seemeth by your process in both, that you know not what confusion of natures is.1 And then your ignorance therein: must needs declare that you be utterly ignorant of all their whole discourse, which tendeth only to prove that the two natures in Christ, his divinity and his humanity be not confounded. And for ignorance of confusion, you confound all together. Gelasius and Theodorete prove, that the two natures in Christ be not confounded, because they remain §2both in their own substances and properties, so that the remaining declareth no confusion, which should be confounded if they remained not. If a drop of milk be put into a pot of wine, by and by it looseth the first nature and substance, and is confounded with the nature and substance of wine. And if wine and milk be put together in equal quantity, then both be confounded, because neither remaineth, neither perfect wine with his substance & natural proprieties, nor perfect milk, with the substance & proprieties of milk, but a confusion, an humble jumble or hotch potch, a posset or syllabub is made of them both together, like as in mans body, the four elements be confounded, to the constitution of the same, not one of the elements remaining in his proper substance, form & pure natural qualities.
IF that which you haue sayd to Gelasius be well considered and conferred with this in Theodorete, it seemeth by your processe in both, that you know not what confusion of natures is.1 And then your ignorance therin: must needes declare that you be vtterly ignorant of all their whole discours, which tendeth onely to proue that the two natures in Christ, his diuinity and his humanity be not confounded. And for ignorance of confusion, you confounde all togither. Gelasius and Theodorete proue, that the two natures in Christ be not confounded, bicause they remayne §2both in their owne substances and properties, so that the remayning declareth no confusion, which should be confounded if they remayned not. If a droppe of milke be put into a pot of wine, by and by it looseth the first nature and substance, and is confounded with the nature and substance of wine. And if wine and milke be put togither in equale quantity, then both be confounded, bicause neyther remayneth, neyther perfect wine with his substāce & natural proprieties, nor perfect milke, with the substance & proprieties of milke, but a cōfusion, an humble iomble or hotch potch, a posset or sillabub is made of thē both togither, like as in mans body, the foure elemēts be cōfoūded, to ye cōstitutiō of ye same, not one of ye elemēts remayning in his proper substāce, forme & pure naturall qualities.
So that if one nature remain not, the same is confounded. And if there be more natures that lose their substance, they be all confounded, except there be an utter consumption or annihilation of the thing that looseth his substance, and therefore the argument which all the old ecclesiastical authors use, to save the confusion of the two natures in Christ, is to prove, that they both remain. And if we may learn that, by the similitude of the sacrament (as Gelasius and Theodoret teach, and you here confess the same) then must needs the substance of bread and wine remain, or else is there none example nor similitude of the remaining of two natures in Christ, but of their confusion, as by your feigned doctrine the substance of bread is confounded with the body of Christ, neither being annihilate, nor remaining, but transubstantiated, confounded and converted into the substance of Christs body. And thus with your well understanding of the matter, you confound all together, where as I with my ignorance, not blaspheming that holy union and mystery of Christs ⟨p. 322⟩incarnation, do save all the natures whole, without mixtion, confusion or Transubstantiation, either of the divine & humane nature in Christ or of the soul and body in man, or of the bread & wine in the Sacrament, but all the substance & natures be saved & remain clearly with their natural properties & conditions, that the proportion in that point may be like, and one to be the true Image and similitude of the other. But surely more gross ignorance or wilful impiety then you have showed in this matter, hath not lightly been seen or red of.
So that if one nature remayne not, the same is confounded. And if there be more natures that lose their substance, they be all confounded, except there be an vtter consumption or adnihilation of the thing that looseth his substance, and therfore the argument which all the old ecclesiasticall authors vse, to saue the confusion of the two natures in Christ, is to proue, that they both remayne. And if we may learne that, by the similitude of the sacrament (as Gelasius and Theodoret teach, and you here confesse the same) then must needes the substance of bread and wine remayne, or els is there none example nor similitude of the remayning of two natures in Christ, but of their confusion, as by youre fayned doctrine the substance of bread is confounded with the body of Christ, neyther being adnihilate, nor remayning, but transubstantiated, confounded and conuerted into the substance of Christes body. And thus with your well vnderstanding of the matter, you confound all togither, where as I with my ignorance, not blaspheming that holy vnion and mistery of Christes
And where you say, that I by oversight, or the Printer by negligence, have left out a (not,1) if I should have put in that (not) of mine own §2head contrary to the original in Greek, and to all the translators in Latin, and the translation of Master Peter Martyr also, I should have been as far overseen as you be, which as it seemeth of purpose confound and corrupt, you care not whether any Authors words, or their meaning.
And where you say, that I by ouersight, or the Printer by negligence, haue left out a (not,1) if I should haue put in that (not) of myne owne §2head contrarye to the originall in Greeke, and to all the translatours in Latine, and the translation of Master Peter Martyr also, I should haue bene as farre ouerseene as you bee, whiche as it seemeth of purpose confound and corrupt, you care not whether any Authors wordes, or their meanyng.
And as for my forked dilemma, you shall never be able to answer there to, but the more you travail therein, the more you shall entangle your self. For either you must grant (as unwilling as you be) that the nature and substance of bread and wine remain after the consecration, or else that the nature and substance of Christs humanity and divinity remain not after his incarnation, wherein erred not only Eutiches (whom you say I should have put for Nestorius) but also Martion, Ebion, Ualentinus, Nestorius, and other as in my book I have declared.
And as for my forked dilemma, you shall neuer be able to aunswer ther to, but the more you trauayle therein, the more you shall entangle your selfe. For eyther you must graunt (as vnwilling as you be) that the nature and substance of bread and wine remayne after the consecration, or els that the nature and substance of Christes humanity and diuinitie remayne not after his incarnation, wherein erred not onely Eutiches (whome you say I should haue put for Nestorius) but also Martion, Ebion, Ualentinus, Nestorius, and other as in my booke I haue declared.
And one thing is principally to be noted in your answer to Theodoret §3how you can sophisticate and falsify all mens sayings, be they never so plain. For where between me and the Papists the matter here in contention is this. Whether the bread and wine remain in their proper nature and substance or no. I saying that they remain, and the Papists saying that they remain not, the Issue being in this point whether they remain, or remain not, I bring for me Chrysostom (who saith, the nature of bread remaineth:) I bring Gelasius, (who saith, that there ceaseth not the substance or nature of bread and wine) I bring this Theodoret, whose words be these: The bread and wine after consecration lose not their proper nature, but keep their former substances, form and figure. Now how can any man devise to speak the truth in more plain words than these be? For they say the very same words that I say. And yet because the truth is not liked, here must be devised a crafty Lawyers gloss, of them that never sought other, but to calumniate the truth, and must be said (against all learning, reason and speech) that substance is taken for the visible and palpable qualities or accidents: well yet then you confess that those old ancient Authors agree with me in words, and say as I do, that the bread and wine be not transubstantiated, but remain in their former substance: And then the issue plainly passeth with me by the testimony of these three witnesses, until such time as you can prove that these authors spake one thing, and meant an other, and that qualities and accidents be substances. And if you understood whereunto §4the argument of Theodoret and Gelasius tendeth, you would not say that they spake against the Eutiches, any more then they do against the Nestorians. For if the bread and wine remain not (as you say) but be ⟨p. 323⟩swallowed up of the body and blood of Christ, then likewise in the principal mystery, either the deity must be swallowed up of the humanity, or the humanity of the deity. The contrary whereof is not only against the Eutychians, but also against the Nestorians, Marcionists, and all other that denied any of his two natures to remain perfectly in Christ.
And one thing is principally to be noted in your answere to Theodoret §3how you can sophisticate and falsefy all mens sayinges, be they neuer so playne. For where betweene me and the Papistes the matter here in contention is this. Whether the bread and wine remayne in their proper nature and substauce or no. I saying that they remayne, and the Papistes saying that they remayne not, the Issue being in this poynt whether they remayne, or remayne not, I bring for me Chrisostome (who sayth, the nature of bread remayneth:) I bring Gelasius, (who sayth, that there ceaseth not the substance or nature of bread and wine) I bring this Theodoret, whose wordes be these: The bread and wine after consecration lose not their proper nature, but keepe their former substances, forme and figure. Now how can any man deuise to speake the truth in more playne wordes than these be? For they say the very same wordes that I say. And yet bicause the truth is not liked, here must be deuised a crafty Lawyers glose, of them that neuer sought other, but to calumniate the truth, and must be sayd (agaynst all learning, reason and speach) that substance is taken for the visible and palpable qualities or accidents: well yet then you confesse that those olde auncient Authors agree with me in wordes, and say as I do, that the bread and wine be not transubstantiated, but remayne in their former substance: And then the issue playnly passeth with me by the testimony of these three witnesses, vntill such tyme as you can proue that these authors spake one thing, and ment an other, and that qualities and accidents be substances. And if you vnderstoode whereunto
And where as you with all the route of the Papists, both privately and openly report me to be unlearned and ignorant, because you would thereby impair my credit in this weighty matter of our faith, my knowledge is not any whit the less, because the Papists say it is nothing, nor yours any deal the more, because the Papists do say, that you only be learned, whom for any thing that ever I could perceive in you, I have found more full of words and talk then of learning. And yet the note of ignorance, I nothing pass of, if thereby the truth and Gods glory should not be hindered.
And where as you with all the route of the Papistes, both priuately and openly report me to be vnlearned and ignorant, bycause you would therby impayre my credite in this weighty matter of our fayth, my knowledge is not any whit the lesse, bicause the Papistes say it is nothing, nor yours any deale the more, bicause the Papistes do say, that you onely be learned, whome for any thing that euer I could perceaue in you, I haue found more full of wordes and talke then of learning. And yet the note of ignorance, I nothing passe of, if therby the truth and Gods glory should not be hindered.
Now after the reproof of your doctrine of Transubstantiation, by all the old writers of Christs church, I write in my book after this manner.
Now after the reproofe of your doctrine of Transubstantiation, by all the old writers of Christes church, I write in my booke after this māner.
Now forasmuch as it is proved sufficiently (as well by the holy Scripture,1 as by natural operation, by natural reason, by all our senses, and by the most old and best learned authors, and holy martyrs of Christs church,) that the substance of bread and wine do remain, and be received of faithful people in the blessed Sacrament, or supper of the Lord: It is a thing worthy to be considered and well weighed, what moved the School authors of late years to defend the contrary opinion, not only so far from all experience of our senses, and so far from all reason, but also clean contrary to the old church of Christ, and to God's most holy word. Surely nothing moved them thereto so much, as did the vain faith which they had in the church and sea of Rome.
Now forasmuch as it is proued sufficiently (as well by the holy Scripture,1 as by naturall operation, by naturall reason, by all our sences, and by the most olde and best learned authors, and holy martirs of Christes church,) that the substance of bread and wine do remayne, and be receaued of faythfull people in the blessed Sacrament, or supper of the Lord: It is a thing worthy to be considered and well wayed, what moued the Schoole authors of late yeares to defend the contrary opinion, not onely so far from all experience of our sences, and so farre from all reason, but also cleane contrary to the olde church of Christ, and to Godes most holy word. Surely nothing moued them therto so much, as did the vayne fayth which they had in the church and sea of Rome.
For Joannes Scotus,1 otherwise called Duns, (the subtlest of all the school authors) entreating of this matter of Transubstantiation, showeth plainly the cause thereof. For (saith he) the words of the Scripture might be expounded more easily, and more plainly without Transubstantiation, but the church did choose this sense, (which is more hard, being moved thereto (as it seemeth) chiefly, because that of the Sacraments men ought to hold, as the holy church of Rome holdeth: But it holdeth, that bread is transubstantiate or turned into the body, and wine into the blood, as it is showed De summa Trinitate & fide Catholicae. Firmiter credimus.
For Ioannes Scotus,1 otherwise called Duns, (the subtillest of all the schoole authors) intreating of this matter of Transubstantiation, sheweth playnly the cause therof. For (sayth he) the wordes of the Scripture might be expounded more easely, and more playnly without Transubstantiation, but the church did choose this sense, (which is more hard, being moued therto (as it seemeth) chiefly, bicause that of the Sacramentes men ought to hold, as the holy churh of Rome holdeth: But it holdeth, that bread is transubstantiate or turned into the body, and wine into the bloud, as it is shewed De summa Trinitate & fide Catholicae. Firmiter credimus.
And Gabriel also (who of all other wrote most largely upon the Canon of the Mass) saith thus.1 It is to be noted, that although it be taught in the scripture, that the body of Christ is truly contained and received of christen people under the kinds of bread & wine, yet how the body of Christ is there, whether by conversion of any thing into it, or without conversion the body is there with the bread, both the substance and accidence of bread remaining there still, it is not found expressed in the Bible. Yet forasmuch as of the sacraments men must hold as the holy church of Rome holdeth, as it is written De haereticis, Ad abolendum. And that church holdeth and hath determined, that the bread is transubstantiated into the body of Christ, and the wine into his blood, Therefore is this opinion received of all them that be catholic, that the substance of bread remaineth not, but really and truly is turned, transubstantiated and changed ⟨p. 324⟩into the substance of the body of Christ.
And Gabriell also (who of all other wrote most largely vpon the Canon of the Masse) sayth thus.1 It is to be noted, that although it be taught in the scripture, that the body of Christ is truely conteined and receaued of christen people vnder the kindes of bread & wine, yet how the body of Christ is there, whether by conuersion of any thing into it, or without conuersion the body is there with the bread, both the substance and accidence of bread remayning there still, it is not found expressed in the Bible. Yet forasmuch as of the sacraments men must hold as the holy church of Rome holdeth, as it is written De haereticis, Ad abolendum. And that church holdeth and hath determined, that the bread is trāsubstantiated into the body of Christ, and the wine into his bloud, Therfore is this opinion receaued of all them that be catholike, that the substance of bread remayneth not, but really and truely is tourned, transubstantiated and changed ⟨p. 324⟩into the substance of the body of Christ.
1Thus you have heard the cause, wherefore this opinion of Transubstantiation at this present is holden and defended among christen people, that is to say, because the church of Rome hath so determined, although the contrary, by the Papists own confession, appear to be more easy, more true, and more according to the Scripture.
1Thus you haue heard the cause, wherfore this opinion of Transubstantiation at this present is holden and defended among christen people, that is to say, bicause the church of Rome hath so determined, although the contrary, by the Papistes owne confession, appeare to be more easy, more true, and more according to the Scripture.
But because our english papists (who speak more grossly herein then the Pope himself, affirming that the natural body of Christ is naturally in the §5bread and wine) can not, nor dare not ground their faith, concerning transubstantiation, upon the church of Rome: which although in name it be called most holy, yet in deed it is the most stinking dunghill of all wickedness that is under heaven, and the very synagogue of the devil, which whosoever followeth, can not but stumble, and fall into a pit full of errors. Because I say the English papists dare not now stablish their faith upon that foundation of Rome, therefore they seek Fig leaves, that is to say, vain reasons, gathered of their own brains and authorities, wrested from the intent and mind of the authors, wherewith to cover and hide their shameful errors. Wherefore I thought it good somewhat to travail herein, to take away those fig leaves, that their shameful errors may plainly to every man appear.
But bicause our english papistes (who speake more grossely herein then the Pope himselfe, affirming that the naturall body of Christ is naturally in the §5bread and wine) can not, nor dare not ground their fayth, concerning transubstantiation, vpon the church of Rome: which although in name it be called most holy, yet in deede it is the most stinking dongehill of all wickednes that is vnder heauen, and the very sinagoge of the deuill, which whosoeuer followeth, can not but stumble, and fall into a pit ful of erroures. Bicause I say the English papistes dare not now stablish their fayth vpon that foundation of Rome, therfore they seeke Figge leaues, that is to say, vayne reasons, gathered of their owne braynes and authorities, wrested from the intent and minde of the authors, wherwith to couer and hide their shamefull errours. Wherfore I thought it good somwhat to trauayle herein, to take away those figge leaues, that their shamefull errours may playnly to euery man appeare.
1The greatest reason and of most importance, and of such strength (as they think) or at the least as they pretend, that all the world can not answer thereto, is this: Our saviour Christ, taking the bread, brake it, and gave it to his disciples, saying: This is my body. Now (say they) as soon as Christ had spoken these words, the bread was straight way altered and changed, and the substance §6thereof was converted into the substance of his precious body.
1The greatest reason and of most importance, and of such strength (as they thinke) or at the least as they pretend, that all the world can not answere therto, is this: Our sauiour Christ, taking the bread, brake it, and gaue it to his disciples, saying: This is my body. Now (say they) as sone as Christ had spoken these wordes, the bread was straight way altered and changed, and the substāce §6therof was conuerted into the substance of his precious body.
But what christen ears can patiently hear this doctrine, that Christ is every day made a new, and made of an other substance, than he was made of in his mothers womb? For where as at his incarnation he was made of the nature and substance of his blessed mother, now (by these papists opinion) he is made every day of the nature and substance of bread and wine, which (as they say) be turned into the substance, of his body and blood. O what a marvellous Metamorphosis and abominable heresy is this? to say, that Christ is daily made a new, and of a new matter? whereof it followeth necessarily, that they make us every day a new Christ, and not the same that was borne of the virgin Mary, nor that was crucified upon the cross, and that it was not the same Christ that was eaten in the supper, which was borne and crucified, as it shall be plainly proved by these arguments following.
But what christen eares canne paciently heare this doctrine, that Christ is euery day made a new, and made of an other substance, than he was made of in his mothers wombe? For where as at his incarnation he was made of the nature and substance of his blessed mother, now (by these papistes opinion) he is made euery day of the nature and substance of bread and wine, which (as they say) be turned into the substance, of his body and bloud. O what a meruaylous Metamorphosis and abhominable heresie is this? to say, that Christ is dayly made a new, and of a new matter? wherof it followeth necessarely, that they make vs euery day a new Christ, and not the same that was borne of the virgine Mary, nor that was crucified vpon the crosse, and that it was not the same Christ that was eaten in the supper, which was borne and crucified, as it shall be playnly proued by these arguments folowing.
First thus: If Christs body that was crucified was not made of bread, but the body that was eaten in the supper was made of bread, (as the papists say) than Christs body that was eaten in the supper was not the same that was crucified. For if they were all one body, than it must needs follow, that either Christs body that was eaten was not made of bread, or else that his body that was crucified was made of bread.
First thus: If Christes body that was crucified was not made of bread, but the body that was eaten in the supper was made of bread, (as the papistes say) than Christes body that was eaten in the supper was not the same that was crucified. For if they were all one body, than it must needes follow, that either Christes body that was eaten was not made of bread, or els that his body that was crucified was made of bread.
And in like manner it followeth: If the body of Christ in the Sacrament, be made of the substance of bread and wine, and the same body was conceived in the Virgins womb, than the body of Christ in the Virgins womb was made of bread and wine.
And in like manner it followeth: If the body of Christ in the Sacrament, be made of the substance of bread and wine, and the same body was conceaued in the Virgines wombe, than the body of Christ in the Virgines wombe was made of bread and wine.
Or else turn the argument thus: The body of Christ in the Virgins womb was not made of bread and wine, but this body of Christ in the Sacrament ⟨p. 325⟩is made of bread and wine, than this body of Christ is not the same that was conceived in the virgins womb.
Or els turne the argument thus: The body of Christ in the Virgines wombe was not made of bread and wine, but this body of Christ in the Sacrament ⟨p. 325⟩is made of bread and wine, than this body of Christ is not the same that was conceaued in the virgines wombe.
An other argument. Christ that was borne in the Virgins womb, as concerning his body, was made of none other substance, but of the substance of his blessed mother, but Christ in the Sacrament is made of an other substance, and so it followeth, that he is an other Christ.
An other argument. Christ that was borne in the Virgines wombe, as concerning his body, was made of none other substance, but of the substance of his blessed mother, but Christ in the Sacrament is made of an other substance, and so it followeth, that he is an other Christ.
And so the Antichrist of Rome, the chief author of all idolatry, would bring faithful christen people from the true worshipping of Christ that was made and borne of the blessed virgin Mary, through the operation of the holy ghost, and suffered for us upon the cross, to worship an other Christ made of bread and wine through the consecration of Popish priests, which make themselves the makers of God. For (say they) the priest by the words of consecration maketh that thing which is eaten and drunken in the Lords supper, and that (say they) is Christ himself both God and man, and so they take upon them to make both God and man.
And so the Antichrist of Rome, the chiefe author of all idolatrie, would bring faythfull christen people from the true worshipping of Christ that was made and borne of the blessed virgine Mary, through the operation of the holy ghost, and suffered for vs vpon the crosse, to worship an other Christ made of bread and wine through the consecration of Popish priestes, which make themselues the makers of God. For (say they) the priest by the wordes of consecration maketh that thing which is eaten and dronken in the Lordes supper, and that (say they) is Christ himselfe both God and man, and so they take vpon them to make both God and man.
But let all true worshippers worship one God, one Christ, once corporally made, of one only corporal substance, that is to say, of the blessed virgin Mary, that once dyed, and rose once again, once ascended into heaven, and there sitteth and shall sit at the right hand of his father evermore, although spiritually he be every day amongst us, and who so ever come together in his name, he is in the middest among them. And he is the spiritual pasture and food of our souls, as meat and drink is of our bodies, which he signifieth unto us by the institution of his most holy supper in the bread and wine, declaring that as the bread and wine corporally comfort and feed our bodies, so doth he with his flesh and blood spiritually comfort and feed our souls.
But let all true worshipers worship one God, one Christ, once corporally made, of one onely corporall substance, that is to say, of the blessed virgin Mary, that once dyed, and rose once agayne, once assended into heauen, and there sitteth and shall sit at the right hand of his father euermore, although spiritually he be euery day amongst vs, and who so euer come togither in his name, he is in the middest among them. And he is the spirituall pasture and food of our soules, as meat and drincke is of our bodyes, which he signifieth vnto vs by the institution of his most holy supper in the bread and wine, declaring that as the bread and wine corporally comfort and feed our bodyes, so doth he with his flesh and bloud spiritually comfort and feed our soules.
And now may be easily answered the Papists argument whereof they do so much boast,1 For brag they never so much of their conversion of bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ, yet that conversion is spiritual, and putteth not away the corporal presence of the material bread and wine. But for as much as the same is a most holy sacrament of our spiritual nourishment (which we have by the body and blood of our saviour Christ) there must needs remain the sensible element, that is to say, bread and wine, without the which there can be no sacrament.
And now may be easely answered the Papistes argument wherof they do so much boast,1 For bragge they neuer so much of their conuersion of bread and wine into the body and bloud of Christ, yet that conuersion is spirituall, and putteth not away the corporall presence of the materiall bread and wine. But for as much as the same is a most holy sacrament of our spirituall norishment (which we haue by the body and bloud of our sauiour Christ) there must needes remayne the sensible element, that is to say, bread and wine, without the which there can be no sacrament.
As in our spiritual regeneration there can be no sacrament of baptism, if there be no water. For as baptism is no perfect sacrament of spiritual regeneration, without there be aswell the element of water, as the holy ghost, spiritually regenerating the person that is baptised (which is signified by the said water) even so the supper of the Lord can be no perfect Sacrament of spiritual food, except there be as well bread and wine, as the body and blood of our saviour Christ, spiritually feeding us, which by the said bread and wine is signified.
As in our spirituall regeneration there can be no sacrament of baptisme, if there be no water. For as baptisme is no perfect sacrament of spirituall regeneration, without there be aswell the element of water, as the holy ghost, spiritually regenerating the person that is baptised (which is signified by the sayd water) euen so the supper of the Lord can be no perfect Sacrament of spirituall food, except there be as well bread and wine, as the body and bloud of our sauiour Christ, spiritually feeding vs, which by the sayd bread and wine is signified.
And how so ever the body and blood of our Saviour Christ be there present, they may as well be present there with the substance of bread and wine, as with the accidents of the same, as the school authors, do confess them selves, and it shall be well proved if the adversaries will deny it. Thus you see the strongest argument of the Papists answered unto, and the chief foundation whereupon they build their error of Transubstantiation, utterly subverted and overthrown.
And how so euer the body and bloud of our Sauiour Christ be there present, they may as well be present there with the substance of bread and wine, as with the accidents of the same, as the scholeauthors, do confesse them selues, and it shall be well proued if the aduersaries will deny it. Thus you see the strongest argument of the Papistes answered vnto, and the chiefe foundation wherupon they buyld their errour of Transubstantiation, vtterly subuerted and ouerthrowen.
Wherein this author not seeing how little he hath done, concludeth yet as constantly as though he had thrown all down afore him, intending to show that the doctrine of Transubstantiation dependeth only of authority, which is not so, using the sayings of Duns and Gabriel (as he reporteth them) for his purpose, because they (as he saith)§1 boast themselves what they could do, if the determination of the counsel were not, and thus every idle speech may have estimation with this author against the received truth. And from this point of the matter, the author of this book maketh a passage with a little sport at them, he fan••eth or liketh to call so English Papists by the way to enterprise to answer all such as he supposeth reasons for Transubstantiation and authorities also.
Wherein this author not seeing how little he hath done, concludeth yet as constantly as though he had throwen all downe afore him, entending to shew that the doctrine of Transubstantiation dependeth onely of authority, which is not so, using the sayinges of Duns and Gabriell (as he reporteth them) for his purpose, bicause they (as he sayth)§1 boast themselues what they could doe, if the determination of the counsaile were not, and thus euery idle speach may haue estimation with this author agaynst the receaued truth. And from this poynt of the matter, the author of this booke maketh a passage with a litle sport at them, he fan••eth or liketh to call so English Papistes by the way to enterprise to answere all such as he supposeth reasons for Transubstantiation and authorities also.
1First he findeth himself mirth in devising as he calleth them the Papists, to say that Christ is made a new, which fancy if it were so, is against the real presence as well as transubstantiation. In which words because every wise reader may see how this author playeth: I will say no more but this, Christ is not made a new, nor made of the §2substance of bread, as of a matter, and that to be the Catholic doctrine, this author if he be right named, knoweth well enough, and yet spendeth two leaves in it.
1First he findeth himselfe mirth in divissing as he calleth them the Papistes, to say yt Christ is made a new, which fansie if it were so, is agaynst the reall presence as well as transubstantiation. In which wordes bicause euery wise reader may see how this author playeth: I will say no more but this, Christ is not made a new, nor made of the §2substance of bread, as of a matter, and that to be the Catholique doctrine, this author if he be right named, knoweth well enough, and yet spendeth two leaues in it.
When I have proved most evidently, as well by the testimony of the scripture, as by the consent of the old authors of Christs church both greeks and Latins, from the beginning continually from time to time, that transubstantiation is against gods most holy word, against the old church of Christ, against all experience of our senses, against all reason, and against the doctrine of all ages (until the Bishops of Rome devised the contrary) therefore. I conclude that the said doctrine of Transubstantiation may justly be called the Romish or papistical doctrine. And where I have showed further, that the chief pillars of the papistical doctrine, as Duns, Gabriel, Durand, with other do acknowledge, that if it had not been for the determination of the church of Rome, they would have thought otherwise (which is a most certain argument, that this doctrine of Transubstantiation came from Rome, and therefore is worthily called a papistical doctrine) all this must be answered with these words (as this author reporteth) and Duns and Gabriel boast §1what they could do) whereas neither Duns nor any of the other, either brag or boast, but plainly and frankly declare what they think. And if I report then otherwise then they say, reprove me therefore, and tell me wherein. But these be but shifts to shake of the matter that you cannot answer unto. Therefore until you have made me a more full and direct answer, I am more confirmed in my assertion, to call transubstantiation a papistical doctrine, then I was before.
WHen I haue proued most euidently, as well by the testimony of the scripture, as by the consent of the olde authors of Christes church both greekes and Latines, from the beginning continually from tyme to tyme, that transubstantiation is agaynst gods most holy word, agaynst the olde church of Christ, agaynst all experience of our sences, agaynst all reason, and agaynst the doctrine of all ages (vntill the Bishops of Rome deuised the contrary) therfore. I conclude that the sayd doctrine of Transubstantiation may iustely be called the Romish or papisticall doctrine. And where I haue shewed further, that the chiefe pillers of the papisticall doctrine, as Duns, Gabriell, Durand, with other do acknowledge, that if it had not bene for the determination of the church of Rome, they would haue thought otherwise (which is a most certayne argument, that this doctrine of Transubstantiation came from Rome, and therfore is worthely called a papisticall doctrine) all this must be answered with these wordes (as this author reporteth) and Duns and Gabriell boast §1