Fourthly,1 it is showed by many testimonies of Scripture, that the Wills and voluntary Actions of good and wicked men, which our adversaries maintain to be and have been free, and we also, according to the right meaning of this word Liberty, do willingly confess, are so guided by the secret and unchangeable purpose of God, that they neither can or could either do, or be otherwise. Wherefore either so many manifest places of Scripture must be denied, or openly corrupted: or it must be granted, that one and the same Action of the Will is free & contingent in respect of the Will, and necessary in respect of Gods government. Fifthly, it is declared by many places of Scripture,2 that all contingent effects do retain their contingency, which they have from the nature of their causes, although they be done by the unchangeable determination of the purpose or providence of God: But all voluntary effects or motions are contingent in respect of the Will, which by nature was alike able to have done the plain contrary unto them. They therefore retain their contingency, that is, their liberty (for this is the contingency of the actions of the Will) although they be so determined of by Gods Will, that there can be no other. The reason of the Major in this argument is, for that God so moveth the second causes, and by them bringeth to pass what he will, that in the mean season by this providence he doth not destroy or abolish their nature wch he gave them at their creation, but rather preserveth and nourisheth it: so that as concerning their nature, some work contingently, some necessarily, although in respect of the liberty of Gods purpose, all work contingently, and in respect of the unchangeableness of his decree, all work necessarily, so as they do. For when God by the rising of the Sun lighteneth the world, he maketh not the Sun so, as if being risen it did not necessarily lighten, or were apt by nature not to lighten: and yet it is in the power of God, either to change the nature of the Sun, or that remaining as it is, not to lighten the world: as he showed in Egypt, and at the passion of Christ. In like manner, when the Quails light at the Tents of the Israelites, and the Ravens carry meat to Elijah, and one sparrow falleth on the ground, God doth not make the nature of these living creatures such, as could not be carried elsewhere:
Fourthly,1 it is shewed by many testimonies of Scripture, that the Wils and voluntary Actions of good and wicked men, which our adversaries maintaine to be and have been free, and we also, according to the right meaning of this word Liberty, doe willingly confesse, are so guided by the secret and unchangeable purpose of God, that they neither can or could either doe, or be otherwise. Wherefore either so many manifest places of Scripture must be denied, or openly corrupted: or it must be granted, that one and the same Action of the Wil is free & contingent in respect of the Wil, and necessary in respect of Gods government. Fiftly, it is declared by many places of Scripture,2 that al contingent effects doe retain their contingency, which they have from the nature of their causes, although they be done by the unchangable determination of the purpose or providence of God: But al voluntary effects or motions are contingent in respect of the Wil, which by nature was alike able to have done the plaine contrary unto them. They therefore retain their contingency, that is, their liberty (for this is the contingency of the actions of the Wil) although they be so determined of by Gods Wil, that there can be no other. The reason of the Major in this argument is, for that God so moveth the second causes, and by them bringeth to passe what he wil, that in the mean season by this providence he doth not destroy or abolish their nature wch he gave them at their creation, but rather preserveth and nourisheth it: so that as concerning their nature, some work contingently, some necessarily, although in respect of the liberty of Gods purpose, al work contingently, and in respect of the unchangeablenesse of his decree, all work necessarily, so as they doe. For when God by the rising of the Sun lightneth the world, hee maketh not the Sun so, as if being risen it did not necessarily lighten, or were apt by nature not to lighten: and yet it is in the power of God, either to change the nature of the Sun, or that remaining as it is, not to lighten the world: as he shewed in Egypt, and at the passion of Christ. In like manner, when the Quailes light at the Tents of the Israelites, and the Ravens carry meat to Elias, and one sparrow falleth on the ground, God doth not make the nature of these living creatures such, as could not be carried elsewhere:
- 1Many places of Scripture confirm the necessity of those actions, the liberty of which yet both we and our adversaries acknowledge.Many places of Scripture confirme the necessity of those actions, the liberty of which yet both we and our adversaries acknowledge.
- 2Contingent effects lose not their contingency, by reason of any necessity imported by Gods decree. The same is to be said of the effects of the will, which are in respect thereof contingent, that is, free, and might as well not be done, as be done.Contingent effects lose not their contingencie, by reason of any necessity imported by Gods decree. The same is to be said of the effects of the will, which are in respect thereof contingent, that is, free, and might as well not be done, as be done.