The Explication.
pp. 335–34645 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 335–34645 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
IN this last part of the Apostolic confession are contained six Articles; whereof the first speaketh of the person of the holy Ghost: the next of the Church, which is gathered, confirmed, and preserved by the holy Ghost: the four Articles following are of the benefits bestowed by the holy Ghost on the Church, and of the communion of Saints: 2. of remission of sins: 3. of the resurrection of the flesh: 4. of everlasting life. Touching the holy Ghost, three things are especially to be considered; his person, his office, his gifts and works. But for more full and ample explication hereof, these Questions following are each in their order to be examined.
IN this last part of the Apostolick confession are contained six Articles; whereof the first speaketh of the person of the holy Ghost: the next of the Church, which is gathered, confirmed, and preserved by the holy Ghost: the foure Articles following are of the benefits bestowed by the holy Ghost on the Church, and of the communion of Saints: 2. of remission of sins: 3. of the resurrection of the flesh: 4. of everlasting life. Touching the holy Ghost, three things are especially to be considered; his person, his office, his gifts and works. But for more full and ample explication hereof, these Questions following are each in their order to be examined.
1. What the name *Spirit signifieth. 2. Who, and what the holy Ghost or Spirit is. 3. What is the holy Ghosts office. 4. What, and of how many sorts his gifts are. 5. Of whom the holy Ghost is given, and wherefore. 6. To whom, and how far forth he is given. 7. When, and how he is given and received. 8. How he is retained and kept. 9. Whether he may be lost, and how. 10. Wherefore he is necessary. 11. How we may know that he dwelleth is us.
1. What the name *Spirit signifieth. 2. Who, and what the holy Ghost or Spirit is. 3. What is the holy Ghosts office. 4. What, and of how many sorts his gifts are. 5. Of whom the holy Ghost is given, and wherefore. 6. To whom, and how far forth he is given. 7. When, and how hee is given and received. 8. How he is retained and kept. 9. Whether he may be lost, and how. 10. Wherefore hee is necessary. 11. How wee may know that hee dwelleth is us.
The name spirit is sometimes taken for the cause; sometimes for the effect. When it is taken for the cause, it signifieth a nature incorporeal, and living, of a spiritual essence, wielding, moving, and stirring something; and this nature is either create, or uncreate. Uncreate, and so God essentially and personally is a Spirit; that is, incorporeal without any bodily dimension or quantity, invisible; God is a Spirit. Create, and so the Angles, whether good or bad, are in this sense spirits: 1Which maketh his Angels spirits: And after the same manner the souls of men are called spirits; 2He breathed in his face breath of life, that is, he sent a spirit or soul into him:3 When thou takest away their breath, they die. When the word spirit is taken for an effect, it signifieth, 1. The air moved. 2. The moving it self, and motion of the air. 3. The wind, and moving vapours. 4. Spiritual affections or motions, good or bad. So it is said The spirit of fear: And contrary. The spirit of princes, that is, courage: likewise, the spirit of fornication. 5. New spirit signifieth the gifts of the holy Spirit: as,4 Quench not the spirit. In this doctrine which we have in hand, Spirit signifieth the cause stirring and moving; namely, the third person of the God head, which is forcible in the minds and wills of men: And this third person of the God-head is called a ⟨p. 336⟩Spirit, §151. Because he is a spiritual essence or substance, incorporeal and invisible. §22. Because he is inspired of the Father and the Son: that is, because he is the person by which the Father and the Son immediately work their motions in the hearts of the elect; or because he is the immediate stirrer and mover of divine works: The Father and the Son move, but by this Spirit. §33. Because himself inspireth and immediately worketh motions in the hearts of the elect; whence he is called,6 The power of the most High. §44. Because he is God, equal, and the same with the Father and the Son: and God is a Spirit. This third person of the God-head is called holy; §171. Because he in himself, by himself, and of his own nature is holy. §22. Because he is hallower or sanctifier; that is, he immediately halloweth, or sanctifieth and maketh holy others. The Father and the Son sanctify by him, and therefore immediately.
THe name spirit is sometimes taken for the cause; sometimes for the effect. When it is taken for the cause, it signifieth a nature incorporeall, and living, of a spirituall essence, wielding, moving, and stirring something; and this nature is either create, or uncreate. Uncreate, and so God essentially and personally is a Spirit; that is, incorporeall without any bodily dimension or quantity, invisible; God is a Spirit. Create, and so the Angles, whether good or bad, are in this sense spirits: 1Which maketh his Angels spirits: And after the same manner the soules of men are called spirits; 2He breathed in his face breath of life, that is, hee sent a spirit or soule into him:3 When thou takest away their breath, they die. When the word spirit is taken for an effect, it signifieth, 1. The aire moved. 2. The moving it selfe, and motion of the aire. 3. The wind, and moving vapours. 4. Spirituall affections or motions, good or bad. So it is said The spirit of fear: And contrary. The spirit of princes, that is, courage: likewise, the spirit of fornication. 5. New spirit signifieth the gifts of the holy Spirit: as,4 Quench not the spirit. In this doctrine which wee have in hand, Spirit signifieth the cause stirring and moving; namely, the third person of the God head, which is forcible in the minds and wils of men: And this third person of the God-head is called a ⟨p. 336⟩Spirit, §151. Because he is a spirituall essence or substance, incorporeall and invisible. §22. Because hee is inspired of the Father and the Son: that is, because hee is the person by which the Father and the Son immediately work their motions in the hearts of the elect; or because hee is the immediate stirrer and mover of divine works: The Father and the Son move, but by this Spirit. §33. Because himselfe inspireth and immediately worketh motions in the hearts of the elect; whence hee is called,6 The power of the most High. §4
The holy Ghost is the third person of the true and only God-head, proceeding from the Father and the Son, and co eternal, co-equal, and consubstantial with the Father and the Son: and is sent from both into the hearts of the elect, to sanctify them unto eternal life. Here are we to say the same things of the God-head of the holy Ghost, which have been spoken before of the God-head of the Son: for this definition is also to be proved and confirmed by the same four parts:1 1. That the holy Ghost is a person. 2. That he is the third person, or that he is other and distinct from the Father and the Son. 3. That he is true God with the Father and the Son, or that he is equal to the Father and the Son. 4. That he is of the same God head with the Father and the Son, or that he is consubstantial unto both. All these that testimony of the Apostle jointly proveth: No man knoweth the things of God but the Spirit of God. 2Now we have received, not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit which is of God, that we might know the things which are given unto us of God. Also that other else where: All these things worketh even the self-same Spirit, 3distributing to every man severally as he will. But we will proceed to treat of each of these in their order.
THe holy Ghost is the third person of the true and only God-head, proceeding from the Father and the Son, and co eternall, co-equall, and consubstantiall with the Father and the Son: and is sent from both into the hearts of the elect, to sanctifie them unto eternall life. Here are wee to say the same things of the God-head of the holy Ghost, which have been spoken before of the God-head of the Son: for this definition is also to be proved and confirmed by the same four parts:1 1. That the holy Ghost is a person. 2. That he is the third person, or that he is other and distinct from the Father and the Son. 3. That he is true God with the Father and the Son, or that he is equall to the Father and the Son. 4. That he is of the same God head with the Father and the Son, or that he is consubstantiall unto both. All these that testimony of the Apostle jointly proveth: No man knoweth the things of God but the Spirit of God. 2Now we have received, not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit which is of God, that wee might know the things which are given unto us of God. Also that other else where: All these things worketh even the selfe-same Spirit, 3distributing to every man severally as he will. But we will proceed to treat of each of these in their order.
I. First therefore,1 That the holy Ghost is a person, is proved, §12By his apparitions, because he hath appeared visibly: The holy Ghost came down in a bodily shape like a Dove. And there appeared unto them cloven tongues like fire, and it (that is, the fire, or the holy Ghost) sate upon each of them. Seeing then the holy Ghost descended in bodily shape upon Christ, and sate upon the Apostles, it followeth that he is subsisting: for no quality or created motion of minds or hearts is able to do in like manner: For an accident doth not only not take upon it any shape, but standeth in need of something else in which it self should consist and be. Neither is the air the place or subject of holiness, godliness, love of God, and other spiritual motions, but the minds of men. §23He is proved to be a person, because he is called God: Know ye not that ye are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you? Why hath Satan filled thine heart, that thou shouldest lie unto the holy Ghost? Thou hast not lied unto men, but unto God. Howsoever then the adversaries of this doctrine grant the holy Ghost to be God, yet this cannot be, but he must be a subsistent or person,4 seeing God is a being: but our godliness, goodness, godly motions, and other divine affections cannot be called God.§3 5He is a person, because he is the author of our baptism, and we are baptised in his name, that is, by his commandment and will. But we are not baptised by the commandment and will of a dead thing, or of a thing not existing; neither are we baptised in the name of the graces or gifts of God.§4 6Because the properties of a person are attributed unto him; as that he teacheth, that he distributeth gifts even as he will, that he comforteth,7 confirmeth, ruleth, reigneth: likewise, that he sendeth Apostles,8 that he speaketh in the Apostles: The holy Ghost shall teach you in the same hour what you ought to say. So also he declareth the things to come: The Spirit of truth will show you the things to come.
I. First therefore,1 That the holy Ghost is a person, is proved, §12By his apparitions, because hee hath appeared visibly: The holy Ghost came downe in a bodily shape like a Dove. And there appeared unto them cloven tongues like fire, and it (that is, the fire, or the holy Ghost) sate upon each of them. Seeing then the holy Ghost descended in bodily shape upon Christ, and sate upon the Apostles, it followeth that he is subsisting: for no quality or created motion of minds or hearts is able to doe in like manner: For an accident doth not only not take upon it any shape, but standeth in need of something else in which it selfe should consist and be. Neither is the aire the place or subject of holinesse, goldinesse, love of God, and other spirituall motions, but the minds of men. §23Hee is proved to be a person, because hee is called God: Know yee not that yee are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you? Why hath Satan filled thine heart, that thou shouldest lie unto the holy Ghost? Thou hast not lied unto men, but unto God. Howsoever then the adversaries of this doctrine grant the holy Ghost to be God, yet this cannot be, but hee must be a subsistent or person,4 seeing God is a being: but our goldinesse, goodnesse, godly motions, and other divine affections cannot be called God.§3 5Hee is a person, because hee is the authour of our baptisme, and wee are baptised in his name, that is, by his commandement and will. But we are not baptised by the commandement and will of a dead thing, or of a thing not existing; neither are wee baptised in the name of the graces or gifts of God.§4 6Because the properties of a person are attributed unto him; as that hee teacheth, that hee distributeth gifts even as hee will, that he comforteth,7 confirmeth, ruleth, reigneth: likewise, that he sendeth Apostles,8
He giveth prophecies of Simeons death, of Judas the traitor, of Peters journey to Cornelius, of Pauls bands and afflictions which should ⟨p. 337⟩betide him at Jerusalem, of a falling away, and of the deceivers in the last times, of the meaning of the high priests entrance into the holiest of all,1 of the first tabernacle, of the new covenant, of Christs sufferings, and his glory which should follow after them, and such like: he maketh request for us with sighs, which cannot be uttered; he crieth in our hearts, Abba, Father; he is tempted by them who lie unto him, he is a witness in heaven with the Father and the Son, he commandeth and willeth that the Apostles be separated; and lastly, he appointeth teachers in the Church: All these things are proper unto a person existing, intelligent, endued with a will, working and living.2 §53Because he is plainly distinguished from the gifts and graces of God. All these things worketh the self-same Spirit, distributing to every man severally as he will. There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit: Wherefore the gifts differ much from the Spirit it self. Obj. The gift of God is not a person: 4The holy Ghost is called the gift of God: Therefore he is not a person. Ans. The Major is false, if it be universally taken: for the Son being given, is the gift of God, and yet is a person. The holy Ghost is called the gift of God, because he is sent from the Father and the Son.5 I will send the comforter unto you from the Father. Or we may answer; He is called a gift, in respect that he was sent, and dwelleth in the hearts of the saints to whom he is given; and is such a gift as worketh by his virtue and power the rest of his gifts and graces. Now that, to proceed, signifieth to exist, or to be from both, I prove; Because Paul calleth him the Spirit of God, which is of God, and in God: Of God; Because the Spirit floweth from the Father and the Son. In God; Therefore he is some-what of God himself. Other spirits are not in God, that is, in the substance of God. And what is in God, that is the very essence of God.
Hee giveth prophecies of Simeons death, of Judas the traitor, of Peters journey to Cornelius, of Pauls bands and afflictions which should ⟨p. 337⟩betide him at Jerusalem, of a falling away, and of the deceivers in the last times, of the meaning of the high priests entrance into the holiest of all,1 of the first tabernacle, of the new covenant, of Christs sufferings, and his glory which should follow after them, and such like: he maketh request for us with sighs, which cannot be uttered; he crieth in our hearts, Abba, Father; he is tempted by them who lie unto him, he is a witnesse in heaven with the Father and the Son, he commandeth and willeth that the Apostles be separated; and lastly, he appointeth teachers in the Church: All these things are proper unto a person existing, intelligent, indued with a will, working and living.2 §53Because he is plainly dishinguished from the gifts and graces of God. All these things worketh the self-same Spirit, distributing to every man severally as he will. There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit: Wherefore the gifts differ much from the Spirit it selfe. Obj. The gift of God is not a person: 4The holy Ghost is called the gift of God: Therefore he is not a person. Ans. The Major is false, if it be universally taken: for the Son being given, is the gift of God, and yet is a person. The holy Ghost is called the gift of God, because he is sent from the Father and the Son.5 I will send the comforter unto you from the Father. Or we may answer; He is called a gift, in respect that he was sent, and dwelleth in the hearts of the saints to whom he is given; and is such a gift as worketh by his vertue and power the rest of his gifts and graces. Now that, to proceed, signifieth to exist, or to be from both, I prove; Because Paul calleth him the Spirit of God, which is of God, and in God: Of God; Because the Spirit floweth from the Father and the Son. In God; Therefore he is some-what of God himself. Other spirits are not in God, that is, in the substance of God. And what is in God, that is the very essence of God.
II. That the holy Ghost is other, that is, distinct from the Father and the Son, we prove against those who say, He is the subsistent of the Father, namely, the Sabellians.1 Which we prove, §12From the very appellation, in that he is called the Spirit of the Father and the Son: For none is his own Spirit, as none is his own Father, and none is his own Son: Therefore he is other from both. Object. That which is common to all the persons ought not to be distinguished and severed: The name Spirit is common to all the three persons: Therefore it ought not to be distinguished. Ans. This whole reason we grant, if it be understood of the essence of the persons, and not of their order of being and working: for as he that breatheth, and the breath it self differ; so he that inspireth, and the spirit are different: he that proceedeth is one, and he another from whom he proceedeth: the third person of the God-head is one, and the first or second another. But the holy Ghost is said to be the third person of the God-head, and this is not in that respect, as if there were in God any first or last in time; but in respect of the order or manner of being; because the holy Ghost hath his essence from the Father and the Son, from both which he proceeded from everlasting; as also he is the spirit of both. In like manner the Son is called the second person, because he is of the Father; the Father the first person, because he is of none.§2 3The holy Ghost is in express words called another: I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter. There are three which bear record in heaven, the Father, 4the Word, and the holy Ghost; and these three are one: The holy Ghost therefore is a distinct person from the Father and the Son.§3 5He is sent of the Father and the Son: Therefore he is another from both; for none is sent of himself: One may come of his own will or of himself; but none can be sent of himself.6 I will send him unto you from the Father. The Father sendeth him in my name. §47The holy Ghost hath distinct attributes or properties personal from them. The holy Ghost proceedeth only from the Father and the Son. He alone appeared in the shape of a Dove, in the likeness of fire; not the Father or the Son. Christ is said to have been conceived, not by the Father or the Son, but by the holy Ghost, that is, by the immediate virtue and efficacy of the holy Ghost.
II. That the holy Ghost is other, that is, distinct from the Father and the Son, we prove against those who say, He is the subsistent of the Father, namely, the Sabellians.1 Which we prove, §12From the very appellation, in that he is called the Spirit of the Father and the Son: For none is his own Spirit, as none is his own Father, and none is his own Son: Therefore he is other from both. Object. That which is common to all the persons ought not to be distinguished and severed: The name Spirit is common to all the three persons: Therefore it ought not to be distinguished. Ans. This whole reason we grant, if it be understood of the essence of the persons, and not of their order of being and working: for as he that breatheth, and the breath it self differ; so he that inspireth, and the spirit are different: he that proceedeth is one, and he another from whom he proceedeth: the third person of the God-head is one, and the first or second another. But the holy Ghost is said to be the third person of the God-head, and this is not in that respect, as if there were in God any first or last in time; but in respect of the order or manner of being; because the holy Ghost hath his essence from the Father and the Son, from both which he proceeded from everlasting; as also he is the spirit of both. In like manner the Son is called the second person, because he is of the Father; the Father the first person, because he is of none.§2 3The holy Ghost is in expresse words called another: I will pray the Father, and hee shall give you another Comforter. There are three which bear record in heaven, the Father, 4the Word, and the holy Ghost; and these three are one: The holy Ghost therefore is a distinct person from the Father and the Son.§3 5Hee is sent of the Father and the Son: Therefore he is another from both; for none is sent of himself: One may come of his own will or of himself; but none can be sent of himself.6 I will send him unto you from the Father. The Father sendeth him in my name. §47
The holy Ghost shall come upon thee, 1and the power of the most High shall over-shadow thee. Wherefore he is another from the Father and the Son; which is diligently to be observed: for the adversaries hereof, being convicted of the person of the holy Ghost, grant that he is a subsistence, but of the Father: and thus they argue or reason, Object. The virtue and power of the Father, ⟨p. 338⟩is the Father himself: The holy Ghost is called the virtue and power of the Father: Therefore the holy Ghost is the Father himself. Ans. This reason is sophistical, because virtue is not taken for the same in the Major, for which it is taken in the Minor: for in the Major it is taken for the power of the Father; in the Minor for the person by whom the Father showeth forth his power.
The holy Ghost shall come upon thee, 1and the power of the most High shall over-shadow thee. Wherefore he is another from the Father and the Son; which is diligently to be observed: for the adversaries hereof, being convicted of the person of the holy Ghost, grant that he is a subsistence, but of the Father: and thus they argue or reason, Object. The vertue and power of the Father, ⟨p. 338⟩is the Father himselfe: The holy Ghost is called the vertue and power of the Father: Therefore the holy Ghost is the Father himself. Ans. This reason is sophisticall, because vertue is not taken for the same in the Major, for which it is taken in the Minor: for in the Major it is taken for the power of the Father; in the Minor for the person by whom the Father sheweth forth his power.
III. That the holy Ghost is equal with the Father and the Son, these arguments do prove:1 §12The essence of the Father and the Son is communicated unto him; because he proceedeth from both, and is the Spirit of both: But there is nothing in God which is not his essence: Seeing then that is indivisible, it must needs be whole and the same communicated unto him, which is in the Father and the Son. As the spirit of man which is in man is of the essence of man: so the Spirit of God which is in God is of the essence of God. By this it appeareth, What is the proceeding of the holy Ghost; namely, the communicating of the divine essence, whereby the third person of the God-head alone receiveth the same and whole or entire essence from the Father and the Son, as from him whose Spirit he is: as also the begetting of the Son is a communicating of the divine essence, which the second person of the God-head alone receiveth, as a Son of his Father, whole and entirely the same which the Father hath and retaineth.
III. That the holy Ghost is equall with the Father and the Son, these arguments doe prove:1 §12The essence of the Father and the Son is communicated unto him; because hee proceedeth from both, and is the Spirit of both: But there is nothing in God which is not his essence: Seeing then that is indivisible, it must needs be whole and the same communicated unto him, which is in the Father and the Son. As the spirit of man which is in man is of the essence of man: so the Spirit of God which is in God is of the essence of God. By this it appeareth, What is the proceeding of the holy Ghost; namely, the communicating of the divine essence, whereby the third person of the God-head alone receiveth the same and whole or entire essence from the Father and the Son, as from him whose Spirit hee is: as also the begetting of the Son is a communicating of the divine essence, which the second person of the God-head alone receiveth, as a Son of his Father, whole and entirely the same which the Father hath and retaineth.
1And, That the holy Ghost proceedeth from the Son also, is proved by certain reasons: §11. Because he is called the Sons Spirit; If any man hath not the Spirit of Christ, the same is not his. 2He hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts. The Spirit of his Son; that is, not given unto the Son of the Father; but existing and proceeding, as of the Fathers, so of the Sons substance, seeing the Son is equal and consubstantial with the Father. §22. Because the Son, together with the Father, giveth him:3 Receive the holy Ghost. §33. Because the holy Ghost receiveth the wisdom of the Son, which he revealeth unto us: He shall receive of mine, and shall show it unto you. 4But seeing the holy Ghost is true God, consubstantial with the Father and the Son, he cannot receive any thing but of him of whose substance he is. Wherefore he proceedeth of the substance of the Son, because he receiveth that of him which is the Sons.
1And, That the holy Ghost proceedeth from the Son also, is proved by certain reasons: §11. Because he is called the Sons Spirit; If any man hath not the Spirit of Christ, the same is not his. 2He hath sent forth the Spirit of his Son into your hearts. The Spirit of his Son; that is, not given unto the Son of the Father; but existing and proceeding, as of the Fathers, so of the Sons substance, seeing the Son is equall and consubstantiall with the Father. §22. Because the Son, together with the Father, giveth him:3 Receive the holy Ghost. §33. Because the holy Ghost receiveth the wisdome of the Son, which hee revealeth unto us: Hee shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you. 4But seeing the holy Ghost is true God, consubstantiall with the Father and the Son, hee cannot receive any thing but of him of whose substance hee is. Wherefore he proceedeth of the substance of the Son, because he receiveth that of him which is the Sons.
1The holy Ghosts equality with the Father and the Son is proved by those divine attributes and properties which are attributed and communicated to the holy Ghost: as, §12Eternity; because he created heaven and earth, and because God was never without his Spirit:3 The Spirit of the Lord moved upon the waters. §24Immensity, or unmeasurablenesse, as who dwelleth whole and entirely in all the elect:5 The Spirit of God dwelleth in you. Through the holy Ghost which dwelleth in us. §36Omnipotency; because he, together with the Father and the Son, created and preserveth all things:7 By the Word of the Lord were the heavens made, and the hosts of them by the Breath of his mouth. All these things worketh even the self same Spirit, distributing to every man severally as he will. §48Omniscience; that is,9the knowledge of all things: The Spirit searcheth all things, even the deep things of God. §510Infinite goodness and holiness, and the causing of goodness and sanctity in the creatures:11 Let thy good Spirit lead me into the land of righteousness. Ye are sanctified in the name of our Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. §612Unchangeableness:13 This Scripture must needs have been fulfilled which the holy Ghost spake. §714Truth not to be doubted of, and the fountain of truth: When the Comforter shall come, 15even the Spirit of truth. The Spirit is truth. §816Unspeakable mercy: The love of God is shed abroad in our hearts by the holy Ghost which is given unto us. 17The Spirit also helpeth our infirmities §918Indignation against even hidden sins: They rebelled, and vexed his holy Spirit. The blasphemy against the holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men. 19Why have ye agreed together to tempt the Spirit of the Lord? Grieve not the holy Spirit of God, by whom ye are sealed.
1The holy Ghosts equality with the Father and the Son is proved by those divine attributes and properties which are attributed and communicated to the holy Ghost: as, §12Eternity; because hee created heaven and earth, and because God was never without his Spirit:3 The Spirit of the Lord moved upon the waters. §24Immensity, or unmeasurablenesse, as who dwelleth whole and intirely in all the elect:5 The Spirit of God dwelleth in you. Through the holy Ghost which dwelleth in us. §36Omnipotency; because hee, together with the Father and the Son, created and preserveth all things:7 By the Word of the Lord were the heavens made, and the hosts of them by the Breath of his mouth. All these things worketh even the selfe same Spirit, distributing to every man severally as hee will. §48Omnisciency; that is,9the knowledge of all things: The Spirit searcheth all things, even the deep things of God. §510Infinite goodnesse and holinesse, and the causing of goodnesse and sanctity in the creatures:11 Let thy good Spirit lead mee into the land of righteousnesse. Yee are sanctified in the name of our Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. §612Unchangeablenesse:13 This Scripture must needs have been fulfilled which the holy Ghost spake.
1The same divine works which are attributed to the Father and the Son, are also attributed to the holy Ghost; and these, both the general and universal works, as the general creation, preservation, and government of the whole world: ⟨p. 339⟩His Spirit hath garnished the heavens. The Spirit of God hath made me, and the breath of the Almighty hath given me life. And also singular and special effects; as miracles:2 I cast out Devils by the Spirit of God. There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit. Likewise, those works which properly belong to the salvation of his Church; as the calling and sending of Prophets: The Lord God and his Spirit hath sent me. 3The holy Ghost said, Separate me Barnabas and Saul. Take heed to all the flock whereof the holy Ghost hath made you overseers. The bestowing of competent and fit graces for the ministry on ministers: The holy Ghost shall teach you. 4The manifestation of the Spirit is given to every man to profit withal. The publishing of the doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles: Holy men of God spake as they were moved by the holy Ghost. 5The instituting of Sacraments: Baptise them in the name of the Father, 6the Son and the holy Ghost. Whereby the holy Ghost this signified, 7that the way into the Holiest of all was not yet opened, while as yet the first tabernacle was standing. The fore-telling and prophesying of things to come: he will show you the things to come. 8Agabus signified that there should be a great famine. The Spirit speaketh evidently, that in the later times some shall depart from the faith. The gathering of the Church:9 In whom also ye are built together to be the habitation of God by the Spirit. 10By one Spirit are we all baptised into one body. The enlightening of mens minds:11 The holy Ghost shall teach you all things. He shall lead you into all truth. God gave unto you the Spirit of wisdom and revelation through the knowledge of him. Regeneration and sanctification:12 Except a man be borne again of water and of the Spirit, 13&c. We are changed into the same image, from glory to glory, as by the Spirit of the Lord. The governing of the actions and whole life of the godly: As many as are led by the Spirit of God, 14they are the sons of God. They were forbidden of the holy Ghost to preach the word in Asia. 15Comforting in temptations: The Comforter is the holy Ghost, 16whom the Father will send in my name.
1The same divine works which are attributed to the Father and the Son, are also attributed to the holy Ghost; and these, both the generall and universall works, as the generall creation, preservation, and government of the whole world: ⟨p. 339⟩His Spirit hath garnished the heavens. The Spirit of God hath made me, and the breath of the Almighty hath given mee life. And also singular and speciall effects; as miracles:2 I cast out Divels by the Spirit of God. There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit. Likewise, those works which properly belong to the salvation of his Church; as the calling and sending of Prophets: The Lord God and his Spirit hath sent me. 3The holy Ghost said, Separate mee Barnabas and Saul. Take heed to all the flock whereof the holy Ghost hath made you overseers. The bestowing of competent and fit graces for the ministery on ministers: The holy Ghost shall teach you. 4The manifestation of the Spirit is given to every man to profit withall. The publishing of the doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles: Holy men of God spake as they were moved by the holy Ghost. 5The instituting of Sacraments: Baptise them in the name of the Father, 6the Son and the holy Ghost. Whereby the holy Ghost this signified, 7that the way into the Holiest of all was not yet opened, while as yet the first tabernacle was standing. The fore-telling and prophecying of things to come: he will shew you the things to come. 8Agabus signified that there should be a great famine. The Spirit speaketh evidently, that in the later times some shall depart from the faith. The gathering of the Church:9 In whom also yee are built together to be the habitation of God by the Spirit. 10By one Spirit are wee all baptised into one body. The enlightning of mens mindes:
1The Churches were edified and multiplied by the comfort of the holy Ghost. I will pour upon the house of David the Spirit of grace and compassion. 2The strengthening and preserving of the regenerate against the force of temptation, even unto the end: The Spirit of strength shall rest upon him. 3He shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever. In whom also ye are sealed with the holy Spirit of promise. The pardoning of sins, and adopting the sons of God: Ye have received the Spirit of adoption. 4Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty. Ye are justified in the name of our Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. The bestowing of salvation and life everlasting:5 It is the Spirit that quickeneth. If the Spirit of him which raised up Christ from the dead dwell in you, 6he that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies, because that his Spirit dwelleth in you. Judgement and sentence against sin:7 When the Comforter shall come, he shall reprove the world of sin. 8The blasphemy against the holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men.
1The Churches were edified and multiplyed by the comfort of the holy Ghost. I will powre upon the house of David the Spirit of grace and compassion. 2The strengthening and preserving of the regenerate against the force of temptation, even unto the end: The Spirit of strength shall rest upon him. 3Hee shall give you another Comforter, that hee may abide with you for ever. In whom also yee are sealed with the holy Spirit of promise. The pardoning of sins, and adopting the sonnes of God: Yee have received the Spirit of adoption. 4Where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty. Yee are justified in the name of our Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. The bestowing of salvation and life everlasting:5 It is the Spirit that quickeneth. If the Spirit of him which raised up Christ from the dead dwell in you, 6hee that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortall bodies, because that his Spirit dwelleth in you. Judgement and sentence against sin:7 When the Comforter shall come, he shall reprove the world of sin. 8The blasphemy against the holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men.
1Equal and the same honour is given to the holy Ghost, which is given both to the Father and the Son. To no creature, but to God alone is to be given divine honour, that is, honour proper to God only: But this is given to the holy Ghost: Therefore he is God equal with the Father and the Son:2 There are three which bear witness in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the holy Ghost, and these three are one: The holy Ghost therefore is the same true God with the Father and the Son. Go and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and the Son, and the holy Ghost: By this testimony we are taught,3 1. That we are baptized also into the name, faith, worship, and religion of the holy Ghost. 2. That the holy Ghost is author also of baptism and the ministry. In like sort also we believe and put our trust in him: Let not your hearts be troubled: I will pray the Father, 4and he shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever. That sin which is committed against him is not remitted; therefore we sin against him. We are his temple: Ye are the temple of the holy Ghost▪ 5and the Spirit of God dwelleth in you. The Apostles in their Epistles wish unto the Churches grace and peace from the holy Ghost: The communion of the holy Ghost be with you. 6Object. 1. He that is sent, is not equal with him that sendeth: The holy Ghost is sent, and the Father and the Son ⟨p. 340⟩send him: Therefore the holy Ghost is not equal with the Father and the Son. Ans. We deny the Major: For Christ that is sent may be equal with him that sendeth: for Christ also being sent of the Father, yet is equal with the Father; this sending doth not betoken any servile subjection. Object. 2. He that receiveth of another, is not equal with him that giveth: The holy Ghost receiveth of the Father and the Son: Therefore he is not equal with both. Ans. The Major is true of one that receiveth of another but a part, and not the whole; but the holy Ghost receiveth the same and whole essence of the Father and the Son. Again, it is true of him that receiveth in time, or successively: but the holy Ghost receiveth before all time. Thirdly, to the Minor we say, that he received, as touching the ordaining and sending of him unto us, to teach us immediately: but this sending establisheth and confirmeth his equality, because it is a divine work:
1Equall and the same honour is given to the holy Ghost, which is given both to the Father and the Son. To no creature, but to God alone is to be given divine honour, that is, honour proper to God only: But this is given to the holy Ghost: Therefore hee is God equall with the Father and the Son:2 There are three which bear witnesse in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the holy Ghost, and these three are one: The holy Ghost therefore is the same true God with the Father and the Son. Goe and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and the Sonne, and the holy Ghost: By this testimony wee are taught,3 1. That wee are baptized also into the name, faith, worship, and religion of the holy Ghost. 2. That the holy Ghost is authour also of baptisme and the ministery. In like sort also we beleeve and put our trust in him: Let not your hearts be troubled: I will pray the Father, 4and hee shall give you another Comforter, that hee may abide with you for ever. That sin which is committed against him is not remitted; therefore wee sin against him. We are his temple: Ye are the temple of the holy Ghost▪ 5and the Spirit of God dwelleth in you. The Apostles in their Epistles wish unto the Churches grace and peace from the holy Ghost: The communion of the holy Ghost be with you. 6Object. 1. Hee that is sent, is not equall with him that sendeth: The holy Ghost is sent, and the Father and the Son ⟨p. 340⟩send him: Therefore the holy Ghost is not equall with the Father and the Son. Ans. We deny the Major: For Christ that is sent may be equall with him that sendeth: for Christ also being sent of the Father, yet is equall with the Father; this sending doth not betoken any servile subjection. Object. 2. He that receiveth of another, is not equall with him that giveth: The holy Ghost receiveth of the Father and the Son: Therefore he is not equall with both. Ans. The Major is true of one that receiveth of another but a part, and not the whole; but the holy Ghost receiveth the same and whole essence of the Father and the Son. Again, it is true of him that receiveth in time, or successively: but the holy Ghost receiveth before all time. Thirdly, to the Minor we say, that he received, as touching the ordaining and sending of him unto us, to teach us immediately: but this sending establisheth and confirmeth his equality, because it is a divine work:
and the ordaining of him to teach us immediately, doth not lessen, but strengthen his equality. Obj. 3. The Father made all things by the Son: therefore he made the holy Ghost by him also. Answ. The Father made all things by the Son;1 that is, all things that were made, because it is said, And without him was made nothing that was made. But the holy Ghost is not made, but proceedeth from the Father and the Son.
1IIII. That the holy Ghost is consubstantial, that is, one and the same true God with the Father and the Son, is proved by these reasons: §11. Because he is the Fathers and the Sons Spirit. But the divine essence cannot be multiplied, as neither can another be created, nor the same divided: Therefore the self-same, and the whole must needs be communicated to the holy Ghost, which is the essence of the Father and the Son. From both which the holy Ghost proceedeth, as the Spirit of God in God, and of God. §22. There is but one true God. The holy Ghost is true God: therefore the holy Ghost is that one and the same true God with the Father and the Son, consubstantial with both. §33. There is but one Jehovah, that is, but one divine essence or being, one essentially: who alone is of none, but himself communicateth his being to all things, and preserveth it in them. The holy Ghost is Jehovah:* therefore he is the same with the Father and the Son, God consubstantially with both. Object. He that is of another, is not consubstantial with him, or is not the same with him, of, or from whom he is: The holy Ghost is of the Father and the Son: Therefore he is not the same with them, or consubstantial. Answ. The Major is true in creatures, but not in God. 2. There is an ambiguity in this term, to be of another: He that is of another, and hath not the same or whole essence, is not consubstantial: But the holy Ghost hath the same and whole essence, and therefore it followeth only, that he is not the same person. Therefore by inverting the argument we answer; that he who is of the Father, and from the Father, is consubstantial with him, as likewise with the Son, of, and from whom he also is.
1IIII. That the holy Ghost is consubstantiall, that is, one and the same true God with the Father and the Sonne, is proved by these reasons: §11. Because hee is the Fathers and the Sons Spirit. But the divine essence cannot be multiplied, as neither can another be created, nor the same divided: Therefore the selfe-same, and the whole must needs be communicated to the holy Ghost, which is the essence of the Father and the Son. From both which the holy Ghost proceedeth, as the Spirit of God in God, and of God. §22. There is but one true God. The holy Ghost is true God: therefore the holy Ghost is that one and the same true God with the Father and the Son, consubstantiall with both. §33. There is but one Jehovah, that is, but one divine essence or being, one essentially: who alone is of none, but himselfe communicateth his being to all things, and preserveth it in them. The holy Ghost is Jehovah:* therefore he is the same with the Father and the Son, God consubstantially with both. Object. Hee that is of another, is not consubstantiall with him, or is not the same with him, of, or from whom he is: The holy Ghost is of the Father and the Sonne: Therefore hee is not the same with them, or consubstantiall. Answ. The Major is true in creatures, but not in God. 2. There is an ambiguity in this terme, to be of another: He that is of another, and hath not the same or whole essence, is not consubstantiall: But the holy Ghost hath the same and whole essence, and therefore it followeth only, that he is not the same person. Therefore by inverting the argument we answer; that he who is of the Father, and from the Father, is consubstantiall with him, as likewise with the Son, of, and from whom he also is.
The office of the holy Ghost is sanctification, 1which is wrought immediately by him from the Father and the Son, and therefore he is called The Spirit of sanctification. The chief parts of his office are, To teach, To regenerate, To unite with Christ and God, To govern. To comfort, To confirm or strengthen us. The holy Ghost therefore, §12Teacheth and illuminateth us, that we may know those things which we ought, and may conceive them aright, according to Christs promise: The holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things: and bring all things to your remembrance, which I have told you. The Spirit of truth will lead you into all truth. So he taught the Apostles at Whitsuntide, when they were raw before, of Christs death and his kingdom: he kindled in their hearts a new light, he poured into them the miraculous knowledge of tongues and fulfilled the testimony and record of Joel. Hereof he is called in Scripture, The Teacher of truth, the Spirit of wisdom, revelation, understanding, counsel and knowledge, &c. §23He regenerateth us, when he endoweth us with new qualities, and putteth new inclinations in our hearts, that is, he worketh faith and conversion in the hearts of the chosen.4 Except a man ⟨p. 341⟩be born of water, and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God. I baptise you with water to amendment of life: but he that cometh after me, 5he will baptise you with the holy Ghost, and with fire. This baptism which is wrought of Christ by the holy Ghost is the very regeneration or renewing it self, the same which was signified by the outward baptism of John, and of other ministers.§3 6He conjoineth us with Christ, that we may be his members, and may be quickened by him, and so maketh us partakers of all Christs benefits. I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh. 7But ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. Know ye not that your body is the temple of the holy Ghost which is in you, 8whom ye have of God? No man can say that Jesus is the Lord, but by the holy Ghost. There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit. By one Spirit we are all baptised into the same Spirit. Hereby we know that he abideth in us, 9even by the same Spirit which he hath given us. §410He ruleth and governeth us:
THe office of the holy Ghost is sanctification, 1which is wrought immediately by him from the Father and the Son, and therefore he is called The Spirit of sanctification. The chiefe parts of his office are, To teach, To regenerate, To unite with Christ and God, To governe. To comfort, To confirme or strengthen us. The holy Ghost therefore, §12Teacheth and illuminateth us, that wee may know those things which wee ought, and may conceive them aright, according to Christs promise: The holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, hee shall teach you all things: and bring all things to your remembrance, which I have told you. The Spirit of truth will lead you into all truth. So he taught the Apostles at Whitsontide, when they were raw before, of Christs death and his kingdom: he kindled in their hearts a new light, he powred into them the miraculous knowledge of tongues and fulfilled the testimony and record of Joel. Hereof he is called in Scripture, The Teacher of truth, the Spirit of wisdom, revelation, understanding, counsell and knowledge, &c. §23He regenerateth us, when he endoweth us with new qualities, and putteth new inclinations in our hearts, that is, hee worketh faith and conversion in the hearts of the chosen.4 Except a man ⟨p. 341⟩be born of water, and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdome of God. I baptise you with water to amendment of life: but hee that cometh after me, 5hee will baptise you with the holy Ghost, and with fire. This baptisme which is wrought of Christ by the holy Ghost is the very regeneration or renewing it selfe, the same which was signified by the outward baptisme of John, and of other ministers.§3 6Hee conjoyneth us with Christ, that we may be his members, and may be quickned by him, and so maketh us partakers of all Christs benefits. I will powr out my Spirit upon all flesh. 7But yee are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. Know ye not that your body is the temple of the holy Ghost which is in you,
Now, to be ruled and guided by the holy Ghost, is to be instructed with wisdom and counsel in the actions of our life and vocation, and inclined to follow those things which are right and good, and to perform the duties of love and charity towards God and our neighbour:1 As many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God. And they began to speak with tongues, 2as the Spirit of God gave them utterance. §53He comforteth us amidst our afflictions and dangers. The Apostles, who were first flying away for fear of the Jews, now being erected by the comfort and solace of the holy Ghost, come forth into open place, and rejoice when they are to suffer for the confession of the Gospel:4 He will give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever. §65He confirmeth us which stagger and waver in faith, and assureth us of salvation; that is, he continueth and cherisheth in us Christs benefits unto the end: So he made the Apostles courageous and bold, who were before timorous, and wrapped and entangled with many doubts. These things we may plainly see, if we compare that Sermon which Peter made at Whitsuntide, with their speech who went to Emmaus, who say,6 We trusted that it had been he which should have delivered Israel. Hereof Christ saith: Your hearts shall rejoice, and your joy shall no man take from you. He shall abide with you for even. Hence is he called the Spirit of boldness: and the seal of our inheritance.
Now, to be ruled and guided by the holy Ghost, is to be instructed with wisdome and counsell in the actions of our life and vocation, and inclined to follow those things which are right and good, and to perform the duties of love and charity towards God and our neighbour:1 As many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God. And they began to speak with tongues, 2as the Spirit of God gave them utterance. §53He comforteth us amidst our afflictions and dangers. The Apostles, who were first flying away for fear of the Jews, now being erected by the comfort and solace of the holy Ghost, come forth into open place, and rejoice when they are to suffer for the confession of the Gospel:4 He will give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever. §65He confirmeth us which stagger and waver in faith, and assureth us of salvation; that is, he continueth and cherisheth in us Christs benefits unto the end: So he made the Apostles couragious and bold, who were before timorous, and wrapped and intangled with many doubts. These things we may plainly see, if we compare that Sermon which Peter made at Whitsontide, with their speech who went to Emmaus, who say,6 Wee trusted that it had been he which should have delivered Israel. Hereof Christ saith: Your hearts shall rejoice, and your joy shall no man take from you. He shall abide with you for even. Hence is he called the Spirit of boldnesse: and the seale of our inheritance.
1These are the chief and principal parts of the holy Ghosts office, who, in respect of this his office, hath divers titles of commendation in the Scripture: for hereof he is called, §12The Spirit of adoption; because he assureth us of the fatherly good will of God towards us, and is a witness unto us of that free goodness and mercy wherewith the Father embraceth us in his only begotten Son. Therefore by his Spirit we cry, Abba, Father. §23He is called the earnest and seal of our inheritance; because he assureth us of our salvation: It is God which stablisheth us with you in Christ, and hath anointed us: who hath also sealed us, and hath given the earnest of the Spirit in our hearts. In which Gospel also after that ye believed, ye were sealed with the holy Spirit of promise, which is the earnest of our inheritance. §34He is called life; because he quickeneth us: or (as the Apostle saith) The Spirit of life, who mortifieth the old man, and quickeneth the new The law of the Spirit of life which is in Christ Jesus hath freed me from the law of sin and of death. §45He is called water, whereby he refresheth us, being almost dead in sin, purgeth out sin, and maketh us fruitful, that we may bring forth the fruit of righteousness unto God. §56He is called fire; because he doth daily burn up and consume concupiscences and vices in us, and kindleth our hearts with the love of God and our neighbour.§6 7He is called the fountain; because celestial riches do flow unto us from him, and by him.§7 8He is called the Spirit of prayer; because he stirreth us up unto prayer, and instructeth us to pray: I will pour upon the house of David, and upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem the Spirit of grace, and of prayer, and they shall look upon me. The Spirit also helpeth our infirmities: for we know not what to pray as we ought. §89The oil of gladness; because he maketh us joyful, forward, and lively: Wherefore God, even thy God hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness. §910He is called the Comforter; because he worketh faith in us, and purifieth our consciences, and so comforteth us, that we exult and rejoice in afflictions. §1011He is called Intercessor; because the Spirit maketh request ⟨p. 342⟩or intercession for us, with sighs which cannot be expressed. §1112He is called lastly, the Spirit of truth, of wisdom, of joy, of gladness, of fear of God, of boldness, and the like.
1These are the chiefe and principall parts of the holy Ghosts office, who, in respect of this his office, hath divers titles of commendation in the Scripture: for hereof he is called, §12The Spirit of adoption; because he assureth us of the fatherly good will of God towards us, and is a witnesse unto us of that free goodnesse and mercy wherewith the Father imbraceth us in his only begotten Son. Therefore by his Spirit we cry, Abba, Father. §23He is called the earnest and seal of our inheritance; because he assureth us of our salvation: It is God which stablisheth us with you in Christ, and hath annointed us: who hath also sealed us, and hath given the earnest of the Spirit in our hearts. In which Gospel also after that yee beleeved, yee were sealed with the holy Spirit of promise, which is the earnest of our inheritance. §34Hee is called life; because he quickneth us: or (as the Apostle saith) The Spirit of life, who mortifieth the old man, and quickeneth the new The law of the Spirit of life which is in Christ Jesus hath freed me from the law of sin and of death. §45Hee is called water, whereby hee refresheth us, being almost dead in sin, purgeth out sin, and maketh us fruitfull, that wee may bring forth the fruit of righteousnesse unto God. §56Hee is called fire; because he doth daily burn up and consume concupiscences and vices in us, and kindleth our hearts with the love of God and our neighbour.§6 7Hee is called the fountaine; because celestiall riches do flow unto us from him, and by him.§7 8He is called the Spirit of prayer; because he stirreth us up unto prayer, and instructeth us to pray: I will powr upon the house of David, and upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem the Spirit of grace, and of prayer, and they shall look upon me. The Spirit also helpeth our infirmities: for we know not what to pray as we ought.
Object. 1. Those parts of the Spirits office before specified are not proper to the holy Ghost, but belong also to the Father and the Son. Therefore they are not well assigned to the holy Ghost as proper. Answ. They belong also the Father and the Son, but mediately by the holy Ghost: But unto the holy Ghost they belong immediately. Rep. But after the same manner also it seemeth, that the preservation of things, the invention of arts and sciences, and the like, are to be attributed as proper functions unto the holy Ghost: for those also doth the Father and the Son work by the holy Ghost; according as it is said, The Spirit of the Lord filleth all the world. 1Ans. To the assigning of a work as proper unto the holy Ghost, is required, not only that it be immediately done by him; but in such wise also, as that he be acknowledged and worshipped therein. Now there doth the holy Ghost work properly where he sanctifieth and halloweth; for therefore also is he called holy.
Object 2. It was said before, that the holy Ghost is the earnest of our inheritance: But Saul and Judas had the holy Ghost, neither yet obtained they the inheritance, but were reprobate: Therefore the holy Ghost is not the earnest of our inheritance. Ans. Saul and Judas had the holy Ghost, a••oncerning some gifts of the holy Ghost: but they had not the Spirit of adoption. Repl. But it is the same Spirit. Ans. It is the same Spirit indeed, but doth not work the same things in all: For he worketh adoption and conversion in the elect only. Here therefore we are to entreat of the gifts of the holy Ghost, and their differences.
Object 2. It was said before, that the holy Ghost is the earnest of our inheritance: But Saul and Ju•as had the holy Ghost, neither yet obtained they the inheritance, but were reprobate: Therefore the holy Ghost is not the earnest of our inheritance. Ans. Saul and Judas had the holy Ghost, a••oncerning some gifts of the holy Ghost: but they had not the Spirit of adoption. Repl. But it is the same Spirit. Ans. It is the same Spirit indeed, but doth not work the same things in all: For he worketh adoption and conversion in the elect only. Here therefore we are to intreat of the gifts of the holy Ghost, and their differences.
1All the gifts of the holy Ghost may be referred to the parts of his office before rehearsed; namely, our illumination and enlightening, the gift of tongues, the gift of prophecy, of interpretation, of miracles; our faith, regeneration, prayer, strength,2 and constancy, &c. These gifts are of two sorts: Some are common to the godly and ungodly: some are proper to the godly and elect only. Those again which are common to the godly and ungodly are two-fold; for some of them are given but to certain men and at certain times; as the gift of miracles, and of tongues, prophecies, the faith of miracles; and these were necessary for the Apostles and the primitive Church when the Gospel was first to be dispersed: therefore they were miraculously bestowed on them. Some are given to all the members of the Church, and at all times; as the gift of tongues, the gift of interpretation, sciences, arts, prudence, learning, eloquence, and such like; all which pertain to the maintenance and preservation of the ministry: These are now also given to every member of the Church, according to the measure of Christs gift, as the calling & vocation of every member needeth; though they be not miraculously bestowed as they were on the Apostles,3 but attained unto by labour and study. The gifts of the holy Ghost proper unto the godly, are all those things which we comprehend under the name of sanctification and adoption: as justifying faith, regeneration, true prayer, unfeigned love of God and our neighbour, hope, patience, constancy, and other gifts profitable to salvation;4 these are all conferred on the elect alone in their conversion: Whom the world cannot receive. The Spirit witnesseth with our spirit that we are the sons of God. The Spirit maketh request for us with sighs which cannot be expressed. Hence is he called the Spirit of adoption. Obj. Many out of the Church have had tongues and sciences: The tongues therefore and sciences are not the gifts of the holy Ghost. Ans. The tongues and sciences out of the Church are also the gifts of the holy Ghost, but by a general working of God, which is without the true knowledge of him. But in the Church the tongues and sciences are the gifts of the holy Ghost joined with the true knowledge of God.
1ALl the gifts of the holy Ghost may be referred to the parts of his office before rehearsed; namely, our illumination and enlightning, the gift of tongues, the gift of prophecie, of interpretation, of miracles; our faith, regeneration, prayer, strength,2 and constancy, &c. These gifts are of two sorts: Some are common to the godly and ungodly: some are proper to the godly and elect only. Those again which are common to the godly and ungodly are two-fold; for some of them are given but to certain men and at certain times; as the gift of miracles, and of tongues, prophecies, the faith of miracles; and these were necessary for the Aposties and the primitive Church when the Gospel was first to be dispersed: therefore they were miraculously bestowed on them. Some are given to all the members of the Church, and at all times; as the gift of tongues, the gift of interpretation, sciences, arts, prudence, learning, eloquence, and such like; all which pertain to the maintenance and preservation of the ministery: These are now also given to every member of the Church, according to the measure of Christs gift, as the calling & vocation of every member needeth; though they be not miraculously bestowed as they were on the Apostles,3 but attained unto by labour and study. The gifts of the holy Ghost proper unto the godly, are all those things which we comprehend under the name of sanctification and adoption: as justifying faith, regeneration, true prayer, unfained love of God and our neighbour, hope, patience, constancy, and other gifts profitable to salvation;4 these are all conferred on the elect alone in their conversion: Whom the world cannot receive. The Spirit witnesseth with our spirit that we are the sons of God. The Spirit maketh request for us with sighs which cannot be expressed. Hence is he called the Spirit of adoption. Obj. Many out of the Church have had tongues and sciences: The tongues therefore and sciences are not the gifts of the holy Ghost. Ans. The tongues and sciences out of the Church are also the gifts of the holy Ghost, but by a generall working of God, which is without the true knowledge of him. But in the Church the tongues and sciences are the gifts of the holy Ghost joined with the true knowledge of God.
Moreover, all those gifts (as we have said) are fitly referred to those five principal parts before numbered of the holy Ghosts office, as the knowledge of tongues and of sciences to his function of teaching; and that miraculous and extraordinary ⟨p. 343⟩gift of tongues, partly to his function of ruling (for the holy Ghost did rule and govern their tongues;) partly to his function of teaching and confirming. So also the gift of prophecy and interpretation belongeth to his office of teaching: for he teacheth both by enlightening the minds within by his virtue, and by instructing them without by the word. The institution and ordinance of the Sacraments appertaineth to his office of teaching, but chiefly to his office of confirming. Faith and conversion belong to his office of regenerating and conjoining us with Christ. That he is the Spirit of prayer, instructing us how to pray, belongeth to his office of ruling and governing. In like sort, the rest of the gifts may be referred to certain parts of the holy Ghosts office.
Moreover, all those gifts (as we have said) are fitly referred to those five principall parts before numbred of the holy Ghosts office, as the knowledge of tongues and of sciences to his function of teaching; and that miraculous and extraordinary ⟨p. 343⟩gift of tongues, partly to his function of ruling (for the holy Ghost did rule and govern their tongues;) partly to his function of teaching and confirming. So also the gift of prophecy and interpretation belongeth to his office of teaching: for hee teacheth both by illightning the minds within by his vertue, and by instructing them without by the word. The institution and ordinance of the Sacraments appertaineth to his office of teaching, but chiefly to his office of confirming. Faith and conversion belong to his office of regenerating and conjoyning us with Christ. That he is the Spirit of prayer, instructing us how to pray, belongeth to his office of ruling and governing. In like sort, the rest of the gifts may be referred to certain parts of the holy Ghosts office.
1He is given of the Father and the Son, and also by the Son of the Father, but not by the Father: for the Father giveth the holy Ghost from no other, but from himself as who is of no other but of himself, neither worketh from any other but from himself: The Son giveth the holy Ghost from the Father, from whom also himself both worketh and is. That he is given of and from the Father,2 these testimonies do confirm: He commandeth them to wait for the promise of the Father. I will pour out of my spirit upon all flesh. I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter. 3The Father will send him in my name. That the holy Ghost is given of the Son, these testimonies do prove: I will send you from the Father the Spirit of truth. If I depart, 4I will send him unto you. Since he by the right hand of God hath been exalted, 5and hath received of his Father the promise of the holy Ghost, he hath shed forth this which ye now see and hear. Wherefore the Son also giveth him, but in this order, that the Son sendeth him from the Father; whence is gathered a strong argument for proof of Christs God-head: for who giveth the Spirit of God, and who hath any right or title unto him, but God? for the humane nature of Christ, so far off is it that it should have this right and power to send the holy Ghost, that contrarily it self was hallowed and sanctified by the holy Ghost.6 Now we are to understand this giving of the holy Ghost by the Father and the Son, as that both of them is effectual and forcible by him, and that the holy Ghost worketh on a precedency of the will of the Father and the Son: For we are to mark and observe the order of operation or working in the persons of the Divinity, which is such in working as it is in subsisting; the Fathers will goeth before, the will of the Son followeth, and the will of the holy Ghost followeth them both, yet not in time, but in order.7 The cause wherefore he giveth us the holy Ghost, is none other but only of his free election, through the merit and intercession of his Son:8 Which hath blessed us with all spiritual blessings in heavenly things in Christ, as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world. 9I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter.
1HEe is given of the Father and the Son, and also by the Son of the Father, but not by the Father: for the Father giveth the holy Ghost from no other, but from himself as who is of no other but of himself, neither worketh from any other but from himself: The Son giveth the holy Ghost from the Father, from whom also himself both worketh and is. That he is given of and from the Father,2 these testimonies do confirm: Hee commandeth them to wait for the promise of the Father. I will powr out of my spirit upon all flesh. I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter. 3The Father will send him in my name. That the holy Ghost is given of the Son, these testimonies do prove: I will send you from the Father the Spirit of truth. If I depart, 4I will send him unto you. Since he by the right hand of God hath been exalted, 5and hath received of his Father the promise of the holy Ghost, he hath shed forth this which ye now see and hear. Wherefore the Son also giveth him, but in this order, that the Son sendeth him from the Father; whence is gathered a strong argument for proof of Christs God-head: for who giveth the Spirit of God, and who hath any right or title unto him, but God? for the humane nature of Christ, so far off is it that it should have this right and power to send the holy Ghost, that contrarily it self was hallowed and sanctified by the holy Ghost.6 Now we are to understand this giving of the holy Ghost by the Father and the Son, as that both of them is effectuall and forcible by him, and that the holy Ghost worketh on a precedency of the will of the Father and the Son: For wee are to mark and observe the order of operation or working in the persons of the Divinity, which is such in working as it is in subsisting; the Fathers will goeth before, the will of the Son followeth, and the will of the holy Ghost followeth them both, yet not in time, but in order.7 The cause wherefore he giveth us the holy Ghost, is none other but only of his free election, through the merit and intercession of his Son:8 Which hath blessed us with all spirituall blessings in heavenly things in Christ, as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world.
The Son giveth us him, or he is given by the Son, because he hath obtained for us by his merit that he should be given unto us, and he by his own intercession bestoweth him on us.
The Son giveth us him, or he is given by the Son, because hee hath obtained for us by his merit that hee should be given unto us, and he by his own intercession bestoweth him on us.
1The holy Ghost is said to be given unto them to whom he communicateth his gifts, and who acknowledge him. Wherefore the holy Ghost is given to divers parties, according to diverse gifts. He is given to the whole Church or assembly of those that are called; that is, both to the elect, and to hypocrites; but in a diverse manner to the one and the other: To the elect he is given, not only as concerning his common gifts, but also as concerning his proper and saving graces: that is, not only as concerning the knowledge of Gods doctrine, but also as concerning regeneration, faith, and conversion: because, besides that he kindleth in them the knowledge of Gods truth and will, he doth further also regenerate them, and endow them with true faith and conversion. He is therefore so given unto them, that he worketh and effectuateth in them his gifts of their salvation, and that themselves ⟨p. 344⟩also may know and feel by those gifts imparted unto them, the holy Ghost dwelling in them. And further, he is no otherwise given unto them then as themselves also be willing and desirous of him; and then is augmented and increased in them if they persevere.2 But to hypocrites the holy Ghost is given only as touching the knowledge of doctrine, and other his common and general gifts: The world cannot receive him, because it seeth him not, neither knoweth him. Hence it is apparent, how the knowledge of tongues, sciences, and the like gifts bestowed on the heathen, differ from those which are bestowed on the Church: for they, who amongst the heathen excelled in the knowledge of tongues, and good arts, and things profitable, had indeed the gifts of God, but not the holy Ghost; whom none are said to have, but they whom he hath sanctified, and who acknowledge him to be the author of the gifts received.
1THe holy Ghost is said to be given unto them to whom he communicateth his gifts, and who acknowledge him. Wherefore the holy Ghost is given to divers parties, according to diverse gifts. He is given to the whole Church or assembly of those that are called; that is, both to the elect, and to hypocrites; but in a diverse manner to the one and the other: To the elect he is given, not only as concerning his common gifts, but also as concerning his proper and saving graces: that is, not only as concerning the knowledge of Gods doctrine, but also as concerning regeneration, faith, and conversion: because, besides that he kindleth in them the knowledge of Gods truth and will, hee doth further also regenerate them, and endow them with true faith and conversion. Hee is therefore so given unto them, that he worketh and effectuateth in them his gifts of their salvation, and that themselves ⟨p. 344⟩also may know and feel by those gifts imparted unto them, the holy Ghost dwelling in them. And further, he is no otherwise given unto them then as themselves also be willing and desirous of him; and then is augmented and increased in them if they persevere.2 But to hypocrites the holy Ghost is given only as touching the knowledge of doctrine, and other his common and generall gifts: The world cannot receive him, because it seeth him not, neither knoweth him. Hence it is apparent, how the knowledge of tongues, sciences, and the like gifts bestowed on the heathen, differ from those which are bestowed on the Church: for they, who amongst the heathen excelled in the knowledge of tongues, and good arts, and things profitable, had indeed the gifts of God, but not the holy Ghost; whom none are said to have, but they whom he hath sanctified, and who acknowledge him to be the author of the gifts received.
1The holy Ghost is then given when he imparteth or communicateth his gifts, as hath been already proved. And he is given either visibly, when he bestoweth his gifts adjoining outward signs and tokens; or invisibly, when he bestoweth his gifts without signs or tokens. He was not always given visibly, but at certain times, and for certain causes: yet was he more plentifully poured on men in the time of the new Testament, then before in the time of the old; for so had Joel prophesied:2 In the last days I will pour out of my Spirit. So he was given visibly unto the Apostles and others in the primitive Church:3 There appeared unto them cloven tongues like fire, and it sate upon each of them. The holy Ghost fell on all them which heard the word. I saw the holy Ghost come down from heaven, &c. And these and other like speeches are so to be expounded, as that the sign taketh the name of the thing it self; and therefore that is affirmed of the thing which agreeth unto the sign; by which sign the holy Ghost witnesseth his presence and efficacy. So also John saw the holy Ghost descending on Christ in bodily shape like a dove: 4He saw then the shape of a dove, under which God showed the presence of his Spirit. Wherefore we must not think that there is any local motion in God,5 but his presence and operation, which he showeth and exerciseth in the Church: For the holy Ghost is spread abroad every-where, and filleth both heaven and earth; in which respect he is said to be given, sent, poured out, when by his effectual and forcible presence he doth create, stir up, and by little and little perfect his gifts in the members of the Church.6 He always was and is given unto the Church invisibly, from the beginning unto the end of the world; for he spake by the prophets: and he which hath not the Spirit of Christ is none of his: 7yea, without the holy Ghost there never had been,8 never should be any Church. He is given after an ordinary way by the ministry of the word, and by the use of the Sacraments; and 1. In manifesting himself unto us through the studying and meditation of the doctrine of the Gospel: for when he is known of us, he will communicate himself unto us; and when he showeth himself to be known of us, he doth also renew and reform our hearts: So did he work in the elect by Peters sermon in the day of Pentecost:9
1THe holy Ghost is then given when he imparteth or communicateth his gifts, as hath been already proved. And he is given either visibly, when he bestoweth his gifts adjoyning outward signes and tokens; or invisibly, when he bestoweth his gifts without signes or tokens. Hee was not alwayes given visibly, but at certain times, and for certain causes: yet was he more plentifully powred on men in the time of the new Testament, then before in the time of the old; for so had Joel prophecied:2 In the last dayes I will powr out of my Spirit. So hee was given visibly unto the Apostles and others in the primitive Church:3 There appeared unto them cloven tongues like fire, and it sate upon each of them. The holy Ghost fell on all them which heard the word. I saw the holy Ghost come down from heaven, &c. And these and other like speeches are so to be expounded, as that the signe taketh the name of the thing it selfe; and therefore that is affirmed of the thing which agreeth unto the signe; by which signe the holy Ghost witnesseth his presence and efficacy. So also John saw the holy Ghost descending on Christ in bodily shape like a dove: 4Hee saw then the shape of a dove, under which God shewed the presence of his Spirit. Wherefore we must not think that there is any locall motion in God,5 but his presence and operation, which hee sheweth and exerciseth in the Church: For the holy Ghost is spread abroad every-where, and filleth both heaven and earth; in which respect hee is said to be given, sent, powred out, when by his effectuall and forcible presence he doth create, stir up, and by little and little perfect his gifts in the members of the Church.6 He alwayes was and is given unto the Church invisibly, from the beginning unto the end of the world; for hee spake by the prophets: and hee which hath not the Spirit of Christ is none of his: 7yea, without the holy Ghost there never had been,8 never should be any Church. Hee is given after an ordinary way by the ministery of the word, and by the use of the Sacraments; and 1. In manifesting himselfe unto us through the studying and meditation of the doctrine of the Gospel: for when he is known of us, he will communicate himself unto us; and when hee sheweth himself to be known of us, hee doth also renew and reform our hearts: So did hee work in the elect by Peters sermon in the day of Pentecost:
Likewise he wrought in Cornelius and the rest there present by the same Peter speaking. But yet notwithstanding he doth so work by the word and sacraments as that he is not tied to those means: 1for he converted Paul in his journey, and he furnished John Baptist with his gifts in his womb. Now when we say, he is given by the ministry of the word and sacraments, we mean this of persons of a competent age, and repute this way for ordinary, and speak of that visible sending of the holy Ghost, whereby several men in the Church partake of his accustomed or ordinary gifts,2 and whereof it is said, He hath sent the Spirit of his Son into your hearts &c. He which hath not the Spirit of Christ is none of his. 2. He is given by working a desire of him in the elect:3 for he is given to them that desire him. Hence is drawn a forcible argument to prove the God-head of the holy Ghost: for to work effectually by the ministry is proper to God only:4 Neither is he that planteth ⟨p. 345⟩any thing, neither he that watereth, but God that giveth the increase. 5I baptise you with water to amendment of life: but he that cometh after me, will baptise you with the holy Ghost, and with fire. The Gospel is the power of God, 6because the holy Ghost is forcible in working by it: whereupon also the Gospel is called the ministration of the spirit. 7Now the holy Ghost is received by faith. Wherein also after that ye believed, 8ye were sealed with the holy Spirit of promise. The world cannot receive the Spirit of truth, because it neither seeth him, nor knoweth him. Object. But faith is the gift and fruit of the holy Ghost. 9By grace are ye saved through faith, and that not of your selves: it is the gift of God. No man can say, that Jesus is the Lord, but by the holy Ghost: 10Therefore the holy Ghost goeth before faith: How then is he said to be received by faith? Answ. 1. The working of the spirit is in order of nature before faith, but in time both are together: because the first beginning of faith is the receiving of the holy Ghost. 2. Faith being once begun, the holy Ghost is more and more received,11 who worketh afterwards other things in us by faith. As it is said, Faith worketh by love. By faith mens hearts are purified.
Likewise he wrought in Cornelius and the rest there present by the same Peter speaking. But yet notwithstanding hee doth so work by the word and sacraments as that hee is not tied to those means: 1for hee converted Paul in his journey, and hee furnished John Baptist with his gifts in his wombe. Now when wee say, hee is given by the ministery of the word and sacraments, we mean this of persons of a competent age, and repute this way for ordinary, and speak of that visible sending of the holy Ghost, whereby severall men in the Church partake of his accustomed or ordinary gifts,2 and whereof it is said, Hee hath sent the Spirit of his Son into your hearts &c. He which hath not the Spirit of Christ is none of his. 2. He is given by working a desire of him in the elect:3 for hee is given to them that desire him. Hence is drawn a forcible argument to prove the God-head of the holy Ghost: for to work effectually by the ministery is proper to God only:4 Neither is he that planteth ⟨p. 345⟩any thing, neither he that watereth, but God that giveth the increase. 5I baptise you with water to amendment of life: but he that cometh after me, will baptise you with the holy Ghost, and with fire. The Gospel is the power of God, 6because the holy Ghost is forcible in working by it: whereupon also the Gospel is called the ministration of the spirit. 7Now the holy Ghost is received by faith. Wherin also after that ye beleeved, 8ye were sealed with the holy Spirit of promise. The world cannot receive the Spirit of truth, because it neither seeth him, nor knoweth him. Object. But faith is the gift and fruit of the holy Ghost. 9By grace are ye saved through faith, and that not of your selves: it is the gift of God. No man can say, that Jesus is the Lord, but by the holy Ghost:
The holy Ghost is retained and kept for the most part by the same means by which it is given and received. §11. By diligent use of the Ecclesiastical Ministry. He gave some to be Apostles, 1some to be Prophets for the edification of the body of Christ, till we all meet together in the unity of faith. §22. By meditation in the doctrine of the Gospel, and by studying to profit therein.2 He that doth meditate in the Law of the Lord day and night, shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of waters, that will bring forth her fruit in due season. Let the word of Christ dwell in you plenteously in all wisdom, 3teaching and admonishing your selves. §33. He is kept by increase and continuance, and amendment of life: that is, by a desire of bewaring to offend against our conscience. Unto him that hath, shall be given. He that is righteous, let him be righteous still. 4Grieve not the holy Spirit of God, by whom ye are sealed unto the day of redemption. Hither may be referred a desire of avoiding evil company and sin. For he that will avoid sin, must avoid all occasion of sinning. §44. He is retained by daily and earnest prayer and invocation.5 How much more shall your heavenly Father give the holy Ghost to them that desire him? This kind is not cast out but by prayer and fasting. The same may we see in that panoply or complete harness, which the Apostle describeth. Likewise,6 it is confirmed by the example of David, who prayeth,7 That God will not take his holy Spirit from him. §55. He is retained by applying Gods gifts to their right use, that is, to his glory, and to the safety of our neighbour. And when thou art converted,8 confirm thy brethren. Unto every man that hath, it shall be given; and from him that hath not, even that he hath shall be taken away.
THe holy Ghost is retained and kept for the most part by the same meanes by which it is given and received. §11. By diligent use of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery. He gave some to be Apostles, 1some to be Prophets for the edification of the body of Christ, till we all meet together in the unity of faith. §22. By meditation in the doctrine of the Gospel, and by studying to profit therein.2 He that doth meditate in the Law of the Lord day and night, shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of waters, that will bring forth her fruit in due season. Let the word of Christ dwell in you plenteously in all wisdome, 3teaching and admonishing your selves. §33. He is kept by increase and continuance, and amendment of life: that is, by a desire of bewaring to offend against our conscience. Unto him that hath, shall be given. He that is righteous, let him be righteous still. 4Grieve not the holy Spirit of God, by whom yee are sealed unto the day of redemption. Hither may be referred a desire of avoiding evill company and sin. For he that will avoid sin, must avoid all occasion of sinning. §44. He is retained by daily and earnest prayer and invocation.5 How much more shall your heavenly Father give the holy Ghost to them that desire him? This kind is not cast out but by prayer and fasting. The same may we see in that panoply or complete harnesse, which the Apostle describeth. Likewise,6 it is confirmed by the example of David, who prayeth,7 That God will not take his holy Spirit from him. §55. He is retained by applying Gods gifts to their right use, that is, to his glory, and to the safety of our neighbour. And when thou art converted,8
1HE may be lost of Hypocrites and Reprobates finally: that is, so as they shall never recover him: and totally; that is, so that they shall retain none of his graces. Of the Elect, he is never wholly lost, but only as touching many gifts: because they always retain some gifts, as Davids example testifieth unto us, who said; Restore to me the joy of thy salvation. Take not thine holy spirit from me. 2Neither is he finally lost of the Elect, because at length they return to repentance. But of the Reprobate he is altogether or wholly lost, and finally; so that they never receive him. Object. But the holy Ghost departed from Saul: Therefore he may also depart from the Elect. Ans. He departed from Saul; but not the spirit of regeneration; for he never had him: only the spirit of prophecy, prudence, courage, and other gifts, wherewith he was richly endowed, left and forsook him. For he was elect and chosen, not unto life, but unto the Kingdom, as Judas was unto an Apostleship. Repl. Yea, but the regenerating spirit also departeth; because David prayeth, 3Restore to me the joy of thy salvation. Ans. He is lost oftentimes, as concerning some gifts of regeneration, but not wholly. For it cannot possibly be, that the godly should retain no remnants; ⟨p. 346⟩seeing they do not sin to death, but only of the infirmity of their flesh, inasmuch as they are not yet borne again. This Saint John teacheth expressly, saying; Whosoever is borne of God, sinneth not: for his seed remaineth in him, neither can be sin, because he is borne of God. David in his fall lost the joy of his heart, the purity of conscience, and many other gifts, which he coveteth to have restored unto him. But the holy Ghost he had not utterly lost: for if so, how then could he have said, Take not thine holy spirit from me? wherefore he had not utterly lost him. A man (saith Bernard) never abideth in the same state: either he goeth backward or forward. For this difference is to be observed and held for the assoiling of that question; How namely the perseverance of the Elect may be notwithstanding certain, albeit they lose the holy Ghost: which is, because they are never wholly and finally destitute of the holy Ghost.4 Now the holy Ghost may be lost five ways, and those contrary to those other means, whereby he is retained: §11. By contempt of the Ecclesiastical Ministry. §22.
1HE may be lost of Hypocrites and Reprobates finally: that is, so as they shall never recover him: and totally; that is, so that they shall retaine none of his graces. Of the Elect, he is never wholly lost, but onely as touching many gifts: because they alwayes retaine some gifts, as Davids example testifieth unto us, who said; Restore to me the joy of thy salvation. Take not thine holy spirit from me. 2Neither is he finally lost of the Elect, because at length they return to repentance. But of the Reprobate he is altogether or wholly lost, and finally; so that they never receive him. Object. But the holy Ghost departed from Saul: Therefore he may also depart from the Elect. Ans. He departed from Saul; but not the spirit of regeneration; for he never had him: only the spirit of prophecy, prudence, courage, and other gifts, wherewith he was richly indowed, left and forsooke him. For he was elect and chosen, not unto life, but unto the Kingdome, as Judas was unto an Apostleship. Repl. Yea, but the regenerating spirit also departeth; because David prayeth, 3Restore to me the joy of thy salvation. Ans. He is lost oftentimes, as concerning some gifts of regeneration, but not wholly. For it cannot possibly be, that the godly should retaine no remnants; ⟨p. 346⟩seeing they doe not sinne to death, but only of the infirmity of their flesh, inasmuch as they are not yet borne againe. This Saint John teacheth expresly, saying; Whosoever is borne of God, sinneth not: for his seed remaineth in him, neither can be sinne, because he is borne of God. David in his fall lost the joy of his heart, the purity of conscience, and many other gifts, which he coveteth to have restored unto him. But the holy Ghost he had not utterly lost: for if so, how then could he have said, Take not thine holy spirit from me? wherefore he had not utterly lost him. A man (saith Bernard) never abideth in the same state: either he goeth backward or forward. For this difference is to be observed and held for the assoiling of that question; How namely the perseverance of the Elect may be notwithstanding certaine, albeit they lose the holy Ghost: which is, because they are never wholly and finally destitute of the holy Ghost.4 Now the holy Ghost may be lost five wayes, and those contrary to those other meanes, whereby he is retained: §11. By contempt of the Ecclesiasticall Ministery. §2