The Explication.
pp. 436–45582 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 436–45582 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This general precept, without any special exception or expectation of any particular injunction, should no less bind us all unto obedience, and to the adoring of Christ in the bread, if we had any evident proof of his invisible existence therein, than if we beheld him present with our eyes. Thus Thomas expecteth not some special express warrant, but doth well in worshipping towards the place where he seeth Christ standing, saying; My Lord, and my God. Wherefore,1 as long as the opinion of corporal presence standeth, so long the Papists idolatrous adoration and oblation, and their whole Mass must needs stand also. For the Papists themselves will not have, that we understand their offering of Christ in the Mass of any slaughtering or murdering him, but only of a public showing him being there corporally present, and of a craving and obtaining remission of sins for his sake, whom the Priests bear in their hands, and present unto God the Father.
This generall precept, without any speciall exception or expectation of any particular injunction, should no lesse binde us all unto obedience, and to the adoring of Christ in the bread, if we had any evident proofe of his invisible existence therein, than if we beheld him present with our eyes. Thus Thomas expecteth not some speciall expresse warrant, but doth well in worshipping towards the place where he seeth Christ standing, saying; My Lord, and my God. Wherefore,1 as long as the opinion of corporall presence standeth, so long the Papists idolatrous adoration and oblation, and their whole Masse must needs stand also. For the Papists themselves will not have, that we understand their offering of Christ in the Masse of any slaughtering or murthering him, but only of a publique shewing him being there corporally present, and of a craving and obtaining remission of sinnes for his sake, whom the Priests beare in their hands, and present unto God the Father.
1. Like phrases have a like sense and interpretation. But all these phrases are accounted for like; namely, for sacramental forms of speech, wherein the names or proper effects of the things signified, are attributed to the sign: as, Circumcision is the Govenant of God. The Lamb is the Passover of the Lord. 1The Sabbath is the Covenant of the Lord. The Levitical sacrifices are an expiation or doing away of sin. The blood of sacrifices is the blood of the Covenant. The covering of the Ark is the mercy seat. The Rock was Christ. The bread is the body of Christ. The cup is the New Testament. Baptism washeth away sin. Baptism is the washing of the new birth. Baptism saveth us, &c. Therefore their interpretation is alike. Now God himself interpreteth some of them thus; Circumcision is a sign of the Covenant. The Lamb is a sign and memorial of the Passover. The Sabbath is a sign of the Covenant: Therefore we may justly interpret the rest on the same manner. The Levitical sacrifices signify the atonement for sins, made by the Messiah. The blood of sacrifices is a Sacrament ⟨p. 446⟩or sign confirming the Covenant; or a sign of Christs blood, whereby the Covenant was established. The covering of the Ark signifieth the Mercy-seat. The Rock signifieth Christ. The bread is a Sacrament of the body of Christ. The cup is a Sacrament sealing the new Covenant. Baptism is a Sacrament of the washing away of sins, and of our regeneration and salvation.
1. LIke phrases have a like sense and interpretation. But all these phrases are accounted for like; namely, for sacramentall formes of speech, wherein the names or proper effects of the things signified, are attributed to the signe: as, Circumcision is the Govenant of God. The Lamb is the Passeover of the Lord. 1The Sabbath is the Covenant of the Lord. The Leviticall sacrifices are an expiation or doing away of sinne. The bloud of sacrifices is the bloud of the Covenant. The covering of the Arke is the mercy seate. The Rock was Christ. The bread is the body of Christ. The cup is the New Testament. Baptisme washeth away sinne. Baptisme is the washing of the new birth. Baptisme saveth us, &c. Therefore their interpretation is alike. Now God himselfe interpreteth some of them thus; Circumcision is a signe of the Covenant. The Lamb is a signe and memoriall of the Passeover. The Sabbath is a signe of the Covenant: Therefore we may justly interpret the rest on the same manner. The Leviticall sacrifices signifie the attonement for sinnes, made by the Messias. The bloud of sacrifices is a Sacrament
2. As the cup is the New Testament, so is the blood of Christ the New Testament. The cup is the New Testament Sacramentally; that is, it is a sign of the New Testament: Therefore Christs blood is a sign of the New Testament. The Major is apparent, because without doubt the words of Luke and Paul, This cup is the New Testament in my blood; and the words of Matthew and Mark, This is my blood of the New Testament, have all one meaning. The Minor is proved before in the first argument, and cannot be taken otherwise. For the New Testament is no external thing or ceremony, but a free reconciliation with God, promised in the Gospel, through the blood and death of Christ. The cup then is either the thing promised, or the seal of the promise; but it is not the promise, nor the thing promised: Therefore it is the seal of the promise.
2. As the cup is the New Testament, so is the bloud of Christ the New Testament. The cup is the New Testament Sacramentally; that is, it is a signe of the New Testament: Therefore Christs bloud is a signe of the New Testament. The Major is apparent, because without doubt the words of Luke and Paul, This cup is the New Testament in my bloud; and the words of Matthew and Marke, This is my bloud of the New Testament, have all one meaning. The Minor is proved before in the first argument, and cannot be taken otherwise. For the New Testament is no externall thing or ceremony, but a free reconciliation with God, promised in the Gospel, through the bloud and death of Christ. The cup then is either the thing promised, or the seale of the promise; but it is not the promise, nor the thing promised: Therefore it is the seale of the promise.
3. The bread which we break (saith the Apostle) is it not the communion of the body of Christ? As bread is the communion of the body of Christ, so also it is the body of Christ. The reason is clear, because Pauls words and Christs have both one meaning; seeing Paul interpreteth Christ. But the bread is the communion of the body of Christ sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or sign of our spiritual communion with Christs body. For properly and literally, bread cannot be termed a communion: Therefore, bread also is Christs body sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or sign of Christs body. Now that the communion or communication of Christs body is spiritual, is thus proved: 1. Paul speaketh of such a communion, as whereby we being many, are made one bread, one body. But we being many, are one body spiritually: Therefore the communion mentioned of Paul is spiritual. 2. The communion of Christ, whereof he speaketh, cannot stand with the communion of Devils:1 Ye cannot (saith he) drink the cup of the Lord, and the cup of the Devils: ye cannot be partakers of the Lords Table, and of the table of the Devils. The argument is not deduced from an inconvenience or an undecency, as some fondly tell us,2 but from an impossibility: as that of Christ, Ye cannot serve God and Mammon. Where the words [Greek or Hebrew], ye are not able; or, ye have no possibility, are likewise used, as well as in this place:3 and as that of the same Apostle else-where; What concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath the Believer with the Infidel? 3. This communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, is spiritually expounded in Scripture,4 Our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ. If we say, that we have fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lye, and do not truly. But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin. Neither do we in the Creed believe any other communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, but that which is spiritual. 54. Lastly, Chrysostom interpreteth Pauls words of a spiritual communion. Why said he not participation? That he might manifest unto thee somewhat more excellent then it, to wit, the strongest and mightiest union that can be.
And a little after, Why call I it communion? Yea, we are the self-same body of Christ. What is the bread? even the body of Christ. What are they made, who receive the body of Christ? not many bodies, but one body. For as the bread is kneaded of many grains, so we also are joined with Christ.
And a little after, Why call I it communion? Yea, we are the selfe-same body of Christ. What is the bread? even the body of Christ. What are they made, who receive the body of Christ? not many bodies, but one body. For as the bread is kneaded of many graines, so we also are joyned with Christ.
4. Out of the words of Christ:1 What then if ye should see the Son of man ascend up where he was before? It is the Spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing: the words that I speak unto you are spirit and life. In these words Christ expressly rejecteth all eating of his flesh with our mouths, and overthroweth by two arguments, which we have heretofore declared: and on the other side he approveth and confirmeth our spiritual eating his flesh. Wherefore we may not forge any corporal eating of Christs body in the Supper, when such a kind of eating is precisely reproved in the Gospel. Object. The sixth chapter of John treateth not of the Supper: ⟨p. 447⟩Therefore this testimony maketh nought against the eating of Christs body with our mouths instituted in the Supper. Answ. Here our Adversaries deceitfully argue from the denial of a part, to the denial of the whole. This Chapter, we grant, pertaineth not to the Ceremony of the Supper: But hence it followeth not, that simply it pertaineth not to the Supper. For it concerneth the promise; This is my body, which is given for you: because this promise is desumed out of this Christs Sermon registered in this sixth of John, and is ratified and confirmed by the signs of bread and wine. Wherefore it cannot be understood of any other eating of Christs body in the Supper, then of that which is delivered in the sixth of John, which is spiritual. For, bodily eating is in that Sermon condemned. Repl. It is not simply the eating with the mouth that is there condemned, but a Capernaiticall eating. Answ. All eating with the mouth is Capernaiticall. For, a Capernaiticall eating is not a bloody renting only and eating of Christs flesh, and chewing it between the teeth, but simply any eating with the mouth. For the Capernaites say not among themselves: How can this man give us his flesh to devour, to gnaw on with our teeth, to rend asunder? &c. But they say: How can this man give us his flesh to eat? 2Neither doth Christ re-call them from a gross eating with the mouth, to a subtle kind of eating with the mouth; but to his ascension into Heaven, which should shortly come to pass, and thereby his body should be far removed from their mouths, and trained them to a spiritual eating, which is with the heart by faith.
4. Out of the words of Christ:
5. Out of the same sixth Chapter of John, To eat Christs flesh, and, To drink his blood, signifieth, To believe in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, 1To have Christ dwelling in us: as appeareth, because he attributeth the same effect of eternal life to both; namely, to the eating of his flesh, and to faith in him: But in the Supper this eating is authorised: (For no other purpose besides this can be showed in the whole Gospel, for sealing whereof the Supper was instituted.) Therefore, To eat Christs body, and, To drink his blood, is, To believe in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, To have him dwelling in us.
5. Out of the same sixth Chapter of John, To eate Christs flesh, and, To drinke his bloud, signifieth, To beleeve in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, 1To have Christ dwelling in us: as appeareth, because he attributeth the same effect of eternall life to both; namely, to the eating of his flesh, and to faith in him: But in the Supper this eating is authorised: (For no other purpose besides this can be shewed in the whole Gospel, for sealing whereof the Supper was instituted.) Therefore, To eate Christs body, and, To drink his blood, is, To beleeve in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, To have him dwelling in us.
6. By one spirit are we all baptised into one body, whether we be Jews or Grecians, 1whether we be bond or free, and have been all made to drink into one spirit. Hence we draw two arguments: 1. Such as is the drinking of Christ, such is the eating of him in the Supper. The drinking of him is spiritual: Therefore the eating of him is spiritual. 2. The eating of Christs body, and drinking his blood, is common to all the faithful, even to the Fathers of the Old Testament. For we have all bin made to drink into one spirit. But the eating with the mouth is not common to all the faithful: (For the Fathers before Christs birth could not, and at this day Infants, and many of ripe years, having not liberty to partake of the Supper, cannot eat his flesh with their mouths.) Wherefore, this mouthy eating of Christs flesh, urged by our Adversaries, is not that true eating which the Gospel promiseth, and which the Supper sealeth.
6. By one spirit are we all baptised into one body, whether we be Jews or Grecians, 1whether we be bond or free, and have beene all made to drink into one spirit. Hence we draw two arguments: 1. Such as is the drinking of Christ, such is the eating of him in the Supper. The drinking of him is spirituall: Therefore the eating of him is spirituall. 2. The eating of Christs body, and drinking his bloud, is common to all the faithfull, even to the Fathers of the Old Testament. For we have all bin made to drink into one spirit. But the eating with the mouth is not common to all the faithfull: (For the Fathers before Christs birth could not, and at this day Infants, and many of ripe yeeres, having not liberty to partake of the Supper, cannot eate his flesh with their mouthes.) Wherefore, this mouthy eating of Christs flesh, urged by our Adversaries, is not that true eating which the Gospel promiseth, and which the Supper sealeth.
Unto these arguments drawn out of the sacred Scripture, and the ground of our faith, may be added testimonies of the Fathers, and the purer Church; who, if we look into their writings, we shall find, that they plainly teach the same doctrine touching the Lords holy Supper, which we do. Among many we will produce only some few notable and clear in this point. Irenaeus saith,1 The earthly bread, taking his name from the word of God, is no longer common bread, but becometh the Eucharist or Sacrament, which consisteth of two things; an earthly, and an heavenly thing. Tertullian, The bread which he took and distributed among his Disciples, he made it his body, saying, This is my body; that is, The figure of my body.2 Clemens of Alexandria, This is to drink Christs blood, to be partaker of Christs immortality. Cyprian, Neither can his blood, wherewith we are redeemed and justified, seem to be in the Chalice, when the wine faileth in the Chalice, wherein Christs blood is showed, which is spoken of in every Sacrament and testimony of Scripture. Again, the same Father saith, As often as ⟨p. 448⟩we do this, we sharpen not our teeth to bite withal, but we break and part the sanctified bread with a sincere faith, whilst we distinguish and separate that which is divine, from that which is humane, and joining them again after their separation, confess one God and man: yea, we our selves are made his body by this Sacrament, and knit and united to our head by the thing signified by the Sacrament. 3The Canon of the Nicene Council: Again, here also is the Lords Table: Let us not childishly cleave to the bread and wine set before us, but lifting up our minds on high, by faith, let us consider, that on that Table is set the Lamb of God taking away the sins of the world, which is offered of the Priests without killing: and let us, truly receiving his precious body and blood, believe that they are SIGNS of our resurrection. For therefore we receive not much, but little; thereby to acknowledge that it is not received to satisfy, 4but to sanctify us. Basil: We have set on the Table the figures of the sacred body and blood. Hillary: The bread and wine received, and drunk, effect and work that both we are in Christ,
being mindful thereof, in eating, and drinking we Signify, (or Represent) the flesh and blood that were offered up for us. 1Again, This oblation is the FIGURE OF THE BODY AND BLOOD of our LORD Jesus CHRIST. Augustine: Our Lord doubted not to say, This is my body, when he gave a TOKEN of his body. Again, The Lord admitted Judas to that banquet, wherein he ministered and gave to his disciples the FIGURE of his body and blood. The same Father saith: Unless Sacraments had a certain likeness of the things, whereof they be Sacraments, without question they were no Sacraments. And in consideration of this likeness, oftentimes they bear the names of the things themselves. As therefore the Sacrament of the body of CHRIST is AFTER A CERTAIN MANNER the body of Christ: and the Sacrament of Christs blood is his blood: so the Sacrament of faith is faith. 2Again, As then the celestial bread, Christs flesh, is IN SOME SORT called Christs body, whereas indeed it is a Sacrament of Christs body; namely, that visible, palpable, and mortal body which was nailed on the Cross, and the sacrificing of his flesh, done by the hands of the Minister, is called Christs Passion, death, and crucifying, NOT IN THE TRUTH OF THE THING, but in a mystery SIGNIFYING it: So the Sacrament of faith, by which is meant Baptism, is faith. 3Also: These, my brethren, are therefore called Sacraments, because in them one thing is seen, another understood. That which is seen hath a bodily form: that which is understood, hath a spiritual fruit or benefit. 4Chrysostom: This is my blood, which is shed for the remission of sins; which Christ said, to show that his Passion and Cross was a mystery, and to comfort his disciples. 5Theodoret: Our Saviour verily changed the names of the signs and the things signified, and gave the same name to the body, which is proper to the sign; and that to the sign which is proper to the body. The cause of this change is manifest to them that are entered into the first principles of divine mysteries. For he would that they who use the Sacraments should not bend and set their minds on the nature of the things which are seen, but, for the alteration of the names, should believe that alteration which is made through grace.
For he who termed that by name of corn and bread, which is by nature a body, and called himself a vine, he honoured the signs, which are seen, with the title and name of his body and blood, not by changing the nature, but by adding grace to the nature. Macarius the Monk hath a famous saying to this purpose:1 Bread and wine are a correspondent type of his flesh, and they who receive the bread which is showed, eat the flesh of Christ spiritually. Other testimonies for briefness sake we omit.
For he who tearmed that by name of corne and bread, which is by nature a body, and called himselfe a vine, he honoured the signes, which are seene, with the title and name of his body and bloud, not by changing the nature, but by adding grace to the nature. Macarius the Monke hath a famous saying to this purpose:1 Bread and wine are a correspondent type of his flesh, and they who receive the bread which is shewed, eate the flesh of Christ spiritually. Other testimonies for briefenesse sake we omit.
Now it is easy to see what we are to think of Transubstantiation, even that it is an impious invention and device of the Papists: which also we will show and prove briefly by divers reasons. But first we must declare in a word what the Papists properly mean by their Transubstantiation. They suppose that by force of Consecration; that is, of uttering these words upon the creatures of bread and wine, This is my body, This is the cup of the new Testament in my blood, the bread and wine is substantially ⟨p. 449⟩converted or turned into the body and blood of Christ, the forms only or accidents of bread and wine remaining; namely, the shape or figure, the heat, the taste, the weight, &c. They therefore call these words of Consecration, operatorie, and effective, able to work and effect the conversion and change: and they say, that the change is fully accomplished in the very last instant of uttering the syllable* DY, This is my boDY: and then there is no longer bread and wine, but the body and blood of Christ is present, and is contained under the forms of bread and wine, and is eaten and drunk in the Eucharist or Supper by the mouth of the Communicants. Concerning the manner of the change, it is not agreed on by all. Some say, that the substance of bread and wine is by Transubstantiation changed into the substance of Christs body and blood: so that the bread and wine is essentially made the very body and blood of Christ, the external forms only remaining; and this they term a substantial change, or change of the substance.2 Others are of opinion that the substance of bread and wine is not changed, but vanisheth by annihilation, or by being brought to nothing; and that then the substance of Christs body and blood succeedeth in place thereof; so that the substance of Christs body and blood after the consecration, cometh under these forms and accidents, under which before was the substance of the bread and wine: And this they call a formal change, or a change of forms. Lombard in his Sentences expoundeth both these opinions,3 and seemeth to approve the former alone. Howbeit they call both these changes by the name of Transubstantiation.
NOw it is easie to see what we are to think of Transubstantiation, even that it is an impious invention and device of the Papists: which also we will shew and prove briefly by divers reasons. But first we must declare in a word what the Papists properly meane by their Transubstantiation. They suppose that by force of Consecration; that is, of uttering these words upon the creatures of bread and wine, This is my body, This is the cup of the new Testament in my bloud, the bread and wine is substantially
They affirm also that the particle This, in the words of consecration, doth note some indeterminate substance in general (as they use to speak) without quantity or quality, contained under those accidents, so that it demonstrateth unto us neither bread, nor Christs body, but only something contained under the forms and accidents, which before Consecration was bread, but by vigour and force of the words of Consecration, began to be the body of Christ: so that the meaning is on this wise; This is my body, that is,1 that which is contained under this, or these forms, is my body. Touching the accidents, where they are grounded and seated, whether in the body of Christ, or in the air, or in the surface of the bread and wine, or in nothing, they curiously and diversely dispute; and the common received opinion is, that they are existent without any subject. This is the doctrine of the School-men and all Papists, whereof (as we see) there are two main heads: one of Transubstantiation, another of eating Christs body with the mouth. But each of them is a false profane forgery, utterly repugnant with the words of Christ. As for the later of these, it is overthrown and refuted by the same arguments whereby we have already proved the spiritual eating of Christs body; and Transubstantiation is thus oppugned:
They affirm also that the particle This, in the words of consecration, doth note some indeterminate substance in generall (as they use to speak) without quantity or quality, contained under those accidents, so that it demonstrateth unto us neither bread, nor Christs body, but only something contained under the formes and accidents, which before Consecration was bread, but by vigour and force of the words of Consecration, began to be the body of Christ: so that the meaning is on this wise; This is my body, that is,1 that which is contained under this, or these formes, is my body. Touching the accidents, where they are grounded and seated, whether in the body of Christ, or in the aire, or in the surface of the bread and wine, or in nothing, they curiously and diversely dispute; and the common received opinion is, that they are existent without any subject. This is the doctrine of the Schoole-men and all Papists, whereof (as we see) there are two maine heads: one of Transsubstantiation, another of eating Christs body with the mouth. But each of them is a false profane forgery, utterly repugnant with the words of Christ. As for the later of these, it is overthrown and refuted by the same arguments whereby we have already proved the spirituall eating of Christs body; and Transsubstantiation is thus oppugned:
1. That which is Christs body in the Supper, remaineth and is not therein transformed, nor reduced to nothing: else Christs body should not remain,1 nor be present in the Eucharist: But in the bread is Christs body, namely, sacramentally, as before we have made evident demonstrance:) Therefore bread remaineth in the Supper, and is not transformed, or reduced to nothing. The Minor is already proved, and is confirmed,2 1. By the authority of Luke and Paul, in these words: This cup is the new testament: and, The bread is the communion of the body of Christ. 2. Farther proofs are deduced also out of these words thus: What Christ brake, that he called his body: But he brake bread, not some uncertain substance, nor the mere accidents of the bread. Therefore the bread is the body of Christ. Again, The Article THIS demonstrateth and pointeth out either the bread, or the mere accidents, or the body of Christ, or some determinate thing or substance whatsoever. But it concerneth not any indeterminate substance; Because Christ brake not any undeterminate thing, that is, I know not what: but determinately and precisely it is said, He brake bread, it concerneth not Christs visible or invisible body; for his visible body sate and talked with his Disciples: and an invisible body Christ never had: and moreover the Papists themselves confess, that Christs body is not yet present under the form of bread, when the Priest beginneth to pronounce the particle THIS, but then, when once the change is made; the change (say they) is made in the last instant of consecration, at the pronouncing of this ⟨p. 450⟩last syllable DY, in these words, This is my boDY. Lastly, it concerneth not the accidents only of the bread; For Christ brake not bare and mere accidents. Wherefore, the Article THIS intimateth nothing else but the bread; and Christs words. This is my body, have no other meaning then this, This bread is my body.
1. That which is Christs body in the Supper, remaineth and is not therein transformed, nor reduced to nothing: else Christs body should not remaine,1 nor be present in the Eucharist: But in the bread is Christs body, namely, sacramentally, as before we have made evident demonstrance:) Therefore bread remaineth in the Supper, and is not transformed, or reduced to nothing. The Minor is already proved, and is confirmed,
2.Christ brake bread: but he did not then break his body: therefore the bread is not really his body.
3. Christs body was given for us: The bread was not given for us: Therefore the bread is not really Christs body.
4. Christ saith not, as the Transsubstantiaries say, Under these forms is my body, or, My body is contained under these forms: Therefore the Transsubstantiaries retain not, but pervert Christs words.
4. Christ saith not, as the Transsubstantiaries say, Ʋnder these formes is my body, or, My body is contained under these formes: Therefore the Transsubstantiaries retaine not, but pervert Christs words.
5. Christ said not, Let this be made, but, This is my body. Therefore Christs words turn not the bread into the substance of his body; but they teach only that the bread in this use is Christs body, to wit sacramentally.
5. Christ said not, Let this be made, but, This is my body. Therefore Christs words turne not the bread into the substance of his body; but they teach onely that the bread in this use is Christs body, to wit sacramentally.
6. Paul expressly calleth that which is taken, bread, both before and after the eating: Therefore the bread is not reduced to nothing, nor changed into the substance of Christs body, but continueth bread.
6. Paul expresly calleth that which is taken, bread, both before and after the eating: Therefore the bread is not reduced to nothing, nor changed into the substance of Christs body, but continueth bread.
7. Two things there are in every Sacrament: the sign, and the thing signed: or, as Irenaeus speaketh, the earthly, and the heavenly thing; and without these two, no Sacrament can consist or stand. But Transubstantiation taketh away the sign or earthly thing, namely bread and wine from the Eucharist. Therefore it taketh away the whole fence or nature of a Sacrament.
7. Two things there are in every Sacrament: the signe, and the thing signed: or, as Irenaeus speaketh, the earthly, and the heavenly thing; and without these two, no Sacrament can consist or stand. But Transsubstantiation taketh away the signe or earthly thing, namely bread and wine from the Eucharist. Therefore it taketh away the whole fence or nature of a Sacrament.
8. A bare imagination of bread and wine cannot confirm the faith of heavenly things, but will mock and deceive it, as being a vain thing, and not that which it seemeth. But the sign in the Lords Supper must confirm the faith of heavenly things, to wit, that we are as certainly fed with the body and blood of our Lord, as we are sure we receive the bread and wine. For Sacraments were instituted to confirm faith by visible signs. Farewell Transubstantiation, which transformeth the sign into a shadow and imagination.
8. A bare imagination of bread and wine cannot confirme the faith of heavenly things, but will mock and deceive it, as being a vaine thing, and not that which it seemeth. But the signe in the Lords Supper must confirme the faith of heavenly things, to wit, that we are as certainly fed with the body and bloud of our Lord, as we are sure we receive the bread and wine. For Sacraments were instituted to confirme faith by visible signes. Farewell Transsubstantiation, which transformeth the signe into a shadow and imagination.
9. Transubstantiation taketh away the analogy or proportion of the sign and the thing signed;1 whereof Saint Augustine saith, that The body so feedeth the soul, as the bread nourisheth the body: and as corn bread, is one mass made of many grains; so many are made one bread and one body, which partake of one bread. For, the bare accidents of bread and wine cannot uphold and bear this Analogy, seeing they nourish not; neither can you say, As the accidents of the bread and wine nourish the body, to the maintenance of this life; so Christs body nourisheth my soul to life eternal: for then the comparison will be between a true and a false thing: wherefore the very Analogy of the sign, and the thing, do sufficiently refute Transubstantiation.
9. Transsubstantiation taketh away the analogie or proportion of the signe and the thing signed;1 whereof Saint Augustine saith, that The body so feedeth the soule, as the bread nourisheth the body: and as corn bread, is one masse made of many grains; so many are made one bread and one body, which partake of one bread. For, the bare accidents of bread and wine cannot uphold and beare this Analogie, seeing they nourish not; neither can you say, As the accidents of the bread and wine nourish the body, to the maintenance of this life; so Christs body nourisheth my soule to life eternall: for then the comparison will be betweene a true and a false thing: wherefore the very Analogie of the signe, and the thing, doe sufficiently refute Transsubstantiation.
The Papists feigned that two great miracles were wrought in the Eucharist by the virtue of Consecration, namely, the changing of the substances of bread and the Lords body, and the subsisting of Accidents without any subject: of which two, the former subverteth the Analogy of the whole Christian faith; the later contradicteth all sound Philosophy. And that force of Consecration they boast of, is nothing else but a magical device of the Devil,1 and an invention of mans brain. This, when of ancient some Doctors espied, to avoid these so absurd miracles, in stead of Transubstantiation they coined Consubstantiation: that is, The co-existence of two substances in one place; or, the presence of Christs body and blood, not under the forms of bread and wine, but under the bread and wine it self. These therefore were of opinion that the signs were not transubstantiated, that is, changed not their substance, but consubstantiated, that is, that the bread and wine remained, but with, in, and under the bread and wine: Christs body and blood were really and substantially present, and eaten and drunken with the month of the Receivers.2 This opinion Lombard relateth, and testifieth that it was before his time maintained by some; but he calleth it a Paradox, a strange or wonderful opinion. Guitmund fathereth it on Berengarius, after his ⟨p. 451⟩recantation, and termeth it Impanation. Others impute it to one Walrame, against whom Anselm hath two books extant. Some fasten it on Rupert Abb. Tuit, who lived not long after Guitmond, about the year of the Lord 1124. Petrus de Alliaco, Cardinall of Cambray, saith,3 that he had rather defend Consubstantiation the Transubstantiation, unless the Church of Rome had defined the contrary. He lived about the year of our Lord 1416.4 At length Luther approving the judgement of this Cardinal of Cambray, as himself witnesseth, first thought it no article of faith to believe that the substance of bread remaineth, or remaineth not; but either point might be held without heresy. Afterwards it seemed more probable unto him, that the bread should remain, and the body of Christ should be under, in, and with the bread. And this is now their opinion, who name themselves Lutherans. Wherefore they interpret Christs words, This is my body, thus: In this, with this, under this bread is my body:
and they glory and boast no less then the Papists, that they retain the letter without any trope or figure. And so have they ranked themselves, that, if they combat with Papists, then the particle This, noteth with them bread only, and the bread it self is the body of Christ: If they bend their forces against us, whom they call Sacramentaries, then the particle This, shall not signify bread only, but bread with the body of Christ lodged invisibly therein; and the sense shall be, This is my body, that is, This bread, and my body lying hid in this bread, is my body. They illustrate this their gloss with vulgar similes, as they call them; that Christ, when he gave his invisible body in the bread, in like manner said, This is my body; as the Country-man saith of the grain in his sack, This is corn, pointing at the sack: or the Merchant, of the money in his purse, This is money, pointing at his purse: or the Mother, of the Infant in his cradle, This is my child, showing the cradle only: or the Vintner, of his wine, This is Rhenish wine, when he reacheth out the Goblet. These forms of speech are noted and observed out of their books and disputations. But (good men) they have that luck which the Poet allotteth unto fools: Fools when they seek to avoid an inconvenience, 1fall into an evil. For in place of that absurd miracle, of the subsisting of accidents without any subject, they have induced another more absurd, of the penetration of two bodies: and, whether we respect the letter or the sense, they have wandered & departed farther from Christs words, then the Papists. For the letter thus lieth; This, that is, This bread is my body: The sense standeth thus: The visible bread broken and distributed is my true and essential body, given for you. It is my true body, not by any change of essence and nature, as the Papists would have it (for bread was not assumed by the Word for us; neither was bread given and crucified for us): but it is my true body in a mystical sense and Sacramental kind of speech, according to the interpretation of the sounder antiquity, of Paul, yea, and of Christ himself. The Transsubstantials gloss is fart wide of this the letter, and meaning of Christs words. As then the Papists retain not the letter, when in stead of Christs words, This is my body, they annex this seraphical or super-angelical gloss:
and they glory and boast no lesse then the Papists, that they retain the letter without any trope or figure. And so have they ranked themselves, that, if they combate with Papists, then the particle This, noteth with them bread only, and the bread it self is the body of Christ: If they bend their forces against us, whom they call Sacramentaries, then the particle This, shall not signifie bread only, but bread with the body of Christ lodged invisibly therein; and the sense shall be, This is my body, that is, This bread, and my body lying hid in this bread, is my body. They illustrate this their glosse with vulgar similies, as they call them; that Christ, when he gave his invisible body in the bread, in like manner said, This is my body; as the Country-man saith of the graine in his sacke, This is corne, pointing at the sack: or the Merchant, of the money in his purse, This is money, pointing at his purse: or the Mother, of the Infant in his cradle, This is my child, shewing the cradle only: or the Vintner, of his wine, This is Rhenish wine, when he reacheth out the Goblet. These formes of speech are noted and observed out of their books and disputations. But (good men) they have that luck which the Poet alotteth unto fooles: Fooles when they seeke to avoid an inconvenience,
This thing or substance whatsoever, undeterminate, contained under these forms, is my body: so much less do these reserve entire the letter and sense of Christs words, when, instead of them, they place their own, saying: My body is in, with, under the bread: or, The bread, and the body lying hid invisibly in the bread, is my body: For neither is the bread alone, nor the bread with the body enclosed therein, properly Christs body; as an empty or full purse, is not properly, and without all figure of speech, termed money. Now, the phrases they use, are too improper, and too much unfitting that they would express. For as for the instances produced by them we know as soon as the Country-man. Merchant, Mother, or Vintner speaketh, that grain is in the sack, money in the purse, an infant in the cradle, and wine in the goblet. But when these men tell us, This is Christs body, we know not forth-with that Christs body is in the bread; neither can it be proved; because an Article of the Christian faith testifieth, that it is in heaven.
This thing or substance whatsoever, undeterminate, contained under these formes, is my body: so much lesse doe these reserve entire the letter and sense of Christs words, when, instead of them, they place their own, saying: My body is in, with, under the bread: or, The bread, and the body lying hid invisibly in the bread, is my body: For neither is the bread alone, nor the bread with the body inclosed therein, properly Christs body; as an empty or full purse, is not properly, and without all figure of speech, termed money. Now, the phrases they use, are too improper, and too much unfitting that they would expresse. For as for the instances produced by them we know as soone as the Countrey-man. Merchant, Mother, or Vintner speaketh, that graine is in the sacke, money in the purse, an infant in the cradle, and wine in the goblet. But when these men tell us, This is Christs body, we know not forth-with that Christs body is in the bread; neither can it be proved; because an Article of the Christian faith testfieth, that it is in heaven.
Luther's foundation and main ground, at first, was those words only of Christ, This is my body. Afterwards in a disputation bad with the adversaries of this opinion ⟨p. 452⟩pinion the 27. and 28. year he retired and fled to the Ubiquity, and for that one foundation or ground afore-named he assumed four other: 1. The personal union of the natures in Christ. The right hand of God, which is every where. 3. The truth of God, which cannot lie. 4. The three fold manner of the existence of Christs body in any place. But being at length repulsed from these holds, he betook himself again to Christs words, and desired that all disputation of Ubiquity should quite be revoked. Notwithstanding, since his time, some, Lutherans by profession, finding no sufficient warrant for their cause in Christs words, have set Ubiquity on foot again, and at this day account it the best stake in their hedge;1 though others utterly disclaim it. Hence arose a faction and division among the Consubstantials: some are *simply Lutherans, who by Christs words only defend the being of Christs body in the bread, and the eating it with the mouth: some are *multipresentiarie and omnipotentiarie Lutherans, that is, such as think Christs body to be present at once in many hosts, by reason of the omnipotency really communicated therewith. Lastly, some are *omnipresentiarie Lutherans, who, to assoil the presence of Christs body in the bread, lay hold on the shield of Ubiquity, and teach that Christs body is every where present by virtue of the union with the Word, and therefore is present in the bread, both before and after the use thereof in the Supper; and that the right of consecration doth effect only that it be eaten in the bread. Of this our young Divines, for the understanding of this controversy, may not be ignorant. For hereby they perceive, that at this day there are two main columns or pillars erected to under-prop Consubstantiation, namely,5 1. The Ubiquity. 2. The words of Christ. The Ubiquity hath been at large discoursed of before in expounding the Articles of the personal union of the two natures in Christ, of his ascension into heaven, and of his sitting at the right hands of God the Father, and the difficulties therein discussed, fully resolved, and Ubiquity it self confuted.
Christs words (witness the Papists themselves) neither intimate Consubstantiation, neither can bear that interpretation. Which the Ubiquitaries also in their writings dissemble not: and have therefore devised and invented the Ubiquity because they saw that the ground and foundation of their opinion, if it were laid on Christs words only, were too ruinous, and like to have a speedy down-fall. Christ said, This is my body, which is given for you; which words the Consubstantials retain not,1 neither literally, nor according to their sense and meaning. We need not therefore any argument to refute Consubstantiation, but Christs very words, whereunto we recall them, and thus reason against them: Christ said not, In this bread is my body; but, This is my body: neither is the sense of both these propositions all one; seeing the former declareth what is in the bread, and where Christs body is; the later, what the bread it self is in the Eucharist: Therefore the Consubstantials who teach, that in the bread is Christs body, retain neither the letter, nor the meaning of Christs words.
Christs words (witnesse the Papists themselves) neither intimate Consubstantiation, neither can beare that interpretation. Which the Ubiquitaries also in their writings dissemble not: and have therefore devised and invented the Ubiquity because they saw that the ground and foundation of their opinion, if it were laid on Christs words only, were too ruinous, and like to have a speedy down-fall. Christ said, This is my body, which is given for you; which words the Consubstantials retaine not,1 neither literally, nor according to their sense and meaning. We need not therefore any argument to refute Consubstantiation, but Christs very words, whereunto we recall them, and thus reason against them: Christ said not, In this bread is my body; but, This is my body: neither is the sense of both these propositions all one; seeing the former declareth what is in the bread, and where Christs body is; the later, what the bread it selfe is in the Eucharist: Therefore the Consubstantials who teach, that in the bread is Christs body, retaine neither the letter, nor the meaning of Christs words.
1Object. 1. It is an usual kind of speech when two things are jointly given, the one apparent, the other in covert, that that only be named, which appeared not: as we say of purses fraught with money, This is money: of a cask of wine, This is wine. But Christ in his Supper delivering in the same manner two things jointly at once, namely, the bread and his body, named that only, which appeared not, under the bread, saying: Take, this is my body: Therefore Christs manner of speech is most usual and proper, neither needeth it any explication at all. Answ. To the Major we answer, that it is a form of speech most usual, &c. but with this limitation, when it is certain that the thing which is named, though it be not apparent, yet it is contained in that thing which is apparent; as it is certain, that money is in the purse, and wine in the cask. Otherwise it is no usual, plain, or true form of speech, to say of an empty purse, This is money. But hitherto it is not clear, neither have the Consubstantials as yet proved, that Christs body lay hid in the bread, when Christ said thereof, This is my body; as it ought to be evident, that money is in the purse, and wine in the vessel, when it is said, This is money, This is wine. Yea, and we avouch the contrary, to wit, that Christs ⟨p. 453⟩body in the first Supper, lay not hid in the bread, but sate at table, and now is in heaven, until it thence return in judgement: Therefore this form of reasoning, is a begging of that which is in controversy betwixt us. Answ. 2. The Minor also is false. For Christ, delivering unto his Disciples, not his body but bread, taken from the table, and broken said, Take, cate, This (that is, this bread) is my body. Which exposition is proved: 1. Because it is said of the cup, This cup is the New Testament. 2. Paul expoundeth the particle This, of the bread, saying: The bread which we break is the communion of Christs body. 3. Because the bread and body of Christ (both together) are neither properly, not figuratively Christs very body: and hereby a Tautology, or a vain and childish iteration of the same thing should be fathered on Christ, in saying; My body is my body. 4. We deny also the consequence, because their conclusion compriseth more then their premisses in force. For they conclude, that it is a most usual and proper speech.
1OBject. 1. It is an usuall kind of speech when two things are joyntly given, the one apparent, the other in covert, that that onely be named, which appeared not: as we say of purses fraught with money, This is money: of a caske of wine, This is wine. But Christ in his Supper delivering in the same manner two things joyntly at once, namely, the bread and his body, named that onely, which appeared not, under the bread, saying: Take, this is my body: Therefore Christs manner of speech is most usuall and proper, neither needeth it any explication at all. Answ. To the Major we answer, that it is a forme of speech most usuall, &c. but with this limitation, when it is certaine that the thing which is named, though it be not apparent, yet it is contained in that thing which is apparent; as it is certaine, that money is in the purse, and wine in the caske. Otherwise it is no usuall, plaine, or true forme of speech, to say of an empty purse, This is money. But hitherto it is not cleere, neither have the Consubstantials as yet proved, that Christs body lay hid in the bread, when Christ said thereof, This is my body; as it ought to be evident, that money is in the purse, and wine in the vessell, when it is said, This is money, This is wine. Yea, and we avouch the contrary, to wit, that Christs
But these two, usual and proper, are not in force and signification alike. For the most usual form of speech may be figurative, as those very trivial, and yet Synecdochical speeches urged by them, This is money, This is wine: who is so mad, as to think the purse alone, or the purse with the money, is properly money? So was that Sacramental speech of the Passover frequent, and well known unto the Disciples of Christ: Where wilt thou that we provide the Passover? Yet spake they not properly, but figuratively, attributing to the sign the name of the thing signified, by a sacramental Metonymy or change of names. That which followeth therefore out of the premisses, is only this, That Christs words were trivial, plain and known to the Disciples; but not that they were understood properly, literally, and without all Trope or Figure.
But these two, usuall and proper, are not in force and signification alike. For the most usuall form of speech may be figurative, as those very triviall, and yet Synecdochicall speeches urged by them, This is money, This is wine: who is so mad, as to think the purse alone, or the purse with the mony, is properly money? So was that Sacramentall speech of the Passeover frequent, and well knowne unto the Disciples of Christ: Where wilt thou that we provide the Passeover? Yet spake they not properly, but figuratively, attributing to the signe the name of the thing signified, by a sacramentall Metonymie or change of names. That which followeth therefore out of the premisses, is only this, That Christs words were triviall, plaine and known to the Disciples; but not that they were understood properly, literally, and without all Trope or Figure.
Object. 2. Christ said, This is my body. But Christ is true: Therefore we must believe him, setting apart all Philosophical subtlety and sharpness; and so by consequent, bread is not a sign of his body, but his body, as the words lie; which are simply and literally to be understood. Ans. Here they allege us that for a cause, which is indeed no cause of the matter in hand. For Christs truth is a cause only that his words are true; yea, most true: to which we ought to give credence, setting apart all Philosophical subtlety: but it is no cause why his words should be proper, and literally taken. For he which speaketh figuratively, may also speak truly: as Christ him self was no less true, yea truth it self, when he said, I am the light of the world, the door of the sheepfold, the good Shepherd, the true Vine, my Father is an Husbandman, ye are the branches; then when he said, This is my body. And they deserve to be hissed out of Schools, who presume to term figurative speeches by the name of lies. 2. We retort their Minor thus; Christ is true: Therefore he said not, that his body lay hid in the bread, when all his Disciples saw that it sate at Table. 3. We retort their conclusion on them thus; Christs words must be understood simply: Therefore ye may not cloak and colour them with your gloss, which perverteth the letter, when ye say, that In, With, Under the bread is Christs body; or that the bread is the closet of Christs body.
Object. 2. Christ said, This is my body. But Christ is true: Therefore we must beleeve him, setting apart all Philosophicall subtilty and sharpnesse; and so by consequent, bread is not a signe of his body, but his body, as the words lie; which are simply and literally to be understood. Ans. Here they alledge us that for a cause, which is indeed no cause of the matter in hand. For Christs truth is a cause onely that his words are true; yea, most true: to which we ought to give credence, setting apart all Philosophicall subtilty: but it is no cause why his words should be proper, and literally taken. For he which speaketh figuratively, may also speak truly: as Christ him selfe was no lesse true, yea truth it selfe, when he said, I am the light of the world, the doore of the sheepfold, the good Shepheard, the true Vine, my Father is an Husbandman, ye are the branches; then when he said, This is my body. And they deserve to be hissed out of Schooles, who presume to terme figurative speeches by the name of lies. 2. We retort their Minor thus; Christ is true: Therefore he said not, that his body lay hid in the bread, when all his Disciples saw that it sate at Table. 3. We retort their conclusion on them thus; Christs words must be understood simply: Therefore yee may not cloake and colour them with your glosse, which perverteth the letter, when ye say, that In, With, Ʋnder the bread is Christs body; or that the bread is the closet of Christs body.
Object. 3. Christ is omnipotent: Therefore he can effect that his body should be really in the bread. Ans. The reason is of no force, which will conclude a thing to be done, because it may be done. The question is not, What Christ can do, but what he will. He no where promised the presence of his body in the bread, or in the presence of the bread: Therefore we derogate nothing at all from his omnipotency, when we believe no such presence. Repl. Bread is present in place of the Supper. Bread is Christs body: Therefore Christs body is present in place of the Supper. Ans. The Minor of this Syllogism is figurative, by the confession of the adversaries themselves. For Jacobus Andreas in a disputation held at Mulbr. when he could no ways else escape, expressly confessed, that this proposition is figurative; Bread is the body of Christ. 1The same Andreas afterwards wrote, that this phrase, Bread is Christs body, is proper,2 and to be understood, without any trope or Figure. Is not this to blow hot and cold out of the same mouth? to say one thing, and to unsay it again?
Object. 3. Christ is omnipotent: Therefore he can effect that his body should be really in the bread. Ans. The reason is of no force, which will conclude a thing to be done, because it may be done. The question is not, What Christ can doe, but what he will. He no where promised the presence of his body in the bread, or in the presence of the bread: Therefore we derogate nothing at all from his omnipotency, when we beleeve no such presence. Repl. Bread is present in place of the Supper. Bread is Christs body: Therefore Christs body is present in place of the Supper. Ans. The Minor of this Syllogisme is figurative, by the confession of the adversaries themselves. For Jacobus Andreas in a disputation held at Mulbr. when he could no wayes else escape, expresly confessed, that this proposition is figurative; Bread is the body of Christ. 1The same Andreas afterwards wrote, that this phrase, Bread is Christs body, is proper,2 and to be understood, without any trope or Figure. Is not this to blow hote and cold out of the same mouth? to say one thing, and to unsay it againe?
Object. 4. Christs words are not to be changed. Christ used the word IS: This IS my body: Therefore there may not be put in place thereof the word SIGNIFIETH. Ans. We grant the whole. For we place not the word signifieth instead of the word ⟨p. 454⟩is; neither do we change Christs words; but retain them as they were pronounced by Christ. But we say, that this is the true and natural sense of those words; namely, that the bread is the body of Christ symbolically: that is, as a symbol or token of it, or that it signifieth Christs body: For so Christ himself construeth them, saying; Do this in remembrance of me: So Paul interpreteth them; This cup is the New Testament in my blood. 1And Tertullian saith, The bread which he took and distributed among his Disciples, he made it his body, saying: This is my body; that is, the figure of my body. 2And Augustine; Our Lord doubted not to say, This is my body, when he gave a token of his body. 2. We retort the argument on our adversaries, thus Christs words are not to be changed: Therefore the Transubstantials gloss is false, averring thus; Under these forms is, or is contained my body: and likewise the Corsubtantials gloss, in, with, under this bread is my body invisibly present. 3. The words are not to be changed, to wit, into another sense then Christ will have: but otherwise, they are often to be changed; that is, interpreted aright: as when it is said, Pluck out thine eye. To him that taketh away thy coat, give thy cloak also. For words are to be understood according to the nature of things.
Object. 4. Christs words are not to be changed. Christ used the word IS: This IS my body: Therefore there may not be put in place thereof the word SIGNIFIETH. Ans. We grant the whole. For we place not the word signifieth instead of the word ⟨p. 454⟩is; neither doe we change Christs words; but retaine them as they were pronounced by Christ. But we say, that this is the true and naturall sense of those words; namely, that the bread is the body of Christ symbolically: that is, as a symbole or token of it, or that it signifieth Christs body: For so Christ himselfe construeth them, saying; Doe this in remembrance of me: So Paul interpreteth them; This cup is the New Testament in my bloud.
Object. 5. The words of Testaments are to be understood properly, lest occasion of striving about the will of the Testator fall out: the Supper is the New Testament: Therefore the words therein are properly to be understood. Ans. To be Major we make answer, that the words of Testaments are properly to be understood, if they be properly spoken; and figuratively, if they be figuratively uttered. If they say, All words of Testaments are properly to be understood, we deny the Major: For it is sufficient, that the words of Testaments be clear and plain, though oftentimes they be not proper, but figurative. For when we are sure of the Testators will, what it is, in vain do we then dispute of the letter. So God in the old time spake figuratively of Circumcision, of the Paschal Lamb, of the Sacrifices. And Christ in the New Testament spake by a figure, Take, drink; This cup is the New Testament in my blood. For here is a double figure: 1. A Synecdoche, when he biddeth them drink of the cup; that is, of the wine in the cup. 2. A Metonymy, when he calleth the cup the New Testament; that is, the reconciliation of mankind with God, sealed by his blood.
Object. 5. The words of Testaments are to be understood properly, lest occasion of striving about the will of the Testator fall out: the Supper is the New Testament: Therefore the words therein are properly to be understood. Ans. To be Major we make answer, that the words of Testaments are properly to be understood, if they be properly spoken; and figuratively, if they be figuratively uttered. If they say, All words of Testaments are properly to be understood, we deny the Major: For it is sufficient, that the words of Testaments be cleere and plaine, though oftentimes they be not proper, but figurative. For when we are sure of the Testators will, what it is, in vaine doe we then dispute of the letter. So God in the old time spake figuratively of Circumcision, of the Paschall Lamb, of the Sacrifices. And Christ in the New Testament spake by a figure, Take, drinke; This cup is the New Testament in my bloud. For here is a double figure: 1. A Synecdoche, when he biddeth them drink of the cup; that is, of the wine in the cup. 2. A Metonymie, when he calleth the cup the New Testament; that is, the reconciliation of mankind with God, sealed by his bloud.
Object. 6. The eating of bread is done by the mouth: but the eating of the body, is the eating of bread: Therefore the eating of the body is done by the mouth. Answ. The Minor is either figurative, or false: It is figurative, if you understand it thus, The eating of the body is the thing signified and sealed by the eating of bread. And so, the manner of predication or affirmation being changed, nothing is proved. If it be properly understood, it is false. For the eating of the bread is external, corporal, and visible: but the eating of the body is internal, spiritual and invisible. Wherefore they are not properly one kind of eating; but as the thing signified is distinguished from the sign, so the receipt of both of them is distinct, though both be at once in the lawful use of the Sacraments.
Object. 6. The eating of bread is done by the mouth: but the eating of the body, is the eating of bread: Therefore the eating of the body is done by the mouth. Answ. The Minor is either figurative, or false: It is figurative, if you understand it thus, The eating of the body is the thing signified and sealed by the eating of bread. And so, the manner of predication or affirmation being changed, nothing is proved. If it be properly understood, it is false. For the eating of the bread is externall, corporall, and visible: but the eating of the body is internall, spirituall and invisible. Wherefore they are not properly one kind of eating; but as the thing signified is distinguished from the signe, so the receit of both of them is distinct, though both be at once in the lawfull use of the Sacraments.
3. The bread which we breake (saith the Apostle) is it not the communion of the body of Christ? As bread is the communion of the body of Christ, so also it is the body of Christ. The reason is cleere, because Pauls words and Christs have both one meaning; seeing Paul interpreteth Christ. But the bread is the communion of the body of Christ sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or signe of our spirituall communion with Christs body. For properly and literally, bread cannot be termed a communion: Therefore, bread also is Christs body sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or signe of Christs body. Now that the communion or communication of Christs body is spirituall, is thus proved: 1. Paul speaketh of such a communion, as whereby we being many, are made one bread, one body. But we being many, are one body spiritually: Therefore the communion mentioned of Paul is spirituall. 2. The communion of Christ, whereof he speaketh, cannot stand with the communion of Divels:1 Ye cannot (saith he) drink the cup of the Lord, and the cup of the Divels: ye cannot be partakers of the Lords Table, and of the table of the Divels. The argument is not deduced from an inconvenience or an undecency, as some fondly tell us,2 but from an impossibility: as that of Christ, Ye cannot serve God and Mammon. Where the words 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, ye are not able; or, ye have no possibility, are likewise used, as well as in this place:3 and as that of the same Apostle else-where; What concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath the Beleever with the Infidell? 3. This communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, is spiritually expounded in Scripture,4 Our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ. If we say, that we have fellowship with him, and walke in darkenesse, we lye, and do not truely. But if we walke in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the bloud of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sinne. Neither doe we in the Creed beleeve any other communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, but that which is spirituall. 54. Lastly, Chrysostome interpreteth Pauls words of a spirituall communion. Why said he not participation? That he might manifest unto thee somewhat more excellent then it, to wit, the strongest and mightiest union that can be.
UNto these arguments drawne out of the sacred Scripture, and the ground of our faith, may be added testimonies of the Fathers, and the purer Church; who, if we looke into their writings, we shall finde, that they plainly teach the same doctrine touching the Lords holy Supper, which we do. Among many we will produce onely some few notable and cleere in this point. Irenaeus saith,1 The earthly bread, taking his name from the word of God, is no longer common bread, but becometh the Eucharist or Sacrament, which consisteth of two things; an earthly, and an heavenly thing. Tertullian, The bread which he tooke and distributed among his Disciples, he made it his body, saying, This is my body; that is, The figure of my body.2 Clemens of Alexandria, This is to drinke Christs bloud, to be partaker of Christs immortality. Cyprian, Neither can his blood, wherewith we are redeemed and justified, seeme to be in the Chalice, when the wine faileth in the Chalice, wherein Christs bloud is shewed, which is spoken of in every Sacrament and testimony of Scripture. Againe, the same Father saith, As often as ⟨p. 448⟩we doe this, we sharpen not our teeth to bite withall, but we breake and part the sanctified bread with a sincere faith, whilst we distinguish and separate that which is divine, from that which is humane, and joyning them againe after their separation, confesse one God and man: yea, we our selves are made his body by this Sacrament, and knit and united to our head by the thing signified by the Sacrament. 3The Canon of the Nicene Councell: Againe, here also is the Lords Table: Let us not childishly cleave to the bread and wine set before us, but lifting up our minds on high, by faith, let us consider, that on that Table is set the Lamb of God taking away the sinnes of the world, which is offered of the Priests without killing: and let us, truely receiving his precious body and bloud, beleeve that they are SIGNES of our resurrection. For therefore we receive not much, but little; thereby to acknowledge that it is not received to satisfie, 4but to sanctifie us. Basil: We have set on the Table the figures of the sacred body and blood. Hillarie: The bread and wine received, and drunke, effect and worke that both we are in Christ, 5and Christ in us. Gregory Nazianzene: The figures of the precious body and bloud of Christ. Ambrose: Because we are delivered by our LORDS death;
being mindfull thereof, in eating, and drinking wee Signifie, (or Represent) the flesh and bloud that were offered up for us. 1Againe, This oblation is the FIGƲRE OF THE BODY AND BLOƲD of our LORD Jesus CHRIST. Augustine: Our Lord doubted not to say, This is my body, when he gave a TOKEN of his body. Againe, The Lord admitted Judas to that banquet, wherein he ministred and gave to his disciples the FIGƲRE of his body and bloud. The same Father saith: Ʋnlesse Sacraments had a certaine likenesse of the things, whereof they bee Sacraments, without question they were no Sacraments. And in consideration of this likenesse, oftentimes they beare the names of the things themselves. As therefore the Sacrament of the body of CHRIST is AFTER A CERTAINE MANER the body of Christ: and the Sacrament of Christs bloud is his bloud: so the Sacrament of faith is faith. 2Againe, As then the celestiall bread, Christs flesh, is IN SOME SORT called Christs body, whereas indeed it is a Sacrament of Christs body; namely, that visible, palpable, and mortall body which was nailed on the Crosse, and the sacrificing of his flesh, done by the hands of the Minister, is called Christs Passion, death, and crucifying, NOT IN THE TRƲTH OF THE THING, but in a mysterie SIGNIFYING it: So the Sacrament of faith, by which is meant Baptisme, is faith. 3Also: These, my brethren, are therefore called Sacraments, because in them one thing is seene, another understood. That which is seene hath a bodily forme: that which is understood, hath a spirituall fruit or benefit. 4Chrysostome: This is my bloud, which is shed for the remission of sinnes; which Christ said, to shew that his Passion and Crosse was a mysterie, and to comfort his disciples. 5Theodoret: Our Saviour verily changed the names of the signes and the things signified, and gave the same name to the body, which is proper to the signe; and that to the signe which is proper to the body. The cause of this change is manifest to them that are entred into the first principles of divine mysteries. For he would that they who use the Sacraments should not bend and set their minds on the nature of the things which are seene, but, for the alteration of the names, should beleeve that alteration which is made through grace.
THe Papists feigned that two great miracles were wrought in the Eucharist by the vertue of Consecration, namely, the changing of the substances of bread and the Lords body, and the subsisting of Accidents without any subject: of which two, the former subverteth the Analogie of the whole Christian faith; the later contradicteth all sound Philosophy. And that force of Consecration they boast of, is nothing else but a magicall device of the Devill,1 and an invention of mans brain. This, when of ancient some Doctors espied, to avoid these so absurd miracles, in stead of Transsubstantiation they coined Consubstantiation: that is, The co-existence of two substances in one place; or, the presence of Christs body and bloud, not under the formes of bread and wine, but under the bread and wine it selfe. These therefore were of opinion that the signs were not transsubstantiated, that is, changed not their substance, but consubstantiated, that is, that the bread and wine remained, but with, in, and under the bread and wine: Christs body and bloud were really and substantially present, and eaten and drunken with the month of the Receivers.2 This opinion Lombard relateth, and testifieth that it was before his time maintained by some; but he calleth it a Paradox, a strange or wonderfull opinion. Guitmund fathereth it on Berengarius, after his ⟨p. 451⟩recantation, and termeth it Impanation. Others impute it to one Walrame, against whom Anselme hath two books extant. Some fasten it on Rupert Abb. Tuit, who lived not long after Guitmond, about the year of the Lord 1124. Petrus de Alliaco, Cardinall of Cambray, saith,3 that he had rather defend Consubstantiation the Transubstantiation, unlesse the Church of Rome had defined the contrary. He lived about the year of our Lord 1416.4 At length Luther approving the judgement of this Cardinal of Cambray, as himself witnesseth, first thought it no article of faith to beleeve that the substance of bread remaineth, or remaineth not; but either point might be held without heresie. Afterwards it seemed more probable unto him, that the bread should remaine, and the body of Christ should be under, in, and with the bread. And this is now their opinion, who name themselves Lutherans. Wherefore they interpret Christs words, This is my body, thus: In this, with this, under this bread is my body:
LUthers foundation and maine ground, at first, was those words onely of Christ, This is my body. Afterwards in a disputation bad with the adversaries of this opinion ⟨p. 452⟩pinion the 27. and 28. yeere he retired and fled to the Ubiquity, and for that one foundation or ground afore-named he assumed four other: 1. The personall union of the natures in Christ. The right hand of God, which is every where. 3. The truth of God, which cannot lie. 4. The three fold manner of the existence of Christs body in any place. But being at length repulsed from these holds, he betook himselfe againe to Christs words, and desired that all disputation of Ubiquity should quite be revoked. Notwithstanding, since his time, some, Lutherans by profession, finding no sufficient warrant for their cause in Christs words, have set Ubiquity on foot againe, and at this day account it the best stake in their hedge;1 though others utterly disclaime it. Hence arose a faction and division among the Consubstantials: some are *simply Lutherans, who by Christs words only defend the being of Christs body in the bread, and the eating it with the mouth: some are *multipresentiarie and omnipotentiarie Lutherans, that is, such as think Christs body to be present at once in many hosts, by reason of the omnipotency really communicated therewith. Lastly, some are *omnipresentiarie Lutherans, who, to assoile the presence of Christs body in the bread, lay hold on the shield of Ubiquity, and teach that Christs body is every where present by vertue of the union with the Word, and therefore is present in the bread, both before and after the use thereof in the Supper; and that the right of consecration doth effect only that it be eaten in the bread. Of this our young Divines, for the understanding of this controverfie, may not be ignorant. For hereby they perceive, that at this day there are two maine columnes or pillars erected to under-prop Consubstantiation, namely,5 1. The Ʋbiquity. 2. The words of Christ. The Ubiquity hath beene at large discoursed of before in expounding the Articles of the personall union of the two natures in Christ, of his ascension into heaven, and of his sitting at the right hands of God the Father, and the difficulties therein discussed, fully resolved, and Ubiquity it selfe confuted.