OF SIN IN GENERAL.OF SIN IN GENERALL.
pp. 48–103215 passagespart 3 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 48–103215 passagespart 3 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Now in the process of this our discourse, we will gather in one the testimonies of Scripture, resolve certain doubts, and discover the very fountain and original of sin. Many are the testimonies of Scripture which teach us, that God is not the author of sin; of which it shall suffice to propose only some few: God made not death, 1neither hath he pleasure in the destruction of the living. I desire not the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way, and live: For thou art not a God that loveth wickedness, neither shall evil dwell with thee. The foolish shall not stand in thy sight. God made man righteous, 2but they have sought many inventions. Our unrighteousness commendeth the righteousness of God. 3By one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin. I know that in me there dwelleth no good thing. Of this we conclude, that God is not the author of sin, but that the original of evil springeth from man himself, by the instigation of the Devil; yet so nevertheless, that we say, that the Devil, being at the first corrupted, did corrupt man; but could have done nothing, except man of his own accord had consented to evil.4 Here are we to remember again the fall of our father Adam. God made Adam to his own image and similitude; that is, he made him most good, uncorrupt, holy, righteous, and immortal; he furnished him with most excellent gifts, that nothing might be wanting unto him to all blessedness in God: Wherefore his Understanding was wholly divine, his Will most free, and most holy, he had power of doing good and evil; a law was given him of God, which showed him what he should do, or what he should not do: For the Lord said,5 Thou shalt not eat of the tree of knowledge both of good and evil. God simply required of him Obedience and Faith, and that the whole Adam should depend of him, and that not constrained by necessity, but should do it freely.6 God made man from the beginning, and left him in in the hand of his counsel, saying: If thou wilt, thou shalt observe the commandments, and testify thy good will. Therefore when the Serpent tempted man, and counselled him to taste of the forbidden tree, man was not ignorant that the counsel of the Serpent did not agree with the commandment of God:7 Ye shall not eat of the tree, neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die.
Now in the processe of this our discourse, wee will gather in one the testimonies of Scripture, resolve certain doubts, and discover the very fountain and originall of sin. Many are the testimonies of Scripture which teach us, that God is not the author of sin; of which it shall suffice to propose only some few: God made not death, 1neither hath he pleasure in the destruction of the living. I desire not the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turne from his way, and live: For thou art not a God that loveth wickednesse, neither shall evill dwell with thee. The foolish shall not stand in thy sight. God made man righteous, 2but they have sought many inventions. Our unrighteousnesse commendeth the righteousnesse of God. 3By one man sin entred into the world, and death by sin. I know that in me there dwelleth no good thing. Of this we conclude, that God is not the author of sinne, but that the originall of evill springeth from man himselfe, by the instigation of the Divell; yet so neverthelesse, that wee say, that the Divell, being at the first corrupted, did corrupt man; but could have done nothing, except man of his owne accord had consented to evill.4 Here are we to remember againe the fall of our father Adam. God made Adam to his owne image and similitude; that is, he made him most good, uncorrupt, holy, righteous, and immortall; he furnished him with most excellent gifts, that nothing might be wanting unto him to all blessednesse in God: Wherefore his Understanding was wholly divine, his Will most free, and most holy, he had power of doing good and evill; a law was given him of God, which shewed him what hee should doe, or what hee should not doe: For the Lord said,5 Thou shalt not eat of the tree of knowledge both of good and evill. God simply required of him Obedience and Faith, and that the whole Adam should depend of him, and that not constrained by necessity, but should doe it freely.6 God made man from the beginning, and left him in in the hand of his counsell, saying: If thou wilt, thou shalt observe the commandements, and testifie thy good will. Therefore when the Serpent tempted man, and counselled him to taste of the forbidden tree, man was not ignorant that the counsell of the Serpent did not agree with the commandement of God:7
Wherefore it was in the hand of his counsel to ear, or not to eat: God declared unto him his will, plainly charging him that he should not eat; and adding the peril, he did withdraw him from eating, lest perhaps thou die. Satan also (as neither could he) did not use any force, but did probably move him unto it, and at length did overcome him: for when the will of the woman declined to the word of the Devil, her mind departed from the word of God, and rejecting a good law, she committeth an evil work. Afterwards she drew on her husband, willingly following her, to be partaker of her sin. That doth the Scripture inculcate in these words:1 So the woman (seeing that the tree was good for meat, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to get knowledge) took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also to her husband with her, and he did eat. Here have you the beginning of evil, the Devil, and that which moved the Will of man, that is, the false commendation of the Devil; and even as a mere lye, and the delectable show and sightliness of the tree: Wherefore Adam and Eve do of their own accord that which they do, being led with a hope of more excellent wisdom, which the Seducer had lyingly promised them.
Wherefore it was in the hand of his counsell to ear, or not to eat: God declared unto him his will, plainly charging him that he should not eat; and adding the perill, he did withdraw him from eating, lest perhaps thou die. Satan also (as neither could he) did not use any force, but did probably move him unto it, and at length did overcome him: for when the will of the woman declined to the word of the Divell, her mind departed from the word of God, and rejecting a good law, she committeth an evill work. Afterwards she drew on her husband, willingly following her, to be partaker of her sinne. That doth the Scripture inculcate in these words:1 So the woman (seeing that the tree was good for meat, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to get knowledge) took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also to her husband with her, and he did eat. Here have you the beginning of evill, the Divell, and that which moved the Will of man, that is, the false commendation of the Divell; and even as a meere lye, and the delectable shew and sightlinesse of the tree: Wherefore Adam and Eve doe of their owne accord that which they doe, being led with a hope of more excellent wisdome, which the Seducer had lyingly promised them.
We conclude therefore, that sin hath his beginning not from God, who forbideth ⟨p. 67⟩evil, but from the Devil, and the free electron of man, 1which was corrupted by the Devils falsehood: And therefore the Devil, and mans corrupted will obeying him, are the most true cause of sin. This evil floweth from our first Parents unto all their posterity, so that sin hath not else-whence his beginning then from our selves, and our corrupt judgement and wicked will, and the suggestion of Satan: For an evil root, and that first corruption, bringeth forth of it a rotten branch agreeable to the nature thereof, which Satan now also setteth forward, and laboureth it, as it were plants, by his guiles and lies: but in vain doth he labour, except we yield our selves to be fashioned and dressed by him. That is called Original sin, which proceedeth from the first Original, that is, was derived from the first Patents into all by propagation or generation: for this sin we bring with us in our nature out of our mothers womb into this life; I was borne in iniquity 2and in sin hath my mother conceived me. And of the Devil Christ speaketh thus: He hath been a murderer from the beginning, 3and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lye, he speaketh of his own: For he is a liar, and the father thereof.
We conclude therefore, that sinne hath his beginning not from God, who forbideth ⟨p. 67⟩evill, but from the Divell, and the free electron of man, 1which was corrupted by the Divels falshood: And therefore the Divell, and mans corrupted will obeying him, are the most true cause of sinne. This evill floweth from our first Parents unto all their pos•erity, so that sinne hath not else-whence his beginning then from our selves, and our corrupt judgement and wicked will, and the suggestion of Sathan: For an evill root, and that first corruption, bringeth forth of it a rotten branch agreeable to the nature thereof, which Sathan now also setteth forward, and laboureth it, as it were plants, by his guiles and lies: but in vaine doth hee labour, except we yeeld our selves to be fashioned and dressed by him. That is called Originall sinne, which proceedeth from the first Originall, that is, was derived from the first Patents into all by propagation or generation: for this sin we bring with us in our nature out of our mothers womb into this life; I was borne in iniquitie
To this may be added this reason,1 That sin cannot be a proper and natural effect of any cause, but of that which hath power to do against the Law; but this no nature hath power to do, besides the nature of Angels and of men: for God is a Law unto himself, and cannot do or intend any thing against his Law. And other creatures, whereas they are not endued with reason, and therefore the Law not made for them, they cannot commit sin; because, take away the Law, and there is no place left for sin: Wherefore it necessarily followeth, that sin is such an effect, as agreeth to those Angels alone who fell, and to men.
To this may be added this reason,1 That sin cannot be a proper and naturall effect of any cause, but of that which hath power to doe against the Law; but this no nature hath power to doe, besides the nature of Angels and of men: for God is a Law unto himselfe, and cannot doe or intend any thing against his Law. And other creatures, whereas they are not endued with reason, and therefore the Law not made for them, they cannot commit sin; because, take away the Law, and there is no place left for sin: Wherefore it necessarily followeth, that sin is such an effect, as agreeth to those Angels alone who fell, and to men.
If humane reason do here object, That God is the author and causer of punishment: 1If therefore sins be the punishments of sins, it followeth, that God is the cause of sins. We answer, that there is a fallacy of the accident in the Minor: For it cometh to pass by an accident, that is, by the fault of those who sin, that when by the just judgement of God, either themselves or others are punished by evil men, they in the mean season (God permitting, that is, not showing them that he would have those things to be done by them for to punish them. which things yet he hateth, and which he will punish both in this life and the life to come) do fulfil their desires, swerving from the Law of God, and estranging themselves more and more from God by sinning, do purchase more grievous punishments unto themselves. Or if we will distinguish the Major, it is in effect the same: For punishments come from God, as author and causer of them, as they are punishments: but inasmuch as they are sins, so they come, God neither willing them, nor approving them, nor causing, but only permitting: For to permit this kind of punishments, which sinners by sinning inflict either upon themselves or others, is nothing else then not to cause that evil men should do this, which God would have done for punishment, to the same end, that they may obey this will of God.
If humane reason doe here object, That God is the author and causer of punishment: 1If therefore sins be the punishments of sins, it followeth, that God is the cause of sins. We answer, that there is a fallacy of the accident in the Minor: For it cometh to passe by an accident, that is, by the fault of those who sin, that when by the just judgement of God, either themselves or others are punished by evill men, they in the meane season (God permitting, that is, not shewing them that hee would have those things to be done by them for to punish them. which things yet hee hateth, and which he will punish both in this life and the life to come) do fulfill their desires, swerving from the Law of God, and estranging themselves more and more from God by sinning, do purchase more grievous punishments unto themselves. Or if we will distinguish the Major, it is in effect the same: For punishments come from God, as author and causer of them, as they are punishments: but inasmuch as they are sins, so they come, God neither willing them, nor approving them, nor causing, but only permitting: For to permit this kind of punishments, which sinners by sinning inflict either upon themselves or others, is nothing else then not to cause that evill men should do this, which God would have done for punishment, to the same end, that they may obey this will of God.
So also we answer to that argument, The privation or want of righteousness and divine wisdom, God inflicteth as a punishment upon men; but that privation is sin: Therefore God is the causer of sin: For this privation is not sin, as by the just judgement of God it is inflicted; but as it is of men themselves, voluntarily brought upon them by their own misdeeds and demerits, and is admitted or received into the mind, will, and heart; even as evil actions are not sins, as they are governed by God, but as they are done by man.
So also we answer to that argument, The privation or want of righteousnesse and divine wisdome, God inflicteth as a punishment upon men; but that privation is sin: Therefore God is the causer of sin: For this privation is not sin, as by the just judgement of God it is inflicted; but as it is of men themselves, voluntarily brought upon them by their owne misdeeds and demerits, and is admitted or received into the mind, will, and heart; even as evill actions are not sins, as they are governed by God, but as they are done by man.
They say further, He that mindeth the end, mindeth also the means: God mindeth the ends of sin, that is, punishment, 1and the showing of justice and wrath in punishment: Wherefore he mindeth sin also, by which those ends are come unto. But the Minor is to be denied, that Punishment and the Manifestation of the glory of God are the ends of sin: For the end is that which moveth the efficient cause to bring forth an effect; but Punishment, or the Manifestation of the glory of God, do not move the sinners to sin: These cannot therefore be said to be the ends of sin. But those are the proper ends of sin, which the Devils and men respect in sinning: ⟨p. 68⟩that is, the destruction of men, the fulfilling of evil desires, the oppression and reproach of God, and his truth.
They say further, Hee that mindeth the end, mindeth also the meanes: God mindeth the ends of sin, that is, punishment, 1and the shewing of justice and wrath in punishment: Wherefore hee mindeth sinne also, by which those ends are come unto. But the Minor is to be denied, that Punishment and the Manifestation of the glory of God are the ends of sinne: For the end is that which moveth the efficient cause to bring forth an effect; but Punishment, or the Manifestation of the glory of God, do not move the sinners to sin: These cannot therefore be said to be the ends of sin. But those are the proper ends of sinne, which the Divels and men respect in sinning: ⟨p. 68⟩that is, the destruction of men, the fulfilling of evill desires, the oppression and reproach of God, and his truth.
1If they reply, That men indeed have not those ends, but that God respecteth them: For that which God permitteth, to show his justice by punishing it, the end which God proposeth thereof, is the punishment of the sinners, and his own glory; but he permitteth sin to punish it, and to declare himself just by punishing it: Therefore these are the ends of sin, in respect of the purpose and intent of God. We deny the Major: for God, suffering sin to be committed, respecteth as the end (not of another's work, that is, of the sin of Devils or men; but of his own work, that is, of his permission of sin) the punishment of sin, and the manifestation of his own justice: For sin is one thing, and the permission of sin another,2 whereof is spoken, For this cause have I appointed thee, to show my power in thee, 3and to declare my name throughout all the world. The Lord hath made all things for his own sake: yea even the wicked man for the day of evil. God, being willing to show his truth, 4and to make his power known, hath suffered with long patience the vessels of wrath prepared to destruction: Wherefore punishment is not the end, but the consequent or proper effect of sin; and an accidentary effect thereof is the manifestation of the glory of God:5 as Paul showeth, For, if the verity of God hath more abounded through my lie to his glory, &c.
1If they reply, That men indeed have not those ends, but that God respecteth them: For that which God permitteth, to shew his justice by punishing it, the end which God proposeth thereof, is the punishment of the sinners, and his owne glory; but he permitteth sin to punish it, and to declare himselfe just by punishing it: Therefore these are the ends of sin, in respect of the purpose and intent of God. We deny the Major: for God, suffering sinne to be committed, respecteth as the end (not of anothers work, that is, of the sinne of Divels or men; but of his own work, that is, of his permission of sin) the punishment of sin, and the manifestation of his owne justice: For sin is one thing, and the permission of sin another,
1If here again they reply, He that will the Consequent, will also the Antecedent; but God will these things which are the Consequents of sins, that is, Punishment and Execution of his justice: Therefore he will also the Antecedent, that is, Sin it self, without which these should not follow, or be Consequents. We deny the whole consequence of this reason: For nothing followeth, or can be concluded in reason, when both the former propositions are mere particular. For the Major of this reason is not universally true, but only then holdeth it, when as the Antecedent, together with the Consequent, agreeth with the nature of him which will the Consequent; and not when only the Consequent agreeth, and not the Antecedent: For when it falleth thus out, then is the Consequent by his will, but the Antecedent is not by his will, but only by permission: For God is said to will those things which he liketh, as agreeing with his nature and rightness; but to permit those things which yet he disliketh, abhorreth, and condemneth, but nevertheless for just causes hindereth them not from being done. And therefore it is said in the Scripture, that he will, and causeth life everlasting, which is the Consequent; and the conversion of men, which is the Antecedent, and goeth before: and that he will not, but only permitteth punishment, as it is sin, which followeth, and is the Consequent of sins: as is delivered in holy Scripture.
1If here againe they reply, He that will the Consequent, will also the Antecedent; but God will these things which are the Consequents of sins, that is, Punishment and Execution of his justice: Therefore he will also the Antecedent, that is, Sin it selfe, without which these should not follow, or be Consequents. We deny the whole consequence of this reason: For nothing followeth, or can be concluded in reason, when both the former propositions are meere particular. For the Major of this reason is not universally true, but only then holdeth it, when as the Antecedent, together with the Consequent, agreeth with the nature of him which will the Consequent; and not when only the Consequent agreeth, and not the Antecedent: For when it falleth thus out, then is the Consequent by his will, but the Antecedent is not by his will, but only by permission: For God is said to will those things which he liketh, as agreeing with his nature and rightnesse; but to permit those things which yet he disliketh, abhorreth, and condemneth, but neverthelesse for just causes hindereth them not from being done. And therefore it is said in the Scripture, that he will, and causeth life everlasting, which is the Consequent; and the conversion of men, which is the Antecedent, and goeth before: and that he will not, but only permitteth punishment, as it is sin, which followeth, and is the Consequent of sins: as is delivered in holy Scripture.
If again they urge,1 He that forbiddeth not sin, when he may forbid it to be committed, in him is some cause and fault of sin; but God permitteth it, when he might forbid it: Therefore there is some cause and fault of sin in him. We deny the Consequent, because the Major is not universally true: For it is only true of him who doth not perfectly hate sin,2 and therefore forbiddeth it not, when he may; and who is bound to hinder sin, that it be not committed: But it is not true of God, who with unspeakable anger accurseth and condemneth sin, neither yet hindereth is from being committed; because he is neither bound to do so, neither doth he permit it, without most good and just causes.
If againe they urge,1 He that forbiddeth not sin, when he may forbid it to be committed, in him is some cause and fault of sinne; but God permitteth it, when he might forbid it: Therefore there is some cause and fault of sin in him. We deny the Consequent, because the Major is not universally true: For it is onely true of him who doth not perfectly hate sinne,2 and therefore forbiddeth it not, when hee may; and who is bound to hinder sin, that it be not committed: But it is not true of God, who with unspeakable anger accurseth and condemneth sin, neither yet hindereth is from being committed; because he is neither bound to do so, neither doth he permit it, without most good and just causes.
1If they object farther, He that doth evil that good may come of it, doth not well; God, when he permitteth evil for good ends, doth evil that good may come of it: Wherefore he doth against his justice and law; and by a Consequent is bound to hinder evil. We deny the Minor: for God, when he permitteth evil, doth not evil, but good. For the permission of sin is one thing, which is the good and just work of God; and sin is another thing, which is the evil and unjust work of the Devil, or man sinning and transgressing the Law.
1If they object farther, He that doth evill that good may come of it, doth not well; God, when he permitteth evill for good ends, doth evill that good may come of it: Wherefore he doth against his justice and law; and by a Consequent is bound to hinder evill. Wee deny the Minor: for God, when he permitteth evill, doth not evill, but good. For the permission of sin is one thing, which is the good and just work of God; and sin is another thing, which is the evill and unjust work of the Divell, or man sinning and transgressing the Law.
Lastly, they say, What God permitteth willingly, that he will to be done; but he willingly permitteth sin: wherefore he will sin to be committed, and by a Consequent is the cause of sin. 1But the Major is to be denied: God will the permission, that is, the privation of his spirit and grace: but the sin of his creature, which concurreth ⟨p. 69⟩with it, he will not: because he neither mindeth it, nor approveth it. They confirm their Major by this argument: To permit, is either to Will, or, Not to will: but it is not, Not to will (for then either that should not be done, which God is said to permit, or something should be done that God would not: both of which are absurd.) Wherefore to Permit, is the same that to Will, and by a Consequent, God when he permitteth sin, doth will sin. We deny the Consequence, because there is not a sufficient enumeration of the diversities of will in the Minor: for God is said to Will, and not to Will a thing after two ways: Either to will, as when together he both liketh and worketh a thing; or, as he liketh a thing only, (under which also is comprehended his commanding) but doth not work it. And he is said, Not to will any thing, either, as he both disliketh and hindereth a thing; or, as he only disliketh it, but doth not forbid or hinder it. Both which kinds of will are contained in the Major; but only one of them in the Minor: which is, both to dislike and hinder a thing from being done. For, it God in that sense would not sin to be committed, then those absurdities should follow which they speak of. But when we say that God will not sins, we understand that they do greatly displease him, and yet that God hindereth them not from being committed: which also is not, to Will, but to Not will sin. For God can will nothing, but that which is agreeable to his own nature and goodness: neither doth the holy Scripture show any where, that God will those things which are contrary to his nature, in such sort as they are contrary.
Lastly, they say, What God permitteth willingly, that he will to be done; but he willingly permitteth sin: wherefore hee will sin to be committed, and by a Consequent is the cause of sin. 1But the Major is to be denied: God will the permission, that is, the privation of his spirit and grace: but the sinne of his creature, which concurreth
1This is also objected, He that is the cause or the efficient of a Cause, is also the author of the Effects of that cause, if not the next, yet afar off. But God is the cause of that Will, which is the cause of sin: therefore is he the cause of the Effect of the Will, that is, of sin. We answer to the Major, by distinguishing of the cause. For a cause which is afar off a cause, is sometimes by it self, and sometimes only by an accident a cause. That is, a cause by it self of an effect, which doth not only bring forth the next cause of the effect, but also doth move and govern it in bringing forth the effect which it self intended, or unto which it was appointed; as when God frameth and bendeth the will of men, which himself made, to good works, or to such actions as himself will have done; when the Father or Master bringeth up his Son or his Scholar to good things, and the learning which he instilleth into his mind moveth him to do well: when the Sun and rain maketh the earth fertile, and the earth bringeth forth corn. But when the cause which is a far off a cause either doth not move the next cause of the effect, or doth not intend or mind the effect, neither is appointed thereunto, it cannot be said to be a cause of that effect, but by an accident: as, when of a good Father, is borne an evil and evil-living Son; or of an evil Father, a good and well-living Son: when a godly Magistrate by his commandment •oveth the will of a wicked executioner to execute a guilty person, and he, being impelled either by desire of revenge, or by hatred, or by cruelty, rejoiceth at his evil whom he executeth, and so committeth murder before God: and lastly, when one maketh a sword, and another useth it well, or ill. Now, as often as the next cause is either before the bringing forth of the effect depraved, or in the very bringing of it forth, either by it self, or by an other cause; then bringeth it forth a bad effect, which the cause removed, or a far off, that either bringeth forth or moveth this next cause, neither intendeth neither, as by any ordination or appointment unto it, produceth. As when the will and hand of the cleaver purpose to cut a thing, and the iron, being too dull causeth that to break which is taken in hand to be cut: So also God maketh and moveth the will;
1This is also objected, Hee that is the cause or the efficient of a Cause, is also the author of the Effects of that cause, if not the next, yet afarre off. But God is the cause of that Will, which is the cause of sinne: therefore is hee the cause of the Effect of the Will, that is, of sinne. Wee answer to the Major, by distinguishing of the cause. For a cause which is afarr off a cause, is sometimes by it selfe, and sometimes onely by an accident a cause. That is, a cause by it selfe of an effect, which doth not onely bring forth the next cause of the effect, but also doth move and governe it in bringing forth the effect which it selfe intended, or unto which it was appointed; as when God frameth and bendeth the will of men, which himselfe made, to good workes, or to such actions as himselfe will have done; when the Father or Master bringeth up his Son or his Schollar to good things, and the learning which he instilleth into his minde moveth him to doe well: when the Sun and raine maketh the earth fertill, and the earth bringeth forth corne. But when the cause which is a farre off a cause either doth not move the next cause of the effect, or doth not intend or minde the effect, neither is appointed thereunto, it cannot be said to be a cause of that effect, but by an accident: as, when of a good Father, is borne an evill and evil-living Son; or of an evil Father, a good and wel-living Sonne: when a godly Magistrate by his commandement oveth the will of a wicked executioner to execute a guilty person, and he, being impelled either by desire of revenge, or by hatred, or by cruelty, reioyceth at his evil whom hee executeth, and so committeth murther before God: and lastly, when one maketh a sword, and another useth it well, or ill. Now, as aften as the next cause is either before the bringing forth of the effect depraved, or in the very bringing of it forth, either by it selfe, or by an other cause; then bringeth it forth a bad effect, which the cause removed, or a farre off, that either bringeth forth or moveth this next cause, neither intendeth neither, as by any ordination or appointment unto it, produceth. As when the will and hand of the cleaver purpose to cut a thing, and the iron, being too dull causeth that to breake which is taken in hand to be cut: So also God maketh and moveth the will;
but because the will of men is depraved by the Devil and it self, it bringeth forth sin, which God neither when he maketh nor when he moveth the will, intendeth or mindeth to bring forth. Wherefore it followeth not at all, that God is the cause of those things which are committed by his creatures, depraved and corrupted of themselves.
but because the will of men is depraved by the Divel and it selfe, it bringeth forth sin, which God neither when hee maketh nor when hee moveth the will, intendeth or mindeth to bring forth. Wherefore it followeth not at all, that God is the cause of those things which are committed by his creatures, depraved and corrupted of themselves.
Likewise it is objected: Second causes are able to do nothing without the first cause, which is good: Wherefore neither is sin brought forth, neither do they deprave themselves, but that also the first cause worketh it with them. We answer to the Antecedent, ⟨p. 70⟩The second causes do nothing without the first cause, that is, without the first cause preserve and move them to do,1 so far forth as it is good which they do: but they do without the first cause concurring with them to the bringing forth of evil, as it is a fault, or of sin. Woe to the rebellious children, saith the Lord, that take counsel, but not of me: and cover with a covering, but not by my spirit, that they may lay sin upon sin.
Likewise it is objected: Second causes are able to doe nothing without the first cause, which is good: Wherefore neither is sinne brought forth, neither doe they deprave themselves, but that also the first cause worketh it with them. We answer to the Antecedent, ⟨p. 70⟩The second causes doe nothing without the first cause, that is, without the first cause preserve and move them to doe,1 so farre forth as it is good which they doe: but they doe without the first cause concurring with them to the bringing forth of evill, as it is a fault, or of sinne. Woe to the rebellious children, saith the Lord, that take counsell, but not of me: and cover with a covering, but not by my spirit, that they may lay sinne upon sinne.
Likewise they object: That which is good, cannot by sinning corrupt it self, except it be some otherway corrupted: as it is said: A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit: The will of the Devil & Adam, before the fall of both, was good: Therefore it could not corrupt it self by sinning, except it were by some other means corrupted. We deny the Major. For although the creature be good,1 yet God not preserving his goodness, that is, moving or willing that his will should be moved by outward objects, neither in the mean season lightning and governing the will with the knowledge of his own divine will, it is not only possible, but it must necessarily follow that he must sin, become an evil tree, and through his own will and fault avert himself from God, run to worse and worse, and purchase blindness, the just punishment of sin, both unto him and his:2 as it is said; Without me ye can do nothing.
Likewise they object: That which is good, cannot by sinning corrupt it selfe, except it be some otherway corrupted: as it is said: A good tree cannot bring forth evill fruit: The will of the Devill & Adam, before the fall of both, was good: Therefore it could not corrupt it selfe by sinning, except it were by some other meanes corrupted. We deny the Major. For although the creature be good,1 yet God not preserving his goodnesse, that is, moving or willing that his wil should be moved by outward objects, neither in the meane season lightning and governing the will with the knowledge of his owne divine wil, it is not onely possible, but it must necessarily follow that he must sin, become an evil tree, and through his owne wil and fault avert himselfe from God, run to worse and worse, and purchase blindnesse, the just punishment of sin, both unto him and his:2 as it is said; Without me ye can doe nothing.
1Again, they object: He that is the cause of those things which make sin, is the cause of sin. God is the cause of those things which make sin, that is, of the Action, which is the matter, and of the privation of righteousness in man, which is the form of sin. Wherefore he is the author of sin. To these the answer hath been made before: For the Minor is to be denied; because the action and privation of the divine light and direction do make sin as they are contrary to the law: and they are contrary to the law of God, and make sin as they are committed by man, and are in him: but as they are guided by God, and inflicted, they are not sin, but a trial of him that would sin, or a punishment of him that had sinned. Wherefore that is not of God, but of man and the Devil which maketh sin.
1Againe, they object: He that is the cause of those things which make sin, is the cause of sin. God is the cause of those things which make sin, that is, of the Action, which is the matter, and of the privation of righteousnesse in man, which is the forme of sin. Wherefore he is the author of sin. To these the answer hath been made before: For the Minor is to be denyed; because the action and privation of the divine light and direction doe make sin as they are contrary to the law: and they are contrary to the law of God, and make sin as they are committed by man, and are in him: but as they are guided by God, and inflicted, they are not sin, but a tryal of him that would sin, or a punishment of him that had sinned. Wherefore that is not of God, but of man and the Devil which maketh sin.
1Last of all they urge: Seeing that God would the fall of Adam, either as it was sin, or as a punishment, and could not will it as a punishment, because no sin had gone before which should be therewith punished; it seemeth to follow that God would that work as it was sin. But this consequence also is deceitful, because there is not a sufficient enumeration in the Major. For although the first sin was no punishment, yet God would that action not as a sin, and contrary to his will and nature; but as in punishing, and receiving again mankind into favour by his Son, it was a way and occasion of exercising and manifesting his justice and mercy, and an example of the weakness of all creatures, yea of the most excellent, if they be not by the singular goodness of the Creator preserved; as it is declared, God hath shut up all in unbelief, that he might have mercy on all. 2And in the same place it is showed concerning the blindness of the Jews, That partly this obstinacy was come to Israel, until the fullness of the Gentiles were come in: and that the Jews are enemies, of the Gospel for our sakes; and that we have obtained mercy through their unbelief: That is, that God would this their obstinacy, not as it was a sin of the Jews, neither only as a punishment of other sins, but also an occasion of translating the Gospel unto the Gentiles. And it is said that God in the preaching of the Law respecteth this, That all the world be culpable before him. 3Wherefore this also he respected and would in permitting of sin, which if it had not come between, The Law had not made the world culpable before God.
1Last of all they urge: Seeing that God would the fall of Adam, either as it was sin, or as a punishment, and could not will it as a punishment, because no sin had gone before which should be therewith punished; it seemeth to follow that God would that worke as it was sin. But this consequence also is deceitfull, because there is not a sufficient ennumeration in the Major. For although the first sin was no punishment, yet God would that action not as a sin, and contrary to his will and nature; but as in punishing, and receiving againe mankinde into favour by his Son, it was a way and occasion of exercising and manifesting his justice and mercy, and an example of the weakenesse of al creatures, yea of the most excellent, if they be not by the singular goodnesse of the Creator preserved; as it is declared, God hath shut up all in unbeleefe, that he might have mercy on all.
Object. 1. Satan was made of God: And therefore the malice also of Satan. Answ. God made indeed all the Angels;1 yea those who became Apostates and Devils: but yet he created all the Angels at the beginning good. But Satan is said not to have stood steadfast in the truth: Then before his fall he stood in the truth; but after he treacherously fell from his allegiance, and sinned against God: and therefore the crime of that evil sticketh in that run-away the Devil. For since that time, after he fell, there is no truth in him, no faith, no integrity, no fear of God, no light, no goodness.2 He that committeth sin is of the Devil, &c. for he is the first sinner, and the fountain of sin.
Object. 1. Sathan was made of God: And therefore the malice also of Sathan. Answ. God made indeed all the Angels;1 yea those who became Apostates and Devils: but yet he created al the Angels at the beginning good. But Sathan is said not to have stood stedfast in the truth: Then before his fall he stood in the truth; but after hee treacherously fell from his allegeance, and sinned against God: and therefore the crime of that evill sticketh in that run-away the Devill. For since that time, after he fell, there is no truth in him, no faith, no integrity, no feare of God, no light, no goodnesse.2 He that committeth sin is of the Devill, &c. for he is the first sinner, and the fountaine of sinne.
Object. 2. God made Adam: Therefore he made sin. Answ. Sin is the corruption of nature created good of God, but not any creature made of God in man.1 God made man good; who by Satan's persuasion corrupted willingly that goodness which he received of God, so that now sin is mans, and not a creature of God created in man. Neither is the nature of man the cause of sin: for God, who created all things, and the very nature of man, created them all good;2 wherefore the very nature of man also was created good: but sin is an accidental quality which befell unto man in his fall, and after his fall, being even from the beginning such as now it is, but no substantial property, nor of the nature of man. Now indeed whereas we are borne in sin, sin is a natural property of men, 3according to the judgement of Augustine. But and if we say any man to be naturally evil, we say so, because of the original of the old sin, in which all our mortality now is borne.
Object. 2. God made Adam: Therefore he made sin. Answ. Sin is the corruption of nature created good of God, but not any creature made of God in man.1 God made man good; who by Sathans perswasion corrupted willingly that goodnesse which he received of God, so that now sin is mans, and not a creature of God created in man. Neither is the nature of man the cause of sin: for God, who created all things, and the very nature of man, created them all good;2 wherefore the very nature of man also was created good: but sinne is an accidentall quality which befell unto man in his fall, and after his fall, being even from the beginning such as now it is, but no substantiall property, nor of the nature of man. Now indeed whereas we are borne in sin, sin is a naturall property of men, 3according to the judgement of Augustine. But and if we say any man to be naturally evill, we say so, because of the originall of the old sin, in which all our mortality now is borne.
Object. 3. But the will and power which was in Adam was from God: Therefore sin also is from God. Ans. God gave not man a will and power to work evil.1 For he made a Law to forbid evil. Wherefore Adam himself did ill bestow that will and power which he received of God, in ill using of them. The prodigal son received money of his father, not that he should lash it out wastefully, but that he might have so much as sufficed need. Wherefore when himself did ill bestow his money, and perished; he perished through his own default, and not by his father, though he received the money of his father. Therefore the fault is in the abuse. He that giveth thee them, leaveth the use of them unto thee. If he be just, he giveth them thee for to use, and not to abuse. When thou abusest them, the fault is laid on thee who abusest them, and not on him who gave them. So God gave a will and power to Adam to do good, not to work evil.
Object. 3. But the will and power which was in Adam was from God: Therefore sin also is from God. Ans. God gave not man a will and power to work evill.1 For hee made a Law to forbid evill. Wherefore Adam himself did ill bestow that will and power which he received of God, in ill using of them. The prodigall son received money of his father, not that he should lash it out wastfully, but that he might have so much as sufficed need. Wherefore when himself did ill bestow his money, and perished; he perished through his owne default, and not by his father, though hee received the money of his father. Therefore the fault is in the abuse. He that giveth thee them, leaveth the use of them unto thee. If he be just, he giveth them thee for to use, and not to abuse. When thou abusest them, the fault is laid on thee who abusest them, and not on him who gave them. So God gave a will and power to Adam to do good, not to work evill.
Object. 4. God made man so as he might fall, 1neither did confirm and establish in him the goodness of his nature. Wherefore he would have him to fall, or sin. Answ. The Scripture beateth back this forwardness of men wickedly curious. Who art thou which pleadest against God? Woe be unto him that striveth with his Maker. Except God had made man so as he might fall, there had been no praise of his work or virtue. And what if it were necessary that man should be so made as he might fall? For so did the very nature of God require. God doth not grant his glory to any creature. Adam was a man, no God. And as God is good, so is he also just. He doth good unto men, but he will have them to be obedient and thankful unto him. He bestoweth infinite goodness upon man, therefore he should have been thankful, and obedient, and subject unto him. For he declareth by his law what he would, and what he would not. Of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, saith he, thou shalt not eat: When thou eatest, thou shalt die. As if he should say; Thou shalt regard me, thou shalt cleave unto me, obey me, serve me: neither shalt thou else-where seek for the rules of good and evil but of me, and so shalt thou show thy self obedient unto me. Repl. God fore-knew the fall of man, which if he would, he might have hindered: but he did not hinder it: Therefore God was in the fault that Adam sinned. Ans. Unto this objection answer hath been made before: neither doth that necessity follow upon the fore-knowledge of God, that Adam must needs have sinned, because God did fore-know that he would sin. Some wise father did fore-know by some signs and tokens that his son should hereafter at some time be slain with a sword. Neither doth this his fore-knowledge deceive him: for he was thrust through for fornication. But he is not therefore thought to be slain, because his father did fore-know that he should be slain, but because he was a fornicator.2 So saith Ambrose, speaking of the murder which Cain committed: Verily God did fore-know to what the fury of him, being in a rage, would come: neither yet was the attempt of his will forced of necessity to sin, because the knowledge of God could not be deceived. And Austine: God is a just revenger of those things, of which yet he is not an evil author.
Object. 4. God made man so as he might fall, 1
Wherefore, those sins which ensue and follow, are, in respect of God, considered as most just punishments; which, as they are punishments, have their being from him as their author and causer: but as they are sins, in respect of men, they come God neither willing nor causing them, but permitting only, seeing he doth not ⟨p. 72⟩cause men to do that which he would have done for a punishment, to this end, as for to obey therein his will: For, one and the same work is good and holy in respect of God,1 and sin in respect of men, by reason of the diversity both of the efficients, and of the ends. For, §11. Man, by reason of his great both ignorance and corruption, wills and worketh evil only; but God, because he is exceeding good, and the very rule of goodness and righteousness, doing in all things what he will, wills and worketh always only that which is good. §22. Men have such an end of their actions as is disagreeing from the Law of God, that is, what they do, they do not to that end to obey God, but to fulfil their bad and corrupt desires; but God hath the end of all his works agreeing with his Nature and Law, even that he may declare and execute his justice, goodness, and mercy. By these two things it cometh to pass, that the reasonable creature, working together with God, God working uprightly and holily, doth nevertheless it self work unholily and corruptly.
Wherefore, those sinnes which ensue and follow, are, in respect of God, considered as most just punishments; which, as they are punishments, have their being from him as their authour and causer: but as they are sinnes, in respect of men, they come God neither willing nor causing them, but permitting only, seeing hee doth not ⟨p. 72⟩cause men to do that which he would have done for a punishment, to this end, as for to obey therein his will: For, one and the same work is good and holy in respect of God,1 and sin in respect of men, by reason of the diversity both of the efficients, and of the ends. For, §1
Now that it is defined what sin is, and from whence it came, we are to consider also, what be the evils which follow sin: For, except this be also known, we know not yet how great evil there is in sin, and with how great hatred God pursueth it. It hath been said before, that evil was of two sorts: one of crime or offence, which is sin; the other of pain or punishment. The evil of punishment is the effect of the evil of offence. That this may be the better understood, we must here again remember, that of punishments, some are Only punishments, as are the destruction of nature, or torments: others, Both punishments and sin, as all sins, which have followed since the first fall.
NOw that it is defined what sinne is, and from whence it came, we are to consider also, what be the evils which follow sin: For, except this be also known, we know not yet how great evill there is in sin, and with how great hatred God pursueth it. It hath been said before, that evill was of two sorts: one of crime or offence, which is sin; the other of paine or punishment. The evill of punishment is the effect of the evill of offence. That this may be the better understood, we must here againe remember, that of punishments, some are Onely punishments, as are the destruction of nature, or torments: others, Both punishments and sin, as all sins, which have followed since the first fall.
1The sins which follow are the effects of those which go before. So Original sin is the effect of the sin or fall of our first Parents: By one mans disobedience many were made sinners.
1The sins which follow are the effects of those which goe before. So Originall sin is the effect of the sin or fall of our first Parents: By one mans disobedience many were made sinners.
1The effect of actual sin is the increase of them, that is, greater guiltiness by reason of the most just judgement of God; because God punisheth sins with sins. Wherefore God also gave them up to their hearts lusts: And therefore God shall send them strong delusions, that they should believe lies. From him that hath not, shall be taken away also that which he hath.
1The effect of actuall sin is the increase of them, that is, greater guiltinesse by reason of the most just judgement of God; because God punisheth sins with sins. Wherefore God also gave them up to their hearts lusts: And therefore God shall send them strong delusions, that they should beleeve lies. From him that hath not, shall be taken away also that which he hath.
1The effect of all actual sins are also oftentimes other mens sins, by reason of scandal or example, whereby some are made worse of others, and are enticed or moved to sin. So the persuasion of the Devil caused man to decline from God; and now it worketh in stubborn-minded men. The Devil put it into the heart of Judas to betray Christ. 2Evil speeches corrupt good manners: So evil teachers do withdraw men from God to errors, idolatry, and other sins. So a use of liberty, out of season, offendeth, and draweth men to sin.
1The effect of all actuall sins are also oftentimes other mens sins, by reason of scandall or example, whereby some are made worse of others, and are intised or moved to sin. So the perswasion of the Divell caused man to decline from God; and now it worketh in stubborn-minded men. The Divell put it into the heart of Judas to betray Christ. 2Evill speeches corrupt good manners: So evill teachers do withdraw men from God to errours, idolatry, and other sins. So a use of liberty, out of season, offendeth, and draweth men to sin.
1There followeth sin, in the immovable and perpetual order of Gods judgement, an evil conscience, which is the knowledge and dislike which we have in our mind of our own sin, and the knowledge of the judgement of God against sin, and that proceeding out of the knowledge of Gods Law, upon which ensueth the fear of the wrath of God and punishment, according to the order of Gods justice, and a flying and hatred of God who destroyeth sin; which is the beginning of despaira•ion and eternal torments, except it be cured by the comfort of the Gospel. The Gentiles show the effect of the Law written in their hearts, 2their conscience also bearing witness, 3and their thoughts accusing one another, or excusing. And, There is no peace to the wicked.
1There followeth sin, in the immoveable and perpetuall order of Gods judgement, an evill conscience, which is the knowledge and dislike which wee have in our mind of our own sin, and the knowledge of the judgement of God against sin, and that proceeding out of the knowledge of Gods Law, upon which ensueth the feare of the wrath of God and punishment, according to the order of Gods justice, and a flying and hatred of God who destroyeth sin; which is the beginning of despaira•ion and eternall torments, except it be cured by the comfort of the Gospel. The Gentiles shew the effect of the Law written in their hearts, 2their conscience also bearing witnesse, 3and their thoughts accusing one another, or excusing. And, There is no peace to the wicked.
1Temporal and Spiritual evils: as temporal death, and in a word all the calamities of this life: These evils are only punishments, that is, torments and dissolution of nature. If any man object, That they also are subject to temporal death and other calamities, who have all their sins remitted; and therefore all temporal evils are not the ⟨p. 73⟩punishments or effects of sin, but some have other causes. We answer,2 that the consequence holdeth not from the denial of one particular to the denial of the general. For albeit the calamities of the regenerate are not effects of sin as a punishment, which is inflicted on men sinning, that so the justice of God might be satisfied; yet are they effects of sin, as chastisements and exercises, whereby sin is repressed, and more and more purged out, until at length by corporal death the whole be abolished. Now that of the blind man, Neither this man hath sinned, 3nor his Parents, Christ meaneth not simply that they had not sinned, or that their sins were not a cause of this calamity; but that their sins were not the principal cause why he was borne blind: but that the works of God should be showed on him, Christ by a miracle opening his eyes.
1Temporall and Spirituall evils: as temporall death, and in a word all the calamities of this life: These evils are only punishments, that is, torments and dissolution of nature. If any man object, That they also are subject to temporall death and other calamities, who have all their sinnes remitted; and therefore all temporall evils are not the ⟨p. 73⟩punishments or effects of sinne, but some have other causes. Wee answer,2 that the consequence holdeth not from the deniall of one particular to the deniall of the generall. For albeit the calamities of the regenerate are not effects of sinne as a punishment, which is inflicted on men sinning, that so the justice of God might be satisfied; yet are they effects of sin, as chastisements and exercises, whereby sin is repressed, and more and more purged out, untill at length by corporall death the whole be abolished. Now that of the blind man, Neither this man hath sinned,
1Eternal death, which is the effect of all sins, as they are sins: For all sins, of what quality soever they be, are punished either with eternal pain, as in the Reprobate; or with equivalent pain to eternal, as in the Son of God. This death doth begin in the Reprobate, even in this world, that is, anxiety, and torment of conscience, which we also should feel except we were delivered by the grace of God. Now, by the name of eternal death is not understood the destruction of the soul or body, or the separation of them; but the abandoning and banishing of the soul and body living from the face of God, a continual horror, and torment, and a feeling and flying of Gods wrath and judgement, a horrible murmuring against God, taking vengeance of their sins. If they object, That the sins of those who believe in Christ, are not punished with eternal death: We answer, that those were punished in Christ with a punishment, which both for the grievousness of the punishment, and for the dignity of the person who suffered it, is equivalent to those eternal punishments, which were to be inflicted upon us for our sins: As it is said,2 He hath laid upon him the iniquity of us all. Against that which we affirm, That eternal death is the effect of all sins, yea even of the least, some thus dispute: Ob. Like is not to be given to things unlike; but sins are not like: Therefore all ought not to be punished with eternal death. Answ. There is more in the conclusion of this reason,3 then was in the premisses; for only this followeth to be concluded: Therefore all sins ought not to be punished with like punishment. For all sins, even the least, deserve eternal punishment; because all sins offend against the eternal and infinite good. Wherefore, as concerning the durance and lasting of the punishment, all sins are punished with like punishment; but not as concerning the degrees of punishment: All sins are punished with eternal torments, yet so, as not with equal torments. The servant who knoweth the will of his Master, and doth it not, shall be beaten with many stripes. It shall be easier for them of the land of Sodom in the day of judgement, then for thee. Greater sins shall be punished with more grievous torments, and lesser sins with lighter, but both for ever.
1Eternall death, which is the effect of all sins, as they are sins: For all sinnes, of what quality soever they be, are punished either with eternall pain, as in the Reprobate; or with equivalent paine to eternall, as in the Son of God. This death doth begin in the Reprobate, even in this world, that is, anxiety, and torment of conscience, which we also should feele except we were delivered by the grace of God. Now, by the name of eternall death is not understood the destruction of the soule or body, or the separation of them; but the abandoning and banishing of the soule and body living from the face of God, a continuall horrour, and torment, and a feeling and flying of Gods wrath and judgement, a horrible murmuring against God, taking vengeance of their sins. If they object, That the sinnes of those who beleeve in Christ, are not punished with eternall death: We answer, that those were punished in Christ with a punishment, which both for the grievousnesse of the punishment, and for the dignity of the person who suffered it, is equivalent to those eternall punishments, which were to be inflicted upon us for our sins: As it is said,
Here the Stoics object, That all sins or vices are joined with any one vice; and therefore all are like and equal: But neither is this consequence of force, whereas also things unlike & unequal may be joined together; neither is the Antecedent granted, that seemeth to be proved by the saying of James, He that faileth in one, 1is guilty of all. But James saith not, that all sins or vices concur and are joined with one: but first, that in the breach of one point the whole Law is violated; as the whole body is said to be hurt, when one part is harmed: Then, that there concurreth with every sin the fountain or cause of all other sins, that is, the contempt of God. And this evil being seated in the heart, doth violate the love of God, and so all other parts of our obedience towards God: For no work, which proceedeth not from the perfect love, dread & reverence of God, can agree with the Law of God, or please God. And yet have we experience that this hindereth not, but that which is infected with one vice, may be propense and prone to some sins more, and to some less, especially since vices themselves also are one opposite to another; by the one of which contraries, and not by both at one time, every man violateth virtue. Neither are those principles also of the Stoical Philosophers to be granted: That how far soever thou go in sinning, after thou hast once past the line or middle, which ⟨p. 74⟩is virtue, it is not material for the increasing or augmenting the fault of passing beyond the line: and that all virtues are alike and equal one to another, so that no man is stronger then a strong man. For, whereas sin is a swerving from the middle, it is manifest, that how much greater the swerving is, so much is the sin more grievous. And that virtues are both in the same, and in divers men, other-whiles greater, other-whiles lesser, even as much as the qualities of the body are different in degrees, experience doth witness: Wherefore in the judgement of God also there are degrees put as well of punishments as of sins.
Here the Stoicks object, That all sins or vices are joyned with any one vice; and therefore all are like and equall: But neither is this consequence of force, whereas also things unlike & unequall may be joyned together; neither is the Antecedent granted, that seemeth to be proved by the saying of James, He that faileth in one, 1
1It is requisite that this doctrine be known in the Church: §11. That knowing how great an evil sin is, we may yield the praise of justice unto God, who doth most severely punish it. §22. That we may abhor all sins with our whole heart, and desire the more earnestly to be fenced and defended of God against all sin. §33. That by extenuating or lessening any, we flatter not our selves in a conceit of our own righteousness, or in hope of escaping. §44. That measuring our sin by the Law of God, neither esteeming evil for good, or good evil, we loose not our consciences when God bindeth them, nor bind them when God looseth them: and acknowledging the remnant of sin in us, and our manifold fallings, we should not despair of pardon, flying to God the Mediator with boldness. §55. That also we may be able to discern our selves from the wicked and profane men, in whom sin reigneth, and from all those that sin against the holy Ghost, and that we may conceive in our mind hope and confidence of Gods mercy. §66. That we lay not the cause or fault of our sins and destruction on God, but remember that it is to be sought in our selves. §77. That knowing there are degrees of punishments, and sins, we add not sins to sins, but consider, that lesser sins shall be punished with lesser punishments, and greater with greater. §88. That remembering the sins of Parents are punished also in their posterity, we spare not only our selves, but our posterity also in avoiding sins. §99. That we may give and render thanks unto God for this benefit, that he, for his own glory, and the gathering and salvation of his Church, doth maintain and continue also amongst the wicked some order of virtue and discipline. §1010. That true and perpetual thankfulness may be kindled in us towards God, and his Son our Lord Jesus Christ, in that he hath delivered us from these great evils, sin, and the pains and punishment of sin.
The Question of Free-will, or of the power of mans will in well-doing, and performing obedience to God, occurreth next in order after the tract of Mans Misery: For necessary it is to know, what ability man was of before his fall, and of what strength after the same, that thence descrying aright the effects of the first sin, we may be the more pricked forwards and provoked to humility, and to an earnest desire of Gods divine grace and protection, and finally unto thankfulness towards him. For this doctrine of Free-will is a view or contemplation not of mens ability and excellency, but of their weakness and misery.
THe Question of Free-will, or of the power of mans will in well-doing, and performing obedience to God, occurreth next in order after the tract of Mans Misery: For necessary it is to know, what ability man was of before his fall, and of what strength after the same, that thence descrying aright the effects of the first sin, we may be the more pricked forwards and provoked to humility, and to an earnest desire of Gods divine grace and protection, and finally unto thankfulnesse towards him. For this doctrine of Free-will is a view or contemplation not of mens ability and excellency, but of their weaknesse and misery.
1THE principal scope and question of this disputation is, Whether as man averted himself from God; so on the other side he be able by his own strength to return to God, to receive grace offered by God, and to amend himself. And further, Whether the Will of man be the first and principal cause why others are converted, others persist in their sins: and as well of the converted, as not converted, others are more, others less good or evil; and in a word, do either good or evil, some after one manner, some after another. To this question the Pelagians and the like adversaries make answer, That so much grace is both given of, and left by nature to all men, that they are able to return unto God, and obey him: neither ought we to seek any other cause before, or above mans Will, for which others receive or retain, others refuse or cast away divine succour and aide in avoiding sin, and do after this or that manner order and institute their counsels and actions. Contrariwise, we have learned out of the sacred Scriptures, That no work pleasing to God can be undertaken or performed by any man without regeneration, and the s•••all grace of the holy Spirit; neither can more or less good be in any mans counsels or actions, then God of his free goodness doth cause in them; neither any other way can the will of any creature be inclined, then whither it shall seem good to the eternal and good counsel of God: and yet all the actions of the created will, both good and bad, are wrought freely. For the clearing hereof we are to consider: 1 What the liberty of the will, or free-will is. 2 What difference there is of the free-will which is in God, and that which is in reasonable creatures, Angels and Man. 3 Whether there be any liberty of mans will. 4 What manner of liberty of will is in man; or how many are the degrees of free-will, according to the four estates of man.
1THE principall scope and question of this disputation is, Whether as man averted himselfe from God; so on the other side hee be able by his owne strength to returne to God, to receive grace offered by God, and to amend himselfe. And further, Whether the Will of man be the first and principall cause why others are converted, others persist in their sinnes: and as well of the converted, as not converted, others are more, others lesse good or evill; and in a word, doe either good or evill, some after one manner, some after another. To this question the Pelagians and the like adversaries make answer, That so much grace is both given of, and left by nature to all men, that they are able to returne unto God, and obey him: neither ought wee to seeke any other cause before, or above mans Will, for which others receive or retaine, others refuse or cast away divine succour and aide in avoiding sinne, and doe after this or that manner order and institute their counsels and actions. Contrariwise, we have learned out of the sacred Scriptures, That no worke pleasing to God can be undertaken or performed by any man without regeneration, and the sall grace of the holy Spirit; neither can more or lesse good be in any mans counsels or actions, then God of his free goodnesse doth cause in them; neither any other way can the will of any creature be inclined, then whither it shall seeme good to the eternall and good counsell of God: and yet all the actions of the created will, both good and bad, are wrought freely. For the clearing hereof we are to consider: 1 What the liberty of the will, or free-will is. 2 What difference there is of the free-will which is in God, and that which is in reasonable creatures, Angels and Man. 3 Whether there be any liberty of mans will. 4 What manner of liberty of will is in man; or how many are the degrees of free-will, according to the foure estates of man.
1It is requisite that this doctrine be knowne in the Church: §11. That knowing how great an evill sin is, we may yeeld the praise of justice unto God, who doth most severely punish it. §22. That we may abhorre all sins with our whole heart, and desire the more earnestly to be fenced and defended of God against all sin. §33. That by extenuating or lessning any, wee flatter not our selves in a conceit of our owne righteousnesse, or in hope of escaping. §44. That measuring our sin by the Law of God, neither esteeming evill for good, or good evill, we loose not our consciences when God bindeth them, nor bind them when God looseth them: and acknowledging the remnant of sin in us, and our manifold fallings, wee should not despaire of pardon, flying to God the Mediatour with boldnesse. §55. That also wee may be able to discerne our selves from the wicked and profane men, in whom sin reigneth, and from all those that sin against the holy Ghost, and that wee may conceive in our mind hope and confidence of Gods mercy. §66. That wee lay not the cause or fault of our sins and destruction on God, but remember that it is to be sought in our selves. §77. That knowing there are degrees of punishments, and sins, we adde not sins to sins, but consider, that lesser sins shall be punished with lesser punishments, and greater with greater. §88. That remembring the sins of Parents are punished also in their posterity, we spare not only our selves, but our posterity also in avoiding sins. §99. That we may give and render thankes unto God for this benefit, that he, for his owne glory, and the gathering and salvation of his Church, doth maintain and continue also amongst the wicked some order of vertue and discipline. §1010. That true and perpetuall thankfulnesse may be kindled in us towards God, and his Son our Lord Jesus Christ, in that he hath delivered us from these great evils, sin, and the paines and punishment of sin.