To whatsoever organ the eating of one thing in the Lords Supper doth agree, to that same it is needful, that the eating of another thing should agree: but to the mouth of the body, the eating of one thing; that is, of the bread in the Supper, doth agree: and therefore of another thing; that is, of Christs body. Answ. The Major is true of foods that are naturally conjoined, or contain each other: as meat, or flesh-pies; but the bread and Christs body are not thus conjoined: and therefore of these the Major is false. But he proves the Major: Whosoever includes, under the same word of eating, bread and wine, the body and blood of Christ, he also affirms, that both are received by the same instrument; but Christ includes bread and wine, his body and blood, within the same word of eating: Therefore Christ affirms also, that both are received by the same instrument of eating. Answ. 1. The Disputer doth not conclude the Major that is denied, which he should conclude by an universal Syllogism in Barbara: therefore his proof is idle. Answ. 2. The Major is a petition of the thing in question, and is denied. The falsehood also is plain out of John 3. where Christ, under the same word of birth, includes the spirit and flesh: and yet it follows not, that both are borne after the same manner, or by the same instrument. Answ. 3. The Minor is also false: For, the word Eat is referred to the consecrated bread, and not to the body, but only by consequence or analogy: for properly it belongs to that which Christ took with his hands, and broke; which was bread, and not his body. This reason is worth the noting; because, according to the Papists, and the simple Consubstantiators, the body of Christ is not present, till the words of consecration be uttered: but in the last instant of uttering these syllables, For this is my body, it begins to be present. But according to the Ubiquitaries, who are (as it were) chemical Consubstantiators, it is present, as in any other bread; but is not eatable, till after the consecration. Christ then did not command us to eat that in the bread, which as yet was not there, or not as yet eatable. We say briefly, that by the word of eating, is only commanded the oral manducation of the outward Sacrament, or the bread: but by the word of promise, This is my body, which is given for you; which promise agreeth with that, John 6.52.
To whatsoever organ the eating of one thing in the Lords Supper doth agree, to that same it is needfull, that the eating of another thing should agree: but to the mouth of the body, the eating of one thing; that is, of the bread in the Supper, doth agree: and therefore of another thing; that is, of Christs body. Answ. The Major is true of foods that are naturally conjoyned, or contain each other: as meat, or flesh-pies; but the bread and Christs bodie are not thus conjoyned: and therefore of these the Major is false. But he proves the Major: Whosoever includes, under the same word of eating, bread and wine, the body and bloud of Christ, he also affirmes, that both are received by the same instrument; but Christ includes bread and wine, his body and bloud, within the same word of eating: Therefore Christ affirmes also, that both are received by the same instrument of eating. Answ. 1. The Disputer doth not conclude the Major that is denied, which he should conclude by an universall Syllogisme in Barbara: therefore his proofe is idle. Answ. 2. The Major is a petition of the thing in question, and is denied. The falshood also is plaine out of