[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
pp. 770–844447 passagespart 9 of 12
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Reas. 1. Because the faithful only by faith receive the promise by which the things signified are offered. Reas. 2. Because the believers alone have the Spirit of Christ, from which his living flesh cannot be separated. Reas. 3. Because Christ dwells only in the faithful, and they in him by faith, Ephes. 3.17. Reas. 4. Because the believers alone receive and have life eternal, John 3. and 6.
Reas. 1. Because the faithful only by faith receive the promise by which the things signified are offered. Reas. 2. Because the beleevers alone have the Spirit of Christ, from which his living flesh cannot be separated. Reas. 3. Because Christ dwels onely in the faithfull, and they in him by faith, Ephes. 3.17. Reas. 4. Because the beleevers alone receive and have life eternall, John 3. and 6.
Propos. 2. Impious or incredulous men coming without faith, receive the signs without the thing signified; but, the things themselves being proffered, they reject, because of their infidelity.
Propos. 2. Impious or incredulous men coming without faith, receive the signes without the thing signified; but, the things themselves being proferred, they reject, because of their infidelity.
For the Reasons, see Explicat. Catechet. q. 81. Titulo, What the wicked receive in the Lords Supper. As for the Objections concerning wicked mens eating in the Supper, see ibid.
GOD, by an eternal and immutable Decree, in his Son Christ Jesus, before the foundation of the world, did decree, out of the lapsed race of man-kind, subject to sin, to save such in, for, and by Christ, as by the grace of the holy Spirit do believe in the same Son, and persevere in that obedience of Faith to the end, by the same grace. On the other side, he decreed to relinquish and condemn, as strangers from Christ, such as are not converted, but continue in infidelity, subject to sin and wrath; according to that of the Gospel, John 3.36. He that believeth in the Son, hath life eternal; but he that believeth not, shall not see life eternal, but the wrath of God abideth on him.
GOD, by an eternall and immutable Decree, in his Son Christ Jesus, before the foundation of the world, did decree, out of the lapsed race of man-kinde, subject to sin, to save such in, for, and by Christ, as by the grace of the holy Spirit do beleeve in the same Son, and persevere in that obedience of Faith to the end, by the same grace. On the other side, he decreed to relinquish and condemne, as strangers from Christ, such as are not converted, but continue in infidelity, subject to sin and wrath; according to that of the Gospell, John 3.36. He that beleeveth in the Son, hath life eternall; but he that beleeveth not, shall not see life eternall, but the wrath of God abideth on him.
AT first sight, this Article seems to have no question or inconvenience in it, but to deliver the sum of the Gospel, what sort of men, by what means God decreed from eternity to save; to wit, believers in the Son of God, and perseveres to the end in faith, and in the obedience of faith, by the grace of the holy Ghost. On the other side, what sort of men he hath appointed to condemn; to wit, such as are not converted, Infidels, strangers from Christ: both which is taught in the Gospel.
AT first sight, this Article seemes to have no question or inconvenience in it, but to deliver the summe of the Gospell, what sort of men, by what meanes God decreed from eternity to save; to wit, beleevers in the Son of God, and perseveres to the end in faith, and in the obedience of faith, by the grace of the holy Ghost. On the other side, what sort of men he hath appointed to condemne; to wit, such as are not converted, Infidels, strangers from Christ: both which is taught in the Gospell.
So many good men, chiefly Politicians, judge of this Article: neither do they think it fitting to wade deeper into this Controversy; especially, seeing it seems to ascribe all the means of salvation fully to God, to Christ, and to grace. And truly, here should be no question, if the Authors meant only this, that by this Article is explained the popular doctrine of the qualities of those that shall be saved or damned. But, because in the Conference they profess,1 That this Article contains the doctrine of predestination to salvation; but deny, that the qualities of those that shall be saved, to wit, faith and perseverance, proceed from predestination, as from their fountain: but contend, that these are in order before predestination ⟨p. 818⟩or election, and not obscurely, they make them depend upon mans will: whence necessarily, God must be robbed of the full glory of our salvation, man must be puffed up with pride, our Christian comfort in life and death must be undermined, free justification, and the assurance of salvation must be denied, whatsoever they pretend in their garnished speeches to the contrary. Therefore, this Article cannot be simply approved of: and it is full of equivocations, and dangerous swelling phrases; under which, Pelagianism is under-hand brought into the Church: which fraud, that it might appear the less, they purposely abstain from the word predestination.
So many good men, chiefly Politicians, judge of this Article: neither do they think it fitting to wade deeper into this Controversie; especially, seeing it seemes to ascribe all the meanes of salvation fully to God, to Christ, and to grace. And truly, here should be no question, if the Authors meant onely this, that by this Article is explained the popular doctrine of the qualities of those that shall be saved or damned. But, because in the Conference they professe,1 That this Article containes the doctrine of predestination to salvation; but deny, that the qualities of those that shall be saved, to wit, faith and perseverance, proceed from predestination, as from their fountaine: but contend, that these are in order before predestination ⟨p. 818⟩or election, and not obscurely, they make them depend upon mans will: whence necessarily, God must be robbed of the full glory of our salvation, man must be puffed up with pride, our Christian comfort in life and death must be undermined, free justification, and the assurance of salvation must be denied, whatsoever they pretend in their garnished speeches to the contrary. Therefore, this Article cannot be simply approved of: and it is full of equivocations, and dangerous swelling phrases; under which, Pelagianisme is under-hand brought into the Church: which fraud, that it might appeare the lesse, they purposely abstaine from the word predestination.
Now, in Austin's time, the Pelagian Heresy was thus: 1. That Adams sin hutted no man but himself; and, that man is not borne now in a worse condition then he was created. 2. That Christ was seen, and died to expiate all sins committed by imitation of Adam. 3. That salvation in Christ is so proposed to all men, that whosoever will believe and be baptised, may be saved. 4. That God fore-knew before the foundation of the world, who were to believe and do good works, and who were to continue in the Faith, being assisted by grace; and that he predestinated for his kingdom whom he fore-saw, being freely called, would believe above others, and would be worthy of their calling, and should die an happy •eath. 5. That the grace of God was given to all men, according to their merit, for the better using of their free-will. 6. And that in this life so much is given, that man may, if he will, be free from all sin.
Now, in Austines time, the Pelagian Heresie was thus: 1. That Adams sin hutted no man but himselfe; and, that man is not borne now in a worse condition then he was created. 2. That Christ was seene, and died to expiate all sins committed by imitation of Adam. 3. That salvation in Christ is so proposed to all men, that whosoever will beleeve and be baptised, may be saved. 4. That God fore-knew before the foundation of the world, who were to beleeve and doe good works, and who were to continue in the Faith, being assisted by grace; and that he predestinated for his kingdome whom he fore-saw, being freely called, would beleeve above others, and would be worthy of their calling, and should die an happie •eath. 5. That the grace of God was given to all men, according to their merit, for the better using of their free-will. 6. And that in this life so much is given, that man may, if he will, be free from all sin.
Against this Heresy Hierome and Austin disputed at large; and Austin retracted three whole Chapters, Tom. 7. in opusculis: 1. Concerning original sin. 2. Of grace, and the cause of predestination. 3. Of the perfection of righteousness. Pelagius in the Synod of Palestine, being condemned, did so far revoke his error, that he wished Anathema to him that thinks or says, 1that the grace of God, by which Christ came into this world to save sinners, is not necessary, not only every hour, or every moment, but also, to every one of our actions; and who go about to take this away, they shall be punished eternally. Who would not clear Pelagius in this case? but under the buskin of this word grace, he deluded the Palestine Bishops, as Austin showeth: he left behind him two disciples, Caelestius and Julianus, young men, of a sharp wit, and with whom Austin in Africa had much ado. At last, this infection flew over the Mediterrane-sea, into Sicily, and Marseilles in France; not all of it, but only so much as concerned the point of grace and predestination, and the death of Christ; the Asserters of which were called Semi-pelagians, and the remainders of the Pelagians; of which points there are extant the Epistles of Prosper Aquitanicus, and of Hilarius Arelatensis to Austin; whose learned Answer, contained in two Books, of the predestination of the Saints, and of the good of perseverance; and in a third, concerning correction and grace. To which Answer, if the Authors of these Articles at this day, would stand as they may and should stand, (for, it is altogether S. Pauls doctrine) the matter had been decided ere this. For, indeed, Arminius, with his followers, have at this day re-assumed the cause of the Marsilians and Syracusians, but somewhat more handsomely dressed: Neither could he be ignorant of this, and therefore he used but little ingenuity in his tergiversation, when he wrote in the Articles, That he acknowledgeth neither Semi-pelagianism objected against him, nor nine, nor five, nor four inches of it. But, to return to the Article; in it there be divers equivocations, as shall appear.
Against this Heresie Hierome and Austine disputed at large; and Austine retracted three whole Chapters, Tom. 7. in opusculis: 1. Concerning originall sin. 2. Of grace, and the cause of predestination. 3. Of the perfection of righteousnesse. Pelagius in the Synod of Palestina, being condemned, did so farre revoke his errour, that he wished Anathema to him that thinks or sayes, 1
1. The first lofty phrase lieth hid in Gods immutable Decree. According to Scripture, that is Gods immutable Decree, which absolutely is not changed, nor by the creatures can be changed; for, so God pronounceth himself immutable, and his counsel immutable:1 I am God and change not. My counsel shall stand, and I will do all that I have decreed. But they understand, that God by an immutable Decree indeed, hath decreed to save believers, in regard of the species; that is, none but believers, but not by a decree altogether immutable, in respect of the individuals: to wit, of this or that believer; but under a condition, if this or that believer do not cause a change. For, they think (as appears by the fifth Article) that they who believe ⟨p. 819⟩to day, may be unbelievers to morrow; and again, of unbelievers, may come to believe: consequently therefore, they think that God to day may decree not to save, which yesterday by his immutable decree he appointed to save; and that again he can decree to save them, still changing their condition. If this be to give to God an immutable decree, let themselves judge: sure,2 no shadow can be more changeable then such a decree, which the Scripture denieth.
1. The first lofty phrase lieth hid in Gods immutable Decree. According to Scripture, that is Gods immutable Decree, which absolutely is not changed, nor by the creatures can be changed; for, so God pronounceth himselfe immutable, and his counsell immutable:1 I am God and change not. My counsell shall stand, and I will do all that I have decreed. But they understand, that God by an immutable Decree indeed, hath decreed to save beleevers, in regard of the species; that is, none but beleevers, but not by a decree altogether immutable, in respect of the individuals: to wit, of this or that beleever; but under a condition, if this or that beleever do not cause a change. For, they thinke (as appeares by the fifth Article) that they who beleeve ⟨p. 819⟩to day, may be unbeleevers to morrow; and againe, of unbeleevers, may come to beleeve: consequently therefore, they thinke that God to day may decree not to save, which yesterday by his immutable decree he appointed to save; and that againe he can decree to save them, still changing their condition. If this be to give to God an immutable decree, let themselves judge: sure,
The Authors Decreti Holland. pag. 5. place such a decree in God,1 denying That any by God are invited to salvation, to whom he hath not altogether decreed to give salvation; for, this being granted, we must say, that God had altogether decreed to give salvation to the Cities of Judea and Galilee, whom Christ by preaching invited to salvation; but seeing they believed not, they were not saved: therefore, either he before did •ot decree to save them, or afterward he changed his decree.
The Authors Decreti Holland. pag. 5. place such a decree in God,1 denying That any by God are invited to salvation, to whom he hath not altogether decreed to give salvation; for, this being granted, we must say, that God had altogether decreed to give salvation to the Cities of Judea and Galilee, whom Christ by preaching invited to salvation; but seeing they beleeved not, they were not saved: therefore, either he before did •ot decree to save them, or afterward he changed his decree.
2. The second ••••ing phrase, and that the chiefest, the foundation of the rest, containing the •••••e of the whole cause, and difference of both parts, is in the word appointed. This, according to the Scripture, signifieth to us, that God not only from eternity appo•••ed to save them who in time believe and persevere, and are saved; but also, to elect them in Christ, and to predestinate them to salvation, and decreed to bestow on them qualities requisite to salvation; to wit, faith,1 conversion, and perseverance, by the word, and grace of the holy Ghost, that they may be infallibly saved; and that to declare the praise of his glorious grace: On the contrary, that he hath from eternity decreed not to save those, who in time neither believe, nor persevere, nor are saved; and that he hath not appointed to elect them in Christ, nor to ordain them to life eternal,2 nor to give them faith and perseverance, but to leave them in their original blindness and infidelity, and to condemn them for their sins; and that to declare his wrath, and make known his power upon them.
2. The second ••••ing phrase, and that the chiefest, the foundation of the rest, containing the •••••e of the whole cause, and difference of both parts, is in the word appointed. This, according to the Scripture, signifieth to us, that God not onely from eternity appo•••ed to save them who in time beleeve and persevere, and are saved; but also, to elect them in Christ, and to predestinate them to salvation, and decreed to bestow on them qualities requisite to salvation; to wit, faith,1 conversion, and perseverance, by the word, and grace of the holy Ghost, that they may be infallibly saved; and that to declare the praise of his glorious grace: On the contrary, that he hath from eternity decreed not to save those, who in time neither beleeve, nor persevere, nor are saved; and that he hath not appointed to elect them in Christ, nor to ordaine them to life eternall,
The continued History of the world also, and experience do witness, that God sometimes did so discriminate people, that on some he vouchsafed to bestow the grace of his Covenant, and vocation by the word, on others not; that he also differenced the individuals of those he calls, that upon the one he confers effectual grace, faith, conversion, perseverance, and salvation; but, on the other not, and that without any merit of people, or individuals, or without any regard had to the excellency of their natures and dispositions; for, he found all alike averse from heavenly things, and he might have drawn and directed all to himself equally, had he pleased; this difference then proceeded merely from his will and goodness. So he chose the Israelites for his peculiar people, other Nations being rejected. Psal. 147.19. His judgements he declares to Israel, he hath not done so to any other Nation▪Jer. 41.9. I have chosen thee, and have not reprobated thee. But why? Deut. 7.7. Not because you were greater, or more then other people, did the Lord love and choose you, but because he loved you, &c. Again, of these Israelites that were called, some he elected, others he reprobated. Jacob have I loved, Esau have I hated, 1&c. And that not of works, but that the purpose of election might remain firm, &c. And in this Age he vouchsafes to call us Christians, by the word of the Gospel; which favour he showeth not to Turks, Pagans, &c. And of these Christians, whom he calls, to some he gives true faith, conversion, perseverance, and eternal salvation; to others he gives not, but leaves them in ignorance and hypocrisy.
The continued History of the world also, and experience do witnesse, that God sometimes did so discriminate people, that on some he vouchsafed to bestow the grace of his Covenant, and vocation by the word, on others not; that he also differenced the individuals of those he cals, that upon the one he conferres effectuall grace, faith, conversion, perseverance, and salvation; but, on the other not, and that without any merit of people, or individuals, or without any regard had to the excellency of their natures and dispositions; for, he found all alike averse from heavenly things, and he might have drawne and directed all to himself equally, had he pleased; this difference then proceeded meerely from his will and goodnesse. So he chose the Israelites for his peculiar people, other Nations being rejected.
Neither can this discrimination of people and persons be derogated from divine providence, and ascribed to mens dispositions, without blasphemy: otherwise, for choosing us by vocation and adoption above others, there should be no need of prayers to God, nor should we give thanks to God; nor should that of the Apostle ⟨p. 820⟩stand,1 Who hath separated thee? What hast thou, which thou hast not received? but if thou hast received, why doest thou glory, as if thou hadst not received it? Then Atheism must stand, which the Pelagian Heresy brought in: I have separated my self, I have that which I have not received; which is the gulf of hell.
Neither can this discrimination of people and persons be derogated from divine providence, and ascribed to mens dispositions, without blasphemy: otherwise, for choosing us by vocation and adoption above others, there should be no need of prayers to God, nor should we give thanks to God; nor should that of the Apostle ⟨p. 820⟩stand,1 Who hath separated thee? What hast thou, which thou hast not received? but if thou hast received, why doest thou glory, as if thou hadst not received it? Then Atheisme must stand, which the Pelagian Heresie brought in: I have separated my selfe, I have that which I have not received; which is the gulfe of hell.
But,1 in Divinity there is an undoubted Rule, depending on the authority of the holy Scripture; Whatsoever God did in time, he decreed to do it from eternity, seeing in God there is no change. Therefore among Christians it ought to be out of doubt, why God from eternity made this difference of the elect and not elect, but reprobate; of those that shall be saved, and not saved, but for sin condemned; which we see God hath done,2 and doth in time, and therefore decreed to do it before time. For, God being spoiled of his power and wisdom in choosing, (saith Luther) what will he be else but the Idol of Fortune, by whose Deity all things were done temerariously? And at last it will come to this, that men shall be saved and damned without Gods knowledge, as who did not by any certain election discriminate who should be saved, who damned: but offering to all a general lenity, tolerating and obdurating, then a mercy correcting and punishing, hath left to mens choice, whether they will be saved or damned; he himself perhaps being gone to the Ethiopian feast, as Homer speaks. And this is the sum of the orthodoxall doctrine of predestination; and so the word appointed in the Article, is to be understood altogether according to experience and Scripture. But to them it signifieth far otherwise; to wit, that God from eternity appointed to save those, who in time believe and persevere, under this condition, that they believe and persevere: otherwise, that he hath no more ordained them to salvation, then all other men; nor hath elected them in Christ, but only casually, so far as they above others would believe in Christ and persevere, (for, they make faith and perseverance antecedent to election:) but that these rather then others should believe and persevere, God did not decree to effect this in them by any singular grace; but decreed to offer unto all men, a certain universal exciting and preventing grace, but indifferent and resistible; to which, they who make no resistance, but, by using well their free-will, do assent and co-operate, for the begetting of faith, and performing of perseverance to the end; they, I say, are elected and predestinated in Christ; and therefore God, from eternity hath casually, and out of their fore-seen faith and perseverance elected them in Christ, and hath predestinated them to salvation, or hath appointed to save them:
but who resist the same, or will not co-operate with faith and perseverance, these are not elected and predestinated in Christ; and therefore, God from eternity, casually also of their fore-seen infidelity, hath predestinated them to damnation, or hath decreed to condemn them. That this is their proper meaning, all their Declarations show; and, that this was the opinion of the Semi-pelagians, Marsilians, and Syracusians, he that will not believe, let him read in Austin, in the places formerly alleged. And, it is manifest, that, according to this opinion, neither faith, nor perseverance, nor conversion, nor salvation, nor our separation from others, are due to Gods grace alone, but to our will and cooperation. For example, when in one City, of many that hear the same Sermon, and have the same exciting grace, the one believes, the other doth not; the one perseveres, the other fails: if the Apostle Paul should demand of the believer and perseverer, Who separated thee? What hast thou which thou hast not received? He will answer, I separated my self, because I was willing to co-operate with exciting grace, I had a will to co-operate, I received it not. By which blasphemous lye, shall not man cast himself headlong with Satan into hell? But if faith, and perseverance, and our salvation shall be built upon our will, how can free justification stand? And whereas nothing is more mutable then mans will, shall not our whole salvation stand upon the sand, and all the assurance and comfort of a Christian be reduced to nothing? And so much of this other high phrase.
but who resist the same, or will not co-operate with faith and perseverance, these are not elected and predestinated in Christ; and therefore, God from eternity, casually also of their fore-seene infidelity, hath predestinated them to damnation, or hath decreed to condemne them. That this is their proper meaning, all their Declarations shew; and, that this was the opinion of the Semi-pelagians, Marsilians, and Syracusians, he that will not beleeve, let him reade in Austine, in the places formerly alledged. And, it is manifest, that, according to this opinion, neither faith, nor perseverance, nor conversion, nor salvation, nor our separation from others, are due to Gods grace alone, but to our will and cooperation. For example, when in one City, of many that heare the same Sermon, and have the same exciting grace, the one beleeves, the other doth not; the one perseveres, the other failes: if the Apostle Paul should demand of the beleever and perseverer, Who separated thee? What hast thou which thou hast not received? He will answer, I separated my selfe, because I was willing to co-operate with exciting grace, I had a will to co-operate, I received it not. By which blasphemous lye, shall not man cast himselfe headlong with Satan into hell? But if faith, and perseverance, and our salvation shall be built upon our will, how can free justification stand? And whereas nothing is more mutable then mans will, shall not our whole salvation stand upon the sand, and all the assurance and comfort of a Christian be reduced to nothing? And so much of this other high phrase.
3. There is also an equivocation in the words, Out of the lapsed and sinful race of mankind. By the lapsed race of mankind, the Scripture and Catechise do understand man as he is lost in original sin by Adams fall; that is, not only dead in sin, but also so viciated and corrupted, that he is altogether unfit to do any good thing, ⟨p. 821⟩and b•nt to all evil, till he be regenerated by the holy Ghost: as God decreed to propagate, and, as in time, he gathered for himself; so, from eternity, he appointed to gather for himself: that is, he hath elected an eternal Church in Christ. They understand, indeed, that man is fallen, and subject to original sin, (of which they have not yet declared themselves) as likewise to actual transgressions; yet, that he is not so depraved, but that he can freely both will and choose good and evil; hear God, calling on him; open to him, knocking; either resist, or assent, or co-operate with exciting grace: which interpretation is repugnant to Scripture and truth; Who hath separated thee? We are not fit of our selves, 1&c. The wisdom of the flesh is enmity against God.
3. There is also an equivocation in the words, Out of the lapsed and sinfull race of mankinde. By the lapsed race of mankinde, the Scripture and Catechise do understand man as he is lost in originall sin by Adams fall; that is, not onely dead in sin, but also so viciated and corrupted, that he is altogether unfit to do any good thing, ⟨p. 821⟩and b•nt to all evill, till he be regenerated by the holy Ghost: as God decreed to propagate, and, as in time, he gathered for himself; so, from eternity, he appointed to gather for himselfe: that is, he hath elected an eternall Church in Christ. They understand, indeed, that man is fallen, and subject to originall sin, (of which they have not yet declared themselves) as likewise to actuall transgressions; yet, that he is not so depraved, but that hee can freely both will and choose good and evill; heare God, calling on him; open to him, knocking; either resist, or assent, or co-operate with exciting grace: which interpretation is repugnant to Scripture and truth; Who hath separated thee? We are not fit of our selves,
4. There is also a notable Cothurne in the relative them, which we, with the Apostle, Rom. 8.30. understand of certain individual men: as, of Peter, of Paul. &c. predestinated by God, not only to salvation and glory; but also to the antecedent means of salvation, and to the qualities required in those that shall be saved; to outward and inward calling, to faith and justification, to conversion and perseverance to the end, according to the Apostles saying, Whom he predestinated, them he called: whom he called, them he justified: whom he justified, them he hath also glorified: Whose number (saith Austin) is so certain, there can be none added to it, 1nor diminished from it. To whom alone it is given infallibly, that they believe and persevere, and that they cannot perish: as it is said, They believed, so many as were ordained to life eternal; that is, as Chrysostom expounds it, They that were predestinated by God: And, Who hath begun a good work in you, will perfect it, against the day of Jesus Christ. It is impossible that the elect shall be seduced. Now, they understand not certain men, but whosoever casually will believe; or, certain men, but in the species only, not in the individual: believers, before their election, predestinate not to faith and perseverance; but after faith to salvation casually, if they persevere. More briefly, we understand them, whom election and predestination makes believers and perseverers; but they mean those, whom election finds believing and persevering.2 Most briefly thus, We understand those that were to believe, or believers consequently, or after election; they, such as were to believe, or believers antecedently, or in order before election; to wit, after the same manner that the chariot draws the horse: for, if faith cannot be before vocation, which is after election and predestination, how can it be before election? But the Apostle on the contrary, He hath chosen us, that we might be holy; not, when we were holy:3 But faith is the beginning of our sanctification, Act. 15.9.
4. There is also a notable Cothurne in the relative them, which we, with the Apostle,
5. Much like is that Cothurne in the words, In Christ: We understand with the Apostle, that God, before the foundation of the world elected us in Christ consequently; that is, that by Faith and the Spirit we might be engrafted in Christ, as members in the head; and, that we might be in Christ after election: for, the Apostle declares shortly after ver. 4. He hath predestinated us into adoption by Jesus Christ: But adoption is by faith, John 1.12. But they understand, that God elected us in Christ antecedently; that is, existing in Christ before election, by fore-seen faith; but how could the elect have faith, in order before the election? Had they it by Gods grace? No surely: for, the Apostle makes grace posterior to election and predestination, saying, He elected and predestinated us, to the praise of the glory of his grace: Is it not then of free will? This of necessity they must hold with Pelagius. See August. de praedest. Sanct. c. 19.
5. Much like is that Cothurne in the words, In Christ: We understand with the Apostle, that God, before the foundation of the world elected us in Christ consequently; that is, that by Faith and the Spirit we might be engraffed in Christ, as members in the head; and, that we might be in Christ after election: for, the Apostle declares shortly after ver. 4. Hee hath predestinated us into adoption by Jesus Christ: But adoption is by faith, John 1.12. But they understand, that God elected us in Christ antecedently; that is, existing in Christ before election, by fore-seen faith; but how could the elect have faith, in order before the election? Had they it by Gods grace? No surely: for, the Apostle makes grace posteriour to election and predestination, saying, He elected and predestinated us, to the praise of the glory of his grace: Is it not then of free will? This of necessitie they must hold with Pelagius. See August. de praedest. Sanct. c. 19.
6. In the words, By Christ, and for Christ, it may be doubted, whether a cothurnall phrase lieth not hid. We, simply in and for Christs satisfactory ransom; but they think and speak otherwise of Christs satisfaction: For, 'tis known, that Vorstius, with whom they draw the same cord, disputed long since scandalously many things out of Socinus the Samosatenian, of Christs satisfaction; as if it had been either none, or half full, or not necessary.
6. In the words, By Christ, and for Christ, it may be doubted, whether a cothurnall phrase lyeth not hid. We, simply in and for Christs satisfactorie ransome; but they think and speak otherwise of Christs satisfaction: For, 'tis knowne, that Vorstius, with whom they draw the same cord, disputed long since scandalously many things out of Socinus the Samosatenian, of Christs satisfaction; as if it had been either none, or halfe full, or not necessarie.
7. A notable high strain is couched up in the word Grace: which, though elsewhere it hath divers significations; yet, in the question, concerning the cause of faith, of conversion, perseverance, and of our salvation, grace properly is an effectual ⟨p. 822⟩motion and drawing of Gods mercy in the minds and hearts of the elect, working, by an unspeakable way, faith, perseverance, and conversion: Of which Christ saith,1 No man can come to me, except the Father, who sent me, draw him. And Austin, Let the Pelagians read and understand, behold and confess, that not by the law and doctrine, sounding from without; but, by an internal and occult, a marvellous and ineffable power God worketh in the hearts of men, not only new revelations, but good wills also. But they understand the grace of outward calling by the Word, and of inward moral persuasion by the Spirit, but indifferent, which is in the power of mans free-will to determine well or ill, to receive or refuse: therefore they call it Resistible, as shall appear, Artic. 5. which opinion derogates from Gods glory, and makes man proudly sacrifice to his own net; that is, grow proud against God and shakes the certainty of salvation, and our comfort in life and death: as was showed, cothurno 2.
7. A notable high straine is couched up in the word Grace: which, though elsewhere it hath divers significations; yet, in the question, concerning the cause of faith, of conversion, perseverance, and of our salvation, grace properly is an effectuall ⟨p. 822⟩motion and drawing of Gods mercie in the minds and hearts of the elect, working, by an unspeakable way, faith, perseverance, and conversion: Of which Christ saith,1 No man can come to mee, except the Father, who sent mee, draw him. And Austin, Let the Pelagians reade and understand, behold and confesse, that not by the law and doctrine, sounding from without; but, by an internall and occult, a marvellous and ineffable power God worketh in the hearts of men, not onely new revelations, but good wills also. But they understand the grace of outward calling by the Word, and of inward morall perswasion by the Spirit, but indifferent, which is in the power of mans free-will to determine well or ill, to receive or refuse: therefore they call it Resistible, as shall appeare, Artic. 5. which opinion derogates from Gods glory, and makes man proudly sacrifice to his owne net; that is, grow proud against God and shakes the certaintie of salvation, and our comfort in life and death: as was shewed, cothurno 2.
8. Likewise in the word Believe, and in the Noun Faith, they (doubtless) delude us: for, to believe, with us, is not only to assent to the whole word of God, but chiefly and properly to be confident in the promise of the Gospel, concerning grace and remission of sins, by the blood of Christ, Mar. 5.26. Only believe, for confide. And it hath this meaning chiefly in the phrase, to believe in God, in Christ,1 &c. If you believe in God, believe also in me; for, be you confident: For, there he comforts the Apostles, Lord, who is he, that I may believe in him? for, that I may confide in him. Saving faith with us, is joined with confidence of the promise of the Gospel, or of the promised mercy of God, concerning remission of sins, through the blood of Christ:2 As, when we are said to be justified by faith, there faith signifieth confidence; and, to be justified by faith, is, in the confidence of Christs merits to be absolved from sin; which sense the Apostle delivers, when he saith, Whom God set forth as an atonement by faith in his blood, to declare his justice, by the remission of sins past: Where faith in his blood can signify nothing else, but confidence in Christs blood. But with them, faith is assent only; and, to believe, is to give an assent: this appears, because in the Article the words, John 3.36. [Greek or Hebrew], are rendered by them thus, But who assenteth not to the Son, for, who believeth not the Son: then their slippery disputes, concerning faith, teach the same: In which, for the most part, they require not confidence in faith; and they will have faith to justify, or to be imputed for justice, not because it applies to it self Christs merits; but, because the very act of faith is reputed a fulfilling of the Law: which was the opinion of Alberius Triuncurianus, a pitiful man. Therefore, seeing this Article doth deprave the true doctrine of Predestination with so many equivocations, and conceals the false, it cannot be simply allowed,
8. Likewise in the word Beleeve, and in the Noune Faith, they (doubtlesse) delude us: for, to beleeve, with us, is not onely to assent to the whole word of God, but chiefly and properly to be confident in the promise of the Gospel, concerning grace and remission of sins, by the bloud of Christ,
But you'll say, What need we dispute so much about Predestination? Is it not sufficient to salvation, to hold the sum of the Gospel delivered in this Article, Who believeth in the Son of God, hath life eternal: Who believeth not, the wrath of God remains on him? And may not this Article hitherto be tolerated?
But you'l say, What need we dispute so much about Predestination? Is it not sufficient to salvation, to hold the summe of the Gospel delivered in this Article, Who beleeveth in the Son of God, hath life eternall: Who beleeveth not, the wrath of God remaines on him? And may not this Article hitherto be tolerated?
I know some judge so: yea, some men, otherwise learned and pious, have written, that we ought not to dispute of Predestination now under the Gospel, but only preach upon the universal promises of grace. But these good men observe not, that by writing thus, they contradict the holy Ghost, who, in the Gospel, hath delivered the doctrine of Predestination; as above, cothurn. 2. in the alleged places may be seen. These unwise men seem, under this pretext, either to overthrow the foundations of our faith and comfort; or else, not to take notice, that they are overthrown by others: therefore that religious speech, whether of Ambrose or Prosper, 1is to be held concerning Predestination, These things are not to be searched into, what God will have concealed; and what are manifest, are not to be denied: lest in them we be found unlawfully curious; and in these, damnably ingrateful. As it is ⟨p. 823⟩then unlawful curiosity, to search into the mysteries of Predestination, not revealed in the Gospel; so it is damnable ingratitude to deny, or suppress what God hath revealed concerning Predestination in the Gospel. But to the Query thus we answer:
I know some judge so: yea, some men, otherwise learned and pious, have written, that we ought not to dispute of Predestination now under the Gospel, but onely preach upon the universall promises of grace. But these good men observe not, that by writing thus, they contradict the holy Ghost, who, in the Gospel, hath delivered the doctrine of Predestination; as above, cothurn. 2. in the alledged places may be seen. These unwise men seem, under this pretext, either to overthrow the foundations of our faith and comfort; or else, not to take notice, that they are overthrowne by others: therefore that religious speech, whether of Ambrose or Prosper, 1is to be held concerning Predestination, These things are not to be searched into, what God will have concealed; and what are manifest, are not to be denied: lest in them we be found unlawfully curious; and in these, damnably ingratefull. As it is ⟨p. 823⟩then unlawfull curiositie, to search into the mysteries of Predestination, not revealed in the Gospel; so it is damnable ingratitude to deny, or suppresse what God hath revealed concerning Predestination in the Gospel. But to the Quere thus we answer:
For Sufficiency, you may as well ask in the Church, If the doctrine of the Catechism be sufficient to salvation, concerning mans misery, and deliverance by Christ, and concerning gratitude: Why then should we read the Bible, or higher points of divinity? In Logic is it not sufficient to hold, that there are so many Figures of Syllogisms, and so many Moods? then what need is there of Aristotle's Organum in the Schools? In the Politics, is not the popular knowledge of right and equity sufficient to guide a State? what need is there then of such a number of laws, and so great toil, as the study of the law requires? In the Mathematics, is it not sufficient to know, that a triangle hath three angles equal to two? &c. that the diameter, to the circumference, is in a subtriple proportion, &c? what need is there then of Euclid's hard and intricate demonstrations?
For Sufficiencie, you may as well aske in the Church, If the doctrine of the Catechisme be sufficient to salvation, concerning mans miserie, and deliverance by Christ, and concerning gratitude: Why then should we reade the Bible, or higher points of divinitie? In Logick is it not sufficient to hold, that there are so many Figures of Syllogisms, and so many Moods? then what need is there of Aristotles Organum in the Schooles? In the Politicks, is not the popular knowledge of right and equitie sufficient to guide a State? what need is there then of such a number of lawes, and so great toile, as the studie of the law requires? In the Mathematicks, is it not sufficient to know, that a triangle hath three angles equall to two? &c. that the diameter, to the circumference, is in a subtriple proportion, &c? what need is there then of Euclyd's hard and intricate demonstrations?
To these any man may answer with facility, that to some the first rudiments of these sciences, or the knowledge of the quid sit, is sufficient; but not to all.
To these any man may answer with facilitie, that to some the first rudiments of these sciences, or the knowledge of the quid sit, is sufficient; but not to all.
To the Catechumeni, or Novices in the Church, the catechetical Rudiments of salvation may suffice; as milk is sufficient nutriment for infants: but to those that are adult in faith, who require more solid meat, this is not sufficient: Not to School-Doctors, not to the Pastors of the Church, whose office and conscience require of necessity a fuller measure of Theological knowledge. To young Logicians, the knowledge of so many Moods & Figures is enough for their syllogizing; but Philosophers must have the science propter quid, delivered in Aristotle's Organum: to wit, whence, and why there are so many, and why there can be no more. To an inferior or pedant Judge, the elements of law and justice are sufficient; but to a Doctor of the law, to an Advocate or Chancellor, the fountains of the law must necessarily be known. For a Mechanic, the [Greek or Hebrew] of a triangle and circle is sufficient to work by; but a Mathematic Doctor, who is studious of demonstrations, requires the science of [Greek or Hebrew].
To the Catechumeni, or Novices in the Church, the catecheticall Rudiments of salvation may suffice; as milk is sufficient nutriment for infants: but to those that are adult in faith, who require more solid meat, this is not sufficient: Not to School-Doctors, not to the Pastors of the Church, whose office and conscience require of necessitie a fuller measure of Theologicall knowledge. To young Logicians, the knowledge of so many Moods & Figures is enough for their syllogizing; but Philosophers must have the science propter quid, delivered in Aristotle's Organum: to wit, whence, and why there are so many, and why there can be no more. To an inferiour or pedant Judge, the elements of law and justice are sufficient; but to a Doctor of the law, to an Advocate or Chancellour, the fountaines of the law must necessarily be knowne. For a Mechanick, the 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 of a triangle and circle is sufficient to work by; but a Mathematick Doctor, who is studious of demonstrations, requires the science of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
After the same manner we may say, that this Article (putting now aside all equivocations) is sufficient for salvation to the Catechumeni and private vulgar men, which are not capable of sublimer mysteries; and this [Greek or Hebrew] is enough, what they must be, and what means they must use to attain salvation: to wit, that they must believe in Christ, that they must persevere in faith, and obedience of faith to the end; by the ministry of the Word and Sacraments, and by grace, co-operating with these: But to those that are more adult in faith, especially to the Doctors of Schools & Churches, whoso will say, that there is nothing besides this needful, his judgement will be accounted very weak and jejune: yea, rather it is necessary, that they should search the Scriptures, and more exactly know the very [Greek or Hebrew] of the foresaid doctrine; that is, the fountain and prime cause revealed in the Scriptures, whence these qualities and means of salvation, with grace and salvation it self, may originally descend on us; from whence also may proceed that difference, which we see, of people, and particular persons, which are to be saved from the multitude of those that perish: lest, perhaps (which by ignorance, or by forsaking the fountain, must need• come to pass) we dig to our selves broken cisterns, 1which will hold no water; that is, lest we ascribe vocation, faith, perseverance, and our salvation, either to the wit, strength, or merit of men: or else to grace, which is indifferent, and to our own free-will in part, or in whole, not without dishonour to God, and destruction to our selves.
After the same manner we may say, that this Article (putting now aside all equivocations) is sufficient for salvation to the Catechumeni and private vulgar men, which are not capable of sublimer mysteries; and this 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 is enough, what they must be, and what meanes they must use to attain salvation: to wit, that they must beleeve in Christ, that they must persevere in faith, and obedience of faith to the end; by the ministerie of the Word and Sacraments, and by grace, co-operating with these: But to those that are more adult in faith, especially to the Doctors of Schooles & Churches, whoso will say, that there is nothing besides this needfull, his judgement will be accounted very weak and jejune: yea, rather it is necessarie, that they should search the Scriptures, and more exactly know the very 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 of the foresaid doctrine; that is, the fountaine and prime cause revealed in the Scriptures, whence these qualities and meanes of salvation, with grace and salvation it selfe, may originally descend on us; from whence also may proceed that difference, which wee see, of people, and particular persons, which are to be saved from the multitude of those that perish: lest, perhaps (which by ignorance, or by forsaking the fountain, must need come to passe) we digge to our selves broken cisternes,
Now, this fountain, this prime and supreme cause, is Gods eternal predestination; that is, his eternal counsel, in saving us before others: for, from this fountain flows the outward calling, and inward also to faith in Christ, of all those who shall be saved. Hence flow faith and repentance, justification, obedience, and perseverance in faith; yea, our whole salvation and glorification: which the Scripture perspicuously teacheth, and confirms in these and such like sayings, Whom he ⟨p. 824⟩predestinated, 1them he called; whom he called, them he justified; whom he justified, them also he glorified. Also, Election hath obtained, the rest waxed hard. Also, So many as were ordained to salvation, believed. Also, He elected us in Christ, before the foundations of the world, that we might be holy and blameless before him in love: whom he hath predestinated unto adoption by Jesus Christ, 2to the praise of his glorious grace, &c. Austin confirms the same, saying, This predestination of the Saints is nothing else, but a preparation of Gods bounties, by which they are most assuredly freed, who are freed. Luther also very emphatically confirms the same, in these words, Both flow, and have their original from Gods eternal predestination; to wit, who shall believe, who shall not believe: who shall be absolved from sin, who not: that all this may be out of our power, and only in the hand of God, that we are justified.
Now, this fountaine, this prime and supreme cause, is Gods eternall predestination; that is, his eternall counsell, in saving us before others: for, from this fountaine flowes the outward calling, and inward also to faith in Christ, of all those who shall be saved. Hence flow faith and repentance, justification, obedience, and perseverance in faith; yea, our whole salvation and glorification: which the Scripture perspicuously teacheth, and confirmes in these and such like sayings, Whom he ⟨p. 824⟩predestinated, 1them he called; whom he called, them he justified; whom he justified, them also he glorified. Also, Election hath obtained, the rest waxed hard. Also, So many as were ordained to salvation, beleeved. Also, He elected us in Christ, before the foundations of the world, that we might be holy and blamelesse before him in love: whom he hath predestimated unto adoption by Jesus Christ,
That this fountain therefore must chiefly be known by Divines, and by all, who will be strengthened in faith and comfort, and that it is to be perspicuously and soberly taught in Schools and Churches, who will doubt? and that specially for two causes: 1. For the glory of God; that, knowing the means and causes of salvation, and the qualities of those that are to be saved, and salvation it self not to depend from us, but from Gods good pleasure alone; we may ascribe our salvation not to our selves, but wholly to Gods mercy. 2. For our consolation; that being assured, that our faith, perseverance, and salvation depend not from our own strength, or free-will, but that they are grounded on Gods eternal and immutable counsel, we may be confident, that the same is certain and immovable: and, in this confidence,1 we may study to make our election and vocation sure to us, by continually prayers and good works, ordained by God for this end.
That this fountaine therefore must chiefly be knowne by Divines, and by all, who will be strengthened in faith and comfort, and that it is to be perspicuously and soberly taught in Schooles and Churches, who will doubt? and that specially for two causes: 1. For the glory of God; that, knowing the meanes and causes of salvation, and the qualities of those that are to be saved, and salvation it self not to depend from us, but from Gods good pleasure alone; we may ascribe our salvation not to our selves, but wholly to Gods mercie. 2. For our consolation; that being assured, that our faith, perseverance, and salvation depend not from our owne strength, or free-will, but that they are grounded on Gods eternall and immutable counsell, we may be confident, that the same is certaine and immoveable: and, in this confidence,1 we may studie to make our election and vocation sure to us, by continuali prayers and good works, ordained by God for this end.
But this Article doth altogether foul and obstruct this most clear fountain, with the dirt of equivocation: for it denieth (see the Conference) that our faith and perseverance proceed from the fountain of eternal election, as the effect from the first cause: and it ascribeth both these in show to Gods grace; but, indeed, to mans will; because it makes mans will the mistress of Gods resistible grace, it makes mans free-will stronger, and more powerful then Gods grace, which can be resisted; and makes the whole difference of those that are to be damned and saved, depend on mens wills: by which means it is plain, that the glory of mans salvation cannot be wholly ascribed to God, but he is of necessity robbed of it.
But this Article doth altogether foule and obstruct this most cleere fountaine, with the dirt of equivocation: for it denieth (see the Conference) that our faith and perseverance proceed from the fountain of eternall election, as the effect from the first cause: and it ascribeth both these in shew to Gods grace; but, indeed, to mans will; because it makes mans will the mistresse of Gods resistible grace, it makes mans free-will stronger, and more powerfull then Gods grace, which can be resisted; and makes the whole difference of those that are to be damned and saved, depend on mens wills: by which meanes it is plain, that the glory of mans salvation cannot be wholly ascribed to God, but he is of necessitie robbed of it.
Hence it utterly overthrows both the certainty of faith, grace, justification, perseverance, and, indeed, of our whole salvation; and consequently, of our only comfort in life and death: For, who doth not understand, that the assurance of grace, justification, perseverance, salvation, and our whole comfort in life and death, can no ways consist with resistible grace, and with mans will resisting, or able to resist: as it were with two principles, either repugnant to each other, or changing every hour?
Hence it utterly overthrowes both the certaintie of faith, grace, justification, perseverance, and, indeed, of our whole salvation; and consequently, of our onely comfort in life and death: For, who doth not understand, that the assurance of grace, justification, perseverance, salvation, and our whole comfort in life and death, can no waies consist with resistible grace, and with mans will resisting, or able to resist: as it were with two principles, either repuguant to each other, or changing every houre?
Hence it is apparent, what we are to judge of tolerance: for, who can say, that an Article so equivocal, and so captious with dangerous high tragical strains, is tolerable? Who wittingly and willingly would buy or eat sugar mixed with poison? Who will account that a benefit,1 to have the apple of contentions flung into our Churches, which will afford matter of perpetual strife? Will Physicians endure in their Schools, that Empirics adulterate or deny their doctrine of diseases? Can Mathematicians endure the false delineations of Mechanics, introducing (for example) into a quadrangle, a false sine for a true one, and so overthrowing the grounds of their science.
Hence it is apparent, what we are to judge of tolerance: for, who can say, that an Article so equivocall, and so captious with dangerous high tragicall straines, is tolerable? Who wittingly and willingly would buy or eat sugar mixt with poyson? Who will account that a benefit,1 to have the apple of contentions flung into our Churches, which will afford matter of perpetuall strife? Will Physicians endure in their Schooles, that Empericks adulterate or deny their doctrine of diseases? Can Mathematicians endure the false delineations of Mechanicks, introducing (for example) into a quadrangle, a false sine for a true one, and so overthrowing the grounds of their science.
Much less should equivocal doctrines be tolerated in the Church, which, using the pretext of grace,1 deny grace; by which, the original of salvation is placed in man: mans will is preferred to Gods will: & therefore one is helped, because he wills it; but doth not will, because he is helped. Men are made believe, that they, who are originally evil, receive the beginning of their goodness, not from God, but from themselves: and 'tis taught, that God is pleased by other means, then by those which he himself hath given. And so much of the equivocations of the first Article: but how that is rightly to be understood, filled up, and formed, is explained* above.
Much lesse should equivocall doctrines be tolerated in the Church, which, using the pretext of grace,1 deny grace; by which, the originall of salvation is placed in man: mans will is preferred to Gods will: & therfore one is helped, because he wills it; but doth not will, because he is helped. Men are made beleeve, that they, who are originally evill, receive the beginning of their goodnesse, not from God, but from themselves: and 'tis taught, that God is pleased by other means, then by those which he himself hath given. And so much of the equivocations of the first Article: but how that is rightly to be understood, filled up, and formed, is explained* above.
Therefore Jesus Christ, the Saviour of the world, dyed for all and singular, and so far, that he hath obtained reconciliation and remission of sins for all by his death: but on this condition, that no man can really enjoy the said remission of sins, except the faithful man; and this is according to the Gospel, John 3.16. God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son; that whosoever believeth in him might not perish, but have life eternal. And, 1 John 2.2. And he is the propitiation for our sins; and not for ours alone, but for the sins of the whole world.
Therefore Jesus Christ, the Saviour of the world, dyed for all and singular, and so far, that he hath obtained reconciliation and remission of sins for all by his death: but on this condition, that no man can really enjoy the said remission of sins, except the faithfull man; and this is according to the Gospel, John 3.16. God so loved the world, that he gave his onely begotten Son; that whosoever beleeveth in him might not perish, but have life eternall. And, 1 John 2.2. And he is the propitiation for our sins; and not for ours alone, but for the sins of the whole world.
1Coll. Hag. p. 84.
that the grace of God, by which Christ came into this world to save sinners, is not necessary, not onely every houre, or every moment, but also, to every one of our actions; and who goe about to take this away, they shall be punished eternally. Who would not cleere Pelagius in this case? but under the buskin of this word grace, he deluded the Palestine Bishops, as Austine sheweth: he left behinde him two disciples, Caelestius and Julianus, young men, of a sharpe wit, and with whom Austine in Africa had much adoe. At last, this infection flew over the Mediterrane-sea, into Sicilie, and Marsiles in France; not all of it, but onely so much as concerned the point of grace and predestination, and the death of Christ; the Asserters of which were called Semi-pelagians, and the remainders of the Pelagians; of which points there are extant the Epistles of Prosper Aquitanicus, and of Hilarius Arelatensis to Austine; whose learned Answer, contained in two Books, of the predestination of the Saints, and of the good of perseverance; and in a third, concerning correction and grace. To which Answer, if the Authors of these Articles at this day, would stand as they may and should stand, (for, it is altogether S. Pauls doctrine) the matter had beene decided ere this. For, indeed, Arminius, with his followers, have at this day re-assumed the cause of the Marsilians and Syracusians, but somewhat more handsomly dressed: Neither could he be ignorant of this, and therefore he used but little ingenuity in his tergiversation, when he wrote in the Articles, That he acknowledgeth neither Semi-pelagianisme objected against him, nor nine, nor five, nor foure inches of it. But, to returne to the Article; in it there be divers equivocations, as shall appeare.
nor to give them faith and perseverance, but to leave them in their originall blindnesse and infidelity, and to condemne them for their sins; and that to declare his wrath, and make knowne his power upon them.
. Not because you were greater, or more then other people, did the Lord love and choose you, but because he loved you, &c. Againe, of these Israelites that were called, some he elected, others he reprobated. Jacob have I loved, Esau have I hated,
&c. And that not of workes, but that the purpose of election might remaine firme, &c. And in this Age he vouchsafes to call us Christians, by the word of the Gospell; which favour he sheweth not to Turks, Pagans, &c. And of these Christians, whom he calls, to some he gives true faith, conversion, perseverance, and eternall salvation; to others he gives not, but leaves them in ignorance and hypocrisie.
in Divinity there is an undoubted Rule, depending on the authority of the holy Scripture; Whatsoever God did in time, he decreed to doe it from eternity, seeing in God there is no change. Therefore among Christians it ought to be out of doubt, why God from eternity made this difference of the elect and not elect, but reprobate; of those that shall be saved, and not saved, but for sin condemned; which we see God hath done,
and doth in time, and therefore decreed to do it before time. For, God being spoiled of his power and wisdome in choosing, (saith Luther) what will he be else but the Idoll of Fortune, by whose Deity all things were done temerariously? And at last it will come to this, that men shall be saved and damned without Gods knowledge, as who did not by any certaine election discriminate who should be saved, who damned: but offering to all a generall lenity, tolerating and obdurating, then a mercy correcting and punishing, hath left to mens choise, whether they will be saved or damned; he himselfe perhaps being gone to the Ethiopian feast, as Homer speakes. And this is the summe of the orthodoxall doctrine of predestination; and so the word appointed in the Article, is to be understood altogether according to experience and Scripture. But to them it signifieth far otherwise; to wit, that God from eternity appointed to save those, who in time beleeve and persevere, under this condition, that they beleeve and persevere: otherwise, that he hath no more ordained them to salvation, then all other men; nor hath elected them in Christ, but onely casually, so far as they above others would beleeve in Christ and persevere, (for, they make faith and perseverance antecedent to election:) but that these rather then others should beleeve and persevere, God did not decree to effect this in them by any singular grace; but decreed to offer unto all men, a certaine universall exciting and preventing grace, but indifferent and resistible; to which, they who make no resistance, but, by using well their free-will, do assent and co-operate, for the begetting of faith, and performing of perseverance to the end; they, I say, are elected and predestinated in Christ; and therefore God, from eternity hath casually, and out of their fore-seene faith and perseverance elected them in Christ, and hath predestinated them to salvation, or hath appointed to save them:
. understand of certaine individuall men: as, of Peter, of Paul. &c. predestinated by God, not onely to salvation and glory; but also to the antecedent meanes of salvation, and to the qualities required in those that shall be saved; to outward and inward calling, to faith and justification, to conversion and perseverance to the end, according to the Apostles saying, Whom he predestinated, them he called: whom he called, them he justified: whom he justified, them he hath also glorified: Whose number (saith Austin) is so certaine, there can be none added to it,
nor diminished from it. To whom alone it is given infallibly, that they beleeve and persevere, and that they cannot perish: as it is said, They beleeved, so many as were ordained to life eternall; that is, as Chrysostome expounds it, They that were predestinated by God: And, Who hath begun a good work in you, will perfect it, against the day of Jesus Christ. It is impossible that the elect shall be seduced. Now, they understand not certaine men, but whosoever casually will beleeve; or, certaine men, but in the species onely, not in the individuall: beleevers, before their election, predestinate not to faith and perseverance; but after faith to salvation casually, if they persevere. More briefly, we understand them, whom election and predestination makes beleevers and perseverers; but they meane those, whom election finds beleeving and persevering.
Most briefly thus, We understand those that were to beleeve, or beleevers consequently, or after election; they, such as were to beleeve, or beleevers antecedently, or in order before election; to wit, after the same manner that the chariot drawes the horse: for, if faith cannot be before vocation, which is after election and predestination, how can it be before election? But the Apostle on the contrarie, He hath chosen us, that we might be holy; not, when we were holy:
&c. If you beleeve in God, beleeve also in me; for, be you confident: For, there he comforts the Apostles, Lord, who is he, that I may beleeve in him? for, that I may confide in him. Saving faith with us, is joyned with confidence of the promise of the Gospel, or of the promised mercie of God, concerning remission of sins, through the bloud of Christ:
As, when we are said to be justified by faith, there faith signifieth confidence; and, to be justified by faith, is, in the confidence of Christs merits to be absolved from sin; which sense the Apostle delivers, when he saith, Whom God set forth as an atonement by faith in his bloud, to declare his justice, by the remission of sins past: Where faith in his bloud can signifie nothing else, but confidence in Christs bloud. But with them, faith is assent onely; and, to beleeve, is to give an assent: this appeares, because in the Article the words, John 3.36. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, are rendred by them thus, But who assenteth not to the Son, for, who beleeveth not the Son: then their slippery disputes, concerning faith, teach the same: In which, for the most part, they require not confidence in faith; and they will have faith to justifie, or to be imputed for justice, not because it applies to it selfe Christs merits; but, because the very act of faith is reputed a fulfilling of the Law: which was the opinion of Alberius Triuncurianus, a pitifull man. Therefore, seeing this Article doth deprave the true doctrine of Predestination with so many equivocations, and conceales the false, it cannot be simply allowed,
which will hold no water; that is, lest we ascribe vocation, faith, perseverance, and our salvation, either to the wit, strength, or merit of men: or else to grace, which is indifferent, and to our owne free-will in part, or in whole, not without dishonour to God, and destruction to our selves.
to the praise of his glorious grace, &c. Austin confirmes the same, saying, This predestination of the Saints is nothing else, but a preparation of Gods bounties, by which they are most assuredly freed, who are freed. Luther also very emphatically confirmes the same, in these words, Both flow, and have their originall from Gods eternall predestination; to wit, who shall beleeve, who shall not beleeve: who shall be absolved from sin, who not: that all this may be out of our power, and onely in the hand of God, that we are justified.