[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
pp. 770–844447 passagespart 7 of 12
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This explication, true and consonant to Scripture, being observed, it will appear, 1. That there is something amiss in both sides of the controvertents: in the former, because they confound the justice of the person, with the justice of merit; and, by dividing merit into many heterogeneall parts, they do not only disturb our faith and comfort; but also, against Scripture, they separate justification from Christs death. In the later, because from the justice of merit, they exclude the whole life of Christ, with his humility and sufferings, that went before his death. And they oppose the exclusive particle Alone in their phrases (as when they say, The death of Christ alone justifieth, His blood alone purgeth) to his life and antecedent obedience; whereas it is opposed in meritorious or material causes partly to personal justice, partly and chiefly to mens merits, and all other external causes; except they restrain this particle Alone to sufficiency, of which we have said in ⟨p. 802⟩the fifth position. Again, it will appear, that this will be an easy way to reconcile the controversy, if all of them will agree to urge against the Papists, and mens merits, all these common passages, in which (as I said already) they agree, concerning free justification of faith, by Christs imputed justice; and that they would not use scrupulous disputations, concerning this justice, or the matter of imputative justice before the people in their Sermons; but that they would use Scripture phrases, and be content, that we are justified not by works, but by faith; not by our own righteousness, but by another's obedience; to wit, by the blood and death of the Son of God, imputed to us, and applied by faith, &c. For these are sufficient to beget true comfort to all, and to refute humane merits.
This explication, true and consonant to Scripture, being observed, it will appeare, 1. That there is something amisse in both sides of the controvertents: in the former, because they confound the justice of the person, with the justice of merit; and, by dividing merit into many heterogeneall parts, they doe not onely disturbe our faith and comfort; but also, against Scripture, they separate justification from Christs death. In the later, because from the justice of merit, they exclude the whole life of Christ, with his humility and sufferings, that went before his death. And they oppose the exclusive particle Alone in their phrases (as when they say, The death of Christ alone justifieth, His bloud alone purgeth) to his life and antecedent obedience; whereas it is opposed in meritorious or materiall causes partly to personall justice, partly and chiefly to mens merits, and all other externall causes; except they restraine this particle Alone to sufficiency, of which wee have said in ⟨p. 802⟩the fifth position. Againe, it will appeare, that this will be an easie way to reconcile the controversie, if all of them will agree to urge against the Papists, and mens merits, all these common passages, in which (as I said already) they agree, concerning free justification of faith, by Christs imputed justice; and that they would not use scrupulous disputations, concerning this justice, or the matter of imputative justice before the people in their Sermons; but that they would use Scripture phrases, and be content, that we are justified not by workes, but by faith; not by our owne righteousnesse, but by anothers obedience; to wit, by the bloud and death of the Son of God, imputed to us, and applyed by faith, &c. For these are sufficient to beget true comfort to all, and to refute humane merits.
As for the controversy it self, if it must at all be handled in the Schools, it is needful for a tolerable reconciliation to beware on both sides, that the Disputants minds may not be too much alienated. The later sort are offended at the partition of merit into so many divers pieces; because they see many absurdities spring from thence, and the Scripture to be wronged. On the other side, the former are offended, by restraining merit to the death of Christ; because they fear, lest his life and antecedent obedience be excluded against the Scripture. What shall be done then? It is needful, that the one forbear to divide the matter of merit into two, three, or four, as they use: and that they do not separate the merit of justice from Christs death, nor justification from remission of sins: That the others restrain not merit to the effusion of blood upon the Cross, or to the three days death; and, that they exclude not his life and antecedent obedience: And both must distinguish, with the Scripture, personal justice from merit, as the efficient cause, or sine qua non, from the material; seeing many inconveniences must arise of confusion, by which, the sense of Scripture is overthrown, the consciences are disturbed, and occasion of cavilling is ministered to Papists, as we showed in the first and second Position. 2. Let the personal justice of the Mediator be rightly limited, according to the third Position. 3. Let the justice of merit be rightly defined, and let the Synecdoche of the blood, death, and passive obedience, &c. be understood of Christs whole humiliation, according to the fourth and fifth Positions. 4. For a better reconciliation, let this also be added, That under the humiliation, is comprehended his voluntary subjection to the Law; and consequently, his active obedience, as they call it: so that this also, in some respect comes under the notion of merit; to wit, so far as it is considered to be a voluntary servitude, undertaken and performed for us by the Son of God. For, this obedience may be considered two ways: 1. As it is a conformity with the Law, and so it is the personal justice of the Mediator. 2. As the servitude of the Law, to which, for our sakes, Christ made himself obnoxious; and so it belongs to merit: For, although Christ, as man, was bound to obey the Law; yet, as just, holy, and the Son of God;
As for the controversie it selfe, if it must at all be handled in the Schooles, it is needfull for a tolerable reconciliation to beware on both sides, that the Disputants minds may not be too much alienated. The later sort are offended at the partition of merit into so many divers pieces; because they see many absurdities spring from thence, and the Scripture to be wronged. On the other side, the former are offended, by restraining merit to the death of Christ; because they feare, lest his life and antecedent obedience be excluded against the Scripture. What shall be done then? It is needfull, that the one forbeare to divide the matter of merit into two, three, or foure, as they use: and that they doe not separate the merit of justice from Christs death, nor justification from remission of sins: That the others restraine not merit to the effusion of bloud upon the Crosse, or to the three dayes death; and, that they exclude not his life and antecedent obedience: And both must distinguish, with the Scripture, personall justice from merit, as the efficient cause, or sine qua non, from the materiall; seeing many inconveniences must arise of confusion, by which, the sense of Scripture is overthrowne, the consciences are disturbed, and occasion of cavilling is ministred to Papists, as we shewed in the first and second Position. 2. Let the personall justice of the Mediatour be rightly limited, according to the third Position. 3. Let the justice of merit be rightly defined, and let the Synecdoche of the bloud, death, and passive obedience, &c. be understood of Christs whole humiliation, according to the fourth and fifth Positions. 4. For a better reconciliation, let this also be added, That under the humiliation, is comprehended his voluntary subjection to the Law; and consequently, his active obedience, as they call it: so that this also, in some respect comes under the notion of merit; to wit, so far as it is considered to be a voluntary servitude, undertaken and performed for us by the Son of God. For, this obedience may be considered two waies: 1. As it is a conformity with the Law, and so it is the personall justice of the Mediatour. 2. As the servitude of the Law, to which, for our sakes, Christ made himselfe obnoxious; and so it belongs to merit: For, although Christ, as man, was bound to obey the Law; yet, as just, holy, and the Son of God;
yea, even according to his humanity, he was not obliged to many duties of the first and second Table, to which nevertheless he did spontaneously subject himself; and so he was made a servant to the whole Law for us, that he might redeem us from the servitude, coaction, and damnation of the Law. So, it was a voluntary servitude, that he would be circumcised, that he would observe the Sabbaths and Feasts, that he was subject to his parents, and payed tribute to Cesar, and served his neighbour, &c. being Lord of the circumcision, of the Sabbath, of patents, of Cesar, of his neighbour, &c. Of this servitude of the Law, that of the Apostle is to be understood,1 God sent his Son, made of a woman, made under the Law, &c. and so, the complaint of excluding active obedience from merit, will be of less force. This way of reconciliation, perhaps, will not satisfy the scrupulous; yet it will not be displeasing to them, who desire these differences of opinions may be buried: or else, surely, they will think more of some means of peace, and will show better. In the interim, I am satisfied with these.
yea, even according to his humanity, hee was not obliged to many duties of the first and second Table, to which neverthelesse he did spontaneously subject himselfe; and so he was made a servant to the whole Law for us, that hee might redeem us from the servitude, coaction, and damnation of the Law. So, it was a voluntary servitude, that he would be circumcised, that hee would observe the Sabbaths and Feasts, that he was subject to his parents, and payed tribute to Cesar, and served his neighbour, &c. being Lord of the circumcision, of the Sabbath, of patents, of Cesar, of his neighbour, &c. Of this servitude of the Law, that of the Apostle is to be understood,1 God sent his Son, made of a woman, made under the Law, &c. and so, the complaint of excluding active obedience from merit, will be of lesse force. This way of reconciliation, perhaps, will not satisfie the scrupulous; yet it will not be displeasing to them, who desire these differences of opinions may be buried: or else, surely, they will think more of some meanes of peace, and will shew better. In the interim, I am satisfied with these.
By what we have said,1 it will now appear (which was our third Query) how this doctrine is to be handled in popular Sermons: whether positively, and refutatively it will be fit to dispute of it before the people. For my part, I think it is not fitting: ⟨p. 803⟩for, what else can be expected of such a disceptation, but that the more ignorant sort will stagger in their faith, and will presently think, that the doctrine of faith, hitherto taught in our Churches, hath been very slippery and uncertain; which, notwithstanding, caused us first of all to renounce Popery? And the Church can be edified in faith and consolation, without such opposition: by which, not our Adversaries, but our brethren should be touched, and wrung; their minds distracted into dangerous divisions and contentions, and scandals should be increased by our fault. Surely, the Romanists willingly, with both hands, would lay hold upon this opportunity, to traduce us; to wit, that we cannot agree in that, which we make the main point of the Gospel. When Luther began, with others, to reform the doctrine of Justification, Popery received a deadly wound. What? shall we go about to heal again this wound of the Beast? And do we not think, what an account we are to make unto God, for the delight we take in strife and altercation?
By what we have said,1 it will now appear (which was our third Quere) how this doctrine is to be handled in popular Sermons: whether positively, and refutatively it will be fit to dispute of it before the people. For my part, I think it is not fitting: ⟨p. 803⟩for, what else can be expected of such a disceptation, but that the more ignorant sort will stagger in their faith, and will presently think, that the doctrine of faith, hitherto taught in our Churches, hath been very slippery and uncertain; which, notwithstanding, caused us first of all to renounce Popery? And the Church can be edified in faith and consolation, without such opposition: by which, not our Adversaries, but our brethren should be touched, and wrung; their minds distracted into dangerous divisions and contentions, and scandals should be encreased by our fault. Surely, the Romanists willingly, with both hands, would lay hold upon this opportunity, to traduce us; to wit, that we cannot agree in that, which we make the maine point of the Gospel. When Luther began, with others, to reforme the doctrine of Justification, Popery received a deadly wound. What? shall we goe about to heale againe this wound of the Beast? And doe wee not think, what an account we are to make unto God, for the delight wee take in strife and altercation?
But you'll say, There is danger, lest error, in stead of truth, should prevail in the Church. Truly, there is none; if so be these things be retained, and diligently taught, which are in our Confession: In other points, let moderation and candour be used. Let our brethren be heard with calmness, and let their opinions be compared one with another, and with Gods word. Lastly, seek not a knot in a bulrush.
But you'l say, There is danger, lest errour, in stead of truth, should prevaile in the Church. Truly, there is none; if so be these things be retained, and diligently taught, which are in our Confession: In other points, let moderation and candor be used. Let our brethren be heard with calmnesse, and let their opinions be compared one with another, and with Gods word. Lastly, seek not a knot in a bulrush.
The fourth head remains, concerning the Catechism,1 and Palatinate Directory, Whether it be sit to omit, or put out any thing in them? Here I know not, whether I should rather admire, or grieve at the precipitate temerity of some, who think, they may lawfully judge and censure sacred and profane things as they list; choose and reject what they please: this humour is not to be endured. If their wisdom be greater then other mens, they should do well to new-mould their own Catechism and Directory: Or, if they have perceived any error in that of the Palatinate, they should, in a brotherly way, admonish those, who have the care of this, and who will be ready to give them an account. Sure, this pretended zeal seems neither to have much conscience, nor knowledge in it: For, with what conscience can they pass by their own Catechisms, and make changings in ours? Shall private men put out that, which publicly belongs to many Churches? If they have knowledge sufficient, that is, if they understand well the meaning of the Catechism in every passage, and will be ingenuous, as they ought to be in ambiguous matters, they will find they have no reason to do thus; because all things agree sufficiently, if so be that which is doubtful, be explained by that which is clearer; and what is briefly set down, be enlarged as if fitting.
The fourth head remaines, concerning the Catechisme,1 and Palatinate Directorie, Whether it be sit to omit, or put out any thing in them? Here I know not, whether I should rather admire, or grieve at the precipitate temerity of some, who think, they may lawfully judge and censure sacred and profane things as they list; choose and reject what they please: this humour is not to be endured. If their wisdome be greater then other mens, they should doe well to new-mould their own Catechisme and Directorie: Or, if they have perceived any errour in that of the Palatinate, they should, in a brotherly way, admonish those, who have the care of this, and who will be ready to give them an account. Sure, this pretended zeale seems neither to have much conscience, nor knowledge in it: For, with what conscience can they passe by their owne Catechismes, and make changings in ours? Shall private men put out that, which publickly belongs to many Churches? If they have knowledge sufficient, that is, if they understand well the meaning of the Catechisme in every passage, and will be ingenuous, as they ought to be in ambiguous matters, they will find they have no reason to doe thus; because all things agree sufficiently, if so be that which is doubtfull, be explained by that which is cleerer; and what is briefly set downe, be enlarged as if fitting.
But you will say, that in the Catechism nothing should be ambiguous or doubtful. I confess, indeed: neither had any such thing crept into our Catechism, if it were now to be written, since the moving of these scruples. But the passages of our Catechism, which be more manifest, and at large, are these:
But you will say, that in the Catechisme nothing should be ambiguous or doubtfull. I confesse, indeed: neither had any such thing crept into our Catechisme, if it were now to be written, since the moving of these scruples. But the passages of our Catechisme, which be more manifest, and at large, are these:
Quest. 12. and 14. there is taught, That no other way of deliverance and of reconciliation with God could be found, then that either the sinner himself, or else a Mediator for the sinner, should, by condigne punishment, satisfy divine justice: therefore the punishment of the Mediator for us, is our satisfaction; and that thing, by and for which we are justified and reconciled to God: for, in the Apostle, these two are all one, Rom. 5.9, 10.
Quest. 12. and 14. there is taught, That no other way of deliverance and of reconciliation with God could be found, then that either the sinner himself, or else a Mediatour for the sinner, should, by condigne punishment, satisfie divine justice: therefore the punishment of the Mediatour for us, is our satisfaction; and that thing, by and for which we are justified and reconciled to God: for, in the Apostle, these two are all one, Rom. 5.9, 10.
Quest. 15.16. there is taught, That it was needful for the Mediator to be true God, and true man, and perfectly just; that he might be able to pay the ransom for us, which we sinners could not pay: therefore the justice of the person is distinguished from the ransom, as the cause from the effect; so that the actual and formal justice of the Mediator, belongs to the justice of the person, as the cause sine qua non.
Quest. 15.16. there is taught, That it was needfull for the Mediatour to be true God, and true man, and perfectly just; that hee might be able to pay the ransome for us, which we sinners could not pay: therefore the justice of the person is distinguished from the ransome, as the cause from the effect; so that the actuall and formall justice of the Mediatour, belongs to the justice of the person, as the cause sine qua non.
Quest. 21. is taught, That for this ransom of Christs remission of sins, eternal justice and life are bestowed upon all believers: therefore the Catechism doth ⟨p. 804⟩not so divide remission of sins and justice, as if that were given because of the ransom, and this, because of Christ active justice.
Quest. 21. is taught, That for this ransome of Christs remission of sins, eternall justice and life are bestowed upon all beleevers: therefore the Catechisme doth ⟨p. 804⟩not so divide remission of sins and justice, as if that were given because of the ransome, and this, because of Christ active justice.
Quest. 37. it is taught, That Christ by his Passion, as by the only propitiatory Sacrifice hath obtained for us the favour of God, justice, and life; and that this his suffering extends through the whole course of his life that he lived here on earth; albeit the chief act of his suffering was in the end of his life: therefore again, the merit of justice and of life is not ascribed to active, but to passive obedience; and with all, the Passion Synecdochically is understood of the whole humiliation.
Quest. 37. it is taught, That Christ by his Passion, as by the onely propitiatory Sacrifice hath obtained for us the favour of God, justice, and life; and that this his suffering extends through the whole course of his life that he lived here on earth; albeit the chiefe act of his suffering was in the end of his life: therefore againe, the merit of justice and of life is not ascribed to active, but to passive obedience; and with all, the Passion Synecdochically is understood of the whole humiliation.
Quest. 40. it is again taught, That by no other means could satisfaction be made to divine truth and justice for our sins, then by the death of the Son of God; therefore it is confirmed again, that the death of the Son of God is our satisfaction; that is to say, that thing for, and by which we are justified.
Quest. 40. it is again taught, That by no other meanes could satisfaction be made to divine truth and justice for our sins, then by the death of the Son of God; therefore it is confirmed again, that the death of the Son of God is our satisfaction; that is to say, that thing for, and by which we are justified.
Quest. 45. the Catechism saith, That Christ therefore rose, that he might make us partakers of his justice, which he purchased for us by his death. Therefore, the death of Christ hath obtained justice for us, and by imputation thereof we are accounted not only not unjust, but just also.
Quest. 45. the Catechisme saith, That Christ therefore rose, that he might make us partakers of his justice, which he purchased for us by his death. Therefore, the death of Christ hath obtained justice for us, and by imputation thereof we are accounted not onely not unjust, but just also.
Quest. 56. teacheth, That God, for the satisfaction of Christ (which is his punishment and death) hath forgot all our sins, even original too, and hath bestowed freely upon us the righteousness of Christ. Therefore it confirms again, That his death is not only the merit of the remission of all our sins, even of original too, but also of justification: and that it is not needful that original sin should be covered with the holiness of his humanity, lest it appear in the sight of God.
Quest. 56. teacheth, That God, for the satisfaction of Christ (which is his punishment and death) hath forgot all our sins, even originall too, and hath bestowed freely upon us the righteousnesse of Christ. Therefore it confirmes againe, That his death is not onely the merit of the remission of all our sins, even of originall too, but also of justification: and that it is not needfull that originall sin should be covered with the holinesse of his humanity, lest it appeare in the sight of God.
Finally, Quest. 66.67.70.72.74.67.80. it is often repeated, that we have remission of sins, justice, and life eternal, for the only sacrifice, blood, and death of Christ. Therefore, in all these, there is neither taught, nor can be imagined such a partition of merit; as if by the imputation of Christs death, we did only obtain remission of sins, and, as some lately phrase it, only privative benefits; but by the imputation of actual obedience we obtain justice, and positive benefits. The Catechism ascribes all together to Christs death, as the Scripture also doth, John 3. He gave his only begotten Son, (to wit, to death) that whosoever believeth, (to wit, that the Son was given, and died for him) may not perish, but have life eternal, &c. But you will say, Quest. 60.61. That imputative justice is expressly divided into three, to wit, perfect satisfaction, justice, and sanctity, which it saith, are imputed to us. And, Quest. 36. it saith, That the Mediator, by his innocency, and perfect sanctity, hath covered our sins in which we are conceived, that they may not appear in the sight of God.
Finally, Quest. 66.67.70.72.74.67.80. it is often repeated, that we have remission of sins, justice, and life eternall, for the onely sacrifice, bloud, and death of Christ. Therefore, in all these, there is neither taught, nor can be imagined such a partition of merit; as if by the imputation of Christs death, we did onely obtaine remission of sins, and, as some lately phrase it, onely privative benefits; but by the imputation of actuall obedience we obtaine justice, and positive benefits. The Catechisme ascribes all together to Christs death, as the Scripture also doth, John 3. He gave his onely begotten Son, (to wit, to death) that whosoever beleeveth, (to wit, that the Son was given, and died for him) may not perish, but have life eternall, &c. But you will say, Quest. 60.61. That imputative justice is expresly divided into three, to wit, perfect satisfaction, justice, and sanctity, which it saith, are imputed to us. And, Quest. 36. it saith, That the Mediatour, by his innocency, and perfect sanctity, hath covered our sins in which we are conceived, that they may not appeare in the sight of God.
As for the first, either we must confess, that these fight against the former, which charity, and Christian candour will not allow; or the partition must be denied, and a convenient interpretation, and a reconciliation of them must be found. Without wronging other mens judgements, I will tell my mind here, and how I am wont to excuse the Catechism: I say then, that the Catechism joins these three together, but doth not (as we said) divide them expressly as three: it joins, I say, these three, not as if it divided imputative justice into these three, as into divers parts, as if the imputed satisfaction did make us not unjust, the justice just, the sanctity holy; for it taught the contrary before: but either because the Compilers of the Catechism did retain this phrase, out of Mr. Beza's Confession, (whose it is properly known to be) not fearing there would be cavilling about it; they themselves in the mean while neither intending, nor observing any partition: or, because they would more emphatically note by these phrases, as Synonymous, the whole course of his obedience, and humiliation till death: for, Christs humiliation and death is our satisfaction; because by it satisfaction is made to divine justice for us: It is also justice; because it is the fulfilling of the Law by suffering: It is lastly holiness,1 because it is a holy Sacrifice; of which it is said, Father, I sanctify my self for them: And, By one oblation he hath consecrated all who are justified. This I conjecture, because, in the first edition of the Fundamentals of the Lords Supper, […]
As for the first, either we must confesse, that these fight against the former, which charity, and Christian candor will not allow; or the partition must be denied, and a convenient interpretation, and a reconciliation of them must be found. Without wronging other mens judgements, I will tell my minde here, and how I am wont to excuse the Catechisme: I say then, that the Catechisme joynes these three together, but doth not (as we said) divide them expresly as three: it joynes, I say, these three, not as if it divided imputative justice into these three, as into divers parts, as if the imputed satisfaction did make us not unjust, the justice just, the sanctity holy; for it taught the contrary before: but either because the Compilers of the Catechisme did retain this phrase, out of Mr. Beza's Confession, (whose it is properly knowne to be) not fearing there would be cavilling about it; they themselves in the meane while neither intending, nor observing any partition: or, because they would more emphatically note by these phrases, as Synonymous, the whole course of his obedience, and humiliation till death: for, Christs humiliation and death is our satisfaction; because by it satisfaction is made to divine justice for us: It is also justice; because it is the fulfilling of the Law by suffering: It is lastly holinesse,
A piece of a Speech, concerning that Question; To whom properly do the benefits of Christs sufferings and death belong? And, How Christ is said to die for all. IN The famous University of HEIDELBERG, declaimed by JOSHUA ZEVELIUS of Colen, the day before Easter, An. 1590.
A piece of a Speech, concerning that Question; To whom properly doe the benefits of Christs sufferings and death belong? And, How Christ is said to die for all. IN The famous University of HEIDELBERGE, declaimed by JOSUA ZEVELIUS of Colen, the day before Easter, An. 1590.
I Think I have spoken sufficiently of the history and benefits of our Lords Resurrection: it now remains, that what we had reserved for the last place, be now explained; to wit, to whom these benefits belong. Therefore, that we may direct our course by the Cynosure, or by the Pole-Star of holy Writ; we affirm, that, according to the same Scripture, these precious fruits do belong to all the Elect, and to them alone: but, as for the incredulous and impious, so long as they remain such, we exclude them from these benefits. For, all the believers, and they only, taste the sweetness of these fruits; to wit, of free justification before God, of vivification from the death of sin, and of the body; and, at last, they all, and they alone, feel the sweetness of immortality and glory; because they alone apply to themselves these fruits:1 They are those who hear the word of Christ, who receive it with a good and an honest heart, who believe it, and have life eternal, and shall not come into condemnation: these are justified by faith, are reconciled to God, and have peace through our Lord Jesus Christ: These being regenerated by the holy Ghost, are raised unto a new life with Christ, whose hearts are purified by faith: These at last are they, who, sleeping in Jesus, shall be raised by God from the dead, whom God will bring with him, that they may for ever enjoy the glory of eternal life.
I Thinke I have spoken sufficiently of the history and benefits of our Lords Resurrection: it now remaines, that what we had reserved for the last place, be now explained; to wit, to whom these benefits belong. Therefore, that we may direct our course by the Cynosure, or by the Pole-Star of holy Writ; we affirme, that, according to the same Scripture, these precious fruits do belong to all the Elect, and to them alone: but, as for the incredulous and impious, so long as they remaine such, we exclude them from these benefits. For, all the beleevers, and they onely, taste the sweetnesse of these fruits; to wit, of free justification before God, of vivification from the death of sin, and of the body; and, at last, they all, and they alone, feel the sweetness of immortality and glory; because they alone apply to themselves these fruits:1 They are those who heare the word of Christ, who receive it with a good and an honest heart, who beleeve it, and have life eternall, and shall not come into condemnation: these are justified by faith, are reconciled to God, and have peace through our Lord Jesus Christ: These being regenerated by the holy Ghost, are raised unto a new life with Christ, whose hearts are purified by faith: These at last are they, who, sleeping in Jesus, shall be raised by God from the dead, whom God will bring with him, that they may for ever enjoy the glory of eternall life.
As for the wicked, and such as want justifying faith,1 why should they partake so much happiness, who please not God? (and, Without faith 'tis impossible to please God) Who belong not to Christ, who are not heirs, neither have right to, or in that life, how can Christ or his benefits belong to them? They are rather by the voice of the Gospel debarred from these treasures, and are judged to eternal death and malediction. He that believeth not is judged already, and the wrath of God remaineth on him. And, Who ha•h not the Spirit of Christ, is none of his. Which place of the Apostle, I suppose is thus meant. For, if Infidels belong not to Christ, they ⟨p. 808⟩are none of Christs: We conclude strongly from the correlative, that Christ and his benefits belong not to the wicked: and as they are not Christs, so neither is Christ theirs. And how, I pray, should Christ belong to them whom he will, in the last judgement, pronounce before all the world, to be strangers from himself, from his benefits, from his Kingdom? who, he will testify, were never known to him? whom finally, as accursed workers of iniquity, he will cast into hell fire?
As for the wicked, and such as want justifying faith,1 why should they partake so much happinesse, who please not God? (and, Without faith 'tis impossible to please God) Who belong not to Christ, who are not heires, neither have right to, or in that life, how can Christ or his benefits belong to them? They are rather by the voice of the Gospell debarred from these treasures, and are judged to eternall death and malediction. He that beleeveth not is judged already, and the wrath of God remaineth on him. And, Who ha•h not the Spirit of Christ, is none of his. Which place of the Apostle, I suppose is thus meant. For, if Insidels belong not to Christ, they ⟨p. 808⟩are none of Christs: We conclude strongly from the correlative, that Christ and his benefits belong not to the wicked: and as they are not Christs, so neither is Christ theirs. And how, I pray, should Christ belong to them whom he will, in the last judgement, pronounce before all the world, to be strangers from himselfe, from his benefits, from his Kingdome? who, he will testifie, were never knowne to him? whom finally, as accutsed workers of iniquity, he will cast into hell fire?
But, you will say, Christ died for all, therefore rose again for all. The Answer is double: One is, As often as the Gospel extends the fruits of the works and benefits of Christ to all, this is to be understood of all those that believe in Christ: for, this is the perpetual and constant voice of the Gospel, He that believeth shall be saved; he shall not come into judgement: who believeth not, is already condemned, and the wrath of God remaineth upon him. Therefore, the Gospel debars from the benefits of Christ, all Infidels; not only by a plain exclusion, but also by that condition of faith and repentance, under which, either expressly or tacitly, God promiseth to men the benefits of Christ, and which is never to be found in those that persevere in sin. So then, Christ is said to die for all, to wit, all that do or shall believe in him; for whom alone he prayed, and in whom alone he finds the faith of his death: but as for Infidels and Reprobates, for whom Christ prayed not, whom he never acknowledged for his own, upon whom the wrath of God abideth for ever;1 to extend, I say on these, the benefits of Christ, what is it else, but against his own command, To give that which is holy unto dogs, and to cast pearls before swine? These we could solidly defend by authority of Scripture, and orthodox Fathers; and they mainly concern Christian consolation.
But, you will say, Christ died for all, therefore rose againe for all. The Answer is double: One is, As often as the Gospell extends the fruits of the works and benefits of Christ to all, this is to be understood of all those that beleeve in Christ: for, this is the perpetuall and constant voice of the Gospell, He that beleeveth shall be saved; he shall not come into judgement: who beleeveth not, is already condemned, and the wrath of God remaineth upon him. Therefore, the Gospell debarres from the benefits of Christ, all Infidels; not onely by a plaine exclusion, but also by that condition of faith and repentance, under which, either expresly or tacitly, God promiseth to men the benefits of Christ, and which is never to be found in those that persevere in sin. So then, Christ is said to die for all, to wit, all that do or shall beleeve in him; for whom alone he prayed, and in whom alone he findes the faith of his death: but as for Infidels and Reprobates, for whom Christ prayed not, whom he never acknowledged for his owne, upon whom the wrath of God abideth for ever;1 to extend, I say on these, the benefits of Christ, what is it else, but agnst his owne command, To give that which is holy unto dogs, and to cast pearles before swine? These we could solidly defend by authority of Scripture, and orthodox Fathers; and they mainely concerne Christian consolation.
There is an other Answer usual in the Schools, by which we may gratify the contentious; that Christ absolutely died for all, if you consider the amplitude and sufficiency of his price and merit; for, it is out of controversy, that the death of the Son of God is of that value, that it sufficeth to expiate the sins, not only of one, but of millions of worlds, if so be they had faith to apply this Physic to their sins. But the Question is properly of the efficacy and participation it self of these fruits, when we demand if Christ died for all: Because, to die for another, is properly to die in the stead and place of another, so that he is freed from death, and saved alive; as when David weeping, cried out, I wish I had died for thee. O Absalom; that is, I wish I had died in thy stead, that thou mightest have lived. But we utterly deny, that this participation of Christs merits is common to all unbelievers, as well as to those that believe; or, that this is promised, or exhibited in the Gospel: for, in this regard, we conclude, that Christ did not die properly for all, even for unbelievers and reprobates.
There is an other Answer usuall in the Schooles, by which we may gratifie the contentious; that Christ absolutely died for all, if you consider the amplitude and sufficiency of his price and merit; for, it is out of controversie, that the death of the Son of God is of that value, that it sufficeth to expiate the sins, not onely of one, but of millions of worlds, if so be they had faith to apply this Physick to their sins. But the Question is properly of the efficacy and participation it selfe of these fruits, when we demand if Christ died for all: Because, to die for another, is properly to die in the stead and place of another, so that he is freed from death, and saved alive; as when David weeping, cryed out, I wish I had died for thee. O Absalom; that is, I wish I had died in thy stead, that thou mightest have lived. But we utterly deny, that this participation of Christs merits is common to all unbeleevers, as well as to those that beleeve; or, that this is promised, or exhibited in the Gospell: for, in this regard, we conclude, that Christ did not die properly for all, even for unbeleevers and reprobates.
But here, some unlucky patrons of Infidels, taking it ill that we do not divide the pearls equally amongst sheep and swine, cry out, that we deny the blood of Christ, and that we produce a Saracenical Mahumeticall, and more then an Heathenish blasphemy, which utterly overthroweth Christian Religion.
But here, some unluckie patrons of Infidels, taking it ill that we do not divide the pearles equally amongst sheepe and swine, cry out, that we deny the bloud of Christ, and that we produce a Saracenicall Mahumeticall, and more then an Heathenish blasphemy, which utterly overthroweth Christian Religion.
But, Sirs, it is not our purpose to encounter or contend with such railing prattlers. But first, we protest against such bitter calumnies, making our appeal to the unanimous consent of the orthodoxall Church, and the perpetual voice of the Gospel, that we deny not, but honour the blood of Christ, when we say, it is poured out, not for those that slight it, and tread Christ under their feet; but for those who by faith are justified through it, as the Apostle saith, Whom God hath given to be an atonement by faith in his blood, 1to declare his righteousness by the remission of sins, that went before: for, this is not the voice of Infidels; Who hath washed us in his blood from our sins: and that, The blood of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin. Out of Gods word we know and believe, that this is no Saracenical, Mahumeticall, and more then Heathenish blasphemy, as this calumny doth impudently blaspheme; but that it is the genuine, true, and saving doctrine of the Gospel of Jesus Christ; and this we are ready at all times •o demonstrate before the whole Church. Besides, we hold it worth the while, and necessary, with as much brevity as may be, to pull off from these Wolves the Sheeps-skins with which they are ⟨p. 809⟩clothed, and to paint out in its own colours this their prodigious doctrine, which cunningly lurks under the calumny,2 which under this they go about to bring into the Church.
But, Sirs, it is not our purpose to encounter or contend with such rayling pratlers. But first, we protest against such bitter calumnies, making our appeale to the unanimous consent of the orthodoxall Church, and the perpetuall voice of the Gospell, that we deny not, but honour the bloud of Christ, when we say, it is poured out, not for those that slight it, and tread Christ under their feet; but for those who by faith are justified through it, as the Apostle saith, Whom God hath given to be an atonement by faith in his bloud, 1to declare his righteousnesse by the remission of sins, that went before: for, this is not the voice of Infidels; Who hath washed us in his bloud from our sinnes: and that, The bloud of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin. Out of Gods word we know and beleeve, that this is no Saracenicall, Mahumeticall, and more then Heathenish blasphemy, as this calumny doth impudently blaspheme; but that it is the genuine, true, and saving doctrine of the Gospell of Jesus Christ; and this we are ready at all times o demonstrate before the whole Church. Besides, we hold it worth the while, and necessary, with as much brevity as may be, to pull off from these Wolves the Sheeps-skins with which they are
They contend, That Christ dyed for all. Who denieth this? for this is the Scripture phrase. They add, That he dyed for all and singular. Neither do we simply deny this; to wit, in that sense which we showed a little before: although we do not find the Scripture speak so. They go on: That he dyed for all and singular alike; for the elect and reprobate, for Cain and David, for Judas and Peter, for the damned, as well as for those that are saved, without any respect of faith, or infidelity. This is hard. They proceed, finally, That he dyed for all and singular, not only in respect of sufficiency, but also in regard of the efficacy of the price. But what is this? to wit, That Christ by his death hath truly delivered from death, purged from sin, sanctified, and reconciled to God all absolutely, even those who are not saved, but have been damned ever since Cain, and are damned, and furthermore, are to be damned; all those, they say, he hath received into his favour. This is that impious monster, by which they conclude another, no less impious and false; to wit, That wicked men, whosoever have perished, do, or shall perish, that they have perished, do, and shall perish not for their sins (for they were expiated by the blood of Christ,) but only for their incredulity. They who have read their Books and Disputations, will confess, that this is no fiction of ours: But how monstrous are these to Christian ears?
They contend, That Christ dyed for all. Who denieth this? for this is the Scripture phrase. They adde, That he dyed for all and singular. Neither doe wee simply deny this; to wit, in that sense which we shewed a little before: although we do not find the Scripture speak so. They go on: That he dyed for all and singular alike; for the elect and reprobate, for Cain and David, for Judas and Peter, for the damned, as well as for those that are saved, without any respect of faith, or infidelity. This is hard. They proceed, finally, That he dyed for all and singular, not onely in respect of sufficiencie, but also in regard of the efficacie of the price. But what is this? to wit, That Christ by his death hath truly delivered from death, purged from sin, sanctified, and reconciled to God all absolutely, even those who are not saved, but have been damned ever since Cain, and are damned, and furthermore, are to be damned; all those, they say, he hath received into his favour. This is that impious monster, by which they conclude another, no lesle impious and false; to wit, That wicked men, whosoever have perished, doe, or shall perish, that they have perished, doe, and shall perish not for their sins (for they were expiated by the bloud of Christ,) but onely for their incredulity. They who have read their Books and Disputations, will confesse, that this is no fiction of ours: But how monstrous are these to Christian eares?
These brave patrons of wicked men teach, that all wicked and impure dogs, before and after the death of Christ, are received into the bosom and favour of God. But we say, first, That this is a false and impious doctrine; because it plainly opposeth Scripture, which continually cries out, that wicked men, so long as they remain without faith and repentance, are not in the favour of God; but that they remain the sons of wrath, and of eternal malediction: That they are not delivered from sin and death, but are held captives by the snares of the Devil, and are strongly deluded; yea, that they are already condemned, and are under the wrath of God. Again, we affirm, that this is a most absurd monster, which overthrows many principles of Christian faith, and it self also. For now let us set down and examine their Position, All men, without exception, faithful and unfaithful, before, and since the death of Christ, are truly and undoubtedly, by the blood of Christ, received into the grace and favour of God. What will from hence follow? surely, a world of absurdities.
These brave patrons of wicked men teach, that all wicked and impure dogs, before and after the death of Christ, are received into the bosome and favour of God. But we say, first, That this is a false and impious doctrine; because it plainly opposeth Scripture, which continually cries out, that wicked men, so long as they remaine without faith and repentance, are not in the favour of God; but that they remaine the sons of wrath, and of eternall malediction: That they are not delivered from sin and death, but are held captives by the snares of the Divell, and are strongly deluded; yea, that they are already condemned, and are under the wrath of God. Againe, we affirme, that this is a most absurd monster, which overthrowes many principles of Christian faith, and it selfe also. For now let us set downe and examine their Position, All men, without exception, faithfull and unfaithfull, before, and since the death of Christ, are truely and undoubtedly, by the bloud of Christ, received into the grace and favour of God. What will from hence follow? surely, a world of absurdities.
1. So original sin shall be taken away, neither shall there be any guilt thereof; and so it will be false to say, That all men are born the sons of wrath; because all shall be born in the grace and favour of God: But the Scripture pronounceth, that all men, by nature, are the sons of wrath.
1. So originall sin shall be taken away, neither shall there be any guilt thereof; and so it will be false to say, That all men are born the sons of wrath; because all shall be born in the grace and favour of God: But the Scripture pronounceth, that all men, by nature, are the sons of wrath.
2. All the children of Turks, Saracens, Centaurs, and Cannibals, which are out of the Covenant and Church of God, shall be borne in the favour and grace of God; and so salvation shall be found without the Covenant, and out of the Church of God. O men, as cruel as Briareus! who doubt not to place the infants of Turks, born out of the Church, in the favour of God; but as for Christian infants before baptism, cruelly they fling them headlong into hell.
2. All the children of Turkes, Saracens, Centaures, and Canibals, which are out of the Covenant and Church of God, shall be borne in the favour and grace of God; and so salvation shall be found without the Covenant, and out of the Church of God. O men, as cruell as Briareus! who doubt not to place the infants of Turkes, born out of the Church, in the favour of God; but as for Christian infants before baptisme, cruelly they fling them headlong into hell.
3. This monster overthrows another Tenet of theirs, concerning the infants of faith full men, who are borne out of grace: yea, who are before baptism possessed with the Devil, and damned; for, they place them all in the grace and favour of God.
3. This monster overthrowes another Tenet of theirs, concerning the infants of faith full men, who are borne out of grace: yea, who are before baptisme possessed with the Divell, and damned; for, they place them all in the grace and favour of God.
4. All wicked men, who before Christs death were damned to hell, by Christs death are again redeemed from hell, and brought into Gods favour. How then could they again fall from thence, who, being dead, were received, when they could not any more sin by incredulity? Therefore wicked men either must remain in the favour of God, and be saved without faith; or else, without incredulity, they must be cast headlong from thence: both which have a kind of madness in them.
4. All wicked men, who before Christs death were damned to hell, by Christs death are againe redeemed from hell, and brought into Gods favour. How then could they againe fall from thence, who, being dead, were received, when they could not any more sin by incredulity? Therefore wicked men either must remaine in the favour of God, and be saved without faith; or else, without incredulitie, they must be cast headlong from thence: both which have a kind of madnesse in them.
5. Either incredulity is no sin; or, if it be, all sins were not expiated by Christs death: or, if all be, this will at least be more effectual then Christs death. But all this is false and impious: for, infidelity is both ⟨p. 810⟩a sin, and the mother of other sins, and in the regenerate now and then it appears with other sins, notwithstanding by the blood of Christ it is most effectually expiated and pardoned.
5. Either incredulitie is no sin; or, if it be, all sins were not expiated by Christs death: or, if all be, this will at least be more effectuall then Christs death. But all this is false and impious: for, infidelitie is both ⟨p. 810⟩a sin, and the mother of other sins, and in the regenerate now and then it appeares with other sins, notwithstanding by the bloud of Christ it is most effectually expiated and pardoned.
6. It is an impudent lye, that wicked men are not condemned for sin, but for incredulity only: for what is that, 1 Cor. 6.10. Thieves, covetous persons, drunkards, &c. shall not inherit the Kingdom, of God? and which Christ in his last Judgement shall say to the wicked, Go into hell fire, because you fed me not, &c? Is not incredulity the chief of all sins? Yea, we conclude on the contrary, that they are condemned for sin, because they are condemned for incredulity: for, scarce is there any sin more grievous then infidelity. But the Apostate trifles too much with his exception, saying, That incredulity is not to be considered as a sin in it self, but as it rejects the means of salvation. Is not (I pray) the rejecting of the means of salvation, the contempt of Gods calling, a most grievous sin? For this cause then incredulity is a sin, in that it rejects salvation, and the means thereof.
6. It is an impudent lye, that wicked men are not condemned for sin, but for incredulitie onely: for what is that, 1 Cor. 6.10. Theeves, covetous persons, drunkards, &c. shall not inherit the Kingdome, of God? and which Christ in his last Judgement shall say to the wicked, Goe into hell fire, because you fed mee not, &c? Is not incredulitie the chiefe of all sins? Yea, wee conclude on the contrary, that they are condemned for sin, because they are condemned for incredulitie: for, scarce is there any sin more grievous then infidelitie. But the Apostate trifles too much with his exception, saying, That incredulitie is not to be considered as a sin in it selfe, but as it rejects the meanes of salvation. Is not (I pray) the rejecting of the meanes of salvation, the contempt of Gods calling, a most grievous sin? For this cause then incredulitie is a sin, in that it rejects salvation, and the meanes thereof.
7. This prodigious doctrine gives to the wicked, that, notwithstanding the doctrine of the Church concerning original sin, and the guilt of wicked men; yet, that this is at no time in them, nor can truly be pronounced of them. Let us take a Turkish infant, or a Barbarian man of years, who never heard of Christs death, and therefore never rejected him by incredulity. Now, let these Disputers tell us, what moment of time will they give them to be in the grace and favour of God, justified, and sanctified, and reconciled to him? Will they, whilst they are Embryons, or newly borne, or children, or young men, or old men, or lastly, living, or dead? Yea, let them tell, if they be received, how they fell away, when neither sin, nor actual incredulity could drive them thence? for these do not befall them; but were expiated by the death of Christ. Whatsoever they say, we shall hear, that either without faith some do please God; or, that without actual incredulity, some are debarred from the favour of God: which are false and impious prodigies, overthrowing one the other.
7. This prodigious doctrine gives to the wicked, that, notwithstanding the doctrine of the Church concerning originall sin, and the guilt of wicked men; yet, that this is at no time in them, nor can truly be pronounced of them. Let us take a Turkish infant, or a Barbarian man of yeares, who never heard of Christs death, and therefore never rejected him by incredulitie. Now, let these Disputers tell us, what moment of time will they give them to be in the grace and favour of God, justified, and sanctified, and reconciled to him? Will they, whilst they are Embryons, or newly borne, or children, or young men, or old men, or lastly, living, or dead? Yea, let them tell, if they be received, how they fell away, when neither sin, nor actuall incredulitie could drive them thence? for these doe not besall them; but were expiated by the death of Christ. Whatsoever they say, wee shall heare, that either without faith some doe please God; or, that without actuall incredulitie, some are debarred from the favour of God: which are false and impious prodigies, overthrowing one the other.
Lastly, what greater blasphemy can be spoken, then that God receiveth into his grace and favour all infidels and wicked men? Cain, Saul, Judas, Herod, Caligula, and finally, all flagitious men, yea, Hogs? What comfort can be more like to mockery, then that thou shouldst be redeemed by the death of Christ, restored into the grace and favour of God; whereas many thousands of them, who have been thus restored, notwithstanding perish eternally? I tremble to relate more of this monster; therefore who will doubt, but that so false, impious, absurd, blasphemous tenets, are to be banished from the confines of the Church?
But here, me thinks, I hear them cry out, that the promises of the Gospel are universal, and belong to all. But first, we ask how this will follow? The promises are universal: Ergo, reprobates, impure dogs, and hogs are received into the favour of God. Besides, so long as they urge their All, all, so long will we our Believers, believers: For, the promises are universal; but with respect to penitents and believers of the Gospel. And here, before all the world, we appeal to the literal promises: Come to me all (saith Christ;) but he adds, that are weary, and heavy laden; that is, who faint and groan under the burden of sin, which they do who repent.1 And else-where, So God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth, should not perish, but have life eternal. So Paul, The righteousness of God by faith in Jesus Christ, upon all, and over all that believe. And elsewhere, The Scripture hath concluded all under sin, that the promise, by faith in Christ Jesus, should be given to all believers. So Christ, He that believeth in the Son, hath life eternal. And Peter, To him bare all the Prophets witness, that all who believe in him, shall receive remission of sins through his Name. There is the like reason of all other Evangelical promises: for, they have annexed expressly or tacitly the condition of faith and repentance; nor can they, without blasphemy, be understood, but of the universality of the faithful. But they will except, that so the promises will be but particular.2 Let Prosper answer for us, de vocat. Gent. The people of God have their plenitude; and although a great part of men either neglect, or reject the grace of salvation: yet, in the elect, and those that are fore-seen, and separated, there is a special kind of universality, ⟨p. 811⟩that out of all the world, the world may seem to be delivered; and, out of all men, all men may seem to be redeemed: Therefore the promises of the Gospel remain universal to the faithful; although they belong not to dogs and swine. The Major also of the practical Syllogism remains universal: thus, The promises belong to all believers; I believe: Ergo, they belong to me. Again, Christ dyed, and prayed for all believers; I believe: Ergo, he dyed and prayed for me. But they are too cold comforters, who teach afflicted consciences thus to reason: Christ dyed for all men;
I am a man: Ergo, he dyed for me. Why may not a Turk, a dog, or a hog wallowing in the mire, conclude so? O brave comforters and Preachers of Gods word for, the maine•inew of Christian comfort is, not to be a man, but to be engrafted into Christ.
I am a man: Ergo, he dyed for mee. Why may not a Turk, a dog, or a hog wallowing in the mire, conclude so? O brave comforters and Preachers of Gods word for, the maine•inew of Christian comfort is, not to be a man, but to be ingraffed into Christ.
Again, they object out of the Apostle, That all are made alive in Christ,1 as all dyed in Adam: But if they will absolutely say, that all are made alive in Christ, Scripture and experience will refel them. This is it then the Apostle saith, that Christ gives life to all his own, as Adam brought death upon all his own: And he, indeed, by grace, which is more; but this by natural propagation, which is easier. This sense of the Apostle is proved by the subsequent words: for, when he had said, that all were made alive in Christ, he presently subjoins, Every one in his own order: Christ, as the first-fruits, afterward they that are Christs; that is, believers, who are given to him by the Father, and for whom he earnestly prayed to the Father. Neither is Austins interpretation different from this:2 therefore it is said, that all are alive in Christ; not, as if all that die in Adam, were members of Christ: but because, as no man, except in his natural body, dyeth in Adam; so no man in the spiritual body is quickened, but in Christ. Neither have they cause to object, that by these means Adam is made stronger then Christ, if he destroy more by death, then Christ preserveth by his death and life. They know not what they bark against. Be it so, that all, who are lost in Adam, are saved by Christ: But this way grace shall not abound, but will be only equal to sin. The power of both is not to be measured by the number of those who die or live, but by the manner, by which perdition and vivification are obtained; or else, by the greatness of the benefits received, or lost. Its an easy matter to wound, but hard to cure; according to the Proverb, You shall sooner, and with more ease destroy 600 men, then save one: You shall sooner tumble down many men from off the bridge into the water, then you can preserve one from drowning: So it was more easy to undo all mankind, then to restore one man from destruction. That Satan could do, Adam could do; but this none can effect, except Christ. Beasts or afflictions can hurt, offend, and kill men; but it is in no mans power, save only in his, who is the Creator of all things, •o restore salvation and life eternal: Therefore Christs death had been stronger then Adams, though he had restored but one man to life.
Againe, they object out of the Apostle, That all are made alive in Christ,1
Besides, it is certain, and out of question, that the good things we have by Christ, do as far excel those things which we lost by Adam, as heaven and eternity exceed terrene and transient blessings: For, Adam was earthly (saith the Apostle) Christ heavenly; he was natural, this spiritual: he ejected us out of an earthly Paradise, this hath introduced us into an heavenly Mansion, and hath crowned us with eternity of happiness.
Besides, it is certaine, and out of question, that the good things we have by Christ, doe as far excell those things which we lost by Adam, as heaven and eternitie exceed terrene and transient blessings: For, Adam was earthly (saith the Apostle) Christ heavenly; he was naturall, this spirituall: he ejected us out of an earthly Paradise, this hath introduced us into an heavenly Mansion, and hath crowned us with eternitie of happinesse.
Thus, I suppose, we have sufficiently demonstrated and defended, that the fruit of Christs death and resurrection doth appertain to all, and only to them who repent, and by faith adhere to Christ.
Thus, I suppose, we have sufficiently demonstrated and defended, that the fruit of Christs death and resurrection doth appertaine to all, and onely to them who repent, and by faith adhere to Christ.
because it is a holy Sacrifice; of which it is said, Father, I sanctifie my selfe for them: And, By one oblation he hath consecrated all who are justified. This I conjecture, because, in the first edition of the Fundamentals of the Lords Supper, 〈…〉
But here, me thinks, I heare them cry out, that the promises of the Gospel are universall, and belong to all. But first, we aske how this will follow? The promises are universall: Ergo, reprobates, impure dogs, and hogs are received into the favour of God. Besides, so long as they urge their All, all, so long will we our Beleevers, beleevers: For, the promises are universall; but with respect to penitents and beleevers of the Gospel. And here, before all the world, wee appeale to the literall promises: Come to mee all (saith Christ;) but he addes, that are weary, and heavie laden; that is, who faint and groan under the burthen of sin, which they doe who repent.
And else-where, So God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever beleeveth, should not perish, but have life eternall. So Paul, The righteousnesse of God by faith in Jesus Christ, upon all, and over all that beleeve. And elsewhere, The Scripture hath concluded all under sin, that the promise, by faith in Christ Jesus, should be given to all beleevers. So Christ, He that beleeveth in the Son, hath life eternall. And Peter, To him bare all the Prophets witnesse, that all who beleeve in him, shall receive remission of sins through his Name. There is the like reason of all other Evangelicall promises: for, they have annexed expresly or tacitely the condition of faith and repentance; nor can they, without blasphemy, be understood, but of the universalitie of the faithfull. But they will except, that so the promises will be but particular.
Let Prosper answer for us, de vocat. Gent. The people of God have their plenitude; and although a great part of men either neglect, or reject the grace of salvation: yet, in the elect, and those that are fore-seen, and separated, there is a speciall kind of universality,
⟨p. 811⟩
that out of all the world, the world may seem to be delivered; and, out of all men, all men may seem to be redeemed: Therefore the promises of the Gospel remaine universall to the faithfull; although they belong not to dogs and swine. The Major also of the practicall Syllogisme remaines universall: thus, The promises belong to all beleevers; I beleeve: Ergo, they belong to mee. Againe, Christ dyed, and prayed for all beleevers; I beleeve: Ergo, he dyed and prayed for mee. But they are too cold comforters, who teach afflicted consciences thus to reason: Christ dyed for all men;
as all dyed in Adam: But if they will absolutely say, that all are made alive in Christ, Scripture and experience will refell them. This is it then the Apostle saith, that Christ gives life to all his owne, as Adam brought death upon all his owne: And he, indeed, by grace, which is more; but this by naturall propagation, which is easier. This sense of the Apostle is proved by the subsequent words: for, when he had said, that all were made alive in Christ, hee presently subjoynes, Every one in his owne order: Christ, as the first-fruits, afterward they that are Christs; that is, beleevers, who are given to him by the Father, and for whom he earnestly prayed to the Father. Neither is Austins interpretation different from this:
therefore it is said, that all are alive in Christ; not, as if all that die in Adam, were members of Christ: but because, as no man, except in his naturall bodie, dyeth in Adam; so no man in the spirituall bodie is quickned, but in Christ. Neither have they cause to object, that by these meanes Adam is made stronger then Christ, if he destroy more by death, then Christ preserveth by his death and life. They know not what they bark against. Be it so, that all, who are lost in Adam, are saved by Christ: But this way grace shall not abound, but will be onely equall to sin. The power of both is not to be measured by the number of those who die or live, but by the manner, by which perdition and vivification are obtained; or else, by the greatnesle of the benefits received, or lost. Its an easie matter to wound, but hard to cure; according to the Proverb, You shall sooner, and with more ease destroy 600 men, then save one: You shall sooner tumble downe many men from off the bridge into the water, then you can preserve one from drowning: So it was more easie to undoe all mankind, then to restore one man from destruction. That Satan could doe, Adam could doe; but this none can effect, except Christ. Beasts or afflictions can hurt, offend, and kill men; but it is in no mans power, save onely in his, who is the Creatour of all things, •o restore salvation and life eternall: Therefore Christs death had been stronger then Adams, though he had restored but one man to life.