Harpesfield. I Am not ignorant what a weighty matter it is, to entreat of the whole order and trade of the scriptures:1 and most hard it is to, in the great contention of Religion, to show the ready way, whereby the scriptures may be best understanded. For the often reading of them doth not bring the true understanding of them. What other thing is there then? Verily this is the ready way, not to follow our own heads and senses, but to give over our judgement unto the holy catholic Church, who hath had of old years the truth, and always delivered the same to their posterity: but if the often reading of scriptures, and never so painful comparing of places should bring the true understanding, then divers heretics might prevail even against whole general Councils. The *Jews did greatly brag of the knowledge of the law, and of the Saviour that they waited for. But what availed it them? Notwithstanding, I know right well, that divers places of the scripture do much warn us of the often reading of the same, and what fruit doth thereby follow: as Scrutamini, &c. Search the scriptures: for they do bear witness of me, &c. Lex Domini, &c. The law of the Lord is pure, able to turn souls. And that saying of S. Paule: Omnis Scriptura, &c. All Scripture inspired from above, doth make that a man may be instructed to all good works. Howbeit, doth the law of the Jews convert their souls? are they by reading instructed to every good work? The letter of the old Testament, is the same that we have.
The heretics also have ever had the same scriptures which we have that be Catholics. But they are served as Tantalus that the Poets do speak of, who in the plenty of things to eat and drink, is said to be oppressed with hunger and thirst. The swifter that men do seek the Scriptures without the Catholic church, the deeper they fall, and find hell for their labour. Saint Cyprian never swerving from the Catholic Church, saith: He that doth not acknowledge the Church to be his mother, shall not have God to be his father. Therefore it is true Divinity,* to be wise with the Church, where Christ sayeth: Nisi manducaveritis, &c. Unless ye eat my flesh, and drink my blood, ye have no life in you.
If he had meant of only eating bread, and drinking wine, nothing had been more pleasant to the Capernaites, neither would they have forsaken him.
Harpesfield. I Am not ignoraunt what a weighty matter it is, to entreat of the whole order and trade of the scriptures:1 and most hard it is to, in the great contention of Religion, to shew the ready way, whereby the scriptures may be best vnderstanded. For the oftē reading of them doth not bring the true vnderstanding of them. What other thing is there then? Uerily this is the redy way, not to folow our owne heads and senses, but to geue ouer our iudgement vnto the holy catholike Church, who hath had of olde yeres the truth, and alwayes deliuered the same to their posteritie: but if the often readyng of scriptures, and neuer so paynefull comparing of places should bring the true vnderstandyng, then diuers heretikes might preuaile euen agaynst whole generall Councels. The *Iewes did greatly brag of the knowledge of the law, and of the Sauiour that they waited for. But what auailed it them? Notwithstanding, I know right well, that diuers places of the scripture doe much warne vs of the often reading of the same, and what fruit doth therby follow: as Scrutamini, &c. Search the scriptures: for they do beare witnesse of me, &c. Lex Domini, &c. The law of the Lord is pure, able to turne soules. And that saying of S. Paule: Omnis Scriptura, &c. All Scripture inspired from aboue, doth make that a man may bee instructed to all good workes. Howbeit, doth the lawe of the Iewes conuert their soules? are they by reading instructed to euery good worke? The letter of the old Testament, is the same that we haue.
The heretikes also haue euer had the same scriptures which we haue that be Catholikes. But they are serued as Tantalus that the Poetes do speake of, who in the plentye of thynges to eate and drinke, is sayd to bee oppressed with hunger and thirst. The swifter that men do seeke the Scriptures without the Catholike church, the deeper they fall, and fynde hell for their labour. Saint Cyprian neuer swaruing from the Catholike Church, saith: He that doth not acknowledge the Church to bee his mother, shall not haue God to be his father. Therefore it is true Diuinitie,* to bee wise with the Church, where Christ sayeth: Nisi manducaueritis, &c. Vnlesse ye eate my fleshe, and drinke my bloud, ye haue no lyfe in you.
If he had meant of onely eating bread, and drinkyng wyne, nothyng had bene more pleasaunt to the Capernaites, neither would they haue forsaken hym.
- 1April. 1. The judgement of M. Harpsfiel• for the be•• way to understand […] Scripture▪ If Master Harpsfiel• had will us to […] our senses to the hol• ghost he had said much better.Aprill. 1. The iudgement of M. Harpsfiel• for the be•• way to v••derstād 〈…〉 Scripture▪ If Master Harpsfiel• had wille vs to 〈…〉 our sences to the hol• ghost he had sayd much better.
- *No, but those Jews, sticking so much to th• old custo•• and face of their Church, & not seeking for knowledge, by ignorance the Scriptures wer• deceived […] so be you.No, but those Iewes, sticking so much to th• old custo•• and face of theyr Church, & not seeking for knowledge, by ignorance the Scriptures wer• deceiued 〈…〉 so be you.
- *Under th• forms th•• is, under th• properties of bread […] wine & so all this is true. In the material […] of […] body there is no variety: for to eat mans flesh eyth•• under acci•dences or not accidē •ces both is against th• Scripture […] against na•ture.