pp. 1416–141734 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1ON Monday following, being the 30. of October, the Prolocutor demanded of John Philpot Archdeacon of Winchester, whether he would answer in the questions before propounded to their objections, or no? To whom he made this answer, that he would willingly so do, if, according to their former determination, they would first answer sufficiently to some of his arguments, as they had promised to do: whereof he had a dozen, not half of the first being yet decided: And if they would answer fully, and sufficiently but to one of his Arguments, he promised that he would answer all the objections that they should bring.
1ON Mondaye following, being the 30. of October, the Prolocutor demaunded of Iohn Philpot Archdeacon of Winchester, whether he would answere in the questions before propounded to their obiections, or no? To whome he made this answeare, that he woulde willingly so doe, if, according to theyr former determination, they would firste aunswere sufficiently to some of hys argumentes, as they had promised to do: wherof he had a dozen, not halfe of the first being yet decided: And if they woulde aunswere fully, and sufficiently but to one of his Arguments, he promised that he would answere all the obiections that they shoulde bryng.
Then the Prolocutor bade him propound his Argument, and it should be resolutely answered by one of them: whereunto M. Morgan was appointed.1 Upon Wednesday last (quoth he) I was enforced to silence before I had prosecuted half of mine Argument: the sum whereof was this (as was gathered by the just context of the scripture) that the human body of Christ was ascended into heaven, and placed on the right hand of God the father: wherefore it could not be situate upon earth in the sacrament of the altar, invisible after the imagination of man. The argument was denied by Morgan: For the proof whereof, Philpot said, that this was it wherewith he had to confirm his first argument, if they would have suffered him the other day, as now he trusted they would.
Then the Prolocutor bade him propounde hys Argument, and it should be resolutely answered by one of them: whereunto M. Morgan was appoynted.1 Upon Wensday last (quoth he) I was inforced to silence before I had prosecuted halfe of mine Argument: the summe whereof was this (as was gathered by the iust context of the scripture) that the humain body of Christ was ascended into heauen, and placed on the right hand of God the father: wherefore it coulde not be situate vpon earth in the sacrament of the altare, inuisible after the imagination of man. The argument was denied by Morgan: For the profe wherof, Philpot sayd, that this was it wherwith he had to confirme his first argument, if they would haue suffred him ye other day, as now he trusted they would.
ri- But the body of Christ is an humane nature, distinct from the Deity, and is a proper nature of it self.
ri- But the body of Christ is an humane nature, distincte from the Deitie, and is a proper nature of it selfe.
o. Ergo, it cannot receive any thing that is contrary to that nature, and that varieth from it self.
o. Ergo, it cannot receiue any thyng that is contrarye to that nature, and that varieth from it selfe.
But bodily to be present, and bodily to be absent, to be on earth, and to be in heaven, and all at one present time, be things contrary to the nature of an human body, Ergo, it cannot be said of the human body of Christ, that the self same body is both in heaven, & also in earth at one instant, either visibly or invisibly.
But bodely to be present, and bodely to be absent, to be on earth, and to be in heauen, and al at one present time, be things contrary to the nature of an humaine body, Ergo, it cannot be saide of the humaine body of Christ, that the selfe same body is both in heauen, & also in earth at one instant, either visibly or inuisibly.
Morgan denied the Major, that is,1 the first part of the argument. The which Philpot vouched out of Vigilius an ancient writer.2 But Morgan cavilled that it was no scripture, and bade him prove the same out of scripture.
Morgan denied the Maior, that is,1 the firste parte of the argument. The which Philpot vouched out of Vigilius an auncient wryter.2 But Morgan cauilled that it was no scripture, and bade him prooue the same out of scripture.
Philpot said he could also so do, and right well deduce the same out of S. Paul, who sayeth, that Christ is like unto us in all points, except sin: and therefore like as one of our bodies cannot receive in it self any thing contrary to the nature of a body, as to be in Pauls church, and at Westminster at one instant, or to be at London visibly, & at Lincoln invisibly at one time: for that is so contrary to the nature of a body,1 and of all creatures (as Didimus and Basilius affirm) that an invisible creature, as an Angel, cannot be at one time in divers places, wherefore he concluded, that the body of Christ might not be in moe places then in one, which is in heaven, and so consequently, not to be contained in the sacrament of the altar.
Philpot sayd he could also so do, and right well deduce the same out of S. Paule, who sayeth, that Christ is like vnto vs in all poyntes, except sinne: and therefore like as one of our bodies cannot receiue in it selfe any thing contrarye to the nature of a body, as to be in Paules churche, and at Westminster at one instant, or to be at Londō visibly, & at Lincoln inuisibly at one time: for that is so contrary to the nature of a body,1 and of all creatures (as Didimus and Basilius affirme) that an inuisible creature, as an Angell, cannot be at one time in diuers places, wherfore he concluded, that the body of Christ might not be in moe places then in one, which is in heauen, and so consequently, not to be contained in the sacrament of the altare.
To this the Prolocutor took upon him to answer,1 saying, that it was not true that Christ was like unto us in all points, as Philpot took it, except sin,2 For that Christ was not conceived by the seed of man, as we be.
To thys the Prolocutor tooke vpon him to answeare,1 saying, that it was not true that Christe was like vnto vs in all poynts, as Philpot tooke it, except sinne,2 For yt Christ was not conceiued by the seede of man, as we be.
Whereunto Philpot again replied, that Christs conception was prophesied before by the Angel to be supernatural, but after he had received our nature by the operation of the holy Ghost in the virgins womb, he became in all points like unto us, except sin.
Whereunto Philpot againe replied, that Christes conception was prophesied before by the Angel to be supernatural, but after he had receiued our nature by the operation of the holy Ghost in the virgins wombe, hee became in all poynts like vnto vs, except sinne.
Then Morgan inferred that this saying of Paul did not plainly prove his purpose. Well, quoth Philpot,1 I perceive that you do answer but by cavillation, yet am I not destitute of other scriptures to confirm my first argument,2 although you refuse the probation of so ancient and catholic a doctor as Vigilius is. Saint Peter in the sermone that he made in the third of the Acts, making mention of Christ, saith these words, whom heaven must receive until the consummation of all things. &c. 3Which words are spoken of his humanity. If heaven must hold Christ, then can he not be here on earth in the Sacrament, as is pretended.
Then Morgan inferred that thys saying of Paule dyd not plainly proue his purpose. Wel, quoth Philpot,1 I perceiue that you do answere but by cauillation, yet am I not destitute of other scriptures to confirme my first argumēt,2 although you refuse the probation of so ancient and catholicke a doctour as Vigilius is. Sainte Peter in the sermone that he made in the thirde of the Actes, making mention of Christe, sayth these woordes, whome heauen must receiue vntill the consummation of all things. &c. 3Which words are spoken of hys humanitie. If heauen must holde Christ, then can hee not be heere on earth in the Sacrament, as is pretended.
Then Morgan laughing at this,1 and giving no direct answer at all, Harpfield stood up, being one of the Bishop of London's chaplains, and took upon him to answer to the saying of S. Peter, & demanded of Philpot, whether he would, ex necessitate, that is, of necessity, force Christ to any place, or no?
Then Morgan laughing at this,1 and geuing no direct answer at all, Harpfield stoode vp, being one of the Bishop of Londons chaplaines, and tooke vpon him to answer to the saying of S. Peter, & demaunded of Philpot, whether he would, ex necessitate, that is, of necessitie, force Christ to any place, or no?
Philpot said, that he would no otherwise force Christ of necessity to any place,1 then he is taught by the words of the holy Ghost, which sound thus: that Christs human body must abide in heaven until the day of judgement, as I rehearsed out of the chapter before mentioned.
Philpot sayd, that he would no otherwise force Christe of necessity to any place,1 then he is taught by the wordes of the holy Ghost, which sounde thus: that Christes humaine body must abide in heauen vntill the day of iudgement, as I rehearsed out of the chapter before mentioned.
Why quoth Harpsfield, do you not know that Christ is God omnipotent? Yes said Philpot,1 I know that right well, neither doubt I any thing at all of his omnipotency. But of Christs omnipotency what he may do, is not our question, but rather what he doeth. I know he may make a stone in the wall a man, if he list, and also that he may make moe worlds, but doeth he therefore so? It were no good consequent so to conclude: he may do this, or that, therefore he doth it.
Why quoth Harpsfield, do you not knowe that Christe is God omnipotent? Yes said Philpot,1 I know that right wel, neither doubt I any thing at all of his omnipotencie. But of Christes omnipotencie what he may do, is not our question, but rather what he doeth. I knowe he may make a stone in the wall a manne, if he liste, and also that he may make moe worldes, but doeth he therefore so? It were no good consequent so to conclude: hee maye doe this, or that, therefore he doth it.
Ba- Only so much is to be believed of Gods omnipotency, as is in the word expressed.
Ba- Only so much is to be beleeued of Gods omnipotencie, as is in the woorde expressed.
ra- That Christs body is both in heaven and here also really in the sacrament, is not expressed in the word.
ra- That Christes body is both in heauen and heere also really in the sacrament, is not expressed in the word.
co. Ergo, it is not to be believed that the body of Christ, being in heaven is here also really in the sacrament.
co. Ergo, it is not to be beleeued that the body of Christe, being in heauen is heere also really in the sacrament.
Why quoth the Prolocutor, then you will put Christ in prison in heaven. To the which Philpot answered, do you reckon heaven to be a prison? God grant us all to ⟨p. 1417⟩come to that prison.
Why quoth the Prolocutor, then you will putte Christ in prisone in heauen. To the which Philpot answered, doe you recken heauen to be a prisone? God graunt vs all to ⟨p. 1417⟩come to that prisone.
After this, Harpsfield inferred that this word Oportet in S. Peter,1 which signifieth in English must, did not import so much as I would infer of necessity, as by other places of Scripture it may appear, as in the first to Tim. where Paul sayeth, Oportet Episcopum esse unius uxoris virum: A bishop must be the husband of one wife. Here quoth he, Oportet doeth not import such a necessity, but that he that never was married may be a Bishop.
After this, Harpsfield inferred that this word Oportet in S. Peter,1 which signifieth in Englishe must, did not import so much as I woulde inferre of necessitie, as by other places of Scripture it may appeare, as in the first to Tim. where Paule sayeth, Oportet Episcopum esse vnius vxoris virum: A bishop must be the husband of one wife. Here quoth he, Oportet doeth not import suche a necessitie, but that hee that neuer was maried may be a Bishop.
To this Philpot said again, that the places were not like which he went about to compare, and that in comparing of the Scriptures we must not consider the naked words,1 but the meaning rather of the Scriptures, for that in the place by him alleged,2 S. Paul doeth declare of what quality a Bishop ought to be. But in the other S. Peter teacheth us the place where Christ must necessarily be until the end of the world: which we ought to believe to be true. And this comparison of this word Oportet, doeth no more answer mine argument, then if I should say of you now being here Oportet te hic esse, you must needs be here, which importeth such necessity for the time, that you can no otherwise be but here, & yet you would go about in words to avoid this necessity with another Oportet, in an other sense, as this, Oportet te esse virū bonum, you must be a good man, where Oportet doeth not in very deed conclude any such necessity, but that you may be an evil man. Thus you may see that your answer is not sufficient, & as it were, no answer to mine argument.
To this Philpot saide againe, that the places were not like whych he went about to compare, and that in comparing of the Scriptures wee muste not consider the naked wordes,1 but the meaning rather of the Scriptures, for yt in the place by him alleaged,2 S. Paule doeth declare of what qualitie a Bishop ought to be. But in the other S. Peter teacheth vs the place where Christ must necessarily be vntil the ende of the worlde: which we ought to beleeue to be true. And this comparison of this worde Oportet, doeth no more aunswer mine argument, then if I should say of you now being here Oportet te hic esse, you must nedes be heere, which importeth such necessity for the time, that you can no otherwise be but here, & yet you would go about in words to auoide this necessitye with another Oportet, in an other sense, as this, Oportet te esse virū bonum, you must be a good man, where Oportet doeth not in very deede conclude any such necessity, but that you may be an euill man. Thus you may see that your answere is not sufficient, & as it were, no answere to mine argument.
Then the Prolocutor brought in another Oportet, to help this matter (if it might be) saying,1 what say you to this, Oportet haereses esse, must heresies needs be therefore because of this word Oportet?
Then the Prolocutour brought in another Oportet, to helpe this matter (if it mighte be) sayinge,1 what say you to this, Oportet haereses esse, must heresies needes be therefore because of thys word Oportet?
1Yea truly, quoth Philpot, it cannot otherwise be, if you will add that which followeth immediately upon these words of Paul, that is, Ut qui electi sunt, manifestentur, that is: That such as be the elect of God, may be manifested and known.
1Yea truely, quoth Philpotte, it cannot otherwise be, if you will adde that which followeth immediatly vpon these woordes of Paul, that is, Vt qui electi sunt, manifestentur, that is: That suche as be ye elect of God, may be manifested and knowen.
Why, quoth the Prolocutor, the time hath been that no heresies were.1 I know no such time quoth Philpot. For since the time of Abel and Cain, heresies have been, and then began they.2 Then said the Prolocutor, will you now answer Morgan an argument or two? I will quoth Philpot, if I may first be answered to my argument any thing according to truth and learning.3 What quoth the Prolocutor, you will never be answered. Howe I am answered, quoth Philpot,4 let all men that are here present, judge: and specially such as be learned, & with what cavillations you have dallied with me.
Why, quoth the Prolocutor, the time hath bene that no heresies were.1 I knowe no suche time quoth Philpot. For since the time of Abell and Caine, heresies haue bene, and then began they.2 Then sayd the Prolocutor, wil you nowe answer Morgan an argument or two? I wil quoth Philpot, if I may first be answered to my argument any thyng according to truth and learning.3 What quoth the Prolocutor, you will neuer be answeared. Howe I am answeared, quoth Philpot,4 let all men that are here present, iudge: and specially such as be learned, & with what cauillations you haue dallied with me.
First to the ancient authority of Vigilius, you have answered nothing at all, but only denying it to be scripture that he saith. Secondly, to the saying of S. Peter in the acts, ye have answered thus, demanding of me whether I would keep Christ in prison or no, let men now judge if this be a sufficient answer or no.
First to the auncient authority of Vigilius, you haue answered nothing at all, but only denying it to be scripture yt he sayth. Secondly, to the saying of S. Peter in the actes, yee haue aunsweared thus, demaunding of me whether I would keepe Christ in prison or no, let men nowe iudge if this be a sufficient answere or no.
Yes, quoth he, if it be the true Catholic Church. And sith you speak so much of the Church,1 I would fain that you would declare what the church is.
Yes, quoth he, if it be the true Catholicke Church. And sith you speake so much of the Churche,1 I would faine that you would declare what the church is.
The church, quoth Morgan, is diffused and dispersed throughout the whole world.1 That is a diffuse definition quod Philpot, for I am yet as uncertain as I was before what you mean by the church:2 but I knowledge no church, but that which is grounded and founded on Gods word, as S. Paul saith,3 upon the foundation of the Apostles & Prophets, and upon the scriptures of God.
The church, quoth Morgan, is diffused and dispearsed throughout the whole worlde.1 That is a diffuse definition quod Philpot, for I am yet as vncertaine as I was before what you meane by ye church:2 but I knowledge no church, but that which is grounded and founded on Gods woord, as S. Paul sayth,3 vpon the foundation of the Apostles & Prophets, and vpon the scriptures of God.
What quoth Moreman, was the Scripture before the church? yea quoth Philpot. But I will prove nay, quoth Moreman, and I will begin at Christs time. The Church of Christ was before any scripture written. For Matthew was the first that wrote the Gospel, about a dozen years after Christ, Ergo, the church was before the scripture.
What quoth Moreman, was the Scripture before the church? yea quoth Philpot. But I will prooue nay, quoth Moreman, and I wil begin at Christes time. The Church of Christ was before any scripture wrytten. For Mathewe was the first that wrote the Gospell, about a dosen yeares after Christ, Ergo, the church was before the scripture.
To whom Philpot answering, denied this argument. Which when Moreman could not prove, Philpot showed that his argument was Elenchus, or a fallacy, that is, a deceivable argument. For he took the Scripture only to be that, which is written by men in letters, whereas in very deed,1 all Prophecy, uttered by the spirit of God, was counted to be Scripture before it was written in paper & ink, for that it was written in the hearts, and graven in the minds, yea, and inspired in the mouths of good men, and of Christs Apostles by the spirit of Christ: As the salutation of the Angel was the scripture of Christ, and the word of God before it was written. At that Moreman cried, fie, fie, wondering that the Scripture of God should be counted scripture, before it was written, and affirmed that he had no knowledge that said so.
To whom Philpot answering, denied this argument. Which when Moreman could not prooue, Philpot shewed that his argument was Elenchus, or a fallace, that is, a deceiueable argument. For he tooke the Scripture only to be that, whych is wrytten by men in letters, wheras in very deede,1 all Prophecie, vttered by the spirite of God, was counted to be Scripture before it was wrytten in paper & inke, for that it was wrytten in the heartes, and grauen in the mindes, yea, and inspired in the mouthes of good men, and of Christes Apostles by the spirite of Christ: As the salutation of the Angel was the scripture of Christe, and the word of God before it was written. At that Moreman cried, fie, fie, wondring that the Scripture of God shoulde be counted scripture, before it was wrytten, and affirmed that he had no knowledge that said so.
1To whom Philpot answered, that concerning knowledge in this behalf, for the trial of the truth about the questions in controversy, he would wish himself no worse matched then with Moreman.
1To whom Philpot answered, that concerning knowledge in this behalfe, for the triall of the truth about ye questions in controuersie, he woulde wish hymselfe no worse matched then with Moreman.
At the which saying the Prolocutor was grievously offended, saying, that it was arrogantly spoken of him,1 that would compare with such a worshipful learned man as Moreman was, being himself a man unlearned,2 yea a mad man, meter to be sent to Bedlam, then to be among such a sort of learned and grave men as there were, and a man that never would be answered, and one that troubled the whole house: and therefore he did command him that he should come no more into the house, demanding of the house whether they would agree thereupon, or no. To whom a great number answered, yea. Then said Philpot again, that he might think himself happy that was out of that company.
At the which saying the Prolocutor was greuously offended, saying, that it was arrogantly spoken of hym,1 that woulde compare with suche a worshipfull learned man as Moreman was, being himselfe a manne vnlearned,2 yea a madde man, meter to be sent to Bedlem, then to be among such a sorte of learned and graue men as there were, and a man that neuer woulde be answeared, and one that troubled the whole house: and therefore he did commaund him that he shoulde come no more into the house, demaunding of the house whether they would agree thereuppon, or no. To whome a great number aunsweraed, yea. Then sayde Philpot againe, that he might thinke himselfe happye that was out of that companie.
After this, Morgan rose up, and rounded the Prolocutor in the ear.1 And then again the Prolocutor spake to Philpot and said, least you should slander the house, & say that we will not suffer you to declare your mind, we are content you shall come into the house as you have done before, so that you be apparelled with a long gown & a tippet as we be, and that you shall not speak, but when I command you. Then quoth Philpot, I had rather be absent altogether.
After this, Morgan rose vp, and rounded the Prolocutor in the eare.1 And then againe the Prolocutor spake to Philpot and said, least you should slaunder the house, & say that we will not suffer you to declare youre minde, we are content you shal come into the house as you haue done before, so that you be apparelled wyth a long gowne & a tippette as we be, and that you shall not speake, but when I commaund you. Then quoth Philpot, I had rather be absent altogether.
Thus they reasoning to and fro, at length about the 13. of December, Q. Mary, to take up the matter, sendeth her commandment to Boner Bishop of London, that he should dissolve and break up the convocation.1 The copy of which commandment here followeth.
Thus they reasoning to and fro, at length about the 13. of December, Q. Mary, to take vp the matter, sendeth her commaundement to Boner Byshoppe of London, that he should dissolue and breake vp the conuocation.1 The copie of which commaundement here followeth.