pp. 1430–143118 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
ON Monday D. Weston,1 withal the residue of the Visitors, Censors, and Opponents: repairing to the Divinity school, each one installed themselves in their places. D. Cranmer with a route of rusty bills was brought thither, and set in the answers place, with the Major & Aldermen sitting by him. Where D. Weston Prolocutor, apparelled in a scarlet gown (after the custom of the University) began the disputation, with this Oration. His words in latin as he spake them were these.
ON Monday D. Weston,1 withall the residue of the Uisitours, Censors, and Opponētes: repayring to ye Diuinity schole, eche one enstalled themselues in theyr places. D. Cranmer with a route of rusty bils was brought thyther, and set in the aunsweres place, with the Maior & Aldermen sitting by him. Where D. Weston Prolocutor, apparelled in a skarlet gowne (after the custome of the Uniuersity) began the disputatiō, with this Oratiō. His wordes in latin as he spake them were these.
Conuenistis hodie fratres profligaturi detestandam illam haeresin de veritate corporis Christi in Sacramento. &c. that is:1 Ye are assembled hither (brethren) this day, to confound the detestable heresy of the verity of the body of Christ in the sacrament. &c. At which words thus pronounced of the Prolocutor unawares, divers of the learned men there present, considering and well weighing the words by him uttered, burst out into a great laughter as though even in the entrance of the disputations, he had bewrayed himself and his Religion, that termed the opinion of the verity of christs body in the Sacrament a detestable heresy. The rest of his Oration tended all to this effect, that it was not lawful by Gods word to call these questions into controversy: for such as doubted of the words of Christ, might well be thought to doubt both of the trueth and power of God. Whereunto Doctor Cranmer desiring licence, answered in this wise.
Conuenistis hodie fratres profligaturi detestandam illam haeresin de veritate corporis Christi in Sacramento. &c. that is:1 Ye are assembled hither (brethrē) this day, to confound the detestable heresy of the verity of the body of Christ in the sacrament. &c. At which wordes thus pronounced of ye Prolocutor vnwares, diuers of the learned men there present, considering and well weying the wordes by him vttered, burst out into a great laughter as though euen in the entraunce of the disputations, he had bewrayed himselfe and his Religion, that termed the opinion of the verity of christes body in the Sacrament a detestable heresye. The rest of his Oration tended all to this effect, that it was not lawfull by Gods word to call these questions into cōtrouersy: for such as doubted of the wordes of Christ, myghte well be thought to doubte both of the trueth and power of God. Whereunto Doctor Cranmer desiring licence, aunswered in this wise.
We are assembled (saith he) to discuss these doubtful controversies,1 and to lay them open before the eyes of the world: whereof ye think it unlawful to dispute. It is in deed no reason (saith he) that we should dispute of that which is determined upon, before the trueth be tried. But if these questions be not called in controversy, surely mine answer then is looked for in vain. This was the sum and effect of his answer: and this done, he prepared himself to disputations.
We are assembled (sayth he) to discusse these doubtfull controuersies,1 and to lay them open before the eyes of the world: whereof ye thinke it vnlawfull to dispute. It is in deed no reason (saith he) that we should dispute of yt which is determined vpon, before the trueth be tryed. But if these questions be not called in controuersy, surely mine answer then is looked for in vayne. This was the summe and effect of his answere: and this done, he prepared himselfe to disputations.
Reverend M. Doctor, these 3. conclusions are put forth unto us at this present to dispute upon.
Reuerend M. Doctor, these 3. conclusions are put forth vnto vs at this present to dispute vpon.
1 In the Sacrament of the altar is the natural body of Christ, 1conceived of the Virgin Mary, and also his blood present really under the forms of bread & wine, by virtue of Gods word pronounced by the priest.
1 In the Sacrament of the aultar is the naturall body of Christe, 1conceiued of the Virgine Mary, and also his bloud present really vnder the formes of bread & wine, by vertue of Gods word pronounced by the priest.
2 There remaineth no substance of bread and wine after the consecration, nor any other substance, but the substance of God and man.
2 There remayneth no substaunce of breade and wyne after the consecration, nor any other substaunc, but the substaunce of God and man.
3 The lively sacrifice of the Church is in the Mass, propitiatory as well for the quick as the dead.
3 The liuely sacrifice of the Church is in the Masse, propitiatory as well for the quicke as the dead.
These be the conclusions propounded, whereupon this our present controversy doth rest. Now to the end we might not doubt how you take the same, you have already given up unto us your opinion thereof. I term it your opinion, in that it disagreeth from the catholic. Wherefore thus I argue.
These be the conclusions propounded, wherupon this our present controuersye doth rest. Nowe to the ende wee might not doubt how you take the same, you haue already geuen vp vnto vs your opinion therof. I terme it your opinion, in that it disagreeth from the catholicke. Wherefore thus I argue.
Cranmer. I deny the antecedent.
Ched. Christ when he instituted his last supper, spake to his Disciples: Take, eat, this is my body, which shall be given for you. But his true body was given for us: Ergo, his true body is in the sacrament. ☞The right form of this Argument is thus to be framed. Da- The same which was given for us, is in the sacrament.1 ri- But his true body was given for us: j. Ergo, his true body is in the sacrament.
Ched. Christ when he instituted his last supper, spake to his Disciples: Take, eate, this is my body, which shall be geuen for you. But his true body was geuen for vs: Ergo, his true body is in the sacrament. ☞The right forme of this Argument is thus to be framed. Da- The same which was geuē for vs, is in ye sacrament.1 ri- But his true body was geuen for vs: j. Ergo, his true body is in the sacrament.
Cran. His true body is truly present to them that truly receive him: but spiritually.1 And so is it taken after a spiritual sort. For when he said: This is my body, it is all one as if he had said, this is the breaking of my body, this is the shedding of my blood. As oft as you shall do this, it shall put you in remembrance of the breaking of my body, and the shedding of my blood: that as truly as you receive this sacrament, so truly shall you receive the benefit promised by receiving the same worthily.
Cran. His true body is truely present to them that truelye receiue him: but spiritually.1 And so is it taken after a spirituall sort. For when he sayd: This is my body, it is all one as if he had sayde, this is the breaking of my body, this is the sheding of my bloud. As oft as you shal do this, it shal put you in remembraunce of the breaking of my body, and the sheding of my bloud: that as truely as you receiue this sacrament, so truly shal you receiue the benefite promised by receiuing the same worthely.
Ched. Your opinion differeth from the church, which saith that the true body is in the sacrament.1 Ergo your opinion therein is false.
Ched. Your opinion differeth from the church, which saith that the true body is in the sacrament.1 Ergo your opinion therin is false.
Ched. Christ, when he spake these words: This is my body, spake of the substance, but not of the effect.
Ched. Christ, when he spake these woordes: This is my body, spake of the substaunce, but not of the effect.
Cran. I grant he spake of the substance, and not of the effect after a sort: and yet it is most true that the body of Christ is effectually in the sacrament. But I deny that he is there truly present in bread,1 or that under the bread in his organical body. And because it should be to tedious (he said) to make discourse of the whole, he delivered up there his opinion thereof to D. Weston written at large, with answers to every one of their 3. propositions: which he desired D. Weston,2 sitting there on high, to read openly to the people: which he promised to do. But it was not the first promise that such Papists have broken. The copy of this writing although it were not there read, yet the contents thereof here we have drawn out as followeth.
Cran. I graunt he spake of the substaunce, and not of the effect after a sorte: and yet it is most true that the bodye of Christ is effectually in the sacrament. But I denye that he is there truly presēt in bread,1 or that vnder the bread in his organicall body. And because it should be to tedious (hee sayd) to make discourse of the whole, he deliuered vp there his opinion therof to D. Weston writtē at large, with answeres to euery one of theyr 3. propositions: which he disired D. Weston,2 sitting there on high, to read openly to the people: which he promised to doe. But it was not the first promise that such Papistes haue broken. The copye of this writing although it were not there read, yet the contentes therof here we haue drawne out as foloweth.