pp. 1431–1441310 passagespart 6 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
West. But your own book printed by Wolfe your own Printer, hath vero.
West. But your owne booke printed by Wolfe your owne Printer, hath vero.
Cran. That Book is taken from me, which easily might ⟨p. 1438⟩have ended this controversy. I am sure the book of Decrees hath vero.
Cran. That Booke is taken from me, which easily myght ⟨p. 1438⟩haue ended this controuersie. I am sure the booke of Decrees hath vero.
Cran. Touching the sense of the matter, there is little difference. The change of one letter for an other, is but a small matter.
Cran. Touching the sence of the matter, there is little difference. The chaunge of one letter for an other, is but a small matter.
West. No•s? Pastor (as you know) signifieth a Bishop, and Pistor signifieth a Baker, But Pastor shall be Pistor, a Bishop shall be a Baker by this your change of one letter. If verè and vero do nothing change the sense.
West. No•s? Pastor (as you know) signifieth a Byshop, and Pistor signifieth a Baker, But Pastor shalbe Pistor, a Bishop shall be a Baker by this your chaunge of one letter. If verè and vero doe nothing chaunge the sence.
Cran. Let it be so that in Pistor and Pastor one letter maketh some difference: Yet let Pistor be either a Baker or maker of bread, ye see here the change of a letter, and yet no great difference to be in the sense.
Cran. Let it be so that in Pistor and Pastor one letter maketh some difference: Yet let Pistor be either a Baker or maker of bread, ye see here the change of a letter, and yet no great difference to be in the sence.
Young. This disputation is taken in hand, that the truth might appear. I perceive that I must go an other way to work then I had thought.1 It is a common saying: against him that denieth principles, we must not dispute. Therefore that we may agree of the principles, I demand whether there be any other body of Christ then his instrumental body.
Young. This disputation is taken in hand, that the truth myght appeare. I perceiue that I must goe an other waye to worke then I had thought.1 It is a common saying: againste hym that denyeth principles, we must not dispute. Therfore that we may agree of the principles, I demaund whether there be any other body of Christ then his instrumentall body.
Cran. There is no natural body of Christ, but his organical body.
Cran. There is no naturall body of Christe, but his organicall body.
Young. Again I demand whether sense & reason ought to give place to faith.
Young. Againe I demande whether sence & reason ought to geue place to faith.
Cran. They ought.
Yong. Thirdly, whether Christ be true, in all his words?
Yong. Thirdly, whether Christ be true, in all his wordes?
Cran. Yea, he is most true, and trueth it self.
Cran. Yea, he is most true, and trueth it selfe.
Yong. Fourthly, whether Christ at his supper minded to do that which he spake or no?
Yong. Fourthly, whether Christ at his supper mineded to doe that which he spake or no?
Cran. Dicendo dixit, non fecit dicendo: sed fecit Discipulis Sacramentum. That is: In saying he spake, but in saying he made not, but made the sacrament to his disciples.
Cran. Dicendo dixit, non fecit dicendo: sed fecit Discipulis Sacramentum. That is: In saying he spake, but in sayinge hee made not, but made the sacrament to his disciples.
Yong. Answer according to the truth: whether did Christ that as God and man,1 which he spake, when he said: This is my body.
Yong. Answer according to the truthe: whether did Christ that as God and man,1 whych he spake, when he sayde: This is my body.
Cran. This is a sophistical cavillation: go plainly to work. There is some deceit in these questions. You seek subtleness, leave your crafty fetches.
Cran. This is a sophistical cauillation: go plainly to work. There is some deceite in these questions. You seeke subtlenesse, leaue your craftie fetches.
Young. I demand whether Christ by these words wrought any thing or no?
Young. I demaunde whether Christe by these woordes wrought any thing or no?
Cran. He did institute the Sacrament.
Yong. But answer, whether did he work any thing?
Yong. But answere, whether did he worke any thing?
Cran. He did work in instituting the Sacrament.
Cran. He did worke in instituting the Sacrament.
Yong. Now I have you: for before you said it was a figurative speech. 1But a figure worketh nothing. Ergo, it is not a figurative speech. A liar ought to have a good memory.
Yong. Now I haue you: for before you said it was a figuratiue speache. 1But a figure worketh nothing. Ergo, it is not a figuratiue speach. A lyar ought to haue a good memorie.
Cran. I understood your Sophistry before. You by working understand converting into the body of Christ: but Christ wrought the Sacrament, not in converting, but in instituting.
Cran. I vnderstoode your Sophistrie before. You by working vnderstande conuerting into the body of Christe: but Christ wrought the Sacrament, not in conuerting, but in instituting.
Young. Woe be to them that make Christ a deceiver. Did he work any other thing then he spake, or the self same thing?
Young. Woe be to them that make Christ a deceiuer. Did hee worke any other thyng then hee spake, or the selfe same thing?
Cran. He wrought the sacrament, and by these words he signified the effect.
Cran. He wrought the sacrament, and by these wordes he signified the effect.
Fes- Yong. A figurative speech is no working thing. ti- But the speech of Christ is working: no. Ergo, it is not figurative.
Fes- Yong. A figuratiue speach is no working thing. ti- But the speach of Christ is working: no. Ergo, it is not figuratiue.
Cran. It worketh by instituting, not by converting.
Cran. It worketh by instituting, not by conuerting.
Young. The thing signified in the sacrament, is it not in that Sacrament?
Young. The thing signified in the sacramēt, is it not in that Sacrament?
Cran. 1It is. For the thing is ministered in a sign. He followeth the letter that taketh the thing for the sign. Augustine separateth the Sacrament from the thing. The Sacrament (sayeth he) is one, and the thing of the Sacrament an other.
Cran. 1It is. For the thing is ministred in a signe. He followeth the letter that taketh the thing for the signe. Augustine separateth the Sacrament from the thing. The Sacrament (sayeth he) is one, and the thing of the Sacrament an other.
Weston. Stick to this Argument. It is a figurative speech. Ergo, it worketh nothing.
Weston. Sticke to thys Argument. It is a figuratiue speach. Ergo, it worketh nothing.
Young. But the speech of Christ is a working thing. Ergo, it is not figurative.
Young. But the speach of Christ is a working thing. Ergo, it is not figuratiue.
Cran. O how many crafts are in this Argument? they are mere fallacies: I said not that the words of Christ do work, but Christ himself: and he worketh by a figurative speech.
Cran. O howe many craftes are in this Argument? they are meere fallacies: I sayd not that the words of Christ do worke, but Christ himselfe: and he worketh by a figuratiue speache.
Weston. If a figure work, it maketh of bread the body of Christ.
Weston. If a figure worke, it maketh of bread the bodye of Christ.
Cran. A figurative speech worketh not.
Cran. A figuratiue speach worketh not.
West. A figurative speech by your own confession, worketh nothing. But the speech of Christ in the supper (as you grant) wrought somewhat:
West. A figuratiue speach by your owne cōfession, worketh nothing. But the speach of Christ in the supper (as you graunt) wrought somewhat:
Ergo. The speech of Christ in the Supper was not figurative.
Ergo. The speach of Christe in the Supper was not figuratiue.
Cran. I answer these are mere sophisms:1 the speech doth not work, but Christ by the speech doth work the sacrament. I look for Scriptures at your hands: for they are the foundation of disputations.
Cran. I answer these are meere sophismes:1 the speach doth not worke, but Christ by the speache doth worke the sacrament. I looke for Scriptures at your handes: for they are the foundation of disputations.
Young. Are not these words of scripture: This is my body, The word of Christ is of strength: and by the Lords words the heavens were made. He said: This is my body. Ergo, he made it.
Young. Are not these wordes of scripture: This is my body, The word of Christ is of strength: and by the Lordes wordes the heauens were made. He sayd: This is my body. Ergo, he made it.
Cranmer. He made the Sacrament: and I deny your Argument.
Young. If he wrought nothing, nothing is left there. He said: This is my body. You say contrary to the Scriptures, it is not the body of Christ, and fall from the faith.
Young. If he wrought nothing, nothing is left there. Hee sayde: This is my body. You say contrary to the Scriptures, it is not the body of Christ, and fall from the faith.
Cran. You interpret the scriptures contrary to all the old writers, and feign a strange sense.
Cran. You interprete the scriptures contrary to all the old wryters, and faine a straunge sense.