pp. 18620 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
AS touching the first, we learn that it may be, that some thing may be claimed by the right of war, which may be confirmed both by mans laws, and by the laws of God. But I will begin with mans laws. In the Digestes de captivis et postliminio reversis in the law Postliminium: 1The things that we have lost in war, or in affairs of war, if we afterward recover the same again, we shall possess them by the law Postliminium. For so long as they are not recovered, they are possessed of our enemies. And this right is toward those, which are declared to be enemies. But such were declared to be enemies, against whom the people of Rome publicly proclaimed war, or they which publicly prohibited war against the people of Rome, as it is had in the same title, in the law Hosts. For Pirates or thieves cannot by this means attain to be owners, or possess any thing by the law of war. For war ought to be made, to the end to attain something by the right of war. And in the Digestes de acquirendo rerum dominio, in the law Naturale, paragrapho the last. Such things as are taken from enemies, by the common law of all men, agreeing unto natural reason, are straightway made theirs which take them. And thus the laws of man as touching this thing, are very manifest.
AS touching the first, we learne that it may be, that some thing may be claymed by the right of warre, which maye be confirmed both by mans lawes, and by the lawes of God. But I wyl begyn with mans lawes. In the Digestes de captiuis et postliminio reuersis in the law Postliminium: 1The thinges that we haue lost in war, or in affaires of war, if we afterward recouer the same again, we shal possesse them by the law Postliminium. For so long as they are not recouered, they are possessed of our enemies. And thys ryghte is towarde those, whyche are declared to bee enemyes. But suche were declared to bee enemies, against whom the people of Rome publikelye proclaimed warre, or they which publikely prohibited warre against the people of Rome, as it is had in the same title, in the law Hostes. For Pirates or theues cannot by this meanes attaine to be owners, or possesse any thing by the law of warre. For warre ought to be made, to the ende to attaine something by the right of warre. And in the Digestes de acquirendo rerum dominio, in ye lawe Naturale, paragrapho the last. Such thinges as are taken from enemies, by the common law of all men, agreing vnto naturall reason, are straightwaye made theirs which take them. And thus the lawes of man as touching this thing, are very manifest.
So is it also by the laws of God. Abraham, as it manifestly appeareth in the book of Genesis the .14. chap. made war against the .v. kings, which had led away Lot prisoner. The battle being finished, their pray came into the hands and power of Abraham: which may easily be proved, because of that pray he gave tithes unto Melchizedek. But it had not been lawful for him to have given tithes of an other mans goods: therefore they were his own, of which he gave. Wherefore we must believe that that pray was truly in his possession. For in that he gave it to the king of Sodom, it was of his mere liberality: for he was not thereunto compelled by the law. I could make mention, what things Joshua, Othoniel, David, Solomon, and many other mo possessed by the right of war. For when those Princes had the victory,1 the things taken from their enemies, came into their possession. But it is not sufficient to make war, to claim something by the right thereof, but the war also must be just. Because unless it be just, it is not war, but robbery.
So is it also by the lawes of God. Abraham, as it manifestlye appeareth in the booke of Genesis the .14. chap. made warre against the .v. kinges, whiche had led away Lot prisoner. The battaile being finished, theyr praye came into the handes and power of Abraham: which maye easelye bee proued, bicause of that pray he gaue tithes vnto Melchisedech. But it had not bene lawfull for him to haue geuen tithes of an other mans goods: therfore they wer his own, of which he gaue. Wherfore we must beleue that that pray was truelye in his possession. For in that he gaue it to the king of Sodom, it was of his mere liberality: for he was not therunto compelled by the law. I coulde make mencion, what thinges Iosua, Othoniel, Dauid, Salomon, and manye other mo possessed by the ryght of warre. For when those Princes had the victory,1 the thinges taken from their enemies, came into their possession. But it is not sufficient to make warre, to clayme something by the right therof, but the warre also must be iust. Bycause vnles it be iust, it is not warre, but robbery.
But how shall we know when war is just or unjust?1 Augustine (as he is alleged in the .23. Question .2. chap. Notandum) writeth that his war between Sihon and the Israelites was just. For they desired to pass without hurt, through his kingdom, which thing by humane fellowship should not have been denied them, especial seeing they had faithfully promised, not to be troublesome to any man. This sentence of Augustine, the Glosser goeth about to defend, and that by civill laws. In the Digestes de aqua pluvia cohercenda, in the law in summa, in the Paragraph item varus, something is permitted in an other mans ground, so that it be done without the hurt of the possessor. And in the Code D• Seruitutibus, in the law per agrum, Maximianus and Diocletianus do thus ordain: That no man can prohibit thee to use the common high way. And that thing only did the Israelites desire: wherefore being repulsed, they justly took war in hand. So much saith the Glosser,2 whose reason doth not so fully satisfy me. For that which Augustine speaketh of private men, may easily be admitted, and these things which are brought out of the civill law, do seem also to ⟨image 193⟩be written concerning private men. But if a man will lead an host through an other mans country, and if they faithfully promise, not to be troublesome, yet, whether a way ought straightway to be granted him, or whether he ought to be believed, it is not certain. They promise (thou wilt say) that their host shall do no harm, but if they stand not to their promises, then shall the land be in their power. Undoubtedly Julius Cesar would not permit the Helvetians to pass through his Province, although they promised, that they would pass without doing injury or hurt.3 But I say that the war which the Israelites made against Sihon, was just, but not therefore because he denied them leave to pass through his country, but because he came out of his borders with his host, and willingly offered wrong unto the Israelites. For every man ought to defend both himself and his against violence. That which Augustine bringeth, hath some show, yet his reason is not firm. For how could Sihon know certainly, whither the Israelites would do him no hurt, especially they being so many in number? For there were six hundred, three score & six thousand armed soldiers, & well appointed to the battle.
He might peradventure have permitted them to have passed. and that safely, although not all of them together, but by bands. But seeing the first reason before alleged is sufficient, we must not much labour for Augustine's sake.
He might peraduenture haue permitted them to haue passed. and that safely, although not al of them together, but by bandes. But seing the first reason before alledged is sufficient, wee must not muche labour for Augustines sake.
1But now I will generally declare, what manner of war is counted just. Such a war is counted just, which is taken in hand at the commandment of the Magistrate, either to demand things again, or else to put away injuries, or to revenge them, as it is had in the .23. question, the .2. chap. justum, and they are the words of Isidorus. 2For first we must beware that war be not taken in hand by the authority of a private man. But the causes wherefore war may justly be made, are these, to require things taken away, or else to repulse injury. Whereunto is agreeable that which Augustine writeth in the same place in the chapter Dominus: 3Just war is that which is taken in hand to revenge injuries. After this manner war is justly proclaimed against Cities, when they will not either render things taken away, or amend those things which of theirs was unjustly done. For if they will not punish the guilty, it is lawful for other to make war against them. So all Israel took war in hand against Benjamin, that a most filthy wicked crime should not remain unpunished. But Augustine addeth, that those wars also do in especial seem just, which are taken in hand by the commandment of God, as are many which were done in the old Testament. For if God command once to make war, we must not seek for any other cause of justice. For God knoweth very well what is to be rendered unto every man. For then both captain and soldiers are not so much to be counted authors of the war, as ministers of God & of his law. And therefore when the people are after this manner called to war, they ought not to neglect the commandment.4 Wherefore the same Augustine in his .205. epistle to Bonifacius the Earle, a man of war, which at that time governed Africa under Cesar: Thou oughtest not (saith he) to think, that they which with weapons serve the public wealth, can not please God. This was the proposition, whereof afterward he bringeth reasons. For David saith he, made many wars, and yet was he dearly beloved of God.
1But now I wil generally declare, what maner of war is counted iust. Such a war is counted iust, whiche is taken in hande at the commaundement of the Magistrate, either to demaund things againe, or els to put away iniuries, or to reuenge them, as it is had in the .23. question, the .2. chap. iustum, and they ar the woordes of Isidorus.
And undoubtedly I could bring forth very many examples out of the old testament. But the Anabaptists cry, that the old Testament pertaineth nothing unto us. I will therefore make mention of those things which Augustine allegeth out of the new Testament. The Centurion came unto Christ, and desired him to heal his servant which was sick: but Christ said he would come to his house. The Centurion said: I am not worthy that thou shouldest come under my roof: but only say the word, & my servant shall be healed. And other words which are red in the .8. chapter of Matthew. At the last Christ answered, that he found not so much faith in Israel, no not in those which seemed most holy. ⟨p. 187⟩And the same man was a Centurion, and had soldiers under him: unto whom for all that Christ ascribeth a very good and most excellent faith. In the Acts also of the Apostles, the .x. chapter, it is written that Cornelius so lived in warfare, that the Angel testified of him, that his prayers were heard of God. Yea & God also so regarded him, that at Peters hand he heard the Gospel, was baptised, and received the holy ghost. And the Soldiers when they came unto John, to be baptised of him, as it is in the third chapter of Luke, asked what they should do. John answered, ye shall do violence unto no man: be ye content with your wages. Neither called he them back from warfare, but rather confirmed them, when he commanded them to be content with their wages. The same Augustine against Faustus in his .xxii. book, and .lxxiiii. chapter saith: The Lord was tempted of the Herodians, whither it were lawful to give tribute unto Cesar, and he answered: Give unto Cesar that which is Caesars, and the things that are of God, to God. By which words he would signify nothing else, but that tributes are to be given unto Princes. And tributes are given, that Princes should use the sword, defend the right of the public wealth, and make war, when need shall require. Which thing if it had not been lawful, the Lord would never have commanded them to pay tributes unto them.
And vndoubtedly I could bring forth very many examples out of the old testament. But the Anabaptistes cry, that the old Testament pertaineth nothing vnto vs. I wil therfore make mencion of those thinges whych Augustine alledgeth out of the new Testament. The Centurion came vnto Christ, and desired him to heale his seruant which was sicke: but Christ said he would come to hys house. The Cēturion said: I am not worthy that thou shouldest come vnder my roofe: but onely say the woord, & my seruant shalbe healed. And other woordes which are red in the .8. chapter of Mathew. At the last Christ answered, that he founde not so muche faith in Israel, no not in those whiche seemed most holye.
But to return to the Epistle of Augustine. In making of just war, saith he,1 many things are to be taken heed of. For it is not sufficient that the war be just, except also the war be justly handled. Wherefore he admonisheth his Earle: when, saith he, thou puttest on thine armour, remember that thy strength is the gift of God, and determine with thy self not to abuse that gift against God. Yea rather do this, fight for his laws and name, let promises be kept even with enemies, but much more with friends, for whom thou makest war. By which words he reprehendeth those Soldiers, which are more grievous in Cities, then the very enemies, of which we see in our days a great many mo then we would, which when they are in their places where they winter, it is wonderful to see how they handle the Citizens, and the men of the country: it is horrible to see what filthy and abominable things they commit. He addeth also the third caution. Think with thy self that war must not be made but for necessity. Wherefore let the mind always be inclined unto peace. Make war, because thou canst not otherwise do: but if thou canst make peace, refuse it not.
But to returne to the Epistle of Augustine. In making of iust war, saith he,1 many thinges are to be taken heede of. For it is not sufficient that the warre be iust, except also the warre be iustly handled. Wherefore he admonisheth hys Earle: when, saythe hee, thou puttest on thyne armour, remember that thy strength is the gyft of God, and determine wyth thy selfe not to abuse that gift against God. Yea rather doo thys, fyght for hys lawes and name, let promises be kept euen with enemies, but muche more with friendes, for whom thou makest warre. By which woordes hee reprehendeth those Soldiours, whiche are more grieuous in Cities, then the very enemies, of which we see in our dayes a great many mo then we would, which when they are in their places where they wynter, it is wonderfull to see how they handle the Citezens, and the men of the country: it is horrible to see what filthy and abhominable things they commit. He addeth also the thirde caution. Thinke with thy selfe that warre must not be made but for necessity. Wherefore let the minde alwaies be enclined vnto peace. Make warre, bicause thou canst not otherwyse doo: but if thou canst make peace, refuse it not.
War is taken in hand only to amend things amiss. Yea, and the Apostles afflicted certain, that they might become the better. Paul said unto the Corinthians, deliver such a one to Satan to the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved. And to Timothy he saith of Hymeneus & Alexander, I have delivered them to Satan, to learn not to curse. So ought they also to restrain Princes, that they may be made better. Augustine also in his .xix.1 book De civitate dei, sayth, that wars though they be never so just, yet unto godly men, they seem both troublesome and grievous: for besides other things which the nature of man escheweth, they shall see the iniquity of their adversaries side, for which they are compelled to fight: and they cannot but be sorry for it. And in the Epistle before alleged: Rage not, saith he, nor wax not insolent against those that submit them selves, but show mercy to those that are overcome. Wherefore Virgil saith: Spare them that submit them selves,2 and destroy the proud.
Warre is taken in hand onely to amende thinges amysse. Yea, and the Apostles afflicted certaine, that they might become the better. Paul sayd vnto the Corrinthians, deliuer suche a one to Sathan to the destruction of the fleshe, that the spirite may be saued. And to Timothe he sayth of Hymeneus & Alexander, I haue delyuered them to Sathan, to learne not to cursse. So oughte they also to restrayne Princes, that they maye bee made better. Augustine also in his .xix.1 booke De ciuitate dei, sayth, that warres though they bee neuer so iust, yet vnto godly men, they seeme both troublesome and grieuous: for besydes other things which the nature of man escheweth, they shall see the iniquity of their aduersaries syde, for which they are compelled to fyght: and they cannot but be sorye for it. And in the Epistle before alledged: Rage not, saythe hee, nor waxe not insolent agaynst those that submyt them selues, but shewe mercye to those that are ouercome. Wherefore Virgil sayth: Spare them that submit them selues,2 and destroye the proude.
Moreover he admonisheth the same Earle, to beware of vices, which are wont to follow hosts, namely of filthy lust, of ravenous pilling, and of drunkenness. For it is a thing most vile for thee therefore to make war, to amend the vices of others, when as thou in the mean time art a great deal more vicious, and much more art overcome both with affections ⟨image 194⟩and diseases, then they are which are overcome.
Moreouer he admonisheth the same Earle, to beware of vyces, whyche are wont to followe hostes, namelye of fylthye luste, of rauenous pyllynge, and of dronkennesse. For it is a thyng moste vyle for thee therefore to make warre, to amende the vices of others, when as thou in the meane tyme art a great deale more vicious, and muche more art ouercome bothe wyth affections ⟨image 194⟩and diseases, then they are whyche are ouercome.
For in war we reprove not the end, but the desire to hurt, the cruelty of avengement, the outrageousness of rebelling, and the lust of bearing dominion. These things saith he, are condemned. For they, which forsaking such vices do make just war, are the Ministers of God and of the laws. The same father against Faustus Manicheus: This order saith he, is to be kept, that the war be proclaimed, either of God, or of Princes, to break the pride of man, and to came the stubborn.
For in warre we reproue not the ende, but the desire to hurt, the crueltye of auengement, the outragiousnesse of rebelling, and the lust of bearing dominion. These thinges saith he, are condemned. For they, which forsaking suche vices doo make iust warre, are the Ministers of God and of the lawes. The same father against Faustus Manicheus: This order saith he, is to bee kept, that the war be proclaimed, either of God, or of Princes, to breake the pryde of man, and to came the stubburne.
Farther, the Soldiers ought to be persuaded, that the war is justly made, and not taken in hand against the word of God: otherwise let them not fight. Neither do I to this end speak these things, because I would have Soldiers to understand the secretes of Princes, but that knowing & wittingly they suffer not themselves to fight against true and just causes. Yet it may be (saith Augustine) that the Prince may make war against his conscience, and yet his Soldiers nothing offend, so long as they obey the ordinary power. For the people must obey their Prince. And in their so doing, it may be doubtful unto them, whether their Prince make war contrary to the commandment of God. But they are excused, so long as they obey their own Prince in a doubtful cause, their own Prince I say, and not a strange Prince. Wherefore those hired Soldiers can not be excused, which having no respect unto the cause,1 but only for money and rewards sake do serve strange Princes. Wherefore Jephthah thus reasoned, as touching the first point of his Oration, we have taken the land by the right of war: therefore thou unjustly requirest the same of us.
Farther, the Souldiours oughte to bee perswaded, that the warre is iustlye made, and not taken in hande againste the woorde of God: otherwyse let them not fight. Neither doo I to this ende speake these thinges, bicause I woulde haue Soldiours to vnderstand the secretes of Princes, but that knowing & wittingly they suffer not themselues to fight against true and iust causes. Yet it may be (saith Augustine) that the Prince may make warre againste his conscience, and yet his Soldiours nothing offende, so long as they obey the ordinarye power. For the people must obey their Prince. And in their so doyng, it may be doubtfull vnto them, whether their Prince make warre contrarye to the commaundement of God. But they are excused, so long as they obey their owne Prince in a doubtful cause, their own Prince I say, and not a straunge Prince. Wherefore those hired Soldiours can not be excused, which hauing no respecte vnto the cause,1 but onely for mony and rewardes sake do serue straunge Princes. Wherefore Iiphtah thus reasoned, as touching the first point of his Oracion, we haue taken the land by the right of warre: therefore thou vniustly requirest the same of vs.
The next point is, our God hath given it unto us, which is the Lord and distributer of all things humane. He brinketh his argument from the gift of God.1 And that God might give and distribute kingdoms, the very Ethnic authors also saw. And therefore in Virgil Aeneas doth so often boast, that he by the commandment of God went into Italy, and for that cause would not abide either at Carthage, or in Sicily, when he mought have obtained either of those kingdoms.2 Augustine in his .v. book De civitate dei, the .xxviii. chap. Of kingdoms saith he, and Provinces it is certain that God distributeth them, both when, and how much, and to whom he will: and that by secrete judgements, but not unjust. In the book of Genesis, God promised unto Abraham and his posterity, the land of Canaan: but he promised it after four hundred years. Now, saith he, I will not give it, for as yet the since of the Canaanites are not full. I will not cast them out now, but I will tarry till their iniquity be come to the highest: afterward I will bring you in. Also in the second chapter of Deuteronomy, it is written that the Horites dwelled in mount Seir, which were men expert in wars and very valiant, whom God saith he drave out of those mountains, that the Children of Esau might possess the land. And in the same chapter he testifieth that he did cast out the people of Emim, & gave their kingdoms unto the Ammonites, and drave out Zanzumim out of their places, and placed the Moabites there.
The next poynt is, our God hath geuen it vnto vs, whiche is the Lorde and distributer of all thinges humane. He brinketh his argument from the gyfte of God.1 And that God might geue and distribute kingdomes, the verye Ethnike authours also sawe. And therefore in Virgil Eneas doth so often boast, that hee by the commaundement of God went into Italy, and for that cause would not abide either at Carthage, or in Sicilia, when he mought haue obtained either of those kingdomes.2 Augustine in his .v. booke De ciuitate dei, the .xxviii. chap. Of kingdomes sayth he, and Prouinces it is certaine that God distributeth them, both when, and how muche, and to whom hee wyll: and that by secrete iudgementes, but not vniust. In the booke of Genesis, God promised vnto Abraham and his posterity, the land of Chanaan: but hee promised it after foure hundred yeares. Now, saith he, I wyl not geue it, for as yet the synnes of the Chananites are not full. I wyll not cast them out now, but I wyll tary tyll their iniquitye be come to the hyghest: afterward I wyll bring you in. Also in the seconde chapter of Deutronomy, it is written that the Horites dwelled in mount Seir, which were men experte in warres and very valiant, whom God sayth he draue oute of those mountaynes, that the Chyldren of Esau myght possesse the lande. And in the same chapter he testifieth that he dyd cast out the people of Emim, & gaue their kingdomes vnto the Ammonites, and draue out Zanzumim oute of theyr places, and placed the Moabites there.
If thou wilt say, that this was done by God peculiarly against these nations, because the Edomites had their offspring of Esau, the Ammonites and Moabites of Lot, which was kinsman unto Abraham, and had together with him accomplished most dangerous voyages: I answer, the same may be said also in the same place of other nations, which came not of Abraham. The Cappadocians drave out the Hevites which were the first inhabitants, who going out of Cappadocia, 1destroyed them, and in their place inhabited those Regions. And in Deuteronomy the .xxxii. chapter it is written, when God by lot divided the Gentiles, and the people according to the number of the Children of Israel. ⟨p. 188⟩In that it is said to be done by lot, all that is to be referred unto our understanding, which see not the causes of things. But with God nothing is done by lot. God hath distributed the nations according to the number of the children of Israel. For the Israelites were not yet increased, when God put the people in those Regions, who at the last gave place unto the Israelites when they came.
If thou wylt say, that thys was done by God peculiarly agaynste these nacious, bycause the Edomites had their ofspring of Esau, the Ammonites and Moabites of Lot, which was kynsman vnto Abraham, and had together with hym accomplished most daungerous viages: I aunswer, the same may be saide also in the same place of other nacions, which came not of Abrahrm. The Capadocians draue out the Heuites whyche were the first inhabiters, who going out of Capadocia, 1destroyed them, and in their place inhabited those Regions. And in Deuteronomy the .xxxii. chapter it is wrytten, when God by lot deuided the Gentiles, and the people according to the number of the Chyldren of Israell. ⟨p. 188⟩In that it is sayde to be done by lot, al that is to be referred vnto our vnderstandyng, whiche see not the causes of thinges. But wyth God nothing is done by lot. God hath distributed the nacions according to the number of the chyldren of Israel. For the Israelites were not yet increased, when God put the people in those Regions, who at the laste gaue place vnto the Israelites when they came.
Neither ought we to be offended, if by this distribution oftentimes fertile and fat lands happen unto the ungodly. For Augustine in hys .4.1 book De civitate dei, the .xxxiii. chapter, saith: That gifts which dure but for a time, happen both to the just and unjust. For God maketh his sun to shine, both upon the good and the evil, and raineth upon the just and unjust. But by this common benefit the godly have this commodity only, that they understand that these things are not the chiefest gifts which we ought to look for, because these are common both to the good and to the evil. But the godly wait for other more excellent, which are not common to the good and evil. Yea and Daniel saith: The name of the Lord be blessed for ever: for it is he which transferreth kingdoms, and driveth out the first inhabitants, and bringeth in other. Neither doth he only bring men into Provinces, but also setteth Angels to rule over them, as we there read of the Prince of the Persians and Grecians. And he hath not only divided men by lands, but also by tongues and manners. Farther, we must remember that these mutations were not done only at the beginning, but also in the latter times. For the French men possessed Gallia, and the English Saxons Britain. but the Britons heing cast out by them, found new places in Gallia by power and violence, and that part which they obtained, they called Britain of them selves. The men of Gallia also of late, going out of their own borders, possessed a great part of Italy. The Huns subdued unto themselves the Pannonites, and called the Country Hungaria. So God distributeth kingdoms, casteth out some, and bringeth in other some, as it seemeth good unto his just judgement, which is secrete. For the earth is the Lords, and the fullness thereof. This distribution chanced even from the beginning to the sons of Noah, and afterward to those which builded the Tower of Babel: for God dispersed them throughout the whole world.
Neyther ought we to be offended, if by this distribution oftentimes fertil and fat landes happen vnto the vngodly. For Augustine in hys .4.1 booke De ciuitate dei, the .xxxiii. chapter, sayth: That giftes whiche dure but for a tyme, happen both to the iust and vniust. For God maketh his sunne to shyne, both vpon the good and the euyll, and rayneth vpon the iust and vniust. But by this common benefite the godly haue this commoditye onely, that they vnderstande that these thinges are not the chiefest gyftes which wee oughte to looke for, bycause these are common both to the good and to the euyll. But the godlye wayte for other more excellent, which are not common to the good and euyll. Yea and Danyel saith: The name of the Lord be blessed for euer: for it is he whiche transferreth kingdomes, and driueth out the first inhabiters, and bringeth in other. Neither doth he onely bring men into Prouinces, but also setteth Aungels to rule ouer them, as we there reade of the Prince of the Persians and Grecians. And he hath not onely deuided men by landes, but also by tounges and manners. Farther, we must remember that these mutacions were not done onelye at the begynning, but also in the latter times. For the Frenche men possessed Gallia, and the Englishe Saxones Britane. but the Britanes heing cast out by them, found new places in Gallia by power and violence, and that part whiche they obtayned, they called Britane of them selues. The men of Gallia also of late, going out of their own borders, possessed a great part of Italy. The Hunnes subdued vnto themselues the Pannonites, and called the Countrey Hungaria. So God distributeth kyngdomes, casteth out some, and bringeth in other some, as it seemeth good vnto his iust iudgement, which is secrete. For the earth is the Lordes, and the fulnes thereof. This distribution chaunced euen from the beginning to the sonnes of Noe, and afterwarde to those whych builded the Tower of Babel: for God dispersed them throughout the whole world.
Now I will declare by what means God is wont to give kingdoms.1 He giveth them of his own liberality, no right compelling him thereunto. That is the true manner of gift, which otherwise is not a gift, unless it be free. And yet nothing letteth, but that God by the duties and obedience of godly men, may be provoked to give. He giveth in deed often times many things unto godly men, but yet of no duty. For there hath been none at any time so godly, that he could desire any thing of God, as his own by right. For he must do his duty, though God give nothing. And yet is a gift a certain reward, which although it be free, and given without any right compelling thereunto, nevertheless, because it is after a sort bestowed upon duties, it hath a show of a reward. So in Ezekiel God gave a gift unto the king of Babylon. Because (saith he) he laboured in the siege of Tire, I will give unto him the land of Egypt.
Now I wyl declare by what meanes God is wont to geue kyngdomes.1 He geueth them of his owne liberalitye, no right compelling him thereunto. That is the true manner of gifte, which otherwyse is not a gift, vnlesse it be free. And yet nothing letteth, but that God by the dutyes and obedience of godlye men, may be prouoked to geue. He geueth in deede often tymes manye thinges vnto godly men, but yet of no dutye. For there hath bene none at anye tyme so godlye, that he coulde desyre any thing of God, as his owne by right. For hee muste doo hys dutye, though God geue nothing. And yet is a gyft a certayne reward, which although it be free, and geuen wythout any right compelling thereunto, neuerthelesse, bicause it is after a sorte bestowed vpon duties, it hath a shewe of a rewarde. So in Ezechiel God gaue a gift vnto the king of Babilon. Bycause (sayth he) he laboured in the siege of Tire, I wyll geue vnto hym the lande of Egipt.
There are also amongest men recompenses,1 when one office is recompensed with an other office. These also are voluntary, neither can they be demanded by judicial action, and therefore they are counted among gifts. But we have nothing which we can give unto him.2 Wherefore if we attempt to bring any thing unto him, we render unto him his own. And therefore there is no respect of merit to be referred in us toward him. Wherefore God giveth liberally, no law compelling him thereunto.
Ther ar also amongest men recompences,1 when one office is recōpenced with an other office. These also are voluntarye, neyther can they bee demaunded by iudiciall action, and therefore they are counted among giftes. But we haue nothing which we can geue vnto him.2 Wherfore if we attempt to bring any thing vnto him, we render vnto him his owne. And therfore there is no respect of merite to be referred in vs towarde him. Wherefore God geueth liberally, no law compelling hym thereunto.
1But it may be demanded, whether such gifts may be revoked? Why should they not? when as the gifts of men also are sometimes revoked, as it is in the Code De revocatione donacionum. First, if they have conditions annexed to them, which have not been performed. And after that manner undoubtedly God gave the land of Canaan to the Children of Israel, namely that they should worship him, not only in ceremonies, but also in good manners and holiness. But seeing this condition was not performed, God justly revoked his gift, and led them away captive, and gave the land unto the Babylonians, Assyrians, Egyptians, and Romans.
1But it may be demaunded, whether suche giftes maye bee reuoked? Why should they not? when as the giftes of men also are sometimes reuoked, as it is in the Code De reuocatione donacionum. First, if they haue condicions annexed to them, whych haue not bene performed. And after that manner vndoubtedlye God gaue the lande of Chanaan to the Chyldren of Israell, namelye that they shoulde woorshyppe hym, not onely in ceremonies, but also in good manners and holynes. But seing thys condicion was not performed, God iustlye reuoked hys gyfte, and ledde them awaye captiue, and gaue the lande vnto the Babilonians, Assirians, Egiptians, and Romanes.
A great ingratitude also of him that is endued with the gift, debilitateth the gift: for if he be so ingrate, that he will be contumelious and reproachful unto the giver, the gift is then revoked. So God in Ezekiel complaineth: I have clothed thee with vestures and garments of sundry colours: thou haste made those proper unto Idols, and haste given them to Baal. Therefore will I take away my garments from thee,1 and my clothings of sundry colours. &c But thou wilt say, the gifts and vocation of God are without repentance, as it is written to the Romans. I grant that: but the changing is in us, and not in God. For if we shall continue thankful, and stand to the conditions, the gift should be firm and ratified. Farther, Paul in that sentence spake of gifts and calling, which come unto men by the eternal predestination of God, and not of those which are given but only for a time. Wherefore seeing God had not for the causes before rehearsed, cast out the Israelites from the land of Canaan, the gift remained ratified and whole. And Jephthah's argument drawn of it, hath his strength and sure foundation. Moreover it may also seem that God gave that land unto the Israelites in the name of a dowry: for he would after a sort wed unto himself the Church of the Jews,2 and give unto it somewhat for a dowry. And yet gave he not that land unto them, to the injury of the Canaanites. For they were ungodly, and defiled with most grievous wicked acts, as it appeareth in the .xx. chap. of Numbers. Neither could they complain that they were cast out wrongfully: wherefore Jephthah doth very well make his argument from the gift of God.
A great ingratitude also of hym that is endued wyth the gifte, debilitateth the gyft: for if he be so ingrate, that he wyll bee contumelious and reprochefull vnto the geuer, the gift is then reuoked. So God in Ezechiel complayneth: I haue clothed thee with vestures and garmentes of sundrye coulours: thou haste made those proper vnto Idolles, and haste geuen them to Baal. Therefore wyll I take away my garmentes from thee,1 and my clothings of sundry coulours. &c But thou wylt say, the giftes and vocation of God are wythoute repentaunce, as it is wrytten to the Romanes. I graunt that: but the chaunging is in vs, and not in God. For if we shall continue thankefull, and stande to the condicions, the gyft shoulde be firme and ratefied. Farther, Paule in that sentence spake of gyftes and calling, whych come vnto men by the eternal predestination of God, and not of those which are geuen but onely for a time. Wherefore seing God had not for the causes before rehearsed, cast out the Israelites from the lande of Chanaan, the gift remayned ratefied and whole. And Iiphtahs argument drawen of it, hath his strength and sure foundacion. Moreouer it may also seeme that God gaue that lande vnto the Israelites in the name of a dowry: for he woulde after a sorte wedde vnto hymselfe the Churche of the Iewes,
He addeth farther the third argument, derived from prescription: We have now (saith he) possessed this land three hundred years. Therefore thou doest us injury, in requiring it now of us at the last.
He addeth farther the third argument, deriued from prescription: VVe haue now (sayth hee) possessed thys lande three hundred yeares. Therefore thou doest vs iniury, in requiring it now of vs at the last.
But how shal we know when war is iust or vniust?1 Augustine (as he is alledged in th .23. Question .2. chap. Notandum) writeth that his war betwene Sihon and ye Israelites was iust. For they desired to passe wythout hurt, through his kingdome, which thing by humane fellowship should not haue bene denyed them, especiall seing they had faithfully promised, not to be troublesome to any man. This sentence of Augustine, the Gloser goeth about to defende, and that by ciuill lawes. In the Digestes de aqua pluuia cohercenda, in the lawe in summa, in the Paragraphe item varus, somethyng is permitted in an other mans ground, so that it be done without the hurt of the possessor. And in the Code D• Seruitutibus, in the law per agrum, Maximianus and Diocletianus doo thus ordaine: That no man can prohibite thee to vse the common high waye. And that thing onely did the Israelites desire: wherfore being repulsed, they iustly tooke warre in hand. So much sayth the Gloser,2 whose reason doth not so fully satisfy me. For that which Augustine speaketh of priuate men, may easely be admitted, and these thinges which are brought out of the ciuill law, do seeme also to ⟨image 193⟩be written concerning priuate men. But if a man wil leade an host through an other mans country, and if they faithfully promise, not to be troublesome, yet, whether a way ought straightway to be graunted him, or whether he ought to be beleued, it is not certaine. They promise (thou wilt say) that their host shal do no harme, but if they stand not to their promises, then shall the lande be in theyr power. Vndoubtedly Iulius Cesar would not permit the Heluecians to passe thorow his Prouince, although they promised, that they woulde passe without doing iniury or hurt.3 But I say that the warre which the Israelites made against Sihon, was iust, but not therfore bicause he denied them leaue to passe throughe his country, but bicause he came out of his borders with his host, and willinglye offred wrong vnto the Israelites. For euery man ought to defend both himself and his against violence. That which Augustine bringeth, hath some shewe, yet his reason is not firme. For how could Sihon know certainly, whither the Isralites would do him no hurt, especially they being so many in number? For ther were sixe hundred, three score & sixe thousand armed souldiours, & wel appoynted to the battail.