Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 9 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
For instance, the separatists cast off him, whom before they chose for their Officer, supposing now, unless he will renounce his ordination he is no Minister, doth he therefore cease to be a Minister? how busy some Congregational Churches are in with-drawing from their Officers, it is too manifest, and many go to the Anabaptists, some turn Seekers, and-if all the Members do thus, do they now cease to be Ministers?
For instance, the separatists cast off him, whom before they chose for their Officer, supposing now, unlesse he will renounce his ordination he is no Minister, doth he therefore cease to be a Minister? how bufie some Congregationall Churches are in with-drawing from their Officers, it is too manifest, and many goe to the Anabaptists, some turne Seekers, and-if all the Members doe thus, doe they now cease to be Ministers?
2 But if the with-drawing be regular, the cause just, tried, &c. then that which is sufficient ground for their with-drawing from him, is just cause, why he should be excommunicated, being pertinaciously scandalous, or Heretical, as Mr. Hooker ⟨p. 70⟩supposeth. If then the case of a Church be so, as they are cast by providence into some remote place, where are no Churches besides to combine with, then as their election of him, &c. [as I said before] may supply the want of ordination; so this with-drawing in such an extraordinary case may be Analogum to excommunication; but (say our Divines) if that Church be in combination with other Churches, as now under a Classis, then the people shall not need to stay there, in their with-drawing, but the case being judged and tried by the Classis, they as they ordained him, when the people elected him [the people consenting] do excommunicate him; then as a man cast out of one Church, is cast out from the Catholic Church visible; so he who is cast out from being an Officer to this Church, is cast out from being a Minister to the Church-Catholic visible.
2 But if the with-drawing be regular, the cause just, tried, &c. then that which is sufficient ground for their with-drawing from him, is just cause, why he should be excommunicated, being pertinaciously scandalous, or Hereticall, as Mr. Hooker ⟨p. 70⟩supposeth. If then the case of a Church be so, as they are cast by providence into some remote place, where are no Churches besides to combine with, then as their election of him, &c. [as I said before] may supply the want of ordination; so this with-drawing in such an extraordinary case may be Analogum to excommunication; but (say our Divines) if that Church be in combination with other Churches, as now under a Classis, then the people shall not need to stay there, in their with-drawing, but the case being judged and tryed by the Classis, they as they ordained him, when the people elected him [the people consenting] doe excommunicate him; then as a man cast out of one Church, is cast out from the Catholick Church visible; so he who is cast out from being an Officer to this Church, is cast out from being a Minister to the Church-Catholicke visible.
For the other Argument, 1the people conveying of power to an Officer; I know of no power the people conveys, only a designation of such a person to officiate in this or that Society; but their power they receive from Christ immediately (as our Congregational men affirm) and hence they act in his Name, not in the name of the Church.
For the other Argument, 1the people conveying of power to an Officer; I know of no power the people conveyes, only a designation of such a person to officiate in this or that Society; but their power they receive from Christ immediatly (as our Congregationall men affirme) and hence they act in his Name, not in the name of the Church.
- 1Burro. Iren. p. 50 Nort. resp. ad Apoll. p. 76, 78
5 The last answer I would give to this Proposal is this; if you conceive this to be the only way of Reformation, then you must give the Ministers strong proof that you may ordain; the Ministers will as much question your power to ordain, as you question the Bishops power; so that we take it for granted you are able to prove this, because you are so punctual, you say, for reforming by the word. But of this practise I much doubt.
5 The last answer I would give to this Proposall is this; if you conceive this to be the only way of Reformation, then you must give the Ministers strong proofe that you may ordaine; the Ministers will as much question your power to ordaine, as you question the Bishops power; so that we take it for granted you are able to prove this, because you are so punctuall, you say, for reforming by the word. But of this practise I much doubt.
1 My ground is, because I find not one Iota of any such thing in the New Testament.
1 My ground is, because I finde not one Iota of any such thing in the New Testament.
Obj. Though you do not in the New Testament, yet in the Old Testament there is, Numb. 8.10.
Obj. Though you doe not in the New Testament, yet in the Old Testament there is, Numb. 8.10.
A. That place is the only refuge, but
A. That place is the only resuge, but
1 It is commonly answered, That it is no fair arguing to go to the Old Testament for one thing we would have, and when another comes to the same Polity for an argument for their turn, now to debar them, and tell them this is the old Polity; either leave out the Jewish Polity altogether, or else give others leave to fetch Arguments from thence, as well as your selves.
1 It is commonly answered, That it is no faire arguing to goe to the Old Testament for one thing we would have, and when another comes to the same Politie for an argument for their turne, now to debarre them, and tell them this is the old Politie; either leave out the Jewish Politie altogether, or else give others leave to fetch Arguments from thence, as well as your selves.
3 But in that Church at that time there were Officers, Aaron and his sons, thence (if that be a rule) it must follow, that though there be Officers in a Church, yet the people may ordain, which I am sure those Divines, who are for the peoples power in ordination, will never admit, being cross to their own Principles, and Scripture.
3 But in that Church at that time there were Officers, Aaron and his sonnes, thence (if that be a rule) it must follow, that though there be Officers in a Church, yet the people may ordaine, which I am sure those Divines, who are for the peoples power in ordination, will never admit, being crosse to their owne Principles, and Scripture.
4 We find in the eleventh verse, that after that was done, Aaron did wave these Levites before the Lord, so that they were not complete till Aaron had done his Act; whence I remember learned Master Cotton (in his discourse with me) said, the peoples [Greek or Hebrew] there, did but answer to the peoples [Greek or Hebrew] in the New Testament, and Aaron's waving of them did answer to our [Greek or Hebrew]: this clause only I remember, but he had a larger answer, which I took from him in discourse, by which, I remember, he did enervate this Objection, but I lost his notes, with all my other helps, in my shipwreck.
4 We finde in the eleventh verse, that after that was done, Aaron did wave these Levites before the Lord, so that they were not compleat till Aaron had done his Act; whence I remember learned Master Cotton (in his discourse with me) said, the peoples 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 there, did but answer to the peoples 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in the New Testament, and Aarons waving of them did answer to our 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: this clause only I remember, but he had a larger answer, which I tooke from him in discourse, by which, I remember, he did enervate this Objection, but I lost his notes, with all my other helps, in my shipwrack.
These men call for precept and example, give you us one for this in the New Testament, for you put us to that also, we must give you them out of the New Testament; yea, I would go further, and desire them to give me one example in the first six hundred years after Christ, that ever the people did ordain their Minister; now this is strange to me, that we can find no foot-step of any such thing in the Scripture, nor in the Ages next, and yet that we should make it so frequent, that they must ordain most frequently; for if every particular Church be Independent (as now such a Church where I am in a small Village, where the maintenance will not keep one Minister, and therefore to be sure we cannot have more Ministers) then if the Minister remove, or dye, if there come a new Minister, the people must ever ordain, thus it must be in most places in England, few will be excepted; 1and if every new election must have a new ordination, then it must always be in the peoples power; In the Primitive times, there were Churches in Cities, and Villages, but that the Christians in Villages did ordain their Officers, I would gladly see that proved.
These men call for precept and example, give you us one for this in the New Testament, for you put us to that also, we must give you them out of the New Testament; yea, Iwould goe further, and desire them to give me one examplein the first six hundred yeares after Christ, that ever the people did ordaine their Minister; now this is strange to me, that we can finde no foot-step of any such thing in the Scripture, nor in the Ages next, and yet that we should make it so frequent, that they must ordaine most frequently; for if every particular Church be Independent (as now such a Church where I am in a small Village, where the maintenance will not keep one Minister, and therefore to be sure we cannot have more Ministers) then if the Minister remove, or dye, if there come a new Minister, the people must ever ordaine, thus it must be in most places in England, few will be excepted; 1and if every new election must have a new ordination, then it must alwayes be in the peoples power; In the Primitive times, there were Churches in Cities, and Villages, but that the Christians in Villages did ordaine their Officers, I would gladly see that proved.
- 1Justin. Mart. Apol. 2
Ordination in those times was carried by a continued succession, the Apostles ordained some Ministers, those ordained others, ⟨p. 72⟩so downwards, but never by the people.
Learned Dr. 1Ames seems to answer this; for whereas Bellarmine had said, In novo Testamento ubicunque mentio fit manunm impositionis, semper ea Apostolis caeterisque Episcapis, nunquàm vero plebi tribuitur. The Doctor answers to this; In Historiâ novi Testamenti, exempla babemus constitutionis Ministerii, & ejusdem etiam conservationis, sed non restaurationis ejus aut reformationis post generalem Apostasiam; omnia igitur quae pertinent ad plebem fidelem, in tali casu non representantur ibi certis exemplis. However these words seem to carry it, as if the Doctor did hold, that the people had this power, in a general Apostasy, yet I question whether the Doctor would look upon the Churches of England now under such a notion, neither would he deny the ordination of our Ministers, to be valid for substance; but yet here one might cast in something, in times of Reformation it may be, he saith:
Learned Dr. 1Ames seemes to answer this; for whereas Bellarmine had said, In novo Testamento ubicunque mentio fit manunm impositionis, semper ea Apostolis caeterisque Episcapis, nunquàm vero plebi tribuitur. The Doctor answers to this; In Historiâ novi Testamenti, exempla babemus constitutionis Ministerii, & ejusdem etiam conservationis, sed non restaurationis ejus aut reformationis post generalem Apostasiam; omnia igitur quae pertinent ad plebem fidelem, in tali casu non representantur ibi certis exemplis. However these words seeme to carry it, as if the Doctor did hold, that the people had this power, in a generall Apostasie, yet I question whether the Doctor would looke upon the Churches of England now under such a notion, neither would he deny the ordination of our Ministers, to be valid for substance; but yet here one might cast in something, in times of Reformation it may be, he saith:
- 1•ell. ever. to. 2. l. 3. c. 2. s. 6•ell. ener. to. 2. l. 3. c. 2. s. 6
1 To Reform the Minister, is to Form it now as it was first formed.
1 To Reforme the Minister, is to Forme it now as it was first formed.
But the Ministry was not at first formed by the people, ergo the Ministry cannot be now reformed by the people.
I think the Major will not be denied, for the Minor, let any prove that. According to this some will say, We must have Apostles, they formed the Ministers first [we speak of ordination] I say, Non sequitur, unless you can prove the Apostles ordained only quâ Apostles; if so, I know not how those Ministers, whom the Apostles did ordain, could ordain others, but to be sure they did.
I thinke the Major will not be denyed, for the Minor, let any prove that. According to this some will say, We must have Apostles, they formed the Ministers first [we speake of ordination] I say, Non sequitur, unlesse you can prove the Apostles ordained only quâ Apostles; if so, I know not how those Ministers, whom the Apostles did ordaine, could ordaine others, but to be sure they did.
2 I desire a text of Scripture that holds out this, that the people may ordain in a general Apostasy.
2 I defire a text of Scripture that holds out this, that the people may ordaine in a generall Apostasie.
3 I doubt we shall rarely find such times, when there is a Society of godly Christians to ordain, but there is some Ministers also; ordinarily there are Ministers who teach this people.
3 I doubt we shall rarely finde such times, when there is a Society of godly Christians to ordaine, but there is some Ministers also; ordinarily there are Ministers who teach this people.
4 It will be a question, Whether the Apostasy hath been such as to require this, for if Baptism was not repeated, but was thought valid, though administered by a Romish Minister, because he was set apart to the work, and kept the essence of the ordinance, why might not the ordination administered by those Ministers hold as well?
4 It will be a question, Whether the Apostasie hath been such as to require this, for if Baptisme was not repeated, but was thought valid, though administred by a Romish Minister, because he was set apart to the worke, and kept the essence of the ordinance, why might not the ordination administred by those Ministers hold as well?
2 A second ground that makes me doubt is this, it seems strange to me, that Christ should appoint extraordinary officers, ⟨p. 73⟩and make that a part of their work, which the people themselves may do; Paul leaves Titus to ordain, but what needs that? the people might well say, what need Paul leave Titus to do that, which we can do our selves? Frustra fit per plura, &c. the Apostles never needed but to preach, and convert the people to the faith, when they had done so, they should have said, we have now done our work, brought you to be believers, you may now elect an Officer, and ordain him your selves, the power is yours, (only here would have been some trouble about baptizing) since then I find, that this was part of their Office, then I cannot believe this is the peoples work. Paul might easily have left us a president in some Society of Christians, that would have quieted all our disputes.
2 A second ground that makes me doubt is this, it seemes strange to me, that Christ should appoint extraordinary officers, ⟨p. 73⟩and make that a part of their work, which the people themselves may doe; Paul leaves Titus to ordaine, but what needs that? the people might well say, what need Paul leave Titus to do that, which we can doe our selves? Frustra fit per plura, &c. the Apostles never needed but to preach, and convert the people to the faith, when they had done so, they should have said, we have now done our worke, brought you to be beleevers, you may now elect an Officer, and ordaine him your selves, the power is yours, (onely here would have been some trouble about baptizing) since then I finde, that this was part of thier Office, then I cannot beleeve this is the peoples worke. Paul might easily have left us a president in some Society of Christians, that would have quieted all our disputes.
More might be said (and is said by others) but I see our New England Divines do almost yield it, by giving power to some Ministers to ordain in other Congregations.
More might be said (and is said by others) but I see our New England Divines do almost yeeld it, by giving power to some Ministers to ordaine in other Congregations.
Since nothing can be drawn from Scripture, by precept, or example to prove this, hence some would draw it out by Argument.
Those who can do the greater, may do the less.
Those who can do the greater, may doe the lesse.
The people can do the greater, viz. elect.
The people can doe the greater, viz. elect.
Ergo,
The minor is as freely denied, as it is affirmed, election is not the greater, Scripture-light being judge. That was the design I doubt of making Ordination but an Adjunct, for so indeed it would easily be granted, if election gives the essence, and this only be an adjunct, the people may well ordain; Yea, and in a Church, where there are Officers to Ordain, I know not why they, who give the essence may not give the adjunct, why should an adjunct be proper to the Officers only in that Church, when the essence doth not belong to them, 1further then as members, they join with the people? for so it seems the Officers elect as members, and if you do elect only as members, why should you not also ordain as members? for election is the greater, this the less.
The minor is as freely denyed, as it is affirmed, election is not the greater, Scripture-light being judge. That was the designe I doubt of making Ordination but an Adjunct, for so indeed it would easily bee granted, if election gives the essence, and this only be an adjunct, the people may well ordaine; Yea, and in a Church, where there are Officers to Ordaine, I know not why they, who give the essence may not give the adjunct, why should an adjunct be proper to the Officers only in that Church, when the essence doth not belong to them, 1further then as members, they joyne with the people? for so it seemes the Officers elect as members, and if you doe elect only as members, why should you not also ordaine as members? for election is the greater, this the lesse.
- 1Mr. N. W. Omnis quaestio non per aliud quod quaeritur babebit resolutionem nec ambiguitas per ambiguitatem, sed ex elaris manifestis, &c. Irenae l. 2. c. 10.
The other Argument is, the people are the first subject of the power of the keys. Ergo: But this is not easily yielded; it was a witty speech of him, Let the Elders keep the keys, and the people the keyclog; it proves so too often. What our Divines have said about it is well known. I think they have battered this notion pretty well.
The other Argument is, the people are the first subject of the power of the keyes. Ergo: But this is not easily yeelded; it was a witty speech of him, Let the Elders keep the keyes, and the people the keyclog; it proves so too often. What our Divines have said about it is well knowne. I thinke they have battered this notion pretty well.
Augustine sometime is quoted for this opinion, but I am confident it was never in Augustine's thoughts; In Evan. Joan. Tract. 50. Tract. 124. I am mistaken, if he be not rather for the Catholic Church ⟨p. 74⟩by his words especially in the latter place quoted, not mentioning what other Divines have spoken, there are two or three things that have made me doubt of this, so as I never did throughly close with this notion, when I was but a private member of a Church.
Augustine sometime is quoted for this opinion, but I am confident it was never in Augustines thoughts; In Evan. Joan. Tract. 50. Tract. 124. I am mistaken, if he be not rather for the Catholick Church ⟨p. 74⟩by his words especially in the latter place quoted, not mentioning what other Divines have spoken, there are two or three things that have made me doubt of this, so as I never did throughly close with this notion, when I was but a private member of a Church.
1. That which is the primum subjectum, is the proprium subjectum: none doubt of this, Proprium subjectum est quod cum suo accidente reciprocatur. Animal est proprium subjectum sensus, homo risus, hence we say, omnis homo est risibilis, & omne risibile est homo, this is Axioma [Greek or Hebrew]: but every Axiom that is [Greek or Hebrew] doth include in it the rule [Greek or Hebrew], where the predicate is true de omni subjecto, omni loco, omni tempore, this is true of animal & sensus. So it must be true of the power of the keys and the Fraternity, Omni tempore; but if we find the power of the keys exercised before there was a Fraternity, then there was some other subject before the Fraternity; When Paul came to Corinth, he preached Authoritativè, Ergo there was the power of the keys in some subject, but the Fratemity was Non-ens at this time, how then could they be the subject?
1. That which is the primum subjectum, is the proprium subjectum: none doubt of this, Proprium subjectum est quod cum suo accidente reciprocatur. Animal est proprium subjectum sensus, homo risus, hence we say, omnis homo est risibilis, & omne risibile est homo, this is Axioma 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: but every Axiome that is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 doth include in it the rule 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, where the predicate is true de omni subjecto, omni loco, omni tempore, this is true of animal & sensus. So it must be true of the power of the keyes and the Fraternity, Omni tempore; but if we finde the power of the keyes exercised before there was a Fraternity, then there was some other subject before the Fraternity; When Paul came to Corinth, he preached Authoritativè, Ergo there was the power of the keyes in some subject, but the Fratemity was Non-ens at this time, how then could they be the subject?
Those, who are the effect of the power of the keys, are not the first subject, that is clear.
Those, who are the effect of the power of the keyes, are not the first subject, that is clear.
But the Fraternity is the effect; it was so in all the Churches, which the Apostles gathered, and is indeed to this day. This was one Argument troubled me.
So that which is primum, is immediatum subjectum: but how can this be? since Mediantibus Apostolis, and so now Mediantibus Ministris the Fraternity is made: The elector is before the elected: its true of Christ, who elected the Apostles, and gave to them the keys, from whom by a continued succession of Ministers still the Fraternity was made; but had not the power of the keys had some effect, there had not been a Fraternity to choose an Officer: though they are now in time before him, whom they now elect, yet they were not before him or them [quâ fratres] who by the power of the keys in the ministry made them capable to choose an Officer; therefore the power of the keys was in some subject before them.
So that which is primum, is immediatum subjectum: but how can this be? since Mediantibus Apostolis, and so now Mediantibus Ministris the Fraternity is made: The elector is before the elected: its true of Christ, who elected the Apostles, and gave to them the keyes, from whom by a continued succession of Ministers still the Fratemity was made; but had not the power of the keyes had some effect, there had not been a Fraternity to choose an Officer: though they are now in time before him, whom they now elect, yet they were not before him or them [quâ fratres] who by the power of the keyes in the ministry made them capable to choose an Officer; therefore the power of the keyes was in some subject before them.
Besides election is no part of the power of the keys, 1therefore to argue, the people elect, ergo they are the first subject, &c. is fallacia non causae procansâ [causae nomen hic usurpat ur pro quo vis argumento] taking that to be a part of the power which is not.
Besides election is no part of the power of the keyes, 1therefore to argue, the people elect, ergo they are the first subject, &c. is fallacia non causae procansâ [causae nomen hic usurpat ur pro quo vis argumento] taking that to be a part of the power which is not.
- 1Doma: log. p. 461. Keckes. syst: log. l. 2. c. 20.
2 If so, that which is primum, est absolutum subjectum, cui accidens absolutè sint ulla limitation partis inharet: sic animal est ⟨p. 75⟩absolutum subjectum sensus, adeoque visus & auditus; ideoque tantum animal dicitur rectê videre & audire: oculus non videt propriè, quia non est Animal: quando ergo oculus dicitur videre, id non subjectivè intelligendum est, sed instrumentaliter, quod animal videat per oculum. To apply this to our case, the power of the keys is in the whole body, so the power of preaching &c. there is the power subjectivè & propriè; so that if we ask who preached to day, we must answer, properly and subjectively the people preached, but instrumentally only the Pastor preached; so for the administration of the Sacraments, this is very harsh; hence again, because animal videt, if a man dye, or beast, the eye which was the instrument of seeing, excepting it may be the dissipation of the animal spirits, else as an Organ, it remains entire in the coats, humours and optic nerves, but yet it sees not.
2 If so, that which is primum, est absolutum subjectum, cui accidens absolutè sint ulla limitatione partis inharet: sic animal est ⟨p. 75⟩absolutum subjectum sensus, adeoque visus & auditus; ideoque tantum animal dicitur rectê videre & audire: oculus non videt propriè, quia non est Animal: quando ergo oculus dicitur videre, id non subjectivè intelligendum est, sed instrumentaliter, quod animal videat per oculum. To apply this to our case, the power of the keyes is in the whole body, so the power of preaching &c. there is the power subjectivè & propriè; so that if we aske who preached to day, we must answer, properly and subjectively the people preached, but instrumentally only the Pastor preached; so for the administration of the Sacraments, this is very harsh; hence againe, because animal videt, if a man dye, or beast, the eye which was the instrument of seeing, excepting it may be the dissipation of the animal spirits, else as an Organ, it remains intire in the coates, humors and optick nerves, but yet it sees not.
So it seems a Minister, in case his body, the people, should dye, he being but the instrument of their preaching, he can preach no more: this is strange; how do they preach out of their own bodies ordinarily? If the men dye, and only women and children be left, the officer hath lost his preaching, and cannot preach to them authoritatively, because the Fraternity, in whom the power was subjectivè, is dead.
So it seemes a Minister, in case his body, the people, should dye, he being but the instrument of their preaching, he can preach no more: this is strange; how doe they preach out of their own bodies ordinatily? If the men dye, and only women and children be left, the officer hath lost his preaching, and cannot preach to them authoritatively, because the Fraternity, in whom the power was subjectivè, is dead.
3 I have observed, that seven have been esteemed enough to make a Church; suppose now one of these should offend another of the seven, he must deal with him, if he will not hear, he must take two more, here are four of the seven, if he will not hear them, tell the Church, that is, the three left, the rest are parties.
3 I have observed, that seven have been esteemed enough to make a Church; suppose now one of these should offend another of the seven, he must deale with him, if he will not heare, he must take two more, here are four of the seven, if he will not hear them, tell the Church, that is, the three left, the rest are parties.
But this is somewhat doubted, for that in Mat. 18. may well be meant of a particular Church, 1but in this place the Church must be meant of the Catholic visible Church: for it must be such a Church as must not fail.
But this is somewhat doubted, for that in Mat. 18. may well bee meant of a particular Church, 1but in this place the Church must bee meant of the Catholike visible Church: for it must be such a Church as must not faile.
- 1The visible Church is here meant saith Mr. Hoober Sur. p. 278.
But particular Churches may, this or that particular Church I mean.
But particular Churches may, this or that particular Church I meane.