Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 7 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. It is very easy to choose one of these, for v. 21. It was one who had accompanied them from the time, &c. This was easy for the meanest to know, but to choose a man fit for a Pastor, requires more skill then so.
2. It is very easie to choose one of these, for v. 21. It was one who had accompanied them from the time, &c. This was easie for the meanest to know, but to choose a man fit for a Pastor, requires more skill then so.
3. If we observe it narrowly, they did not so properly elect the Apostle, for when they had appointed two, Joseph and Matthias suppose one should have asked Peter, or the rest, which of these is the Apostle? he must have said he could not tell, properly God made the election: then they knew who was the Apostle, like to some Corporations in the choice of a Mayor, the floor nominate two, but the Aldermen choose which they will have, whence the people say, The Aldermen choose the Mayor. 1. Something may here be gathered for popular election, but very different is this practise from ours; I could add other scruples, but I forbear.
3. If we observe it narrowly, they did not so properly elect the Apostle, for when they had appointed two, Joseph and Matthias suppose one should have asked Peter, or the rest, which of these is the Apostle? he must have said he could not tell, properly God made the election: then they knew who was the Apostle, like to some Corporations in the choice of a Mayor, the floore nominate two, but the Aldermen choose which they will have, whence the people say, The Aldermen choose the Mayor. 1. Something may here be gathered for popular election, but very different is this practise from ours; I could adde other scruples, but I forbeare.
2 The second place is Act. 6.3. a very clear place for the popular election of a Deacon, but the last words of the verse do very much shake this notion of Ordination, being but an adjunct, yea, it shakes the essential causality of popular election, Do ye look on, &c. but they add, whom We may appoint over this business. How do the Apostles appoint them over the business? It is by Ordination vers. 16. Those that do authoritatively appoint another, or others over some business, they put forth a causal virtue surely in that appointing; these appointed by this Act of Ordination [the Apostles did not not meddle here with the election] then the Apostles Ordination was more then an Adjunct.
2 The second place is Act. 6.3. a very cleare place for the popular election of a Deacon, but the last words of the verse do very much shake this notion of Ordination, being but an adjunct, yea, it shakes the essentiall causality of popular election, Doe yee looke on, &c. but they adde, whom Wee may appoint over this businesse. How doe the Apostles appoint them over the businesse? It is by Ordination vers. 16. Those that doe authoritatively appoint another, or others over some businesse, they put forth a causall vertue surely in that appointing; these appointed by this Act of Ordination [the Apostles did not not meddle here with the election] then the Apostles Ordination was more then an Adjunct.
From this place Divines argue commonly, If they may choose Deacons, then much more Pastors, to whom they are more engaged, must honour, maintain them, &c.
From this place Divines argue commonly, If they may choose Deacons, then much more Pastors, to whom they are more engaged, must honour, maintaine them, &c.
Thus we argue one while a majori, the people elected an Apostle, ergo, they may elect a Pastor; here now a minori, the people elect a Deacon, ergo, they may elect a Pastor, but then those Axioms one of them must be false, a majori licet [Greek or Hebrew] solummodo, & à minori solùm [Greek or Hebrew], both which experience proves to be false, and Logicians observe it; but put the case we should question this argument; The people may elect a Deacon, ergo, their Pastor; election followeth the judgement, and is guided by it, but must we needs suppose the people to be as able to judge, who is fit for a Pastor, as who is fit for a ⟨p. 53⟩Deacon? Dr. Ames saith, à minori ad majus, si quantitas probabilitatis intelligatur, semper concluditur affirmatè. Is this as probable? 1Sure it is less probable, that the people should be fit to judge of the fitness of a Pastor, then a Deacon. I am confident there are hundreds of Congregations in England, in which there are many real Saints, yet all the Jesuits in Rome might scatter themselves into these Congregations, and not be discerned, if the people were left alone to their own election: 2Hence therefore our Divines dare not trust the people alone with the election of an officer, but tells us they must have the counsel of the Presbyters, as Dr. Ames, and Mr. Cartwright upon Act. 14.23. Rhem. Test. We do not only give unto the Bishops (Scripture Bishops) Ordination, but also we make them the chief, and directors in the election, saith he, where is this practised?
Thus we argue one while a majori, the people elected an Apostle, ergo, they may elect a Pastor; here now a minori, the people elect a Deacon, ergo, they may elect a Pastor, but then those Axioms one of them must bee false, a majori licet 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 solummodo, & à minori solùm 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, both which experience proves to be false, and Logicians observe it; but put the case we should question this argument; The people may elect a Deacon, ergo, their Pastor; election followeth the judgement, and is guided by it, but must we needs suppose the people to be as able to judge, who is fit for a Pastor, as who is fit for a
The third is that of Act. 14.23. [Greek or Hebrew], but certainly if we come to find out the substantives to this participle, they must be the same which were substantives to [Greek or Hebrew], and they were Paul and Barnabas: I know what is said about [Greek or Hebrew] to defend the peoples election, as the custom was taken from the Grecians; Dr. 1Ames saith [Greek or Hebrew] apud veteres idem sepe sonant, so it appears by that passage of Basil quoted by Chamier to prove, that no private person may baptise [Greek or Hebrew], but if it it be taken in that sense here, I do not know how it will pleasure the people, unless we should go cross to the grammatical construction.
The third is that of Act. 14.23. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, but certainly if we come to find out the substantives to this participle, they must be the same which were substantives to 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and they were Paul and Barnabas: I know what is said about 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 to defend the peoples election, as the custome was taken from the Grecians; Dr. 1Ames saith 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 apud veteres idem sepe sonant, so it appears by that passage of Basil quoted by Chamier to prove, that no private person may baptise 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, but if it it be taken in that sense here, I doe not know how it will pleasure the people, unlesse we should goe crosse to the gramaticall construction.
- 1To. 4. l. 5. c. 14. s. 65.
The sum is, 1there are no places brought for the peoples election, but those who are but shallow, will find enough from the Texts to wrangle very hard, though I am for the peoples election my self.
The summe is, 1there are no places brought for the peoples election, but those who are but shallow, will finde enough from the Texts to wrangle very hard, thouh I am for the peoples election my selfe.
- 1Zanchy in 4 praec. Calvin in loc. Piscat. in loc. obs. 2 Malcol. in loc. Diodat. in loc. English Annot. &c expound it of the ordination of Paul & Barnabas
The Texts brought for Ordination are these:
Act. 6.6. When they had prayed, they laid on hands on them.
Act. 13.3. When they had fasted and prayed, and laid on hands, &c. they did not separate Paul and Barnabas by Election, but Ordination.
Heb. 6.2. The laying of bands there, is meant of Ordination, say Pareus, Dickson, Gillespie, Johnson. H. Jacob urges the Text, so that he would overthrow all the Ministry of England, because (he said), they erred in the Foundation, but he mistakes: Mr. Hooker proves Church-discipline to be a fundamental point ⟨p. 54⟩of Religion from this place thus: That which is a fundamental point of Religion, that hath Divine Institution, &c.
Heb. 6.2. The laying of bands there, is meant of Ordination, say Pareus, Dickson, Gillespie, Johnson. H. Jacob urges the Text, so that he would overthrow all the Ministry of England, because (he said), they erred in the Foundation, but he mistakes: Mr. Hooker proves Church-discipline to be a fundamentall point ⟨p. 54⟩of Religion from this place thus: That which is a fundamentall point of Religion, that hath Divine Institution, &c.
Laying on of hands, being by a metonymy of the Adjunct, put for Ordination; Ordination, one particular, put for the whole of Church discipline. So Mr. Hooker.
1 Tim. 4.14. With the laying on of the hands of the Presbytery: I know not that this Text is questioned by our Divines, Mr. Hooker, and our New England Divines from this Text conceive Imposition of hands in Ordination to be nearest the rule, as I have quoted them before.
1 Tim. 5.22. Though some would have it of the admitting of penitents, of which we have no example in Scripture, yet the common interpretation is of imposition of hands in Ordination; this interpretation hath other Scriptures to confirm it, the other none.
1 Tim. 5.22. Though some would have it of the admitting of penitents, of which we have no example in Scripture, yet the common interpretation is of imposition of hands in Ordination; this interpretation hath other Scriptures to confirme it, the other none.
1 Tit. 5. Ordain Elders in every City. I do not find that our Divines oppose this place neither. What Sectaries carp at, I weigh not.
1 Tit. 5. Ordaine Elders in every City. I doe not finde that our Divines oppose this place neither. What Sectaries carp at, I weigh not.
Rom. 110.15. How shall they preach, except they be sent? Mr. Gillespy hath, I think, sufficiently cleared this Text. To be sure, he is not alone in his interpretation. He likewise clears Ordination from that, Heb. 5.4. and first verses.
Rom. 110.15. How shall they preach, except they be sent? Mr. Gillespy hath, I thinke, sufficiently cleared this Text. To be sure, he is not alone in his interpretation. He likewise clears Ordination from that, Heb. 5.4. and first verses.
- 1Miscel. p. 37.
Now since the Scripture is more copious, and plain in giving us examples, and presidents of ordination of Ministers, then of the peoples election of Ministers (though I grant something may well be drawn out of those Texts for election against the Papists, besides the ancient course of the Church) I cannot see any reason (if Scripture be our guide) why we should clothe these Texts for Ordination with this logical affection of an Adjunct, and the other with the affection of a formal cause: I should put most upon that, where the Scripture is plainest and fullest, which I am sure in any mans esteem, that observes those Texts with an impartial eye, is ordination.
Now since the Scripture is more copious, and plaine in giving us examples, and presidents of ordination of Ministers, then of the peoples election of Ministers (though I grant something may well be drawne out of those Texts for election against the Papists, besides the ancient course of the Church) I cannot see any reason (if Scripture be our guide) why we should cloath these Texts for Ordination with this logicall affection of an Adjunct, and the other with the affection of a formall cause: I should put most upon that, where the Scripture is plainest and fullest, which I am sure in any mans esteeme, that observes those Texts with an impartiall eye, is ordination.
Whether Ordination according to Scripture-light be not as essential to a Minister as Election, 1let any one judge. I think Mr. Hudson speaks Christianly, I prefer one Divine Testimony, before ten arguments, and one good argument, before ten humane Testimonies. ⟨p. 45⟩But thus by clothing these Scriptures with these logical affections, we have cried up election, and cried down Ordination, sectaries take advantage of this, and hence come in our disorders. Ordination is a Divine institution.
Whether Ordination according to Scripture-light be not as essentiall to a Minister as Election, 1let any one judge. I thinke Mr. Hudson speakes Christianly, I preferre one Divine Testimony, before ten arguments, and one good argument, before ten humane Testimonies. ⟨p. 45⟩But thus by cloathing these Scriptures with these logicall affections, we have cried up election, and cryed downe Ordination, sectaries take advantage of this, and hence come in our disorders. Ordination is a Divine institution.
- 1Vind. chu. Cath. vis.
Ars est in rebus, and Logic is a general Art, so that we must give some logical terms to Election and Ordination: I deny not this, only it is good to bring Art to Scripture, and not carry Scripture to Art: If you ask, what logical Arguments are there between a Ministers call, and Election and Ordination? 1what if I should answer, The Call is Totum integral, Election and Ordination are membra constituting this Totum; Thus I make Election to be essential, and so I speak the highest of Election, though I must profess upon serious thought, I rather question whether Election be essential, then I do Ordination. Reverend Mr. Hooker indeed saith, Ordination is but the approbation of a person constituted in his office; but I am apt to think, Ordination doth most respect that inward, or Arcanam vocationem (as Zanchy calls it) which God gives a man into the Ministry, fitting and qualifying of a man first for the work (which none else can do) and giving him an earnest desire to the work, God did there as it were, separate him inwardly, and now he doth it outwardly in Ordination. The particular Congregation doth but give him a Call by their election and subjection to him, to exercise this power among them pro hic & nunc; That which moves me to think so is,
Ars est in rebus, and Logicke is a generall Art, so that we must give some logical terms to Election and Ordination: I deny not this, onely it is good to bring Art to Scripture, and not carry Scripture to Art: If you aske, what logicall Arguments are there betweene a Ministers call, and Election and Ordination? 1what if I should answer, The Call is Totum integrale, Election and Ordination are membra constituting this Totum; Thus I make Election to be essentiall, and so I speake the highest of Election, though I must professe upon serious thought, I rather question whether Election be essentiall, then I doe Ordination. Reverend Mr. Hooker indeed saith, Ordination is but the approbation of a person constituted in his office; but I am apt to thinke, Ordination doth most respect that inward, or Arcanam vocationem (as Zanchy calls it) which God gives a man into the Ministry, fitting and qualifying of a man first for the worke (which none else can do) and giving him an earnest desire to the worke, God did there as it were, separate him inwardly, and now he doth it outwardly in Ordination. The particular Congregation doth but give him a Call by their election and subjection to him, to exercise this power among them pro hic & nunc; That which moves me to thinke so is,
First, Churches may not choose whom they list (as do our Sectaries) but persons qualified by God.
First, Churches may not choose whom they list (as doe our Sectaries) but persons qualified by God.
Secondly, the Scripture is so full and clear for Ordination over it is for Election, though I deny not but Election may well be proved.
Secondly, the Scripture is so full and cleare for Ordination over it is for Election, though I deny not but Election may well bee proved.
Thirdly, because a man may in some cases be ordained to the Ministry, when no election of the people doth precede, as I shall give instance afterward.
2. I argue thus:
If the election of the people doth give the essentials to an officer, then may a man elected execute all official power without ordination, and that commonly.
If the election of the people doth give the essentials to an officer, then may a man elected execute all officiall power without ordination, and that commonly.
But no man may execute official power, and that commonly without ordination; ergo, election doth not give the essentials; by the essentials here, he means the formal cause, ⟨p. 56⟩for as for the material cause, they cannot give that, and we have but two causes that do dare essentiam, though all four doe dare esse.
But no man may execute officiall power, and that commonly without ordination; ergo, election doth not give the essentialls; by the essentials here, he meanes the formall cause, ⟨p. 56⟩for as for the materiall cause, they cannot give that, and we have but two causes that doe dare essentiam, though all foure doe dare esse.
The consequence is clear, that they may execute, &c. without ordination, for forma dat operari; but election gives the form, say these Reverend men, and ordination is but an Adjunct, effects do not depend upon Adjuncts, for operation the form gives that.
The consequence is cleare, that they may execute, &c. without ordination, for forma dat operari; but election gives the forme, say these Reverend men, and ordination is but an Adjunct, effects doe not depend upon Adjuncts, for operation the forme gives that.
The minor, that they must not do so.
The minor, that they must not doe so.
Secondly, It is cross to your own practise; it is frequent in New England to have a man elected, and preach half a year, a whole year, yea, I know one elected and preached two years to his people, and they maintained him all that while, and yet all that time he never administered a Sacrament to his people, but he and they, when they would partake of the Lords Supper, went ten miles to the Church, out of which they issued, to receive the Sacrament; but this was very hard and needless, if he had the form given him in election.
Secondly, It is crosse to your owne practise; it is frequent in New England to have a man elected, and preach halfe a yeare, a whole yeare, yea, I know one elected and preached two yeares to his people, and they maintained him all that while, and yet all that time he never administred a Sacrament to his people, but he and they, when they would partake of the Lords Supper, went ten miles to the Church, out of which they issued, to receive the Sacrament; but this was very hard and needlesse, if he had the forme given him in election.
2. That which doth nextly invest a man with official power, so as now he may perform official acts, and before which he could not do so, that doth give essence, and consequently is not a mere adjunct.
2. That which doth nextly invest a man with official power, so as now he may performe officiall acts, and before which he could not doe so, that doth give essence, and consequently is not a meer adjunct.
But Ordination doth nextly invest a Minister with official power, so as now he may perform official acts, which before he could not do; ergo,
But Ordination doth nextly invest a Minister with official power, so as now he may perfome official acts, which before he could not doe; ergo,
The minor is clear by the Scripture examples.
Secondly, it is clear by your own practise, for those who for two years, and more, stood only by election, but that while dispensed no Sacraments, when they were ordained, did presently put forth all official acts.
Secondly, it is clear by your owne practise, for those who for two yeares, and more, stood onely by election, but that while dispensed no Sacraments, when they were ordained, did presently put forth all official acts.
The major, take all together, I suppose will not be denied; it doth nextly invest a man with official power, so as now he can perform official acts, and before he could not do it; to say he had official power before given him by election, but could not act it, is strange, frustra est illa potentia, &c. had such a person continued twice as long unordained, he had not executed any official power, nay, his preaching all that time was not esteemed preaching by way of office.
The major, take all together, I suppose will not be denied; it doth nextly invest a man with official power, so as now he can performe official acts, and before he could not doe it; to say he had official power before given him by election, but could not act it, is strange, frustra est illa potentia, &c. had such a person continued twice as long unordained, he had not executed any official power, nay, his preaching all that time was not esteemed preaching by way of office.
Neither can it be said such preach only upon trial, for I now speak of such, as had been tried before, nay, have been preachers in England long before they went over, and such I am sure, as the people would willingly had them ordained within one month after they had chosen them, they were so well satisfied in the persons, whom they had chosen.
Neither can it be said such preach onely upon triall, for I now speake of such, as had beene tried before, nay, have beene preachers in England long before they went over, and such I am sure, as the people would willingly had them ordained within one month after they had chosen them, they were so well satisfied in the persons, whom they had chosen.
Fourthly, it is something that solemnity the Scripture expresseth, that was in the ordination of Ministers, prayer and fasting, and imposition of hands: we read of no such solemnity in election, though people ought to pray before they do choose. So it was in New England, this act was very solemn; when notice was given of the ordination of an officer to the several Churches (as before any ordination, all the Churches adjacent had notice given) it ran in that form, There is an Ordination to be this week at such a Church, &c. for the election of the person, we knew it long before, whom they had chosen, and though the people did by their suffrage declare their election in this day of Humiliation, yet they declared no more then the Country knew before; and I hope you will not say, he was not elected before now, when first they chose him to go with them, or come to them, and there continued a year or two preaching, & they contributing to his maintenance; the same I might say in regard of myself, I had as full an election of my people at my first coming, as was declared at my ordination, and it was above two years, before I could get my ordination in the place where I was elected (through the troubles of the times) but all that while I did not conceive my self invested with official power, till I was also ordained. The Scripture then expressing such solemnity in this act, and not in the other, makes me think, this is not such a slight Adjunct, and the other only essential.
Fourthly, it is something that solemnity the Scripture expresseth, that was in the ordination of Ministers, prayer and fasting, and imposition of hands: we read of no such solemnity in election, though people ought to pray before they doe choose. So it was in New England, this act was very solemne; when notice was given of the ordination of an officer to the severall Churches (as before any ordination, all the Churches adjacent had notice given) it ran in that forme, There is an Ordination to be this weeke at such a Church, &c. for the election of the person, we knew it long before, whom they had chosen, and though the people did by their suffrage declare their election in this day of Humiliation, yet they declared no more then the Country knew before; and I hope you will not say, he was not elected before now, when first they chose him to goe with them, or come to them, and there continued a yeare or two preaching, & they contributing to his maintenance; the same I might say in regard of myself, I had as ful an election of my people at my first coming, as was declared at my ordination, and it was above two years, before I could get my ordination in the place where I was elected (through the troubles of the times) but all that while I did not conceive my selfe invested with official power, till I was also ordained. The Scripture then expressing such solemnity in this act, and not in the other, makes me thinke, this is not such a slight Adjunct, and the other onely essentiall.
Fifthly, I observe two Texts, which make me think ordination is not an Adjunct, 2 Tim. 2. And the things which thou hast heard of me among many witnesses, the same commit thou to faithful men, who should be able to teach others also. And that Text, 1 Tim. 5.22. Lay hands suddenly upon no man, neither be partakers of other mens sins &c. Timothy is a Church-officer, here is a charge given to him to take heed, who comes into the Ministry, yea, he may be partaker of other mens sins, if he have not a special care, whom he admitteth into the Ministry, Nam si quem cito ordinaveris, qui ⟨p. 58⟩indignus sit, 1communicabis peccatis alienis, dum ille malè docebit, aut vivet, saith Gerhard in Loc. He quotes also Leo Papa, Ep. 87. Ad Africanos Episc. Quid est citò manus imponere, nisi ante aetatem maturitatis, antè tempus examinis, ante meritum laboris, antè experientiam Disciplinae, sacerdotalem honorem tribuere non probatis? Calvin also on the last words, Keep thy self pure; Ac si dixisset, si quid perperam fiat ab aliis, vide ne ulla ex consensu, vel approbatione contagio ad te perveniat. He refers it to Timothy, joining with others in ordaining unworthy persons; now these texts do not belong to the people, but Ministers, Officers, as was Timothy, which makes me think, that what the Ministers do in examining, trying, ordaining, is more then the peoples election; where do we find such things spoken to the people? Where the greatest blame lies, for unworthy men coming into the Ministry, surely there must lye the greatest power of admitting men into the Ministry, else the blame is not just; but we see the blame is here laid upon the Ministers; 2Paul no where writes to the people to commit the things they have heard, &c. nor doth he bid them not lay on hands suddenly, &c. he bad them indeed look out men for Deacons, but that doth not answer these texts; but if the great stroke, the formal cause lye in the popular election, the Ministers may well say, We do but ordain, we give but an Adjunct, the people did the main Act, they gave the essence, the essence being given, we must give the Adjunct, so that there will be no blame left for the Ministers.
6 It should seem by a passage of Doct. 1Ames, that ordination is more then an Adjunct; Bellarmine had said, Vocatio seu missio ministrorum non ad populum pertinet, sed ad Episcopos, &c. Doct. Ames in his second answer hath these words; Absurdè ad modum distinguitur vocatio ministri, ab ejus Ordinatione & electione, tanquam pars distincta; neque in Scripturis, neque in antiquis Patribus alia vocatio ordinaria memoratur, quam illa, quae exurgit, quasi Totum, ex electione & ordinatione: what Totum the Doctor means, is plain by his words, Exurgit ex ordinatione & electione, he means Totum integral; so then ordination and election are members of this Integrum, but all the members do give essence to the Integrum, for Membra sunt symbola causarum essentialium. If so, then ordination cannot be an Adjunct in respect of a Ministerial Call, for no Adjunct gives essence, but follows the essence, supposing the subject complete in its essence before; if then ordination doth give essence, as well as election, this notion may hold, else we ⟨p. 59⟩should have an Integrum consisting but of two parts, and but one part give the essence, which cannot be. This notion of a Ministers Call to consist as a Totum ex electione & ordinatione, is much nearer the Rule, then to have election alone to give the essence, and ordination to be but an Adjunct.
6 It should seeme by a passage of Doct. 1Ames, that ordination is more then an Adjunct; Bellarmine had said, Vocatio seu missio ministrorum non ad populum pertinet, sed ad Episcopos, &c. Doct. Ames in his second answer hath these words; Absurdè ad modum distinguitur vocatio ministri, ab ejus Ordinatione & electione, tanquam pars distincta; neque in Scripturis, neque in antiquis Patribus alia vocatio ordinaria memoratur, quam illa, quae exurgit, quasi Totum, ex electione & ordinatione: what Totum the Doctor meanes, is plaine by his words, Exurgit ex ordinatione & electione, he meanes Totum integrale; so then ordination and election are members of this Integrum, but all the members doe give essence to the Integrum, for Membra sunt symbola causarum essentialium. If so, then ordination cannot be an Adjunct in respect of a Ministeriall Call, for no Adjunct gives essence, but followes the essence, supposing the subject compleat in its essence before; if then ordination doth give essence, as well as election, this notion may hold, else we
To this agrees Mr. Jacob [a man well known] There are two essential parts of calling to the Ministry, Election, Ordination: 1so the Calling is a Totum. As for the Objections made against this, if ordination be essential, what then shall become of our Ministers, whose ordination is not legitimate? This I have spoken to before; and so, what will you do in case a Church were so cast by providence, that they could get no Officers to Ordain them an Officer? [for those who are of this opinion deny the People power to ordain] it is easily yielded by our Divines, that may be done in an extraordinary case, which ordinarily ought not to be done. See Rutherford, Due right of Presbytery, p. 187. Gillespie, Miscel. p. 34. &c. for my part, I conceive then the Church fasting, and praying, for such a one, who is elected, may do that which is equivalent to ordination, though it be not ordination formalitèr.
To this agrees Mr. Jacob [a man well known] There are two essentiall parts of calling to the Ministry, Election, Ordination: 1so the Calling is a Totum. As for the Objections made against this, if ordination be essentiall, what then shall become of our Ministers, whose ordination is not legitimate? This I have spoken to before; and so, what will you doe in case a Church were so cast by providence, that they could get no Officers to Ordaine them an Officer? [for those who are of this opinion deny the People power to ordaine] it is easily yeelded by our Divines, that may be done in an extraordinary case, which ordinarily ought not to be done. See Rutherford, Due right of Presbytery, p. 187. Gillespie, Miscel. p. 34. &c. for my part, I conceive then the Church fasting, and praying, for such a one, who is elected, may doe that which is aequivalent to ordination, though it be not ordination formalitèr.
- 1Dr. Seaman quotes him, Ans. to Diat, p. 64