Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 8 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The strong argument where-with reverend Master Hooker proves, That Election gives the Essentials to an Officer is this: One Relate gives the essential constituting causes to another. But Pastor and People are Relates; ergo.
The strong argument where-with reverend Master Hooker proves, That Election gives the Essentials to an Officer is this: One Relate gives the essentiall constituting causes to another. But Pastor and People are Relates; ergo.
The answer which Mr. Rutherford gives to it, viz. That ordination made him a Minister before, and election doth but appropriate him; This Mr. Hooker denieth to be any answer, because it supposeth ordination to antecede election, which is quite cross to the Scripture pattern, Act. 6.3.6. But (with favour) I should humbly propound this question, 1Whether Ordination may in no case precede election? As now in this case, Suppose one of the Scholars in the College, or suppose four, or more had learned the Indian Language, and upon examination they were found to be Ministerially qualified; suppose now the Presbytery should solemnly set apart these young men to the work of the Ministry, and send them forth to preach among the Indians, though the Indians have not elected them; here indeed would the essentials of an Officer be given without election: I pray what breach of rule would here be? If it be said, that the ⟨p. 60⟩examples mentioned, Act. 6. & Act. 14. show their election goes first; It is true indeed where there are Churches, but here are none. Besides, Act. 13.3. when Paul and Barnabas were sent out to preach among the Gentiles they were ordained, 2when no election did precede; it is true, they were extraordinary Officers, but what then? though this doth not make those young men extraordinary Officers, as were the Apostles, to have power in all Churches, yet I see not any breach of rule in separating them to this work. If it be said, what need of that Ordination, they may preach without? It is true, they may, but it is not so comfortable, as when men are set apart by a Divine institution, there is an authority more conferred; they may now baptize as they find success of their Ministry (which was the old way) and shall not need be put to those troubles, which now they are; 3as suppose they should convert divers Indians forty or fifty miles from any Plantation, how shall these be baptised? what, shall they now elect, and ordain these men? shall unbaptized persons ordain an Officer? where have we a rule for that? then it seems all these must come to another Church, &c. forty or fifty miles distant, to a Church also whose language they understand not, and there be baptised by a Minister, whom they understand not, nor he them.
Here are many odd things fall in, cross to all Scripture presidents, but to have these ordained and sent forth, is not cross to the Scripture presidents; but if this be granted, then Ordination without election may give the essentials to an Officer.
Here are many odde things fall in, crosse to all Scripture presidents, but to have these ordained and sent forth, is not crosse to the Scripture presidents; but if this be granted, then Ordination without election may give the essentials to an Officer.
But further, here you say election gives the essentials, I beseech you, what shall we do then with all those Scriptures, where ordination is held out so fully? shall we omit them if they contain but an Adjunct? No, I am sure this gracious Saint would not do so, his heart was so awed with high thoughts of God, and his Word, that he dared not omit such a Divine institution, as those Scriptures hold out; are then those six or seven Scriptures alleged for ordination, as necessary to a Ministers Call, as those three which are brought for election? if not, I pray give a reason, why some Scriptures should be less set by, then others in this nature; Divine Authority we acknowledge in both: but this was far from this reverend mans thoughts, for we see him prove Church-Discipline to be a fundamental point of Religion, from imposition of hands; then if these ⟨p. 61⟩Scriptures be equally as necessary to the constitution of a Minister, that none must dare to omit them, we do but [Greek or Hebrew] in saying, that ordination is but an Adjunct, &c. In constituted Churches, those, who omit ordination, go cross to those many texts of Scripture, they follow not the pattern, 1and so sin against the second Commandment, as do they, who go cross to the texts for election; and if election in an extraordinary case may serve without a formal ordination, in the like case may ordination be without election, and so we are even.
But further, here you say election gives the essentials, I beseech you, what shall we doe then with all those Scriptures, where ordination is held out so fully? shall we omit them if they containe but an Adjunct? No, I am sure this gracious Saint would not doe so, his heart was so awed with high thoughts of God, and his Word, that he dared not omit such a Divine institution, as those Scriptures hold out; are then those six or seven Scriptures alledged for ordination, as necessary to a Ministers Call, as those three which are brought for election? if not, I pray give a reason, why some Scriptures should be lesse set by, then others in this nature; Divine Authority we acknowledge in both: but this was far from this reverend mans thoughts, for we see him prove Church-Discipline to be a fundamentall point of Religion, from imposition of hands; then if these ⟨p. 61⟩Scriptures be equally as necessary to the constitution of a Minister, that none must dare to omit them, we doe but in saying, that ordination is but an Adjunct, &c. In constituted Churches, those, who omit ordination, goe crosse to those many texts of Scripture, they follow not the patterne,
Further, in answer to the Argument, they are Relates; suppose I should say, The election of the people gives a part of the essence to the Officer [for so we considered the Call of a Minister to be a Totum arising out of election and ordination, as Doctor Ames] it may be you will say, Relata, quà sic, do not give a part of the essence, but the whole: here then will be our trouble, whether we must bring Scripture to Logic, or carry our Logic to Scripture; why then do not Ministers act officially upon bare election, as I said before? But it is answered, their election gives the essence, as he is their Minister, but ordination gives the essence, as he is a Minister; 1for ordination doth invest a Minister with power to act beyond those, who have called him, giving him an habitual power in actu primo to exercise and perform the Acts belonging to his Office elsewhere upon a Call. I know indeed our New England Divines, many (I say not all) as well as reverend Mr. Hooker, are of another opinion, That a man is an Officer only to his own particular Congregation, Relatorum mutuum est iter; but suppose I should say, A Minister bears an habitual relation to the whole Church-Catholic visible, which some of our Divines do now (I think) strongly prove; for my part I could never swallow that notion, that a Pastor preaches only, as a Pastor, to those who elected him, and to other Churches, as a gifted Brother. I dare boldly affirm in the Apostles times, and the purest Ages next them, this notion was never heard. As for this notion of a Catholic visible Church, I have not so much busied my head about it till of late, & in my weak judgement I think, there is so much said for it by Mr. Hudson (especially) and others, that I suppose it will not easily be answered; that which made me lean to this opinion, was;
Further, in answer to the Argument, they are Relates; suppose I should say, The election of the people gives a part of the essence to the Officer [for so we considered the Call of a Minister to be a Totum arising out of election and ordination, as Doctor Ames] it may be you will say, Relata, quà sic, doe not give a part of the essence, but the whole: here then will be our trouble, whether we must bring Scripture to Logick, or carry our Logick to Scripture; why then doe not Ministers act officially upon bare election, as I said before? But it is answered, their election gives the essence, as he is their Minister, but ordination gives the essence, as he is a Minister; 1for ordination doth invest a Minister with power to act beyond those, who have called him, giving him an habituall power in actu primo to exercise and performe the Acts belonging to his Office elsewhere upon a Call. I know indeed our New England Divines, many (I say not all) as wel as reverend Mr. Hooker, are of another opinion, That a man is an Officer only to his own particular Congregation, Relatorum mutuum est iter; but suppose I should say, A Minister bears an habitual relation to the whole Church-Catholick visible, which some of our Divines doe now (I thinke) strongly prove; for my part I could never swallow that notion, that a Pastor preaches only, as a Pastor, to those who elected him, and to other Churches, as a gifted Brother. I dare boldly affirme in the Apostles times, and the purest Ages next them, this notion was never heard. As for this notion of a Catholick visible Church, I have not so much busied my head about it till of late, & in my weak judgement I think, there is so much said for it by Mr. Hudson (especially) and others, that I suppose it will not easily be answered; that which made me leane to this opinion, was;
First; the light which his Scriptures and Arguments bring along with them.
2 I did not see by this notion, that the people were at all ⟨p. 62⟩defrauded of what is properly theirs, they may elect officers, they may have power to bring in testimony, to exclude unworthy communicants, yea, or may object against any, who should be admitted Church-members (if Churches were in their first constituting) if they knew good reason why they should not be admitted; neither are they debarred from consenting with their officers in excommunication; I say, I do not see but these privileges may consist with this notion.
2 I did not see by this notion, that the people were at all ⟨p. 62⟩defrauded of what is properly theirs, they may elect officers, they may have power to bring in testimony, to exclude unworthy communicants, yea, or may object against any, who should be admitted Church-members (if Churches were in their first constituting) if they knew good reason why they should not be admitted; neither are they debarred from consenting with their officers in excommunication; I say, I doe not see but these priviledges may consist with this notion.
3. 1I saw this notion did not cross that Position, which I have held out, viz. That a particular Church organized, and walking regularly, may execute all the power of the Keys within it self. I see not how a particular Church in this case is at all hindered, for such a Church to walk irregularly, and to claim exemption from all other Church-power, let those, that will, be members of such Churches, I desire not to be so, but in such Churches, where there may be means to help a wicked heart.
3. 1I saw this notion did not crosse that Position, which I have held out, viz. That a particular Church organized, and walking regularly, may execute all the power of the Keyes within it self. I see not how a particular Church in this case is at all hindred, for such a Church to walke irregularly, and to claime exemption from all other Church-power, let those, that will, be members of such Churches, I desire not to be so, but in such Churches, where there may bee meanes to helpe a wicked heart.
- 1Mr. Huds. vind. 160. 161. Let particular churches walk as they should regularly and they have as much liberty as they can desire; if they walk irregularly See Mr. Cottons Keys 53.54. the second Impression.Mr. Huds. vind. 160. 161. Let particular churches walk as they should regularly and they have as much liberty as they can desire; if they walk irregularly See Mr. Cottons Keyes 53.54. the second Impression.
4. In this notion I saw a way how Congregations, that have no Ministers may have Ministers ordained successively by officers (which I am sure was the old way) yea, and officers may be judged per pares and excommunicated; I saw it would bring in much order into Churches.
5. The practises I observed in New England that did imply such a notion as this, did lead me much to it.
1. As that members of one Church did so frequently partake of the Sacraments, both the Lords Supper, and Baptism in other Churches; one Pastor it may be might administer the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, to the members of five or six Churches at one time; I know it is often said that a Mayor of one Corporation, may administer justice to the members of another Corporation, if they be under his jurisdiction, but he must not go to them, but similia ad pompam, non ad pugnam. The Analogy between a Commonwealth, and the Church will not hold, as I may touch afterward; but this I am sure, according to that practise, that seven make a Church, they may admit five or six whole Churches, and a Pastor chosen by none of them may administer the Sacrament to them all at one time; but do we find whole Corporations go to the Mayor of another Corporation for Justice? Mr. Philips Pastor of the Church in Water-town, while Mr. Wilson Pastor of the Church of Boston was here in England, went to Boston, and administered the Lords Supper to that Church ⟨p. 63⟩(I was not then in the Country, but I heard of it soon after, when I went over with Mr. Wilson) I know no sin in that act. I thought to have given some Instances, how frequent this was in the Primitive Churches, 1for one Minister to act officially beyond the people, who elected him: But Mr. Hudson (a man far more able) hath set down those examples, which I would have given, and many more, to whom I refer the Reader; Yea, it was ordinary for the members of one Church to dwell one or two years; nay, six, or seven years in another Town, and to partake of the Sacraments there as frequently, as any of the members of that Church: Indeed of late the Elders have not liked this, to have them live so remote from the inspection of their own officers, and therefore have required such to join with the Church, where they dwell, this is good and orderly: The letters also of Recommendation, which the Churches make for the members, when they come over hither, requiring of the Churches here what communion, counsel, or comfort they shall need, promising the performance of the like debt to others, &c.
1. As that members of one Church did so frequently partake of the Sacraments, both the Lords Supper, and Baptisme in other Churches; one Pastor it may be might administer the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, to the members of five or six Churches at one time; I know it is often said that a Mayor of one Corporation, may administer justice to the members of another Corporation, if they be under his jurisdiction, but he must not goe to them, but similia ad pompam, non ad pugnam. The Analogie betweene a Commonwealth, and the Church will not hold, as I may touch afterward; but this I am sure, according to that practise, that seven make a Church, they may admit five or six whole Churches, and a Pastor chosen by none of them may administer the Sacrament to them all at one time; but doe we finde whole Corporations goe to the Mayor of another Corporation for Justice? Mr. Philips Pastor of the Church in Water-town, while Mr. Wilson Pastor of the Church of Boston was here in England, went to Boston, and administred the Lords Supper to that Church
2. Also I saw, if a man were excommunicated out of one Church, he stood excommunicated out of them all, but if a man be disfranchised in one Corporation, another Corporation may receive him, and give him his freedom, if they please, this shows there is something more in a Church, then in a Commonwealth.
2. Also I saw, if a man were excommunicated out of one Church, he stood excommunicated out of them all, but if a man be disfranchised in one Corporation, another Corporation may receive him, and give him his freedome, if they please, this shews there is something more in a Church, then in a Commonwealth.
3. I saw they preached frequently in other Churches, but that it should be only, as gifted brethren, this is so harsh to conceive: I pray what act doth the mayor of one Corporation do in another Corporation like this, that carries authority in it? and that here we must distinguish of the Mayor, if he did this at home, he did it as a Mayor authoritatively, but in this Corporation he doth it as a private man?
3. I saw they preached frequently in other Churches, but that it should be onely, as gifted brethren, this is so harsh to conceive: I pray what act doth the mayor of one Corporation do in another Corporation like this, that carries authority in it? and that here we must distinguish of the Mayor, if he did this at home, he did it as a Mayor authoritatively, but in this Corporation he doth it as a private man?
Further, they are Ministers or Pastors only to those, who elect, and the fraternity only elect (where there is no officer) but there are divers in the several Townes, who are not joined to the Churches, so they did not elect, then it seems they preach as pastors, only to those, who elected; but to the rest of the Town, as gifted men; consequently, when God blesses their labours to the conversion of any of those, they convert them (instrumentally) not as Ministers of Christ, ordained, separated ⟨p. 64⟩to that work, but only as gifted men; yea, they never convert any, as Ministers, unless some of those, who elected them be close hypocrites, and so they convert them; but ordinarily those, who choose, are reputed godly already, and they are Ministers only to them. Hence rises that vile notion, that some here have taken up, That Pastors should preach only to the edification of the Saints, not to others.
Further, they are Ministers or Pastors onely to those, who elect, and the fraternity only elect (where there is no officer) but there are divers in the severall Townes, who are not joyned to the Churches, so they did not elect, then it seemes they preach as pastors, onely to those, who elected; but to the rest of the Towne, as gifted men; consequently, when God blesses their labours to the conversion of any of those, they convert them (instrumentally) not as Ministers of Christ, ordained, separated ⟨p. 64⟩to that worke, but onely as gifted men; yea, they never convert any, as Ministers, unlesse some of those, who elected them be close hypocrites, and so they convert them; but ordinarily those, who choose, are reputed godly already, and they are Ministers only to them. Hence rises that vile notion, that some here have taken up, That Pastors should preach onely to the edification of the Saints, not to others.
4. I have heard since I came away, that when people have chosen an Officer, and had no Officers to ordain him, that the Ministers of other Congregations have done it, and the Confession of Church-discipline by the Synod of New England, as also Mr. Hooker, 1allow as much.
4. I have heard since I came away, that when people have chosen an Officer, and had no Officers to ordaine him, that the Ministers of other Congregations have done it, and the Confession of Church-discipline by the Synod of New England, as also Mr. Hooker, 1allow as much.
- 1Survey part. 2. pag. 59.
5. If one Congregation should prove pertinaciously scandalous, and heretical, then though they do not formally excommunicate such a Congregation, yet all the Churches in the Country would proceed to the Non-communion of such a Church; and for all the Churches to express so much to such a Church, We do all renounce communion with you, &c. this amounts to a censure, and is equivalent to excommunication, containing in it all the effects, that appear in excommunication, and so I should reckon my self as much excommunicated.
5. If one Congregation should prove pertinaciously scandalous, and hereticall, then though they doe not formally excommunicate such a Congregation, yet all the Churches in the Country would proceed to the Non-communion of such a Church; and for all the Churches to expresse so much to such a Church, We do all renounce communion with you, &c. this amounts to a censure, and is equivalent to excommunication, containing in it all the effects, that appear in excommunication, and so I should reckon my selfe as much excommunicated.
Mr. Burroughs saith, They may by a solemn act in the name of Christ, 1refuse any communion with them, till they repent. They may declare in the name of Christ, that these erring Churches are not to be received into fellowship with any Churches of Christ, nor to have communion one with another in the Ordinances of Christ; all this solemnly in Christs name: Only some (may be) will say, if this be an Ordinance of Christ, bring out the texts to prove this, and then we shall see, if those texts will not bear it out, that the Churches united thus in this censure, have not some authority over that particular Church. If you go to the old polity, the Synedrion had power over particular Congregations; if to light of nature, that will carry it; so that we must have texts to decide this Question. For my part I must leave this to better heads.
Mr. Burroughs saith, They may by a solemne act in the name of Christ, 1refuse any communion with them, till they repent. They may declare in the name of Christ, that these erring Churches are not to be received into fellowship with any Churches of Christ, nor to have communion one with another in the Ordinances of Christ; all this solemnly in Christs name: Onely some (may be) will say, if this be an Ordinance of Christ, bring out the texts to prove this, and then we shall see, if those texts wil not beare it out, that the Churches united thus in this censure, have not some authority over that particular Church. If you goe to the old politie, the Synedrion had power over particular Congregations; if to light of nature, that will carry it; so that we must have texts to decide this Question. For my part I must leave this to better heads.
- 1Iren. 43.
Laying all together, the Churches seem to practise, as if there were such a Church.
Laying all together, the Churches seeme to pactise, as if there were such a Church.
Some things there are, which a little trouble me in this notion, that make me not come off so roundly in receiving it; I question not the Church-catholic-visible, but I mean that ⟨p. 65⟩it is one organical body, but as he said Veritas est temporis filia, so I believe Time will cleave out this, but so much I see, as commands me to lean to that side.
Some things there are, which a little trouble me in this notion, that make me not come off so roundly in receiving it; I question not the Church-catholicke-visible, but I meane that ⟨p. 65⟩it is one organicall body, but as he said Veritas est temporis filia, so I beleeve Time will cleave out this, but so much I see, as commands me to lean to that side.
I was thinking how dangerous this might prove; If the major part of the Catholic-visible-church should decline, grow superstitious &c. other Churches yet remaining pure, if they did not subject to the major part, what then? but I saw inconveniences also on the other side, if a Congregation be so entire, that they can elect, ordain, and are exempted from all power, then Arians, Photinians, and all manner of Heretics may elect, ordain, &c. who shall deny them? and besides, suppose the major part of Congregational Churches should decline, they would proceed to Non-communion of other particular Churches more pure, and this is in a manner all one.
I was thinking how dangerous this might prove; If the major part of the Catholick-visible-church should decline, grow superstitious &c. other Churches yet remaining pure, if they did not subject to the major part, what then? but I saw inconveniences also on the other side, if a Congregation be so entire, that they can elect, ordaine, and are exempted from all power, then Arians, Photinians, and all manner of Hereticks may elect, ordaine, &c. who shall deny them? and besides, suppose the major part of Congregationall Churches should decline, they would proceed to Non-communion of other particular Churches more pure, and this is in a manner all one.
Further, If so, then if a Minister be removed from one Congregation to another, or if his people should dye, he now is but a private person, and may nor baptise, &c.
Hence also he must have another ordination when elected, and as oft as he is elected; 1I confess I am not clear in the practise; I have searched to find what Scriptural grounds there were for it, but I find none that these Reverend Elders express; some have alleged in conference, that Act. 13.3. Paul and Barnabas were ordained before, and now they are ordained again: but I find Mr. Hooker saying, 2here was no ordination to office at all. Survey part. 2. pag. 83. then I perceive this will not warrant it; I find learned Chamier also of that opinion, he saith, 3there was not properly any ordination into a new Ecclesiastical office, but confirmatio missionis ad Gentes, ad quas nondum erant ex professò missi. The Author of the Diatribe, saith they were Ministers before, Act. 12. ult. but I doubt that place will not prove it, for their fulfilling of their Ministry or Charge there, may refer to C. 11.29, 30. the carrying of the relief to the Saints at Jerusalem, which they might do, though no Apostles.
Hence also he must have another ordination when elected, and as oft as he is elected; 1I confesse I am not cleare in the practise; I have searched to finde what Scripturall grounds there were for it, but I find none that these Reverend Elders expresse; some have alleadged in conference, that Act. 13.3. Paul and Barnabas were ordained before, and now they are ordained againe: but I finde Mr. Hooker saying, 2here was no ordination to office at all. Survey part. 2. pag. 83. then I perceive this will not warrant it; I finde learned Chamier also of that opinion, he saith, 3there was not properly any ordination into a new Ecclesiasticall office, but confirmatio missionis ad Gentes, ad quas nondum erant ex professò missi. The Author of the Diatribe, saith they were Ministers before,
Here then we are in the dark what to judge of the text, if we rest only upon mens opinions, there are many, who are for the contrary opinion, that here was ordination, as I have named before, and I think those, whom Chamier quotes in the twentieth Section of the former Chapter, conceive so, saith he, Act. 13. Imponuntur manus Paulo, & Barnabae mittendis ad Evangelii praedicationem in Gentes, quid hoc est? Chrysostomus, Theophylactus ⟨p. 66⟩Oecumenius, [Greek or Hebrew], ad Apostolatum. Me thinks when I see here are the same acts done, which are done at another Ordination, and there was no Ordination before, nor after, where any more acts were done, why this should not be understood for Ordination, I know not: A man to be separated to the work whereunto God called him (the work of the Ministry) therefore to have prayer, fasting, and imposition of hands, this was done at other Ordinations, when others were separated, though not to be Apostles, as these were. I dare not say that these were not Apostles before now, because I see so many Divines are of that opinion; for Barnabas we find him made mention of, Act. 4.36. a Levite, and a man of excellent gifts, no doubt, as it appears in Chap. 11. but to say he was an Apostle before, I do not see it made so clear, Act. 13.1. There were Prophets and Teachers, as Barnabas, so that Barnabas was one of them, but as yet not an Apostle, for we know these are distinguished, Apostles, Prophets, &c. though I dare not gain-say it, but impute it rather to my ignorance; for Paul, there seemeth to be more said for him, Act. 9 for those that say Ananias his imposition of hands upon Paul, was to separate him to the work of his Apostleship (for that was one end of Imposition of hands) I dare not oppose Divines in this, 1the 12. vers. saith, He saw one in a vision, putting his hands upon him, that he might receive his sight, and Ananias saith, vers. 17. The Lord hath sent me, that thou mightest receive thy sight, and be filled with the Holy Ghost. Now if that necessarily implies that ergo now he was ordained to his Apostleship, I will not oppose, though it is possible that might be, though he were not yet an Apostle; and this is somewhat different from others, that first Ananias alone, secondly in a private house, (the question is who were with Paul in the house) 3.
before he was baptised, should be ordained thus to be an Apostle, though I cannot oppose much, for if Christ will have it, it is orderly enough; but if they were men extraordinarily qualified, and not set apart to the office of their Apostleship, then this place of Act. 13.3. may be interpreted of their ordination to the office of their Apostleship. But suppose they were Apostles, yet will this text be sufficient proof to maintain, that Ministers must be newly ordained, if they remove from one particular Congregation to another? I am sure there may be sufficient grounds, given, why they may remove; if indeed the case were now, as then it ⟨p. 67⟩was with the Gentiles [Act. 11.19. The scattered Disciples preached to the Jews only, but the Gentiles had none sent among them before in this manner, as those were sent (though Peter had been with Cornelius) to be Apostles of the Gentiles) we might allow a second Ordination: In Antiquity we do not find a second Ordination made mention of; something we find to the contrary, as in that Tract of Cyprian, which though it may be proved not to be Cyprian's own, yet no doubt the Author may be as ancient as Cyprian, written in his time, as Pamelius observes, neither doth Goulartius oppose him in it; 1Nemo sacros ordines semel datos iterum renovat, &c.
before he was baptised, should be ordained thus to be an Apostle, though I cannot oppose much, for if Christ will have it, it is orderly enough; but if they were men extraordinarily qualified, and not set apart to the office of their Apostleship, then this place of Act. 13.3. may be interpreted of their ordination to the office of their Apostleship. But suppose they were Apostles, yet wil this text be sufficient proofe to maintaine, that Ministers must bee newly ordained, if they remove from one particular Congregation to another? I am sure there may bee sufficient grounds, given, why they may remove; if indeed the case were now, as then it ⟨p. 67⟩was with the Gentiles [
In the 67. Can. Apost. thus, Si quis Episcopus, aut Presbyter, aut Diaconus, secundam ab aliquo ordinationem susceperit, deponiter tàm ipse, quam qui ipsum ordinavit, nisi forte constet ordinationem eum babere ab haereticis, &c.
Augustine speaking of Baptism and Ordination saith, 1Ʋ trumque enim Sacramentum est, & quadam consecratione utrumque homini datur, illud cum baptizatur, istud cum ordinatur; ideoque in Catholicâ utrumque non licet iterari. To the same purpose he speaks in his book, de bono conjugali, contra Jovin. c. 24.
Augustine speaking of Baptisme and Ordination saith, 1Ʋ trumque enim Sacramentum est, & quadam consecratione utrumque homini datur, illud cum baptizatur, istud cum ordinatur; ideoque in Catholicâ utrumque non licet iterari. To the same purpose he speakes in his booke, de bono conjugali, contra Jovin. c. 24.
- 1Contra permian l. 2. c. 13.
From which places I gather it was not their manner to iterate Ordination; indeed Scripture and strong Argument, is more then humane Testimony; but that is not sufficient to say, Ordination is but the approbation of a person constituted in his office, unless it could be proved that Ordination is no more, which will easily be denied.
From which places I gather it was not their manner to iterate Ordination; indeed Scripture and strong Argument, is more then humane Testimony; but that is not sufficient to say, Ordination is but the approbation of a person constituted in his office, unlesse it could be proved that Ordination is no more, which will easily be denyed.
For our Modern Divines, I do not know any that maintain this iteration of Ordination, in case a man remove from the place where he was first ordained.
For our Moderne Divines, I do not know any that maintaine this iteration of Ordination, in case a man remove from the place where he was first ordained.
The second Argument which Reverend Mr. Hooker useth to prove that Election gives the essentials, &c. is this:
It is lawful for the people to reject a Pastor upon just causes, and put him out of his office, ergo, it is in their power to Call him outwardly, and put him into his office. By this Rejection, he means Excommunication, for so he saith afterward, This rejection cuts him off from being a member, &c. So consequently it must needs make him cease from being an officer.
It is lawfull for the people to reject a Pastor upon just causes, and put him out of his office, ergo, it is in their power to Call him outwardly, and put him into his office. By this Rejection, he means Excommunication, for so he saith afterward, This rejection cuts him off from being a member, &c. So consequently it must needs make him cease from being an officer.
For that phrase of putting him into his office, if it be taken secundum quid, and as to their officer, it hath not been opposed, ⟨p. 68⟩but if taken absolutely, that their election makes him a Minister, (as Mr. Hooker doth) that is it which is denied.
For that phrase of putting him into his office, if it be taken secundum quid, and as to their officer, it hath not beene opposed, ⟨p. 68⟩but if taken absolutely, that their election makes him a Minister, (as Mr. Hooker doth) that is it which is denied.
As for the Antecedent, whether people have power to reject, (or if you mean Excommunication, as it seems that is meant) that is another question; If there be officers, and the people consent with them to cast out an officer, pertinaciously scandalous and heretical, none doubt of that; but for the people, being but a homogeneall body, to reject, i.e. excommunicate an officer, will cost more to prove; had Reverend Mr. Hooker been alive, and saw what work Church-members make here in England in very many Churches, I think it would have caused him to bethink himself again of the peoples power. Something we hear of, is done in a Church not far from the place where he lived, it cannot be kept close; the light of that fire shines into England. For the people to withdraw their subjection from such an officer, when there are no other officers to join with them to excommunicate him, this is not denied, for by their subjection to him, they made him their officer (that was some part) so they may withdraw their subjection again.
As for the Antecedent, whether people have power to reject, (or if you meane Excommunication, as it seemes that is meant) that is another question; If there be officers, and the people consent with them to cast out an officer, pertinaciously scandalous and hereticall, none doubt of that; but for the people, being but a homogeneall body, to reject, i.e. excommunicate an ossicer, will cost more to prove; had Reverend Mr. Hooker beene alive, and saw what work Church-members make here in England in very many Churches, I thinke it would have caused him to bethinke himselfe againe of the peoples power. Something we heare of, is done in a Church not farre from the place where he lived, it cannot be kept close; the light of that fire shines into England. For the people to withdraw their subjection from such an officer, when there are no other officers to joyne with them to excommunicate him, this is not denied, for by their subjection to him, they made him their officer (that was some part) so they may withdraw their subjection againe.
But for Excommunication, Mr. Cotton saith, It is one of the highest acts of rule in the Church, 1and therefore cannot be performed but by some Rulers.
- 1Keys p. 16
Mr. Burroughs saith, 1If the Church be without officers, they cannot do that which belongs to officers to do, they have no Sacraments amongst them, neither can they have any spiritual jurisdiction exercised amongst them, only brotherly admonition, and withdrawing from such as walk disorderly, for their own preservation.
Mr. Burroughs saith, 1If the Church be without officers, they cannot doe that which belongs to officers to doe, they have no Sacraments amongst them, neither can they have any spirituall jurisdiction exercised amongst them, onely brotherly admonition, and withdrawing from such as walke disorderly, for their owne preservation.
- 1Iren. 51.
So then here is a way for the people to preserve themselves though they cannot excommunicate, and those Texts which Reverend Mr. Hooker brings, Matth. 7.15. and Phil. 3.2. do not prove the Church, as a homogencal body, to have power to excommunicate their officers, though they may prove withdrawing, as also Rom. 16.17. may prove it.
So then here is a way for the people to preserve themselves though they cannot excommunicate, and those Texts which Reverend Mr. Hooker brings, Matth. 7.15. and Phil. 3.2. doe not prove the Church, as a homogencal body, to have power to excommunicate their officers, though they may prove withdrawing, as also Rom. 16.17. may prove it.
For the reason of his consequence, that staple rule, ejusdem est Instituere, destituere, this maxim is turned every way, sometimes to prove the people may excommunicate their officers, because they do Instituere.
For the reason of his consequence, that staple rule, ejusdem est Instituere, destituere, this maxime is turned every way, sometimes to prove the people may excommunicate their officers, because they doe Instituere.
The people in Election put forth no act of jurisdiction, therefore they may put forth the highest act of jurisdiction, in excommunication; that there is no act of jurisdiction in election, ⟨p. 69⟩Doctor Ames acknowledgeth; Ovas rationales possunt eligere sibi Pastorem, sicut sponsa eligit sibisponsum, non per jurisdictionem aut Gubernationem sed potius per subjectionem. In the answer before he affirms the same, and else-where: now what arguing is this, 1to argue from subjection, to the highest Act of Jurisdiction? there was no Authority in election, for electio non cogit [yet there is more power seen in Civill elections, then Church-elections, as I shall touch afterward] but in Excommunication, Authority appears. That also is denied, that the people do instituere in constituted Churches, and ordinarily what may be done in an extraordinary case is no ordinary rule.
The people in Election put forth no act of jurisdiction, therefore they may put forth the highest act of jurisdiction, in excommunication; that there is no act of jurisdiction in election, ⟨p. 69⟩Doctor Ames acknowledgeth; Ovas rationales possunt eligere sibi Pastorem, sicut sponsa eligit sibisponsum, non per jurisdictionem aut Gubernationem sed potius per subjectionem. In the answer before he affirmes the same, and else-where: now what arguing is this, 1to argue from subjection, to the highest Act of Jurisdiction? there was no Authority in election, for electio non cogit [yet there is more power seene in Civill elections, then Church-elections, as I shall touch afterward] but in Excommunication, Authority appeares. That also is denied, that the people doe instituere in constituted Chruches, and ordinarily what may be done in an extraordinary case is no ordinary rule.
- 1Bellar. ever. to. 2 l. 3. c. 2. S. 19. Ib. S. 13.Bellar. ener. to. 2 l. 3. c. 2. S. 19. Ib. S. 13.
Here the maxim is turned, to prove that they may Jnstituere, because they can destituere, but that will be denied, unless it be in the sense before mentioned, i. e. in what manner, and how far they did instituere, i.e. by a subjection to be their Officer, so they may with-draw their subjection from him, and not own him to be their Officer; but to Excommunicate is more.
Here the maxime is turned, to prove that they may Jnstituere, because they can destituere, but that will be denyed, unlesse it be in the sence before mentioned, i. e. in what manner, and how farre they did instituere, i.e. by a subjection to be their Officer, so they may with-draw their subjection from him, and not owne him to be their Officer; but to Excommunicate is more.
Quest. But suppose this be granted, that the Fraternity cannot excommunicate ;their Officer, but with-draw their subjection they may, you say, and so he ceases to be their Officer; but what, is he now an Officer to other Churches?
A. If the with-drawing their subjection, and rejecting be irregular, then though they make him not their Officer de facto, [which he is still de jure] yet his relation to the Church-Catholic visible doth still hold, and another Church giving him a Call, he hath then power actu second to administer the Ordinances there.
A. If the with-drawing their subjection, and rejecting be irregular, then though they make him not their Officer de facto, [which he is still de jure] yet his relation to the Church-Catholick visible doth still hold, and another Church giving him a Call, he hath then power actu secund• to administer the Ordinances there.