pp. 285–305184 passagespart 4 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
QUEEN MARY after this, partly fearing the Londoners, by reason of Wyatt's conspiracy, and partly perceiving most of the city, for the sake of religion, not greatly to favour her proceedings, in order to show her displeasure, and to their hindrance, summonsed a parliament to be held at Oxford, with a view also of gratifying that city, where both the university, town, and country, had shown themselves very obedient and forward, especially in restoring the catholic religion. For this purpose, great provision was made, as well by the queen's officers, as by the townsmen of Oxford, and the country round about. But her majesty's mind soon changed, and in April following, the same parliament was held at Westminster; where the queen, among other matters, proposed her marriage with king Philip, which was agreed upon; and likewise the pope's supremacy, which was agreed upon; and likewise the restoring of the pope's supremacy, which could not be obtained. At the same time when this parliament was summonsed, the queen likewise summonsed a convocation of the bishops and clergy, writing unto Bonner, (whom she had made vicegerent in the room of Cranmer, then in the Tower) in the following stile, different from that of Henry VIII. and Edward VI.
QUEEN MARY after this, partly fearing the Londoners, by reason of Wyat's conspiracy, and partly perceiving most of the city, for the sake of religion, not greatly to favour her proceedings, in order to shew her displeasure, and to their hindrance, summonsed a parliament to be held at Oxford, with a view also of gratifying that city, where both the university, town, and country, had shewn themselves very obedient and forward, especially in restoring the catholic religion. For this purpose, great provision was made, as well by the queen's officers, as by the townsmen of Oxford, and the country round about. But her majesty's mind soon changed, and in April following, the same parliament was held at Westminster; where the queen, among other matters, proposed her marriage with king Philip, which was agreed upon; and likewise the pope's supremacy, which was agreed upon; and likewise the restoring of the pope's supremacy, which could not be obtained. At the same time when this parliament was summonsed, the queen likewise summonsed a convocation of the bishops and clergy, writing unto Bonner, (whom she had made vicegerent in the room of Cranmer, then in the Tower) in the following stile, different from that of Henry VIII. and Edward VI.
"MARY, by the grace of God, of England, France, and Ireland, queen, defender of the faith; to the Rev. father in God, Edmund, lord bishop of London, sendeth greeting, &c."
HERE the queen's title is altered, the latter part being omitted, namely, "Of the churches of England and Ireland, supreme," because in this session of parliament the supremacy was taken from the crown of England, and restored to the pope: and bishop Bonner giving his certificate upon the same, leaves out Autoritate, &c. "By the authority of our most illustrious queen empowered;" which part of the bishop's title, in the same parliament, ⟨p. 301⟩was likewise repealed and taken away. It is also to be observed, that on opening the convocation, Bonner, bishop of London, made a certain exhortation, or oration, to the clergy then assembled, wherein he set forth the most incomparable and superangelical order of priesthood, as will appear from the following fragment, collected by some present, which is well worthy the reader's notice, both because the author of it should not be forgot, and because the estimation of the blessed order should lose nothing of its pre-eminence; an order, which, according to bishop Bonner, standeth above angels and kings.
HERE the queen's title is altered, the latter part being omitted, namely, "Of the churches of England and Ireland, supreme," because in this session of parliament the supremacy was taken from the crown of England, and restored to the pope: and bishop Bonner giving his certificate upon the same, leaves out Autoritate, &c. "By the authority of our most illustrious queen impowered;" which part of the bishop's title, in the same parliament, ⟨p. 301⟩was likewise repealed and taken away. It is also to be observed, that on opening the convocation, Bonner, bishop of London, made a certain exhortation, or oration, to the clergy then assembled, wherein he set forth the most incomparable and superangelical order of priesthood, as will appear from the following fragment, collected by some present, which is well worthy the reader's notice, both because the author of it should not be forgot, and because the estimation of the blessed order should lose nothing of its pre-eminence; an order, which, according to bishop Bonner, standeth above angels and kings.
WHEREFORE it is to be known, that priests and elders be worthy of all men to be worshipped for the dignity sake which they have of God, as in Matthew xvi. "Whatsoever ye shall loose upon earth, &c. and whatsoever ye shall bind," &c. For a priest by some means is like Mary the Virgin, and is showed by three points; as the blessed Virgin by five words did conceive Christ, as it is said, Luke i. Fiat mihi secundum verbum tuum: that is to say, "Be it unto me according to thy word:" so the priest by five words doth make the body of Christ. Even as immediately after the consent of Mary, Christ was whole in her womb; so immediately after the speaking of the words of consecration, the bread is substantiated into the very body of Christ. Secondly, As the Virgin carried Christ in her arms, and laid him in an ox-stall after his birth; even so the priest, after the consecration, doth lift up the body of Christ, and placeth it, and carrieth it, and handleth it with his hands. Thirdly, As the blessed Virgin was sanctified before she had conceived; so the priest being ordained and anointed before he doth consecrate, because without orders he could consecrate nothing; therefore the lay-man cannot do that thing, although he be ever so holy, and do speak the self-same words of consecration. Therefore here is to be known, that the dignity of priests by some means passeth the dignity of angels, because there is no power given to any of the angels to make the body of Christ. Whereby the least priest may do on earth, what the highest and greatest angel in heaven cannot do, as St. Bernard saith, "O worshipful dignity of priests, in whose hands the son of God is, as in the womb of the Virgin he was incarnate•" St. Augustine saith, That angels in the consecration of the sacred host do serve him, and the Lord of heaven descendeth to him. Whereupon St. Ambrose upon St. Luke saith, "Doubt thou not the angels to be where Christ is present upon the altar." Wherefore priests are to be honoured before all kings of the earth, princes, and nobles. For a priest is higher than a king, happier than an angel, maker of his Creator. Wherefore, &c.
WHEREFORE it is to be known, that priests and elders be worthy of all men to be worshipped for the dignity sake which they have of God, as in Matthew xvi. "Whatsoever ye shall loose upon earth, &c. and whatsoever ye shall bind," &c. For a priest by some means is like Mary the Virgin, and is shewed by three points; as the blessed Virgin by five words did conceive Christ, as it is said,
WE have here before observed, that Dr. Ridley was removed from Fremingham to the Tower; while there, being one day invited to the lord lieutenant's table, he had a conference, or conversation, with secretary Bourne, Mr. Fecknam, (the queen's commissioners,) and others, concerning the controversies in religion; the sum whereof, as penned by Dr. Ridley himself, is as follows.
MR. THOMAS BRIDGES said, at his brother's, the lord lieutenant's table, I pray you, doctors, for my information, tell me what an heretic is. Secretary Bourne said, I will tell you who is an heretic; whoso stubbornly and stiffly maintaineth an untruth he is an heretic. You mean, sir, said I, an untruth in matters of religion, and concerning our faith. Yes, that is true, said he; and in this we are soon agreed. Then said Mr. Fecknam, whom they called master dean of St. Paul's, sitting at the upper end of the table, I will tell you by St. Augustine who is an heretic; "He that either for the sake of princes, or for the sake of filthy lucre, sets on foot or propagates wrong notions, he is an heretic." Sir, said I, I think St. Augustine addeth the third number, which is, "Or for the sake of vain glory." You say even true, master doctor, said he, and thus far we did agree all three.
MR. FECKNAM began again, saying, Whoso doth not believe what the scripture affirmeth, but will obstinately maintain the contrary, he is an heretic: as in the sacrament of the altar, Matthew doth affirm there to be Christ's body, Mark doth affirm it, Luke affirmeth it, Paul affirmeth it, and none denieth ⟨p. 302⟩it: therefore to hold the contrary, is heresy. It is the same body and flesh that was born of the virgin; and this is confirmed by unity, antiquity, and universality. For none before Berengarius did ever doubt of this, and he was an heretic, as master doctor there knoweth full well; I do take to witness his own conscience, said he.
IN truth, said the secretary, Mr. Fecknam hath spoken well. These are great matters unity, antiquity, and universality. Do not you think so, Dr. Ridley?
HERE, while I seemed unwilling to talk, one of the commissioners said, Peradventure Dr. Ridley doth agree with Mr. Fecknam, and in that case there needs not much debating of the matter.
SIR, said I, in some things I do, and shall agree with him; and in some things which he has spoken, to be plain, I do not agree with him at all. Masters, said I, ye are (as I understand) the queen's commissioners here, and if ye have commission to examine me in these matters, I shall declare unto you plainly my faith; if ye have not, then I shall pray you either to give me leave to speak my mind freely, or else to hold my peace.
THERE is none here, said the secretary, that doth not favour you: and then every man showed what favour they bare towards me, and how glad they would be of an agreement.
THERE is none here, said the secretary, that doth not favour you: and then every man shewed what favour they bare towards me, and how glad they would be of an agreement.
TAKING this show of courtesy for a licence to speak my sentiments freely, I thus proceeded:
TAKING this shew of courtesy for a licence to speak my sentiments freely, I thus proceeded:
TO Mr. Fecknam's arguments of the manifold affirmations where no denial was, I answered: Where is a multitude of affirmations in scripture, and where is one affirmation, all is one concerning the truth of the matter; for that which any one of the evangelists spake, inspired by the Holy Ghost, was as true as that which is spoken of them all. It is as true what John saith of Christ, "I am the door of the sheep," as if all had said it. For it is not in scripture as in witness of men, where the number is credited more than one, because it is uncertain with what spirit he doth speak. And where Mr. Fecknam spake of so many, affirming, without any negation, &c. Sir, said I, all they do affirm the thing which they meant. Now if ye take their words, to leave their meaning, then do they affirm what ye take, but not what they meant. If in talk with you, I should so utter my mind in words, that ye by the same do, and may plainly perceive my meaning, and could, if you would be captious, cavil at my words, and writhe them to another sense. I would think ye were no gentle companions to talk with, except ye would take my words as ye perceived I did mean.
MR. FECKNAM perceiving whereunto my discourse tended, said, What circumstances can you show that shall move me to think of any other sense than as the words plainly say, "This is my body which shall be betrayed for you?"
MR. FECKNAM perceiving whereunto my discourse tended, said, What circumstances can you shew that shall move me to think of any other sense than as the words plainly say, "This is my body which shall be betrayed for you?"
SIR, said I, even the next sentence that followeth, viz. "Do this in my remembrance." And also by what reason ye say the bread is turned into Christ's carnal body, by the same I may say, that it is turned into his mystical body. For as that saith of it, "This is my body which shall be betrayed for you;" so Paul, who spake by Christ's Spirit, saith, "We being many, are all but one bread and one body, inasmuch as we are partakers of one bread.
HERE he called one bread, one loaf, said the secretary.
YES, said I, one loaf, one bread, all is one with me.
BUT what say you of the universality, antiquity, and unity, that Mr. Fecknam spoke of▪
I assure you, said I, I think them weighty matters, and to be considered well. As for unity, the truth is before God, I do believe it, and embrace it, so it be with variety, and joined to our head Christ, and such an one as St. Paul speaketh of, saying, "One faith, one God, one baptism." And for antiquity, I am also persuaded that to be true which Irenaeus saith, That which is first is true. In our religion Christ's faith was first truly taught by Christ himself, by his apostles, and by many good men, that from the beginning did succeed next unto ⟨p. 303⟩them; and for this controversy of the sacrament, I am persuaded that those old writers, which wrote before the controversy, and the usurping of the see of Rome, do all agree, if they be well understood in this truth.
I assure you, said I, I think them weighty matters, and to be considered well. As for unity, the truth is before God, I do believe it, and embrace it, so it be with varity, and joined to our head Christ, and such an one as St. Paul speaketh of, saying, "One faith, one God, one baptism." And for antiquity, I am also persuaded that to be true which Irenaeus saith, That which is first is true. In our religion Christ's faith was first truly taught by Christ himself, by his apostles, and by many good men, that from the beginning did succeed next unto ⟨p. 303⟩them; and for this controversy of the sacrament, I am persuaded that those old writers, which wrote before the controversy, and the usurping of the see of Rome, do all agree, if they be well understood in this truth.
NOW as for universality, it may have two meanings; one to understand that to be universal, which from the beginning in all ages hath been allowed; another to understand universality for the multitude of our age, or of any other singular age.
NO, no, said Mr. Secretary, these three do always agree, and where there is one, there is all the rest: and here he and I changed many words. To be short in this matter, we did not agree.
THERE was none, said Mr. Fecknam, before •erengarius, Wycliffe, and Huss, and now in our days Carolostadius and O•colampadius. Carolostadius saith, Christ pointed to his own body, and not to the sacrament, and said, This is my body. And Melanchthon writeth to one Miconius (Miconius? said I) these or the like words: "I can find no grounded reason to cause me to dissent from the belief of our fore-fathers." Sir, said I, it is certain that others before them have written of this matter, and whole books treat of it alone, as Bertram, &c.
THERE was none, said Mr. Fecknam, before •erengarius, Wickliffe, and Huss, and now in our days Carolostadius and O•colampadius. Carolostadius saith, Christ pointed to his own body, and not to the sacrament, and said, This is my body. And Melancthon writeth to one Miconius (Miconius? said I) these or the like words: "I can find no grounded reason to cause me to dissent from the belief of our fore-fathers." Sir, said I, it is certain that others before them have written of this matter, and whole books treat of it alone, as Bertram, &c.
BERTRAM? said the secretary, what man was he? and who was he? and how do you know, &c. with many more questions.
SIR, said I, I have read his book; he propoundeth the same which is now in controversy, and answereth so directly, that no man may doubt but that he affirmeth, that the substance of bread remaineth still in the sacrament, and wrote unto Carolus Magnus.
NAY, said he, but observe, he wrote to Henricus, and not to Carolus; for no author maketh any such mention of Bertram.
YES, I replied, Trithemius, in his catalogue of famous writers, speaketh of him; and though Trithemus was but of late time, yet he speaketh of them that were of antiquity. Here, after much discourse about Bertram, what authors can you mention, said Mr. Secretary, who make of the sacrament a figure?
SIR, said I, you know (I think) that Tertullian, in plain words, speaketh thus; This is my body; that is to say, a figure of my body. And Gelasius saith plainly, that the substance of bread remaineth. And Origen likewise, That which is sanctified, as touching the matter or substance, passeth away into the draught. Upon this Mr. Secretary said to me, you know very well as any man, &c. And here, if I would, I might have been set in a foolish paradise of his commendation of my learning, and a man of much reading. But this I would not take at his hand. He set me not up so high, but I brought myself as low again; and here was much ado.
AS for Melanchthon (said I) whom Mr. Fecknam spake of, I marvel that ye will allege him, for we are more nigh an agreement here in England, than the opinion of Melanchthon is to you: for in this point we all agree here, that in the sacrament there is but one material substance, and Melanchthon, as I think, saith there are two.
AS for Melancthon (said I) whom Mr. Fecknam spake of, I marvel that ye will alledge him, for we are more nigh an agreement here in England, than the opinion of Melancthon is to you: for in this point we all agree here, that in the sacrament there is but one material substance, and Melancthon, as I think, saith there are two.
TRUE, said Mr. Secretary; Melanchthon's opinion is so. But you have heard, that the sacrament was i• old time so reverenced, that many were then forbidden to be present at the ministration thereof: Catec••meni, and many more.
TRUE, said Mr. Secretary; Melancthon's opinion is so. But you have heard, that the sacrament was i• old time so reverenced, that many were then forbidden to be present at the ministration thereof: Catec••meni, and many more.
YES, sir, there were some called Audientes, some Poenite••••, some Catechumeni, and some Energumeni, which were commanded to depart.
NOW, then, (said he) how can you make but a figure or a sign of the sacrament, as that book doth which is set forth in my lord of Canterbury's name? I know you can tell who made it; did not you make it? and here was much murmuring of the rest, as though they would have given me the glory of the writing of that book; which yet was said of some there to contain the most heinous heresy that ever was.
MR. Secretary, said I, that book was made by a great learned man, and one who is able to do the like again: as for me I assure you (be not deceived in me) I was never able to do or write any such like ⟨p. 304⟩thing; he surpasseth me no less than the learned master his young scholar.
BUT, sir, methinks it is not charitable to suppose any man doth so lightly esteem the sacrament, as to make of it only a figure; for your [but] maketh it a mere figure, without any more profit, which that book doth often deny, as appeareth to all readers plainly.
YES, said he, that they do.
SIR, I replied, of a truth they do not; as for myself, I assure you, I say, that whosoever receiveth the sacrament, receiveth therewith either life o• death.
THE scripture saith not so, returned Mr. Secretary.
SIR, said I, although not in the same sound of words, yet it doth in the same sense, and St. Augustine saith it in the sound of words also: for Paul saith, "The bread which we break, is it not the partaking or fellowship of the body of Christ? And St. Augustine, Eat life, drink life.
THEN said Mr. Pope, what can ye make of it when ye say, "There is not the real body of Christ, which I do believe, &c. and I pray God, I may never believe other. How can it bring (as ye say) either life or death, when Christ's body is not there."