pp. 18–1271,448 passagespart 16 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. I know what St. Cyprian writeth in that behalf; but he meaneth nothing as you take it.
A Doctor. St. Cyprian hath these words, That upon Peter was built the church, as upon the first beginning of unity.
Phil. He declareth that in an example, that unity must be in the church; he grounded on Peter his church alone, and not upon men. Which he doth more manifestly declare in the book De simplicitate Praelatorum, saying, in the person of one man God gave the keys to all, that he in signification thereby might declare the unity of all men.
A Doctor. What, will you understand St. Cyprian so? That were good indeed.
Phil. I think you cannot understand St. Cyprian better, than he doth declare himself.
Bond. I will desire you (Mr. Chancellor) to take some pains with Dr. Chedsey, about his examination, for I must go to the parliament-house. And I desire you will dine with me.
Bon. I will desire you (Mr. Chancellor) to take some pains with Dr. Chedsey, about his examination, for I must go to the parliament-house. And I desire you will dine with me.
Phil. Then the doctor again took his former ⟨p. 55⟩authority in hand for want of another, and would have mad a further circumstance, digressing from his purpose. To whom I said he knew not whereabouts he went, and herewith he laughed. And I said his divinity was nothing but scoffing.
A Doctor. Yes, then I have done with you, and so went away.
Phil. You are too young in divinity to teach me in the matters of my faith. Though you may be more learned in other things than I, yet in divinity I have been longer practised than you, for any thing I can hear of you; therefore be not too hasty to judge what you do not perfectly know.
Chan. Peter and his successors from the beginning have been allowed for the supreme head of the church, and that by the scriptures, for Christ said unto him in St. John thrice, "Feed my sheep."
Phil. That is no otherwise to be taken, than, "Go ye and preach," which was spoken to all the apostles as well as unto Peter. And that Christ said thrice, "Feed my sheep," it signifieth nothing else but the earnest study that the ministers of God ought to have in preaching the word. God grant that you of the clergy would weigh your duty in this behalf more than you do. Is this a just interpretation of the scripture, to take "Feed my sheep," for to be lord of the whole world? IN the mean while a bachelor of divinity came in, which is a reader of Greek in Oxford, belonging to the bishop, and he took upon him to help Mr. Chancellor.
Scholar. What will you say if I can show you a Greek author called Theophylact to interpret it so? Will you believe his interpretation?
Scholar. What will you say if I can shew you a Greek author called Theophylact to interpret it so? Will you believe his interpretation?
Phil. Theophylact is a late writer, and one that was a favourer of the bishop of Rome, and therefore not to be credited, since his interpretation is contrary to the determination of many general councils.
Scholar. In what general council was it otherwise, that the bishop of Rome was not supreme head over all?
Phil. In the council of Nice I am sure it was otherwise; for Athanasius was there the chief bishop and president of the council, and not the bishop of Rome.
Scholar. Nay, that is not so.
Phil. Then I perceive you are better seen in words than in knowledge of things: and I will lay with you what you will it is so, as you may see in the Epitome of the councils.
Scholar. I will fetch Eusebius and show the contrary, and the book of General Councils. He went into my lord's closet, and brought Eusebius, but the General Councils he brought not, saying (for saving of his honesty) that he could not come by them, and there he would have defended that it was otherwise in Eusebius, but he was not able to show the same, and so shrunk away confounded.
Scholar. I will fetch Eusebius and shew the contrary, and the book of General Councils. He went into my lord's closet, and brought Eusebius, but the General Councils he brought not, saying (for saving of his honesty) that he could not come by them, and there he would have defended that it was otherwise in Eusebius, but he was not able to shew the same, and so shrunk away confounded.
Chan. The church of Rome hath been always taken for the catholic church; therefore I would advise you to come into the same with us. You see all the men of this realm do condemn you. And why will you be so singular?
Phil. I have said, and still do say, that if you can be able to prove it unto me, that I will be of the same. But I am sure that the church, which you make so much of, is a false church, and a synagogue of Satan. And you with the learned men of the realm do persecute the true church, and condemn such as are more righteous than you.
Chan. Do you hear, Mr. Doctor, what he saith, that the church of Rome is the devil.
Ched. I wish you did think more reverently of the church of Rome. What will you say if I can show you out of St. Austin, in his epistle written unto pope Innocent, that the whole general council of Carthage did allow the church of Rome to be the chief over all others?
Ched. I wish you did think more reverently of the church of Rome. What will you say if I can shew you out of St. Austin, in his epistle written unto pope Innocent, that the whole general council of Carthage did allow the church of Rome to be the chief over all others?
Phil. I am sure you can show no such thing. And with that he fetched me the book of St. Austin, and turned to the epistle, but he could not prove his allegation manifestly, but by conjectures in this wise.
Phil. I am sure you can shew no such thing. And with that he fetched me the book of St. Austin, and turned to the epistle, but he could not prove his allegation manifestly, but by conjectures in this wise.
Ched. Here you may see, that the council of Carthage writing to Innocent, the bishop, calleth the see of Rome the apostolic see. And besides this, they write to him, certifying him of things done in the council for the condemnation of the Donatists, requiring his approbation in the same; which they would not have done if they had not taken the church of Rome for the supreme head of others. And moreover you may see how St. Austin doth prove the church of Rome to be the catholic church, by continual succession of the bishops until his time, which succession we can prove until our days: therefore by the same reason of St. Austin we say now, that the church of Rome is the catholic church.
Phil. Mr. Doctor, I have considered how you do weigh St. Austin; and contrary to his meaning and words, you would infer your false conclusion. AS concerning that it was called by him the apostolical see, that is not material to prove the church of Rome now to be the catholic church. I will grant indeed that it is the apostolic see, in respect that Paul and Peter did there once preach the gospel, and abode there for a certain season. I wish you could prove it to be the apostolical see of the true religion and sincerity as the apostle left it, and did teach the same; which if you could do, you might boast of Rome as of the apostolical see; otherwise it is now of no more force, than if the Turks at Antioch and at Jerusalem should boast of the apostolic sees, because the apostles did there once abide, and founded the church of Christ. AND whereas the whole council of Carthage did write unto pope Innocent, certifying him of what was done in the general council, and willing him to set his helping hand to the suppressing of the Donatists, as they had done; that fact of the council doth not prove the supremacy of the bishop of Rome, no more than if the whole convocation-house now gathered together▪ and agreeing upon certain articles, might send the same to some bishop that upon certain impediments is not present, desiring hi• […] agree thereto, and to set them forth in his diocese. Which fact doth not make any such bishop of greater authority than the rest, because his consent is brotherly required. AND touching the succession of the bishops of Rome, brought in by St. Augustine, it maketh nothing now thereby to prove the same catholic church, unless you can conclude with the same reason as St Augustine doth. And the rehearsal of the succession of the bishops doth tend to this only, to prove the Donatists to be heretics, because they began as well at Rome as in Africa, to found another church of their own setting up, than was grounded by Peter and Paul, and by their successors, whom he recited until his time, which all taught no such doctrine, neither such church as the Donatists. Rome (whereof you do glory) that such doctrine hath not been taught by any of the successors of Peter's see, as is now taught and believed by us, you have good reason against us: otherwise it is of no force, as I am able to declare.
Phil. Mr. Doctor, I have considered how you do weigh St. Austin; and contrary to his meaning and words, you would infer your false conclusion. AS concerning that it was called by him the apostolical see, that is not material to prove the church of Rome now to be the catholic church. I will grant indeed that it is the apostolic see, in respect that Paul and Peter did there once preach the gospel, and abode there for a certain season. I wish you could prove it to be the apostolical see of the true religion and sincerity as the apostle left it, and did teach the same; which if you could do, you might boast of Rome as of the apostolical see; otherwise it is now of no more force, than if the Turks at Antioch and at Jerusalem should boast of the apostolic sees, because the apostles did there once abide, and founded the church of Christ. AND whereas the whole council of Carthage did write unto pope Innocent, certifying him of what was done in the general council, and willing him to set his helping hand to the suppressing of the Donatists, as they had done; that fact of the council doth not prove the supremacy of the bishop of Rome, no more than if the whole convocation-house now gathered together and agreeing upon certain articles, might send the same to some bishop that upon certain impediments is not present, desiring hi agree thereto, and to set them forth in his dcese. Which fact doth not make any such bishop of greater authority than the rest, because his consent is brotherly required. AND touching the succession of the bishops of Rome, brought in by St. Augustine, it maketh nothing now thereby to prove the same catholic church, unless you can conclude with the same reason as St Augustine doth. And the rehearsal of the succession of the bishops doth tend to this only, to prove the Donatists to be heretics, because they began as well at Rome as in Africa, to found another church of their own setting up, than was grounded by Peter and Paul, and by their successors, whom he recited until his time, which all taught no such doctrine, neither such church as the Donatists. Rome (whereof you do glory) that such doctrine hath not been taught by any of the successors of Peter's see, as is now taught and believed by us, you have good reason against us: otherwise it is of no force, as I am able to declare.
Chan. Well, Mr. Doctor, you see we can do no good in persuading of him: let us administer the articles which my lord hath lest us, unto him. How say you, Mr. Philpot, to these articles? Mr. Johnson, I pray you write his answers.
Phil. Mr. Chancellor, you have no authority to inquire of me my belief in such articles as you go about, for I am not of my lord of London's diocese; and to be brief with you, I will make no further answer herein than I have already to the bishop.
Chan. Why then let us go our ways, and let his keeper take him away.
THUS ended the seventh part of his tragedy.
EARLY the next morning the bishop sent one of his men to me, to call me up into his chapel to •ear mass.
Bishop's man. Mr. Philpot, where are you?
Phil. Who is that that calleth me?
Bishop's man. My lord's will is, you should rise and come to hear mass: will you come or no?
Phil. My stomach is not very good this morning: you may tell my lord I am sick. After this, the keeper was sent to bring me to my lord.
Keep. Mr. Philpot, you must rise and come to my lord.
Phil. I am at your command, Mr. Keeper, as soon as I can: and going out of the prison, he asked me saying:
Keep. Will you go to mass?
Phil. My stomach is too raw to digest such raw meats of flesh, blood, and bone this morning. AFTER this, my keeper presented me to the bishop in his hall.
Bond. Mr. Philpot, I charge you to answer unto such articles as my chaplain and my register have from me to object against you: go and answer them.
Bon. Mr. Philpot, I charge you to answer unto such articles as my chaplain and my register have from me to object against you: go and answer them.