pp. 18–1271,448 passagespart 30 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
York. Your definition is of many words to no purpose.
Phil. I do not precisely define the church, but declare unto you what I think the church is.
York. Is the church visible or invisible?
Phil. It is both visible and invisible. The invisible church is of the elect of God only; the visible consists both of good and bad, using all things in faith, according to God's word.
York. The church is an universal congregation of faithful people in Christ throughout the world; which this word catholic doth well express; for what is catholic else? doth it not signify universal?
Phil. The church is defined by St. Augustine to be called catholic in this wise, "The church is called therefore catholic, because it is truly perfect, and halteth in nothing."
Phil. The church is defined by St. Augustine to be called catholic in this wise, "The church is called therefore ca•holic, because it is truly perfect, and halteth in nothing."
York. Nay, it is called catholic, because it is universally received of all christian nations, for the most part.
Phil. The church was catholic in the apostles time, yet was it not universally received of the world; but because their doctrine which they had received of Christ was perfe••, and appointed to be preached and received of the whole world, therefore it is called the catholic faith, and all persons receiving the same, to be counted th• catholic church. And St. Augustine in another place writeth, ⟨p. 87⟩that the catholic church is that which believeth aright.
Phil. The church was catholic in the apostles time, yet was it not universally received of the world; but because their doctrine which they had received of Christ was perfe••, and appointed to be preached and received of the whole world, therefore it is called the catholic faith, and all persons receiving the same, to be counted th• c••holic church. And St. Augu•tine in another place writeth, ⟨p. 87⟩that the catholic church is that which believeth aright.
York. If you will learn, I will show you St. Augustine, writing against the Donatists, that he proveth the catholic church by two principal points, which is, universality and succession of bishops, in one apostolical see, from time to time. Now thus I will make mine argument. THE church of of Rome is universal, and hath her succession of bishops from time to time. ERGO, it is the catholic church. HOW answer you to this argument?
York. If you will learn, I will shew you St. Augustine, writing against the Donatists, that he proveth the catholic church by two principal points, which is, univers•lity and succession of bishops, in one apostolical see, from time to time. Now thus I will make mine argument. THE church of of Rome is universal, and hath her succession of bishops from time to time. ERGO, it is the catholic church. HOW answer you to this argument?
Phil. I deny the antecedent, that the catholic church is only known by universality and succession of bishops.
York. I will prove it, and with that he brought forth a book, which he had noted out of the doctors, and turned to his common places therein of the church, and recited one or two out of St. Augustine, especially out of his epistle written against the Donatists, where St Augustine manifestly proveth, that the Donatists, were not the catholic church because they have no succession of bishops in their opinion, neither universality; and the same force hath St. Augustine's argument against you.
Phil. My lord I have weighed the force of that argument before now, and I perceive it maketh nothing against me, neither cometh it to your purpose; for I will stand to the tri•l of St Augustine for the approbation of the catholic church whereof I am. For St. Augustine speaketh of universality joined with verity, and of faithful successors of Peter before corruption came into the church And so if you can deduce your argument for the see •f Rome •ow, as St. Augustine might do in his time, I would say it might be of some force, otherwise not.
Phil. My lord I have weighed the force of that argument before now, and I perceive it maketh nothing against me, neither cometh it to your pur•pose; for I will stand to the tri•l of St Augus•tine for the approbation of the catholic church whereof I am. For St. Augustine speaketh of universality joined with verity, and of faithful successors of Peter before corruption came into the church And so if you can deduce your argument for the see •f Rome •ow, as St. Augustine might do in his time, I would say it might be of some force, otherwise not.
York. St. Augustine proveth the catholic church principally by succession of bishops, and therefore you understand not St. Augustine. For what, I pray you, was the opinion of the Donatists, against whom he wrote, can you tell▪ what country were they of?
York. St. Augustine proveth the catholic church principally by succession of bishops, and therefore you und•rstand not St. Augustine. For what, I pray you, was the opinion of the Donatists, ag•inst whom he wrote, can you tell▪ what country were they of?
Phil. They were a certain sect of men, affirming, among other heresies that the dignity of the sacraments depended upon the worthiness of the minister; so that if the minister was good, the sacraments which he ministered were available, or else not.
Chi. That was their error, and they had none other but that. And he read another authority of St. Austin, out of a book which he brought, even to the same purpose that the other was.
Phil. I challenge St. Austin to be with me thoroughly in this point, and will stand to judgment, taking one place with another.
Chi. If you will not have the church to be certain, I pray you be judged in matters of controversy.
Phil. I do not deny the church to be certain; but I deny that it is necessarily tied to any place, longer than it abideth in the word; and for all controversies the word ought to be judge.
Chi. But what if I take it one way, and you another, how then?
Phil. St. Austin showeth a remedy for that, and willeth, "That one place of the scripture ought to be understood by the majority."
Phil. St. Austin sheweth a remedy for that, and willeth, "That one place of the scripture ought to be understood by the majority."
York. How answer you to this argument? ROME hath known succession of bishops, which your church hath not. ERGO, That is the catholic church, and your's is not, because there is no such succession can be proved in your church.
Phil. I deny, my lord, that succession of bishops is an infallible point to know the church by: for there may be a succession of bishops known in a place, and yet there be no church, as at Antioch and Jerusalem, and in other places, where the apostles abode as well as at Rome. But if you put to the succession of bishops, succession of doctrine ⟨p. 88⟩withal, as St. Austin doth, I will grant it to be a good proof for the catholic church: but a local succession only is nothing available.
York. You will have no church then, I see well.
Phil. Yes, my lord, I acknowledge the catholic church, as I am bound by my creed; but I cannot acknowledge a false church for the true.
Chi. Why, are there two catholic churches then?
Phil. No, I know there is but one catholic church, but there have been, and be at this present, that take upon them the name of Christ and of his church, which be not so […], as it is written, "There be they that call themselves apostles and be not so indeed, but the synagogue […] and liars." And now it is with us as it was wi•h […] two women in Solomon's time, which la• together, and the […] overlaid her child, and afterwards went about to challenge the true mother'• child.
Phil. No, I know there is but one catholic church, but there have been, and be at this present, that take upon them the name of Christ and of his church, which be not so 〈…〉, as it is written, "There be they that call themsel•es apostles and be not so indeed, but the synagogue 〈…〉 and liars." And now it is with us as it was wi•h 〈…〉 two women in Solomon's time, which la• toge••er, and the 〈…〉 overlaid her child, and afterwa•ds went about to challenge the true mother'• child.
Chi. What a babbling is here with you now? I see you lack humility. You will go ••out to teach, and not to learn.
Phil. My lords, I must desire you to bear with my hasty speech, it is my infirmity of nature. All that I speak is to learn by, I wish you did understand all my mind, that I might be satisfied by you through better authority.
Phil. My lords, I must desire you to bear with my hasty speech, it is my infirmity of n•ture. All that I speak is to learn by, I wish you did understand all my mind, that I might be satisfied by you through better authority.
Chi. My lord, if it please your grace tur• the argument upon him which you have […], a•d let him show the succession of the bishops of his church, as we can do. How say you, can you show the succession of bishops in your church from time to time? I tell you this argument troubled Dr. Ridley so sore, that he could never answer it; yet he was a man well learned, I dare say you will say so.
Chi. My lord, if it please your grac• tur• the argument upon him which you have 〈…〉, a•d let him shew the succession of the bishops of his church, as we can do. How say you, can you shew the succession of bishops in your church from time to time? I tell you this argument troubled Dr. Ridley so sore, that he could never answer it; yet he was a man well learned, I dare say you will say so.
Phil. He was a man so learned, that I was not worthy to carry his books for learning.
Chi. I promise you he was never able to answer that. He was a man that I loved well, and he me; for he came unt• me divers times being in prison, and conferred with me▪
Phil. I wonder, my lord, you should make this argument, which you would turn upon me, for the trial of my church whereof I am, or that you would make bishop Ridley so ignorant that he was not able to answer it, since it is of no force. For behold, first I denied you that a local succession of bishops in one place is a necessary point alone to prove the catholic church by, and that which I have denied you cannot prove: and is it then reason that you should put me to the trial of that, which by you is unproved, and of no force to conclude against me?
Chi. I see, my lords, we do but lose our labours to reason with him, he thinketh himself better learned than we.
Phil. I take upon me the name of no learning. I boast of […] knowledge but of faith and of Christ, and that I am bound […] to know, as I am sure I do.
Phil. I take upon me the name of no learning. I boast of 〈…〉 knowledge but of faith and of Christ, and that I am bound 〈…〉 to know, as I am sure I do.
Chi. These heretics ta•e upon them to be sure of all things they stand in. You should say rather with humility, I trust I know Christ, than that you be sure thereof
Phil. Let him doubt of his fa••h that listeth; God giveth me grace always to believe that I am sure of true faith and favour in Christ.
Bath. How will you be able to answer heretics, but by determination of the known catholic church.
Phil. I am able to answer all heretics by the the word of God, and convince them of the same.
Chi. How arrogantly is that spoken! I dare not say so.
Phil. My lords, I pray you bear with me; for I am bold on truth's side, and I speak somewhat by experience that I have had with heretics: and I know the Arians be the subtlest that ever were, and yet I have manifest scriptures to beat them down withal.