pp. 18–1271,448 passagespart 9 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Cur. I can prove that Ireneus (which was within an hundred years after Christ) came to Victor, then bishop of Rome, to ask his advice about the excommunication of certain heretics, which (by all likelihood) he would not have done, if he had not taken him to be supreme head.
Cov. Mark well this argument. How are you able to answer the same? Answer if you can.
Phil. It is soon answered, my lord, for that is of no force; neither doth this fact of Ireneus make any more for the supremacy of the bishop of Rome, than mine hath done, who have been at Rome as well as he, and might have spoken with the pope if I had list; and yet I would none in England did favour his supremacy more than I.
St. Asaph. You are more to blame (by the faith of my body) for that you favour the same no better, since all the catholic church (until these few years) have taken him to be the supreme head of the church, besides this good man Ireneus.
Phil. That is not likely, that Ireneus so took him, or the primitive church: for I am able to show seven general councils after Ireneus's time, wherein he never took him for supreme head.
Phil. That is not likely, that Ireneus so took him, or the primitive church: for I am able to shew seven general councils after Ireneus's time, wherein he never took him for supreme head.
The other bishop. This man will never be satisfied, say what we can. It is but folly to reason any more with him.
Phil. O, my lords, would you have me satisfied with nothing? Judge, I pray you, who hath better authority, he which bringeth the example of one man going to Rome, or I that by these many general councils am able to prove, that he was never so taken in many hundred years after Christ, as by Nicene, Ephesine, the first and second Chalcedon, Constantinopolitan, Carthaginese, Aquilense.
Cov. Why will you not admit the church of Rome to be the catholic church?
Phil. Because it followeth not the primitive catholic church, neither agreeth with the same, no more than an apple is like a nut.
Cov. Wherein doth it dissent?
Phil. It were too long to recite all, but two things I will name, the supremacy and transubstantiation.
Cur. As for transubstantiation, albeit it was set forth and decreed for an article of faith not much above three hundred years ago, yet it was always believed in the church.
Bond. Yes, that it was. Very well said of you, Mr. Curtop.
Bon. Yes, that it was. Very well said of you, Mr. Curtop.
Phil. You have said right, that transubstantiation is but a late plantation of the bishop of Rome, and you are not able to show any ancient writer, that believed any such thing; and with this Curtop shrank away. And immediately after the ambassador of Spain came in, to whom my lord of London went, leaving the others with me. To whom I said, My lords, if you can show me that this church of Rome (whereof you are members) is the catholic church, I shall be con••nt to be one thereof, and as conformable to the same ⟨p. 37⟩as you can require me in all things; for I know there is no salvation but within the church.
Phil. You have said right, that transubstantiation is but a late plantation of the bishop of Rome, and you are not able to shew any ancient writer, that believed any such thing; and with this Curtop shrank away. And immediately after the ambassador of Spain came in, to whom my lord of London went, leaving the others with me. To whom I said, My lords, if you can shew me that this church of Rome (whereof you are members) is the catholic church, I shall be con••nt to be one thereof, and as conformable to the same ⟨p. 37⟩as you can require me in all things; for I know there is no salvation but within the church.
Cov. Can you disprove that the church of Rome is the catholic church?
Phil. Yes, that I am able, but I desire rather to hear of you the proof thereof. And seeing I cannot have my request at your hands, neither be satisfied with any probable authority, I will show you good proof why it is not. For if the primitive church were catholic, as it was indeed, and ought to be the form and school-mistress unto the world's end; then is not the church of Rome now the catholic church, which dissenteth so far from the same both in doctrine and use of the sacraments.
Phil. Yes, that I am able, but I desire rather to hear of you the proof thereof. And seeing I cannot have my request at your hands, neither be satisfied with any probable authority, I will shew you good proof why it is not. For if the primitive church were catholic, as it was indeed, and ought to be the form and school-mistress unto the world's end; then is not the church of Rome now the catholic church, which dissenteth so far from the same both in doctrine and use of the sacraments.
Cov. How prove you that the church of Rome now dissenteth in doctrine and use of the sacraments from the primitive church?
Phil. Compare the one with the other, and it shall soon appear; as you may see both in Eusebius and others ecclesiastical and ancient writers.
Cov. What have you to say more, why it is not the catholic church?
Phil. Because it is not [by your interpretation of Catholic] universal, neither ever was, albeit you falsely persuade the people it is so. For the world being divided into three parts, Asia, Africa, and Europe, two parts thereof, Asia and Africa, professing Christ as well as we, did never consent to the church of Rome, which is of Europe; which is a sufficient testimony that your faith was never universal.
Cov. How prove you that?
Phil. All the historians which write of the proceedings of the church, do testify the same. Besides that, this present time doth declare that to be true which I say▪ for at present the churches of Asia, and Africa, do not consent to the church of Rome. Yea, and besides all this, most part of Europe doth not agree, neither allow the church of Rome; as Germany, the kingdom of Denmark, the kingdom of Poland, a great part of France, England, and Zealand, which is a manifest probation that your church is not universal. AFTER this the bishop of London called away the other bishops, and left with me divers gentlem•n, with certain of his chaplains, as Dr. Saverson, an Englishman, who began with me in this manner.
Dr. Say. Mr. Philpot, I remember you beyond sea, since the time you reasoned with a friar, (a notable learned man) coming from Venice to Padua in a barge.
Dr. Sav. Mr. Philpot, I remember you beyond sea, since the time you reasoned with a friar, (a notable learned man) coming from Venice to Padua in a barge.
Phil. I cannot forget that; for the friar threatened to accuse me of heresy as soon as he came to Padua, because I talked to him so boldly of the truth. He was not so learned a man as you name him to be, but only in his school points a good purgatory friar.
Dr. Say. Well, he was a learned man for all that. And I am sorry that you this day, having communed with so many notable learned men, are no more conformable to them than you be.
Dr. Sav. Well, he was a learned man for all that. And I am sorry that you this day, having communed with so many notable learned men, are no more conformable to them than you be.
Phil. I will be conformable to all them that be conformable to Christ in his word. And I pray you, good Mr. Doctor, be not so conformable to please men more than God, contrary to your learning, for worldly estimation sake.
Dr. Say. No, that I am not. Upon what occasion should you think thus of me?
Dr. Sav. No, that I am not. Upon what occasion should you think thus of me?
Phil. Upon no evil that I do know of you, Mr. Doctor, but I speak as one wishing that you should not be led away from the truth, for promotion's sake, as many be now a-days.
Dr. Say. I have heard your arguments hitherto, and think that a great many of the old ancient writers be against you, in that you do not allow the church of Rome, neither the supremacy; for St. Cyprian (which is an ancient writer) doth allow the bishop of Rome to be supreme head of the church.
Dr. Sav. I have heard your arguments hitherto, and think that a great many of the old ancient writers be against you, in that you do not allow the church of Rome, neither the supremacy; for St. Cyprian (which is an ancient writer) doth allow the bishop of Rome to be supreme head of the church.
Phil. That I am sure he doth not. For he, writing to Cornelius, then bishop of Rome, calleth him but his companion and his fellow bishop, neither attributed to him the name either of pope, ⟨p. 38⟩or of any other usurped terms, which now be ascribed to the bishop of Rome, to the setting forth of his dignity.
Dr. Say. You cannot be able to show that St. Cyprian calleth Cornelius his fellow-bishop.
Dr. Sav. You cannot be able to shew that St. Cyprian calleth Cornelius his fellow-bishop.
Phil. I will wager you with what I am able to make, that I can show it you in St. Cyprian, as I have said.
Phil. I will wager you with what I am able to make, that I can shew it you in St. Cyprian, as I have said.
Dr. Say. I will lay no other wager with you but book for book, that it is not so.
Dr. Sav. I will lay no other wager with you but book for book, that it is not so.
Phil. I agree thereto, and I pray you one of my lord's chaplains to fetch us Cyprian hither for the trial hereof. And with that one of them went to my lord's study, and he brought forth Cyprian, and by and by he turned to the first book of his epistles, the third epistle, and there he would have seemed to gather a strong argument for the supremacy of the bishop of Rome, because he saith, "It goeth not well with the church when the high-priest is not obeyed, which supplieth the stead of Christ, after God's word, and the consent of his fellow-bishops, and the agreement of the people."
Dr. Say. How can you avoid this place which maketh so plainly for the bishop of Rome's supremacy?
Dr. Sav. How can you avoid this place which maketh so plainly for the bishop of Rome's supremacy?
Phil. It maketh not so plain, Mr. Doctor, on your side, as you gather, as by and by I will give you to understand. But first I challenge the wager which we made, that your book is mine. For here you may see that he calleth Cornelius his fellow-bishop, as he doth also in other places. And for the understanding of that place, you do misconstrue it, to take the high-priest only for the bishop of Rome, and otherwise than it was in his time. For there were by the Nicene council four patriarch of Constantinople, the patriarch of Alexandria, and the patriarch of Rome, of which four, the patriarch of Rome was placed lowest in the council, and so continued many years, for the time of seven or eight general councils, as I can show. THEREFORE St. Cyprian writing to Cornelius, patriarch of Rome, (whom he calleth his fellow-bishop) findeth himself offended that certain heretics, being justly excommunicated by him, (as the Novatians were) did flee from his diocese, which was their chief bishop, (refusing to be obedient to him and to be reformed) to the bishop of Rome, and the patriarch of Constantinople, and there were received in communion of the congregation, in derogation of good order and discipline in the church, and to the maintaining of heresies and schisms: and that heresies did spring up, and schisms daily rise hereof, that obedience was not given to the priest of God, nor was it once considered him to be in the church for the time the priest, and for the time the judge in Christ's stead, (as in the decree of the Nicene council was appointed) not the bishop of Rome only, but every patriarch in his precinct; who had every one of them a college or cathedral church of learned priests, in hearing of whom by a convocation of his fellow-bishops, with the consent of the people, all heresies were determined by the word of God: and this is the meaning of St. Cyprian.
Phil. It maketh not so plain, Mr. Doctor, on your side, as you gather, as by and by I will give you to understand. But first I challenge the wager which we made, that your book is mine. For here you may see that he calleth Cornelius his fellow-bishop, as he doth also in other places. And for the understanding of that place, you do misconstrue it, to take the high-priest only for the bishop of Rome, and otherwise than it was in his time. For there were by the Nicene council four patriarch of Constantinople, the patriarch of Alexandria, and the patriarch of Rome, of which four, the patriarch of Rome was placed lowest in the council, and so continued many years, for the time of seven or eight general councils, as I can shew. THEREFORE St. Cyprian writing to Cornelius, patriarch of Rome, (whom he calleth his fellow-bishop) findeth himself offended that certain heretis, being justly excommunicated by him, (as the Novatians were) did flee from his diocese, which was their chief bishop, (refusing to be obedient to him and to be reformed) to the bishop of Rome, and the patriarch of Constantinople, and there were received in communion of the congregation, in derogation of good order and discipline in the church, and to the maintaining of heresies and schisms: and that heresies did spring up, and schisms daily rise hereof, that obedience was not given to the priest of God, nor was it once considered him to be in the church for the time the priest, and for the time the judge in Christ's stead, (as in the decree of the Nicne council was appointed) not the bishop of Rome only, but every patriarch in his precinct; who had every one of them a college or cathedral church of learned priests, in hearing of whom by a convocation of his fellow-bishops, with the consent of the people, all heresies were determined by the word of God: and this is the meaning of St. Cyprian.
Dr. Say. You take it so, but it seemeth to me otherwise.
Dr. Sav. You take it so, but it seemeth to me otherwise.
Phil. Upon what ground it should seem otherwise unto you I know not, but this meaning which I have declared, the general councils, seven or eight, one after another, confirmed it so to be, which did not allow one supreme head only.
Pen. There were not so many general councils, but four only allowed.
Phil. That is not so, Mr. Pendleton, although there be four specially allowed for the confirmation of the Trinity: but besides these four, there were many other general councils, as you may learn by many writers.