Unto this master D. Gager replying and desiring Master Rainoldes to forbear, Master Rainoldes did rejoin as followeth.Vnto this maister D. Gager replying and desiring Maister Rainoldes to forbeare, Maister Rainoldes did reioine as followeth.
pp. 29–163154 passagespart 4 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
An other injury is it, that you term those proofs of mine, a comparison; and (which is more) a comparison without all measure. What hmeasure you did use in the meting out hereof, I can not guess: unless peradventure, because that you had heard that comparisons are odious, you hoped you should make all my proofs odious by naming them comparisons. For I, having noted, against your argument drawn from sports and recreations, that sports by the light of nature, are accounted unseemly, bad, infamous, and so is all stage-dancing; did allege the judgements of Romans, of Philistines, of ancient laws well nigh all, and of reason it self, as testimonies to prove that proposition by; not as comparisons, but as testimonies And therefore in the note of Arias Montanus, I did omit that he saith of 2the law of God condemning stage-plays likewise, because that might go higher then the light of nature. Otherwise, you may be sure that I, who cited him for mens laws, a thing of weaker proof, would not have omitted the law of GOD, his strongest argument. But if I had joined supernatural light to the light of nature, and had produced testimonies of the Scripture also: would you have replied, that, to allege the Scripture, is a comparison without all measure? You must by like reason. And what should stay you from it? All would have espied that it were no comparison. Why more, then the note of Arias Montanus? which yet, when you had cast my allegation of the Romans and Philistines in such a mould, that it could not appear I brought them in as testimonies; you named with them for company a comparison too. Though, seeing you are grieved with my applying of it against your stage-dancing, and that induced you to call it a comparison: me thinks you should have fastened that odious name rather on the proposition ⟨p. 135⟩proved by those testimonies. For the proofs reach not you immediately, they fight not nigh at hand: the proposition doeth; as being the major of that argument, whereof your stage-players make the minor. And the proposition, condemning all stage-dancing, doth give a deadlier wound; nether can it choose but light on your stage-dancing: the proofs might seem to be more easily avoided; or, coming so far off, to raze the skin only. Again, my applying of the proposition to you, by the assumption, would deserve more worthily the name of a comparison:
An other iniurie is it, that you terme those proofes of mine, a comparison; and (which is more) a comparison without all measure. What hmeasure you did vse in the meting out hereof, I can not guesse: vnlesse peradventure, because that you had heard that comparisons are odious, you hoped you should make all my proofes odious by naming them comparisons. For I, having noted, against your argument drawne from sports and recreations, that sports by the light of nature, are accounted vnseemelie, bad, infamous, and so is all stage-dansing; did alleage the iudgements of Romans, of Philistines, of ancient lawes well nigh all, and of reason it selfe, as testimonies to proove that proposition by; not as comparisons, but as testimonies And therefore in the note of Arias Montanus, I did omitt that he saith of 2the law of God condemning stage-playes likewise, because that might goe higher then the light of nature. Otherwise, you may be sure that I, who cited him for mens lawes, a thing of weaker proofe, would not have omitted the lawe of GOD, his strongest argument. But if I had ioyned supernaturall light to the light of nature, and had produced testimonies of the Scripture also: would you have replied, that, to alleage the Scripture, is a comparison without all measure? You must by like reason. And what should stay you from it? All would have espied that it were no comparison. Why more, then the note of Arias Montanus? which yet, when you had cast my allegation of the Romans and Philistines in such a mould, that it could not appeare I brought them in as testimonies; you named with them for company a comparison too. Though, seeing you are greeved with my applying of it against your stage-dansing, and that induced you to call it a cōparison: me thinks you should have fastned that odious name rather on the proposition ⟨p. 135⟩prooved by those testimonies. For the proofes reach not you immediatlie, they fight not nigh at hande: the proposition doeth; as being the maior of that argument, wherof your stage-players make the minor. And the proposition, condemning all stage-dansing, doth giue a deadlyer wound; nether can it choose but light on your stage-dansing: the proofes might seeme to be more easilie avoided; or, comming so farre off, to raze the skinne onely. Againe, my applying of the proposition to you, by the assumption, would deserve more woorthily the name of a comparison:
and the assumption being particular, or singular; the proposition universal; were not this applying of all against some, a comparison without all measure?
and the assumption being particular, or singular; the proposition vniversall; were not this applying of all against some, a comparison without all measure?
The third injurious part offered me in this point, is, that you allege the judgement of Homer and Sir Thomas Eliot, as making for that dancing, which I did reprove. And bringing in the former of them by a 3figure, saying, To omit Homers judgment thereof; him self you call an excellent observer of decorum in all things, and quote for his judgement ithe eight book of his Odyssea. Now, better had it ben••or you to omit him without a figure in deed: sith he, describing there the life of King Alcinous, and of his people, the Phaeacians, sayeth, that 4they took pleasure continually in feasting, and music, and dancing, and bravery of apparel, and hot baths, and chambering: wherein a lively pattern of a wanton, riotous, voluptuous, Epicures life, being set forth by Homer, as kHorace, lAthenaeus, mEustathius may teach you: if I should not have blamed dancing in your plays, because such an excellent observer of decorum saith the Phoeacians used it; then must the nbelly be your players God, because such an excellent observer of decorum saith the Phoeacians served it. Moreover seeing that the Music which the minstrel gave them to their dancing, was a 5song of Mars taken in adultery with Venus Vulcans wife; & you commend in dancing the number of the footing well expressing, answering, and as it were acting the measure and meaning of the Music: you see what good instructions you give men by extolling your excellent observer of decorum in all things. Add thereunto that he, so good an observer of decorum, maketh the ⟨p. 136⟩Phoeacian actors dance with 6others of their own sex, or 7single. Which how much, & why, it is more allowable, then men and women to dance together: I wish you to consider, by weighing, with examples mentioned in oScripture, the judgement of pDivines thereon. So shall you perceive, that Homer in the eight book of his Odyssea, hath no sufficient warrant for Melantho to dance together with Eurymachus, the maids with the wooers; no not though they were maids and Melantho in deed; much less for boys attired like Melantho, & maids, to dance with men upon a stage. The later of your authors you allege directly; and, that learned Knight Sir Thomas Eliot, say you, among other things that he writeth in a book of his, in the praise of dancing, compareth the man treading the measures, to Fortitude, and the woman on his hand, to Temperance.
The third iniurious part offered me in this point, is, that you alleage the iudgement of Homer and Syr Thomas Eliot, as making for that dansing, which I did reproove. And bringing in the former of them by a 3figure, saying, To omit Homers iudgment thereof; him self you call an excellent observer of decorum in all things, and quote for his iudgement ithe eight booke of his Odyssea. Now, better had it ben••or you to omit him without a figure in deede: sith he, describing there the life of King Alcinous, and of his people, the Phaeacians, saieth, that 4they tooke pleasure continually in feasting, and musicke, and daunsing, and braverie of apparell, and hott baths, and chambering: wherein a livelie paterne of a wanton, riotous, voluptuous, Epicures life, being sett foorth by Homer, as kHorace, lAthenaeus, mEustathius may teach you: if I should not haue blamed dansing in your playes, because such an excellent observer of decorum saith the Phoeacians vsed it; then must the nbelly bee your players God, because such an excellent observer of decorū saith the Phoeacians served it. Moreover seeing that the Musicke which the minstrell gave thē to their dansing, was a 5song of Mars taken in adulterie with Venus Vulcans wife; & you commend in dansing the number of the footing wel expressing, answering, and as it were acting the measure and meaning of the Musike: you see what good instructions you give men by extolling your excellent observer of decorum in all things. Adde therevnto that he, so good an observer of decorum, maketh the ⟨p. 136⟩Phoeacian actors danse with 6others of their owne sexe, or 7
3Praeteritio.
iOdyss. […].Odyss. 〈…〉.
4[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
kEpist. lib. 1. ep. 2. Alcinoique In cute curanda plus aequo operata juventus.Epist. lib. 1. ep. 2. Alcinoique In cute curanda plus aequo operata iuventus.
You add, that you have seen the book, and you remember he useth this comparison in it. But did you not remember the name of the book too? or was it for some special cause that you concealed it? your words might give a man occasion to think, that he had written a book in the praise of dancing: which that he did, I qfind not. I guess you mean therefore his book entitled the Governor. Wherein rhe praiseth Dancing, and uttereth somewhat like to that avouched by you, and streateth of circumstances (a point you touch also) which being all observed, dancing may be honestly and honourably used: But his speech of Fortitude and Temperance represented by men and maidens in a dance, cometh nothing near your maids and wooers measures, whereto you would stretch it. For, among diverse manners and kinds of dancing used in ancient time, he rehearseth one, wherein (as tLucian saith, translated word for word by him in a manner) 8danced young men and maidens; the man going before, and expressing 9such motions as he might afterward use in war; the maiden following him modestly and shamefastlie; so that it represented a pleasant conjunction of temperance & fortitude. Now those warlike motions were (as vPlato showeth, speaking of the like dance) gestures which resembled, partly the avoiding all sorts of wounds and blows by 1bending aside, by 2going back, by 3leaping up, by 4bowing down; partly ⟨p. 137⟩the enforcing of enemies by shooting 5arrows, and casting 6darts at them, and giving them 7all sorts of wounds. Wherefore this being it, that represented Fortitude in the dance described by Sir Thomas Eliot: far was it from his meaning to make your measures, your sober measures, warlike motions; or compare a wooer treading them, to Fortitude. As far, as to compare a boy doing the same in maidens likeness, to Temperance. Which, if you had otherwise expressed his sense rightly, yet should you have forborne to apply to yours for the observing of decorum, a thing that you commend so in Homer, and your self aim at: sith those maids and wooers, intended both by Homer and you, to be wantons, must use lascivious dances; and the man (if you will needs have such resemblances) be compared rather to Mollitude, or Cowardnes, the woman to Incontinence. Beside that, the praise which that learned Knight giveth unto dancing, he giveth it not simply;
You adde, that you have seene the booke, and you remember hee vseth this comparison in it. But did you not remember the name of the booke too? or was it for some speciall cause that you concealed it? your woordes might giue a man occasion to thinke, that he had written a booke in the praise of dansing: which that he did, I qfinde not. I guesse you meane therefore his booke entituled the Governour. Wherein rhe prayseth Dansing, and vttereth somewhat like to that avouched by you, and streateth of circumstances (a point you touch also) which being all observed, dansing may be honestlie and honorably vsed: But his speech of Fortitude and Temperance represented by men and maidens in a danse, commeth nothing neere your maides and wooers measures, whereto you would stretch it. For, among diverse maners and kindes of dansing vsed in ancient time, he rehearseth one, wherein (as tLucian saith, translated woord for woorde by him in a maner) 8dansed young men and maidens; the man going before, and expressing 9such motions as he might afterward vse in warre; the maiden following him modestly and shamefastlie; so that it represented a pleasant coniunction of temperance & fortitude. Now those warlike motions were (as vPlato sheweth, speaking of the like danse) gestures which resembled, partlie the avoiding all sortes of woundes and blowes by 1bending aside, by 2going backe, by 3leaping vp, by 4bowing downe; partlie ⟨p. 137⟩the enforcing of enimies by shooting 5
(for he saith xsome dances, do corrupt the minds of them that dance, and provoke sin:) but with limitation, to wit, ybeing used and continued in such form, and with such observations and rules, as he specifieth. Whereof the first (to name one for example) is, that, by the courtesy or reverent inclination made at beginning of dancing, the dancers and beholders should mark and remember this to be signified, that at the beginning of all our acts, we should do due honour to God, which is the root of prudence. And in deed if dancers in treading of their measures had such regards and meditations: then not Sir Thomas Eliot only, but the Fathers would praise dancing too. For, when godly Bishops assembled in the Councils of zLaodicea, and aIlarda, decreed that Christians ought not to dance at marriages; when St bChrysostom blamed women for so doing, as being a stain unto their sex; when St cAmbrose cited and averred that of dTully, that such as dance are drunk, or mad; when St eAustin said that it were better to spend the Sabbath day in digging & delving, then in dancing: they meant not to restrain men from marking, and remembering, that at the beginning of all their acts, they should do due honour to God; but they thought that dancers have commonly their minds on things of an other ⟨p. 138⟩quality. Which if your wooers and maidens also had; as (I am persuaded) them selves will not deny, and you seem to have thought by touching so nicely, or rather scarcely touching, the circumstances that you say should be observed in dancing: you abuse the name of that learned Knight, in urging his praise of a good dance that might be, against my dispraise of an ill dance that is. It had been more reason, that when his conceit carried him a little out of the way sometimes, as in that fhe praiseth Lucians stage-dancer, who danced the adultery of Mars and Venus with resembling of 8every act therein, (which I hope, your self would not allow on your stage;) you should have acknowledged that through too great a love of dancing, he liked too well of Lucians treatise: though otherwise he fancied not the author much; as ghe well declareth by noting of *his ribaldry, and his too much scorning; and by saying farther, It were better that a child should never read any part of Lucian, then all Lucian. Or, if the sentence of a Knight, so worthy, had such credit with you;
(for he saith xsome danses, doe corrupt the mindes of them that danse, and provoke sinne:) but with limitation, to weete, ybeing vsed and continued in such forme, and with such observations and rules, as hee specifieth. Whereof the first (to name one for example) is, that, by the curtesie or reverent inclination made at beginning of dansing, the dansers and beholders should marke and remember this to be signified, that at the beginning of all our actes, we should doe due honour to God, which is the roote of prudence. And in deede if dansers in treading of their measures had such regards and meditations: then not Syr Thomas Eliot onely, but the Fathers would praise dansing too. For, when godly Bishops assembled in the Councells of zLaodicea, and aIlarda, decreed that Christians ought not to danse at mariages; when St bChrysostome blamed women for so doeing, as being a staine vnto their sexe; when St cAmbrose cited and averred that of dTullie, that such as danse are drunke, or madde; when St eAustin said that it were better to spend the Sabbat day in digging & delving, then in dansing: they meant not to restraine men from marking, and remembring, that at the beginning of all their actes, they should doe due honour to God; but they thought that dansers haue commonlie their mindes on thinges of an other ⟨p. 138⟩qualitie. Which if your wooers and maidens also had; as (I am perswaded) them selves will not deny, and you seeme to have thought by touching so nicely, or rather scarcelie touching, the circumstāces that you say should be observed in dansing: you abuse the name of that learned Knight, in vrging his prayse of a good danse that might bee, against my disprayse of an ill danse that is. It had bene more reason, that when his conceit caried him a litle out of the way sometimes, as in that f
why did you not consider hhis religious wish, that the names of idols, of Paynim Gods and Goddesses, were not used at this day in ballads and ditties, to the corrupting of many good wits with godless fantasies? For though his reproof do specially touch the most vile idols, Venus, and Bacchus, remembered so in dancing-songs as if the dance were to their honour and memory; a matter most abhorring from Christs religion, and savouring of the ancient error of Paganism: yet as the iScripture, the ground of his reproof, doeth generally condemn such naming of other Gods, semblably he showeth, that, if you had attributed so much to his judgement, you should have eschewed that fault in your tragedy. At least, where the words are uttered as it were in your own person: as kthose of 9the Gods enlightened or beautified by Homers fables are. Perhaps, where players of other mens persons also speak: as lUlysses, and mEumaeus, adoring spirits of 1Devils, or of dead 2men, and 3women, with sacrifices and prayers; nTelemachus 4swearing by Jupiter; oPhilaetius, first 5blaspheming GOD under Jupiter's name, then 6confessing to him that there are Gods in heaven. Chiefly seeing that these speeches are delivered ⟨p. 139⟩by the flower of those persons, by whose parts (you say) no hurt could come to any man: and Sir Thomas Eliot thought that such speeches, savouring of Paganism, might corrupt good wits. But howsoever you shall distinguish your Poem from the ballads and ditties, in which he controlleth this irreligious custom of giving the honour of God to vile idols: your self do bear witness that he commendeth not the dancing of Eurymachus & the rest of your wooers with their Melanthos on the stage. For among the parts of their dissolute behaviour imagined to be done within, you rehearse their 7dancing: and that in the person, not of a carping Momus, but of wise pTelemachus. Now look what was imagined to be done within, the same was expressed on the stage in part, by your own confession: as Telemachus also saith, that in 8their manners at home they kept their wont, Their dancing on the stage then, your self acknowledge, was unhonest dancing. And the dancing praised by Sir Thomas Eliot is honest dancing, you say. Therefore you do manifest wrong unto us both, in alleging him as praising that which I dispraised.
why did you not consider hhis religious wish, that the names of idoles, of Paynim Gods and Goddesses, were not vsed at this day in balades and dities, to the corrupting of many good wittes with godlesse fantasies? For though his reproofe doe specially touch the most vile idoles, Venus, and Bacchus, remembred so in dansing-songs as if the danse were to their honour and memorie; a matter most abhorring from Christes religion, and savouring of the ancient errour of Paganisme: yet as the iScripture, the ground of his reproofe, doeth generallie condemne such naming of other Gods, semblably he sheweth, that, if you had attributed so much to his iudgement, you should haue eschewed that fault in your tragedie. At least, wher the woords are vttered as it were in your owne person: as kthose of 9the Gods enlightned or beautificd by Homers fables are. Perhaps, where players of other mens persons also speake: as lUlysses, and mEumaeus, adoring spirits of 1Devills, or of dead 2men, and 3women, with sacrifices and prayers; nTelemachus 4swearing by Iuppiter; oPhilaetius, first 5blaspheming GOD vnder Iuppiters name, then 6confessing to him that there are Gods in heaven. Chieflie seeing that these speeches are delivered ⟨p. 139⟩
qWhen the Lacedaemonians had accused the Thebans of many and grievous matters: In deed, quoth Epaminondas, 9these have made you give over your short form of speaking. I wish I might be short, as were the Lacedaemonians; but you constrain me to be long: you deal so Theban-like continually with me. A doubtful word being used in a question of yours, 1whether we account it a loss recitare, to recite Seneca; Whereunto I answered that it is one thing 2to recite, another thing 3to play, as I declared by sundry writers; and added that I would have been content to hear your tragedy recited; had it been recited or pronounced only; you reply that the word is used in Quintilian; not onely de scripto, but also memoriter recitare; and therefore you might use it indifferently, for agere, in a general acceptation; moreover, that as Horace and Persius do scoff bitterly at recitatores also, and the law in the generality of the term noteth also with imfamie, them, qui pronuntiandi, that is properly, recitandi causa in scenam prodeunt: so the University would have thought it a more absurd thing to have heard you, or any other, ⟨p. 140⟩openly reading your Ulysses to them, then to have seen it acted as it was. Wherein to the intent you may see how you play the Theban, I will use a comparison, and that within some measure I trust. rPlutarch hath written a dialogue to prove that brute beasts have reason as well as men have: in jest peradventure, seeing he maketh it to be avouched by 4Gryllus: or meaning, that they have a natural sagacity and understanding like to reason, not reason capable of Religion, as in the 5conclusion he seemeth to insinuate, and a scertain Christian writer hath maintained, though speaking not so fitly in saying they have reason, sith the tScripture termeth them 6Creatures void of reason. But suppose that some man being of Gryllus mind, (or let us call him Gryllus for more perspicuity, and make Sempronius likewise his adversaries name;) suppose then that Gryllus having asked this question, 7Do you think that animal, a living creature endued with sense, wanteth reason? Sempronius answered him, that animal is one thing, and a beast an other, as vTully declareth, affirming a 8man (whom he calleth animal) to be full of reason, whereof he saith, that 9no beast at all is partaker.
qWhen the Lacedaemonians had accused the Thebans of manie and greevous matters: In deed, quoth Epaminondas, 9these have made you give over your short forme of speaking. I wishe I might be short, as were the Lacedaemonians; but you constraine me to be long: you deale so Theban-like continually with me. A doubtfull woord being vsed in a question of yours, 1whether we account it a losse recitare, to recite Seneca; Wherevnto I answered that it is one thing 2to recite, another thing 3to play, as I declared by sundrie writers; and added that I would have bene content to heare your tragedie recited; had it bene recited or pronounced onely; you reply that the woord is vsed in Quintilian; not onely de scripto, but also memoriter recitare; and therefore you might vse it indifferentlie, for agere, in a generall acceptatiō; moreover, that as Horace and Persius doe scoffe bitterly at recitatores also, and the law in the generalitie of the terme noteth also with imfamie, them, qui pronuntiandi, that is properly, recitandi causa in scenam prodeunt: so the Universitie would have thought it a more absurd thing to have heard you, or any other, ⟨p. 140⟩openly reading your Vlysses to them, then to have seene it acted as it was. Wherein to the intent you may see how you play the Theban, I will vse a comparison, and that within some measure I trust. rPlutarch hath written a dialogue to proove that brute beastes haue reason as well as men haue: in iest peradvēture, seeing he maketh it to be avouched by 4Gryllus: or meaning, that they haue a naturall sagacitie and vnderstanding like to reason, not reason capable of Religion, as in the 5conclusion he seemeth to insinuate, and a scertaine Christian writer hath mainteined, though speaking not so fitlie in saying they have reason, sith the t
qPlutarch. apophthe. reg. & imperat.
9[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
1Senecamne tu recitare jacturam putes?
2Recitare.
3Agere.
r[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
4[Greek or Hebrew] a pig, or hog.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 a pigge, or hogge.
If Gryllus should reply that the word is used in xOvid for 1all things that have life and sense, not for men only, and therefore he might use it indifferently for beasts in a general acceptation: would not they, who see, that belike he meant to comprehend men also under that general word, thereby the more closely to fetch in beasts with them; and that, restraining it to beasts, his question must be, Think you that beasts want reason? which were an idle question, and openly implying a begging of the point in controversy; would they not, I say, condemn him as a wrangling and contentious Sophister? Now, if in the same vain, or rather in a worse, he should add moreover, that as yHorace and zPersius speak scoffingly of mad men too, and the alaw appointeth gar••s for idiots, that is properly, for men wanting the use of re•; so the grave Athenian bench of Areopagus would judge it more absurd to say that men have reason, then that beasts have it, chiefly certain beasts, as 2horses and ⟨p. 141⟩oxen dancing upon stages in a more exquisite manner then men are lightly able: would not this speech of Gryllus show that he deserveth a sharper commendation, then Plutarch by praising 3his sophistry meant unto him? Here your usual dealing causeth me to fear that you will ask whether I make you a Gryllus. As bwhen a Catholic Bishop, being rebuked by an Arian Emperor for standing alone with Athanasius against the whole world, said that the doctrine of faith was not impeached though he alone maintained it, seeing that of old time cthree alone were found who stood against the Kings commandment: What? quoth an Eunuch, 4doest thou make our Emperor a Nebuchadnezzar? But, I pray you, leave this Eunuchs odious practise in racking my comparisons: and mark the main point whereat I aim in them, and which I seek to open by them. For, as in Gryllus question, and verse, framed like yours, the circumstances give, that he used the general word comprising man, thereby to breed a fancy that if this kind of animal have reason, why not the other? In like sort your express mention of 5reading, I say, of reading, not of playing, in showing what a jewel you take the reciting of Seneca to be; maketh it probable that you meant to do by the generality of the word recitare.
If Gryllus should reply that the woord is vsed in xOvid for 1all things that have life and sense, not for men onely, and therfore he might vse it indifferently for beasts in a general acceptatiō: would not they, who see, that belike he meant to comprehend men also vnder that generall woord, thereby the more closely to fetch in beastes with them; and that, restraining it to beasts, his question must bee, Thinke you that beastes want reason? which were an idle question, and openly implying a begging of the point in controversie; would they not, I say, condemne him as a wrangling and contentious Sophister? Now, if in the same vaine, or rather in a woorse, he should adde moreover, that as yHorace and zPersius speake scoffingly of mad men too, and the alaw appointeth gar••s for idiots, that is properly, for men wanting the vse of re•; so the grave Athenian bench of Areopagus would iudge it more absurd to say that men haue reason, then that beasts haue it, chieflie certaine beastes, as 2horses and ⟨p. 141⟩oxen dansing vpon stages in a more exquisit maner then men are lightlie able: would not this speech of Gryllus shew that he deserveth a sharper commendation, then Plutarch by praysing 3his sophistrie meant vnto him? Here your vsuall dealing causeth mee to feare that you will aske whether I make you a Gryllus. As bwhen a Catholike Bishop, being rebuked by an Arian Emperour for standing alone with Athanasius against the whole worlde, said that the doctrine of faith was not impeached though he alone mainteined it, seeing that of olde time cthree alone were found who stoode against the Kings commandement: What? quoth an Eunuche,
xMetamor. lib. 1.
1Pronaque cùm spectent animalia caetera terram, os homini sublime dedit.
yEpist lib. 1. epi. 1.
zSatyr. 3.
aL. 2. D. de postulando. l. 2. D. de curatorib. suriosor.
2[Greek or Hebrew], saith Gryll• in Plutarch.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, saith Gryll• in Plutarch.
5Cuius vel unum simile carminibus me• Benigna carmen malo posteritas legate: legate, you say, not agat; though agat would have fitted the verse as well as legate.Cuius vel vnum simile carminibus me• Benigna carmen malo posteritas legat: legat, you say, not agat; though agat would haue fitted the verse as well as legat.
The more, because you used it not only in your verse, where your excuse might serve, that it stood better then agere would in that place; as Gryllus might say likewise for versifying animal rather, then bestiam: but in your prose also, the 6title of your tragedy; as if Gryllus, setting down the point controversed between him and Sempronius, should make it, utrum animal sit rationis expers; where the word 7bestia, would serve as fitly in prose; nay, (if plain dealing were meant) a great deal more fitly. And if you intended not to make that reason which I supposed you did, it is no loss to recite Seneca, Ergo no loss to play him: but meant to use the general word for the special, and to ask Momus only, Think you it a loss to play Seneca? then you begged at Momus hand, or took as granted, the point you should have proved; sith the playing of Seneca was condemned by him, and you undertook to confute his arguments. Again, as Horace, Persius, the law, alleged ⟨p. 142⟩by Gryllus, do show that certain men want the use of reason, but neither prove that beasts have it, nor that mankind wanteth it; and his presumed testimony of the Areopagus, brought in with a particle of similitude, So, as hitting jump with Horace, Persius, and the law, is too too absurd: in like sort the same authors, alleged by your self, do show that some reciters are misliked by them, but neither prove that players are liked, nor all reciters misliked; and the Universities testimony which you bring in with the same particle, as hitting jump with those authors, I can not say you bring it altogether as Gryllus, but you bring it strangely. For dHorace scoffeth at them, who 8recite their writings out of due place or time, and are 9importunately displeasant: ePersius, at 1wantons reciting 2wanton verses, with an 3effeminate voice, and a 4vainglorious mind. The law noteth with infamy such as come upon the stage to recite: belike, for their vain-glorious desire of 5being seen, and 6getting mens applause, which Persius jesteth at. Now in that you add hereto the University, and make us join with the former in opinion, saying; So the University would have thought it a more absurd thing, to have heard me, or any other, openly reading my Ulysses to them, then to have seen it acted, as it was: what mean you by this term, So?
The more, because you vsed it not onely in your verse, where your excuse might serve, that it stoode better then agere would in that place; as Gryllus might say likewise for versifying animal rather, then bestiam: but in your prose also, the 6title of your tragedie; as if Gryllus, setting downe the point controversed betweene him and Sempronius, should make it, vtrum animal sit rationis expers; where the woorde 7bestia, would serve as fitlie in prose; nay, (if plaine dealing were meant) a great deale more fitlie. And if you intended not to make that reason which I supposed you did, it is no losse to recite Seneca, Ergo no losse to play him: but meant to vse the generall woorde for the speciall, and to aske Momus onely, Thinke you it a losse to play Seneca? thē you begged at Momus hand, or tooke as graunted, the point you should haue prooved; sith the playing of Seneca was condemned by him, and you vndertooke to confute his arguments. Againe, as Horace, Persius, the law, alleaged ⟨p. 142⟩by Gryllus, doe shew that certaine men want the vse of reason, but neither proove that beasts haue it, nor that mankind wanteth it; and his presumed testimonie of the Areopagus, brought in with a particle of similitude, So, as hitting iumpe with Horace, Persius, and the law, is too too absurd: in like sort the same autours, alleaged by your selfe, doe shew that some reciters are misliked by them, but neither prove that players are liked, nor all reciters misliked; and the Vniversities testimonie which you bring in with the same particle, as hitting iumpe with those autours, I can not say you bring it altogether as Gryllus, but you bring it strangely. For dHorace scoffeth at them, who 8recite their writings out of due place or time, and are 9importunatlie displeasant: ePersius, at 1wantons reciting 2wanton verses, with an 3
6Tragoedia nova, in aede Christi recitata.Tragoedia noua, in aede Christi recitata.
7In the larger sense, that Tully giveth it: Tusc quae. lib. 5. De nat. Deor. lib. 2. not in the stricter of your Lawyers: l. 1. § removet. D de postulando. l. 1. §. in bestiis. D. si quadrup. pauper. sec. di.In the larger sense, that Tullie geueth it: Tusc quae. lib. 5. De nat. Deor. lib. 2. not in the stricter of your Lawiers: l. 1. § removet. D de postulando. l. 1. §. in bestiis. D. si quadrup. pauper. sec. di.
dSatyr. lib. […]. sat. 4. &. De art. poët.Satyr. lib. 〈…〉. sat. 4. &. De art. poët.
8In medio qui Scripta foro recitent, sunt multi, quique lavantes.
9Indoctum doctumque fugat recitator acerbus.
eSatyr. 1.
1Patranti fractus ocello.
2Quum carnima lúbum Intrant, & tremulo scalpuntur ubi in•ma versu.
4Quo didicisse, nisi hoc fermentum, & qua semel intus innata est, rupto jecore exierit caprificus? & usque adeò ne Scire •uú nihil est, nisi te scire hoc sciat alter?Quo didicisse, nisi hoc fermentum, & qua semel intus innata est, rupto jecore exierit caprificus? & vsque adeò ne Scire •uú nihil est, nisi te scire hoc sciat alter?
5Populo, pexusque, togaque recenti, & natalitia tandem cum sardonyche albus, Seed legens celsa.Populo, pexusque, togaque recenti, & natalitia tandem cum sardonyche albus, Sede legens celsa.
That if you, or an other, had read your Ulysses openly unto them, it had been done out of due place, or due time? or, they should have heard wanton verses read? or wantonly? or by a wanton? or with a vain-glorious mind? or on the stage? In deed, they should have heard 7some wanton verses, I grant: and both out of due place, and time, if you had read it 8where, & 9when it was acted. Neither do I doubt but the University would have thought such open reading, of such stuff, on such a day, absurd: though, whether more absurd, then to have seen it acted as it was, I know not. But whatsoever they would have thought in this comparison, wherein the flaw, that you cite, noting both with infamy, should give (me thinks) a deeper print thereof to acting then reading, all things weighed: you are far ⟨p. 143⟩from hitting the mark, whereat you shoot; namely, from convincing by the Universities testimony, and judgement, my sentence as absurd, that if your tragedy had been recited only, I would have accounted it no more loss of time to have heard you pronounce it, then my self to read it. For, I did not mean, if it had been recited as those were, which the authors by you alleged, do reprove: but as gHorace used to 1recite his own writings; as 2poems were recited to Quintilius Varus; as hPersius did recite his book unto Cornutus, before he published it. Whereof if you pronounce (as you do, if you speak to purpose) that our University would have thought it a more absurd thing, then to have seen it acted as it was: you deal in like manner with our University, as Gryllus with the reverend bench of Areopagus, if he should abuse their name and estimation, to persuade that brute beasts have more reason, then the wisest men have.
That if you, or an other, had read your Vlysses openly vnto them, it had bene done out of due place, or due time? or, they should haue heard wanton verses read? or wantonly? or by a wanton? or with a vaine-glorious minde? or on the stage? In deede, they should haue heard 7some wanton verses, I graunt: and both out of due place, and time, if you had read it 8where, & 9when it was acted. Neither doe I doubt but the Universitie would haue thought such open reading, of such stuffe, on such a day, absurd: though, whether more absurd, then to haue seene it acted as it was, I know not. But whatsoever they would haue thought in this comparison, wherein the flaw, that you cite, noting both with infamie, should giue (mee thinkes) a deeper print thereof to acting then reading, all things weighed: you are farre ⟨p. 143⟩from hitting the marke, whereat you shoote; namely, from cō vincing by the Universities testimonie, and iudgement, my sentence as absurd, that if your tragedie had bene recited onely, I would have accounted it no more losse of time to haue heard you pronounce it, then my selfe to reade it. For, I did not meane, if it had bene recited as those were, which the autours by you alleaged, doe reproove: but as gHorace vsed to 1recite his owne writings; as 2poëmes were recited to Quintilius Uarus; as hPersius did recite his booke vnto Cornutus, before he published it. Whereof if you pronounce (as you doe, if you speake to purpose) that our Universitie would haue thought it a more absurd thing, then to have seene it acted as it was: you deale in like maner with our Vniversitie, as Gryllus with the reverend bench of Areopagus, if he should abuse their name and estimation, to perswade that brute beastes have more reason, then the wisest men have.
7In Melanthos part, & Eurymachus.
8Qui pronuntiandi causa in scenam prodierit.
9Die Dominico.
fL. 1. D. de his qui not. infam.
gLib. 1. sat 4.
1Non recite cuiquam, nisi amicis, idque coactus. Non ubivis corámve quibuslibet.Non recite cuiquam, nisi amicis, idque coactus. Non vbiuis corámve quibuslibet.
2Quintilio si quid recitares corrige sodes Hoc aiebat, & hoc. Hora. de art. poet.
hPersii vita. Gloss. vet. […] Persium.Persii vita. Gloss. vet. 〈…〉 Persium.
Hereto would be annexed that, which in the fourth and, last head of reasons, you urge again concerning our Universities judgement for the approbation of your plays in general: if your interlaced defence of wasteful cost in setting forth thereof (the only point remaining besides) were discussed. And this is easily done, considering what hath been already proved against you touching the inconveniences and mischiefs of your plays. For having made Momus object the great charges; which how great they were, you know better then I, who summed them perhaps too much beneath the due when I did mention thirty pound; but having made him say that it should have been bestowed on the poor rather, you take him up with three answers: one, that the money was your own, not his; an other, that the charge, though great to him, was mean to you; the third, that none would give the less to the poor for that, none would have given the more without it. All the which I showed to be of no force for warranting of expenses on things of that quality, because, both unhonest spending of a mans own, is wastefulness & riot, condemned by our Saviour in the prodigal son: and, as Nero giving much to get a Plaudit, was the less able to help the poor by so much, and the less willing too perhaps; in like ⟨p. 144⟩sort may you be. Hereupon you demand of me, What similitude is there, or can there be, between the prodigal son, that in such a sort, as he did, spent all, and brought him self to the extremest misery; and between your expense? A question, which you would not have pressed, as you do; for your unlikeness to him in that he wasted all, and brought him self to extreme misery thereby: if you had considered that 3word in the original text of the Gospel, whereto my quotation for iriot did direct you. For usually it noteth the quality of expenses made by loose & wanton persons on their pleasures, as in foreign writers, kAristotle and lTully; so in mScripture likewise: and, to that effect in the same parable of the prodigal son is it said nafterward, that he devoured his goods 4with harlots. Now, in Rome, of old time, there were common 5harlots to be hired for 6two pence half-penny. The price in our days, by reason of the otribute, which they are to pay the Pope, may be enhanced.
Hereto would be annexed that, which in the fourth and, last head of reasons, you vrge againe concerning our Universities iudgement for the approbation of your playes in generall: if your interlaced defense of wastfull cost in setting foorth therof (the onely point remaining besides) were discussed. And this is easilie done, considering what hath bene alreadie prooved against you touching the inconveniences and mischifes of your playes. For having made Momus obiect the great charges; which how great they were, you know better then I, who summed them perhaps too much beneath the due whē I did mention thirtie pound; but having made him say that it should haue bene bestowed on the poore rather, you take him vp with three answeres: one, that the mony was your own, not his; an other, that the charge, though great to him, was meane to you; the thirde, that none would give the lesse to the poore for that, none would have given the more without it. All the which I shewed to be of no force for warrāting of expēses on things of that qualitie, because, both vnhonest spending of a mans owne, is wastfulnes & riott, condemned by our Saviour in the prodigall sonne: and, as Nero giving much to gett a Plaudite, was the lesse able to help the poore by so much, and the lesse willing too perhaps; in like ⟨p. 144⟩sort may you be. Herevpon you demand of me, What similitude is there, or can there be, betweene the prodigall sonne, that in such a sort, as he did, spent all, and brought him selfe to the extreemest miserie; and betweene your expense? A question, which you would not have pressed, as you doe; for your vnlikenes to him in that he wasted all, and brought him selfe to extreeme miserie thereby: if you had considered that 3woord in the originall text of the Gospell, whereto my quotation for iriott did direct you. For vsually it noteth the qualitie of expenses made by loose & wanton persons on their pleasures, as in forein writers, kAristotle and lTullie; so in mScripture likewise: and, to that effect in the same parable of the prodigall sonne is it said nafterward, that he devoured his goods 4
6Two oboli being the third part of drachma, or denarius; & eight drachma, or denarii, weighing an ounce of silver.Two oboli beeing the third part of drachma, or denarius; & eight drachma, or denarii, weighing an ounce of siluer.
oJo. Athon. gloss. in constit. Othon. de concubin. clericor. removend. Fr. Sansovin. de administr. regnor & rerumpub. lib. 11. cap. de mareschallo.Io. Athon. gloss. in constit. Othon. de concubin. clericor. remouend. Fr. Sansouin. de administr. regnor & rerumpub. lib. 11. cap. de mareschallo.
But if one, desirous of an harlots company, could have her so cheap, and should plead for him self that the money he spendeth on her is his own, & the charge not great, neither would he give the less unto the poor for that, nor more without it: were this a lawful bar to stay us from accusing him of 7riot, I mean, of wasteful and unhonest spending; (give it a fitter English name, if you know any; I took that which our best interpreters agree on;) but might we not accuse him thereof upon the same ground that Scripture doeth the prodigal son? Or, if some Preacher, more severe then pCato, should deal so strictly and rigorously with him; might he ask what similitude there is, or can be, between his expense of two pence half-penny, and the prodigal son, who in such a sort, as he did, spent all, and brought himself to the extremest misery? Much fault have you found with my hard incomparable comparisons and similitudes; & some of them are 8hard in deed, though none incomparable: but I must say thereof, as the Apostle of his boasting, qyou have compelled me. For when I took a softer and more gentle course, as here, to encounter that answer made to Momus, Thou sayest the charge is great; but thou mayst come, and look on, Momus, and pay nothing, no man doeth ask thee a penny; ⟨p. 145⟩I resembled it to an answer which the prodigal son might thus have made to his reprover, Thou blamest me for wasting, but I wast none of thine; thou mayst drink with me scot-free, if thou be a good fellow, & welcome: albeit the very word, wasting, might have showed I meant unhonest spending, (for rthings spent honestly are not wasted,) chiefly sith I used it in respect of the riot noted by our Saviour; and in the unthrifts speech, drawing good fellows to drink with him, I pointed to his lusty, excessive, dissolute sdrinkings with lewd companions like himself; yet you did reply, that, if he had been as moderate and thrifty in spending at his board, as you were at your plays, he might well enough have said to any niggard, that should have unwisely found fault with him, as much as I make him say, not with the note of a prodigal, but with the commendation of an ingenuous and liberal disposition.
But if one, desirous of an harlots company, could have her so cheape, and should pleade for him self that the moony he spendeth on her is his owne, & the charge not great, neither would he geve the lesse vnto the poore for that, nor more without it: were this a lawfull barre to stay vs from accusing him of 7riott, I meane, of wastfull and vnhonest spending; (give it a fitter English name, if you know any; I tooke that which our best interpreters agree on;) but might we not accuse him thereof vpon the same ground that Scripture doeth the prodigall sonne? Or, if some Preacher, more severe then pCato, should deale so strictly and rigorously with him; might he aske what similitude there is, or can be, betweene his expense of two pence half-peny, and the prodigall sonne, who in such a sort, as he did, spent all, and brought himselfe to the extremest miserie? Much fault haue you found with my hard incomparable comparisons and similitudes; & some of them are 8hard in deede, though none incōparable: but I must say thereof, as the Apostle of his boasting, qyou haue compelled me. For when I tooke a softer and more gentle course, as here, to encounter that aunswere made to Momus, Thou saist the charge is great; but thou mayst come, and looke on, Momus, and pay nothing, no man doeth aske thee a peny; ⟨p. 145⟩I resembled it to an aunswere which the prodigall sonne might thus haue made to his reproover, Thou blamest me for wasting, but I wast none of thine; thou mayst drinke with me scotfree, if thou be a good felow, & welcome: albeit the very woord, wasting, might haue shewed I meant vnhonest spending, (for rthinges spent honestly are not wasted,) chiefly sith I vsed it in respect of the riot noted by our Saviour; and in the vnthrifts speech, drawing good felowes to drinke with him, I pointed to his lusty, excessive, dissolute sdrinkings with lewde companions like himselfe; yet you did reply, that, if hee had bene as moderate and thrifty in spending at his boord, as you were at your playes, he might well enough have said to any niggard, that should haue vnwisely found fault with him, as much as I make him say, not with the note of a prodigall, but with the commendation of an ingenuous and liberall disposition.
7[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
pHorat. satyrar. li 1. sat. 2
8Sed quid opus teneras mordaci radere vero Auricolas? Pers. sat. 1.
Whereby you make me see, to what reproachful contumelies of a niggardly mind, and want of wisdom and discretion, I should have laid my self open, if I had still endeavoured to disclose unto you the weakness of your answers by gentle similitudes. That similitude therefore of mine, the tender smoothness whereof occasioned you to mistake my meaning, and entertain it so coarsely, I have now corrected with substituting a rougher, which may deliver you from error, and me from such taunts. For seeing you perceive this to be my meaning, that the threefold answer made by you to Momus is like as if tGallonius, or some other Epicure, reproved by a Stoic for going to the stews, should answer him; Thou blamest me for spending two pence half-penny on a wench, but I spend none of thine; thou mayest go with me thither, if thou be a good fellow, & I will give her as much for thee too; the charge, though it seem great to thee, is small to me; neither will I bestow a dodkin less upon the poor for that, nor more without it: you will not reply, that if Gallonius had been as moderate and thrifty in his spending at his bed, as you were at your plays, (they cost a number of you more, you wot, in several, then twice two pence half-penny;) he might well enough have said to any niggard, that should have unwisely found fault with him, as much as I make him say, not with the note of a prodigal, but with the ⟨p. 146⟩commendation of an ingenuous and liberal disposition. And so, by the other similitude likewise mended, and as it were rough hewen, you may the better learn to discern my drift, and spare your own replying. For when, to discover the poverty of your answer touching the poor, I said, that Nero peradventure was either less able, or less willing to help the poor, by reason of five or six thousand pound given for a Plaudit; which charge notwithstanding he might better bear, then some of your students may five or six shillings: you replied, that, if Nero could have as well spared such huge sums of money, which he spent that way often, as your House, with the company in it, and belonging to it, can once in many years thirty pounds: Nero should have been wronged greatly, being an Emperor, to have been noted of wastefulness; and, if ever he had any such good mind, he mought nevertheless have relieved the poor.
Whereby you make mee see, to what reprochefull contumelies of a niggardly minde, and want of wisedome and discretion, I should haue laid my selfe open, if I had still endevoured to disclose vnto you the weaknes of your aunswers by gentle similitudes. That similitude therefore of mine, the tender smoothnes whereof occasioned you to mistake my meaning, and intertaine it so coursly, I have now corrected with substituting a rougher, which may deliver you from errour, and me from such tantes. For seeing you perceve this to be my meaning, that the threefold answer made by you to Momus is like as if tGallonius, or some other Epicure, reprooved by a Stoike for going to the stewes, should answer him; Thou blamest me for spending two pence half-peny on a wench, but I spend none of thine; thou maist goe with me thither, if thou be a good felow, & I will give her as much for thee too; the charge, though it seeme great to thee, is small to me; neither will I bestow a dodkin lesse vpon the poore for that, nor more without it: you will not reply, that if Gallonius had bene as moderate and thrifty in his spending at his bedde, as you were at your playes, (they cost a number of you more, you wote, in severall, then twise two pence halfe-peny;) hee might well enough have said to any niggard, that should haue vnwisely found fault with him, as much as I make him say, not with the note of a prodigall, but with the ⟨p. 146⟩commendation of an ingenuous and liberall disposition. And so, by the other similitude likewise mended, and as it were rough hewen, you may the better learne to discerne my drift, and spare your owne replying. For when, to discover the povertie of your aunswere touching the poore, I said, that Nero peradventure was either lesse able, or lesse willing to helpe the poore, by reason of five or sixe thousand pownd given for a Plaudite; which charge notwithstanding he might better beare, then some of your students may fiue or six shillings: you replyed, that, if Nero could haue as well spared such huge summes of moony, which hee spent that way often, as your House, with the company in it, and belonging to it, can once in many yeares thirty powndes: Nero should haue bene wronged greatly, being an Emperour, to haue bene noted of wastfulnes; and, if ever hee had any such good minde, hee mought neverthelesse haue releeved the poore.
Now, altering and changing Neros charge on Plaudit into vhis charge on Act (a harlot whom he loved better then his wife,) and telling you that he was less able, or less willing (nay, both) to help the poor, by reason of 9gifts bestowed on her: I shall not hear, I trust, that, if Nero could have as well spared the sundry sums of money which he spent that way often, as your House, with the company in it, and belonging to it, can once in many years thirty pounds: Nero should have been wronged greatly, being an Emperor, to have been noted of wastefulness. No, not, though in adding that clause, being an Emperor, you seem to allude to xAristotle's saying, that 1Princes are not termed wasteful, or prodigal. For therein he respecteth 2the abundance of their wealth, which Nero could hardly exceed in gifts and expenses: not the 3quality of the matters that they spend their wealth on, wherein as prodigal persons may and do wast, so Nero. Neither will you affirm that Nero mought nevertheless have relieved the poor; for fear least you cause your reader to suspect you of shamelessness, or sophistry. Shamelessness, if you say, that, whatsoever it were which Nero gave to Act, he had no whit the less in his coffers to give others. Sophistry, if by the word nevertheless, you mean, notwithstanding. For Phoedria in the yComedy, mought have helped Parmeno, notwithstanding ⟨p. 147⟩the money that he spent on Thais. Yet 4the greater charge he was at with his harlot, the less had he remaining to give his poor servant. And your doubt, if Nero had ever any such good mind, will be as badly opposed unto my speech of his less willingness. For both him self, zhaving so good a mind once, became aworse minded afterward, when he was grown bwasteful such ways, yea, simply wasteful, proving that to be possible which Aristotle judgeth 5not easy to be done: and if he had always been equally ill-minded, yet cometh it otherwise to pass in mans nature, as you might have learned by Caesar and Plutarch. Of whom the one, beholding certain rich strangers and foreigners, at Rome, carrying whelps of dogs and apes in their bosoms, and making much of them, did ask, Whether women brought not forth children in their countries:
Nowe, altering and changing Neros charge on Plaudite into vhis charge on Acte (a harlot whom hee loved better then his wife,) and telling you that he was lesse able, or lesse willing (nay, both) to helpe the poore, by reason of 9gifts bestowed on her: I shall not heare, I trust, that, if Nero could haue as well spared the sundry summes of moony which he spent that way often, as your House, with the company in it, and belonging to it, can once in many yeares thirty powndes: Nero should haue bene wronged greatly, beeing an Emperour, to haue bene noted of wastfulnes. No, not, though in adding that clause, being an Emperour, you seeme to allude to xAristotles saying, that 1Princes are not termed wastfull, or prodigall. For therin he respecteth 2the abundance of their wealth, which Nero could hardly exceede in gifts and expenses: not the 3qualitie of the matters that they spend their wealth on, wherin as prodigall persons may and doe wast, so Nero. Neither will you affirme that Nero mought neverthelesse have releeved the poore; for feare least you cause your reader to suspect you of shamelesnesse, or sophistrie. Shamelesnesse, if you say, that, whatsoever it were which Nero gaue to Acte, he had no whit the lesse in his coffers to giue others. Sophistrie, if by the woorde neverthelesse, you meane, notwithstanding. For Phoedria in the yComedie, mought haue helped Parmeno, notwithstanding ⟨p. 147⟩the moony that he spent on Thais. Yet 4the greater charge he was at with his harlot, the lesse had he remaining to giue his poore seruant. And your dout, if Nero had ever any such good minde, will bee as badly opposed vnto my speech of his lesse willinglesse. For both him selfe, zhaving so good a minde once, became a
vCorn. Tacit. annal. li. 13.
9Quae Princeps furtim mulierculae tribuebat.
xEthicor. li. […].Ethicor. li. 〈…〉.
1[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
2[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
3[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
yTerent. Eun.
4Nam quod nos capere oportet haec intercipit.
zSueton Ner. cap. 10.
aCap. 32. & 38.
bca. 30. & 31.
5[Greek or Hebrew] in the words alleged.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in ye woords alleaged.
cthe other saith that Caesar herein gave a worthy and princely admonition to them 6who do consume & wast, upon beasts, the natural affection and love due to men. Both, evidently showing, that the more we spend on things of less value, the less we are disposed to spend on things more precious; sith, das a mans love is, so is his willingness to spend for love sake: and the love of apes and dogs may better stand with the love of Children, eeach of them being to be loved, though not alike; then expenses on plays may with relieving of the poor, fthe Lord accounting mercy had upon the poor, as had upon him self, & money spent on plays, being as money spent on harlots. Wherefore, if you will be suitable to your self, & as you deal for plays, so for the love of apes & dogs, for which you may more reasonably; your threefold answer against Momus in your own defence, is quickly turned against Caesar & Plutarch, for those strangers: The love, which they did bear to the whelps of dogs and apes, was their own love, it was not Caesars, or Plutarchs; great might it be to Caesar and Plutarch, mean to them; neither would they love children the less for that, nor more without it. And as you assaulted Momus with the Scripture, telling him that Judas his speech, who said, what needed this wast? is an evil speech; and now, notwithstanding the difference between your plays and Christ; us and Judas, do think that it ⟨p. 148⟩may also be applied against either the niggardise, or the hypocrisy of any Momus, that shall condemn all expense, as cast away, that is sometime moderately bestowed upon honest sports and pastimes, and not upon the poor: so, what letteth you to think that it may also be applied against either the clownishness, or the hypocrisy of Caesar and Plutarch, who condemned all love, as cast away, that is sometime, moderately bestowed upon sweet whelps of dogs and apes, and not upon children? For, if you should answer, the case is unlike because you can not prove that mens colling and dandling of such whelps is seemly, which Caesar and Plutarch saw good cause to reprove: you must be remembered that yet you may say, the thing is seemly, though say it only, and deny their reproof to be just, though not refute it;
cthe other saith that Caesar herein gaue a woorthy and princely admonition to them 6who doe consume & wast, vpon beasts, the naturall affection and loue due to men. Both, evidently shewing, that the more wee spend on thinges of lesse value, the lesse we are disposed to spend on thinges more pretious; sith, das a mans loue is, so is his willingnes to spend for loue sake: and the loue of apes and dogges may better stande with the loue of Children, eeche of them beeing to bee loved, though not alike; then expenses on playes may with releeving of the poore, fthe Lorde accounting mercy had vpō the poore, as had vpō him selfe, & mony spēt on playes, being as mony spent on harlots. Wherfore, if you wil be sutable to your self, & as you deale for playes, so for the loue of apes & dogges, for which you may more reasonably; your threefold answer against Momus in your own defense, is quicklie turned against Caesar & Plutarch, for those strangers: The loue, which they did beare to the whelpes of dogges and apes, was their owne loue, it was not Caesars, or Plutarchs; great might it be to Caesar and Plutarch, meane to them; neither would they loue children the lesse for that, nor more without it. And as you assaulted Momus with the Scripture, telling him that Iudas his speech, who said, what needed this wast? is an evill speech; and nowe, notwithstanding the difference betwene your playes and Christ; vs and Indas, doe thinke that it ⟨p. 148⟩may also be applyed against either the niggardise, or the hypocrisie of any Momus, that shall condemne all expense, as cast away, that is sometime moderatly bestowed vpon honest sportes and pastimes, and not vpon the poore: so, what letteth you to thinke that it may also bee applyed against either the clownishnes, or the hypocrisie of Caesar and Plutarch, who condemned all loue, as cast away, that is sometime, moderatly bestowed vpon sweete whelpes of dogges and apes, and not vpon children? For, if you should answer, the case is vnlike because you can not proove that mens colling and dandeling of such whelpes is seemely, which Caesar and Plutarch sawe good cause to reproove: you must bee remembred that yet you may say, the thing is seemely, though say it onely, and deny their reproofe to bee iust, though not refute it;
as you avouch against me that your plays were honest and lawful recreations, whatsoever is rather objected then proved to the contrary. Nay, if Caesar, or Plutarch, had, beside their reasons to prove it unseemly; alleged sundry testimonies of Romans and Grecians so esteeming it, as I did the judgements of a Lacedaemonian, of Horace, of Tully of other learned men, to show that they deemed such cost, as you were at, to be vain and wasteful: yet, as you reply to me that all Paynim and heathen judgement you have answered in the defence of your first reason; so might you to them, that all the testimonies which they bring, you have answered in the 7prologue of your last play. I have read gthat when the Spaniards invincible navy met with ours, about some five years since, upon the narrow seas, it was published in print, at Paris, by Mendoza the Spaniards procurement, that they got a brave victory, wherein my Lord Admiral of England, with sixteen of the Queens great ships, were sunk to the bottom of the sea, and the rest put to flight with the Vice-admiral Francis Drake. But, God be thanked, we saw my Lord Admiral of England alive at her Majesties late being here with us: and now may the Mendozians pick out of their own hMercurius Gallobelgicus, that neither any one ship of the Queens navy, were it great, or small, was sunk by the Spaniards, nor the Vice-admiral put to flight.
as you avouch against mee that your playes were honest and lawfull recreations, whatsoever is rather obiected then prooved to the contrary. Nay, if Caesar, or Plutarch, had, beside their reasons to proove it vnseemely; alleaged sundry testimonies of Romans and Grecians so esteeming it, as I did the iudgements of a Lacedemonian, of Horace, of Tullie of other learned men, to shew that they deemed such cost, as you were at, to bee vaine and wastfull: yet, as you reply to me that all Paynim and heathen iudgement you haue answered in the defense of your first reason; so might you to them, that all the testimonies which they bring, you haue aunswered in the 7prologue of your last play. I haue read gthat whē the Spaniards invincible navie mett with ours, about some five yeares since, vpon the narow seas, it was published in print, at Parise, by Mendoza the Spaniards procurement, that they gott a brave victorie, wherein my Lorde Admirall of England, with sixteene of the Queenes great shippes, were sunke to the bottome of the sea, and the rest put to flight with the Vice-admirall Francis Drake. But, God bee thanked, wee saw my Lord Admirall of England alive at her Maiesties late being here with vs: and now may the Mendozians picke out of their owne hMercurius Gallobelgicus, that neither any one shippe of the Queenes navie, were it great, or small, was sunke by the Spaniards, nor the Vice-admirall put to flight.
And thus at length approaching unto the conclusion, I come ⟨p. 149⟩to your maintenance of that which you objected concerning the judgement of our University. Wherewith (least I pass any thing of weight in your reply, as you do many in mine) I will join that elsewhere you touch about the worshipful, & sometimes honourable presence at your plays; and those reverend, famous, and excellent men, for life, and learning, and their places in the Church of God, who have been not only writers of such things them selves, but also actors, and do think well of them (as you affirm) to this day. Our Universities judgement therefore you avow that you produced rightfully to the approving of your plays, because the greater part of the University did with their hearty applause approve them. An argument, that neither layeth sound foundation, nor buildeth thereupon to purpose. For how prove you, first, that the greater part did with their hearty applause approve them; seeing you acknowledge that many, some absent, some present, disallowed them? Forsooth, you say, you are sure of it. But your bold avouching things, you are not sure of, doeth make me doubt of your assurance. For, upon my speech that certain who came thither were pressed thereunto by great importunity, you wish they had more truly, and more charitably, for dancing, kissing, and other demeanour, reported to me of your plays, with such a mind as you will forbear (you say) to speak of. Wherein you do charge them, how charitably, judge your self; but questionless, most untruly, with making false reports of your plays to me, to whom they made no report at all thereof. Yea, you take upon you to pronounce of their thoughts: and say they did it with such a mind, as in your ifigurative forbearing to speak of, you speak most bitterly of, and raise a very wrongful and vile suspicion of them. Again, where I told you how the grave and learned man, our common friend, showed me his dislike of the representation of amorousness, and drunkenness; in the Comedy, both; the former, not in it only: you say, that you know how far he did somewhat dislike some Comical action; but you are sure he commended much the plays to you, & would be sorry that any speech of his should be, by mistaking, alleged against you.
And thus at length approching vnto the conclusion, I come ⟨p. 149⟩to your maintenance of that which you obiected concerning the iudgement of our Vniversitie. Wherewith (least I passe any thing of weight in your reply, as you doe many in mine) I will ioyne that elswhere you touch about the woorshipfull, & sometimes honorable presence at your playes; and those reverend, famous, and excellent men, for life, and learning, and their places in the Church of God, who haue bene not onely writers of such things them selves, but also actors, and doe thinke well of them (as you affirme) to this day. Our Vniversities iudgement therefore you avow that you produced rightfully to the approoving of your playes, because the greater part of the Universitie did with their harty applause approove them. An argument, that neither layeth sound foundation, nor buildeth therevpon to purpose. For how proove you, first, that the greater part did with their harty appause approove them; seeing you acknowledge that many, some absent, some present, disallowed them? Forsooth, you say, you are sure of it. But your bolde avouching thinges, you are not sure of, doeth make mee dout of your assurance. For, vpon my speech that certaine who came thither were pressed therevnto by great importunitie, you wish they had more truly, and more charitably, for dansing, kissing, and other demeanour, reported to me of your playes, with such a minde as you will forbeare (you say) to speake of. Wherein you doe charge them, how charitably, iudge your selfe; but questionlesse, most vntruly, with making false reports of your playes to me, to whom they made no report at all thereof. Yea, you take vpon you to pronounce of their thoughts: and say they did it with such a minde, as in your ifigurative forbearing to speake of, you speake most bitterly of, and raise a very wrongfull and vile suspicion of them. Againe, where I tolde you how the grave and learned man, our common friend, shewed me his dislike of the representation of amorousnes, and drunkennes; in the Comedie, both; the former, not in it onely: you say, that you know how farre hee did somewhat dislike some Comicall action; but you are sure he commended much the playes to you, & would be sorry that any speech of his should bee, by mistaking, alleaged against you.
And do you not in assuring us after this sort that he did like of your ⟨p. 150⟩plays, saving a little in the Comedy, imply that he disliked nought in any tragedy? Or breed you not a slanderous surmise of his integrity, as if he had commended to you the very same, which unto me he discommended? Or seek you not to make men think that I mistook him, in fathering that upon him; when him self hath sithence acknowledged unto me, that I mistook him not; and (as I am persuaded) hath certified you no less too?
And doe you not in assuring vs after this sort that hee did like of your ⟨p. 150⟩playes, saving a litle in the Comedie, imply that hee disliked nought in any tragedie? Or breede you not a sclanderous surmise of his integritie, as if hee had commended to you the very same, which vnto me he discommended? Or seeke you not to make men thinke that I mistooke him, in fathering that vpon him; when him selfe hath sithence acknowledged vnto mee, that I mistooke him not; and (as I am perswaded) hath certified you no lesse too?
Wherefore your pronouncing, that you are sure the greater part did with their hearty applause approve your plays, may rather prove you to be rash, then your assertion to be true. Chiefly, sith you mention, not only their applause, a thing that sense might judge of; but their hearty applause, a circumstance presumed by your conceit peradventure. For as they did 8clap their hands after your plays, so 9after the appendix thereof touching Momus. Which yet some approvers of your plays approved not: as them selves have signified. How can you then be sure, that all, who did clap their hands, did it with liking; and that the applause, which they gave, was hearty? Beside that, if their hearts joined with their hands, how can you be sure they approved your plays by such applause, and not somewhat else? As kTully declareth that the Romans used it to show their love of gracious persons: and in lone of your plays 1you wished it to be given to her gracious Majesty. Nether is it impossible, but that, as a mnumber gave it to the 2apparel and furniture of the stage at Rome: so lighter bodies might with you. And what if the graver sort did show the liking of your pains and charges employed for their delight sake? or of the better parts; not of wantons, of drunkards, & of the whole plays? Now, suppose the greater part of the University approved them with their hearty applause: might you therefore lawfully urge the Universities judgment as making for them? Yea, say you, if the greater part may denominate the whole, Nay, by your leave, even so too will you come short still, unless you add, that judgement and hearty applause is all one: which nhe, who affirmed that 3the people of Rome was lead with affection sometimes, not with judgement, did put a difference ⟨p. 151⟩between. And though the greater part denominate the whole, commonly; & always may, if the word, greater, be well expounded: yet there fall out cases when the lesser part in number shall denominate it, and the greater shall not. For example sake, othere were in the primitive Church certain Christians (as in ours there are) who, having lost somewhat, would go to a wizard, or a setter of figures, or other such soothsayer, to know how it went from them, or by what means they might recover it. pOne of the general Councils spake against this: and called it 4a pernicious and an heathenish custom.
Wherefore your pronouncing, that you are sure the greater part did with their hartie applause approoue your playes, may rather proove you to bee rash, then your assertion to be true. Chieflie, sith you mention, not onely their applause, a thing that sense might iudge of; but their harty applause, a circumstance presumed by your conceit peradventure. For as they did 8clappe their handes after your playes, so 9after the appendix thereof touching Momus. Which yet some approovers of your playes approoved not: as them selves haue signified. How can you then be sure, that all, who did clappe their handes, did it with liking; and that the applause, which they gave, was hartie? Beside that, if their hearts ioyned with their handes, how can you be sure they approoved your playes by such applause, and not somewhat else? As kTullie declareth that the Romans vsed it to shew their loue of gratious persons: and in lone of your playes 1you wished it to be geuen to her gratious Maiestie. Nether is it impossible, but that, as a mnumber gaue it to the 2apparell and furniture of the stage at Rome: so lighter bodyes might with you. And what if the grauer sort did shew the liking of your paines and charges employed for their delite sake? or of the better parts; not of wantons, of drunckards, & of the whole playes? Now, suppose the greater part of the Vniversitie approoued them with their harty applause: might you therefore lawfully vrge the Universities iudgment as making for them? Yea, say you, if the greater part may denominate the whole, Nay, by your leaue, euen so too will you come short still, vnlesse you adde, that iudgement and harty applause is all one: which nhe, who affirmed that 3the people of Rome was lead with affection sometimes, not with iudgement, did put a difference ⟨p. 151⟩betweene. And though the greater part denominate the whole, cōmonly; & alwayes may, if the woord, greater, be well expounded: yet there fall out cases when the lesser part in number shall denominate it, and the greater shall not. For example sake,
3In comitiis, praesertim aedilitiis, studium esse populi, non •dicium.
oSynod. A• cyr. can. 2•. Basil. ep. ad Amphil. can. 83. Greg. Nysse. epist. ad. Lat. can. 3
pSext. synod. in Trul. can. 61.
4[Greek or Hebrew], saith the Councell touching this and the like customs.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, saith the Councell touching this and the like customes.
The number of Bishops assembled in that Council was lesser of all likelihood (amounting qnot to twelve score) then the number of Christians, who either used that practise them selves, or liked it in others. Yet, in my opinion, the Churches judgement did control it: and to say the contrary, because the greater part denominateth the whole, were most injurious to the Church. Or, if this example satisfy you not, rthe same Council made a decree, that 5no man should put on woman's raiment. Whereto, being pressed by me, when you reply that the voice of the Church therein may be interpreted by them who are of your mind; you acknowledge, that, taking it in the right sense, it is the Churches judgement. And the sense thereof by 6your interpretation of putting on, or wearing, must be that none may do it commonly. So, the Council speaking of doing it in plays, you grant that the Churches judgement is against it as common players use to practise it. But greater assemblies of Christians then that Council, allow it in common players: the Curtain and Theatre can tell so much. Neither will you say, that common players are approved by the Churches judgement. For, the Churches judgement you profess obedience too: yet 7common players you condemn. The lesser part therefore in number may sometime denominate the whole; and the greater may not. Which if we apply to the case in question, it is plain you should not have urged the Universities judgement for your plays, although the greater part thereof had approved them. For, the chiefest cause that moved the governors of our University, the Uicechancellour and Convocation, to forbid by ⟨p. 152⟩statute the use of common plays among us, was, sleast the younger sort should be spectators of so many lewd and evil sports as in them are practised. Now, reason doeth give, that men of understanding, who, through a godly care of the good training up of youth, restrained them from seeing those plays, because of such sports; must think it inconvenient for them to see such sports in what soever plays, even in your Rivals. And, if inconvenient to see such sports only, much more to play and represent such:
The number of Bishops assembled in that Councell was lesser of all likelyhoode (amounting qnot to twelve score) then the number of Christians, who either vsed that practise them selves, or liked it in others. Yet, in my opinion, the Churches iudgement did controll it: and to say the contrary, because the greater part denominateth the whole, were most iniurious to the Church. Or, if this example satisfie you not, rthe same Councell made a decree, that 5no man should put on womans raiment. Whereto, being pressed by me, whē you reply that the voice of the Church therein may be interpreted by them who are of your minde; you acknowlege, that, taking it in the right sense, it is the Churches iudgement. And the sense thereof by 6your interpretation of putting on, or wearing, must be that none may doe it commonly. So, the Councell speaking of doeing it in playes, you graunt that the Churches iudgement is against it as common players vse to practise it. But greater assemblies of Christians then that Councell, allow it in common players: the Curtaine and Theater can tell so much. Neither will you say, that common players are approoved by the Churches iudgement. For, the Churches iudgement you professe obedience too: yet 7cōmon players you condemne. The lesser part therefore in number may sometime denominate the whole; and the greater may not. Which if wee apply to the case in question, it is playne you should not have vrged the Universities iudgement for your playes, although the greater part thereof had approoved them. For, the chiefest cause that moved the governours of our Vniversitie, the Uicechancellour and Convocation, to forbidde by ⟨p. 152⟩statute the vse of common playes among vs, was, sleast the younger sort should be spectators of so many lewde and evil sports as in them are practised. Now, reason doeth give, that men of vnderstanding, who, through a godly care of the good training vp of youth, restrayned them from seeing those playes, because of such sportes; must thinke it inconvenient for them to see such sportes in what soever playes, even in your Rivales. And, if inconvenient to see such sportes onely, much more to play and represent such:
qTheodor. Balsam. de ea synodo quae dicitur sexta.
rCan. 62.
5[Greek or Hebrew].〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
6Of the text of Scripture, Deut. 22. 5. where the Greek tram slation hath, [Greek or Hebrew]: the very words used by the Councell.Of the text of Scripture, Deut. 22. 5. where the Greeke trā slation hath, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: the very woords vsed by the Councell.
7Histrioniam accusas? Non defendo sed famam, pudorem, atque innocentiam. Histrioniam vero ipsam, vel tecum accusabo, si voles.
sThe University statute against common stageplayers: made in the year 1584.The Vniuersitie statute against common stageplayers: made in the yeare 1584.
the representing of them being so far worse, then the beholding, in tPlato's judgement, that 8they would be seen and known, he sayeth, because their contraries, honest things and serious, can not be known without them, if one intend to be wise; but 9practise both them, and their contraries, it is impossible, if one intend to have as much as a spark of virtue. Our governors might think more hopefully, then Plato, that virtuous youths may do them both: and Plato peradventure meant by impossible, very hard, as vTully 1elsewhere doeth interpret him. But the dutiful reverence, which I owe unto them, will not permit me to judge of them, that where Plato suffered his citizens to see sports of folly and scurrility, yet none 2beside bondslaves & mercenary strangers to imitate and express them: the guides of our University should deem it convenient for youths to be actors of loose and wanton pranks, whereof to be spectators, they have pronounced it unmeet and hurtful for them. Wherefore, what soever the greater part approved with their hearty applause, I am persuaded still that you did wrong in urging the Universities judgement as making for your plays. No less in a manner, then if one beholding a great number of Scholars playing in winter time at football, should say, the Universities judgement doeth approve it. Which I contrariwise should be so far from thinking, that if any graver man were looking on them, or touched the ball with his foot, I would take it rather to savour of affection borne to some playing thereat, then of judgement.
the representing of them beeing so farre woorse, then the beholding, in tPlatos iudgement, that 8they would be seene and knowne, hee sayeth, because their contraries, honest things and serious, can not be knowen without them, if one intend to bee wise; but 9practise both them, and their contraries, it is impossible, if one intende to have as much as a sparke of vertue. Our gouvernours might thinke more hopefully, then Plato, that vertuous youths may doe them both: and Plato peradventure meant by impossible, very hard, as vTullie 1elswhere doeth interpret him. But the duetifull reverence, which I owe vnto them, will not permitt me to iudge of them, that where Plato suffered his citizens to see sportes of folly and scurrilitie, yet none 2beside bondslaves & mercenarie strangers to imitate and expresse them: the guides of our Universitie should deeme it convenient for youths to be actors of loose and wanton prankes, whereof to be spectatours, they have pronounced it vnmeete and hurtfull for them. Wherefore, what soeuer the greater part approoved with their harty applause, I am perswaded still that you did wrong in vrging the Universities iudgement as making for your playes. No lesse in a manner, then if one beholding a great number of Scholers playing in winter time at footeball, should saye, the Universities iudgement doeth approove it. Which I contrariewise should be so farre from thinking, that if any graver man were looking on them, or touched the ball with his foote, I would take it rather to savour of affection borne to some playing thereat, then of iudgement.
As for the worshipful, and sometimes honourable presence at your plays, you might seem to press it against me with more credit, ⟨p. 153⟩if honourable and worshipful persons never used to grace any plays, save only yours, with their presence. But if they be present at common plays also, such as our University-statute banisheth hence, and your self make offer that 3you will join with me in writing against the players thereof, if I will: consider with your self what you would answer to this argument alleged by those players, and let the same serve on my behalf to yours. For a supply whereof I add, that worthy personages, who, upon entreaty, become your spectators, perhaps think with Plato, that the seeing of Comedies played can do no harm, of tragedies may be dangerous; perhaps incline to Aristotle, that they both may safely be seen by elder folk, not by younger: and so, though them selves behold one, or both, yet do they warrant neither of the points you strive for; I mean, that either students of Christ-church may be actors, or the youth of Oxford spectators of your plays. xThere were at Vienna, in the time of Trajan the Emperor, by some bodies last will and testament, certain solemn games and shows set forth yearly: 4the which, as Pliny saith, had stained the manners of the inhabitants of that city, in like sort as the games & shows set forth at Rome had stained the manners of all the world. This corruption of manners was not bred by other exercises and masteries tried, in those games, but by the stage-plays, as a ylearned man of your profession judgeth: and zPlinies own speech, concerning sundry kinds of games among the Romans, maketh it most probable, that he meant, the corruption grew from stage-plays chiefly, if not from them alone.
As for the worshipfull, and sometimes honorable presence at your playes, you might seeme to presse it against me with more credit, ⟨p. 153⟩if honorable and worshipfull persons never vsed to grace any playes, saue onely yours, with their presence. But if they be present at common playes also, such as our Vniversitie-statute banisheth hence, and your selfe make offer that 3you will ioyne with me in writing aginst the players thereof, if I will: consider with your selfe what you would aunswere to this argument alleaged by those players, and let the same serve on my behalfe to yours. For a supply whereof I adde, that worthy personages, who, vpon intreatty, become your spectators, perhaps thinke with Plato, that the seeing of Comedies played can doe no harme, of tragedies may be dangerous; perhaps incline to Aristotle, that they both may safely bee seene by elder folke, not by younger: and so, though them selves beholde one, or both, yet doe they warrant neither of the pointes you strive for; I meane, that either students of Christ-church may bee actors, or the youth of Oxford spectators of your playes. xThere were at Uienna, in the time of Traian the Emperour, by some bodyes last will and testament, certaine solemne games and shewes sett foorth yearely: 4the which, as Plinie saith, had stained the maners of the inhabitants of that citie, in like sort as the games & shewes sett foorth at Rome had stained the maners of all the world. This corruption of maners was not bredde by other exercises and masteries tried, in those games, but by the stage-playes, as a ylearned man of your profession iudgeth: and zPlinies owne speech, concerning sundry kindes of games among the Romans, maketh it most probable, that he meant, the corruption grew from stage-playes chiefly, if not from them alone.
3Histrioniam ipsam vel tecum accusabo, si voles.
xPliny epistolar. lib. […]. ep. 22. ad Sempronium Rufum.Plini epistolar. lib. 〈…〉. ep. 22. ad Sempronium Rufum.
4Placuit ag• na tolli, qui mores Viennensium infecerat, ut noster hic omnium.Placuit ag• na tolli, qui mores Viennensium infecerat, vt noster hic omnium.
But when the Uiennians plays were taken away by Trebonius Rufinus, a governor of theirs, and he was accused to the Emperor for it: Junius Mauricus, a grave and faithful Counsellor, being asked by the Emperor, what he thought thereof, said, 5it was not meet the plays should be restored again to the Viennians; adding, 6I would to God they might be taken away at Rome too. Which corollary of his sentence touching plays at Rome, it may be, that as 7Pliny liked very well of, so the Emperor did: albeit he gave order for the not restoring of the Uiennians only; and yet showed great mislike of plays therein ⟨p. 154⟩also, forbidding that to be done which by ones atestament was required. Deceive not your self, Master D. Gager, with a vain conceit, as if, because a Prince, far and far more excellent then Trajan, though surnamed 8most virtuous, with Her counsellors and Nobles more honourable then Mauricus, did vouchsafe the last year to see that Comedy played, which being played a few months before I reproved, therefore you had gained against me the matter in question between us. Her Majesty with their Honours, & Commons of the realm, having made an Act of Parliament blong since, and csith that time renewed it, that common players in interludes, not licensed by special authority to go abroad, shall be adjudged rogues and vagabonds, hath taken away more plays, and in more places, then Trajan did by giving order that they should not be used again at Vienna. Whether the taking of them away at Oxford too, have been wished by any of the Counsellors, who might be notwithstanding present with her Highness, as Pliny & Mauricus of likelihood were with Trajan at the plays in Rome: you and I are not so near of their counsel, that we can define. But thus much I may say, and say it upon knowledge, that, if your Comedy had still as homely speeches (to say no worse) as it had when your dprologue praised it, there is greater cause why you should fear the check which 9Augustus gave one (were not our Augusta the more gracious to us) for presuming to play it before a presence of such honour: then why you should mention to the credit of your plays, and to my discredit, that they are things done by you, in a worshipful, and sometimes honourable presence.
But when the Uiennians playes were taken away by Trebonius Rufinus, a governour of theirs, and he was accused to the Emperour for it: Iunius Mauricus, a graue and faithfull Counseller, being asked by the Emperour, what he thought thereof, said, 5it was not meete the playes should be restored againe to the Viennians; adding, 6I would to God they might be taken away at Rome too. Which corollarie of his sentence touching playes at Rome, it may bee, that as 7Plinie liked very well of, so the Emperour did: albeit he gave order for the not restoring of the Uiennians onely; and yet shewed great mislike of playes therein ⟨p. 154⟩also, forbidding that to bee done which by ones atestament was required. Deceve not your selfe, Maister D. Gager, with a vaine conceit, as if, because a Prince, farre and farre more excellent then Traian, though surnamed 8most vertuous, with Her counsellers and Nobles more honorable then Mauricus, did vouchsafe the last yeare to see that Comedie played, which being played a few moonths before I reprooved, therefore you had gained against me the matter in question betwene vs. Her Maiestie with their Honors, & Commons of the realme, having made an Act of Parlament blong since, and csith that time renewed it, that common players in enterludes, not licensed by speciall autoritie to goe abrode, shall bee adiudged rogues and vagabonds, hath taken away more playes, and in more places, then Traian did by giving order that they should not bee vsed againe at Vienna. Whether the taking of them away at Oxford too, haue bene wished by any of the Counsellers, who might bee notwithstanding present with her Highnes, as Plinie & Mauricus of likelyhoode were with Trajan at the playes in Rome: you and I are not so neere of their counsell, that we can define. But thus much I may say, and say it vpon knowledge, that, if your Comedie had still as homely speeches (to say no worse) as it had when your dprologue praysed it, there is greater cause why you should feare the checke which
5Non esse restituendū Viennensibus agôna.Non esse restituendū Viennensibus agôna.
6Vellem etiam Romae tolli posset.
7Viennensium vitia intra ipsos residunt: nostra late vagantur. Utque in corporibus, si• imperio gravissinus est morbus, qui à capite d• funditur.Viennensium vitia intra ipsos residunt: nostra late vagantur. Vtque in corporibus, si• imperio gravissinus est morbus, qui à capite d• funditur.
aL. ult in sin. c. de fideicomm. Nov. 1. in praefat. §. Semper.
8Optimus, Plin. locis citatis; & Dio, Trajan. Xiphilini epit.
b14 Eliz. ca. 5
c35 Eliz. ca. 7
dPrologue. in Rivals comaediam: actam Febr. 1591.Prolog. in Rivales comaediam: actam Febr. 1591.
9Non putabā me tibi tam familiarem. Macrob. Saturn. lib. 2. cap. 4.Non putabā me tibi tam familiarem. Macrob. Saturn. lib. 2. cap. 4.
But reverend, famous, excellent men, for life, and learning (you say) and for their places in the Church of God, have been not only writers of such things themselves, but also actors; and to this day do think well of them: to whom it were a great reproach (thus you amplify it) at any time to have been acquainted with things of so vile & base quality; & much more, still to allow of them. eWhen the Donatists praised St 1Cyprian's life, and learning, and spake of 2his place in the church of God, to countenance their error by the reputation of such a Bishop and Martyr, ⟨p. 155⟩S. Austin, answering them, said that 3the authority of Cyprian did not dismay him, because the humility of Cyprian did relieve him. Which as Austin said, considering how fCyprian had set down in writing, that Peter, whom the Lord chose his gfirst Apostle, and hupon whom he built his Church, did not, when iPaul afterward grew to question with him touching circumcision, take proudly on him self, to say that he had the prerogative of being first, and that new-sprung and later-come ought rather to obey him; neither despised he Paul for khaving been a persecutor of the Church before, but yielded to the advise of truth, and easily approved the rightful way, which Paul contended for; giving us a lesson of peaceableness, and patience, that we should not obstinately love our own conceits; but such things as sometimes are profitably and wholesomely showed us by our brethren and fellows in office, those should we account of as our own rather, if they be true and rightful: whereunto Paul having a careful eye also, and Christianly providing for concord and peace, said, lLet the Prophets speak, two or three, and let the rest judge; and if any thing be revealed to an other that sitteth by, let the first hold his peace; teaching therein that many things are revealed better to particular persons; and that every one, if any thing be found better and more profitable, ought gladly to embrace it, not obstinately to strive for that which he hath once conceived and maintained: as these points (I say) noted thus by Cyprian made mAustin be persuaded of him, that seeing he knew, he might more easily err then Peter, he would have been very well content to change his mind, if any man by 4Scripture had proved him to be overseen, or 5the Church had sifted the truth in a general Council, and agreed of it;
But reverend, famous, excellent men, for life, and learning (you say) and for their places in the Church of God, have bene not onely writers of such thinges themselves, but also actors; and to this day doe thinke well of them: to whom it were a great reproche (thus you amplifie it) at any time to have bene acquainted with things of so vile & base qualitie; & much more, still to allow of thē. eWhen the Donatists praysed St 1Cyprians life, and learning, and spake of 2his place in the church of God, to countenance their errour by the reputation of such a Bishop and Martyr, ⟨p. 155⟩S. Austin, answering thē, said that 3the autoritie of Cyprian did not dismay him, because the humilitie of Cyprian did relieve him. Which as Austin saide, considering how fCyprian had sett down in writing, that Peter, whom the Lord chose his gfirst Apostle, and hvpon whom he built his Church, did not, when iPaul afterward grew to question with him touching circumcision, take proudly on him selfe, to say that hee had the prerogative of beeing first, and that new-sprong and later-come ought rather to obey him; neither despised he Paul for khaving bene a persequuter of the Church before, but yeelded to the advise of truth, and easily approoved the rightfull way, which Paul contended for; giving vs a lesson of peaceablenes, and patience, that wee should not obstinately loue our owne conceits; but such things as sometimes are profitably and holesomly shewed vs by our brethren and felowes in office, those should we account of as our owne rather, if they bee true and rightfull: whervnto Paul having a carefull eye also, and Christianly providing for concord and peace, said, lLet the Prophets speake, two or three, and let the rest iudge; and if any thing be reveiled to an other that sitteth by, lett the first holde his peace; teaching therein that many things are reveiled better to particular persons; and that every one, if any thing bee found better and more profitable, ought gladly to embrace it, not obstinately to striue for that which hee hath once conceived and mainteined: as these points (I say) noted thus by Cyprian made
eAugust. de bapt. contr. Donatist. lib. 2. cap. 1.
1Cyprianus, cujus tantum meritum novimus, tantā que doctrinā.Cyprianus, cujus tantum meritum novimus, tantā que doctrinā.
2Cum coëpiscopis suis.
3Non me deterret autoritas Cypriani, quia reficit humilitas Cypriani.
4Satis ostendit, facillimè see correcturū fuisse sententiam suam, si quis ei demonstraret, and so forth; meaning this kind of proof, as appeareth by that he addeth, undè multa jam diximus, con pared with yt he pointeth to, lib. 1. ca. 7. & by Cypri. ep. 47. ad Pompeium.Satis ostendit, facillimè se correcturū fuisse sententiam suam, si quis ei demonstraret, and so forth; meaning this kinde of proofe, as appeereth by that hee addeth, vndè multa jam diximus, cō pared with yt hee pointeth to, lib. 1. ca. 7. & by Cypri. ep. 47. ad Pompeium.
5Gu• & ipse sine dubio cederet, si jam illo tempore quaestionis hu jus veritas eliquata & declarata per plenariū concilium solidaretur.Gu• & ipse sine dubio cederet, si jam illo tempore quaestionis hu ius veritas eliquata & declarata per plenariū concilium solidaretur.
so the knowledge of the same engraven in those learned and godly men, whom you speak of, induceth me to think that when they shall have weighed what grounds of Gods word, what consent of the Church, what Councils, what Fathers, impugn their opinion, they will not approve your obstinate striving for it. It may be, that they will mislike of your art too, in that, for the surer uniting of them to you, and stirring them up against me, you do not only affirm that they are exceedingly tainted in honour, if plays, which they ⟨p. 156⟩allow of, be justly disallowed by me: but also, that it were a great reproach to them, though not so exceedingly great, as is the other, yet a great reproach, at any time to have been acquainted with things of so vile and base quality. For why? Is the writing of Comedies, or tragedies, but what speak I of writing? in mentioning whereof your art appeareth farther, sith I condemned it not: is the playing of them made by me a thing of so vile and base quality, as persecuting, or blaspheming? Yet Saint Paul thought it no great disgrace for him, nin former time to have been a blasphemer, and a persecutor, when ohe was now become a faithful minister of Christ: no more then for the Romans pto have been slaves of sin, when they did now obey the doctrine of the Gospel; or for Abraham qto have been in the land of Chaldea & served other Gods there; when rhe came now to Canaan. and sserved there the Lord. Not, tto have been evil, is a reproach; but to be. Again, what reason have you to say that a much greater reproach it were to them, still to allow of plays: when you commend St Cyprian as a man of singular godliness, and zeal, vwho did more then allow, an other manner of matter then plays, even rebaptizing of men baptized by heretics? For as he followed xhis predecessors in this error, and therefore was the more excusable: so had the reverend men, whom you allege, their predecessors that trained them to the liking of plays. Neither is it probable that they have been advertised of their oversight by any such mans writing, as Cyprian was by yStephanus. And zCyprian continued in his error still, notwithstanding that advertisement: how know you that they have not changed their opinion? Or, if they have not changed it, they may ere they dye:
so the knowledge of the same engraven in those learned and godlie men, whom you speake of, induceth me to thinke that when they shall haue weighed what grounds of Gods woord, what consent of the Church, what Councels, what Fathers, impugne their opinion, they will not approove your obstinat striving for it. It may bee, that they will mislike of your art too, in that, for the surer vniting of them to you, and stirring them vpp against mee, you doe not onelie affirme that they are exceedinglie tainted in honour, if playes, which they ⟨p. 156⟩allow of, bee iustlie disallowed by mee: but also, that it were a great reproche to them, though not so exceedingly great, as is the other, yet a great reproch, at any time to haue bene acquainted with things of so vile and base qualitie. For why? Is the writing of Comedies, or tragedies, but what speake I of writing? in mentioning whereof your art appeereth farther, sith I condemned it not: is the playing of them made by mee a thing of so vile and base qualitie, as persequuting, or blaspheming? Yet Saint Paul thought it no great disgrace for him, nin former time to have bene a blaspemer, and a persequuter, when ohe was now become a faithfull minister of Christ: no more then for the Romans pto haue bene slaves of sinne, when they did now obey the doctrine of the Gospell; or for Abraham qto haue bene in the land of Chaldaea & served other Gods there; when rhe came now to Chanaan. and sserved there the Lord. Not, tto haue bene evill, is a reproche; but to bee. Againe, what reason have you to say that a much greater reproch it were to them, still to allow of playes: when you commend St Cyprian as a man of singular godlines, and zeale, vwho did more then allow, an other maner of matter then playes, even rebaptizing of men baptized by heretikes? For as he folowed x
which none is able to say that Cyprian did, for ought that aAustin could find, a man most likely to have found it, had there been ought that could have showed it. Wherefore it savoureth strongly of a bad quality, that you would persuade them, they must by my judgement be noted and disgraced with a foul exceeding great reproach and infamy, if they allow of plays still. Much worse doeth it savour, that you bear them in hand, although their minds should alter and think hereof when they pray, bRemember ⟨p. 157⟩not, O Lord; the sins of my youth, it must be nevertheless a great reproach unto them, at any time to have been acquainted with the writing and playing of such matters. But what quality, nay, what canker shall I say it savoureth of, that, unto the Prophets, whose judgement and authority the cspirits of these Prophets were likely to be moved with, I mean, unto the Fathers and Councils laid in balance by me against your testimonies, you reply, that, if they be rightly understood, their forces are not bent against you; Whereas your own pen telleth you, that you know the contrary. For, the first and greatest Council that I quoted, is dthat general Council of Constantinople, which (grounding it self upon the place of Deuteronomy) noteth mens wearing of women's raiment in plays as a heinous crime. Now this to make against you, even being rightly understood, your self did acknowledge when I alleged it afore: in so much that you opposed thereunto the opinion of others interpreting that text otherwise then the Council doeth. The same did you likewise confess of sundry Fathers upon the same occasion, & namely of Saint Cyprian; whom here notwithstanding you do namely mention as making not against you: yea, whom you moreover do set down for a special pattern of the rest, to infer the general, that none of all the Fathers or Councils do reprove your plays. For, Saint eCyprian (say you) inveigheth most eloquently and godly against the abuses of the 6tragic buskin in his time. So he doeth also against the evils of war, of judgement seats, of judges, of advocates, of gold, and riches. Shall we therefore conclude there should be no war, no tribunals, no judges, no advocates, no gold, no riches; and likewise no tragic buskin in any sort? Whereupon you add;
which none is able to say that Cyprian did, for ought that aAustin could finde, a man most likely to haue found it, had there bene ought that could haue shewed it. Wherefore it savoureth stronglie of a bad qualitie, that you would perswade them, they must by my iudgement bee noted and disgraced with a fowle exceeding great reproche and infamie, if they allow of playes still. Much woorse doeth it savour, that you beare them in hand, although their mindes should alter and thinke hereof when they praye, bRemember ⟨p. 157⟩not, O Lord; the sinnes of my youth, it must bee neverthelesse a great reproche vnto them, at anie time to have bene acquainted with the writing and playing of such matters. But what qualitie, nay, what canker shall I say it savoureth of, that, vnto the Prophets, whose iudgement and autoritie the cspirits of these Prophets were likely to be mooved with, I meane, vnto the Fathers and Councels laid in balance by me against your testimonies, you reply, that, if they be rightly vnderstoode, their forces are not bent against you; Whereas your owne penne telleth you, that you know the contrary. For, the first and greatest Councell that I quoted, is dthat generall Councell of Constantinople, which (grounding it selfe vpō the place of Deuteronomie) noteth mens wearing of wemens raiment in playes as a heinous crime. Now this to make against you, euen being rightly vnderstoode, your selfe did acknowledge whē I alleaged it afore: in so much that you opposed therevnto the opinion of others interpreting that text otherwise then the Councell doeth. The same did you likewise confesse of sundry Fathers vpon the same occasion, & namely of Saint Cyprian; whom here notwithstāding you doe namelie mention as making not against you: yea, whom you moreover doe sett downe for a speciall paterne of the rest, to inferre the generall, that none of all the Fathers or Councells doe reproove your playes. For, Saint eCyprian (say you) inveigheth most eloquentlie and godly against the abuses of the 6tragike buskin in his time. So hee doeth also against the evills of warre, of iudgement seates, of iudges, of advocates, of golde, and riches. Shall we therefore conclude there should bee no warre, no tribunals, no iudges, no advocates, no golde, no riches; and likewise no tragike buskin in any sort? Wherevpon you adde;
No doubt the Fathers, as holy men of God, both in their Councils, and in their books, have decreed, and written, many zealous & most godly things against the theatrical sights of their times: but distinguish the times, the places, the qualities of the sights & actors, and the use from the abuse; and it is evident by that which is said before, that we and our plays are not reproached by them. Thus labour you to face it out that your plays are not reproached by the Fathers, as dealing forsooth, just like Saint Cyprian ⟨p. 158⟩against the abuses of playing tragedies, not the use; when yet you had granted that fhe condemneth 7the attiring of boys in women's raiment, and teaching them to 8play the women, the self same thing he doth in the 9place you quote: so that your tragedy-playing is reproved by him in your own conscience, because of your Melantho and Nais played by boys, although it were true that he inveigheth only against the abuses thereof, as you distinguish.
No doubt the Fathers, as holy men of God, both in their Councelles, and in their bookes, have decreed, and written, many zealous & most godly things against the theatricall sightes of their times: but distinguish the times, the places, the qualities of the sights & actors, and the vse from the abuse; and it is evident by that which is said before, that we and our playes are not reproched by them. Thus labour you to face it out that your playes are not reproched by the Fathers, as dealing forsooth, iust like Saint Cyprian ⟨p. 158⟩against the abuses of playing tragedies, not the vse; when yet you had graunted that fhe condemneth 7the attyring of boyes in womens raiment, and teaching them to 8play the women, the self same thing he doth in the 9place you quote: so that your tragedie-playing is reprooved by him in your owne conscience, because of your Melantho and Nais played by boyes, although it were true that hee inveigheth onely against the abuses thereof, as you distinguish.
fEpist. 61. or (as your copy hath it) lib. 1. ep. 10.Epist. 61. or (as your copie hath it) lib. 1. ep. 10.
7Cùm in lege prohibeantur viri mu•ierē induere vestē & maledicti eiusmodi judicentur: quā to maioris est criminis non tantum muliebria indumenta accipere, sed & gestus quoque turpes, & molles, & muliebres, magisterio artis impudicae exprimere?Cùm in lege prohibeantur viri mu•ierē induere vestē & maledicti eiusmodi iudicentur: quā to maioris est criminis non tantum muliebria indumenta accipere, sed & gestus quoque turpes, & molles, & muliebres, magisterio artis impudicae exprimere?
8Quemadmodum masculus frangatur in foeminam.
9Evirantur mares; honor omnis & vigor sexus enervati corporis dedecore mollitur; plusque illic placet quisquis virū in foeminam magis fregerit.Evirantur mares; honor omnis & vigor sexus enervati corporis dedecore mollitur; plusque illic placet quisquis virū in foeminam magis fregerit.
The trueth is that he distinguished not so, neither for tragic buskin, nor for comic startup, but inveigheth against stage-playing it self: in like sort as he doeth against the games and sights of 1fencers, or sword-players, and of 2beast-players (so to term them) wherewith he matcheth this of 3stage-players. So that the absurd conclusion which you frame, of no war, no judges, no advocates, no riches, if no tragic buskin, is framed amiss on error, and would have reason enough if it were framed rightly, as it should be, thus, that, if no stage-playing ought to be allowed by Saint Cyprian's judgement, then ought there no. 4unjust wars, no perfidious advocates, no 56corrupt judges, no. 7covetous encroachers on the poor, to be allowed: because he inveigheth as well against the iniquity, treachery, bribery, and misery of these, as he doeth against stage-playing. Or, if you will needs have him to reprove the abuses only of stage-playing, not the thing: then by like reason he reproveth not the bloody sport and game of beast-players, or of sword-players, but the abuses of it. Which, I hope you will not affirm to be his meaning, no not for the former, sith 8the Church condemned it, as gEpiphanius witnesseth: 9it, I say, the thing, not the abuses of it, as if it had a right use, allowed by the Church. At least you will not make it his meaning ⟨p. 159⟩for the later; which Emperors, less severe then that holy Martyr, even hConstantine, iTheodosius, kHonorius, and lJustinian, took absolutely away by edicts and laws, as a thing faulty of it self. Though, when I consider your speech, above rehearsed, of so many Circi, Theatra, Amphitheatra, builded by the greatest & bravest Romans with huge charge; and of games set out therein, referred by Aristotle to magnificence, a goodly virtue: Your professed desire of approving the Romans judgement so far forth, as serveth for the necessary defence of your own doings, causeth me to doubt that seeing in 1Theatra, condemned by the Church, you distinguish abuse from use, you will in 2Circi also, and 3Amphitheatra; and therefore say that Cyprian reproveth not the use, but the abuses only of beast-plays, yea of sword-plays, unless there come some other shift into your mind for severance of your stage-plays from them.
The trueth is that he distinguished not so, neither for tragike buskin, nor for comike stertvp, but inveigheth against stage-playing it selfe: in like sort as he doeth against the games and sights of 1fensers, or sword-players, and of 2beast-players (so to terme them) wherewith he matcheth this of 3stage-players. So that the absurd conclusion which you frame, of no warre, no iudges, no advocates, no riches, if no tragike buskin, is framed amisse on errour, and would have reason enough if it were framed rightlie, as it should be, thus, that, if no stage-playing ought to be allowed by Saint Cyprians iudgement, then ought there no. 4vniust warres, no perfidious advocates, no 56corrupt iudges, no. 7covetous encrochers on the poore, to be allowed: because he inveigheth as well against the iniquitie, treacherie, briberie, and miserie of these, as he doeth against stage-playing. Or, if you will needes have him to reproove the abuses onely of stage-playing, not the thing: then by like reason he reprooveth not the blooddy sport and game of beast-players, or of sword-players, but the abuses of it. Which, I hope you will not affirme to be his meaning, no not for the former, sith 8the Church condemned it, as gEpiphanius witnesseth: 9it, I say, the thing, not the abuses of it, as if it had a right vse, allowed by the Church. At least you will not make it his meaning ⟨p. 159⟩for the later; which Emperours, lesse severe then that holie Martyr, even hConstantine, i
2Quid illud, oro te, quale est, ubi se feris obiiciunt quos nemo damnavit?Quid illud, oro te, quale est, vbi se feris obiiciunt quos nemo damnauit?
3Convert hi• vultus ad diversa spectaculi non minus paenitenda contagia: in theatris conspicies, quod tibi & dolori sit & pudori.Converte hi• vultus ad diuersa spectaculi non minus paenitenda contagia: in theatris conspicies, quod tibi & dolori sit & pudori.
9[Greek or Hebrew], translated venationem, meaning that hunting which Cassiodore describeth, variar. lib. 5. epist. 42. Quo muner• venator explendus est, qui, ut spectantibus placeat, suis mortibus elaborat. &c.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, translated venationem, meaning that hunting which Cassiodore describeth, variar. lib. 5. epist. 42. Quo muner• venator explendus est, qui, vt spectantibus placeat, suis mortibus elaborat. &c.
And sure if one possessed with mMachiavells humour and love of bloody sacrifices, as helping by the sight thereof to make men valiant, should wish for bloody games of sword-players in like respect: he might, by your example, not only challenge them from the mark of infamy wherewith the Romans branded them, (for nfuvenal, oSuetonius, pTacitus, and so forth, do reproach noble men and Knights for sword-playing, not base folk;) but also defend them from the reproof of Cyprian and all the rest of the Fathers. For qCyprian inveigheth most eloquently and godly against the abuses of sword-playing in his time. So rhe doth also against the evils of war, of judgement seats, of judges, of advocates, of gold, and riches. Shall we therefore conclude there should be no war, no tribunals, no judges, no advocates, no gold, no riches, and likewise no sword-playing in any sort? No doubt the sFathers, as holy men of God, have written many Zealous and most godly things against the amphitheatrical sights of their times: but distinguish the times, the places, the qualities of the sights and actors, and the use from the abuse; and it is evident by that which Machiavell saith, that sword-plays of our age are ⟨p. 160⟩not reproached by them. A very true sentence, that, no doubt the Fathers have written many zealous and most godly things against those sights of both sorts: and likewise true, no doubt, that it is as evident by Machiavel's discourse, that, if such swordplays should now be used in London, as were then at Rome, the Fathers check them not; as it is by yours, that the Fathers do not reproach the same stage-plays of Plautus, Terence, Seneca, or worse (which comparison Rivals may well bear) played here, of late, among us. Wherefore it had been better for your credit to contain your self within generalities, by saying that men mistake the Fathers: as Machiavell contented him self to say in gross, that base and cowardly wretches have miss-interpreted our religion. For then I could not have blamed you about particulars; your policy had prevented me, as it hath in Chrysostom: whose testimony, tquoted by me against your wasteful expenses on such toys, you make no answer to, no more then to vothers whom I quoted not.
And sure if one possessed with mMachiavells humour and loue of blooddy sacrifices, as helping by the sight thereof to make men valiant, should wish for blooddy games of swoord-players in like respect: he might, by your example, not onely chalenge them from the marke of infamie wherewith the Romans branded them, (for nfuvenal, oSuetonius, pTacitus, and so foorth, doe reproche noble men and Knights for swoord-playing, not base folke;) but also defende them from the reproofe of Cyprian and all the rest of the Fathers. For qCyprian inveigheth most eloquently and godly against the abuses of swoord-playing in his time. So rhe doth also against the evills of warre, of iudgement seates, of iudges, of advocates, of gold, and riches. Shall wee therefore conclude there should be no warre, no tribunals, no iudges, no advocates, no gold, no riches, and likewise no swoord-playing in any sort? No dout the sFathers, as holy men of God, haue written many Zealous and most godly things against the amphitheatricall sights of their times: but distinguish the times, the places, the qualities of the sights and actors, and the vse from the abuse; and it is evident by that which Machiavell saith, that swoord-playes of our age are ⟨p. 160⟩not reproched by them. A very true sentence, that, no dout the Fathers haue written many zealous and most godly thinges against those sights of both sorts: and likewise true, no dout, that it is as evident by Machiavels discourse, that, if such swoordplayes should now be vsed in London, as were then at Rome, the Fathers checke them not; as it is by yours, that the Fathers doe not repoche the same stage-playes of Plautus, Terence, Seneca, or woorse (which comparison Rivales may well beare) played here, of late, among vs. Wherefore it had bene better for your credit to conteine your selfe within generalities, by saying that men mistake the Fathers: as Machiavell contented him selfe to say in grosse, that base and cowardly wretches have misse-interpreted our religion. For then I could not haue blamed you about particulars; your policie had prevented me, as it hath in Chrysostome: whose testimonie,
Now, when you affirm that Cyprian, and the rest, writing against the theatrical sights of their times, do not write against such as in our time are used: I must needs tell you, that you show less conscience and singleness in your writing, then to whom you ought and easily might excel in all religious duties, Bodinus, and Lipsius. Of whom xthe one, declaring what need there is for Censors for theatres of our time, allegeth sundry Fathers, and namely Cyprian, against them: yea, that very epistle of yCyprian, which you specify, and wring to the contrary. The zother, observing how the Fathers have inveighed against games, as 4springs of lust, and cruelty; pointing, in the term of lust, unto theatres; of cruelty, unto amphitheatres; doeth argue that sword-plays, if they were used in our time, might be as well denied to be reproached by the Fathers, as stage-plays of our time are. But, with whatsoever cunning or boldness, you blind the eyes of children, and make them believe that these ancient Prophets write not against your fancy: the praise given by you to our own Prophets, those reverend and famous persons now living, causeth me to fear I was too faint when I said, They will not approve your obstinate striving for it; I should have said, They ⟨p. 161⟩will not approve your bare opinion or this, will, is also too faint; They do not approve it. For, being excellent men in life, they love modesty, and yield unto the known truth. Being excellent in learning, they know that your theatrical sights are of the same kind, that the Fathers have decreed in their Councils, and written in their books against. The things which the Fathers have decreed and written, are not only zealous, but also most godly, as you say. Most godly; therefore consonant to the holy Scriptures: on the ground whereof it is expressly noted by aEpiphanius likewise that 5the churches doctrine and ordinances were framed. And how can it be thought then with any likelihood, that those reverend persons do approve your stage-plays: which, by all presumptions, and your own verdict, they know that the Church, the Fathers, the Councils, the Scriptures have condemned? In deed if they were Papists, and such as would rather put on the shameless forehead of the whore of Babylon, then confess them selves to have been overseen:
Now, when you affirme that Cyprian, and the rest, writing against the theatricall sights of their times, doe not write against such as in our time are vsed: I must needes tell you, that you shew lesse conscience and singlenes in your writing, then to whom you ought and easily might excell in all religious duties, Bodinus, and Lipsius. Of whom xthe one, declaring what neede there is for Censors for theaters of our time, alleageth sundry Fathers, and namelie Cyprian, against them: yea, that very epistle of yCyprian, which you specifie, and wring to the contrarie. The zother, observing how the Fathers have inveighed against games, as 4springes of lust, and crueltie; pointing, in the terme of lust, vnto theaters; of crueltie, vnto amphitheaters; doeth argue that swoord-playes, if they were vsed in our time, might bee as well denied to bee reproched by the Fathers, as stage-playes of our time are. But, with whatsoever cunning or boldnes, you blinde the eyes of children, and make them beleeve that these ancient Prophets write not against your fansie: the praise given by you to our owne Prophets, those reverend and famous persons now living, causeth me to feare I was too faint when I said, They will not approove your obstinate striving for it; I should haue said, They ⟨p. 161⟩will not approove your bare opinion or this, will, is also too faint; They doe not approove it. For, being excellent men in life, they love modestie, and yeeld vnto the knowen truth. Beeing excellent in learning, they know that your theatricall sights are of the same kinde, that the Fathers have decreed in their Councells, and written in their bookes against. The thinges which the Fathers have decreed and written, are not only zealous, but also most godly, as you say. Most godly; therefore consonant to the holy Scriptures: on the ground whereof it is expressely noted by aEpiphanius likewise that 5the churches doctrine and ordinances were framed. And how can it bee thought then with any likelyhoode, that those reverend persons doe approove your stage-playes: which, by all presumptions, and your own verdict, they know that the Church, the Fathers, the Councels, the Scriptures have condemned? In deede if they were Papists, and such as would rather put on the shamelesse forehead of the hoore of Babylon, then confesse them selves to have bene overseene:
a man might have reason to think, that their own doings they would still allow of. For, whereas the profane and wicked toys of Passion-plays, plays setting forth Christs passion, procured 6by Popish Priests, who, being bcorrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ, as they have transformed the celebrating of the Sacrament of cthe Lords supper into a dMass-game, and all other parts of Ecclesiastical service into etheatrical sights; so, in stead of fpreaching the word, they caused it to be played; a thing gput in practise by their flowers, the Jesuits, among the poor Indians; but whereas these babbles were reproved by hVives: the iPurgatory-censors commanded 7that reproof of his to be defaced; and the kDivines of Lovan have razed it out accordingly. Yea, though lsome Italian Bishops in a Council, under their Archbishop Cardinal Borrhomaeus, have 8ordered, for their Province, that the Passion shall not be played hereafter any where: yet (for fear of breeding a scruple in mens minds that their Church might err) they say, 9it was a custom religiously brought in. So loth are ambitious spirits to acknowledge ⟨p. 162⟩their oversights and faults. But seeing that our reverend Pastors and Doctors have an other spirit, as mhe saith of Caleb, and profess a purer religion then Papists: you must give me leave to suspect rather that you charge them wrongfully, then that men of excellent godliness and wisdom do allow and think well of so manifold evils, as in your plays I have disclosed.
a man might haue reason to think, that their owne doeings they would still allow of. For, wheras the profane and wicked toyes of Passion-playes, playes setting foorth Christs passion, procured 6by Popish Priests, who, being bcorrupted from the simplicitie that is in Christ, as they have transformed the celebrating of the Sacrament of cthe Lords supper into a dMasse-game, and all other partes of Ecclesiasticall service into etheatricall sights; so, in steede of fpreaching the word, they caused it to be played; a thing gput in practise by their flowres, the Iesuits, among the poore Indians; but whereas these bables were reprooved by hVives: the iPurgatorie-censors commanded 7that reproofe of his to be defaced; and the kDivines of Lovan have razed it out accordingly. Yea, though lsome Italian Bishops in a Councell, vnder their Archbishop Cardinall Borrhomaeus, have 8ordered, for their Province, that the Passion shall not bee played hereafter any where: yet (for feare of breeding a scruple in mens mindes that their Church might erre) they say, 9it was a custome religiously brought in. So loth are ambitious spirits to acknowledge ⟨p. 162⟩
6Magno scelere atque impretate sacerdotum, qui eiusmodi fieri curant: faith Vives.Magno scelere atque impretate sacerdotum, qui eiusmodi fieri curant: faith Viues.
8Statuimus ut deinceps Saluatoris passio nec in sacro, nec in profano loco agatur.Statuimus vt deinceps Saluatoris passio nec in sacro, nec in profano loco agatur.
9Pie introducta consuetudo repraesentandi populo venerandam Christi Domini passionem.
And thus, a great deal later then my desire and hope was, but as soon as sickness and business would permit, have you that performed, which in your conclusion, by words, you request me to forbear the doing of; in your whole discourse, by deeds, you have induced and urged me to undertake. The reason added by you to move me to forbear it, namely, that I have some thing else to do, then to trouble my self, and my better studies, with a matter of this nature and moment; I know not whether it would have seemed sound to others, sure to me it did not. For, if I had lived among the Jews at that time, when nthe priests neglecting the service of the altar, and sacrifices of the law, made hast to be partakers 1of unlawful games in the wrestling place: I should of all studies have deemed that the best, which the Lord requireth at his Prophets hands, oto rise up in the gap, and keep out pthe enemy striving to enter in thereby, What study therefore could I account so good, as this, to spend my vacant time in, when Christians, qanointed by God, ran holy Priesthood, make hast from spiritual sacrifices and service to be partakers of stage-plays; that is, of more unlawful games then were 2those exercises in the wrestling place, as sthe thing it self, & your own tlaw may teach you? Again, the vvirtuous training up of youth among us, and the xgodly life of all sorts of persons, are matters of great moment and weight in his sight, ywho without respect of person judgeth every man according to his work. Now, what hurt it is for youth to be seasoned with a liking of stage-players; I say not, to be stage-players them selves, which is worse, but to have a liking and love of such only; the author of zthe dialogue (were it Tacitus, or Quintilian) touching the decay of eloquence among the Romans, doeth show by 3their example. And, how the manners of all spectators commonly are hazarded by the contagion of ⟨p. 163⟩theatrical sights, I made plain unto you in my former letters by the testimonies of learned men and noble nations; all granted by your self, or as good as granted, in that you have either not answered them at all, or unsufficientlie. Wherefore, considering S. aAust. zealous care to reclaim Alipius (a young man whom he loved, a worthy Bishop afterward) from 4the vain delight that he took in seeing games of chariot-drivers:
And thus, a great deale later then my desire and hope was, but as soone as sicknes and busines would permit, haue you that performed, which in your conclusion, by woords, you request me to forbeare the doeing of; in your whole discourse, by deedes, you haue induced and vrged mee to vndertake. The reason added by you to move mee to forbeare it, namely, that I have some thing else to doe, then to trouble my selfe, and my better studies, with a matter of this nature and moment; I knowe not whether it would haue seemed sound to others, sure to mee it did not. For, if I had lived among the Iewes at that time, when nthe priests neglecting the service of the altar, and sacrifices of the law, made hast to be partakers 1of vnlawfull games in the wrastling place: I should of all studies haue deemed that the best, which the Lord requireth at his Prophets hands, oto rise vp in the gappe, and keepe out pthe enemie striving to enter in thereby, What studie therefore could I account so good, as this, to spend my vacant time in, when Christians, qanointed by God, ran holy Priesthood, make hast from spirituall sacrifices and service to be partakers of stage-playes; that is, of more vnlawful games then were 2those exercises in the wrastling place, as sthe thing it selfe, & your own tlaw may teach you? Againe, the vvertuous training vp of youth among vs, and the xgodly life of all sorts of persons, are matters of great moment and weight in his sight, ywho without respect of person iudgeth everie man according to his woorke. Now, what hurt it is for youth to bee seasoned with a liking of stage-players; I say not, to bee stage-players them selves, which is woorse, but to have a liking and love of such onely; the autour of
I could not but esteem it a thing of price, and worth, to seek to reclaim from a far more vain and dangerous delight the Students of your house, among whom there are many no less deer to me then Alipius was to Austin, and as likely (by Gods grace) hereafter to prove well. With whom I have also greater cause to hope that I shall prevail, then he had with Alipius, because your self tell me, that you do and ever will most gladly embrace, not only my good will, but also my judgement in this cause so far as I write in the general against stage-players. For I am persuaded that their opinions of me are as kind as yours: and then do they agree with me in a manner about the point we treat of. They will agree wholly, if they weigh advisedly one rule, which byou can teach them, and I would I might entreat you so to do: namely, that 5the general doeth evermore comprise the special. The Lord behold both them, and you, in his mercy: and give you all his grace to know the way that leadeth unto life eternal, and to walk therein.
I could not but esteeme it a thing of price, and woorth, to seeke to reclaime from a farre more vaine and dangerous delite the Students of your house, among whom there are many no lesse deere to me then Alipius was to Austin, and as likelie (by Gods grace) hereafter to proove well. With whom I have also greater cause to hope that I shall prevaile, then he had with Alipius, because your selfe tell me, that you doe and ever will most gladly embrace, not onely my good will, but also my iudgement in this cause so farre as I write in the generall against stage-players. For I am perswaded that their opinions of me are as kinde as yours: and then doe they agree with me in a maner about the point wee treate of. They will agree wholy, if they weigh advisedlie one rule, which byou can teach them, and I would I might entreat you so to doe: namely, that 5the generall doeth evermore comprise the speciall. The Lord behold both them, and you, in his mercy: and giue you all his grace to know the way that leadeth vnto life eternall, and to walke therein.
bL. 147. D. de regulis juris.L. 147. D. de regulis iuris.
At Queens College, the 30th of May. 1593. Yours in the Lord John Rainolds.
At Queenes College, the 30th of May. 1593. Yours in the Lord Iohn Rainolds.
single. Which how much, & why, it is more allowable, then men and women to danse together: I wish you to consider, by weighing, with examples mentioned in
Divines thereon. So shall you perceiue, that Homer in the eight booke of his Odyssea, hath no sufficient warrant for Melantho to danse together with Eurymachus, the maides with the wooers; no not though they were maides and Melantho in deede; much lesse for boyes attired like Melantho, & maides, to danse with men vpon a stage. The later of your autours you alleage directlie; and, that learned Knight Syr Thomas Eliot, say you, among other things that he writeth in a booke of his, in the prayse of dansing, compareth the man treading the measures, to Fortitude, and the woman on his hande, to Temperance.
all sortes of wounds. Wherfore this being it, that represented Fortitude in the danse described by Syr Thomas Eliot: farre was it frō his meaning to make your measures, your sober measures, warlike motions; or compare a wooer treading them, to Fortitude. As farre, as to compare a boy doeing the same in maidens likenes, to Temperance. Which, if you had otherwise expressed his sense rightlie, yet should you haue forborne to apply to yours for the observing of decorum, a thing that you commend so in Homer, and your selfe aime at: sith those maides and wooers, intended both by Homer and you, to be wantons, must vse lascivious danses; and the man (if you will needes haue such resemblances) bee compared rather to Mollitude, or Cowardnes, the woman to Incontinencie. Beside that, the praise which that learned Knight geveth vnto dansing, he giveth it not simply;
〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
he prayseth Lucians stage-danser, who dansed the adulterie of Mars and Venus with resembling of
every act therein, (which I hope, your selfe would not allow on your stage;) you should haue acknowledged that through too great a love of dansing, he liked too well of Lucians treatise: though otherwise he fansied not the autour much; as
his ribaudrie, and his too much scorning; and by saying farther, It were better that a childe should never read any part of Lucian, then all Lucian. Or, if the sentence of a Knight, so woorthy, had such credit with you;
by the flower of those persons, by whose partes (you say) no hurt could come to any man: and Syr Thomas Eliot thought that such speeches, savouring of Paganisme, might corrupt good wittes. But howsoever you shall distinguish your Poëme from the balades and dities, in which he controlleth this irreligious custome of giving the honour of God to vile idoles: your selfe doe beare witnesse that he commēdeth not the dansing of Eurymachus & the rest of your wooers with their Melanthos on the stage. For among the partes of their dissolute behaviour imagined to be doon within, you rehearse their
Telemachus. Now looke what was imagined to bee doon within, the same was expressed on the stage in part, by your owne confession: as Telemachus also saith, that in
their maners at home they kept their wont, Their dansing on the stage then, your self acknowledge, was vnhonest dansing. And the dansing praysed by Syr Thomas Eliot is honest dansing, you say. Therefore you doe manifest wrong vnto vs both, in alleaging him as praysing that which I dispraysed.
Quos jam reliqui more viventes suo, Tumultuantes, atque saltantes domi.
Creatures voide of reason. But suppose that some man being of Gryllus minde, (or let vs call him Gryllus for more perspicuitie, and make Sempronius likewise his adversaries name;) suppose then that Gryllus having asked this question,
Doe you thinke that animal, a living creature indued with sense, wanteth reason? Sempronius answered him, that animal is one thing, and a beast an other, as
doest thou make our Emperour a Nabuchodonosor? But, I pray you, leave this Eunuches odious practise in racking my cōparisons: and marke the maine point whereat I aime in them, and which I seeke to open by them. For, as in Gryllus question, and verse, framed like yours, the circumstances giue, that he vsed the generall woord comprising man, thereby to breed a fansie that if this kinde of animal haue reason, why not the other? In like sorte your expresse mention of
reading, I say, of reading, not of playing, in shewing what a iewell you take the reciting of Seneca to be; maketh it probable that you meant to doe by the generalitie of the woord recitare.
getting mens applause, which Persius iesteth at. Now in that you adde hereto the Universitie, and make vs ioyne with the former in opinion, saying; So the Vniversitie would have thought it a more absurd thing, to have heard me, or any other, openly reading my Ulysses to them, then to have seene it acted, as it was: what meane you by this terme, So?
6At pulchrum est digito monstrari, & dicier, hic est.
with harlotts. Now, in Rome, of olde time, there were common
not easy to bee done: and if he had alwayes bene equally ill-minded, yet commeth it otherwise to passe in mans nature, as you might haue learned by Caesar and Plutarch. Of whom the one, beholding certaine rich strangers and foreiners, at Rome, carying whelpes of dogges and apes in their bosomes, and making much of them, did aske, Whether wemen brought not foorth children in their countries:
there were in the primitiue Church certaine Christians (as in ours there are) who, having lost sowewhat, would goe to a wisard, or a setter of figures, or other such soothsayer, to knowe how it went from them, or by what meanes they might recover it.
Augustus gaue one (were not our Augusta the more gratious to vs) for presuming to play it before a presence of such honour: then why you should mention to the credit of your playes, and to my discredit, that they are thinges done by you, in a worshipfull, and sometimes honorable presence.
Austin bee perswaded of him, that seeing he knew, he might more easilie erre then Peter, he would haue bene very well content to change his minde, if any man by
the Church had sifted the truth in a generall Councell, and agreed of it;
his predecessors in this errour, and therfore was the more excusable: so had the reverend men, whom you alleage, their predecessors that trained them to the liking of playes. Neither is it probable that they have bene advertised of their oversight by any such mans writing, as Cyprian was by
Cyprian continued in his errour still, notwithstanding that advertisement: howe knowe you that they haue not changed their opinion? Or, if they have not changed it, they may ere they dye:
Iustinian, tooke absolutely away by edictes and lawes, as a thing faulty of it selfe. Though, when I consider your speech, above rehearsed, of so many Circi, Theatra, Amphitheatra, builded by the greatest & bravest Romans with huge charge; and of games sett out therein, referred by Aristotle to magnificence, a goodlie vertue: Your professed desire of approoving the Romans iudgement so farre foorth, as serveth for the necessarie defense of your owne dooings, causeth mee to dout that seeing in
Amphitheatra; and therefore say that Cyprian reprooveth not the vse, but the abuses onely of beast-playes, yea of swoord-playes, vnlesse there come some other shift into your minde for severance of your stageplayes from them.
1[Greek or Hebrew]. Epiphanius. in the place quoted.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Epiphanius. in the place quoted.
2Ludi circenses: which he nameth [Greek or Hebrew].Ludi circenses: which he nameth 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
3[Greek or Hebrew]. Dio. lib. 43. used not only to [Greek or Hebrew], whereof Epiphanius; but also to [Greek or Hebrew] & gladiatoria certamina. Tertull. de spect. cap. 12 & 1•.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Dio. lib. 43. vsed not onely to 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, whereof Epiphanius; but also to 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 & gladiatoria certamina. Tertull. de spect. cap. 12 & 1•.
he saith of Caleb, and professe a purer religion then Papists: you must give mee leave to suspect rather that you charge them wrongfully, then that men of excellent godlines and wisdome doo allow and thinke well of so manifold evills, as in your playes I haue disclosed.
their example. And, how the maners of all spectators commonlie are hazarded by the contagion of
⟨p. 163⟩
theatricall sights, I made plaine vnto you in my former letters by the testimonies of learned men and noble nations; all granted by your selfe, or as good as granted, in that you haue either not answered them at all, or vnsufficientlie. Wherefore, considering S.