Rainoldes. They thought so, (I grant,) good men, and well meaning, abused by the craft of the Scribes and Pharisees: who, to win the people thereby the more easily unto their opinions, did utter them in Moses words, though with an other sense then Moses. As, that which mhe meant of lawful oaths, and vows; nthey turned it to unlawful: oof punishment by public judgement; pthey turned it to private revengement. But this shift of theirs, (which Christ doth but allude unto, as notorious,) did carry S. qAustin away with such a prejudice: that he thought this also to be written in the law, (because *it cometh in, as the rest,) Thou shalt hate thine enemy; whereas the law rcommandeth men to love their enemies, and to do them good. The less marvel is it, if he were deceived in the former points. In the which yet afterward he saw his error and corrected it. For, when the Manichees, who condemned the God of the old Testament as contrary to the new, did reason out of this place that Christ reproveth sundry points in the law of Moses: she answered that Christ reproveth not the law, but them who mistook it, who thought that the forbidding of murder and adultery did touch, not the affections and lusts, but acts only. And though it came not then into his mind neither, that the law saith not, Thou shalt hate thine enemy: tyet he considered, that it could not otherwise be meant in the old Testament, then, as in the new we must hate our enemies, or rather Gods enemies, hate utheir vices, not their persons. S. Chrysostom in this point slipped not so much. For xhis words thereof be such, that it seemeth not, he thought it written in the law. If in the rest he did not retract, as Austin did: he had not the Manichees to sharpen him, as Austin had. Their folly would have made him wiser. At least, what soever the Fathers thought therein: it is certain that Christ reproved not the law of God, but the glosses of men upon it. Which the newer writers, even of yyour own, acknowledge: yea, zthe Catechism of Trent too. And one, aa Jew by offspring, converted to the Christian faith, doth note out of the writings of an bancient Jew, who ⟨p. 320⟩lived about the time of Christ, that the Jews thought the outward deeds only, and not the motions of the mind to be forbidden by the commandments.
Rainoldes. They thought so, (I graunt,) good men, and well meaning, abused by the craft of the Scribes and Pharises: who, to winne the people thereby the more easily vnto their opinions, did vtter them in Moses wordes, though with an other sense then Moses. As, that which mhe meant of lawfull othes, and vowes; nthey turned it to vnlawfull: oof punishment by publike iudgement; pthey turned it to priuate reuengement. But this shift of theirs, (which Christ doth but allude vnto, as notorious,) did cary S. qAustin away with such a preiudice: that he thought this also to be writen in the law, (because *it cometh in, as the rest,) Thou shalt hate thine enimie; whereas the law rcommaundeth men to loue their enimies, and to doo them good. The lesse maruell is it, if he were deceiued in the former pointes. In the which yet afterward he saw his errour and corrected it. For, when the Manichees, who condemned the God of the old Testament as contrarie to the new, did reason out of this place that Christ reproueth sundry pointes in the law of Moses: she answered that Christ reproueth not the law, but them who mistooke it, who thought that the forbidding of murther and adulterie did touch, not the affections and lustes, but actes onely. And though it came not then into his mind neither, that the law saith not, Thou shalt hate thine enimie: tyet hee considered, that it could not otherwise be meant in the old Testament, then, as in the new we must hate our enimies, or rather Gods enimies, hate utheir vices, not their persons. S. Chrysostome in this point slipped not so much. For xhis wordes thereof be such, that it séemeth not, he thought it writen in the law. If in the rest he did not retract, as Austin did: he had not the Manichees to sharpen him, as Austin had. Their folly would haue made him wiser. At least, what soeuer the Fathers thought therein: it is certaine that Christ reproued not the law of God, but the gloses of men vpon it. Which the newer writers, euen of
- mLeu. 19.12. Num. 30.3.
- nMat. 5.33.
- oExod. 21.24.
- pMat. 5.38.
- qDe Serm. Dom. in mont. l. 1. c. 21.
- *Matt. 5.43.
- rExod. 23.4.
- sAugustin. contr. Faust. Manich. lib. 19. cap. 23.
- tcap. 24.
- uReu. 2.6. Augustin. in Psal. 138.
- xHe saith the speech is lewd, and the thing unjust. In Matth. hom. 13. in opere imperfect.He saith the speech is lewd, and the thing vniust. In Matth. hom. 13. in opere imperfect.
- yArias Montanus & Johannes Ferus in Mat. 5.Arias Montanus & Iohannes Ferus in Mat. 5.
- zIn exposit. praecepti, Non occides.
- aNic. Lira in