The sixth Chapter. The two main grounds, on which the supremacy usurped by the Pope, doth lie. The former, that there should be one Bishop over all in earth: 1 because Christ said, There shall be one flock, and one pastor; 2 and among the Jews there was one judge, and hie Priest. The later, that the Pope is that one Bishop: 3 because Peter was Bishop of Rome, (as some say,) 4 and the Pope succeedeth Peter. Both examined, and showed to fail in the proof of the Popes supremacy.The sixth Chapter. The two maine groundes, on which the supremacie vsurped by the Pope, doth lie. The former, that there should be one Bishop ouer all in earth: 1 because Christ said, There shall be one flocke, and one pastor; 2 and among the Iewes there was one iudge, and hie Priest. The later, that the Pope is that one Bishop: 3 because Peter was Bishop of Rome, (as some say,) 4 and the Pope succeedeth Peter. Both examined, and shewed to faile in the proofe of the Popes supremacie.
pp. 230–452703 passagespart 7 of 18
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Hart. 1You shall not teach me how to reason. The first proposition of Pighius is good, though it be admitted that his conclusion is faulty. For the learned Catholics, albeit they grant that Honorius was an heretic and condemned justly by the sixth general Council: yet they hold that Christ prayed for the Pope, and that therefore the Pope cannot err; but how? Christ did not respect S. Peters person, but his office, when he prayed for him that his faith should not fail: for it was to this end, that he being converted might strengthen and confirm his brethren. Now, because the Church, for whose sake that privilege was given unto Peter, should need to be strengthened afterward no less then in his time: therefore was it given to him, not as to him alone for himself, but as for his successors in the Church of Rome too. So, the Pope is privileged from falling into error by the prerogative of his office, through the ordinance of Christ: that would have all Bishops and Pastors of the world to depend on him for their confirmation in faith and ecclesiastical regiment. Whereof it ensueth that he cannot err in respect of his office, although in respect of his person he may: or (to speak it after the phrase of the