REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDERED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Universities.REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDRED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Vniuersities.
pp. 17–326288 passagespart 6 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Wherefore he believeth, to whom any thing is certain and assured without doubting. Now we ⟨p. 234⟩believe everlasting life, therefore it ought to be most certain & assured to us without any doubting. I require now nothing more, the Catechism of the Council of Trent, ratified by the authority of the Pope and Council, teacheth me that a man ought to be certain of his salvation.
Wherefore he beleeueth, to whom any thing is certaine and assured without doubting. Now we ⟨p. 234⟩beleeue euerlasting life, therefore it ought to be most certaine & assured to vs without any doubting. I require now nothing more, the Catechisme of the Councell of Trent, ratified by the authoritie of the Pope and Councell, teacheth me that a man ought to be certaine of his saluation.
But are you not yet quiet, but still question farther, for (say you) how can a man be sure lof his future perseverance? That may be certain, Campian, by faith, which if it be true cannot utterly decay.2 The Apostle termeth faith them ground of things that are hoped for, & the evidence of things that are not seen. Now how are those things extant which be hoped for, or demonstrated which are not seen, if faith be not perpetual? But they which are endued with this faith, they do now after a sort enjoy those good things, which are yet hoped for, & they do contemplate those things, which cannot be seen with mens ⟨p. 235⟩eyes. So that faith admits us being alive here, and as the Apostle saith,4
certain that we shall one day be there, we seem now after a sort to live and converse in heaven. But all these things would be fading and light, if saith could not persevere. Therefore
Paul had a most certain persuasion, that neither life nor death, nor things present, nor things to come, nor any other creature can separate us from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus.
But such as do not persevere, they may be separated: but these cannot be separated, therefore they persevere. And for this cause the pledge of our adoption, even the holy Ghost himself is given to us, who assureth us most certainly that we are the sons of God, so as now we do not doubt to call God Father.
we know that we shall be like him. Knowledge is certain, & consisteth on assured principles: to doubt is the property of opinion, not of knowledge. Hear Cyprian:
Let such a man fear to die, who not being borne again of water and the spirit, is thrall to the fire. Let him fear to die, that thinketh not he hath his part in Christs Cross and Passion.
Chrysostom upon these words of the Apostle, Into this grace wherein we stand, writeth thus: The grace of God hath no end, it
⟨p. 236⟩
knoweth no full point, but it maketh progress unto greater. And anon after, saith he, we must be fully assured not only of things given, but also of things to be given as well as of things given already. And Augustine:
But are you not yet quiet, but stil question farther, for (say you) how can a man be sure lof his future perseuerance? That may be certaine, Campian, by faith, which if it be true cannot vtterly decay.2 The Apostle termeth faith them ground of things that are hoped for, & the euidence of things that are not seene. Now how are those things extant which bee hoped for, or demonstrated which are not seene, if faith bee not perpetuall? But they which are endued with this faith, they doe now after a sort enioy those good things, which are yet hoped for, & they do contemplate those things, which cannot be seene with mens ⟨p. 235⟩eies. So that faith admits vs being aliue here, and as the Apostle saith,4 walking by faith and not by sight, into the very possession of heauen, so as because vve aren certaine that wee shall one day bee there, wee seeme now after a sort to liue and conuerse in heauen. But all these things would be fading and light, if saith could not perseuere. Thereforeo Paul had a most certaine perswasion, that neither life nor death, nor things present, nor things to come, nor any other creature can seperate vs from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus. 7But such as doe not perseuere, they may be separated: but these cannot bee separated, therefore they perseuere. And for this cause the pledge of our adoption, euen the holy Ghost himselfe is giuen to vs, who assureth vs most certainely that we are the sonnes of God, so as now we do not doubt to call God Father.8 But how dare such a one call him Father, who thinketh that he may be sometime not his sonne? for the Saints may professe with the Apostle,9 we know that we shall bee like him. Knowledge is certaine, & consisteth on assured principles: to doubt is the property of opinion, not of knowledge. Heare Cyprian: 10Let such a man feare to die, who not being borne againe of water and the spirit, is thrall to the fire. Let him feare to die, that thinketh not hee hath his part in Christs Crosse and Passion. 11Chrysostome vpon these words of the Apostle, Into this grace wherein we stand, writeth thus: The grace of God hath no end, it ⟨p. 236⟩knoweth no full point, but it maketh progresse vnto greater. And anone after, saith he, we must be fully assured not only of things giuen, but also of things to be giuen as well as of things giuen alreadie. And Augustine:
lDVR. Who could ever be certain of his own perseverance to the end, without the peculiar revelation of God? WHIT. pag. 626. In this speech you cut in sunder the sinews of Gods everlasting decree. For seeing Gods predestination is certain and unchangeable, it doth cause our calling, justifying, and glorifying to be as certain as it self. For is it in your power to dissolve and break in sunder that golden chain of the Apostle? Rom. 8.30. and to whom can his own perseverance be doubtful, seeing God testifieth his perpetual good will towards us, as these scriptures fully teach. Jer. 32 40. Joh. 13. 1. Luc 22.32. Job. 17.20.21. Matth. 21.22. Rom. 8.9. Joh. 14.16. Joh. 10.28. Phil. 2.6. Rom. 11.29. 1. Joh. 3.9. Matth. 24.24.DVR. VVho could euer be certaine of his ovvne perseuerance to the end, vvithout the peculiar reuelatiō of God? WHIT. pag. 626. In this speech you cut in sunder the sinevves of Gods euerlasting decree. For seeing Gods predestination is certaine and vnchangeable, it doth cause our calling, iustifying, and glorifying to be as certaine as it selfe. For is it in your povver to dissolue and breake in sunder that golden chaine of the Apostle? Rom. 8.30. and to vvhom can his owne perseuerance be doubtfull, seeing God testifieth his perpetual good wil towards vs, as these scriptures fully teach. Ier. 32 40. Ioh. 13. 1. Luc 22.32. Iob. 17.20.21. Matth. 21.22. Rom. 8.9. Ioh. 14.16. Ioh. 10.28. Phil. 2.6. Rom. 11.29. 1. Ioh. 3.9. Matth. 24.24.
mDVR. No man ever doubted but that all those things which we believe are most certain. But you ought to show that every ode ought to believe that he shall persevere in that faith to his end, Saint Paul she weth that certain had made shipwreck of faith. 1. Tim. 1.19. WHIT. pag. 627. The question is not whether things believed be certain or no: for that the Devils do certainly know; which is as much as you Papists do believe, by your own confession, and so you confess your selves to be void of true faith But the faith, the Apostle speaketh of, doth not only believe those things are true in themselves, but that they are partakers of them. Therefore he saith, it is the ground of things hoped for, because it enjoyeth those good things which are prepared for another life by a certain & an approved hopes and the evidence of things not seen, because it now beholdeth things that are hid from our eyes. The perseverance then of the faithful is so certain, that they may think they have the possession of those things which they shall receive in another world. Now the faith S. Paul speaketh of, is not a justifying faith, but only true and sound doctrine, of which Hym•naeus and Alexander had made shipwtacke.DVR. No man euer doubted but that all those things which vve beleeue are most certaine. But you ought to shevv that euery ode ought to beleeue that he shall perseuere in that faith to his end, Saint Paul she vveth that certaine had made shipvvracke of faith. 1. Tim. 1.19. WHIT. pag. 627. The question is not vvhether things beleeued be certaine or no: for that the Diuels do certainly knovv; vvhich is as much as you Papists doe beleeue, by your ovvne confession, and so you confesse your selues to bee void of true faith But the faith, the Apostle speaketh of, doth not only beleeue those things are true in themselues, but that they are partakers of them. Therefore he saith, it is the ground of things hoped for, because it enioyeth those good things vvhich are prepared for another life by a certaine & an approued hopes and the euidence of things not seene, because it novv beholdeth things that are hid from our eies. The perseuerance then of the faithfull is so certaine, that they may thinke they haue the possession of those things vvhich they shall receiue in another vvorld. Novv the faith S. Paul speaketh of, is not a iustifying faith, but only true and sound doctrine, of vvhich Hym•naeus and Alexander had made shipvvtacke.
nDVR. 1. Cor. 10. He that standeth let him take heed lest he fall. Phil. 2. work out your salvation which fear:the like. Heb. 4. WHIT. pag. 633. 1. You have falsified, 1. Cor. 10. for Pauls words are, he that thinketh he standeth let him take heed lest he fall. Wherein you go against even your own authentical Latin translation. Blush you not at this? 2. The very Saints themselves are diligently to be admonished, to fly carnal security, to be ware of Sathans assaults, and to be in continual care. And yet this hind•eth not, but that they are in the mean while most certain of their salvation. For although Paul (Act. 27) sailing, did not doubt a whit whether he should come safe to land, yet he let pass nothing, which it behooved a man careful of his safety, to care for and to do.DVR. 1. Cor. 10. He that standeth let him take heed lest he fall. Phil. 2. vvorke out your saluation vvhich feare:the like. Heb. 4. WHIT. pag. 633. 1. You haue falsified, 1. Cor. 10. for Paules vvords are, he that thinketh he standeth let him take heed lest hee fall. Wherein you go against euen your ovvne authenticall Latin translation. Blush you not at this? 2. The very Saints themselues are diligently to be admonished, to flie carnal securitie, to be ware of Sathans assaults, and to be in cōtinual care. And yet this hind•eth not, but that they are in the meane vvhile most certaine of their saluation. For although Paul (Act. 27) sayling, did not doubt a whit whether he should come safe to land, yet he let passe nothing, vvhich it behooued a man carefull of his safetie, to care for and to do.
oDVR Will you say that the Apostle speaketh in the person of all t•e elect. WHIT. pag. 629. The Apostle proveth it, speaking •n their person; what shall separate us (not me only) from the love of Christ. And again, I am persuaded that nothing shall separate us (not me only) from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus. Therefore he speaketh of all those who are predestinated.DVR Will you say that the Apostle speaketh in the person of all t•e elect. WHIT. pag. 629. The Apostle proueth it, speaking •n their person; vvhat shall separate vs (not me only) from the loue of Christ. And againe, I am persvvaded that nothing shall separate vs (not me only) from the loue of God which is in Christ Iesus. Therefore he speaketh of all those vvho are predestinated.
1because therefore (saith he) the promise is firm not according to our merits, but according to his mercy, no man ought with fearfulness to preach (the kingdom of Christ in his Saints) whereof he ought not to doubt. But Augustine is wholly ours. For as you did lately conclude, that Augustine did allow free will, because he wrote three books of free will, so may I reason after the same manner, that Augustine did think of perseverance, as we do, because he wrote one book of the good of perseverance. To this I will join Bernard, whose golden words these be,2 My conscience is troubled, but it is not over troubled, because I will remember the wounds of the Lord. But I will allege no more testimonies. Faith is either perpetual, or else it is none at all: either it perseveres to the last breath, or else that which is esteemed for faith, is but some fancy.
1because therefore (saith he) the promise is firme not according to our merits, but according to his mercy, no man ought with fearefulnes to preach (the kingdome of Christ in his Saints) whereof he ought not to doubt. But Augustine is wholy ours. For as you did lately conclude, that Augustine did allow free will, because hee wrote three bookes of free will, so may I reason after the same manner, that Augustine did thinke of perseuerance, as we do, because he wrote one booke of the good of perseuerance. To this I will ioyne Bernard, whose golden words these be,2 My conscience is troubled, but it is not ouer troubled, because I will remember the wounds of the Lord. But I will alleadge no more testimonies. Faith is either perpetuall, or else it is none at all: either it perseuers to the last breath, ot else that which is esteemed for faith, is but some fancie.
As for that, that you allege touching Luther, who you say affirmeth, that a Christian though he will cannot lose his salvation, unless he will not believe, this Luther never affirmed, either in that book or any where else. For if you shall turn over all Luther's writings, which you have not saluted, nor I believe, so much as seen, yet you can find this sentence no where. The Fathers of Trent have condemned this proposition and worthily: for it is impious, and to be reckoned among the chiefest paradoxes. But whose soever it was, certainly it was not Luther's. But, say you, Luther wrote so in his book of the captivity of Babylon. That is false: yet he wrote some such thing. I will tell you what it is; and that in a word. Luther reproveth the Papists, for that they thought that the grace of Baptism is quite lost by sin, and ⟨p. 237⟩withal they brought in Penance a new Sacrament, which they term a second board, whereby the grace of Baptism might be recovered. Therefore he denieth that the power and grace of Baptism can so be lost by sins, but that it may be repaired by faith; which thing he proveth by many and mighty reasons. In that therefore Luther taught, that the grace of Baptism cannot be lost, unless one will not believe; and this the Fathers of Trent and our countryman Campian do so interpret, as if he had said, that which these men object, that a Christian though he will cannot leese his salvation, unless he will not believe. Why should I confute so unsavoury an imagination with more words?
As for that, that you alleage touching Luther, who you say affirmeth, that a Christian though he will cannot lose his saluation, vnlesse hee will not beleeue, this Luther neuer affirmed, either in that booke or any where els. For if you shall turne ouer all Luthers writings, which you haue not saluted, nor I beleeue, so much as seene, yet you can finde this sentence no where. The Fathers of Trent haue condemned this proposition and worthily: for it is impious, and to bee reckoned among the chiefest paradoxes. But whose soeuer it was, certainly it was not Luthers. But, say you, Luther wrote so in his booke of the captiuity of Babylon. That is false: yet he wrote some such thing. I will tell you what it is; and that in a word. Luther reproueth the Papists, for that they thought that the grace of Baptisme is quite lost by sinne, and ⟨p. 237⟩withall they brought in Penance a new Sacrament, which they terme a second boord, wherby the grace of Baptisme might be recouered. Therefore he denieth that the power and grace of Baptisme can so bee lost by sinnes, but that it may bee repaired by faith; which thing he proueth by many and mighty reasons. In that therefore Luther taught, that the grace of Baptisme cannot be lost, vnlesse one will not beleeue; and this the Fathers of Trent and our countriman Campian do so interprete, as if hee had said, that which these men obiect, that a Christian though he will cannot leese his saluation, vnlesse he will not beleeue. Why should I confute so vnsauoury an imagination with more words?
You make hast to the Sacraments. 1And I will pursue you as much hast as you make. Now here you cry out most pitifully, O blessed Christ, they have left never a Sacrament, not two, not one. Dare you appeal to Christ, whose Sacraments ye have banished with great reproach out of the Church, that ye might bring in certain impure Sacraments not worthy to be named? we retain those Sacraments which Christ hath commended to us: if there had been need of more, he would have left more. We have two Sacraments, Baptism, and the Lords Supper: these Christ did institute,p these the ancient Church acknowledge, and with these the later Church ought to have been contented. For that it is most evident, that for seven Sacraments, for so many you hold, that not a footstep of antiquity can be found. O blessed Christ, they ⟨p. 238⟩have seven Sacraments, & yet they have no Sacrament, because they have not thine. For those Sacraments which are not thine, are no Sacraments at all. Their bread, say you, is poison, and what is our wine? but the common people among you taste not of that at all: belike, lest they should think that you did drink to them of a poison. We do use that bread and that wine in the Lords Supper, which Christ himself commanded to use. That which he delivered, we have received: that which he did, we do: in the bread and wine we celebrate the remembrance of our Redeemer. If those were wholesome, ours cannot be deadly. Baptism (say you) although it be as yet among them true, notwithstanding in their judgement it is nothing. You your self confess that our Baptism is true• I take it for granted. But why is it true? because we baptize so, as Christ hath commanded us. We keep the law of Christ, we throw your, I know notq what, trash away; the like have we done in the other Sacrament, not have we departed a nails breadth from Christs precept. If ours be true Baptism, then is out ⟨p. 239⟩rEucharist true also. But in their judgement (say you) it is nothing. Why so? It is not the water of salvation, it is not the conduit of grace, it doth not derive the merits of Christ into ut; but only it is a signification of salvation. All these things are feigned & false. For we preach it to be the saving water, and as channel of grace, and we doubt not but it deriveth Christs merits into us.
You make hast to the Sacraments. 1And I will pursue you as much hast as you make. Now here you cry ont most pittifully, O blessed Christ, they haue left neuer a Sacrament, not two, not one. Dare you appeale to Christ, whose Sacraments yee haue banished with great reproch out of the Church, that ye might bring in certaine impure Sacraments not worthy to be named? we retaine those Sacraments which Christ hath commended to vs: if there had been need of more, he would haue left more. We haue two Sacraments, Baptisme, and the Lords Supper: these Christ did institute,p these the auncient Church acknowledge, and with these the later Church ought to haue been contented. For that it is most euident, that for seuen Sacraments, for so many you hold, that not a footstep of antiquity can be found. O blessed Christ, they ⟨p. 238⟩haue seuen Sacramēts, & yet they haue no Sacramēt, because they haue not thine. For those Sacraments which are not thine, are no Sacraments at all. Their bread, say you, is poison, and what is our wine? but the common people among you taste not of that at all: belike, lest they should thinke that you did drinke to them of a poison. Wee doe vse that bread and that wine in the Lords Supper, which Christ himselfe commanded to vse. That which hee deliuered, we haue receiued: that which he did, we do: in the bread and wine we celebrate the remembrance of our Redeemer. If those were wholesome, ours cannot bee deadly. Baptisme (say you) although it be as yet among them true, notwithstanding in their iudgement it is nothing. You your self cōfesse that our Baptisme is true• I take it for granted. But why is it true? because wee baptize so, as Christ hath commanded vs. We keepe the law of Christ, we throw your, I know notq what, trash away; the like haue we done in the other Sacrament, not haue wee departed a nailes bredth from Christs precept. If ours be true Baptisme, then is out ⟨p. 239⟩rEucharist true also. But in their iudgement (say you) it is nothing. Why so? It is not the water of saluation, it is not the conduit of grace, it doth not deriue the merits of Christ into vt; but only it is a signification of saluation. All these things are feined & false. For we preach it to be the sauing water, and as
1Of the Sacraments.
pDVR. Our seven Sacraments stand upon good ground and reason, & hath antiquity for them. WHIT. pag. 643. You should then produce some antiquity for the proof of them; but having none, why do you so brag of it. I wonder not at your silence, because I know that, that this number was never heard of before Hugo de Sancto Victore, and Peter Lombard brought them into the Church: and yet for them Lombard never gathered any testimony of ancient Fathers. Neither ever any Councell, before the Florentine Councell, did approve or establish this number. But your five bastard Sacraments, 1. Order. 2. Confirmation. 3. Extreme Unction. 4. Penance. 5. Marriage. I prove thus to be no true Sacraments of Christs Church. 1. In every Sacrament is necessarily required and element or visible matter. But that neither your Order, not Confirmation, nor Penance, nor Marriage have, by any warrant of Scripture. 2. Those which are the proper Sacraments of the Church Christ did institute. But Christ instituted not any one of those five for Sacraments. 3. Sacraments belong to all Christians, But your Order, and Marriage pertain to a few in comparison. 4. Seeing you faine that grace lieth hid in the Sacraments, and is by them transmitted unto men, prove us which parts of these Sacraments do contain the grace enclosed. What answer soever you make you will be taken napping. Therefore these five bastard Sacraments, are no true Sacraments of Christs Church.DVR. Our seuen Sacraments stand vpon good ground and reason, & hath antiquitie for them. WHIT. pag. 643. You should then produce some antiquitie for the proofe of them; but hauing none, why do you so brag of it. I wonder not at your silēce, because I know that, that this number was neuer heard of before Hugo de Sancto Victore, and Peter Lombard brought them into the Church: and yet for them Lombard neuer gathered any testimony of auncient Fathers. Neither euer any Councell, before the Florentine Councell, did approue or establish this number. But your fiue bastard Sacraments, 1. Order. 2. Confirmation. 3. Extreame Vnction. 4. Penance. 5. Marriage. I proue thus to be no true Sacramēts of Christs Church. 1. In euery Sacramēt is necessarily required and elemēt or visible matter. But that neither your Order, not Cōfirmation, nor Penance, nor Marriage haue, by any warrant of Scripture. 2. Those which are the proper Sacramēts of the Church Christ did institute. But Christ instituted not any one of those fiue for Sacraments. 3. Sacraments belong to all Christians, But your Order, and Marriage pertaine to a few in comparison. 4. Seeing you faine that grace lye•h hid in the Sacraments, and is by them transmitted vnto men, proue vs which parts of these Sacraments do containe the grace inclosed. What answere soeuer you make you will be taken napping. Therefore these fiue bastard Sacraments, are no true Sacraments of Christs Church.
For it doth not only signify salvation, but also it performeth & bringeth it indeed to them that use Baptism aright and holily. For in Baptism we receive forgiven▪ of our sins, we are accepted into the family of Christ, we are endowed with the holy Ghost, we are raised up to a most certain hope of everlasting life. Are these matters of nothing to you, Campian? shall this Baptism be nothing, wherein we obtain so many and so great good things? but what manner of thing is your Baptism: or what hath it more, which ours ought to have? hath it grace? or the merits of Christ? or salvation? Ours also hath these things; what then is wanting in it, why it should not be true both in ours and others judgement? I know your meaning. It conveyeth not grace by the work wrought. This indeed is a magical and pestilent device, that you should thinkt grace to be enclosed in the water it self, as it were in a pipe, which sheddeth it self forth into all men, though quite void ⟨p. 240⟩of faith. For what availeth the Sacrament without faith, but to his perdition who receiveth the Sacrament: that monster I do abhor and detest with mine whole hart. You add, therefore they have made no more reckoning of the Baptism of Christ, then of Johns, that is, a mere ceremony. I am not ignorant what the Fathers thought of the Baptism of John. But I heed what the Scriptures teacheth, not what they imagined. In them both there was theu same ceremony, the same doctrine, and the same grace. If there were any thing unlike in these things, I refuse not to confess, that the Baptism of John and Christ were divers. Now John joined repentance,3 which is the fruit of true regeneration, with his Baptism, and off•ed this Baptism for the remission of sins. If the Baptism of John wanted not repentance and remission of sins, I see not why it should be held so much different from the Baptism of Christ. And what is the cause,* why the Fathers demand, wherefore Christ, who needed no regeneration, did come to the Baptism of John, but because they judged that his Baptism had the power of regeneration?
For it doth not only signifie saluation, but also it performeth & bringeth it indeed to them that vse Baptisme aright and holily. For in Baptisme we receiue forgiuene▪ of our sinnes, we are accepted into the familie of Christ, we are endowed with the holy Ghost, we are raised vp to a most certaine hope of euerlasting life. Are these matters of nothing to you, Campian? shall this Baptisme be nothing, wherin we obteine so many and so great good things? but what manner of thing is your Baptisme: or what hath it more, which ours ought to haue? hath it grace? or the merits of Christ? or saluation? Ours also hath these things; what then is wanting in it, why it should not be true both in ours and others iudgement? I know your meaning. It conueigheth not grace by the worke wrought. This indeed is a magicall and pestilent deuice, that you should thinket grace to be inclosed in the water it selfe, as it were in a pipe, which sheadeth it self forth into all men, though quite void ⟨p. 240⟩of faith. For what auaileth the Sacrament without faith, but to his perdition who receiueth the Sacrament: that monster I doe abhorre and detest with mine whole hart. You adde, therfore they haue made no more reckoning of the Baptisme of Christ, then of Iohns, that is, a meere ceremonie. I am not ignorant what the Fathers thought of the Baptisme of Iohn. But I heed what the Scriptures teacheth, not what they imagined. In them both there was theu same ceremonie, the same doctrine, and the same grace. If there were any thing vnlike in these things, I refuse not to confesse, that the Baptisme of Iohn and Christ were diuers. Now Iohn ioyned repentance,3 which is the fruit of true regeneration, with his Baptisme, and off•ed this Baptisme for the remission of sinnes. If the Baptisme of Iohn wanted not repentance and remission of sinnes, I see not why it should bee held so much different from the Baptisme of Christ. And what is the cause,* why the Fathers demand, wherfore Christ, who needed no regeneration, did come to the Baptisme of Iohn, but because they iudged that his Baptisme had the power of regeneration?
tDVR. We think not so, but that it is in it, as in an instrument. And so hath Thomas taught. WHIT. pag. 664. Then you reject and condemn all your old Sophisters, who have taught that grace is included in the Sacrament, as health is in a medicine or salve. For as that doth cure the disease whether he believe or no that is sick, only if he take it: so the Sacrament doth give grace without any faith or good motion of the receiver, so he hath no mortal sin to hinder it.DVR. VVe thinke not so, but that it is in it, as in an instrument. And so hath Thomas taught. WHIT. pag. 664. Then you reiect and condemne all your old Sophisters, who haue taught that grace is included in the Sacrament, as health is in a medicine or salue. For as that doth cure the disease whether he beleeue or no that is sicke, only if he take it: so the Sacrament doth giue grace without any faith or good motion of the receiuer, so he hath no mortall sinne to hinder it.
uDVR. But Matth. 3.11. John baptised with water only, Christ with the Spirit. WHIT. pag. 669. Here is no comparison between the Baptism, but the persons: for not John only, but not Peter nor any Minister of the Gospel, can give the holy Ghost to those whom they do baptise. Men give but the outward sign, it is Christ who giveth the Spirit. DVR. Why were they Act. 19 4.5. baptised again whom John had baptised, if it be the same Baptism. WHIT. pag. 671. They were not rebaptized, as Ambr•se saith, de Spirit. Sanct. lib. 1. cap. 3. And the 5. vers. being S. Pauls words, they are to be understood not of those Ephesians, but of the people whom John baptised. As if S. Paul had said. John taught those who came to his Baptism to believe in Christ who was to come: and they when they heard it, were baptised in the name of the •ord Jesus. From this then can be gathered no difference of thes• two Baptisms.DVR. But Matth. 3.11. Iohn baptised with water only, Christ with the Spirit. WHIT. pag. 669. Here is no comparison betweene the Baptisme, but the persons: for not Iohn only, but not Peter nor any Minister of the Gospel, can giue the holy Ghost to those whom they doe baptise. Men giue but the outward signe, it is Christ who giueth the Spirit. DVR. VVhy vvere they Act. 19 4.5. baptised againe vvhom Iohn had baptised, if it be the same Baptisme. WHIT. pag. 671. They were not rebaptised, as Ambrse saith, de Spirit. Sanct. lib. 1. cap. 3. And the 5. vers. being S. Paule words, they are to be vnderstood not of those Ephesians, but of the people whom John baptised. As if S. Paul had said. John taught those who came to his Baptisme to beleeue in Christ who was to come: and they when they heard it, were baptised in the name of the ord Iesus. From this then can be gathered no differenc of thes tvvo Baptismes.
Concerning that which you annex: If you have it, it is well: if you want it, there is no hurt: believe, and ⟨p. 241⟩you shall be saved before you be baptised; we do not speak so loosely, as you imagine. For we will not have it to be in any ones choice, to be baptised if he will, and to leave it if he will not. Yet we do not think that Baptism is sox simply necessary to salvation, that he that is not entered by Baptism, must needs perish everlastingly. For the salvation of a Christian man consisteth in the mercy of God, which is not so tied & bound to any Sacraments,y as that he cannot save those, whom he will not have perish, without them. Where the opportunity of Baptism is not, Gods promise alone is abundantly sufficient of it self. But whosoever either neglecteth Baptism through heedlessness, or boldly contemneth it, him we condemn of very heinous sin. For he doth both diminish the Majesty of Christ, and also refuseth his own salvation. But he that committeth neither, shall not answer for the fault of another. Therefore very right was that judgement of Bernard, znot the want, but the contempt of Baptism is damnable.4
Concerning that which you annexe: If you haue it, it is well: if you want it, there is no hurt: beleeue, and ⟨p. 241⟩you shall be saued before you bee baptised; wee doe not speake so loosely, as you imagine. For wee will not haue it to be in any ones choice, to be baptised if hee will, and to leaue it if hee will not. Yet wee doe not thinke that Baptisme is sox simplie necessarie to saluation, that he that is not entred by Baptisme, must needs perish euerlastingly. For the saluation of a Christian man cōsisteth in the mercie of God, which is not so tyed & bound to any Sacraments,y as that he cannot saue those, whom he will not haue perish, without them. Where the opportunity of Baptisme is not, Gods promise alone is abundantly sufficient of it selfe. But whosoeuer either neglecteth Baptisme through heedlesnes, or boldly contemneth it, him we condemne of very hainous sin. For he doth both diminish the Maiestie of Christ, and also refuseth his owne saluation. But he that committeth neither, shal not answere for the fault of another. Therefore verie right was that iudgement of Bernard, znot the want, but the contempt of Baptisme is damnable.4
xDVR. What? If without Baptism infants may obtain eternal life, is it not your judgements, that it is no burt to them though they want Baptism? But Christ thought far • therwise. Joh. 3.5. WHIT. pag. 675. It is a wicked and batbarou• opinion to think that they who die before they can come to Baptism, are damned. For who will say, that the infants of the Jews, who died before the eight day did p• rish? And when in former ages they deferred Baptism till the hour of death, did they think it so absolute necessary? Will you say that an infant is not of the number of the elect, because God will that he die before Baptism? if you will, you shall be accounted bold, rash, and impious. As for the place of John. Christ doth not think that none can come into heaven, which wanteth the outward Baptism. The thief was with Christ in Paradise, and yet was unbaptized with the outward Baptism. But the truth is, by water Christ meaneth there the Spirit, as appeareth by conference of places. Matth. 3.11. As there fire, so here water signifieth the power of the Spirit: & Joh. 4.10.DVR. VVhat? If without Baptisme infants may obtaine eternall life, is it not your iudgements, that it is no burt to them though they want Baptisme? But Christ thought farre • therwise. Ioh. 3.5. WHIT. pag. 675. It is a wicked and batbarou• opinion to thinke that they who die before they can come to Baptisme, are damned. For who will say, that the infants of the Iewes, who died before the eight day did p• rish? And when in former ages they deferred Baptisme till the houre of death, did they think it so absolute necessary? Will you say that an infant is not of the nūber of the elect, because God wil that he die before Baptisme? if you will, you shall be accounted bold, rash, and impious. As for the place of Iohn. Christ doth not thinke that none can come into heauen, which wanteth the outward Baptisme. The theefe was with Christ in Paradise, and yet was vnbaptised with the outward Baptisme. But the truth is, by water Christ meaneth there the Spirit, as appeareth by conference of places. Matth. 3.11. As there fire, so here water signifieth the power of the Spirit: &
In the rest that follow, as being small matters, you do but trifle. For neither do you your self declare any thing of your own opinions, nor can you reprove any thing in ours. But I long to know, what you think of the faith of Infants. I suppose, you will grant that they have grace? For (say you) Baptism conferreth grace. But will you not yield that they have faith? I wish therefore you would teach me, to the end you may draw me wholly into your opinion, how there can be any grace more ancient than faith. But (say you) how can they believe, who do not yet understand whether they live or no? and do they therefore not live, because they understand not that they live? It is absurd. Wherefore if they live, although they do not understand they do so:a happily also they do believe, albeit they perceive not that they believe. That is hard (say you:) be it so. Nor do I speak these things, as if I were wholly of that mind, but to the end I may fish out your mind, which our University m•n doubtless make great account of. But let us hear Luther's medicine: It is better (saith he) to omit it, because except the Infant believe, he is washed ⟨p. 243⟩•e•er a whit. But this medicine came out of your shop, not out of Luther's. And indeed you have offered us many such like medicines, very unsavoury, and ill favouredly seasoned: so that all your confections seem to be corrupt. But Luther did never persuade that Baptism should be omitted; & he was always earnest on that part, that Baptism should be given to Infants: and therefore you are so much the more unjust in this place, in that you would mar Luther's opinion with your medley. For these things are so alleged by you, as if Luther said, it were better to omit Baptism. Therefore let us hear Luther himself, and let Campians medicine alone. And yet (saith he) we deny not that Infants are to be baptised, 2nor do we avow that they receive Baptism without faith: but we say, that at Baptism they do believe by the power of the Word. He addeth: Or otherwise there would be mere and intolerable lies, when the Baptizer demandeth of the Infant whether he do believe: as intending not to baptise, unless it be answered in the child stead, I believe. Wherefore doth the Minister ask whether he do believe, if i• be a certain thing that they do not believe, as Cocleus maintaineth? Then he concludeth thus:
In the rest that follow, as being small matters, you doe but trisle. For neither doe you your selfe declare any thing of your owne opinions, nor can you reproue any thing in ours. But I long to know, what you thinke of the faith of Infants. I suppose, you wil grant that they haue grace? For (say you) Baptisme conferreth grace. But will you not yeeld that they haue faith? I wish therefore you would teach me, to the end you may draw me wholy into your opinion, how there can be any grace more ancient than faith. But (say you) how can they beleeue, who doe not yet vnderstand whether they liue or no? and do they therfore not liue, because they vnderstand not that they liue? It is absurd. Wherefore if they liue, although they doe not vnderstand they do so:a happily also they doe beleeue, albeit they perceiue not that they beleeue. That is hard (say you:) bee it so. Nor doe I speake these things, as if I were wholy of that mind, but to the end I may fish out your mind, which our Vniuersity m•n doubtles make great account of. But let vs heare Luthers medicine: It is better (saith he) to omit it, because except the Infant beleeue, he is washed ⟨p. 243⟩•e•er a whit. But this medicine came out of your shop, not out of Luthers. And indeed you haue offred vs many such like medicines, very vnsauourie, and ill fauouredly seasoned: so that all your confections seeme to be corrupt. But Luther did neuer perswade that Baptisme should be omitted; & he was alwaies earnest on that part, that Baptisme should be giuen to Infants: and therefore you are so much the more vniust in this place, in that you would marre Luthers opinion with your medley. For these things are so alledged by you, as if Luther said, it were better to omit Baptisme. Therfore let vs heare Luther himself, and let Campians medicine alone. And yet (saith he) we deny not that Infants are to be baptised, 2nor do we anow that they receiue Baptisme without faith: but wee say, that at Baptisme they do beleeue by the power of the Word. He addeth: Or otherwise there would bee meere and intolerable lies, when the Baptiser demandeth of the Infant whether he do beleeue: as intending not to baptise, vnlesse it be answered in the child• stead, I beleeue. Wherfore doth the Minister aske whether he do beleeue, if i• be a certaine thing that they do not beleeue, as Cocleus maintaineth? Then he concludeth thus:
aDVR. But speak plainly; if Infants have no faith, your new Evangelical doctrine, teaching that the force of the Sacrament doth depend upon the faith of the receivers, must vanish. WHIT. pag. 681. I do no: think that Infants do believe, there being neither reason nor Scripture for it. And I answer that is not our doctrine you faine to be. We say, that to men of years without saith it is a Sacrament, but not a saving Sacrament: to children of believing patents, though they cannot for their years believe, yet it is a saving Sacrament, as Circumcision was to the Infants of the Jews. For we doubt not but the Spirit of God is powerful unto them after a hidden and wonderful manner. As in the examples of Jacob, Jeremiah, John Baptist, and others.DVR. But speake plainly; if Infants haue no faith, your nevv Euangelicall doctrine, teaching that the force of the Sacrament doth depend vpon the faith of the receiuers, must vanish. WHIT. pag. 681. I do no: thinke that Infants do beleeue, there being neither reason nor Scripture for it. And I answere that is not our doctrine you faine to bee. Wee say, that to men of yeares without saith it is a Sacrament, but not a sauing Sacrament: to children of beleeuing patents, though they cannot for their yeares beleeue, yet it is a sauing Sacrament, as Circumcision was to the Infants of the Iewes. For wee doubt not but the Spirit of God is powerfull vnto them after a hidden and vvonderfull manner. As in the examples of Iacob, Ieremie, Iohn Baptist, and others.
But we hold that Infants are not to be Baptised, •f it be true that they in Baptism do not believe. Luther then maintaineth and determineth, that little children do believe, and he reproveth the Papists, because they teach things contrary each to other, while they deny that an Infant hath faith and yet, to the end he may be baptised, they require faith of him. Who seeth not to what these things may be referred, so that he must needs be a most malicious man, who maketh Luther in these words a persuader of so wicked an opinion?
But we hold that Infants are not to be Baptised, •f it be true that they in Baptisme do not beleeue. Luther then maintaineth and determineth, that little children do beleeue, and he reproueth the Papists, because they teach things contrary each to other, while they deny that an Infant hath faith and yet, to the end he may be baptised, they require faith of him. Who seeth not to what these things may be referred, so that hee must needs bee a most malicious man, who maketh Luther in these words a perswader of so wicked an opinion?
And these things do they speak (say you) being doubtful in their own mind, what to maintain positively. Howsoever some do doubt of the faith of infants, yet we all determine clearly and positively that ⟨p. 244⟩they are to be baptised. Therefore there was no need that you should send for that Pacimentan• daysman, who was always more inclining to your side than to ours. But why do you object the Anabaptists to us, who hate us much more eagerly than you, and not without cause?b for we have both convicted them for heretics by our arguments, and also have expulsed them as seditious and pernicious men out of our Commonwealths, who if they dwelt not with you, could find no place to remain in through the Christian world. You pass over the rest of the Sacraments, which I acknowledge to be none at all: nor do I understand which is that beast of many heads, whereof you make mention, unless perhaps you mean that three-headed beast, of which John writeth many things in the Revelation.
And these things doe they speake (say you) being doub•full in their own mind, what to maintaine positiuely. Howsoeuer some doe doubt of the faith of infants, yet wee all determine cleerely and positiuely that ⟨p. 244⟩they are to be baptised. Therfore there was no need that you should send for that Pacimentan• dayesman, who was alwayes more enclining to your side than to ours. But why doe you obiect the Anabaptists to vs, who hate vs much more eagerly than you, and not without cause?b for we haue both cōuicted them for heretikes by our arguments, and also haue expulsed them as seditious and pernicious men out of our Commonwealths, who if they dwelt not with you, could find no place to remaine in through the Christian world. You passe ouer the rest of the Sacraments, which I acknowledge to bee none at all: nor doe I vnderstand which is that beast of many heads, whereof you make mention, vnlesse perhaps you meane that threeheaded beast, of which Iohn writeth many things in the Reuelation.
bDVR. I know you do fight hotly against the Anabaptists, but with what weapons? Calvin was glad to fly to the Tradition of the Church: for be brought no place of Scripture against them, neither could be bring any. WHIT. pag. 685. You betray the Scriptures that you may establish Traditions. What can be spoken either more contumeliously against the Scriptures, or more for the advantage of Anabaptists, then that this their heresy cannot be confuted by Scripture? But are you ignorant that Calvin used Scripture to refel this? And yet he produceth these places. Gen. 17.4. Matth. 19.13. & 28.19. which sufficiently overthrow the Anabaptists. And in the place you allege, he rather renounceth Traditions, then flieth to them for any defence. Jast. lib. 4 cap. 16. sect. 8.DVR. I knovv you doe fight hotly against the Anabaptists, but vvith vvhat vveapons? Caluin vvas glad to flie to the Tradition of the Church: for be brought no place of Scripture against them, neither could be bring any. WHIT. pag. 685. You betray the Scriptures that you may establish Traditions. What can be spoken either more contumeliously against the Scriptures, or more for the aduantage of Anabaptists, then that this their heresie cannot be cōfuted by Scripture? But are you ignorant that Caluin vsed Scripture to refell this? And yet he produceth these places. Gen. 17.4. Matth. 19.13. & 28.19. which sufficiently ouerthrow the Anabaptists. And in the place you alleadge, hee rather renounceth Traditions, then flieth to them for any defence. Jast. lib. 4 cap. 16. sect. 8.
Hitherto Campian, 1you have examined certain opinions and positions of our men: in all which you have found as yet never a Paradox. For either the things that you object are such, as that nothing can be truer then they, or else they are craftily and treacherously wrested by you into a perverse meaning. But now, as if you were some new Censurer, and Master of the ancient discipline and severity, you make search into our manners, not, I think, to make them better, but to make them seem much worse than they be. Although he that reproveth the manners of other, it were meet that he should be without fault. And is there so great a change made of Rome upon the sudden? is their life now such? are their manners begun to be so goodly, that you being returned thence a Friar dare strive with us about virtue, shamefastness, ⟨p. 245⟩and honesty? howsoever there be here many things done which ought not to be, yet if you shall say that there is as great impunity and licentiousness of sins in England, as you your self have seen at Rome, the very tower of your religion and kingdom, all men will judge you to be too too impudent. Wherefore then do you propose to us those pieces of faults in Luther, seeing among you not only some fragments of vices, but huge bodies of the greatest crimes are plainly seen? surely as long as those public stews and dens of whores stand still in Rome, you could scarce honestly make mention of manners. But what are these pieces of faults in Luther? Is it for that you reprove some crime in his life? but that you neither can do, nor go about to do. You object certain sayings caught out of his books, and as you are wont torn from the rest of the body of the sentence; which seem presently as soon as they be propounded by you, to make show of some filthiness. About the most of which, seeing that you have had an answer made you by him whom you name, Reverend Charke, I marvel that you have returned them to us here again. There must needs be great lack of true imputations, seeing that you have no variety at all of false ones. And seeing that my fellow soldier and companion in Christ William Charke did labour diligently in these things, those things which are largely enough confuted by him, shall be run over now by me briefly and shortly.
Hitherto Campian, 1you haue examined certaine opinions and positions of our men: in all which you haue found as yet neuer a Paradoxe. For either the things that you obiect are such, as that nothing can be truer then they, or else they are craftily and treacherously wrested by you into a peruerse meaning. But now, as if you were some new Censurer, and Master of the auncient discipline and seuerity, you make search into our manners, not, I thinke, to make them better, but to make them seeme much worse than they be. Although he that reproueth the manners of other, it were meet that he should bee without fault. And is there so great a change made of Rome vpon the sodaine? is their life now such? are their manners begunne to bee so goodly, that you being returned thēce a Frier dare striue with vs about vertue, shamefastnes, ⟨p. 245⟩and hon•stie? howsoeuer there be here many things done which ought not to be, yet if you shall say that there is as great impunity and licenciousnes of sinnes in England, as you your selfe haue seene at Rome, the very towre of your religion and kingdome, all men will iudge you to bee too too impudent. Wherefore then doe you propose to vs those peeces of faults in Luther, seeing among you not only some fragments of vices, but huge bodies of the greatest crimes are plainely seene? surely as long as those publike stewes and dens of whoores stand still in Rome, you could scarce honestly make mention of manners. But what are these peeces of faults in Luther? Is it for that you reproue some crime in his life? but that you neither can do, nor go about to doe. You obiect certaine sayings caught out of his bookes, and as you are wont torne from the rest of the body of the sentence; which seeme presently as soone as they bee propounded by you, to make shew of some filthines. About the most of which, seeing that you haue had an answere made you by him whom you name, Reuerend Charke, I maruell that you haue returned them to vs heere againe. There must needs be great lacke of true imputations, seeing that you haue no varietie at all of false ones. And seeing that my fellow souldier and companion in Christ William Charke did labour diligētly in these things, those things which are largely enough confuted by him, shall bee run ouer now by mee briefely and shortly.
It shall be therefore enough for me to cut in sunder these your pieces, which have been before so broken in shivers, as that they might seem able to hurt none.
It shall bee therefore enough for mee to cut in sunder these your peeces, which haue been before so broken in shiuers, as that they might seeme able to hurt none.
Wherefore now spue out these your morsels of reproaches. And hear ye them: If the wife will not, or cannot, let the maid come. A filthy and uncleanly speech as it seemeth. Luther wrote a little book of ⟨p. 246⟩marriage, in the second part whereof he remembers three causes, whereby he thinketh marriage may be dissolved. The first is Impotency: another is, Adultery: the third is, Desertion. Now he expounds that to be desertion, when as the wilful and obstinate wise can by no means be persuaded to perform the office of due benevolence to the husband, for there are some such froward wives found, that although the husband do fall ten times into whoredom, yet they regard it never a whit. Wherefore Luther thinketh it fit for the husband, to fray his wife with words, and to threaten her on this manner: If you will not, another will: If the mistress will not, let the maid come. With whom if threats prevail not, let him convent her before others, and bring the matter to the Church. But now if she be neither moved with private threatenings, nor by the public reproofs of the Church, then, saith Luther, divorce her and take Ester into Vashti's place. Only to propound these things in this manner, is a very evident confutation of Campians reproach. For who doth not mark what counsel Luther gave to the husband? not that he should presently take his maid, but that he should propose threats of divorce to his obstinate wife, and break her stomach by that mean? Now as for this opinion of Luther about this kind of divorce, though I do not defend, yet you cannot accuse it.c For among you there be infinite causes of divorce, so as in so great liberty of divorce, it is marvel that any marriage stood in force. If Luther had at any time written any such thing, as we read was written by Clement, whom you brag ⟨p. 247⟩to have been Pope of Rome, what tragedies would ye have raised? Hear Campian, & I would have you mark whereto this speech tendeth:d The common use of all things, 3that are in this world, ought to be to all men. But through mens naughtiness one said that this was his, and another that; and so there is a division made between mortal men. Finally one of the wise men of the Grecians, knowing this to be so, saith, that all things among friends ought to be common. Now among all things, without doubt are husbands and wives.
Wherefore now spue out these your morsels of reproches. And heare ye them: If the wife will not, or cannot, let the maid come. A filthie and vncleanely speech as it seemeth. Luther wrote a little booke of ⟨p. 246⟩marriage, in the second part whereof hee remembers three causes, whereby hee thinketh marriage may be dissolued. The first is Impotencie: another is, Adultrie: the third is, Desertion. Now hee expoundes that to be desertion, when as the wilful and obstinate wise can by no meanes bee perswaded to performe the office of due benouelence to the husband, for there are some such froward wiues found, that although the husband doe fall ten times into whordome, yet they regard it neuer a whit. Wherefore Luther thinketh it fit for the husband, to fray his wife with words, and to threaten hir on this manner: If you will not, another will: If the mistrisse will not, let the maide come. With whom if threats preuaile not, let him conuent her before others, and bring the matter to the Church. But now if she be neither moued with priuate threatnings, nor by the publike reproofes of the Church, then, saith Luther, diuorce her and take Ester into Vashties place. Only to propoūd these things in this māner, is a very euident confutation of Campians reproch. For who doth not marke what counsaile Luther gaue to the husband? not that he should presently take his mayd, but that he should propose threats of diuorce to his obstinate wife, and breake her stomacke by that meane? Now as for this opinion of Luther about this kind of diuorce, though I doe not defend, yet you cannot accuse it.c For among you there be infinite causes of diuorce, so as in so great liberty of diuorce, it is maruaile that any marriage stood in force. If Luther had at any time written any such thing, as wee reade was written by Clement, whom you brag ⟨p. 247⟩to haue beene Pope of Rome, what tragedies would yee haue raised? Heare Campian, & I would haue you marke whereto this speech tendeth:d The common vse of all things, 3that are in this world, ought to be to all men. But through mens naughtines one said that this was his, and another that; and so there is a diuision made betweene mortall men. Finally one of the wise men of the Grecians, knowing this to bee so, saith, that all things among friēds ought to be common. Now among al things, without doubt are husbands and wiues.
cDVR. You are ignorant that with us only adultery is the cause of divorce. WHIT. pag. 688. Nay you are ignorant of your own Canons, for to omit others, see what the Tridentine Fathers decreed. If any shall say that the Church doth err when she decreeth that for many causes divorce from b•dde and cobabitation, may be had either for a certain or unlimited time, let him be accursed. Do not you now differ from your own Councell, as al•o from the Apostle?DVR. You are ignorant that vvith vs only adultery is the cause of diuorce. WHIT. pag. 688. Nay you are ignorant of your owne Canons, for to omit others, see what the Tridentine Fathers decreed. If any shall say that the Church doth erre vvhē shee decreeth that for many causes diuo•ce from b•dde and cobabitation, may be had either for a certaine or vnlimited time, let him be accursed. Do not you now differ from your owne Councell, as al•o from the Apostle?
dDVR. If you had seen some old copies, or weighed the scope of the Epistle, you might easily have seen that the place is corrupted. WHIT. pag. 689. I can be content you should defend Clement, for I easily think that Clement would never speak so dishonestly. But when you father Epistles upon ancient Bishops, such as they never writ, God would show your perfidy by manifest demonstrations For copies we have none whether old or new but from you; and many I have seen, and they all have it. Yet remember that you here confess the Popes decretal Epistles to be corrupted (why […] forged?) which other where you peremptorily deny.DVR. If you had seene some old copies, or vvaighed the scope of the Epistle, you might easilie haue seene that the place is corrupted. WHIT. pag. 689. I can be content you should defend Clement, for I easily thinke that Clement would neuer speake so dishonestly. But when you father Epistles vpon auncient Bishops, such as they neuer writ, God would shew your perfidie by manifest demonstrations For copies we haue none whether old or new but from you; and many I haue seene, and they all haue it. Yet remember that you here confesse the Popes decretall Epistles to bee corrupted (why 〈…〉 forged?) which other where you peremp•orily deny.
You may think you hear some Plato discoursing of the community of things: allege some like place of Luther's. What then followeth after in those patches of yours? For because the carnal knowledge of the wife is as necessary to every one, as meat, and drink, and sleep are. eThe Apostle commandeth,2 that every one for the avoiding of fornication, have his wife, and every woman her own husband: and that they that cannot contain, should marry. They therefore who have it not given to them by God, as that they can always be without wives; to such it is necessary that they marry wives if ⟨p. 248⟩they will be honest and chaste. For I confess that marriage is not necessary for them who may wallow without punishment in all manner of uncleanness and lust. But go forward: Marriage is much better than Virginity, and against this, Christ and Saint Paul persuaded Christian men. The same things do not agree to all men: and that which is most profitable to some one, may be contrary to the inclinations of others. Virginity is one of those indifferent things, which are as they are used: for it is not simply good (for then it were unlawful at all to think of marriage) but after a sort.f Thus therefore stands the matter: they that can preserve their chastity in Virginity, they may be desirous of Virginity, and yet not absolutely, but by reason of the troubles which for the most part accompany marriage: but they that cannot live chaste, such must betake them to marriage, and that so as that if they do otherwise, they enfold themselves in great sin. So that Virginity is never, save only in some respect better than marriage, but g marriage oftentimes is absolutely better than virginity. Surely we do think honourably of both these estates of life: but among you virginity is advanced, but marriage ⟨p. 249⟩basely esteemed. Basil holdeth rightly, Let virginity be honoured, let not marriage be despised. I had rather you should approve virginity by your deeds, than praise it with your words.4 Why doth the tongue sound out chastity, and the whole body show forth uncleanness? For so do ye. Even as Epiphanius writeth of the Origenists. You refuse marriages, but not lust: it is not holiness, but hypocrisy that is in honour among you. For neither did Christ nor Paul enjoin virginity to any one that had not power to receive it.
You may think you heare some Plato discoursing of the communitie of things: alleadge some like place of Luthers. What thē followeth after in those patches of yours? For because the carnall knowledge of the wife is as necessarie to euery one, as meate, and drinke, and sleepe are. eThe Apostle commandeth,2 that euery one for the au•iding of fornication, haue his wife, and euery woman her owne husband: and that they that cannot conteine, should marrie. They therefore who haue it not giuen to them by God, as that they can alwaies be without wiues; to such it is necessary that they marry wiues if ⟨p. 248⟩they will bee honest and chaste. For I confesse that marriage is not necessarie for them who may wallow without punishment in all manner of vncleannesse and lust. But goe forward: Marriage is much better than Virginitie, and against this, Christ and Saint Paul perswaded Christian men. The same things doe not agree to all men: and that which is most profitable to some one, may be contrarie to the inclinations of others. Virginitie is one of those indifferent things, which are as they are vsed: for it is not simply good (for then it were vnlawfull at all to thinke of marriage) but after a sort.f Thus therefore stands the matter: they that can preserue their chastitie in Virginitie, they may be desirous of Virginitie, and yet not absolutely, but by reason of the troubles which for the most part accompanie marriage: but they that cannot liue chast, such must betake them to marriage, and that so as that if they doe otherwise, they infolde themselues in great sinne. So that Virginitie is neuer, saue onely in some respect better than marriage, but g marriage oftentimes is absolutely better than virginitie. Surely we doe thinke honourably of both these estates of life: but among you virginitie is aduaunced, but marriage ⟨p. 249⟩basely esteemed. Basil holdeth rightly, Let virginity be honored, let not marriage be despised. I had rather you should approue virginitie by your deeds, than praise it with your words.4 Why doth the tongue sound out chastity, and the whole bodie shew forth vncleannes? For so do ye. Euen as Epiphanius writeth of the Origenists. You refuse marriages, but not lust: it is not holinesse, but hypocrisie that is in honour among you. For neither did Christ nor Paul enioyne virginitie to any one that had not power to receiue it.
eDVR. Tertul. de Monog. Hieron. lib. 1. contra Jovinian. understand it only of those who are married, that they might lawfully keep and have their wives still. WHIT pag. 690. That which Tertullian writ for the heretic Montanus, that you greatly approve of. And he that knoweth not Hierome to be further carried in the contempt of marriages, then the Scriptures do allow of, he accounteth the authority of Hieromes writings more then of the Word of God. But the Apostle rejecteth this interpretation, for when he commandeth that every man should have his wife to avoid fornication; who seeth not that this law concerneth the unmarried, who are forbidden fornication as well as the married? And after in the 9. vers he speaketh to the unmarried▪ If they cannot abstain, let them mar•••: for it is better to marry then to burn. Therefore he doth not only command that they who have wives keep them still; but that they wh•• have not, should marry, if they found it necessary for them to avoid inconti•••cie.DVR. Tertul. de Monog. Hieron. lib. 1. contra Iouinian. vnderstand it only of those vvho are married, that they might lawfully keepe and haue their wiues still. WHIT pag. 690. That which Tertullian writ for the heretike Montanus, that you greatly approue of. And hee that knoweth not Hierome to bee further carried in the contempt of marriages, then the Scriptures do allow of, he accounteth the authoritie of Hieromes writings more then of the Word of God. But the Apostle reiecteth this interpretation, for when he commandeth that euery man should haue his wife to auoid fo•nication; vvho seeth not that this law concerneth the vnma•ried, who are forbidden fornication as well as the married? And after in the 9. vers he speaketh to the vnmarried▪ If they cannot absteine, let them mar•••: for it is better to marrie then to burne. Therefore hee doth not onli• commaund that they vvho haue vviues keepe them still; but that they vvh•• haue not, should marrie, if they found it necessarie for them to auoid inconti•••cie.
For (saith Bernard) virginity is not commanded, 1but advised. Nay, they that cannot contain, are commanded to marry. Wherefore the Apostle was not only of opinion that those ought not to keep their virginity, but also he dissuaded them from it: nor would he have dissuaded them from it, if Christ had persuaded them to it. Neither are these positions proper to Luther: for all good men do both acknowledge and defend them.
For (saith Bernard) virginitie is not commaunded, 1but aduised. Nay, they that cannot conteine, are commaunded to marrie. Wherefore the Apostle was not onely of opinion that those ought not to keepe their virginitie, but also he disswaded them from it: nor would he haue disswaded them from it, if Christ had perswaded them to it. Neither are these positions proper to Luther: for all good men doe both acknowledge and defend them.
But let us hear the rest:h The more wicked that thou art, (saith he) so much the nearer art thou unto grace. The grace of Christ is sufficient not only for small sins, but also for the greatest: nor are small offenders only invited by Christ to come to him, ⟨p. 250⟩but they also that are laden with the burden of their sins. Luther exhorts thee not to go forward in sin, but that thou shouldest not despair of pardon. And certainly thei more wicked that thou hast been in thy life by-past, so much the more abundant grace shall embrace thee, if thou be truly penitent for thy sins.3 For where sin hath abounded, grace hath overabounded. If you condemn Luther, who will think that you let Paul pass free? For you have the same action against both, sith they be of one and the same judgement. What followeth? All good actions be sins; of God be severe in judgement, they are damnable sins; if he be favourable, they be but small ones, kLuther said this, and he said it truly. For in every action of a man, ⟨p. 251⟩lthough never so excellent, there is some fault, which may wholly mar the action, and make it odious to God, if that which is done be weighed in the balance of divine justice. But after that the Lord hath received us wholly to favour in Christ, those things which are but begun in us, & besprinkled with some blots,m yet they please him as if they were entire and pure, because he looketh upon our persons, and he doth not make search into the worth and merit ⟨p. 252⟩of the work. These things spake Luther and confirmed them by the sentences of sacred Scriptures and holy Fathers: which you could much more easily pass by than confute. Go forward. No man of himself thinketh evil. This is maliciously objected, as are all the rest. God doth throw into no man an evil thought, he compelleth the will of none to sin: yet nothing is done by chance or fortune: and in the very sins of men the providence of God ruleth. Those thoughts of men which are evil, spring out of a certain inbred naughtiness proper to every one: and yet the Lord can apply them to his own will. For so Joseph answereth his brethren: Ye thought evil against me, but the Lord turned it to good.7
But let vs heare the rest:h The more wicked that thou art, (saith he) so much the neerer art thou vnto grace. The grace of Christ is sufficient not onely for small sinnes, but also for the greatest: nor are small offenders onely inuited by Christ to come to him, ⟨p. 250⟩but they also that are laden with the burthen of their sinnes. Luther exhorts thee not to goe forward in sinne, but that thou shouldest not despaire of pardon. And certainely thei more wicked that thou hast been in thy life by-past, so much the more aboundant grace shall imbrace thee, if thou be truely penitent for thy sinnes.3 For where sinne hath abounded, grace hath ouerabounded. If you condemne Luther, who will thinke that you let Paul passe free? For you haue the same action against both, sith they be of one and the same iudgement. What followeth? All good actions be sinnes; of God be seuere in iudgement, they are damnable sinnes; if hee bee fauourable, they be but small ones, kLuther said this, and hee saide it truely. For in euery action of a man, ⟨p. 251⟩lthough neuer so excellēt, there is some fault, which may wholy marre the action, and make it odious to God, if that which is done bee weighed in the ballance of diuine iustice. But after that the Lord hath receiued vs wholy to fauour in Christ, those things which are but begun in vs, & besprinkled with some blots,m yet they please him as if they were entire and pure, because he looketh vpon our persons, and he doth not make search into the worth and merit ⟨p. 252⟩of the worke. These things spake Luther and confirmed them by the sentences of sacred Scriptures and holy Fathers: which you could much more easilie passe by than confute. Goe forward. No man of himselfe thinketh euill. This is maliciously obiected, as are all the rest. God doth throw into no man an euill thought, he compelleth the will of none to sinne: yet nothing is done by chaunce or fortune: and in the very sinnes of men the prouidence of God ruleth. Those thoughts of men which are euill, spring out of a certaine inbred naughtines proper to euery one: and yet the Lord can applie them to his owne will. For so Ioseph answereth his brethren: Ye thought euill against me, but the Lord turned it to good.
hDVR. Do you not think therefore that the devil himself is nearest of all to grace? WHIT. pag. 6•6. It is devilish so to dispute; Luther meant nothing else, but to stay mens consciences afflicted and troubled with the greatness of sin, and to comfort them with the mercy of God which, the greater sinner thou art, the greater is it on thee, when thou dost truly turn unto the Lord, as the Apostle saith, where sin abounded, grace abounded much more. Rom. 5.20.DVR. Doe you not thinke therefore that the diuell himselfe is neerest of all to grace? WHIT. pag. 6•6. It is diuellish so to dispute; Luther meant nothing els, but to stay mēs consciences afflicted and troubled with the greatnes of sin, and to comfort them vvith the mercie of God which, the greater sinner thou art, the greater is it on thee, vvhen thou dost truly turne vnto the Lord, as the Apostle saith, vvhere sinne abounded, grace abounded much more. Rom. 5.20.
iDVR. Where learned you to call him a wicked man, that is truly penitent for his sins? WHIT. pag. 697. Christ saith, Luk. 15.7 There shall be joy in heaven over one sinner that repenteth. Ask now, who taught Christ to call him a sinner that repenteth him of his sins; or why do you not quarrel with the Apostle, when he saith, God justifieth the ungodly. Rom 4.5? For he that is ungodly is not justified.DVR. VVhere learned you to call him a wicked man, that is truly penitent for his sins? WHIT. pag. 697. Christ saith, Luk. 15.7 There shal be ioy in heauen ouer one sinner that repenteth. Aske novv, vvho taught Christ to call him a sinner that repenteth him of his sinnes; or vvhy do you not quarrell with the Apostle, vvhen he saith, God iustifieth the ungodly. Rom 4.5? For he that is vngodly is not iustified.
Now you add:n The decalogue belongeth not to Christians. God doth not care for our works. Touching the decalogue and works, this answer I make you briefly. In the law the old covenant is contained; Do this and live: 2oCursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them. The law promiseth life to them, which ⟨p. 253⟩obey the Law in all things: they that offend in any thing, to them it threateneth death and damnation.p An hard condition, and which no man can ever satisfy. Christ doth propose to us another condition much easier:5 Believe and thou shalt be saved. By this new Covenant the oldq is abrogated; so as whosoever believeth the Gospel, is freed from the condition of the Law.7 For they that rbelieve are not under the Law, but under grace. What needs many words? ⟨p. 254⟩sChristians are delivered from the curse of the law, but not from the obedience of it. As for our works, surely God regardeth them: and if they be good, he rewardeth them: if contrary, he judgeth them worthy of punishment:t but in justifying of us, God hath no respect to our works:u for the just shall live, not by his works, but by his faith. Now go ⟨p. 255⟩on.* Only they do rightly receive the Lords Supper, who bring sorrowful, afflicted, & confounded consciences. And so it is indeed, for they are no right receivers, who trusting to their own merits come audaciously, but they who heing oppressed with the greatness of their sins,13 do desire to be eased. For they which are whole desire not the Physician. A contrite and broken hart is an acceptable sacrifice to God. wherefore they which have greatest feeling of their sins and sorrow for them, to them that heavenly food is wont to be most wholesome. Good Lord, who would ever think it might come to pass, that any Christian should dislike these things! But is there any thing else?x You may confess you sins, but to any ⟨p. 256⟩body, ywho if he do absolve you but in jest, so as you believe, you are absolved. And why not? for it is not need full, either to number sins by our fingers, or to use a Priest or a Friar, such a one as your self.16 We may confess our faults one to another, so as Friars may be idle hereafter. And whosoever believeth that his sins are forgiven him, him saith it self absolves, whether he be absolved in jest or in earnest.
Now you adde:n The decalogue belongeth not to Christians. God doth not care for our workes. Touching the decalogue and workes, this answere I make you briefely. In the law the olde couenant is contained; Doe this and liue: 2oCursed is euery one that continueth not in all things which are written in the booke of the law to do them. The law promiseth life to them, which ⟨p. 253⟩obey the Law in all things: they that offend in any thing, to them it threatneth death and damnation.p An hard condition, and which no man can euer satisfie. Christ doth propose to vs another condition much easier:5 Beleeue and thou shalt bee saued. By this new Couenant the oldq is abrogated; so as whosoeuer beleeueth the Gospell, is freed from the condition of the Law.7 For they that rbeleeue are not vnder the Law, but vnder grace. What needs many words? ⟨p. 254⟩sChristians are deliuered from the curse of the law, but not from the obedience of it. As for our works, surely God regardeth them: and if they be good, he rewardeth them: if contrarie, he iudgeth them worthy of punishment:t but in iustifying of vs, God hath no respect to our works:u for the iust shall liue, not by his works, but by his faith. Now goe ⟨p. 255⟩on.* Only they do rightly receiue the Lords Supper, who bring sorrowful, afflicted, & cōfounded consciences. And so it is indeed, for they are no right receiuers, who trusting to their owne merits come audaciously, but they who heing opprested with the greatues of their sinnes,
nDVR. Then why answered Christ the young man in the Gospel with this, keep the Commandments? And how do thieves and adulterers sin? or how is it a sin now to omit the duties of the moral Law, more then to omit offering up of sacrifices? WHIT. pag. 703. That which Christ answered to the young man Matth. 19.17. may well be said unto you. For you seek righteousness by the Law: wherefore keep the Law if you vvill enter into life. But here you shall find no way to enter. Luther nor any of us, ever denied that the Law pertaineth unto Christians. For the righteousness of the Law is eternal, and every man ought with all endeavour to frame his life according to the same. But it is one thing to be bound by the Law, and another thing to conform and fr•me our lives by the rule of the Law. Wherefore thieves do sin, and are justly punished; and much more they that establish the ceremonies of Moses Law, which are wholly abrogated.DVR. Then vvhy ansvvered Christ the yong man in the Gospell vvith this, keepe the Cō mandements? And hovv doe theeues and adulterers sinne? or hovv is it a sinne novv to omit the duties of the morall Lavv, more then to omit offering vp of sacrifices? WHIT. pag. 703. That vvhich Christ ansvvered to the yong man Matth. 19.17. may vvell bee said vnto you. For you seeke righteousnes by the Lavv: vvherefore keepe the Lavv if you vvill enter into life. But here you shall find no vvay to enter. Luther nor any of vs, euer denied that the Lavv pertaineth vnto Christians. For the righteousnes of the Lavv is eternall, and euery man ought vvith all endeuour to frame his life according to the same. But it is one thing to bee bound by the Lavv, and another thing to conforme and fr•me our liues by the rule of the Lavv. Wherfore theeues do sinne, and are iustly punished; and much more they that establish the ceremonies of Moses Lavv, vvhich are vvholy abrogated.
oDVR Moses denounceth not the curse against the breaches of every small precept, but to those only, which he there reckoneth up: which were certainly very heinous sins. WHIT. pag. 708. If that curse be only proper to those, who are guilty of the sins there numbered and set down, what shall we then think of blasphemers, adulterers, and of other horrible malefactors? are they free from this curse? if this be impious and absurd, then must it be understood of all, even as many as do transgress the Law. And so S. Paul interpreteth the place, who undoubtedly understood the meaning of Moses better then all Jesuits. For he instructing the Galatians, as concerning the justice of the Law, proveth by this testimony,
Well, make haste. To read prayers by the hour, belongeth not to Priests, but to lay men. What your Priests do, or what they think they ought to do, it concerns me not. Let them read, let them pray, let them say Mass, let them drink, let them play, and in a word, let them be always like themselves. It behoveth a Minister of the Gospel not to recite certain ⟨p. 257⟩Collects by an hour-glass, and to make his walk in them certain spaces of hours, but to give daily diligence unto reading,1 exhortation, and doctrine; which things your Priests have ever thought to be far different from their office. But these same prayers by the hour albeit they do not ill agree to your sacrificing priests, who unless they should spend the time on this fashion, would never go out of Stews and Taverns, yet are they unworthy of a Christian man, because of their infinitez superstition. Let us hear the rest. Christians are free from the laws of men. That never came into Luther's mind, to pluck in pieces the authority of the Magistrates, which he did always defend most diligently against the Anabaptists.a Christians are free, not that they may obey no laws, and live only to themselves, but that they may understand that their consciences and minds are freed from making the laws of men to ⟨p. 258⟩be religion. The Pope of Rome hath bound the consciences of Christian men with his Decrees and Canons, and thereby hath laid such a snare upon their minds, as that they might think they are no less bound by the Popes Canons, then by Christs precepts. Therefore Luther freeth Christian liberty from those evil opinions wherein it had been infolded, and bringeth it into that state in which Christ would have it to be, that we should acknowledge him only to be the Lord of our conscience, and that we should obey the laws of men with a free conscience. We are now at length come to the bottom of this puddle, which although you have stirred with all your diligence, yet you have not found so much as one paradox, or a piece of a paradox of ours.
Well, make haste. To reade prayers by the houre, belongeth not to Priests, but to lay mē. What your Priests do, or what they thinke they ought to do, it concernes me not. Let them reade, let them pray, let them say Masse, let them drinke, let them play, and in a word, let them be alwayes like themselues. It behoueth a Minister of the Gospell not to recite certaine ⟨p. 257⟩Collects by an houre-glasse, and to make his walke in them certaine spaces of houres, but to giue daily diligence vnto reading,1 exhortation, and doctrine; which things your Priests haue euer thought to be farre different from their office. But these same prayers by the houre albeit they do not ill agree to your sacrificing priests, who vnlesse they should spēd the time on this fashion, would neuer goe out of Stewes and Tauernes, yet are they vnworthie of a Christian man, because of their infinitez superstition. Let vs heare the rest. Christians are free from the lawes of men. That neuer came into Luthers mind, to pluck in peeces the authority of the Magistrates, which he did alwaies defend most diligently against the Anabaptists.a Christians are free, not that they may obey no lawes, and liue only to themselues, but that they may vnderstand that their consciences and minds are freed from making the lawes of men to ⟨p. 258⟩be religion. The Pope of Rome hath bound the consciences of Christian men with his Decrees and Canons, and thereby hath laid such a snare vpon their minds, as that they might thinke they are no lesse bound by the Popes Canons, then by Christs precepts. Therfore Luther freeth Christian liberty from those euill opinions wherein it had bene infolded, and bringeth it into that state in which Christ would haue it to be, that we should acknowledge him only to be the Lord of our conscience, and that we should obey the lawes of men with a free conscience. We are now at length come to the bottome of this puddle, which although you haue stirred with all your diligence, yet you haue not found so much as one paradoxe, or a peece of a paradoxe of ours.
zDVR. Js it superstition to sing Psalms unto God, to pray for remission of sins, and other temporal and spiritual graces, and to perform other exercises of religion? who knoweth not, that Christians had their night Psalms? that the Hymns of Ambrose were at set times. In the Acts we read, that Peter and John went into the Temple at the ninth hour of prayer. WHIT. pag. 726. These things I reproved not as superstitious and impious, but that all the time, which should be bestowed in instructing the people, should be spent in saying their daily appointed hours, specially in that tongue which not the people, and often times not the Priest himself doth understand. No man is ignorant that Christians had their night hours, but it was because they might not assemble themselves in the day time: vvill you keep this custom, and not be accounted superstitious? The Hymns of Ambrose are full of piety, and far from superstitious chanting As for the Apostles, they went not up to sacrifice nor to keep Canonical hours, but to instruct the people who came thither to the evening sacrifice in great multitudes.DVR. Js it superstition to sing Psalmes vnto God, to pray for remission of sinnes, and other temporall and spirituall graces, and to performe other exercises of religion? vvho knovveth not, that Christians had their night Psalmes? that the Hymnes of Ambrose vvere at set times. In the Acts vve read, that Peter and Iohn vvent into the Temple at the ninth houre of prayer. WHIT. pag. 726. These things I reproued not as superstitious and impious, but that all the time, which should be bestovved in instructing the people, should be spent in saying their daily appointed houres, specially in that tongue vvhich not the people, and often times not the Priest himselfe doth vnderstand. No man is ignorant that Christians had their night houres, but it vvas because they might not assemble themselues in the day time: vvill you keepe this custome, and not be accounted superstitious? The Hymnes of Ambrose are full of piety, and sarre from superstitious chaunting As for the Apostles, they vvent not vp to sacrifice nor to keepe Canonicall houres, but to instruct the people who came thither to the euening sacrifice in great multitudes.
aDVR. It they be bound to obey, how are their consciences free from the religion of them? Jf was a humane law, Act. 15.20. touching, strangled and blood. And Rom. 13.2.5. and
But now if I would but a little make search into the most filthy puddles of your writers, as to reckon up what they have affirmed, of God, of the Providence of God, of Predestination, of the Person and Offices of Christ, of Original sin, of the Law, of Righteousness, of the Sacraments, of Purgatory, of the Pope of Rome, and of the rest of the greatest controversies in Religion, how many Carts should I fill with paradoxes, horrible to be spoken, or thought? But it is ⟨p. 259⟩better not at this time to stir this common Sewer: and otherwhere (I hope) occasion will be given to speak hereof. Now in that you would join the Lutherans and Zwinglians together, therein surely you have not offended us, for we both reverence Luther as a father, and we embrace them as very deer brethren in Christ. And verily we hope it will come to pass, that this controversy, which is between us being compounded, we shall all with joint minds and studies set upon the common enemy. As for that you say touching your self, I am easily persuaded to think it to be true, whether it be that you speak it heartily or feignedly. For what (I beseech you) have you alleged, for which we should not rather think you to be some Rhetorical Actor upon a Stage, then a learned and experienced Divine? Campian, if you be wise, be quiet, for (believe me) you cannot endure the force and violence of this combat. Let those choice and old soldiers put themselves into the camp, who are, if not more bold to provoke, yet more wary to avoid blows, and much more skilful in all discipline of war. To enter combat with these, both the Universities have many worthy men, and I trust there will never want excellent Divines to wage perpetual war with the broken bands of Antichrist.
But now if I would but a little make search into the most filthy puddles of your writers, as to recken vp what they haue affirmed, of God, of the Prouidence of God, of Predestination, of the Person and Offices of Christ, of Originall sin, of the Law, of Righteousnes, of the Sacraments, of Purgatory, of the Pope of Rome, and of the rest of the greatest controuersies in Religion, how many Carts should I fill with paradoxes, horrible to be spoken, or thought? But it is ⟨p. 259⟩better not at this time to stirre this common Sewre: and otherwhere (I hope) occasion will be giuen to speake hereof. Now in that you would ioine the Lutherans and Zwinglians together, therein surely you haue not offended vs, for we both reuerence Luther as a father, and we embrace them as very deere brethren in Christ. And verily we hope it will come to passe, that this controuersie, which is betweene vs being compounded, we shall all with ioint minds and studies set vpon the common enemie. As for that you say touching your selfe, I am easily perswaded to thinke it to be true, whether it be that you speake it hartily or sainedly. For what (I beseech you) haue you alledged, for which wee should not rather thinke you to be some Rhetoricall Actor vpon a Stage, then a learned and experienced Diuine? Campian, if you be wise, be quiet, for (beleeue me) you cannot indure the force and violence of this combate. Let those choise and old souldiers put themselues into the camp, who are, if not more bold to prouoke, yet more wary to auoid blowes, and much more skilfull in all discipline of warre. To enter combate with these, both the Vniuersities haue many worthie men, and I trust there will neuer want excellent Diuines to wage perpetuall warre with the broken bands of Antichrist.
IT is an ancient Proverb, that a pore-blind man may be a King amongst the blind. Amongst the ignorant sort of people many times a coloured argument taketh place, the which the Philosophers school doth hiss at. The* Adversary herein much offendeth, but namely in four kinds of fallaces he is well practised, which I had rather disclose in the University schools, then in the common streets, whither only rude people do resort. The first fault is called Schiamachia, 2which is a forcible striking of the air, and beating of shadows on this sort, against those that are single and have* sworn and solemnly vowed to live in Chastity, because Marriage is good, but Virginity is better. They bring scriptures that speak very* honourably of Matrimony:5 Whom do they pierce with their darts? Against the* merits of a Christian man dipped in Christs blood, without the which there is no merit at all. They recite testimonies, which command us to put our affiance neither in nature nor in the law, but in the blood of Christ; whom do they confute? Against those that honour Saints, as the most acceptable servants of Christ, there are vouched whole pages of scripture, which prohibit the* worshipping of many gods? Such Arguments as these, which I see swarm amongst the Adversaries, cannot hurt us, well may they be loathsome unto you.
IT is an auncient Prouerb, that a pore-blinde man may be a King amongst the blinde. Amongst the ignorant sort of people many times a coloured argument taketh place, the which the Philosophers schoole doth hisse at. The* Aduersarie herein much offendeth, but namely in foure kinds of fallaces he is well practised, which I had rather disclose in the Vniuersitie schooles, then in the common streets, whither only rude people do resort. The first fault is called Schiamachia, 2which is a forcible striking of the ayer, and beating of shadowes on this sort, against those that are single and haue* sworne and solemnely vowed to liue in Chastity, because Marriage is good, but Virginitie is better. They bring scriptures that speake very* honorably of Matrimony:5 Whom do they pierce with their darts? Against the* merits of a Christian man dipped in Christes bloud, without the which there is no merit at all. They recite testimonies, which commaund vs to put our affiance neither in nature nor in the lawe, but in the bloud of Christ; whom do they confute? Against those that honor Saints, as the most acceptable seruants of Christ, there are vouched whole pages of scripture, which prohibit the* worshipping of many gods? Such Arguments as these, which I see swarme amongst the Aduersaries, cannot hurt vs, well may they be loathsome vnto you.
*This is false: you can produce none of our sophisms: and those you speak of are yours, not oursThis is false: you can produce none of our sophismes: and those you speake of are yours, not ours
2Schiamachia.
*Those oaths and vows are taken and made against the scriptures.Those oathes and vovves are taken and made against the scriptures.
*Marriage is honourable in all conditions of men, therefore in Ministers.Marriage is honorable in all conditions of men, therefore in Ministers.
*All he can do are his duties, therefore there can be no merits.
*They who worship many Saints, worship many Gods. Papists worship many Saints ergo.They vvho vvorship many Saints, vvorship many Gods. Papists vvorship many Saints ergo.
The second fault is Logomachia, 1which is a leaning of the matter it self, and contentiously to strive about ⟨p. 261⟩a bare word. Find if thou canst (say they) this word Missa, 1. Mass, or Purgatorium. 1. Purgatory in the scripture. What if I cannot? Is there not a* Trinity, a consubstantiality, or the person of God to be proved out of the Bible, because these words Trinitas 1. a trinity, Homoousios, 1. of the same substance, Persona, 1. a person be not there found? Of great alliance to this fault is Literarum aucupium, when neglecting the common usage and true meaning of the speakers, which is the very life of the word, they cavil against the bare letters. For thus they argue: Presbyter 1. a Priest, is nothing else in Greek but Senior, 1. an Elder. Sacramentum 1. a Sacrament, signifieth all kind of mystery. But S. Thomas herein as in all other matters saith most wisely, that in words we must mark not so much from whence, as to what purpose they are spoken. The third fault is Homonymia, 3which they most commonly use, as when they say to what purpose was the order of* Priesthood instituted, seeing that S. John hath called us all Priests?5 So hath he also added this, We are all Kings and shall reign upon the earth. Wherefore then were Kings ordained? Again, they say, the Prophet biddeth us observe a spiritual feast, that is, that we should refrain from our old sins: Farewell all* change of meats, and prescript times of fasting. Is the matter so indeed? Then Moses, David, Elijah, S. John Baptist, and the Apostles were stark fools, who ended their fasting from usual food after two days, three days, and certain weeks, whereas their fast from sin should have endured so long as they lived. What this fallacy is you have now seen, I hast forward. The fourth fault added to this,7 is Circulatio, a going about the bush in this manner: Tell me (I say to one of them) the true marks of the Church. He answereth the word of God, and the purest ministering of the Sacraments. Are these marks to be found amongst you, say I? who doubteth of that, saith he? I utterly deny it. Then quoth he peruse ⟨p. 262⟩the word of God. I* have already perused it, and I think worse of your side then I did before. Tush, saith he for all that the matter is most plain; prove me that, say I: because (saith he) we swerve not a finger breadth from the word of God.
The second fault is Logomachia, 1which is a leaning of the matter it selfe, and contentiously to striue about ⟨p. 261⟩a bare word. Find if thou canst (say they) this word Missa, 1. Masse, or Purgatorium. 1. Purgatorie in the scripture. What if I cannot? Is there not a* Trinity, a consubstantiality, or the person of God to be proued out of the Bible, because these words Trinitas 1. a trinity, Homoousios, 1. of the same substāce, Persona, 1. a person be not there found? Of great alliance to this fault is Literarum aucupium, when neglecting the common vsage and true meaning of the speakers, which is the very life of the word, they cauill against the bare letters. For thus they argue: Presbyter 1. a Priest, is nothing else in Greeke but Senior, 1. an Elder. Sacramentum 1. a Sacrament, signifieth all kind of mysterie. But S. Thomas herein as in all other matters saith most wisely, that in words we must marke not so much from whence, as to what purpose they are spoken. The third fault is Homonymia, 3which they most commōly vse, as whē they say to what purpose was the order of* Priesthood instituted, seeing that S. Iohn hath called vs all Priests?5 So hath he also added this, We are all Kings and shall raigne vpon the earth. Wherefore then were Kings ordained? Againe, they say, the Prophet biddeth vs obserue a spirituall feast, that is, that we should refraine from our old sinnes: Farewell all* change of meates, and prescript times of fasting. Is the matter so indeed? Then Moyses, Dauid, Helias, S. Iohn Baptist, and the Apostles were starke fooles, who ended their fasting from vsuall food after two dayes, three dayes, and certaine weekes, whereas their fast from sinne should haue endured so long as they liued. What this fallacy is you haue now seene, I hast forward. The fourth fault added to this,7 is Circulatio, a going about the bush in this manner: Tell me (I say to one of them) the true marks of the Church. He answereth the word of God, and the purest ministring of the Sacraments. Are these marks to be found amongst you, say I? who doubteth of that, saith he? I vtterly deny it. Then quoth he peruse
1Logomachia.
*A most foolish and unjust comparison.A most foolish and vniust comparison.
3Homonymia.
*Here is no Homonymy, for there are now no Priests in a Christian Church.Heere is no Homonymy, for there are now no Priests in a Christian Church.
*Campian placeth fasting in the choice of meats, and observation of days, which in mere Judaism.Campian placeth fasting in the choise of meates, and obseruation of daies, vvhich in meere Iudaisme.
7Circulatio.
*If you had consulted with the word of God, you should easily have perceived that it was so: but you consult with the Church of Rome and not with the word.If you had consulted with the vvord of God, you should easily haue perceiued that it vvas so: but you consult vvith the Church of Rome and not with the word.
Where is thy sharp wit thou braggest of? Wilt thou still for thy proof infer that which is in controversy? How often have I blamed thee for this. Wilt thou not awake out of thy dreams. Must thou have a torch lighted that thou mayest see to speak? I tell thee once again, that thou doest maliciously misconstrue the word of God. I have for my witnesses fifteen hundred years. Stand to the judgement, neither thine nor mine, but of these 1500. years. I will stand, saith he, to the judgement of the word of God.1 The spirit doth breath where he listeth. Behold what roundabouts he fetcheth, what round rings he treadeth. I know not to whom this jester and coiner of so many waste words and foolish fallaces may be a terror; troublesome peradventure he will be: may it please your wisdoms to tolerate his troublesomeness; as for the fear, the cause it self hath already quite taken away.
Where is thy sharp wit thou braggest of? Wilt thou still for thy proofe inferre that which is in controuersie? How often haue I blamed thee for this. Wilt thou not awake out of thy dreames. Must thou haue a torch lighted that thou maist see to speake? I tell thee once againe, that thou doest malitiously miscōstrue the word of God. I haue for my witnesses fifteene hundred yeares. Stand to the iudgement, neither thine nor mine, but of these 1500. yeares. I will stand, saith he, to the iudgemēt of the word of God.1 The spirit doth breath where he listeth. Behold what roundabouts he fetcheth, what round rings he treadeth. I know not to whom this iester and coyner of so many waste words and foolish fallaces may be a terror; troublesome peraduenture he will be: may it please your wisedomes to tollerate his troublesomnesse; as for the feare, the cause it selfe hath alreadie quite taken away.
IT is a goodly thing that Sophisters complain of fallacies, and that you, who your selves are altogether compact of fraud, lies, and impostures, do upbraid us with Sophistry. All your Divinity, which ought to be honest and sincere without deceit and fraud, hath of late ⟨p. 263⟩degenerated into a subtle sleight of disputing like School-boys and Sophisters: for after that you had abandoned true Divinity out of the Churches, and as it were exiled the light from mens eyes, then you began at last to put forth curious questions in the Schools; and so, as pore blind men, to be admired of those who saw nothing. Hence arose that innumerable army of Sophisters, who confounded themselves with their refined idle disputes, as with mutual wounds, in so much as who so could best skill of counterfeit and captious trifling conclusions, he should be reputed as some King or petty God over those blind and squint-eyed smatterers in Divinity. And this hope of domineering amongst so many blind ones hath egged on you Jesuits thus diligently to dwell upon this craft, and to put down all the ancient Sophisters for deceit and fraud, your selves being yet but upstarts: For if there were ever any kingdom of pore-blind men over the stark blind, questionless it is now wholly descended unto you, to whom the ancienter orders of Monks and Friars do willingly yield the garland, because they think▪ you see something. Play your prizes now you noble Sophisters, and execute with all diligence the Sophistical dominion which you have gotten, lest some hereafter happily sly dispossess you of this honour: for shortly some one or other new family and sect of Sophisters will gather strength, which (if you look not well about you) will at last shoulder and shuffle you violently out of place, and enter upon this sovereignty over the school of Sophistry, which now for some years you have possessed. For out of doubt, kingdoms themselves entitled upon petty sleights and deceitful conveyances of words, cannot long continue. Seeing therefore this your whole show of new learning consists in furbishing up of untruths, and refining the former ⟨p. 264⟩Sophistry, verily I make no question, but as it is of yesterdays building, so it will shortly fall to ruin.
IT is a goodly thing that Sophisters complaine of fallacies, and that you, who your selues are altogether compact of fraud, lies, and impostures, do vpbraid vs with Sophistrie. All your Diuinitie, which ought to be honest and sincere without deceipt and fraud, hath of late ⟨p. 263⟩degenerated into a subtle fleight of disputing like Schoole-boyes and Sophisters: for after that you had abandoned true Diuinitie out of the Churches, and as it were exiled the light from mens eyes, then you began at last to put forth curious questions in the Schooles; and so, as pore blind men, to be admired of those who saw nothing. Hence arose that innumerable army of Sophisters, who confounded themselues with their refined idle disputes, as with mutuall wounds, in so much as who so could best skill of counterfet and captious trifling conclusions, he should be reputed as some King or petie God ouer those blind and squint-eyed smatterers in Diuinitie. And this hope of domineering amongst so many blind ones hath egged on you Iesuites thus diligently to dwell vpon this craft, and to put downe all the ancient Sophisters for deceipt and fraude, your selues being yet but vpstarts: For if there were euer any kingdome of pore-blind men ouer the starck blind, questionlesse it is now wholly descended vnto you, to whom the ancienter orders of Monks and Friers do willingly yeeld the garland, because they thinke▪ you see something. Play your prizes now you noble Sophisters, and execute with all diligence the Sophisticall dominion which you haue gotten, lest some hereafter happily sleely dispossesse you of this honor: for shortly some one or other new family and sect of Sophisters will gather strength, which (if you looke not well about you) will at last shoulder and shuffle you violently out of place, and enter vpon this soueraigntie ouer the schoole of Sophistrie, which now for some yeares you haue possessed. For out of doubt, kingdomes themselues entitled vpon pety sleights and deceiptfull conueiances of words, cannot long continue. Seeing therefore this your whole shew of new learning consists in furbushing vp of vntruths, and refining the former ⟨p. 264⟩Sophistrie, verily I make no question, but as it is of yesterdayes building, so it will shortly fall to ruine.
But for as much as you mention certain Sophisms as ours, and persuade your favourites that we use very much sophistry; before I answer to these your falsehoods which you lay to our charge, I will give the reader a taste of your own most notorious false-groundeda disputations, and deceitful Elenches; that so,2 whether you or we be more truly to be termed Sophisters, the School and University it self may determine betwixt us, where you desire rather these things should be discussed, then amongst the vulgar. I for my part do appeal unto this school of Philosophers, and University of Divines; and I earnestly beseech all men who have understanding in the principles either of Divinity or Logic, and as many as ever tasted of any School-learning, that they will heedfully observe how current these your conclusions be, and examine them by the rules of right and true disputation.
But for as much as you mention certain Sophismes as ours, and perswade your fauorites that we vse very much sophistrie; before I answere to these your falshoods which you lay to our charge, I will giue the reader a tast of your owne most notorious false-groundeda disputations, and deceiptfull Elenches; that so,2 whether you or we be more truly to be tearmed Sophisters, the Schoole and Vniuersitie it selfe may determine betwixt vs, where you desire rather these things should be discussed, then amongst the vulgar. I for my part do appeale vnto this schoole of Philosophers, and Vniuersitie of Diuines; and I earnestly beseech all men who haue vnderstanding in the principles either of Diuinitie or Logick, and as many as euer tasted of any Schoole-learning, that they will heedfully obserue how current these your conclusions be, and examine them by the rules of right and true disputation.
aDVR. Our Ancestors, otherwise most wise men, having not always to deal with wilful spirits, did not strictly stand upon exact form of teaching. WHIT. pag. 734. The cause is the more desperate when such wise men could find no better arguments to maintain it, but such as even your self confess to be but weak: and both their hearers were then too credulous to believe, and you are now ridiculous to defend such loose arguments.DVR. Our Auncestors, otherwise most wise men, hauing not alvvaies to deale with wilfull spirits, did not strictly stand vpon exact forme of teaching. WHIT. pag. 734. The cause is the more desperate whē such wise mē could find no better arguments to maintaine it, but such as euen your self confesse to be but weake: and both their hearers were then too credulous to beleeue, and you are now ridiculous to defend such loose arguments.
And indeed to choose, I will there begin, where you your self have made an entrance. We maintain, that it is lawful for Ministers of the Gospel, and for Deacons, to be married. You scorn the arguments whereby we make it good. Wherefore let us consider what goodly stuff is brought on your side for the contrary.
And indeed to chuse, I will there begin, where you your selfe haue made an entrance. We mainteine, that it is lawfull for Ministers of the Gospell, and for Deacons, to be maried. You skorne the arguments whereby we make it good. Wherefore let vs consider what goodly stuffe is brought on your side for the contrarie.
Pope Innocent, the second of that name,1 thus concludeth (you must suppose) by divine inspiration against these marriages: They which are inb the flesh ⟨p. 265⟩cannot please God:3 Unto the pure, all things are pure, but unto them that are defiled and unbelieving, is nothing pure. Be ye holy, because I the Lord your God am holy. And because S. Paul permitteth married people (by consent) to sleep apart for a season, to the end they may more conveniently give themselves to fasting & prayer;4 here hence the Pope gathereth, that this is much morec to be done of Priests, whose office is to pray always, & to offer that daily sacrifice.6 Last of all, seeing they must be a temple of the Lord, and an oratory of the spirit,d they ought not to abase themselves with bed-pleasures & uncleannesses. Now out of all these he concludeth that which he propounded, that Deacons and Priests are flatly forbidden to marry.8 If these things be absurdly disputed, let us hear others. Several Pastors have rule over several flocks:c therefore the Pope ought to ⟨p. 266⟩have dominion over all Churches. Christ said to Peter feed my sheep;f therefore Peter is the chief & principal Pastor of the Church. The Lord made two great lights, the Sun,g & the Moon: therefore the Pope excelleth the Emperor in honour and greatness. Here are two swords; therefore theh Pope must ⟨p. 267⟩bear both swords. The servant is not above his master: thereforei it is lawful for no man to accuse or reprove the Pope. Christ prayed that Peters faith should not fail him:k therefore the Pope cannot err. The vulgar people cometh seldom and negligently to the Lords Supper:l therefore the Priest may celebrate private Mass. Christ admitted only his Apostles to Sup: therefore Priests alone mustm receive the Sacrament; the people ought to be contented only with one part. The title which Pilate fastened upon the Cross, was written in Hebrew, ⟨p. 268⟩Greek, & Latin: thereforen prayers must be read in the Churches in no language, but either Hebrew, or Greek, or Latin.18 That which is holy must not be given to dogs:o therefore the vulgar people must be forbidden to read the Scriptures. This is my body: therefore thep bread is turned into Christs body. Fall down before his footstool:q therefore the Sacrament must be worshipped. God is no respectre of persons:22rtherefore he chooseth no ⟨p. 269⟩man to life eternal, but with respect of merits. S.
Pope Innocent, the second of that name,1 thus concludeth (you must suppose) by diuine inspiration against these mariages: They which are inb the flesh ⟨p. 265⟩cannot please God:3 Vnto the pure, al things are pure, but vnto them that are defiled and vnbeleeuing, is nothing pure. Be yee holy, because I the Lord your God am holy. And because S. Paul permitteth married people (by consent) to sleepe apart for a season, to the end they may more conueniently giue themselues to fasting & praier;4 here hēce the Pope gathereth, that this is much morec to be done of Priests, whose office is to pray alwaies, & to offer that daily sacrifice.6 Last of al, seeing they must be a tēple of the Lord, and an oratory of the spirit,d they ought not to abase themselues with bed-pleasures & vncleannesses. Now out of all these he cōcludeth that which he propounded, that Deacons and Priests are flatlie forbidden to marry.8 If these things be absurdly disputed, let vs heare others. Seuerall Pastors haue rule ouer seuerall flockes:c therefore the Pope ought to ⟨p. 266⟩haue dominion ouer all Churches. Christ said to Peter feed my sheepe;f therefore Peter is the chiefe & principall Pastor of the Church. The Lord made two great lights, the Sunne,g & the Moone: therfore the Pope excelleth the Emperour in honour and greatnes. Heere are two swords; therfore theh
bDVR. Pope Innocent spake of Priests, who had vowed single life of their own accord, but afterward yielded to lust. WHIT. pag. 735. Nay he spake that of all Deacons and Priests, for he saith further (Distinct. 82. cap. proposuisti) It is not lawful to admit them to holy offices, which use carnal company •ith their wives, because it is written, ••e ye holy, for […] the Lord your God am holy: for then he esteemed marriage duty to be an unholy thing in it self; not in respect of their vow, of which he speaketh not a word.DVR. Pope Innocent spake of Priests, who had vowed single life of their ovvne accord, but aftervvard yeelded to lust. WHIT. pag. 735. Nay he spake that of all Deacons and Priests, for hee saith further (Distinct. 82. cap. proposuisti) It is not lawfull to admit them to holy offices, which vse carnall companie •ith their wiues, because it is written, ••e yee holy, for 〈…〉 the Lord your God am holy: for then hee esteemed marriage duty to bee an vnholie thing in it selfe; not in respect of their vow, of which he speaketh not a word.
cDVR. This argument is good and can have no show of error. For, above all men, a Priest must be chaste, saith Origen, Homil. 6 4. in Levit. Also Jerome and Ambrose, and Epiphanius taught the same WHIT. pag. 736. Yea you er•e and mistake S. Paul in theree things: 1. What he wrote to all Christians, you expound of Lay-men only. 2. He speaketh only of extraordinary fasts & prayer, but you apply it unto all sorts thereof. That the Apostle speaketh of extraordinary, appears, 1. Because he hath joined fasting with them, 1. Cor. 7.5.2. Because Christ and his Apostle have commanded all to pray continually, and so all ought to l•ue a single life. 3. From a short abstinence of Lay-men, you childishly would prove a perpetual single life to be necessary for Ministers. You abuse also Origens words, (& play the heretic) as if chastity were contrary to matrimony; whereas the Fathers of the Nicene Councell, consented to Paphnutius, who said openly, that society with a lawful wie, is chastity: Socrates lib. 1. cap. 11. Jerome indeed disputed too sophistically against matrimony, seeking victory more then verity, as himself confessed. Ambrse and Epiphanius dissuaded Ministers only from second marriages, allowing their fist.
James commandeth that sick persons should be anointed:s therefore we must now ever and anon anoint the sick. This is a great mystery:t therefore Matrimony is a Sacrament. Elijah and John Baptist lived in the wilderness:u therefore they invented the manner of life and discipline of Monks. There are seven deadly sins:x therefore there are just seven Sacraments. God made man after his image:y therefore images must be set up in Churches. The chiefest of these is charity:z therefore we are justified more by charity than by faith. I will go,7 saith the Lord, to my place, until they ponder ⟨p. 270⟩in their heart, and seek my face: (which indeed he spakea ironically, and after the manner of men) therefore men may be converted unto the Lord, by their own mere will and disposition. The Lord commandeth us to do many things:b therefore those things may be performed of us. Christ descended to the dead: therefore he deliveredc the Fathers out of Limbus. The Church discerneth the Scriptures:d therefore the authority of the Church is greater than the authority of the Scriptures. Saint Paul commandeth the Thessalonians,12 that they keep the ordinances which they had learned: ⟨p. 271⟩thereforee all things are not written which are necessary to salvation.14 He himself shall be safe, yet as it were through fire: ftherefore men pass through the fire of Purgatory to life eternal.
Iames commaundeth that sicke persons should be anointed:s therefore we must now euer and anon anoint the sicke. This is a great mysterie:t therefore Matrimonie is a Sacrament. Elias and Iohn Baptist liued in the wildernesse:u therefore they inuented the manner of life and discipline of Monkes. There are seuen deadly sinnes:x therefore there are iust seuen Sacraments. God made man after his image:y therefore images must be set vp in Churches. The chiefest of these is charitie:z therefore we are iustified more by charitie than by faith. I will goe,7 saith the Lord, to my place, vntill they ponder ⟨p. 270⟩in their heart, and seeke my face: (which indeede he spakea ironically, and after the manner of men) therefore men may be conuerted vnto the Lord, by their owne meere will and disposition. The Lord commaundeth vs to doe many things:b therefore those things may be performed of vs. Christ descended to the dead: therefore he deliueredc the Fathers out of Limbus. The Church discerneth the Scriptures:d therefore the authoritie of the Church is greater than the authoritie of the Scriptures. Saint Paul commaundeth the Thessalonians,12 that they keepe the ordinances which they had learned: ⟨p. 271⟩thereforee
sDVR. The sick want health now as well as then, and therefore must now have the same helping remedy. WHIT. pag. 763. Anointing was a sign of healing in those times of extraordinary gifts in the Church; your anointing healeth nothing that wanteth health; and so is frivolous.DVR. The sicke vvant health novv as vvell as then, and therefore must novv haue the same helping remedie. WHIT. pag. 763. Anointing was a signe of healing in those times of extraordinarie giftes in the Church; your anointing healeth nothing that wanteth health; and so is friuolous.
tDVR. The Apostle speaketh that properly of Matrimonte. WHIT. pag. 764. Nay, he himself expounds it of the mystical union between Christ and the Church.DVR. The Apostle speaketh that properly of Matrimonte. WHIT. pag. 764. Nay, he himselfe expoundes it of the mysticall vnion betweene Christ and the Church.
uDVR. These men left a famous example of Monkish life. WHIT. pag. 765. The Monks life is not proved by their examples: for Elijah was commanded to go into the desert during peril; they do that without both precept and peril: John Baptist indeed lived in the desert, but wherein men did dwell, to whom also he preached; and there were many cities and towns in that desert, Josh. 15.61. what is this to idle Monkish life?DVR. These men left a famous example of Monkish life. WHIT. pag. 765. The Monkes life is not proued by their examples: for Elias was commaunded to goe into the desert during perill; they doe that without both precept and perill: John Baptist indeede liued in the desert, but wherein men did dwell, to whom also he preached; and there were many cities and townes in that desert, Josh. 15.61. what is this to idle Monkish life?
xDVR. Name him that thus disputeth. WHIT. pag. 766. It is John L•d•wicke, in a book entitled. The golden work of true contrition, leaf 128. Where are abunuen sorts of men in the Church, &c.DVR. Name him that thus disputeth. WHIT. pag. 766. It is Iohn L•d•vvicke, in a booke intituled. The golden vvorke of true contrition, leafe 128. Where are abunuen sorts of men in the Church, &c.
To what purpose should I rehearse innumerable others your disputations like these? Now, Campian, let us hear a few of your own. Augustine wrote three books of free will: therefore Augustine approved that man hath free will. Christ was ignorant of some thing: therefore Christ was not without sin. The Fathers diligently searched the Scriptures: therefore it is never lawful to dissent from the Fathers.
To what purpose should I rehearse innumerable others your disputations like these? Now, Campian, let vs heare a few of your owne. Augustine wrote three bookes of free will: therefore Augustine approued that man hath free will. Christ was ignorant of some thing: therefore Christ was not without sinne. The Fathers diligently searched the Scriptures: therefore it is neuer lawfull to dissent from the Fathers.
These your argumentations I have thus briefly collected: which what goodly ones they be, our University ⟨p. 272⟩students easily perceive. Do you acknowledge them to be your own, Campian, so sophistical, so inconsequent, so full of deceit and falsehoods? You were in a great strait if you could not deny it; but if you confess it, you are quite overthrown: for all these are very unlearnedly concluded; either by mistaking words of double signification; or by wresting phrases figuratively spoken: or without any consequent; or from ignorance of the Elenche; or (to conclude) altogether trifling. It sufficeth that I have touched these but lightly: now I come to those which you object against us.
These your argumentations I haue thus briefely collected: which what goodly ones they be, our Vniuersitie ⟨p. 272⟩students easilie perceiue. Doe you acknowledge them to be your owne, Campian, so sophisticall, so inconsequent, so full of deceite and falsehoods? You were in a great straite if you could not denie it; but if you confesse it, you are quite ouerthrowne: for all these are very vnlearnedly concluded; either by mistaking words of double signification; or by wresting phrases figuratiuely spoken: or without any consequent; or from ignorance of the Elenche; or (to conclude) altogethe trifling. It sufficeth that I haue touched these but lightly: now I come to those which you obiect against vs.
There be four chief heads of deceitful disputing,1 wherein you say our sophistry chiefly consisteth: to wit, Sciamachia, a fighting with a shadow, Logomachia, a contention about words. Homonymia, a mistaking of the sense of words: and Circulatio, a going about the bush. Let us see how grossly we use to err in them. Sciamachia, or a fighting with ones shadow, you first define, then you produce examples (of our supposed practise.) I dislike not the definition, and hasten to those examples. Against those that have vowed single life (say you) they allege Scriptures which speak honourably of marriage; whom smite they with such weapons? Whom but your self, Campian, and those so worthy Prelates on your side, which first imposed the vow of perpetual virginity upon Ministers of the Gospel. For if the Scriptures do indeed speak honourably of wedlock, then Pope Syricius, and Innocent the second of that name, and such others your stout maintainers of single life, can by no means be defended, who, as is well known, have spoken many things basely,a despitefully, and wickedly ⟨p. 273⟩of matrimony. Consider well those speeches which even now I produced, taken out of your law: deny, if you can for shame, that they be dishonest in themselves, and egregiously injurious to wedlock. Certainly if these Scriptures do indeed wound (the ancient heretics) Saturninus, Severus, bTatianus, the Encratites, and the Archontici, needs must they also most sharply touch you to the quick, which commonly are wont to judge and speak no whit more honourably of wedlock than they have done. For show me, Campian, if you can, wherein those reproachful speeches may any whit more touch the marriage of Ministers, than of other men. Thus then both you your selves have apparently fled to the heretics holds; and also these Scriptures which do speak so honourably of wedlock, do disprove your heresy, and give you a very deadly wound. For thus I press our argument more effectually (than you:) If wedlock be honourable in every degree of men, and the bed undefiled; then in no degree ought they to be esteemed dishonest or impure: but the antecedent isc true; therefore the consequent is necessarily true also.5 What can you here disprove? or why hath it not the force of a necessary conclusion, out of which you shall never be able to wind your self?
There be foure chiefe heads of deceitfull disputing,1 wherein you say our sophistrie chiefely consisteth: to wit, Sciamachia, a fighting with a shadow, Logomachia, a contention about words. Homonymia, a mistaking of the sense of words: and Circulatio, a going about the bush. Let vs see how grossely wee vse to erre in them. Sciamachia, or a fighting with ones shadow, you first define, then you produce examples (of our supposed practise.) I dislike not the definition, and hasten to those examples. Against those that haue vowed single life (say you) they alleage Scriptures which speake honourably of mariage; whom smite they with such weapons? Whom but your selfe, Campian, and those so worthy Prelates on your side, which first imposed the vowe of perpetuall virginitie vpon Ministers of the Gospell. For if the Scriptures doe indeed speake honourably of wedlocke, then Pope Syricius, and Innocent the second of that name, and such others your stoute maintainers of single life, can by no meanes be defended, who, as is well knowne, haue spoken many things basely,a despitefully, and wickedly ⟨p. 273⟩of matrimonie. Consider well those speeches which euen now I produced, taken out of your law: deny, if you can for shame, that they be dishonest in themselues, and egregiouslie iniurious to wedlocke. Certainely if these Scriptures doe indeed wound (the auncient heretikes) Saturninus, Seuerus, bTatianus, the Encratites, and the Archontici, needs must they also most sharpely touch you to the quicke, which commonly are woont to iudge and speake no whit more honourably of wedlocke than they haue done. For shew me, Campian, if you can, wherein those reprochfull speeches may any whit more touch the marriage of Ministers, than of other men. Thus then both you your selues haue apparantly fled to the heretikes holdes; and also these Scriptures which doe speake so honourably of wedlocke, doe disproue your heresie, and giue you a very deadly wound. For thus I presse our argument more effectually (than you:) If wedlocke be honourable in euery degree of men, and the bed vndefiled; then in no degree ought they to be esteemed dishonest or impure: but the antecedent isc true; therefore the consequent is necessarily true also.5 What can you here disproue? or why hath it not the force of a necessarie conclusion, out of which you shall neuer be able to winde your selfe?
1Sciamachia.
aDVR. This is your impudency, for we say matrimony is so holy, that it is even a Sacrament, yet not equal with Virginity. WHIT. pag. 778. All men know what Syricius and Jnnocentius wrote of Matrimony. By the Scriptures it appeareth to be equally holy with virginity; if not, why bring you no testimony to the contrary? And it is very absurd, that you account virginity more holy, and yet will needs have matrimony to be a Sacrament: virginity should rather be a Sacrament, seeing (by your opinion) it is the more holy.DVR. This is your impudencie, for vve say matrimony is so holie, that it is euen a Sacrament, yet not equall vvith Virginitie. WHIT. pag. 778. All men know what Syricius and Jnnocentius wrote of Matrimony. By the Scriptures it appeareth to be equally holy with virginity; if not, why bring you no testimony to the contrarie? And it is very absurd, that you account virginity more holy, and yet wil needs haue matrimony to be a Sacrament: virginity should rather be a Sacrament, seeing (by your opinion) it is the more holy.
bDVR. What Catholic ever esteemed marriage to be no better than pollution, as those heretics did? WHIT. pag. 779. Pope Innocent in effect, in that he dissuaded Deacons from it, because they must be holy, and have nothing to do with pollutions, and bed-pleasures: than which Tatianus himself could say nothing against marriage more impious.DVR. VVhat Catholike euer esteemed marriage to be no better than pollution, as those heretikes did? WHIT. pag. 779. Pope Innocent in effect, in that he disswaded Deacons from it, because they must be holy, and haue nothing to do with pollutiōs, and bed-pleasures: than which Tatianus himselfe could say nothing against mariage more impious.
cDVR. By this argument, you may as well condemn Saint Paul: for marriage is honourable, even in those widows, who yet have damnation (saith he) because they will marry. WHIT. pag. 779. S. Paul disalloweth such widows, not because they would marry, but because they would reject their faith & Christian profession, by waxing wanton, & marrying with Infidels.DVR. By this argument, you may as well cōdemne Saint Paul: for marriage is honorable, euē in those widowes, who yet haue damnation (saith he) because they will marry. WHIT. pag. 779. S. Paul disalloweth such widowes, not because they vvould marry, but because they vvould reiect their faith & Christian professiō, by waxing wanton, & marrying with Infidels.
Against the merits of a Christian man, dipped in Christs blood (say you) they recite testimonies, which command us to put our affiance neither in nature, nor in the Law, but in the blood of Christ: whom do they confute with these testimonies? Those arguments ⟨p. 274⟩which are urged by our side against mens merits, do most clearly confute you and strike you dead. Mans nature is corrupt;1 and the Law showeth the disease, but doth not cure it: therefore all our hope of salvation consisteth in Christs blood. But you have devised us a kind of merit, forsooth, dipped in the blood of Christ, which may avail much to deserve salvation. For so you maintain, that salvation doth not wholly consist in the blood of Christ, but that it much what dependeth upon your own merits; yet so as that they be dipped with Christs blood; lest you might be thought down right Pelagians. To speak more plainly: this is that you teach, wherein the whole sum (first and last) of your righteousness consisteth: namely, That Christ hath merited for us by his blood, that we might dmerit salvation. This is that merit dipped with the blood of Christ, which you speak of, Confute now our arguments, if you can, which usually are alleged against it. Whatsoever is required as ae debt, that meriteth not: but whatsoever (good ⟨p. 275⟩thing) we do,4 is wholly a debt: therefore we have no merit at all of our own. And that you may understand, that we ought to put confidence in the blood of Christ only, and not in our own merits; I will thus reason from Saint Pauls doctrine.5 If righteousness be by the Law; then Christ died in vain: but if we be justified by ourf merits, we are justified by the Law: therefore if we be justified by our merits, Christ died in vain. What need I here mention innumerable other our arguments, not one whereof, but it is concluded demonstratively, and infallibly: whereas your own merits, alas, are very pitifully and shamelessly defended by you, against the blood of Christ.
Against the merits of a Christian man, dipped in Christs blood (say you) they recite testimonies, which commaunde vs to put our affiance neither in nature, nor in the Law, but in the blood of Christ: whom doe they confute with these testimonies? Those arguments ⟨p. 274⟩which are vrged by our side against mens merits, doe most clearely confute you and strike you dead. Mans nature is corrupt;1 and the Law sheweth the disease, but doth not cure it: therefore all our hope of saluation consisteth in Christs blood. But you haue deuised vs a kinde of merit, forsooth, dipped in the blood of Christ, which may auaile much to deserue saluation. For so you maintaine, that saluation doth not wholy consist in the blood of Christ, but that it much what dependeth vpon your owne merites; yet so as that they be dipped with Christs blood; lest you might bee thought downe right Pelagians. To speake more plainely: this is that you teach, wherein the whole summe (first and last) of your righteousnesse consisteth: namely, That Christ hath merited for vs by his blood, that we might dmerit saluation. This is that merit dipped with the blood of Christ, which you speake of, Confute now our arguments, if you can, which vsually are alleaged against it. Whatsoeuer is required as ae debte, that meriteth not: but whatsoeuer (good ⟨p. 275⟩thing) we doe,4 is wholy a debt: therefore we haue no merit at all of our owne. And that you may vnderstand, that we ought to put confidence in the blood of Christ onely, and not in our owne merits; I will thus reason from Saint Pauls doctrine.5 If righteousnesse be by the Law; then Christ died in vaine: but if we be iustified by ourf merits, we are iustified by the Law: therefore if we be iustified by our merits, Christ died in vaine. What neede I here mention innumerable other our arguments, not one whereof, but it is concluded demonstratiuely, and infallibly: whereas your owne merits, alas, are verie pittifully and shamelesly defended by you, against the blood of Christ.
dDVR. We teach plainly, that all the merits of our good works, have their force and effect only from Christs blood. WHIT. pag. 780. Thus you detract salvation from Christs merits, and ascribe it to ou• merits, dipped with his blood: which the Scriptures no where teach, but utterly condemn, proving that all our good works, are in something faulty, and so merit not eternal life. Again by your doctrine, every man should be redeemed by his own works, and so not by one only Mediator. 1. Tim. 2.5. Thirdly, Christ undertook to obtain for us remission of sins by his own death, which he performed not perfectly, if it be in part by our own works. Fourthly; so should we not trust in God only, but also in our works dipped in Christs blood, which were blasphemy. DVR. The Scripture saith, we are worthy the kingdom of God. WHIT. pag. 782. It saith we are worthy, not because of our own merits, but in that Christs merits are communicated unto us. DVR. Life eternal is often called a reward in Scriptures, and the Fathers. WHIT. pag. 78•. Reward doth not always argue merit, but is oftentimes freely given: and the Scriptures never mention any of our merits.DVR. VVee teach plainely, that all the merits of our good workes, haue their force and effect only from Christs blood. WHIT. pag. 780. Thus you detract saluation frō Christs merits, and ascribe it to ou• merits, dipped with his blood: vvhich the Scriptures no vvhere teach, but vtterly condemne, prouing that all our good vvorkes, are in something faulty, and so merit not eternall life. Againe by your doctrine, euery man should bee redeemed by his ovvne vvorkes, and so not by one only Mediator. 1. Tim. 2.5. Thirdly, Christ vndertooke to obtaine for vs remission of sinnes by his ovvne death, which he performed not perfectly, if it be in part by our owne workes. Fourthly; so should we not trust in God only, but also in our workes dipped in Christs blood, which were blasphemie. DVR. The Scripture saith, we are vvorthie the kingdome of God. WHIT. pag. 782. It saith we are worthie, not because of our owne merits, but in that Christs merits are communicated vnto vs. DVR. Life eternall is often called a revvard in Scriptures, and the Fathers. WHIT. pag. 78•. Reward doth not alwaies argue merit, but is oftentimes freely giuen: and the Scriptures neuer mention any of our merits.
You add to these a third example (saying) Against those which honour saints, as the most acceptable servants of Christ, there are vouched whole pages of Scriptures, which prohibit the worshipping of many gods: where are they now? Verily the Lord by his own authority reserveth unto himself,1 that we invocate him alone: wherefore who so worshippeth and inuocatethg Saints, he giveth to them the honour due to God: for he both presupposeth that they can perform any thing whatsoever, and also that they ⟨p. 276⟩beh present every where, both which are the peculiar properties of God only. So that whatsoever is (truly) alleged against many gods, that is altogether effectual against your Saints in heaven, whom both you worship more zealously than God himself, and rob him of his due honour to adorn them.4 There is (indeed) one mediator of God and men, the man Jesus Christ; he for ever maketh intercession for us; therefore they which bring in new intercessors, and mediators, arei injurious unto Christ. Tell me, Campian, have you any face to defend these your sentences following?k Command him by thy motherly authority; and those which are often chanted in the rude rime of the Mass of the virgin Mary's conception, thus:
You adde to these a third example (saying) Against those which honour saints, as the most acceptable seruants of Christ, there are vouched whole pages of Scriptures, which prohibit the worshipping of many gods: where are they now? Verily the Lord by his owne authoritie reserueth vnto himselfe,1 that we inuocate him alone: wherefore who so worshippeth and inuocatethg Saints, hee giueth to them the honour due to God: for he both presupposeth that they can performe any thing whatsoeuer, and also that they ⟨p. 276⟩beh present euery where, both which are the peculiar properties of God onely. So that whatsoeuer is (truly) alleaged against many gods, that is altogether effectuall against your Saints in heauen, whom both you worship more zealously than God himselfe, and robbe him of his due honour to adorne them.4 There is (indeed) one mediator of God and men, the man Iesus Christ; he for euer maketh intercession for vs; therefore they which bring in new intercessors, and mediators, arei iniurious vnto Christ. Tell me, Campian, haue you any face to defend these your sentences following?k Commaunde him by thy motherly authoritie; and those which are often chaunted in the rude ryme of the Masse of the virgin Maries conception, thus:
gDVR. We worship not Saints as Gods, but as the friends and servants of God; and Saint Paul himself desired to be helped by the prayers of sundry Christian Churches: so that you cavil with us, as the heathen and heretics did of old against the Fathers. WHIT. pag. 787. The honour of invocation may not be given to any of Gods friends; for we must pray to none, but whom we may call, Father, Luk. 11.2. and in whom we may believe, Rom. 10.14. therefore not to Saints at all. As for Saint Paul, he craved the prayers of Saints for him, whilst they lived▪ but he never either prayed to them living, or dead. Nor did the Catholic Fathers worship, adore, or invocate Saints departed, as you do: For Augustine Epist. 44. saith to Maximus the Heathen, know you that no Catholic Christian doth worship any of the dead, & Jerome to Vigilantius, saith, who is so mad, as to worship any of the Martyrs?DVR. VVe worship not Saints as Gods, but as the friends and seruants of God; and Saint Paul himselfe desired to be helped by the prayers of sundrie Christian Churches: so that you cauill with vs, as the heathen and heretikes did of old against the Fathers. WHIT. pag. 787. The honor of inuocation may not be giuen to any of Gods friends; for we must pray to none, but whom we may call, Father, Luk. 11.2. and in whom we may beleeue, Rom. 10.14. therefore not to Saints at all. As for Saint Paul, he craued the prayers of Saints for him, vvhilest they liued▪ but he neuer either prayed to them liuing, or dead. Nor did the Catholike Fathers vvorship, adore, or inuocate Saints departed, as you doe: For Augustine Epist. 44. saith to Maximus the Heathen, know you that no Catholike Christian doth worship any of the dead, & Ierome to Vigilantius, saith, who is so madde, as to vvorship any of the Martyrs?
hDVR. The Saints hear our prayers, though they be absent. WHIT. pag. 790. Every one that prayeth to Saints supposeth thē to be present, & to know even his thoughts, and so (in effect) maketh them Gods: as Basil proveth the holy Ghost to be God, because he heareth godly mens prayers wheresoever. DVR. The Saints are in many far distant places at once, though not every where. WHIT pag. 791. Duraeus doteth to say so: for as well they might be in all, as in many places at once: But Damascene, lib. 2. cap. 3. and Anas, quaest. 52. art. 2 say of the very Angels, that when they be in heaven, they are not in earth.
That is to say, Thou (blessed Virgin Mary) art the infallible lhope of such as are in misery, the true mother of Orphans; Thou art the consolation of such as ⟨p. 277⟩be oppressed, the medicine of such as be diseased, Thou art all min all to all men (or) in all necessities; and other such like abominable speeches, and full of strange blasphemy? If happily you think our reproving of these things, be but some fighting with a shadow, then do you no more respect the glory of God, than the shadow of an Ass.
That is to say, Thou (blessed Virgin Marie) art the infallible lhope of such as are in miserie, the true mother of Orphanes; Thou art the consolation of such as ⟨p. 277⟩be oppressed, the medicine of such as bee diseased, Thou art all min all to all men (or) in all necessities; and other such like abominable speeches, and full of strange blasphemie? If happily you thinke our reproouing of these things, be but some fighting with a shadow, then doe you no more respect the glorie of God, than the shadow of an Asse.
lDVR. Saint Paul calleth the Thessalonians his hope, 1. Thess. 2.19. WHIT. pag. 796. But he never put his trust in, nor called upon them, as you do the Virgin Mary: he called them his hope, because he received great hope and joy by his labours in their conversion. You make the Virgin an instrument of our salvation, and therefore you trust in her, but the Scriptures teach every where to trust in God and Christ only. As Psal. 71.3. Jer. 17.5.7. 1. Tim. 1.1. and 1. Pet. 1.21.DVR. Saint Paul calleth the Thessalonians his hope, 1. Thess. 2.19. WHIT. pag. 796. But hee neuer put his trust in, nor called vpon them, as you doe the Virgin Marie: hee called them his hope, because he receiued great hope and ioy by his labours in their conuersion. You make the Virgin an instrument of our saluation, and therefore you trust in her, but the Scriptures teach euery where to trust in God and Christ only. As Psal. 71.3. Ier. 17.5.7. 1. Tim. 1.1. and 1. Pet. 1.21.
mDVR. The sentence of the Catholic Church, hath no where alloved this; but if it had, it might be conveniently defended. WHIT pag. 797. Duraeus can conveniently expound that, which most absurdly taketh the office of redemption from Christ and giveth it to the Virgin Mary.DVR. The sentence of the Catholike Church, hath no vvhere alloued this; but if it had, it might be conueniently defended. WHIT pag. 797. Duraeus can conueniently expound that, which most absurdly taketh the office of re•ēption frō Christ and giueth it to the Virgin Mary.
The second error in disputation wherewith you charge us,1 is, that we often use Logomachia, which is when the sense is neglected, and men contend about the word. I understand it well: but which be those our faults committed in this kind? Can you find us (say they) the Mass, or Purgatory in the Scriptures. And is not this our demand reasonable? For where should these be found rather than in the Scriptures? There was nothing wont to be accounted more holy than the Mass, and there could nothing be invented more gainful than Purgatory: that neither of these now at last should be found in the Scriptures, certainly it may well seem a very strange and unreasonable thing. Belike then (say you) Trinitas, the Trinity; Homousios, coessential; Persona, a person, are no where in the Bible, because these very terms are not to be found there. Neither say we so, Campian, nor will it follow at all hereupon; and these things be altogether unequally compared. For albeit these very terms are not in Scriptures,2 yet the matter it self, and the sense, as Epiphanius writeth, cometh to hand in all places, and is easily every where to be found. But yourn Mass and Purgatory, are not in ⟨p. 278⟩this manner in the Scriptures, seeing neither the names nor the things themselves any where do appear: yea they are plainly against the Scriptures. For what else is either the Mass, than as* an empty sepulchre where is only the title of the Lords Supper? or what is Purgatory more than a shameless merchandise of souls, and an intolerable contempt against the blood of Christ? Wherefore this is not a trifling contention about words, but a most weighty one about matters of moment; except peradventure you make account of the Mass and Purgatory, not to be matters of moment, but words of Art only. As for the nameo Presbyter, and Sacrament, it is appropriated from the common signification, to some certain and particular things, as likewise many other names are; (to wit) Ecclesia the Church, Episcopus a Bishop, Apostolus an Apostle, Dia•onus a Deacon: and these names we willingly use, but so that we carefully shun their impertinent ⟨p. 279⟩significations. Neither was that indeed sufficient cause, why you should register Matrimony in the catalogue of Sacraments, because S. Paul wrote (thus) Sacramentum hoc magnum, 6This is a great mystery.
The second error in disputation wherewith you charge vs,1 is, that wee often vse Logomachia, which is when the sense is neglected, and men contend about the word. I vnderstand it well: but which bee those our faults committed in this kinde? Can you finde vs (say they) the Masse, or Purgatorie in the Scriptures. And is not this our demaund reasonable? For where should these be found rather than in the Scriptures? There was nothing wont to be accounted more holy than the Masse, and there could nothing be inuented more gainfull than Purgatorie: that neither of these now at last should be found in the Scriptures, certainly it may well seeme a very strange and vnreasonable thing. Belike then (say you) Trinitas, the Trinitie; Homousios, coessentiall; Persona, a person, are no where in the Bible, because these very termes are not to be found there. Neither say we so, Campian, nor will it follow at all hereupon; and these things be altogether vnequally compared. For albeit these very termes are not in Scriptures,2 yet the matter it selfe, and the sense, as Epiphanius writeth, commeth to hand in all places, and is easily euery where to bee found. But yourn Masse and Purgatorie, are not in ⟨p. 278⟩this manner in the Scriptures, seeing neither the names nor the things themselues any where do appeare: yea they are plainly against the Scriptures. For what else is either the Masse, than as* an empty sepulchre where is onely the title of the Lords Supper? or what is Purgatorie more than a shamelesse merchandise of soules, and an intolerable contempt against the blood of Christ? Wherefore this is not a trisling contention about words, but a most waightie one about matters of moment; except peraduenture you make account of the Masse and Purgatorie, not to bee matters of moment, but words of Arte only. As for the nameo Presbyter, and Sacrament, it is appropriated from the common signification, to some certaine and particular things, as likewise many other names are; (to wit) Ecclesia the Church, Episcopus a Bishop, Apostolus an Apostle, Dia•onus a Deacon: and these names wee willingly vse, but so that wee carefully shunne their impertinent ⟨p. 279⟩
1Logomachia
2Epiphan. contra Semiarian. l. 3 [Greek or Hebrew].Epiphan. contra Semiarian. l. 3 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
nDVR. Did you never read these words of Christ in his last Supper: this is my body? WHIT. pag. 799. Yea; but Christ ordained then a Sacrament, not a sacrifice: he offered himself a sacrifice only once upon the Cross, Heb 9 10. not in his last Supper, except you will say, he died then also, which he must have done to make it a sacrifice; but he was then alive, & it were most absurd to say he was alive and dead at one time, which he needs must be, both then and in all your Masses, if there be any sacrifice in the Mass at all. Again, external sacrifices, as you say your Mass is, are subject to the sight & outward senses, but no man ever saw Christ to be sacrificed, either in the Supper or in the Mass. Therefore there is none, neither in the one nor in the other. DVR. Jt was a sacrifice, for Christ was really contained under those former of bread and wine: and so the Mass is now an unbloody sacrifice. WHIT. pag. 801. You cannot prove him to be so present there as you teach, by no Scripture; and if he were, yet that was not therefore a sacrifice, except you will have his real being in the Virgins womb also to be a sacrifice, in which he was contained. As for your unbloody propitiatory sacrifice: first, it is absurd, for to sacrifice killeth a body, but your Transubstantiation maketh a body: secondly, it hath no word of God for it: thirdly, it is needless, Christs sacrifice being perfect: fourthly, Christ ordained that supper in memory of his sacrifice, not to be it self a sacrifice: WHIT. pag. •03. DVR. Many of the Fathers call the Eucharist by the name of sacrifice. WHIT. pag 805. Not because it is that same which Christ offered (as you teach) but because it is a memorial and Sacrament of it. DVR. Purgatory is most plainly proved by the fact of Judas Machabaeus, in the second book and 12. chapter. WHIT. pag. 806. Those books are not Canonical Scripture, neither doth that act prove a Purgatory by your own doctrine, who say those that die in deadly sin, (as those did there mentioned) go to hell, and not to Purgatory.DVR. Did you neuer reade these vvords of Christ in his last Supper: this is my body? WHIT. pag. 799. Yea; but Christ ordeined then a Sacramēt, not a sacrifice: he offered himselfe a sacrifice only once vpon the Crosse, Heb 9 10
For in that place, Sacramentum, is used in a large signification for any mystery, not for that ceremony which may properly be called a Sacrament. As for that counsel of Thomas Aquinas, we do very well approve it.
For in that place, Sacramentum, is vsed in a large signification for any mysterie, not for that ceremony which may properly be called a Sacrament. As for that counsell of Thomas Aquinas, we doe very well approue it.
The third head,1 or kind of deceitful disputation which you say we usually err in, is Homonymia, equivocation, or a mistaking the sense of words: whereof you propound two examples: For (say you) we both confound the order of Priests, because S. John hath termed us all Priests; and also abolish choice of meats, and prescribed observation of days, 2because the Prophet highly commendeth a spiritual fast. 3I will speak a few words both of the one and other, that I may clearly quit us of this crime of Homonymy. Saint John alone hath not named allp Christians Priests,5 but S. Peter also hath termed them a holy, and a royal Priesthood: and this name is in no place of the new Testamentq properly applied to the Ministers of the Gospel. For Christ being made an high Priest for ever after the order of Melchizedek, hath no copartners ⟨p. 280⟩of thisr Priesthood: therefore Christ hath left unto his (Churches) a Ministry, and not a new Priesthood. Neither doth there remain to uss any such sacrifice; for the administration whereof some special Priests must needs be authorised. For that sacrifice of praise, and doing good, 9which the Apostle mentioneth, and which now remaineth only; that (I say) appertaineth indifferently to all Christians. Notwithstanding we permit none to execute the administration of this ministry, which Christ would have to be perpetual in his Church, but them whom it concerneth, and who are by due ordert called thereunto. Albeit then Christ have made us all both Kings, that we might be able to subdue our sins; and Priests, that we might offer him spiritual sacrifices: ⟨p. 281⟩notwithstanding as it is not lawful for every man to dream of a kingdom, so it is a thing detestable for any man to enter upon the holy Ministry, who hath not that function committed unto him by divine authority. Wherefore I see not at all why you should charge us with any such Homonymy (or falsehood from ambiguous signification) in this word. As for your manner of fasting, that indeed is wholly in show, and hath nothing in it of a Christian fast, but the very name. For to make choice of meats, as a thing more religious, and to prescribe certain, and perpetual set days, wherein we must necessarily fast, theu one is witless, the other superstitious.
The third head,1 or kinde of deceitfull disputation which you say we vsually erre in, is Homonymia, equiuocation, or a mistaking the sense of words: whereof you propound two examples: For (say you) we both confound the order of Priests, because S. Iohn hath tearmed vs all Priests; and also abolish choice of meates, and prescribed obseruation of daies, 2because the Prophet highly commendeth a spirituall fast. 3I wil speake a few words both of the one and other, that I may cleerly quit vs of this crime of Homonymie. Saint Iohn alone hath not named allp Christians Priests,5 but S. Peter also hath tearmed them a holy, and a royall Priesthood: and this name is in no place of the new Testamentq properly applied to the Ministers of the Gospell. For Christ being made an high Priest for euer after the order of Melchisedech, hath no copartners ⟨p. 280⟩of thisr Priesthood: therefore Christ hath left vnto his (Churches) a Ministerie, and not a new Priesthood. Neither doth there remaine to vss any such sacrifice; for the administration whereof some speciall Priests must needs be authorised. For that sacrifice of praise, and doing good, 9which the Apostle mentioneth, and which now remaineth onely; that (I say) appertaineth indifferently to all Christians. Notwithstanding we permit none to execute the administration of this ministery, which Christ would haue to be perpetuall in his Church, but them whom it concerneth, and who are by due ordert called thereunto. Albeit then Christ haue made vs all both Kings, that we might be able to subdue our sinnes; and Priests, that we might offer him spirituall sacrifices: ⟨p. 281⟩
pDVR. By this argument you may as well prove the Jews had no Priests; properly so called. WHIT. pag. 809. Not so, for the Lord ordained such a Priesthood amongst them, which he hath not amongst Christians.DVR. By this argument you may as well proue the Iewes had no Priests; properly so called. WHIT. pag. 809. Not so, for the Lord ordained such a Priesthood amongst them, which he hath not amongst Christians.
qDVR. So the name, Sacrament, is never given to Baptism, nor to the Eucharist in the New testament. WHIT. pag. 810. But the substance of it, agreeth to them both, and is there, whereas the name, Sacerdos, a Priest, is not in the new Testament, nor doth the thing it self properly belong to any but Christ, since his death. DVR. Yea Christ instituted a sacrifice in his Supper, and where a sacrifice is, there is a Priest also. WHIT. pag. 810. Christ ordained thē no sacrifice, but only a Sacrament of a sacrifice. DVR. Isaiah calleth the Ministers of the Gospel, Priests, cap. 6•.6. & 66.21. WHIT. Isaiah in the first place speaketh of all Christians; and in the second, of Ministers in the phrase of that time; whence also you may as well say Deacons are Levites, which you vvill not say they are properly. DVR Ministers are needless, except they be Priects, and as mediators betwixt God and men unto salvation: and your Ministers are but Lay-men. WHIT. pag. 810. •15. They must preach the Word, and administer the Sacraments, but not offer sacrifice of mediation betwixt God and men, as you say, you do in the Mass: to do these we have a calling ordained of Christ; for your sacrifice you have none. DVR. The Apostles name them not Priests, because they are not of the order of Aaron; but the Fathers call them Priests, who knew the Apostles m•a•ing: and you call them Priests in English. WHIT pag. 812. Christ only is a Priest, after the order of Melchizedek:
chanell of grace, and we doubt not but it deriueth Christs merits into vs.
qDVR. What is that you call trash? which of the ancient Fathers have been. who have not made mention of our ceremonies. WHIT. pag. 658. Christ commanded nothing to the Church touching these trifles; & though we read often of Baptism in the word, & of many, yet there is no word touching any of these Shall we then think that the Church in later times hath known better, what ceremonies were fitter for the Sacrament then Christ and his Apostles? where did ever any of them use salt, spittle, candles, &c. in this Sacrament.DVR. What is that you call trash? vvhich of the auncient Fathers haue been. vvho haue not made mention of our ceremonies. WHIT. pag. 658. Christ cōmaunded nothing to the Church touching these trifles; & though we reade often of Baptisme in the word, & of many, yet there is no word touching any of these Shall we then thinke that the Church in later times hath knowne better, vvhat ceremonies vvere fitter for the Sacrament then Christ and his Apostles? vvhere did euer any of them vse salt, spittle, candles, &c. in this Sacrament.
rDVR. When bread and wine is your Eucharist (neither do you believe Christ gave any other thing in the Supper) we leave you your Eucharist also. WHIT. pag. 660. If we have true Baptism; why not the Eucharist? we follow Christs commandment in both. Further you falsely accuse us, who think bread & wine to be but one part of the Sacrament, as Ireneus and antiquity hath done; & Christ his body and blood the other. But you have no Eucharist at all, who profess you have neither bread nor wine.DVR. VVhen bread and vvine is your Eucharist (neither doe you beleeue Christ gaue any other thing in the Supper) vvee leaue you your Eucharist also. WHIT. pag. 660. If wee haue true Baptisme; why not the Eucharist? wee follow Christs commandement in both. Further you falsely accuse vs, who thinke bread & wine to be but one part of the Sacrament, as Ireneus and antiquity hath done; & Christ his body and blood the other. But you haue no Eucharist at all, who professe you haue neither bread nor wine.
sDVR But Calvin denieth all this, making it only a sign and seal, by which we are assured of the grace best••ed upon us. WHIT. pag. 663. Doth it follow hence that grace and remission of sin is not given unto us in Baptism? As if by the seal of the Kings Charter some thing is not both given unto us, and confirmed? And in Baptism this confirmation is but a more bountiful donation.DVR But Caluin denieth all this, making it only a signe and seale, by vvhich vve are assured of the grace best••ed vpon vs. WHIT. pag. 663. Doth it follow hence that grace and remission of sinne is not giuen vnto vs in Baptisme? As if by the seale of the Kings Charter some thing is not both giuen vnto vs, and confirmed? And in Baptisme this confirmation is but a more bountifull donation.
*DVR. Because that Baptism did prepare men to regeneration, of which preparation Christ had no need. WHIT. pag. 673. This is but your coined distinction, for the Fathers speak and answer otherwise. Christ. in 3. Matth. not that he should receive remission of sin by baptism, but that be might leave sanctified waters for those who should after be baptised. And August. in cat. •ur. in 3. Matth. Our Saviour would therefore be baptised, not that be might be sanctified, but that he might sanctify the waters for us.DVR. Because that Baptisme did prepare men to regeneration, of vvhich preparation Christ had no need. WHIT. pag. 673. This is but your coyned distinction, for the Fathers speake and answere otherwise. Chrys•st. in 3. Matth. not that he should receiue remission of sinne by •aptisme, but that be might leaue sa•ctified waters for those who should after be baptised. And August. in cat. •ur. in 3. Matth. Our Sauiour would therefore be baptised, not that bee might bee sanctified, but that he might sanctifie the waters for vs.
yDVR. God hath showed his vvill, Joh. 3.5. And •hen S. Paul makes all by nature the Children of wrath: Ephes. 2.3. If there be no remedy against this evil in the Scripture, but Baptism, what can be, but that they who die without Baptism, must needs die in the same condition? WHIT. 677. God in no place hath showed this to be his will; that they who die without Baptism, shall perish. Of the words of Christ have •in spoken, which if they be understood of Baptism, they belong only to those who are of grown years. That by no other means we can be freed from the miserable state of nature, but by Baptism, is very false. For the Spirit of God doth in and without the Sacrament, doth communicate his graces.DVR. God hath shewed his vvill, Ioh. 3.5. And •hen S. Paul makes all by nature the Children of wrath: Ephes. 2.3. If there be no remedie against this euill in the Scripture, but Baptisme, what can be, but that they vvho die vvithout Baptisme, must needs die in the same condition? WHIT. 677. God in no place hath shewed this to bee his will; that they who die without Baptisme, shall perish. Of the words of Christ haue •in spoken, which if they be vnderstood of Baptisme, they belong only to those who are of growne yeares. That by no other meanes we can be freed from the miserable state of nature, but by Baptisme, is very false. For the Spirit of God doth in and without the Sacrament, doth communicate his graces.
zDVR. He speaketh not of infants, but of those who endued with true faith, were prevented by an untimely death that they could not be baptised. WHIT. pag. 680. How truly you speak we may judge out of the same Epistle. For he thus writeth. Who is ignorant that in former times they had other remedies against original sin; besides Baptism? for to Abraham and his seed ut as the Sacrament of Circumcision given to this end. But in other nations, so many as were found faithful, we believe that they, who were of years, were sanctified by faith and sacrifices: but the parents faith did profit their infants, yea and was sufficient for them. If this was so before Christ, shall we think the condition of infants is now worse?DVR. He speaketh not of infants, but of those vvho indued with true faith, were preuented by an vntimely death that they could not be baptised. WHIT. pag. 680. How truly you speake we may iudge out of the same Epistle. For he thus writeth. VVho is ignorant that in former times they had other remedies against originall sinne; besides Baptisme? for to Abraham and his seed vt as the Sacrament of Circumcision giuen to this end. But in other nations, so many as vvere found faithfull, vvee beleeue that they, vvho vvere of yeares, vvere sanctified by faith and sacrifices: but the parents faith did profit their infants, yea and vvas sufficient for them. If this was so before Christ, shall we thinke the condition of infants is now worse?
4Bernard. in Epist. ad Hugon.
DVR. What is this else but even the same that Jovinian answered unto Hierome & the rest of the ancient Fathers? As Augustine sheweth De. Sancta Virginitate cap. 21.22.23.24. WHIT. pag. 691. Whosoever will be single for this only end that he may live so much the more […] •ase and in the more pleasure, and not be troubled with the necessary cares of marriage, do deserve to be blamed with Jovinian. And this sort of men it is that Augustine doth justly reprove. For virginity is to be desired, not simply for that end that we may •idde and free our selves from the necessary business and cares accompanying marriage, but to the end we may with sitter opportunity and more conveniency serve God, as also the Apostle •peaketh; That you may so ••w that which is honest, and that you may cleave fast unto the Lord without separation. 1. Co. 7.35. […] DVR. Who seeth not that that is more excellent in it self, which is more difficult and hard? And Christ saith, that after this life there is no marrying at all. And S. Paul, He that giveth his virgin to marriage, doth well: but he that giveth her not to marriage doth better. 1. Cor. 7.38. WHIT. pag 69•. I do not dispute against holy virginity, which I acknowledge is both hard & excellent. But single life must be distinguished from holy virginity. Very few attain this of that every one may make choice of. But your reason is of no great force, for the hardest things are not the most excellent. It is most hard for a man to live an hundred years: shall we therefore think that they who live so long, are more excellent then others? As for that in the kingdom of heaven there are no marriages, it is not of force against us: for we speak of the state of this life, after which, as there shall be no marriages, so no vows of virginity. In S. Paul, better, is as much as si••es and more commodious: for if it were supply better, it were never lawful to do otherwise; which he alloweth. Therefore he thus spake not for the nature of the thing, but in respect of circumstances: as you may see, vers. 26.28.32.35.DVR. VVhat is this else but euen the same that Iouinian ans•vered vnto Hierome & the rest of the auncient Fathers? As Augustine shevveth De. Sancta Virginitate cap. 21.22.23.24. WHIT. pag. 691. Whosoeuer will be single for this only end that he may liue so much the more 〈…〉•ase and in the more pleasure, and not be troubled with the necessary cares of marriage, do deserue to be blamed with Iouinian. And this sort of men it is that Augustine doth iustly reproue. For virginitie is to be desired, not simplie for that end that we may •idde and free our selues from the necessarie businesse and cares accompanying marriage, but to the end we may with sitter opportunitie and more conueniencie serue God, as also the Apostle •peaketh; That you may so ••vv that vvhich is honest, and that you may cleaue fast vnto the Lord vvithout separation. 1. Co. 7.35. 〈…〉 DVR. VVho seeth not that that is more excellent in it selfe, vvhich is more difficult and hard? And Christ saith, that after this life there is no marrying at all. And S. Paul, He that giueth his virgin to marriage, doth well: but hee that giueth her not to marriage doth better. 1. Cor. 7.38. WHIT. pag 69•. I do not dispute against holy virginity, which I acknowledge is both hard & excellent. But single life must be distinguished frō holy virginity. Very few attaine this of that euery one may make choise of. But your reasō is of no great force, for the hardest things are not the most excellent. It is most hard for a man to liue an hundred yeares: shal we therfore thinke that they who liue so long, are more excellent then others? As for that in the kingdome of heauē there are no marriages, it is not of force against vs: for we speak of the state of this life, after which, as there shall be no marriages, so no vowes of virginitie. In S. Paul, better, is as much as si••es and more commodious: for if it were su•plie better, it were neuer lawfull to do otherwise; which he alloweth. Therefore he thus spake not for the nature of the thing, but in respect of circumstances: as you may see, vers. 26.28.32.35.
4Hieron. ad Furiam. [Greek or Hebrew].Hieron. ad Furiam. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
. For this purpose the Sonne of God appeared, that heo might loose the works of the Devil. Neither did S. Paul well to compare good works to silver, gold, and precious stones.
. Neither did the Prophets and Apostle• well to exhort us to good works. And if all our actions (though good) be sin, do not you your selves sin whilst you believe to be justified by faith? For faith is a work, seeing Christ saith, This is the work of God, that you believe. WHIT. pag. 698. That even our good actions are tainted with some sin, no man can doubt, that either knoweth the Scriptures, or himself. As Isay saith 64.10. Now it even all our righteous actions be like unto a stinking & filthy clout, they are surely tainted with some sin. The Prophet David prayeth
. Upon which place Gregory Moral. lib. 9. cap. 1. thus writeth. The holy man because he seeth, that even all the merit of our very virtue is sin, if by an inward judgement it be rightly judged of, doth well add &c. Here Gregory calleth the merits of our virtue, that is, our very best works, sins. And again the same Gregory cap. 14. As we have often said, all humane righteousness is convinced to be unrighteousness, if it be rightly judged of. Now he that calleth our rigeteousnes unrighteousness, what saith he else, then that which Luther said, That there is some sin in every good work? This Paradox therefore Luther learned our of the Scriptures and ancient Fathers. But to come to your slender reasons. If thou take a wife, thou sinnest not. I answer here is a fallacy. For we say not to marry a wise is sin, but that they who marry wives intermix some sin in that good action. And to the place of S. Peter. I say that there you use also a fallacy: for to fall, in that place signifieth to fall away wholly and altogether from grace and salvation. For the place of S. John, we mean not that good works are sins, but that they have some sin mixed with them. For it followeth not that silver is dross, because it hath some dross mingled with it. And Christ came not to the end there should be no sin left in his Saints whilst they live here, but that he might take away the guilt of sin. And what if S. Paul hath compared our good works to silver, gold, or precious stones? Know you not that even in the best metals, and in such stones there may some dross be found? But the Apostle compareth sound doctrine to these things; than which there is nothing more precious if it be kept pure and incorrupted. The Prophets and Apostles do well to exhort us to do good works: but if they bid us do our duty, doth it therefore follow, that we may not commit some sin in doing thereof? Last of all touching your demand concerning faith, you bewray your ignorance; for we are not justified by faith, as it is a work or action of ours, for it is imperfect: but because it is as the hand whereby we lay hold on Christ, and Christ calleth faith a work either by imitation, or because it is the work of the holy Ghost that kindleth it in our hearts.
DVR. The Apostle S. Paul then said not truly; If thou take a vvife thou sinnest not. 1 Cor. 7. Then S. Peter said not truly, 2. Pet. 1.10. For if yee do these things, yee shall neuer fall. Neither said Sa•nt Iohn truly, 1. Ioh 3.8. For this purpose the Sonne of God appeared, that heo might loose the workes of the Diuell. Neither did S. Paul vvell to compare good vvorkes to siluer, gold, and precious stones. 1. Cor. 3.12. Neither did the Prophets and Apostle• well to exhort vs to good vvorks. And if all our actions (though good) be sinne, doe not you your selues sinne vvhilest you beleeue to be iustified by faith? For faith is a vvorke, seeing Christ saith, This is the worke of God, that you beleeue. WHIT. pag. 698. That euen our good actions are tainted vvith some sinne, no man can doubt, that either knoweth the Scriptures, or himself. As Isay saith 64.10. Now it euen al our righteous actiōs be like vnto a stincking & filthie clout, they are surely tainted with some sin. The Prophet Dauid prayeth Psal. 143.2. Wherefore no worke, (though good) can deliuer vs from the iust iudgement of God. And this is that which the Apostle Paul speaketh Gal. 5.17. and Rom. 7.21. also Job 9.2. Vpon which place Gregorie Moral. lib. 9. cap. 1. thus writeth. The holy man because he seeth, that euen all the merit of our very vertue is sinne, if by an invvard iudgement it be rightly iudged of, doth vvell adde &c. Heere Gregorie calleth the merits of our vertue, that is, our very best workes, sinnes. And againe the same Gregorie cap. 14. As vve haue often said, all humane righteousnes is conuinced to be v•righteousnes, if it be rightly iudged of. Now he that calleth our rigeteousnes vnrighteousnes, what saith he else, then that which Luther said, That there is some sinne in euery good vvorke? This Paradoxe therefore Luther learned our of the Scriptures and auncient Fathers. But to come to your slender reasons. If thou take a vvife, thou sinnest not. I answere heere is a fallacie. For we say not to marrie a wise is sinne, but that they vvho marrie wiues intermixe some sinne in that good action. And to the place of S. Peter. I say that there you vse also a fallacy: for to fall, in that place signifieth to fall away wholy and altogether from grace and saluation. For the place of S. Iohn, vve meane not that good workes are sinnes, but that they haue some sinne mixed with them. For it followeth not that siluer is drosse, because it hath some drosse mingled with it. And Christ came not to the end there should be no sinne left in his Saints whilest they liue here, but that he might take away the guilt of sinne. And what if S. Paul hath compared our good workes to siluer, gold, or precious stones? Know you not that euen in the best mettals, and in such stones there may some drosse be found? But the Apostle compareth sound doctrine to these things; than which there is nothing more precious if it be kept pure and incorrupted. The Prophets and Apostles do well to exhort vs to doe good workes: but if they bid vs do our duty, doth it therefore follow, that vvee may not commit some sinne in doing thereof? Last of all touching your demaund concerning faith, you bewray your ignorance; for we are not iustified by faith, as it is a worke or action of ours, for it is imperfect: but because it is as the hand wherby we lay hold on Christ, and Christ calleth faith a worke either by imitation, or because it is the worke of the holy Ghost that kindleth it in our hearts.
lDVR. Therefore no action can ever be either excellent or good. Well said Dionysius, That that which is good, must needs come of a cause perfectly good. WHIT. pag. 701. Is there any so dull, as to say that there is no health not soundness in the body at all, because there is only some thing in the body not so sound as it should be? As for Dionysius, he speaketh of that entire and perfect good which we never attain to in this life. For as long as the flesh lusteth against the spirit, there can be no such entire good in us, proceeding from entire and perfect causes.DVR. Therefore no action can euer be either excellent or good. VVell said Dionysius, That that vvhich is good, must n•edes come of a cause perfectly good. WHIT. pag. 701. Is there any so dull, as to say that there is no health not soundnes in the body at all, because there is onlie some thing in the body not so sound as it should be? As for Dionysius, he speaketh of that entire and perfect good which we neuer attaine to in this life. For as long as the flesh lusteth against the spirit, there can be no such entire good in vs, proceeding from entire and perfect causes.
mDVR. What a monstrous speech is this? Is it possible that even sins should please God? WHIT. pag. 702. Can you put no difference between the corruption of the action, and the action it self? A good father loveth the obedience and duty of his sonne, which he knoweth nevertheless is not such as it ought to be, and how much more doth God accept the slender and weak endeavours of his children?DVR. VVhat a monstrous speech is this? Is it possible that euen sinnes should please God? WHIT. pag. 702. Can you put no difference betvveene the corruption of the action, and the action it selfe? A good father loueth the obedience and dutie of his sonne, vvhich he knovveth neuerthelesse is not such as it ought to be, and how much more doth God accept the slender and vveake endeuours of his children?
doe desire to bee eased. For they which are whole desire not the Physitian. A contrite and broken hart is an acceptable sacrifice to God. wherefore they which haue greatest feeling of their sinnes and sorrow for them, to them that heauenly food is wont to bee most wholesome. Good Lord, who would euer thinke it might come to passe, that anie Christian should dislike these things! But is there any thing else?
who if he do absolue you but in iest, so as you beleeue, you are absolued. And why not? for it is not need full, either to number sins by our fingers, or to vse a Priest or a Frier, such a one as your selfe.
We may confesse our faults one to another, so as Friers may be idle hereafter. And whosoeuer beleeueth that his sinnes are forgiuen him, him saith it selfe absolues, whether he be absolued in iest or in earnest.
. that none can be justified by the works of the Law, but he that continueth in all things. Either then deny that any law was written touching small offences, or else confess that that curse belongeth to the least offences. If the Apostle had understood it as you do, the Galatians might have answered him, that they were free from those great sins, and so from the curse, and therefore might well hope to be justified by the Law. Finally if
. Christ hath freed us from the curse of the Law, shall we think that this is only, from the curse due to a few grievous sinners? I hope by this time, you see the error of your interpretation, which you have sucked from your corrupt masters.
DVR Moses denounceth not the cursse against the breaches of euery small precept, but to those only, vvhich he there reckoneth vp: vvhich vvere certainly very haynous sinnes. WHIT. pag. 708. If that curse be only proper to those, vvho are guilty of the sinnes there numbred and set dovvne, vvhat shall vve then thinke of blasphemers, adulterers, and of other horrible malefactors? are they free from this cursse? if this be impious and absurde, then must it be vnderstood of all, euen as many as do transgresse the Lavv. And so S. Paul interpreteth the place, vvho vndoubtedly vnderstood the meaning of Moses better then all Iesuites. For he instructing the Galathians, as concerning the iustice of the Lavv, proueth by this testimonie, Gal. 3.10. that none can be iustified by the vvorks of the Lavv, but he that continueth in all things. Either then deny that any lavv vvas vvritten touching small offences, or else confesse that that cursse belongeth to the least offences. If the Apostle had vnderstood it as you doe, the Galathians might haue ansvvered him, that they vvere free from those great sinnes, and so from the cursse, and therefore might vvell hope to be iustified by the Lavv. Finally if Gal. 3.13. Christ hath freed vs from the cursse of the Law, shall vve thinke that this is only, from the cursse due to a fevv grieuous sinners? I hope by this time, you see the error of your interpretation, which you haue sucked from your corrupt maisters.
pDVR. Yet Christ Math. 11.30. saith, My youke is easy and my burden light. And S. John. 1. Epist. 2.4. Ho that saith, I know him and keepeth not his Commandments, is alayr. WHIT. pag. 705. S. Joh. 1. Epist. 5.3.4. expoundeth the speech of Christ, His Commandments are not grievous: For all that is borne of God, overcometh the world: and this is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith. This yoke then to those who have faith seameth not grievous, because they are inflamed with the love of Gods Law, neither fear they the curse of it because they are ingrafted by faith into Christians for the place of S. John, I answer; they are said to keep the Commandement•, who do their best enendevour to keep them. If any do think that he so keepeth them, that he is without all sin, that is, that he perfectly keepeth them, S. John calleth him a liar, 1. Joh. 1.8.DVR. Yet Christ Math. 11.30. saith, My youke is easie and my burden light. And S. Iohn. 1. Epist. 2.4. Ho that saith, I know him and keepeth not his Commandements, is alayr. WHIT. pag. 705. S. Ioh. 1. Epist. 5.3.4. expoundeth the speech of Christ, His Commandements are not grieuous: For all that is borne of God, ouercommeth the world: and this is the victorie that ouercommeth the world, euen our faith. This yoke then to those who haue faith seameth not grieuous, because they are inflamed with the loue of Gods Law, neither feare they the curse of it because they are ingrafted by faith into Christans for the place of S. Iohn, I answere; they are said to keepe the Commandement•, who do their best enendeuour to keepe them. If any do thinke that he so keepeth them, that hee is without all sinne, that is, that he perfectly keepeth them, S. Iohn calleth him a lyar, 1. Ioh. 1.8.
qDVR. If it be abrogated, how are we not freed from the obedience of it? If God require only that you believe; then by believing you fulfil the Law, and so have not only an imputed, but an inherent righteousness. WHIT. pag. 614. I say not, that the Law is simply abolished, but in some respect. Therefore it vvill not follow that we are freed from the obedience of it. Again, we say not, that faith fulfilleth the Law, as if it did perform perfect obedience to it, but because it layeth hold on Christ, who is the end and perfection of the Law, and on his righteousness. Therefore is it not an inherent, but an imputative justice.DVR. If it be abrogated, how are we not freed from the obedience of it? If God require only that you beleeue; then by beleeuing you fulfill the Lavv, and so haue not only an imputed, but an inherent righteousnes. WHIT. pag. 614. I say not, that the Law is simplie abolished, but in some respect. Therefore it vvill not follovv that vve are freed from the obedience of it. Againe, vvee say not, that faith fulfilleth the Law, as if it did performe perfect obediēce to it, but because it layeth hold on Christ, vvho is the end and perfection of the Lavv, and on his righteousnes. Therefore is it not an inherent, but an imputatiue iustice.
rDVR. Christ saith not as you write, but He that believeth and is baptised shall be saved, Now they who are baptised, have received from God a good will to keep the whole Law, which they determine afterwards by the grace of Christ to observe. WHIT. pag. 715. The words of Christ confirm as ••ch as I brought them for. For Baptism is not a work of the Law, but a wale of faith. And Christ showeth that our salvation consisteth only in faith. And though the baptised frame theirlives according to the rule of the Law, and are endued with new wills and new strength, yet they do it not with that mind to justify themselves by their obedience before the Lord. Then should they lose the righteousness of faith, which doth not consist in our merits and good works, but is such as the Apostle describeth Rom. 4.5.DVR. Christ saith not as you write, but Hee that beleeueth and is baptised shall be saued, Now they who are baptised, haue receiued from God a good will to keepe the whole Law, which they determine afterwards by the grace of Christ to obserue. WHIT. pag. 715. The words of Christ confirme as ••ch as I brought them for. For Baptisme is not a worke of the Law, but a wale of faith. And Christ sheweth that our saluation consisteth only in faith. And though the baptised frame theirliues according to the rule of the Law, and are endued with new wills and new strength, yet they do it not with that mind to iustifie themselues by their obedience before the Lord. Then should they lose the righteousnes of faith, which doth not consist in our merits and good vvorkes, but is such as the Apostle describeth Rom. 4.5.
sDVR. This is your new Divinity, that we should be freed from the curse of the Law, which we cannot fully obey, when as Christ at the last shall pronounce the curse against those who have not obered And Christ (as S. Paul saith) hath freed us from the curse, because by his death be •ath deserved grace for us, whereby we may keep the Law. WHIT. pag. 713. This is your ignorance in Divinity. For who is ignorant of that, which the Apostle affirmeth plainly, Gal. 3.13. that Christ hath freed us from the curse of the Law? Though then we cannot fully keep the Law, yet being ingrafted into Christ, and he communicating his righteousness unto us, we escape the curse of the Law. At the last day it is no marvel if Christ pronounce the curse of the Law against the reprobates, who never were freed from the cursle. And if Christ by his death brought us grace to keep the Law, why might not the Galatians have kept the Law, and obtained righteousness by it? But the Apostle showeth them, that Christ took the cursle, because he took both the sin and the punishment upon him, & not that thereby he procured thē grace to fulfil the Law.DVR. This is your new Diuinitie, that vvee should be freed from the cursse of the Lavv, vvhich vvee cannot fully obey, vvhen as Christ at the last shall pronounce the cursse against those vvho haue not obered And Christ (as S. Paul saith) hath freed vs from the cursse, because by his death be •ath deserued grace for vs, vvhereby we may keepe the Lavv. WHIT. pag. 713. This is your ignorance in Diuinity. For who is ignorant of that, which the Apostle affirmeth plainely, Gal. 3.13. that Christ hath freed vs from the cursse of the Law? Though then we cannot fully keepe the Law, yet being ingrafted into Christ, and he communicating his righteousnes vnto vs, wee escape the cursse of the Lavv. At the last day it is no maruell if Christ pronounce the cursse of the Law against the reprobates, vvho neuer vvere freed from the cursle. And if Christ by his death brought vs grace to keepe the Law, why might not the Galathians haue kept the Lavv, and obtained righteousnes by it? But the Apostle shevveth them, that Christ tooke the cursle, because he tooke both the sinne and the punishment vpon him, & not that therby he procured thē grace to fulfill the Law.
tDVR. Jn those who are justified, God much respecteth their works, as in Abraham Jam 2.21. and 1. Joh. 3.7. And in Phinehas, Psal. 106.31. his work imputed for righteousness. WHIT. pag. 716. To the places of Saint James and Saint John you have been answered before. The fact of Phinehas proceeded from faith, and so the praise of it to be given to faith, not to the work. If you accounted of Thomas, as you make show of, your judgment would be sounder in these things. For thus he writeth on Galat. 3. Works are not the cause that any one is just before God. but they are affects and manifestations of righteousness. Neither Luther, not any of us say any more.DVR. Jn those vvho are iustified, God much respecteth their vvorkes, as in Abraham Iam 2.21. and 1. Ioh. 3.7. And in Phinehas, Psal. 106.31. his vvorke imputed for righteousnes. WHIT. pag. 716. To the places of Saint Iames and Saint Iohn you haue been ansvvered before. The fact of Phin•ha• proceeded from faith, and so the praise of it to bee giuen to faith, not to the worke. If you accounted of Th•mas, as you make shew of, your iudgment vvould bee sounder in these things. For thus he vvriteth on Galat. 3. VVorkes are not the cause that any one is iust before God. but they are aff•ctes and manifestations of righteousnes. Neither Luther, not any of vs say any more.
uDVR. The Prophet saith not that a man is just, because be beleeneth, but that be who is just, doth live by his faith, that is, doth uphold himself by his faith, and sainteth not. It is as absurd to be just by another mans justice, as to live by another mans life. WHIT. pag. 716. I could admit of your exposition, but that I am persuaded the Apostle understood the Prophers mind beaver then you. For the Apostle hath used it to prove, that we are justified by faith, and not by the works of the Law: no not by those which are wrought after faith; for thus he reasoneth, Gal. 3.11. That […] man is justified by the Law in the sight of God, it is evident, for the just shall live by faith. And the Law is not of faith. What hath he concluded but that you demy? that is, that the Prophet hath said, that a man is justified, because he believeth. So Chrysast in Gal. 3. showeth that saith justifieth by the testi•••nie of the Prophet Abakuk. Which if it were not, what concerneth it the Galatians, who were endued with faith, and joined their works with their faith. If it be absurd to be just by another mans righteousness, I pray you tell me, how the Scripture calleth Christ both the curse and sin? As for us we had rather be absurd with the holy Ghost, then wise with you.DVR. The Prophet saith not that a man is iust, because be beleeneth, but that be vvho is iust, doth liue by his faith, that is, doth vphold himselfe by his faith, and sainteth not. It is as absurd to be iust by another mans iustice, as to liue by another mans life. WHIT. pag. 716. I could admit of your exposition, but that I am persvvaded the Apostle vnderstood the Prophers mind beuer then you. For the Apostle hath vsed it to proue, that we are iustified by faith, and not by the workes of the Law: no not by those which are wrought after faith; for thus he reasoneth, Gal. 3.11. That 〈…〉 man is iustified by the Law in the sight of God, it is euident, for the iust shall liue by faith. And the Law is not of faith. What hath he concluded but that you demy? that is, that the Prophet hath said, that a man is iustified, because hee beleeueth. So Chrysast in Gal. 3. sheweth that saith iustifieth by the testi•••nie of the Prophet Abakuk. Which if it were not, what concerneth it the Galathians, who vvere endued vvith faith, and ioyned their vvorkes vvith their faith. If it be absurd to be iust by another mans righteousnes, I pray you tel me, hovv the Scripture calleth Christ both the cursse and sinne? As for vs we had rather be absurd vvith the holy Ghost, then vvise vvith you.
*DVR. Then where is your faith which assureth you of the remission of your sins, and quiteth all your troubled thoughts? But holy men diligently prepared themselves, and so came to this Sacrament. having quiet minds, free from guilt of sin. And in the Primitive times they who had fallen, were not admitted to the Eucharist, but after confession & full satisfaction made for their sins. And then a Deacon was wont to cry. Holy things are for holy men. WHIT. pag. 718. You have not tasted what true faith is, if you think all sorrows & doubts are removed, so soon as faith is begotten. The Prophet often remembereth his sorrows, Psal. 42.5.6. & 32.4. And this all the faithful have experience of, and yet are upheld by their faith. They are the best prepared who have the greatest sorrows for their sins, and in the word and Sacrament seek a salve for them. For wherefore was the supper ordained, but to strengthen and confirm our faith. Therefore the best prepared have many temptations and sorrows in themselves. The custom of the Church proveth nothing against this. For will you account them wicked and profane, whose consciences are frighted with the sense and bitter sorrows for their sins? So shall you wickedly condemn the most holy servants of God.DVR. Then where is your faith which assureth you of the remission of your sinnes, and quiteth all your troubled thoughts? But holy men diligently prepared themselues, and so came to this Sacrament. hauing quiet minds, free frō guilt of sinne. And in the Primitiue times they who had fallen, were not admitted to the Eucharist, but after cō fession & full satisfaction made for their sins. And then a Deacon was wont to crie. Holy things are for holy men. WHIT. pag. 718. You haue not tasted what true faith is, if you thinke all sorrowes & doubts are remoued, so soone as faith is begotten. The Prophet often remembreth his sorrowes, Psal. 42.5.6. & 32.4. And this all the faithfull haue experience of, and yet are vpheld by their faith. They are the best prepared who haue the greatest sorrowes for their sins, and in the word and Sacrament seeke a salue for them. For wherefore was the supper ordained, but to strengthen and confirme our faith. Therfore the best prepared haue many temptations and sorrowes in themselues. The custome of the Church proueth nothing against this. For will you account them wicked and prophane, whose consciences are frighted with the sense and bitter sorrowes for their sinnes? So shall you wickedly condemne the most holie seruants of God.
xDVR. Who knoweth not that the Novatians were condemned of the whole Church for denying this authority to the Priests? And that it was an old custom of the Church, as Tertullian hath it, that penitentials were sent to none but to the Priests: to whom, as Ambrole, Hierome, & Chrysostom writ, the keys and power of binding and loosing are committed. WHIT. pag. 720. That you speak of the Novatians and the custom of the Church toucheth not Luther, for they admitted neither repentance not confession in the Church: did Luther ever any such thing? or did he ever reprove the custom of the Church, that they who had offended publicly, did publicly testive their repentance. It was a private auricular confession of all sins which he reproved, which is without testimony either of Scripture of sincere Antiquity: which made Nectarius Bishop of Constantinople put it out of the Church for the offence of a Deacon. For the Fathers by which you would establish your keys, we have against them Augustine in Joan. tract. 124. and Theophil in Matth. 18.DVR. VVho knoweth not that the Nouatians vvere condemned of the vvhole Church for denying this authoritie to the Priests? And that it vvas an old custome of the Church, as Tertullian hath it, that penitentials vvere sent to none but to the Priests: to whom, as Ambrole, Hierome, & Chrysostome writ, the keyes and power of binding and loosing are committed. WHIT. pag. 720. That you speake of the Nouatians and the custome of the Church toucheth not Luther, for they admitted neither repentance not confession in the Church: did Luther euer any such thing? or did he euer reproue the custome of the Church, that they who had offended publikely, did publikely testiue their repentance. It was a priuate auricular confession of all sinnes which hee reproued, which is without testimonie either of Scripture of sincere Antiquitie: which made Nectarius Bishop of Constantinople put it out of the Church for the offence of a Deacon. For the Fathers by which you would establish your keyes, we haue against them Augustine in Ioan. tract. 124. and Theophil in Matth. 18.
yDVR. Uvhat is then more manifest then that he may give a Sacrament which never intended […]? We believe that Priests as Judges can absolve the guilty from their sins. WHIT pag. 722. When as faith dependeth upon no mans will, and faith bringeth remission of sins, another mans will cannot hinder, but that they who believe, may have the pardon of their sins For that to the Centurion, Mat. 8.13. is to every man▪ As thou believest, so b••t ••to thee, & not as another will. If absolution were then in the Ministers will, it should not be as men believe, but as their Minister thinketh: than which nothing can be more abs••d. What skilleth it, whether the Minister be in •est or earnest? if I believe seriously his jest shall not hurt me. And what is more miserable, then to ba•g the dignity of the Sacrament upon the thought and intention of the Minister? which if it were true of Sacraments, yet what is that to absolution, which never was a Sacrament? whereas you say you believe that the Pries•• do absolve men, as Judges do, I do not find fault with it. And such •u•ges are they, as Priests under the Law were of diseases. The chief Pr••st judged of the Leprosy, which he neither inflicted nor cured. So the Minister doth pronounce and judge all believers to be absolved, and the contrary upon the wicked and unbelievers.DVR. ƲVhat is then more manifest then that hee may giue a Sacrament which neuer intēded 〈…〉? VVe beleeue that Priests as Iudges can absolue the guilty from their sins. WHIT pag. 722. When as faith dependeth vpon no mans will, and faith bringeth remission of sins, another mans will cānot hinder, but that they who beleeue, may haue the pardon of their sins For that to the Centurion, Mat. 8.13. is to eu•ry man▪ As thou beleeuest, so b••t ••to thee, & not as another wil. If absolution were then in the Ministers will, it should not be as men beleeue, but as their Minister thinketh: than vvhich nothing can be more abs••d. What skilleth it, vvhether the Minister be in •est or earnest? if I beleeue seriously his iest shall not hurt mee. And what is more mi•erable, then to ba•g the dignitie of the Sacrament vpon the thought and intention of the Minister? which if it were true of Sacramēts, yet what is that to absolution, which neuer was a Sacramēt? wheras you say you beleeue that the Pries•• do absolue men, as Iudges do, I do not find fault with it. And such •u•ges are they, as Priests vnder the Law were of diseases. The chiefe Pr••st iudged of the Leprosie, which he neither inflicted nor cured. So the Minister doth pronounce and iudge all beleeuers to be absolued, and the contrarie vpon the wicked and vnbeleeuers.
.13. WHIT. pag. 730. To the first I answer, that some things may be done, whereunto we are not bound in conscience: we must •bey humane and politic laws, because they are necessary for peace and public tranquillity. Yet we must distinguish humane laws from Divine. For the Laws of God must simply be obeyed without any difference of time, place and circumstance: but the laws of men as he circumstances require. For example, he that is a Roman and liveth at Rome must obey the Roman laws? If he go into Persia, he is not bound to keep there the Roman lawea upon any necessity. Then they bind not the conscience, for then should they in all places bind alike. 2. That Law of the Apostles did not simply bind the conscience, but in respect of the weak brother lest he should be offended: whom the law of God bindeth not to offend. Again this was the law, not of men, but of the spirit of God. 3. For the places of S. Paul and S. Peter, I answer, the Apostles doth not ensnare the conscience with every particular precept of the Magistrate, but they speak of his authority, which is sacred and holy, and cannot with any good conscience be contemned. It is the commandment of God, that we obey Magistrates, and this doth bind the conscience: in general therefore he is to be obeyed for conscience sake; but his particular laws do not bind the conscience. Again, when we observe their particular laws, we do not so stand upon the precepts, as if doing of them would quiet the conscience and satisfy it: but we look to the end, that is, the will of God, which commandeth obedience to honest and just laws.
DVR. It they be bound to obey, hovv are their consciences free from the religion of them? Jf vvas a humane lavv, Act. 15.20. touching, strangled and blood. And Rom. 13.2.5. and 1. Pet. 2.13.13. WHIT. pag. 730. To the first I answere, that some things may be done, vvhereunto vve are not bound in conscience: vve must •bey humane and politike lavves, because they are necessary for peace and publike tranquillitie. Yet vve must distinguish humane lavves from Diuine. For the Lawes of God must simplie bee obeyed without any difference of time, place and circumstance: but the lawes of men as he circumstances require. For example, he that is a Romane and liueth at Rome must obey the Romane lavves? If hee goe into Persia, he is not bound to keepe there the Romane lavvea vpon any necessitie. Then they bind not the conscience, for then should they in all places bind alike. 2. That Law of the Apostles did not simplie binde the conscience, but in respect of the weake brother lest he should be offended: vvhom the lavv of God bindeth not to offend. Againe this was the law, not of mē, but of the spirit of God. 3. For the places of S. Paul and S. Peter, I answere, the Apostles doth not insnare the conscience vvith euery particular precept of the Magistrate, but they speake of his authoritie, which is sacred and holy, and cannot with any good conscience bee contemned. It is the commandement of God, that we obey Magistrates, and this doth bind the conscience: in generall therefore he is to be obeyed for conscience sake; but his particular lawes do not bind the conscience. Againe, when we obserue their particular lawes, wee doe not so stand vpon the precepts, as if doing of them would quiet the conscience and satisfie it: but wee looke to the end, that is, the will of God, vvhich commandeth obedience to honest and iust lavves.
haue already perused it, and I thinke worse of your side then I did before. Tush, saith he for all that the matter is most plaine; proue me that, say I: because (saith he) we swarue not a finger breadth from the word of God.
Pope must
⟨p. 267⟩
beare both swords. The seruant is not aboue his master: therefore
man to life eternall, but with respect of merits. S.
•
•
•
DVR. This argument is good and can haue no shew of error. For, aboue all men, a Priest must be chaste, saith Origen, Homil. 6 4. in Leuit. Also Ierome and Ambrose, and Epiphanius taught the same WHIT. pag. 736. Yea you er•e and mistake S. Paul in theree things: 1. What he wrote to all Christians, you expound of Lay-men only. 2. He speaketh only of extraordinarie fasts & prayer, but you applie it vnto all sorts thereof. That the Apostle speaketh of extraordinarie, appeares, 1. Because he hath ioyned fasting with them, 1. Cor. 7.5.2. Because Christ and his Apostle haue commanded all to pray continually, and so all ought to l•ue a single life. 3. From a short abstinence of Lay-men, you childishly would proue a perpetuall single life to be necessary for Ministers. You abuse also Origens words, (& play the heretike) as if chastitie were contrary to matrimony; whereas the Fathers of the Nicene Councell, consented to Paphnutius, who said openly, that society with a lavvfull wi•e, is chastitie: Socrates lib. 1. cap. 11. Jerome indeed disputed too sophistically against matrimony, seeking victory more then verity, as himself confessed. Ambr•se and Epiphanius disswaded Ministers only from second m••riages, allowing their fi•st.
6Distinct. 28 Decernimus
dDVR. Tertullian used this same argument against second marriage. WHIT. pag. 739. Tertullian therein erred with Montanus, (as all the learned know) condemning second marriages, of uncleanness, not only in Ministers, but in all Christians: yet he himself being a Priest, was married, and lived with his wife, continuing his Ministry: so that he neither judged marriage to be uncleanness, nor unlawful in Ministers, simply; but only second marriages.DVR. Tertullian vsed this same argument against second marriage. WHIT. pag. 739. Tertullian therein erred with Montanus, (as all the learned know) condemning second marriages, of vncleannes, not only in Ministers, but in all Christians: yet he himselfe being a Priest, was married, and liued with his wife, continuing his Ministery: so that he neither iudged marriage to be vncleanenes, nor vnlavvfull in Ministers, simplie; but only second marriages.
8Harding and Dorman and others.
cDVR. The Pope challengeth no Lordship over the Churches, but professeth himself the severuant of Gods servants. WHIT. pag. 740. But his dee•s bewray his tyranny: for he prescribeth, commandeth, threateneth, punisheth, and doth whatsoever any Lord can do. DVR. You can disprove this consequent by no argument. WHIT. pag. 741. It is an absurd argument, like these; Every several man hath one head; therefore all men must have one head: Every several flock hath his shepherd; therefore all flocks must have one to rule them. Again: no one man can possibly teach and feed the whole Church with the Word and Sacrament as a faithful Pastor should, and may do in a particular Church Christ only can thus feed all particular Churches, which can never be made one visible body, and therefore can have none but Christ the general head and Pastor over them. DVR. Jerome, Cyprian, and Ireneus, have written the same we do. WHIT. pag 742. Not one of them. First, Jerome defendeth the superiority of one Pastor in the Church, not as a matter of accessitie, but of conveniency, to prevent schisms: and saith, that the Church is founded upon all the Apostles alike, and that every one equally hath received the keys of the kingdom of heaven; even in that place where you quote him: (against Jovinian, lib. 1.) Secondly, Cyprian concludeth only, that there should be but one Pastor in one Church and never thought upon the Popes primacy; but saith plainly, that every particular Bishop hath all whatsoever any one hath by right; in the same book which you allege, of the Churches unity. Lastly, Ireneus called the Roman, the chief Church, not for any superiority, but because she excelled all others in constancy, largeness, fame, and soundness of faith.DVR. The Pope challengeth no Lordship ouer the Churches, but professeth himselfe the seueruant of Gods seruants. WHIT. pag. 740. But his dee•s bewray his tyranny: for he prescribeth, commandeth, threatneth, punisheth, and doth whatsoeuer any Lord can do. DVR. You can dispro•e this consequent by no argument. WHIT. pag. 741. It is an absurd argument, like these; Euery seuerall man hath one head; therefore all men must haue one head: Euery seuerall flocke hath his shepheard; therefore all flockes must haue one to rule them. Againe: no one man can possiblie teach and feed the whole Church with the Word and Sacrament as a faithfull Pastor should, and may doe in a particular Church Christ only can thus feed al particular Churches, which can neuer be made one visible body, and therefore can haue none but Christ the generall head and Pastor ouer them. DVR. Ierome, Cyprian, and Ireneus, haue written the same we doe. WHIT. pag 742. Not one of them. First, Ierome defendeth the superiority of one Pastor in the Church, not as a matter of accessitie, but of conueniency, to preuent schismes: and saith, that the Church is founded vpon all the Apostles alike, and that euery one equally hath receiued the keies of the kingdome of heauen; euen in that place where you quote him: (against Iouinian, lib. 1.) Secondly, Cyprian cōcludeth only, that there should be but one Pastor in one Church and neuer thought vpon the Popes primacie; but saith plainly, that euery particular Bishop hath all whatsoeuer any one hath by right; in the same booke which you alleadge, of the Churches vnity. Lastly, Ireneus called the Romane, the chiefe Church, not for any superiority, but because she excelled all others in constancie, largenes, fame, and soundnes of faith.
fDVR. Jt is manifest by this place, that Christ gave greater authority of feeding to Peter, than to the other Apostles, and so made him head of all his Church. WHIT. p. 744. It will not follow upon this place, that Peter had greater authority to feed, or that he only must feed all: for he said to them all alike, Matth. 28.19. Go ye, teach all nations: and Job. 20 21. As the Father sent me, so I send you: Therefore he spake so often then to Peter, to confirm him after his grievous fall, that he might not doubt of his Apostolical calling, as saith Augustines treatise on John 123. so that it no whit concerneth the Pope.DVR. Jt is manifest by this place, that Christ gaue greater authoritie of feeding to Peter, than to the other Apostles, and so made him head of all his Church. WHIT. p. 744. It will not follow vpon this place, that Peter had greater authority to feed, or that he only must feede all: for he said to them all alike, Matth. 28.19. Goe yee, teach all nations: and Iob. 20 21. As the Father sent me, so I send you: Therefore he spake so often then to Peter, to confirme him after his grieuous fall, that he might not doubt of his Apostolicall calling, as saith Augustines treatise on Iohn 123. so that it no whit concerneth the Pope.
gDVR. The Pope useth this as a similitude to amplify, not as an argument to prove by authority. WHIT. pag. 746. This is an idle shift; a similitude is an argument, and Johannes Andraeas would prove hereby, that the Pope excelleth the Emperor in dignity, seventy times seven degrees.DVR. The Pope vseth this as a similitude to amplifie, not as an argument to prooue by authoritie. WHIT. pag. 746. This is an idle shift; a similitude is an argument, and Johannes Andraeas would prooue hereby, that the Pope excelleth the Emperor in dignitie, seuentie times seuen degrees.
hDVR. We gather nothing hence, but what Bernard did: saying, This sword (of temporal power) is thine also, happily at thy command, though not to be drawn with thy hand: speaking to the Pope. WHIT. pag. 747. Duraeus is ashamed of this sophism, bu• yet he fathereth it upon Bernard, which also Johannes a Capistrano (of the Pope and Councels, p 77.) and others of them have handled▪ and Pope Boniniface girt himself with a sword in sign hereof: but this place speaketh nothing at all for any such power.DVR. VVe gather nothing hence, but vvhat Bernard did: saying, This sword (of temporall povver) is thine also, happily at thy commaund, though not to be drawne with thy hand: speaking to the Pope. WHIT. pag. 747. Duraeus is ashamed of this sophisme, bu• yet he fathereth it vpon Bernard, which also Iohannes a Capistrano (of the Pope and Councels, p 77.) and others of them haue handled▪ and Pope Boniniface girt himselfe with a sword in signe hereof: but this place speaketh nothing at all for any such power.
iDVR. What Catholic ever taught, or wrote thus? howbeit the Fathers of the Sinuessan Councell said. The chief seat is judged of no man. WHIT. pag. 749. Thus you will make the Pope no Catholic who saith (Dist. 40. si P•pa) The Pope may be reproved of no mortal man, though he lead with him innumerable people unto hell. And who knoweth not these two pillars of Popery; the Church of Rome cannot err, whatsoever it teacheth: and the Pope may not be accused whatsoever •e doth? The Bishops of the Sinuessan Synod spake to Marcellinus the Pope, who had denied Christ, and committed Idolatry, and might be accused by the Popes own laws, so that in citing that authority, you contradict both your self and your laws.DVR. What Catholike euer taught, or wrote thus? howbeit the Fathers of the Sinuessan Councell said. The chiefe seate is iudged of no man. WHIT. pag. 749. Thus you will make the Pope no Catholike who saith (Dist. 40. si P•pa) The Pope may bee reproued of no mortall man, though he leade with him innumerable people vnto hell. And who knoweth not these two pillers of Popery; the Church of Rome cannot erre, whatsoeuer it teacheth: and the Pope may not be accused whatsoeuer •e doth? The Bishops of the Sinuessan Synode spake to Marcellinus the Pope, who had denied Christ, and committed Idolatrie, and might bee accused by the Popes owne lawes, so that in citing that authoritie, you contradict both your selfe and your lawes.
kDVR. Christ made Peter his Vicar on earth, and by his prayer obtained that his Vicars faith might not fail; by force whereof the Pope cannot err: as Augustine and Cyprian also perceived. WHIT pag. 750. It is not true that Christ made Peter his Vicar, nor doth it follow; Peters faith failed not, therefore no Popes faith hath failed, who are his successors: for Popes have done, and may fall into heresies, as you will confess; and may err in faith, saith Pope Boniface (D•st 40. Papa:) which he could not do it this argument of yours were true. Further Christ prayed for all his Apostles, and the whole Church: shall we say Christs prayer was less effectual for the rest then for Peter? If it be not, then none of their successors could err no more then Peters: which I suppose you will not affirm. And Augustine, and Cyprian never reasoned as you do; you abuse their names.DVR. Christ made Peter his Vicar on earth, and by his prayer obtained that his Vicars faith might not faile; by force vvherof the Pope cannot erre: as Augustine and Cyprian also perceiued. WHIT pag. 750. It is not true that Christ made Peter his Vicar, nor doth it follow; Peters faith failed not, therefore no Popes faith hath failed, who are his successors: for Popes haue done, and may fall into heresies, as you will confesse; and may erre in faith, saith Pope Boniface (D•st 40. Papa:) which he could not do it this argument of yours vvere true. Further Christ prayed for all his Apostles, and the whole Church: shal we say Christs prayer was lesse effectuall for the rest then for Peter? If it be not, then none of their successors could erre no more then Peters: which I suppose you will not affirme. And Augustine, and Cyprian neuer reasoned as you do; you abuse their names.
lDVR. If you believed the Prophet Malachi, or the Mass, you would confess this argument to be good. WHIT pag. 753. You can never prove your Mass by the Prophet Malachi, who speaketh of the prayers of the godly, as Tertullian, Eusebius, and Jerome expound him: and if the Mass were a sacrifice indeed, (as you call it) the peoples negligence, is no sufficient cause to make it private, and yet to profit the people, yea though they be absent: you may aswell abuse the Word it self so; and say it is enough, when it is in public, it the Priest handle it and hear it, and believe it alone, yet the people being absent and not dreaming of any such thing, may be saved by it.DVR. If you beleeued the Prophet Malachie, or the Masse, you vvould confesse this argument to be good. WHIT pag. 753. You can neuer proue your Masse by the Prophet Malachie, who speaketh of the prayers of the godly, as Tertullian, Eusebius, and Jerome expound him: and if the Masse were a sacrifice indeed, (as you call it) the peoples negligence, is no sufficient cause to make it priuate, and yet to profit the people, yea though they be absent: you may aswel abuse the Word it selfe so; and say it is inough, when it is in publike, it the Priest handle it and heare it, and beleeue it alone, yet the people being absent and not dreaming of any such thing, may be saued by it.
mDVR. The people also receive the whole Sacrament, under one kind. WHIT pag. 754. It is childish dotage to say so; as though one part of a thing, were the whole; or, as if Christ appointing both bread and wine, ordained more then a whole Sacrament: that Pope was wiser, which said of certain heretics that refrained from the Cup, as you do•, (De concil. dist. 2. cap. Comperimus:) Let them either receive the whole Sacrament, or refuse all. DVR. Christs words, Drink ye all of this, prove n•t that all Christians must do so. WHIT. pag. 755. They do prove it, as those words, take eat, do prove that all must eat: and you may as well keep both the elements from the people, as one, contrary to S. Paul, 1. Cor. 11.23. DVR. The Passover might be eaten without wine. WHIT. pag. 756. It might, because God had not commanded wine, but Christ himself commandeth it in his Supper, 1. Cor. 11.45. DVR. The common people are a•t bound to drink of the Cap: for S. Paul saith, As oft as ye drink it, to signify they were not commanded so to do. WHIT. So he saith of the bread also, As of, as ye eat, 1. Cor. 11.26. so that, by your argument, neither is the bread commanded them.DVR. The people also receiue the vvhole Sacrament, vnder one kind. WHIT pag. 754. It is childish dotage to say so; as though one part of a thing, were the vvhole; or, as if Christ appointing both bread and wine, ordained more then a whole Sacrament: that Pope was wiser, vvhich said of certaine heretikes that refrained from the Cup, as you do•, (De concil. dist. 2. cap. Comperimus:) Let them either receiue the vvhole Sacrament, or refuse all. DVR. Christs vvords, Drinke yee all of this, proue n•t that all Christians must doe so. WHIT. pag. 755. They doe proue it, as those vvords, take eate, doe proue that all must eate: and you may as vvell keepe both the elements from the people, as one, contrarie to S. Paul, 1. Cor. 11.23. DVR. The Passeouer might be eaten vvithout vvine. WHIT. pag. 756. It might, because God had not commaunded vvine, but Christ himselfe commaundeth it in his Supper, 1. Cor. 11.45. DVR. The common people are a•t bound to drinke of the Cap: for S. Paul saith, As oft as ye drinke it, to signifie they were not commanded so to doe. WHIT. So he saith of the bread also, As of, as yee eate, 1. Cor. 11.26. so that, by your argument, neither is the bread commanded them.
nDVR. No Catholic doth so reason; we say, that title had in it a mystery: and Augustine proveth by it, that the word, coessential, [Greek or Hebrew], may be used in the Creed. WHIT. pag. 757. Papists often reason thus, as all men know which read their writings, though you be ashamed of it. Tell us what mystery you mean, if it be worth the labour; as for Augustine, he speaks no word that makes here for your cause, yet you blush not to quote him.DVR. No Catholike doth so reason; we say, that title had in it a mysterie: and Augustine proueth by it, that the vvord, coessent•all, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, may be vsed in the Creede. WHIT. pag. 757. Papists often reason thus, as all men knovve which read their writings, though you bee ashamed of it. Tell vs what mysterie you meane, if it bee worth the labour; as for Augustine, hee speakes no word that makes here for your cause, yet you blush not to quote him.
18Harding.
oDVR. We say not, that all, but that some of the people may not have the Scriptures committed to them. WHIT. pag. 758. Who doubteth but that wisdom is to be used in teaching the people; and that they which show themselves dogs, and hogs, must be barred from the Scriptures: but this is nothing to the present question; whether this reason be good, which Papists sometimes use: and which here you should have spoken to, and not thus wander.DVR. VVe say not, that all, but that some of the people may not haue the Scriptures committed to them. WHIT. pag. 758. Who doubteth but that vvisedome is to be vsed in teaching the people; and that they vvhich shevv themselues dogges, and hogges, must be barred from the Scriptures: but this is nothing to the present question; vvhether this reason be good, vvhich Papists sometimes vse: and vvhich here you should haue spoken to, and not thus vvander.
pDVR. Christ said it way his body. WHIT. pag. 759. Christ by an usual phrase of Scripture, called the thing signifying by the name of the thing signified, because of the sacramental joint receiving of both, to wit, of the bread with the mouth, and of his body by faith. Again, if that which was in Christs hands were his real body, when he said so, then was transubstantiation before (which you deny) and then he had two bodies: but if it were bread, then is there a metonymy in his words, as we truly say.DVR. Christ said it vvay his bodie. WHIT. pag. 759. Christ by an vsuall phrase of Scripture, called the thing signifying by the name of the thing signified, because of the sacramentall ioint receiuing of both, to vvit, of the bread vvith the mouth, and of his bodie by faith. Againe, if that vvhich vvas in Christs hands vvere his reall body, vvhen he said so, then vvas transubstantiation before (vvhich you deny) and then he had tvvo bodies: but if it vvere bread, then is there a metonymie in his vvords, as vvee truly say.
qDVR. Ambrose and Augustine reasoned so from this Scripture. WHIT p. 761. That is false: they teach only, that we must worship Christ in the mysteries and Sacrament; not the mysteries and Sacrament themselves.DVR. Ambrose and Augustine reasoned so from this Scripture. WHIT p. 761. That is false: they teach onely, that vve must vvorship Christ in the mysteries and Sacrament; not the my•teries and Sacrament themselues.
22Pighius.
rDVR. That was Pighius his error: but the judgement of Catholic Universities is, that foreseeing of merits is no cause of Predestination. WHIT. pag. 762. Thus you fall from your champion Pighius in words, but indeed many of your Schools defend him: saying, the kingdom of heaven is prepared for them which have merited it by their good works.DVR. That vvas Pighius his error: but the iudgement of Catholike Vniuersities is, that foreseeing of merits is no cause of Predestination. WHIT. pag. 762. Thus you fall from your champion Pighius in vvords, but indeed many of your Schooles defend him: saying, the kingdome of heauen is prepared for them vvhich haue merited it by their good works.
all things are not written which are necessarie to saluation.
therefore men passe thorow the fire of Purgatorie to life eternall.
yDVR. Pope Adrian proveth not the use of images by this place, but saith it was signified by it. WHIT. pag. 767. Then you confess he allegeth that Scripture to prove the use of images was signified by it, and who but a superstitious doctor, would have done so?DVR. Pope Adrian proueth not the vse of images by this place, but saith it vvas signified by it. WHIT. pag. 767. Then you confesse he alleageth that Scripture to proue the vse of images was signified by it, and who but a superstitious doctor, would haue done so?
zDVR. The chiefest gift must come from the chiefest virtue. WHIT. pag. 768. S. Paul 1. Cor. 13. doth not in all things prefer charity before faith, but only because it endureth in the life to come, when we shall not need faith, as Chrysostom expounds it: now faith only apprehends Christ our righteousness, and therein excelleth charity. Lastly, you err grossly in effect, ascribing our justification to the merit of virtue in us; which only is merited by Jesus Christ.DVR. The chiefest gift must come from the chiefest vertue. WHIT. pag. 768. S. Paul 1. Cor. 13. doth not in all things preferre charitie before faith, but onely because it indureth in the life to come, when wee shall not neede faith, as Chrysostome expoundes it: now faith onely apprehends Christ our righteousnesse, and therein excelleth charitie. Lastly, you erre grossely in effect, ascribing our iust•fication to the merit of vertue in vs; vvhich onely is merited by Iesus Christ.
aDVR. Do you think that God calleth men to repentance ironically. WHIT. pag. 799. No; but when men will not seek God, being called thereto by his bounty; no marvel though he withdraw it from them, and (as it were) laugh at their madness: of which ironies there be many examples in Scriptures.DVR. Do you thinke that God calleth men to repentace ironically. WHIT. pag. 799. No; but when men will not se•k God, being called thereto by his bountie; no maruaile though hee withdraw it from them, and (as it were) laugh at their madnes: of which ironies there be many examples in Scriptures.
bDVR. Augustine denieth that God hath commanded impossible thin•s. WHIT. pag. 770. He expoundeth his own meaning, that Adam before his fall could, and that we in heaven shall be able to keep all Gods commandments; but he often saith, that no man in this life can fulfil the Law of God. DVR. Men use not to make laws impossible to be kept. WHIT. We must not measure Gods doing by mans: Again, when these laws were first given, man could perform them, and we must not look that God should alter them to fit our corruption. DVR▪ God could not justly punish lawbreakers, if they could not keep it. WHIT. pag. 771. Answer then Eusebius, (Evangelical demonst. lib. 1) who saith, that Moses Law was impossible to be kept of any man: And Thomas Aquinas, upon Gal. 3. sect. 4. saying: Moses commanded many things, which no man could fulfil.DVR. Augustine denieth that God hath commanded impossible thin•s. WHIT. pag. 770. Hee expoundeth his owne meaning, that Adam before his fall could, and that we in heauen shal be able to keepe all Gods commandements; but he often saith, that no man in this life can fulfill the Law of God. DVR. Men vse not to make lavves impossible to be kept. WHIT. We must not measure Gods doing by mans: Againe, when these lawes were first giuen, man could performe them, and vvee must not looke that God should alter them to fit our corruption. DVR▪ God could not iustly punish lavvbreakers, if they could not keepe it. WHIT. pag. 771. Answere then Eusebius, (Euangelicall demonst. lib. 1) who saith, that Moses Lavv vvas impossible to be kept of any man: And Thomas Aquinas, vpon Gal. 3. sect. 4. saying: Moses commaunded many things, vvhich no man could fulfill.
cDVR Tell me for what other cause Christ went into bel, but to deliver the Fathers from Limbus? WHIT. pag. 772. Nay, first prove you that he did go so to hell, as you think; for my part I believe it not, but that his soul went presently to heaven. Again, you beg the question, saying, he went to hell to deliver the Fathers. DVR. I prove it by these Scriptures: Zac. 9.11. Psal 68.18. Heb. 9.8. WHIT. Zachary speaketh only of the Jews delivery from the captivity of Babylon. David speaketh of Christs ascending into heaven, and triumph over his enemies; and you childishly infer hereupon, therefore he descended to hell to deliver the Patriarchs from Limbus: but most ridiculously you abuse that place to the Hebrews, the true sense whereof is; that we are not reconciled to God, by the Jewish sacrifices, but by Christ; therefore you infer, that none of the Patriarchs went to heaven, until Christ came out of hell, and opened heaven by his bodily ascension.DVR Tell me for what other cause Christ went into bel, but to deliuer the Fathers from Limbus? WHIT. pag. 772. Nay, first proue you that he did go so to hel, as you thinke; for my part I beleeue it not, but that his soule went presently to heauen. Againe, you begge the question, saying, he went to hell to deliuer the Fathers. DVR. I proue it by these Scriptures: Zac. 9.11. Psal 68.18. Heb. 9.8. WHIT. •acharie speaketh only of the Iewes deliuery from the captiuitie of Babylon. Dauid speaketh of Christs ascending into heauen, and triumph ouer his enemies; and you childishly inferre hereupon, therefore he descended to hell to deliuer the Patriarkes from Limbus: but most ridiculously you abuse that place to the Hebrewes, the true sense whereof is; that we are not reconciled to God, by the Iewish sacrifices, but by Christ; therefore you inferre, that none of the Patriarkes vvent to heauen, vntill Christ came out of hell, and opened heauen by his bodilie ascension.
dDVR. Catholics say not so. WHIT. pag. 773 But your false Church doth so; for it interpreteth Scriptures as it listeth: and constraineth all Christians to rest therein, be it never so false, and contrary to the Scriptures; else it doth condemn him for an heretic.DVR. Catholikes say not so. WHIT. pag. 773 But your false Church doth so; for it interpreteth Scriptures as it listeth: and constraineth all Christians to rest therein, bee it neuer so false, and contrarie to the Scriptures; else it doth condemne him for an heretike.
eDVR. What error find you in this argument? WHIT. pag. 774. I find in it a threefold false consequent: first you cannot prove hence; that the things which S. Paul spake by word, were not the same in effect which he wrote to them: secondly, if he wrote not all to them which he had taught thē, it followeth not that he taught something which is not written in the Scriptures: thirdly; admit many things were left unwritten, yet it followeth not, that all things necessary to salvation be not written: nor do the ancient Fathers say so.DVR. What error find you in this argument? WHIT. pag. 774. I find in it a threefold false consequent: first you cannot proue hence; that the things which S. Paul spake by word, were not the same in effect which hee wrote to thē: secondly, if he wrote not all to thē which he had taught thē, it followeth not that hee taught something which is not written in the Scriptures: thirdly; admit many things were left vnwritten, yet it followeth not, that all things necessary to saluatiō be not written: nor do the ancient Fathers say so.
fDVR. Sundry Fathers expound this place of Purgatory fire. WHIT. pag. 776. But the place it self showeth that it cannot be meant of any such fire: for 1. S. Paul speaketh of the purging away that which is a fault: but in your Purgatory faults are not consumed, but (you say) punishments are suffered for f•u••s. 2. S. Paul saith every mans work, be it gold or wood, shall be tried; but you cast nothing but wood, hay, and stubble into your feigned Purgatory. 3. S. Paul saith every mans work shall be manifest by this fire; but your Purgatory fire is obscure, and never showeth such light. 4. The word fire, is used by S. Paul Metaphorically, as also are gold, silver, hay, wood &c. but you say your Purgatory fire, is true fire. The fire which S. Paul here meaneth, is the holy Ghost, who proveth all doctrines, and severeth the false from the true. Ambrose on Psal. 118. saith, This fire is the word of Christ: Angustine indeed spake doubtfully of Purgatory, saying, (Enchiridion, cap. 69.) it may be that there is some such thing, but whether yea or no, it is a question; and in his book of the City of God; he saith, perhaps it is true: many others of the Fathers thought this purging should be at Christs coming to judgement; which much differeth from your Purgatory. Chrysostom in his Preface on Isaiah, saith; God at one instant abolisheth sin, freeth from punishment, and giveth righteousness; Tertullian in his book of Baptism, saith: Guilt and punishment are taken away together. Hierome saith, upon the 31. Psalm; the sin which is covered is not seen; that which is not seen is not imputed; that which is not imputed shall not be punished: so that nothing is left for your Purgatory, by these mens judgements.DVR. Sundry Fathers expound this place of Purgatory fire. WHIT. pag. 776. But the place it selfe sheweth that it cannot bee meant of any such fire: for 1. S. Paul speaketh of the purging away that which is a fault: but in your Purga•orie faults are not consumed, but (you say) punishments are s•ffred for f•u••s. 2. S. Paul saith euery mans worke, be it gold or wood, shall be tried; but you cast nothing but wood, hay, and stubble into your fained Purgatory. 3. S. Paul saith euery mans worke shall be manifest by this fire; but your Purgatory fire is obscure, and neuer sheweth such light. 4. The word fire, is vsed by S. Paul Metaphorically, as also are gold, siluer, hay, wood &c. but you say your Purgatory fire, is true fire. The fire which S. Paul heer• meaneth, is the holy Ghost, who proueth all doctrines, and seuereth the false from the true. Ambrose on Psal. 118. saith, This fire is the vvord of Christ: Angustine indeed spake doubtfully of Purgatory, saying, (Enchiridion, cap. 69.) it may be that there is some such thing, but whether yea or no, it is a question; and in his booke of the Citie of God; he saith, perhaps it is true: many others of the Fathers thought this purging should bee at Christs comming to iudgement; vvhich much differeth from your Purgatorie. Chrysostome in his Preface on Esay, saith; God at one instant abolisheth sin, freeth from punishment, and giueth righteousnes; Tertullian in his booke of Baptisme, saith: Guilt and punishment are taken away togither. Hierome saith, vpon the 31. Psalme; the sin which is couered is not seene; that vvhich is not seene is not imputed; that which is not imputed shall not be punished: so that nothing is left for your Purgatorie, by these mens iudgements.
Hebr. 13.4
.
eDVR. The Angels have merited, & our first parents might have merited blessedness before their fall, yet all that they could do, was a due debt unto God. WHIT. pag. 785. If Christ say truly, that they are unprofitable servants which do all that is commanded, & no more; then neither may the Angels, nor might those out first parents ascribe any thing to their own merits, but to Gods free mercy, seeing they could do no more good then they ought, and was commanded them.DVR. The Angels haue merited, & our first parents might haue merited blessednes before their fall, yet all that they could doe, was a due debt vnto God. WHIT. pag. 785. If Christ say truly, that they are vnprofitable seruants which do all that is commanded, & no more; then neither may the Angels, nor might those out first parents ascribe any thing to their ovvne merits, but to Gods free mercy, seeing they could do no more good then they ought, and vvas commanded them.
fDVR. W•e are justified by the merits of our works, not done by our own power, and help of the Law only, but by grace in Christ. WHIT. pag. 786. Thus might the Galatians have answered S. Paul, whose faith was all one with yours in this point; when be reproved them for joining the works of the Law with grace to justification: but S. Paul showed them, that the inheritance is of promise only, and so merely of grace; and no whit of works; which are ever of the Law, whether before or after faith.DVR. VV•e are iustified by the merits of our workes, not done by our owne power, and helpe of the Law only, but by grace in Christ. WHIT. pag. 786. Thus might the Galathians haue answered S. Paul, whose faith was all one vvith yours in this point; vvhen be reproued them for ioyning the workes of the Law vvith grace to iustification: but S. Paul shevved them, that the inheritance is of promise only, and so meerely of grace; and no vvhit of works; which are euer of the Law, whether before or after faith.
•••
DVR. The Saints heare our prayers, though they be absent. WHIT. pag. 790. Euery one that prayeth to Saints supposeth thē to be present, & to know euē his thoughts, and so (in effect) maketh them Gods: as Basil proueth the holie Ghost to be God, because hee heareth godly mens prayers whersoeuer. DVR. The Saints are in many far distant places at once, though not euery where. WHIT pag. 791. Duraeus doteth to say so: for as well they might be in all, as in many places at once: But Damascene, lib. 2. cap. 3. and A•••nas, quaest. 52. art. 2 say of the very Angels, that when they be in heauen, they are not in earth.
iDVR. Christ is the only Mediator of Redemption; and Saints may be Mediators of Intercession, without injury to him. WHIT. pag. 793. Christ alone is Mediator of both, as these Scriptures prove plainly: and Christ himself saith, no man cometh to the Father but by me, Job. 14.6. and, he will give you all things in my name, Joh. 16.23. and 1 Joh. 2.2. so that it is sacrilege against Christs Priesthood, to make Saints mediators to commend us to God.DVR. Christ is the only Mediator of Redemption; and Saints may be Mediators of Intercession, without iniurie to him. WHIT. pag. 793. Christ alone is Mediator of both, as these Scriptures proue plainly: and Christ himselfe saith, no man commeth to the Father but by me, Iob. 14.6. and, hee will giue you all things in my name, Ioh. 16.23. and 1 Ioh. 2.2. so that it is sacrilege against Christs Priesthood, to make Saints mediators to commend vs to God.
kDuraeus excuseth this, persuading himself the writer meant no ill in it; though it be indeed intolerable, as are many other such their usual speeches of the blessed Virgin: see Whit. pag. 794.Duraeus excuseth this, perswading himself the writer meant no ill in it; though it be indeed intolerable, as are many other such their vsuall speeches of the blessed Virgin: see VVhit. pag. 794.
significations. Neither was that indeede sufficient cause, why you should register Matrimonie in the catalogue of Sacraments, because S. Paul wrote (thus) Sacramentum hoc magnum,
. not in his last Supper, except you will say, he died then also, vvhich he must haue done to make it a sacrifice; but he was then aliue, & it were most absurd to say he was aliue and dead at one time, which he needs must be, both then and in al your Masses, if there be any sacrifice in the Masse at all. Againe, externall sacrifices, as you say your Masse is, are subiect to the sight & outward senses, but no man euer saw Christ to be sacrificed, either in the Supper or in the Masse. Therefore there is none, neither in the one nor in the other. DVR. Jt vvas a sacrifice, for Christ vvas really conteined vnder those former of bread and vvine: and so the Masse is novv an vnbloodie sacrifice. WHIT. pag. 801. You cannot prooue him to be so present there as you teach, by no Scripture; and if he were, yet that was not therefore a sacrifice, except you will haue his reall being in the Virgins wombe also to be a sacrifice, in which he was conteined. As for your vnbloody propitiatorie sacrifice: first, it is absurd, for to sacrifice killeth a bodie, but your Transubstantiation maketh a bodie: secondly, it hath no word of God for it: thirdly, it is needlesse, Christs sacrifice being perfect: fourthly, Christ ordained that supper in memorie of his sacrifice, not to be it selfe a sacrifice: WHIT. pag. •03. DVR. Many of the Fathers call the Eucharist by the name of sacrifice. WHIT. pag 805. Not because it is that same which Christ offered (as you teach) but because it is a memoriall and Sacrament of it. DVR. Purgatorie is most plainely prooued by the fact of Iudas Machabaeus, in the second booke and 12. chapter. WHIT. pag. 806. Those bookes are not Canonicall Scripture, neither doth that act prooue a Purgatorie by your owne doctrine, who say those that die in deadly sinne, (as those did there mentioned) goe to hell, and not to Purgatorie.
*Bustum coenae Dominica.
oDVR. The office of a Presbyter, or Elder, in the Gospel is the same that the Priests office was in the Law. WHIT. pag. 807. It is not so: for if the office did remain; why should the name be changed, for Elders are never called Priests in the new Testament. And there be ruling Elders in the Church, which labour not in the Ministry of the word and Sacraments, as the Priests did.DVR. The office of a Presbyter, or Elder, in the Gospell is the same that the Priests office vvas in the Lavve. WHIT. pag. 807. It is not so: for if the office did remaine; why should the name be changed, for Elders are neuer called Priests in the new Testament. And there be ruling Elders in the Church, which labour not in the Ministerie of the word and Sacraments, as the Priests did.
notwithstanding as it is not lawfull for euery man to dreame of a kingdome, so it is a thing detestable for any man to enter vpon the holy Ministery, who hath not that function committed vnto him by diuine authoritie. Wherefore I see not at all why you should charge vs with any such Homonymy (or falshood from ambiguous signification) in this word. As for your maner of fasting, that indeed is wholly in shew, and hath nothing in it of a Christian fast, but the very name. For to make choyce of meates, as a thing more religious, and to prescribe certaine, and perpetuall set dayes, wherein we must necessarily fast, the
. so then there be no Priests at all, you confess: the Fathers call them so by custom, but not properly & the Apostles of purpose abstaining from the name of Priests, might teach us hereafter better wisdom to do so also.
DVR. So the name, Sacrament, is neuer giuen to Baptisme, nor to the Eucharist in the New testament. WHIT. pag. 810. But the substance of it, agreeth to them both, and is there, whereas the name, Sacerdos, a Priest, is not in the nevv Testament, nor doth the thing it selfe properly belong to any but Christ, since his death. DVR. Yea Christ instituted a sacrifice in his Supper, and where a sacrifice is, there is a Priest also. WHIT. pag. 810. Christ ordeined thē no sacrifice, but only a Sacrament of a sacrifice. DVR. Esay calleth the M•nisters of the Gospell, Priests, cap. 6•.6. & 66.21. WHIT. Esay in the first place speaketh of all Christians; and in the second, of Ministers in the phrase of that time; vvhence also you may as well say Deacons are Leuites, vvhich you vvill not say they are prope•ly. DVR Ministers are needlesse, except they be Priects, and as mediators betwixt God and men vnto saluation: and your Ministers are but Lay-men. WHIT. pag. 810. •15. They must preach the Word, and administer the Sacraments, but not offer sacrifice of mediation betwixt God and men, as you say, you do in the Masse: to do these we haue a calling ordeined of Christ; for your sacrifice you haue none. DVR. The Apostles name them not Priests, because they are not of the order of Aaron; but the Fathers call them Priests, who knevv the Apostles m•a•ing: and you call them Priests in English. WHIT pag. 812. Christ only is a Priest, after the order of Melchisedecke: Heb. 7.3. so then there be no Priests at all, you confesse: the Fathers call them so by custome, but not properly & the Apostles of purpose abstaining frō the name of Priests, might teach vs hereafter better vvisdome to do so also.
rDVR. True, for it is Christ that presenteth himself in the sacrifice, we only are as ministers. WHIT. p. 814. If you be Ministers only, then are you not properly Priests; & why then will you be so called? DVR. Yet we as truly sacrifice, as baptise. WHIT. Thus you will be Ministers only, and no Priests, nor be copa•tners in Christs sacrifice; yet you will b• termed Priests, and truly sacrifice; these be contraries, and cannot stand together, yea, mere madness and dotages.DVR. True, for it is Christ that presenteth himselfe in the sacrifi•e, vve onely are as ministers. WHIT. p. 814. If you be Ministers only, then are you not properly Priests; & why then will you be so called? DVR. Yet vve as truely sacrifice, as baptise. WHIT. Thus you will be Ministers only, and no Priests, nor be copa•tners in Christs sacrifice; yet you will b• tearmed Priests, and truly sacrifice; these be contraries, and cannot stand together, yea, meere madnes and dotages.
sDVR. Thus you strip the Gospel of all sacrifice and religion. WHIT. pag. 816. 817. All your religion by this your doctrine, is in your Mass, which we willingly have not; but notwithstanding we have the sacrifice of Christ, which is perpetual and inchangeable, Heb. 7 2•.28. and 10.14. your invisible sacrifice the Scripture knoweth not.DVR. Thus you strippe the Gospell of all sacrifice and •eligion. WHIT. pag. 816. 817. All your religion by this your doctrine, is in your Masse, which we willingly haue not; but notwithstanding we haue the sacrifice of Christ, which is perpetuall and inchangeable, Heb. 7 2•.28. and 10.14. your inuisible sacrifice the Scripture knoweth not.
tDVR. Who called Luther, Calvin, Beza, &c. your Ministers? WHIT. pag. 820. Luther, Zuinglius, Bucer, &c. were Priests of your own, and so had a calling (except your order of Priesthood be no calling) and might call others by your law. Again, God is not tied so to order, but that he may for the good of the Church, call Ministers extraordinarily. And the Churches have lawful power to choose Ministers (so that we need not to call any from you that service) as saith Cyprian. Epist. 68. Thus were Calvin and Beza chosen.DVR. VVho called Luther, Caluin, Beza, &c. your Ministers? WHIT. pag. 820. Luther, Zuinglius, Bucer, &c. were Priests of your owne, and so had a calling (except your order of Priesthood be no calling) and might call others by your law. Againe, God is not tied so to order, but that he may for the good of the Church, call Ministers extraordinarily. And the Churches haue lavvfull povver to chuse Ministers (so that we need not to call any from you that seruice) as saith Cyprian. Epist. 68. Thus were Calui• and Beza chosen.
uDVR. This savoureth of Luthers spirit: but Pope Leo saith, that the holy Ghost taught the Apostles, the discipline of fasting, for one of the chief Sacraments of heavenly doctrine. WHIT. pag. 8•1. &c. We allow Christian fasting; but what spirit taught Leo to say so of your solemn superstitious fasts? the Scriptures speak no such thing, which we preferie before all mens judgements.DVR. This sauoureth of Luthers spirit: but Pope Leo saith, that the holy Ghost taught the Apostles, the discipl•ne of fasting, for one of the chiefe Sacraments of heauenly doctrine. WHIT. pag. 8•1. &c. Wee allow Christian fasting; but vvhat spirit taught Leo to say so of your solemne superstitious fasts? the Scriptures speake no such thing, which wee preferie before all mens iudgements.