1. Motives inducing.
pp. 40–101302 passagespart 3 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 40–101302 passagespart 3 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Agricii nomine Cataphronius. Caelestinus. Caesarius. Constantini nomine Leontius. Contumeliosius. Cyprianus. Eucherius. Florentius. Galliani nomine Melerius. Joannis nomine Desiderius. Julianus. Maximus. Philagrius. Praetextatus. Proitianus. Severi nomine Cataphronius.
Thus they are reckoned up on both sides by Vossius, amongst whom there is but one name common. To help this, Vossius deviseth a 4th Council of Arles and that the Bishops mentioned to have subscribed Faustus his Epistle, to be the Bishops assembled in the 4th Council of Arles, and not those whom we read to have been assembled ⟨p. 57⟩at the Third. But that any such Bishops were assembled at a 4th Council of Arles he brings no evidence, that I find; but his own conjecture is the best ground for this. And all this pains is taken to salve Faustus his reputation in this. And the reason that moves Vossius to conceive that this subscription was not a mere fiction of Faustus, is this; Because forsooth if this had been a mere fiction of Faustus, surely Maxentius in opposing him, would not have failed to have cast this in his teeth. Binius is eager in the defence of these Episcopal subscriptions, but withal confesseth, that either Faustus himself, or some in his name, practised to countenance his Books also by the authority of those Bishops. In fine (saith he) hujus Commentarii & Libelli, ipse Faustus, vel alius quis dolosè addider at haec verba, In quo quidem opusculo post Arelatinsis Concilii subscriptionem, novis erroribus deprehensis adjici aliqua Synodus Lugdunensis exegit, ut scilicet (saith Binnius) aliquo fuco venditari posset quasi scriptum de gratiâ & libero arbitrio Commentarium duae Synodi recepissent & approbassent. Now if such were the dishonest art of Faustus in counterfeiting this, why might he not be as dishonest in counterfeiting the former Episcopal subscriptions also? And if Vossius his reason to salve Faustus his credit, were of force in this, why should it not be in force in the other also? For Maxentius we do not find to have excepted against his fidelity, more in the one then in the other? And why might not Maxentius be ignorant of them both? And in Biblioth. Sanct. Patrum. there is an admonition added to Faustus his Epistle to Loentius, ex Indice Expurgat. M. Script. Pelatii, wherein though Faustus his epistle to Lucidus, is acknowledged to have been approved by the Episcopal subscriptions in the Council of Arles, yet as touching Faustus his mendicating authority from those Fathers to his books, De Grat. & Lib. Arbit. The Author thereof spares not in plain terms to give Faustus the lye in these words.
Thus they are reckoned up on both sides by Vossius, amongst whom there is but one name common. To help this, Vossius deviseth a 4th Councel of Arles and that the Bishops mentioned to have subscribed Faustus his Epistle, to be the Bishops assembled in the 4th Councel of Arles, and not those whom we read to have been assembled ⟨p. 57⟩at the Third. But that any such Bishops were assembled at a 4th Councell of Arles he brings no evidence, that I find; but his own conjecture is the best ground for this. And all this pains is taken to salve Faustus his reputation in this. And the reason that moves Vossius to conceive that this subscription was not a meer fiction of Faustus, is this; Because forsooth if this had been a meer fiction of Faustus, surely Maxentius in opposing him, would not have failed to have cast this in his teeth. Binius is eager in the defence of these Episcopall subscriptions, but withall confesseth, that either Faustus himselfe, or some in his name, practised to countenance his Books also by the authority of those Bishops. In fine (saith he) hujus Commentarii & Libelli, ipse Faustus, vel alius quis dolosè addider at haec verba, In quo quidem opusculo post Arelatinsis Concilii subscriptionem, novis erroribus deprehensis adjici aliqua Synodus Lugdunensis exegit, ut scilicet (saith Binnius) aliquo fuco venditari posset quasi scriptum de gratiâ & libero arbitrio Commentarium duae Synodi recepissent & approbassent. Now if such were the dishonest art of Faustus in counterfeiting this, why might he not be as dishonest in counterfeiting the former Episcopall subscriptions also? And if Vossius his reason to salve Faustus his credit, were of force in this, why should it not be in force in the other also? For Maxentius we doe not find to have excepted against his fidelity, more in the one then in the other? And why might not Maxentius be ignorant of them both? And in Biblioth. Sanct. Patrum. there is an admonition added to Faustus his Epistle to Loentius, ex Indice Expurgat. M. Script. Pelatii, wherein though Faustus his epistle to Lucidus, is acknowledged to have been approved by the Episcopall subscriptions in the Councell of Arles, yet as touching Faustus his mendicating authority from those Fathers to his books, De Grat. & Lib. Arbit. The Author thereof spares not in plain termes to give Faustus the lye in these words.
Neutiquam tamen ullus ob id existimet ab utroque Concilio approbatos tres libros Fausti de Gratiâ, ut ipse mendaciter innuere videtur in ea quae his subjicitur, praefatoriâ Epistolâ ad Episcopum Leontinum &c. But can Vossius show that Maxentius did cast this juggling course of Faustus in his teeth?
Neutiquam tamen ullus ob id existimet ab utroque Concilio approbatos tres libros Fausti de Gratiâ, ut ipse mendaciter innuere videtur in ea quae his subjicitur, praefatoriâ Epistolâ ad Episcopum Leontinum &c. But can Vossius shew that Maxentius did cast this jugling course of Faustus in his teeth?
But it seems that Vossius had no great need to trouble himself in the vindicating of Faustus his reputation in pretending the subscription of Bishops to his Epistle written to Lucidus. For how doth it appear that Faustus is the author of any such pretence? It is true, in the Epistle it self that he wrote to Lucidus, he professeth that he kept a copy of it, to show to that assembly of Bishops, Hujus Epistolae exemplar mecum retineo in conventu Sanctorum Antistitum, si ita necesse fuerit, proferendum: by the way observe that this resolution of his, was not absolute, but si ita necesse fuerit, and this necessity he signifies wherein it did consist, namely in case Lucidus by his silence, did give testimony of his continuance in his error, as he calls it, His words are these, Quod si eam subscriptam transmitter nolueris, aperte adhuc te in error persistere ipso silentio comprobabis, ac perinde jam necessitatem mihi facies ad personam tuam publicis conventibus exponendam. Now as for that which follows after the end of the Epistle, Et subscripserunt Episcopi, qui ordine subsequuntur qui in eâ quoque Synodo adfuerunt.
But it seems that Vossius had no great need to trouble himselfe in the vindicating of Faustus his reputation in pretending the subscription of Bishops to his Epistle written to Lucidus. For how doth it appeare that Faustus is the author of any such pretence? It is true, in the Epistle it selfe that he wrote to Lucidus, he professeth that he kept a copy of it, to shew to that assembly of Bishops, Hujus Epistolae exemplar mecum retineo in conventu Sanctorum Antistitum, si ita necesse fuerit, proferendum: by the way observe that this resolution of his, was not absolute, but si ita necesse fuerit, and this necessity he signifies wherein it did consist, namely in case Lucidus by his silence, did give testimony of his continuance in his errour, as he calls it, His words are these, Quod si eam subscriptam transmittere nolueris, aperte adhuc te in errore persistere ipso silentio comprobabis, ac perinde iam necessitatem mihi facies ad personam tuam publicis conventibus exponendam. Now as for that which followes after the end of the Epistle, Et subscripserunt Episcopi, qui ordine subsequuntur qui in eâ quoque Synodo adfuerunt.
Auxanius in Christi nomine Episcopus, Relegi & subscripsi Faustus exemplar Epistolae meae Relegi & subscrip. Paulus Episcopus in Christi nomine, Rel. & subscrip. Eutropius &c.
Observe the admonition subjoined by Henricus Canisius. These subscriptions, saith he, are not in the Manuscript. Hae subscriptiones non sunt in Manuscripto Codice. Consider I pray the fair issue of this Authors learned pretence of Antiquity, he honoureth the grey hairs of Faustus, and those grave assemblies mentioned by him whereof we have no certainty; but how honoureth he the greyer hairs of Austin, & of all the Assemblies against the Pelagians, that you may guess, though he concealeth it. And herein his devotion to this kind of Antiquity, where he thinketh it will serve his turn, he is content you should conceive it doth exceed the devotion of Calvin and Beza, yea and of Austin also; whose answer to Prosper he is content to pass by as not savouring so much of piety in his judgement, but the Massilienses zeal of the Ancients represented by Prosper unto Austin, that is suitable to his humour, he relisheth that well, and so well that he thinks it fit vehemently to mistrust those doctrines which they never approved, but disliked and condemned. Yet of any condemnation other then what is implied by Faustus, a man infamous, and whose ⟨p. 58⟩Writings were condemned by 70 Bishops, he makes no mention. And before Austins days, and the days of Pelagius, the Ancients were not exercised with any controversy hereabouts. And was their non-approbation of his doctrine, concerning absolute predestination, any motive to Austin vehemently to mistrust the truth thereof? I think he will not say it was; and therefore I hope he will give Calvin and Beza leave, never a whit the more for that cause, to mistrust the same doctrine, in granting the Ancients to have conceived predestination to proceed secundum praescientiam according unto foreknowledge, he is content to conform himself to their judgement; but in mistrusting the contrary doctrine, hereupon you must give him leave to follow his own, or any, rather then not Calvins or Beza's, but even Austins also, though never so much magnified by the Church of God, and his writings countenanced especially against the Pelagians, and the contrary condemned, by other manner of Councils then Arelatense 3d, and Lugdunense.
Observe the admonition subjoyned by Henricus Canisius. These subscriptions, saith he, are not in the Manuscript. Hae subscriptiones non sunt in Manuscripto Codice. Consider I pray the fair issue of this Authors learned pretence of Antiquity, he honoureth the gray haires of Faustus, and those grave assemblies mentioned by him whereof we have no certainty; but how honoureth he the grayer haires of Austin, & of all the Assemblies against the Pelagians, that you may guesse, though he concealeth it. And herein his devotion to this kind of Antiquity, where he thinketh it will serve his turne, he is content you should conceive it doth exceed the devotion of Calvin and Beza, yea and of Austin also; whose answer to Prosper he is content to passe by as not savouring so much of piety in his judgement, but the Massilienses zeale of the Ancients represented by Prosper unto Austin, that is suitable to his humour, he relisheth that well, and so well that he thinks it fit vehemently to mistrust those doctrines which they never approved, but disliked and condemned. Yet of any condemnation other then what is implied by Faustus, a man infamous, and whose ⟨p. 58⟩Writings were condemned by 70 Bishops, he makes no mention. And before Austins daies, and the daies of Pelagius, the Ancients were not exercised with any controversy hereabouts. And was their non-approbation of his doctrine, concerning absolute predestination, any motive to Austin vehemently to mistrust the truth thereof? I think he will not say it was; and therefore I hope he will give Calvin and Beza leave, never a whit the more for that cause, to mistrust the same doctrine, in granting the Ancients to have conceived predestination to proceed secundum praescientiam according unto foreknowledge, he is content to conform himselfe to their judgement; but in mistrusting the contrary doctrine, hereupon you must give him leave to follow his own, or any, rather then not Calvins or Beza's, but even Austins also, though never so much magnified by the Church of God, and his writings countenanced especially against the Pelagians, and the contrary condemned, by other manner of Councells then Arelatense 3d, and Lugdunense.
I remember when Epicurus was demanded why, seeing he followed Leucippus so much, he did not follow him throughout, made this answer saying, I do as a man that is a thirst when he takes the cup to drink, for he drinks what will serve his turn, and sets the rest by: so you must give this Author leave to represent his devotion to grey hairs, so far as they serve his turn, and no farther. Yet I have showed how Austin maintains, as touching the Ancients that went before him, that they concurred with him in fundomento praedestinationis, which he accounted the the doctrine of Free grace, and cites to this purpose Cyprian, Ambrose, and Nazianzen, and by the common prayers of the Church, that God would convert the unbelievers unto the faith of Christ; that the same doctrine, which was in his judgement the foundation of predestination, as he maintained it according to the Word of God, was generally received in the Church of God.
I remember when Epicurus was demanded why, seeing he followed Leucippus so much, he did not follow him throughout, made this answer saying, I doe as a man that is a thirst when he takes the cup to drink, for he drinks what will serve his turne, and sets the rest by: so you must give this Author leave to represent his devotion to gray haires, so farre as they serve his turne, and no farther. Yet I have shewed how Austin maintaines, as touching the Ancients that went before him, that they concurred with him in fundomento praedestinationis, which he accounted the the doctrine of Free grace, and cites to this purpose Cyprian, Ambrose, and Nazianzen, and by the common prayers of the Church, that God would convert the unbelievers unto the faith of Christ; that the same doctrine, which was in his judgement the foundation of predestination, as he maintained it according to the Word of God, was generally received in the Church of God.
Before I part from this, I think fit to add something concerning the stile here given to Lucidus, before the revocation of his pretended error; for here I find him styled the Predestinarian. Now I presume this Author, that pretends so great reverence to grey hairs, and so much prefers Antiquity before Novelty, hath good ground for this his denomination of him, and that out of Antiquity. Now I desire he would be pleased to communicate unto us, his learned reading in Antiquity for this; and the rather, because in the whole story of the business between Faustus and Lucidus, I find no mention of any such attribute given to his person, or to the doctrine (reputed by Faustus erroneous) maintained by him. The term Praedestinatus qualifying a person, I find first in Arnobius junior, and from that time I find not the Praedestinati, or Praedestinatians mentioned till the days of Hinemarus, about the year of our Lord God 850. And as for the story of the Predestinarian Heresy, which this Author licks his lips at, the original whereof is referred to the year 415 by Sigibertus; it is very strange, that in Austins days it was not known unto him, or being known, not taken notice of by him, nor by Prosper neither after him. And Alphonsus à Castro in his Book contra Haereses, professeth that the Author of this Heresy he found not, neither in Sigibert, nor in any other; because indeed not one of those who wrote of Heresies makes mention of this Heresy, besides Bernard of Lutzenburg in his Catalogue of Heretics; and he saith no more of it, then what Sigibert mentioneth in his Chronicle. And withal he adds, that after this error was buried, by the space of almost a thousand years, it was revived by John Huss the Bohemian. Whereby it appears, that Alphonsus was not of this Authors opinion in censuring this Lucidus for a Predestinarian. And the first that I find to intimate so much is Hincmarus about the year 850. In like sort Prateölus acknowledgeth that, Quis corum Dux & institutor fuerit, nescitur. But Gerardus Vossius hath herein helped us with this conjecture, referring the original of this Heresy to the Monks of Adrumetum; and Bishop Usher in his Historiá Godescalci saith, Vossius was the first that charged those Adrumetine Monks to be the author thereof. Yet if I be not deceived, he might be beholding to Coccius for helping him to this conceit.
Before I part from this, I think fit to adde something concerning the stile here given to Lucidus, before the revocation of his pretended error; for here I find him stiled the Predestinarian. Now I presume this Author, that pretends so great reverence to gray haires, and so much preferres Antiquity before Novelty, hath good ground for this his denomination of him, and that out of Antiquity. Now I desire he would be pleased to communicate unto us, his learned reading in Antiquity for this; and the rather, because in the whole story of the businesse between Faustus and Lucidus, I find no mention of any such attribute given to his person, or to the doctrine (reputed by Faustus erroneous) maintained by him. The terme Praedestinatus qualirying a person, I find first in Arnobius junior, and from that time I find not the Praedestinati, or Praedestinatians mentioned till the daies of Hinemarus, about the year of our Lord God 850. And as for the story of the Predestinarian Heresy, which this Author licks his lipps at, the originall whereof is referred to the yeare 415 by Sigibertus; it is very strange, that in Austins daies it was not known unto him, or being known, not taken notice of by him, nor by Prosper neither after him. And Alphonsus à Castro in his Book contra Haereses, professeth that the Author of this Heresy he found not, neither in Sigibert, nor in any other; because indeed not one of those who wrote of Heresics makes mention of this Heresy, besides Bernard of Lutzenburg in his Catalogue of Heretiques; and he saith no more of it, then what Sigibert mentioneth in his Chronicle. And withall he addes, that after this errour was buried, by the space of almost a thousand years, it was revived by John Husse the Bohemian. Whereby it appears, that Alphonsus was not of this Authors opinion in censuring this Lucidus for a Predestinarian. And the first that I find to intimate so much is Hincmarus about the yeare 850. In like sort Prateölus acknowledgeth that, Quis corum Dux & institutor fuerit, nescitur. But Gerardus Vossius hath herein helped us with this conjecture, referring the originall of this Heresy to the Monks of Adrumetum; and Bishop Usher in his Historiá Godescalci saith, Vossius was the first that charged those Adrumetine Monks to be the author thereof. Yet if I be not deceived, he might be beholding to Coccius for helping him to this conceit.
But this makes the matter more strange another way, namely that Austin should not take notice of this Predestinarian Heresy, seeing none was so well acquainted with the opinion of those his neighbour Monks, as he, being the man, whom they consulted about the difference that rose thereabouts, and wrote two Books thereupon and composed all. And yet I see no reason why Vossius should refer it to the Adrumetine Monks hand over head, when as it is clear by the relation of them, that came over to Austin to complain thereof, and to confer with him thereupon; that they were but few, who were carried away with that error, whereof they complained, ⟨p. 59⟩and that it was but one, that troubled the place of their Monastery herein, who was as it were the Ringleader to the rest; of which Vossius could not be ignorant. And therefore I see no cause why he should charge them all indifferently, or that party either, who were tainted herewith, as is pretended; seeing there was an Antesignanus who led the rest, of whom Vossius speaks nothing at all; and I suppose he knew some good cause why. Besides, the Predestinarian Heresy is pretended to have risen Ab Augustini libris malè intellectis. Now I find no colour of evidence hitherto, that these Monks of Adrumentum, whom Vossius makes the founders of this Heresy, were led awry by the misunderstanding of Austins writings. Neither doth Vossius any where, that I know, take any pains to clear this. And I would gladly be beholding to this Author, that pretends so much zeal unto, and skill in the knowledge of Antiquity, and so boldly stileth Lucidus a Predestinarian, for communicating unto us his rare evidences concerning this point, out of his great observations. And so much the rather, to take me off from mine error, who since the first time that I travelled in the search after this Predestinarian Heresy in dealing with Corvinus, which is now some three years ago. I have been apt to conceive that this Heresy from the first, was but a mere fiction of the Pelagians and Semi-Pelagians, cunningly to disgrace thereby the doctrine of St Austin. And since the coming forth of Dr Ushers History in the cause of Godescalcus, I have been confirmed herein;
But this makes the matter more strange another way, namely that Austin should not take notice of this Predestinarian Heresy, seeing none was so well acquainted with the opinion of those his neighbour Monks, as he, being the man, whom they consulted about the difference that rose thereabouts, and wrote two Books thereupon and composed all. And yet I see no reason why Vossius should referre it to the Adrumetine Monks hand over head, when as it is cleer by the relation of them, that came over to Austin to complaine thereof, and to conferre with him thereupon; that they were but few, who were carried away with that errour, whereof they complained, ⟨p. 59⟩and that it was but one, that troubled the place of their Monastery herein, who was as it were the Ringleader to the rest; of which Vossius could not be ignorant. And therefore I see no cause why he should charge them all indifferently, or that party either, who were tainted herewith, as is pretended; seeing there was an Antesignanus who led the rest, of whom Vossius speaks nothing at all; and I suppose he knew some good cause why. Besides, the Predestinarian Heresy is pretended to have risen Ab Augustini libris malè intellectis. Now I find no colour of evidence hitherto, that these Monks of Adrumentum, whom Vossius makes the founders of this Heresy, were led awry by the misunderstanding of Austins writings. Neither doth Vossius any where, that I know, take any pains to cleare this. And I would gladly be beholding to this Author, that pretends so much zeale unto, and skill in the knowledge of Antiquity, and so boldly stileth Lucidus a Predestinarian, for communicating unto us his rare evidences concerning this point, out of his great observations. And so much the rather, to take mee off from mine errour, who since the first time that I travelled in the search after this Predestinarian Heresy in dealing with Corvinus, which is now some three years agoe. I have been apt to conceive that this Heresy from the first, was but a meer fiction of the Pelagians and Semi-Pelagians, cunningly to disgrace thereby the doctrine of St Austin. And since the coming forth of Dr Ushers History in the cause of Godescalcus, I have been confirmed herein;
as wherein he gives to understand, that whereas Tyro Prosper wrote hereof before Sigibert, although the Printer hath made him to speak as Sigibert doth, namely, that Haec Haeresis orta est ab Augustini libris malè intellectis: yet that is not the language of Tyro himself, but plainly this, Haec Haeresis ab Augustino orta est, and that learned Bishop hath showed out of two Manuscripts of Tyro, the one in Bennet College in Cambridge, the other in our Kings Library: and this he farther confirms by comparing the description which Gennadius makes of that, which he calls the Predestinatian Heresy, with the doctrine of Augustin. lib. 5. cont. Julian. Pelag. cap. 4. & de Bono Persev. cap. 15. And withal the same learned Bishop makes it appear, that look what doctrine Sigebertus ascribes to the Predestinatians, the same doctrine was charged upon Austin, and such as concurred with him therein. This I say that learned Bishop proves out of the beginning of the 6 Book Hypemnesticon. Credere nos vel praedicare sugillatis quod Deus quosdam hominum sic praedestinet ad vitam regni caelorum, ut si nolint or are, aut jejunare, aut in omni opere divino vigiles esse, eos omninò perire non posse, nec prorsus sui debere esse sollicitos quos Deus quia voluit semel jam elegendo praedestinavit ad vitam: quosdam verò sic praedestinavit in Gehennae paenam ut etiam si credere velint, si jejuniis & or ationibus, omnique see voluntati divinae subjicerent, in his Deum non delectari & vitam illis aeternam in totum dari non posse, &c. Now this in effect is the very Heresy of the Predestinatians related by Sigebert. Therefore I much desire this Author would take the pains to prove, that this pretended Predestinarian Heresy was indeed received to be an Heresy by the Catholic Church, and not rather a fiction of the remnants of the Pelagians, wherewithal to reproach the doctrine of S. Austin in the point of Predestination.
as wherein he gives to understand, that whereas Tyro Prosper wrote hereof before Sigibert, although the Printer hath made him to speak as Sigibert doth, namely, that Haec Haeresis orta est ab Augustini libris malè intellectis: yet that is not the language of Tyro himselfe, but plainly this, Haec Haeresis ab Augustino orta est, and that learned Bishop hath shewed out of two Manuscripts of Tyro, the one in Bennet Colledge in Cambridge, the other in our Kings Library: and this he farther confirmes by comparing the description which Gennadius makes of that, which he calls the Predestinatian Heresy, with the doctrine of Augustin. lib. 5. cont. Julian. Pelag. cap. 4. & de Bono Persev. cap. 15. And withall the same learned Bishop makes it appeare, that look what doctrine Sigebertus ascribes to the Predestinatians, the same doctrine was charged upon Austin, and such as concurred with him therein. This I say that learned Bishop proves out of the beginning of the 6 Book Hypemnesticon. Credere nos vel praedicare sugillatis quod Deus quosdam hominum sic praedestinet ad vitam regni caelorum, ut si nolint or are, aut jejunare, aut in omni opere divino vigiles esse, eos omninò perire non posse, nec prorsus sui debere esse sollicitos quos Deus quia voluit semel jam elegendo praedestinavit ad vitam: quosdam verò sic praedestinavit in Gehennae paenam ut etiam si credere velint, si jejuniis & or ationibus, omnique se voluntati divinae subjicerent, in his Deum non delectari & vitam illis aeternam in totum dari non posse, &c. Now this in effect is the very Heresy of the Predestinatians related by Sigebert. Therefore I much desire this Author would take the paines to prove, that this pretended Predestinarian Heresy was indeed received to be an Heresy by the Catholique Church, and not rather a fiction of the remnants of the Pelagians, wherewithall to reproach the doctrine of S. Austin in the poynt of Predestination.
Thus have I examined this Authors pretence of the Novelty of our Tenet. I come to the consideration of that which follows.
Thus have I examined this Authors pretence of the Novelty of our Tenent. I come to the consideration of that which followes.
ITS unwillingness to abide the Trial. I find that the Authors and Abettors of it, have been 1very backward to bring it to the Standard, not only when they have been called upon by their Adversaries to have been weighed, but also when they have been entreated thereto by their chief Magistrates who might have commanded them. A shrewd argument (me thinks) that it is too light.
ITS unwillingnesse to abide the Tryall. I find that the Authors and Abettors of it, have been 1very backward to bring it to the Standard, not only when they have been called upon by their Adversaries to have been weighed, but also when they have been intreated thereto by their chief Magistrates who might have commanded them. A shrewd argument (mee thinks) that it is too light.
In the Disputation at Mompelgard Anno 1586 held between Beza and Jacobus Andreas with some Seconds on both sides, Beza and his company having disputed with the Lutherans about the person of Christ, the Lords Supper &c. When they came to this Point, did decline the sifting of it, and 1gave this reason among others, that it could not then possibly be disputed of, sine gravi eorum offendiculo, qui tanti mysterii capaces non sunt, without the great scandal and hurt of the ignorant, and unacquainted with these high mysteries.
In the Disputation at Mompelgard Anno 1586 held between Beza and Jacobus Andreas with some Seconds on both sides, Beza and his company having disputed with the Lutherans about the person of Christ, the Lords Supper &c. When they came to this Point, did decline the sifting of it, and 1gave this reason among others, that it could not then possibly be disputed of, sine gravi eorum offendiculo, qui tanti mysterii capaces non sunt, without the great scandall and hurt of the ignorant, and unacquainted with these high mysteries.
The Contra-Remonstrants also in their Conference with their Adversaries at the Hague in the year 1611 could not be drawn to dispute with them about this point, but delivered a Petition to the States of Holland and Westfrizland that they might not be urged to it, resolving rather to break off the Conference, then to meddle with it.
In the Synod likewise of Dort, in the year 1618, and 1619. the Remonstrants were warned by the President of the Synod ut de Electione potius quàm de odiosâ Reprobations materiâ agerent, that they 1should rather dispute of the point of Election, then the odious point of Reprobation.
Can this Doctrine be a truth, and yet blush at the light, which makes all thing manifest? especially considering these things.
1. That Reprobation is a principal Head of Practical divinity by the ill, or well stating of which, the glory of God, and good of Religion is much promoted, or hindered.
1. That Reprobation is a principall Head of Practicall divinity by the ill, or well stating of which, the glory of God, and good of Religion is much promoted, or hindered.
2. That there is such a necessary connection between the points of Election and Reprobation (both being parts of predestination) that the one cannot well be handled without the other.
2. That there is such a necessary connexion between the points of Election and Reprobation (both being parts of predestination) that the one cannot well be handled without the other.
3. That Reprobation was the chief cause of all the uproars in the Church at that time.
3. That Reprobation was the chief cause of all the uproares in the Church at that time.
4. That it was accused with open mouth, and challenged of falsehood, and therefore bound in justice to purge it self of the crimination.
4. That it was accused with open mouth, and challenged of falshood, and therefore bound in justice to purge it selfe of the crimination.
5. That it may easily be defended, if (as some say) it be such an apparent truth, for Nihil est ad defendendum puritate tutius, nihil ad dicendum veritate facilius, saith S. Hierom.
The striving to lye close and hide it self, though perhaps it be not so infallible, yet it is a very probable argument of a bad cause. Truth covets no corners, but is willing to abide the trial, whether in men or in doctrines. David knowing his heart to be without guile, offers himself ready to the 1Lords trial, Search me, o God, and know my heart, try me and know my thoughts, and see if there be any wicked way in me. And our Saviour tells us that, Every one that doth evil, hates the light and comes not to the light, least his deeds should be reproved; but he that doth truth, comes to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. As S. Paul saith of an Heretic, he is [Greek or Hebrew] self condemned, and so may we say of Heresy and untruth, it condemns it self, and by nothing more then by refusing the Touch-stone. He is to be thought an empty Scholar, who is loath to be opposed, and his gold to be light and counterfeit, that will not have it touched and weighed, and these Opinions to be but errors, which would so willingly walk in a mist, and dwell in silence, when it concerns the peace of the Church so much to have them examined.
The striving to lye close and hide it selfe, though perhaps it be not so infallible, yet it is a very probable argument of a bad cause. Truth covets no corners, but is willing to abide the tryall, whether in men or in doctrines. David knowing his heart to be without guile, offers himselfe ready to the 1Lords tryall, Search me, o God, and know my heart, try me and know my thoughts, and see if there be any wicked way in me. And our Saviour tells us that, Every one that doth evill, hates the light and comes not to the light, least his deeds should be reproved; but he that doth truth, comes to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God. As S. Paul saith of an Heretick, he is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 selfe condemned, and so may we say of Heresy and untruth, it condemnes it selfe, and by nothing more then by refusing the Touch-stone. He is to be thought an empty Scholler, who is loath to be opposed, and his gold to be light and counterfeit, that will not have it touched and weighed, and these Opinions to be but errours, which would so willingly walk in a mist, and dwell in silence, when it concernes the peace of the Church so much to have them examined.
Who are these Authors of this Doctrine, who here are said to have been backward to bring it to the standard? Is Beza those Authors? whereof was he the Author? Was it the doctrine of predestination as proceeding of the mere pleasure of God, and not upon foresight of mans faith and works? Is it not apparent that this was the doctrine of Austin 1200 years ago, and that in opposition to the Pelagians and Semi-Pelagians? Or was it the doctrine of reprobation, as not proceeding upon the foresight of sin, but of the mere pleasure of God? Is this Author so ignorant, as not to know what are the conclusions of Alvarez in the question, Whether there be any cause of reprobation on mans part. Lib. 10. de Auxil. disc. 110. pag. 866.
VVHo are these Authors of this Doctrine, who here are said to have been backward to bring it to the standard? Is Beza those Authors? whereof was he the Author? Was it the doctrine of predestination as proceeding of the meer pleasure of God, and not upon foresight of mans faith and works? Is it not apparent that this was the doctrine of Austin 1200 years agoe, and that in opposition to the Pelagians and Semi-Pelagians? Or was it the doctrine of reprobation, as not proceeding upon the foresight of sinne, but of the meer pleasure of God? Is this Author so ignorant, as not to know what are the conclusions of Alvarez in the question, Whether there be any cause of reprobation on mans part. Lib. 10. de Auxil. disc. 110. pag. 866.
1. His first Conclusion is this, Reprobation whereby God decreed not to give unto some everlasting life, and to permit their sin, is not conditionate, but absolute: neither doth it presuppose in God, foresight of the deserts of reprobates, or of their perseverance in sin unto the last period of their life.
1. His first Conclusion is this, Reprobation whereby God decreed not to give unto some everlasting life, and to permit their sinne, is not conditionate, but absolute: neither doth it presuppose in God, foresight of the deserts of reprobates, or of their perseverance in sinne unto the last period of their life.
2. His next Conclusion is, In the Angels that fell, there is no cause of their reprobation on their part, as touching the whole effect thereof, but before any foresight of their future sin, God, pro sua Voluntate, of his mere will, did reprobate some of them, and suffered them to fall into sin.
2. His next Conclusion is, In the Angells that fell, there is no cause of their reprobation on their part, as touching the whole effect thereof, but before any foresight of their future sinne, God, pro sua Voluntate, of his meer will, did reprobate some of them, and suffered them to fall into sinne.
3. The third, Infants departing in Original sin alone, there is no cause on their part of ⟨p. 61⟩reprobation, if they be considered in comparison with others which are not reprobated, and the like is to be said proportionably of men of ripe years.
3. The third, Infants departing in Originall sinne alone, there is no cause on their part of ⟨p. 61⟩reprobation, if they be considered in comparison with others which are not reprobated, and the like is to be said proportionably of men of ripe years.
4. The fourth, Not only comparatively, but absolutely there is no cause of reprobation. Therefore neither sin actual, nor original, nor both of them foreseen by God, was indeed the meritorious and motive cause of the reprobation of any, as touching all the effects thereof, and the proof hereof he prosecutes at large.
4. The fourth, Not only comparatively, but absolutely there is no cause of reprobation. Therefore neither sinne actuall, nor originall, nor both of them foreseen by God, was indeed the meritorious and motive cause of the reprobation of any, as touching all the effects thereof, and the proofe hereof he prosecutes at large.
5. Reprobation as touching the last effect thereof, presupposeth in signo rationis the foresight of sin original, or actual, for which a reprobate is damned. Mark it well, He does not say as the cause for which God decrees his damnation, but as the cause for which a reprobate is damned. And Aquinas (whose followers the Dominicans are) expresseth this doctrine in this manner, and that more Scholastically and accurately then Alvarez. Praescientia peccatorum potest esse aliqua ratio reprobationis ex parte paenae quae praeparatur reprobatis, in quantum scilicet Deus proponit se puniturum malos propter peccata, &c. in Ad Rom. 9. Sect. 2. in fine, that is, Prescience of sins may be some reason of reprobation on the part of punishment, to wit, in as much as God purposeth to punish wicked men for their sins. Where sin is evidently made the cause of damnation, and that by virtue of Gods purpose, but by no means the cause of the decree it self. And the same Aquinas elsewhere professeth that, No man was so mad as to affirm that merits are the cause of Predestination, as touching the act of God Predestinating: and that it cannot be the cause thereof, he proves, because nothing can be the cause of Gods will, as touching the act of God willing, but as touching the things willed by God, as formerly he had proved. The same doctrine in effect is taught by Durand in 1. dist. 41. q. 2. Bonaventure applies the same distinction to reprobation it self. Odium aeternum, saith he, implies two things, Principal significatum & connotatum &c. & primum non est ex meritis, sed secundum. This he explicates in the words following, Quod patet si resolvatur, quia Odium est propositum puniendi: Propositum autem nullus meretur sed paenam, that is, Hatred (or reprobation) is Gods purpose to punish: Of this divine purpose there is no meritorious cause, but only of the punishment. The same was the Opinion of Gandavensis, Scotus, Halensis, as I have showed in my Vindiciae.
5. Reprobation as touching the last effect thereof, presupposeth in signo rationis the foresight of sinne originall, or actuall, for which a reprobate is damned. Marke it well, He does not say as the cause for which God decrees his damnation, but as the cause for which a reprobate is damned. And Aquinas (whose followers the Dominicans are) expresseth this doctrine in this manner, and that more Scholastically and accurately then Alvarez. Praescientia peccatorum potest esse aliqua ratio reprobationis ex parte paenae quae praeparatur reprobatis, in quantum scilicet Deus proponit se puniturum malos propter peccata, &c. in Ad Rom. 9. Sect. 2. in fine, that is, Prescience of sinnes may be some reason of reprobation on the part of punishment, to wit, in as much as God purposeth to punish wicked men for their sinnes. Where sinne is evidently made the cause of damnation, and that by vertue of Gods purpose, but by no means the cause of the decree it selfe. And the same Aquinas elsewhere professeth that, No man was so mad as to affirme that merits are the cause of Predestination, as touching the act of God Predestinating: and that it cannot be the cause thereof, he proves, because nothing can be the cause of Gods will, as touching the act of God willing, but as touching the things willed by God, as formerly he had proved. The same doctrine in effect is taught by Durand in 1. dist. 41. q. 2. Bonaventure applies the same distinction to reprobation it selfe. Odium aeternum, saith he, implies two things, Principale significatum & connotatum &c. & primum non est ex meritis, sed secundum. This he explicates in the words following, Quod patet si resolvatur, quia Odium est propositum puniendi: Propositum autem nullus meretur sed paenam, that is, Hatred (or reprobation) is Gods purpose to punish: Of this divine purpose there is no meritorious cause, but only of the punishment. The same was the Opinion of Gandavensis, Scotus, Halensis, as I have shewed in my Vindiciae.
Now judge I pray with how little judgement, or modesty this Author intimates Beza to be the author of the doctrine of absolute reprobation. Perhaps he will say his meaning is, that he was the author of the Upper-way, as touching the making of the object of Predestination mankind not yet created. But to this I answer, that Beza doth so indeed, but he was never called to a conference hereabouts, and consequently he never declined it. And that which was declined, he makes to be declined by the abettors, as well as the authors; which cannot be understood of this nice and Logical point, as touching the object of reprobation. The main question is, whether there be any cause of reprobation, as touching the act of God reprobating: the Negative whereof, was maintained very generally amongst School-Divines before Beza was borne. And was it ever known, that those I have named did shrink in their heads or decline the trial thereof? What a silly thing is it then to infer, that because Beza at such a time, did decline the disputation hereof, and the Contra-Remonstrants at another time, therefore it is suspectable to be an untruth? Yet let us examine his instances.
Now judge I pray with how little judgement, or modesty this Author intimates Beza to be the author of the doctrine of absolute reprobation. Perhaps he will say his meaning is, that he was the author of the Upper-way, as touching the making of the object of Predestination mankind not yet created. But to this I answer, that Beza doth so indeed, but he was never called to a conference hereabouts, and consequently he never declined it. And that which was declined, he makes to be declined by the abettors, as well as the authors; which cannot be understood of this nice and Logicall poynt, as touching the object of reprobation. The main question is, whether there be any cause of reprobation, as touching the act of God reprobating: the Negative whereof, was maintained very generally amongst Schoole-Divines before Beza was borne. And was it ever known, that those I have named did shrink in their heads or decline the triall thereof? What a silly thing is it then to inferre, that because Beza at such a time, did decline the disputation hereof, and the Contra-Remonstrants at another time, therefore it is suspectable to be an untruth? Yet let us examine his instances.
Beza he saith did decline the sifting of this doctrine (to wit, of predestination) (for on that they were moved to dispute.) I doubt this Author speaks by rote, and that he is nothing at all acquainted with the story hereof, either in Osiander or in Beza, but transcribes only what another hath prompted unto him. For it is apparent by Osianders History, that they did confer thereof. It is true he stood off at the first, and gave reasons for it, but at length he and his fellows, condescended to the instance and importunity of their Adversaries, and so came on to the Conference hereabout, His words are these. Praefat. in 2. part. Respons. ad Acta Colloq. Mompelg. Quamvis quò evasura essent reliqua satis prospiceremus, mane nihilominus mutata sententia Illustriss. Principe salutato, in reliquam sequentem Collationem consensimus; eâ tantùm conditione additâ, ne propter proximum Paschae Festum, ea disceptatio longius protraheretur. Et ita demùm ad audiendas D. Andreae declamations rursum processimus.
Beza he saith did decline the sifting of this doctrine (to wit, of predestination) (for on that they were moved to dispute.) I doubt this Author speaks by rote, and that he is nothing at all acquainted with the story hereof, either in Osiander or in Beza, but transcribes only what another hath prompted unto him. For it is apparent by Osianders History, that they did conferre thereof. It is true he stood off at the first, and gave reasons for it, but at length he and his fellowes, condescended to the instance and importunity of their Adversaries, and so came on to the Conference hereabout, His words are these. Praefat. in 2. part. Respons. ad Acta Colloq. Mompelg. Quamvis quò evasura essent reliqua satis prospiceremus, mane nihilominus mutata sententia Illustriss. Principe salutato, in reliquam sequentem Collationem consensimus; eâ tantùm conditione additâ, ne propter proximum Paschae Festum, ea disceptatio longius protraheretur. Et ita demùm ad audiendas D. Andreae declamationes rursum processimus.
Was it this point alone the sifting whereof, as this Author phraseth it, Beza declined? It is apparent they were no less then three Points. This appears by the second part of Beza's answer Ad act. Colloq. Mompelg. as also by the answer of Jacobus Andreae, as if he were the mouth of the Prince, namely, that if they list not De Tribus illis ⟨p. 62⟩confer, yet he thought it fit that Theses written by them on those three Articles should be rehearsed in the hearing of all, which afterwards Beza and his fellows might take home with them to address an answer to them afterwards, as they thought good. And these three Articles were concerning, Predestination, Baptism, and the putting down of Images in Churches. Concerning all which Jacobus Andreae gives his reasons, why he thought it fit they should entertain farther Conference; Whereunto Beza makes answer in his Preface to that second part of his Answer Ad Act. Colloq. Mompelg. It is true, this reason Beza gave why he thought it not fit in that place publicly to dispute thereof, to wit, of predestination, Quod haec gravissima quaestio publicè in illo caetu allatis utrinque contrariis sententiis disceptari absque nonnullorum offendiculo non posse videretur. For both the mysterious nature of it is such, as few are capable of it; the Massilienses professed as much, as appears in Prospers Epistle unto Austin, De his taceri exigunt (saith Prosper) quorum altitudinem nullus attigerit. And to the same purpose, even they who durst not dislike Austins doctrine thereof professed as much, as appears by the Letter of Hilarius unto Austin. Consentientibus etiam his qui hanc definitionem improbare non audent, ut dicant, Quid opus fuit hujusmodi disputationis incerto tot minus intelligentium corda turbari? Then again it was in a Lutheran Assembly, and amongst many brought up in the hatred of the doctrine which Beza maintained, who in all likelihood would be the more exasperated. Causas verum tacendi 1tongum est omnes quaerere (saith Austin) quarum tamen est & haec una ne priors faciamus eos qui non intelligunt. No wise man, saith our Saviour, putteth new wine into old bottles. Quanto minus sapit, saith Beza in that Preface of his, qui de praest antissimo vino prius in utres faecibus adhuc, & vappa obsitos immittendo quàm de repurgandis illis & apparandis cogitet.
Was it this point alone the sifting whereof, as this Author phraseth it, Beza declined? It is apparent they were no lesse then three Points. This appears by the second part of Beza's answer Ad act. Colloq. Mompelg. as also by the answer of Jacobus Andreae, as if he were the mouth of the Prince, namely, that if they list not De Tribus illis ⟨p. 62⟩conferre, yet he thought it fit that Theses written by them on those three Articles should be rehearsed in the hearing of all, which afterwards Beza and his fellowes might take home with them to addresse an answer to them afterwards, as they thought good. And these three Articles were concerning, Predestination, Baptisme, and the putting down of Images in Churches. Concerning all which Jacobus Andreae gives his reasons, why he thought it fit they should entertaine farther Conference; Whereunto Beza makes answer in his Praeface to that second part of his Answer Ad Act. Colloq. Mompelg. It is true, this reason Beza gave why he thought it not fit in that place publiquely to dispute thereof, to wit, of predestination, Quod haec gravissima quaestio publicè in illo caetu allatis utrinque contrariis sententiis disceptari absque nonnullorum offendiculo non posse videretur. For both the mysterious nature of it is such, as few are capable of it; the Massilienses professed as much, as appears in Prospers Epistle unto Austin, De his taceri exigunt (saith Prosper) quorum altitudinem nullus attigerit. And to the same purpose, even they who durst not dislike Austins doctrine thereof professed as much, as appears by the Letter of Hilarius unto Austin. Consentientibus etiam his qui hanc definitionem improbare non audent, ut dicant, Quid opus fuit hujusmodi disputationis incerto tot minus intelligentium corda turbari? Then again it was in a Lutheran Assembly, and amongst many brought up in the hatred of the doctrine which Beza maintained, who in all likelihood would be the more exasperated. Causas verum tacendi 1tongum est omnes quaerere (saith Austin) quarum tamen est & haec una ne priores faciamus eos qui non intelligunt. No wise man, saith our Saviour, putteth new wine into old bottells. Quanto minus sapit, saith Beza in that Preface of his, qui de praest antissimo vino prius in utres faecibus adhuc, & vappa obsitos immittendo quàm de repurgandis illis & apparandis cogitet.
Lastly, Beza perceiveth the practice of Jacobus Andreas standing upon a place of advantage, to urge them to confer upon such a point, the truth whereof is most harsh to carnal affections, that so he might have the better opportunity to make them odious. And truly what Jacobus Andreas was, I know not, but Beza sets him forth as a man of a most malevolent disposition to the French Protestants: and our Saviour hath admonished us, Not to give that which is holy unto dogs, or to cast pearl before swine. Yet Andreas to serve his turn, and to draw them into a snare, pleads that the doctrine of Predestination, is not so to be put over in the Schooles, ut non opus sit eam ruddy & imperito populo ponere; yet Hunnius a man of the same profession, is so far different from Jacobus Andreas, that he thinks it not fit to preach before the rude people of prescience divine, but very sparingly; how much less would he think it fit to Preach before them of Predestination divine? De Praedest. quest. & respons. pag. 394. his words are these, Interim hoc repeto quod supra monui rudioribus (quibus Apostolus vult lac propinari, non cibum solidum apponi) non esse multum de praescientiâ Dei disputandum, hâc solummodo de causa quia haud perinde capiunt ea quae alias in Scholis in Disputationibus contra adversarios, &, ut Paulus ait, inter perfectos utiliter & ex fundamentis eloquiorum Dei astrui solent. Coram rudioribus ergo simplicior loquendi ratio & ipsorum captui accommodatior est si dicamus, Deum ad haereditatem regni caelestis elegisse & certo salvare decrevisse eos omnes qui resipiunt, & in vera fide filii Dei ex hâc vitâ decedunt. Its well known what order King James took in his time, in the restraint of preaching this doctrine in the Pulpits, by any under the degree of a Dean, and counselled the States likewise to forbid the preaching of those controversial points amongst them. And if it were wisdom in them to take this course, without any prejudice to the truth of the doctrine, why should Beza's with-holding from conference hereupon, be any thing prejudicial thereto.
Lastly, Beza perceiveth the practice of Jacobus Andreas standing upon a place of advantage, to urge them to conferre upon such a poynt, the truth whereof is most harsh to carnall affections, that so he might have the better opportunity to make them odious. And truly what Jacobus Andreas was, I know not, but Beza sets him forth as a man of a most malevolent disposition to the French Protestants: and our Saviour hath admonished us, Not to give that which is holy unto doggs, or to cast pearle before swine. Yet Andreas to serve his turne, and to draw them into a snare, pleads that the doctrine of Predestination, is not so to be put over in the Schooles, ut non opus sit eam rudi & imperito populo ponere; yet Hunnius a man of the same profession, is so farre different from Iacobus Andreas, that he thinks it not fit to preach before the rude people of prescience divine, but very sparingly; how much lesse would he think it fit to Preach before them of Predestination divine? De Praedest. quest. & respons. pag. 394. his words are these, Interim hoc repeto quod supra monui rudioribus (quibus Apostolus vult lac propinari, non cibum solidum apponi) non esse multum de praescientiâ Dei disputandum, hâc solummodo de causa quia haud perinde capiunt ea quae alias in Scholis in Disputationibus contra adversarios, &, ut Paulus ait, inter perfectos utiliter & ex fundamentis eloquiorum Dei astrui solent. Coram rudioribus ergo simplicior loquendi ratio & ipsorum captui accommodatior est si dicamus, Deum ad haereditatem regni caelestis elegisse & certo salvare decrevisse eos omnes qui resipiunt, & in vera fide filii Dei ex hâc vitâ decedunt. Its well known what order King Iames took in his time, in the restraint of preaching this doctrine in the Pulpits, by any under the degree of a Deane, and counselled the States likewise to forbid the preaching of those controversall points amongst them. And if it were wisdome in them to take this course, without any prejudice to the truth of the doctrine, why should Beza's with-holding from conference hereupon, be any thing prejudiciall thereto.
But were there not other causes of moment, to move him hereunto, which this Author conceals, and which Beza proposeth in the first place? as namely, that the Prince who invited them hereunto, in his Letters Missive, alleged no other cause of that meeting, but Infaelicem de Coenâ Domini controversiam, that unhappy Controversy about the Supper of the Lord. Secondly, that their Cities sent them over accordingly to this Conference for no other cause, but to confer thereabouts. This Jacobus Andreas acknowledgeth, and giveth a reason why in those Letters of the Prince, there was no mention made of those three Articles, whereabout they were afterwards urged to confer, to wit, quod illos in istis quoque dissidere non intellexerat Princeps Illustrissimus. And thirdly, because the Feast of Easter approached, and they desired to be at home in their own Cities by that time.
But were there not other causes of moment, to move him hereunto, which this Author conceales, and which Beza proposeth in the first place? as namely, that the Prince who invited them hereunto, in his Letters Missive, alleaged no other cause of that meeting, but Infaelicem de Coenâ Domini controversiam, that unhappy Controversy about the Supper of the Lord. Secondly, that their Citties sent them over accordingly to this Conference for no other cause, but to conferre thereabours. This Iacobus Andreas acknowledgeth, and giveth a reason why in those Letters of the Prince, there was no mention made of those three Articles, whereabout they were afterwards urged to conferre, to wit, quod illos in istis quoque dissidere non intellexerat Princeps Illustrissimus. And thirdly, because the Feast of Easter approched, and they desired to be at home in their own Citties by that time.
Lastly, doth if follow, that because they declined the sifting the truth of these points (as this Author phraseth it) after such a manner, to wit, by public disputation; doth it herehence follow, that they declined the sifting of it? They made ⟨p. 63⟩this offer to propose their opinion herein, and the confirmation of it out of the Word of God, in private before the Prince: and if Jacobus Andreas were pleased to propose any Theses against it, they would take them along with them and upon consideration to address a convenient Answer thereunto; This Beza sets down in that Preface: Let D. Andrews show if he can, saith Beza, hanc Christianae doctrinae partem aut à nostris sive scribendo sive concionando praetermissam, aut a suis rectius & acuratius quàm a nostris pertractatam. And truly for my part, I no way like such conferences, being privy to mine own imperfections, as having neither such strength of memory as to command a present use of my knowledge in these points upon all occasions, nor such command of my passions, as to keep them from breaking forth in such sort as might be obnoxious to censures, not knowing how I might be provoked; but certainly I fear not to come to the examination of any of their Writings, or to offer mine own to be examined by any of them. One thing I had almost omitted out of Beza, in his Preface to the First Part of his Answer to these Acts. It was Beza's motion that all things passing between them on both sides, might be set down in writing, under the hands of Collators; and this course I confess I could willingly approve of, and after this manner to confer with any. But this so fair a motion was rejected by Andreas; He would confer rather by word of mouth then by writing. A second motion proposed by Beza was this, that what was spoken on both sides, might be set down in writing by Notaries chosen and appointed thereunto by common consent. But neither would Andreas admit of this. Petivimus, saith Beza, initio ut utrinque omnia scriptis propria Collocutorum manu subsignatis agerentur. Quod cum D. Andreae non placuisset qui verbis agi malebat (for the Auditory was very propitious to him for the most part) postulavi ut utrinque dicta à probatis & utriusque partis consensu delectis Notariis exciperentur, quae deinde cuique party recognoscere & addita subscription confirmare liceret.
Lastly, doth if follow, that because they declined the sifting the truth of these poynts (as this Author phraiseth it) after such a manner, to wit, by publique disputation; doth it herehence follow, that they declined the sifting of it? They made ⟨p. 63⟩this offer to propose their opinion herein, and the confirmation of it out of the Word of God, in private before the Prince: and if Jacobus Andreas were pleased to propose any Theses against it, they would take them along with them and upon consideration to addresse a convenient Answer thereunto; This Beza sets down in that Preface: Let D. Andrews shew if he can, saith Beza, hanc Christianae doctrinae partem aut à nostris sive scribendo sive concionando praetermissam, aut a suis rectius & acuratius quàm a nostris pertractatam. And truly for my part, I no way like such conferences, being privy to mine own imperfections, as having neither such strength of memory as to command a present use of my knowledge in these poynts upon all occasions, nor such command of my passions, as to keep them from breaking forth in such sort as might be obnoxious to censures, not knowing how I might be provoked; but certainly I feare not to come to the examination of any of their Writings, or to offer mine own to be examined by any of them. One thing I had almost omitted out of Beza, in his Preface to the First Part of his Answer to these Acts. It was Beza's motion that all things passing between them on both sides, might be set down in writing, under the hands of Collators; and this course I confesse I could willingly approve of, and after this manner to conferre with any. But this so faire a motion was rejected by Andreas; He would conferre rather by word of mouth then by writing. A second motion proposed by Beza was this, that what was spoken on both sides, might be set down in writing by Notaries chosen and appoynted thereunto by common consent. But neither would Andreas admit of this. Petivimus, saith Beza, initio ut utrinque omnia scriptis propria Collocutorum manu subsignatis agerentur. Quod cum D. Andreae non placuisset qui verbis agi malebat (for the Auditory was very propitious to him for the most part) postulavi ut utrinque dicta à probatis & utriusque partis consensu delectis Notariis exciperentur, quae deinde cuique parti recognoscere & addita subscriptione confirmare liceret.
Haec enim erat profectò justa & sincera colloquendi ratio ut sic falsationi occurreretur. Quum autem ne hoc quidem admitteret D. Andreas, &c. Now let any indifferent person that is not soured with partial affections, judge whose carriage is to be thought in equity more prejudicial to their cause, the carriage of Andreas, or the carriage of Beza.
Haec enim erat profectò justa & sincera colloquendi ratio ut sic falsationi occurreretur. Quum autem ne hoc quidem admitteret D. Andreas, &c. Now let any indifferent person that is not sowred with partiall affections, judge whose carriage is to be thought in equity more prejudiciall to their cause, the carriage of Andreas, or the carriage of Beza.
I come to the Contra-Remonstrants unwillingness to confer upon the point of reprobation. What their reasons were I know not. But this I am sure of, the Scripture is free in speaking of election, and express; not so of reprobation, leaving us to take notice of the condition of reprobation by its opposition to election. And in conformity hereunto, both Austin in his time, and Remigius in his time, and Bradwardine in his time, speaks liberally of predestination, but very sparingly of reprobation. And the doctrine of reprobation as it is nothing less mysterious then that of election; so it is far more harsh to carnal affections. And it is well known that at the time of the Hague Conference, Barnavelt that ruled the roast amongst the States, was too great a friend to the Arminian Party.
I come to the Contra-Remonstrants unwillingnesse to conferre upon the poynt of reprobation. What their reasons were I know not. But this I am sure of, the Scripture is free in speaking of election, and expresse; not so of reprobation, leaving us to take notice of the condition of reprobation by its opposition to election. And in conformity hereunto, both Austin in his time, and Remigius in his time, and Bradwardine in his time, speaks liberally of predestination, but very sparingly of reprobation. And the doctrine of reprobation as it is nothing lesse mysterious then that of election; so it is farre more harsh to carnall affections. And it is well known that at the time of the Hague Conference, Barnavelt that ruled the rost amongst the States, was too great a friend to the Arminian Party.
But, what boldness doth this Author take in passing his suspicious censures upon a doctrine, because some defenders of it, at some time have been loath to come to entertain a public Conference thereupon? For what argument call you this, The Contra-Remonstrants would not be brought to give their reasons on this point; therefore the doctrine of Austin delivered 1200 years (or thereabouts) before, concerning the absoluteness both of Predestination on the one side, and of preterition on the other (as Vossius acknowledgeth) is to be suspended of untruth? And if my readiness to come to the trial hereon doth nothing credit the cause as maintained by others; why should others unwillingness to come to the same trial, be any disparagement to the same cause, as it is maintained by me or any other? It is well known that Peter Moulin, concurring with us in the point of absolute predestination, maintains reprobation to proceed upon the divine foresight of final perseverance in impenitency. If this Author differed from us no more the Mr Moulin doth, and acknowledged the mere pleasure of God, in giving grace to whom he will, and denying it to whom he will, I do not think any friend of his would think any whit the worse of him, or charge him with defection from the truth of God in this. Neither can I think, that he ever was of any other opinion, considering how many worthy Divines opposite to the Arminians, do either conceive, or at least seem to conceive ⟨p. 64⟩that the purpose of God to damn, doth presuppose in signo rationis the foresight of final impenitency, yet concurring with us in this, that all are fallen in Adam and so brought forth into the world in damnatâ Massà, as Austin calleth it. God of his mere pleasure cures this natural corruption (the fruits whereof are infidelity and impenitency) in some, by regenerating them and bestowing the grace of faith and repentance upon them, and leaves it uncured in others by refusing to regegenerate them, to bestow faith and repentance upon them; We give the hands of Christian fellowship, and brotherly amity one unto another, without all exception notwithstanding some nice differences, which in the issue I hope, will prove to be merely Logical, and nothing Theological.
But, what boldnesse doth this Author take in passing his suspicious censures upon a doctrine, because some defenders of it, at some time have been loath to come to entertaine a publique Conference thereupon? For what argument call you this, The Contra-Remonstrants would not be brought to give their reasons on this point; therefore the doctrine of Austin delivered 1200 years (or thereabouts) before, concerning the absolutenesse both of Predestination on the one side, and of preterition on the other (as Vossius acknowledgeth) is to be suspended of untruth? And if my readinesse to come to the triall hereon doth nothing credit the cause as maintained by others; why should others unwillingnesse to come to the same triall, be any disparagement to the same cause, as it is maintained by me or any other? It is well known that Peter Moulin, concurring with us in the poynt of absolute predestination, maintaines reprobation to proceed upon the divine foresight of finall perseverance in impenitency. If this Author differed from us no more the Mr Moulin doth, and acknowledged the meer pleasure of God, in giving grace to whom he will, and denying it to whom he will, I doe not think any friend of his would think any whit the worse of him, or charge him with defection from the truth of God in this. Neither can I think, that he ever was of any other opinion, considering how many worthy Divines opposite to the Arminians, doe either conceive, or at least seem to conceive ⟨p. 64⟩that the purpose of God to damne, doth presuppose in signo rationis the foresight of finall impenitency, yet concurring with us in this, that all are fallen in Adam and so brought forth into the world in damnatâ Massà, as Austin calleth it. God of his meer pleasure cures this naturall corruption (the fruits whereof are infidelity and impenitency) in some, by regenerating them and bestowing the grace of faith and repentance upon them, and leaves it uncured in others by refusing to regegenerate them, to bestow faith and repentance upon them; We give the hands of Christian fellowship, and brotherly amity one unto another, without all exception notwithstanding some nice differences, which in the issue I hope, will prove to be meerly Logicall, and nothing Theologicall.