[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
pp. 770–844447 passagespart 6 of 12
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
By which craft, Satan (doubtless) goeth about to undermine the necessity of satisfaction; and, withal, Christs satisfaction for us; and consequently, our whole faith, and utterly to destroy these: For it is not unknown, that Socinian niceties aim at this. Good God! what means this itching humour of arguing, and this lust of ⟨p. 792⟩innovating and pulling up of every thing? Whatsoever yesternight they dreamed of, to day they utter it in their Pulpits, as if they were Oracles; and with great eagerness defend: to morrow they are of another opinion, and they change their opinions, as often as they do their clothes; as though there were not already too many strifes, and monstrous opinions in the Church. I fear, lest these sparks shortly burst out into a flame, which will by degrees set our Churches in a combustion, if we be not the more watchful: Therefore, Noble Count, your singular care and study deserve high commendation, in that (out of your grave wisdom and excellent piety) you do not slightly pass over these increasing evils; but you perceive that you are concerned, when your neighbours house is on fire: and therefore you endeavour to find out fit remedies for these fresh wounds. As for my self, although I confess that I am not willing to meddle with this controversy, but by all means desire it may be buried; both because I judge it unworthy of our Churches, and Evangelical Schools, especially in this clear light of Scripture and Reformation; as also, because I perceive our Adversaries take occasion to oppress the truth by our wranglings; then lastly, because whatsoever I say, will presently be thought a casting of oil into the fire, as the Proverb is, by reason of the heat of some, who are so violent in maintaining this cause, that they can scarce abide their brethren, if they be of another opinion. Notwithstanding, seeing what in this case is demanded from me, is not dissonant to mine office and profession, I shall think it no burden, freely to deliver mine opinion of this question: and that I may answer in order to all your Lordships interrogatories, I will first of all briefly touch the chief opinions and reasons of moment in this controversy; to wit, §I1. Whether Christs passive justice alone, or his active also, be imputed to us for righteousness. §II2.
By which craft, Satan (doubtlesse) goeth about to undermine the necessitie of satisfaction; and, withall, Christs satisfaction for us; and consequently, our whole faith, and utterly to destroy these: For it is not unknowne, that Socinian nicities aime at this. Good God! what meanes this itching humour of arguing, and this lust of ⟨p. 792⟩innovating and pulling up of every thing? Whatsoever yesternight they dreamed of, to day they utter it in their Pulpits, as if they were Oracles; and with great eagernesse defend: to morrow they are of another opinion, and they change their opinions, as often as they doe their clothes; as though there were not already too many strifes, and monstrous opinions in the Church. I feare, lest these sparkes shortly burst out into a flame, which will by degrees set our Churches in a combustion, if we be not the more watchfull: Therefore, Noble Count, your singular care and studie deserve high commendation, in that (out of your grave wisdome and excellent pietie) you doe not slightly passe over these increasing evils; but you perceive that you are concerned, when your neighbours house is on fire: and therefore you endeavour to find out fit remedies for these fresh wounds. As for my selfe, although I confesse that I am not willing to meddle with this controversie, but by all meanes desire it may be buried; both because I judge it unworthy of our Churches, and Evangelicall Schooles, especially in this cleere light of Scripture and Reformation; as also, because I perceive our Adversaries take occasion to oppresse the truth by our wranglings; then lastly, because whatsoever I say, will presently be thought a casting of oile into the fire, as the Proverb is, by reason of the heat of some, who are so violent in maintaining this cause, that they can scarce abide their brethren, if they be of another opinion. Notwithstanding, seeing what in this case is demanded from mee, is not dissonant to mine office and profession, I shall think it no burthen, freely to deliver mine opinion of this question: and that I may answer in order to all your Lordships interrogatories, I will first of all briefly touch the chiefe opinions and reasons of moment in this controversie; to wit, §I1. Whether Christs passive justice alone, or his active also, be imputed to us for righteousnesse. §II2.
I will in few words unfold what I think of other mens opinions, and of the best way to procure concord in this case. §III3. Whether it be fit to handle this Argument positively, and refutatively in popular Sermons. §IV4. I will briefly give mine opinion, if it be needful to leave out, or to put out any passages in the Palatinate Catechism and Directory.
I will in few words unfold what I think of other mens opinions, and of the best way to procure concord in this case. §III3. Whether it be fit to handle this Argument positively, and refutatively in popular Sermons. §IV4. I will briefly give mine opinion, if it be needfull to leave out, or to put out any passages in the Palatinate Catechisme and Directorie.
As for the first head, That the state of the controversy may be better understood, we must know in what these Disputers agree, or disagree. They all agree, 1. That to justify, in that sense it is used in the Courts of Justice, (signifieth to absolve from guilt, and to repute one just. 2. That we sinners are justified before God, not legally, but evangelically; that is, not by works, but by faith: not by our own, but by another's justice. 3. That this justice of another is not infused, but imputed by God to the faithful, and that freely. 4. That the application of imputed justice is done by faith only; and, that to be justified by faith, is the same that is to be justified by the justice of another imputed, and by faith applied. 5. That this external justice is the merit of Christ alone, and his satisfaction for us, or Christs righteousness imputed to us.
As for the first head, That the state of the controversie may be better understood, we must know in what these Disputers agree, or disagree. They all agree, 1. That to justifie, in that sense it is used in the Courts of Justice, (signifieth to absolve from guilt, and to repute one just. 2. That wee sinners are justified before God, not legally, but evangelically; that is, not by workes, but by faith: not by our owne, but by anothers justice. 3. That this justice of another is not infused, but imputed by God to the faithfull, and that freely. 4. That the application of imputed justice is done by faith onely; and, that to be justified by faith, is the same that is to be justified by the justice of another imputed, and by faith applied. 5. That this externall justice is the merit of Christ alone, and his satisfaction for us, or Christs righteousnesse imputed to us.
But they disagree in the explication of this merit, or of Christs justice: First, as the justice of God in Scripture equivocally signifieth sometimes that, by which God himself is just; sometimes that, by which he justifieth us: So, the justice of Christ equivocally is called that, by which Christ, God and man, is just; as also that, which he hath merited for us, and which by faith he bestoweth on us: the neglect of this equivocation is the cause of all the controversy.
But they disagree in the explication of this merit, or of Christs justice: First, as the justice of God in Scripture equivocally signifieth sometimes that, by which God himselfe is just; sometimes that, by which he justifieth us: So, the justice of Christ equivocally is called that, by which Christ, God and man, is just; as also that, which hee hath merited for us, and which by faith hee bestoweth on us: the neglect of this equivocation is the cause of all the controversie.
Again, when in Christ, as God and man, there is a four-fold justice affirmed by some: 1. His divine or essential. 2. His humane, or formal, or original. 3. His active filling of the Law. 4. His passive obedience; the question is, Whether all these justices, or some, or the last only, be that thing, by the imputation of which, we are justified? Some call this the matter, others the form of our justice; I, to be better understood, will call it the matter.
Againe, when in Christ, as God and man, there is a foure-fold justice affirmed by some: 1. His divine or essentiall. 2. His humane, or formall, or originall. 3. His active filling of the Law. 4. His passive obedience; the question is, Whether all these justices, or some, or the last onely, be that thing, by the imputation of which, we are justified? Some call this the matter, others the forme of our justice; I, to be better understood, will call it the matter.
This question hath drawn with it another, concerning the form of our justification, whether remission of sins be the whole, or only the half of our justification? And so far, as I can remember, this controversy began first to be in agitation amongst some Divines of Marchia, about the year 64. then in the year 70. ⟨p. 793⟩by the mediation of the University of Wittenberg, it was in some sort laid asleep, or rather suppressed: heretofore it was unknown to the Reformed Churches; neither is there any mention or dispute of it, for ought I know, in the writings of Luther, Melanchthon, Zuinglius, Calvin, Martyr, Musculus, Hyperius, or of the other Divines of this Age. But the simple doctrine of Scripture, was received by consent of all, to wit, that we are justified by the death of Christ, whereas by it we have remission of sins. Now, there are in a manner four opinions, which, whilst I am writing, I think of Lombard, who rehearseth also four opinions of his side,1 concerning Justification, he himself being ignorant what to think.
This question hath drawne with it another, concerning the forme of our justification, whether remission of sins be the whole, or onely the halfe of our justification? And so far, as I can remember, this controversie began first to be in agitation amongst some Divines of Marchia, about the yeare 64. then in the yeare 70. ⟨p. 793⟩by the mediation of the University of Witteberg, it was in some sort laid asleep, or rather suppressed: heretofore it was unknowne to the Reformed Churches; neither is there any mention or dispute of it, for ought I know, in the writings of Luther, Melancthon, Zuinglius, Calvin, Martyr, Musculus, Hyperius, or of the other Divines of this Age. But the simple doctrine of Scripture, was received by consent of all, to wit, that we are justified by the death of Christ, whereas by it we have remission of sins. Now, there are in a manner foure opinions, which, whilst I am writing, I thinke of Lombard, who rehearseth also foure opinions of his side,1 concerning Justification, he himselfe being ignorant what to thinke.
The first sort are they, who will have all these four justices of Christ at once to be imputed to us; to them the matter of justification is the four-fold righteousness of Christ; the form, the quadripartite imputation: yet, this they reduce sometimes to two parts; to wit, the remission of sins by the death of Christ, and the imputation of Christs righteousness, divine, humane, active, &c. and the proper reason of these is, that whole of Christ, God and man, is our Saviour, King, and Priest, &c. and that the dignity of Christs merit, especially from the dignity of the person, that is, of the divinity, hath its dependence.
The first sort are they, who will have all these foure justices of Christ at once to be imputed to us; to them the matter of justification is the foure-fold righteousnesse of Christ; the forme, the quadripartite imputation: yet, this they reduce sometimes to two parts; to wit, the remission of sins by the death of Christ, and the imputation of Christs righteousnesse, divine, humane, active, &c. and the proper reason of these is, that whole of Christ, God and man, is our Saviour, King, and Priest, &c. and that the dignity of Christs merit, especially from the dignity of the person, that is, of the divinity, hath its dependence.
Others will have the three latter justices of Christ to be the matter, and the three-fold imputation of them, to be the form of justification: And they teach, that first is imputed to us the passive obedience, to this end, that we may not be unjust; that is, for remission of sins. Secondly, the active obedience, for this end, that we may be just; that is, to righteousness. Thirdly, the formal, or, as they call it, the habitual sanctity, for this end, that we may be accounted holy; that is, to perfect holiness.
Others will have the three latter justices of Christ to be the matter, and the three-fold imputation of them, to be the forme of justification: And they teach, that first is imputed to us the passive obedience, to this end, that we may not be unjust; that is, for remission of sins. Secondly, the active obedience, for this end, that we may be just; that is, to righteousnesse. Thirdly, the formall, or, as they call it, the habituall sanctity, for this end, that we may be accounted holy; that is, to perfect holinesse.
The third sort make the two latter justices only of Christ the matter of justification, and the two-fold imputation of them, the form of justification. All these three agree in this, that they distinguish remission of sins and justification, as the part and the whole, sometime also as the integral parts of the whole; and the former they attribute to the death of Christ, the latter to his active obedience: they all likewise use the same arguments, and words of Scripture, of which I will briefly set down the chiefest.
The third sort make the two latter justices onely of Christ the matter of justification, and the two-fold imputation of them, the forme of justification. All these three agree in this, that they distinguish remission of sins and justification, as the part and the whole, sometime also as the integrall parts of the whole; and the former they attribute to the death of Christ, the latter to his active obedience: they all likewise use the same arguments, and words of Scripture, of which I will briefly set downe the chiefest.
1. As by the disobedience of one man, many were made sinners; so by the obedience of one, many are made righteous, Rom. 5. But Adams disobedience was active; therefore we are justified by Christs active obedience. 2. He was made obedient, even to the death of the Cross, Phil. 2. Here is a two-fold obedience of Christ, the one before death, the other in death; therefore both are imputed. 3. God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, and made under the Law, that he might redeem those that were under the Law, Gal. 4. Therefore, the active fulfilling of the Law by Christ is imputed to us. 4. He was made of God to us, wisdom, righteousness, sanctification, &c. 1 Cor. 1. Therefore his justice and sanctity are imputed to us. 5. The Law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus, freed me from the law of sin, and of death, Rom. 8.2. Therefore, the life of Christ, or his active obedience, is imputed to us. 6. Whole Christ is our justice, with which he justifieth us; therefore, whole Christ is imputed. 7. Active justice cannot be excluded from Christs merit, and from justification, ergo, it is imputed. 8. The Law obligeth both to obedience, and to punishment; therefore, it behooved Christ both to fulfil the obedience of the Law for us, and also to suffer punishment. 9. To whom the Law doth promise life, such must we be by the grace of Christ, that we may obtain life: the Law promiseth life, not to them who transgress not the Law, but to them who fulfil it all: but by the imputation of his passive obedience, we are accounted indeed not unjust, not sinners, or, not transgressors of the Law; but we are not as yet accounted just, or fulfillers of the Law; for, what is more vain, then to call him just, who hath not fulfilled the Law? Therefore, not only must his passive obedience be imputed to us for this, that we may not be unjust, or not transgressors of the Law; but also his active, for this, that we may be just, or fulfillers of the Law: for, he that in Christ is accounted for no sinner, shall escape death; but by what right ⟨p. 794⟩shall he also sue for life, unless he fulfil the whole righteousness of the Law in the same Christ? 10. The sacrifice and death of Christ comfort us against the guilt, and death eternal: but his holiness against our inherent impurity, or the remainders of sin; therefore, the imputation of both is necessary for our consolation, 11.
Lastly, the Catechism of the Palatinate teacheth qq. 60. and 61. that the perfect satisfaction, justice, and sanctity of Christ, are imputed and given to us, to be our justice: and q. 36. that our Mediator, by his innocency, and perfect sanctity covers our sins in which we were conceived, lest they should appear in the sight of God. The same is found every-where in the Palatinate Directory.
Lastly, the Catechisme of the Palatinate teacheth qq. 60. and 61. that the perfect satisfaction, justice, and sanctity of Christ, are imputed and given to us, to be our justice: and q. 36. that our Mediatour, by his innocency, and perfect sanctity covers our sins in which we were conceived, lest they should appeare in the sight of God. The same is found every-where in the Palatinate Directory.
I have faithfully set down the arguments, by which the former sort maintain their opinions: the fourth sort remain, who make Christs passive obedience only our righteousness, and define justification by remission of sins only; these make use chiefly of two arguments taken our of Scripture, the one from the matter, the other from the form of justification: The first is this; The Scripture showeth the whole matter of our righteousness to consist in the passion, Cross, blood, and death of Christ; therefore, this only is it for which we are justified. They prove the Antecedent by testimonies of Scripture:a We are justified freely by redemption made in Christ Jesus, whom God hath set as a propitiation by faith in his blood. bWe are justified by his blood, being reconciled by the death of his Son. cHim who knew no sin, be hath made sin, (that is, a sacrifice for sin), that we might become the righteousness of God in him. dHe being made a curse for us upon the tree, hath redeemed us from the curse of the Law. eWe have redemption by his blood. fHaving made peace by the blood of his Cross, by him he hath reconciled all things to himself; hath reconciled them in the body of his flesh by death. gWe are redeemed by the precious blood of the immaculate Lamb. hBy whose stripes we are healed iThe blood of Christ purgeth us from all our sins. kThou hast redeemed us by thy blood. They have washed their robes, and made them white in the blood of the Lamb.
The latter is this: The Scripture defines our whole justification, by remission of sins through the blood of Christ; therefore, only the effusion of blood is that, by imputation of which we are justified; and the remission of sins is our whole righteousness. They confirm the Antecedent by testimonies of Scripture:l God be merciful to me a sinner. I tell you, that he went down unto his house justified rather then the other. mBe it known to you, that to you is preached remission of sins, through him; and from all things, from which by the Law you could not be absolved, by him all that believe are justified. Here, to be absolved, to be justified, to have remission of sins, are the same things. David pronounceth that man blessed, to whom God imputeth righteousness without works:n Blessed are they whose sins are forgiven, and whose iniquities are hid. Blessed is the man to whom God imputeth no sin. oWho shall lay any thing to the charge of Gods Elect? It is God that justifieth; who shall condemn? It is Christ who is dead, &c. pGod was in Christ, reconciling to himself the world by not imputing to them their sins. qIn whom we have redemption by his blood; that is, remission of sins, &c. They have also other arguments, which, for brevities sake, I omit; they allege also for themselves the Catechism of the Palatinate, qq. 37.45.66.55.57.72.76.80.84. &c. In which it is taught, that we obtain remission of sins, justice, and life eternal, for the alone sacrifice of Christ on the Cross; and that only the blood of Christ purgeth us from all sin: which very thing, is every-where found in the Directory of the Palatinate. Hitherto the different opinions concerning justice.
The latter is this: The Scripture defines our whole justification, by remission of sins through the bloud of Christ; therefore, onely the effusion of bloud is that, by imputation of which we are justified; and the remission of sins is our whole righteousnesse. They confirme the Antecedent by testimonies of Scripture:
I now pass to the second head, where I will briefly show, without prejudice to others, what I can approve or disapprove in those who follow the first opinion: I cannot see how they can prove out of Scripture the imputation of Gods essential justice: or, why that should be said to be imputed, seeing man was never obliged, either to the possession or performance of it: for, God never conferred upon man his essential justice, and man never lost it. They make God then unjust, as if he did require of man divine justice, which he never gave him, nor ever will give him.
I now passe to the second head, where I will briefly shew, without prejudice to others, what I can approve or disapprove in those who follow the first opinion: I cannot see how they can prove out of Scripture the imputation of Gods essential justice: or, why that should be said to be imputed, seeing man was never obliged, either to the possession or performance of it: for, God never conferred upon man his essentiall justice, and man never lost it. They make God then unjust, as if he did require of man divine justice, which he never gave him, nor ever will give him.
The reason is a Paralogisme non causae; for, although whole Christ is a King, ⟨p. 795⟩Priest, and Saviour, and whole Christ justifieth; yet, it is known, that he performs the effects of his office, among which is justification, by the distinct operations of his natures: therefore whole Christ justifieth; but one way, according to his divinity, to wit, as the efficient cause; another way, according to his humanity, to wit, as a meritorious cause: and the dignity of the merit flows from the dignity of the person; that is, from the deity of the Mediator. But from hence it doth not follow, that the deity can challenge any part of the merit, being the fountain of merit. It behooved then the Mediator to be God, not that the deity, or justice of the deity might be imputed to us; or, according to Osianders madness, essentially dwelling in us, might become our justice: but for the cause explained in the Catechism, q. 17. Therefore, the justice of the divinity differs from merit, as the cause from the effect.
The reason is a Paralogisme non causae; for, although whole Christ is a King, ⟨p. 795⟩Priest, and Saviour, and whole Christ justifieth; yet, it is knowne, that he performes the effects of his office, among which is justification, by the distinct operations of his natures: therefore whole Christ justifieth; but one way, according to his divinity, to wit, as the efficient cause; another way, according to his humanity, to wit, as a meritorious cause: and the dignity of the merit flowes from the dignity of the person; that is, from the deity of the Mediatour. But from hence it doth not follow, that the deity can challenge any part of the merit, being the fountaine of merit. It behooved then the Mediatour to be God, not that the deity, or justice of the deity might be imputed to us; or, according to Osianders madnesse, essentially dwelling in us, might become our justice: but for the cause explained in the Catechisme, q. 17. Therefore, the justice of the divinity differs from merit, as the cause from the effect.
Other inconveniences also of this opinion belong to the two ensuing; therefore, I join the second and third opinion together; for, they differ not, save only that the one makes two parts, the other three parts of imputative justice. All which opinions are subject to the same inconveniences.
Other inconveniences also of this opinion belong to the two ensuing; therefore, I joyne the second and third opinion together; for, they differ not, save onely that the one makes two parts, the other three parts of imputative justice. All which opinions are subject to the same inconveniences.
1. All confound the justice of the person, and of the merit of Christ, which the Scripture oftentimes conjoins, but doth also manifestly distinguish, as the efficient cause, or sine qua non; and the material cause of our justice: as, My righteous servant by his knowledge shall justify many. For, such an High-Priest became us, who might be holy, separated from sinners: that he might offer not for his own, but for the sins of the people. Him who knew not sin, he hath made sin for us, that we, &c. 1 Pet. 3. Christ suffered once, the just for the unjust. And so our Catechism, quest. 15.16.
1. All confound the justice of the person, and of the merit of Christ, which the Scripture oftentimes conjoynes, but doth also manifestly distinguish, as the efficient cause, or sine qua non; and the materiall cause of our justice: as, My righteous servant by his knowledge shall justifie many. For, such an High-Priest became us, who might be holy, separated from sinners: that he might offer not for his owne, but for the sins of the people. Him who knew not sin, he hath made sin for us, that we, &c. 1 Pet. 3. Christ suffered once, the just for the unjust. And so our Catechisme, quest. 15.16.
2. These distinctions which they make between not unjust, and just; between not transgressing of the Law, and fulfilling of the Law; between not dead, and alive: they have more subtlety then verity; being indeed equivalent terms, as I will afterward show: for, of necessity, he that before God is not unjust, must be just; who transgresseth not the Law, fulfils it; who is not dead, is alive. Seeing all these are immediate contraries, one of which being affirmed or denied, the other must necessarily be affirmed or denied.
2. These distinctions which they make betweene not unjust, and just; betweene not transgressing of the Law, and fulfilling of the Law; betweene not dead, and alive: they have more subtlety then verity; being indeed equivalent termes, as I will afterward shew: for, of necessity, he that before God is not unjust, must be just; who transgresseth not the Law, fulfils it; who is not dead, is alive. Seeing all these are immediate contraries, one of which being affirmed or denied, the other must necessarily be affirmed or denied.
3. If by the imputation of the passive obedience we are not as yet just, but only not unjust, how is this true, We are justified by the blood of his Son? We are reconciled by his death, &c?
3. If by the imputation of the passive obedience we are not as yet just, but onely not unjust, how is this true, We are justified by the bloud of his Son? We are reconciled by his death, &c?
4. If remission of sins be not whole justification, how can that be true, Blessed are they whose iniquities are forgiven? Rom. 4. &c. how doth the Apostle in the same place take for the same thing, To impute righteousness, and, Not to impute sin?
4. If remission of sins be not whole justification, how can that be true, Blessed are they whose iniquities are forgiven? Rom. 4. &c. how doth the Apostle in the same place take for the same thing, To impute righteousnesse, and, Not to impute sin?
5. If the omission of obedience to the Law, and the imperfection of our holiness, are not expiated by Christs passive obedience, but necessarily that must be covered with Christs actual obedience, this with his natural holiness; how again can this be true, The blood of Jesus Christ purgeth us from all sin? unless, perhaps, omission and imperfection be not sins.
5. If the omission of obedience to the Law, and the imperfection of our holinesse, are not expiated by Christs passive obedience, but necessarily that must be covered with Christs actuall obedience, this with his naturall holinesse; how againe can this be true, The bloud of Jesus Christ purgeth us from all sin? unlesse, perhaps, omission and imperfection be not sins.
6. If we are not justified by the passive, but by the active obedience of Christ; how is it, that Christ died not in vain? For, what need was there that Christ should die, and by his death procure to us pardon for our sins, if by his just and holy life, he had already merited righteousness for us? for, righteousness necessarily presupposeth remission of sins.
6. If we are not justified by the passive, but by the active obedience of Christ; how is it, that Christ died not in vaine? For, what need was there that Christ should die, and by his death procure to us pardon for our sins, if by his just and holy life, he had already merited righteousnesse for us? for, righteousnesse necessarily presupposeth remission of sins.
7. It is manifest, that all these partitions of Christs merits into two or three members, do exceedingly derogate, either from the death of Christ, or from the justice of God. For, these two or three parts of our justice, are either three perfect justices of Christ, every one of which apart satisfieth the Law; or, they are so many imperfect justices, concurring to make up one perfect righteousness. If they are imperfect, do they not manifestly derogate from the death of Christ? If perfect, how is not God unjust, who, for one fault, demands two or three perfect satisfactions, whereas his justice requires but one?
7. It is manifest, that all these partitions of Christs merits into two or three members, do exceedingly derogate, either from the death of Christ, or from the justice of God. For, these two or three parts of our justice, are either three perfect justices of Christ, every one of which apart satisfieth the Law; or, they are so many imperfect justices, concurring to make up one perfect righteousnesse. If they are imperfect, do they not manifestly derogate from the death of Christ? If perfect, how is not God unjust, who, for one fault, demands two or three perfect satisfactions, whereas his justice requires but one?
8. If a part of our justice must be sought for here, a part there, a part in the death, a part in the actual Antecedent obedience, and a part in the natural holiness ⟨p. 796⟩of Christ; is not our faith dangerously distracted, and our comfort undermined?
8. If a part of our justice must be sought for here, a part there, a part in the death, a part in the actuall Antecedent obedience, and a part in the naturall holinesse ⟨p. 796⟩of Christ; is not our faith dangerously distracted, and our comfort undermined?
9. Lastly, that which chiefly with-holds me, is, that I read no-where in Scripture, such a tripartite, or bipartite division of our justice: I read no-where, that Christs humane holiness is imputed to us; that either it, or any part of it, is our righteousness. If any man hath read it, I entreat him to show it, that I may also read and believe it. Neither do I read this any-where of actual obedience; nor do the five testimonies which they bring, prove any such thing; which I briefly show, thus:
9. Lastly, that which chiefly with-holds me, is, that I reade no-where in Scripture, such a tripartite, or bipartite division of our justice: I reade no-where, that Christs humane holinesse is imputed to us; that either it, or any part of it, is our righteousnesse. If any man hath read it, I intreat him to shew it, that I may also reade and beleeve it. Neither do I reade this any-where of actuall obedience; nor do the five testimonies which they bring, prove any such thing; which I briefly shew, thus:
Out of that saying Rom. 5. they conclude more then follows; for, the consequence will not hold: We are justified by Christs obedience, ergo, by his active obedience. The Apostle sets in opposition, Christs obedience, and Adams disobedience; not as action against action, but as satisfaction against the fault, as the remedy against the disease; otherwise, the sins of omission were not transgressions: but Adams sin was not only a perpetration of evil, but the omission of good also. Now, the obedience which he understands here, in another place he doth more expressly declare, saying, He was made obedient to death, even the death of the Cross. But this was the obedience of his exinanition, and of death; and of the same obedience Theophylact interprets both places. Therefore, we deny that in this other place, which they object the second time, any mention is made of two obediences: for, the text showeth, that the Apostle speaks of his continuated obedience, Even to the death of the Cross; 1which began, when he assumed a servile condition, and ended with his death.2 Neither doth that place, Gal. 4. avail any whit to the active obedience; for, how Christ for us was made subject to the Law, the Apostle himself explains clearly, chap. 3. He redeemed us from the curse of the Law, being made a curse for us; that the blessing of Abraham may be extended upon the Gentiles in Christ Jesus. But this is understood of Christs voluntary humiliation, even to the death appointed by the Law for our sins. How, notwithstanding, this place may be understood of the servitude to the whole Law, I will speak hereafter.
Out of that saying Rom. 5. they conclude more then followes; for, the consequence will not hold: We are justified by Christs obedience, ergo, by his active obedience. The Apostle sets in opposition, Christs obedience, and Adams disobedience; not as action against action, but as satisfaction against the fault, as the remedy against the disease; otherwise, the sinnes of omission were not transgressions: but Adams sin was not onely a perpetration of evill, but the omission of good also. Now, the obedience which he understands here, in another place he doth more expresly declare, saying, He was made obedient to death, even the death of the Crosse. But this was the obedience of his exinanition, and of death; and of the same obedience Theophylact interprets both places. Therefore, we deny that in this other place, which they object the second time, any mention is made of two obediences: for, the text sheweth, that the Apostle speakes of his continuated obedience, Even to the death of the Crosse;
In that saying to the Corinthians,1 the Apostle joineth four things, but not as parts of imputed justice, (for, who will reckon among these, wisdom, or redemption it self?) but as the chief heads of Christs benefits; of which, some do help us only by imputation, as justice; others, by real participation also: in this life inchoatively, in the other life perfectly, as all the rest. Hence then no partition can be proved.
In that saying to the Corinthians,1 the Apostle joyneth foure things, but not as parts of imputed justice, (for, who will reckon among these, wisdome, or redemption it selfe?) but as the chiefe heads of Christs benefits; of which, some do helpe us onely by imputation, as justice; others, by reall participation also: in this life inchoatively, in the other life perfectly, as all the rest. Hence then no partition can be proved.
In that place to the Romans is the fallacy of Figura dictionis; 1for there, The Law of the Spirit of life, doth not signify life, or Christs active obedience, much less his formal holiness; but it signifieth, the doctrine, or quickening grace of the Gospel. The place is somewhat obscure; but, by the scope, the simple meaning may be known: that the remainders of the flesh condemn not godly men, if so be they make resistance against them, by the help of the Spirit. What the Apostle said in the first verse, he proves in the second, by supposing his own person, from the effect of the Gospel: The Law, saith he, of the spirit of life; that is, the doctrine or grace of the Gospel, which is the ministry of the Spirit of life, or of that which makes us live in Christ Jesus: hath made me free; that is, hath absolved me, and all the faithful, and pronounceth us free from the law of sin and of death; that is, from condemnation, with which the Law threateneth sinners; therefore, the Apostle opposeth here, the law of the Spirit, and the law of death; as he opposeth the ministry of the Spirit, and the Ministry of condemnation, 2 Cor. 3.8. as if he would say, Although that killing law endeavoureth to condemn those that are justified in Christ Jesus, because of the remainders of sin in them, with which as yet they wrestle: yet, the Law of the Spirit of life; that is, the living doctrine and grace of the Gospel, doth absolve them from damnation, notwithstanding these remainders of sin, seeing these also are pardoned them through Christ; for, The blood of Jesus Christ purgeth us from all sin, and from all remainders of sin. This (without prejudice to other mens judgements) seems to me, to be the genuine ⟨p. 797⟩meaning of the Apostle. But this by the way: I hasten to the other Arguments.
In that place to the Romans is the fallacy of Figura dictionis; 1for there, The Law of the Spirit of life, doth not signifie life, or Christs active obedience, much lesse his formall holinesse; but it signifieth, the doctrine, or quickning grace of the Gospell. The place is somewhat obscure; but, by the scope, the simple meaning may be knowne: that the remainders of the flesh condemne not godly men, if so be they make resistance against them, by the helpe of the Spirit. What the Apostle said in the first verse, he proves in the second, by supposing his owne person, from the effect of the Gospell: The Law, saith he, of the spirit of life; that is, the doctrine or grace of the Gospell, which is the ministery of the Spirit of life, or of that which makes us live in Christ Jesus: hath made me free; that is, hath absolved me, and all the faithfull, and pronounceth us free from the law of sin and of death; that is, from condemnation, with which the Law threatneth sinners; therefore, the Apostle opposeth here, the law of the Spirit, and the law of death; as he opposeth the ministery of the Spirit, and the Ministery of condemnation,
To the sixth we have already answered. Christ wholly quickeneth us: but one way, as he is the efficient; another way, as he is the matter of righteousness. And nevertheless he all justifieth, although his passion or death is only said to be imputed: for, he all suffered and dyed. Neither is his active obedience excluded from merit or justification, though it is not said to be imputed; which is that the seventh Reason would have. For, how can the efficient cause, or that which is called sine qua non, be excluded from its effect? Truly, both the obediences, as well the active, as the passive, were required in the Mediator, for our justification, but after a divers way: that, as the cause, sine qua non, or without which the effect cannot be produced, as also his natural holiness: this, as the matter.
To the sixth wee have already answered. Christ wholly quickneth us: but one way, as he is the efficient; another way, as he is the matter of righteousnesse. And neverthelesse he all justifieth, although his passion or death is onely said to be imputed: for, he all suffered and dyed. Neither is his active obedience excluded from merit or justification, though it is not said to be imputed; which is that the seventh Reason would have. For, how can the efficient cause, or that which is called sine qua non, be excluded from its effect? Truly, both the obediences, as well the active, as the passive, were required in the Mediatiour, for our justification, but after a divers way: that, as the cause, sine qua non, or without which the effect cannot be produced, as also his naturall holinesse: this, as the matter.
In the eighth Reason we deny the Antecedent: For, it was never heard, that the Law did oblige both to obedience and punishment, at the same time; but every law obligeth (dis-junctively, not copulatively) either to obedience, or to punishment: For, so long as obedience is performed, the Law obligeth no man to punishment; that is, it pronounceth no man guilty of punishment, but promiseth life: but when obedience is violated, then the Law obligeth the sinner to punishment. This is generally true, both of divine and humane laws.
In the eighth Reason we deny the Antecedent: For, it was never heard, that the Law did oblige both to obedience and punishment, at the same time; but every law obligeth (dis-junctively, not copulatively) either to obedience, or to punishment: For, so long as obedience is performed, the Law obligeth no man to punishment; that is, it pronounceth no man guilty of punishment, but promiseth life: but when obedience is violated, then the Law obligeth the sinner to punishment. This is generally true, both of divine and humane lawes.
Therefore their suppositions, which they here assume, are untrue, and repugnant to Gods justice: 1. That Adam, before his fall, at once was tied to obedience and punishment. 2. That man, after his fall (and so the Mediator for man) was obliged both to fulfil the Law, and to suffer punishment. When obedience, indeed, is violated, the sinner is bound to make satisfaction by punishment; this being performed, he is no more a sinner: and he is tied to obedience, not to that, for the violation of which he hath satisfied by punishment, but to another new obedience; or, if again he violate this, to a new punishment. Christ then, taking upon him our person, he is obliged to satisfy for us, by suffering punishment; this being paid, and imputed to us by faith, we are just: and are tied furthermore to new obedience, or to new punishment. This new obedience Christ also by regeneration repairs in us, but imperfectly; and this imperfection is hid by Christs satisfaction, that it may not condemn us: because the blood of Jesus Christ doth cleanse us from all sins, as well from those that follow, as from those that precede justification.
Therefore their suppositions, which they here assume, are untrue, and repugnant to Gods justice: 1. That Adam, before his fall, at once was tyed to obedience and punishment. 2. That man, after his fall (and so the Mediatour for man) was obliged both to fulfill the Law, and to suffer punishment. When obedience, indeed, is violated, the sinner is bound to make satisfaction by punishment; this being performed, he is no more a sinner: and he is tyed to obedience, not to that, for the violation of which he hath satisfied by punishment, but to another new obedience; or, if againe he violate this, to a new punishment. Christ then, taking upon him our person, he is obliged to satisfie for us, by suffering punishment; this being paid, and imputed to us by faith, we are just: and are tyed furthermore to new obedience, or to new punishment. This new obedience Christ also by regeneration repaires in us, but imperfectly; and this imperfection is hid by Christs satisfaction, that it may not condemne us: because the bloud of Jesus Christ doth cleanse us from all sins, as well from those that follow, as from those that precede justification.
The ninth Reason seems to be the quickest of all, but is indeed fraughted with contradictions, and overthrows it self; and besides, is repugnant to Scripture. First, there is a manifest contradiction, when it saith, That the Law promiseth life to those that fulfil the Law, and promiseth not life to those that transgress it not: The reason is, because, not to transgress the Law, and to fulfil the Law, are the same in effect. This is proved by the contrary: to transgress the Law, is to violate the Law; either by committing what the Law forbids, or by omitting what it commands: therefore not to transgress the Law, is not to violate the Law, by committing what it forbids, or by omitting what it commands; but this is truly to fulfil the Law: for, he that commits nothing against the Law, nor omits what should be done by the Law, doth truly fulfil the Law: therefore whosoever doth not transgress the Law, fulfils it. This is manifest in our first father Adam before his fall: for, so long as he sinned not, he fulfilled the Law, by a continual act in his original integrity. And do not the Angels in heaven fulfil the Law, even in that they sin not? And shall not we in life eternal fulfil the Law, when we shall not offend against it? Either then these are the same, or so knit together, that it's impossible either to separate them, or to devise a medium betwixt them. Secondly, this also is inconsistent which they say, That the Law doth not promise life to them that transgress it not; but it promiseth life to the fulfillers of the Law. Now, not to transgress, is to fulfil. Thirdly, this implieth a contradiction, when they say, That by passive obedience we are accounted not unjust, or not sinners; and yet are not accounted just: Also, That they who sin not, in Christ do escape death, but dare not sue for life: for the same thing here is both ⟨p. 798⟩affirmed and denied of terms equivalent: for surely, he that is not a sinner before God, is just; and, who is not dead, or who hath escaped death, is alive: For these are immediate contraries, as is said. Fourthly, this is plainly repugnant to Scripture, when it is said, that we are not accounted just by Christs passive obedience, that is not justified: For, on the contrary, it is said expressly, Being justified by his blood, being reconciled by his death, they have washed their robes in the blood of the Lamb.
The ninth Reason seems to be the quickest of all, but is indeed fraughted with contradictions, and overthrowes it selfe; and besides, is repugnant to Scripture. First, there is a manifest contradiction, when it saith, That the Law promiseth life to those that fulfill the Law, and promiseth not life to those that transgresse it not: The reason is, because, not to transgresse the Law, and to fulfill the Law, are the same in effect. This is proved by the contrarie: to transgresse the Law, is to violate the Law; either by committing what the Law forbids, or by omitting what it commands: therefore not to transgresse the Law, is not to violate the Law, by committing what it forbids, or by omitting what it commands; but this is truly to fulfill the Law: for, hee that commits nothing against the Law, nor omits what should be done by the Law, doth truly fulfill the Law: therefore whosoever doth not transgresse the Law, fulfils it. This is manifest in our first father Adam before his fall: for, so long as he sinned not, he fulfilled the Law, by a continuall act in his originall integritie. And doe not the Angels in heaven fulfill the Law, even in that they sin not? And shall not we in life eternall fulfill the Law, when we shall not offend against it? Either then these are the same, or so knit together, that it's impossible either to separate them, or to devise a medium betwixt them. Secondly, this also is inconsistent which they say, That the Law doth not promise life to them that transgresse it not; but it promiseth life to the fulfillers of the Law. Now, not to transgresse, is to fulfill. Thirdly, this implyeth a contradiction, when they say, That by passive obedience we are accounted not unjust, or not sinners; and yet are not accounted just: Also, That they who sin not, in Christ doe escape death, but dare not sue for life: for the same thing here is both
To the tenth Reason we answer out of that saying, The blood of Jesus Christ purgeth us from all sin. But surely, that impurity that sticks to the Saints, is sin: therefore from that also the blood of Christ purgeth us. Why then should trembling consciences be driven in their temptations from the blood of Christ, to seek out other remedies, against so manifest a Scripture?
To the tenth Reason wee answer out of that saying, The bloud of Jesus Christ purgeth us from all sin. But surely, that impuritie that sticks to the Saints, is sin: therefore from that also the bloud of Christ purgeth us. Why then should trembling consciences be driven in their temptations from the bloud of Christ, to seek out other remedies, against so manifest a Scripture?
Lastly, as for the Palatinate Catechism, that tells us in two places, that the satisfaction, justice, and sanctity of Christ is imputed to us. And once, that original sin is covered by the holy nativity and conception of the Mediator. But that these Authors never thought of a tripartite matter in imputative justice, or of derogating the expiation of original sin, and justification from the blood of Christ, is assuredly known by this, in that elsewhere so often and so plainly, they ascribe the merit of justice and life eternal, to the passion, death, and sacrifice of Christ, and that solely and only to it. And they witness, that our inherent sin is forgiven us for this merit. Either then the Catechism is repugnant to it self, which, God forbid; or it makes no tripartite division of justice imputative: nor doth it derogate from Christs passive obedience the merit of righteousness.
Lastly, as for the Palatinate Catechisme, that tells us in two places, that the satisfaction, justice, and sanctitie of Christ is imputed to us. And once, that originall sin is covered by the holy nativitie and conception of the Mediatour. But that these Authors never thought of a tripartite matter in imputative justice, or of derogating the expiation of originall sin, and justification from the bloud of Christ, is assuredly knowne by this, in that elsewhere so often and so plainly, they ascribe the merit of justice and life eternall, to the passion, death, and sacrifice of Christ, and that solely and onely to it. And they witnesse, that our inherent sin is forgiven us for this merit. Either then the Catechisme is repugnant to it selfe, which, God forbid; or it makes no tripartite division of justice imputative: nor doth it derogate from Christs passive obedience the merit of righteousnesse.
The fourth opinion remains, That our justice is the obedience even to death, or the punishment of the Son of God for our sins, that whole justification is the remission of sins, for this satisfaction imputed to us. Which opinion, as being truer, simpler, and safer, I confess, I do embrace; but so, as it may be understood and explained rightly, and according to the Scriptures meaning. I say, it is truer; because it is the constant voice of the whole Gospel, That we are justified by the death and blood of the Son of God, and that our justification consisteth in the sole remission of sin. The testimonies of the Gospel were rehearsed above.
The fourth opinion remaines, That our justice is the obedience even to death, or the punishment of the Son of God for our sins, that whole justification is the remission of sins, for this satisfaction imputed to us. Which opinion, as being truer, simpler, and safer, I confesse, I doe embrace; but so, as it may be understood and explained rightly, and according to the Scriptures meaning. I say, it is truer; because it is the constant voice of the whole Gospel, That wee are justified by the death and bloud of the Son of God, and that our justification consisteth in the sole remission of sin. The testimonies of the Gospel were rehearsed above.
Object. But there is a Synecdoche totius in the terms of blood death, &c. Answ. There is, indeed, but not such an one, as hath gathered into one merit two or three justices altogether heterogeneous; such as the natural sanctity, the active justice, and the passive obedience; for, there is no reason why the two former should be called by the name of death and blood: but it is the Synecdoche of the whole humiliation, as shall be said. I say also, it is simpler: for, it doth not distract our faith hither and thither, by any partition of merit; nor doth it disturb our comfort; but in our spiritual wrestlings with the Scriptures, it sends our consciences to the only death of Christ; to wit, by which alone Gods justice and commination is satisfied. Thou shalt dye the death: By this satisfaction, being applied to us by faith, we our selves have satisfied, are absolved, justified, reconciled to God, by the blood of his Son.
Object. But there is a Synecdoche totius in the termes of bloud death, &c. Answ. There is, indeed, but not such an one, as hath gathered into one merit two or three justices altogether heterogeneous; such as the naturall sanctitie, the active justice, and the passive obedience; for, there is no reason why the two former should be called by the name of death and bloud: but it is the Synecdoche of the whole humiliation, as shall be said. I say also, it is simpler: for, it doth not distract our faith hither and thither, by any partition of merit; nor doth it disturb our comfort; but in our spirituall wrestlings with the Scriptures, it sends our consciences to the only death of Christ; to wit, by which alone Gods justice and commination is satisfied. Thou shalt dye the death: By this satisfaction, being applyed to us by faith, we our selves have satisfied, are absolved, justified, reconciled to God, by the bloud of his Son.
But, you will say, To make us just, it is not enough to suffer for sin, but the fulfilling of the Law is also required. Answ. The punishment is the fulfilling of the Law; then 'tis sufficient: For, the Law is fulfilled two ways; either by yielding perfect obedience, or, when this is violated, by suffering condigne punishment: by both there is satisfaction made to Gods justice; each then is the fulfilling of the Law,1 and each is justice. Of the former it is said, He that doth righteousness, is righteous. Of the later, He that is dead, is justified from sin. The first fulfilling was in man, before his fall; and by that he was just: Neither was he tied to the other, so long as he sinned not; because Gods justice requires not both together, but either of them: seeing the Law, as is said, doth tie the reasonable creatures, not conjunctively to obedience and punishment together (for it were great iniquity, to oblige them to punishment, that obey the Law:) but dis-junctively, either to obedience, […] ⟨p. 801⟩of his humane justice with the Law, as the chief perfection of the person of the Mediator, without which, he could not be our High-Priest and Saviour: so the justice of his merit, or [Greek or Hebrew], is not only the blood and death, but comprehends also all the obedience of his humiliation, from the minute of his conception, even till the death of the Cross. For the whole life of Christ, being full of miseries and sorrows, what else was it, then a perpetual suffering and punishment for our sins? For, by the order of divine justice, whereas Christ was most just, his life should not have been miserable and calamitous; but altogether sorrowless, fortunate, and happy: but in that it was miserable, it was by reason he suffered and satisfied for our sins.
But, you will say, To make us just, it is not enough to suffer for sin, but the fulfilling of the Law is also required. Answ. The punishment is the fulfilling of the Law; then 'tis sufficient: For, the Law is fulfilled two waies; either by yeelding perfect obedience, or, when this is violated, by suffering condigne punishment: by both there is •atisfaction made to Gods justice; each then is the fulfilling of the Law,1 and each is justice. Of the former it is said, He that doth righteousnesse, is righteous. Of the later, He that is dead, is justified from sin. The first fulfilling was in man, before his fall; and by that he was just: Neither was he tyed to the other, so long as he sinned not; because Gods justice requires not both together, but either of them: seeing the Law, as is said, doth tye the reasonable creatures, not conjunctively to obedience and punishment together (for it were great iniquitie, to oblige them to punishment, that obey the Law:) but dis-junctively, either to obedience,
4. Therefore, when the Scripture points out to us justice in the blood, cross, and death of Christ; he doth not speak exclusively, as if the sufferings that went before his death did nothing belong to his merit; but synecdochically, comprehending under the complete finishing of our redemption, all the antecedent degrees also; that is, the beginning, increase, and consummation. The beginning was in his Incarnation; when, having assumed the form of a servant, he became poor, &c. for us. The increase was throughout all his life, which he led in perpetual miseries, tentations, and dangers, being subject to Gods wrath for us. Lastly, the consummation was in his cross and death; when, giving up the ghost, he cried out, It is finished. All these the Prophet conjoins in the price of our redemption, which Christ paid for us: He did truly bear our infirmities,1 and took upon him our sorrows; he was wounded for our transgressions, and bruised for our iniquities: and with his stripes we are healed. So the Apostle, 2 Corinth. 5. When he was rich, be became poor for us; that we, by his poverty, might be rich. So Herb. 2. He was made somewhat inferior to the Angels, by suffering of death. But chiefly, Phil. 2. Being in the form of God, he emptied himself, taking the form of a servant; and he humbled himself, being made obedient even to the death of the Cross. Nor will their cavil avail, in saying, that the Apostle speaks not here of the matter of our justice: it is enough, that he here extends Christs obedience, which elsewhere he showed was our justice, to his whole humiliation. Neither is that place, Hebr. 9.22. against us, Without shedding of blood there is no remission: It only follows from hence, that the shedding […] blood is not excluded from the cause of remission; but that it is the cause sine qua non of this. But it will not follow, that it is the only cause; or, that death which followed, or the antecedent sufferings are excluded: Therefore to Christs death belongeth the whole obedience of his humiliation, even to the death of the Cross.
4. Therefore, when the Scripture points out to us justice in the bloud, crosse, and death of Christ; he doth not speak exclusively, as if the sufferings that went before his death did nothing belong to his merit; but synecdochically, comprehending under the complete finishing of our redemption, all the antecedent degrees also; that is, the beginning, encrease, and consummation. The beginning was in his Incarnation; when, having assumed the forme of a servant, hee became poore, &c. for us. The encrease was throughout all his life, which he led in perpetuall miseries, tentations, and dangers, being subject to Gods wrath for us. Lastly, the consummation was in his crosse and death; when, giving up the ghost, he cried out, It is finished. All these the Prophet conjoynes in the price of our redemption, which Christ paid for us: He did truly beare our infirmities,
5. But why the Scripture ascribes merit, which Christ hath purchased for us in all the course of his obedience, to his death; as if it were peculiar only, and proper to that; the reason is, because the sufficiency of merit consisteth in the death of Christ alone: for, had he not dyed, the obedience of his humiliation had not been absolute; neither had the wrath of God, in threatening death to Adam, been satisfied: Therefore all the rest of Christs obedience, without dying, had been an insufficient merit, and unprofitable to us. But they, who attribute the merit of justice to his active obedience, or natural holiness, they make void (doubtless) the death of Christ.
5. But why the Scripture ascribes merit, which Christ hath purchased for us in all the course of his obedience, to his death; as if it were peculiar onely, and proper to that; the reason is, because the sufficiencie of merit consisteth in the death of Christ alone: for, had hee not dyed, the obedience of his humiliation had not been absolute; neither had the wrath of God, in threatning death to Adam, been satisfied: Therefore all the rest of Christs obedience, without dying, had been an insufficient merit, and unprofitable to us. But they, who attribute the merit of justice to his active obedience, or naturall holinesse, they make void (doubtlesse) the death of Christ.
1
Lib. 3. d. 19.
1. As by the disobedience of one man, many were made sinners; so by the obedience of one, many are made righteous, Rom. 5. But Adams disobedience was active; therefore we are justified by Christs active obedience. 2. He was made obedient, even to the death of the Crosse, Phil. 2. Here is a two-fold obedience of Christ, the one before death, the other in death; therefore both are imputed. 3. God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, and made under the Law, that he might redeeme those that were under the Law, Gal. 4. Therefore, the active fulfilling of the Law by Christ is imputed to us. 4. He was made of God to us, wisdome, righteousnesse, sanctification, &c. 1 Cor. 1. Therefore his justice and sanctity are imputed to us. 5. The Law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus, freed me from the law of sin, and of death, Rom. 8.2. Therefore, the life of Christ, or his active obedience, is imputed to us. 6. Whole Christ is our justice, with which he justifieth us; therefore, whole Christ is imputed. 7. Active justice cannot be excluded from Christs merit, and from justification, ergo, it is imputed. 8. The Law obligeth both to obedience, and to punishment; therefore, it behooved Christ both to fulfill the obedience of the Law for us, and also to suffer punishment. 9. To whom the Law doth promise life, such must we be by the grace of Christ, that we may obtaine life: the Law promiseth life, not to them who transgresse not the Law, but to them who fulfill it all: but by the imputation of his passive obedience, we are accounted indeed not unjust, not sinners, or, not transgressors of the Law; but we are not as yet accounted just, or fulfillers of the Law; for, what is more vaine, then to call him just, who hath not fulfilled the Law? Therefore, not onely must his passive obedience be imputed to us for this, that we may not be unjust, or not transgressours of the Law; but also his active, for this, that we may be just, or fulfillers of the Law: for, he that in Christ is accounted for no sinner, shall escape death; but by what right ⟨p. 794⟩shall he also sue for life, unlesse he fulfill the whole righteousnesse of the Law in the same Christ? 10. The sacrifice and death of Christ comfort us against the guilt, and death eternall: but his holinesse against our inherent impurity, or the remainders of sin; therefore, the imputation of both is necessary for our consolation, 11.
I have faithfully set downe the arguments, by which the former sort maintaine their opinions: the fourth sort remaine, who make Christs passive obedience onely our righteousnesse, and define justification by remission of sins onely; these make use chiefly of two arguments taken our of Scripture, the one from the matter, the other from the forme of justification: The first is this; The Scripture sheweth the whole matter of our righteousnesse to consist in the passion, Crosse, bloud, and death of Christ; therefore, this onely is it for which we are justified. They prove the Antecedent by testimonies of Scripture:a We are justified freely by redemption made in Christ Jesus, whom God hath set as a propitiation by faith in his bloud. bWe are justified by his bloud, being reconciled by the death of his Son. cHim who knew no sin, be hath made sin, (that is, a sacrifice for sin), that we might become the righteousnesse of God in him. dHe being made a curse for us upon the tree, hath redeemed us from the curse of the Law. eWe have redemption by his bloud. fHaving made peace by the bloud of his Crosse, by him he hath reconciled all things to himselfe; hath reconciled them in the body of his flesh by death. gWe are redeemed by the precious bloud of the immaculate Lamb. hBy whose stripes we are healed iThe bloud of Christ purgeth us from all our sins. kThou hast redeemed us by thy bloud. They have washed their robes, and made them white in the bloud of the Lambe.
Be it knowne to you, that to you is preached remission of sins, through him; and from all things, from which by the Law you could not be absolved, by him all that beleeve are justified. Here, to be absolved, to be justified, to have remission of sins, are the same things. David pronounceth that man blessed, to whom God imputeth righteousnesse without works:
In whom we have redemption by his bloud; that is, remission of sins, &c. They have also other arguments, which, for brevities sake, I omit; they alledge also for themselves the Catechisme of the Palatinate, qq. 37.45.66.55.57.72.76.80.84. &c. In which it is taught, that we obtaine remission of sins, justice, and life eternall, for the alone sacrifice of Christ on the Crosse; and that onely the bloud of Christ purgeth us from all sin: which very thing, is every-where found in the Directory of the Palatinate. Hitherto the different opinions concerning justice.
Neither doth that place, Gal. 4. availe any whit to the active obedience; for, how Christ for us was made subject to the Law, the Apostle himselfe explaines cleerely, chap. 3. He redeemed us from the curse of the Law, being made a curse for us; that the blessing of Abraham may be extended upon the Gentiles in Christ Jesus. But this is understood of Christs voluntary humiliation, even to the death appointed by the Law for our sins. How, notwithstanding, this place may be understood of the servitude to the whole Law, I will speake hereafter.
. as if he would say, Although that killing law endeavoureth to condemne those that are justified in Christ Jesus, because of the remainders of sin in them, with which as yet they wrestle: yet, the Law of the Spirit of life; that is, the living doctrine and grace of the Gospell, doth absolve them from damnation, notwithstanding these remainders of sin, seeing these also are pardoned them through Christ; for, The bloud of Jesus Christ purgeth us from all sin, and from all remainders of sin. This (without prejudice to other mens judgements) seems to me, to be the genuine
⟨p. 797⟩
meaning of the Apostle. But this by the way: I hasten to the other Arguments.
affirmed and denied of termes equivalent: for surely, he that is not a sinner before God, is just; and, who is not dead, or who hath escaped death, is alive: For these are immediate contraries, as is said. Fourthly, this is plainly repugnant to Scripture, when it is said, that we are not accounted just by Christs passive obedience, that is not justified: For, on the contrarie, it is said expresly, Being justified by his bloud, being reconciled by his death, they have washed their robes in the bloud of the Lamb.
〈…〉
⟨p. 801⟩
of his humane justice with the Law, as the chiefe perfection of the person of the Mediatour, without which, he could not be our High-Priest and Saviour: so the justice of his merit, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, is not onely the bloud and death, but comprehends also all the obedience of his humiliation, from the minute of his conception, even till the death of the Crosse. For the whole life of Christ, being full of miseries and sorrowes, what else was it, then a perpetuall suffering and punishment for our sins? For, by the order of divine justice, whereas Christ was most just, his life should not have been miserable and calamitous; but altogether sorrowlesse, fortunate, and happy: but in that it was miserable, it was by reason hee suffered and satisfied for our sins.
and took upon him our sorrowes; he was wounded for our transgressions, and bruised for our iniquities: and with his stripes we are healed. So the Apostle, 2 Corinth. 5. When he was rich, be became poore for us; that we, by his poverty, might be rich. So Herb. 2. He was made somewhat inferiour to the Angels, by suffering of death. But chiefly, Phil. 2. Being in the forme of God, he emptied himselfe, taking the forme of a servant; and he humbled himselfe, being made obedient even to the death of the Crosse. Nor will their cavill availe, in saying, that the Apostle speaks not here of the matter of our justice: it is enough, that he here extends Christs obedience, which elsewhere he shewed was our justice, to his whole humiliation. Neither is that place, Hebr. 9.22. against us, Without shedding of bloud there is no remission: It onely followes from hence, that the shedding 〈…〉 bloud is not excluded from the cause of remission; but that it is the cause sine qua non of this. But it will not follow, that it is the onely cause; or, that death which followed, or the antecedent sufferings are excluded: Therefore to Christs death belongeth the whole obedience of his humiliation, even to the death of the Crosse.