pp. 1426–142862 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Master Thomas of Bridges said at his brother master Lieutenants board: I pray you M. Doctors,1 for my learning tell me what an heretic is. M. Secretary Bourne said, I will tell you who is an heretic: who so stubbornly & stiffly maintaineth an untruth, he is an heretic.2 Ye mean sir (said I) an untruth in matters of religion, & concerning our faith. Yea that is true said he: & in this we are soon agreed. Then said master Fecknam, sitting at the upper end of the table, whom they called M. Dean of Pauls: I will tell you by S. Augustine who is an heretic. Qui adulandi principibus vel lucri gratia falsas opiniones gignit vel sequitur, hereticus est, sayth S. Augustine.3 And then he englished the same. Sir said I, I ween S. Augustine addeth the third member, which is, vel vanae gloriae causa. Ye say even true M. Doctor, said he, and thus far we did agree all three.
MAister Thomas of Bridges sayd at his brother mayster Lieuetenantes boorde: I pray you M. Doctours,1 for my learning tell me what an heretick is. M. Secretary Bourne sayd, I will tell you who is an hereticke: who so stubbernly & stifly maynteineth an vntruth, he is an hereticke.2 Ye meane syr (sayd I) an vntrueth in matters of religion, & concerning our fayth. Yea that is true sayd he: & in this we are soone agreed. Then sayd maister Fecknam, sitting at the vpper end of the table, whom they called M. Deane of Paules: I wil tell you by S. Austine who is an hereticke. Qui adulandi principibus vel lucri gratia falsas opiniones gignit vel sequitur, hereticus est, sayth S. Austine.3 And then he englished the same. Sir sayd I, I wene S. Austine addeth the thyrd member, which is, vel vanae gloriae causa. Ye say euen true M. Doctor, sayd he, and thus farre we did agree all three.
M. Fecknam began again to say, who so doth not believe that scripture affirmeth,1 but will obstinately maintain the contrary, he is Haereticus, as in the sacrament of the altar: Matthew doth affirm there to be Christs body. Mark doth affirm it, Luke affirmeth it, Paul affirmeth it, and none denieth it: therefore to hold the contrary it is heresy. It is the same body and flesh that was borne of the virgin: & this is confirmed by unity, antiquity & universality. For none before Berengarius did ever doubt of this,2 & he was an heretic, as M. doctor there knoweth full well: I do testify his own conscience said he.
M. Fecknam began againe to say, who so doth not beleue that scripture affirmeth,1 but will obstinately maintein the contrary, he is Haereticus, as in the sacramēt of the aultar: Mathew doth affirm there to be Christs body. Marke doth affirme it, Luke affirmeth it, Paule affirmeth it, and none denyeth it: therfore to hold the cōtrary it is heresy. It is the same body and flesh that was borne of the virgine: & this is confirmed by vnity, antiquity & vniuersalitye. For none before Berengarius did euer doubt of this,2 & he was an heretick, as M. doctor there knoweth full well: I do testify his owne conscience sayd he.
Mary sir, said master Secretary, master Fecknam hath spoken well. These be great matters, unity antiquity and universality. Do ye not think so master Doctor said he to me?
Mary sir, saide mayster Secretary, maister Fecknam hath spoken well. These be great matters, vnitie antiquitie and vniuersalitie. Do ye not thinke so maister Doctour said he to me?
Here while I strained courtesy and pretended as nothing to talk, said one of the Commissioners: peradventure M. Ridley doth agree with M. Fecknam, and then there needs not much debating of the matter.
Here while I strayned curtesye and pretended as nothinge to talke, sayd one of the Commissioners: peraduenture M. Ridley doth agree with M. Fecknam, and then there needes not much debating of the matter.
Sir said I in some things I do and shall agree with him, and in some things which he hath spoken to be plain. I do not agree with him at all. Master said I, ye be (as I understand) the Queens Commissioners here and if ye have commission to examine me in these matters, I shall declare unto you plainly my faith, if ye have not, then I shall pray you either give me leave to speak my mind freely, or else to hold my peace.
Syr saide I in some thinges I doe and shall agree with him, and in some things which he hath spoken to be playne. I doe not agree with him at all. Maister sayde I, ye be (as I vnderstād) the Queenes Commissioners here and if ye haue commissiō to examine me in these matters, I shall declare vnto you playnely my faythe, if yee haue not, then I shall pray you either geue mee leaue to speake my minde freely, or els to hold my peace.
There is none here, said M. Secretary, that doth not favour you: and then every man showed what favour they ⟨p. 1427⟩bare towards me, and how glad they would be of an agreement.
There is none here, sayde M. Secretary, that doth not fauour you: and thē euery man shewed what fauour they ⟨p. 1427⟩bare towardes me, and howe glad they woulde be of an agreement.
But as I strained to have licence of them in plain words to speak my mind,1 so me thought they granted me it but vix or agrè. Well at the last I was content to take it for licensed, and so began to talk.
But as I strayned to haue licence of thē in playn wordes to speak my minde,1 so me thought they graunted me it but vix or agrè. Well at the last I was content to take it for licenced, and so began to talke.
To M. Fecknam's arguments of the manifold affirmation where no denial was,1 I answered: where is a multitude of affirmations in scripture, and where is one affirmation, all is one concerning the trueth of the matter: for that any one of the Evangelists spake inspired by the holy ghost,2 was as true as that which is spoken of them all. It is as true that John saith of Christ: Ego sum ostium ovium. i. I am the door of the sheep, as if all had said it. For it is not in scripture as in witness of men where the number is credited more then one, because it is uncertain of whose spirit he doth speak. And where M. Fecknam spake of so many, affirming without any negation. &c. Sir said I, all they do affirm the thing which they meant. Now if ye take their words to leave their meaning then do they affirm what ye take,3 but not what they meant. Sir said I, if in talk with you, I should so utter my mind in words, that ye by the same do, and may plainly perceive my meaning & could (if ye would be captious) cavil at my words & writhe them to an other sense, I would think ye were no gentle companion to talk with, except ye would take my words as ye did perceive that I did mean.
To M. Fecknams argumentes of the manifold affirmatiō where no denial was,1 I answered: where is a multitude of affirmations in scripture, and where is one affirmation, all is one concerning the trueth of the matter: for that any one of the Euangelists spake inspired by the holy ghost,2 was as true as that which is spoken of them all. It is as true that Iohn sayth of Christ: Ego sum ostium ouium. i. I am the dore of the sheepe, as if all had sayde it. For it is not in scripture as in witnes of men where the number is credited more then one, because it is vncertayne of whose spirit he doth speake. And where M. Fecknam spake of so many, affirming without any negation. &c. Syr sayd I, all they do affirme the thing which they ment. Now if ye take theyr wordes to leaue theyr meaning then do they affirme what ye take,3
Mary, quoth M. Secretary, we should else do you plain injury and wrong.
Mary, quoth M. Secretary, we should els do you plain iniury and wrong.
M. Fecknam perceiving whereunto my talk went, why (quoth he) what circumstances can ye show me that should move to think of any other sense, then as the words playnely say: Hoc est corpus meum, quod pro vobis tradetur. i. This is my body which shall be betrayed for you?
M. Fecknam perceiuing whereunto my talke went, why (quoth he) what circumstaunces can ye shew me that should moue to thinke of any other sense, then as the wordes playnely say: Hoc est corpus meum, quod pro vobis tradetur. i. This is my body which shall be betrayed for you?
Sir said I, even the next sentence that followeth: vix. Hoc facite in meam commemorationem. i. Do this in my remembrance. 1And also by what reason, ye say the bread is turned into Christs carnal body: By the same I may say, that is turned into his mystical body. For as that saith of it: Hoc est corpus quod pro vobis tradetur: 2so Paul which spake by Christs spirit saith: Unus panis & unum corpus multi sumus omnes, qui de uno pane participamus. i. We being many are all but one bread and one body, in as much as we are partakers of one bread.
Syr sayd I, euen the next sentence that foloweth: vix. Hoc facite in meam commemorationem. i. Do this in my remembraunce. 1And also by what reason, ye say the bread is turned into Christes carnall body: By the same I may say, that is turned into his misticall body. For as that sayth of it: Hoc est corpus quod pro vobis tradetur: 2so Paule which spake by Christes spirit sayth: Vnus panis & vnum corpus multi sumus omnes, qui de vno pane participamus. i. We being many are all but one bread and one body, in as much as we are partakers of one bread.
Here he calleth one bread, one loaf, said Master Secretary.
Here he calleth one bread, one loafe, sayd Mayster Seretary.
Yea said I, one loaf, one bread, all is one with me.
Yea sayd I, one loafe, one bread, all is one with me.
But what say ye quoth master Secretary, of the Universality, antiquity, and unity, that M. Fecknam did speak of?
But what saye ye quoth maister Secretary, of the Uniuersalitye, antiquitye, and vnity, that M. Fecknam dyd speake of?
I ensure you said I, I think them matters weighty and to be considered well.1 As for unity, the truth is, before God, I do believe it and embrace it, so it be with verity, & joined to our head Christ, and such one as Paul, speaketh of saying: Una fides, unus Deus, unum Baptisma. i. On faith, one God,2 one Baptism. And for antiquity I am also persuaded to be true that Iraeneus sayth: Quod primum verum. i. That is first is true. In our Religion Christs faith was first truly taught by Christ himself, by his Apostles and by many good men that from the beginning did succeed next unto them: and for this controversy of the Sacrament I am persuaded, that those old writers which wrote before the controversy and the usurping of the sea of Rome do all agree, if they be well understanded in this truth.
I ensure you sayd I, I thinke them matters weighty and to be considered well.1 As for vnity, the truth is, before God, I doe beleue it and embrace it, so it be with verity, & ioyned to our head Christ, and such one as Paule, speaketh of saying: Vna fides, vnus Deus, vnum Baptisma. i. On fayth, one God,2 one Baptisme. And for antiquity I am also persuaded to be true that Iraeneus sayth: Quod primum verum. i. That is first is true. In our Religion Christes fayth was first truely taught by Christ himselfe, by his Apostles and by manye good men that from the beginning did succeede next vnto them: and for this controuersy of the Sacramēt I am perswaded, that those olde writers which wrote before the controuersye and the vsurping of the sea of Rome do all agree, if they be well vnderstanded in this truth.
I am glad to hear, said Master Secretary, that ye do so well esteem the Doctors of the church.
I am glad to heare, sayd Maister Secretary, that ye do so well esteme the Doctors of the church.
1Now as for universality, it may have 2. meanings: one to understand that to be universal which from the beginning in all ages hath been allowed, another, to understand universality for the multitude of our age or of any other singular age.
1Now as for vniuersality, it may haue 2. meanings: one to vnderstand that to be vniuersall which from the beginning in all ages hath bene alowed, another, to vnderstand vniuersalitye for the multitude of our age or of anye other singuler age.
No, no, saith master Secretary, these 3. do always agree, and where there is one, there is all the rest, and here he and I changed many words. And finally, to be short in this matter we did not agree.
No, no, sayth maister Secretary, these 3. doe alwayes agree, and where there is one, there is all the rest, and here he and I chaunged many wordes. And finally, to be shorte in this matter we did not agree.
There was none quoth master Fecknam, before Berengarius, Wycliffe, and Hus, and now in our days Carolostadius, Oecolampadius. And Carolostadius saith, Christ pointeth to his own body and not to the Sacrament, and sayd: Hoc est Corpus meum. And Melancton writeth to one Micronius (Miconius said I) these or like words:1 Nullam satis gravem rationem inuenire possum, propter quam a fide maiorum in hac materia dissentiam. i. I can find no grounded reason to cause me to dissent from the belief of our foreelders.
There was none quoth mayster Fecknam, before Berengarius, Wickliffe, and Hus, and now in our dayes Carolostadius, Oecolampadius. And Carolostadius sayth, Christ poynteth to his owne body and not to the Sacrament, and sayd: Hoc est Corpus meum. And Melancton writeth to one Micronius (Miconius sayde I) these or like wordes:1 Nullam satis grauem rationem inuenire possum, propter quam a fide maiorum in hac materia dissentiam. i. I can finde no grounded reason to cause me to dissent from the beliefe of our foreelders.
1Thus when he had spoken at length, with many other words moe: Sir said I, it is certain that other before these have written of this matter. Not by the way only, and obiter, as doth for the most all the old writers, but even ex professo, and their whole books entreat of it alone, as Bertram.
1Thus when hee had spoken at length, with manye other wordes mo: Sir sayd I, it is certain that other before these haue written of this matter. Not by the way onelye, and obiter, as doth for the most all the olde writers, but euen ex professo, and theyr whole bookes intreat of it alone, as Bertram.
Bertram said the Secretary, what man was he? & whom was he, and how do ye know? &c. with many questions.
Bertram said the Secretary, what man was he? & whō was he, and how do ye know? &c. with many questions.
Sir quoth I, I have read his book: He proponeth the same which is now in controversy, and answereth so directly that no man may doubt but that he affirmeth, that the substance of bread remaineth still in the Sacrament, and he wrote unto Carolus Magnus.
Syr quoth I, I haue read his booke: He proponeth the same which is now in controuersy, and aunswereth so dyrectly that no man may doubt but that he affirmeth, that ye substance of bread remaineth still in the Sacrament, and he wrote vnto Carolus Magnus.
Mary (quoth he) mark for there is a matter. He wrote quoth he, ad Henricum, and not ad Carolum, for no Author maketh any such mention of Bertramus.
Mary (quoth he) marke for there is a matter. He wrote quoth he, ad Henricum, and not ad Carolum, for no Authour maketh any such mention of Bertramus.
Yes quoth I, Trithemius in Catalogo illustrium scriptorū, speaketh of him. Trithemius was but o• late time: but he speaketh quoth I of them that were of antiquity. Here, after much talk of Bertram, what authors have ye quoth M. Secretary to make of the sacrament a figure?
Yes quoth I, Trithemius in Catalogo illustrium scriptorū, speaketh of him. Trithemius was but o• late time: but he speketh quoth I of them that were of antiquitye. Here, after much talke of Bertram, what authors haue ye quoth M. Secretary to make of the sacrament a figure?
Sir quoth I, ye know (I think) that Tertullian in plain words speaketh thus: Hoc est corpus, id est, 1figu•• Corporis mei. i. This is my body, that is to say, a figure o• my body. And Gelasius saith plainly that Substantia panis manet. i. The substance of bread remaineth. And Origene sayth likewise, Quod sanctificatur secundum materiam, ingreditur stomachum & vadit in secessum. i. 2That which is sanctified, as touching the matter or substance, passeth away into the draught. This when I had englished, M. Secretary said to me, you know very well as any man. &c. and here, if I would, I might have been set in a foolish Paradise of his commendation of my learning, and quòd essem vir multae Lectionis. i. A man of much reading. But this I would not take at his hand. He set me not up so high, but I brought my self as low again: and here was much ado.
Syr quoth I, ye knowe (I thinke) that Tertullian in playne wordes speaketh thus: Hoc est corpus, id est, 1figu•• Corporis mei. i. This is my bodye, that is to say, a figure o• my body. And Gelasius sayth playnly that Substantia panis manet. i. The substaunce of bread remayneth. And Origene sayth likewise, Quod sanctificatur secundum materiam, ingreditur stomachum & vadit in secessum. i. 2That which is sanctified, as touching the matter or substance, passeth away into the draught. This when I had englished, M. Secretarye sayd to me, you know very well as any man. &c. and here, if I woulde, I might haue bene set in a foolishe Paradise of his commendation of my learning, and quòd essem vir multae Lectionis. i. A manne of much readyng. But thys I woulde not take at his hand. He set me not vp so high, but I brought my selfe as low againe: and here was much adoe.
As for Melancton (quoth I) whom M. Fecknam spake of, I marvel that ye will allege him, for we are more nigh an agreement here in England, then the opinion of Melancton to you: for in this point we all agree here, that there is in the sacrament but one material substance: & Melanchthon as I ween, saith there are two.
As for Melancton (quoth I) whō M. Fecknam spake of, I maruell that ye will alledge him, for we are more nye an agrement here in England, then the opinion of Melācton to you: for in this poynt we all agree here, that there is in the sacrament but one materiall substance: & Melanctō as I weene, sayth there are two.
Ye say trueth quoth M. Secretary: Melanchthon's opinion is so. But I pray you, ye have read that the sacrament was in old time so reverenced, that many were then forbidden to be present at the ministration thereof. Catecumeni (quoth he) and many moe.
Ye say trueth quoth M. Secretary: Melancthons opinion is so. But I pray you, ye haue read that the sacramēt was in olde time so reuerenced, that many were then forbidden to be present at the ministration thereof. Catecumeni (quoth he) and many moe.
Truth sir (quoth I) there were called some Audientes, some Penitents, some Catechumeni, and some Evergumeni, 1which were commanded to depart.
Truth sir (quoth I) there were called some Audientes, some Poenitentes, some Catechumeni, and some Euergumeni, 1which were commaunded to depart.
Now (quoth he) then. And how can ye then make but a figure or a sign of the Sacrament, as that book which is set forth in my Lord of Canterburies name, I wise, […] can tell who made it, did not ye make it?1 & here was much murmuring of the rest, as though they would have given me the glory of the writing of the book, which yet there was said of some there, to contain most heinous heresy that ever was.
Now (quoth he) then. And howe can ye then make but a figure or a signe of the Sacrament, as that booke whyche is set forth in my Lord of Canterburyes name, I wisse, 〈…〉 can tell who made it, did not ye make it?1 & here was much murmuring of the rest, as though they would haue geuen me the glorye of the writing of the booke, whiche yet there was sayd of some there, to conteyne most haynous heresy that euer was.
Master Secretary (quoth I) that book was made of a great learned man, and him which is able to do the like again: as for me I ensure you (be not deceived in me) I was never able to do or write any such like thing, he passeth me no less, then the learned master his young scholar.
Mayster Secretary (quoth I) that booke was made of a great learned man, and him which is able to do the like again: as for me I ensure you (be not deceiued in me) I was neuer able to do or write any such like thing, he passeth me no lesse, then the learned mayster his yong scholer.
Now, here every man would have his saying, which I pass over, not much material for to tell. But sir quoth I, me thinks it is not charitably done, to bear the people in hand that any man doth so lightly esteem the sacrament, as to make of it a figure. For that [but] maketh it a bare figure without any more profit, which that book doth often deny, as appeareth to the reader most plainly.
Now, here euery man would haue his saying, which I passe ouer, not much materiall for to tell. But sir quoth I, me thinkes it is not charitably done, to beare the people in hand that any man doth so lightly esteme the sacrament, as to make of it a figure. For that [but] maketh it a bare figure without any more profit, which that book doth often deny, as appeareth to the reader most playnely.
Yes quoth he that they do.
Sir, no quoth I, of a truth: and as for me, I ensure you I make no less of the sacrament then thus: I say whosoever receiveth the sacrament, he receiveth therewith either life or death.
Sir, no quoth I, of a truth: and as for me, I ensure you I make no lesse of the sacrament then thus: I say whosoeuer receiueth the sacrament, he receiueth therewith eyther life or death.
No quoth M. Secretary, scripture saith not so.
No quoth M. Secretary, scripture sayth not so.
Sir quoth I, although not in the same sound of words, yet it doth in the same sense, and S. Augustine saith, in the sound of words also: for Paul saith: The bread which we break, is it not the partaking or fellowship of the body of Christ? And S. Augustine, Manduca vitam, Bibe vitam, i. eat life, drink life.
Sir quoth I, although not in the same soūd of words, yet it doth in the same sense, and S. Augustine sayth, in the sound of words also: for Paule sayth: The bread which we breake, is it not the partaking or felowship of the bodye of Christ? And S. Augustine, Manduca vitam, Bibe vitam, i. eate life, drinke life.
Then said master Pope, what can ye make of it when ye say, there is not the real body of Christ? Which I do believe. &c. & I pray God I may never believe other. How can it bring (as ye say) either life or death,1 when Christs body is not there?
Then sayd mayster Pope, what can ye make of it whē ye say, there is not the reall body of Christ? Whiche I doe beleue. &c. & I pray God I may neuer beleue other. How can it bring (as ye say) either life or death,1 when Christes body is not there?
Sir quoth I, when you hear Gods word truly preached, if ye do believe it and abide in it, ye shall and do receive life withal: and if ye do not believe it, it doth bring unto you ⟨p. 1428⟩death: and yet Christs body is still in heaven and not carnal in every preachers mouth.
Syr quoth I, when you heare Gods word truely preached, if ye do beleue it and abide in it, ye shal and do receiue life withal: and if ye do not beleue it, it doth bring vnto you ⟨p. 1428⟩death: and yet Christes body is still in heauen and not carnall in euery preachers mouth.
I pray you tell me quoth he, how can you answer to this:1 Quod pro vobis tradetur, which shall be given for you: was the figure of Christs body given for us?
I pray you tell me quoth he, how can you aunswere to this:1 Quod pro vobis tradetur, which shall be geuen for you: was the figure of Christes body geuen for vs?
No sir quoth I, but the very body it self, whereof the sacrament is a sacramental figure.
No sir quoth I, but the very body it selfe, wherof the sacrament is a sacramentall figure.