pp. 1459–1463117 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Harps. I deny your argument, though some would not have had him say so.
Harps. I denye your argument, though some would not haue had hym say so.
Cran. The argument is good. It standeth upon contradictories, which is the most surest hold.
Cran. The argument is good. It standeth vpon contradictories, which is the most surest hold.
Harps. I deny that there are contradictions.
Cran. I thus prove it. Haber modum quantitativum & non habere, sunt contradictoria. Sed Christus in coelis, ut dicitis, habet modum quantitativū, in terra non habet: Ergo, duo sunt corpora eius in quae cadunt haec contradictoria: Nam in idem cadere non possunt.
Cran. I thus prooue it. Habere modum quantitatiuum & non habere, sunt contradictoria. Sed Christus in coelis, vt dicitis, habet modum quantitatiuū, in terra non habet: Ergo, duo sunt corpora eius in quae cadunt haec contradictoria: Nam in idem cadere non possunt.
West. 1I deny the Minor.
Harps. I answer, that the Major is not true. For Habere quantum, & non habere, non sunt contradictoria nisi sic considerantur eiusdem ad idem, eodem modo & simpliciter.
Harps. I aunswer, that the Maior is not true. For Habere quantum, & non habere, non sunt contradictoria nisi sic considerantur eiusdem ad idem, eodem modo & simpliciter.
West. I confirm the same: for one body may have modum quantitativum, and not have:1 and idem corpus was passible and impassible, one body may have wounds, and not wounds.
West. I confirme the same: for one body may haue modum quantitatiuum, and not haue:1 and idem corpus was passible and impassible, one body may haue woundes, and not woundes.
Cran. This cannot be at one time.
Cran. This cannot be at one tyme.
Weston. The ensample of the Potter doth prove that I say: who of that that is clay now, maketh a pot or cup forthwith.
Weston. The ensample of the Potter doth prooue that I say: who of that that is clay now, maketh a pot or cuppe forthwith.
Cran. But I say again, that it is so but at divers times: as one piece of meat to be raw and sodden, cannot be at one time together. But you would have it otherwise, that Christ should be here and in heaven at one time, & should have modum quantitativum, and not have: which cannot be but by such argument as I have showed you.
Cran. But I say againe, that it is so but at diuers tymes: as one piece of meat to be rawe and sodden, cannot be at one time together. But you would haue it otherwise, that Christ should be here and in heauen at one time, & should haue modum quantitatiuum, and not haue: which cannot be but by such argument as I haue shewed you.
West. But I say, Christs body was passible and not passible at one *instant.
West. But I say, Christes body was passible and not passible at one *instant.
Seat. You may ask as well other questions, how he is in heaven? whether he sit or stand, and whether he be there as he lived here.
Seat. You may aske as well other questions, how he is in heauen? whether he sit or stand, and whether he bee there as he liued here.
Cran. You your self by putting a natural presence, do force me to question how he is here. Therefore, next I do ask this question: Whether good and evil men do eat the body in the sacrament?
Cran. You your selfe by putting a naturall presence, doe force me to question how he is here. Therfore, next I doe aske this question: Whether good and euill men do eat the body in the sacrament?
Harps. Yea, they do so, even as the sun doth shine upon kings palaces, and on dung heaps.
Harps. Yea, they do so, euen as the sunne doth shine vppon kings pallaices, and on dung heapes.
Cran. Then do I enquire how long Christ tarrieth in the eater.
Cran. Then doe I enquire how long Christ tarieth in the eater.
Harps. These are curious questions, unmeet to be asked.
Harps. These are curious questions, vnmeet to be asked.
Cranmer. I have taken them out of your Schools and Schoolmen, which you your selves do most use: and there also do I learn to ask how far he goeth into the body.
Cranmer. I haue taken them out of your Schooles and Schoolemen, which you your selues doe most vse: and there also doe I learne to aske how farre he goeth into the body.
Harps. We know that the body of Christ is received to nourish the whole man concerning both body and soul: Eo usque progreditur corpus quousque *species.
Harps. Wee know that the bodye of Christ is receyued to nourish the whole man concernyng both body and soule: Eo vsque progreditur corpus quousque *species.
Cran. How long doth he abide in the body?
Seat. S. Augustine saith, our flesh goeth into his flesh. But after he is once received into the stomach, it maketh no matter for us to know how far he doth pierce, or whether he is conveyed. ¶Here M. Tresham and one M. London answered, that Christ being given there under such form and quantity as pleased him, it was not to be enquired of his tarrying, or of his descending into the body.
Seat. S. Augustine saith, our flesh goeth into his flesh. But after he is once receiued into the stomacke, it maketh no matter for vs to know how far he doth pierce, or whether he is conueied. ¶Here M. Tresham and one M. London answered, that Christ beyng geuen there vnder such forme and quantitie as pleased him, it was not to be enquired of his tarying, or of his descending into the body.
Harps. You were wont to lay to our charge, that we added to the scripture: saying always that we should fetch the truth out of the scripture, and now you your self bring questions out of the Schoolmen, which you have disallowed in us.
Harps. You were woont to lay to our charge, that we added to the scripture: saying alwayes that we should fetch the truth out of the scripture, and now you your selfe bring questions out of the Schoolemen, which you haue disallowed in vs.
Cran. I say as I have said alway, that I am constrained to ask these Questions, because of this carnal presence, which you imagine: and yet I know right well, that these questions be answered out of the Scriptures: As to my last question: How long he abideth in the body? &c. The scripture answereth plainly, that Christ doth so long dwell in his people, as they are his members. Whereupon I make this argument. Ba- They which eat the flesh of Christ, do dwell in him▪ and he in them.1 ro- But the wicked do not remain in him, nor he in them: co. Ergo, the wicked do not eat his flesh, nor drink his blood.
Cran. I say as I haue sayd alway, that I am constrayned to aske these Questions, because of this carnall presence, which you imagine: and yet I know right wel, that these questions be answered out of the Scriptures: As to my last question: How long he abideth in the body? &c. The scripture answereth plainly, that Christ doth so lōg dwell in his people, as they are his members. Wherupō I make this argument. Ba- They which eate the flesh of Christ, do dwel in hym▪ and he in them.1 ro- But the wicked doe not remaine in hym, nor he in them: co. Ergo, the wicked do not eate his flesh, nor drinke his bloud.
Harps. I will answer unto you, as S. Augustine saith▪ 1not that how so ever a man do eat, he eateth the body: but he that eateth after a certain manner.
Harps. I will answer vnto you, as S. Augustine saith▪ 1not that how so euer a man do eate, he eateth the body: but he that eateth after a certaine maner.
Cran. I cannot tell what manner ye appoint, but I am sure that evil men do not eat the flesh and drink the blood of Christ, as Christ speaketh in the sixth of John.
Cran. I cannot tel what maner ye appoint, but I am sure that euill men do not eate the flesh and drinke the bloud of Christ, as Christ speaketh in the sixt of Iohn.
Harps. In the sixth of John, some things are to be referred to the godly, and some to the ungodly.
Harps. In the sixt of Iohn, some things are to be referred to the godly, and some to the vngodly.
Cranmer. Whatsoever he doth entreat there of eating, doth pertain unto good men.
Cranmer. Whatsoeuer he doth entreat there of eating, doth pertayne vnto good men.
Harps. If you do mean only of the word of eating, it is true: if concerning the thing, it is not so: And if your meaning be of that which is contained under the word of •ating, it may be so taken, I grant.1
Harps. If you do meane onely of the worde of eating, it is true: if concerning the thing, it is not so: And if your meaning be of that which is conteined vnder the word of •ating, it may be so taken, I graunt.1
Cran. Now to the Argument, He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him. Doth not this prove sufficiently, that evil men do not eat that the good do?
Cran. Now to the Argument, He that eateth my fleshe, and drinketh my bloud, dwelleth in mee, and I in hym. Doth not this prooue sufficiently, that euill men doe not eate that the good doe?
Tresh. You must adde, Qui manducat dignè: He that eateth worthily.
Tresh. You must adde, Qui manducat dignè: He that eateth woorthily.
Cran. I speak of the same manner of eating, that Christ speaketh of.
Cran. I speake of the same manner of eatyng, that Christ speaketh of.
Weston. Augustinus ad fratres in Eremo, Sermon. 28. Est c•• dan• ⟨p. 1462⟩manducandi modus. i. There is a certain manner of eating. Augustine speaketh of two manners of eating: the one of them that eat worthily, the other that eat unworthily.
Weston. Augustinus ad fratres in Eremo, Sermon. 28. Est c•• dan• ⟨p. 1462⟩manducandi modus. i. There is a certaine manner of eating. Augustine speaketh of two maners of eating: the one of them that eat worthely, the other that eat vnworthely.
Harps. All things in the 6. of John are not to be referred to the Sacrament,1 but to the receiving of Christ by faith. The Fathers do agree that there is not entreaty made of the supper of the Lord, before they come unto, Panis quem dabo vobis, caro mea est. &c.
Harps. All thinges in the 6. of Iohn are not to be referred to the Sacrament,1 but to the receiuing of Christe by faith. The Fathers doe agree that there is not entreatie made of the supper of the Lorde, before they come vnto, Panis quem dabo vobis, caro mea est. &c.
Cran. There is entreating of Manna both before & after.
Cran. There is entreatinge of Manna both before & after.
Harps. I will apply an other answer. This argument hath a kind of poison in it, which must be thus bitten away, that Manna and this Sacrament be not both one. Manna hath not his efficacy of him self, but of God.
Harps. I wil apply an other answer. This argument hath a kinde of poysone in it, which must be thus bitten away, that Manna and this Sacrament be not both one. Manna hath not his efficacie of him selfe, but of God.
Cran. But they that did take Manna worthily, had fruit thereby:1 and so by your assertion, he that doth eat the flesh of Christ worthily, hath his fruit by that. Therefore the like doth follow of them both: and so there should be no difference between Manna & this sacrament by your reason.
Cran. But they that did take Manna worthily, had fruite therby:1 and so by your assertion, he that doth eat the flesh of Christ worthily, hath his fruite by that. Therfore the like doth folow of them both: and so there should be no difference betwene Manna & thys sacrament by your reason.
Harps. When it is said, that they which did eat Manna, are dead, it is to be understand, that they did want the * virtue of Manna. *If M. Harpsfield do mean of bodily life, they which eat the Sacrament do die, as well as they which did eat the Manna. If he mean of spiritual life, neither be they all damned that did eat Manna, nor all saved that do eat the Sacrament. Wherefore the truth is, that neither the eating of Manna bringeth death, nor the eating of the Sacrament bringeth salvation: but only the spiritual believing upon Christs bodily passion, which only justifieth both them and us. And therefore as the effect is spiritual, which Christ speaketh of in this chapter: so is the cause of that effect spiritual whereof he meaneth, which is our spiritual believing in him, and not our bodily eating of him.
Harps. When it is sayde, that they which did eate Manna, are dead, it is to be vnderstand, that they did want the * vertue of Manna. *If M. Harpsfield do meane of bodily life, they which eate the Sacrament doe die, as well as they which did eate the Manna. If he meane of spiritual life, neither be they all damned that did eat Manna, nor all saued that do eate the Sacrament. Wherefore the truth is, that neither the eating of Manna bringeth death, nor the eating of the Sacrament bringeth saluation: but only the spirituall beleeuing vppon Christes bodely passion, which onely iustifieth both them and vs. And therefore as the effect is spirituall, whych Christ speaketh of in this chapter: so is the cause of that effecte spirituall whereof hee meaneth, which is our spirituall beleeuing in him, and not our bodely eating of him.
Cran. They then which do eat either of them worthily, do live.
Cran. They then which doe eate either of them worthely, doe liue.
Harps. They do live which do eat Manna worthily, not by Manna, but by the power of God given by it. The other which do eat this Sacrament, do live by the same.
Harps. They doe lyue whiche doe eate Manna worthely, not by Manna, but by the power of God geuen by it. The other which doe eate this Sacrament, do liue by the same.
Cran. Christ did not entreat of the cause, but the effect which followed: he doth not speak of the cause whereof the effect proceedeth.
Cran. Christe did not entreate of the cause, but the effecte which folowed: he doth not speake of the cause whereof the effect proceedeth.
Harps. I do say the effects are divers, life and death, which do follow the worthy, and the unworthy eating thereof.
Harps. I do say the effects are diuers, life and death, which do folow the worthy, and the vnworthy eating therof.