A14350:1128
The common places of the most famous and renowned divine Doctor Peter Martyr divided into four principal parts: with a large addition of many theological and necessary discourses, some never extant before. Translated and partly gathered by Anthony Marten, one of the sewers of her Majesties most honourable chamber.The common places of the most famous and renowmed diuine Doctor Peter Martyr diuided into foure principall parts: with a large addition of manie theologicall and necessarie discourses, some neuer extant before. Translated and partlie gathered by Anthonie Marten, one of the sewers of hir Maiesties most honourable chamber.
Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rowe, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henry Denham, Thomas Chard, William Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583Imprinted at London : In Pater noster Rovve, by Henry Denham and Henry Middleton at the costs and charges of Henrie Denham, Thomas Chard, VVilliam Broome, and Andrew Maunsell, 1583
No title page in the transcription: set from the catalogue record.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
33 By these places we perceive, that the Lords death was throughly foreknown, and understood, and did in no respect infringe the liberty, either of Christ, or of the father. Therefore Cicero, otherwise a very learned man, is greatly to be wondered at: 1against whom Augustine, in his fift book De civitate Dei, especiallie in the ninth & tenth chapters, earnestly disputeth concerning this question. The controversy dependeth upon this, that in the latter book De divinatione, all things are refelled, which were brought by Quintus, Ciceros brother, in the former book. And Cicero endeavoureth by all means, to overthrow all predictions of things to come, and of the prescience of God. Therefore Augustine affirmeth, that the Astrologians had reasons, which were better to be borne withal, than his: because, though they attribute overmuch unto the stars, yet they take not away all divination and prescience. 2And a certain Physician (as the same Augustine declareth in his book of confessions) being a grave man, and one that detested Astrology; when he was demanded, how it came to pass that Mathematicians did prophesy so many truths, he durst not (contrary unto all histories and experience) deny every divination; but he answered, that a certain destiny was spread over things: and he affirmed, that it was not incredible, but that reasonable souls did after a sort feel it. Surely there is nothing to be found more repugnant, 3than of the one side to affirm God to be; and on the other side to take from him the prescience of things to come. The prophet Isaiah would these things to be so firmly knit together, as he said; Show us what things shall come to pass, 4and we will declare you to be gods. But that Cicero had small knowledge, and no good judgement of God; it appeareth by his book, which he intituled ⟨p. 277⟩De natura deorum: wherein, disputing under the person of Cotta, he striveth utterly to take away the nature of God.
33 By these places we perceiue, that the Lords death was throughlie foreknowne, and vnderstood, and did in no respect infringe the libertie, either of Christ, or of the father. Therefore Cicero, otherwise a verie learned man, is greatlie to be woondered at: 1against whom Augustine, in his fift booke De ciuitate Dei, especiallie in the ninth & tenth chapters, earnestlie disputeth concerning this question. The controuersie dependeth vpon this, that in the latter booke De diuinatione, all things are refelled, which were brought by Quintus, Ciceros brother, in the former booke. And Cicero indeuoreth by all meanes, to ouerthrowe all predictions of things to come, and of the prescience of God. Therefore Augustine affirmeth, that the Astrologians had reasons, which were better to be borne withall, than his: bicause, though they attribute ouermuch vnto the starres, yet they take not awaie all diuination and prescience. 2And a certeine Physician (as the same Augustine declareth in his booke of confessions) being a graue man, and one that detested Astrologie; when he was demanded, how it came to passe that Mathematicians did prophesie so manie truths, he durst not (contrarie vnto all histories and experience) denie euerie diuination; but he answered, that a certeine destinie was spred ouer things: and he affirmed, that it was not incredible, but that reasonable soules did after a sort féele it. Surelie there is nothing to be found more repugnant, 3than of the one side to affirme God to be; and on the other side to take from him the prescience of things to come. The prophet Esaie would these things to be so firmelie knit togither, as he said; Shew vs what things shall come to passe, 4and we will declare you to be gods. But that Cicero had small knowledge, and no good iudgement of God; it appéereth by his booke, which he intituled ⟨p. 277⟩De natura deorum: wherein, disputing vnder the person of Cotta, he striueth vtterlie to take awaie the nature of God.
And surely, it is to be lamented, that so notable a man is to be charged with that, which the psalm of David ascribeth unto fools: for there it is written; 1that The foolish man hath said in his hart, There is no God. Upon what occasion he appointed those parts in the dialog unto Cotta, which was a bishop; I do not well understand: unless perhaps he considered, that none in a manner are to be found, which both more freely speak, and worse do esteem of God, than they do, to whose trust are committed ceremonies and holy things. And because it was not hidden to Tullius Cicero, that it is a very odious thing to profess an opinion, whereby God should be denied: therefore, when he had disputed as much as he thought good; in the end of his book he showed his opinion, yet in the behalf of Lucius Balbus; and so, as he saith to Velleius, that the opinion of Cotta is to be allowed. Cicero was a man very studious, as well of all kind of learning, as specially of the civill law. And whereas he thought, 2that the state of mans doings should be overthrown, if free will were denied: and he not knowing by what means this liberty might be retained, with a prescience of things to come; he rather yielded, that Gods wisdom should be taken from him, than that we should be deprived of the freedom of our will.
And surelie, it is to be lamented, that so notable a man is to be charged with that, which the psalme of Dauid ascribeth vnto fooles: for there it is written; 1that The foolish man hath said in his hart, There is no God. Vpon what occasion he appointed those parts in the dialog vnto Cotta, which was a bishop; I doo not well vnderstand: vnlesse perhaps he considered, that none in a maner are to be found, which both more fréelie speake, and woorse doo estéeme of God, than they doo, to whose trust are committed ceremonies and holie things. And bicause it was not hidden to Tullius Cicero, that it is a verie odious thing to professe an opinion, whereby God should be denied: therefore, when he had disputed as much as he thought good; in the end of his booke he shewed his opinion, yet in the behalfe of Lucius Balbus; and so, as he saith to Velleius, that the opinion of Cotta is to be allowed. Cicero was a man verie studious, as well of all kind of learning, as speciallie of the ciuill lawe. And whereas he thought,
Whereupon it may be gathered, into what darkness and obscurity of things the sin of the first man hath driven mankind: for what a madness is it to go about to throw GOD, the creator of all things, out of the fortress of his wisdom, 1that thou mayest preserve man? This is that over self-love, which every-where in the scriptures is condemned: we would that all things should perish, rather than our selves. This doth not godliness require. Wherefore we, which be taught by the spirit of God, declare that both must be confessed; namely, that both God doth foreknow all things, and also that the freedom of our mind (as we have showed before) must be retained. So do the holy scriptures instruct us, wherein we read; 2Whom he foreknew, them hath he predestinate to be made conformable to the image of his son: and that We were chosen by God before the foundations of the world were laid. 3In them do we learn, that The hairs of our head every one are numbered: 4that The little sparrows light not without the will of our heavenly father. And seeing we judge, that God doth all things rightly and justly; we cannot think that he dealeth without reason and understanding.
Wherevpon it may be gathered, into what darknesse and obscuritie of things the sinne of the first man hath driuen mankind: for what a madnes is it to go about to throwe GOD, the creator of all things, out of the fortresse of his wisedome, 1that thou maist preserue man? This is that ouer selfe-loue, which euerie-where in the scriptures is condemned: we would that all things should perish, rather than our selues. This dooth not godlinesse require. Wherfore we, which be taught by the spirit of God, declare that both must be confessed; namelie, that both God dooth foreknow all things, and also that the fréedome of our mind (as we haue shewed before) must be reteined. So doo the holie scriptures instruct vs, wherein we read; 2Whom he foreknew, them hath he predestinate to be made conformable to the image of his sonne: and that We were chosen by God before the foundations of the world were laid.
34 But go to, let us more nearly consider the manner of Ciceros reasoning. 1If (saith he) things to come are certainly known before, things among themselves shall have some certain order: and forsomuch as nothing is done without a cause, of necessity also it shall be granted, that there is an order and knitting together of causes. Whereby will come to pass, that all things, which be done, be done of necessity; by which means just and wholesome laws shall perish: and no admonitions or rebukings will be left, neither can there be any place for religion or prayers. Wherefore thou must choose, whether of these two evils thou wilt: either that there is divination, and prescience of God; or else to maintain the free power of mans will. Both together cannot be had, they be repugnant one with another, as he thinketh. Wherefore unto him it seemeth altogether necessary, that one of these be maintained and defended; and that the other be refused, as false and unprofitable. Which deliberation being taken, 2as Augustine no less wittily, than godly said; Cicero, otherwise a very prudent man, while he coveteth to make us free, maketh us impious and wicked persons, who should rob God of the knowledge, which he hath of things to come.
34 But go to, let vs more néerelie consider the maner of Ciceros reasoning. 1If (saith he) things to come are certeinlie knowne before, things among themselues shall haue some certeine order: and forsomuch as nothing is doone without a cause, of necessitie also it shall be granted, that there is an order and knitting togither of causes. Whereby will come to passe, that all things, which be doone, be doone of necessitie; by which meanes iust and wholsome lawes shall perish: and no admonitions or rebukings will be left, neither can there be anie place for religion or praiers. Wherefore thou must choose, whether of these two euils thou wilt: either that there is diuination, and prescience of God; or else to maintaine the frée power of mans will. Both togither cannot be had, they be repugnant one with another, as he thinketh. Wherefore vnto him it séemeth altogither necessarie, that one of these be mainteined and defended; and that the other be refused, as false and vnprofitable. Which deliberation being taken,
And we must diligently mark, that his arguments make no less against the foretellings of our prophets; than they impugn the divinations of the Ethnics, whereof he at that time disputed. Wherefore thus I think best to answer his curious reasons. Let us grant him what he would; to wit, that for the establishing of Gods prescience, we agree that there is a certain and determinate order before GOD, 1as well of things, as of causes. But that which he bringeth in at last; namely, that all things will therefore come to pass of necessity; that will we deny. For though there be an order of causes appointed, yet doth it not follow thereof, that there cannot be some causes found among them, which may keep their liberty, or (as they call it) their contingence. And in this point Cicero seemeth to err more than the Stoics: for he, 2to save the liberty of man, would that all order of causes, and foreshowing of things to come, should be utterly taken away; which things take so sure hold of the nature of God, that the same being spoiled of them, it cannot seem to consist. But the Stoics, because they would take nothing from the nature of GOD, 3do bring in their destiny: and that our entire and perfect will may have a place, they altogether remove the same from the order of causes joined together.
And we must diligentlie marke, that his arguments make no lesse against the foretellings of our prophets; than they impugne the diuinations of the Ethniks, whereof he at that time disputed. Wherefore thus I thinke best to answer his curious reasons. Let vs grant him what he would; to wit, that for the establishing of Gods prescience, we agrée that there is a certeine and determinate order before GOD, 1as well of things, as of causes. But that which he bringeth in at last; namelie, that all things will therefore come to passe of necessitie; that will we denie. For though there be an order of causes appointed, yet dooth it not followe therof, that there cannot be som causes found among them, which may kéepe their libertie, or (as they call it) their contingence. And in this point Cicero séemeth to erre more than the Stoiks: for he, 2
35 But here let us join issue with him, that we may steadfastly deny, that the knowledge of GOD doth nothing at all hinder our will; although it comprehend the things which ⟨p. 278⟩are to come: for never shall the will of man bring any thing to effect, unless GOD have both foreknown it, and wild it to be brought to effect. When he shall know before hand, that to morrow I will either run or read; indeed I shall run and read, yet not driven thereto of any necessity, but (as they speak) contingently: for as far as belongeth to my self, I might do neither one nor other. But if thou urge further, and say; Yet nevertheless thou shalt do it, in such sort as God knew that thou shouldst do it. I grant: but thereof it followeth not, that I could not otherwise do; because we do not always that which we can do: nay rather, many things might be done, which in no wise be done. 1And in that I shall read or run, it proceedeth altogether of my own choice: for of all things it is most in our power, to will, or not to will. Wherefore when they say; Because God knew before, that thou wouldest read or run; Therefore of necessity thou shalt read: we must demand of them again, whether under the name of necessity, they mean a compelled and a repugnant will.
35 But here let vs ioine issue with him, that we may stedfastlie denie, that the knowledge of GOD dooth nothing at all hinder our will; although it comprehend the things which ⟨p. 278⟩are to come: for neuer shall the will of man bring anie thing to effect, vnlesse GOD haue both foreknowne it, and wild it to be brought to effect. When he shall knowe before hand, that to morrowe I will either runne or read; indéed I shall runne and read, yet not driuen thereto of anie necessitie, but (as they speake) contingentlie: for as farre as belongeth to my selfe, I might doo neither one nor other. But if thou vrge further, and saie; Yet neuerthelesse thou shalt doo it, in such sort as God knew that thou shouldst doo it. I grant: but thereof it followeth not, that I could not otherwise doo; bicause we doo not alwaies that which we can doo: nay rather, manie things might be doone, which in no wise be doone. 1
1For if this be their mind, that we utterly deny: because it may be, that God foreknew that I would do some thing, and that neither unwillingly, nor with a constrained mind; but that I would do it willingly. But if by necessity, they mean that this should in any wise be done of me, we will not deny it: for so much as the controversy now is, not of the thing which is done, or is not done; but the disputation between us is only of the manner and form of doing. 2Neither (as he thought) are admonitions, laws, rebukings, or religious prayers taken away: these things doubtless will be of force, and that more frequentedlie than he could persuade himself; because God not only hath mans safety in his foreknowledge, but also he comprehendeth in his understanding, the ways and means, whereby he will help them. Wherefore if we shall perceive our brother to have need of the remedies, which we have here mentioned, we must boldly use them: for they have so far forth appeared, as God before hand knew, and would, that they should be profitable. Neither must we desist from our duty, although it may be, that all mortal men would affirm that we labour in vain. For we must follow the law prescribed unto us, and not the secret prescience of God, whereof we have no surety what he hath decreed of things to come.
1For if this be their mind, that we vtterlie denie: bicause it may be, that God foreknew that I would doo some thing, and that neither vnwillinglie, nor with a constrained mind; but that I would doo it willinglie. But if by necessitie, they meane that this should in anie wise be doone of me, we will not denie it: for so much as the controuersie now is, not of the thing which is doone, or is not doone; but the disputation betwéene vs is onelie of the maner and forme of dooing. 2Neither (as he thought) are admonitions, lawes, rebukings, or religious praiers taken awaie: these things doubtles will be of force, and that more frequentedlie than he could persuade himselfe; bicause God not onelie hath mans safetie in his foreknowledge, but also he comprehendeth in his vnderstanding, the waies and meanes, whereby he will helpe them. Wherefore if we shall perceiue our brother to haue néed of the remedies, which we haue héere mentioned, we must boldlie vse them: for they haue so farre foorth appéered, as God before hand knew, and would, that they should be profitable. Neither must we desist from our dutie, although it may be, that all mortall men would affirme that we labour in vaine. For we must followe the lawe prescribed vnto vs, and not the secret prescience of God, whereof we haue no suertie what he hath decréed of things to come.
And seeing the prescience of God is not the nature, or (as they term it) the essence or being of our mind; we must give judgement of the actions which proceed from the same, according as they ought to be esteemed by the nature of the mind and will; and not by that which is placed out of the same. Wherefore, seeing the nature of will is, that it is moved, neither unwillingly nor by constraint; it cannot be excluded from it by any outward means. 1It may sooner be abolished not to be at all, than that the violent action can be taken there from: even as thou mayest easilier rid any of us from being men, than when we be men to make us that we shall not be furnished with a reasonable soul; for it followeth immediately, that the soul being abandoned of reason, he cannot any longer be a man.
And séeing the prescience of God is not the nature, or (as they terme it) the essence or being of our mind; we must giue iudgement of the actions which procéed from the same, according as they ought to be estéemed by the nature of the mind and will; and not by that which is placed out of the same. Wherefore, séeing the nature of will is, that it is mooued, neither vnwillinglie nor by constraint; it cannot be excluded from it by anie outward means. 1It may sooner be abolished not to be at all, than that the violent action can be taken there from: euen as thou maist easilier ridde anie of vs from being men, than when we be men to make vs that we shall not be furnished with a reasonable soule; for it followeth immediatlie, that the soule being abandoned of reason, he cannot anie longer be a man.
36 But if thou demand yet further, whether it be a matter of necessity, that I shall read to morrow; seeing God hath this foreknown: 1we answer, that upon condition, or supposition, some necessity may be granted; but not perfect and absolute. Wherefore with that necessity, which we grant, the choice of free will may very well agree. Moreover, Aristotle in his Ethics, disputeth, and that learnedly (as he doth all other things) whether the casting forth, which is done in the sea, when shipwreck is at hand, is to be appointed among things voluntary. And although he there confesseth a certain action, that is mixed with willingness and unwillingness: yet nevertheless he concludeth, that those kind of actions belong unto the voluntary sense; seeing for that time, wherein the shipmen be in danger, they will them, and altogether make choice of them. And if so be that notable Philosopher doubted not to place willingness in this kind of action, whereas men by a certain force are tried to constrain themselves, to choose that thing, which otherwise (if that chance had not been) they would never have done; then how much rather shall not we take willingness from our usual and common actions, when we perceive our selves, of our own accord, and with a mind most willing, to do and endeavour those things, which we think good; although we doubt not, but God did long before understand of the same?
36 But if thou demand yet further, whether it be a matter of necessitie, that I shall read to morrowe; séeing God hath this foreknowen: 1we answer, that vpon condition, or supposition, some necessitie may be granted; but not perfect and absolute. Wherefore with that necessitie, which we grant, the choise of frée will may verie well agrée. Moreouer, Aristotle in his Ethiks, disputeth, and that learnedlie (as he dooth all other things) whether the casting foorth, which is doone in the sea, when shipwracke is at hand, is to be appointed among things voluntarie. And although he there confesseth a certeine action, that is mixed with willingnesse and vnwillingnesse: yet neuerthelesse he concludeth, that those kind of actions belong vnto the voluntarie sense; séeing for that time, wherein the shipmen be in danger, they will them, and altogither make choise of them. And if so be that notable Philosopher doubted not to place willingnesse in this kind of action, wheras men by a certeine force are tried to constraine themselues, to choose that thing, which otherwise (if that chance had not béene) they would neuer haue doone; then how much rather shall not we take willingnesse from our vsuall and common actions, when we perceiue our selues, of our owne accord, and with a mind most willing, to doo and indeuour those things, which we thinke good; although we doubt not, but God did long before vnderstand of the same?
And that the necessity of this kind which we have taught to be by supposition, doth not overthrow the free power of our will; 1Chrysostom doth plainly show, while he writing upon the first epistle to the Corinthians, & interpreting these words; It behooveth that heresies be, that they which be tried among us, 2may be made manifest, saith: Not unlike this form of speech Christ used, when he said; 3It is necessary that offences do come, but woe be unto that man by whom they shall happen. Also he said to his apostles, that It behooved Christ to have suffered, and so to enter into his glory. 4All these things in holy matters are so to be expounded, as when they be called things of necessity; yet ⟨p. 279⟩nothing must be taken away from the nature of mans will. 5And this among the School-men is wont to be called, A necessity not of the consequent, but of consequence.
And that the necessitie of this kind which we haue taught to be by supposition, doth not ouerthrowe the frée power of our will; 1Chrysostome doth plainlie shew, while he writing vpon the first epistle to the Corinthians, & interpreting these words; It behooueth that heresies be, that they which be tried among vs, 2may be made manifest, saith: Not vnlike this forme of spéech Christ vsed, when he said; 3It is necessarie that offenses doo come, but wo be vnto that man by whom they shall happen. Also he said to his apostles, that It behooued Christ to haue suffered, and so to enter into his glorie. 4
37 There be some which commonly say, that doubtless these distinctions help us nothing at all; if God have known before hand of things, those shall in any wise come to pass. Yes verily, they are profitable unto us, and that not meanly: for because thereby we understand, that mans will is not compelled; but that willingly and without compulsion it desireth whatsoever it will. For otherwise I will ask thee again, whether thou wouldest be saved against the will and consent of God? I suppose not. But if thou wouldest be saved according to his will, he of necessity is not ignorant of thy salvation: for so it is ordained, that none willeth that which he is ignorant of. 1It happeneth unto us very often, that we together behold players; yet dare we not say, that the sight and knowledge which we have, bringeth any necessity to them which play: and yet, while we see them in play, it is of necessity, that they do play. Wherefore, as that necessity infringeth not the nature of their will; even so the excellency of God compelleth not the will of man.
37 There be some which commonlie saie, that doubtles these distinctions helpe vs nothing at all; if God haue knowen before hand of things, those shall in anie wise come to passe. Yes verelie, they are profitable vnto vs, and that not meanlie: for bicause thereby we vnderstand, that mans will is not compelled; but that willinglie and without compulsion it desireth whatsoeuer it will. For otherwise I will aske thée againe, whether thou wouldest be saued against the will and consent of God? I suppose not. But if thou wouldest be saued according to his will, he of necessitie is not ignorant of thy saluation: for so it is ordeined, that none willeth that which he is ignorant of. 1It happeneth vnto vs verie often, that we togither behold plaiers; yet dare we not saie, that the sight and knowledge which we haue, bringeth anie necessitie to them which plaie: and yet, while we sée them in plaie, it is of necessitie, that they doo plaie. Wherefore, as that necessitie infringeth not the nature of their will; euen so the excellencie of God compelleth not the will of man.
Some brawl at us, and say, that this similitude is far from the question proposed; because none at any time do behold players, which be not, and play not indeed. Whereas it is ascribed to God, that he hath had a knowledge before hand, of all our doings even from the beginning: when as yet, neither we, nor any of our actions appeared to be. To these men I might answer, that unto God all things are no otherwise present, than they which do play are conversant in the fight of them which behold. 1Let every one therefore take heed to himself, that he cast not the causes of his sins upon God; and when such a kind of cogitation entereth into his mind, let him have respect unto lust, voluptuousness, wrath, hatred, and other perturbations of the mind, wherewith he is sore diseased; and out of these fountains let him seek for the causes of his sins. 2Neither must there be much credit given unto the Peripatetics in this matter, which deny, that God hath understanding of particular affairs; least they should seem to think, that the mind of God were abject & vile, if he should draw his knowledge from frail and transitory things. This thing is not agreeable unto our documents: for we do believe, that God of himself hath a perfect knowledge of all things; neither that he hath any need to challenge knowledge else-where to himself.
Some brall at vs, and saie, that this similitude is farre from the question proposed; bicause none at anie time doo behold plaiers, which be not, and plaie not indéed. Whereas it is ascribed to God, that he hath had a knowledge before hand, of all our doings euen from the beginning: when as yet, neither we, nor anie of our actions appéered to be. To these men I might answer, that vnto God all things are no otherwise present, than they which doo plaie are conuersant in the fight of them which behold. 1Let euerie one therefore take héed to himselfe, that he cast not the causes of his sinnes vpon God; and when such a kind of cogitation entreth into his mind, let him haue respect vnto lust, voluptuousnesse, wrath, hatred, and other perturbations of the mind, wherewith he is sore diseased; and out of these fountaines let him séeke for the causes of his sinnes. 2
138 And whereas touching the third point, it was judged, that the power of God is a hinderance to our will: the argument is neither perfect nor strong. For, although that God by his infinite power, wherewith he is endued, 2doth what his pleasure is; yet doth he suffer the state and nature of things to stand whole: neither doth he violate them, or wrest them any other way, than the condition of them doth bear. Wherefore it is said in the book of Wisdom; that God doth mightily reach even from one end to another, and doth pleasantly dispose all things: or (as the Greek text saith) [Greek or Hebrew], that is, Profitably. Which might not be said, if by the high power of God the natures of things were disturbed. The sum is, that God doth here moderate his power in ruling of the world, that he may fitly apply his action unto all manner of things. In the fourth place sin seemed to be a hinderance to the liberty of the will; 3as if it so weakened the powers of man, that after a sort they might be able to do nothing any more. But there needeth not now many words about this matter; because there hath been plenty enough spoken in those things which we have declared, how much our liberty hath been diminished by reason of sin; and that specially as touching very perfect and good actions, which might be acceptable and well pleasing unto God. Besides, it hath been declared, that our liberty is not by this means utterly taken away; but rather, that there is as yet a great deal of it remaining.
138 And whereas touching the third point, it was iudged, that the power of God is a hinderance to our will: the argument is neither perfect nor strong. For, although that God by his infinit power, wherewith he is indued, 2doth what his pleasure is; yet doth he suffer the state and nature of things to stand whole: neither doth he violate them, or wrest them anie other waie, than the condition of them doth beare. Wherfore it is said in the booke of Wisdome; that God doth mightilie reach euen from one end to another, and doth pleasantlie dispose all things: or (as the Gréeke text saith) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, Profitablie. Which might not be said, if by the high power of God the natures of things were disturbed. The summe is, that God doth here moderate his power in ruling of the world, that he may fitlie applie his action vnto all maner of things. In the fourth place sinne séemed to be a hinderance to the libertie of the will;
39 Moreover, concerning the powers celestial, there shall be no great need to entreat; 1seeing the Astronomers do glory in their own books, that The wise shall bear rule among the stars. But and if so be that these things, which they pronounce, might not be escaped, all their gains would fall away: for no man would bestow cost upon the skill of those things, which he thought he should not be able, neither to avoid, nor change, either by endeavour or study. Which thing without controversy would ensue, if so be they should ascribe a mere necessity unto their foreshowings. By this means all prayers, piety, and worshipping of God would be taken away: for who would pray to God for obtaining of any thing, if he were already persuaded, that the same should not be granted unto him? Wherefore Augustine said; 2They which thus think, do great wrong unto heaven: for there they believe is a court appointed, 3wherein are notable acts decreed, which cannot be avoided: the which if it were in the earth, it should needs be taken away. How much less must we think, that the same is done by God in the celestial parts? I beseech you what judgement would be left, if so be we did all things upon constraint?
39 Moreouer, concerning the powers celestiall, there shalbe no great néed to intreate; 1séeing the Astronomers doo glorie in their owne bookes, that The wise shall beare rule among the starres. But and if so be that these things, which they pronounce, might not be escaped, all their gaines would fall awaie: for no man would bestowe cost vpon the skill of those things, which he thought he should not be able, neither to auoid, nor change, either by indeuour or studie. Which thing without controuersie would ensue, if so be they should ascribe a méere necessitie vnto their foreshewings. By this meanes all praiers, pietie, and worshipping of God would be taken awaie: for who would praie to God for obteining of anie thing, if he were alreadie persuaded, that the same should not be granted vnto him? Wherefore Augustine said; 2
This matter some excuse, saying, that from heaven is only signified what shall come to pass: ⟨p. 280⟩yet that we be not thereby driven by any necessity. And they bring forth a place out of the book of Genesis, 1wherein it seemeth to be spoken; that The stars be put as signs. But that place is to be understood concerning seasons, winds, 2rains, tempests, and such like sort. But how can they affirm, that in heaven they see certain signs of things to come? They shall hardly prove it, especially touching mans affairs. 3For what answer can they make of twins, which being conceived at one time, and have all one aspect of the heavens; yet (as experience teacheth) the chance and success of them is altogether differing?
This matter some excuse, saieng, that frō heauen is onelie signified what shall come to passe: ⟨p. 280⟩yet that we be not thereby driuen by anie necessitie. And they bring foorth a place out of the booke of Genesis, 1wherein it séemeth to be spoken; that The starres be put as signes. But that place is to be vnderstood concerning seasons, winds, 2raines, tempests, and such like sort. But how can they affirme, that in heauen they sée certeine signes of things to come? They shall hardlie prooue it, especiallie touching mans affaires. 3For what answer can they make of twins, which being conceiued at one time, and haue all one aspect of the heauens; yet (as experience teacheth) the chance and successe of them is altogither differing?
1Augustine, in his fift book De civitate Dei, and second chapter, is worth the reading; where he writeth, 2that sometime there happened two brothers to be like affectioned, that when one sickened, the other also was diseased: and when the one recovered, the other was also eased. Concerning which thing Hippocrates being demanded of his opinion, 3made answer, that he thought them to be twins; and that therefore they had the temperature or complexion of their body all of one nature. 4But Possidonius the Mathematician did ascribe the whole cause unto the stars; because in their nativity they occupied all one aspect of the heavens. But what (saith Augustine) will these men say of twins, and innumerable living creatures, which are borne in hours and moments alike; and yet attain to such diversity of fortunes? 5And Augustine witnesseth, that this example was taken out of Cicero; the which nevertheless we read not in his books at this day extant, unless perhaps he found the same in his book De fato, which remaineth amongst us all torn, mangled, and diminished.
1Augustine, in his fift booke De ciuitate Dei, and second chapter, is woorth the reading; where he writeth, 2that sometime there happened two brothers to be like affectioned, that when one sickened, the other also was diseased: and when the one recouered, the other was also eased. Concerning which thing Hippocrates being demanded of his opinion, 3made answer, that he thoght them to be twins; and that therefore they had the temperature or complexion of their bodie all of one nature. 4But Possidonius the Mathematician did ascribe the whole cause vnto the starres; bicause in their natiuitie they occupied all one aspect of the heauens. But what (saith Augustine) will these men saie of twins, and innumerable liuing creatures, which are borne in houres and moments alike; and yet atteine to such diuersitie of fortunes?